Who Was The BETTER Power Forward: Kevin Garnett OR Tim Duncan?!
Вставка
- Опубліковано 23 тра 2024
- Sheed and Bonzi debate another two power forwards and who was better, this time between Tim Duncan and Kevin Garnett. The two think that Garnett might have been more dominant but that it's tough to pick against the Big Fundamental.
Sheed and Tyler Is LIVE every Tuesday-Thursday at 5pET throughout the NBA Playoffs!
🏀 Ready for some fantasy basketball? Go to play.underdogfantasy.com/p-sheed and use promo code 'SHEED' to get up to $250 in bonus cash AND a special pick to enter best ball tournaments, try our DFS contests, and build pick'em entries.
💸 Promo to play: play.underdogfantasy.com/p-sheed
💬 Join the Underdog Discord for access to exclusive giveaways and promos: / discord
🍿 Previous Episodes
Sheed and Tyler ➝ • Sheed & Tyler
Underdog NBA Shorts ➝ • UDNBA Shorts
▶️Underdog’s UA-cam Channels
The Underdog Football Show → / @underdogfantasy
Underdog NBA → / @sheedandtyler
Gil's Arena → / @gilsarena
✍️ We Also Write at Underblog!
Underdog Network ➝ underdognetwork.com/
Follow Underdog on Twitter ➝ / underdogfantasy
Follow Justin Phan on Twitter → / jphanned
Follow Underdog NBA on Twitter → / underdog__nba
Follow Underdog NFL on Twitter → / underdog__nfl
Follow Underdog Pick'em on Twitter → / underdogpicks
💸 Get up to $250 in bonus cash AND a special pick ➝ play.underdogfantasy.com/p-sheed - Спорт
TD beat Sheed, Ben Wallace and Antonio McDyess in 2005 finals with one leg.
Damn! I didn't know that
As a Piston fan who watched every game in that series Manu Ginobili was the best player in that series.
@@marquscrews detroit cant stop manu, thats true. the real mvp of the finals.
but sheed is butthurt of game 7 loss.
@@marquscrewsIgnoring context. Duncan was doubled almost every touch allowing Manu 1v1 looks against Rip Hamilton.
@@hardwoodthought1213 and Tayshaun
Tim duncan didn't play in a system, HE WAS THE SYSTEM
Amen
STOP IT...
He did. The time around
Tim was just a supremely fundamental player, a better version of joker really,
@@darrellmahan8404 No he wasnt..stop lying...Joker is a Hundred Times more fundamentally skilled he basically has no athleticism and all he does is based on fundamentals....stop repeating what dumb media lies to you
Man KG was a beast but Tim was just so good for so long.
They were both good for long.
He was cuz he had help
@@NotAnAstronaut2kthat’s what they keep leaving out
🧢. His peak wasn’t even that long
@@est.inthe80sand KG didn’t have help on the Celtics? lol he literally had Paul Pierce and Allen, Rondo in their primes and they managed to only win 1 Chip when they for sure should of won at least 2-3
5:38 98-99 “Tim wasn’t the #1 option”)
David Robinson - 15.8 & 10 (playoffs: 15.6 & 9.9)
Tim Duncan - 21.7 & 11.4 (playoffs: 23.2 & 11.5)
You are right. But you can't compare their first years in a 1 to 1 comparison. Tim Duncan went to college and having better help, let him score easier. KG was a skinny 18 year old, without the same level of help. So defenses could clamp down on him and not have to worry about him passing. I feel like KG's first 2 seasons shouldn't even count because he was skinny and really should have went to college for a year or two.
@@Davivd2 KG was an all-star at the same time Duncan was. It has nothing to do with college and KG being skinny. He was naturally not as physically big as Duncan. Duncan's edge was he was wider than KG and could post up on the block easily unlike KG.
KG was an all star in year two.
@@Davivd2 they’re the same age.. like 3 weeks apart.. so you can definitely do a 1 for 1 comparison.. KG developed against NBA talent, Timmy developed against the NCAA.
Someone knows........
Translation: We liked KG more. Bonzi straight up said Duncan is the better option if you trying to win a chip. That means he is the better player.
Pretty much KG is the guy they would like to hang out with hence why he's better than Duncan.
holy shit thats bonzi wells? I started watching nba in 2007 so wasnt really familiar with a lot of 90s and early 00s guys but I watched enough hardwood classics on nba tv in the early 2010s to know some of the earlier guys. I remember watching hardwood classic lakers vs Trail Blazers 2000 western conference finals game 7 bonzi going crazy against LA
Pretty much lol. The disrespect is real. Tim was an absolute monster on both ends from day 1 and is roundly acknowledged as the best PF of all time. This isn’t a personality contest.
It easy to say that when you had a great coach a great front office and a better team I mean before Boston how many great teams was KG on think about it
@@est.inthe80sExactly, like I love Tim, but he was drafted into a much better situation, He had Pop and a great organization from the jump, an all time great in David Robinson and great vets like Avery Johnson, Sean Elliott and Steve Kerr, KG didn’t have anything close to that until 04, then again in 08, just think about it.
KGs defensive impact is actually underrated imo
TDs too, specially in his younger years
One of best of all time not underrated
KG can guard guys on the perimeter. That was never something Duncan could do
@@MikeBNumba6 prime kg was a more versatile defender than prime td, but not a better defender
@@MikeBNumba6 dude avg 5 blocks in the finals, so take that to the bank!
