Conflict Zone: Deadlocked and divided: What now for the Palestinians? | DW English
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 лис 2018
- Palestinian leaders are deadlocked with Israel, face internal challenges and have clashed with the U.S. DW’s Conflict Zone met Chief Palestinian Negotiator Saeb Erekat and asked him about his next steps.
Conflict Zone is Deutsche Welle's top political interview. Every week, our hosts Tim Sebastian and Michel Friedman are face-to-face with global decision-makers, seeking straight answers to straight questions, putting the spotlight on controversial issues and calling the powerful to account.
Subscribe: ua-cam.com/users/deutschew...
Twitter: / dw_conflictzone
Facebook: / dw.conflictzone
More about Tim Sebastian: www.dw.com/p/1G7K9
More about Michel Friedman: www.dw.com/p/1IMJx
#SaebEkerat #Palestine #dwConflictZone
I am an Israeli and I do sympathise with the Palestinian people.
I wish Palestinians better life as free and independent people.
Though, Social divide, Religious fanaticism, 3rd world Corruption and coward & un pragmatic leaders stands on the way.
In case Israel withdraw from the west bank, within days it becomes another Gaza.
and off course Israel is to be blame for that !!!!
Jonathan Namir Time is running out for the Israeli occupation your government is on the brink of collapsing your leader will have to start a war soon but Israel could be fighting on 3 fronts. Why is Israel so afraid of Peace with the Palestinians ether one state or two Time is not on your side.
@@billjohns9488 Israel still lives..
As a Palestinian who lives in the west bank I can tell you that someday you will withdraw to Europe.. the place where you came from
For some reason that Erekat chose to be treated in a Israeli hospital... Why not a Palestinian one or a Jordanian, Egyptian etc...?
wow, he didnt said nothing true the whole interview
Who is pocketing the money? Drive through Ramallah or down Israel's route 6 and see the Palestinian mansions, sprawling extravagant architecture. See the high priced brand new cars.
Western taxes pay for them
True. Fake nation real diamonds.
I hear Netanyahu et al are pretty good at pocketing too.
@@aerohead9676 --Please use your own figures and compare Netanyahu with a miner office holder in PA --Does it even come close to the PA ?
Why don't you mention Gaza then? If Palestinian in other places live a nice life then that's good for them
and you may find it surprising, but he takes care for his health in israeli hospital, turning away and hiding his face when being filmed by other patients
wownouser the Palestinians were thrown out of their land in 1948. Nobody had the right to give their land to another people. That’s why people say Israel stole Palestinian land.
@@ankhmorpok1497 people say so many rubbish things, my dear friend, do not take it for granted
WHERE DID ALL THOSE MULTIPLE BILLIONS AND BILLIONS GO , SAAEB ?
To Islamist terrorisem. thank you for asking Mr. Mizrahi. 😁
That my friend is a good question. Has that cash been used to better the lives of the palestinians? have they built universities hospitals and schools?
so he was born and raised Jordanian. why is he demanding a palestinian state and not to reunite with Jordan?
Good point. None of the Palywoodans were born in Palywood but Israeli leaders were.
All israelies are foreiners in palestine they came from poland, germany, russia, usa, yemen, iran, egyp..etc..
You did with the Palestineans like you treated all minority’s. Lol nothing new from western hypocrisy and exploitation.
We fled to Jordan in the 1960s. Because of occupation.
cause in people's head jordan is a seperate entitiy. to get behind the fact that the arab palestinian identity was invented in the mid 60's is for most people too much of an effort to wrap their head around. its easier to sell a lie if people don't want to investigate for themselves.
When the world listens, the Palestinians talk about peace, when they talk to other Palestinians they talk about war.
How can people shake his hand after all this...
Gosh! Tim Sebastian is tough. He does his homework. It sure is going to be nerve wracking being interviewed by him.
This guy was born in 1955in Jericho, but forget to mention that Jericho was a Jordan city at the time, so he's a Jordanian.
And all Israelis are Europeans because they were born in Europe.
“Palestine is a democracy “ hahahahaha funniest thing I’ve heard this year
The journalist Tim Sebastian is the same with everyone. He is a tough interviewer.
yeah he destroyed the israelis he interviewed and destroys the palestinians he's interviewing . he's equally aggressive interviewer
This Palestinian guy is the same as the whole scam that Palestine is: a thuggish liar
I agree and that style is the worst
Jesse Eek So how long will the Palestinean be guilty.
