Its a shameful day for Indian democracy. All hell breaks loose with going to an extent of banning visas because Canada accused India and didn't provide evidence. But when Indian government raids and arrests its own journalists without any evidence, there is dead silence in the public. 😔
Public , the mass billions doesn't care n least bothered and don't watch news as they are busy with day to day work. I am talking about common citizens of india.
Singham has been exposed even in left media NewYorkTimes report which clearly states Newsclick was funded by China through Singham! China tries to drive narrative through media n NGO’s around the world including US according to that report!
@@mg.f.9023 Rafale scam, 2G scam, Robert Vadra scam, Adarsh housing scam, MNREGA scam, commonwealth scam.. atleast now we can have defence deals for aircraft’s, drones, submarines , 4G,5G, G20 etc without scams! Congress has set the bar so low! What about Lalu PRASAD of India alliance? He has been found GUILTY in many cases! Ajit pawar at is under ED lens but let’s wait n watch if he is pronounced guilty.
Singham has been exposed even in left media NewYorkTimes report which clearly states Newsclick was funded by China through Singham! China tries to drive narrative through media n NGO’s around the world including US according to that report!
The nation that neglects social inequality, internal contradictions, mischievously increases military budgets, and then uses its power internally to suppress the citizens on the pretext of threat by an external enemy is on the road to extinction. - Yang Wen-li (Legend of the Galactic Heroes)
Karan sir unfortunately voters have chosen a swagger,liar,pretentious marketing based PM who is cruel equally to strangulate his own people.god save the nation from monster.
Extremely meaningful analysis of the matter under deliberation .Your meaningful and fearless journalism with substance allways enlighten me and your viewer's with truth as usual .many thanks .satyamev jayate .jai hind .
@@samyvik2888RSS is founded on the basis of FASCISM. Even their uniform is the same as Mussuloni's army.Hitler had one GOEBBELS , JHUTLER has countless.
@@vargheseb8602Every disciplined org has a uniform to indicate that everyone in that group is equal - according to your your judgement every school is a fascist supporter?? ridiculous assumption. In anycase, RSS is a social service org. Some of the policies are a reaction to abrahamic faiths - Islam believes non-muslims must be coerced, converted, taxed (jaziya) or economically boycotted (halal) or killed while Christianity believes that non-christians are uncivilized and need to be coerced & converted. So, someone needs to organized against these barbarian invaders who talk 'secularism' but believe that their is no god except their own. Either they understand that god is man's invention and stop converting & killing others or they probably have no place in India.
If any person can be put in Jail without having any proof against him, then obviously it is NOT a system of Justice but a very bad system of INJUSTICE .
Any charges have to be proved in court as soon as possible. It cannot be that a person is arrested for life long but case is never heard or proved in court.
All those Officers , who have acted unlawfully against journalists,should be given harsh punishment. It’s shameless behaviour on their part.They are acting against the people of India, whom they are supposed to provide security. Wish all those acting against the people are severely punished.
We want karan sir to bring out the true nature of some corrupt organisations who wrongly misinterpret innocent citizens. It's time we the people of India realize the need of a stable government who work for the people.
Singham has been exposed even in left media NewYorkTimes report which clearly states Newsclick was funded by China through Singham! China tries to drive narrative through media n NGO’s around the world including US according to that report!
Superb!! interview Karan Sir & Ram Sir. 🇮🇳🍃 FREE PRESS must be protected at all cost. INDIA🇮🇳 must be protected from the dangers of the tsunami that is inching closer by the day...People of INDIA must stand in solidarity with Honorable 🍃Journalists/FREE PRESS. Thank you, both. 🙏
These raids etc.... are just a boo boo bhooth hoon kind of frightening tatics to shoo away small utubers and small journalists who have of late become very very effective in reaching out and touching the pulse of the common man.
Modi is running scared. That is why he is cracking down on those that are critical of the government. It is appalling. Yet at the same time, it gives me hope that the BJP are worried about the coming election. Maybe the people are opening their eyes.