Tim won even in Shaq Kobe Era,just think about that.
Only thing KG had over Tim was Athleticism and his mouth.
If Duncan was loud, talked a lot, did commercials and so forth he would be much higher on people radar and GOAT debates
Only thing Duncan did better was score (in the paint 🎨) and shot block. Garnett did literally everything else better.
Shooting and guarding 1-5.. Duncan can't guard 1-5 or out shoot KG.. KG beat Team USA in 1v1s.. Duncan not doing non of that..
KG was a far superior passer, ball handler, and off-ball defender than Duncan. Probably a better rebounder and outside shooter as well. Get real. Arguably the most well rounded big man ever
Kevin Garnett was able to guard point guards in his prime lol that’s should tell you right there who was the better player
Kevin Garnett was more box office than Tin Duncan, that's why we pick Garnett 😂
Garnett was a phenom. He had a 99 in all of the early 2Ks for a reason!
Love KG but its Timmy for the W
Exactly!
NO 👎🏼
Tim is the most overrated. The spurs had a squad they were legit the Warrior back in the day.
Duncan never carried shit with his 18ppg 🤦♂️
Duncan. Next?
Luis Scola Gold Duncan bronze next ?
Garnett, next.
Robert Horry next
It’s hilarious how casuals like you that have never played organized basketball say Duncan in a heartbeat. But players who actually faced both are torn between the two. Think about that.
@@thsu8 to assume somebody has never played the game organized kinda shows you never played fyi lol
People don't know Tim Duncan have 15 all defensive teams let that sink in
but no DPOY awards. I've always found that strange.
@@rnssr71 Voters prioritise blocks too much
@@rnssr71 it’s a bad mark on the league, IMO. Dude was All-NBA and All-Defense in his first 13 seasons, only player in history to accomplish that. He anchored one of the consistently greatest defenses in the league for 15 seasons. He did all of that and not a single DPOY? That’s a blight on the league as far as I’m concerned.
Did u watch all 15 seasons or u just saying stats
@@cortezflowers3464yup. Once a player gets a rep they can coast and keep getting accolades especially if they are like
If Tim Duncan had more swag and didn’t play with Yu-Gi-Oh cards, we wouldn’t even be having this conversation Tim Dunkin clears by a mile
Yugioh 😂😂😂😂
Duncan came in out the gate carrying the Admiral.Duncan Was the MAN in the first finals 1999.Stop the disrespect and hos defense was craaazy
Robinson was better than Duncan for years after Duncan entered the league.
@@penkima4923
When from 99 to 2003 lol?
@@penkima4923 Duncan got MVP consideration during his rookie year while Robinson was not in the MVP voting.
DRob was old.
@@21stcenturycynicalguyviews82 Robinson finished 7th in MVP-voting after Duncan's rookie season, even though Robinson gave up his spot at the center completely to Duncan. Duncan was 5th in MVP-voting as a rookie.
Tim Duncan won Finals MVP in 99, He was the first option Day 1
Yeah did Ewing played ??
@@PIP...33He was also All-NBA 1st team and top 5 in MVP voting as a rookie. So again, how was he not the first option from day 1?
@@hardwoodthought1213 EASY TO BE WHEN ADMIRAL DOES MOST JOB. JUST LIKE WILT CHAMBERLAIN LET JERRY WEST POINTS BUT DOES EVERY JOB FOR TEAM. U LITERALLY NEVER SAW NBA IN YOUR LIFE. JOKIC IS NOT FIRST OPTION ITS JAMAL MURRAY YET JOKIC DOES EVERYTHING ELSE
You're not wrong, but Tim Duncan didn't come to the league straight out of high school. Apples and oranges...
If you switch Duncan and KG, The Spurs may have more chips.
Sheed is just salty he lost to one legged TD in 2005 finals. KG was drafted in 1995 and got traded to Boston in 2007. During his tenure with Minnesota he reached wcf once. Duncan had 4 chips already at that time.
True but Duncan had the better teams and coach by far. KG really had no help till he got traded. But I agree Sheed is salty 😅
Team stability is a thing
Bro put Tim on the twolves & KG in SA
@@stevencollins920 by that logic you would argue that Iverson was the same or even better than Jordan since the second one had way better supporting cast during his career. They both had semi-comparable stats but somehow one won 6 chips while the other none.
@@RedSynthez bad take. AI did not have the same SKILL SET as MJ. Good reach tho
The one who is nearly a consensus pick for PF GOAT.
Kevin McHale & Hakeem Olajuwon
Well, Tim Duncan didn't play 1 game of basketball as a power forward. He wasn't good enough to be the best center ever, so I guess somebody started a false narration that he was a PF.
@@penkima4923 Duncan was PF when Robinson was Center ... Like Olajuwon PF/Center ... Love Duncan ... LOVE Olajuwon & Kevin McHale MORE ...
@@bryanfox6726 Duncan wasn't in the league, when Robinson played center. Duncan was listed more as a center than power forward for his career. Duncan was listed as a power forward as a rookie, only because Robinson was taller. But Robinson still played power forward and Duncan the center.