Ole Abdallah come on- Saeb got crushed here. When Sebastian confronts the Israelis they counterpunch. All Saeb did was bob and weave
It's been a long time since I laughed so much!
Great interviewer who obviously did his homework and doesn't fall into lies.
הוא קשוח ככה עם כל מי שהוא מראיין.
הוא היה ככה גם עם פוליטיקאים ודיפלומטים ישראלים שהוא ראיין בעבר.
זה הדרך שלו להיות אובייקטיבי.
אין קשר בין להיות קשוח לבין להגיד למרואין בפרצוף שהוא שקרן ומושחת
@@michalebeb לא הבנתי איפה הסתירה.
אני מציע לך לראות את הראיון שלו עם בנט ועם עוד כמה נציגים ישראלים במהלך השנים האחרונות. הוא תקיף כמעט באותה מידה אם לא יותר לפעמים, ככה שכמעט בלתי אפשרי לזהות את דעותיו או לשייך אותו לאיזשהו צד. אני אומר את זה לזכותו אם זה לא מובן.
צחקתי על עריקאת, אם לא ברור.
המראיין עשה עבודה מעולה ומקצועית בחשיפת השקרים של עריקאת
@@michalebeb כן זה ברור.
Sigh... its a deep difficult reality that affect human lives. And as most people see I see too - Palestinian people's biggest problem are their leaders.
I can see the US providing aid to a true and helpful democratic ally, but not to terrorists and inciters with a dictatorship.
Yet the US does business with Saudi Arabia.
Finally, asking the correct questions
Long live Palestine
Kł
7:21 "We are a full democracy"
😂😂😂😂😂😂
"... a fool democracy"
@@ronaaron6935 Makes more sense ;-)
They are a Humoos Full democracy
@@omriko5041 Haha... only a Hebrew speaker can understand this joke 😜
They're so ful of humus, the results are coming out the back end
Notice he keeps comparing his record to the Arab and Muslim World. That's not exactly a high bar. :-)
there is no bar at all
If Ekerat spins anymore he would turn to a man-made hurricane.
The demand from the Palestinians, which is suicide for Israel, for the 'right of return' is the real obstacle to peace and the Palestinians cling to it knowing Israel can not possibly agree. We will know they are ready when they become reasonable on this front. Tim Sebastian made a critical error not asking about this, in my opinion.
There is no LEGAL right of return for 4th generation refugees.
It's a story that they told each other enough times that they think it's true
Fool Democracy :)
Strong interviewer who had presented the truth about what is really happening on the ground
A real sugar delight :) thank you - Great Job Tim
Unbelievable that this crook gets so much attention and not to mention hundreds of millions of dollars a year which he spends on terrorists in prisons
"I have done everything humanly possible to make peace".
I didn't know that it is humanly impossible to accept PM Olmert's offer in 2007 to create a Palestinian state in the 67 borders with some land swaps + east Jerusalem
Immediately blames others. Says " not honest" brokers....and yet....he can never give two interviews that are the same or consistent....lies in English...speaks with a bloody mouth in Arabic.
Well saiddddd
Erekat is not so much a negotiator as a liar in chief.
1. No reason in having a connecyion between and Gaza and Judea and Sameria terrotorries, they have no real joined history. 2. there are no 6 miliion sunni arabs living in those territories.
lol SAEB is almost foaming at times.
the "audacity" of that interviewer...who are you to use actual facts and acceptable human behavior at their face? :P
Hardtalk. If I'd change something, I'd ask Tim to allow the guest to answer.
Finally someone tells the truth when interviewing Palestinian leadership
10:31 "We are a full democracy," bruh you havent had elections in 16 years.
Erekat says that everyday there are protests against Abbas and his corrupt authority and Erekat quotes this as a FREEDOM - the only Muslim country that ALLOWS such demonstrations. What a twisted proof of freedom. Freedom would be to live WITHOUT corruption, (and he doesn't even deny how these demonstrators risk their lives by such protests). He even sanctimoniously says he helps when ordinary Palestinians are being tortured! Helps? He is the "King of Jericho". He is the one who AUTHORISES the torture!!!
