'It's like partition time in Manipur with tribal Kukis fleeing to hills, Meiteis confined to valley'

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 6 вер 2024
  • #PoliticalAdda #ManipurViolence
    Who is responsible for the ongoing crisis in Manipur? In this week’s Political Adda, political editor DK Singh and deputy editor Moushumi Das Gupta discuss the ongoing crisis with Dr A Bimol Akoijam and Dr Thongkholal Haokip, two noted academics from Delhi’s Jawaharlal Nehru University.
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Exclusive content, special privileges & more - Subscribe to ThePrint for Member benefits: theprint.in/su...
    ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Connect with ThePrint
    » Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/su...
    » Subscribe to our UA-cam Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
    » Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
    » Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
    » Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
    » Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
    » Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
    » Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
    » Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,8 тис.

  • @sikh123
    @sikh123 Рік тому +87

    After listening this interviews, i belived meeti r more intellectual and their views r quite different from kuki. Hats off to Dr. Bimol 👏👏👏🙏

    • @Uff1234
      @Uff1234 Рік тому +11

      It's probably not wise to judge an entire community based on just a few people's knowledge, performance or status.

    • @davidlyn2948
      @davidlyn2948 Рік тому +7

      You are absolutely right Simran kaur .

    • @laststand2976
      @laststand2976 Рік тому +3

      I think you are confusing someone’s fluency in the English language as the measure of his intelligence, listen closely…points raised are valid even if not in proper English.

    • @nongbaan4095
      @nongbaan4095 Рік тому

      No doubt.. 1000+ illegal kukis found on just first day of combing operation by Indian Army at Kuki areas. Imagine how many illegals are there in Manipur.

    • @Brick-rv6sf
      @Brick-rv6sf Рік тому

      ​@@laststand2976 typical Indian.

  • @veesaga9355
    @veesaga9355 Рік тому +91

    So many good points from both Bimol and Thongkholal, this is how a real talk should be! Thank you, Print, for starting this conversation 🙌

    • @sanglyan3080
      @sanglyan3080 Рік тому

      Thusawi an in thiam hleih deuh hlek em aw...hetiang hunah Thangkhansuan Sausing ka ngai thin

    • @soramsoram3108
      @soramsoram3108 10 місяців тому

      good points were only from Sir Bimol

  • @rojibalaningombam4928
    @rojibalaningombam4928 Рік тому +90

    The way Prof Bimol Akoijam has looked at the ongoing carnage in Manipur--his ability of self-appraisal, self-criticism, objective and logical approach to the current issue, all the while offering ways to alleviate the situation and the need to go beyond colonial given concepts and terms--manifests how erudite he is. And also, to be able to critique fellow academics' approach to the current mayhem takes not just intellectual superiority but also courage. Thank you, Sir. It was an enlightening observation. It would be great if Karan Thapar and oja Bimol have a discussion on this issue.

    • @meerabaithangjam6209
      @meerabaithangjam6209 Рік тому +6

      I wish we can request Mr.Karan Thapar to have a conversation with Sir Bimol

    • @dhuidrom
      @dhuidrom Рік тому +12

      @@meerabaithangjam6209 it won't yield anything as thapar is hell bent on bashing Manipur/meetie as it is part of BJP government. Print did a wonderful job to have a good conversation and not trying to present one sided story

    • @kapilrajkumar3211
      @kapilrajkumar3211 Рік тому +8

      Karan thapar is a propagandist no point in talking

    • @sadman2443
      @sadman2443 Рік тому +2

      Exactly my point.
      But i bet he won't digest this point of view cz he has already been hypnotize by the other side. May bless u n ur misunderstanding

    • @thangjamvictoriadevi1582
      @thangjamvictoriadevi1582 Рік тому +2

      Karan Thapar is one sided. On my point a person must be allow to speak

  • @jessevincentsawian9077
    @jessevincentsawian9077 Рік тому +141

    Dr Bimol Akoijam should be given a wider platform to speak, very insightful man.

    • @desiinmybloodtruth
      @desiinmybloodtruth Рік тому

      sure, but he's misplaced in that people want seperate administration becoz of funds and there are other ways of asking for it??? We are asking seperate administration for our survival! forget funds we lost our blo.ody homes!!! He is an academician at the end of the day, and remains an idealists. This conflict wont have arise if the valleys are content in valleys but wanna grab the hill areas. Why else will they protest many times for "territorial integrity" and shout "go back kuki immigrant" at the same time.

    • @Cathy-mi1zw
      @Cathy-mi1zw Рік тому +5

      Clever but intentions can't b hidden. 🤭🤭

    • @nomhaokip9645
      @nomhaokip9645 Рік тому

      many people here says that this interview has been neutral and whatnot but from what i see, one of them is merely giving a perspective point of view in the most subdued manner just to conceal the fact that he lowkey is evidently siding his own community. No disrespect. I respect him for his intelligence but his intentions says otherwise.

