Aespa 'Black Mamba' Ningning High Note | MV vs Live Perform vs Acapella

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 20 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 701

  • @SouthKorea-Lover
    @SouthKorea-Lover 4 місяці тому +576

    PLEASE PLEASE PIN THIS!:
    IF YOUR A STAY (Fan of Stray Kids) PLEASE READ THIS!
    On July 25th a stay decided to murder or kill Hyunjin, the person is in Korea waiting for the concert to happen.
    No, it's not one person, it's many "stays" - clearly not real fans. Some people say they have their own team.
    Please share this around!
    - REPOSTED!

    • @lovek-pop
      @lovek-pop  4 місяці тому +32

      Okay

    • @SouthKorea-Lover
      @SouthKorea-Lover 4 місяці тому +13

      @@lovek-pop THANK YOU SO MUCH!!!

    • @cd21999
      @cd21999 4 місяці тому +43

      Please I BEG U before spreading misinformation like this that causes people to panic, you should do your own research. I'm a stay, where do you got that info from? They don't even have a concert on that date in Korea

    • @cd21999
      @cd21999 4 місяці тому +27

      ​@@lovek-pop this is clearly a stupid rumour created probably on tik tok like every other stupid rumour, just to make people panic. Please before spreading misinfo like this, do your own research 🙏🏻 they don't even have a concert on that date in Korea. Delete this pin

    • @SouthKorea-Lover
      @SouthKorea-Lover 4 місяці тому +2

      @@cd21999 I saw someone else like about 1 week ago have this, I said it's reposted at the end of my message....
      And it said to spread the message. Also, it's better safe than sorry...we STAYS should always be prepared to protect our idols and warn them about any danger.

  • @viberious
    @viberious Рік тому +5524

    ningning's high note is my fav bcs her voice clear and effortless

  • @albertaringo8717
    @albertaringo8717 Рік тому +10458

    She deserve the recognition Karina and Winder have

    • @ahood2005
      @ahood2005 Рік тому +174

      Of course

    • @dumdummer1404
      @dumdummer1404 Рік тому +261

      Selle too.

    • @istarelmie2111
      @istarelmie2111 Рік тому +286

      She is the most famous one in the group but karina and winter are famous in korea

    • @akillasoares4816
      @akillasoares4816 Рік тому +49

      @@istarelmie2111 ela é a mais famosa do grupo? Tá ficando louco ?kkkkkkk

    • @DontPopBubble
      @DontPopBubble Рік тому +190

      @@akillasoares4816 she meant that KARINA AND WINTER are only famous in KOREA
      And ningning has known more in INTERNATIONAL because of her vocals and HER MEMES

  • @euphoriarevival
    @euphoriarevival Рік тому +5297

    Ning say: i'm the queen of vocal

    • @thisistheresa
      @thisistheresa Рік тому +69

      I don't think that's true, there are still many other idols who have better voices than Ningning

    • @MinaAshido-w2m
      @MinaAshido-w2m Рік тому +126

      ​@@thisistheresa It's not about Voice it's about support, flow, vocals etc.
      Find the difference

    • @ASI1485
      @ASI1485 Рік тому +106

      One of best vocalist in 4th gen😌❤

    • @catlover9437
      @catlover9437 Рік тому +42

      for 4gen idol i can agreed with you 🥰

    • @treasure_all_12
      @treasure_all_12 Рік тому +43

      ​@@ASI1485 nayul,lily, haewon are better, how come she's the best vocalist?

  • @alison-pv4fk
    @alison-pv4fk Рік тому +1311

    no matter what
    this is that one high note in k-pop industry
    that gives me goosebump everytime
    especially that Coachella performance
    ningning HIGHNOTE>>>>>>

    • @multistan204
      @multistan204 Рік тому +7

      Same

    • @migu8328
      @migu8328 5 місяців тому +7

      Its got that SM high note trajectory perfectly

    • @maybelawliet1049
      @maybelawliet1049 3 місяці тому +1

      Her high note vibes give me the same feeling as chens in monster (exo) and I love it sm!! Sm ent my fave

  • @husainsiregar3372
    @husainsiregar3372 Рік тому +2090

    Ningning the high note are really cool..

