Other than Brett Favre, Peyton Manning had the longest Iron Man streak -- Favre - 297 Games Straight as starter Manning -- 208 Games as starter straight. People make the argument that Tom Brady is better than Peyton Tom Brady -- 5 for 8 in SB games --- Billecheck as Coach --- super genius Supreme Defenses behind him; Very solid Running game backing him up. HOF kicker and defenders Handicaps -- No HOF and very few Pro bowl receivers Peyton -- 2 for 4 in SB games -- average coaching except for Tony Dungey (only great coach he ever had) HOF receivers -- 2: Marvin Harrison and Reggie Wayne Running support -- 6 years or so of Edgerin James -- Pro bowler Handicaps --- 1. No consistent Coach or system 2. Crappy Defenses that were below average 3. No great Running game after James left 4. In Denver -- only 1 probowl receiver -- he made the other receivers there into pro bowlers When Tom Brady gets great pro-bowl receivers like Randy Moss, he can't win -- must have been more on the defense and kicker huh ? When Peyton Manning Loses great run support like Edgerin James -- SUPERBOWL!!! When he gets any kind of good defense at all like 2015 Denver --SUPERBOWL. Defense wins championships -- Denver learned that the hard way from Seattle. Then they taught that lesson to Cam Newton.
paysonfox88 other than farce, Eli had the longest iron man streak, and was benched for a game by Ben macatard. As a life long giants fan, Peyton has always been my favorite NFL player.
Eightys Baby87 Brady is a blessed man with consistency and excellence from his coaching. He’s a great player, no doubt. Peyton was the better quarterback however.
@@babyjay2932 that's a joke Tom Brady is way better and a lot more clutch in big games there is no comparison anymore they both played the same amount of games and seasons but Tom Brady has 3 times the wins in the superbowls and two times the superbowls twice as many playoff wins with less losses 1 4th the one and dones in the playoffs and he has 237 wins all together to p manning 200 in that same time frame that's 3 more seasons of wins and he has 80 plus less interceptions then p manning with almost the same amount of touchdowns and yards and he didnt play half his games in a dome when p manning plays outta the dome his yards and touchdowns go down quite a bit and post season and playoff combined he is way ahead of him with yards and touchdowns and still adding to this day
As a life long Indy resident and a top tier Colts fan I can say with absolute confidence that when Peyton went to Denver, the Broncos gained every single Colts fan to their roster. We loved every single win he pulled off .
I can remember going to Knoxville to the orange and white game during Payton’s senior year and getting his autograph he took the time to say something to everybody that came up to him he’s a hell of a athlete and a even better man!!!
_In the 54 years since the super bowl era began:_ *108 starting quarterbacks* *Some starting QBs appeared more than once* *Even fewer are those who have won more than 1 superbowl* *Only 3 have appeared with more than 1 team; Craig Morton, Kurt Warner, Peyton Manning* *_There is only 1 starting quarterback to ever win a superbowl with more than 1 team:_* Peyton Manning
B Rumph I agree. Not only did the offense perform on all cylinders, the defense was scoring more points than any other team too. They were so good they chose money over a ring
Peyton would have won 8 Super Bowls with Belichick as his coach, because Belichick would have built a team of great offense and great defense. Belichick is the greatest coach of all time; that is why Brady was so blessed.
Amen. I'm glad we got the W in SB50 but yeah, we should've had 2 more Lombardi's during those 4 awesome years. Prior to 2012 if someone would've told me I'd actually shed a few tears when Peyton retired in a few years I would've laughed in their face. GO BRONCOS!! SB50 CHAMPS!!