    • @Necessary_EvilMLBB
      @Necessary_EvilMLBB Рік тому +15

      @@nomhaokip9645 To a man with a hammer like u, everything looks like a nail😂

    • @nomhaokip9645
      @nomhaokip9645 Рік тому +1

      @@Necessary_EvilMLBBif he is truly neutral to the core 100% why is he speaking in favour of one community in the end ??

  • @Ibjays2021
    @Ibjays2021 Рік тому +23

    Sir Associate professor Bimol akoijam , you are outstanding. One of my fav person from now onwards. Salute to your great knowledge and understanding.😊👍👍

  • @wanglennganbichanu7216
    @wanglennganbichanu7216 Рік тому +44

    Salute to Dr. Bimol Sir, for his great and transparent explaination.

  • @meghanathsingh
    @meghanathsingh Рік тому +107

    Thank you Professor Bimol for bringing forward your unbiased and neutral viewpoint and sharing this with the larger population

    • @Necessary_EvilMLBB
      @Necessary_EvilMLBB Рік тому +11

      @@nomhaokip9645 To a man with a hammer like u, everything looks like a nail

    • @nomhaokip9645
      @nomhaokip9645 Рік тому +2

      @@Necessary_EvilMLBB supporting facts on both sides doesn’t make one unbiased, it’s the decision made & their truest intentions that counts

    • @nomhaokip9645
      @nomhaokip9645 Рік тому +1

      @@Necessary_EvilMLBB “man with a hammer” just by sharing my POV ? This is the mentality that erupted the violence. 😔

    • @Srbh...01
      @Srbh...01 Рік тому +1

      @@nomhaokip9645 you people can't stay without increasing conflicts

  • @ananmaish1665
    @ananmaish1665 Рік тому +50

    Great insight from Dr Bimol Sir. Hope lots of the people can be benefited with such a wonderful narrative.

  • @Ns_ningthouja
    @Ns_ningthouja Рік тому +20

    This is one of the talk shows where Oja Bimol can show his thinking and studies at its best ❤ thank you oja🙏

  • @jayantasharma9116
    @jayantasharma9116 Рік тому +21

    We strongly support you Dr. Bimol akoijam what you have said is 100% true as a manipuri i support you.

    • @Corgi_Manu
      @Corgi_Manu Рік тому +1

      Yes I agree he spoke alot of truth. but his solution is an age old solution which has already been tried and failed. A commitee with no decision powers on budget allocation cannot fix the grievances of lack of hill district development.

  • @purnetm
    @purnetm Рік тому +77

    Huge shout out to Dr. Bimol for bringing the spotlight on the truth of the matter. His POV on how all the current communal riots in Manipur could be to serve a means to an end - does bring a fresh perspective to any viewer. Seems like the civilians are only a mere scapegoat to a larger political game of who will get the wealth distributed by the centre of the nation?

    • @nomhaokip9645
      @nomhaokip9645 Рік тому

      No and no.!
      Speaking of scapegoats, We’re done being a punching bag of the majoritarian section of Manipur’s community whenever they feel insecure, or “seeing us flourishing means a threat to their existence.”
      We want separation. We dont want to go back to the valley where we’re vulnerable and WHERE KIL*ING US IS CELEBRATED. Mind it. Us demanding to prevent ourselves from such incidents again has nothing to do with POLITICS.

  • @Vin_angomcha6
    @Vin_angomcha6 Рік тому +22

    I want dr bimol to be interviewed by karan thapar

    • @meiteilaba7989
      @meiteilaba7989 Рік тому +5

      Karan Thapar will put down paper after the interview.

    • @skngnr
      @skngnr Рік тому

      ​@Seiroly Respectfully, Sapam is clearly uneducated 😂😂😂.

  • @rohid24eva
    @rohid24eva Рік тому +12

    Wow, Sir.Bimol, What a class without any hatred!! Salute🙏👍👏🙇‍♂️🙇‍♀️

  • @hengamkhongsai5878
    @hengamkhongsai5878 Рік тому +14

    The best soul ever Dr. A Bimol.

  • @meeteim6325
    @meeteim6325 Рік тому +15

    Dr akoijam end game shooting is sharp and hit the target nicely 😅. Such a smart intellect he is .

  • @mangaalkha-nganba7366
    @mangaalkha-nganba7366 Рік тому +12

    This is called a true journalism, there should be more debate like this, well explained Sir Dr. Bimol Akoijam ❤ we need people like you to fix this mess in our state.

  • @hyperzchannel8972
    @hyperzchannel8972 Рік тому +72

    Last Words of Prof. Bimol are so Clear & Based that it explains everything.

    • @natalieh152
      @natalieh152 Рік тому +5

      I appreciated Dr. Bimol Sir, He is one of the Real Meitei Heroes of Meitei leibak (Kangleipak), he shows humanity as a good human being, everyone need to learn something from him, I like his sense of humour, learn and understand if you wanna be a good human being, some people need to be like him if you wanna be a good leader or wanna have good leadership quality.

