India-US Relations After Modi's DC Visit | Mideast Policy | India-Pak Trade | EP 162 | Ashok Malik
Вставка
- Опубліковано 28 тра 2024
- In this episode, Uzair talks to Ashok Malik about Modi’s visit to the United States and the future of US-India relations. We also talked about India’s foreign policy in the Middle East, and prospects of trade between India and Pakistan.
Ashok Malik is a Partner at The Asia Group and Chair of its New Delhi-based subsidiary in India where he leads the firm’s in-market business strategy and services.
Drawing on over 30 years of experience in government, media, and thought leadership Ashok is a recognized specialist on India’s policy landscape and the intersection of business and politics. Ashok advises clients on tailored strategies for market entry and expansion in India, enterprise level risk management and crisis mitigation. His areas of expertise include India’s foreign and trade policies and the government’s approach to international business, resilient supply chains and national capacities.
Prior to joining TAG, Ashok served for three years (2019-22) as Policy Advisor/Additional Secretary in India’s Ministry of External Affairs. In that capacity, he worked closely with External Affairs Minister Dr. S. Jaishankar and others in the senior leadership of the Ministry to help shape and explain India’s foreign policy in a crucial and eventful period for the international system.
Chapters:
0:00 Introduction
1:30 Key takeaways from Modi’s US visit
25:46 India’s foreign policy in the Middle East
39:20 Future of India-Pakistan relations
Uzair, it’s seems that most of the comments are from Indians and so on could make an assumption that so are the viewers. This podcast was pure gold and It’s such a shame that Pakistanis don’t care enough to watch this. Thank you for this Uzair
What % of pakistani understands or speak english ??
Pakistanis are busy in the Urdu world. The economy is alien to Pakistanis as it's not written in the Quran
Any time Pakistanis are invited to an English tv discussion, within a minute they will make it a Hindi/Urdu discussion. Extremely frustrating for anyone who starts watching thinking it will be an English discussion
Why would they (🇵🇰) watch Ashok Malik, on India-US relations?
This gentleman is thoughtful and well spoken. Quite in contrast to so many empty vessels that make loud noises on the internet these days. Kudos to Uzair for bringing him. He demonstrates very well how you can be a strong advocate for your Nation without being offensive and degrading other players.
You don't know who Ashok Malik is?
@@Kaafiristanino. Who's he?
Lol "Offensive", "Degrading". Such depraved Dhimmitude
@@Heretic-007another "aman ki asha" preacher 😂
The people of India have moved on and don't factor in pak Muslims in any trade or activity or plans
That was such an insightful discussion. India is blessed to have experts like him being consulted by the MEA.
😂As contrasted by the "advisors" and "consultants" of our past such as Sam Pitroda - whose only qualification was an expertise in gandhi dynasty ass kissery.
No , Pakistan literally has better experts. Come out of Godi media and you might see the reality
Pre partition generation is more or less gone & with them those who romanticized Indo Pak relations. Even the torch bearer of Aman Ki Asha Mr. Kyldeep Nayyar. The first generation of post partition borns are still carrying the vivid images of what was narrated to them by their grandparents & parents about the horrors of Independence. The current generation only looks towards those countries which offer them something that is of interest to them. Be it travel,education,culture, cuisine,adventure or competitive sports, business & career opportunities. Pakistan does not count on any of these grounds. This generation is not even sware of Pakistan unless it is some negative event in Pakistan or involving Pakistan. There is no scope of any possibility of reapproachment.
I absolutely agree. I’m from a Punjabi Hindu family that ‘migrated’ from Lahore to Delhi.
My great grandparents spoke about their neighbours in Lahore.
My grandparents spoke about their schools and their homes in Lahore.
My parents spoke about their parents speaking about their homes in Lahore.
I sometimes (once in 2-3 months) watch a Pakistani podcast on UA-cam and then forget about everything I heard. I also can’t point out Lahore on a map.
My children will probably not even know that we ‘migrated’ to Delhi, and they will most likely not even know that we have any connection to Pakistan.
The ‘relationship’ is absolutely over.
25:27
As an ordinary Indian Citizen, not politician or diplomat, the best way to make Obama know he wasn't being in his limits, i dare say meddling, is by calling him out loud, as loud as possible.
It might not change, his way of consituency induced thinking, but the message has to go that the common Indian isnt very happy with his unilateral sweeping negativity.
