Can You Survive on a Plant Based Diet in the Wild?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 2 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 88

  • @captainjonna1034
    @captainjonna1034 3 місяці тому +1

    lol if your soley a vegan living in the woods you'll have to become a panda and spend 16 + hours a day eating bamboo just to get the energy to migrate 200 meters to next sawft of bamboo hahahahaha.

  • @naturewithandy7204
    @naturewithandy7204 Рік тому +4

    Correct me if I’m wrong but as far as I know. There’s not one non agrarian tribe living off the land even in tropical regions that does not rely on animal protein.

    • @sigma3survivalschool
      @sigma3survivalschool  Рік тому +2

      None that I’m aware of.

    • @JohnLocke1776
      @JohnLocke1776 3 місяці тому

      Haven't eaten meat/dairy in close to a decade, feel great 💪 🙏 plus, mRNA 💉 are now all in the meat, dairy products 😮

  • @BananaBabys
    @BananaBabys Рік тому +4

    I say no

  • @phillipschris2274
    @phillipschris2274 Рік тому +3

    Professional quality videos. Love all the knowledge. 👊

    • @sigma3survivalschool
      @sigma3survivalschool  Рік тому

      I’m about to start a new channel. Just built a huge basement video studio. Hope you are well. Glad to see your progress with your own school. Cheers 🍻

    • @phillipschris2274
      @phillipschris2274 Рік тому

      Can't wait to see what's next from you, know it will be good.

  • @Chasenoir
    @Chasenoir 4 місяці тому +1

    What about Taoism or Chinese Buddhist in the late 4th century? Or Jainism? Aren’t those some of the earliest vegetarians/vegans?

    • @malabikabhattacharyya3760
      @malabikabhattacharyya3760 4 місяці тому +1

      Agriculturalist

    • @JohnLocke1776
      @JohnLocke1776 3 місяці тому

      Daniel and the 2 Hebrews switched up to basically vegan when held as slaves to the Persians. Veganism has its roots in the Bible

  • @Mom0fTwins
    @Mom0fTwins Рік тому +2

    After studying (recreationally) paleoanthropology....I agree 100% with Rob.

    • @sigma3survivalschool
      @sigma3survivalschool  Рік тому +3

      its really irrefutable information. Vegans will dislike this video, but its just basic human history. And teaching survival puts me in touch with what is possible as far as food for all humans in a variety of environments.

  • @sachinraghavan4556
    @sachinraghavan4556 7 місяців тому

    The majority of people aren't in survival situations necessitating animal agriculture. If you physically can't live without animal consumption then it's fine to commit it, but we're morally obligated to live without it whenever we can.

  • @Wheeling88
    @Wheeling88 10 місяців тому +1

    Vegatarian is an old indian word, meaning piss poor hunter.

    • @sachinraghavan4556
      @sachinraghavan4556 2 місяці тому

      That's an old insult used by people without an argument to refute the moral motivations behind vegetarianism and veganism. Nobody should strive to be good at being violent. I'd prefer being terrible at inflicting pain and suffering on individuals when there's no survival necessity for it.

    • @Wheeling88
      @Wheeling88 2 місяці тому

      @@sachinraghavan4556 thats why youre at the bottom of the food chain.

  • @magasiva6963
    @magasiva6963 4 місяці тому

    So guessing humans are not meant to be vegans. Thanks Rob.

  • @109aushiksingh2
    @109aushiksingh2 4 місяці тому

    oops...sseedscontain fats....as they contain oils

  • @adityadipayuda813
    @adityadipayuda813 7 місяців тому

    Vegan need to learn from elf tribe maybe lmao 😂😂😂

  • @silverchairsg
    @silverchairsg 10 місяців тому +1

    Don't forget to eat the vegans to supplement your diet 😁.

  • @HamRadioPrep
    @HamRadioPrep 11 місяців тому

    Great video! We would love to collaborate with you on some ham radio information for your viewers. It is THE BEST comms options for a survival situation 📻A solid handheld radio is an essential piece of kit.

    • @sigma3survivalschool
      @sigma3survivalschool  10 місяців тому

      I'm game to do that, send me a message to sigma3survivalschool@gmail.com

  • @ROBERTBROOKES-if2si
    @ROBERTBROOKES-if2si Рік тому +4

    Its possible, if you have knowledge of identifying wild eatable plants.

    • @SherrickDuncan
      @SherrickDuncan Рік тому

      The Chimpanzee, Silverback Gorrilla, Orangutans beg to differ. They are almost entirely vegan 90 plus percent dietarily in most cases most of the time in the wild. And require much more protein and calories than us. And are much stronger than us with much more energy than us. They eat almost no meat. Mostly fruits, leafy greens, vegetables, roots, nuts, seeds etc.
      They get plenty vitamins and minerals. Short only vitamin b12 and they get that from eating a bit of their own poop.