@@penkima4923 Either Way ... I'm sayin' if we're talkin' GOAT PF ... I'm takin' McHale or Olajuwon ...
Tim Duncan was the go to guy his first year
Who was the go to guy when Garnett came?
David Robinson was
@@melvynsngltn27 look at the stats stop it Tim came in ready
@yanettevaladez2623 I saw Tim when he came in the league. The fact that you Don't know Robinson led the team in scoring shows your age. After 1998 Robinson started to play second option to Duncan
@@melvynsngltn27 lol I know who Robinson is lol Duncan was finals mvp his second year in the league but okay
Tim was an mvp candidate his rookie year and second team all defense. He was finals mvp his second year. He swept Kobe and Shaq his second year. Saying he can't carry a team like kg? Yeah, right. David was well past his prime the year the Spurs won their first title.
Yup after 98, the admiral was a shell of himself
@@elbowgang9715 Shell ?? He just won 1996 gold as best player in USA popovich tanked him.
@@elbowgang9715 funny how shell 2001 was allstar ?? If Admiral was shell that means 28 other centers who didnt make it allstar game 2001 was 0 ppg
Prime Tim Duncan was in a great system that fit his style. No answer is really wrong. Prime KG was something too. Ferocious on both ends. When he got talent on Minnesota, they were good. If you’re just talking straight hooping. This is a toss up.
@@PIP...33 lol oh you’re just being silly.
This is a perfect example of that not all former NBA players are good analysts.
KG had a more varied offensive game and would appeal to a certain segment who love his persona. But it took him time to get to his peak because he joined the league straight out of high school. Duncan played all four years of college even though he could have entered the draft earlier. Maybe KG would have achieved the same or even more if they exchanged places, but maybe he wouldn't be able to diversify if he played in a different system. Individual success, in my opinion, is still shaped by the context of the team. This is why I would pick Duncan even though I love KG.
KOBE BRYANT WAS 3 YEARS BENCH SO WHATS YOUR POINT ?? KG IS COMPLETE PLAYER 2 WAY. DUNCAN CANT GUARD GUARDS OR WINGS HAS NO SPEED OR DRIBBLING OR FADEAWAY,
Thank you, tell these young casuals to hush. They talking like they watched them play.
Duncan is the greatest PF of all time but KG is my favorite PF of all time 🔥 🏀
I'm going with Tim Duncan every time.
They like KG better as a person and Duncan beat them both in huge spots (Blazers, Pistons) so they'll automatically say KG was better.
Duncan didn’t beat them. The Spurs with the best front office in the league beat them. It’s a team game. Tim Duncan would not have won anything in Garnett’s shoes in Minnesota from 1995-2007 playing with Sam Cassell, Malik Sealy, Sprewell, and Wally World. Aren’t you smart enough to use context in your arguments?
You want context? Duncan won in '03 in a Shaq & Kobe West--closed out the Finals with a quad-double that was incorrectly recorded. That team's 2nd-leading scorer was 19-YO Tony Parker who would sometimes get benched in the playoffs for stretches of the 4th for Speedy Claxton. 3rd-leading scorer was 24-YO Stephen Jackson and fourth was MALIK ROSE. David Robinson could barely move in 2003.
You just saw a bunch of names of great players and didn't consider the context of where they were in their careers.
Do you believe if you replace Duncan with KG that team wins a ring?
@@PitchfordStache 2003 Spurs with Garnett absolutely win a ring. KG was just as good or better than Duncan in 2003. Go watch their matchups from that year.
@@thsu8 Similar offensively, Duncan superior TS% and PER with much better defense and carries to a ring. Gimme a break.
KG had a postseason WS/48 > .2 one time, in a 4-game series loss to the Spurs in '01. Duncan did it seven times.
@@thsu8 I disagree with 1 point : Do you mean Sprewell and Cassell weren't top class players ?!
The man’s nickname was literally The Big Fundamental I.e CONSISTENT PRODUCTION
Duncan 1000%
Truth, they are just arguing KG's peak because he is with trash teammates and he needs to carry.
Consistent double double for more than 15 years, Duncan all day long.
KG NICK NAME WAS THE BIG TICKET BIG NBA CONTRACT
Tim is the greatest power forward ever and made Pop. His teammates were whatvthey was because of him. He just wasnt flashy. Remember he got his shit done during lakers dynasty. Lebron superteams era , greatest power forward era.a nd side note wentvto college four years and was great
The greatest of ever and made PoP? You're definitely a casual.
@@younglove3362 what's pop record without him
Duncan came to a very good team that only got him because Robinson got hurt....KG went to a bottom feeder
@@twizzy585ful Robinson never won without Tim but Tim won without him. KG that deal but Tim got him. I will give you about the team though
@@younglove3362 bruh grow up with name calling g. Talk sports not the b.s
Kg had Marbury and sprewell
And Cassell, and Billups, and Wally Z
All for one year. And each time he had legit help, his teams got to the conference finals, the finals, or won. Had he'd been on the Spurs they would have been better and Duncan would have no ring.
@@younglove3362 No shot bro. If Timmy was on the wolves they probably win 2 or 3 chips. We wouldn't be talking about Pop as the best coach of all time, wouldn't remember who Ginobli and Parker were. TD IS the Spurs culture. He was the engine, the mechanic and the driver.