You don’t have editors of that stature- sad truth. Which is why this is worse than the emergency, with large media in Modi’s lap unlike in Indira’s during the emergency
Earpier we heard that PM care fund wlhad close to 10000 crore funds received which was a private trust and not a govt fund account. If so, the funds received were true and from Chinese companies. If true Does that account to booking the custodians in the same sections of IPC as these journalist are booked. Durig 2021 . This case was in all social media.
Won’t the writers have copyright over their research and development of articles? Taking them away without permission could be a criminal offence. The Supreme courts and legal system is being challenged by unethical people.
The media wields the power to set agendas and frame narratives, exerting a significant influence on public opinion. The stories covered, the language used, and the perspectives highlighted all contribute to shaping the public discourse. In the Indian context, the media plays a critical role in democracy as the Fourth Estate, acting as a watchdog over the government and institutions. It holds the power to expose corruption, raise awareness about social issues, and advocate for change. Yet, this power comes with great responsibility. Upholding journalistic ethics and standards is crucial to ensure that media acts as a reliable source of information, fostering transparency and accountability. However, journalism in India faces several challenges. Political interference, media ownership issues, and threats to journalist safety pose significant hurdles in maintaining a free and unbiased press. The rise of fake news and misinformation further complicates the landscape, eroding public trust and fueling divisive narratives.
Fruitfully insightful facts, Mr. Baqir, however, I'm afraid to say that the mainstream journalism in our country is long dead. We're at the crossroad now and I hope we turn towards democracy and block the path of dictatorship once and for all. Only this will save our country from an obvious civil war. People of India, please be wise.
It's time we build a physical monument that marks permanent defiance to RSS/BJP mentality. You can't argue/denigrate a lifeless entity. Symbolism is boring and unhelpful when it comes to anti-communal discourse. BJP has purposefully blurred words like India, culture, nationalism, good, bad.
The power from almost all the institutions when combined together is concentrated at a certain place under a certain control, it threatens even the existence of life and the country as a whole making it alarming and if there is no authority to control it , it may go to any extent for retaining power for being in deep love with power.
It is very disturbing to hear this interview. Things are going out of hand in this country of ours. We are in an extended undeclared ‘Emergency’ without any time frame along with majoritarianism. When will the common man step out of his/her cosy homes when we are losing our freedom abruptly.
Common man ie common citizens of India doesn't live in cosy homes. And they don't watch news either because they are so busy with their day to day work to take care of their families. If you want you can complain this to upper middle class people who live cosy n luxury houses and take their support to raise the issue.
Thank you for the reminder. It proves that my comment has reached those who watched this interview and react in different ways. Of course there are others who may not be part of this. I think even they have a say in a democracy. There may be others who may have an access to them. In fact I too consider myself as one from lower middle class and have some knowledge of the language we are communicating with. With appreciation.
I found the second charge very odd. China released map with arunachal pradesh as part of it. Pakistan and china shows parts of Kashmir as part of Pakistan. How is reporting about it a crime? The question should be to China. Not reporters.
Government is ABSOLUTELY RIGHT. All anti India activities must be dealt with strongly. Media is no God and if media does illegal and anti India activities it must face the music and must not play victim card.
Singham is funding left oriented and progressive ideology across the globe, including America. Singham is an American citizen and an NRI. America has not imposed any restrictions on Singham's organization. though Singham is funding left ideology. Legally operating company in America. But Mauritius has closed Chang Chung-Ling shell company categorizing under terror funding organization. Chan is a chinese funded Adani through shell companies in Mauritius. After taking money from China, Adani and Ambani channels supporting China occupying Arunachal Pradesh. This is in fact anti national and sabotaging the country for self gains. Godi anchors can be prosecuted for this sabotage.
करण, मैं आपकी बहस का प्रशंसक हूं लेकिन अधिकांश दर्शक अशिक्षित हैं और वे आपकी शुद्ध अंग्रेजी नहीं समझते हैं। मैं आपसे अनुरोध करूंगा कि कृपया हिंदी में एक उपशीर्षक बनाएं ताकि गरीब लोग समझ सकें। मोदी ने पढ़े-लिखे लोगों को भी ऐसी मोगली घुट्टी पिलाई है कि वे उनकी तारीफ किए बिना नहीं रह पा रहे हैं.