    • @Vigilante123
      @Vigilante123 Рік тому +5

      ​@@nomhaokip9645 you have your representative MLAs and MP who are Ministers and MLA.. Stop fooling around.

    • @hyperzchannel8972
      @hyperzchannel8972 Рік тому +8

      @@nomhaokip9645 same way like Meiti community is forced out of 90% land of Manipur & confined to valley only.

    • @natalieh152
      @natalieh152 Рік тому

      ​​@@nomhaokip9645 you the kuki refugee, illegal immigrants kuki chin whatever you called, just accept on 3rd may '23 so called solidarity mass really with AK 47, well pre-planned, strategy collaborated with kuki militant with 10 MLAs and all the Government employees, hired by some news channels against Meitei, you did whatever kuki refugee people wanted to do including killing people after tortured brutally, raped nurses and doctors including innocent small children, still blaming and torturing people in churachandpur nearby villages by kuki militant, no humanity, no one can change kuki chin, kuki refugee, immigrants people refugee mindset, after getting food and shelter now demanding own state, just think once before you blamed to others, what a unity of refugee, i can imagined, slow clap, well, you said Biren is at Meitei's favor, that is absolutely wrong, do you think, CC PUR 10 MLAs is also at Meitei favor, if you did something accept, admit whatever you did, do not try to run away and blamed to others , that is not the solution my dear refugee kuki, do not try to be stupid after killing innocent people without any reason, stop saying targeting kuki refugee people, stop fooling around, truth can not hide anymore, you the kuki refugee are the responsible of Manipur violence, keep that in mind

    • @neji-hyuga-
      @neji-hyuga- Рік тому +1

      @@nomhaokip9645 political agenda as pointed out by Dr Bimol. Example right here guys.

  • @AwakenedMeiteiNongsa
    @AwakenedMeiteiNongsa Рік тому +13

    One thing is evident; Dr Haokip does not call out any of the Kuki leaders even once whereas Dr Akoijam has enough guts to call a spade a spade on both sides. Dr Haokip's recommendation is that of a separatist, which has been the narrative from CCpur since day 3 of the conflict. Like Dr Akoijam said this looks like a means to an end which was sophisticatedly orchestrated and funded accordingly.

  • @user-pc3jl8hg1w
    @user-pc3jl8hg1w Рік тому +11

    Oja Bimol Akoijam took the noob Thongkholal Haokip for a spin and legend has it that he's not recovered from it yet. Next is KK Suan. We must demand a debate between KK Suan and Oja Bimol Akoijam. Karan Thapar must also have the courage to sit down Bimol Akoijam in his show

  • @msd963
    @msd963 Рік тому +18

    Thank you Dr. Akoijam Bimol for clarifying the current crisis in Manipur with all the truth and for giving a message of integrity. Huge respect from ❤.

  • @laishramsingh3058
    @laishramsingh3058 Рік тому +36

    Hats off to this man Dr. Akoijam. He spoke to the point without taking any sides. Persons like him must be brought to other national stages if we really are looking for solution to present crisis.

    • @Corgi_Manu
      @Corgi_Manu Рік тому +1

      yes but he did not give proper solution. all he said was kuki mlas should demand a committee that looks after its grievances. Arey but they have already made such demands. and how will a community with no decision powers on budget allotment solve the issue? Cos this is, afterall, about budget allocation, if you dig deep enough.

    • @despicable-mi
      @despicable-mi Рік тому +1

      ​@@Corgi_Manubudget allocation?? 😂
      It's about Myanmar refugees and mushrooming villages of kuki

    • @ok00
      @ok00 Рік тому

      What about BIREN?

    • @Corgi_Manu
      @Corgi_Manu Рік тому

      @@despicable-mi Nobody is defending refugees or poppy. Tribals themselves have been involved in many anti-poppy drives. You have no brain.

  • @ysc3123
    @ysc3123 Рік тому +27

    Salute to Dr Bimol for bringing out the facts rather than blame game for current situation in Manipur. He should be in the limelight for discussing the current situation in Manipur. Out of so many he is the only one who clearly brings out likely causes and impact of what is going on in this part of the country.

  • @Henmin80Kholhou
    @Henmin80Kholhou Рік тому +29

    I respect the integrity and wisdom of Dr A Bimol

  • @thoibaThiyam-jn9hb
    @thoibaThiyam-jn9hb Рік тому +72

    Factually narrated by Dr. Bimol Akoijam. Salute to u sir. We need u sir, for bringing a strong Manipur once again.

    • @jamesboth3785
      @jamesboth3785 Рік тому +1

      "Bringing back Manipur again"???😂😂😂😂 we already left your 690sq miles of Manipur. No turning back

    • @debashisharambam8998
      @debashisharambam8998 Рік тому +2

      @@jamesboth3785 are you the one who did the mischief with his car?

    • @ningthem2023
      @ningthem2023 Рік тому

      @@jamesboth3785 hey 0 Sq mile. Don't bark here like glady vaiphei

  • @ronaldolaishram9977
    @ronaldolaishram9977 Рік тому +16

    Thank you Oja Bimol for sharing such a thought-provoking and insightful talk on the Manipur issue. viewpoint is refreshingly neutral and you shed light on many important nuances that often go overlooked.

