My favorite historical doll is Nellie. She was the second doll in my collection, and was always my favorite of my dolls growing up. As an adult collector now, the doll I had to have was Kit. I loved her story growing up! ❤
@@kelseymorgan94 Nellie has a perfect, cute doll aesthetic. I just wish I didn’t have such bad luck with Josefina mold dolls! As pretty as the sculpt is, I almost always get one with weird eyes. BUT! I can see why people love Nellie so much, especially her wardrobe.
Shocker! Claudie! Love seeing your picks! I love the best friends, Ruthie is my #1, hahaha!! Your love of the Hoffman twins is making me reconsider my snobbiness about them not being historical!
@@EmilyRavenscraft-w5f yay, I honestly love when a doll that doesn’t resonate with me (Ruthie) is someone else’s favorite. It’s silly, but I feel bad about dolls I don’t love. I guess I see the twins as the most contemporary historical dolls… but the 90s do feel like a long time ago 🤯☠️ It’s like Mattel said the dolls PC made are antiques
I am binge watching AG content today. It's been a rough week here. Thanks for the video, I always enjoy seeing your dolls and hearing you talk about them.
@@nanasewdear awww I know exactly what you’re talking about! In fact I was so down I almost didn’t record a video. Then I decided to do this one because it was a light and fluffy topic. I hope it was a comforting distraction so to speak…
I so enjoy the way you style your dolls! Please do a video on styling their hairstyles with the outfits, you really knock it out of the ball park with your visual displaying! Definitely time for an updated display tour, you have added so many new dolls. Interested to see how you incorporate the Maplelea dolls into some displays. Your collection is absolutely stunning. Thank you for this video today! Just what I needed. ❤
@@carolreardon528 hmmm I don’t feel like I’m very good at hair - or maybe I’m unable to do more complex styles I wish I could do. If I can figure out a way to work that into a video, there’s no harm lol. And you’re right - my display update is so overdue. I’m having trouble sorting out the wall you see behind me in my videos. The shelves came right out of the wall!!
@ just use 200 Lb anchors! I have my displays on shelves and have not had any problem. I use the heavy duty white shelving with grey brackets so it doesn’t distract from my girls! If I lived near by I could pop by and install them! So I know you can do it.
@ you just need a masonry bit. First grab your anchors, the package will tell you what size bit you need. Drill the hole and then add your anchor. I like the zip anchors! Very easy to use! I’ll try to send pictures!
Hi Blaine, thanks for cheering us up with another fantastic video! Loved seeing your ranking and hearing your reasoning for putting them there. There was never a doubt who would be #1. 😂 ❤
@@mykls2153 it was a tumultuous week eh? I had to force myself to record, so I went with something light in case anyone else needed a distraction too. I think I just wanted to brag about how Claudie is the best even in pjs 🤣🤣🤣
Blaine, Thank you so much for this video! As some others have mentioned it has been a devastating week here in the US. I really have been needing to just escape to my doll world! I am crazy for how you styled your Kirsten. She looks soooo adorable. I am also in love with your PC Samantha. I’d love to find one with a similar expression. I have that same outfit on my Beforever Samantha. Samantha is definitely a favorite of my historicals too! My Claudie, also a favorite, is currently wearing Rebecca’s newer Hannukah outfit and it looks so good on her,I don’t know if I can take her out of it. Please keep the videos coming!
@@EStern-18 awww I totally understand, I mean it. That’s the reason I pulled myself out of a funk to record. I figured it would help distract me and maybe someone else out there too. Isn’t Kirsten a little cutie this way?? I finally figured out how to get her bangs out of her eyes! I have seen a similar Samantha to mine since I got her, so she definitely turns up. She’s very strange (in a good way of course) but I can’t place why she looks like this lol. You have my fave historical girl (Claudie) in my fave historical outfit!!! I won’t dare risk putting her in it lol. I’d need an 11th Claudie doll!!!
Hah! You really should risk it with Claudie and that outfit, you’ll love it I think! I will keep my eyes open for a PC Samantha and I might just have to find that coat and skates for my Kirsten!
@@stephaniefriend9912 I agree, and I think that’s why I love her to a surprising degree. I got really lucky. Do I need to read her book?? I barely read any of them 🥴
so cute! kirsten in that cosy winter outfit 😍I also have Maryellen and some of her 50s collection ,Caroline is so unique😊very interesting video,loved watching
@@DisBlaine yes I have Caroline-I recently bought her holiday gown outfit which I love, I think its her curls and her unusual eye colour that makes her special☺
@@chantelconrad4221 if it weren’t for Claudie, I’m not sure I ever would’ve warmed up to the dolls the way I did (before her I only collected the clothes and playsets)
32:30 I think you mean Lisa Frank, not Anne Frank 😅 great video though! I have a similar ranking of my own dolls to you. Claudie is just in a league of her own! Also, I love your Isabel. I'm thinking of getting her for myself for Christmas ❤
@@FixMyAGDoll oh noooo I was so afraid of getting their names mixed up you can probably see panic wash over me. Ugh!!! I should delete this whole video, so embarrassing!!!
Kit is my favorite historical doll. I have been collecting all of her original retired outfits and accessories. I have spent a small fortune this summer! LOL. Love the historical dolls! I have a PC Samantha and Kirsten. I also have a first edition Felicity. Great video! ❤
@@kashlaw01 I forgot to mention other unique qualities about Kit (hence why I have her in the first place lol). Her Bob is adorable, and we don’t get a lot of short haired dolls. I felt so bad talking about the first few dolls, because I only got them because I love them… but not everyone can make the top 5 🥴
Claudie and Addy are definitely 2 of my most favorite Historical dolls. Felicity is my 3rd. I dobfind Elizabeth beautiful, I resisted fer her for awhile by creating my own book version but I finally succumbed. I don't have a cannon Rebekah or Ruthie but I think they're beautiful dolls
@@shannonchristie-wickham8453 my top 5 were no brainers, but the others took a lot of mental gymnastics to figure out! I’m surprised I only have 1 Felicity tbh. Her wardrobe is outstanding, so I wish I could see more of it displayed.
I find these sort of lists fascinating. I love hearing what sort of criteria people consider for ranking them - it sounds like for you it was the doll and their collection? I know that if I were to ever do a ranking, I would end up including their books/stories, too, because I grew up reading the historical books and it's hard for me to keep those out of my feelings. I totally expected Nanea to be at the bottom of your list, based on things you've said about her before. I do sometimes wonder if you had a different Nanea, if your feelings might be different (I personally think my Nanea is absolutely gorgeous, and she looks very different than yours). I was absolutely unsurprised by Claudie being your number one, but was surprised that Ivy and Samantha were numbers two and three - I knew you loved the eyes, but didn't know they swayed you so hard! Your Kirsten is amazingly cute, I love her cheeks, and I love the way you styled her hair. While I knew the Joss mold was up there for you, in terms of favorites, I never would have guessed at how high Isabel is - maybe because I don't think we see her terribly often in your videos? I could be wrong, I don't have an encyclopedic knowledge of your videos. Really enjoyed hearing about your ranking and reasons for where they all fell. The idea that you'll someday be ranking ALL your dolls... I am VERY curious how that will turn out, someday! My ranks, based SOLEY on my dolls (so not taking into account their collections TOO much, and working very hard to disregard their books so as to keep in line with your criteria): 1) Addy 2) Claudie 3) Rebecca 4) Nanea 5) Ivy 6) Cecile 7) Melody 8) Molly 9) Kaya 10) Nicki 11) Samantha 12) Kit 13) Caroline 14) Josefina 15) Kirsten 16) Courtney 17) Felicity. Continuing with my unowned historicals, none of which I want to buy: 18) Maryellen (my mother owns her and I'll inherit her someday) 19) Ruthie 20) Nellie 21) Emily 22) Isabel 23) Marie Grace (I do actually own an MG, but I customized her heavily into a modern girl) 24) Julie 25) Elizabeth.
@@eliseelliot haha my doll math was all over the place figuring out how to rank them! I looked at each doll individually and considered different ways to measure my love for them. Some dolls didn’t need any consideration. I knew exactly where they went. I totally agree with you about Nanea! I think I need a nicer one someday. Mine looks really funny. (Then I would customize her too 🥴) Oops I didn’t put Ivy and Samantha high BECAUSE of the eyes, I just thought it was funny they made top 3 and had that in common. I love those 3 dolls individually. I was surprised about Isabel too 🤯 I fought myself to put her lower, but it felt wrong. Ranking is weird 🤣🤣🤣 Aside from Rebecca, most of our high ranked dolls are similar! If you weren’t going to inherit Maryellen one day, would you have her? It looks like you don’t have any of the dolls I don’t have either. Funny!
@@DisBlaine I mean, don't get me wrong, your Nanea is perfectly nice, I don't mean to insult the poor thing. She gets enough trouble from your one doll in the 50s (can't remember- Mary Louise? Mary Lou?), I don't want to pile onto her! I just wonder if one with better eyes would change your feelings about Nanea herself. As for Maryellen... I would probably end up owning her, because the historicals are my favorites and I would need a 1950s doll from AG. I only have one doll from each era (hence why I have Ivy but not Julie), and since there isn't a best friend for ME, I would end up getting her. Thankfully, though, Mum has her instead and I don't need to worry about that just yet! She's a good doll, she just would be very, very low on my priority list. Similar to how I got Courtney last, to complete my "one per era" collection.
