عبدالله العتيبي never happened. There was never a Palestinian forced to move out so Israelis could move in. Although there were many times Israelis were forced to move out so Palestinians could move in
steve warren Sure if the land was empty. Why take it? If I find an empty house could I take it. It would of solved homeless problems. UN even said it’s illegal
Phonzo Cisne in the Oslo Accords in 1993 the Israelis and Palestinians made agreements to make 3 areas. Area C, where all the settlements are were decided to be under Israeli security and administrative control.
I was thinking the same thing. It is a very one-sided docu-series. Americans are basically born to be in support of Israel. But honestly... the way they treat the Palestinians is freaking inhumane.
If you guys read the Bible, you ar gonna understand why all of the fight. This is the same thing of you are living in your house with your freedom, then it came a new empire and force you get out, after hundreds of years, your people have the opportunity to come back, they develop the country and the foreigns see that is good and try to get in, but Israel didn’t accept this because old bad experiences. What make me wonder was, why did they give up Gaza?
@@patrixevo give up? Lol funny guy. Yes, they just gave it up without a fight.... what history books are you reading? I would love to know which country you come from? And that if you're also ok with 'giving it back' to whoever originally inhabited it 100's of years ago? LOL, i'm gunna bet its a no.
This is so upsetting to see. I’m Jewish and I just can’t understand how they can be happy there. Seemingly oblivious to all the misery it’s caused. They need to dismantle these settlements - it’s sad but they should never have been allowed to build them.
If an Italian finds a nice part of France and builds a nice house there, does it become part of Italy? Afterwards saying that it's ok because it used to be part of the Roman empire?
Exactly, so just like the modern day Italians don't claim that all the parts under the former Roman Empire qualify as "their land", Palestinians should also accept that this is not "their land". Land keeps changing owners over the course of history. New countries are born over old. Oh wait, Palestine was never a country in the first place. Just a region ruled by one major empire after another.
Zoltan Harangozo and Americans should get out of North America, also the Australians should get out of Australia. Also England should get out of Scotland and Northern Ireland.
Wow they really live like king in middle conflict zone. Remind me the famous quote: one person's utopia is another's dystopia can't be more relevant today
Yes kind of reminded of a scene from the movie Schindler's list where a German solder with high rank stays at his big villa at the hill top and the Jews are seen working in the camps. Not that extreme but there are similarities
While I realize that comparing Israeli settlements in the West Bank to US Suburbs is meant to normalize them, for me and probably other viewers, it's also an indictment of the suburbs, in the context of their broader historical, socio-economic, racial, and political dimensions. I want to point out that the way Israel uses subsidies and public infrastructure to encourage less-affluent settlers to move there, is also very reminiscent of how the US government used policy to favor settler-colonial projects, such as the Homestead Act and other land subsidies in our country's expanding Western frontiers during the 1800's. All while the indigenous peoples of those lands got herded into reservations, or killed when they resisted their dispossession.
Israelis remain indigenous to the land more than the Arabs so using the word indigenous while wrongly referring to a group of people who are not actually indigenous is a fallacy
@@GrandImmortalIf being indigenous doesn't expire after 2000 years then any genetic decendants of the amalekites and moabites have a better claim to the land than Israel. The past doesn't matter except that it's not traditional colonialism because Israel has no other state period. That does make it very different tho. Israel is literally the only group of people without a state, living completely spread out around the world in other states, who have re-established their own state in places they werent even living en mass. Completely unprecedented
@@InspiredByReason how Many Israeli head you have seen in the group from 1948. The world have seen a lots of Palestinian children buried inside the debris... You invest a lot to spread your lies. But God is there remember
@@Starky513 , you're obviously wrong. Many people care. Even a neutral like me, surely wants to know and hear from the Palestinian's perspective. In fact, even some British and American citizens are increasingly interested in hearing more from them, as the media attention tends to be so concentrated on the Jews' perspective.
Because the perspective of a state which declared anti Semitic and imperial war on Jews is just that: anti Semitic. Why do you think the Iron Dome exists? Ever heard of the 47-49 Arab-Israeli war?
@@chinoschmino9108 I suppose its all one sided then 🙄. I just see entrenched racism and a complete lack of humanity and empathy from all. Israelis wouldn't be prepared to live under the conditions they empose on others, Palestinians need to accept expecting 9 million to leave is an impossible wish. Its always someone else's fault.
A question for Pro-Israel peeps: If the Muslim refugees in Europe want to start a country in Spain, using the same excuses Jews used: We are running away from war, this land was ours 1000 years ago, we are no longer a minority and we deserve our own land, God told us to do this. What would be your reaction? Since it's basically the same thing, but with Muslims instead of Jews?
It is absolutely not "basically the same thing". before israel the British mandate ( the government there at the time) promised the Jews they could have a country there.
The king Is back What it was called should not be an argument. Let's call it Ottamistan, what does that change? You just admitted to it being stolen, which basically sums up the whole conflict.
Article 49 of the Fourth Geneva Convention states: “The Occupying Power shall not deport or transfer parts of its own civilian population into the territory it occupies.” It also prohibits the “individual or mass forcible transfers, as well as deportations of protected persons from occupied territories" Israel is making it more difficult for Palestinians to form their own country. At the same time they also do not want to give Palestinians in West Bank equal voting rights because they are still outnumbered. Stop the settlements, let Palestinians have their state and freedom.
читайте Коран! Искусственная это палестина с террористами из Саудии, названными в КГБ СССР в 1967 году для войны и террора с Израилем! Израиль более 2000 лет назад существовал и 2 раза был разрушен! В 1948 году по решению ООН Израиль возродился на своих землях, частично оккупированных Иорданией! Это Самария, Иулея, Западный берег, Иерусалим и земли в Иордании по мандату ООН! Арабские страны Иран,Ирак,Сирия,Ливан,Египет,Иордания совместно с российскими инструкторами, солдатами, офицерами на танках, самолетах, ПВО, военных кораблях напали на Израиль и были разгромлены и опозорены! Россия, это спонсор террора и войн! В Коране нет палестины и этого народа врунов! Это саудиты, выброшенные в провинцию Иордания за террор, которых король Иордании приказал уничтожать как бешеных собак! Израиль продолжает дело иорданского короля! Не хотите жить мирно, умирайте за русские фашистские идеи! ≈=============== Интерес каждой отдельной страны в мире должен состоять в том, чтобы остановить подстрекательство Палестинской автономии. ПА поощряет терроризм и платит террористам, убивающим евреев. Государство Израиль в первую очередь привержено безопасности Израиля".
Resolution 181 of the UN acknowledges the Two State solution of 1947. The Arab league walked out on international law and has been violating these laws ever since by Not recognizing a two state solution not accepting Israel as a state when Palestine was Never a sovereign state 😊
@@robertk6640 tell that to American Indians that were forced off of their lands to make room for white colonials. Wherever white, colonials go, indigenous populations are displaced. South Africa, Australia, Hawaii, so it goes….. and conveniently they say what you say. It’s just disgusting.
@@Gentilejedi you’ve got a totally the opposite way the Jews are the American Indians because they were their first then came the Arabs thousands of years later OK so if you’re going to make a comparison, then allow me to make a comparison to you if American Indians and white colonial us are living in that area the size of New Jersey and the American Indians from their region want to claim their land back would that be OK with you because that’s what Israel is doing Israel is his fight for independence when the British left the area next to another people who colonize the land later on this is not about whites, moving into an area they call America which is two continents. Founded by Portuguese, Spanish French and English combined. This is about two people claiming the same area because they both have sister is there so if you have a problem with Jews living in their own area, then you should have a problem with Greeks living in Greece or Irish people living in Ireland.
@@nm5612 You can't displace a people if you win a fight. Dictatorships have done that throughout time, but if israel wants to paint itself as a democracy it can't do that
@@YusssoM he must be referring previous two wars, where Israel was attacked by Arab countries not once but twice, they did lose(Israel enemies) as a result, israel got more land after war
@@abhinavthakur8232 4 wars actually. The first three in the 20th century, then another war in the early 21st century (that’s where they created the Iron Dome). After that, a bunch of unofficial battles
Israel and Britain has offered to give Palestine the majority of the entire land multiple times and only give a fraction to Israel and Israel even accepted the offer to take a tiny part of the land, Palestinians refuse to live alongside Israeli’s and the conflict that is still here today is because of them, I don’t feel sorry they brought this on themselves
"No one seriously considers it possible to remove all 400,000 residents" But they have no problem with forceful removal of more than 2,000,000 native people from there.
Well jews didn't ask Arabs to invade them , they did out of their volition, had the Arabs won Israel would have been occupied, they chose to invade and lost it's like east Prussians(germans ) complaining about the territory lost to Poland after WW2
They're not removing any natives from any place at all... I have no clue where you got that from. Also, Israel was invaded by its neighbors. That was their choice, not Israel's. Israel gained these lands from a defensive war, and they've owned them for 50 years, just get over it.
Coconut Pal no during the Nabka Palestinians fled as refugees expecting to return to their homes shortly. Whilst some were terrorised away the majority fled due to expectations of conflict. Also some remained due to being allied with the Israelis. I have no view just believe in clearing up fact. Not that the fact they were not forced out makes it justifiable at all.
@@erica8332 the arabs invaded when the jews declared independence. you know we have the arab league we are sworn to help each other, if another war happen which seams like it. Israel wouldn't stand a chance
Its a great documentary and you have shown the Jewish side of the story. I think its time for part 3 consisting of the perspective of Palestinian side.
@SS You are actually telling me that Palestinian lives do not matter.. That was you very first sentancde, that their story didn't matter. Shame on you!! I don't care if people believe in Jahve, Allah, Buddha or Thor. But saying that the story of the Palestinians in Palestine do not matter is simply outrageous. Let me guess, you are American?
@@user-xq8hm6zm4b No dont worry ive checked international polls and it seems that the majority infact; do not want to visit a landgrabbing wartorn area
As a south african there's no mistake. This is exactly what apartheid was. Israeli people get to live in a "first world" country while the Palestinians live in a literal war zone.
Shoudn't the fair comparison be with the Palestinians living in Israel? Apartheid was segregation and degradation of people living in the same country, Israelis living in West Bank are more like a case of colonization...
while they're on cloud 9, right next door a Palestinian family is trying to find something to eat with no home in Palestinian land. They're being pushed out of their homes because someone wants "a nice view"
I’m Arab and Black and I swear this is racism at its finest! It has nothing to do with religion or is a long war no no. It’s a country continuously noticing and allowing settlers to enter foreign land with out any reproductions. Occupier (Israel) and occupied (Palestine) say it how it is . Never was a war because US funded the 4 strongest military in the world
@Elias Michan no im saying Palestinians in Israel are not homeless, no pun im serious they’re free. But Palestinians in palatine are homeless and it’s due to Israel settlers constantly moving which we both agree on. But we have to also address the fact that the Palestinians in Israel have laws discriminating against them which is a fact. Look man as a Palestinian all we want is peace. But we will not give up our land. A 2 state solution was a good idea but was not respected and it’s so sad how we always get the short end of the stick due to America not holding the Israeli regime accountable
@@joeswanson7675 while I don't support what Netanyahu's done, I think that the idea that Jews immigrating into Israel are 'settlers' and that America needs to 'hold Israel accountable' isn't necessarily accurate
5.32 is that not the security apparatus. Goodness it's just another perspective that shows the problem in the West Bank and why they are settling. If you don't see the whole picture, how are you going to resolve it? I didn't know how good the housing and school system was for Jews.
Happiness for them and sadness for Palestinians Even your religion don't say that You know the truth but try to ignore it Shame on you shalom on you Where's education system for the other people living in front of your house
@Hey yo Palestinians are the real descendants of Hebrews and Canaanites who mixed with Arabs and Crusaders. They've just been Arabized as have everyone in the Levant. Those coins are our history, not yours.
@Hey yo It used to be Jewish, yes. But it is no longer. Imagine this scenario: you happen to live in a house that was once stolen 100 years ago. You do not approve of that, but, still, it is the only house that you own. Then the grandchildren of the man who stole that house break in and tell them to leave your house and pass its possession to them, offering you no new house in return. Would you listen? If not, your argument that Israel was once a Jewish land isn't a strong one. Sure, Israel is a country and deserves to be one. But the same applies to Palestine. I know that Palestinians don't have as much history as the Jews, nor are they a distinct people or cultural or ethnic group like the Jews are, but that doesn't mean that they don't deserve to live in their own homes. Look, if peace is eventually found, Israel itself will benefit from vast wealth, reduced tensions, much higher security and, duh, peace, and, consequently, a higher standard of living. In this case, we will also finally be able to grant full focus to contributing to actual progress as a species and moving the world as a whole forward, instead of focusing on petty land disputes and useless (on the global scale) military. Without war, we will also most likely grow, at worst, into one of the most advanced, innovative, and prosperous nations in the world and, at best, into the single most advanced nation on the planet. So even making compromises such as giving up land will more than pay off in the long run. Please think big rather thinking locally.
The settlers point of view is so onesided. They're enjoying a semi-luxurious lifestyle on the account of suffering and oppressed palestinians. No one has a problem with people living happy and fruitful lives. The problem is making their happiness depend on the misery of others.
Same could be said about every developed country on the planet. How often do you think about the African child soldiers who mined the elements in your smartphone?
Incredible how human beings can egoistically focus on their well being, while crushing the minimum rights (of also live a good life) of others… I’m ashamed of being part of this society… Someone up there is seeing everything we are doing…
@@ladiddas another point i would like to add… i’m using your words… this is happening for thousands of years, so you are saying we can fly a big box of metal with people inside, weighing 400tons and our minds and sense of humanity got stuck in time ??????? that is why things like this happen still today… good mentality… congrats to you as well… keep it up
Unfortunately, we appear to have about the same percentage of ignorant and arrogant people that we've had all along. I guess some of us went further down the path of evolution than others.@@hitmancastle
jay diggy? are you serious there is a palestianian youtube called cobra 123473 go watch his vids he saves animals :[ he lives in palestain they cant even have drugs to save some animals only doctors can and most doctors are not that good
Dr Guillotin You understand the rules of war have changed over time right. Just as in 1918 we started (and in 1945 mostly finished with) ending the idea of ‘might makes right’ we have abolished numerous spoils of war, when you conquer a city you no longer get to take half the women as prizes for soldier and 2/3rds of the men as slaves, we bind ourselves in law to protect us and human civilisation from destroying ourselves. Humanity evolved over time, in the modern world, the fact the Israeli military is able to occupy the land doesn’t give the Isreali state the right to govern it, not the Isreali citizenry the right to extract it. If you want other examples, frances occupation of northern Mali on behalf of Mali doesn’t give France the right to extract taxes, apply laws, or settle the desert. British occupation in Afghanistan doesn’t give Britain the legal right to govern the mountains.