  • @ningombamreagan9094
    @ningombamreagan9094 Рік тому +17

    Absolutely wonderful talk professor Bimol. You are a genius.😊

  • @yuunique9676
    @yuunique9676 Рік тому +12

    Damnn the professor's comprehensive viewpoint on the issue was really impressive, everything he said on the social economics to the poilitcal issue was spot on,no wonder karan Thapar didn't dare invite him on the interview,his whole baised view on bjp or his hatred for modi would have been shut down instantly

  • @bobymaibam8704
    @bobymaibam8704 Рік тому +31

    Thank you The print for bringing out such a possible solution. Thank you Dr. Bimol Sir for suggesting the best solution and excellent explanation.

  • @beblissandbloomwithbeda577
    @beblissandbloomwithbeda577 Рік тому +20

    Hats off sir Bimol
    He is such an insightful person I have ever seen.
    It was great watching this episode. He should attend more n more media to spread this knowledge. It's an eye opening session 👏👏👏👏👏

  • @pkabujam
    @pkabujam Рік тому +36

    Now this is the perfect combination of excellent knowledge, great sincerity and optimum expression...Salute u sir Akoijam Bimol 👍👍

  • @sApreIndia
    @sApreIndia Рік тому +20

    Sir Bimol, wow ... what a presentation. Respect.

  • @Thangjou444
    @Thangjou444 Рік тому +8

    We can see a very practical, neutral point of views from Dr Bimol, that's appreciated and must for the moment. Not a one sided mindset which I observed in Haokip's view.

  • @Ivanborah
    @Ivanborah Рік тому +128

    Please bring Mr. Associate Prof. Sir from JNU for more podcasts,the way he expresses and explains brings goosebumps. Thank you The Print for focusing on Manipur. We dont need India Pakistan China news, when our own land is in turmoil. 🙏🏻

    • @sauravsuresh
      @sauravsuresh Рік тому +4

      Exactly!

    • @nongmeikapambhopeshwor645
      @nongmeikapambhopeshwor645 Рік тому +1

      What do you know about MANIPUR

    • @francisfernandes4751
      @francisfernandes4751 Рік тому +11

      I hv been following the Manipur case since 3rd May 2023 what was noticed is the exactly the same as described by JNU Associate professor.
      Sir - U R one of the few to observe and use the correct words for the understanding of the people outside Manipur.
      It is a preplanned Ethnic Cleanising orchestrated by the Biren govt and his leaders from Central.

    • @zemaprime6382
      @zemaprime6382 Рік тому +9

      The observations of sir Bimol Akoijam is very earnest, very true and educative. Thnx to sir Akoijam. His ideas are superlative.

    • @surajsoram2667
      @surajsoram2667 Рік тому

      @@francisfernandes4751 lol then you're following news from eastmojo, hornbill tv and beingkuki 😂😂 what is there to gain from wiping off kukis from imphal?

  • @kiranelangbam2810
    @kiranelangbam2810 Рік тому +8

    Dr Bimol sir, such a knowledgeable person.
    The ideas that he shared are deep thought.

  • @mirtunjoynareng8781
    @mirtunjoynareng8781 Рік тому +10

    Discussion is fulfilled because both are Present in discussion Thnkq Professors Sir Bimol ✌️👍 & Thnkq “2 for expressing ❤❤

  • @user-on6ow6ux5h
    @user-on6ow6ux5h Рік тому +6

    Thank you Dr. Akoijam and Dr. Haokip for bringing us such comprehensive discussuons.

  • @devansinghyju5246
    @devansinghyju5246 Рік тому +16

    Bimol sir very very thankful for your clear explanations and suggestions.
    The way you are trying to bring out clarity is so excellent.
    Thank you sir

  • @rksumitra3972
    @rksumitra3972 Рік тому +18

    Ten thousand salutes to you dear Dr Bimol Akoijam 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @trusttheyoga8303
    @trusttheyoga8303 Рік тому +30

    Dr A Bimol Akoijam such a knowledged person.

  • @sasuke-yr6mf
    @sasuke-yr6mf Рік тому +74

    We need more Dr. Bimol, huge respect to you

    • @d0g747
      @d0g747 Рік тому

      You have enough Bimol in the form of Biren and his cohorts.

    • @sasuke-yr6mf
      @sasuke-yr6mf Рік тому

      @@d0g747 next level insecure pple. Dont compare him with the CM. Dr.Bimol has been neutral and unbiased unlike any other intellectuals.

    • @d0g747
      @d0g747 Рік тому

      @@sasuke-yr6mf which is why we need a Separate Administration/State.

