Nizam’s fall, Sardar Patel’s moves & failed bid for ‘sovereign’ Hyderabad - 75 yrs of Operation Polo

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 17 вер 2023
  • #icymi #operationpolo #hyderabad
    Seventy-five years have passed since India launched Operation Polo to ‘liberate’ Hyderabad. In Ep 1070 of Cut The Clutter - 1st published on September 7, 2022 - Editor-in-Chief Shekhar Gupta looks at sequence of events & forces at play that compelled Nizam to agree to ‘integration’ with India.
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Special benefits: theprint.in/subscribe/
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Connect with ThePrint
    » Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/subscribe/
    » Subscribe to our UA-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
    » Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
    » Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
    » Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
    » Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
    » Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintIndia
    » Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
    » Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8

КОМЕНТАРІ • 230

  • @NikhilKumar-lp9bn
    @NikhilKumar-lp9bn 8 місяців тому +38

    Somehow the genocide of Hindus committed by the Razakars is not highlighted enough... Thanks to the movie.. Razakar...for filling that gap... A must watch.

    • @sureshnaidu201
      @sureshnaidu201 8 місяців тому +3

      That will divert the focus from story SG want to tell. What is the point of talking about genocide of hindus beyond what was said here to deliver the story.

    • @sreeraam7229
      @sreeraam7229 8 місяців тому

      ​@@sureshnaidu201because thats the turning point that made decision to take back Hyderabad from Muslim rulers and integrate with India. Maybe you have not seen the pain of razakars through your grand parents. True Hyderabadi knows that

    • @AK-fd1tb
      @AK-fd1tb 8 місяців тому

      ​@@sreeraam7229well said.

  • @PrashantPatil-ye7vf
    @PrashantPatil-ye7vf 8 місяців тому +68

    Being from Marathwada.. region under Nizam, I heard a lot of stories from Congress leaders during my childhood years that how Razakars carried out killings and raps of Hindu population and how they fought to liberate Hyderabad. So it is called as Hyderabad Mukti Sangram all the way long. If people like Shekhar Gupta and others think they can build a new narrative.. they can not sell it at least to my and the older generations.. . and I am in my 40s..

    • @Intellectual_fascist
      @Intellectual_fascist 8 місяців тому +3

      As usual hindus have even witnessed even Jurassic age 😂.
      I heard some hindus claiming that their grandmother witnessed 1921 moplah war.. sorry maths is not adding up for that

    • @veerswami7175
      @veerswami7175 8 місяців тому

      @Intellectual_fascist even for speaking truth ur calling people fascist and bigots then for ur kind info we don't give w fuck I hope some of ur members live under his rule when razakars going on butchering everyone

    • @NiranjanRameshRao
      @NiranjanRameshRao 8 місяців тому +1

      Shekar did say Razakars conducted raids in neighboring states. What narrative is he selling?

    • @kalyanreddy7833
      @kalyanreddy7833 8 місяців тому +9

      ​@@Intellectual_fascist go to Pakistan u will witness minority treatment. In afgan u can taste taliban rule.
      Sitting in India a hindu majority country n giving lectures on secularism has became fashion.

    • @Intellectual_fascist
      @Intellectual_fascist 8 місяців тому +1

      @@kalyanreddy7833 cope hard hindoo..
      Who the hell are you to say that to me.?

  • @panimeda245
    @panimeda245 8 місяців тому +48

    So touching when Shekharji conveys the message on Kassim as a poor soul in his speech we all should shed tears for him who master minded killing of Hindus during the liberation time leading the razakkars.

  • @PrashantPatil-ye7vf
    @PrashantPatil-ye7vf 8 місяців тому +48

    Shekhar ji.. people do notice how you avoided talking about Kasim Rizvi and Razaka’s atrocities and toned down the struggle of millions to ‘Liberate’ and NOT ‘Integrate’ Hyderabad. At the end of the day.. people like your intellectual way of presentation.. but they are not stupid.

    • @Brightb0i
      @Brightb0i 8 місяців тому +2

      Exactly

    • @ecoideazventures6417
      @ecoideazventures6417 6 місяців тому

      Please watch his earlier video on liberation of Hyderabad - ua-cam.com/video/JYc3BcBKUw0/v-deo.html

    • @navinhookoom3584
      @navinhookoom3584 2 місяці тому

      As usual SG adores & excels in buttering the "peace loving community" and in pouring acid on those who have at heart the wellbeing of India! Typical Indian bastard "elite"!

  • @kumarm5961
    @kumarm5961 8 місяців тому +52

    Sekhar sir didn't utter a word about the word razkar atrocity due to his pseudo fans

    • @user-pz6sx7ir1p
      @user-pz6sx7ir1p 8 місяців тому +1

      why would he? you are an idiot who still pay him for his biased views.

    • @sureshnaidu201
      @sureshnaidu201 8 місяців тому +5

      did you even listen to this vedio?

    • @Deveshi.A.
      @Deveshi.A. 8 місяців тому +4

      You didn't even listen to Video and commenting

    • @sreeraam7229
      @sreeraam7229 8 місяців тому +1

      SG didn't say enough of atrocities by Muslims. Just one line Statement is not enough. He should have explained it in much better way.