Unlike Ashok Sir, i dont need to be diplomatic by saying i respect Obama, not after this for sure, none whatsoever.
India Dominates the internet as we have some 800 Million people on net . No other country even has that population ( China has its own internet ) . As the Obama has said some things this dominant indian netizen will find his hidden deeds which was hidden behind his well crafted family man , ethical man image and will be painted all across net . That might change his well crafted PR image upside down .
Obama alluded that India should maintain it's secular credentials as given in our constitution. Modi said that proudly in his reply. Focus on idea. I respect the idea he is represent. The idea in our constitution.
@@IndiaTides Not sure what lead to Obama's urge to iterate that India should maintain it's secular credentials.
Would it be Ok if an ex-Indian PM alluded that US should maintain it's gun culture as given in their constitution?
@@IndiaTides Yup, but regards the constitution was he stating the obvious, if he was only talking about the constitution ?
He was less alluding and more of insinuating, that whatever he was mentioning about minority wasn't being followed here, of course, it could be uninformed or agenda driven statement.
The same secularism holds true in all, whether US allies in Europe, where there is rioting, in many countries including champions of liberty - France, Sweden, Belgium or Greece.
But was there any mention of this by Obama in any interview, no ? That's the reason I called it agenda driven.
ppakistan ( iislamb ka khila) please take all the mmosslim from iindia ...iindia is fade up of iisllamb ...iindia will give u 10 billion dollar free free free.... please take tthem away ..iindia taang aa chuka iislamb se ...leke jao re leke jao.
For pakistani who think 🇮🇳 will attack pakistan they are totally wrong in understanding India . India hve never attack anyone in the history . We want to process and our main aim to become 5 trillion till 2026 . Jai Hind 🇮🇳
Exactly! Only idiots think in terms of military power
India's "soft" nature is counter-productive
pplease ppakistan and ttaliban take all the mmosslim from iindia ...iindia is fade up of iislamb ...india will give u guys 10 billion dollar free free free..... lage k jao rey.. sach main india taang aa chuka hai iislamb se..
Agree with...
Bhains ke aage been Baja rahe ho bhai.
Part of the reason for the social media “noise” is that it is easy to participate in !
Understanding and discussing geopolitical strategy is much more complex and difficult to comment upon!
Thanks for another good discussion- you need to get a wider audience Uzair for your excellent work!
Absolutely.
in 46' election mmosslim voted for paakistan ( more than 90%) but this kaamchor librandu congress party did not do popul. xchange..
@@urrasscal8380 where the hell do u even these datas man?
@@EoamerGaming97 46' election result ----mmosslim constituency ---( Bombay Province 100% seat goes to M. League, Madras 100% , Bengal 95% , Assam 91%, Orissa 100%, Central Province 93% so on so on....)
@@urrasscal8380 dude where the source ???
Uzair and Askok, I incidentally passed through your conversation and feel very refreshingly positive. I very rarely access to a fully English podcast with aPakistani blogger/ journalist and his interviewed person. Uzair never intervened and allowed Ashok come out freely.
Uzair, you got a new subscriber, Indian from Singapore
My first time with Pakistonomy.Excellent discussion.
Ashok Malik was in great form and its amazing that there is so much of alignment and clarity among the various players that make up our MEA team.....Its obvious that what is being said is a polished version of several thoughts, ideas, arguments and steadfast commitment to advancing the best interest of our great country Bharat!
it was also very noticeable that when it comes to Pakistan - Ashok gave a very thoughtful, diplomatic, and nuanced response. The ball is in Pakistan's court. It's a pity that very few in that country can get the subtle signals and grasp the rapidly changing geo-political realities - Perhaps people like Uzair and other intellectuals should influence the powers in Pakistan.
However, the million $ question though is "Who is in charge in Pakistan and what are their motives and intentions" - an honest answer to this 1 question is the only place to start....
This is what we call a discussion or expressing your views without disrespecting others.
Uzair, Eid Mubarak. As a gujarati, we share a history. It will remain forever
You bandyo?
Are you also Arab Turk Irani Afghans qasim ghori ghazni Babar Aurangzeb nadir Shah abdali ki rape jihad ki najayaz paidaish ganduudin namazi aashiq gay rasool?
No Eid in india please
Gujarati is a dying language.