    • @sasuke-yr6mf
      @sasuke-yr6mf Рік тому +1

      @@d0g747 🤣

    • @d0g747
      @d0g747 Рік тому

      @@sasuke-yr6mf 🤣

  • @bliss9460
    @bliss9460 Рік тому +6

    Hats off Dr Bimol!! Wise words from a wise man. Very inspiring 💗 Overall, a very insightful discussion from both sides👏👏

  • @geetamanikhuraijam46
    @geetamanikhuraijam46 Рік тому +46

    we need more knowledgeable person like sir Bimol to bring peace and harmony in the state.

  • @thoudamanjika1689
    @thoudamanjika1689 Рік тому +13

    Heads off to Sir Bimol for such an eloquent explaination.

  • @turtlecreek6043
    @turtlecreek6043 Рік тому +30

    Nation must see this with their eyes open and atleast now you will understand why we need independent media , If you have the means please support The Print and true journalism ❤🙏🇮🇳

  • @MMR640
    @MMR640 Рік тому +15

    If all the politicians of my motherland , the State of Manipur have the same wisdom as you have respected Sir Bimol the present human catastrophe could have been avoided. I pray to God to give you more wisdom to spread the words of love, peace and development and above all the sense of oneness with forgiveness among all the communities living in this part of the world to excel greater heights of advancement. I salute , appreciate and thank you wholeheartedly for speaking the truth so lucidly and loudly 🙏🙏🙏💐

  • @bafo1912
    @bafo1912 Рік тому +12

    Dr Bimol was exceptionally excellent. We need such level-headed people with a logical and rational mindset to sort out problems. The Kukis and Meiteis are really nice people but they should learn how to respect life. If they could follow "Thou shall not kill" then Manipur will turn out to be heaven on earth. All the best!

  • @thokchomshalinidevi2241
    @thokchomshalinidevi2241 Рік тому +5

    Cant agree more with prof. Bimol. This is the thinking we need right now.

  • @yeshingima3472
    @yeshingima3472 Рік тому +24

    The only person who made sense to me till now on Manipur issue is Dr. A Bimol. Definately sharing this and i hope people understand and try see this whole issue from a his POV.

  • @nirupama6111
    @nirupama6111 Рік тому +6

    Thank you The Print..we're indebted to you for bringing out true journalism on the present crisis in Manipur..you are helping save lives by spreading truth and awareness..God bless you🙏

  • @meiteilaba7989
    @meiteilaba7989 Рік тому +27

    Just see how Moshumi is lost in awe of Dr Bimol when he expresses his opinion !!😊

  • @bitanjalileishangthem390
    @bitanjalileishangthem390 Рік тому +9

    Salute to Dr Bimol. You are too good.

  • @chitrasenak9852
    @chitrasenak9852 Рік тому +30

    i appreciate sir Dr. Bimol, ❤

  • @lucyping5908
    @lucyping5908 Рік тому +9

    Dr.Bimol Akoijam's words are like a direct slap to all those scholars who try to bring out a false narratives in the name of minority and dominant blah blah.

  • @pushpanongmaithem2549
    @pushpanongmaithem2549 Рік тому +10

    A big thums up to Dr Bimol.

  • @jiji....5040
    @jiji....5040 Рік тому +3

    I'm really proud of you Dr.haokip

    • @despicable-mi
      @despicable-mi Рік тому

      He is a refugee like you, so your roots are the same. So you have a good reason to be proud.

  • @chosen8428
    @chosen8428 Рік тому +9

    Dr. Akoijam's words are so deep, particularly on, from where the economy of this state is generated 👍......Dr.Haojik your concepts and ideas are like a layman person, not like a resourceful professor.

  • @sushilkumar-mk7je
    @sushilkumar-mk7je Рік тому +26

    Mr.Haokip has always propogated a seperate kukiland despite of being a govt professor in JNU.

    • @Saorse-ov7br
      @Saorse-ov7br Рік тому +5

      Because we r Indians but unfortunately immigrants for manipur pple as u always told us... so separate administration is a must

    • @Erik10Hag36
      @Erik10Hag36 Рік тому +9

      Is it wrong to voice for a seperate administration of your own fgs. The way things have been unfolding it's better both Meeteis and Kukis go seperate ways. I don't see the once famed Manipur from here

    • @hatshihaokip4455
      @hatshihaokip4455 Рік тому +6

      It is always better to be separate administration instead of losing our life and houses in the hand of meetei

    • @nevermindlobe2599
      @nevermindlobe2599 Рік тому +1

      That land doesn't belong to kukis from the first place

    • @eimiworld3216
      @eimiworld3216 Рік тому +7

      It's okay to demand for seperate administration and state under the Ambit of the constitution. The whole concept of this demand is realised only after the violence, please note that.

  • @ponganbahaobam2475
    @ponganbahaobam2475 Рік тому +8

    Awesome debate tamo Dr. Bimol , like the way it ended❤

  • @indrakumarrachalaishram7636
    @indrakumarrachalaishram7636 Рік тому +12

    The interview was so wonderful that the speech by Dr. Akoijam ,i assume, would invoke the inner desire to learn the subject matter more or atleast to come up with more robust idealogical set before projecting an agenda

  • @its_me_dr_daya
    @its_me_dr_daya Рік тому +9

    Well explained, best interview ever, let peace prevail in Manipur.

