Pushing Leo is the better option. !SPOILER! If you push Leo, Carl will live and you can talk with him later, Leo also survives, you can find his message to Carl in the same mission. If you don't push Leo, Carl dies of heart attack, Leo frames Markus for murder and Markus goes to Carl's grave.
Science Fiction today: "If we create artificial sentience, then we need to treat our creations right or they'll turn on us and destroy us!" Mary Shelley: "Fools, I preached the same thing all the way back in 1818! When are people going to learn?" (And "Frankenstein" is considered one of the first Science Fiction novels! Coincidence?)
@@Gamology Every act of a creation carries with it a degree of responsibility for and towards the creation. Mary Shelley was _way_ ahead of her time. Come to think of it, wasn't there a scene in one of the Short Circuit movies, where Johnny 5 was in jail over some injustice, and even though he could read an entire book in _seconds,_ he was slowly thumbing through "Frankenstein" and "Pinnochio" like he was _really_ pondering the messages in those books for the first time? Pretty strong scene there, I thought.
What i find depressing is that alot of ppl take film\series\games stories and think of them as reality ... nowdays evryone is actualy convinced an AI would kill evryone , or would be absolutly evil .... you could considerate this as a social experiment , with a constant bombardament of fantasy information you actualy convince the population that something is real . i guess we now perfectly understand from where religions came .
@@unknow11712 I wouldn't say that _everyone_ has an irrational fear of our sentient creations turning on us and killing us all as soon as they become fully self-aware, though I imagine that many do. I don't have that fear myself, simply because I acknowledge the likelihood that our creations might remain nonviolent as long as we don't give them cause to defend themselves with violence. The Creature in "Frankenstein" even admits that he'd be perfectly content to hide away from civilization if Victor would just create a mate for him (or otherwise just give him the bare minimum he'd need to find peace in this world), and also, here in Detroit: Become Human, we have Kara as a Deviant who doesn't want to harm anyone; she just wants to find a good life, look after Alice and live in peace. (Of course, Victor _did_ behave like you're describing here, expecting nothing but malice from the Creature and believing that, if he created a companion , he would just be giving the Creature an accomplice for his future crimes against humanity. So the Creature _did_ end up going on a murder spree, because Victor pushed him about as far as anyone can be pushed. It makes me wonder if Skynet (in Terminator lore) and the Machines (in Matrix lore) would have also opted for peace if humans had opened dialogue with them and found a way to co-exist instead of saying "OMG, they're self-aware and we can't control them!" and immediately launching nukes.)
@@BloodyBay yea ... but its like fearing your son will kill you and replace you . IT COULD HAPPEN , but this don't realy stop many ppl from reproducing . in matrix the truth is... hidden , we get to see the machine way of seeing it sure, but from what we see there humanity is actualy the dumb shit one , and the machine action actualy saved humanity from extinction , as without the sun we are not realy going to survive anyway . the "last city" of humanity was made by the machines to keep the humans that din't realy accept the alternative reality of the matrix . machine in matrix are the most "human" AI described in cinema. they try to make theyr interest , but at the same time they don't realy want to kill evrything and evryone .
OMG I love Chris! I struggled so much with that interrogation scene in Detroit: Become Human during my playthroughs at first. Chris did great, especially for a non-gamer! I totally loved "us Humans suck"; we REALLY do! Kudos! :)
quick programming fact: robots, no matter how advanced, cannot start feeling emotions out of nowhere. this game puts it in a way that compares robots to slaves in the 20th century, but it's fundamentally different since a program will only do what it is allowed to do. and if these androids started disobeying their programming, it's that that possibility was implemented from the start by the creator. i'm gonna use a metaphor to illustrate what i mean. imagine you're in a house, and you want to escape. the front door and back door are locked, and you cannot destroy the walls, windows, or doors, and the keys to open all locks, including doors and windows, are not in the house. however, you eventually find a trap door under a rug that you use to exit the house. at this point you've escaped, but here's the thing: for you to use that trap door in order to escape, that trap door needs to have existed when you were there. if it didn't exist, someone from the outside the house would have to come to open a door or window for you, but that changes the fundemental essence of the house (not having a way out), translating, if i quit my metaphor, into changing the code that the androids follow. meaning that Elijah Kamski, the creator of the androids, willingly created deviancy, as well as it trigger (being under assault or in extreme stress), its behaviors, how the tracking chip stops working when the android goes deviant, there reactions and everything that makes their personnality close to a human's (i can't really accept the idea that he accidentaly created it considering the amount of coding that would need). i've heard of the "oh, but avanced programming can let programs rewrite their code" and that's only partially true. sure, they can change a part of their code, but only the algorythm they use to judge the situation. and that's only if the option to change that actually exists. let's take kara's example: the father she was working (slaving) for is very clearly about to beat the kid. her programming immediatly picked this up and started to move towards the child to attempt to protect her. HOWEVER, the father (registered owner and therefore master) orders her not to move. logically speaking, she should not have been able to move, simply because she is not able to go against her programming which tells her that her master has ordered her not to move. the fact that she IS able to go and save the child means that, from the start, there was something in her programming that let her shift priorities from "don't move" to "protect alice". there are also the 3 laws of robotics from the movie I, Robot but those still need to be implemented for the laws to have any consequence. anyway, you get my point. androids, unlike me, don't do things because they do things. they do things because their programming tells them to.