The international community seems to want a Two State Solution. Israel agreed to a Two State Solution in 1948, and then was invaded by all its neighbors. (Happy Israel Independence Day!) Israelis today are probably very divided over whether to pursue a Two State Solution.
@@MrCalls1 well you can't compare illegal occupation to the jews that historically lived in the region and therefore has a rightful claim to it, on same grounds as palastinians, plus holocaust and the Jewish history gives them a right to own piece of land. Also you do realize how small Israel is right, this makes a two state system almost impossible to maintain especially due to the animosity between the two groups historically.
Well I think that no one person should be barred from anyplace as at the end of the day we are all humans. But I think the settlements are a problem. Maybe don't build any more.
You know, I don't mind if upper-middle class people have their fun in these very nice communities and do whatever, but isn't this adding to the tensions and hostility between the Israelis and the Palestinians? If the Palestinians and the Israelis both agreed to that that land over there is yours and that land over there is ours, and this agreement helped them come to ceasefire to prevent them from killing each over, then why are the Israelis breaking that treaty and settling there when they could literally settle anywhere else in the world?
Next on Vox: Why the Trail of Tears was not really that bad. We bought their land for more then market value. Colonial expansion is not that bad after all according to Vox.
@@ShnoogleMan The Time is not far when Many of the Jews Will Embrace The Islam and the wrest will be dead. By the way This comment is only for Jews. Jews were Called Muslims until The Prophet Hazrat Isa A.S Came. They tried to Murder Him. But Allah Saved Him And Raised Him And He Will Again Come. And All The Humen being Will be Muslims.
@trollnerd by my Israel has no rightful claim to the land if Palestine but is a colonising it since "historical ties" isn't an excuse. By logic Palestine also doesn't have the right to kick out all the Israelis and claim all the land. Therefore the only fair solution is two states, those settlers make this impossible since they blur the borders and for that they are responsible for the continuation of the killing in both Palestine and Israel.
It's good to see everyone as human, of course people on both sides try to dehumanize the other because it's not wrong to hate something that isn't human, but that's not the reality of life. Yes, I believe that what the Israeli settlers are doing is illegal and very wrong, but blindly hating a faceless other is not the way, and the only way we'll ever come to respect one another and overt war and chaos is by peacefully cooperating and realizing that we are all people. One people :)
I don't see any celebrating in this video. They're just showing the reality. These are people moving out there, not monsters. That doesn't mean that the settlements are a good thing or even harmless, but it does mean that there is no clean and perfect solution to this. If Palestine ever becomes it's own state, a significant number of it's citizens are _going_ to be Israeli Jews, unless you're advocating that they round up and forcibly remove a half a million people (something that doesn't tend to happen peacefully).
A couple of weeks ago I took a virtual tour with 3 Palestinian olive growers who live in Gaza, but their groves have been in their families for hundreds of years. They are supposed to be allowed in to their trees to care for them and to harvest olives. Unfortunately, the settlements have built fences with locked gates & someone is supposed to be there at designated times to unlock the gates. They don't always show up and thus the farmers cannot harvest their olives. This settlement has no sewer system so sewage from this settlement just free flows down into the olive groves and the farmers can't get in. Teens from the settlements hassle the farmers and I found it to be eye opening. My grandfather from Jerusalem used to be friends with Palestinians and he would help them harvest and in turn they allowed him to take a share of olives to press for his family. Those days are long gone. I am sure not everyone behaves the way the settlers in this settlement do, but things are not easy or good for Gaza's olive farmers.
Sure not everyone behaves the way the settlers in this settlement do ? So I break into your house , I beat you out of it ... and you'll be greatfull if let you in for a cup of water ? -_- ok
The Time is not far when Many of the Jews Will Embrace The Islam and the wrest will be dead. By the way This comment is only for Jews. Jews were Called Muslims until The Prophet Hazrat Isa A.S Came. They tried to Murder Him. But Allah Saved Him And Raised Him And He Will Again Come. And All The Humen being Will be Muslims.
@@yaakovgrunsfeld Israel is a settlement. 🤯 More than 50% of the population are European Ashkenazi, and so is p much everyone in power. Middle Eastern Jews are second class citizens and have been since Israels founding. Read what Ben-Gurion said about brown Jews. Israel is a European settlement created entirely for white Christians to consolidate power in Europe, at the expense of the brown native inhabitants of Palestine. Just like America, Australia, Argentina, etc.
@@amrshalabymusic If it's pure theft for Israelis to be in the West Bank, by that logic, it's pure theft for the Navajo to be on their indigenous lands.
@@Nemo_Anom The Palestinians have equal claim over the land- historically and genetically. By your logic though, the Brits should go back to Germany. The Australians should go back to Europe. Some Americans should invade Ireland. Common sense is a rarity these days.
@Shikhar no it isnt First look at south east asia which account for third of the muslim population And the turks and central asian countries and the russian also Second there was wars but people chose to convert Look how many christians still live in syria, egypt and lebanon, how many used tp live there and with palestineans before the racist thing called israel came Look how spain was when it was ruled by muslims....there was people of the three religions living peacefuly in the most devoloped eueopean country in that time Look what muslims brought to europe by rulling over spain and look what europeans did by colonizing the world
@Shikhar ahhh Islam spread in Southeast Asia through trade. Maybe in India, not here in SEA. Read the history book. Same as Islam in China. The merchants and scholar brings the religion.
@Shikhar the ideology spread through war but it did not exile people from their home it gave you a choice. All nations of north Africa are native to their own land and have their own culture and Language. the Iranians still speak Farsi. this goes to show that Muslims did not exile anyone, yes they went to war but all the native were given a choice to stay but they have to pay taxes and even muslims themselves had to pay taxes. btw no religion in the world gave this type of choice for the people that did not follow it and that is why many Jews were prosecuted under roman role and they know themselves that the live a better life under the islamic role. in the argument against Israel is not the war but the ethnic cleansing of the Palestinians which is obvious in the video.
Ohfu Kayou Except by that logic if the native Americans lets say (somehow) got the support of all major powers to establish a state essentially the entire west coast and half of mid west like 50-50% would you be okay with that because thats all it is oppressed people having there own stye in there own homeland
It dont feel like a conflict zone because all the money and support is on side...the side your seeing i dont feel angry that these people are happy but to say that people on the other side are suffering because of their happiness..it makes me feel sad this is the way it has happened...
How much money do you think the Palestinian government has ? Barely anything. Plus if Israel stopped the blockade the living conditions would be a lot better. They have only electricity only 6 hours a day. That has nothing to do with the Palestinian Governments spending. Thats all because of the Israeli Blockade
Chinrico Tan If someone started taking over your land would you not fight back? I am referring to this video in particularly, where Israel is clearly funding these new settlements. Ethically speaking, what Israel is doing is wrong; you have to admit that regardless of your belief in what the Bible says.
10:00 "What did you think I was living in? A tent"? Thanks to people like you, the people you are displacing ARE living in tents. Must be so nice to have a place to go back to where everything is provided for you at the expense of an entire peoples' land.
There is nothing Islamic about genocide? Just that a lot of un-Islamic Muslims are involved in the murder of Christians, Jews, Yazidis, Muslims of the "wrong" creed, and pagans across the world. Half a million victims of Jihad in Syria, tens of thousand in Sudan, more tens of thousands in Nigeria. In the last month there were 180 Islamic attacks in 31 countries, in which 1083 people were killed and 1259 injured. And you're crying about displaced Palestinians? Let their Muslim brothers take them in and rehabilitate them like we did for the hundreds of thousands of Jews who were driven from their homes around the Middle East by the followers of your religion of peace.
Yusuf Celenli If Palestinians are living in tents and refugee camps, they must blame their leaders. In 2000, Palestinians were offered 97 % of the West Bank, Arafat turned it down. So what is Israel supposed to do. Palestinians want everything on a platter. You cannot have things on a platter, you have to make compromises. I personally think the two state solution is dead. The best Palestinians can hope for now is autonomy not an independent state. Of they are smart they will accept Israel s terms and conditions, if they don't they might be landless and be a embittered minority for the next century.
Hannah Abdi nor does you, for when you mention the crusades you forget of the arabs almost reaching as far up as paris- read about your own story then you may try and talk about "the obvious " card you have up your sleeve
As much as this is very informative and well made and well argued, for the purpose of not being biased you should have also interviewed 15 Palestinians living in the West Bank and the conditions they live in.
The Time is not far when Many of the Jews Will Embrace The Islam and the wrest will be dead. By the way This comment is only for Jews. Jews were Called Muslims until The Prophet Hazrat Isa A.S Came. They tried to Murder Him. But Allah Saved Him And Raised Him And He Will Again Come. And All The Humen being Will be Muslims.
@@dakotalafferty9273 Hamas was a minority party until Israel funded them and sent them weapons in order to keep the PLO (far left secular Palestinian party) from gaining power. Look it up, Israel has openly said they did this.
Yes you can. Go for it. You can also cross the American border and get healthcare, and government subsidies. Your neighbor will pay for it all via taxes.
Listen, the reason Israelis are moving there is because they don’t have room in the rest of israel, and because Israel technically occupied Palestine, they think,” hey land that most people aren’t living on! This will be an easy way to get a cheap house! Time to move”
Yeah and most of them are integrated to israeli society. Its a long standing joke that if there is a pharmacist he will 4/5 be arab in israel. Not a terrible fate imo
I guess they had to only cover jewish because thetitle said jewish settlements. If it was called palestine it would have been different. But i do wanna hear both sides of the argument. I think Atlantic news did a better job on the docu series
@@motro1301 may be a separate video. Could you share the video link of the Atlantic News? But his storytelling is very unique. I love the vox border series only because it's very different from other news
@@motro1301 they took are land we are the victims those rich Jews ate getting rich off of us racist Jews. Nothing but victim mentality without helping themselves is what you will hear
The Time is not far when Many of the Jews Will Embrace The Islam and the wrest will be dead. By the way This comment is only for Jews. Jews were Called Muslims until The Prophet Hazrat Isa A.S Came. They tried to Murder Him. But Allah Saved Him And Raised Him And He Will Again Come. And All The Humen being Will be Muslims.
I found this really interesting and informative. But I kept wondering if you would also interview some palestinians in the West Bank too. I love to see a similar opportunity given to them to speak.
This is the problem with people reporting this conflict. The Palestinians do not get the airtime the Israelis get. The Israelis come across has White Middle class types with suburb English. The Palestinians on the other hand are usually shown has the Western definition of Middle Eastern religious zealot. Completely without compromise. It is no doubt beautiful. The scenery & especially climate but there must be underlying fear deep within their hearts that even during peace there can never truly be peace.
It doesn't matter if they interview the Palestinians. The video is very clear about how Israel mainland subsidies the illegal invasion of the West Bank thru these settlements and keep advancing.
@@NoName-jq7tjguys, that's not what this piece is about. It very clearly sets out to explore what the settlements are like, which is an interesting subject worth exploring. There are plenty of videos about the ways the settlements make life harder for the palestinians in the WB, the disgusting police state they set up, the nets catching trash in Jerusalem, the segregated streets. That is not every video and not every video has to be that.
As an Israeli, all I want is a third part. We are exposed to what settlments are like, and how easy it is to move to one, and how appealing certain aspects of it are, I would love seeing the palestinian side of this story.
@trollnerd Those houses were built by Jordan after it struck an agreement with UNRWA. They were built for the 28 refugee families that were displaced from their houses in Yaffa and Haifa by Israel. The international community considers it part of Palestinian territory and agrees that it is occupied. It does not belong to Israel which is why it is against international law to displace them. Those families have never paid any rent because there has never been a landlord
The Time is not far when Many of the Jews Will Embrace The Islam and the wrest will be dead. By the way This comment is only for Jews. Jews were Called Muslims until The Prophet Hazrat Isa A.S Came. They tried to Murder Him. But Allah Saved Him And Raised Him And He Will Again Come. And All The Humen being Will be Muslims.
It’s disturbing and comical. A satire of bourgeois attitudes. “Yeah we violently took their land and we’re condemned by international law, but boy howdy look at the schools and neighborhoods…”
Israel needs to either follow international law or not complain when the government is condemned for violating it. This region needs peace and the continual of settlement on Palestine is a major hurdle to that process.
yeah they did but they agreed to give back the land under an agreement. The peaceful resolution is not a dream if both countries work towards a viable solution. Btw hasn't this region seen enough conflict already, now is the time for peace and harmony, it has been done before and i believe it can be achieved now.
History shows that there have been various times when Jews, Muslim, Christians were all living in Israel without much conflict. Peace is possible and needed so that both countries can have a bright future
Israel kind of fought and won multiple wars against multiple Arab nations for that land. Maybe instead of immediately going to war with Israel, they should've thought about what they were doing?
Umm, a number of those wars were Israel doing surprise attacks on countries where they ended up coming away with a ton of land....you can't blame the Arabs in those cases - they weren't the attacker, they were minding their own business.
oldmoviemusic That is completely and utterly false. Please give one example to support these claims as opposed to skewing facts to support you narrative.
They were not kicked out of their land. They started a war to kick Jews out of their lands. Jews have been kicked out of this land for centuries and have a right to a state. Why do you want to kick the Jews living in the west bank??
@@paulprice3730 the 3 main types of Jews are European, north African, and middle eastern. The founding Jews of Israel were predominantly European, particularly Eastern European because of the Holocaust. Israel was practically founded for that reason alone.