    • @user-pz6sx7ir1p
      @user-pz6sx7ir1p 8 місяців тому +1

      @@sreeraam7229 then that would create problem for sickular gupta

  • @varaghu3156
    @varaghu3156 8 місяців тому +20

    Atrocities committed by Razakars under played.

    • @Intellectual_fascist
      @Intellectual_fascist 8 місяців тому

      Razakar did nothing wrong compared to what Hindus did to muslims in Jammu

    • @Myanmartiger921
      @Myanmartiger921 8 місяців тому

      @@Intellectual_fascistlol sharia is science. Osama is obama

    • @kalyanreddy7833
      @kalyanreddy7833 8 місяців тому

      ​@@Intellectual_fascist yes kashmir genocide happened n pandits were butchered.
      People were scared of 3% hindus who were educationally, employment wise, wealth n in all aspects, far a head in d state of kashmir. Instead of progressing the state by protecting them n taking inspiration of such intellectual people. As usual peacefuls rock.

    • @Intellectual_fascist
      @Intellectual_fascist 8 місяців тому

      @@kalyanreddy7833 3% of Hindus were not butchered but ousted from Kashmir.. (Kashmiris say that was done indian intelligence agencies to do mass strikes against Kashmiris.. whatever). While Hindu minority of Jammu with the help of RSS and Raja killed majority muslims of Jammu and made it almost muslim free .. why don't you apologise for that .. ? Nobody taught that story in schools..

    • @kalyanreddy7833
      @kalyanreddy7833 8 місяців тому

      ​@@Intellectual_fascist mughals destroyed looted butchered hindus converted at sword point.
      Historians don't teach this in schools. Entire Pakistan bangla both r hindus earlier, fully converted by radical rulers. Who will apologize indian hindus on behalf of regressive mughals. Who should pay price.
      During partition many peacefuls didn't migrate as they don't want to sell their properties cattle etc n not due to patriotism. Our secular leaders assured protection to peacefuls but were silent on Pak minorities. Hindus r expected to follow secularism strictly by our rulers.
      Thank god bcz of 🇮🇳 founding fathers n their reforms, majority of hindus progressed in all sectors education space, IT n all sectors. Some r ruling foreign countries. Unlike peacefuls who r backward in India even after 75 yrs. Terrorism is issue.

  • @rakalokam1
    @rakalokam1 8 місяців тому +6

    MIM AND RAZAKARS ARE NOT DIFFERENT. THEY ARE ONE AND THE SAME

    • @praveenpv9080
      @praveenpv9080 8 місяців тому

      Because mim has a Muslim as leader?. Or u have any story to support ur claim? Why don't u elaborate.

  • @rajeshnaik2808
    @rajeshnaik2808 8 місяців тому +11

    Completely biased story made by Shekhar and his team ....No mention of Atrocities, killing & Raping by Razzakar militia is not mentioned.....shekhar is only blaming Indian hindus & army

  • @adma7298
    @adma7298 8 місяців тому +28

    Everyone was against Indian integration. West Europeans, Arabs, central asians, Australians and internally muslims. But despite of all this, morality won.

    • @iaf010
      @iaf010 8 місяців тому +1

      Dharma always wins

    • @arjuniyer5047
      @arjuniyer5047 8 місяців тому +1

      It wasn't that they were against India's integration. More so they wanted to benefit out of wars and conflict

  • @alvinvazha1144
    @alvinvazha1144 8 місяців тому +75

    Dear Shekhar Ji, Kerala had a GDP growth of 12.01%, higher than the national average. Yet, it is an artificial one relying entirely on remittances with the least dependence on the productive sectors of Kerala. Also, the majority of the youth in Kerala are moving abroad for better opportunities. Could you please clear the clutter about this in one of the episodes? Thanks!

    • @dineshpratapupadhyay924
      @dineshpratapupadhyay924 8 місяців тому

      Communists did it!

    • @bpi8940
      @bpi8940 8 місяців тому +6

      Same in Punjab

    • @akhilkt
      @akhilkt 8 місяців тому +7

      ​@@bpi8940and we both top alcohol consumption numbers as well. Is there any common thread🤔?

    • @watanabe00738
      @watanabe00738 8 місяців тому

      ​@@akhilktyes, both the states are intellectually funded by pakistanis, since pakistan cannot provide money they provide brains which they do not have.

    • @kalyanreddy7833
      @kalyanreddy7833 8 місяців тому

      Highest literacy state supporting 1 national party for the last 3 decades,
      Even after peaks of corruption, unemployment, terrorism, security issues, still most literate state has been gng with same bigot party

  • @dhirajjadhav_mj
    @dhirajjadhav_mj 8 місяців тому +8

    Shekhar is master manipulator when it comes peaceful community 😂

  • @jujijiju6929
    @jujijiju6929 8 місяців тому +10

    There's a lot of Capital and workforce from AP in Hyderabad, so it's still fair to say Hyderabad is still 'their' metro city in many ways. Especially with how AP is being run, lots of capital from AP is fleeing to Hyderabad.

  • @ravindranathsribhashyam8689
    @ravindranathsribhashyam8689 8 місяців тому +15

    Being from Hyderabad, I only knew this part of history in pieces. Thank you for this.