It makes sense to rank all your dolls by having a whole series and you can pick your overall favorites 😅 the stress of doll collecting shall never be underestimated. I am also picking up my Cecile tomorrow. Very excited.
@@happyjollyholly4455 picking up as in Cecile will be new to your collection?? If so, eeeeks I’m so excited for you! Let me know which wig version yours has, and if you have a preference.
@DisBlaine omg I must be a bad collector, because I didn't know until your comment she has two wig variations. I don't know that I have a preference, I don't even know the difference. I've been looking to add her to my collection for a while so I am soooo happy just to have her. Her curls seem a little less ringlet-y but she is in great shape and I love her so dearly!
Thank’s so much for this video I needed it today more than you could possibly know . I live in the states/American born Citizen I’m currently devastated , scared , and walking in a fog.. I wish I could leave the country, but it’s not feasible to do so right now.. I’m hoping my doll’s will help this fear in my mind,, IDUNO , but what I do know this video brightened my day today ,, again much thanks .💜💜💜
@@onlyalisaawilliams hi Alisa. Thank you for sharing that. Truthfully, the only reason I forced myself to record a video was in case anyone needed a little escape, the same thing I needed. I may be in Canada, but America has a profound affect on our politics. Our dolls will need to be more of a comfort than ever, so I didn’t even want to mention the turmoil in the video itself. Stay strong! I’m trying to say other assuring words… but we have no idea what the future holds.
It cracks me up that I knew Claudie would be your favorite! Your least favorite Nanea is my literal most favorite historical character! I have her entire collection with the exception of Mele’s dog bed. I love her so much because she is my second doll of my own from my husband and girlfriends. They got her for my birthday which is on Pearl Harbor day. Which of course is quintessential to her story.
@@Grandma_HoneyVA wait, you guessed my favorite? I actually love being predictable about certain things 🥳 And I feel bad for the dolls that made the bottom of my list, but any I have it’s because I do love them. I think I just got a bad Nanea, so I think I’ll fix her one day. Everyone else seems to have a cute Nanea, so I’m sure yours is adorable-plus she’s got a special story 🥰
Thank you so much for sharing your fave dolls! I was thinking the whole time just what you said. How it’s all about which dolls you connect with! Like, my fave AG doll (only one I have) is Josefina! It’s as if in the Holiday catalog a couple years ago, she was looking at me, and saying, “pick me, pick me!”❤😂
@@JAduo-tf2kn yeah the doll math behind ranking was wild lol! But mostly it was based on different criteria for each doll. I’m so glad you listened to Josefina! Claudie did the same thing to me, but over and over again 🥴🤣
I'm drawn to Molly as my top doll because she looks one way in her meet outfit but when you take her glasses off and change her hair, she looks so transformed. She can look like a very different doll with new back stories.
@@poundcake88 I really enjoy her too tbh. I have 3 of her because some of her outfits are too not to have on display - and the glasses really are adorable. I love that you modernize her too!
Another great video from all those 20 dolls my favorite is Josefina and least favorite is Maryellen all the other dolls there I love I have them almost all only 5 from your 20 I don’t have which I plan to get your dolls all look beautiful ❤I love the winter set you had on the doll thanks for sharing ❤
@@nildajurado8423 awww yay that you love Josefina! But then I do feel bad she’s at the bottom of my list - hence why I like to hear others love her. Which 5 do you plan to get?
@ yes Ivy I hope I can find her with her meet outfit and at a good price I really love all your videos and the stories you tell you really entertain your viewers
@ ooh, and maybe even her meet accessories!! Her bag is so cute! (And thank you, my stories feel realllly boring as I’m recording, so I hit upload hoping it’s just a self conscious thing)
Hi Blaine. I wonder if you took down Nanea’s hair and let it hang in long loose waves around her face if you would like her better? She is gorgeous with her hair down. 🥰 aww I love your Kirstin! She looks adorable in that outfit. You got me at Caroline. One of my favourites. 🥰 Isabel is gorgeous and my favourite Hoffman twin. She is on my list. I wasn’t a huge fan of Courtney until I got my own. Now I think she’s super cute. She also looks a lot like I did in the 80’s LOL Your Samantha is very cute and “dreamy” Claudie of course. ❤ I loved this video. Thanks for sharing your rankings!
@@CherishedDollFriends hey Cheryl! lol I’m always trying to love Nanea more because I love the porential of the mold (it’s honestly so cute!) but so far there hasn’t been a doll ideal for my tastes. I may attempt to customize my Nanea one day and look for a better version of her later. And UGH! I love my Caroline so much. I think I got a good one lol. Something about her really speaks to me. Oh and I love your “spooky” Kirsten-but out of all my Kirsten dolls, the one I shared is the best I have.
Hi Blaine, it’s so interesting to hear everyone’s different tastes in dolls isn’t it? You have such a beautiful collection and I know you love them all ( if not equally) LOL. Caroline is a beauty. Her eyes are stunning. I have an all my American Girl dolls video coming out soon. 😊 Have a great day!
I do plan to do an “All my dolls”video closer to Christmas so we shall see what I have then. The only other 18” dolls I sometimes pick up are “Our Generation” I sometimes find really cute ones in good condition at thrift stores however I often end up selling them. How about you?
I love Courtney's collection. I got everything I could get my hands on. Last Sunday in Chicago's American Girl event I brought home Courtney to be a friend to my first doll Kirsten. The goodie bag was cute Christmas PJ's, calendar, a cute Golden Book, toenail stickers and Christmas stickers. They look very cute both dressed in Courtney's collection. They are great everyday clothes. Love your videos ❤❤❤❤.
@@sandyrusek1761 I saw pics of the grab bag-I love the stickers! And the pjs of course lol. I was the same with Courtney’s collection. I think the only thing I missed was her flats and socks. I can live without it because I’m not about to spend those secondary prices on a pair of shoes for dolls - not even on a pair for myself 😝
Amazing video. Of course everyone KNEW claudie was going to be your number 1😂 but it was interesting to see how the others ranked. Well my personal ranking is very different from yours 😂 and my number 1 is a 3 way tie. Plus my ranking is mostly different for the actual characters as opposed to the dolls themselves. But as for the dolls, it goes: 23. Isabel ( idky she just doesn’t strike me as a favorite) 22. Nikki (i like her looks better than her sister) 21. Courtney (cute, but somethings missing for me) 20. Molly (surprising considering she's one of my least favorite characters, but i think her doll is adorable) 19. Julie (i love her hair and some of her outfits) 18. Emily (i think she's really a cute doll) 17. Mary-ellen (i LOVE the 1950s, and she's so adorable) 16. Nanea (she's so cute and i love the Hawaiian theme) 15. Kirsten (those little braid loops are so cute, and I've wrapped her braids in different ways around her head and she always looks so cute) 14. Caroline (those eyes are so striking!) 13. Ruthie (i actually think she's super cute and gray eyes aren't common in dolls in general so to have a second one in the historical lineup is awesome) 12. Kit (i think she's so cute and i love her collection! Even though she's the complete opposite of me style wise😂) 11. Elizabeth (ohmygosh she's absolutely adorable! Even though she's not original book series accurate, she's still a really beautiful doll) 10. Ivy (she's very unique to the line up and looks so good in everything) 9. Melody (ohmygosh that little hair flip and the way she looks in her purple birthday outfit and just aaahh she's so cute) 8. Rebecca (good gosh she's adorable, and i love her) 7. Marie-grace (she is so absolutely cute and i love how she looks in sky blue) 6. Cecil (it was hard to pick who my favorite was between the 2 of them, but the way cecil looks in rich jewel tone colors and her hair, just aaahh it put her ever so slightly above marie-grace) 5. Josefina (ohmygosh she's so beautiful. So much looks amazing on her, earth tones, jewel tones, multi colors, she's just amazing) 4. Claudie (she has the absolute sweetest looking face ever! And those little curls. Aaahhh) 3. Samantha (specifically the 80s and 90s sam's, there's just something about that early era of Samantha that i love and her collection is amazing 2. Nellie (i just got nellie and she is the cutest little thing ever! She looks amazing in light blues, pinks and greens) 1. Addy, Kaya and Felicity. (It's a 3 way tie between them. I honestly can't put one over the other with these 3. Addy's hair is SO much fun to style and play with, and she looks so amazing in everything! Felicity, i love her eyes and she looks so beautiful in blues and greens, and kaya is just stunning and immaculately well done as a collection and i love her. I love all 3 of them as individual dolls and as characters. Their books are amazing, their collections are absolutely wonderfully done, amd they just are all equally stunning and beautiful dolls) So that's my ranking 😂 also i only own a few of these, so my opinions could change over time as i find the others. The only ones i have personal experience with are: Addy, Felicity, Kaya, Kirsten, Nellie, Samantha, and Josefina. All of whom were rescues in various states of destruction or disarray and most needed severe spa days😂
@@kelseypeterson5172 haha aren’t I so predictable? 🙈🤣 We do have a different ranking BUT! Because your top fave is 3, our number 9 and 3 aligned lol!! I thought Felicity would rank higher for me for the same reason you love your top 3: saving them from previous owners. I had to overhaul my Felicity too (but maybe not as much as you did yours). Oh yes your ranking could definitely change. I can’t believe how my opinions did by the time I sat down to do this.