    • @dollyvivi_.ৎ
      @dollyvivi_.ৎ 6 місяців тому +7

      1.2k likes and no comments lemme fix that^^

  • @anhmai5269
    @anhmai5269 Рік тому +913

    Ningning voice always caught me off guard 😂😂😂😂

    • @yasminchan7425
      @yasminchan7425 Рік тому +2

      In a positive or negative way? 😛

    • @anhmai5269
      @anhmai5269 Рік тому +16

      @@yasminchan7425 I don't have much knowledge in music. I like lofi and not often like high note though I adore her when she raises her voice to reach high note in most songs 😸
      it just sounds good to my ears so I appreciate it! That's all 😁

  • @angelinapratama96
    @angelinapratama96 Рік тому +5798

    To be honest, I don't like the netizens who say that Winter is better at playing vocals than Ning Ning, even though her voice clearly has very unique characteristics.

    • @angelinapratama96
      @angelinapratama96 Рік тому +223

      What's wrong here is with the distribution of song lyrics in aespa, winter should not have excessive lyrics so that Ning Ning's characteristics cannot be absorbed by the audience.

    • @jihyomom_879
      @jihyomom_879 Рік тому +70

      @@angelinapratama96 Winter has a lead dancer position, so she’s usually in the center, singing or even rapping. And shes a visual

    • @angelinapratama96
      @angelinapratama96 Рік тому +185

      @@jihyomom_879.Sorry, but what I'm discussing here is the division of vocals in aespa, winter is Head's lead vocals, and Ning Ning is the main vocals. SM entertainment should provide more lyrics for her

    • @angelinapratama96
      @angelinapratama96 Рік тому +102

      @@jihyomom_879 and btw the center of aespa is karina not winter

    • @jihyomom_879
      @jihyomom_879 Рік тому +31

      @@angelinapratama96 im aware of who the center of aespa is. Just bc Karina is center doesnt mean shes going to be in the center the whole song. Youre talking about how Ning is main vocal and Winter is lead, so ning should have more lines right? What im trying to explain is that Winter has more positions than Ningning so shes automatically going to have more lines (sometimes) even if its just more than 1 second.

  • @milli3171
    @milli3171 25 днів тому +4

    The high notes performed by Ningning are something that you can listen to forever

  • @zerobaseonerickysbutt
    @zerobaseonerickysbutt Рік тому +330

    Ning Ning slayed all the high notes luv her so much

  • @bokki5877
    @bokki5877 2 місяці тому +4

    she’s honestly everything

  • @akiraono4400
    @akiraono4400 Рік тому +28

    ning ning deserves more recognition, her notes are always so effortless and her dancing is addicting!

  • @planetfairy7108
    @planetfairy7108 Рік тому +117

    Acepella high note was unbelievable , ningning is so talented 🌺💜💜

  • @AESPA_X_MYS
    @AESPA_X_MYS 2 місяці тому +6

    Her voice is a masterpiece i always get goosebumps after hearing her high notes!! >>>>>>> ✨🔥❤️

  • @BookieCookie636
    @BookieCookie636 3 місяці тому +4

    She has such clear vibrato….. I’m very jealous 😂😂

  • @inspiritlinspirit3259
    @inspiritlinspirit3259 Рік тому +984

    I love each member for different reasons but honestly Ning’s singing is 2x better than other teammates. Her high notes are SUPPORTED, not just high

    • @saadahmad1675
      @saadahmad1675 Рік тому +11

      You still have the audacity to say that after hearing winters high note in girls? 😂

    • @coollittlebinch4689
      @coollittlebinch4689 Рік тому +1

      What does supported mean?

    • @inspiritlinspirit3259
      @inspiritlinspirit3259 Рік тому +16

      @@coollittlebinch4689 like the voice/air is coming from your stomach, what my singing teacher taught me haha

    • @inspiritlinspirit3259
      @inspiritlinspirit3259 Рік тому +66

      @@saadahmad1675 winter's high notes are very impressive! but ning ning's high notes just sound more supported

    • @coollittlebinch4689
      @coollittlebinch4689 Рік тому

      @@inspiritlinspirit3259 Thanks. Can you support?