  • @singhangomcha4796
    @singhangomcha4796 Рік тому +6

    Proud of you Dr A. Bimol
    You well said

  • @samlalu8736
    @samlalu8736 Рік тому +18

    Tell this to Mr Thapar who is advocating Partition.

    • @natalieh152
      @natalieh152 Рік тому +1

      Is he your father and hired for time being

  • @wjames4705
    @wjames4705 Рік тому +48

    The difference in intellectual level is like North pole to South Pole. One senior professor through research and book knowledge, other through WhatsApp and Facebook video shared among their community. Sad state for JNU.... His expression when senior professor said these are based on literature of scientist.. not from his facebook and whatsapp University videos.

    • @Necessary_EvilMLBB
      @Necessary_EvilMLBB Рік тому +2

      😂👍

    • @darktower7252
      @darktower7252 Рік тому

      Absolutely

    • @Corgi_Manu
      @Corgi_Manu Рік тому

      But the effectiveness of the solution provided by the senior professor and its realistic ability to actually fix the core issues are even more apart than the North and South Poles.

    • @Corgi_Manu
      @Corgi_Manu Рік тому

      Also, whatsapp info when presented by X community is legit, but Y community is not. Hmmm. Fair conclusion indeed. 😂

    • @josephspencergaming575
      @josephspencergaming575 Рік тому

      That's y u people demand for ST isnt

  • @_yawol_
    @_yawol_ Рік тому +8

    kukis have been part and parcel of our life of Manipur. this violence has given us a critical look at this dimension that a kuki who has been together with us will not raise this kind of hatred....
    -an insightful statement by Dr Ak Bimol

  • @sukhamabung2491
    @sukhamabung2491 Рік тому +1

    Dr.Bimol points the facts and clarified many doubtful . He is neutral wheresas Mr. Haokip says unnecessary things and one sided to kuki. also he is not qualified to be judged

  • @jthangboykhongsaikuki2417
    @jthangboykhongsaikuki2417 Рік тому +23

    I support this media as reporting the truth and facts about the Manipur incidents

  • @nejihyuga5578
    @nejihyuga5578 Рік тому +8

    Mr Haokip thats a small section of the problem. The JNU professor already said its a political plan. I bet he has his grievences too considering he is meitei but he is civil to talk about the real problem. You are trying to make the print....the kukiprint. Just know that meiteis were attacked first.

  • @Henmin80Kholhou
    @Henmin80Kholhou Рік тому +20

    The best interview so far. Very rational and neutral perspective given by both Dr A Bimol and Dr Haokip.

  • @pantigonmei7872
    @pantigonmei7872 Рік тому +8

    Yes,Dr Akoijam has been known for a resourceful person who would always speak on facts.Thanks to Dr.Haokip too.

  • @chingkheinganbichingakham3627
    @chingkheinganbichingakham3627 Рік тому +5

    Thank you Print for this insightful interview. Dr Bimol should speak often and everyone should see this.

  • @meiteilaba7989
    @meiteilaba7989 Рік тому +25

    Dr. Akoijam, I am in simply awe of his intelelct level.
    He will give Dr. Jaishankar a run for his money.

  • @milaw1986
    @milaw1986 Рік тому +3

    Mr Haokip, U r not qualified to teach at JNU. U said that dominant community has a lot of reservation and then just u jump into the topic of targeting kuki tribal! What do u want say and do u understand urself? At least, Akoijam has never tried to make communal but You Haokip is the only trying to make it communal. Kuki started the riot in churchanpur which is mainly kuki residents and riot started at churchandpur meitei leikai and then meitei has to react this riot...! i.e reaction from meitei in valley areas.

  • @raulehh36
    @raulehh36 Рік тому +5

    Hats off🫡 Sir Bimol!
    JUSTICE WILL PREVAIL.

  • @wak-9xd
    @wak-9xd Рік тому +7

    Proud of A Bimol Sir, thank you

  • @sagapamkeshav2385
    @sagapamkeshav2385 Рік тому +2

    A master class by Oja Bimol Akoijam. Literally schooled everyone.

  • @KonsamDevkishore
    @KonsamDevkishore Рік тому +8

    Thank you prof. Akoijam for your unbaised crystal clear conclusion

  • @forever-peace
    @forever-peace Рік тому +18

    Ignorance is the field where evil grows its ulterior motives. We need to spread knowledge and positive insights. Kudos to Mr. Bimol! We need more people like you to save the state and bring harmony.

  • @sapamthoren276
    @sapamthoren276 Рік тому +13

    Very well said Prof. Proud of you #SaveIntegrityofManipur

  • @Ericsson-cj9qd
    @Ericsson-cj9qd Рік тому +8

    Well done Prof. Akoijam. Proud of you. Mr Haokip does not have valid point and keep talking about ethnic and blah blah, Seems he is part of the propaganda. #SaveIntegrityofManipur

  • @hemorjithuidrom5294
    @hemorjithuidrom5294 Рік тому +4

    At the end of the interview, all three are speechless in front of Professor Bimol, who gave the clearest picture of what is what.