@@DisBlaine oh, no I saw your felicity and she definitely needed more work than mine did, her main problem was she was sort of dirty and she was SO loose her legs were basically hanging off😂 my samantha looked the worst, due to fried hair and nail polish and whatnot all over, but addy has had the most work put in because of trying to preserve her original 90s hair, and adding new wefts to her wig to fill it out again.(finding identical hair to her 90s texture was hard) my samantha still needs a new wig, because this one is still not great, but your "dreamer" samantha is absolutely beautiful! I love how she looks like she's looking up and wistful, mine has a tendency to look down, as she's got a bit of a hunchback. I've yet to figure out how to adjust her stuffing enough to fix that.🤷♀️ but yeah anyone watching your videos can tell Claudie is your favorite 😂 just as anyone who knows me knows my 3 favorites😂 when you love something enough, it shows😂
I can understand your ranking system. I think, of the historicals, I have Kaya, Molly, Felicity, Cecile, and Courtney as they come. I have a modernized Julie (wig swap to something really close), Nanea (really close wig and eye swap), the twins (eye swap on Isabel). One day, I may get Kirsten, not sure. I have Addy, but she is custom painted and different eyes and wig, so I won't really count her in there. Same with Ivy - wig swap and someone painted lashes on her. Sold Kit a while ago, as well as Josefina (who did not have her meet outfit). Loving your end dolls all together.
@@DarcysNova626 eye swapped Isabel?? Was she donating them to someone you prefer?? It’s the best thing about her lol. And…. YOU CUSTOMIZED IVY??? I have to assume you got her at retail ☠️🤣 Or wait you got her that way? I might eye and wig swap Nanea one day too (if I replace her because mine is… well you saw her lol)
@DisBlaine I bought Ivy and Isabel already customized. A doll friend has the twins without meet clothes at an extremely reasonable price, and she had hand-picked them ($175 shipped for the pair). Ivy, I only know is Ivy since I know what to look for - a customizer was downsizing due to moving, and she was a good price as well($85). I didn't care for the wig she came with, so I found one from my collection.
The historical line has had so many dolls over the years! It’s crazy to see most of them together and compared! I got Isabel on my trip to the store, and I was wondering how she would rank!! 😂😅❤ That’s so crazy that I didn’t realize you don’t own Nellie!! Ruthie is super gorgeous, but I’m trying not to add any more classic molds either!! ❤
@@americangirlfilms you’re a lot more reasonable with your collection. So I know you must really love Isabel! Turns out I love her more than I expected lol. But she is really pretty and unique I only have Nellie’s meet hat and purse. It was accidentally put in a doll set I bought and it took me a long time to figure out what they were 😆
I have an older PC Samantha and an AG LLC one and they look so different. I think the newer one is prettier but the older one is so unique ya gotta love her.
Oh I so love our Nanea, so do not worry, we will be giving her all the attention :) We all here completely understand - you are busy to give attention to all and like them all the same, you have quite a few Claudies to look after 😊
@@DollsAllGrown-Up awww that’s good to know - and I still love my Nanea. She’s just… the least loved, okay that sounds even worse 🤣 One day I’ll fix her eyes, and I bet it’ll change a lot. However! It’s always nice to hear other collectors connect so much with dolls I don’t.
I haven't watched it all yet but I bet the thing your top dolls have in common is decal brown eyes. I am thinking the top two will be Claudie at 1and Samantha at 2.
Wow you must be suuuper rich to get ahold of all these AG dolls! So jealous 😂 I had an Addy when I was around 10 years old in the early 90's, eventually got a Kirsten like 8 years later but sadly have sold them. And then two years ago ended up getting a Nanea and Samantha and sold them too 😭😭 Dunno wtf I was thinking cause I can never afford one now. I think my adhd makes me goes through phases cause now I have been obsessively collecting Barbie. You do not look like you grew up in the 80's at all I thought you were born in '85 like me lol.
@@imperialbeautee wellllll I’ve been collecting dolls so long I often sell off old dolls to pay for new ones. But what I can’t sell off old dolls for? Space! lol. Awww it sucks that you regret selling your old dolls! I always put dolls away when I’m thinking selling to see if I’ll miss them. You really might find a nice deal one day, so never say never! Oh yes I look younger than my age I think - I blame doll collecting. It keeps me young 😆
It's funny cause this is like...the exact same as my list, but reversed. Like I think Nanea and Josefina have by far the prettiest faces and are absolutely going to be my first port of call when and if I ever do manage to get my hands on any of these dolls. ... And I honestly keep forgetting that Claudie even exists.
@@kayleighbrown459 oh i definitely see why people love Nanea-mine doesn’t have as a nice a face as others, but I’ve seen some really beautiful ones! Maybe after Claudie has had more time in existence, she’ll grow on you. Haha first my favorite color and now my historical ranking. It’s fun to know tastes can vary so much!
@@DisBlaine Lol. Yeah. Legit my favourite thing about the doll collecting community objectively subjective everything about it is. Like I might just be lucky but compared to some other communities, there really doesn't seem to be a lot of drama...because how you gonna start drama over little plastic women. There just something so refreshingly superficial about it.
Claudia is my favorite. She has the best combo of cute face hair and meet outfit. I like the newer faces more. Went to a doll show kind of sucks I only found a couple of AG dolls. I like the Nanea face mold it's cute. I would not put her last. I even think Summer is adorable. I just don't like her clothes.
@@iamsoverybored878 truthfully I like the potential of the Nanea mold, but I’ve had to customize the dolls to make myself like them more - and I feel bad because it’s a cute face, so I’m always trying to figure out how to love her lol. One day they’ll make her in a combo I’ll love
I hope your police case is proceeding fast. Just a thought, Indian food is my favorite and I recently tried goat- and loved it! Have you tried it? Great video ❤❤❤
@@jameshamer481 I haven’t heard back from anyone - not even insurance after filling out my claim! Oh and my partner is vegetarian (it’s part of his religion), so I don’t really eat meat in Indian cuisine - but sometimes I’ll sneak some chicken! That’s the only meat I really like. I’m actually a very picky eater, so I wouid never eat something as adventurous as goat 😝
@@illyrianya lol I felt so bad talking about the first few dolls, because I only got them because I love them… but not everyone can make the top 5 🥴 I really struggle with Nanea tho because I think I got a bad one.
Gentle little correction at around the 30 minute mark talking about Ivy (gorgeous doll, agreed the eyes and modified sockets,) you mention Anne Frank, but I think you mean Lisa Frank. Lisa Frank is the woman who did the rainbow folder with the dolphins and such. Anne Frank is the 12 year old Jewish girl who wrote a journal in hiding during the Holocaust. ❤
@@happyjollyholly4455 Holly, I was mortified when someone else pointed that out!! I remember panicking I was going to say the wrong one in the moment. AND I DID 😭 Sometimes when I’m recording my brain moves too fast. I almost deleted this whole video, but no one has been upset about it (so far 👀)
Oooh I’m gonna play the game again (top ten) 1. Claudie (duh) 2. Kaya 3. Addy 4. Cecile 5. Courtney 6. Maryellen 7. Julie (+Ivy) 8. Melody 9. Twins 10. Samantha Okay time to watch!
@@DisBlaine yes i do love nicki she is the doll i named after my fave singer lol and the freaky part is nicki has my fave singers eye color and face if looked at at diff angles!
@@lisbetsoda4874 ohhhhh haha I wondered what I said that was so brutal. Isn’t that funny? I love to see other collectors have different taste. It shows the line has enough diversity to have a wide appeal. (Did I say something specific that was brutal? I promise I tried to explain that I do love all my dolls, so this was hard)
I'm going to be the annoying commenter I guess. So much to say. 😂 I love all the historicals. I tried to start ranking them overall with all the qualities, but there are too many categories. They are all so special, and I have different connections to each. Some have better stories, some have more unique features but im not sure I can rank them!
@@happyjollyholly4455 that’s what made ranking them so hard! Each doll has different strengths, whether it’s their era, playsets, wardrobe, their face. The doll math I used didn’t make logical sense… but somehow I got the answers! I don’t recommend it 🤣
I love your collection…. 💕🙏🏼🩷 I definitely like a variety of skin type /hair on my dolls. Otherwise they look all the same to me 🤭🤭how dare I say that ? …. Lol. I’m a New adult collector since August 2024 … started with an eBay reasonably priced Samantha. Since then 4 more new dolls from AG’s online website. Definitely fallen down the rabbit hole 🐇💲🐰💸But I can’t purchase Moana online? ….. they won’t ship the back ordered Moana doll 🇨🇦🇨🇦here for some packaging reason?? Very strange 😮😮
@@beatriz9293 well! Let me tell you something about being a newer collector and not wanting dolls to look alike… as you add more to your collection, the more you see uniqueness in dolls you once thought looked identical. I literally have 33 AND 102 - who was an updated version of 33 🙄🙄 I just made them sisters pahaaaaa Yeah I don’t know what’s up with Moana not being shipped here! I was able to order to a US address, but I wasn’t expecting that at all
Once you learn something about all the different face molds then you can try to avoid buying the same mold over and over again. I try to get different molds and now I know I lean toward Josefina. I will see a doll I love and then realize: "oh course you love her ,she is Josefina"
I think your Nanaea is cute, but her outfit is plain. Maybe a lei? Does Isabella have the same face mold as Nanaea and Claudie? Your Josephina, at least this one doesn't look like Josephina to me. Looks more like maybe Rebecca? Is Leah a historical doll?