Balestinians are good in saying NO, I love iT.
Weldone Tim, hat up.
This man is infuriating...lies and lies...he failed his people
Forget the 1967 lines , UN resolution 242 doesn't oblige an Israeli retreat to 1967 .
Great question by Tim... keep on
I love conflict zone with Tim
Saeb ("This is Palestinian Ministry of Truth. How Can You Help Us?") Erekat
Rest in peace Eric. One of the few people with a smart mind.
I laughed how people have different opinions ABOUT Tim when he interviewed Bennett in another video. :D
What is Palestine where his history there is no archeological findings could show me of nature
Mr.Saeeb actually is not respecting Palestinians’ history and difficult circumstances but keeping giving excuses and then admitting corruption and human rights abuses and torsion against his people which is so shame and ignoring Palestinians’ claims for Mr. Abbass resignation which will never happen.
Shameful that Erikat such a “leader” I am a Palestinian lawyer migrate to USA to run out this “ironic authority”
Salaam aleikum habibi. Glad a good person like you was able to escape and make a life for yourself. Zvika from Israel
Doctoral Doctorate in Holocaust Denial Abu Mazen devoted his dissertation to denying the Holocaust
What is a Palestinian I searched for and did not find history Every nation has a history for the Germans Turkey to Iran to England France
Why anyone would agree to be interviewed (more like ambushed) by this guy is beyond me?
good job;~>
Plastienien authority one big joke!
Tim Sebestain is one of the best better than all the rest
After this interview someone can belive to any muslim leader ???? So many lies in 10 minutes.
They are not Muslims they represent themselves
Tim Sebastian thank you;
Saeb Erekat - face facts; your days of lying are finished.
PA is a full democracy?
Erekat cannot answer; swerves and stutters away from the questions.
The Palestinians should be concerned after tbis interview. If i were a Palestinian i would jump over the wall and go join the israel.
This is the "moderate" faction.
U.N. Resolution doesn't require a retreat to the 1967 armistice lines !
Good interview.
Would add pay for slay and law against selling property to jews but other than that great
I don't have 26mins : how are the Palestinians deadlocked within?
Green Eggs and Ham You have to go there to visit the poverty and misery from Palestinians. Please prepare thousands of omelettes with eggs, ham and cheddar.
@@joeantony2760 ...Ham ?
May you rest in peace
With due respect to Tim, it seemed he just wanted to let the viewers buy what he believed in. He didn't give Earak one minute to explain. I hope in order to be fair Tim will give the same interviews to Bair and Bush
so forth,he recognized the right of israel to exist with in the 67 lines. not recognizing it as to today
Tim is the best interviewer in history and even today
The best words ...if israeli and Palestinians can't help each other nobody else will help us
In the end the Palestinian people are the ones who get the shaft and suffer and the ones that get blamed, not the government. This creates hatred to Palestinians as a whole. Can you really hate North Korean people based off their government and leader?
If the Palestinians had any sense they would have converted to Judaism long ago, problem totally solved. Instead everyone twists themselves into pretzels attempting to accommodate two mythical belief systems that hate each other for no good reason. The entire mideast is a mess for what amounts to which imaginary being you believe in. What century are we in anyway?
Erekat's "security guard" would exterminate them as collaborators before they get the chance to convert... Unless you believe that their towns are some sort of a 'democracy'.
Lol wut
This would be funny if it wasn't so sad.
Abba Eban he is not....
I listened to whole thing... didn't hear a coherent thought.
Prior to 1967, the West Bank was part of Transjordan and Gaza was part of Egypt .. there never was a Palestinian nation.
There always has been palestine, and palestine will get concurred by the palestinians just wait.
I can tell you one thing it wont be pretty
This is why I support Israel! 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱 /from Sweden
galenikarlek84 You are forced to support them. Because of anti Semitic in your history.
Ron Golan The different that the Swedish did race biology on Jews, you can’t win over me. I will crush you in debates.
Ron Golan Swedish use to measure Jews by heights.
Ron Golan Now you must answer like a man.
Ron Golan The Swedish Democrat’s, you remember. Haha 😆
At the moment might is right ...
Israel has the might and it is right......
But it will suffer
No it gets stronger and stronger year after year. Is on an upward trajectory.
