Mailbag: Jayson Tatum, Jaylen Brown roles moving forward, Boston Celtics vs. the world, and more

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 94

  • @mctaguer
    @mctaguer 3 місяці тому +9

    I wish Bill Russell could've seen the team this year. Bet he would've LOVED how this team plays together.

  • @devinjenkins9964
    @devinjenkins9964 3 місяці тому +11

    John just want to thank you again for keeping up with the champs even though it’s your job to keep a close eye them. It’s still refreshing to hear that the champions are being covered more than the 55th pick in the draft.

  • @TEDSHOTTHAT
    @TEDSHOTTHAT 3 місяці тому +5

    We got the ring behind TEAM

  • @therealdarrell282
    @therealdarrell282 3 місяці тому +15

    The Jays need to continue playing team basketball

    • @TheRobversion1
      @TheRobversion1 3 місяці тому +1

      For sure.

    • @tylerriley2587
      @tylerriley2587 3 місяці тому +1

      The Jays are both three-level athletic scorers that have a lot in the package.

    • @tylerriley2587
      @tylerriley2587 3 місяці тому

      @therealdarell282 Holiday takes the right shot at the right time. John is right. Jrue is a consistent shooter; Smart is a streaky, inconsistent shooter who takes shots at the wrong time.

    • @therealdarrell282
      @therealdarrell282 3 місяці тому

      @@tylerriley2587 Facts. I still say the shots that Smart took was due to the defense leaving him open on purpose. Draymond Green said it after game 1 when he mentioned the shots made by Smart, Grant and Pritchard in the 2024 Finals. How many wide open shots did the role players miss in game 4 that turned that series in favor of GS?

    • @tylerriley2587
      @tylerriley2587 3 місяці тому

      @@therealdarrell282 now look at the young Orlando Magic they will be good but what about the Heat? Orlando has KCP
      Is Bam suited to be the first option for the Heat or no

  • @TheRobversion1
    @TheRobversion1 3 місяці тому +3

    My projected rotation mins for the early part of the season:
    *all mins are based on their mins played last year. Will show 2 scenarios:
    a. Celtics go double big more-
    1- d.white (28), pp (20)
    2- jrue (32), d.white (4), sam (12)
    3- jb (32), sam (8), jt (8)
    4- jt (28), tillman (16), al (4)
    5- al (20), luke (16), queta (12)
    *i like this as jt gets to spend some time at the 3 to hunting smaller wings.
    b. Celtics rest Al on 2nd night of B2B-
    1- d.white (28), pp (20)
    2- jrue (32), d.white (4), baylor (12)
    3- jb (24), sam (20), baylor (4)
    4- jt (36), jb (8), tillman (4)
    5- luke (16), queta (16), tillman (16)
    *tillman, baylor and queta all get extra mins. This is the path for more development time for baylor and queta. Decided to give the extra mins to tillman over luke. This assumes Baylor outplays Walsh.
    not playing: walsh, springer, anton, drew, kp

  • @mctaguer
    @mctaguer 3 місяці тому +1

    Agree with your anti-heliocentric prognosis. I've been predicting it for a decade, it just took this long to have a team that put it all together.
    James Brown T-Shirt: 7.5/10

  • @Brutip1
    @Brutip1 3 місяці тому +2

    I understand the Tatum and Brown questions, I just believe it's irrelevant. Both are great players and leaders. Both are making a great case to be hall of famers one day. We've proven that we can win with the both of them. Whatever it takes

  • @annettehenderson927
    @annettehenderson927 3 місяці тому

    Always luv listening to your podcast and the t shirt

  • @richardj1319
    @richardj1319 3 місяці тому +2

    Now JT and JB are the reigning Jays.

  • @juliusrickles
    @juliusrickles 3 місяці тому

    Ive been saying our starters should start for team USA for well over a month now. Probably around time the playoffs started. Actually it was when KP went down vs miami. But glad you finally bring it up.