@sebindabin
If you really believe that then you are extremely delusional. Stop with the desperate reaching.
And wally
And Timmy as a rookie was double team all the time ,change that franchise from the get go to a winning culture mentality
Admiral was in west finals and u call winning cuture ? Are u deranged
ADMIRAL WAS IN WESTERN FINALS. TF U TALKING BOUT ?
Robinson was the more important player for the franchise during Timmy's rookie season.
@@penkima4923More Important Doesn’t Always Mean Best. Duncan Literally Changed That Series
@@demasceionbyrd3776 Changing some series doesn't always mean the best. But Robinson was better, and had the bigger impact.
KG is a prime example of stats do not always tell the full story, KG affected the games he played in every aspect.
Love this podcast but I gotta disagree with Sheed and Bonzi. KG was carrying Minnesota for sure, but it never amounted to any substantial success save for 2004, and right after that they missed the playoffs for three straight years smack dab in KG's true prime. It's hard to imagine Duncan missing the playoffs because he literally never did. Garnett is more athletic, a better passer, and a more versatile defender, but his offensive game didn't demand the double and triple teams like TD's did because he wasn't a dominant post-up player. Pop started scaling back on Timmy's minutes early on in his career too, during his prime, which along with the Spurs' defensive, low # of possessions strategy, helped deflate his stats in his prime and ultimately across his career. KG was awesome, and Minny's front office sucked for years, but Duncan shouldn't be penalized for having truly dominant success on a good team. I feel that KG helping transform a mediocre team to a perennial first round exit/slightly better but still just on the bubble playoff team is less impressive than Duncan turning a perennial playoff underperformer into one of the most successful teams of his era.
Well said!
Nope. I agree with NBA players who played with or against to what a fan says.
Sheed misremembering a bit. They gave the reigns to Duncan after his rookie season lol. In 1998 they drew up a play for Duncan vs the Jazz for a game winner in game 2. In the playoffs, Duncan carried them offensively right off the BAT! Against Phoenix, Lakers, Jazz etc. I"m a Spurs fan and remember all of this. Garnett was too passive in crunch time.
"Tim duncan had better teams" Kg played with Paul Pierce (one of the clutchest players ever), Ray Allen (one of the greatest shooters ever), and Rondo (one of the greatest passers). You can argue that KG's 2008 Boston celtics was more talented than any team Tim Duncan was on.
Come on now you can’t be serious. Kg got hurt after they won their first one and was never the same. Also his age he was on the downside of his prime. Meanwhile Duncan had Parker, manu, kawhi, patty mills I could name more. Not saying Tim Duncan isn’t better. But this is a debate
@@t-god2439 Bro said patty mills like patty is some type of all star or something. Patty mills is literally a role player. And when Kawhi played with Duncan he wasn’t even an all star player yet. Paul Pierce is better than Tony Parker and Ray Allen is better than manu ginobili and it’s not even close.
@@WonderManFlex you saying that like patty mills in that spurs system wasent a big shot maker and big shot taker. Also throw Danny green in there. Not every big piece is an all star. The same way I’ll throw Derrick fisher in there when people ask who Kobe played with. These guys are very big pieces who helped the spurs have one of the greatest offenses of all time. Also can’t forget Bruce Bowen either a great 3-D player
@@WonderManFlex or Stephan Jackson who did go on to make an all star team
@@t-god2439 You’re stretching it tho. You can replace Patty mills with any other player and the spurs will still win chips. KG’s 2008 Celtics is more talented than any of Duncan’s spurs team and that is a fact. KG, ray Allen, Paul pierce, rondo. All in the starting lineup??? Cmon man
We also gotta stop acting like KG was out there playing 1 on 5 while Duncan was playing with the Dream Team. KG played with Marbury, Wally, Gugliotta, Brandon, Billups before he got Cassell and Sprewell. Go check these dudes numbers, they werent scrubs. Duncan had help. Of course. But these dudes acting like he went from Penny to Kobe to Wade like Shaq.
And the Spurs never went to the lottery while he was there!! The Wolves had so much talent, on top of those all stars you mentioned, they had other lottery picks that were there who just didn’t pan out. Meanwhile, the Spurs had to rummage through the end of the draft, G-league, and weren’t really a free agency destination. Love KG too but, even he said Duncan put him in his place.
Timmy on any team. He was the most unstoppable PF to ever play! And the second most skilled post player in history behind Olajuwan.
Naw Kevin McHale has the 2nd best post moves after Hakeem
better in what ? KG fadeaway duncan never learned. KG better from 2 mid range dunks 3 pts free throws. KG higher vert better speed dribbling can switch 1 to 5. Duncan 1 thing better 260 lbs.
Duncan skilled in what ?? U mean Webber have crossover Garnett played point guard 2004 when cassell injured and duncan cant even dribble.
@@elbowgang9715 Hakeem learned from McHale ...
Olajuwon played & preferred playing PF: Best Two PF's : McHale & Hakeem.
I think everyone including me will pick Timmy here but KG was a beast!
Duncan 10 out of 10 times
I think u r deranged not hear what Sheed talk. Do u even know who Admiral is ?
@@tommydavidwalker2445 better in what ? KG fadeaway duncan never learned. KG better from 2 mid range dunks 3 pts free throws. KG higher vert better speed dribbling can switch 1 to 5. Duncan 1 thing better 260 lbs.