@@joymontague251 usually I have Nanea in Maryellen’s current school outfit, but wanted to show her meet for once lol. Mine has a funny face. Maybe if I fix her eyes. Isabel, Nanea, and Claudie all have different face molds. Josefina and Rebecca have the same mold tho.
I would never get rid of my historical dolls. There would be others that would go first, or wouldn't come to live here. They all have "souls" because they have stories. I haven't got your imagination and some of my other dolls came here mainly for their beauty or for fair representation. All good reasons so we shall see. 😂
@@lisbetsoda4874 hmmm I think my imagination is what gives all my dolls souls. That’s why they can’t picture myself getting rid of any of them. Now I get it!
Get out of here with your Elizabeth despise! 😂😢 (I'm just teasing.) Elizabeth was my very first American girl doll I got at age 5. She was chosen for me by my mom because she looked like me, and so I have developed a strong connection to my Elizabeth. 😅
@@happyjollyholly4455 awwww, it’s the opposite for me. As a kid I wanted dolls who had a different aesthetic from mine (I was blond and blue eyed until I was about 9). And people would want to get me dolls like that 🤣 I looked like Elizabeth too-but with shorter hair lol.
I cannot pick my top historical doll, not even my top ten. I agree that Marie-Grace and Elizabeth are NOT my favourites, nor is Courtney, or in a way, dare I say it, Caroline. The problem is, i haven't read their books yet, and once I do, they will probably win me over. Except Elizabeth. She was supposed to have brown hair. She is a fraud. 😂 They made her after the Felicity movie came out, and in it, Elizabeth was blonde. How about that!!! I identify big time with Julie's time period, and fashion, so I like her an awful lot. We are Jewish so I love Rebecca, i have childhood pictures of my mother with braids in the forties so I love Molly. Caroline is too blond, too blue-eyed, too "pretty" in a very doll-like way. I am a sucker for her time period, the regency era, though. I love the simpler fashions and more modest lives of Addy, Josefina and Kirsten. Some people find them underwhelming; i love their subtlety. And so on, and so on. My least favourite era, fashionwise, is the colonial one. Little girls in dresses much too grown up for them. Too Marie Antoinette for me. But I love that Felicity is a horse girl and her ginger pincurls. Ahh, the dilemmas we have as doll collectors. The twins i didn't want to love - but i actually really do. What gives?
@@lisbetsoda4874 Elizabeth was supposed to be brunette?? That’s so strange! So do you think Julie and Rebecca might tie for your favorite? Or three way split with Molly lol. I don’t think it’s strange you don’t like Caroline. Is she really popular? To me she seems as you said too doll like, rather than a genuine historical character.
@DisBlaine According to the books, which I am embarrassed to say, I haven't read. It was all about selling another blond doll, I'm sure. Those books are in general not the higher literature so although I own all the sets of all the old dolls, I never got through them. My daughter read them when she was little, and I read one sporadically here and there but I feel I know their stories even from the old catalogues. I think that Kirsten also rates really highly, I have her, and Molly and Samantha in white body versions. I love her story of struggles almost as much as Addy's. Too many "Little House on the prairie books as a child, I think. They have always stayed with me. Then there is Kaya, who stands out alone. She and her collection are so spectacular. Hey, I am rambling so much. 🤣 Caroline is too much somehow. Yes. I do think so many collectors like her for the reason that I don't. So pretty, or too pretty, I would say. Her hair is the colour that only young children sometimes have. I have such strong feelings I need to get my own channel. If only I were better with technology. Sigh.
Nanea, Marie Grace, Maryellen and Samantha are my least favorites. I know you aren’t a Kirsten fan (I have five of them) but she, Claudie and Addy are my favorites. My first doll was Rebecca so she’s special too! Oh and the 70s? Yes very gross. The clothing and colors were horrible!
@@sjordan9586 oh, I actually love Kirsten! With the new limited edition doll, I have 4 of her - but one is a deep TLC, so I’m not sure she’ll be Kirsten in the end. I wish I could love Nanea more, so I might have to correct her eyes one day. 🥴
Kirsten was my first doll. I don’t own many of her clothes. I modernized her has a child, so I only have 2 outfits, but since gone back to trying to find outfits appropriate for her era. Emily 🥹🥹🥹 she was my second doll and she was my grandmas favorite I have all her outfits but the recital one (cause I love historical characters and her outfits were top tier in my opinion) Nellie was supposed to be my third but I ended up with a TM21 and I had a meltdown (yay asd) and my mom ended up calling AG and buying me Samantha (who I got for my birthday later that year) because Nellie was sold out. I loved the Molly movie so much I asked for Molly for my 15th birthday (that was a special year for me…) but since learned Molly in the books is a giant bully I kinda have mixed feelings. When Beforever came out I quit AG until they brought back Kit for her 100th Birthday. I absolutely love Kit her story is so good (so far) I also love her little face ☺️ I have Melody who I bought for myself for working over all of spring break (so the paycheck paid for her) i was upset when I got her because she was not brand new like the seller had said but @agtakesover fixed her up for me and now I adore her!! I finally found Nellie (TLC) online and I was able to restring her and I love her so much. I really want Ruthie, but I’m upset they her doll incorrectly portrays her character so I’m iffy on that one. I’m buying Claudie for Christmas and I’m so excited for her. 🥹😭 okay sorry rant over.
@@scarletsavenger1367 modernizing Kirsten makes sense. She had a AGOT clone anyway. Sometimes I have trouble telling them apart! lol you mentioned Emily and I had to look her up. I really do forget about the BF dolls! Her photos are really sweet, but I wish she had a different mold to delineate her from Molly more. 21 is one of my fave TM dolls - I wonder if you’d have liked her better if you weren’t expecting Nellie 🤣 Did you ever get Nellie? I hope after you started collecting again, she was at the top of your list!
My favorite historical doll is Nellie. She was the second doll in my collection, and was always my favorite of my dolls growing up. As an adult collector now, the doll I had to have was Kit. I loved her story growing up! ❤
@@kelseymorgan94 Nellie has a perfect, cute doll aesthetic. I just wish I didn’t have such bad luck with Josefina mold dolls! As pretty as the sculpt is, I almost always get one with weird eyes. BUT! I can see why people love Nellie so much, especially her wardrobe.
We knew all along it would be Claudie... The pj's made me giggle.
@@kerrysmiles are you saying I’m predictable? GOOD! 🤣
I’m glad I’ve made my love for her clear 🥰
@DisBlaine a little bit haha but it's good... It means we're really watching and getting to know you haha
You have actually turned into my absolute favorite AG channel... I'm pretty sure my Mom agrees. Don't tell😛
Don't tell the other channels I mean my mom knows 😂
This video was soooo fun! I love the historical girls😭 Claudie is definitely a star!
@@stephmariem yay I’m glad you liked it - even tho my number one was probably super predictable 🤣🤣
Not that I mind!
Shocker! Claudie! Love seeing your picks! I love the best friends, Ruthie is my #1, hahaha!! Your love of the Hoffman twins is making me reconsider my snobbiness about them not being historical!
@@EmilyRavenscraft-w5f yay, I honestly love when a doll that doesn’t resonate with me (Ruthie) is someone else’s favorite. It’s silly, but I feel bad about dolls I don’t love.
I guess I see the twins as the most contemporary historical dolls… but the 90s do feel like a long time ago 🤯☠️
It’s like Mattel said the dolls PC made are antiques
I am binge watching AG content today. It's been a rough week here. Thanks for the video, I always enjoy seeing your dolls and hearing you talk about them.
@@nanasewdear awww I know exactly what you’re talking about! In fact I was so down I almost didn’t record a video. Then I decided to do this one because it was a light and fluffy topic. I hope it was a comforting distraction so to speak…
I so enjoy the way you style your dolls! Please do a video on styling their hairstyles with the outfits, you really knock it out of the ball park with your visual displaying! Definitely time for an updated display tour, you have added so many new dolls. Interested to see how you incorporate the Maplelea dolls into some displays. Your collection is absolutely stunning. Thank you for this video today! Just what I needed. ❤
@@carolreardon528 hmmm I don’t feel like I’m very good at hair - or maybe I’m unable to do more complex styles I wish I could do. If I can figure out a way to work that into a video, there’s no harm lol.
And you’re right - my display update is so overdue. I’m having trouble sorting out the wall you see behind me in my videos. The shelves came right out of the wall!!
@ just use 200 Lb anchors! I have my displays on shelves and have not had any problem. I use the heavy duty white shelving with grey brackets so it doesn’t distract from my girls! If I lived near by I could pop by and install them! So I know you can do it.