  • @andresamigo5786
    @andresamigo5786 3 місяці тому +4

    She is my fave❤

  • @grmgt
    @grmgt 3 місяці тому +4

    Bro she is so talented wtf.

  • @clamville9216
    @clamville9216 Рік тому +57

    her voice is honestly so satisfying to listen to

  • @alvaromanuelfuentes
    @alvaromanuelfuentes Рік тому +333

    4th gen vocal queen

    • @idol7833
      @idol7833 Рік тому +2

      ​@@superduperordinary don't worry even I'm one of MYs and even Ning Ning is one of my bias in AESPA, I don't close to my eyes from other main vocal from other group there are many powerful main vocals like Lily from NMIXX even I'm not fan of NMIXX, Yunjin from LSFM, Jo Yuri, Jiwon aka Megan from Fromis_9 more powerful main vocal from other gen 4 girl groups🤔😁

    • @Bunnyhanni_4150
      @Bunnyhanni_4150 Рік тому +5

      ​@@superduperordinary nobody closed eyes. They simply gave opinion that in their pov ningning has the best vocals( including me and majority of people think the same) and pretty much its non of your business if u can't digest how successful vocalist is ningning...and who ever u want to praise rn go praise smwhr else here either share ur opinion for ningning either leave

    • @ivaxcx5676
      @ivaxcx5676 Рік тому +2

      ​@@Bunnyhanni_4150 yeah biased as hell lily is technically a more powerful vocalist

    • @miedp2902
      @miedp2902 9 місяців тому +4

      ​@@idol7833ningning > yunjin, jo yuri, jiwon

    • @ayazbaser1206
      @ayazbaser1206 5 місяців тому +2

      ​@@idol7833NINGNING >>>> LILY,YUNJIN,YURI,JIWON,MEGAN

  • @mariaines5735
    @mariaines5735 Рік тому +88

    omg, ningning's vocals are too perfect, man, she's really good at vocals 👏✨👌❤️

  • @karina_aespafannnn
    @karina_aespafannnn 3 місяці тому +3

    The little “Hey” after NingNing sings her part

  • @katherinegomezq.8299
    @katherinegomezq.8299 Рік тому +506

    ✨👑Wooaahh!! NINGNING Queen vocal 👑✨

  • @JustMe-zc5qj
    @JustMe-zc5qj 3 місяці тому +2

    This always makes me shiver. It's like so excellent, Ningning is such a great vocalist

  • @jeromekuek
    @jeromekuek Рік тому +38

    This gurl is my bias in aespa, guys pls support her

  • @elyazidboudries1525
    @elyazidboudries1525 5 місяців тому +12

    Her vocal is just amazing ❤

  • @vivini4347
    @vivini4347 Рік тому +10

    She is the prettiest and most talented in Aespa

    • @aespa.com17
      @aespa.com17 Рік тому +1

      I'm sorry but most talented is karina she can be an ACE

    • @lonelust
      @lonelust Рік тому +5

      @@aespa.com17 i see every member can called ace, not to mention giselle can produce and write

    • @aespa.com17
      @aespa.com17 Рік тому +2

      @@lonelust ate

    • @shinening79
      @shinening79 Рік тому +2

      @@aespa.com17 it's her opinion stop inserting yours because it would sound like you're invalidating her preferences and opinion

    • @aespa.com17
      @aespa.com17 Рік тому +1

      @@shinening79 saying 'most talented ' isn't an opinion

  • @sabrinaleedance
    @sabrinaleedance 4 місяці тому +22

    Got be one of if not my fave high note from an Aespa song by her

  • @chaewsyun_
    @chaewsyun_ Рік тому +327

    best fourth gen vocalist

    • @klovers3547
      @klovers3547 Рік тому +11

      Not true haha, Even Haewon has better cordination

    • @jungwons_wife_but_he_dont_503
      @jungwons_wife_but_he_dont_503 Рік тому +84

      ​@@klovers3547 Bro go praise haewon somewhere else this is there opinion

    • @Gagan__L1485
      @Gagan__L1485 Рік тому +42

      ​@@klovers3547 then search her and comment this under her video not here ok toxic mind 😂😂

    • @chaewsyun_
      @chaewsyun_ Рік тому +10

      @@klovers3547 i ngl think that lily is the best fourth gen vocalist idk why i wrote this but let me appreciate her ig

    • @Gagan__L1485
      @Gagan__L1485 Рік тому +2

      @@chaewsyun_ what???