Pocket History Lesson: there was no state of Israel before 1948. This Pocket History Lesson was brought to you by AreYouEnlightened, and is devoid of hate, sarcasm, or agenda.
this race Jews there ancestors was been exile in the region after the Jewish revolt against Rome. after there defeate the Emperor if the Rome ordered to exile the Jews out in Judea and rename it as an insult to Jews. this Palestine to the ancient Jews is there biggest enemy in the Region. Rome intended to rename it cause that is a sign of an insult to Jews people. tru out the years Jews always been invade by ancient Empire exile they came back and rebuilt. Jews has in own culture and Jerusalem is Part of there Identity as a Jews. it is not just a Land but that land for them is the Land has been defended by the Jews years and years before. even though it was just a dessert before the Jews choose to settle there originally not because of wealth but for there culture
I demand justice also for the million Jews who were thrown out of their homes in Arab lands and that Israel absorbed. Who will repay them for everything they lost.
“Tansik” تنسيق means coordination in Arabic. All the olive harvest in those parts of the Palestinian West Bank under Israeli military control requires coordination (Tansik) with the Israeli army. The real purpose of the “coordination” is to disrupt and damage the harvest. The olive harvest in the West Bank takes place under a constant Israeli land grab, restrictions on access to the plots, settlers attacks on harvesters, and vandalisation of olive trees. Kufr Qaddum is a Palestinian town in the northern West Bank. Its olive groves are located beside the large settlement Kedumim, which was illegally built on Kufr Qaddum’s land. It takes 2 months for the village to harvest its olives. In 2019 the Israeli army gave them a permit for 8 days. Untended trees yield poorer crops, if they can be picked at all. The settlement of Kedumim uses surveillance cameras to monitor the Palestinian land. If the settlers see the farmers working, they will either arrive there to threaten them, or ask the army to come and turn the farmers away from their land. Over one million Palestinian olive trees have been uprooted or burned by Israeli authorities and settlers since 1967.
Upbeat music and cheerful residents talking about how great a life they're living after a military occupation brutally wipes out generations of humans.
They were okay with the divide at the start until the neighbouring Arab nations who had no business intervening invaded Israel in hope of making it a complete Arab state. It's like a taste of their own medicine....except they'll make it 10 times bitter.
It's only as legal as the Geneva Convention is illegal. But then the complete disregard for the Geneva Convention and international laws by the Israeli government and backers of the settlements makes any meaningful discussion impossible.
Get some guns and you can easily claim some land even in the middle of Tel Aviv. Just shoot anyone who dare to oppose and make a youtube video telling they are terrorists
2:33 _Most people here work in the city, and you come back here at night..._ So those "settlements" are nothing more than glorified residential subsurbs of israeli towns. And yet the israeli gorvernment makes it sound like it's impossible to remove them, that it would "uproot" those people. It's just a damn suburb! Detroit had twice that number of people leaving its own suburbs.
Narayana 69 .. Lol prood that you are the true descendants of that people first .. Those well known classical religious claims to gain sympathy when the bible is mentioned won't work anymore .. Btw , the bible never said to expel the people , destroy their future and leave them suffering without any guilt .
Bobby B .. Yeah are totally right .. The israeli government as keep in building settlements to increase the number of their settlers and the infrastructure to dismantle any attempt for a two state or whatever solution to solve this issue .. Israel has onw goal which is to expel the palestinians and replace them with settlers and that was the goal from day one ..
Narayana 69 .. There was no need for your long article .. Your biblical interpretation makes god a real estate agent .. Probably Working for KBR. You could simply confess and say .. Yes we have no proof that we are descendants and don't have a bloodline to the biblical israelities .. Its obvious that you are coverted .. Thanks for your indirect confession .. Lol @ Alien .. This alien has to be from ( god choosen aliens)
Narayana 69 .. Lol , my previous comment already closed the urguement and proved the colonical intentions by the use of religious justificstion .. Btw , speaking hebrew never proves that they are descendants of ancient israelities .. For your info .. Hebrew today isn't the same as ancient hebrew .. Posting lot of comment in an attempt to justify something will make it worse .. Trycto be short and clear .. 😉
Narayana 69 don't maneuver and deviate the subject .. Why you always try to toss the classical words once you are trapped ?? Arabs muslims rape etc .. I dont care about this.. I'm not going to insult you as you did .. Being aggressive won't help. Back to subject .. Yeah speaking arabic doesn't prove either .. Thats is also true .. Its the same concept .. If you can't prove or disprove something then you have to stop the claim that "God Promised the land " simply because you can't be certain who are the real descandants .. So tell me, if palestinians are the real descandants but converted to islam 1400 years ago and became Arabs by tongue .. What will that means to you ??
+David Gill Do you call Assad( Shia) Syrian government? Based on statistical analyses before the war from 2006, of the Syrian population, 74%[2] were Sunnis (including Sufis[3]), whereas 13%[2] were Shias (including 8.0% Alawites from which about 2% are called Mershdis and they are the followers of Sulayman al-Murshid, 3% Twelvers , or 1% Ismailis ), 3%[2] were Druze, while the remaining 10%[2] were Christians Sorry to rain on your parade :).... but, no as you could see Shia (Alawaites) are small minority of Syrian populations 8%, The great majority are Sunni 74%, so, NO.....monster Asssssad is NEVER represented Syrian people! !!!! never....
ha vu they don’t let interviewers go into Palestinian towns to get their side, that’s how they oppress them and show the world only their side. Disgusting society of Israel that supports the illegal settlements, they always want more and more land, never content.
hey Soham you do realize no one dies from these so called "terrorist attacks" by the palestinians, unlike the missile strikes done by the zionists which are funded by the US .
Ihsan Fahmil this video is about the west bank not Gaza , there are no Israeli settlers in Gaza yet still Hamas continues to terrorizing Israelis who lives in the border
I would have loved to hear what settlers who aren't religious zealots think the future of the West Bank is going to be. Like what is their personal vision how this whole conflict is going to turn out? Do they really want the Palestinians to be oppressed forever? Do they really think that's even a viable solution even if it weren't so obviously morally wrong?
Look for one of "Dont tell my mother...." series. In it the host interview one of the more non-zionist Jew in Isreal. Suffice to say the guy got verbal abuse and death threats.
nimay13 Neither the fact that it's rare to be non-Zionist in Israel, nor that this is necessarily a dangerous position to take correspond to my personal experience. Are you sure you haven't been fed some biased views there? It's important to remember that there are probably few countries where the range of political views backed by a substantial portion of the population is larger than in Israel.
Penny Lane Go find the series "Dont tell my mother...", granted it was a few years old but it was produced for National Geographic. The non-zionist Jew guy got verbally abused (by other Jews) in front of the camera. No bias there. Also in that particular episode, the host goes to show both sides of the fence. From the Jews viewpoint and from the Palestine POV. He literally went to West Bank and interview people there. I think he went to Gaza strip too.
While this was quite informative, the tone of this video seems a little weird. You squarely address the illegality and devious strategy of the Israeli government in building these settlements, but you don’t actually criticize them. It’s as if you made a video asking shoplifters about fashion trends and why they chose the outfits they stole? It’s weird.
They’re not worried about the fact that they’re stealing this land They’re just happy it’s five minutes from a hiking trail SMH so sad They’re so oblivious
I think its complicated like maybe they took the land but i think that if they live there now it would be just as immoral to take it back Like honestly I think it would be better if isreal didnt exist in the first place but it dose now so we need a more nuanced discussion than isreal bad and palistine good. People on the left and right both seem to make it seem like it is cut and dry one side bad the other good but its not there is nuance. Saying "both sides" is wrong too however because I think that isreal should not have existed in the way it dose in the first place however there is nuance and I dont think these people are to blame.
his analogy isnt perfect because, we already negotiated over the pizza. UN partitioned the land, the palestinians refused their share, they attacked and lost the war. a better analogy would be, one pizza split between two guys and the greedy one attacked the other and lost parts of his pizza in the process.
i think you got that wrong, in 1948 2 guys were negotiating over a pizza, so UN came and split it in half, but side #1 (Palestinians) attacked side #2 (Israelis) for the Israeli half, but then they lost the war and their half of the pizza... now tell me, giving back to the Palestinians their half of pizza for nothing will just bring us back to the beginning, so Israel wants it like this: "we will give you your half, but you leave us alone". so far the Palestinians declined, so...
of course the Arab rejects the idea of splitting the pizza in half, because the person requesting to share the pizza is just a small boy, descendants of former owner of the house 2000 years ago. A third is more than enough. the boy insists on his own half pizza share, when he can just stay together in Arab house, enjoying the pizza and life together peacefully.
@@yonatansolomon9833 No you got it wrong, it's a man having a pizza and feeling generous and shared a slice with another man, then the other man held a gun to the first mans head and is saying they deserve the entirety of the pizza.
How come these Jews speak English so fluently? Were they born in the US or somewhere else in the West? And then moved to the West Bank and got basically free land stolen from the Palestinians?
no, he actually mentioned in the video that he spoke to mostly american settlers and that they present around 15% of the population. (also this whole video is 7 years ago so some stuff may be outdated)
I have enjoyed many of your videos but this one is a joke. Could you do a video more from the Palestinian perspective and maybe dig into the connections of on how the U.S. funds many of Israels operations?
@@jackkessler9876 Okay dokey, it's all just Muslim Intolerance. So Israeli tolerance and fairness would give citizenship to all legal residents of their territories, right? And not just those that are of the confirmed national faith so that Judaism can retain its place as the center of Israel's legal, governmental and cultural affairs? Fact is, if the population of Gaza, the West Bank, and the Palestinian refugees were allowed to come home and become normal citizens, 'Israel' as a concept would cease to exist and the 'Israelis' would be a minority population again. This isn't about Muslim Intolerance; Israel is a country of people who felt an unjust boot on their necks for centuries (i.e. the CHRISTIAN nations of the world primarily) and now feel entitled to put their own boot on someone else's neck to make sure it isn't done to them again. They have gone from victims to oppressors, tragedy made circular.
@ENDEAVOR RADIO CONTROL if they did they would have started another war with Egypt and Jordan. thay don't want a war becuse they have a peace treaty with them and that is the only thing stopping the Muslim governments from starting a war and invading israel. plus the wast bank was given to the Palestinians by Jordan so they can start building a government again.
It’s not unique. Morocco is using the exact same policy in Western Sahara. Interesting thing is, the world only seems to care when it’s Jews who are doing it.
If any of you believe that the great powers will ever care about the UN without the veto you are delusional. Removing the veto is destroying the Security Council.
Because Israel got power, arms, tech, international support, money and the mindset of not being regretful even if they're stealing those lands... Free real estate
I actually thought they were living in tents or huts. You don't imagine nice and big neighborhoods when you hear the word settlement. It looks like a nice place to live.
lol isn't that same pony-tailed settler who was talking about his right of this land they dreamed of 2000 years ago and he said "we own everything" in the intervew with The atlantic so he turned peacfull and chill now ?
People do technically have a right to change their mind. But you certainly have the right to question if they have. That's the fun thing about the internet; it is forever. People will find you contradicting yourself in the past or present and hold it against you, but I do think intent and reason matters.
@Zoltan Harangozo its ironic because modern 'Israelis' are all decend from europe and not the middle east. Do you think that israel was just empty and before the Jews no one knew let alone lived in the area? So if I would argue that Egyptians had concurred this place from the assyrians before the jews came would you agree that syrians/Egyptians should own israel because they were there before the jews came.
Wow you guys got so much of that wrong. It is traditionally believed that the Israelites were exiled from the land of Israel 2000 years ago by the romans. During the Middle Ages, the Jews were naturally divided to two groups - Ashkenazi Jews and Sephardic (or Mizrachi) Jews. The Ashkenazi Jews are the ones who migrated to eastern and central Europe, while the Sephardic Jews are the ones who migrated to the Iberian peninsula, from which they were exiled as well in 1492, and then migrated mainly to North Africa and the Middle East. In the late 1800s, Zionism - the nationalist Jewish movement - emerged in Europe. Theodor Herzl took great diplomatic, organizational and physical action to bring the Jews from over the world together and get a charter of an establishment of a Jewish state in the then-Ottoman ruled Land of Israel (aka Palestine), while supporting Jewish settlement in the region, which started in 1882. After WW1, the British took hold of Palestine, which was by then settled by both Arabs and Jews, and in 1947 the British declared than on May 15, 1948 they will live Palestine and let the UN decide what’s going to happen next. After a months-long inspection of the area lead by UNSCOP - the UN special committee on Palestine, the UN general assembly voted in favor of a resolution that stated that 45% of land will make a Palestinian state, the other 55% will make a Jewish state and Jerusalem will be an international territory controlled by the UN. While the Jews were happy with this offer, the Palestinians rejected it and started a war on the Jews. Mid-war, the Israeli state was declared on May 14, 1948, and the rest is history...
The Time is not far when Many of the Jews Will Embrace The Islam and the wrest will be dead. By the way This comment is only for Jews. Jews were Called Muslims until The Prophet Hazrat Isa A.S Came. They tried to Murder Him. But Allah Saved Him And Raised Him And He Will Again Come. And All The Humen being Will be Muslims.
@@explorerofyoutube1066 The Time is not far when Many of the Jews Will Embrace The Islam and the wrest will be dead. By the way This comment is only for Jews. Jews were Called Muslims until The Prophet Hazrat Isa A.S Came. They tried to Murder Him. But Allah Saved Him And Raised Him And He Will Again Come. And All The Humen being Will be Muslims.
@@yurichtube1162 The Time is not far when Many of the Jews Will Embrace The Islam and the wrest will be dead. By the way This comment is only for Jews. Jews were Called Muslims until The Prophet Hazrat Isa A.S Came. They tried to Murder Him. But Allah Saved Him And Raised Him And He Will Again Come. And All The Humen being Will be Muslims.
I have been there just after the US announced they'll move their embassy to Jerusalem. The palestian west bank is what can be described as a "3rd world country". It starts right at the borders between the two parts of Jerusalem. Once you leave the Jewish part heavily sponsored by the USA money, you will find your self in a city in a different realm. You can find sights such as roads flooded with running/overflooding or broken sewers/pipes. Unattained infrastructure and buildings. The land is truly beautiful..however what the people have created there "in the name of god" - as they like to phrase it, is an abomination to any level of spirituality. I say the UN should resolve this as these two parties have zero respect towards one another and each side will use all that is to their disposal to undermine the position of the other party. The heavily disputed areas should become something like Kosovo ( a 3rd country alongside with Israel and Palestine). Otherwise this will never stop - endlessly fuelled by the abrahamic curse!