@@lord_of_love_and_thunder Where?
Uzair thank you for calling a brilliant expert Ashok Malik, Discussion was awesome
India's FX and tax rules are most frustrating in all the countries I have done business in. Even if rates are fine, the taxman ensures complaince is an irritant. Same with FEMA
@37:00 the part after this was pure gold. Amazing way to put what we feel in words.
With Imran drawing a Red line in no talks until Article 370 is repealed......no leaders in Pakistan can dare to cross it.
Moreover, unless the Pakistani text books are made free of hatred for India and Hindus..........it's futile to think that relations could improve even in the future.
Gosh! If there ever was an eye-opener for Pakistan, it is Modi's US visit. People (not politicians) in Pakistan need to realize they're being fed with the same BS that they have been for decades now. Same old crap in new packaging. The constant narrative of India being the enemy needs to end. Who needs an external enemy when you have no money within the country? For Pakistan, the writing is on the wall. The way forward is as clear as the summer sky. It's going to take serious will and digging in if the country needs/wants to stand up on its feet. Pretty sure nobody in India cares about the 'Pakistan problem', given the trajectory their economy is on.
You're thinking too much. We are also third world country and faces a lot of issues like chinese agression, slow growth, poverty, cross border terrorism etc.
@@Spectra12 that’s true. Every country has its issues but there is quite a bit India has going for it.
@@mohammadumarkhan4409You have to trust and pressure the government you choose.
@@Spectra12 lol that's the root cause of their problem as elections are useless in Pakistan.
It's a pleasure to listen to Mr. Malik's clarity of thought and expression!!
Awesome discussion. Ashok is always good to listen to
13th minute - India's current (post FY22-23) GDP as per the GoI stands at : $3.7 Trillion. 🇮🇳
Very interesting and educating analysis by Ashok Malik ji! 🙏 🇮🇳
Hindustan zindabad🎉
This podcast episode was amazing…learned so much!
This is far better discussion than our Indian media. our Indian is becoming more and more fanatic jingoist. This is a really good discussion between on India-U.S. relations, national security and economic policy, political messaging in the era of social media, the Middle East, the importance of geography, and India-Pakistan relations, among other topics.
Acha😂😂😂
And you for sure aren't some rape jihad ki najayaz paidaish ganduudin namazi aashiq gay rasool hira Mandi randistani porkistani bhikharistani Pakistani 😂😂😂
You don't see any other media 😂😂😂😂😂
Uzair Bhai, Eid Mubarak.
🙏🙏🙏
Thank you
Very interesting…the guest was v wise and knowledgable about India. I do not usually comment but was forced to do so due to the unusually great conversation
Uzair Bhai eid ki hardik shubhkamnaye
Thank you
@@Pakistonomy is'nt hharram in iislaamm to take greet from a kkaaffir?? ... .. i think i am rright...
@@Bharat-ff2ohUsne th insan dekha or tune dharam.
@@ResponsibleCitizen001 well said
Guys, har Jagah Hagna jaroori hai kya? It's a harmless wishes.
*Indeed it was relatively DEEPER conversation* 😃😃😃😃
Does India even need to trade with Pakistan?, I mean what's in it for them. At the end of the day, it's Pakistan who's losing out, I don't think it has had or will have any effect on India's economy.
India gains a lot as Pakistan is a hugee market (can't stress more) for so many of its goods, considering the similarities in culture, cuisines, love for movies. India would gain more than Pakistan as Pakistan barely has products to export, so there would understandably be a significant trade surplus,
@@anmolnaugaria6965As a percentage of its exports it will still be small. Having said that I don't see issue in having a normal trade relationship, just not at the cost of anything else.
@@anmolnaugaria6965 Their purchasing power is very low. They are empty drums, only make loud noise.
Absolutely no to Pakistan.. Trading with Pakistan is dangerous for us.
We 🇮🇳 should not disturb Pakistan at this juncture... particularly when it is in self destruction mode..
@@anmolnaugaria6965Just look at their buying capacity and their foreign reserves man they can't be lucrative market for India. How much trade are you expecting from them max 1-2 billion that's it. One more thing whenever something happen between us first things Pakistani will do is stop trading.
Dear Ashok,
What I don't understand is why is the reaction from an Indian politician a bigger problem than an American politician's triggering a response for an unwanted comment.