  • @Aes_1dle
    @Aes_1dle 4 місяці тому +16

    See people this is why she DOESSSSS deserve main vocalist !!!

  • @harithhaslan6909
    @harithhaslan6909 4 місяці тому +13

    Ning Ning can’t ever be deny of her talent!

  • @South_KOR
    @South_KOR 4 місяці тому +10

    Many overseas fans don’t know. Ningning and Winter are both main vocalists.
    Their agency SM said they were both main vocalists.
    They both sing well.
    Don't compare the two. Let’s just support each other.

    • @mpetla5482
      @mpetla5482 Місяць тому

      I honestly think that Ningning is a bit of a better vocalist then Winter. (Winter being my bias)

  • @raqibuddin304
    @raqibuddin304 4 місяці тому +4

    This thing was supposed to showcase her vocals which it did👏 but the comments section🤢 turned it into comparing her with others🤮.

  • @dariusdumbledore345
    @dariusdumbledore345 Рік тому +7

    It honesty sends shivers down my spine every time I hear it--- I love ning ning!!! 😻✨️💖🥲🐰🐰🦋✨️✨️✨️

  • @jennie_0fficial
    @jennie_0fficial Рік тому +9

    Ningning is an amazing vocalist, her vocals are just AMAZING 👑♥️

  • @srsly_sia
    @srsly_sia 25 днів тому +3

    one of the best kpop vocalists

  • @idol7833
    @idol7833 Рік тому +28

    Well that's SM main vocal😎👏🏻

  • @susantoarismunandar1933
    @susantoarismunandar1933 10 місяців тому +10

    The live version has vibrato😮

  • @akshika_.1365
    @akshika_.1365 Рік тому +7

    Ningning is waayyyy better than Winter in vocals. She deserves to be recognised, QUEEN 👑💕

  • @yinfeng-z3s
    @yinfeng-z3s 5 днів тому +1

    닝닝은 여태껏 제가 본 사람중에서 미모가 원탑이고 목소리도 제일 아름답네요❤

  • @Kpoplifeline1234
    @Kpoplifeline1234 3 місяці тому +1

    The live one was enough, the high notes like I'm dead 😭🛐

  • @sususu1382
    @sususu1382 Рік тому +11

    我真的想听她唱更多的歌😍

  • @zuzy9075
    @zuzy9075 Рік тому +34

    Nini slayed it in the Live😭

  • @lisshi_
    @lisshi_ Рік тому +29

    ningning queen>>💋

  • @Minyouikpop
    @Minyouikpop Рік тому +38

    The LIVE one😍😍😍

  •  6 місяців тому +3

    she has a golden voice for real it doesn't make a difference between Mv and live and ACAPELLA she slayed in all states❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥

  • @peachyarts386
    @peachyarts386 Рік тому +7

    I don’t give a shit about what anybody else says about Lily, Haewon and other gen 4 vocalist being better… Ningning is still my favorite… I’m gonna Praise her and if I see anybody say they are better… just so ya know I think you have a shallow mindset..😒 no need to bring others up to downplay this queens talent for vocals and singing-
    But Ningnings high notes gives me shivers whether it’s live or not… and even her just doing not high notes she always sounds so good and her voice is very soothing that’s why she is my favorite because she has a soothing voice and is great at giving off an impression on me. AGAIN that does not mean I think she’s the best K-pop vocalist! It just makes her my favorite… end of story… I ain’t afraid to go off on some people nowadays😂

    • @Bunnyhanni_4150
      @Bunnyhanni_4150 Рік тому +3

      Fr, they r bringing those girls (which i dont even know exist) bcs its hard for them to digest ningning's strong vocals. I listened to nmixx and lily didn't really impressed me as much as ningning did tbh, (i dont hate her just she didn't impressed me) she is simply kinda more like other vocalists but something about ningning is unique. Please yall know everyone has diff pov and opinion.