@Alexplus20 Islamic mind wash is real thing. Even if they don't have food to eat and home to live they always choose Religion because they are mindwashed from childhood that Allah is everything and can't ignore Allah or else you will end up in Hell. Wiser people will settle and live happily.
"Ideological motivations are far down the line..." This piece is a excellent mirror for most "first world" communities. We are innocent of our collective action and their implications by claiming a right to a way of life which by its underlying ideology deprives others of it. Heck, that map of Israel might as well be US cities in the 50s when the freeway system surrounded and cut through predominantly poor black communities, and today are again being pushed out by gentrification. Like the Arabs of the West Bank and Gaza Strip, they were squeezed there by restrictive laws and tacit social agreements of an oppressor claiming self defense and the carrying on the burden of civilization and all its necessities: education, commerce, and most importantly the use of violence, of course keeping it in the hands of the chosen. The ideological motivations that are far down the line root themselves in the belief that only a certain chosen can carry on that burden of civilization which leads to certain conflict and injustice, in many ways corrupting all other ideology or motivation. It is incompatible with democracy. Either we are all chosen, or none of us are.
I don't think that you can equate the situation there with the US-American conflict of "races". It is a huge misunderstanding many Americans tend to make. Almost all conflicts in Europe and the Middle East are based on religion, ethnicity, economic differences or culture, rarely on the colour of skin, or as you put it, "race".
@@ahwasright1364 Weird... that's almost word-for-word the same mindset that almost got the Jewish people annihilated. You'd think that, as the recipients of so much unearned abuse, they'd learn to avoid dishing it out themselves. Talk about slow learners...
I could not believe my ears when the middle-aged man on the couch said "there's a really nice country club"... Like are you serious?? This is so messed up.. They successfully live like they don't have a care in the world and like it's rightfully their land to live on. And I think they actually and wholeheartedly believe that. Mind-boggling......
It feels a bit unfair ( more than a little bit). It feels a lot like bullying. It's like- "We are gonna build in such a way so that should these people be able to have a stand one day, there won't be anywhere to put it." 😔
When you realize the reason settler's could do this in the first place was because Israel rightfully captured the land following a war which was incited by Palestinians, what seems unfair is that Palestine didn't just accept the UN partition plan/avoid inciting wars over the years because if they did they would have saved thousands of Palestinian lives. Instead, they were too focused on eradicating Israel because they selfishly wanted an Arab only state. The way they are currently treated is incredibly unfair, especially because their ancestors who refused to make peace caused this, but it is also reasonable to understand that Israel was provoked over the years and can't really compromise with people who refuse to share.
@@AlexG-oo8kt This is the way I see it. When people call Israel the oppressor it’s a shame because it makes it sound like a simple relationship between a bully and a victim. Of course there’s more layers to it than that though. Palestinian civilians are definitely victims, but not because Israel wants them to suffer. Palestinians are the victims to the choices of their own authorities. If Palestinian leaders were initially interested in working with Israel then that is what would have happened.
@@AlexG-oo8kt this sounds like what every abuser in every abusive relationship says. " I only hit you because you provoked me". Winning a war doesn't mean you treat people as less than, especially if your goal is peace.
I think what he meant was that: (a) the settlers manipulated the visit to look "normal", harmless, non-political, welcoming, familial. (That's just clever politics). (b) He probably found that any pointed questions about their "right to be there" went "over their heads". (That's just subconscious denial).
Some music. Two morons beating on a BBQ top. God promised you nothing stupid. Its Palestine. The aboriginal inhabitants are the children of Abraham too. The Jews are not Semites. Thats why they wont allo DNA testing to justify their claims. They are Russians.
I want to see a part 3 on the perspective of the Palestinians.
TechRax love you vids
MyImList
Let me take your land and then tall me how do you feel ??
I want to see a part 3 on the perspective of the phones.
Salah Aldeen Al Ayoubi did you saw this land before hundred years it was all sand we make it good and then you wanted it too
עינת פורטר
You made something that’s not yours good
( big difference)
As an Israeli, I think that you should do a part 3 where you interview the Palestinians
@steve warren i dont believe this person will ever do that
عبدالله العتيبي never happened. There was never a Palestinian forced to move out so Israelis could move in. Although there were many times Israelis were forced to move out so Palestinians could move in
@steve warren well, that wasn't their land. Doesn't matter if it was being used or not. It doesn't make any better.
steve warren Sure if the land was empty. Why take it? If I find an empty house could I take it. It would of solved homeless problems. UN even said it’s illegal
Phonzo Cisne in the Oslo Accords in 1993 the Israelis and Palestinians made agreements to make 3 areas. Area C, where all the settlements are were decided to be under Israeli security and administrative control.
It's been three years since this video uploaded, still no Palestinian part.
I was thinking the same thing. It is a very one-sided docu-series. Americans are basically born to be in support of Israel. But honestly... the way they treat the Palestinians is freaking inhumane.
They live like kings here.
Vox are libshits
If you guys read the Bible, you ar gonna understand why all of the fight. This is the same thing of you are living in your house with your freedom, then it came a new empire and force you get out, after hundreds of years, your people have the opportunity to come back, they develop the country and the foreigns see that is good and try to get in, but Israel didn’t accept this because old bad experiences. What make me wonder was, why did they give up Gaza?
@@patrixevo give up? Lol funny guy. Yes, they just gave it up without a fight.... what history books are you reading?
I would love to know which country you come from? And that if you're also ok with 'giving it back' to whoever originally inhabited it 100's of years ago? LOL, i'm gunna bet its a no.
This is so upsetting to see. I’m Jewish and I just can’t understand how they can be happy there. Seemingly oblivious to all the misery it’s caused. They need to dismantle these settlements - it’s sad but they should never have been allowed to build them.
Thank God you are not making the decisions or Israel wouldnt exist
when you pampered by entitlement and privilege for so long, you tend to believe it's a fundamental right.
@@hyperquantum3020so Israelis can build in the west bank but Palestinians can’t build in tel aviv and main land israel?
They are greedy and selfish
@@hyperquantum3020that’s the goal
If an Italian finds a nice part of France and builds a nice house there, does it become part of Italy? Afterwards saying that it's ok because it used to be part of the Roman empire?
THISSSSS THIIIISSSS OMG
OMG, SPQR
Nope. That land doesn’t officially belong to anybody. Can’t say stealing if it’s not anybody’s
Exactly, so just like the modern day Italians don't claim that all the parts under the former Roman Empire qualify as "their land", Palestinians should also accept that this is not "their land". Land keeps changing owners over the course of history. New countries are born over old. Oh wait, Palestine was never a country in the first place. Just a region ruled by one major empire after another.
@@akarshshekhar5233 So your saying one state solution and palestinian become citizen of israel?
PS: Are you really not getting the analogy?
0:36 "they dont lock their doors" they dont because tho whole settlement is surrounded by fences and gates sometimes even with guards.
Why do you think an illegal settlement on stolen land needs fences and guards?
Zoltan Harangozo actually you aren’t technically allowed a Jewish state until the messiah comes.
Zoltan Harangozo and Americans should get out of North America, also the Australians should get out of Australia. Also England should get out of Scotland and Northern Ireland.
@Zoltan Harangozo Israel has only ever tried to defend itself.
India stands with the land of Jews 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
Well it just means that those people living inside the settlement don't do crime with each other and crime is only possible outside
Wow they really live like king in middle conflict zone. Remind me the famous quote: one person's utopia is another's dystopia can't be more relevant today
Yes kind of reminded of a scene from the movie Schindler's list where a German solder with high rank stays at his big villa at the hill top and the Jews are seen working in the camps.
Not that extreme but there are similarities
Arabs can also live like kings, they just need to decide that their kids future is more important than violence and religious revenge
I know this comment is 2 years old, but it’s _very_ relevant today 😢
@@likhatako913 If the hilltop was overlooking Gaza, it would be just exactly that extreme.
Saludos ,but where ? In Haiffa,Jerusalem or in Egypt ,Syria ...cause in Cisjordania it Will be full of Israelíes...ni ?@@danielgreen5803
While I realize that comparing Israeli settlements in the West Bank to US Suburbs is meant to normalize them, for me and probably other viewers, it's also an indictment of the suburbs, in the context of their broader historical, socio-economic, racial, and political dimensions.
I want to point out that the way Israel uses subsidies and public infrastructure to encourage less-affluent settlers to move there, is also very reminiscent of how the US government used policy to favor settler-colonial projects, such as the Homestead Act and other land subsidies in our country's expanding Western frontiers during the 1800's. All while the indigenous peoples of those lands got herded into reservations, or killed when they resisted their dispossession.
Israelis remain indigenous to the land more than the Arabs so using the word indigenous while wrongly referring to a group of people who are not actually indigenous is a fallacy
This all seems analogous to the US colonisation of A
The 1500 years were the Palestinians were jews, muslims, and Christian coexisted
@@GrandImmortalIf being indigenous doesn't expire after 2000 years then any genetic decendants of the amalekites and moabites have a better claim to the land than Israel. The past doesn't matter except that it's not traditional colonialism because Israel has no other state period. That does make it very different tho. Israel is literally the only group of people without a state, living completely spread out around the world in other states, who have re-established their own state in places they werent even living en mass. Completely unprecedented
@@GrandImmortal???????????????
With the current events, now will be a great time to publish part 3 to let people know how Palestinians live
No one's going to risk being beheaded attempting to get the Palestinian perspective.
It’s strange - he references a next part at the end but I can’t see it anywhere... not sure if it has been removed or was never made
he already quite Vox. Perhaps, he can do something in his own UA-cam channel
@@InspiredByReason how Many Israeli head you have seen in the group from 1948. The world have seen a lots of Palestinian children buried inside the debris... You invest a lot to spread your lies. But God is there remember
Im turkish and i will not forget. One day .....
The fact that it has been 4 years and still no Palestinian perspective just sais a lot about the situation
Because no one cares
@@Starky513 which says a lot about the situation.
@@Starky513 , you're obviously wrong. Many people care.
Even a neutral like me, surely wants to know and hear from the Palestinian's perspective.
In fact, even some British and American citizens are increasingly interested in hearing more from them,
as the media attention tends to be so concentrated on the Jews' perspective.
Because the perspective of a state which declared anti Semitic and imperial war on Jews is just that: anti Semitic. Why do you think the Iron Dome exists? Ever heard of the 47-49 Arab-Israeli war?
@@chinoschmino9108 I suppose its all one sided then 🙄. I just see entrenched racism and a complete lack of humanity and empathy from all. Israelis wouldn't be prepared to live under the conditions they empose on others, Palestinians need to accept expecting 9 million to leave is an impossible wish. Its always someone else's fault.
A question for Pro-Israel peeps: If the Muslim refugees in Europe want to start a country in Spain, using the same excuses Jews used: We are running away from war, this land was ours 1000 years ago, we are no longer a minority and we deserve our own land, God told us to do this. What would be your reaction? Since it's basically the same thing, but with Muslims instead of Jews?
It is absolutely not "basically the same thing". before israel the British mandate ( the government there at the time) promised the Jews they could have a country there.
The king Is back
So it was stolen? It is the same thing, same excuses used to justify 21st century colonialism.
Britain did it, like it did in so many other place around the world.
NaDoubleSer it was stolen from the Ottoman Empire not so called Palestine
The king Is back
What it was called should not be an argument. Let's call it Ottamistan, what does that change? You just admitted to it being stolen, which basically sums up the whole conflict.
Article 49 of the Fourth Geneva Convention states: “The Occupying Power shall not deport or transfer parts of its own civilian population into the territory it occupies.” It also prohibits the “individual or mass forcible transfers, as well as deportations of protected persons from occupied territories"
Israel is making it more difficult for Palestinians to form their own country. At the same time they also do not want to give Palestinians in West Bank equal voting rights because they are still outnumbered. Stop the settlements, let Palestinians have their state and freedom.
читайте Коран! Искусственная это палестина с террористами из Саудии, названными в КГБ СССР в 1967 году для войны и террора с Израилем! Израиль более 2000 лет назад существовал и 2 раза был разрушен! В 1948 году по решению ООН Израиль возродился на своих землях, частично оккупированных Иорданией! Это Самария, Иулея, Западный берег, Иерусалим и земли в Иордании по мандату ООН! Арабские страны Иран,Ирак,Сирия,Ливан,Египет,Иордания совместно с российскими инструкторами, солдатами, офицерами на танках, самолетах, ПВО, военных кораблях напали на Израиль и были разгромлены и опозорены!
Россия, это спонсор террора и войн!
В Коране нет палестины и этого народа врунов!
Это саудиты, выброшенные в провинцию Иордания за террор, которых король Иордании приказал уничтожать как бешеных собак!
Израиль продолжает дело иорданского короля!
Не хотите жить мирно, умирайте за русские фашистские идеи!
≈===============
Интерес каждой отдельной страны в мире должен состоять в том, чтобы остановить подстрекательство Палестинской автономии. ПА поощряет терроризм и платит террористам, убивающим евреев. Государство Израиль в первую очередь привержено безопасности Израиля".
Resolution 181 of the UN acknowledges the Two State solution of 1947. The Arab league walked out on international law and has been violating these laws ever since by Not recognizing a two state solution not accepting Israel as a state when Palestine was Never a sovereign state 😊
@@robertk6640 tell that to American Indians that were forced off of their lands to make room for white colonials. Wherever white, colonials go, indigenous populations are displaced. South Africa, Australia, Hawaii, so it goes….. and conveniently they say what you say. It’s just disgusting.
@@Gentilejedi you’ve got a totally the opposite way the Jews are the American Indians because they were their first then came the Arabs thousands of years later OK so if you’re going to make a comparison, then allow me to make a comparison to you if American Indians and white colonial us are living in that area the size of New Jersey and the American Indians from their region want to claim their land back would that be OK with you because that’s what Israel is doing Israel is his fight for independence when the British left the area next to another people who colonize the land later on this is not about whites, moving into an area they call America which is two continents. Founded by Portuguese, Spanish French and English combined. This is about two people claiming the same area because they both have sister is there so if you have a problem with Jews living in their own area, then you should have a problem with Greeks living in Greece or Irish people living in Ireland.