@@tommydavidwalker2445 why u spread lies here ? Name 1 season duncan played without HOF ?
I've been saying KG since the early 00s. It has never changed
This is the conversation we should've been having for 25 years
Tim Duncan was option 1 as soon as he got there.......David knew Tim was a better player n gladly took a secondary role
Facts, 5th in MVP voting in his rookie year. 15 All nab defensive teams, could play any style of ball (post centric, PnR heavy, heavy ball movement) and won chips doing so. If KG and TD switched teams, Wolves probably win 3 chips, and you wouldn't even know Ginobli and Parker.
Not right away though, especially not in his rookie season when Duncan averaged 21.1 ppg and Robinson averaged 21.6 ppg.
Enough of this BS! TD woulda carried a shite team if he was drafted by one. The disrespect is ridiculous. Eveyone actin’ like the Spurs did anything before him and after him. TD having help has zero to do with who’s greater. Y’all disrespect Parker and Ginobili bc Tim was there, the Spurs bc Tim was there, Pop not great without Tim. Then y’all got the audacity to say Tim had a team around him so he’s not all that! KG even said Tim fd him up. Fck yall!
Parker and Ginobili weren’t even really help in 2003 and Duncan still beat prime Kobe and Shaq
I agreed about what Sheed said about KG, but in the end Tim was a better player.
Duncan was equally skilled if not more skilled & 15-20 pounds bigger = size matters
Tim is living in Sheed's head rent free. Still bitter after the Memorial Miracle😂😂😂
Tim Duncan was almost always surrounded by really good to great players for most of his career, so I understood where Sheed is coming from. Personally Matchup wise KG cant see Duncan... But I feel Sheed on this.
I see where you're coming from but people forget WHY those players seemed good/great. TD made everyone better, he was a selfless leader who let his teammates eat when they were hot, had high IQ to help them get theirs, didn't care what his stat line was as long as they won.. that's why we say he had better teammates, and that's why people struggle to see why TD unfortunately
@@sebindabin This is a hard one for me, because I agree with you but to an extent while disagreeing with you to an extent if that even makes sense. Yes he does make everyone better through his play style and being in that Popovich eco system where everyone has to be selfless to a degree in order to gel cohesively.
But those same players Manu and Tony Parker were them dudes and can go to any team and still be them dudes. Then we're talking about the vets whom have been part of championship teams, like Mario Elie and Kevin Willis out of Houston Rockets (tho I'm a lil sus on Kev). Steve Kerr, Robert Horry again championship pedigree. And also the influx of European players whom overseas are legit dudes... Patty Mills, Boris Diaw. TD was the ultimate anchor for all of these guys but that's also cuz of the Culture Popovich and management created and maintained.
TD was the focal point of their very first ring in 99
Facts
This topic should have waaay more views. One of my favorite debates
They forgot to mention Dirk. Played his whole career with 1 organization
They're both better than Dirk.
they did mention him with that point
We have to go with timmy. Dont forget only rings matter. tim top 5 all time. Thats how we end all debates
Rings matter when comparing teams, and Timmy certainly had the better team.
Look at their stats it shows Garnett is better. And that's something based off individually, not team wise. Assist, steals, rebounds, free throws and even points. Garnett has the edge. Duncan never lead his team in multiple statistics.
Timmy did get to come in with David Robinson. Not to take away from KG but he had some vets when he came in too. Isaiah Rider and Laettner. Then they got Starbury later.
San Antonio didn’t start winning titles until Duncan got there. He carried his team to titles!!!
Facts
Tim had help but was giving guys 20… KG was on a bad team & wasn’t… Bonzi point was spot on..
Garnett scored as much as Garnett, if not more. Stop.
Duncan went to college first. KG was a skinny 18 year old. It's hard to compare their first years as a 1 to 1 comparison.
@Davivd2
And as petty as people want to be, I'm being petty back. Coming from college or coming from Highschool, which one is more impressive 🤔??? The obvious answer is Highschool. And look at how Garnett's career turned out from it. People stay disrespecting Garnett. And I know it's young people that never seen him play earlier in. Duncan chose to finish college, and it wasn't for being groomed to be an NBA player. Greg wanted him earlier than that.
@@Davivd2They’re the same age, only weeks apart and KG had two years of playing with and against NBA talent on Duncan when Duncan came into the league.
Bad logic, we all know if you got no help you carry more of the load. You get more touches, they even said so in the interview. You get more opportunities to score cus you got the green light at all times. So DESPITE having help, Tim Duncan was more efficient and scored more whilst KG was struggling.
Duncan was number1 option from day 1 like seriously sheed lol😂😂😂 man was a all star as a rookie and finals mvp at in 99 in year 2 wow
nah it was still the admiral's team in Duncan's rookie and he was still averaging 20 and 10. then robinson sacrificed his offense for duncan, ginobli and parker.
@@bunduman18 david wasn't even in his prime by the time TD came. TP and Manu just came in when d-rob was headed out. he averaged less than 10 by the time they got there
@@bunduman18 admiral said he was learning from Tim. Cmon now.
@@bunduman18 Nah it was not Admiral's team by the end of the 1st year. Robinson even has said so in interviews. Duncan was 5th in MVP voting his rookie year, it was his team basically game 3 of his rookie year.