Its a shameful day for Indian democracy. All hell breaks loose with going to an extent of banning visas because Canada accused India and didn't provide evidence. But when Indian government raids and arrests its own journalists without any evidence, there is dead silence in the public. 😔
Public , the mass billions doesn't care n least bothered and don't watch news as they are busy with day to day work.
I am talking about common citizens of india.
Indian public very well know Karan & Ram and who they side with
@@unnikrishnac3989 Who's side?
@@bha029lapdogs of China nd ISI
@@Athirahindustani So is PM Modi and Adani.
We are dealing with a Megalomaniac as a leader. Hope Indians realize this sooner than its too late for the country.
Singham has been exposed even in left media NewYorkTimes report which clearly states Newsclick was funded by China through Singham! China tries to drive narrative through media n NGO’s around the world including US according to that report!
He is correct against u corrupted pple
@@cenadg9714
Ajit Pawar?
It will be called 2nd freedom for Indians where few have been sacrificed and jailed to get the same.
@@mg.f.9023 Rafale scam, 2G scam, Robert Vadra scam, Adarsh housing scam, MNREGA scam, commonwealth scam.. atleast now we can have defence deals for aircraft’s, drones, submarines , 4G,5G, G20 etc without scams! Congress has set the bar so low! What about Lalu PRASAD of India alliance? He has been found GUILTY in many cases! Ajit pawar at is under ED lens but let’s wait n watch if he is pronounced guilty.
Karan asked questions earlier in the day to Bura also. N. Ram is more direct and clear in his answers.
True...
This is a frank, revealing, informative and gutsy discussion. Well done.
Modi got nervous for the upcoming Lok Sabha election.
.... going berserk.
It is time to pull this govt down
Things are getting too far
@@pc64667 Our dreams will hopefully turn out to be your living nightmares. :)
Who ? People need involve … in this high level propaganda does people get truth ?!
Hey israeli this India
Excellent discussion. The attack on journalists is strongly condemned and it shows Modi's fear of election. Shame on the Government.
😂😂😂😂
Very true bro
Then start the condemnation with Arnab, following by the ban of journalists by I.N.D.I.A….!! Don’t be selective.
Singham has been exposed even in left media NewYorkTimes report which clearly states Newsclick was funded by China through Singham! China tries to drive narrative through media n NGO’s around the world including US according to that report!
@@hellshighway4u Modi bhagwan hai
How far and low this regime will go. Save press, save democracy.
The nation that neglects social inequality, internal contradictions, mischievously increases military budgets, and then uses its power internally to suppress the citizens on the pretext of threat by an external enemy is on the road to extinction.
- Yang Wen-li (Legend of the Galactic Heroes)
Karan sir unfortunately voters have chosen a swagger,liar,pretentious marketing based PM who is cruel equally to strangulate his own people.god save the nation from monster.
Sir, you seems to be from South. Am I right...?
🤣🤣🤣
Kashmiri i m thrown out by Mughals not Muslims who were basically Brahmins
@@revolutionary5577 he is, he talks sense, not blind like the revolutionary ( what revolution i wonder you lead)
@@lisaac4898😂😂 good one
Wonderful interview to highlight the present situation concerning Newsclick. Thank you so much Karan and N Ram
God save India from this dictator!!
God save India from your kind.
@@knc2111 what kind exactly?
@@huithuThe kind who think Modi is a dictator and the great dynasty who have ruled India for decades can be a saviour
@@huithu Because they think India is still a monarchy.
Extremely meaningful analysis of the matter under deliberation .Your meaningful and fearless journalism with substance allways enlighten me and your viewer's with truth as usual .many thanks .satyamev jayate .jai hind .
Let’s hope the journalists take to the courts. The police deserve strictures for their conduct.
These journalists can be jailed without trial for many years.
Ref.Gulab,whose mindset reflect his uncultured mind set.These tribe will pull download the freedom of spirit of the country's.
It's the sign of fascism
do you know what fascism means?
@@samyvik2888do you think we are too naive and stupid to not know the early symptom of fascism?