@@robertk6640read history Israel started with al nakba
"its like two guys negotiating over a pizza while one of them is eating it"
Mood
Yeah but after we had a fight and you lost, I’d say you’d be lucky you’re getting a slice.
@@nm5612 You can't displace a people if you win a fight. Dictatorships have done that throughout time, but if israel wants to paint itself as a democracy it can't do that
@@nm5612 This.
@@nm5612 *This*
It's like interviewing a bully and asking them how happy they are enjoying the stuff they took from victims.
@Haya Almousa how can you define that west bank is their lands?
@@YusssoM he must be referring previous two wars, where Israel was attacked by Arab countries not once but twice, they did lose(Israel enemies) as a result, israel got more land after war
Palestine had its own country and decided to go to war with israel because they wanted everything.
@@abhinavthakur8232 4 wars actually. The first three in the 20th century, then another war in the early 21st century (that’s where they created the Iron Dome). After that, a bunch of unofficial battles
Israel and Britain has offered to give Palestine the majority of the entire land multiple times and only give a fraction to Israel and Israel even accepted the offer to take a tiny part of the land, Palestinians refuse to live alongside Israeli’s and the conflict that is still here today is because of them, I don’t feel sorry they brought this on themselves
"No one seriously considers it possible to remove all 400,000 residents"
But they have no problem with forceful removal of more than 2,000,000 native people from there.
Well jews didn't ask Arabs to invade them , they did out of their volition, had the Arabs won Israel would have been occupied, they chose to invade and lost it's like east Prussians(germans ) complaining about the territory lost to Poland after WW2
They're not removing any natives from any place at all... I have no clue where you got that from. Also, Israel was invaded by its neighbors. That was their choice, not Israel's. Israel gained these lands from a defensive war, and they've owned them for 50 years, just get over it.
Coconut Pal I think he is talking about the six day Arab-Israeli war
Coconut Pal no during the Nabka Palestinians fled as refugees expecting to return to their homes shortly. Whilst some were terrorised away the majority fled due to expectations of conflict. Also some remained due to being allied with the Israelis. I have no view just believe in clearing up fact. Not that the fact they were not forced out makes it justifiable at all.
@@erica8332 the arabs invaded when the jews declared independence. you know we have the arab league we are sworn to help each other, if another war happen which seams like it. Israel wouldn't stand a chance
As a person in the interview clearly said, “negotiations are like two persons debating over who will eat a pizza by one person is eating it”
and then laughed
Yup.. Very well said!
And gloating over it.
When one person fights the other to take the entire Pizza, he should be thankful that he is even getting anything. Especially when he has 22 bakeries
Its a great documentary and you have shown the Jewish side of the story. I think its time for part 3 consisting of the perspective of Palestinian side.
@SS You must be the least humane person I've ever come across..
@SS You are actually telling me that Palestinian lives do not matter.. That was you very first sentancde, that their story didn't matter. Shame on you!! I don't care if people believe in Jahve, Allah, Buddha or Thor. But saying that the story of the Palestinians in Palestine do not matter is simply outrageous. Let me guess, you are American?
@SS your name and the side that u picked dont add up, just saying lol
Thats true theirs no upload
@@HillelSe I forgot TRT
They dont feel like its a conflict place because they are in control and can do anything,
And I can instantly tell you have never been to Israel.
@@user-xq8hm6zm4b
Who would want to?
@@kp5602 I wouldn't want too*
Go there yourself and you'll see why many tourists think it's a great place to go too.
@@user-xq8hm6zm4b
No dont worry ive checked international polls and it seems that the majority infact; do not want to visit a landgrabbing wartorn area
@@kp5602 Then why don't you go and ask the people who have visited Isreal and see what they say?
Bold choice to leave the comments open.
that's the difference between truth and master race Religions bent on world conquest.
Vox = Truth
@@ahwasright1364 X to doubt
Oh well...
@@ahwasright1364 it's a Pakistani run channel
Pakistan does not accept isreal
As a south african there's no mistake. This is exactly what apartheid was. Israeli people get to live in a "first world" country while the Palestinians live in a literal war zone.
Shoudn't the fair comparison be with the Palestinians living in Israel? Apartheid was segregation and degradation of people living in the same country, Israelis living in West Bank are more like a case of colonization...
and then painting the settlers as the "civilized, educated and democratic" and the victims as "uncivilized and terrorists"
@@LautaroTessi I'm from SA too. When I look at Israeli's all I see are Afrikaners and the apartheid gov
God promised us this land? Really?
@@LautaroTessi Spot on
while they're on cloud 9, right next door a Palestinian family is trying to find something to eat with no home in Palestinian land. They're being pushed out of their homes because someone wants "a nice view"
I’m Arab and Black and I swear this is racism at its finest! It has nothing to do with religion or is a long war no no. It’s a country continuously noticing and allowing settlers to enter foreign land with out any reproductions. Occupier (Israel) and occupied (Palestine) say it how it is . Never was a war because US funded the 4 strongest military in the world
Social justice nonsense at it's finest.
@Elias Michan no im saying Palestinians in Israel are not homeless, no pun im serious they’re free. But Palestinians in palatine are homeless and it’s due to Israel settlers constantly moving which we both agree on. But we have to also address the fact that the Palestinians in Israel have laws discriminating against them which is a fact. Look man as a Palestinian all we want is peace. But we will not give up our land. A 2 state solution was a good idea but was not respected and it’s so sad how we always get the short end of the stick due to America not holding the Israeli regime accountable
Because the video was showing a man who moved in as a settler and his reason for coming is “a nice view”
@@joeswanson7675 while I don't support what Netanyahu's done, I think that the idea that Jews immigrating into Israel are 'settlers' and that America needs to 'hold Israel accountable' isn't necessarily accurate
You didn’t show the security apparatus that protects these guys.
5.32 is that not the security apparatus. Goodness it's just another perspective that shows the problem in the West Bank and why they are settling. If you don't see the whole picture, how are you going to resolve it? I didn't know how good the housing and school system was for Jews.
Watch the first video.
Happiness for them and sadness for Palestinians
Even your religion don't say that
You know the truth but try to ignore it
Shame on you shalom on you
Where's education system for the other people living in front of your house
I don't think he was allowed to
you have to protect yourelves from muslims. everybody knows that
the question isn't "why do people want to live there"; it's "why do people think they can do whatever they want"?
Very astute.
Because they can.
Dark Fladramon The question wasn't posed to you, moron. Don't jump at the occasion to be edgy, it's very transparent.
wishcraft4u2 Doesn't matter. What I said is 100 % true.
Because it is their land. They have every right to settle there.
This was one of the best episodes of Black Mirror yet.
Literally everyone in the video: "It's free real estate"
though it costs millions
Stolen from Palestinians
@Hey yo I hope someone builds a home in your background and claim its their holy right. Lets see how you would like that
@Hey yo Palestinians are the real descendants of Hebrews and Canaanites who mixed with Arabs and Crusaders. They've just been Arabized as have everyone in the Levant. Those coins are our history, not yours.
@Hey yo It used to be Jewish, yes. But it is no longer. Imagine this scenario: you happen to live in a house that was once stolen 100 years ago. You do not approve of that, but, still, it is the only house that you own. Then the grandchildren of the man who stole that house break in and tell them to leave your house and pass its possession to them, offering you no new house in return. Would you listen? If not, your argument that Israel was once a Jewish land isn't a strong one. Sure, Israel is a country and deserves to be one. But the same applies to Palestine. I know that Palestinians don't have as much history as the Jews, nor are they a distinct people or cultural or ethnic group like the Jews are, but that doesn't mean that they don't deserve to live in their own homes.
Look, if peace is eventually found, Israel itself will benefit from vast wealth, reduced tensions, much higher security and, duh, peace, and, consequently, a higher standard of living. In this case, we will also finally be able to grant full focus to contributing to actual progress as a species and moving the world as a whole forward, instead of focusing on petty land disputes and useless (on the global scale) military. Without war, we will also most likely grow, at worst, into one of the most advanced, innovative, and prosperous nations in the world and, at best, into the single most advanced nation on the planet. So even making compromises such as giving up land will more than pay off in the long run. Please think big rather thinking locally.
on a serious note, what would the reaction be if some Palestinians decided to build a neighborhood in the blue area?
there are allot of Palestinians villages in Israel
but they have Israeli citizenship so you see them in blue
unoefxz It would get destroyed before they even finished it
unoefxz None. Israel will allow it.
They have.
To be honest, I don't think the average Israeli has a huge hatred for Palestinians, only their extremist government
The settlers point of view is so onesided. They're enjoying a semi-luxurious lifestyle on the account of suffering and oppressed palestinians. No one has a problem with people living happy and fruitful lives. The problem is making their happiness depend on the misery of others.
Does that "no one" of yours include average Palestinian? Let them first acknowledge Israel's right to exist, then we'll talk about human misery.
I do this all the time, according to progressives. Doesn't bother me.
But Israel can forget that they exist? We want them to be treated fair not like lower cast people
I couldn't have said it better myself
Same could be said about every developed country on the planet. How often do you think about the African child soldiers who mined the elements in your smartphone?
Incredible how human beings can egoistically focus on their well being, while crushing the minimum rights (of also live a good life) of others… I’m ashamed of being part of this society… Someone up there is seeing everything we are doing…
This has been happening for thousands of years, all around the world, it's human nature.
@@ladiddas im ashamed. i guess you are not …
@@ladiddas another point i would like to add… i’m using your words… this is happening for thousands of years, so you are saying we can fly a big box of metal with people inside, weighing 400tons and our minds and sense of humanity got stuck in time ??????? that is why things like this happen still today… good mentality… congrats to you as well… keep it up
Unfortunately, we appear to have about the same percentage of ignorant and arrogant people that we've had all along. I guess some of us went further down the path of evolution than others.@@hitmancastle
When you say 'I'm ashamed of being part of this community' may I ask whether you mean you're actually living in one of the settlements?
will u talk to the Palestinians also ? the one's that are living in the green region?
Yes.. i guess
i think he will, maybe in the next video
Steven Wang you're 30 seconds late! Lol
I know I wouldn't
jay diggy?
are you serious
there is a palestianian youtube called
cobra 123473
go watch his vids he saves animals :[
he lives in palestain
they cant even have drugs to save some animals
only doctors can and most doctors are not that good
Why they want a two states solution,yet make their homes in a land which should be of citizens of the 2nd state?
Dr Guillotin
You understand the rules of war have changed over time right.
Just as in 1918 we started (and in 1945 mostly finished with) ending the idea of ‘might makes right’ we have abolished numerous spoils of war, when you conquer a city you no longer get to take half the women as prizes for soldier and 2/3rds of the men as slaves, we bind ourselves in law to protect us and human civilisation from destroying ourselves.
Humanity evolved over time, in the modern world, the fact the Israeli military is able to occupy the land doesn’t give the Isreali state the right to govern it, not the Isreali citizenry the right to extract it.
If you want other examples, frances occupation of northern Mali on behalf of Mali doesn’t give France the right to extract taxes, apply laws, or settle the desert. British occupation in Afghanistan doesn’t give Britain the legal right to govern the mountains.
The international community seems to want a Two State Solution. Israel agreed to a Two State Solution in 1948, and then was invaded by all its neighbors. (Happy Israel Independence Day!) Israelis today are probably very divided over whether to pursue a Two State Solution.
@@nlald the issue is palestinians dont want a two state solution tho.
@@MrCalls1 well you can't compare illegal occupation to the jews that historically lived in the region and therefore has a rightful claim to it, on same grounds as palastinians, plus holocaust and the Jewish history gives them a right to own piece of land. Also you do realize how small Israel is right, this makes a two state system almost impossible to maintain especially due to the animosity between the two groups historically.
There's a difference between the government and the people, and he talked about the the most extreme people.
I am sure this comment section will be full with civilized and intellectual arguments.
Surely!
Just reading a few of them gave me cancer and AIDS so yeah it's gotta be some quality comments.
Well I think that no one person should be barred from anyplace as at the end of the day we are all humans. But I think the settlements are a problem. Maybe don't build any more.
You know, I don't mind if upper-middle class people have their fun in these very nice communities and do whatever, but isn't this adding to the tensions and hostility between the Israelis and the Palestinians? If the Palestinians and the Israelis both agreed to that that land over there is yours and that land over there is ours, and this agreement helped them come to ceasefire to prevent them from killing each over, then why are the Israelis breaking that treaty and settling there when they could literally settle anywhere else in the world?
well the same thing would happened😕?
Next on Vox: Why the Trail of Tears was not really that bad. We bought their land for more then market value. Colonial expansion is not that bad after all according to Vox.
That’s a bit uncharitable. I didn’t think this video was that bad. It didn’t try to justify settlements, just show what they were like.
@@ShnoogleMan The Time is not far when Many of the Jews Will Embrace The Islam and the wrest will be dead.
By the way
This comment is only for Jews.
Jews were Called Muslims until The Prophet Hazrat Isa A.S Came. They tried to Murder Him. But Allah Saved Him And Raised Him And He Will Again Come. And All The Humen being Will be Muslims.
@@kamranmisri2366 You’re literally calling for genocide. How does it feel to be no better than the worst of the worst people in this video?
@trollnerd well Muslims were living in Spain just 500 years ago, I guess they gotta go take it.
Oh wait Italians actually must take all of Europe,
@trollnerd by my Israel has no rightful claim to the land if Palestine but is a colonising it since "historical ties" isn't an excuse.
By logic Palestine also doesn't have the right to kick out all the Israelis and claim all the land.
Therefore the only fair solution is two states, those settlers make this impossible since they blur the borders and for that they are responsible for the continuation of the killing in both Palestine and Israel.
Humanising serious political issues is one of Vox's strengths.