  • @danielthompson3928
    @danielthompson3928 3 місяці тому +1

    I agree that Jaylen is the better scorer. He is more efficient and more clutch. Jayson is a way better distributor. Jaylen is an inefficient distributor and Jayson is an inefficient scorer. If Jaylen does slightly better distributing and more scoring and Jayson does slightly better scoring and more distributing then I do not see anyone beating this duo. 25, 10, & 10 is kind of a lot but ~20, ~10, and ~10 is fair for Tatum. ~30, ~5 and ~5 for Brown.

    • @juliusrickles
      @juliusrickles 3 місяці тому

      JB could easily lead the league in scoring if he had a pass first point whatever. Unfortunately he has tatum who still wants to jack up the most shots. Dude will be 5-21 and put up 3 more while JB is 8-11

    • @SabLew-yh2or
      @SabLew-yh2or 3 місяці тому

      Tatum has averaged more points on better efficiency literally every season they've played you 🤡
      Tatum also has way better clutch #s than brown
      Casual asss

    • @SabLew-yh2or
      @SabLew-yh2or 3 місяці тому

      Tatum has averaged more points on better efficiency than brown literally every season they've played together you 🤡

  • @mctaguer
    @mctaguer 3 місяці тому +2

    I agree but kinda disagree with the idea of not "needing" to trade Marcus Smart. Obviously, given that the C's tried to trade Brogdon first, that's kinda true. But what the C's NEEDED was a viable, above-average #3 option on offense. Marcus was, arguably, their third best player... just not good enough, and Brad knew it. THAT's why their offense would hit walls. By adding a Porzingis, would Marcus have accepted (along with the emergence of Derrick White as a CLEARLY superior offensive player) being the 5th option on offense? Mostly, I think he would have...but I'm not 100% sure. There's that chaos/occasional bad decision-making thing. Sorry, but I never fully TRUSTED Marcus. Still prone to too many "whuuuuut?" plays that made no sense--not even talking about his shooting. Meanwhile, Jrue is possibly the MOST trustworthy player, maybe in the entire NBA.

    • @TheRobversion1
      @TheRobversion1 3 місяці тому +2

      Yeah i wouldnt trust marcus to accept that.

    • @tylerriley2587
      @tylerriley2587 3 місяці тому

      Smart made to many dumb decisions and bad shots Jrue makes the right decision and takes the right shot

    • @nickgilday8946
      @nickgilday8946 3 місяці тому +1

      I love smart. Love…. But we needed him to step down as a leader to allow the jays to truly blossom and I just cannot see him doing that. As such.. Brad needed to move him for us to win it all. Super tough call, but hard to argue the results.

  • @tylerriley2587
    @tylerriley2587 3 місяці тому

    I agree that Holiday was a steady point guard who pushed the right buttons, but Smart was an inconsistent shooter.

  • @Robin-xt7yo
    @Robin-xt7yo 3 місяці тому +3

    Unselfish TEAM ball is why the Celtics led the league all season long straight to the 🏆. Idiots at ESPN just see heliocentric Luka "magic" and the 🐑🐑 laid $ on the Mavs despite Vegas computation favoring the C's. No sympathy for the 🐑 who lost $. Anyone watching the C's all season knew TEAM ball would dominate!

  • @coolgenuinephil3051
    @coolgenuinephil3051 3 місяці тому

    JT looking like he is 19 again and going for 🏆19 ☘️☘️☘️☘️💪💪😁

  • @martinalbert29
    @martinalbert29 3 місяці тому +1

    Hi just wondering if you have insights in that recent story that Wyc actually only owns 2% of the Celtics and majority is with his 90 year old dad ? Any truth in that? That would be big in that it would suggest the sale is really for estate planning instead of cashing in on high team valuation before the big luxury tax bill kicks in. I’m actually ok with either story just curious as to what the actual development is.

    • @1smhx5
      @1smhx5 3 місяці тому +1

      Well his dad is the owner of there finances and wyc just acting as owner in place of his 89 year old father. But ultimately his dad is in charge and when he says it’s time to hang it up you do wyc had 2 kids I believe but there is no interest at least from an outside perspective that they have any desire to take over. So it’s either sell high or risk the value dropping

  • @tdogg78
    @tdogg78 3 місяці тому

    Brad is drafting the out of the second apron

  • @danielthompson3928
    @danielthompson3928 3 місяці тому

    The Celtics can keep their entire roster active between the Boston and Maine Celtics. KP is out most of the regular season and Al Horford will likely continue to play every other game. Then you have the roster spots in Maine to fill out. So basically, 16.5 guys to split between Boston and the starting lineup of Maine. I expect Luke and Tillman to eat up a lot of KP and Horford minutes and Queta to share his time between both clubs. Same deal for JD Davison. Hopefully, Springer gets more minutes this year now that he knows the system.