    • @peachyarts386
      @peachyarts386 Рік тому +1

      @@Bunnyhanni_4150 my exact thoughts, I don't care if anybody likes lily or haewon's vocals more, its called a preference but I don't like when people shove it down others throats.. its annoying and disrespectful in some cases

  • @MochieeeMoon
    @MochieeeMoon Рік тому +54

    Honestly don’t know why SM doesn’t give Ningning more higher notes when she clearly has better control and technique then winter. I love winter, she has a really beautiful voice but when she sings the high notes her voice strains. Whereas Ningning she can clearly sing the high notes and her voice doesn’t strain. That’s why Ningning is the main vocal and winter is the lead vocal. But lately SM hasn’t been treating both Ningning and Giselle properly. Even Giselle can clearly sing but sm doesn’t show her potential properly.

    • @lonelust
      @lonelust Рік тому +7

      maybe bcs winter korean, idk its just sm bad things

    • @BINNIE_BIAS
      @BINNIE_BIAS 5 місяців тому

      @@lonelustwhy is this so real😭

    • @migu8328
      @migu8328 5 місяців тому

      ​@_I.N.Bias__ i mean they're not wrong tho, as long as you're not korean in SM, you're not the 1st choice

    • @SpiderLilyMoon
      @SpiderLilyMoon 4 місяці тому +1

      Because she's chinese, if you search she's was a singer even before started being a trainee, I don't remember how age she was but I think 11 and her techniques was amazing for a kid, it's almost like a professional singer

  • @clearsight6381
    @clearsight6381 Рік тому +14

    Her, Lily and Haewon leading 4th gen vocals 😍

    • @hyunlixxie2662
      @hyunlixxie2662 Рік тому +1

      haewon? hell nah

    • @clearsight6381
      @clearsight6381 Рік тому +4

      @@hyunlixxie2662 Wdym she is legit Nmixx's main vocalist along side Lily

    • @omarbirkdar5536
      @omarbirkdar5536 Рік тому +6

      ​@@hyunlixxie2662 lily>haewon>ningning

    • @mikamanurung8519
      @mikamanurung8519 Рік тому +3

      Lily,
      Haewon,
      Ningning

    • @clearsight6381
      @clearsight6381 Рік тому

      @@omarbirkdar5536 yes thats what i meant but they the top vocals so i just listed them like that....

  • @Blackpink_kpop_lover15
    @Blackpink_kpop_lover15 Рік тому +47

    Ninging is so talented
    Love Ninging
    Stream Girls

  • @marielaperez9293
    @marielaperez9293 Рік тому +25

    Por eso se ganó ser la vocalista principal 🥲👌
    Te mo ningning 🥰😘

  • @alinakotova2645
    @alinakotova2645 Рік тому +15

    was born to be an idol

  • @Maroshi_34
    @Maroshi_34 4 місяці тому +3

    ningning Has Very good high notes❤

  • @kei4153
    @kei4153 Рік тому +45

    main vocal of 4th gen

  • @mpetla5482
    @mpetla5482 Місяць тому +2

    Ningning is way too underrated for kpop... She needs more attention.!!.