It's good to see everyone as human, of course people on both sides try to dehumanize the other because it's not wrong to hate something that isn't human, but that's not the reality of life. Yes, I believe that what the Israeli settlers are doing is illegal and very wrong, but blindly hating a faceless other is not the way, and the only way we'll ever come to respect one another and overt war and chaos is by peacefully cooperating and realizing that we are all people. One people :)
***** dude... Sooo wrong.
"Humanizing" apparently joining the oppressors in celebrating the supremacy of their own hypocrisy over justice.
They'll probably talk to the Palestinians at some point. Remember, this is an incomplete series.
I don't see any celebrating in this video. They're just showing the reality. These are people moving out there, not monsters. That doesn't mean that the settlements are a good thing or even harmless, but it does mean that there is no clean and perfect solution to this. If Palestine ever becomes it's own state, a significant number of it's citizens are _going_ to be Israeli Jews, unless you're advocating that they round up and forcibly remove a half a million people (something that doesn't tend to happen peacefully).
A couple of weeks ago I took a virtual tour with 3 Palestinian olive growers who live in Gaza, but their groves have been in their families for hundreds of years. They are supposed to be allowed in to their trees to care for them and to harvest olives. Unfortunately, the settlements have built fences with locked gates & someone is supposed to be there at designated times to unlock the gates. They don't always show up and thus the farmers cannot harvest their olives. This settlement has no sewer system so sewage from this settlement just free flows down into the olive groves and the farmers can't get in. Teens from the settlements hassle the farmers and I found it to be eye opening. My grandfather from Jerusalem used to be friends with Palestinians and he would help them harvest and in turn they allowed him to take a share of olives to press for his family. Those days are long gone. I am sure not everyone behaves the way the settlers in this settlement do, but things are not easy or good for Gaza's olive farmers.
Sure not everyone behaves the way the settlers in this settlement do ?
So I break into your house , I beat you out of it ... and you'll be greatfull if let you in for a cup of water ? -_- ok
There are no settlements in gaza.
The Time is not far when Many of the Jews Will Embrace The Islam and the wrest will be dead.
By the way
This comment is only for Jews.
Jews were Called Muslims until The Prophet Hazrat Isa A.S Came. They tried to Murder Him. But Allah Saved Him And Raised Him And He Will Again Come. And All The Humen being Will be Muslims.
Israel doesn’t control Gaza? U should prob blame that on hamas
@@yaakovgrunsfeld Israel is a settlement. 🤯 More than 50% of the population are European Ashkenazi, and so is p much everyone in power. Middle Eastern Jews are second class citizens and have been since Israels founding. Read what Ben-Gurion said about brown Jews. Israel is a European settlement created entirely for white Christians to consolidate power in Europe, at the expense of the brown native inhabitants of Palestine. Just like America, Australia, Argentina, etc.
How can these people live so relaxed when the other half of this land is chaos😐
they dont. this video is a lie.
@@operator9858 is that so? How are they now? Is there any war going on now?
@@toinfinityandbeyond4027 these settlers are one of the main reasons for the conflicts. and has the war really ever stopped for israel?
This comment aged badly
@@operator9858 I am amazed by their god-level of hypocrisy.
If you're ever in doubt who the oppressor is, just look at who is in power and who is suffering.
@metsfan92286 Seriously, what is wrong with you?
@metsfan92286 That’s quite simple- it’s not theirs. It’s pure theft.
@@amrshalabymusic If it's pure theft for Israelis to be in the West Bank, by that logic, it's pure theft for the Navajo to be on their indigenous lands.
@@amrshalabymusic you should be referring to arabs who stole jewish land in 637 AD when islamic empire conquered israel from eastern roman empire
@@Nemo_Anom The Palestinians have equal claim over the land- historically and genetically. By your logic though, the Brits should go back to Germany. The Australians should go back to Europe. Some Americans should invade Ireland. Common sense is a rarity these days.
Why don't you show the Palestinian parts of the West Bank???
Because it is not a good place.
They're always showing that on vice.
So he can keep his head
They were living there for century and haven't managed to create a stabe siciety with a good life standard. Israel managed that within 50 years.
pička nailed it
Behind all of this is men women and kids that were killed, arrested , evacuated and lived the worst life that you can ever imagine
@Shikhar nope the word is you just mentioned directly translates to peace
@Shikhar no it isnt
First look at south east asia which account for third of the muslim population
And the turks and central asian countries and the russian also
Second there was wars but people chose to convert
Look how many christians still live in syria, egypt and lebanon, how many used tp live there and with palestineans before the racist thing called israel came
Look how spain was when it was ruled by muslims....there was people of the three religions living peacefuly in the most devoloped eueopean country in that time
Look what muslims brought to europe by rulling over spain and look what europeans did by colonizing the world
@Shikhar ahhh Islam spread in Southeast Asia through trade. Maybe in India, not here in SEA. Read the history book. Same as Islam in China. The merchants and scholar brings the religion.
@@ahmadanbar4473 actually spain was more advanced during islamic period... Look it up it worth knowing😁
@Shikhar the ideology spread through war but it did not exile people from their home it gave you a choice. All nations of north Africa are native to their own land and have their own culture and Language. the Iranians still speak Farsi. this goes to show that Muslims did not exile anyone, yes they went to war but all the native were given a choice to stay but they have to pay taxes and even muslims themselves had to pay taxes. btw no religion in the world gave this type of choice for the people that did not follow it and that is why many Jews were prosecuted under roman role and they know themselves that the live a better life under the islamic role. in the argument against Israel is not the war but the ethnic cleansing of the Palestinians which is obvious in the video.
They feel safe because they know the Palestinians have almost nothing left.
Palestinians can invest in 1000s of rocket but not for welfare of themselves?
Choose better argument my friend
@@dre4merf498 🤦♂️
Which they shouldn’t, they’ve been given multiple chances to have their own country and rejected it everytime
Dre4mer F
Whats the point of that when you have so little land anyways thats decreasing every year its almost laughable
Ohfu Kayou
Except by that logic if the native Americans lets say (somehow) got the support of all major powers to establish a state essentially the entire west coast and half of mid west like 50-50% would you be okay with that because thats all it is oppressed people having there own stye in there own homeland
"if i don't steal it someone else will" - jacob from brooklyn
Technically the land has been stolen by a lot of empires, Israel was just the latest one ig
"I lost the war, therefore I become a victim" - Abdul from saudi
By winning war
Its Yakoub bro.
Why do comments get so many likes for just quoting a video
It dont feel like a conflict zone because all the money and support is on side...the side your seeing i dont feel angry that these people are happy but to say that people on the other side are suffering because of their happiness..it makes me feel sad this is the way it has happened...
Let me guess no Ethiopian Jews are allowed in these settlements. Israel is brutal and racist apartheid state.
@@tatertots0046 what Israel had a bunch of Ethiopians
@@dopaminedreams1122 there are NO Ethiopian Jewis in these beautiful settlements that have these well funded schools and government subsidized houses
Why don't you go to the Gaza Strip and compare the living conditions there to the ones in the settlements
That could also be because of the funding Israel receives from US?
Israelis basically live in a charity funded by the us.
Anyway the Palestinian government doesn't even have a military
How much money do you think the Palestinian government has ? Barely anything. Plus if Israel stopped the blockade the living conditions would be a lot better. They have only electricity only 6 hours a day. That has nothing to do with the Palestinian Governments spending. Thats all because of the Israeli Blockade
Gaza get's a lot of funding, but they spend it on terror and tunnels..
check that out.
Chinrico Tan If someone started taking over your land would you not fight back? I am referring to this video in particularly, where Israel is clearly funding these new settlements. Ethically speaking, what Israel is doing is wrong; you have to admit that regardless of your belief in what the Bible says.
I can see why the settlers are happy. The US has paid for the settlements development , and US weapons protect them.
Israel is strong because of US
Yeah a 3.4 billion foreign aid which creates a monopoly over israeli weapons are totallly carrying the nation.
And the Palestinians got help from Soviets in the wars
@@zylnexxd842
Want to elaborate on that? Got pictures of tanks, airplanes etc? I didn’t think so.
@@at6686 Soviet union was pro Israel
Living illegal in someone land with military support on your side make you comfort. What a shame
10:00 "What did you think I was living in? A tent"?
Thanks to people like you, the people you are displacing ARE living in tents. Must be so nice to have a place to go back to where everything is provided for you at the expense of an entire peoples' land.
No they aren't. They're living in houses. Check your facts.
There is nothing Islamic about genocide. This is their land and the Israelis have illegally settled upon it.
There is nothing Islamic about genocide? Just that a lot of un-Islamic Muslims are involved in the murder of Christians, Jews, Yazidis, Muslims of the "wrong" creed, and pagans across the world. Half a million victims of Jihad in Syria, tens of thousand in Sudan, more tens of thousands in Nigeria. In the last month there were 180 Islamic attacks in 31 countries, in which 1083 people were killed and 1259 injured. And you're crying about displaced Palestinians? Let their Muslim brothers take them in and rehabilitate them like we did for the hundreds of thousands of Jews who were driven from their homes around the Middle East by the followers of your religion of peace.
like where?
Yusuf Celenli If Palestinians are living in tents and refugee camps, they must blame their leaders. In 2000, Palestinians were offered 97 % of the West Bank, Arafat turned it down. So what is Israel supposed to do. Palestinians want everything on a platter. You cannot have things on a platter, you have to make compromises. I personally think the two state solution is dead. The best Palestinians can hope for now is autonomy not an independent state. Of they are smart they will accept Israel s terms and conditions, if they don't they might be landless and be a embittered minority for the next century.
They are not living at the edge of an intense conflict, they are the conflict.
moxypirate Islam is the conflict everywhere!
@@Succeshero-yw1rl are u sure , wheres your evidence i mean white Christians have killed more than isis ,just blame islam when you knkw nothing about.
Hannah Abdi nor does you, for when you mention the crusades you forget of the arabs almost reaching as far up as paris- read about your own story then you may try and talk about "the obvious " card you have up your sleeve
@@Succeshero-yw1rl they are
moxypirate Yes completely agree, and this vanilla video completely downplays this. Horrible journalism
As much as this is very informative and well made and well argued, for the purpose of not being biased you should have also interviewed 15 Palestinians living in the West Bank and the conditions they live in.
The Time is not far when Many of the Jews Will Embrace The Islam and the wrest will be dead.
By the way
This comment is only for Jews.
Jews were Called Muslims until The Prophet Hazrat Isa A.S Came. They tried to Murder Him. But Allah Saved Him And Raised Him And He Will Again Come. And All The Humen being Will be Muslims.
@@dakotalafferty9273 bruh how did you make this about Christians? actually alot of Palestinians are christian just like you
that's too much to ask Vox for that
@@dakotalafferty9273 Hamas was a minority party until Israel funded them and sent them weapons in order to keep the PLO (far left secular Palestinian party) from gaining power. Look it up, Israel has openly said they did this.
@@ertavampy4622 yes they wanted Palestine to establish a government of their own
No one can expect 400,000 people to move from the west bank, but a million Gazans are expected to move south in 5 minutes.
So can I move in to my neighbor garage because God gave it to me and feel a spiritual connection?!
Yes you can. Go for it. You can also cross the American border and get healthcare, and government subsidies. Your neighbor will pay for it all via taxes.
@@matrixab4356 bruh i wanna meet the person who decided to move to the us for health care.
Yes you can if you are strong enough to defend your belief from your neighbour, police & law.
Listen, the reason Israelis are moving there is because they don’t have room in the rest of israel, and because Israel technically occupied Palestine, they think,” hey land that most people aren’t living on! This will be an easy way to get a cheap house! Time to move”
If your neighbor is a squatter, you probably can.
It looks me incomplete without knowing what is other side of Palestinians.
Live like kings, they get free lands, free education in university, get a lot of money from the government every month
Yeah and most of them are integrated to israeli society. Its a long standing joke that if there is a pharmacist he will 4/5 be arab in israel. Not a terrible fate imo
Google "Vittorio Arrigoni Death"
Syed Sami Ur-Rehman 5:33
@@SuperLovehp חחחח גדול
I would really love to see the other side of the coin. It's been almost three years. You should publish the Palestinian view of the conflict.
I guess they had to only cover jewish because thetitle said jewish settlements. If it was called palestine it would have been different. But i do wanna hear both sides of the argument. I think Atlantic news did a better job on the docu series
@@motro1301 may be a separate video. Could you share the video link of the Atlantic News? But his storytelling is very unique. I love the vox border series only because it's very different from other news
He no longer works for vox
@@motro1301 they took are land we are the victims those rich Jews ate getting rich off of us racist Jews. Nothing but victim mentality without helping themselves is what you will hear
The Time is not far when Many of the Jews Will Embrace The Islam and the wrest will be dead.
By the way
This comment is only for Jews.
Jews were Called Muslims until The Prophet Hazrat Isa A.S Came. They tried to Murder Him. But Allah Saved Him And Raised Him And He Will Again Come. And All The Humen being Will be Muslims.
I found this really interesting and informative. But I kept wondering if you would also interview some palestinians in the West Bank too. I love to see a similar opportunity given to them to speak.
This is the problem with people reporting this conflict. The Palestinians do not get the airtime the Israelis get. The Israelis come across has White Middle class types with suburb English. The Palestinians on the other hand are usually shown has the Western definition of Middle Eastern religious zealot. Completely without compromise. It is no doubt beautiful. The scenery & especially climate but there must be underlying fear deep within their hearts that even during peace there can never truly be peace.
It doesn't matter if they interview the Palestinians. The video is very clear about how Israel mainland subsidies the illegal invasion of the West Bank thru these settlements and keep advancing.
Probably because the Israeli’s wont let you talk with them, and want to censor them
@@NoName-jq7tjguys, that's not what this piece is about. It very clearly sets out to explore what the settlements are like, which is an interesting subject worth exploring. There are plenty of videos about the ways the settlements make life harder for the palestinians in the WB, the disgusting police state they set up, the nets catching trash in Jerusalem, the segregated streets. That is not every video and not every video has to be that.
A mi me pareció triste!!!
This is just unjust. I can't believe I have been so blind about Palestine all this time.
I feel you. This is horrible!
@@nader50352 that is pure antisemitism and factually incorrect
@@edwardcaplan5204 have you seen Yakub in your tv-news
@@adil5994 no, who's that?