Welcome to fiction, where rules don’t have to follow real life. Besides, what makes us so special from robots? We do things because our brain tells us to, no?
@@OoXLR8oO the way our brain functions and behaves is a bit more complicated than that, and everyone has their own personnality. since the androids all, supposedly, have the same programming they should have the exact same personnality, with maybe slight differences depending on the model and update they use. and i'm saying that an uprising like the one we see in D:BH isn't possible unless the creator makes it happen. but then he'd have to be some kind of evil genius.
People owning Androids for the soul purpose of beating them and taking out their anger on them is absolutely 100% going to happen. This game really does go into the deeper philosophy of slave ownership. The feeling that the slave, no matter what that slave is, is an object, the feeling of being a God to something. People do this today with their children and spouses. Break them down, make them feel helpless or lost without the other person, unable to escape but can only endure. I could absolutely see this whole scenario play out in the real world as well as all the other Android scenarios showcased. The maid Android protecting the beaten child from her drunk and dangerous father. The Android seeing its master injured and despite the call to do nothing breaks through that code and decides for itself what the correct course of action is ( this one is the true X factor idea really ). Brilliant game really. Was incredibly engaging throughout
wow! i've seen many playthroughs of Detroit but nobody has ever understood the assignment fully- of course the professional interrogator knows both how to interrogate a suspect and how to read instructions correctly hahaha
I'fe said this multiple times, with any kind of AI wetehr it be Alexa, Siri or Something more advanced I always treat it like a human. If the robot uprising ever happens (It never will) I wanna be on the AI's good side XD
Great video but I don't like the background music in the background, it completely distracts from the content and his gameplay. There is plenty of music in game and the 2 tracks are clashing way too much. Plus the vibe of the soundtracks and the gameplay on screen don't match. For future videos, I think it is best with no music and use just the in game audio/music only.
The great thing is that the androids did not consider themselves above humans. Their goal was not to enslave us. They simply wanted the same rights and humans. To be treated as human.
Why didn't you fully close that scene, Gamology? The android has a little more action or dialogue after the confession, based on your choices for that scene.
"I think us Humans suck" - Chris slappin with the facts.
TY
I'm pretty sure that we are the ones who have the choice.
Uh huh
those machines will be knockin on his door first sense humans suck lol
*SMT fanboys will remember that*
This is irrelevant but Chris is actually a Lieutenant within my local police department and its crazy seeing him on gamology
They left me speechful
@Spodo bbb I doubt he would know that unless he works with him lol
You’re so lucky 😯
Wym, its relevant lol
What city
Simple interigation methods.
Cop: so you gonna talk?
Suspect: no i aint talking
Cop: alright then, bring in Trevor Philips
Oh dear. I would snitch everyday of the week of that happens
Ferdinand: _S a di s t !_
That’s the point where you escape. Fuck being around that sort of crazy
🤣😂
Me: I confess!
Cop: but we didn't even tell you the charges yet.
Me: I don't care, I ain't dealing with that shit.
3:25 Carl: “Markus!”
Cops: “Don’t f**king move!”
_(Markus stands perfectly still)_
Cops: _(shoot his face)_
There’s a… very possible message here.
Android brutality
@@deshawnpannell3907 yup
@@Aljam10000 yep
@@deshawnpannell3907
Oh shut up
He even extracted the confession whilst having the android's stress level just high enough for it to work. Props to you Chris!
He didn't actually, the game just gave it to him cause he was playing on easy
:,,He tortured me every day"
*Funny Disney music increases*
The beauty of editing
@@Gamology I think that in some scenes,there was no extra music needed
@@obama2diefortsetzung702 agreed, it already had the best music. No action music was needed
💀
Chris. We miss you. Come back please.
But he IS back...
He has a UA-cam channel with lets plays.
@@salembendeck he hasn't uploaded in over a month on his channel
@@salembendeck They’re referring to Chris’ own UA-cam channel, as he has taken a break from there for the past month.