  • @ameyasinkar9110
    @ameyasinkar9110 8 місяців тому +9

    Sir it is not a bit of both .. it was Military action which integrated Hyderabad

  • @phaddu7737
    @phaddu7737 8 місяців тому +3

    As the elections are nearing, 'The Print' Shekar Gupta showing it's true colors, trying to follow the 'long game' strategy of the Chinese but you cannot right the wrongs.

  • @nagarajayelahanka2005
    @nagarajayelahanka2005 8 місяців тому +33

    Shekar being Shekar does not elaborate Razakaar's atrocities but elaborate later otherwise. Real Sickular.

    • @bhuvanajagarapu7977
      @bhuvanajagarapu7977 8 місяців тому +1

      well said 👌👏👏👏

    • @sureshnaidu201
      @sureshnaidu201 8 місяців тому +1

      why? why must focus on razakar alone? at least SG talk about much wider perspective

    • @sreeraam7229
      @sreeraam7229 8 місяців тому

      ​@@sureshnaidu201you're an ignorant. I see your comments on almost every section. Must be youre not Hindu. Maybe a muslim or Christian in disguise. Open up your face..

    • @praveenpv9080
      @praveenpv9080 8 місяців тому

      Why don't u publish the story , if u find somebody doesn't say exact things as u want

  • @anudeeptrsv4971
    @anudeeptrsv4971 8 місяців тому +5

    It was not a operation polo it was a operation caterpillar operation polo later changed as operation caterpillar and nizam voluntarily join in indian union he stood on stand still agreement, government of india offered him Rajpramukh he served in the position for many years at the Time of china war nizam donated 6 tons of gold to indian army

    • @Intellectual_fascist
      @Intellectual_fascist 8 місяців тому +2

      Official narrative - Nizam donated
      Unofficial narrative - assets of muslim royals were confiscated.

  • @jujijiju6929
    @jujijiju6929 8 місяців тому +5

    Thank you! I've been one of those who complained a lot about lack of coverage of South Indian politics on The Print for a long time. Sorry to pester you for so long.

    • @ThePrintIndia
      @ThePrintIndia  8 місяців тому

      Thank you for writing in, my friend. Although this is a republished video, our endeavour certainly is to focus more on the southern states. Do keep watching...best wishes, Shekhar

  • @SurajKumar-wn9fg
    @SurajKumar-wn9fg 8 місяців тому +22

    How many hindus were killed by razzakars?
    Mention that.

    • @magma9000
      @magma9000 8 місяців тому +1

      How many Muslim were killed and still are killed by indian armed forces in Kashmir

    • @qwerty83484
      @qwerty83484 8 місяців тому +14

      @@magma9000 some muslims who were terrorists were killed. Not even kasmiri muslims care for them as much as you

    • @veerswami7175
      @veerswami7175 8 місяців тому +1

      Atleast more than 40000

    • @Deveshi.A.
      @Deveshi.A. 8 місяців тому

      ​@@magma9000none

    • @FreddieMurphy746
      @FreddieMurphy746 8 місяців тому

      ​@@magma9000APS, list of mosque damaka is very long... Now, in Baltistan the locals have blocked the highway and are sitting in a few hundred thousand. They r just a minute away from instigating a mass riot

  • @indranibanerjee1548
    @indranibanerjee1548 8 місяців тому +2

    Pls sir can there be a ctc for cash diversion by center which seem complicated for me . If you can please explain it for us

  • @jujijiju6929
    @jujijiju6929 8 місяців тому +6

    El-Edroos is Yemeni, Yemeni people still live in Hyderabad. They're the ones who started all these 'Mandi' restaurants, the arabic style rice and meat dish that many people share from the same plate.

  • @pharaohakhneton9553
    @pharaohakhneton9553 8 місяців тому +12

    Who are the Telengana Govt and more particularly that Communal Part MIM fooling by calling it the integration?. Integration is when you ,on your own volition, agree to join the Indian union. It is a common knowledge that is not the case with Hydersbad for the simple reason that :
    Nizam was right from the beginning clearly unwilling to join,rather expressed for remaining Independant.
    .Nizam stubornly put up resistance. So it is hypocritical on his part to extricate himself by blaming the rogue elements in his govt. That is tactical and hypocritical.
    Typical of these people when going is good,they will happily massacre people and when subjugated/defeated, the will shamelessly take to falsehood. Nizamis no different and said and did that.
    As head of state,how could he free himself from blame and responsibility?.
    MIM ,whatever it might say, deep inside the skin ,it is still the hynae's hesrt. It is bound to have doublespeak in an India which is different from Nizam's.
    History and geography was not in their favour. Till the last, Nizam tried to remain independant It bought Rms from British sympThis
    Hyderabad was liberated by military action and Nizam, being defeated, surrended in a war with India ,so how can MIM or anyone else call it integration.
    It is just playing with words,which has no significance in 2023 India. It bought arms from its British masters,who still want to disintegrate India. His advisors were the British. All his actions reveal he was hostile till his surrender.

    • @bhuvanajagarapu7977
      @bhuvanajagarapu7977 8 місяців тому

      well said, SG is trying to whitewashing his part, shame on him for not even talking razakars of nizam army who raped and tortured Hindu women. and killing Hindu men and kids.