@@samyvik2888RSS is founded on the basis of FASCISM. Even their uniform is the same as Mussuloni's army.Hitler had one GOEBBELS , JHUTLER has countless.
@@vargheseb8602Every disciplined org has a uniform to indicate that everyone in that group is equal - according to your your judgement every school is a fascist supporter?? ridiculous assumption. In anycase, RSS is a social service org. Some of the policies are a reaction to abrahamic faiths - Islam believes non-muslims must be coerced, converted, taxed (jaziya) or economically boycotted (halal) or killed while Christianity believes that non-christians are uncivilized and need to be coerced & converted. So, someone needs to organized against these barbarian invaders who talk 'secularism' but believe that their is no god except their own. Either they understand that god is man's invention and stop converting & killing others or they probably have no place in India.
If any person can be put in Jail without having any proof against him, then obviously it is NOT a system of Justice but a very bad system of INJUSTICE .
The painful irony for Arnabs arrest there was special court sitting and he was released ,same day. He runs Republic TV owned by bjp minister.
Any charges have to be proved in court as soon as possible. It cannot be that a person is arrested for life long but case is never heard or proved in court.
Those arrested can be jailed for few years for nothing. That's the whole idea.
Yes, you are right. Then this is NOT a system of Justice but a very bad system of *INJUSTICE* . @@gulabh
what planet are you living on
???? @@fsckool6894
That is not the same under UAPA.
We are facing the worst governance since 1947. The most insensitive, corrupt communal and authoritarian regime we ever had.
Noren received chinese funds in his Pm care fund and that is why he refused to disclose the name of the contributers.
Very True Sir 💯
All those Officers , who have acted unlawfully against journalists,should be given harsh punishment. It’s shameless behaviour on their part.They are acting against the people of India, whom they are supposed to provide security. Wish all those acting against the people are severely punished.
We want karan sir to bring out the true nature of some corrupt organisations who wrongly misinterpret innocent citizens. It's time we the people of India realize the need of a stable government who work for the people.
Sure He'll
Singham has been exposed even in left media NewYorkTimes report which clearly states Newsclick was funded by China through Singham! China tries to drive narrative through media n NGO’s around the world including US according to that report!
Kachua = tortoise😅😅😅😅
Superb!! interview Karan Sir & Ram Sir. 🇮🇳🍃 FREE PRESS must be protected at all cost. INDIA🇮🇳 must be protected from the dangers of the tsunami that is inching closer by the day...People of INDIA must stand in solidarity with Honorable 🍃Journalists/FREE PRESS. Thank you, both. 🙏
Your. Always awesome karan sir. Salute to your journalism❤❤❤❤
Excellent talk। Yourjournalism means awful lot to us Karan.
Thanks for this excellent discussion !! 👍
Thank you Karan for inviting Sh. N. Ram, such an incredibly credible person who enlightened us on the matter.
N Ram is a genuine person.....his views are worth listening unlike your previous interview...with that individual who back stabbed Dr Manmohan Singh
Indeed enjoyable and exciting. Always waiting for your broadcast
Thanks!
These raids etc.... are just a boo boo bhooth hoon kind of frightening tatics to shoo away small utubers and small journalists who have of late become very very effective in reaching out and touching the pulse of the common man.
Great analysis.
India must wake up soon
Its time citizens understand that Modiji doesn't need Parliament and judiciary to run the country as Law is what BJP leaders say or do.
Earlier journalism was a passion now it has become purely business, profit ,glamour, salary, lack of morality,.
People should only watch true media like ANI, Aaj Tak, Republic TV, ZEE News
Modi is running scared. That is why he is cracking down on those that are critical of the government. It is appalling.
Yet at the same time, it gives me hope that the BJP are worried about the coming election. Maybe the people are opening their eyes.
Very impressive discussion🎉
You don’t have editors of that stature- sad truth. Which is why this is worse than the emergency, with large media in Modi’s lap unlike in Indira’s during the emergency
Karan Thapar is no editor or journalist. He is a joker who long lost any trace of integrity of character. Please keep yourself safe in the emergency😂😂
Plz raise voice for those innocent people too languishing in lock up and jail for speaking against this govt from 2014 afterwards.