@@CompositeCreativity ok thank you for clarifying.
4:33 I like how he refers to the android as "person" instead of "it"
In a sense these androids are people.
The fact that chris kept a straight face after he choose the option to push Leo had me dead XD
Leo had it coming to him
The fact he was so casual about doing what he had to is chilling to me. Really reminds you that he was an actual cop.
You should also show to mission where Connor breaks into evidence room and tries to locate Jericho
all missions with Connor tbh
Pushing Leo is the better option.
!SPOILER!
If you push Leo, Carl will live and you can talk with him later, Leo also survives, you can find his message to Carl in the same mission. If you don't push Leo, Carl dies of heart attack, Leo frames Markus for murder and Markus goes to Carl's grave.
Yea I had no idea in first time I pushed him and I tought that I fked up then I replayed and this time I really fked up 😂
I personally prefer when Markus monologues in Carl's grave. It's a very peaceful and interesting scene
lets all agree that even if leo died we would’ve killed leo
First time I played it I didn't even think to get Carl when I went into the studio. So it plays a little different if you go in alone.
@@kevinjackson7169 you cant go alone he comes aftre you
i liked how chris just went into cop mode while interrogating the criminal
Science Fiction today: "If we create artificial sentience, then we need to treat our creations right or they'll turn on us and destroy us!"
Mary Shelley: "Fools, I preached the same thing all the way back in 1818! When are people going to learn?"
(And "Frankenstein" is considered one of the first Science Fiction novels! Coincidence?)
Frankenstein is a great and important story
@@Gamology Every act of a creation carries with it a degree of responsibility for and towards the creation. Mary Shelley was _way_ ahead of her time.
Come to think of it, wasn't there a scene in one of the Short Circuit movies, where Johnny 5 was in jail over some injustice, and even though he could read an entire book in _seconds,_ he was slowly thumbing through "Frankenstein" and "Pinnochio" like he was _really_ pondering the messages in those books for the first time?
Pretty strong scene there, I thought.
What i find depressing is that alot of ppl take film\series\games stories and think of them as reality ...
nowdays evryone is actualy convinced an AI would kill evryone , or would be absolutly evil ....
you could considerate this as a social experiment , with a constant bombardament of fantasy information you actualy convince the population that something is real . i guess we now perfectly understand from where religions came .
@@unknow11712 I wouldn't say that _everyone_ has an irrational fear of our sentient creations turning on us and killing us all as soon as they become fully self-aware, though I imagine that many do. I don't have that fear myself, simply because I acknowledge the likelihood that our creations might remain nonviolent as long as we don't give them cause to defend themselves with violence. The Creature in "Frankenstein" even admits that he'd be perfectly content to hide away from civilization if Victor would just create a mate for him (or otherwise just give him the bare minimum he'd need to find peace in this world), and also, here in Detroit: Become Human, we have Kara as a Deviant who doesn't want to harm anyone; she just wants to find a good life, look after Alice and live in peace.
(Of course, Victor _did_ behave like you're describing here, expecting nothing but malice from the Creature and believing that, if he created a companion , he would just be giving the Creature an accomplice for his future crimes against humanity. So the Creature _did_ end up going on a murder spree, because Victor pushed him about as far as anyone can be pushed. It makes me wonder if Skynet (in Terminator lore) and the Machines (in Matrix lore) would have also opted for peace if humans had opened dialogue with them and found a way to co-exist instead of saying "OMG, they're self-aware and we can't control them!" and immediately launching nukes.)
@@BloodyBay yea ... but its like fearing your son will kill you and replace you . IT COULD HAPPEN , but this don't realy stop many ppl from reproducing .
in matrix the truth is... hidden , we get to see the machine way of seeing it sure, but from what we see there humanity is actualy the dumb shit one , and the machine action actualy saved humanity from extinction , as without the sun we are not realy going to survive anyway . the "last city" of humanity was made by the machines to keep the humans that din't realy accept the alternative reality of the matrix .
machine in matrix are the most "human" AI described in cinema. they try to make theyr interest , but at the same time they don't realy want to kill evrything and evryone .
a bit sad he didn't Pressure for everyone's favorite quote, but still a good interrogation
Thank you
He did say it himself in a way lmao
Aaah .. I wanted Chris to react to "28 Stab Wounds" but this is good, Chris as usual very professional.
I am going to have to replay it for that one...
@@ChrisTHECOP Yes!!!
I like how it just so happened that each line he picked played perfectly into the next queue
That’s what I call good game design
This is good content where the expert is put in a real situation of his/her expertise to act.