  • @shirishpanwalkar
    @shirishpanwalkar 8 місяців тому +2

    Some say, that the idea of tagging the liberation of Hyderabad as a "police action", was first proposed by the late and great Dr Ambedkar.

    • @AK-yw9qs
      @AK-yw9qs 8 місяців тому

      No it is not, it is by Patel. As he is concerned about the new Indian military reputation. The atrocities that happened are not by present hindu or Muslim. Still we hate each other for nothing. Hindus should forget, Minorities should forget that they are different, especially from others.

  • @atuldeshmukh4471
    @atuldeshmukh4471 8 місяців тому

    Good one, nicely explained by Shekhar Ji!

  • @rajeshkamath822000
    @rajeshkamath822000 Місяць тому

    Superb Shekharji, as always.

  • @rohithkumar47
    @rohithkumar47 8 місяців тому +2

    Yeh toh last year ka re-upload hai

  • @ajitsawant50
    @ajitsawant50 8 місяців тому

    Sir, as usual very informative episode...Thanks a lot..take care

  • @vikashchhapadia2880
    @vikashchhapadia2880 8 місяців тому

    Very good informative video...thanx sekhar ji...😊

  • @srinathmitta661
    @srinathmitta661 8 місяців тому +1

    You are right. South deserves greater study and coverage in the media. The Telengana Armed Struggle, in which the Communists who waged war first against Nizam & Razakars and later against the Indian Army deserves a place in the history. They took over administration in hundreds of villages, distributed the lands of Zamindars and empowered the poor till they surrendered in 1950 About three thousand peasants were killed either in action or in custody. This movement was so popular that the Communist Party candidate from the Nalgonda was elected to the first Lok Sabha with the largest margin in the country.

    • @iaf010
      @iaf010 8 місяців тому

      These "Communist Forces" later also saw the collapse of many Telangana districts into Naxal territories where kangaroo courts, extra-judicial killings and assassinations commonly took place and terrorised the locals in the name of getting rid of the zamindars.
      We must also remember THAT part of the Communist story of Telangana.

  • @surajsajeev1988
    @surajsajeev1988 8 місяців тому +10

    I always say this. Don’t blame the razakars or the nizam. The hardware is not the problem. The software is the problem.

    • @Intellectual_fascist
      @Intellectual_fascist 8 місяців тому +3

      Yes. Software was always anti Hindu like anti Virus

    • @Myanmartiger921
      @Myanmartiger921 8 місяців тому

      @@Intellectual_fascistusa is real anti virus the sunni allah is usa

    • @sreeraam7229
      @sreeraam7229 8 місяців тому

      Whom to blame then??? Are you mad??? If they would have raped your family girls and killed your ancestors, then you will understand. Will you say don't blame them??? Stop being moron. Accept the truth as it is.. maybe you dont belong to Hyderabad. You must be coming from beggar Andhra... stop being illogical and cowardice

    • @anonymous-hl7ez
      @anonymous-hl7ez 8 місяців тому +1

      Gaumutra is the problem

    • @AK-fd1tb
      @AK-fd1tb 8 місяців тому

      ​@@anonymous-hl7ez of course garbage like you call it gaumutra problem. When you know neither history and culture of the place. Our ancestors suffered from Razakars you dare to lecture on it.

  • @mg.f.9023
    @mg.f.9023 8 місяців тому +5

    “A country needs to have an environment of civility where people [are] working together to make good things happen.”
    - Ray Dalio
    Founder,
    Bridgewater Associates

  • @prabhakarnaik1180
    @prabhakarnaik1180 8 місяців тому

    Excellent narrative & unknown facts for many of us who born after independence...the decade of 1945 to 1955 full of untold facts going on in those days..
    community , religious based polatical arenas found across the spectrum & periods..now days it's more highlighted due to technology improvement..

  • @vijayn7200
    @vijayn7200 8 місяців тому +3

    keep telling we dont talk about south often. But keep doing that.

  • @nikhilguvvadi8617
    @nikhilguvvadi8617 8 місяців тому +1

    The Telangana Armed Struggle agaisnt the Nizam and the Indian Army is the most significant part of India's "integration" story. The Print does some really great work, but conveniently ignored it, whatever the reason may be, only looking at the communal side of the story is not in the interest of our nation.

  • @Mouryaaa
    @Mouryaaa 8 місяців тому +1

    Totally left out Telangana Armed Struggle.

  • @manoharshenoy4800
    @manoharshenoy4800 8 місяців тому +20

    You have to give full credit to Sardar Patel for liberating the Hyderabad province and integrating it with India. Mr. Gandhi and Mr Nehru would not or could not have done it.

    • @azmarc4108
      @azmarc4108 8 місяців тому +2

      Not liberate , just invade

    • @AK-fd1tb
      @AK-fd1tb 8 місяців тому

      ​@@azmarc4108of course, it's an invasion according to clowns like you while our ancestors were suffering. There's a reason why Telangana sayuda poratam fought Razakars.

    • @balajisankarkonakalla3369
      @balajisankarkonakalla3369 8 місяців тому +2

      ​@@azmarc4108 It's liberated. Not Integrating. Shameless fellow

  • @vishnuvardhanduggireddy
    @vishnuvardhanduggireddy 8 місяців тому +4

    Atrocities committed by razakars lets not elaborate but lets wait for the other part. Really secular

  • @ramjidharmaraj
    @ramjidharmaraj 8 місяців тому +6

    How many of those murders went Scott free. Not a single one. Who died as always Hindus. Who won and even winning today, Islamists who are still inside India.