@ I think I need a better drill. There’s concrete or something an inch behind the drywall. I’ll figure something out 🙈
@ you just need a masonry bit. First grab your anchors, the package will tell you what size bit you need. Drill the hole and then add your anchor. I like the zip anchors! Very easy to use! I’ll try to send pictures!
Kirsten in her winter outfit is beautiful, and I love your Samantha’s eyes.
@@Nanscee haha I love Kirsten like this so much I had to sneak her into my latest video too (scheduled for later this afternoon)
Hi Blaine, thanks for cheering us up with another fantastic video! Loved seeing your ranking and hearing your reasoning for putting them there. There was never a doubt who would be #1. 😂 ❤
@@mykls2153 it was a tumultuous week eh? I had to force myself to record, so I went with something light in case anyone else needed a distraction too. I think I just wanted to brag about how Claudie is the best even in pjs 🤣🤣🤣
Blaine, Thank you so much for this video! As some others have mentioned it has been a devastating week here in the US. I really have been needing to just escape to my doll world! I am crazy for how you styled your Kirsten. She looks soooo adorable. I am also in love with your PC Samantha. I’d love to find one with a similar expression. I have that same outfit on my Beforever Samantha. Samantha is definitely a favorite of my historicals too! My Claudie, also a favorite, is currently wearing Rebecca’s newer Hannukah outfit and it looks so good on her,I don’t know if I can take her out of it. Please keep the videos coming!
@@EStern-18 awww I totally understand, I mean it. That’s the reason I pulled myself out of a funk to record. I figured it would help distract me and maybe someone else out there too.
Isn’t Kirsten a little cutie this way?? I finally figured out how to get her bangs out of her eyes!
I have seen a similar Samantha to mine since I got her, so she definitely turns up. She’s very strange (in a good way of course) but I can’t place why she looks like this lol.
You have my fave historical girl (Claudie) in my fave historical outfit!!! I won’t dare risk putting her in it lol. I’d need an 11th Claudie doll!!!
Hah! You really should risk it with Claudie and that outfit, you’ll love it I think! I will keep my eyes open for a PC Samantha and I might just have to find that coat and skates for my Kirsten!
your Caroline is Stunning!!🩵
congrats on that!
her books are my favorite , i’ve read several of the 6-book sets & hers so far is my fav
@@stephaniefriend9912 I agree, and I think that’s why I love her to a surprising degree. I got really lucky. Do I need to read her book?? I barely read any of them 🥴
so cute! kirsten in that cosy winter outfit 😍I also have Maryellen and some of her 50s collection ,Caroline is so unique😊very interesting video,loved watching
@@pamelagilbert8077 Kirsten totally stole my heart this way! Do you have Caroline? There’s something really special about the way she comes together.
@@DisBlaine yes I have Caroline-I recently bought her holiday gown outfit which I love, I think its her curls and her unusual eye colour that makes her special☺
Claudie looks cute in everything. So not a surprise she was your number 1 (Lol)
@@chantelconrad4221 if it weren’t for Claudie, I’m not sure I ever would’ve warmed up to the dolls the way I did (before her I only collected the clothes and playsets)
32:30 I think you mean Lisa Frank, not Anne Frank 😅 great video though! I have a similar ranking of my own dolls to you. Claudie is just in a league of her own! Also, I love your Isabel. I'm thinking of getting her for myself for Christmas ❤
@@FixMyAGDoll oh noooo I was so afraid of getting their names mixed up you can probably see panic wash over me. Ugh!!! I should delete this whole video, so embarrassing!!!
@DisBlaine it happens!!! I know when I film I make lots of errors. It's very taxing on the working memory lol
@ I’ll see if anyone is offended I made such a rude mix up! (So far no one else has commented about it, so 🤞🏻)
Yay! Claudie!! Claudie was my first AG doll and I love her so much❤️
@@user-anyuta.-27 she was my first doll too! And now I have 10 of her 💸😆
Kit is my favorite historical doll. I have been collecting all of her original retired outfits and accessories. I have spent a small fortune this summer! LOL. Love the historical dolls! I have a PC Samantha and Kirsten. I also have a first edition Felicity. Great video! ❤
@@kashlaw01 I forgot to mention other unique qualities about Kit (hence why I have her in the first place lol). Her Bob is adorable, and we don’t get a lot of short haired dolls. I felt so bad talking about the first few dolls, because I only got them because I love them… but not everyone can make the top 5 🥴
Claudie and Addy are definitely 2 of my most favorite Historical dolls. Felicity is my 3rd. I dobfind Elizabeth beautiful, I resisted fer her for awhile by creating my own book version but I finally succumbed. I don't have a cannon Rebekah or Ruthie but I think they're beautiful dolls
@@shannonchristie-wickham8453 my top 5 were no brainers, but the others took a lot of mental gymnastics to figure out! I’m surprised I only have 1 Felicity tbh. Her wardrobe is outstanding, so I wish I could see more of it displayed.
I find these sort of lists fascinating. I love hearing what sort of criteria people consider for ranking them - it sounds like for you it was the doll and their collection? I know that if I were to ever do a ranking, I would end up including their books/stories, too, because I grew up reading the historical books and it's hard for me to keep those out of my feelings. I totally expected Nanea to be at the bottom of your list, based on things you've said about her before. I do sometimes wonder if you had a different Nanea, if your feelings might be different (I personally think my Nanea is absolutely gorgeous, and she looks very different than yours). I was absolutely unsurprised by Claudie being your number one, but was surprised that Ivy and Samantha were numbers two and three - I knew you loved the eyes, but didn't know they swayed you so hard! Your Kirsten is amazingly cute, I love her cheeks, and I love the way you styled her hair. While I knew the Joss mold was up there for you, in terms of favorites, I never would have guessed at how high Isabel is - maybe because I don't think we see her terribly often in your videos? I could be wrong, I don't have an encyclopedic knowledge of your videos. Really enjoyed hearing about your ranking and reasons for where they all fell. The idea that you'll someday be ranking ALL your dolls... I am VERY curious how that will turn out, someday!
My ranks, based SOLEY on my dolls (so not taking into account their collections TOO much, and working very hard to disregard their books so as to keep in line with your criteria): 1) Addy 2) Claudie 3) Rebecca 4) Nanea 5) Ivy 6) Cecile 7) Melody 8) Molly 9) Kaya 10) Nicki 11) Samantha 12) Kit 13) Caroline 14) Josefina 15) Kirsten 16) Courtney 17) Felicity. Continuing with my unowned historicals, none of which I want to buy: 18) Maryellen (my mother owns her and I'll inherit her someday) 19) Ruthie 20) Nellie 21) Emily 22) Isabel 23) Marie Grace (I do actually own an MG, but I customized her heavily into a modern girl) 24) Julie 25) Elizabeth.
@@eliseelliot haha my doll math was all over the place figuring out how to rank them! I looked at each doll individually and considered different ways to measure my love for them. Some dolls didn’t need any consideration. I knew exactly where they went.
I totally agree with you about Nanea! I think I need a nicer one someday. Mine looks really funny. (Then I would customize her too 🥴)
Oops I didn’t put Ivy and Samantha high BECAUSE of the eyes, I just thought it was funny they made top 3 and had that in common. I love those 3 dolls individually.
I was surprised about Isabel too 🤯 I fought myself to put her lower, but it felt wrong. Ranking is weird 🤣🤣🤣
Aside from Rebecca, most of our high ranked dolls are similar!
If you weren’t going to inherit Maryellen one day, would you have her? It looks like you don’t have any of the dolls I don’t have either. Funny!
@@DisBlaine I mean, don't get me wrong, your Nanea is perfectly nice, I don't mean to insult the poor thing. She gets enough trouble from your one doll in the 50s (can't remember- Mary Louise? Mary Lou?), I don't want to pile onto her! I just wonder if one with better eyes would change your feelings about Nanea herself. As for Maryellen... I would probably end up owning her, because the historicals are my favorites and I would need a 1950s doll from AG. I only have one doll from each era (hence why I have Ivy but not Julie), and since there isn't a best friend for ME, I would end up getting her. Thankfully, though, Mum has her instead and I don't need to worry about that just yet! She's a good doll, she just would be very, very low on my priority list. Similar to how I got Courtney last, to complete my "one per era" collection.
It makes sense to rank all your dolls by having a whole series and you can pick your overall favorites 😅 the stress of doll collecting shall never be underestimated. I am also picking up my Cecile tomorrow. Very excited.
@@happyjollyholly4455 picking up as in Cecile will be new to your collection?? If so, eeeeks I’m so excited for you! Let me know which wig version yours has, and if you have a preference.
Could you explain about the two wig variations? I didn't know that such a thing existed.
@@DisBlaine
@DisBlaine omg I must be a bad collector, because I didn't know until your comment she has two wig variations. I don't know that I have a preference, I don't even know the difference. I've been looking to add her to my collection for a while so I am soooo happy just to have her. Her curls seem a little less ringlet-y but she is in great shape and I love her so dearly!
Thank’s so much for this video I needed it today more than you could possibly know . I live in the states/American born Citizen I’m currently devastated , scared , and walking in a fog.. I wish I could leave the country, but it’s not feasible to do so right now.. I’m hoping my doll’s will help this fear in my mind,, IDUNO , but what I do know this video brightened my day today ,, again much thanks .💜💜💜
@@onlyalisaawilliams hi Alisa. Thank you for sharing that. Truthfully, the only reason I forced myself to record a video was in case anyone needed a little escape, the same thing I needed. I may be in Canada, but America has a profound affect on our politics.