Kg had a bigger ceiling but Duncan had an entire franchise / system / coach / supporting star all tailored right for him
Duncan was unstoppable as soon as he got into the league..
Sheed is really upset that he lost against Duncan multiple times. Jealousy is a terrible trait big guy.
KG is in any conversation when we talking greatness
Just "pure basketball playing" wise, it's KG. However, NBA is so much more than just playing basketball, so TD is the GOAT power forward.
Man, when you ask athletes who haven't researched this, it can be awful.
In his rookie year, Duncan averaged 21.1 points, 11.9 rebounds, 2.7 assists, 0.7 steals, and 2.5 blocks per game while shooting 54.9% from the field. He was an All-Star in his rookie year. He was the number one option even as a rookie. Robinson was old and on his way out. Spurs were a 30 win team with Dennis Rodman before and after.
Tim made more all defensive teams than kg...what is he talking about?
Garnett won DPOY what are u talking about ?? Garnett led NBa in rebounds Duncan never led in any stats once. KG played alone 12 years show me 1 season Duncan played alone ?
@@PIP...33One season Tim played alone?
Just go look from 00-04, then come back to me. Man was battling prime Kobe and Shaq with Antonio Daniels as the teams 2nd leading scorer 😂😂😂
@@hardwoodthought1213 Admiral 2001 allstar HOF. Ginobili world superstar beat Dream teams 2002, 2004 and 2006 alone hall of fame. Tell me more how liar u r
@@hardwoodthought1213 DAVID ROBINSON WAS ALLSTAR 2001 SO WHAT ARE U SAYING ??
@@hardwoodthought1213 Admiral 2001 allstar HOF. Ginobili world superstar beat Dream teams 2002, 2004 and 2006 alone hall of fame.
The Tim Duncan disrespect in this clip is crazy. They talk about who’s better in their prime but keep mentioning when Duncan first entered the league which isn’t his prime. Then they act like kg wasn’t playing with Marbury in Minnesota. He also played with pierce, ray Allen, rondo, Tony Allen and only won 1 title.
No disrespect. NBA players who played against him know better than you
@@robbdelgadillo6554 you make a valid point. The only argument I was used to against that is we don’t know their relationships. They may be close to kg and not really be friendly with Duncan or they can be a little bitter Duncan eliminated them in the playoffs. You never know ulterior motives
@@robbdelgadillo6554 Duncan 5 championships kg 1
Duncan 2x mvp kg 1
Duncan 3x finals mvp. Kg 0
Duncan rookie of the year/ kg defensive player of the year
Duncan 10x all nba 1st team/ kg 4x all nba 1st
Duncan 8x all nba 1st team defense/ kg 9x
Kg 4x rebound champion.
We can decide for ourselves who the better player was
Excellent topic. I guess Sheed would know he battled them both.
Sheed is correct in pointing out context: KG was the player having to carry thinner teams, whereas the Admiral would have won at least 5 titles playing Duncan's years being on stacked team throughout his entire career with Popovich AND lacking elite big fellow centers* outside of Shaq and some Dwight/Yao.
*Duncan was the Spurs' primary rim-protector, which means center, sharing the role with Admiral then being the sole top shot blocker for the vast majority of his career.
I think Tim Duncan played center more than power forward. He was better than K.G. anyways
Ten years in each position. In the modern NBA, he's a center, but he had the foot speed in his youth to play power forward at the highest level.
I try to tell people this. Basketball Reference explains that 70% of Duncan career minutes came at the center postion..
Tim was always a PF. The 8:31 was the center in his early part of his career
@@arturorodriguez8223 Tim was never a PF. He was always a center. He played PF part time because he was starting next to Robinson. Even Pop said Duncan was their center. Once again go look at BBall Refence minutes breakdown for his career. 70% of his career minutes was played at Center 30% at PF.
Prime td played pf
KG.
I knew sheed was going to hate on Duncan because both were loud and couldn’t stop Duncan
Sheed just mad Timmy been cooking him since the ACC days
I think KG was better in his prime, but Duncan had the better career overall although he was very lucky with the coach & great players he had around him right from the jump. Duncan also came into the league very polished from college, KG didn’t since he came straight out of high school. This debate will go on for generations.
Come playoff time KG wasn’t close to Duncan
Kg choked in the playoffs
@@gonchanli U mean Duncan with 10 allstars choke vs Luis Scola but Garnett never lost gold.
@@gonchanli Rasheed literally told u KG in playoff was triple teamed Duncan was 1 on 1 most of times. Cause no one leaves Admiral open. Are u that much deranged
@@PIP...33 facts. They dont even listen. Making up things cause of superteam rings.
Is this Really a question ✋️
Not really, 5 is greater than 1.
@@superchefliumaohsing 🤡🤡🤡horry smoke them with 7
He also played with Starbury and Gugliotta
Lol stop it
Kg before going to Boston only had one good year with a older Sprewell and Sam Cassel
TD earned 15 All NBA selections in 19 years. KG earned 9 selections in 22-years. Add the 2 MVPs, 3 FMVPs and 15 All Defensive selections (to KGs 12) and this is NOT a conversation AT ALL.