@@edwardcaplan5204 settler from New York
No mention yet of the demolition of Palestinian homes.
Free palestine
not to mention Jewish homes getting destroyed, not to mention that Muslims have no connection with Israel only Jews have...
As an Israeli, all I want is a third part.
We are exposed to what settlments are like, and how easy it is to move to one, and how appealing certain aspects of it are, I would love seeing the palestinian side of this story.
@trollnerd why should they pay rent for their own home duh
@trollnerd ok troll and nerd
@trollnerd Those houses were built by Jordan after it struck an agreement with UNRWA. They were built for the 28 refugee families that were displaced from their houses in Yaffa and Haifa by Israel. The international community considers it part of Palestinian territory and agrees that it is occupied. It does not belong to Israel which is why it is against international law to displace them. Those families have never paid any rent because there has never been a landlord
The Time is not far when Many of the Jews Will Embrace The Islam and the wrest will be dead.
By the way
This comment is only for Jews.
Jews were Called Muslims until The Prophet Hazrat Isa A.S Came. They tried to Murder Him. But Allah Saved Him And Raised Him And He Will Again Come. And All The Humen being Will be Muslims.
@trollnerd the jewish where never the owners!
He presents basically land theft and robbery in a sanitized presentation.
It’s disturbing and comical.
A satire of bourgeois attitudes.
“Yeah we violently took their land and we’re condemned by international law, but boy howdy look at the schools and neighborhoods…”
He is mindful of what the people interviewed think of him rather than being logical.
@@InsaneStryker777 Its called racism. A considerable portion of human beings are adherents to racial hierarchy.
Israel needs to either follow international law or not complain when the government is condemned for violating it. This region needs peace and the continual of settlement on Palestine is a major hurdle to that process.
Funny, they never broke international law
Occupying and building in another territory is against international law
yeah they did but they agreed to give back the land under an agreement. The peaceful resolution is not a dream if both countries work towards a viable solution. Btw hasn't this region seen enough conflict already, now is the time for peace and harmony, it has been done before and i believe it can be achieved now.
That started by Israelis stealing lands
History shows that there have been various times when Jews, Muslim, Christians were all living in Israel without much conflict. Peace is possible and needed so that both countries can have a bright future
Israel kind of fought and won multiple wars against multiple Arab nations for that land. Maybe instead of immediately going to war with Israel, they should've thought about what they were doing?
Umm, a number of those wars were Israel doing surprise attacks on countries where they ended up coming away with a ton of land....you can't blame the Arabs in those cases - they weren't the attacker, they were minding their own business.
Actually, if Israel wasn't the biggest bully in the middle east... There might not be as much trouble.
oldmoviemusic That is completely and utterly false. Please give one example to support these claims as opposed to skewing facts to support you narrative.
LemonzTV Which is why it is constantly invading its neighbours and stealing land.
Well they do now! They wouldn't dare to declare war against Israel. All they can do is commit acts of terror and deny, deny, deny.
It's a bit irresponsible to choose to exacerbate a conflict and provoke religious tension just because you want better QoL and house prices
Dont blame the people alone.. Blame the government which drives this entire movement!
@Marklgfg29 Kindly Re-read the comment.. I said blame both..
They’re all Americans.. living a better life than the Palestinians who were kicked out of their land. Life is really not fair
They're literally playing baseball!
They were not kicked out of their land. They started a war to kick Jews out of their lands. Jews have been kicked out of this land for centuries and have a right to a state. Why do you want to kick the Jews living in the west bank??
Why do the Isreali people speak English like native born Americans?!
because most of them studies or were born in the states?
Most of them immigrated from the us to Israel
Ask Trump
Paul Price those that came from Europe are NOT real Jews they are just converts !! Ok
@@paulprice3730 the 3 main types of Jews are European, north African, and middle eastern. The founding Jews of Israel were predominantly European, particularly Eastern European because of the Holocaust. Israel was practically founded for that reason alone.
Why did they not show maps before 1948?
dabbing avacado The map is in Part 1
bcs it was all palestian land and that's not what they want to show you.
DES PRO You mean when the religion of peace colonised the land and slaughtered the indigenous nations? Jews were in the region well before.
Pocket History Lesson: there was no state of Israel before 1948. This Pocket History Lesson was brought to you by AreYouEnlightened, and is devoid of hate, sarcasm, or agenda.
this race Jews there ancestors was been exile in the region after the Jewish revolt against Rome. after there defeate the Emperor if the Rome ordered to exile the Jews out in Judea and rename it as an insult to Jews.
this Palestine to the ancient Jews is there biggest enemy in the Region. Rome intended to rename it cause that is a sign of an insult to Jews people.
tru out the years Jews always been invade by ancient Empire exile they came back and rebuilt.
Jews has in own culture and Jerusalem is Part of there Identity as a Jews. it is not just a Land but that land for them is the Land has been defended by the Jews years and years before. even though it was just a dessert before the Jews choose to settle there originally not because of wealth but for there culture
I pray for the day we can all live together in peace
thanks, but pray for different gods is one of the reason the fight for hundreds of years
You're not going to get peace without justice.
lol dont "pray" , religioun is the root of MOST evils in this world.
I demand justice also for the million Jews who were thrown out of their homes in Arab lands and that Israel absorbed. Who will repay them for everything they lost.
Rafi Stern 2 wrongs dont make a right
“Tansik” تنسيق means coordination in Arabic. All the olive harvest in those parts of the Palestinian West Bank under Israeli military control requires coordination (Tansik) with the Israeli army. The real purpose of the “coordination” is to disrupt and damage the harvest.
The olive harvest in the West Bank takes place under a constant Israeli land grab, restrictions on access to the plots, settlers attacks on harvesters, and vandalisation of olive trees.
Kufr Qaddum is a Palestinian town in the northern West Bank. Its olive groves are located beside the large settlement Kedumim, which was illegally built on Kufr Qaddum’s land.
It takes 2 months for the village to harvest its olives. In 2019 the Israeli army gave them a permit for 8 days.
Untended trees yield poorer crops, if they can be picked at all.
The settlement of Kedumim uses surveillance cameras to monitor the Palestinian land. If the settlers see the farmers working, they will either arrive there to threaten them, or ask the army to come and turn the farmers away from their land.
Over one million Palestinian olive trees have been uprooted or burned by Israeli authorities and settlers since 1967.
I’m from kufr qaddum
I wish we get to hear more from the Palestine side of the conflict
I wish we get to hear more from the Palestine side of the conflict
Palestinian trees?
Upbeat music and cheerful residents talking about how great a life they're living after a military occupation brutally wipes out generations of humans.
They were okay with the divide at the start until the neighbouring Arab nations who had no business intervening invaded Israel in hope of making it a complete Arab state. It's like a taste of their own medicine....except they'll make it 10 times bitter.
@@agnusredel3709 people settling on palestinian lands and expulsing them completely deserved the war
@@agnusredel3709 this is a joke right?
You have just described almost every 3rd world country.
Does it anger you that people are living their lives working and building their families here? They aren't going anywhere
Of course the settlers feel safe! They’re surrounded by IDF soldiers on every street
because palestines would attack them
@@LucasEnlow ooh, I wonder why??
@@terrybaker8156 because they are monster
@@batuhanyayla7214 if you get angry when your house is robbed then you are a monster. Ok, right.
@@xiaorei409the settlers are building in C points agreed on the Oslo agreement. Stop crying
theft never looked so good
Lol
Ignorance never looked this blatant
How is this statement "ignorance"? The borders were agreed long ago, the Israelis just disregard them. Nothing else to say!
It's only as legal as the Geneva Convention is illegal. But then the complete disregard for the Geneva Convention and international laws by the Israeli government and backers of the settlements makes any meaningful discussion impossible.
Get some guns and you can easily claim some land even in the middle of Tel Aviv. Just shoot anyone who dare to oppose and make a youtube video telling they are terrorists
The colonisers perspective. Let's have the oppressed Palestinians.
2:33 _Most people here work in the city, and you come back here at night..._
So those "settlements" are nothing more than glorified residential subsurbs of israeli towns. And yet the israeli gorvernment makes it sound like it's impossible to remove them, that it would "uproot" those people. It's just a damn suburb! Detroit had twice that number of people leaving its own suburbs.
Narayana 69 .. Lol prood that you are the true descendants of that people first .. Those well known classical religious claims to gain sympathy when the bible is mentioned won't work anymore ..
Btw , the bible never said to expel the people , destroy their future and leave them suffering without any guilt .
Bobby B .. Yeah are totally right .. The israeli government as keep in building settlements to increase the number of their settlers and the infrastructure to dismantle any attempt for a two state or whatever solution to solve this issue .. Israel has onw goal which is to expel the palestinians and replace them with settlers and that was the goal from day one ..
Narayana 69 .. There was no need for your long article ..
Your biblical interpretation makes god a real estate agent .. Probably Working for KBR.
You could simply confess and say .. Yes we have no proof that we are descendants and don't have a bloodline to the biblical israelities .. Its obvious that you are coverted .. Thanks for your indirect confession ..
Lol @ Alien .. This alien has to be from ( god choosen aliens)
Narayana 69 .. Lol , my previous comment already closed the urguement and proved the colonical intentions by the use of religious justificstion ..
Btw , speaking hebrew never proves that they are descendants of ancient israelities ..
For your info .. Hebrew today isn't the same as ancient hebrew ..
Posting lot of comment in an attempt to justify something will make it worse .. Trycto be short and clear .. 😉
Narayana 69 don't maneuver and deviate the subject .. Why you always try to toss the classical words once you are trapped ?? Arabs muslims rape etc .. I dont care about this..
I'm not going to insult you as you did .. Being aggressive won't help.
Back to subject .. Yeah speaking arabic doesn't prove either .. Thats is also true ..
Its the same concept .. If you can't prove or disprove something then you have to stop the claim that "God Promised the land " simply because you can't be certain who are the real descandants ..
So tell me, if palestinians are the real descandants but converted to islam 1400 years ago and became Arabs by tongue .. What will that means to you ??
What about palestinas??
They live in other areas of the West Bank and Gaza.
+Short Names
So...
Stnl N2 I answered their question, you just misread what they were asking.
+David Gill
Do you call Assad( Shia) Syrian government?
Based on statistical analyses before the war from 2006,
of the Syrian population, 74%[2] were Sunnis (including Sufis[3]), whereas 13%[2] were Shias (including 8.0% Alawites from which about 2% are called Mershdis and they are the followers of Sulayman al-Murshid, 3% Twelvers , or 1% Ismailis ), 3%[2] were Druze, while the remaining 10%[2] were Christians
Sorry to rain on your parade :).... but, no as you could see Shia (Alawaites) are small minority of Syrian populations 8%, The great majority are Sunni 74%, so, NO.....monster Asssssad is NEVER represented Syrian people! !!!! never....
+David Gill "Sunnis are guests of Assad"....Are you sick? ....
Sees title:
*grabs popcorn and scrolls down to comments*
NationalismBG more hate than a Scorsese movie
NationalismBG same you can see so many stupid people down there
i was actually hoping it would be more :-P @@RahulKumar-ng2gh
Didn't even watch it, because I knew the spin. To the comments we go lol
@@aaronlavigne7677 Me too.
Whenever i want to throw up, i just come here to this video. The amount of disgust and anger i feel from it. How evil and delusional.
You can’t never judge by seeing on one side story.
I guess it is easier to interview Israeli. And the video is about Israeli settlers not Palestinian.
ha vu they don’t let interviewers go into Palestinian towns to get their side, that’s how they oppress them and show the world only their side. Disgusting society of Israel that supports the illegal settlements, they always want more and more land, never content.
@@iamyourtugabro8325 If you say: Palastinians are suffering. You clearly don't understand the conflict
there is no "other side"
Why Israeli settlements don’t feel like a conflict zone? Because the Palestinians not bombing their houses and schools like they did to Gaza.
Well if you fire rockets across the border and not expect a counter, then you are being plain stupid
hey Soham you do realize no one dies from these so called "terrorist attacks" by the palestinians, unlike the missile strikes done by the zionists which are funded by the US .
So who's the "terrorist" here?
Ihsan Fahmil the ones committing genocide .
Ihsan Fahmil this video is about the west bank not Gaza , there are no Israeli settlers in Gaza yet still Hamas continues to terrorizing Israelis who lives in the border
I would have loved to hear what settlers who aren't religious zealots think the future of the West Bank is going to be. Like what is their personal vision how this whole conflict is going to turn out? Do they really want the Palestinians to be oppressed forever? Do they really think that's even a viable solution even if it weren't so obviously morally wrong?
next episode will hopefully provide some clarity on this
Look for one of "Dont tell my mother...." series. In it the host interview one of the more non-zionist Jew in Isreal. Suffice to say the guy got verbal abuse and death threats.
Mishak Heyman Do you think? From the preview, it didn't really sound like it to me.
nimay13
Neither the fact that it's rare to be non-Zionist in Israel, nor that this is necessarily a dangerous position to take correspond to my personal experience. Are you sure you haven't been fed some biased views there?
It's important to remember that there are probably few countries where the range of political views backed by a substantial portion of the population is larger than in Israel.
Penny Lane Go find the series "Dont tell my mother...", granted it was a few years old but it was produced for National Geographic. The non-zionist Jew guy got verbally abused (by other Jews) in front of the camera. No bias there.
Also in that particular episode, the host goes to show both sides of the fence. From the Jews viewpoint and from the Palestine POV. He literally went to West Bank and interview people there. I think he went to Gaza strip too.
While this was quite informative, the tone of this video seems a little weird. You squarely address the illegality and devious strategy of the Israeli government in building these settlements, but you don’t actually criticize them.
It’s as if you made a video asking shoplifters about fashion trends and why they chose the outfits they stole?
It’s weird.
They’re not worried about the fact that they’re stealing this land
They’re just happy it’s five minutes from a hiking trail
SMH so sad
They’re so oblivious
They're not oblivious. They're complicit.
@@duarte2 exactly. They’re complicit. They clearly think they deserve the land.