  • @cmkar1013
    @cmkar1013 8 місяців тому +2

    Спасибо большое 💞🎉❤

  • @anwarshahid1
    @anwarshahid1 8 місяців тому

    Was it a declared as military operation ..?

  • @distoriank5314
    @distoriank5314 8 місяців тому +9

    He did not once recount atrocities on hindus but look at his enthusiasm to paint hindus as aggressors. What a slimeball

  • @Siddharth_Rao
    @Siddharth_Rao 8 місяців тому +2

    A good short summary of the events that led to Liberation of Hyderabad, given the constraint of time that Shekhar had to work in. That said, what the Razakars did to target one particular community should have been elaborated a bit, perhaps some want the topic of Razakars to be wished away from our History. Who knows?

  • @pmzqhg
    @pmzqhg 8 місяців тому +2

    Hyderabad state had parts of Tamilnadu? Does anyone know of the maps showing it? In schools we studied it to end well up in today’s Andhra Pradesh.

  • @ady_k
    @ady_k 8 місяців тому +1

    Town hall with DK Singh please.

  • @hscplusclinics3661
    @hscplusclinics3661 8 місяців тому +5

    It was militarily liberated using force by defeating the Muslim Army of Nizam of Hyderabad....

  • @KothapellyTharun
    @KothapellyTharun 8 місяців тому +1

    Iam surprised that you not said one word about Communists who actually started a struggle ,fought on behalf of people of Hyderabad and lost their cadre killed by Nizams Razakars and the Indian Army troops brutally. Communists fought against the atrocities of Landlords ,Doras,Deshmukh,patels and patwaries and distributed the lakhs of acres land to the people of Hyderabad. Communists welcomed Indian integration but after Integration in India ,Indian Army generals supported these landlords and reocupied this Land, brutally killed who opposed them.Razakers came to villages stayed in the Gadis of doras (mostly Hindu landlords) and killed our familes. NOTE:- Its not a fight against Muslim Nawab v/s hindu people But a fight against Landlords, Doras,zamindars V/S landless poor people. Doddi Komarai,Chakali Ilamma ,Shoaibulla khan,Magdum Moinuddin,Ravi Narayan Reddy ....they are the real heros of Hyderabad Struggle .Please speak about them.

  • @Anonymous-ez9qn
    @Anonymous-ez9qn 5 місяців тому

    No mention of the local Hindu communist militias who freed major portions of Nalgonda, Khammam, Karimnagar and Warangal. They were tortured by Razakars. But they freed many villages.

  • @anupamdein
    @anupamdein 8 місяців тому +4

    MIM today is.........

  • @ecoideazventures6417
    @ecoideazventures6417 6 місяців тому

    People who are highly concerned about SG's omission on Razakars can watch his earlier video on liberation of Hyderabad - ua-cam.com/video/JYc3BcBKUw0/v-deo.html

  • @rakalokam1
    @rakalokam1 8 місяців тому

    IT IS NOT ASIF JAH... IT IS ASAFJAH ...

  • @anwarshahid1
    @anwarshahid1 8 місяців тому

    The stand taken by the Indian government in the case Kashmir was not just other wise than Huderabad ...?

  • @anwarshahid1
    @anwarshahid1 8 місяців тому

    Were the states given any choic? Did Congress sign any agreement in this regard ..Did it matter ?

  • @vijayraju6182
    @vijayraju6182 8 місяців тому

    Disappointed by SG's review. Nothing new. I am from Raichur (Kar) part of the Nizam and may be knew more about the Nizam then SG.

  • @SomasekharH
    @SomasekharH 8 місяців тому

    Looks like Sydney Cotton was the one who made maximum profits out of this, followed by Owaisis...

  • @narendraarya6479
    @narendraarya6479 8 місяців тому

    You failed to cut the clutter by forgetting contribution of Arya Samaj in hyderabad liberation.

  • @sasiandem
    @sasiandem 8 місяців тому

    Hyderabad state didn't include today's Andhra Pradesh. It was Telangana+ bit of Karnataka and a bit of Maharashtra. @print

    • @AK-fd1tb
      @AK-fd1tb 8 місяців тому

      Nizams gave away 'Ceded' which is now called Rayalaseema and north Sircar (Guntur to Srikakulam). I think you read history more.

  • @vikashchhapadia2880
    @vikashchhapadia2880 8 місяців тому

    I am sure aur bhi bahut sare honge...apse anurodh hai aur bhi jarur sunaien....

  • @jaigagandeep.s5100
    @jaigagandeep.s5100 8 місяців тому +1

    You should have highlighted razakars atrocities

  • @shravancell5210
    @shravancell5210 8 місяців тому

    Unfortunately not a word about Telugu people's fight in villages for Integration into India and against razakars😢
    This video's is purely from Delhi Angle of View

    • @Abhijeetonroll
      @Abhijeetonroll 8 місяців тому

      Its mostly the communist party who rallied peasants and farmers to revolt against the landlords who were in fact majorly Hindus presided over by Nizam.