  • @FootballKicks999
    @FootballKicks999 Рік тому +5

    If we have more academicians like Dr.Bimol Akoijam, Manipur will be peaceful and thriving instead ethnic unnecessary war to put us 75years backward.

  • @huncyhuncy5967
    @huncyhuncy5967 Рік тому +27

    Very well said by Dr. Bimol.. very insightful.. Showing General interest for the humanitarian development. On the contrary Mr Haokip is predominantly prefixed his mind with the aim of encouraging separate administration. 😮

    • @larrytonsing1742
      @larrytonsing1742 Рік тому

      Separate administration is inevitable. The inevitable split has taken place

  • @lordhaokip9398
    @lordhaokip9398 Рік тому +25

    After yesterdays rally in Thoubal District where around 50000 people chanted “Kukis don’t come back” you think there can be peace amongst the people,Mr Akoijam is talking about a utopian state where people can live peacefully again after what happened all the killings ,till now most of the victims and the death counts are mostly kukis and you expect the people to go back to the capital where most of the killings happened .. sir either you are turning a blind eye to it or you are just blaberring gibberish where separate administration is not the answer

    • @nevermindlobe2599
      @nevermindlobe2599 Рік тому

      After 50000 of you chanted not to give ST status to meitei....why can't we protest ?
      Only you can protest because you belong to the minority group? You people are so selfish that you don't even deserve separate administration
      Meitei people will do anything to not give a single piece of our land

    • @babloosingh5362
      @babloosingh5362 Рік тому +2

      Illegal immigrant detected 😂

    • @user-on6ow6ux5h
      @user-on6ow6ux5h Рік тому +2

      People won't just come back to peace. It is impossible now when so much loss and tragedy has happened on both sides. But we need peace.
      I know that no one of us will ever forget what has happened to us and to our close ones. But even if this memory lingers on, we must work on getting over our hate and animosity against each other. This will not be easy. We will have to work hard to rebuild our land and find peace once again.
      Even if it is tough, we need peace, because like it or not, it's not like we can magically create a huge wall between the communities so that they will never meet again in the social, political or economic arena. Also, it's too tough, I don't think any of us can bear any more violence.

    • @mawitevaiphei8960
      @mawitevaiphei8960 Рік тому

      ​@@babloosingh5362 this is how your communal minds got detected

    • @nevermindlobe2599
      @nevermindlobe2599 Рік тому

      @@user-on6ow6ux5h people need to understand this....especially kuki instead of protesting separate administration they should try to live in harmony and peace but theyre spreading false allegations... the situation in valley is mostly due to the retaliation of what they have done in the hill areas...but instead of understanding this their whole mindset thinks we are trying to wiped them out....
      And now they're calling us scheduled theives and all I mean just because 1 person did that doesn't mean whole community did that ...there are different types of people in a community just like some of the kukis are poppy planters and some Loot the banks also doesn't mean the whole community is poppy planter and looters

  • @julkaditapause1774
    @julkaditapause1774 Рік тому +55

    The way professor Bimol express the truth is very impressive

  • @user-ep4qj2xe9s
    @user-ep4qj2xe9s Рік тому +12

    These type of discussion need to be encouraged even more to illuminate us all especially the main land people, more so who are going to take political decision, to know and understand the deeper lines of why, what for and how the present situation takes places and how these things can be resolve amicably rather so soon than later...

  • @Okyouokokay
    @Okyouokokay Рік тому +43

    Unbiased, objective and practical. Thank you The Print for gathering up such discussion forum where humanity prevails.

  • @AkhoJohn
    @AkhoJohn Рік тому +18

    Thank you Dr.Binod Akoijam for the critical breakdown of the problem of Manipur which can be applied to other NE states also.. I think we the middle class should realise sooner than later, that when grassroots fight, the political class benefit…
    Just a small observation: debating parties are not able to come to a conclusion because both parties identify different things as the root cause of the present scenario.. doesn’t help if both are right on a different plane… should try to touch upon even those topics no matter how uncomfortable they are, else the cancer will never be cured.

  • @borisokram8182
    @borisokram8182 Рік тому +1

    Dr. Koijam speech is eye openingly true.

  • @NeymarJr-th6ok
    @NeymarJr-th6ok Рік тому +9

    But let me jz ask one thing why meitei representives meet the interviewer face to face but the representatives for kuki community are always doing it online whether polienlal haokip or thongkholal haokip. But meitei representative whether it be nishikant Or Bimol they always meet face to face. When they say they can't go to valley because they are afraid but supreme court ask them to do it online. But they are doin every interview online here are they afraid of mainlaind india too.