Our dolls will need to be more of a comfort than ever, so I didn’t even want to mention the turmoil in the video itself. Stay strong! I’m trying to say other assuring words… but we have no idea what the future holds.
I love how number 4's legs look like they're turned in, she looks like a real girl. 🥰
@@molls127 she has loose limbs, which makes her fun to pose. Her arms are held behind her too. She can still stand on her own, but I don’t risk it lol
It cracks me up that I knew Claudie would be your favorite! Your least favorite Nanea is my literal most favorite historical character! I have her entire collection with the exception of Mele’s dog bed. I love her so much because she is my second doll of my own from my husband and girlfriends. They got her for my birthday which is on Pearl Harbor day. Which of course is quintessential to her story.
@@Grandma_HoneyVA wait, you guessed my favorite?
I actually love being predictable about certain things 🥳
And I feel bad for the dolls that made the bottom of my list, but any I have it’s because I do love them. I think I just got a bad Nanea, so I think I’ll fix her one day. Everyone else seems to have a cute Nanea, so I’m sure yours is adorable-plus she’s got a special story 🥰
Thank you so much for sharing your fave dolls! I was thinking the whole time just what you said. How it’s all about which dolls you connect with! Like, my fave AG doll (only one I have) is Josefina! It’s as if in the Holiday catalog a couple years ago, she was looking at me, and saying, “pick me, pick me!”❤😂
@@JAduo-tf2kn yeah the doll math behind ranking was wild lol! But mostly it was based on different criteria for each doll. I’m so glad you listened to Josefina! Claudie did the same thing to me, but over and over again 🥴🤣
I'm drawn to Molly as my top doll because she looks one way in her meet outfit but when you take her glasses off and change her hair, she looks so transformed. She can look like a very different doll with new back stories.
@@poundcake88 I really enjoy her too tbh. I have 3 of her because some of her outfits are too not to have on display - and the glasses really are adorable. I love that you modernize her too!
Awesome, and yes, we all knew it would be Claudie
@@annettefedd488 because I’m so obvious or because she’s so amazing? 🤪
@@DisBlaine Because she is totally amazing.
Another great video from all those 20 dolls my favorite is Josefina and least favorite is Maryellen all the other dolls there I love I have them almost all only 5 from your 20 I don’t have which I plan to get your dolls all look beautiful ❤I love the winter set you had on the doll thanks for sharing ❤
@@nildajurado8423 awww yay that you love Josefina! But then I do feel bad she’s at the bottom of my list - hence why I like to hear others love her. Which 5 do you plan to get?
@I plan on getting Melody Courtney the twins and the Asian one forgot her name she is difficult to find and expensive but I really want her so bad
@ Ivy I think you mean - I see she shows up for decent prices nowadays. Especially compared to watt I paid 🤣
But I love my Ivy so I don’t mind.
@ yes Ivy I hope I can find her with her meet outfit and at a good price I really love all your videos and the stories you tell you really entertain your viewers
@ ooh, and maybe even her meet accessories!! Her bag is so cute!
(And thank you, my stories feel realllly boring as I’m recording, so I hit upload hoping it’s just a self conscious thing)
Hi Blaine. I wonder if you took down Nanea’s hair and let it hang in long loose waves around her face if you would like her better? She is gorgeous with her hair down. 🥰 aww I love your Kirstin! She looks adorable in that outfit. You got me at Caroline. One of my favourites. 🥰 Isabel is gorgeous and my favourite Hoffman twin. She is on my list. I wasn’t a huge fan of Courtney until I got my own. Now I think she’s super cute. She also looks a lot like I did in the 80’s LOL Your Samantha is very cute and “dreamy” Claudie of course. ❤ I loved this video. Thanks for sharing your rankings!
@@CherishedDollFriends hey Cheryl! lol I’m always trying to love Nanea more because I love the porential of the mold (it’s honestly so cute!) but so far there hasn’t been a doll ideal for my tastes. I may attempt to customize my Nanea one day and look for a better version of her later.
And UGH! I love my Caroline so much. I think I got a good one lol. Something about her really speaks to me. Oh and I love your “spooky” Kirsten-but out of all my Kirsten dolls, the one I shared is the best I have.
Hi Blaine, it’s so interesting to hear everyone’s different tastes in dolls isn’t it? You have such a beautiful collection and I know you love them all ( if not equally) LOL. Caroline is a beauty. Her eyes are stunning. I have an all my American Girl dolls video coming out soon. 😊 Have a great day!
@ do you have other 18” dolls aside from AG and Maplelea? I was going to ask if you plan to do a video showing all your AG or 18” dolls.
I do plan to do an “All my dolls”video closer to Christmas so we shall see what I have then. The only other 18” dolls I sometimes pick up are “Our Generation” I sometimes find really cute ones in good condition at thrift stores however I often end up selling them. How about you?
I love Courtney's collection. I got everything I could get my hands on. Last Sunday in Chicago's American Girl event I brought home Courtney to be a friend to my first doll Kirsten. The goodie bag was cute Christmas PJ's, calendar, a cute Golden Book, toenail stickers and Christmas stickers. They look very cute both dressed in Courtney's collection. They are great everyday clothes. Love your videos ❤❤❤❤.
@@sandyrusek1761 I saw pics of the grab bag-I love the stickers! And the pjs of course lol.
I was the same with Courtney’s collection. I think the only thing I missed was her flats and socks. I can live without it because I’m not about to spend those secondary prices on a pair of shoes for dolls - not even on a pair for myself 😝
Amazing video. Of course everyone KNEW claudie was going to be your number 1😂 but it was interesting to see how the others ranked. Well my personal ranking is very different from yours 😂 and my number 1 is a 3 way tie. Plus my ranking is mostly different for the actual characters as opposed to the dolls themselves. But as for the dolls, it goes:
23. Isabel ( idky she just doesn’t strike me as a favorite)
22. Nikki (i like her looks better than her sister)
21. Courtney (cute, but somethings missing for me)
20. Molly (surprising considering she's one of my least favorite characters, but i think her doll is adorable)
19. Julie (i love her hair and some of her outfits)
18. Emily (i think she's really a cute doll)
17. Mary-ellen (i LOVE the 1950s, and she's so adorable)
16. Nanea (she's so cute and i love the Hawaiian theme)
15. Kirsten (those little braid loops are so cute, and I've wrapped her braids in different ways around her head and she always looks so cute)
14. Caroline (those eyes are so striking!)
13. Ruthie (i actually think she's super cute and gray eyes aren't common in dolls in general so to have a second one in the historical lineup is awesome)
12. Kit (i think she's so cute and i love her collection! Even though she's the complete opposite of me style wise😂)
11. Elizabeth (ohmygosh she's absolutely adorable! Even though she's not original book series accurate, she's still a really beautiful doll)
10. Ivy (she's very unique to the line up and looks so good in everything)
9. Melody (ohmygosh that little hair flip and the way she looks in her purple birthday outfit and just aaahh she's so cute)
8. Rebecca (good gosh she's adorable, and i love her)
7. Marie-grace (she is so absolutely cute and i love how she looks in sky blue)
6. Cecil (it was hard to pick who my favorite was between the 2 of them, but the way cecil looks in rich jewel tone colors and her hair, just aaahh it put her ever so slightly above marie-grace)
5. Josefina (ohmygosh she's so beautiful. So much looks amazing on her, earth tones, jewel tones, multi colors, she's just amazing)
4. Claudie (she has the absolute sweetest looking face ever! And those little curls. Aaahhh)
3. Samantha (specifically the 80s and 90s sam's, there's just something about that early era of Samantha that i love and her collection is amazing
2. Nellie (i just got nellie and she is the cutest little thing ever! She looks amazing in light blues, pinks and greens)
1. Addy, Kaya and Felicity. (It's a 3 way tie between them. I honestly can't put one over the other with these 3. Addy's hair is SO much fun to style and play with, and she looks so amazing in everything! Felicity, i love her eyes and she looks so beautiful in blues and greens, and kaya is just stunning and immaculately well done as a collection and i love her. I love all 3 of them as individual dolls and as characters. Their books are amazing, their collections are absolutely wonderfully done, amd they just are all equally stunning and beautiful dolls)
So that's my ranking 😂 also i only own a few of these, so my opinions could change over time as i find the others. The only ones i have personal experience with are: Addy, Felicity, Kaya, Kirsten, Nellie, Samantha, and Josefina. All of whom were rescues in various states of destruction or disarray and most needed severe spa days😂
@@kelseypeterson5172 haha aren’t I so predictable? 🙈🤣
We do have a different ranking BUT! Because your top fave is 3, our number 9 and 3 aligned lol!!
I thought Felicity would rank higher for me for the same reason you love your top 3: saving them from previous owners. I had to overhaul my Felicity too (but maybe not as much as you did yours).
Oh yes your ranking could definitely change. I can’t believe how my opinions did by the time I sat down to do this.