  • @padamagarwal8184
    @padamagarwal8184 8 місяців тому +1

    It is surely a liberation , happening an year later when Nizam surrendered to Indian forces

  • @preetishbiswal7753
    @preetishbiswal7753 8 місяців тому

    1. It's Asaf Jah and not Asif Jah. 2. Deccan comes from the word Dakshin.

  • @arkabanerjee1627
    @arkabanerjee1627 8 місяців тому

    History tells nizams was always against Indian..accepting all British conditions

  • @rakalokam1
    @rakalokam1 8 місяців тому

    LAIQ ALI A SHREWD AND TOUGH NEGOTIATOR? PLEASE READ HYDERABAD'S HISTORY. HE WAS A STOOGE OF QASIM RAZVI.

  • @kasisv3846
    @kasisv3846 8 місяців тому +1

    Read Narendra Luther, better than Guha

  • @mirayoobalikhan9573
    @mirayoobalikhan9573 8 місяців тому

    I have always liked Shekhar Gupta since his days elsewhere, not The Print. On Hyderabad he presents a sketchy analysis. He should have spoken about Razakars, their employers and targets; he should have spoken about massacre of Muslims and the rape of their women and destruction of their houses in Hyderabad State of the Nizam. This episode is too simplistic and too shallow. Apart from Sunderlal Committee Reports the shady role of K M Munshi and the fear that gripped the Muslims for several decades. The removal of the Muslims from the government jobs and making their life miserable. I suggest he should revisit Operation Polo and its consequences, both good and bad on the Muslim psyche of Hyderabad. Meanwhile, a movie is coming out--Razakars on the lines of Kashmir Files and the Kerala Story, soon which I fear would lead to polarisation of people in Telangana, Maharashtra and Karnataka.

  • @HimanshuGupta-jx4nk
    @HimanshuGupta-jx4nk 8 місяців тому

    Don't forget, if Gandhi were alive, he wouldn't Indian take Hyderabad by force, hence no liberation at all.

  • @dranilheroor
    @dranilheroor 8 місяців тому

    was the role of the Razakars left out purposely in this talk ? the atrocities of the Razakars are remembered to this day by a lot of people in the areas under nizam rule like Nanded

  • @AbhishekSingh-lq3ee
    @AbhishekSingh-lq3ee 8 місяців тому

    Sir I noticed that u mentioned figures of muslim causality but u didn't mention any figures about hindu causality.
    Stating half fact is misrepresentation of fact.

  • @shamsheeravikal9348
    @shamsheeravikal9348 8 місяців тому

    Have to given adiquate ccompensation of peoples who killed by polo ,have to retain the nizams raja pramuk status if we still remain in sathyameva jayada gov of india should not hve the right to remove the raj pramug status whic was guven to princlt states

  • @firstsparkle5378
    @firstsparkle5378 8 місяців тому +5

    Your explanation is flawed.... According to your logic, Since Indian Army was biased in favour of Hindus during operation therefore term "police Action" Was used..... This logic would have been true if term "police action" Was used after operation.... But this term was not used by looking at the consequence of operation.... In reality, India's ministry of External Affairs used the term "police action" even just before the launch of operation.... It was done to downplay the side effects of the operation at UN.

  • @anupammishra2936
    @anupammishra2936 8 місяців тому

    Not a word about loot, plunder, rape & genocide by the Razakars 🥸

  • @kishenbhatia8068
    @kishenbhatia8068 8 місяців тому

    You are too late Shekhar Gupta. I read every word u've spoken around a week ago.😑

  • @TheBhoomiPutra
    @TheBhoomiPutra 8 місяців тому +8

    Shekar ji, hope you can recall or find out that the same Nizam donated 5,000 kgs of gold to our National Defence when PM Lal Bahadur Shastri called for dinations to revuild the military after the 1962 defeat. This is still the highest ever contribution by an individual. No Ambani no Adani has matched this.

    • @pankajmishra2410
      @pankajmishra2410 8 місяців тому +12

      We should also talk about razakars of nizam army who raped tortured woman .....what u say!!?

    • @debasheesh
      @debasheesh 8 місяців тому +11

      While someone has suggested that what you said is factually incorrect, I'd like to remind you that Reliance has paid 24000 crores in taxes last year ,employs a large number of people and contributes a lot to our GDP
      It is not always necessary to bring down an industrialist to prove any point you're trying to

    • @AtulKumar-cj2ke
      @AtulKumar-cj2ke 8 місяців тому +11

      That was not his personal gold, that gold was looted from common public

    • @Intellectual_fascist
      @Intellectual_fascist 8 місяців тому

      ​@@AtulKumar-cj2keso is the wealth of hindu rajas . Whom upon modern day hindus like Rajputs kang upon 😂

    • @Myanmartiger921
      @Myanmartiger921 8 місяців тому +1

      Whose money was it iit hindu money

  • @desidonusa
    @desidonusa 8 місяців тому +1

    ...lol... Nehru. .. said..... why he can't solve Kashmir

  • @mg.f.9023
    @mg.f.9023 8 місяців тому +2

    "History is a
    tool used by
    politicians
    to justify
    their
    intensions."
    - Ted Koppel

    • @nobody4u77
      @nobody4u77 8 місяців тому +3

      You aren't indian gl comment in your own country's politics

    • @surajs5913
      @surajs5913 8 місяців тому +1

      Religions like islam were also political tools used to control people - me

    • @mg.f.9023
      @mg.f.9023 8 місяців тому

      @@nobody4u77
      You aren't Indian nor human, Calling you a donkey will insult the donkey 😂

  • @Gouthamedara
    @Gouthamedara 8 місяців тому

    In short its a liberation.

