SM is money 1st company...started by a business man and not a music man. They produce the stereotypical kpop sound that most of the globe cringes to when someone mentions kpop to them. Fake sounding vocal due to overproduction...heavy choreo and lip syncing live performances...feminine male idols.
@@leafleaf6575 quit kidding yourself, I love aespa but you can clearly tell they are forced to lip sync and even if they don’t according to you, sm probably makes the backtrack louder or edits them
she literally sounds the same. And yet people discredit her because ning2 doesn't get lines. First of all its not her fault since she doesn't distribute the lines. Second is that people are acting like she dooesn't deserve those lines. Other groups literally funnel all the lines to the famous member even though they can't sing to save their lives
yeah but it's understandable, girl was giving her all in the choreo and even trying to get her voice to be heard, the microphone wasn't that loud so the croud could barely hear her. she must have been tired at that point :[
i love gigi in live performances with audience because you can see she really enjoys making a connection with the audience and just have fun with the performance
I prefer them live singing. Giselle is the only one that really doesn't sound good but I never saw her as charismatic and engaging to watch. Even if her vocal wasn't very good she was a joy to watch and Winter and Ning Ning are just so much more satisfying live And sound amazing.
@@mordecaiissad8529 why isn’t giselle good? in that clip she wasn’t singing she was rapping and it was amazing. you just want to hate on giselle so bad.
@@tenyharyati9355 but, Giselle has a supported range that is actually better than Karina, despite the fact that she is a sub vocalist, she can take vocals, but SM simply does not give her a chance to prove herself in vocals, I know that in the song "Forever" she was given vocal parts
Again, this isn’t necessarily autotune, but vocal layering. Producers tend to do this for a smoother format and to make the voice sooth with the instrumental.
Wow Winter sounds amazing, literally is close to the studio version. I can't really hear Ningning because of the backtrack but I know she still slayed that
Why is no one talking about winter like girl is the most stable in live performances and delivers her highnotes like she's in a freaking recording room
I wish they can perform live more in the future. I don’t understand the people that hate them for lip syncing, that’s not even their choice. They are IDOLS!! And one of the reasons of it it’s that they love singing! They would not be this successful if they were bad at it. Anyways, stan Aespa 💖
And yet there are still people who call them talentless, they are improving so much their vocal skills and they will sing more live in the future but ya'll wanted them to sing live here you have it 😌 Aespa always slays
![[KPOP CHALLENGE] If you can high note, you win](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YFsNnFHKQZc/mqdefault.jpg)
Aespa vocals: 📈
dih
@@susantisusanti4834elu yg idih
Si
even coachella stage director complimented their live vocals 😭 i wish SM let them sing live more often
SM is money 1st company...started by a business man and not a music man. They produce the stereotypical kpop sound that most of the globe cringes to when someone mentions kpop to them. Fake sounding vocal due to overproduction...heavy choreo and lip syncing live performances...feminine male idols.
Frr
FR, it's unfair that they get hate but it's not even their fault
YES@@Thatonekpopstaaan
wish they performed live more ugh
me too, idk why they don’t, they’re OBVIOUSLY capable
Exactly
U people need to stop saying this!! They are singing live at many events..u should first watch their performances
@@leafleaf6575 quit kidding yourself, I love aespa but you can clearly tell they are forced to lip sync and even if they don’t according to you, sm probably makes the backtrack louder or edits them
@@leafleaf6575 exactly
Winter and NingNing slaying 💅🏻✨
Nobody talks about Ningning's high note its more than I can’t explain
Ning ning vocals just gave me the chills the main vocal of the gro here's the reason.
Why nobody talks about Winter? She is so stable 🥺💗
Под такими видео все время говорят про Винтер
she literally sounds the same. And yet people discredit her because ning2 doesn't get lines. First of all its not her fault since she doesn't distribute the lines. Second is that people are acting like she dooesn't deserve those lines. Other groups literally funnel all the lines to the famous member even though they can't sing to save their lives
we all know how perfect winter is
Lol ur ear will hurt when winter sings
@@dredsmiles bcs u'r eart have many dirt, go & clean it. the smell is pungent🙊
Giselle's live vocals are much higher. She's really a singer no one can change my mind.
