MTG Goldfish VS Cardmarket | BATTLE OF THE CHANNELS with

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 635

  • @CardmarketMagic
    @CardmarketMagic  Рік тому +53

    Decklists: bit.ly/3Qpnv4H

  • @MrClaymore152
    @MrClaymore152 Рік тому +937

    I love how Seth was just having fun playing Shandalar while Carl was doing broken speed run strats

    • @DeeGeeG
      @DeeGeeG Рік тому +57

      Sums up the 2 channels. Jk love both yall

    • @bardunshield
      @bardunshield Рік тому +142

      Rumor has it Seth is still playing Shandalar to this day.

    • @Marksmaan
      @Marksmaan Рік тому +33

      It's funny, but also kinda... meh. Would've been OK if Carl just knew the strats, but asking for help. And he picked the challenge. Idk. The whole thing wasn't serious so it's no big deal. Just kinda harmed my enjoyment.

    • @outputcoupler7819
      @outputcoupler7819 Рік тому +1

      Shandalar is fantastic, strongly recommend giving it a go if you haven't played it before. It's pretty easy to find for free since it's abandonware.

    • @chebi97
      @chebi97 Рік тому +41

      @@Marksmaan dude you can look that up faster than the guy in the phone told it. But also its as you said not a serious competition, it's more about having fun and it's good entertainment showing how they both approached the challenge differently.
      But also, look at the Cardmakret deck.. It was definitely more focused and built around the 2v2

  • @ursulcx299
    @ursulcx299 Рік тому +673

    Seth as a Fallout-esque AI robot is what really ties up this Thumbnail.

    • @cuddlequeen3225
      @cuddlequeen3225 Рік тому

      Tru dat

    • @damianosollazzo5747
      @damianosollazzo5747 Рік тому +3

      It also suits saffron's character. I totally expect him to play Mr. house in Fallout Commander

    • @andrewsparkes6275
      @andrewsparkes6275 Рік тому

      Does he ever leave his house??

    • @frenche2480
      @frenche2480 11 місяців тому +1

      ​@@andrewsparkes6275 I was about to ask the same question, his always playing via screens, someone knows anything ? Maybe he has a condition:/ or just he lives super far away 😂

  • @jshavluk4342
    @jshavluk4342 Рік тому +344

    "it's finally my turn, I've waited an hour for this."
    No truer words said during a Commander game

    • @galina5517c
      @galina5517c Рік тому +5

      Ygo players be like

    • @obsidiansiriusblackheart
      @obsidiansiriusblackheart Рік тому +3

      Me, a mono red burn deck against 3 Simic landfall decks

    • @Squagglimole
      @Squagglimole 10 місяців тому

      Honestly, that's why I nudged my playgroup to play faster.
      Plan your turn BEFORE it's your turn. If things change, tough luck, but you will still play much faster
      There's also an app called Commander Clock - have people time their turns like in chess - they will speed up their turns on their own, when they realize they take longer than the other players - trust me - I've been organizing playgroups for 15+ years - often people don't realize they're stopping the flow of the game, or that they even take long
      Another thing I love doing is if you have an even number of players in your group, just make two-headed giant teams,
      so 2 people always share when they have their turn. Literally doubles the playspeed, so 6 ppl feels like the game speed of 3 people.
      This is a HUGE time saver - 6+ players is almost unplayable in EDH, and I always HATED telling people "Na, sorry - we're already too many people" - this way, it doesn't feel like that many people
      If I have an uneven number of players I like doing some version of a Penta, so everyone only has to kill a few people to win.
      It's not perfect, but it makes it a little faster, and gives people a clear enemy, which also saves them a lot of thinking on assessment. Also ofc it helps balance 3-player games.

  • @bryanstokke6566
    @bryanstokke6566 Рік тому +402

    10/10 crossover. Exactly the goofy cringy competitive content I came here for.

  • @SpizzyRich
    @SpizzyRich Рік тому +374

    Blind shot for a colossal dreadmaw was pretty hilarious. 8:36

  • @lolfunne
    @lolfunne Рік тому +142

    my favorite part of this was Seth not knowing how to speedrun Shandalar and just having fun instead

  • @54regas
    @54regas Рік тому +32

    22:43 was peak humor "Oh yeah, it was Onmath, of course!" And the "it was Narset" almost killed me

  • @noahmorris1015
    @noahmorris1015 Рік тому +184

    i've been absolutely pumped for this ever since the community poll! the attempts at trash talk, the 2HG format, the seth being zoomed in, this is literally perfect.