Sad days for Democracy
Earpier we heard that PM care fund wlhad close to 10000 crore funds received which was a private trust and not a govt fund account. If so, the funds received were true and from Chinese companies. If true Does that account to booking the custodians in the same sections of IPC as these journalist are booked.
Durig 2021 . This case was in all social media.
From the charges it seems that Newsclick is paying the price for talking against Adani.
Won’t the writers have copyright over their research and development of articles? Taking them away without permission could be a criminal offence.
The Supreme courts and legal system is being challenged by unethical people.
Good conversation. Thank you
Won't the ED clone the laptops of the accused like they did in Stan Swamy? Possibility?
Those arrested can be jailed for few years for nothing. That's the whole idea.
Only solution is to vote any govt out who behaves like this. No other way.
Views of a great journalist and former Chief of The Hindu are absolutely correct and carry logical weight. Thanks
Last days of Modi!!!!!!!
Very good interview 👍👍
Karan,I love your interviews.I hope the messages come out of your portal. Is well receive by all concerns.
Excellent talk 👍thank you
Thanks
Modi satta pe kabza kiye hain... At least that's how he behaves. So we are not sure how much of loktantra remains in India.
Delighted to see these buggers struggling to defend, one the Newyork times and the other Roy Singham :)
Excellent Message Sir #Karan Ji👍💯🙏
People can go to the steepest low as if it's Do or Die. Once you lose power so many skeletons will tumble out of the cupboard.
Interesting, I guess this would be the first joint venture between the NYT & the government of India.
Very candid discussion
We are always with neutral and intellectual media and Karan Thapar.❤😂🎉😢😮😅😊.
Worst days are yet to come
Thanks sir, for all your efforts.
Journalism shall maintain balance between good and bad. It should not be one sided
Newest low!
Excellent engrossing interview exposing the government who is going downhill day by day due to lack of education/knowledge.
It’s emergency CJI shud intervene and stop this. Unless Modi has threatened him also with impeachment
Modi will not threaten him... Modi will just give him a carrot for a RAJ SABAH seat ... and PURCHASE him 🐷🐷🐷
Well the BJ party IT Cell is threatening him and abusing him.
We are fortunate to have brave hearts like you
The media wields the power to set agendas and frame narratives, exerting a significant influence on public opinion. The stories covered, the language used, and the perspectives highlighted all contribute to shaping the public discourse. In the Indian context, the media plays a critical role in democracy as the Fourth Estate, acting as a watchdog over the government and institutions. It holds the power to expose corruption, raise awareness about social issues, and advocate for change. Yet, this power comes with great responsibility. Upholding journalistic ethics and standards is crucial to ensure that media acts as a reliable source of information, fostering transparency and accountability. However, journalism in India faces several challenges. Political interference, media ownership issues, and threats to journalist safety pose significant hurdles in maintaining a free and unbiased press. The rise of fake news and misinformation further complicates the landscape, eroding public trust and fueling divisive narratives.
Fruitfully insightful facts, Mr. Baqir, however, I'm afraid to say that the mainstream journalism in our country is long dead. We're at the crossroad now and I hope we turn towards democracy and block the path of dictatorship once and for all. Only this will save our country from an obvious civil war. People of India, please be wise.
@@imadahmed3124 I agree with you, let us hope that the BJP and PM Modi are defeated in the next election.
Modi days r over
Go ahea,whole India is with you all,Deshbhakts
It's time we build a physical monument that marks permanent defiance to RSS/BJP mentality.
You can't argue/denigrate a lifeless entity. Symbolism is boring and unhelpful when it comes to anti-communal discourse.
BJP has purposefully blurred words like India, culture, nationalism, good, bad.
Modi ko phir se pani pilao aap 😂😂😂😂😂💪💪
👌🏻👌🏻😁
😂😂😂😂 Modi he Bai 2024 phir modi ji win
Unko ab thak galaa se nahi unthra. Uske aaj tha ek bhi interview danaka dham nahi hai. 56 inches of bhusa.
Just because N Ram knows Singam does not mean he can not be involved in crime or criminal activity
Ob the other hand...