  • @samhillson898
    @samhillson898 3 місяці тому

    we would easily win the gold medal- easily easily easily

  • @TEDSHOTTHAT
    @TEDSHOTTHAT 3 місяці тому

    I agree i dont think it matters

  • @charlesbolstridge3871
    @charlesbolstridge3871 3 місяці тому

    You can't tell me smart was content when it came to who was going to lead the team and had a higher self-worth then what was reality. And of course there was never any tension between the Jays and Marcus besides the chairs flying across the locker room😅

  • @bmcfonzie
    @bmcfonzie 3 місяці тому

    I don't really care how Nomar treated the media. People ragged on Belichick for the same reason, and if you work in the media, I can see how that would matter to you. But it doesn't matter to fans. How Nomar treated his teammates, manager, etc. is, of course, a different story. But I take some of the things being said about him with a grain of salt, since there was a pattern of dirty laundry being aired by the Red Sox every time a star player left town, or was traded. In that case, obviously trading him worked out pretty well for the team. But if his career wasn't derailed by injuries he would have been an easy Hall of Famer, so the comparison is hardly insulting to Marcus Smart.

  • @carolinadnm17
    @carolinadnm17 3 місяці тому

    John, just for the record, there should be NO WAY that Paul Pierce supplants John Havlicek in the greatest of Celtics pantheon.

  • @bmcfonzie
    @bmcfonzie 3 місяці тому

    The Tatum vs Brown debate is tiresome, but... people are somehow forgetting Tatum has been first team All-NBA the past three seasons. Also: I agree that the Celtics have a more team based approach that don't require any one player to score 30 every night. But Tatum actually exemplifies this, since he can score, rebound, and distribute at a high level and also defend against all positions at a high level. Outside of Lebron James, there's been no one else in the league (at least not recently) to have that kind of versatility doing everything. That is another main reason he's the Celtics best player. Note: I don't mean to take anything away from Jaylen Brown, who is also fantastic (he should've been third team All-NBA over Booker), has turned into the team leader, and was probably their best player in the playoffs. It's just that "Who is the Celtics' best player overall?" is a question with a very clear answer over the past several seasons, and I don't think the answer has changed. People have short memories.

    • @bmcfonzie
      @bmcfonzie 3 місяці тому

      In a certain sense, I agree with the mentality of "they're all the best player," since that's a good mentality for the team to have. But in another sense, it's obviously not true. Just look at the contracts they are signing. Clearly the Boston Celtics don't believe that the value of all their players is the same. It's possible to recognize that and also appreciate the way the team actually plays as a team and expect that to continue.

  • @rontardif8740
    @rontardif8740 3 місяці тому

    Would have been nice to keep Oshea Brissett

  • @MrrKing26
    @MrrKing26 3 місяці тому

    Stop forgetting the championship belt

  • @Mptappin12
    @Mptappin12 3 місяці тому

    9:12 well with the new CBA I don’t think he even has a choice.

  • @juliusrickles
    @juliusrickles 3 місяці тому

    JB >jt
    JB a much better scorer and on ball defender. Yes jt gets boards and assist but he plays down low and brings the ball up so he absolutely should.

  • @samhillson898
    @samhillson898 3 місяці тому

    Porzingis will go Holiday will not go away- Brad is too smart for that

  • @boomataco
    @boomataco 3 місяці тому

    If pingus was healthy for the finals. After that first game... No doubt in my mind that he would have been the finals m v p because dallas had no answer

  • @mctaguer
    @mctaguer 3 місяці тому

    If you want to see who they would LOVE to develop into an Al replacement, it's Watson. Don't laugh--not a doubt in my mind they think he could have that kind of upside.