  • @christiangonzalez2830
    @christiangonzalez2830 Рік тому +161

    You guys have some of the most creative MTG content on youtube. Much love from the US

    • @CardmarketMagic
      @CardmarketMagic  Рік тому +25

      That's very kind of you to say! Thank you so much :)

  • @LaserfaceJones
    @LaserfaceJones Рік тому +100

    Tomer immediately apologizing was perfect

  • @idioticavocado9333
    @idioticavocado9333 Рік тому +66

    Judge! My opponent got outside assistance for their outside assitance 😂

  • @Rayan01012
    @Rayan01012 Рік тому +199

    A bigger crossover than Endgame

  • @PraetorGix
    @PraetorGix Рік тому +27

    LOL the whole concept was super fun but the Shandalar surprise challenge was the best. I loved how Seth was pleasantly surprised by the game and the speedrun strat from Frank was top notch. I have Shandalar installed on my PC and I'm absolutely stealing that method for a playthrough!

  • @throwawwy53
    @throwawwy53 Рік тому +32

    the challenges seemed silly at first but Carl busting out the Shandalar Shivan Speedrun strats was top notch work

  • @pinobluevogel6458
    @pinobluevogel6458 Рік тому +39

    Okay that was a lot of fun. Can't lie, I'm not a commander player or a two-headed dragon player, but you guys made something hilarious out of it, enjoyed every second, down to the cheesy playground insults.
    Thanks guys!

  • @Erik_Sjostrom
    @Erik_Sjostrom Рік тому +144

    I really hope that this is another episode of brewer’s kitchen by Phil

    • @CardmarketMagic
      @CardmarketMagic  Рік тому +118

      We recorded a bunch of other content with them :) Including some stuff where Phil goes "Mad Genius" on us a little 😅

    • @GrasenGM
      @GrasenGM Рік тому +11

      @@CardmarketMagic NICE!!!

  • @KKDT
    @KKDT Рік тому +93

    This is exactly the content the whole Internet was created for! Congratulations guys! Also kudos to Carl (and Frank) for beating Shandalar!

    • @CardmarketMagic
      @CardmarketMagic  Рік тому +11

      Thank you! :)

    • @pinobluevogel6458
      @pinobluevogel6458 Рік тому +26

      Having Frank come up with basically a speedrun through the game, cut a lot of time out of the shandalar footage. Smart idea.

    • @2LettersSho
      @2LettersSho Рік тому +33

      I'm glad they wheeled Seth back out later so he could finally stop playing Shandalar XD

    • @CardmarketMagic
      @CardmarketMagic  Рік тому +13

      @@2LettersSho hahahahahahaha!

  • @wolter6102
    @wolter6102 Рік тому +61

    I did NOT expect Shandalar in the middle of this game! That's awesome

  • @Camreth
    @Camreth Рік тому +21

    Really fun video, loved the added shandalar playthrough since I feel it's not really well known despite actually being a really fun way to play old magic. Frank was the real winner there though since he just casually gave Carl what I believe is still the wr speedrun strat.

  • @dudenguy6385
    @dudenguy6385 Рік тому +6

    The Shandalar portion was super funny. "Shandalar is protected for -6 years" Job well done, clearly!!

  • @robertomacetti7069
    @robertomacetti7069 Рік тому +22

    That was the most synergistic turn 1 I've ever seen a two headed giant team ever pull off

  • @whaleofdarkness
    @whaleofdarkness Рік тому +32

    Seth should play some more Shandalar on the MtgGoldfish main channel. He really had a good time with the game.

    • @genzo454
      @genzo454 Рік тому +1

      Alright everyone, Shandalar time. Today we're going to play a turn 2 Serra Angel. Of course for that we need a Black Lotus, one of the strongest cards in ALL of magic. We also have a few wraths to clear the board, some swords, and some Savannah Lions to hold down the early game. We also run two Disenchants to deal with non-creature plans, in the main board since of course we don't have a sideboard, and that's about it, let's get into the games.

  • @6litz585
    @6litz585 Рік тому +31

    Seth was doing his best Robert Edwin House impersonation in preparation for the Fallout Commander decks.

  • @huantian
    @huantian Рік тому +39

    I can’t believe they missed Seth making the bugle rat sound!

  • @tyraniccus9745
    @tyraniccus9745 Рік тому +29

    These uploads make my Thursdays! Cheers lads! I’m sure it will be quite the interesting battle. I especially can’t wait to see if everyone constructed decks to compliment each other or just went lone wolf.