  • @user-hp1uq2hd1o
    @user-hp1uq2hd1o 8 місяців тому

    and how manu Hindus were killed by Razakars, y dont u put those numbers as well Mr. Gupta??

  • @vijayshankertamrakar2586
    @vijayshankertamrakar2586 8 місяців тому

    NIZAMS WERE NEVER BADSHAH AS U INDICATED...

  • @rajendranathanmnair4122
    @rajendranathanmnair4122 8 місяців тому

    Typical Sekhar ji way of saying a story without irritating some peaceful people who still dream of breaking India as per a dream.started in 1927....

  • @kothwali
    @kothwali 8 місяців тому

    Yes south itself gives 40 percent or more GDP to India.. u should talk about South
    Lol

  • @arjuniyer5047
    @arjuniyer5047 8 місяців тому +1

    Sanghis comment here about shekhar not expanding on the razakar atrocities but conveniently forget the communist party uprising of the telugu people in rural areas against the nizam state. Doesnt go well with their hindu nationalist agenda.

  • @balajisankarkonakalla3369
    @balajisankarkonakalla3369 8 місяців тому +1

    It's an insult to people who lost their lives while liberating Hyderabad. This kind of pseudo journalist is dangerous to the country.

    • @praveenpv9080
      @praveenpv9080 8 місяців тому

      Go and follow arnab goswami, if u think shekhar is pseudo journalists

    • @balajisankarkonakalla3369
      @balajisankarkonakalla3369 8 місяців тому

      @@praveenpv9080 are you out of your mind? How Arnab came into the picture. Sekhar is justifying the Nizam's cruelty.

  • @vijayshankertamrakar2586
    @vijayshankertamrakar2586 8 місяців тому

    LAATO KE BHOOT NEEDED IRON FIST TO DEAL WITH RAZAKAARs WHICH PATEL USED

  • @unknown.m.e
    @unknown.m.e 8 місяців тому +15

    Everyone knows Hyderabad wants to join Pakistan.
    Because of India govt at that time took over Hyderabad by force.
    So Modi is correct here.
    I am seeing a lot of stuff where the current Telangana govt changes its history and makes it seem like Andhra is a bad guy while the Nizams are good guys.
    Everyone knows before the British entire Telugu state was ruled by Nizams but most of Telangana don't want to admit it because it makes their moments meaningless.
    They took bhadrachalam and sree Ram temple after the Telangana formation even though it belongs to the Madras presidency. And should belong to the current AP. But they took it by saying it was built by Nizams and once ruled by Nizams. While they don't talk about the current AP.

    • @rahulkarawade7347
      @rahulkarawade7347 8 місяців тому +4

      Don't misinform historical facts. People still remember the atrocity of Nizam(razakar) on its
      subjects espicially hindu.

    • @thesupremesupreme
      @thesupremesupreme 8 місяців тому

      ​@@rahulkarawade7347he is only saying Kcr words how he twisted historical facts and brought Telangana issue for his political career. When maratawada and Hyderabad Karnataka are having same problems because of semi arid nature of soil and poor agriculture and still farmers commit suicide still they remain part of Maharashtra and Karnataka but Telangana with Hyderabad equal to Andhra in every way in gsdp and more than AP in percapita and all proves that all the statements of Kcr as false where he portrays coastal Andhra region people as villains . Those are all fake propaganda . Idea of Telangana in itself is unviable because United Andhra will sustain together with its all three regions . And will be on par with Thailand , Vietnam and turkey in GDP and development and all.

    • @unknown.m.e
      @unknown.m.e 8 місяців тому

      @@rahulkarawade7347 go and say to the Telangana youth they say Nizams develop Hyderabad and AP people just used them and their land. They create this propaganda to get a separate state.
      For them Nizams are far better than current AP people.
      A lot of people even commented to me that the Nizam rule was better and AP govt used and destroyed it.

    • @praveenpv9080
      @praveenpv9080 8 місяців тому

      The division of AP was a blunder by congrass, which backfired them. But created a un reconcilable dent to India

    • @unknown.m.e
      @unknown.m.e 8 місяців тому

      @@praveenpv9080 it was good for AP because AP will develop more because prev govts only set stuff in Telangana area all industries and companies.
      Because of Telangana moment all govt giving extra benefits to Telangana people and doing stuff there but we still get these violence just political gains.
      Rayalasema and AP don't get anything other than political violence now AP can develop more without violence of Telangana and we don't have to give special benefits as well.
      We may not not have capital right now but AP will grow better than Telangana in a few years

  • @P.C1999
    @P.C1999 2 місяці тому +1

    Hindu life matter

  • @sensysllp4022
    @sensysllp4022 8 місяців тому

    Razakkars atrocities are always undermined by journalists

  • @Thereis406
    @Thereis406 3 дні тому

    You totally forget about Telangana militant poratam by communist we call the red brothers if you don't know history don't gas light😂😂