Who is Tim Sebastian?
This was painful to watch: a shouting match.
Erekat has a Ph.D in Peace Studies. You couldn't make this shit up if you tried!!!
Mr. DW ain't strange!
He actually right...they are a Humoos Full democracy
This guy was always full of slogans and devoid of substance.
In every society both pal or Israeli there are people who are prepared to sign peace right now with no conditios attached.... Israel already employs many palestinians.we interact with each other on a daily basis .apart from terrorism and killing nothingelse is required for both Palestinians and Israelis
wait so... i didnt get one thing, wth are "palestinians"?
13:29 That look on Tim’s face when he said he’s 20 years old 😂😂
This chief of negotiate he look like army?
sure you can't become peace negotiater or politician without lying I true why allways people say politician they lying. plz check how he explained himself?
He was a super LIAR and PREVERICATOR. His specialty was whining hysterically.
May he RIP.
Total nonsense! There is a one democratic state solution, two state is a waste of time!
No we will never and cat do one state solution. We have 1.9 million arab israelis as citizens but cannot make the palestinians israeli citizens. We have a democracy, would be outnumbered and instantly lose Israel. Wasting everyone's time calling for that it isn't reasonable
mr saeb erekat just keep stepping back and do not negotiate with the israelis leave them to make peace with themselves.
Where has that got you. You just watch more settlements being built and get worse and worse offers over time. Your only way to stop it is to accept real and prolonged peace and accept what is offered
Ashkenazi
differnce three eggs betwen two
Somtimes I feel all thing are mentioned in the Bible, Revelations.
I'm pro Israel for the Jews to the core but when this guy said "That's on me".... wow that is A MAN!!!
$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ wheres it going or gone some people r living high on the hog ok.
What is Ashkenazy DNA ? They are the real children of ?
Who cares?!
Why are SOOOO pro "Palestinian"?
he has no jop since 2014,jopless,bigest layer ever!!!
Good job Tim as usual, as a Palestinian I am really ashamed of the lies that are being repeated over the years by Erekat who is vehemently advocating the PA as if they never made a mistake. The PA is mired with corruption yet he denies the evident facts shown by Tim. Erekat has to resign after the recurrent failures of negotiations with Israel along the past 25 years that yielded nothing but humiliation, more annexation of land in West Bank and more brutality in the Gaza Strip, needless to mention the complicity of PA with Israeli in besieging Palestinians in Gaza.
The Palestinian authority and the occupation of Israel are the same thing
circus
😆
Tim Sebastian belongs in Russia or China.
Dr. Saeb Erekat is a decent diplomat. The point is that cursed Palestian leaders refused PEACE, several times because they were corrupted communists. Now the peace condition depend upon the mercy of Mr. Netanyahu or someone else who will succeed him, as the Palestinian ordinary people are paying an excessive price of pain, suffering and bloodshed for their miserable leaders . Why they don’t get an advice from Anwar Sadat?
A decent diplomat doesn't embarrass himself with so many obvious lies.
Sebastian did an excellent job in exposing them.
He is a pathological liar like the entire Palestinian authority, he hates Israelis with the exception of his doctors.
How is he a "decent" diplomat? Have you not heard of the "10 days in Jenin"? Erekat stood in front of the world media and screamed that Israel had MASSACRED 500 Palestinians. It was a blatant lie and to this day Erekat has not explained, yet alone apologised for this deliberate action to demonise the Israel Defence Forces - incite hatred against the Israelis. That in fact is the only thing this "diplomat" is successful at doing.
Do you know that he is known as the "King of Jericho" which means he is incredibly rich and powerful, whilst the ordinary people struggle to make a living? He is a dictator in "diplomat's clothing". He talks of elections when there aren't any! He has the opposition beaten up and his defence is "oh well, I commit mistakes."
Sodastream had a factory in the West Bank where hundreds of Palestinians had a meaningful job which enabled them to support their families. Erakat and BDS drove Sodastream out! (They moved to the south of Israel where now hundreds of Israeli Muslim Bedouin work alongside Jewish Israelis and DO support their families.)
This guy has no credibility.
If the UN at this time to decide that Texas is a new country with all native Indian ,what would US people do ??? Dadada you are hypocrites !