I love Obama,, but this comment was extremely hurtful and it deserved a hurtful response, which I think is fine.
Why are we still in this colonial mindset that if we can't be proactively rude, we at least deserve the right to be reactive in the way we deserve it should be responded.
Please don't be apologetic.
Obama deserved a response and personally I feel we still were too meek.
Our FM and CM of Assam just pointed out something which is the truth. Can anyone or even Obama himself deny anything which they said. You tell me?
Exactly we shouldn't be apologetic to anyone specially when they are propaganda driven.
Obama is not an American Politician. Why are you worried about America Internal Affairs?
What the FM said is factually right but USA didn't bomb those muslim countries because of religious reasons....the reasons were something else which were also problematic. And how this government is treating the minorities of the country is a matter of concern....just look at the number of lynchings that happened in the last two months
@@arnabkundu114well fall in line with native culture..or anyone will be lynched be it in india or any other country
@@arnabkundu114since independence there have been only 16 lynching case in which a hindu mob attacked muslim, this is less than the no. of deaths due love jihad in Last month.
What an intelligent conversation! This channel has definitely caught my attention. Good stuff, Uzair!
Young India feels irritation and indifference towards Pakistan and its poorly educated and radicalized people with a hatred mindset. When terrorist incidents take place, anger is always there. I as a person want absolutely nothing to do with the Islamic republic of Pakistan...and this view is shared by all my friends and colleagues! 🇮🇳
fact that there are very few Pakistanis in the comment section, shows why Pakistan is lagging behind, there is no representation in a constructive discussions from the Pakistanis.
You right. 253 countries comments are also missing, they are also behind India. Only a Hindu can think like that.
A very interesting and informative discussion, would like to see this guest back again
very nice discussion...really like his podcast
Ashok malik has all credentials and knowledge of the existing government in India. Good to hear his view.
Very informative and well worth a listen.
Glad you enjoyed it
Simply outstanding 👏
One fact every pakistani who dont have hair on his head talk 100percent real things, like junaid bhai ,uzair bhai
Wow Yunus... You are amazing 👏 ❤️ Lots of love from India 🇮🇳
Superb!
Very informative and logical conversation , hope to see some Pakistani speaking for Pakistan the same way Dr Ashok did in the podcast. Great work by Uzair Younas, keep rocking 👏.
Honestly...BOTH WERE IN A KIND OF ILLUSION OR TRY TO BE GOOD, HOW IT POSSIBLE FOR INDIA 🇮🇳 TO HAVE TRADE WITH A COUNTRY WHICH " CORE IDEA IS PROMOTING TERROR IN INDIA 🇮🇳 "?? 🤔🤔🤔 DO you think MODI WILL DO THAT??
Ashok Malik is really well spoken and knows the reality. 👍🏼👍🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
GIFT CITY IN GUJRAT WILL BE INNOVATIVE CENTER AND listed companies will be newly created. US companies will be listed in new stock exchange.
What Pakistani have done to AHMEDIA/HINDI/SIKH/CHRISTIAN IS WELL KNOWN.
Wonderful conversation
Uzair you did not ask about books which you always do with your Guests 😊
Serious discussion is core to such platform what makes me coming back and seeing it very often
Thoroughly loved the discussion!
Interesting discussion, Uzair.
One thing that i ll disagree with host is that without pakistan we won't be able to trade with Central asia... if we won't be able to sell goods at 100 than certainly on 115 we could via iran.. our big manufacturing center is not punjab its west-east coast juggernaut cities & certainly now UP is coming up but for that we have dedicated freight corridor, interlinking of rivers & huge upgradation of ports.. without pakistan we were doing good & ll do better only thing that concern us is cross border narcotics & terrorism... The way we are growing up we ll let our economic partners to sort it out on our behalf ie economic & political way.. i hope pakistan behave like normal country & feed its people first.
Firstly Central Asian economies are small due to corruption except Kazakhstan so trade with them shall be negligible. Unless Afghanistan becomes stable, trade with Central Asia will never become viable
Haryana is an automobile hub too and Uttarakhand has some chemical industry FYI
Eid mubarak Uzair, really special talk on a really special day, thanks again
Thank you
The discussion was so good.👏
i think you need a designer to make you thumbnails for your video. they are all same!!!
Amazing Podcast! Thanks.