  • @catfactsuk
    @catfactsuk Рік тому +23

    Cardmarket had no chill this day, they came to win. Amazing video.

    • @idanbhk3875
      @idanbhk3875 Рік тому +1

      Wow, yeah. I've never seen them so competitive 😂

  • @whaleofdarkness
    @whaleofdarkness Рік тому +26

    Seth is an AI confirmed. Maybe his mispronunciations are due to Google Translate.

  • @Nukalyptus
    @Nukalyptus Рік тому +12

    This is triple A content. Cardmarket, you’ve really stepped up your game since these three are doing all the UA-cam stuff. Don’t ever stop this! ❤

  • @SmashCentralOfficial
    @SmashCentralOfficial Рік тому +3

    Holy crap the match ending and the out takes had me in tears. You guys are hilarious omg

  • @jaakkonikkila8102
    @jaakkonikkila8102 Рік тому +4

    This is probably my new favorite MTG video! You guys put so much effort into this and combined both of my favorite MTG channels to create something AMAZING!

  • @D4rkRitu4l
    @D4rkRitu4l Рік тому +2

    I love the content of both crews, put them together in one room and you get a master piece!
    I enjoyed everything, from the trashtalk to the goofiness of the mini games and the gameplay itself.
    I'm looking forward to the other videos you guys recorded together. Keep it up, Grüße :)

  • @jiratrello
    @jiratrello Рік тому +1

    Is the intro at burgerpark pankow ???

  • @BerlitzSama
    @BerlitzSama Рік тому +2

    The thumbnail alone is already perfect, the video is just a bonus. Keep up the great work, guys, yours is one of the best MTG content around, hands down

  • @dyslexichitman
    @dyslexichitman Рік тому +2

    I really like the content Cardmarket makes.
    You guys have a wonderful attitude, and I really liked the intro.
    Thanks for all the fun content!

  • @Ashley-Eks
    @Ashley-Eks Рік тому +1

    Hahaha, that was wonderful~! Much wackier than I could have ever expected, great job everyone!

  • @intalekt
    @intalekt Рік тому +10

    Frank was the MVP this game! Like every game :)

  • @jeanvalero1597
    @jeanvalero1597 Рік тому +2

    This was so gooood

  • @jacscottclifford
    @jacscottclifford Рік тому +7

    Anmazing stuff lads. What a delight.

  • @RoRoRoRonan
    @RoRoRoRonan Рік тому +1

    Daaaamn! Worlds collide from my two favourite Magic UA-cam channels!
    I already know this is going to be so much fun :D

  • @matthewgilligan2138
    @matthewgilligan2138 Рік тому +3

    Watching this live was super fun. Keep up the great videos! :)

  • @MMikethehiker
    @MMikethehiker Рік тому +2

    This was absolutely incredible. Amazing watch 12/10. Loved every Second of this match.

  • @SmashedFish76
    @SmashedFish76 Рік тому +4

    Cardmarket only ever puts out bangers as usual! I love the miniganes you do in goofy matches, they always seem really fun!

  • @ComposerMathieu
    @ComposerMathieu Рік тому +1

    This whole thing was such a joy to watch. Much love from an American in Sweden!

  • @cttate
    @cttate Рік тому +2

    This was just absolutely brilliant, thank you for brightening up my day.

  • @begottenhippo3303
    @begottenhippo3303 Рік тому +1

    This was so much fun!!! Every bit of it! Amazing video you guys

  • @tamska
    @tamska Рік тому +2

    I’m so happy that we have these two MTG channels!

  • @Varler_
    @Varler_ Рік тому +2

    That was a ton of fun! Looking forward to more crossovers!!!

  • @renzuki5830
    @renzuki5830 Рік тому

    Best UA-cam content on the planet! Also shoutout to the guy walking past you with a coffee cup at the end wondering wtf is going on.

  • @TerminallyNerdy
    @TerminallyNerdy Рік тому +1

    My 2 favorite MTG Channels in a single video? MAJESTIC. MAJESTIC!

  • @Falksz
    @Falksz Рік тому +2

    You guys have BY FAR the BEST mtg content! Huge fan

  • @ichguckegerneyoutube8837
    @ichguckegerneyoutube8837 Рік тому +2

    this was so much fun to watch, thank you for the amazing content

  • @howardkline4248
    @howardkline4248 Рік тому

    This was so much fun!!! What a great content idea! Loved this!