@@marycage5214 you are crazy if you think that p manning had way to many one and dones and he was not clutch in the postseason tom Brady would have been a all time great anywhere and Tom Brady didnt have 2 hall of fame receivers most his career and Tom made bill b and his defense hasn't really been that good for awhile now
Eventhough he didnt play for my team GB, he did play for my mom's and grandpa's team the Broncos and let me say I never enjoyed watching another team win games because of Peyton manning
Peyton Manning is the GOAT We're not talking about team accomplishments here we're talking about greatness I just can't stand people saying Tom Brady is better just because he has more rings Of course it's important to evaluate your team but Peyton evaluated the Colts more than Brady the Pats Greatness means how good they were individually and prime Peyton beats out prime Tom in every category He could throw the ball more accurate and longer than Tom Brady, he could read defenses better than Tom (even though that was what Brady could do best too), he had about the same pocket awareness as Brady I'd say and he was even a little bit more mobile. If someone comes and says that Brady has more passing yards and TDs then Peyton you're not looking at the facts. Brady played more seasons than Peyton of course he's going to have better career stats. If you take Mitch Trubisky's stats from the 3 years he played he's going to have more yards and TDs than Pat Mahomes in the 2 years he played in does that make him better? Of course not! The only thing you can take from that is that Brady was able to play longer. Manning holds the record for most yards and TDs in a season that is more important than the entire career if you're not looking at the length of the career Now if you're saying Tom Brady is better than Peyton because he's more clutch then stfu. When we're not counting the first three of Brady's SBs (because let's be real he was a game manager back there that was carried by an amazing defense) he's 3:3 in the SB. That's not that good. When we count everything after 2004 the two of them have a record of 7:6 overall for Brady but 3:1 for Manning in the playoffs against each other (who is so clutch now) If we're talking about leadership I think we can agree on a tie because both were great leaders Also I think Manning was more valuable to his teams than Brady to the Pats. Think about it! The Colts were terrible without Peyton Manning in 2011 they went 2:14 (the year before 10:6) that's a drop of of 0.4821428571 winning pct. The Pats went 11:5 missing Brady in 2009 (the year before 16:0) that's a drop of of 0.3125 so a lot less. If you want to factor in pro bowls and all pros fine: 14:14 pro bowls but 10:5 all pros for Manning Also Peyton had success with two diffrent teams and a lot of diffrent systems. I'm not saying Bray is a producr of the system but it helped him at least Another thing is that Peyton had probably the highest football iq ever. He picked defenses apart and called his own plays. While Brady was good in that regard he wasn't close to beeing on Peyton's level But maybe the biggest point is Manning won 5 MVPs with less to work with then Brady So looking at everything I just listed Peyton was better individually on the field, he had better stats, had success in diffent systems, was his own offensive cordinator, was more valuable to his team, is the record holder for MVPs and was just as clutch as Brady) that's pretty much all the should factor into greatness (if I forgot sth please let me know). So what could Brady possibly have done better then Peyton except for having a longer career and having more rings because he played on a better team (running back better, oline better, pass catchers about even, defense better except for a few years in which Mannings team could match, coaching way better)? But I also want to say thay Brady is a really great QB in his own right and everything I said was not meant to trash him. Also if someone says Drew Brees is better than I think I don't have to break it down because if you just look at the facts you see Peyton had a much better career (career stats only go to Brees cause he's played longer, MVP 5:0, 14:13 pro bowls (but they're a fan voting so nothing really meaningful) , 10:5 all pros, 2:1 SB, ...) I don't think any other QB has a shot at the GOAT title but if you think it's any other QB (I don't think we should compare diffrent positions because it's hard to tell who's more dominant if you can't directly compare the two players) let me know and if you want to argue anything I said go ahead I'm all yours☺
Irsay cut him because he ain't want to pay the bonus 3:30.....so nothing Irsay said at the press conference meant anything to me.... Im glad the Sheriff got another ring... Irsay can go to.....
I disagree. Indy is a basketball and car racing town and how many nba champ pacers have? Dont bother look it up i'll answer for you ZERO even indiana university that they extremely proud of hasn't win ncaa in a century. While for nascar and indycar yeah indy 500 is the biggest race but the winners does not represent indy so i would say indy WAS NOT on the sport map before peyton come. And of course he bring super bowl for indy
Brady couldn't beat the Giants to save his life, but Peyton always annihilated his little brother's team. Peyton also would finish 3-1 against Brady in AFC Championship games. If the Colts defenses could get off the field, the line could have blocked, and the coaches didn't make stupid decisions, Peyton would have gotten 8 rings.
After they got squashed by the Seahawks, Manning and the Broncos came out the following season and looked even better. In fact, Peyton was on track to have another record season, but his body betrayed him halfway through. It was sad to see.
That tackle by the Redskins that ruined his neck looked intentional. Definitely a bounty as there's no reason to double up on a guy and bend him in half like that. He could probably still be playing if it weren't for that.
I never ever thought that a day would come when I would be screaming at my TV for freeney to hit peyton so hard he knocked him out of the game but I did and he didn't knock him out of the game but he sacked 18 and it was one of the most bitter sweet experiences of my life and I'll always be a peyton manning fan but I'll always be a colts fan first and for most
No Brady is a system QB you see how the argument will always go. That's what happens when a QB wins in one system his entire career while the other wins with multiple systems
Other than Brett Favre, Peyton Manning had the longest Iron Man streak --
Favre - 297 Games Straight as starter
Manning -- 208 Games as starter straight.
