Sinner Drug Scandal Explained (and why it’s different to the Halep situation)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 гру 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 74

  • @cleonemusician217
    @cleonemusician217 3 місяці тому +15

    General opinion appears to be uninformed of certain legal facts here. Kick a dog when he’s down reveals a highly limited perspective.

    • @andreabonezzi6594
      @andreabonezzi6594 3 місяці тому +3

      kicking a dog when is standing also show a limited perspective

    • @annalax375
      @annalax375 3 місяці тому +1

      I agree. Focus is on low amount. But how is it even possible to get any amount through small wound or skin on feet to blood system and to urine? And when was he tested before Indian Wells? No focus on this very interesting topics. I am very skeptical.

    • @FabioSangiorgi-vu5eg
      @FabioSangiorgi-vu5eg 3 місяці тому +4

      ​@@annalax375This has been thoroughly explained by the experts. If this isn't enough for you then get a degree as a doctor specialised in antidoping and you'll find out yourself.

    • @JamesBaker-n5x
      @JamesBaker-n5x 3 місяці тому

      @cleonemusician217 Sinner says they knew immediately where the contamination came from, how? They had the excuse already prepared! He doped!

    • @FabioSangiorgi-vu5eg
      @FabioSangiorgi-vu5eg 3 місяці тому +1

      @@JamesBaker-n5x sleep well. We are worried about your we'll being. The are more important issues in life to think about.

  • @Zenavesta
    @Zenavesta 3 місяці тому +9

    Explains a lot. However, going with the Simona example, why did they take so long to get back her appeal. She served 18 months before they got back to her. Jannik feels as though they were dealing with this over the phone to how swiftly the back and forth was happeneing

    • @jessadjua
      @jessadjua  3 місяці тому +1

      It’s possibly because it was a different court that made the final decision for Simona and they operate on their own timeframes. If the ITIA had ruled similar to Sinner that Simona’s situation wasn’t intentional in the first place then she may not have needed to wait so long, but that’s my guess

    • @Emmi007s
      @Emmi007s 3 місяці тому +5

      According to some sources, one of the reasons it took so long and couldn't immediately confront the initial claims like Sinner did, is because they couldn't find the source of the contamination. It took a while, the suspension remained and the story broke. Sinner managed in both cases to prove source contamination within a day or 2 and get the suspension lifted. It's terrible how her case was handled, and hopefully Sinner's case will set a precedent that players can be treated more fairly and quickly, rather than asking why his didn't take as long as Halep's.

    • @jessadjua
      @jessadjua  3 місяці тому +3

      @@Emmi007sthank you for this! That would make sense why hers took a long time, I agree it’s good Sinner’s situation was handled quickly and that should be the case for all matters - really unfortunate for Halep

  • @mauyerco
    @mauyerco 3 місяці тому +12

    I'm a chemist and would like to explain that 1 PPB is 1 gram of substance in 1000 Metric Ton of Solvent (One Millions of kilograms!!) .
    We are at the limits of equipments detection.
    No chemical substance has whatever action at this concentration.
    The unequivocal prove that has been a contamination and not intentional doping could be inferred from a previous recent negative analysis before the positive one.

    • @ertugrulsanskopar8248
      @ertugrulsanskopar8248 3 місяці тому +6

      It was an extremely low concentration because most of the substance had left his system

    • @FabioSangiorgi-vu5eg
      @FabioSangiorgi-vu5eg 3 місяці тому +1

      ​@@ertugrulsanskopar8248​@ertugrulsanskopar8248 You know nothing about doping and should shut up and let the experts talk.
      Back off hater.

    • @NN-fw9il
      @NN-fw9il 2 місяці тому

      ​​@@ertugrulsanskopar8248Who're you to infer that??When experts in forensic medicine and sports science have inferred that the dosages are consistent with contamination 🤡🤡.Keep hating.

    • @djo-dji6018
      @djo-dji6018 2 місяці тому

      @@ertugrulsanskopar8248 Prove it.

    • @fanciot
      @fanciot 2 місяці тому

      @@ertugrulsanskopar8248 Your explanation is not confirmed by facts, by Science and by Sinner's Athlete Biological Passport.
      Stay tuned for WADA decisions coming in the next few weeks, and read it all and CAREFULLY

  • @FabioSangiorgi-vu5eg
    @FabioSangiorgi-vu5eg 3 місяці тому +2

    Thanks for your video which sheds some lights on the antidoping issue with real arguments.