Such an insightful discussion!
Thank you Mr. Younus
Great discussion
Uzair bhai , eid mubarak , economy pr latest updates wghera ki videos bnaya kren ya weekly ik video rkh lein, meri ye request hai , shukria.
What about HILALI?😆😆
@@sreekantcp hey what's wrong celebrating aarrab festival by aarrabs ....ppakistan is a aarrab country ... let them celebrate their aarrabic festival.
Lovely!
It was good conversation 🙏... You know Uzair Bhai..... India has in-vested Last 70 yr plus year playing India-Pakistan Game... And we reached nowhere....As Indian state realise there is world beyond pakistan (unfortunately)... As immense interest in Geography....in North American continent compared with south Asia.... there is Large country is America (India).. 2nd most developed economy is Canada (Pakistan) .....but Pakistan doesn't want to be Canada in South Asia... If they don't Bangladesh can win the race.... So pakistan has to think 😅🎉❤
Great Job Uzair
An excellent episode. Seems most viewers of Pakistonomy are Indians
Amazing &Informative 👍. Pls visit Kerala soon❤
Not a single Pakistani guy’s comment. Is there any internet in Pakistan?
they all go silent when something good about india is being said
Why are you worried? Why and what do you want them to comment?
@@vinsin328 At least we should know their opinion.
@@vinsin328 we should know what the cockroaches think. always worried about hindutva in India while being the most vile of islamists at home
@@Spashththis
Uzair, please do a video with Dr Cheema on Intellect of Indian analysts/commentators/ bureaucrats Vs Pakistani bureaucrats/analysts/commentators
Uzair bhai, Pakistan have still free trade agreement with china ?
Well China is almost free to do anything in Pakistan. So that's that.
@@sewaligoswami781😂😂😂😂
Eid Mubarak Uzair bhai
ppakistan is a aarabic country so they sud celebrate their aarrabic festival.
Ab bhikari bhi Amir logo par opinion rakhenge 😂😂😂😂😂
Why Pakistani podcasts are very knowledgeable and not loud?
No Pakistani in the comment section? Lol
🤚
Younus bro, can you do something for indo pak normalization of relations,😢, can pak army accept the reality, or we have to continue hating each other
There was not discussion about internal and external security point of view which has impacted trade vis. Ind - pak
Even though i dont prefer such neutral (pseudo) versions or perspectives over brutal truths...‼️ Brutal truth is the version which is closer to the one truth ‼️
Trade is the King. Trading with each other keeps people engaged.
Trading with Jihadis and terrorists would legitimise Terrorism and enrich the Jihadis
Not with an ideological state.
Books?
U need to ask people from your land..how they see this relationship (India and US)?
Sharing of critical n emerging technologies... digging your grave.
When many of u are going to leave US?
How can u make an enemy nation your new home?
Because we are clear hum sirf char tukde karenge...not thousands of cuts.
Precision guaranteed and incisive operation.
Long live Hindus and Hindutva and polytheism n pluralism.❤❤
Uzair, I like you. I wish more Pakistanis were like you.
He's technically American.
@@Himelizationbut Pakistanis are allowed to hold two passports. So technically be can be both.
Certainly a very interesting conversation. But as it concluded it somehow left me with a feeling that Uzair was rather anxious about India’s immediate neighbour on its West. Though I can appreciate why he would choose to dwell on it so much of his time explaining it certainly is a mystery why Ashok took so much time explaining the ‘relationship’ while the truth has already been stated several times and the best example would be what Professor Ishtiaq Ahead had to say just a few days ago: ua-cam.com/video/EOpVa20fCi8/v-deo.html
There are times when being blunt helps🙏🏼
👏👏👏👏
Your guest is misquoting Indian GDP has lil more than 3 trillion, while it's Significantly more than 3 trillion, it's standing at $3.8 Trillion at current prices, please correct your guests when they misquote these crucial numbers
48:49 What does India gain from trading with Central Asia. There are easier and bigger trading partners than Central Asian countries currently.
Kudos to Uzair for bringing sensible person instead of motor mouths.
44:00
Important
Guma guma ke Jalebi answer on Pakistan😂😂 It’s not in Pakistan Establishment interest to open up relationship with India.
Neighbor is the only relationship! India will ignore this stupid neighbor and move on!