She actually is, all vocal analysis give her good scores, also considering that she is a sub vocalist she's absolutly great
she is a pretty good vocalist, she can support well
@@diduii4507 a lot of sub vocalists don’t have vocal support so the fact that she does support makes her a pretty good sub vocalist
@@asshunnngami some lead vocalist can't support lol
@@diduii4507 i know
Ning2 was using her full chest voice in the studio version... and she's using her heady mixed voice live
Точно такой же голос
@@Artshes1673 и это ещё раз доказывает, что она не зря главный вокалист
@@retryqqm1510 так по факту
yeah but it's understandable, girl was giving her all in the choreo and even trying to get her voice to be heard, the microphone wasn't that loud so the croud could barely hear her. she must have been tired at that point :[
Smart move, she avoiding strain her voice. eventho its less powerfull than studio version
Ningning’s vocals are no joke man
ningnings vocals are so underrated bro😭
I think she’s overrated and winter is underrated as of now
@Furinamochi no she's not overratated and Ningning's vocals are still not appreciated enough
@@ifoundtheimposter1652 she’s already been appreciated every comeback btw so there’s no reason that she’s underrated
@@Furinamochi but neither is she overrated
no she's not@@Furinamochi
Queen Winter is a vocal goddess❤️❤️❤️
Giselle’s voice live is so much better oh my word
The day when SM lets them perform live often is the day we get see vocal perfection.
Katrina's voice sounds even better and more beautiful live
You meant Korina right? Lol
@@bearic_o its karina 💀
isn't that the hurricane
@@siohunndai yes, she blew everyone away with her stunning vocals
@@BanAllSombraMains17 Every time she does that head spin in Black Mamba it blows away the audience
Winter her vocal 😮😮😮
So amazed by Karina. Imagine she dances with power but still sings like that.
Karina voice is much stronger best without autotune
Winter vocals are mind blowing ❤❤
Winter so stable as always, queen!🔥
karina's voice gives me goosebumps
Winter voice and her visuals are just amazing 😍😍😍😍😍
Karina slayed it
Giselle did sing higher than the original version ✨✨✨
Giselle just killing it
winter sounds so much better live
winter's vocal are the best
Karina such a all rounder
Gigi really slayed her part
All the members are really talented
Gigi?..
@@army_black1269 gigi is giselle nickname we all call her like that
@@Readish Thanks for the reply, I didn't know
Oh how i love ningning and giselle's vocals 😭🧎♂️🧎♂️🧎♂️
winter and ningning never disappoint with the highnotes
you can tell the girls were excited to sing live!
Yeah this is their first time live performance in front of audience.
giselle’s stage presence tho
i love gigi in live performances with audience because you can see she really enjoys making a connection with the audience and just have fun with the performance
Winter and Ningning are so stable💖💖💖
Why is winter good at everything?!!
i think they sound really good and i love it when they perform live, what do you think?
Yes and they perform in SMCU 2022 is better.
I prefer them live singing. Giselle is the only one that really doesn't sound good but I never saw her as charismatic and engaging to watch. Even if her vocal wasn't very good she was a joy to watch and Winter and Ning Ning are just so much more satisfying live
And sound amazing.
Yes I love it
They're from SM Entertainment, of course they sound very good when live. So yeah, we need more live singing
@@mordecaiissad8529 why isn’t giselle good? in that clip she wasn’t singing she was rapping and it was amazing. you just want to hate on giselle so bad.
Winter slayed
All of their voices are amazing, but I really love Karina's voice color. It's so unique and beautiful.
winter the best💪
It's crazy how aespa a 4 member group sings a whole 4 min long song with many highnotes with stable vocals 🔥 best 4th gen vocalists
Ning Ning Slayed as always
BEST VOCAL AS 4🛐
Winter eats cds or 💀💀
WINTER KILLED IT 🔥🔥
Miss Ningning you have my respect once again ! Winter was also great 👍
Giselle killing it
Winter's vocal is fire, Taeyeon and Wendy's vocals have an heir now
And it's Ningning
Mm wendys
Give Karina more lines pls her voice is always so pleasing to listen to
Give Giselle more singing lines dude
Up
Yes...... Right!!!