  • @thesoccergod
    @thesoccergod 3 місяці тому +3

    A nice succinct explanation! Well done, Ms. Jess! 👏🏾

  • @cleonemusician217
    @cleonemusician217 3 місяці тому +3

    Jess, so value your factual and well-balanced view of this story.

    • @jessadjua
      @jessadjua  3 місяці тому

      Thank you! I appreciate you watching the video

  • @elifed2368
    @elifed2368 3 місяці тому +3

    well explained❤👏👏👏 can i use a link to this video to reply to those who say Halep was the same but treated differently?? Thanks.

    • @jessadjua
      @jessadjua  3 місяці тому

      Thank you and yes of course!

  • @RandomThings1311
    @RandomThings1311 3 місяці тому +13

    So happy that there’s finally someone not slamming sinner for doping or for favouritism. Kyrgios needs to shut up. Very good explanation

    • @Adriana-x8b
      @Adriana-x8b 3 місяці тому +3

      Kyrgios ...nothing

    • @jessadjua
      @jessadjua  3 місяці тому +2

      Thank you for watching!

    • @groupflix
      @groupflix 3 місяці тому +1

      Kyrgios is a has-been mediocre player who is now a side-kick clown. He is jealous.

  • @oscarronca8748
    @oscarronca8748 3 місяці тому +2

    La Halep non e’ riuscita a dimostrare da subito la sua positività’perciò’ e’ stata sospesa informarsi prego

  • @PaukkuLaukku
    @PaukkuLaukku 3 місяці тому +3

    thx this explains a lot!

  • @jamesah-see8939
    @jamesah-see8939 3 місяці тому

    The thing is that it is well known about this product especially in Italy where it is made.. and there has been some study's about this product, they found that the testing of the drug is basically a time thing. So if he put it on yesterday then today it wouldn't show up as much as yesterday.. and the biggest 1 for me is Sinner is the number 1 rank and they should not of let something like this happen.. and do it again ... Not a good look good Sinner 🤔🧐🤫🤐

    • @franzjack
      @franzjack 3 місяці тому +1

      yeah but sinner is tested every week. how it is possible that during a tournament this substance went from top to 1/1000000000 2 times in a week? Is sinner stupid to take it another time after the first test? (this is the real problem with people that are saying he took it for doping)

  • @Brick_Squared
    @Brick_Squared 3 місяці тому

    I'd appeal for return of points and prize money if the decision was successfully appealed; as it was.

  • @kenechukwuejike3590
    @kenechukwuejike3590 3 місяці тому +1

    Thanks for your explanation.❤

  • @art3mide644
    @art3mide644 3 місяці тому

    grazie per divulgare la verità dei fatti.

  • @retyfuller4641
    @retyfuller4641 3 місяці тому

    Well, they hide it for 6 months 😢

    • @franzjack
      @franzjack 3 місяці тому

      they hide the process and it is written in the rules that they will publish only the results so it is all correct. People now are caliming that he is doped, think what cuold happen if it went viral before the sentence. You are innocent until proven guilty. If I had been Sinner I would have already sued half the people in the circus (and lot's of comment online)

    • @billiey36
      @billiey36 3 місяці тому

      The investigation is always kept quiet until a ruling is made. That's the same rule for everybody. The reason Halep's came out is because she couldn't identify the source so she was banned and that became obvious to everyone. Sinner's ban was lifted before anybody noticed because he could identify the source immediately. By the way, the ATP had nothing to do with this. It doesn't handle doping allegations, so don't try to say they were covering it up. They didn't know about it.

  • @Adriana-x8b
    @Adriana-x8b 3 місяці тому +2

    Different situations.Jannik must to be strong and to play amazing, as always.😊❤

    • @5eul
      @5eul 3 місяці тому

      Again same bot😂

    • @Adriana-x8b
      @Adriana-x8b 3 місяці тому +1

      @@5eulThe expert...ha,ha,ha🤣🤣😂

  • @JH-bb8in
    @JH-bb8in 3 місяці тому

    They should test Novax instead since he's been doping since 2011, I mean "gluten free"

  • @jove6407
    @jove6407 3 місяці тому +6

    Why did Sinner accept the loss of ranking points and $$$ if he supposedly did nothing wrong? Makes no sense. He should be banned 2 years minimum. Drug Cheater

    • @FabioSangiorgi-vu5eg
      @FabioSangiorgi-vu5eg 3 місяці тому +2

      You spread misinformation.
      The rule states that even athletes who are found totally innocent must be deducted points and prize money related to the tournament where detection was carried out.
      Is the rule fair? In.my.mind it's not and it doesn't make any sense but this is the current rule.
      What goes around comes around. You will find yourself accused of being a cheater and it won't matter you be totally innocent.