    • @darktower7252
      @darktower7252 Рік тому +1

      Who is stopping kuki representative to come on the show ..no one ...their one choice. Don't blame this on the Meiteis n Modi also because, Haokip couldn't come to the show live.😂

    • @redundancy100
      @redundancy100 Рік тому +2

      It's easy to vomit all their pre plan concocted data and lies on online rather than facing face to face. 😆

    • @potatoroomkaraoke7762
      @potatoroomkaraoke7762 Рік тому +2

      Maybe they are scared to face the people who speak the truth😂😂

    • @11sunrose
      @11sunrose Рік тому

      The flight tickets from imphal are very costly now maybe that could be the reason.

  • @Cathy-mi1zw
    @Cathy-mi1zw Рік тому +3

    Meiteis should have sent this meitei in Karan Thapars interview

    • @VimsenV
      @VimsenV Рік тому +1

      I agree. Karan Thapar will be Thapaard!

    • @Cathy-mi1zw
      @Cathy-mi1zw Рік тому +1

      @@VimsenV let's see if it happens who gets thappad 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

    • @kalel8141
      @kalel8141 Рік тому +1

      @@Cathy-mi1zw In Thapar's interview all one needs to discuss is the unique history part and he will be bamboozled 😁😁

  • @chandrasekharsingha542
    @chandrasekharsingha542 Рік тому +8

    God will stand up for the Truth
    God will bless and save Manipur
    Long live Manipur

  • @thepipyshow9164
    @thepipyshow9164 Рік тому +6

    May God bless you Dr. A Bimol 🙏

  • @subhrangsudutta8029
    @subhrangsudutta8029 Рік тому +10

    Wonderful Teamwork towards fundamental issues of Manipur 🙏🙏

    • @ThePrintIndia
      @ThePrintIndia  Рік тому +1

      Hi Subhrangsu,
      Happy to note that you liked this video. Thank you for watching.

  • @Pratik-0-0-7
    @Pratik-0-0-7 Рік тому +44

    Famous hate monger Ashok Swain has repeatedly tweeted on the issue with communal intentions as if every riot in 🇮🇳 has to be necessarily communal.

    • @darktower7252
      @darktower7252 Рік тому +1

      Correct!

    • @meis3917
      @meis3917 Рік тому +3

      What is the problem when Sir Ashok spoke for the ones whose voice is not heard by the Central? He isn't a hate monger. Hate mongers are the meiteis, putting in action their hatred towards the tribals.

    • @adsfsgdgfgdfgfh
      @adsfsgdgfgdfgfh Рік тому +4

      @B.Meisharm don't comment like a one sided monger, right now Manipur is burning innocents r dying & u seems enjoying like Mr. Ashok Swain does. Plz act like being a responsible & an educated citizen🙏🏻. Kids game area is in backyards plz🙏🏻

    • @adsfsgdgfgdfgfh
      @adsfsgdgfgdfgfh Рік тому

      that Mr. Ashok Swain is the most prominent monger i had ever seen, he even bring up religious issues between the communities without knowing nothing regarding the issue. He act like a cheap prick in that level of his status

    • @Sam-hm5hm
      @Sam-hm5hm Рік тому +1

      Some in the Meitei community try to make it communal by delibrately targeting Churches

  • @Subh8081
    @Subh8081 Рік тому +42

    "It is almost like ethnic cleansing", "why security forces have not been able to crack down" Dr Bimol says. Some other commentators are also saying the same - "why was the police not controlling the violence". We have seen this before. It could very well be pre-planned. Who benefits from this division between tribals and non-tribals, Hindus and Christians...everyone knows. I hope not only Manipur, but also entire Northeast be on guard against this.

    • @figokipgen4378
      @figokipgen4378 Рік тому

      They burnt down the houses and arson with the help of state force police commando..

    • @lawmisailo3729
      @lawmisailo3729 Рік тому

      Ye ethnic cleansing hi hai kyu ki haatsa hone se pehe govt survey kar raha hain bolke kuki community ka ghar inphal me mark kiya gaya aur thada der ke baat 3 may ko peace rally march khatam hone ke baad me ye kyu haathsa huwa kyu sirf kuki community ko target kiya gaya peace rally to ATSUM kiya tha to sirf kuki ka ghar galaya gaya aur kyu itna kuki ka jaan liya gaya ...

    • @Godfavourite01
      @Godfavourite01 Рік тому

      @MK 💩💩💩💩💩💩💩💩🤏🤏🤏🤏🤏🤏 knowledge 🤔

  • @tikensingh9306
    @tikensingh9306 Рік тому +6

    Very reasonable view of Dr. Bimol.

  • @pothasang7794
    @pothasang7794 Рік тому +6

    today seperate administration, tomorrow seperate state, then seperate country... India has to decide...

  • @ritu3387
    @ritu3387 Рік тому +14

    🙏 salute sir Bimol very well said 👏👏👏long live Manipur

  • @rosegamer1898
    @rosegamer1898 Рік тому +5

    Nice insights by Dr. Akoijam

  • @mkmobilegaming564
    @mkmobilegaming564 Рік тому +5

    The best interview I have seen so far about the current situation in Manipur. 😮