  • @user-ym9cc6yv1i
    @user-ym9cc6yv1i Рік тому +7

    صوتهاا يجنننننن

  • @S.h.K15-g2v
    @S.h.K15-g2v 5 місяців тому +4

    Her voice is divine 💗✨

  • @quuerd
    @quuerd 8 місяців тому +3

    она настолько хороша, что ее голос не отличается от оригинала! НинНин большая умничка, она мой любимый вокалист

  • @user-lk3ow7go7f
    @user-lk3ow7go7f 3 місяці тому +7

    全然変わらんやん。さすがニンニン

  • @loretta_3843
    @loretta_3843 7 місяців тому +2

    Let's face it, they can all hold their own and are talented. I just have a preference for Ningning's voice, hers has that unique quality where the particular sound of her voice is what makes it special.
    Winter and Karina - can sing really, really well, even Giselle can hold her notes well, but Ningning has a character that's unique to her where the other girls sound more like they're singing notes very well rather than have their own voice. This probably doesn't make much sense 😅 It could be how they're instructed to sing, I just appreciate that "human" quality to her voice 🤷🏻‍♀️

  • @naybutninglover
    @naybutninglover 13 днів тому

    She is everytime so flawless

  • @naybutninglover
    @naybutninglover 13 днів тому

    NINGNING, JUST SAY "IM QUEEN OF KPOP" AND KEEP GOING BABY💅🏻

  • @sayoniroychowdhury5777
    @sayoniroychowdhury5777 4 місяці тому +15

    People are so deluded that they are comparing Jisoo and Rosé to Ningning😢

    • @sayoniroychowdhury5777
      @sayoniroychowdhury5777 4 місяці тому +7

      @@Jenorationn I think you are getting me wrong. I was actually praising the vocals of Ningning as compared to Jisoo and Rosé. I actually love Blackpink but I believe that some Blinks hype up the vocals of BP way more than what is real.
      I agree that BP is way better than Aespa in terms of rap and stage presence but when it comes to vocals, Aespa easily takes the cake. SM may be a horrible company but they have proved themselves time and again in terms of vocals.

    • @Jenorationn
      @Jenorationn 4 місяці тому +1

      @@sayoniroychowdhury5777 Ohh your right then

    • @sayoniroychowdhury5777
      @sayoniroychowdhury5777 4 місяці тому +1

      ​@@Jenorationn😊

  • @puputlarasati358
    @puputlarasati358 Місяць тому +1

    That acapella is more melodious

  • @akammhamad5475
    @akammhamad5475 Рік тому +6

    ningning prences

  • @danissegomez7953
    @danissegomez7953 Рік тому +5

    When they just debuted, peoplw keep saying how Winter is a main vocal BUT...
    Winter had nice tone but so does Ningning. thats it. As a lead vocal Winter is really good, The best lead vocal in 4th gen.
    But Ning aint the main vocal for nothing. The very first non Korean main vocal in SM. It says a lot about her skills.
    They could put Winter as main vocal cuz she is Korean, but no!, they can't deny and unhear Ning's voice.
    Also, her range is insane🔥🔥🔥... her low notes or registers is perfection🔥 and till now we dont know how high she can go with the high notes. Every day she surprises us with higher notes.
    Even in Time after Time with Boa and Wendy, she was in charge with the low notes. cuz Boa and Wendy's tone wont fit with the low notes.
    Winter has nice thin tone
    meanwhile Ningning is like Taeyeon who can go both ways between high and low but they have such whole and powerful voice, a qualities of a perfect main vocalist., they need to be flexible.

  • @thebestblinto4
    @thebestblinto4 Місяць тому +1

    Ningning is 4th gen golden voice

  • @miradaniyaatmarini8617
    @miradaniyaatmarini8617 3 місяці тому +1

    Ningning highnot amazing❤

  • @annasmith767
    @annasmith767 Рік тому +5

    Vocal queen NingNing.

  • @softmarshmalllow
    @softmarshmalllow 4 місяці тому +1

    In my opinion Ning² Has one of the most powerful and angelic voices 🔥💖

  • @WG_MC_CR
    @WG_MC_CR Рік тому +9

    all we can say is just wooooooooow 🔥💥

  • @fans.aktormaochisheng
    @fans.aktormaochisheng Рік тому +3

    Nuna Ning ning my new bias semangat fighting ♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️

  • @agnesgratia2012
    @agnesgratia2012 Рік тому +8

    high note ningning terbaik

  • @valatan5345
    @valatan5345 11 місяців тому +6

    The vibrato broo!!

  • @zink_d1665
    @zink_d1665 Рік тому +2

    Ning is Korean and Chinese treasure!