@@DisBlaine oh, no I saw your felicity and she definitely needed more work than mine did, her main problem was she was sort of dirty and she was SO loose her legs were basically hanging off😂 my samantha looked the worst, due to fried hair and nail polish and whatnot all over, but addy has had the most work put in because of trying to preserve her original 90s hair, and adding new wefts to her wig to fill it out again.(finding identical hair to her 90s texture was hard) my samantha still needs a new wig, because this one is still not great, but your "dreamer" samantha is absolutely beautiful! I love how she looks like she's looking up and wistful, mine has a tendency to look down, as she's got a bit of a hunchback. I've yet to figure out how to adjust her stuffing enough to fix that.🤷♀️ but yeah anyone watching your videos can tell Claudie is your favorite 😂 just as anyone who knows me knows my 3 favorites😂 when you love something enough, it shows😂
I can understand your ranking system. I think, of the historicals, I have Kaya, Molly, Felicity, Cecile, and Courtney as they come. I have a modernized Julie (wig swap to something really close), Nanea (really close wig and eye swap), the twins (eye swap on Isabel). One day, I may get Kirsten, not sure.
I have Addy, but she is custom painted and different eyes and wig, so I won't really count her in there. Same with Ivy - wig swap and someone painted lashes on her.
Sold Kit a while ago, as well as Josefina (who did not have her meet outfit). Loving your end dolls all together.
@@DarcysNova626 eye swapped Isabel?? Was she donating them to someone you prefer?? It’s the best thing about her lol.
And….
YOU CUSTOMIZED IVY??? I have to assume you got her at retail ☠️🤣
Or wait you got her that way?
I might eye and wig swap Nanea one day too (if I replace her because mine is… well you saw her lol)
@DisBlaine I bought Ivy and Isabel already customized. A doll friend has the twins without meet clothes at an extremely reasonable price, and she had hand-picked them ($175 shipped for the pair). Ivy, I only know is Ivy since I know what to look for - a customizer was downsizing due to moving, and she was a good price as well($85). I didn't care for the wig she came with, so I found one from my collection.
The historical line has had so many dolls over the years! It’s crazy to see most of them together and compared! I got Isabel on my trip to the store, and I was wondering how she would rank!! 😂😅❤
That’s so crazy that I didn’t realize you don’t own Nellie!! Ruthie is super gorgeous, but I’m trying not to add any more classic molds either!! ❤
@@americangirlfilms you’re a lot more reasonable with your collection. So I know you must really love Isabel! Turns out I love her more than I expected lol. But she is really pretty and unique
I only have Nellie’s meet hat and purse. It was accidentally put in a doll set I bought and it took me a long time to figure out what they were 😆
I have an older PC Samantha and an AG LLC one and they look so different. I think the newer one is prettier but the older one is so unique ya gotta love her.
@@poundcake88 it’s wild how different Samantha looks from doll to doll! There are a couple I have I questioned if she was another doll 😆
Oh I so love our Nanea, so do not worry, we will be giving her all the attention :) We all here completely understand - you are busy to give attention to all and like them all the same, you have quite a few Claudies to look after 😊
@@DollsAllGrown-Up awww that’s good to know - and I still love my Nanea. She’s just… the least loved, okay that sounds even worse 🤣
One day I’ll fix her eyes, and I bet it’ll change a lot. However! It’s always nice to hear other collectors connect so much with dolls I don’t.
josefina at the end is crazy to me!! every other ranking video ive seen shes been near the top
@@kenalueck1811 oh no way! Haha I should’ve added this to my unpopular opinions video 🤣
You can use a bias sorter to help you make your rank list!
@@Emily-oq1on that’s a thing?? Like AI ranking? So funny! Maybe I’ll make a ranking and then use that to see how accurate it is
I haven't watched it all yet but I bet the thing your top dolls have in common is decal brown eyes. I am thinking the top two will be Claudie at 1and Samantha at 2.
@@ladero01 now I’m not saying I’m predictable… so you might in fact be psychic 🤣
@@DisBlaine I forgot Ivy existed.
@ shudder gasp!! Well she is the only historical bff I have, so she might’ve been a sneaky entry
Wow you must be suuuper rich to get ahold of all these AG dolls! So jealous 😂 I had an Addy when I was around 10 years old in the early 90's, eventually got a Kirsten like 8 years later but sadly have sold them. And then two years ago ended up getting a Nanea and Samantha and sold them too 😭😭 Dunno wtf I was thinking cause I can never afford one now. I think my adhd makes me goes through phases cause now I have been obsessively collecting Barbie.
You do not look like you grew up in the 80's at all I thought you were born in '85 like me lol.
@@imperialbeautee wellllll I’ve been collecting dolls so long I often sell off old dolls to pay for new ones. But what I can’t sell off old dolls for? Space! lol.
Awww it sucks that you regret selling your old dolls! I always put dolls away when I’m thinking selling to see if I’ll miss them. You really might find a nice deal one day, so never say never!
Oh yes I look younger than my age I think - I blame doll collecting. It keeps me young 😆
I knew Claudie was going to be #1
@@TeresaMinsinger haha I’m glad I’ve made it obvious 🥳🤣
It's funny cause this is like...the exact same as my list, but reversed. Like I think Nanea and Josefina have by far the prettiest faces and are absolutely going to be my first port of call when and if I ever do manage to get my hands on any of these dolls.
...
And I honestly keep forgetting that Claudie even exists.
@@kayleighbrown459 oh i definitely see why people love Nanea-mine doesn’t have as a nice a face as others, but I’ve seen some really beautiful ones!
Maybe after Claudie has had more time in existence, she’ll grow on you.
Haha first my favorite color and now my historical ranking. It’s fun to know tastes can vary so much!
@@DisBlaine Lol. Yeah. Legit my favourite thing about the doll collecting community objectively subjective everything about it is. Like I might just be lucky but compared to some other communities, there really doesn't seem to be a lot of drama...because how you gonna start drama over little plastic women. There just something so refreshingly superficial about it.
Claudia is my favorite. She has the best combo of cute face hair and meet outfit. I like the newer faces more. Went to a doll show kind of sucks I only found a couple of AG dolls. I like the Nanea face mold it's cute. I would not put her last. I even think Summer is adorable. I just don't like her clothes.
@@iamsoverybored878 truthfully I like the potential of the Nanea mold, but I’ve had to customize the dolls to make myself like them more - and I feel bad because it’s a cute face, so I’m always trying to figure out how to love her lol. One day they’ll make her in a combo I’ll love
Fun video!!
@@steph585 I was in the mood for something light, so I changed my “schedule” to do this one lol
I hope your police case is proceeding fast. Just a thought, Indian food is my favorite and I recently tried goat- and loved it! Have you tried it? Great video ❤❤❤
@@jameshamer481 I haven’t heard back from anyone - not even insurance after filling out my claim!
Oh and my partner is vegetarian (it’s part of his religion), so I don’t really eat meat in Indian cuisine - but sometimes I’ll sneak some chicken! That’s the only meat I really like. I’m actually a very picky eater, so I wouid never eat something as adventurous as goat 😝
Did you ever do Maplelea ranking?
@@QNFirefly no I’ve only started my AG rankings. And I only have 4 Maplelea dolls at the moment lol
@@DisBlaine oh, sort6 that would a too quick video.
Oops I ment sorry that would be a quick video.
@ haha yes and not very interesting. But my deep dive will probably be a good substitute when I get to it
Where did you buy the white wall shelf from?
@@OxChiquitaXo it’s a 5” baseboard 🤣🤣
I couldn’t find a proper shelf the right depth, so I improvised.
@ 🤣 ok thanks
Haha oh no Josephina and Nanea are my favorites 😆 I've not seen a Nanea in person though so that might change my mind on her
@@illyrianya lol I felt so bad talking about the first few dolls, because I only got them because I love them… but not everyone can make the top 5 🥴 I really struggle with Nanea tho because I think I got a bad one.
Gentle little correction at around the 30 minute mark talking about Ivy (gorgeous doll, agreed the eyes and modified sockets,) you mention Anne Frank, but I think you mean Lisa Frank. Lisa Frank is the woman who did the rainbow folder with the dolphins and such. Anne Frank is the 12 year old Jewish girl who wrote a journal in hiding during the Holocaust. ❤
@@happyjollyholly4455 Holly, I was mortified when someone else pointed that out!! I remember panicking I was going to say the wrong one in the moment.
AND I DID 😭
Sometimes when I’m recording my brain moves too fast. I almost deleted this whole video, but no one has been upset about it (so far 👀)
Oooh I’m gonna play the game again (top ten)
1. Claudie (duh)
2. Kaya
3. Addy
4. Cecile
5. Courtney
6. Maryellen
7. Julie (+Ivy)
8. Melody
9. Twins
10. Samantha
Okay time to watch!
@@Emily-oq1on well… you weren’t too far off with some of them. And Claudie at 1 is a gimme 😝
glad nicki is in your top 5
@@AndreaA127 do you love her too? I feel weird ranking a doll who feels so similar to me so high 🥴🤣
@@DisBlaine yes i do love nicki she is the doll i named after my fave singer lol and the freaky part is nicki has my fave singers eye color and face if looked at at diff angles!
@ ohhhh she’s the one you named after her! When I look at Nikki, I think of Lucious Jackson.