  • @SHAILESHKUMAR-lp7yu
    @SHAILESHKUMAR-lp7yu 8 місяців тому +1

    Anti national Gupta continues to insult our intelligence

  • @user-ko3nf5bl4o
    @user-ko3nf5bl4o 2 місяці тому

    Hyderabad was occupied by Islamic invaders it was liberation of Hyderabad and the indigenous people of Hyderabad. Hyderabad name should be changed it does not represent the civilizational Hindu identity of Hyderabad

  • @Intellectual_fascist
    @Intellectual_fascist 8 місяців тому

    Jai Shree Razakars😍😍

    • @bclassic2474
      @bclassic2474 8 місяців тому +1

      Killed liked mad dogs. Only capable of hurting unarmed civilians surrender pants down 😂😂in 3 days. Coward like their papa Pak 93000 sirrender

  • @Mohan-jd8fc
    @Mohan-jd8fc 8 місяців тому +7

    BJP won't concur power in Telugu states the basis of religion like they do in the north So, now they decide to focus on this kinda issues. What happened in the Hyderabad state is in the past definitely horrible but now people in the state has communal harmony. People focusing more on education and jobs instead of politics. Muslim people ideology is also changing positively except where there is BJP/ MIm has a strong hold. Each other communities leaders are accusing each other for their benifits. We can see the positive change through the development of Hyderabad and other places. I hope Political leaders won't disturb the peace for their political benifits. We should not forget the past but the past shouldn't disturb our future and peace between people.

    • @agnimitram340
      @agnimitram340 8 місяців тому +3

      It's good to see the development of Hyderabad. Also KCR is doing a good job it seems. Rooting for similar development of Andhra.

    • @pranjalsoni1743
      @pranjalsoni1743 8 місяців тому +9

      In Kerala BJP even don't have foothold still radicalism among Muslim is highest

    • @sourabhpatil23945
      @sourabhpatil23945 8 місяців тому +17

      In Hyderabad, Dare and go to muslims dominated area,It is fucking feels like we are not in India and you talk of communal harmony.
      One party was holding power for 60 Years by playing caste politics and using Muslims as votebanks, That was and is Ok, But now when Hindu votes consolidated and BJP come to power, Now BJP is doing Politics on the basis of Religion?
      I mean shameless People of AIMIM didn't even bothered to change the Name "MIM" who butched Hindus, And BJP is doing Religion Politics, Wahhh means at least watch the complete Video first before commenting, "Communal Harmony" Bullshit.

    • @Raja-xk3ol
      @Raja-xk3ol 8 місяців тому

      Muslim mentality hasnt changed a bit since 1947. They are waiting to become majority and then the real game will start. We hindus have learnt nothing from what happened to hindus in Pakistand Bangladesh and Afghanistan.

    • @user-pz6sx7ir1p
      @user-pz6sx7ir1p 8 місяців тому +3

      Abdul's blood in you.

  • @omkaarujalambkar4797
    @omkaarujalambkar4797 8 місяців тому

    I was expecting at least a slight mention of genocide of Hindus (Marathi & Telugu speaking population in particular) carried out by Razakars in Maharashtra & other parts. No attempt of whitewashing the image of nizam would work at least in Maharashtra. It was & it is a 'Liberation' for us.

  • @magma9000
    @magma9000 8 місяців тому +3

    WORLD SHOULD PRESSURE INDIA TO FREE KASHMIR

    • @prabhukod1
      @prabhukod1 8 місяців тому +6

      Hah !! You and your wetdreams!!

    • @HeavenRacer422
      @HeavenRacer422 8 місяців тому +10

      Free from is|am 😌

    • @hotelkempton243
      @hotelkempton243 8 місяців тому

      Take Pigs like Owaisi & pak premis staying in India

    • @intrusionman4157
      @intrusionman4157 8 місяців тому +6

      From jihadi

    • @bhuvanajagarapu7977
      @bhuvanajagarapu7977 8 місяців тому

      yes just wait from few more years, the whole world will pressure the India to free the POK Kashmir and from the Islamic Jihadi .

  • @abhishekrai33
    @abhishekrai33 8 місяців тому +1

    Gupta jii....this is nt the time of congress system....u still talk like that u do make narrative.....this is the era of I.T.revolution..."Nijam tried hard to join pakistan".,....plz dnt spread falsehood 😢😢😢😢😢

  • @saisivasababathy
    @saisivasababathy 8 місяців тому

    Basically its liberation of Hyderabad as per Shekar Muslims as per Islam will never support integration as chapter 9 verse 5 of Quran “But once the Sacred Months have passed, kill the polytheists ˹who violated their treaties˺ wherever you find them, capture them, besiege them, and lie in wait for them on every way”

  • @ArunPunnathatta
    @ArunPunnathatta 8 місяців тому

    en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telangana_Rebellion
    Nicely avoided this part of the story....

  • @Aleksandr_Gelyevich_Dugin
    @Aleksandr_Gelyevich_Dugin 8 місяців тому

    I'm not apologetic like you SG sir.
    I say it was liberation of Hyderabad from the Islamic Kingdom of Nizam and Islam lost against Indian army❤