  • @tzaandor
    @tzaandor Рік тому +1

    I've spent years thinking I'm the only person in the world who plays Chainer, Dementia Master in anything. So happy to see my favorite guy out in the wild 🎉

  • @Mr2hyper9
    @Mr2hyper9 Рік тому +1

    Yesss 🙌 MORE two headed giant!!!!!!
    This was my favorite video you’ve done!
    I love pretty much love every video you guys do but this was cream of the crop.

  • @ishae3198
    @ishae3198 Рік тому +1

    "You have protected the plane of Shandalar for the next -6 years." Sounds about right.

  • @shorty1815
    @shorty1815 Рік тому +26

    I am hyped. And Phil is German as well, so only Tomer has to travel there :D
    Liebe Grüße schonmal

    • @Ry_Ku
      @Ry_Ku Рік тому +5

      i think tomers boyfriend lives in france, so maybe he was there and just taveled to germany for a few days, but im not sure. so correct me if im wrong

    • @konnerspears7964
      @konnerspears7964 Рік тому +1

      ​@@Ry_Kuisn't tomer a boy how does he have a boyfriend?

    • @Awesomesausages
      @Awesomesausages Рік тому

      @@konnerspears7964 It's called being gay :)

    • @tartarustrommler5454
      @tartarustrommler5454 Рік тому +40

      @@konnerspears7964 Thanks to the wonderful ancient invention known as "being gay".

    • @konnerspears7964
      @konnerspears7964 Рік тому

      ​@@tartarustrommler5454oh I thought he made a typo my bad

  • @theexplosivefox3884
    @theexplosivefox3884 Рік тому +1

    This needs to be an entire arc. Next we have the Asian Avenger coming to avenge his fallen allies.

  • @tehcodingmonkey
    @tehcodingmonkey Рік тому +1

    looooved the shandalar tech! only thing i think this video was missing was the somehow against-the-odds comeback mtggoldfish always does at the end of each video. hahahaha

  • @Lumpalooza
    @Lumpalooza Рік тому +1

    Thoralf: “This is Thrash, you are trash”
    Carl (in the distance): “ooooooooohhhhh!!”

  • @fel_95
    @fel_95 Рік тому +3

    19:30 didn't Dosan prevent team fish to cast spells on that turn?

    • @bahnarlijohnson8059
      @bahnarlijohnson8059 Рік тому

      Yeah, I noticed that as well, surprised I had to go down this far in the comments, should've been impossible and I'm pretty sure team fish was dead to combat damage right there.

    • @CardmarketMagic
      @CardmarketMagic  Рік тому

      Oko turned dosan into an elk 👍

    • @fel_95
      @fel_95 Рік тому

      @@CardmarketMagic oooh I 100% missed it, thanks

  • @aryst0krat
    @aryst0krat Рік тому +2

    this format kicks ass, I want more!

  • @patrice2847
    @patrice2847 Рік тому +1

    Definetly one of the best mtg related content episode out there amazingly entertaining

  • @editingroomfloor
    @editingroomfloor Рік тому +1

    Love all of the ideas from you guys! Such great content

  • @MopeyN
    @MopeyN Рік тому +1

    4 minutes in and I'm worried how time flies. Such a flowy and funny intro, so stylish trash talk ❤

  • @nicholascabalbag9755
    @nicholascabalbag9755 Рік тому +4

    I was hoping to actually see Seth out and about. I'm now convinced that Seth is an AI that mtggoldfish trained to play and act like a human

  • @tilmandeuschel9771
    @tilmandeuschel9771 Рік тому +1

    What a great show. You guys manage to innovate magic streaming when I thought I've seen everything

  • @starmanda88
    @starmanda88 Рік тому +2

    Ich bin sehr aufgeregt!! Much love from the USA (I’m learning German on Duolingo)

    • @CardmarketMagic
      @CardmarketMagic  Рік тому +1

      Ich freue mich sehr zu hören, dass du aufgeregt ist :) Viel Glück beim Deutschlernen!

    • @starmanda88
      @starmanda88 Рік тому

      @@CardmarketMagic one day I’ll understand more of that but in the meantime thank you for the wonderful content ❤️❤️

  • @hellNo116
    @hellNo116 Рік тому +2

    At this point I feel that Seth is trapped by an unbreakable spell to never live that room. I can't think of a single video I have seen him out of that room even though I know he goes to con and stuff

  • @dannyboy1200
    @dannyboy1200 Рік тому +3

    This whole video is like a fevered dream lol. I love it.