I think its complicated like maybe they took the land but i think that if they live there now it would be just as immoral to take it back Like honestly I think it would be better if isreal didnt exist in the first place but it dose now so we need a more nuanced discussion than isreal bad and palistine good. People on the left and right both seem to make it seem like it is cut and dry one side bad the other good but its not there is nuance. Saying "both sides" is wrong too however because I think that isreal should not have existed in the way it dose in the first place however there is nuance and I dont think these people are to blame.
It's there land, The Muslims stole it from them, they are reclaiming it.. 🇮🇱🇬🇧
@@rubberjohnnyh "the muslims" did not take the land from anyone who lives there now what a rediculous thing to say.
Its like 2 guys negotiating over a pizza and one guys eating it *while holding a gun* in his hands...
his analogy isnt perfect because, we already negotiated over the pizza. UN partitioned the land, the palestinians refused their share, they attacked and lost the war. a better analogy would be, one pizza split between two guys and the greedy one attacked the other and lost parts of his pizza in the process.
i think you got that wrong, in 1948 2 guys were negotiating over a pizza, so UN came and split it in half, but side #1 (Palestinians) attacked side #2 (Israelis) for the Israeli half, but then they lost the war and their half of the pizza...
now tell me, giving back to the Palestinians their half of pizza for nothing will just bring us back to the beginning, so Israel wants it like this: "we will give you your half, but you leave us alone". so far the Palestinians declined, so...
of course the Arab rejects the idea of splitting the pizza in half, because the person requesting to share the pizza is just a small boy, descendants of former owner of the house 2000 years ago. A third is more than enough.
the boy insists on his own half pizza share, when he can just stay together in Arab house, enjoying the pizza and life together peacefully.
@@yonatansolomon9833 No you got it wrong, it's a man having a pizza and feeling generous and shared a slice with another man, then the other man held a gun to the first mans head and is saying they deserve the entirety of the pizza.
@@Superchoco-cv1qr you've got to learn some history, we were there first
I want to see the Palestinian settlements and perspective.
He would be dead
White people wont let that happen
search on youtube,there are lots of videos.
How come these Jews speak English so fluently? Were they born in the US or somewhere else in the West? And then moved to the West Bank and got basically free land stolen from the Palestinians?
most israelis speak english
no, he actually mentioned in the video that he spoke to mostly american settlers and that they present around 15% of the population.
(also this whole video is 7 years ago so some stuff may be outdated)
I have enjoyed many of your videos but this one is a joke. Could you do a video more from the Palestinian perspective and maybe dig into the connections of on how the U.S. funds many of Israels operations?
US only funds israel's iron dome interceptor missile to stop palestinian rocket attacks from gaza into israeli cities
Move to palestine
@@JoeFiddle-ls5jh only if you come to El Salvador
Agreed it's disgusting
There's no point even trying to compare this situation to anywhere else in the world, it's a completely unique set of circumstances.
@@dorashual8753 How is that relevant to the issue of settlements?
@@jackkessler9876 Okay dokey, it's all just Muslim Intolerance. So Israeli tolerance and fairness would give citizenship to all legal residents of their territories, right? And not just those that are of the confirmed national faith so that Judaism can retain its place as the center of Israel's legal, governmental and cultural affairs? Fact is, if the population of Gaza, the West Bank, and the Palestinian refugees were allowed to come home and become normal citizens, 'Israel' as a concept would cease to exist and the 'Israelis' would be a minority population again. This isn't about Muslim Intolerance; Israel is a country of people who felt an unjust boot on their necks for centuries (i.e. the CHRISTIAN nations of the world primarily) and now feel entitled to put their own boot on someone else's neck to make sure it isn't done to them again. They have gone from victims to oppressors, tragedy made circular.
Josh Obrien Sure
@ENDEAVOR RADIO CONTROL if they did they would have started another war with Egypt and Jordan. thay don't want a war becuse they have a peace treaty with them and that is the only thing stopping the Muslim governments from starting a war and invading israel. plus the wast bank was given to the Palestinians by Jordan so they can start building a government again.
It’s not unique. Morocco is using the exact same policy in Western Sahara. Interesting thing is, the world only seems to care when it’s Jews who are doing it.
First 7 minutes: same things said over and over in different ways.
Applauding all those here in 2023 trying to learn more about this conflict 👏🏽
whatever the UN could and would say, there'll always be 'Murica to veto it
The power to veto should have been abolished decades ago
#Fuckveto
Same with Russia in regards to Georgia and Ukraine. And the difference is that Russia actually annexes things after invading them.
If any of you believe that the great powers will ever care about the UN without the veto you are delusional. Removing the veto is destroying the Security Council.
But what i dont understand is why just one veto to cancel everything is okay?
Because Israel got power, arms, tech, international support, money and the mindset of not being regretful even if they're stealing those lands... Free real estate
I actually thought they were living in tents or huts. You don't imagine nice and big neighborhoods when you hear the word settlement. It looks like a nice place to live.
go back to playing rollercoaster tycoon you uneducated child
Adam Smith as an israeli who lived in a settelement for years, its a great place to grow in
Why do you then come to Israel and kill few of us Palestinian and settle in our homes. You could then destroy and rebuild the house too :)
of course, they are sponsored by the israel's government. did you not watch the whole video?? in other words; settlers = sponsored immigrants.
Jewish people are rich af
"It's hard to believe that these settlers are living at the edge of an intense conflict", great way to avoid saying "on stolen land"
Intelligence 100
"This whole peace negotiation is like two guys talking over a pizza while one is eating the pizza".
- well said
lol isn't that same pony-tailed settler who was talking about his right of this land they dreamed of 2000 years ago and he said "we own everything" in the intervew with The atlantic
so he turned peacfull and chill now ?
People do technically have a right to change their mind. But you certainly have the right to question if they have.
That's the fun thing about the internet; it is forever. People will find you contradicting yourself in the past or present and hold it against you, but I do think intent and reason matters.
@@tenchimuyo69 the vox video was before
@Zoltan Harangozo its ironic because modern 'Israelis' are all decend from europe and not the middle east. Do you think that israel was just empty and before the Jews no one knew let alone lived in the area? So if I would argue that Egyptians had concurred this place from the assyrians before the jews came would you agree that syrians/Egyptians should own israel because they were there before the jews came.
@Zoltan Harangozo so called israelis are litteraly polish or germans, arabs are more semite than any israeli dreamer
Wow you guys got so much of that wrong. It is traditionally believed that the Israelites were exiled from the land of Israel 2000 years ago by the romans. During the Middle Ages, the Jews were naturally divided to two groups - Ashkenazi Jews and Sephardic (or Mizrachi) Jews. The Ashkenazi Jews are the ones who migrated to eastern and central Europe, while the Sephardic Jews are the ones who migrated to the Iberian peninsula, from which they were exiled as well in 1492, and then migrated mainly to North Africa and the Middle East. In the late 1800s, Zionism - the nationalist Jewish movement - emerged in Europe. Theodor Herzl took great diplomatic, organizational and physical action to bring the Jews from over the world together and get a charter of an establishment of a Jewish state in the then-Ottoman ruled Land of Israel (aka Palestine), while supporting Jewish settlement in the region, which started in 1882. After WW1, the British took hold of Palestine, which was by then settled by both Arabs and Jews, and in 1947 the British declared than on May 15, 1948 they will live Palestine and let the UN decide what’s going to happen next. After a months-long inspection of the area lead by UNSCOP - the UN special committee on Palestine, the UN general assembly voted in favor of a resolution that stated that 45% of land will make a Palestinian state, the other 55% will make a Jewish state and Jerusalem will be an international territory controlled by the UN. While the Jews were happy with this offer, the Palestinians rejected it and started a war on the Jews. Mid-war, the Israeli state was declared on May 14, 1948, and the rest is history...
Why you didn't ask them what are their thoughts that they are occupying and oppressing palestinians?!!
The colonizers are never afraid of the locals. It works the other way around
Palestine was never a state ,
If palestine didn't make demands, there would be a palestine
The Time is not far when Many of the Jews Will Embrace The Islam and the wrest will be dead.
By the way
This comment is only for Jews.
Jews were Called Muslims until The Prophet Hazrat Isa A.S Came. They tried to Murder Him. But Allah Saved Him And Raised Him And He Will Again Come. And All The Humen being Will be Muslims.
@@explorerofyoutube1066 The Time is not far when Many of the Jews Will Embrace The Islam and the wrest will be dead.
By the way
This comment is only for Jews.
Jews were Called Muslims until The Prophet Hazrat Isa A.S Came. They tried to Murder Him. But Allah Saved Him And Raised Him And He Will Again Come. And All The Humen being Will be Muslims.
@@yurichtube1162 The Time is not far when Many of the Jews Will Embrace The Islam and the wrest will be dead.
By the way
This comment is only for Jews.
Jews were Called Muslims until The Prophet Hazrat Isa A.S Came. They tried to Murder Him. But Allah Saved Him And Raised Him And He Will Again Come. And All The Humen being Will be Muslims.
Show palestinian part of West bank
I have been there just after the US announced they'll move their embassy to Jerusalem. The palestian west bank is what can be described as a "3rd world country". It starts right at the borders between the two parts of Jerusalem. Once you leave the Jewish part heavily sponsored by the USA money, you will find your self in a city in a different realm. You can find sights such as roads flooded with running/overflooding or broken sewers/pipes. Unattained infrastructure and buildings. The land is truly beautiful..however what the people have created there "in the name of god" - as they like to phrase it, is an abomination to any level of spirituality. I say the UN should resolve this as these two parties have zero respect towards one another and each side will use all that is to their disposal to undermine the position of the other party. The heavily disputed areas should become something like Kosovo ( a 3rd country alongside with Israel and Palestine). Otherwise this will never stop - endlessly fuelled by the abrahamic curse!
Well they must be still struggling for food. That's what happens if you don't think practically and keep fighting for man made religion
@Alexplus20 Islamic mind wash is real thing. Even if they don't have food to eat and home to live they always choose Religion because they are mindwashed from childhood that Allah is everything and can't ignore Allah or else you will end up in Hell. Wiser people will settle and live happily.
Well they wont because the series is about the isreali settlements and not the palestinian view! :/
there is none
"Ideological motivations are far down the line..."
This piece is a excellent mirror for most "first world" communities. We are innocent of our collective action and their implications by claiming a right to a way of life which by its underlying ideology deprives others of it. Heck, that map of Israel might as well be US cities in the 50s when the freeway system surrounded and cut through predominantly poor black communities, and today are again being pushed out by gentrification. Like the Arabs of the West Bank and Gaza Strip, they were squeezed there by restrictive laws and tacit social agreements of an oppressor claiming self defense and the carrying on the burden of civilization and all its necessities: education, commerce, and most importantly the use of violence, of course keeping it in the hands of the chosen. The ideological motivations that are far down the line root themselves in the belief that only a certain chosen can carry on that burden of civilization which leads to certain conflict and injustice, in many ways corrupting all other ideology or motivation. It is incompatible with democracy.
Either we are all chosen, or none of us are.
insightful
Why should any Israeli take pity on the Palestinians? They absolutely hate them with all their being.
Living together is the key. Segregation doesn't work.
I don't think that you can equate the situation there with the US-American conflict of "races". It is a huge misunderstanding many Americans tend to make. Almost all conflicts in Europe and the Middle East are based on religion, ethnicity, economic differences or culture, rarely on the colour of skin, or as you put it, "race".
@@ahwasright1364 Weird... that's almost word-for-word the same mindset that almost got the Jewish people annihilated. You'd think that, as the recipients of so much unearned abuse, they'd learn to avoid dishing it out themselves. Talk about slow learners...
kind of like an eye of a storm, where everything around is total chaos but in the center it's actually pretty chill
Yeah, because its the root of all the problems
I could not believe my ears when the middle-aged man on the couch said "there's a really nice country club"... Like are you serious?? This is so messed up.. They successfully live like they don't have a care in the world and like it's rightfully their land to live on. And I think they actually and wholeheartedly believe that. Mind-boggling......
It feels a bit unfair ( more than a little bit). It feels a lot like bullying. It's like- "We are gonna build in such a way so that should these people be able to have a stand one day, there won't be anywhere to put it." 😔
so maddening
When you realize the reason settler's could do this in the first place was because Israel rightfully captured the land following a war which was incited by Palestinians, what seems unfair is that Palestine didn't just accept the UN partition plan/avoid inciting wars over the years because if they did they would have saved thousands of Palestinian lives.
Instead, they were too focused on eradicating Israel because they selfishly wanted an Arab only state. The way they are currently treated is incredibly unfair, especially because their ancestors who refused to make peace caused this, but it is also reasonable to understand that Israel was provoked over the years and can't really compromise with people who refuse to share.
@@AlexG-oo8kt israel is the oppressor.
@@AlexG-oo8kt This is the way I see it. When people call Israel the oppressor it’s a shame because it makes it sound like a simple relationship between a bully and a victim. Of course there’s more layers to it than that though. Palestinian civilians are definitely victims, but not because Israel wants them to suffer. Palestinians are the victims to the choices of their own authorities. If Palestinian leaders were initially interested in working with Israel then that is what would have happened.
@@AlexG-oo8kt this sounds like what every abuser in every abusive relationship says. " I only hit you because you provoked me". Winning a war doesn't mean you treat people as less than, especially if your goal is peace.
"Instead we played music." - great journalism there. 0:18
I think what he meant was that:
(a) the settlers manipulated the visit to look "normal", harmless, non-political, welcoming, familial. (That's just clever politics).
(b) He probably found that any pointed questions about their "right to be there" went "over their heads". (That's just subconscious denial).
The Dolphin good observation My Dolphin friend
Some music. Two morons beating on a BBQ top. God promised you nothing stupid. Its Palestine. The aboriginal inhabitants are the children of Abraham too. The Jews are not Semites. Thats why they wont allo DNA testing to justify their claims. They are Russians.
@@ziblot1235 They actually did a lot of DNA testing and it's now been clearly proven that european Jews originate from Israel.
@@Accassam that's not how DNA works. It doesn't track exact locations in the past.
Not even a single glimpse of a Palestinian ?! .... =(
@@chiefbeef2947 So what you're saying is, you're little more than human garbage? Gotcha.
ENDEAVOR RADIO CONTROL stop
“Two guys negotiating over a pizza, while one of them is eating the pizza” There, that’s it.