Oh Blaine, you are brutal. 😅😢😅
After first four dolls.
Your bottom 10 dolls could almost be my top 10. 😅
@@lisbetsoda4874 ohhhhh haha I wondered what I said that was so brutal. Isn’t that funny? I love to see other collectors have different taste. It shows the line has enough diversity to have a wide appeal. (Did I say something specific that was brutal? I promise I tried to explain that I do love all my dolls, so this was hard)
No, you didn't say anything wrong, honestly. Relax. It just really surprises me when someone has such opposite likes. 😂
@@DisBlaine
I really don’t vibe with Josefina’s eyebrows to be honest. I really don’t know why, but thats the one thing that keeps me from getting her.
@@zoejohnson8411 people don’t talk about that enough! They look brows that were really badly tweezed. Not even 1990s, but 1970s!
My most fave historicals are Addy, Molly, and Courtney. My least fave are Nelly, Emily, and Ruthie.
@@steph585 haha we have the same least faves! I love your faves too of course. But it’s funny your least faves are dolls I have no interest in.
@ I have a hideous Ruthie that has a haircut that I can’t stand. I thought I had to have everyone’s friend but I’m over that. Time for EBay.
@@steph585 oh noooo. Did you buy her that way?
@@DisBlaine sadly yes. The pics were not good and I didn’t know about the haircut. I wasn’t being careful enough.
I'm going to be the annoying commenter I guess. So much to say. 😂 I love all the historicals. I tried to start ranking them overall with all the qualities, but there are too many categories. They are all so special, and I have different connections to each. Some have better stories, some have more unique features but im not sure I can rank them!
@@happyjollyholly4455 that’s what made ranking them so hard! Each doll has different strengths, whether it’s their era, playsets, wardrobe, their face. The doll math I used didn’t make logical sense… but somehow I got the answers!
I don’t recommend it 🤣
I love your collection…. 💕🙏🏼🩷 I definitely like a variety of skin type /hair on my dolls. Otherwise they look all the same to me 🤭🤭how dare I say that ? …. Lol. I’m a New adult collector since August 2024 … started with an eBay reasonably priced Samantha. Since then 4 more new dolls from AG’s online website. Definitely fallen down the rabbit hole 🐇💲🐰💸But I can’t purchase Moana online? ….. they won’t ship the back ordered Moana doll 🇨🇦🇨🇦here for some packaging reason?? Very strange 😮😮
@@beatriz9293 well! Let me tell you something about being a newer collector and not wanting dolls to look alike… as you add more to your collection, the more you see uniqueness in dolls you once thought looked identical. I literally have 33 AND 102 - who was an updated version of 33 🙄🙄 I just made them sisters pahaaaaa
Yeah I don’t know what’s up with Moana not being shipped here! I was able to order to a US address, but I wasn’t expecting that at all
Once you learn something about all the different face molds then you can try to avoid buying the same mold over and over again. I try to get different molds and now I know I lean toward Josefina. I will see a doll I love and then realize: "oh course you love her ,she is Josefina"
Moana is a Corrine mold with extra long evette hair
I think your Nanaea is cute, but her outfit is plain. Maybe a lei? Does Isabella have the same face mold as Nanaea and Claudie? Your Josephina, at least this one doesn't look like Josephina to me. Looks more like maybe Rebecca? Is Leah a historical doll?
@@joymontague251 usually I have Nanea in Maryellen’s current school outfit, but wanted to show her meet for once lol. Mine has a funny face. Maybe if I fix her eyes.
Isabel, Nanea, and Claudie all have different face molds. Josefina and Rebecca have the same mold tho.
I would never get rid of my historical dolls. There would be others that would go first, or wouldn't come to live here. They all have "souls" because they have stories. I haven't got your imagination and some of my other dolls came here mainly for their beauty or for fair representation. All good reasons so we shall see. 😂
@@lisbetsoda4874 hmmm I think my imagination is what gives all my dolls souls. That’s why they can’t picture myself getting rid of any of them. Now I get it!
Get out of here with your Elizabeth despise! 😂😢 (I'm just teasing.) Elizabeth was my very first American girl doll I got at age 5. She was chosen for me by my mom because she looked like me, and so I have developed a strong connection to my Elizabeth. 😅
@@happyjollyholly4455 awwww, it’s the opposite for me. As a kid I wanted dolls who had a different aesthetic from mine (I was blond and blue eyed until I was about 9). And people would want to get me dolls like that 🤣
I looked like Elizabeth too-but with shorter hair lol.
I cannot pick my top historical doll, not even my top ten.
I agree that Marie-Grace and Elizabeth are NOT my favourites, nor is Courtney, or in a way, dare I say it, Caroline. The problem is, i haven't read their books yet, and once I do, they will probably win me over. Except Elizabeth. She was supposed to have brown hair. She is a fraud. 😂 They made her after the Felicity movie came out, and in it, Elizabeth was blonde. How about that!!!
I identify big time with Julie's time period, and fashion, so I like her an awful lot. We are Jewish so I love Rebecca, i have childhood pictures of my mother with braids in the forties so I love Molly.
Caroline is too blond, too blue-eyed, too "pretty" in a very doll-like way. I am a sucker for her time period, the regency era, though. I love the simpler fashions and more modest lives of Addy, Josefina and Kirsten. Some people find them underwhelming; i love their subtlety. And so on, and so on. My least favourite era, fashionwise, is the colonial one. Little girls in dresses much too grown up for them. Too Marie Antoinette for me. But I love that Felicity is a horse girl and her ginger pincurls. Ahh, the dilemmas we have as doll collectors. The twins i didn't want to love - but i actually really do. What gives?
@@lisbetsoda4874 Elizabeth was supposed to be brunette?? That’s so strange!
So do you think Julie and Rebecca might tie for your favorite? Or three way split with Molly lol.
I don’t think it’s strange you don’t like Caroline. Is she really popular? To me she seems as you said too doll like, rather than a genuine historical character.
@DisBlaine According to the books, which I am embarrassed to say, I haven't read. It was all about selling another blond doll, I'm sure. Those books are in general not the higher literature so although I own all the sets of all the old dolls, I never got through them. My daughter read them when she was little, and I read one sporadically here and there but I feel I know their stories even from the old catalogues.
I think that Kirsten also rates really highly, I have her, and Molly and Samantha in white body versions. I love her story of struggles almost as much as Addy's. Too many "Little House on the prairie books as a child, I think. They have always stayed with me. Then there is Kaya, who stands out alone. She and her collection are so spectacular. Hey, I am rambling so much. 🤣
Caroline is too much somehow. Yes. I do think so many collectors like her for the reason that I don't. So pretty, or too pretty, I would say. Her hair is the colour that only young children sometimes have.
I have such strong feelings I need to get my own channel. If only I were better with technology. Sigh.
Nanea, Marie Grace, Maryellen and Samantha are my least favorites. I know you aren’t a Kirsten fan (I have five of them) but she, Claudie and Addy are my favorites. My first doll was Rebecca so she’s special too! Oh and the 70s? Yes very gross. The clothing and colors were horrible!
@@sjordan9586 oh, I actually love Kirsten! With the new limited edition doll, I have 4 of her - but one is a deep TLC, so I’m not sure she’ll be Kirsten in the end.
I wish I could love Nanea more, so I might have to correct her eyes one day. 🥴
Kirsten was my first doll. I don’t own many of her clothes. I modernized her has a child, so I only have 2 outfits, but since gone back to trying to find outfits appropriate for her era. Emily 🥹🥹🥹 she was my second doll and she was my grandmas favorite I have all her outfits but the recital one (cause I love historical characters and her outfits were top tier in my opinion) Nellie was supposed to be my third but I ended up with a TM21 and I had a meltdown (yay asd) and my mom ended up calling AG and buying me Samantha (who I got for my birthday later that year) because Nellie was sold out. I loved the Molly movie so much I asked for Molly for my 15th birthday (that was a special year for me…) but since learned Molly in the books is a giant bully I kinda have mixed feelings. When Beforever came out I quit AG until they brought back Kit for her 100th Birthday. I absolutely love Kit her story is so good (so far) I also love her little face ☺️ I have Melody who I bought for myself for working over all of spring break (so the paycheck paid for her) i was upset when I got her because she was not brand new like the seller had said but @agtakesover fixed her up for me and now I adore her!! I finally found Nellie (TLC) online and I was able to restring her and I love her so much. I really want Ruthie, but I’m upset they her doll incorrectly portrays her character so I’m iffy on that one. I’m buying Claudie for Christmas and I’m so excited for her. 🥹😭 okay sorry rant over.
@@scarletsavenger1367 modernizing Kirsten makes sense. She had a AGOT clone anyway. Sometimes I have trouble telling them apart!
lol you mentioned Emily and I had to look her up. I really do forget about the BF dolls! Her photos are really sweet, but I wish she had a different mold to delineate her from Molly more.
21 is one of my fave TM dolls - I wonder if you’d have liked her better if you weren’t expecting Nellie 🤣
Did you ever get Nellie? I hope after you started collecting again, she was at the top of your list!
@ yes! I finally got Nellie over the summer ☺️💕
@ I really do love my TM 21 now and don’t know what I’d do without her 😂