  • @georgemanolo5671
    @georgemanolo5671 Рік тому +1

    You guys have so good chemistry and always show it on the videos you're the best

  • @SpizzyRich
    @SpizzyRich Рік тому +2

    Did he say "Oakish Boar Master"? That's dope. I prefer that. I want that card. 22:21

    • @pinobluevogel6458
      @pinobluevogel6458 Рік тому

      It seems like an awesome card, fun art, cool ability. If it hadn't had such a big warping effect on formats it would be beloved in casual play for sure.

  • @rokketman159
    @rokketman159 Рік тому +1

    So many cool synergies in two headed giant I never had thought of before.

  • @davidd.w.8681
    @davidd.w.8681 Рік тому +4

    Legends say Seth is still trying to finish Shandalar.

  • @HurricaneGregor
    @HurricaneGregor Рік тому +1

    Would 100% watch a Shandalar playthrough video/series exploring different decks.

  • @CS-wx3ob
    @CS-wx3ob Рік тому +3

    My favorite moment was when Cardmarket spelled their own name incorrectly😂

  • @theCityBear
    @theCityBear Рік тому +1

    This was so silly and fun throughout! Loved every moment of it. Congrats guys!

  • @niklasbolz4267
    @niklasbolz4267 Рік тому +1

    I loved everything about that! Keep up the great content.

  • @Izelor
    @Izelor Рік тому +1

    Now THIS is quality content. Well done!

  • @Miluric
    @Miluric Рік тому +4

    Super fun, as expected of this channel! I loved the card charades, partly because I would have guessed Colossal Dreadmaw right away too.

  • @Soraking007
    @Soraking007 Рік тому +1

    Brewers kitchen being there means theyve already lost to extreme memeyness

  • @baragon023
    @baragon023 Рік тому +1

    The perfect Mashup. So happy to see this happen.

  • @purplelilypervincle4898
    @purplelilypervincle4898 Рік тому +1

    I really laughed hard 😂 loved the politness in the trash talk 🎉

  • @KingQuark27
    @KingQuark27 Рік тому +1

    I like that cardmarket is giving smaller channels a platform to present themselves... like cadrmarket ( 1:13 )

  • @Pyrodactyl
    @Pyrodactyl Рік тому +3

    Love both channels, this is awesome!

  • @Xerdoz
    @Xerdoz Рік тому

    Good stuff.
    I remember seeing that old Shandalar game at my cousin's place, late 90s. I think there was some sort of a bug where you could win by mana burning yourself.

  • @disafear3674
    @disafear3674 Рік тому

    That was amazing! I loved the Seth-screen

  • @chesanceram4842
    @chesanceram4842 Рік тому

    Cool concept, I would just love to see more of the decks!

  • @HolgerBurner
    @HolgerBurner Рік тому

    Great Content, the only missed opportunity: The guy walking behind you at 26:02 should have a thought bubble reading "goddamn nerds"

  • @gbrookes7827
    @gbrookes7827 Рік тому

    I love seeing my two favorite magic channels in one video

  • @Thunderdkfox
    @Thunderdkfox Рік тому +1

    This was so entertaining :) loved every moment of it.

  • @joshvon8495
    @joshvon8495 Рік тому +1

    “It was Omnath”
    Narrator: “It was, in fact, not Omnath”

  • @jeromedarnell6270
    @jeromedarnell6270 Рік тому

    Much better in-your-face brutal insults than you'll ever see in a boxing promo.

  • @TheMCGamer2012
    @TheMCGamer2012 Рік тому +2

    this was an awesome collab! :D

  • @spidery7618
    @spidery7618 Рік тому +1

    This is the WEIRDEST mtg video I have EVER seen, what even... this whole video feels like a fever dream, it's absolutely fantastic and completely absurd hahaha
    I just hope Carl and Seth had played Shandalar beforehand and didn't leave everybody else waiting at the table, because that'd be really boring and mean :P

  • @Ry_Ku
    @Ry_Ku Рік тому +4

    the standoff roast was cringe and i love it :D

  • @somo3082
    @somo3082 Рік тому +2

    Tomer is so incredibly sassy, love him

  • @ethanwales7834
    @ethanwales7834 Рік тому

    Great video! Had me laughing the whole time!!! 😂

  • @keithmpire
    @keithmpire Рік тому

    "That's Oko!" really got me. It suuuure is!

  • @smokey5995.1
    @smokey5995.1 Рік тому +1

    This had everything, trash talk, gaming, but most importantly, it had ya boi, colossal dreadmaw!!!!