KG, Timmy would not do what he did in San Antonio in Minnesota
Not only that, KG would be better than Duncan in the Spurs. He wouldn't score or block as much but He'd rebound more, have more steals, more assists, and you can't foul him because he's hitting those free throws.
@@younglove3362Duncan's offense was always better than Garrett's because be played closer to the basket. Duncan WAS the system in 2003 especially when the spurs won. It was one man in (Duncan) and four men out. It worked. Duncan actually might have won 1 championship in Minnesota. That 2003 Spurs team was not great. Rookie Ginobili, 2nd year parker (who was benched at times for speedy claxton), old David Robinson (with bad stats) and young Stephen Jackson. Duncan won MVP that year for a reason. Duncan had a Dike/Hakeen-like run where the dropoff between him and that 2nd best player was enormous. Spurs had no business beating that 3-peat Lakers team, but Tim was amazing in that series.
I don't think that 2003 team was any more talented than KG's 2004 team. Especially if you don't just look at the names on the jerseys, and actually look at the stats of the supporting cast that year.
The TD slander is insane. Wolves probably win 3 chips with Timmy, probably able to keep Latrell and other stars because of the culture he would have created being a selfless dude.. just completely wrong dude
@tvdij
Did you even watch them play???? That team was based around Duncan but everyone in the line up did their part well. Bruce Bowen played defense and was a 3pt specialist. Kerr with the clutch 3's bailing them out of trouble like they did the Bulls. Robinson still doing his part as a center helping out Duncan. And the goat coach. How you gonna say the number 1 seed wasn't that great? Stop ✋️ you sound like someone that didn't watch them played. And no their team was not as good as the 04 T. Wolves, nore better. Cut the bs
Stop the disrespect!!
Stop the empty comments.
I know right? Garnett gets disrespected way too much.
Y'all tripping. Keep it real Time Duncan came in balling & had great defense. Tim is considered the greatest power forward & top 10 player.
People underrate TD because he wasn't flashy.
It is not even a discussion. Seed is sour grapes because Duncan whooped him. Remember, this is a man who said Jordan was not a good defender when MJ averaged 3.6 steals and 1.6 blocks per game while scoring 37.
This question is fucking laughable it really is, in no way or no day was kg ever better than duncan. Once in their career. Im sorry. Nothing you can point to says otherwise.
You pointed out nothing yourself.
@@penkima4923 I don't feel like I need to. If you're not a casual you pretty much know this much or you should anyway.
@@xaviershelviejohnson5771exactly
If you have to explain this to someone, that someone shouldn't be disputing anything related to basketball
@@xaviershelviejohnson5771if you drop a generational talent like Tim Duncan on a borderline 60 win team with an MVP and surround him with top notch veterans, coaching and HOF players his entire career then yes, i would think you would win more than someone that was drafted by an expansion team 🤣.You guys act like context doesn't matter lol.
@@jb32215 no I don't I acknowledge he had a better situation overall I don't think anyone would deny that, but to me Tim was just better if you switched their teams or Careers idk if kg wins at the level Duncan did and I watched the whole Era every year, year in and year out Duncan was a contender. He won 5 titles homie. WIth 2 or 3 different cores. Only common thread player wise Was him being the cornerstone. Look at kg in Boston. You mean to tell me kg and that crew shouldn't have won at least 2??? They probably should have won 2 out 3 in that Era and ended up with one. Blaming the loss on Perkins getting hurt. Yes kg got hurt the following year but whatever it is what it is. Duncan was just better at just about everything. To me anyway
Love hearing this from someone who played against both at the same position
What did Minnesota ever win with KG. Nothing, KG was more of a talented athlete, but TD is the best power forward ever.
K.G all day
david robinson was a shell of himself by the time tim got there
Admiral was all star 2001 u deranged
funny how shell 2001 was allstar ?? If Admiral was shell that means 28 other centers who didnt make it allstar game 2001 was 0 ppg
Robinson was better than Duncan for several years, after Duncan came to the league.
@Celtics6-0vsMonkeyJordan ok so he made all star in a time where had to pick 2 guards, 2 fowards and 1 center, u acting like he was putting up 25ppg. he didn't even avg 10rpg
@@cv787 ANTONIO DAVIS WAS PF HE STARTED AS CENTER. WHY EAST DIDNT HAD 2001 CENTER IF U FOLLOW THAT RULES ? TO REMIND U RICK SMITS WAS CENTER IN PACERS ANTONIO DAVIS WAS TRADITIONAL PF.
Sheed faced both these dudes day in and day out his entire career...
By the end of his rookie year, TD was handed over the reigns by D-Rob, TD was All-NBA First Team, All-NBA Defensive Second Team, rookie of the year, and 5th in regular season MVP voting.
kg had paul ray allen for 5 years and ony won 1 in 2008 duncan won a chip in 2014 at age 38
Did duncan played 12 years alone wastred health vs triple team ?? U see how deranged u r
I don't think he was criticizing KG. He was saying KG did it past his prime and that it was an accomplishment.
He tore his ACL in 2009 en route to B2B. 20 game win streak. Still should’ve won in 2010 & 2012 if not for questionable officiating.
@@Sticktothemodels i agree they would have won in 2009 perkins going down in 2010 cost them 2012 the heat beat them in 7
they are both great
KG in 2003-2004 was that dude
He was the best player that year.