People make the argument that Tom Brady is better than Peyton
Tom Brady -- 5 for 8 in SB games --- Billecheck as Coach --- super genius
Supreme Defenses behind him; Very solid Running game backing him up. HOF kicker and defenders
Handicaps -- No HOF and very few Pro bowl receivers
Peyton -- 2 for 4 in SB games -- average coaching except for Tony Dungey (only great coach he ever had)
HOF receivers -- 2: Marvin Harrison and Reggie Wayne
Running support -- 6 years or so of Edgerin James -- Pro bowler
Handicaps --- 1. No consistent Coach or system 2. Crappy Defenses that were below average
3. No great Running game after James left 4. In Denver -- only 1 probowl receiver -- he made the
other receivers there into pro bowlers
When Tom Brady gets great pro-bowl receivers like Randy Moss, he can't win -- must have been more on the defense and kicker huh ?
When Peyton Manning Loses great run support like Edgerin James -- SUPERBOWL!!! When he gets any kind of good defense at all like 2015 Denver --SUPERBOWL. Defense wins championships -- Denver learned that the hard way from Seattle. Then they taught that lesson to Cam Newton.
paysonfox88 other than farce, Eli had the longest iron man streak, and was benched for a game by Ben macatard. As a life long giants fan, Peyton has always been my favorite NFL player.
don't forget Jim Marshall
Tom Brady is better
Eightys Baby87 Brady is a blessed man with consistency and excellence from his coaching. He’s a great player, no doubt. Peyton was the better quarterback however.
@@babyjay2932 that's a joke Tom Brady is way better and a lot more clutch in big games there is no comparison anymore they both played the same amount of games and seasons but Tom Brady has 3 times the wins in the superbowls and two times the superbowls twice as many playoff wins with less losses 1 4th the one and dones in the playoffs and he has 237 wins all together to p manning 200 in that same time frame that's 3 more seasons of wins and he has 80 plus less interceptions then p manning with almost the same amount of touchdowns and yards and he didnt play half his games in a dome when p manning plays outta the dome his yards and touchdowns go down quite a bit and post season and playoff combined he is way ahead of him with yards and touchdowns and still adding to this day
The Kevin joke will never get old 😂🤣
17:21 Peyton is just first class. The type of human being you champion for at what ever he does.😎
Greatest Of All Time (The GOAT)!!! The best coach on the field and highest football IQ of all time!!!
Jonathon Bevers FACTS
Jonathon Bevers 😂 ok
In the regular season peyton was damn near unstoppable. Playoffs where it matters most he was average if that.
Watching this helps cope with our current situation.
As a life long Indy resident and a top tier Colts fan I can say with absolute confidence that when Peyton went to Denver, the Broncos gained every single Colts fan to their roster. We loved every single win he pulled off .
I can remember going to Knoxville to the orange and white game during Payton’s senior year and getting his autograph he took the time to say something to everybody that came up to him he’s a hell of a athlete and a even better man!!!
Peyton Manning is the greatest offensive coordinator to ever play QB!
_In the 54 years since the super bowl era began:_
*108 starting quarterbacks*
*Some starting QBs appeared more than once*
*Even fewer are those who have won more than 1 superbowl*
*Only 3 have appeared with more than 1 team; Craig Morton, Kurt Warner, Peyton Manning*
*_There is only 1 starting quarterback to ever win a superbowl with more than 1 team:_*
Peyton Manning
Against the Seahawks it seemed like Peyton was the only one that didn’t know they were throwing the game. Lol
B Rumph I agree. Not only did the offense perform on all cylinders, the defense was scoring more points than any other team too. They were so good they chose money over a ring
Started with his parents, Archie and Olivia, heavenly father has blessed Manning family
GOAT. No question
Wish we had that record breaking offense and legendary defense at the same time, they could of had 2 or 3 super bowls.
Andy S Peyton played 4 years. I think Denver would’ve won the Super Bowl 4 tines if they had that offense and defense at the same time
Peyton would have won 8 Super Bowls with Belichick as his coach, because Belichick would have built a team of great offense and great defense. Belichick is the greatest coach of all time; that is why Brady was so blessed.
Not dissing Brady. He is great, too.