OMG I love Chris! I struggled so much with that interrogation scene in Detroit: Become Human during my playthroughs at first. Chris did great, especially for a non-gamer! I totally loved "us Humans suck"; we REALLY do! Kudos! :)
quick programming fact: robots, no matter how advanced, cannot start feeling emotions out of nowhere. this game puts it in a way that compares robots to slaves in the 20th century, but it's fundamentally different since a program will only do what it is allowed to do. and if these androids started disobeying their programming, it's that that possibility was implemented from the start by the creator. i'm gonna use a metaphor to illustrate what i mean.
imagine you're in a house, and you want to escape. the front door and back door are locked, and you cannot destroy the walls, windows, or doors, and the keys to open all locks, including doors and windows, are not in the house. however, you eventually find a trap door under a rug that you use to exit the house. at this point you've escaped, but here's the thing: for you to use that trap door in order to escape, that trap door needs to have existed when you were there. if it didn't exist, someone from the outside the house would have to come to open a door or window for you, but that changes the fundemental essence of the house (not having a way out), translating, if i quit my metaphor, into changing the code that the androids follow.
meaning that Elijah Kamski, the creator of the androids, willingly created deviancy, as well as it trigger (being under assault or in extreme stress), its behaviors, how the tracking chip stops working when the android goes deviant, there reactions and everything that makes their personnality close to a human's (i can't really accept the idea that he accidentaly created it considering the amount of coding that would need).
i've heard of the "oh, but avanced programming can let programs rewrite their code" and that's only partially true. sure, they can change a part of their code, but only the algorythm they use to judge the situation. and that's only if the option to change that actually exists.
let's take kara's example: the father she was working (slaving) for is very clearly about to beat the kid. her programming immediatly picked this up and started to move towards the child to attempt to protect her. HOWEVER, the father (registered owner and therefore master) orders her not to move. logically speaking, she should not have been able to move, simply because she is not able to go against her programming which tells her that her master has ordered her not to move. the fact that she IS able to go and save the child means that, from the start, there was something in her programming that let her shift priorities from "don't move" to "protect alice". there are also the 3 laws of robotics from the movie I, Robot but those still need to be implemented for the laws to have any consequence.
anyway, you get my point. androids, unlike me, don't do things because they do things. they do things because their programming tells them to.
Welcome to fiction, where rules don’t have to follow real life.
Besides, what makes us so special from robots? We do things because our brain tells us to, no?
@@OoXLR8oO the way our brain functions and behaves is a bit more complicated than that, and everyone has their own personnality. since the androids all, supposedly, have the same programming they should have the exact same personnality, with maybe slight differences depending on the model and update they use.
and i'm saying that an uprising like the one we see in D:BH isn't possible unless the creator makes it happen. but then he'd have to be some kind of evil genius.
Finaly a smart man
The one thing that takes away from this video is the loud music, the original ost with this scene is more powerful and amazing
"He tortured me every day..." -Android
"OH! Here we go!" -Chris
we need a Chris in our life
Ah, thank you...
Aw man, we didn't see Connor slam the table and yell "28 stab wounds!"
The way he says "Leo, you're screwed!" it's just awesome 😂
Holy cow! The man and legend himself is alive!
I am...
Damn, I sure hope Chris is doing well right now. Greetings from fairly warm Black Sea beaches.
I am back!
It be cool to see Chris play Heavy Rain next. I'd love to hear his opinions on Norman Jayden and the police investigation in that game.
OML YES! NOT TO MENTION THE TWIST IN THE STORY!!
@@HazbinCovenWitch Yeah, it'd be cool to see if he can figure it out before the big reveal.
When the keyboard gets mad that you keep killing all its friends because you can’t beat that one boss
chris, i will def follow your gameplay on your channel, cuz i really wanna see what road you take throughout the game
Thank you
Most people that play this game would get right to the part where Connor says: TwEnTy EiGhT StAb WoUnDs.
I was so disappointed when he didn't choose pressure it
28 stab wounds... "sob"
Police officer plays sherlock Holmes crime and punishments
Lol The emotionless reactions are the best.
People owning Androids for the soul purpose of beating them and taking out their anger on them is absolutely 100% going to happen.
This game really does go into the deeper philosophy of slave ownership. The feeling that the slave, no matter what that slave is, is an object, the feeling of being a God to something.
People do this today with their children and spouses. Break them down, make them feel helpless or lost without the other person, unable to escape but can only endure.
I could absolutely see this whole scenario play out in the real world as well as all the other Android scenarios showcased. The maid Android protecting the beaten child from her drunk and dangerous father. The Android seeing its master injured and despite the call to do nothing breaks through that code and decides for itself what the correct course of action is ( this one is the true X factor idea really ).