Make police , ED , CBI free from government by judicial control over them.
Karan Sir, I always enjoy your interviews. ❤❤❤
If this is the biggest democracy in the world...😂😂😂
😂
Illiterates ke lia ye data is of no significance hoping that CJI take adequate steps to put a check on a berserk party gone amok
Ram is actually a Ravan
India is in complete chaos. People of this country only can save this from the mess.
Taking money from 'peoples republic' is not crime. It helps democracy
The power from almost all the institutions when combined together is concentrated at a certain place under a certain control, it threatens even the existence of life and the country as a whole making it alarming and if there is no authority to control it , it may go to any extent for retaining power for being in deep love with power.
PM Cares received Chinese funding too, so..
Karan Thapar sir❤️
So Alarming. Bad to Worst Days ahead if not checked.
It is very disturbing to hear this interview. Things are going out of hand in this country of ours. We are in an extended undeclared ‘Emergency’ without any time frame along with majoritarianism. When will the common man step out of his/her cosy homes when we are losing our freedom abruptly.
Common man ie common citizens of India doesn't live in cosy homes.
And they don't watch news either because they are so busy with their day to day work to take care of their families.
If you want you can complain this to upper middle class people who live cosy n luxury houses and take their support to raise the issue.
Thank you for the reminder. It proves that my comment has reached those who watched this interview and react in different ways.
Of course there are others who may not be part of this. I think even they have a say in a democracy. There may be others who may have an access to them. In fact I too consider myself as one from lower middle class and have some knowledge of the language we are communicating with. With appreciation.
I request M/S Gulab shuld educate himself.Even @my 86yrs,I am trying upgrade my self.
Very worrisome situation but together we can win when we are on the right side of the fence!
Threatening national interests
Modi getting afraid, his end is coming😂
Very True Sir 💯
It's foolish on the part of... to consider Ram's certificate to Singham in this matter
Truth will come out soon and we all will know about Singham and his team of foreign payments received.
It seems to be purely an idea of diverting Manipur issues...
I found the second charge very odd. China released map with arunachal pradesh as part of it. Pakistan and china shows parts of Kashmir as part of Pakistan. How is reporting about it a crime? The question should be to China. Not reporters.
This time around it’s all wrongly wired and bad connections made and it’s fuse is blown for the US Singam and Team.
Good interview that explains “ China” connection well
The China connection by multitude of Chinese made phones used in India?
📜🕊️GREETINGS🕊️📜
Corrupt journalists should be arrested and punished they are not above the law
MP Brij Bushan certainly is 😂
Government is ABSOLUTELY RIGHT. All anti India activities must be dealt with strongly. Media is no God and if media does illegal and anti India activities it must face the music and must not play victim card.
The Godi Media.
Any media is better than anti India media who sell their own country and mother for money😂😂
Covering the farmers' protest, covid hardships are not anti national
ANYONE WITH THE CHINESE SHOULD BE INVESTIGATED.
Even in this Modi copies Indira Gandhi,no original thought in his head.
Singham is funding left oriented and progressive ideology across the globe, including America. Singham is an American citizen and an NRI. America has not imposed any restrictions on Singham's organization. though Singham is funding left ideology. Legally operating company in America.
But Mauritius has closed Chang Chung-Ling shell company categorizing under terror funding organization. Chan is a chinese funded Adani through shell companies in Mauritius. After taking money from China, Adani and Ambani channels supporting China occupying Arunachal Pradesh. This is in fact anti national and sabotaging the country for self gains. Godi anchors can be prosecuted for this sabotage.
करण, मैं आपकी बहस का प्रशंसक हूं लेकिन अधिकांश दर्शक अशिक्षित हैं और वे आपकी शुद्ध अंग्रेजी नहीं समझते हैं। मैं आपसे अनुरोध करूंगा कि कृपया हिंदी में एक उपशीर्षक बनाएं ताकि गरीब लोग समझ सकें। मोदी ने पढ़े-लिखे लोगों को भी ऐसी मोगली घुट्टी पिलाई है कि वे उनकी तारीफ किए बिना नहीं रह पा रहे हैं.