Amen. I'm glad we got the W in SB50 but yeah, we should've had 2 more Lombardi's during those 4 awesome years. Prior to 2012 if someone would've told me I'd actually shed a few tears when Peyton retired in a few years I would've laughed in their face. GO BRONCOS!! SB50 CHAMPS!!
@@marycage5214 you are crazy if you think that p manning had way to many one and dones and he was not clutch in the postseason tom Brady would have been a all time great anywhere and Tom Brady didnt have 2 hall of fame receivers most his career and Tom made bill b and his defense hasn't really been that good for awhile now
The look on Kevin Durant face was priceless!!!😂🤣
Dont forget the only qb with two sb rings with different teams.
that’s a very good point sir
Tom Brady begs to differ
@@caramelsunshine3003 two years too late.
@@AlittleIron Still playing
@@caramelsunshine3003 no shit, I'm saying you're too late to tell him that.
Manning the 🐐
Payton is the goat. Now and forever
I think numbers wise Brady is The GOAT. BUT...I love Peyton and can't stand Brady.
A great man pure class.
Love this video. Peyton crack on Kevin Durant was spot on lol..
PAYTON MANNING WILL ALWAYS IN MY MEMORY UNTILL THE DAY I DIE I SWEAR. ♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡♡
Serge Baron juicing m
Gg
Love to see him roasting Kevin Durant....or anyone really. He is legitimately a funny guy
Classy gentleman
“Let’s get a little organization” @ fans taking pics 😂😂😂
17:40 LOL think fast, kid - CATCH
Class act second to none, in my opinion of course. LUV YA PEYTON!😇🙏👍
Eventhough he didnt play for my team GB, he did play for my mom's and grandpa's team the Broncos and let me say I never enjoyed watching another team win games because of Peyton manning
You can see his forehead over the crowd 😂😂😂
truly an american hero. which quarterback should i highlight next?
Dub Highlights Tom Brady
Drew Brees
Yes, Drew Brees please.
Tom Brady
Drew brees
Peyton Manning gonna be a great coach if he decides to coach in the NFL
Ricky Lam hopefully the cowboys because jason garrett is trash
Peyton Manning is the GOAT
We're not talking about team accomplishments here we're talking about greatness
I just can't stand people saying Tom Brady is better just because he has more rings
Of course it's important to evaluate your team but Peyton evaluated the Colts more than Brady the Pats
Greatness means how good they were individually and prime Peyton beats out prime Tom in every category
He could throw the ball more accurate and longer than Tom Brady, he could read defenses better than Tom (even though that was what Brady could do best too), he had about the same pocket awareness as Brady I'd say and he was even a little bit more mobile.
If someone comes and says that Brady has more passing yards and TDs then Peyton you're not looking at the facts. Brady played more seasons than Peyton of course he's going to have better career stats. If you take Mitch Trubisky's stats from the 3 years he played he's going to have more yards and TDs than Pat Mahomes in the 2 years he played in does that make him better? Of course not! The only thing you can take from that is that Brady was able to play longer. Manning holds the record for most yards and TDs in a season that is more important than the entire career if you're not looking at the length of the career
Now if you're saying Tom Brady is better than Peyton because he's more clutch then stfu. When we're not counting the first three of Brady's SBs (because let's be real he was a game manager back there that was carried by an amazing defense) he's 3:3 in the SB. That's not that good. When we count everything after 2004 the two of them have a record of 7:6 overall for Brady but 3:1 for Manning in the playoffs against each other (who is so clutch now)
If we're talking about leadership I think we can agree on a tie because both were great leaders
Also I think Manning was more valuable to his teams than Brady to the Pats. Think about it! The Colts were terrible without Peyton Manning in 2011 they went 2:14 (the year before 10:6) that's a drop of of 0.4821428571 winning pct. The Pats went 11:5 missing Brady in 2009 (the year before 16:0) that's a drop of of 0.3125 so a lot less.
If you want to factor in pro bowls and all pros fine: 14:14 pro bowls but 10:5 all pros for Manning
Also Peyton had success with two diffrent teams and a lot of diffrent systems. I'm not saying Bray is a producr of the system but it helped him at least
Another thing is that Peyton had probably the highest football iq ever. He picked defenses apart and called his own plays. While Brady was good in that regard he wasn't close to beeing on Peyton's level
But maybe the biggest point is Manning won 5 MVPs with less to work with then Brady
So looking at everything I just listed Peyton was better individually on the field, he had better stats, had success in diffent systems, was his own offensive cordinator, was more valuable to his team, is the record holder for MVPs and was just as clutch as Brady) that's pretty much all the should factor into greatness (if I forgot sth please let me know). So what could Brady possibly have done better then Peyton except for having a longer career and having more rings because he played on a better team (running back better, oline better, pass catchers about even, defense better except for a few years in which Mannings team could match, coaching way better)?