    • @UsDiYoNa
      @UsDiYoNa Рік тому +6

      Lmao try that in northern or southern climates, or anywhere outside of tropical climate zones for that matter. Even in tropical climates, and even with *extensive* botanical knowledge, its not possible for an individual or even a small community to consistently forage enough plant matter with a broad enough range of nutrient profiles to meet their nutritional needs. This includes nuts, seeds, tubers, roots, and those hardy enough to survive freezing as well. But, I encourage every vegan out there to try.

    • @sigma3survivalschool
      @sigma3survivalschool  Рік тому +3

      You’re comparing apples and oranges. They have COMPLETELY DIFFERENT digestive systems. Just because they can eat it doesn’t mean we can.

    • @sigma3survivalschool
      @sigma3survivalschool  Рік тому +3

      I teach wild plants for a living and I’d doubt I’d make it a year or more on wild edibles. Without being extremely malnourished.

    • @SherrickDuncan
      @SherrickDuncan Рік тому

      @sigma3survivalschool human beings axiomatically verifiably scientifically have a much much closer digestive system to the great Apes than they do with a tiger or lion or wolf. That is a fact and objective reality behind question.
      We have the same maze like small and large intestines and weak stomach acid and chewing blending teeth with sharp canines as Apes. Not the straight digestive tract and super duper concentrated stomach acid and cut and swallow meat whole type teeth as carnivores. That is a fact.
      However both humans and Apes could more easily survived on cooked or even raw meat more easily in nature than plants. Of chewed throughly that would be the easiest (not best or healthiest) but easiest source of food for humans or Apes.
      But we unquestionably like Apes have a frugivore and herbivore digestive tract. Nothing at all like a carnivores digestive tract competitively.

  • @SDA001
    @SDA001 Рік тому

    Nope. Not long term in a survival situation, but possibly if one is able to be in the right area of the globe and plant a garden… Omnivore diet.

  • @Bob-67
    @Bob-67 Рік тому +1

    1st!!

  • @1000Commando
    @1000Commando Рік тому +5

    The answer is a big NO !!!

    • @JohnLocke1776
      @JohnLocke1776 3 місяці тому +1

      I haven't eaten meat in close to 10 years, I'm in excellent shape at 42 and stronger than all the you guys at work.

    • @Chaos_
      @Chaos_ 3 місяці тому +1

      @@JohnLocke1776 LOL

  • @JESUSSavesWAKEUP
    @JESUSSavesWAKEUP Рік тому +1

    Not with the high oxalate. In the garden of Eden, it was the WOE gave by God. Now to survive, we can eat anything to have the energy to serve others.

  • @johnboy331
    @johnboy331 Рік тому

    Please tell us where we can get that shirt!

  • @coydogoutdoors
    @coydogoutdoors Рік тому +1

    No way if you made it a full year just eating wild plants it would be a miracle if you dont want to hurt animals thats real sweet lol. but the human body needs meat theirs studies that show plants can communicate with each other which means their intelligent which also means they probably dont want to die so in short for a person to live something has to die.

  • @TheAmazingJimmy
    @TheAmazingJimmy Рік тому +1

    Protein is easy to get on a vegan diet in the wild. You seriously have no idea what you're talking about.

    • @sigma3survivalschool
      @sigma3survivalschool  Рік тому +1

      Oh really. From what plants. I’ve been teaching wild edibles for 15 years full time and run the longest lasting survival instructor programs in the country. Enlighten me as to all these plants that you can get tons of protein from.

    • @TheAmazingJimmy
      @TheAmazingJimmy Рік тому

      @@sigma3survivalschool beans, peas, greens, all plants contain protein.

    • @sigma3survivalschool
      @sigma3survivalschool  Рік тому +1

      Those are agricultural veggies not wild edibles. Those are genetically engineered foods over 1000’s of years of farming. Most peas in the wild are very toxic. And the bioavailability of those proteins even within veggies by volume are very low in comparison to meat. There is a reason a huge majority of vegans are skinny and have lower muscle mass.

    • @sigma3survivalschool
      @sigma3survivalschool  Рік тому +1

      That also doesn’t take into account that most higher protein plants don’t contain the full spectrum of amino acids in order to be healthy. You simply can’t get all your nutrients from wild plants. I’m not knocking veganism, just talking about the facts of living off the land. Which is what I teach full time.

    • @TheAmazingJimmy
      @TheAmazingJimmy Рік тому +2

      @@sigma3survivalschool All plants have protein, some of the strongest creatures on earth are vegans.