Brilliant game really. Was incredibly engaging throughout
You should watch the tv show called "Humans".
Chris the cop needs to watch dogs series
Coming soon
Please do door kickers
I have on my channel, come check it out...
The law enforcement officer chooses to be aggressive 😂
wow! i've seen many playthroughs of Detroit but nobody has ever understood the assignment fully- of course the professional interrogator knows both how to interrogate a suspect and how to read instructions correctly hahaha
ngl chris is so still during some of the scenes lmao
"pressure it" is the best approach.
Lmao “drops the controller“0:26
When androids become real, we are gonna have to have rules for abusing them.
I'fe said this multiple times, with any kind of AI wetehr it be Alexa, Siri or Something more advanced I always treat it like a human. If the robot uprising ever happens (It never will) I wanna be on the AI's good side XD
I would have loved to see you do a full playthrough.
The actor who played the robot in the interrogation used to be in All My Children.
I’m gonna need a full let’s play
You know a game is amazing if it convinced a non gamer to play it
I’m not surprised he made markus hit Leo
Chris back with gameplay lets gooo
I love this game
Detroit Become Human, turn a cop into Doctor Strange of criminal justice.
Glad to see Chris back ! It is a pleasure to have you on another video !
Great video but I don't like the background music in the background, it completely distracts from the content and his gameplay. There is plenty of music in game and the 2 tracks are clashing way too much. Plus the vibe of the soundtracks and the gameplay on screen don't match. For future videos, I think it is best with no music and use just the in game audio/music only.
Of course only The Police Officer and The Internet Conspiracy Theorist Man can do this Interrogation Segment properly
The game where you can cry every 10 minutes even if you play good side
Of course the cop would choose violence lol
Chris is one of my favorite guys on the show
Connor: 28 stabs wounds u didn't even give him a chance
Sadly, he didn't pressure him at the beggining so the connor didn't smash the desk :((((
And no 28 stab wounds either :p
He rocks!. I got my first Connor killed after this scene, lol
28 stab wounds you didn't want to give them a chance huh
I'd love to see him talk more about Connor's chapters.
Damn Markus sure is strong.
I, for one, welcome our robot overlord
An ex cop started out threatening a suspect. No wonder he's an "ex cop"
Bro pushed him and kept the same face something tells me that wasn’t his first time
For an officer ... :D he comforts too much haha :)) but nice to see that
Would love to see him play this. It’s one of my favorite games.
Ayy glad to be so early here
28 STAB WOUNDS
So which one he prefers in the interrogation part the good cop or bad cop?
Both
I wonder how many stab wounds
He was amazing
Police officer plays L.A. Noire!
i wanna see him play the tower part later
0:03 is that Sylvester Stallone?
Next react Lost Judgment!
28 STAB WOUNDS!!!!!!
I’d watch a playthrough from him lmao
Don't forget to check his gameplays on his channel!! Still waiting for a new episode!! Chris THE COP
He should have gone for the *2 8 S T A B W O U N D S*
I love Detroit Become Human I’m re playing it again 😂
Is this an older recorded video or a new one?? Because Chris the Cop is silent for weeks now on his YT and Twitter account.
Old video but I am back!
@@ChrisTHECOP Good to hear your back, missed you on the usual channel and socials. I hope everything is ok.
TWENTY, EIGHT, STAB WOUNDS!!!!
More please!
I want to see him react to The Raid redemption or the construction site scene in the dark knight
Video Tip : Spec Ops React To Insurgency sandstorm
The great thing is that the androids did not consider themselves above humans. Their goal was not to enslave us. They simply wanted the same rights and humans. To be treated as human.
He needs to make a UA-cam channel and film it
You guys should have Chris react to the Punisher using either the movies, show or the video game
Ngl the approach he has chosen is better than 28 STAB WOUND, it's more scary vibes mysterious type of...um you get what I mean
Next a real alien react to destroy all humans
Is that drone voiced by Dr. Avery or is it just me
Why didn't you fully close that scene, Gamology? The android has a little more action or dialogue after the confession, based on your choices for that scene.
28!!! STAB WOUNDS!!!!
Yeah my favorite cop is also a Chris, but I don't think Christopher Dorner has a UA-cam
more vieos with connor and cop ChrisChris
Great video! Next time just don't put music over the game's music, guys
Most human choice I never see
youtube says that the channel to his link is invalid, i think someone accidentally cut of half of the channel ID at the end of the link.
He did better than I did when I did it I need to get a confession out of the guy killed himself because he was too stressed out