English language is totally missing the cultural and religious nuances in relations or enmity between the two countries or to be honest, it’s hiding it. Entire talk about trade, commerce is just nonsense.
I think it's because that's how modern world works? China's ethnic cleansing of muslims doesn't matter to Saudi or Pakistan, Israel occupation doesn't matter to Saudi, turkey.
Happy to see pakistan discussing deep intellectual stuffs
ROBERT GATES IS BACK IN BIDEN ADMINISTRATION, building India USA partnership
....Governments in Islamabad means government in Pindi. i.e Qoum's baaps. LOL.
India Pakistan Trade Tauba Tauba 😂😂
Hi Uzair...Why not you invite people like J.Sai Deepak, Sanjay Sanyal, Vikram sampath in Your show? Why always " Certain" people are here?...IS IT SHOWING PAKISTAN 🇵🇰 AS A " SOFT" COUNTRY, IS YOUR AGENDA??...
uzair , Happy Eid to you and your family and thankyou for this valuable podcast
Thank you! You too!
x-president obama and not president obama ;
People to people contact is the biggest way we can normalise relationship. We are fed with propaganda both sides. If we meet and talk with each other we will realise there are not aliens on the other side of the wire. This is why Indians and Pakistanis stick together and gravitate towards each other abroad. Our shared language and culture makes us close
Narender Modi ji bola kr
tamiz se naam le
A bit too much of a shallow commentary. Not much on the nuclear deal lacking progress, nothing on trade, lack of anything to show on technology, pharma. Just a few defence deals here and there. The jet engine deal is indeed big, but really hope that it does not go the nuclear deal way, that once the deal is signed nothing comes of it, no new reactors are built.
India has good strategic alignment with the USA, but this is not able to deliver much in terms of geo-economics. Part of this is due to Make in India itself failing to deliver, so lets not blame the relationship, but then it is a bit chicken and egg
GE Deal inherently cannot go the nuclear way
GE deal comes with huge domestic demand. Our MK2 (150+), AMCA Mk1(80+), TEDBF(Depend on Navy's req) fighter will be equipped with these very engines.
You are looking at 500+ engines equiped on Indian jets. Limited ToT will help us a long with our indigenous programs.
And I'm not even considering the export potential of Indian fighters which will inflate the numbers further.
Having said that. I believe MoU were signed with US companies for Semi Con Fabs?
Engine deal is just a start.
We can't squeeze everything out of Americans in just one visit. Co op will grow with time.
+Trade deal is quite a big step, US will try to get most out of India if it ever hits the agenda.
@@apoorvchauhan6258 OK. But the GE deal is just an MoU yet. It still has to be converted to a license. Then warranties have to be discussed. This same process went with the Rafale - in the original tender, Dassault was to produce this in HAL. But then the documentation went nowhere. So I am not too hopeful. HAL has not been very receptive to tech transfer. No one is questioning demand. Is implementation of the deal that is the issue
@@abhaygoel4090 Yes! I'll absolutely agree on lethargic attitude of our DPSUs on fruitifying Defence Deals.
But we do have to consider the increased and sweeping role of GoI in such deals, considering the backdrop of MMRCA (RFP goes back to 2001) where GoI simply went for G2G.
But in this case I'm quite hopeful of the progress, MMRCA procurement was in limbo due to issues with Dassaults apprehensions with shifting production to India.
As for GE deal, currently we only have 8 GE F414s which can be utilised for testing TDs and at Max for 1 or 2 LSPs.
Mk2 first flight is in 2025 and we can expect it to hit serial production in 2027.
So HAL has 3-4 years for drawing up contract and setting up facilities.
I'll also consider increased accountability of DPSUs. They have sketchy record but they are now making up for it.
Having said that, one cannot underestimate red tape so I might have to eat my words in future lol.
Time will tell but I'm optimistic
@@abhaygoel4090As we speak you can check today's news on implementation.
Here comes Mr smarty pants.
One unfortunate characteristic I've noticed about public personalities from subcontinent (and this includes women as well) is that when we talk about a person as an example we naturally assume them to be men. Instead of he/him, we should use they/them, he/she or him/her. This isn't LGBTQ ideology, just basic decency to include women. I've actually watched female bureaucrats working in women's welfare departments show this habit as well, which is shocking!
Why you invited a modi, rss fan boy ? LOL