    • @billiey36
      @billiey36 3 місяці тому +3

      He didn't. It's being appealed. It's true it makes no sense to admit someone is innocent and punish them anyway, but don't blame him for that rule.

  • @tops2934
    @tops2934 3 місяці тому +1

    my guess is Sinner was using some drugs, some time has passed and small part of these drugs remained in his body now his team came up with this excuse, i'm sure every top player is doping so shaming Sinner sound ridiculous to me

    • @FabioSangiorgi-vu5eg
      @FabioSangiorgi-vu5eg 3 місяці тому +1

      Oy yeah, and you sound even more ridiculous.
      Back off hater.

    • @billiey36
      @billiey36 3 місяці тому +3

      Except the positive tests were 8 days apart during the time frame when his physio was treating a wound. There have been no positive tests before or since that one short stretch. So your guess is simply a projection of whatever you want the scenario to be. You haven't said anything about the case because you don't seem to know anything, but you have said a lot about yourself.

  • @lesliepropheter5040
    @lesliepropheter5040 2 місяці тому

    NO

  • @aniteivera695
    @aniteivera695 3 місяці тому +1

    Remember Halep ?
    Shame on duble standards !

  • @michaeloban8208
    @michaeloban8208 3 місяці тому +1

    A ban would have been in order. Ultimately athletes are responsible for what goes into their system. It's not unfair to conclude that Sinner's doping. All bad for tennis's credibility!!
    Zero tolerance must be maintained.

  • @trisisi69
    @trisisi69 3 місяці тому +1

    As an athlete you are responsible of what gets into your body. Same with your whole team surrounding you. I wonder what the consequences, reports would be like if the very same amount and the very same steroid was found in Novak´s, Danil´s or Andy´s body. He picked with Naldi someone who already doped basketball players what led to bans for the teams in Italy. It is very obvious he started to become more dominant at some point and had more "power". He cheated and should be banned for 2 years as Nick Kirgious rightfully said. Sinner has lost all respect among true sportsmanship celebrating fans and also players on the tour. Novak said it diplomatically but all others I heard where more like "only Yannik and his team know the truth and what happened". Also totally understandable how other lower ranked players are complaining over different treatment by the board and decision makers.

    • @billiey36
      @billiey36 3 місяці тому +3

      What are your credentials and when did you see the evidence? Learn that your opinions are not facts without proof just because you think so highly of yourself. You wreak of jealousy. Anyone who states what someone else is thinking or feeling without even knowing them personally is a joke. 🤡

  • @JamesBaker-n5x
    @JamesBaker-n5x 3 місяці тому +2

    Are you paid by the ATP? massage just a story and nothing else just a story. He doped!

    • @user-wd7ue1wd6r
      @user-wd7ue1wd6r 3 місяці тому +2

      Exactly. I don't understand how these guys are covering up double standards 🤔

    • @FabioSangiorgi-vu5eg
      @FabioSangiorgi-vu5eg 3 місяці тому +2

      Back off haters.
      Try harder next time.

    • @art3mide644
      @art3mide644 3 місяці тому

      keep crying, hater,

  • @blackgruya011
    @blackgruya011 3 місяці тому +4

    Nothing to explain, he is drug positive, period. 2 years suspension, same as for others. Fact that ALL was hiddem from public since March tells everything

    • @IvanSpaziano-ko5cv
      @IvanSpaziano-ko5cv 3 місяці тому +2

      Nole is 37 goes for 38, come on, it's over. Propably another year

    • @MarinolaTorre
      @MarinolaTorre 3 місяці тому +6

      Great comment to make under a video that explains exactly the opposite 👏

    • @oscarronca8748
      @oscarronca8748 3 місяці тому

      Tu devi essere rinchiuso per le cazzate che dici, ogni situazione e’ diversa

    • @FabioSangiorgi-vu5eg
      @FabioSangiorgi-vu5eg 3 місяці тому +1

      Nothing to explain, you should be banned for life from all social media.
      Back off hater.

    • @isabellasmith8377
      @isabellasmith8377 3 місяці тому +3

      Ignorant opinion