But I also want to say thay Brady is a really great QB in his own right and everything I said was not meant to trash him.
Also if someone says Drew Brees is better than I think I don't have to break it down because if you just look at the facts you see Peyton had a much better career (career stats only go to Brees cause he's played longer, MVP 5:0, 14:13 pro bowls (but they're a fan voting so nothing really meaningful) , 10:5 all pros, 2:1 SB, ...)
I don't think any other QB has a shot at the GOAT title but if you think it's any other QB (I don't think we should compare diffrent positions because it's hard to tell who's more dominant if you can't directly compare the two players) let me know and if you want to argue anything I said go ahead I'm all yours☺
We was hoping Manning would've came back to Indianapolis to be the OC or the HC. But he has went a different route and is doing good.
Irsay cut him because he ain't want to pay the bonus 3:30.....so nothing Irsay said at the press conference meant anything to me.... Im glad the Sheriff got another ring... Irsay can go to.....
Tar heels 215 i also found it funny that said that BS
I think Indianapolis "Was on the sports map" long before Peyton Manning came along, Indy 500 is the greatest spectacle in racing.
I disagree. Indy is a basketball and car racing town and how many nba champ pacers have? Dont bother look it up i'll answer for you ZERO even indiana university that they extremely proud of hasn't win ncaa in a century. While for nascar and indycar yeah indy 500 is the biggest race but the winners does not represent indy so i would say indy WAS NOT on the sport map before peyton come. And of course he bring super bowl for indy
Peyton def put indy on the sports map. No doubt about it. And Ozamataz Buckshank easy on the hoosiers, its only been 32 years, not a century🤣
Bo Nix ❤
That look from Eli was damn he was up on Peyton and now he’s not.
Johnny Unitas
8:52 Did you play basketball!? Yeah🤨. You must not have started 🤔........🤣
He put some fear in Belichick, if that’s all I knew I would be impressed.
Payton would win the presidency No Problem if he were to run.! Excluding the state of Massachusetts.! Lol!!
Jamarcus Russell
Payton is better than Tom Brady by far
My mom has a petyon manning jersey
Can tall imagine if peyton would have went with the cardinals peyton and Larry on the same team wow that would have been a duo
The tom hanks of football
Brady couldn't beat the Giants to save his life, but Peyton always annihilated his little brother's team. Peyton also would finish 3-1 against Brady in AFC Championship games. If the Colts defenses could get off the field, the line could have blocked, and the coaches didn't make stupid decisions, Peyton would have gotten 8 rings.
After they got squashed by the Seahawks, Manning and the Broncos came out the following season and looked even better. In fact, Peyton was on track to have another record season, but his body betrayed him halfway through. It was sad to see.
Goddamnitt payton , let little brother win one :( lmfao
man KD didnt like that comment one bit lol
Do Brees Montana or Farve
In retrospect they should have kept Peyton over Luck
this video is incomplete without a montage of the growth of foreheads frontal lobe.
Doesn’t show one Super Bowl L highlight... OP must be salty that Peyton went to Denver hahahahahaha
That tackle by the Redskins that ruined his neck looked intentional. Definitely a bounty as there's no reason to double up on a guy and bend him in half like that. He could probably still be playing if it weren't for that.
At least he didn't cheat like Tommy Boy
Ruined Mannings legacy by having Skip Bayliss in the Doc
This thing was all cut up and jumped all over the place. It was like it was produced by a platypus. Unwatchable.
Aaron Rodgers
I never ever thought that a day would come when I would be screaming at my TV for freeney to hit peyton so hard he knocked him out of the game but I did and he didn't knock him out of the game but he sacked 18 and it was one of the most bitter sweet experiences of my life and I'll always be a peyton manning fan but I'll always be a colts fan first and for most
I like Manning better than Brady but Brady is the G.O.A.T!
Based on what?
No Brady is a system QB you see how the argument will always go. That's what happens when a QB wins in one system his entire career while the other wins with multiple systems
And he took HGH too
That's false. You might want to do some research before inserting your foot into your mouth.
Who gives a shit if he did. Most people in the league do take some kind of ped especially to heal up injuries
Karo French He might have taken a multivitamin as well. Both were not banned by the league at the time.