    • @TheRobversion1
      @TheRobversion1 3 місяці тому +1

      Watson has potential and should get garbage time mins this year. Garbage time 5 should be baylor, springer, walsh, anton and queta.

  • @TheRobversion1
    @TheRobversion1 3 місяці тому +1

    Agreed john. This is the spider-verse. Everybody's got a shot to be the best player but everybody doesnt care. Make the right play.
    its about THEM. not HIM.
    Hot take for 3Y down the line: KP will take a massive discount to stay with the team and get the team out of the 2nd apron.
    Walsh has a chance to earn early season rotation mins (when Al sits on B2B) if he outplays Baylor. His 3 pt shot should be improved or he wont crack the rotation. The best thing that could happen to him is Sam leaves next offseason.

  • @charlesbolstridge3871
    @charlesbolstridge3871 3 місяці тому +1

    They don't trade Marcus they don't win, come on. The Jays wouldn't have taken a leap they did this year in leadership, the glorification of a role player buy Boston fans and Media way out of proportion😮 Marcus Smart would have never been able to do what Drew holiday did in this playoff run and we all seen it for 9 years we know he's not him😅

  • @danielthompson3928
    @danielthompson3928 3 місяці тому

    Denver would not have Jokic or Murray. The Denver champs would definitely lose in the Olympics without those guys. Whereas the Celtics could win without Porzingis.

  • @tdogg78
    @tdogg78 3 місяці тому

    In 2 years Watson will be Al 2.0

  • @brianreise2449
    @brianreise2449 3 місяці тому

    ☘️☘️👊

  • @cgonz91
    @cgonz91 3 місяці тому

    You NEEDED to trade Marcus back in the bubble when he went 2-28 in fourth quraters the worst in nba history for that stretch where we lost the ecf to miami and kemba went down

    • @nickgilday8946
      @nickgilday8946 3 місяці тому +1

      I don’t think it was his play that lead to needing to trade him, I think it was more the jays, specifically Jaylen, needing the space to step in to a leadership role… smart just wasn’t allowing that. You have to know your role on the court, you also need to know it in the locker room.

    • @cgonz91
      @cgonz91 3 місяці тому

      @@nickgilday8946 it was both! Smart holds the record for the worst nba player in 4th quarters in HISTORY lookit up please its a miraculous stat that he and his fans should be proud of i franckly take it as disrespect when you scum come out and try to spread the blame in those years to the jays, it was the quarter back the man with the rock that thought he was michael jordan pg that wont pass, shooting like he was the man

    • @cgonz91
      @cgonz91 3 місяці тому

      @@nickgilday8946 we didnt bcuz of him in the bubble, the year after, in the finals and last year

    • @nickgilday8946
      @nickgilday8946 3 місяці тому

      @@cgonz91 Wasn't that simple in my opinion. We had several issues and Smart was sometimes one of them sometimes a huge reason we won too. JT and JB weren't ready either, JT was an absolute wreck in the finals v warriors. Ime offense was horrific in general that year as well. We couldn't close lacked composure and exploitable holes defensively too. Smart certainly stepped out of his role too often - a lot of those times though its cuz he saw that his star was fading in the moment and JB was playing too fast and out of control.
      Ultimately thats why I think the smart move was much more locker room thing than an on the court thing. But to each their own.
      JT had historicly bad shooting in playoffs he also had the most turnovers of all time in one of those runs.. you think he was the problem? It was much bigger than individual play.

    • @tylerriley2587
      @tylerriley2587 3 місяці тому

      @@cgonz91 Marcus is not coming back anytime soon we are good with what we have Jrue > Marcus

  • @landonlakes4782
    @landonlakes4782 3 місяці тому

    ☘️☘️☘️☘️

  • @SabLew-yh2or
    @SabLew-yh2or 3 місяці тому

    What a STUPID QUESTION LOL
    Tatum is a top 2 player in the NBA
    Brown is barely top 20

  • @SabLew-yh2or
    @SabLew-yh2or 3 місяці тому

    Tatum is the Celtics best player 90% of games
    Why does this 🤡 even have a show talking about basketball?