Yesssss
but she is the main rapper so what do you expect :(
@@tenyharyati9355 but, Giselle has a supported range that is actually better than Karina, despite the fact that she is a sub vocalist, she can take vocals, but SM simply does not give her a chance to prove herself in vocals, I know that in the song "Forever" she was given vocal parts
Again, this isn’t necessarily autotune, but vocal layering. Producers tend to do this for a smoother format and to make the voice sooth with the instrumental.
NINGNING'S VOCALS ARE MY RELIGION
Giselle's vocals was bothered with the bass like it's so freaking loud but I still love her vocals and raps live as always 💯😎🥺✨
Well, it’s more likely that she’s just hyped and so she’s just kinda yelling her rap in a hype way
@@Sanas_Shy_Language the fact that she CAN sing that high )
@@marylevy7659 she has high tone of voice. Waiting for SM give her high note part
@@Sanas_Shy_Language nah her mic was really weak
Wow Winter sounds amazing, literally is close to the studio version. I can't really hear Ningning because of the backtrack but I know she still slayed that
Karina's voice hasn't changed
karina sounds SOOO good live
Ningning slayed
ningning sending me to church👐👐
Love them all but Karina 😫😍🤩❤️🌹🌹🌹
All have amazing vocals❤
aespa best live vocals
The teal talented girlgroups Aespa,baby monster,Nmixx❤❤❤
U forgot 2NE1
UUUGH I WISH MORE LIVE PERFORMANCES, THEY'RE JUST SO GOOD!!!!
Giselle is killing it.
They are amazing and perfect
Why is no one talking about winter like girl is the most stable in live performances and delivers her highnotes like she's in a freaking recording room
Non she is no very stable but ningning more
@@fatchimamahamadou5419 yes ikr
girl, everybodys talking bout her
@@fatchimamahamadou5419 Winter is more stable , even karina. than ning2. 😂
@@fatchimamahamadou5419 this a damn lie and you know it lmfaooo
💜👑💎aespa best vocal Queens👑💜
Still some duffer haters hate them for their vocals
I wish they can perform live more in the future. I don’t understand the people that hate them for lip syncing, that’s not even their choice. They are IDOLS!! And one of the reasons of it it’s that they love singing! They would not be this successful if they were bad at it. Anyways, stan Aespa 💖
Karina Hermosa vozzzz( ˘ ³˘)♥
ningning sounds the best live
SM idol's can always have the best vocal
WINTER ALWAYS TO BE ICONIC
I just think everybody did very well and amazing. Their voice was very stable and clear ❤❤❤
Your the best dancer who can perform on any language and type of song with perfect moves
aespa don't need autotune, autotune needs aespa!! 💯🔥
Ningning note thooo YeeEEeeEeYy
Ningning 💋
omg ningning indecredible voice
aespa has talent!!
And yet there are still people who call them talentless, they are improving so much their vocal skills and they will sing more live in the future but ya'll wanted them to sing live here you have it 😌 Aespa always slays
From the time they performed at coachella, they sing live all the time
Karinaaaaaaaa 🔥🔥🔥🔥
I love all aespa should perform live more
ot4 slayed people must stop comparing ning2 and winter
æspa vocals will always be at the top and the best.
NingNing's vocals need to be appreciated more 😢❤
Auto tune didn’t exist in that time
Perfect
Winter and karina voice sound better when singing live
this was also their FIRST time singing live on a national scale, i’m so proud of them
Ningning live sounds exactly the same as the studio version. She's the main vocal for a reason.
ningning's such an amazing main vocalist
Their vocals are so amazing ❤
Our girls slayed it..... They are so amazing doing live.... I hope am give us more live concert of them 😭
They looks really enjoy the performance
Ningning high notes at the end: 📈📈📈
woow so amazing
thanks!
Why is real voice better than autotune when aespa is there
Ningningggg
Gigi slayyy
Idk why they are not allowed to sing live more, they DELIVER. Can we talk about winter? She dances and sings PERFECTLY
you should watch their recent performances, they sing live more often now