This isn't even a conversation. Minnesota had the best record in the league one year and didn't win when Cassell had a great year and Sprewell was still good. Tim Duncan is one of the all time greats and KG, great as he was, is not mentioned on that level. Duncan was top 5 MVP 9 times vs. 5 for KG.
Great debate
Tim Duncan > Dirk Nowitzki > Kevin Garnett
Dirk is last. Not an elite two way player
@@BLGClipsx better in what ? KG fadeaway duncan never learned. KG better from 2 mid range dunks 3 pts free throws. KG higher vert better speed dribbling can switch 1 to 5. Duncan 1 thing better 260 lbs.
I'm tellin' you ... McHale & Olajuwon are >>>> Tim Duncan > Dirk Nowitzki > Kevin Garnett
@@Celtics6-0vsMonkeyJordan read my post again. I said Dirk was last not KG
No
This should NOT be a debate… Tim Duncan by far
Yea if you're dumb just say that. That would've been easier
Do Duncan have MVP
@@AaronHodge-el9kf2 mvp and 3 finals mvp 😂
It’s not by far if your talking prime for prime. KG didn’t play with the kind of talent duncan did until he was 32 and out of his prime, and in his first year he won a chip
Tim Duncan is a 2 time league mvp n 3 finals mvp
It's crazy how some people penalize Duncan for having decent teams but never say that for people like Shaq. Shaq had solid teams for most of his career but that's never taken into account. Nor should it be.
Sheed hating 😂 Timmy D got 5 rings and 3 finals MVP’s. He was doing sheed so dirty they put Big Ben on him and he gave it to him too. That was ring number 3 😂 and finals MVP number 3 😂 the next 2 rings he got on Lebron you gotta salute Timmy D and let him be, he super great.
It was also Kevin Garnett's fault why the Timberwolves had a hard time finding a good supporting cast during his time there. After his rookie contract, the Timberwolves offered him a max contract, which was very good for a young all-star caliber player like he was. But he refused and wanted a supermax contract immediately, and that deal would make it impossible for the Timberwolves to sign new players or even keep their own.
As a result, his contract was one of the reasons for the lockout during the 1998-99 season. Because Kevin Garnett demanded more than he should have, the Timberwolves couldn't sign good and reliable players to be his supporting cast, as they might go over the salary cap due to Garnett's massive contract.
In my opinion, Tony and Manu progressed significantly early in their careers because Tim Duncan allowed them to play their own style of basketball. Since Tim was in his prime at that time, he encouraged Tony and Manu to take over games to boost their confidence. This collaborative approach, guided by Pop, helped them grow and mesh together seamlessly, avoiding conflicts and ego clashes. On the other hand, with KG and Marbury, there were different dynamics. KG's massive payday and clashes of egos hindered their team chemistry and progress. Unlike Tim, who was a great leader and passed the torch early, KG struggled to gain the respect and unity of his teammates, leading to missed opportunities for growth and success.
If you're building a team, who would you pick between Duncan and Garnett?
Finally not a pop answer. They answer a real answer. Focus on the player every time.
TD all day long.
Sheed said KG in his prime but then to support his reasoning he talks about KG’s first few years in Minnesota.
To Tim Duncan's credit, he outplayed the 1999 MVP Karl Malone in 2/3 regular season games that season. Tim Duncan rose to his prime pretty quickly after entering the NBA.
In their prime Tim was a monster. He was a better rim protector than KG but KG could guard out to the 3. Tim was better in the post all day. No question Tim was better than KG outside accolades.
KG was a reserve in the very beginning (Laetner), and he also had Isaiah Rider, who was #1 until Rider got up outta there, and Marbury curved too
Sheed said he isn't sure if Duncan could have carried a franchise from the jump.
Rookie year
Rookie of the year
All NBA 1st team
All defense 2nd team
5th in MVP votes
5th in DPotY votes
Duncan was brought into a better system, so he definitely had that advantage, but TD took over a franchise from 2 Hall of Famers and made it his. KG was the first star in Minnesota.
BEST BIGS of that ERA.
PF - 1st DIRK - 2nd KG
C - 1st SHAQ - 2nd DUNCAN
They are not talking about winning championships, they are talking about the skills as a player. Ya’ll forget these guys played against them and what type of team and players on your team matters. I watched a podcast where they were asking the best defensive guys from the Steelers and ravens about who was better Brady or manning and all of them said manning. They wasn’t talking about rings they was talking about individual player, and who they were more scared of. Most people would say Brady though
I hate when they get asked a simple question, and then turn it into more than what it need to be like omg
You already know my answer... not taking anything away from KG, and Sheed was incorrect on some of his comments. Tim was the #1 option when he came in. David was on the tail end of his career past his prime and with Timmy joining that team, they have the highest winning percentage in any in history, which noone really ever talked about.
Hard to say because they were both great. But what I know is KG played as a SF who transitioned into a PF, then a C. Tim was a PF who became a 5 as he got slower. So it's hard to compare because they actually played diff. Easier to compare players who naturally were on same positions, like Malone vs Barkley, Ewing vs the Dream, Kobe vs Jordan, etc.... in my opinion, at least. But if I had a team and needed to choose between them 2, i would gladly take any of them and build my team accordingly 👍