  • @XhappyxHrRIET
    @XhappyxHrRIET 2 місяці тому +1

    ningning is just wow !

  • @sofiaaaa28
    @sofiaaaa28 10 місяців тому +3

    Pra mim a ningning é uma das melhores vocalistas da quarta geração !!

    • @anavictoria-skz
      @anavictoria-skz 7 місяців тому +1

      Minha utt feminina é muito maravilhosa mesmo 🤍

  • @modgamer5799
    @modgamer5799 7 місяців тому +1

    Ningning is my bias cause of Her high note(I am a sucker for high notes)

  • @davinqi987
    @davinqi987 Рік тому +1

    Their coachella performance made me love ningning even more

  • @i_amdisl7593
    @i_amdisl7593 Рік тому +2

    Dude she really was teasing everyone during the live concert...

  • @kishagrisky1787
    @kishagrisky1787 Рік тому +7

    Lily < Ningning
    Ni hate even tho they r both gud
    I like ningnings better

    • @hehe-fl6vm
      @hehe-fl6vm Рік тому +1

      SAMEEEE lol.
      Lily highnote/vocal doesn't satisfy me like I mean I don't like it much. Her voice color is so different than what I like and her 'imsahe' or smth highnote was so cringe to me😭

  • @clarissasan
    @clarissasan 7 місяців тому

    It’s so comforting to hear her voice. She’s a good vocalist. Idc much of how an idol looks like as long as they got a nice voice I’m here for it

  • @devikaad5847
    @devikaad5847 3 місяці тому +9

    Why they were disrespected during coachella😢

  • @won33540
    @won33540 Рік тому +2

    Ning-ning really does have great vocals that's why SM chose her to be the main vocalist because she has a really nice ripe lovely voice

  • @belenquipildor3279
    @belenquipildor3279 Рік тому +3

    Por eso ningning es tan popular afuera de korea sus notas te hacen dar escalofríos

  • @Lisa_Hyunjin_Utted97
    @Lisa_Hyunjin_Utted97 5 місяців тому +1

    Girls never desappoint us❤

  • @みや-k8p
    @みや-k8p 4 місяці тому

    個人的にライブが1番好きなんだけど、音源よりも好きってどんだけ歌上手いのよ、、、、

  • @danissegomez7953
    @danissegomez7953 Рік тому +2

    KingNing
    Main Slayer🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
    the best performer of 4th gen🔥🔥
    an innate talent

  • @doubleknot3049
    @doubleknot3049 Рік тому +2

    🔥🔥Ningning🔥🔥

  • @LikeSomeKindOfSupernova
    @LikeSomeKindOfSupernova 7 місяців тому +1

    NING THE VOCAL QUEEN ON TOP

  • @lizm3979
    @lizm3979 Рік тому +1

    Ningning is an amazing singer, can dance very well and literally slays no matter what. She deserves everything.

  • @primahwish9
    @primahwish9 Рік тому +1

    Wow de gal gat de vocals ❤️❤️❤️🥰🥰🥰🥰

  • @Subakmijeuni
    @Subakmijeuni Рік тому +1

    Plssss æspa deserve more n more live

  • @Kimnicole.e
    @Kimnicole.e Рік тому +2

    « Why ningning is you bias »
    Bro YOU SERIOUSLY ASK THAT ???

  • @KPOP_IDOL_1111
    @KPOP_IDOL_1111 8 місяців тому +1

    Best vocalist in whole industry ❤

  • @slytherinsheir7799
    @slytherinsheir7799 Рік тому +2

    My girl ate it😭

  • @sahilbhallaa
    @sahilbhallaa Рік тому +1

    She is the best for me

  • @DonaldRiles-cw3wc
    @DonaldRiles-cw3wc 2 місяці тому +1

    I love Ning Ning

  • @NicolleCuellarNikki
    @NicolleCuellarNikki Рік тому +1

    Im so proud i tought myself to do the black mamba high note

  • @treasurestolemyheart2421
    @treasurestolemyheart2421 Рік тому +2

    Don’t be shy sm and let them sing with mic on. They slay more in live 💖