Rebels Against the Raj | Ramachandra Guha in conversation with William Dalrymple

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 10 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 24

  • @fastpublish
    @fastpublish 11 місяців тому +6

    Gandhi's non violence is that of a man standing in front of an armory saying "Let's talk". 300 million people just telling you they won't obey you is violence enough. The British were not driven from India, they were shoved out.

    • @VSM101
      @VSM101 11 місяців тому +1

      lmao your a moron if you think that or even beilve these losers

  • @VSM101
    @VSM101 11 місяців тому +5

    Subas Chandra Bose gave us indpendence Ghandi claimed credit for it thats just facts

    • @rakhimukerji7937
      @rakhimukerji7937 10 місяців тому +1

      GSNDHIJI'S LONG POLITICAL CAREER BUILT THE POLITICS IN INDIA previously there was No P🎉POLITICS as such.

    • @himmsingz
      @himmsingz 3 місяці тому

      Lol. INA was roundly defeated along with the Japanese forces by the allies during the 2nd world war. At least read basic world history.

    • @zaphbrox8239
      @zaphbrox8239 2 місяці тому

      Gandhi, Nehru, Bose and many other freedom fighters contributed. To deny that fact is to display a very naive view and a total lack of education. I've never seen "Ghandi" claim credit for independence anywhere.

  • @rupendra79
    @rupendra79 2 місяці тому

    There are 59 muslim majority countries, do they require inter-faith harmony? Btw muslims are the 2nd largest religion with 25% world population while Hindus are have just 2 countries with 15% population. So Muslims are in majority, they should lead the way not Hindus. Non-Muslims should treat Muslims exactly as Muslims muslims treat non-muslims.
    Mr. Guha has a right to be critital about India but he should also see & talk about world around, nothing is in isolation.
    Another point when India was partitioned millions were killed, the political group who are in power now were at best a fringe elements then (pre-1947). But such gory acts happened, why ?

  • @nshorus5001
    @nshorus5001 2 роки тому +3

    What about Indian scholars who see Ghandi as a tool of the British, that he was part of there establishment working in their interests.

    • @Shaggy-8392
      @Shaggy-8392 Рік тому +6

      Those are RSS scholars.

    • @DipakBose-bq1vv
      @DipakBose-bq1vv Рік тому +1

      For British, Gandhi was their man in India to protect the British Empire. That was the reason his statue was erected not far from the statue of Robert Clive the founder of the British Empire.

    • @DipakBose-bq1vv
      @DipakBose-bq1vv Рік тому

      @@Shaggy-8392 Was Ellen Wilkinson, the education minister of the UK in 1945, who said, Gandhi is the best policeman of ours in India, also a RSS woman?????

    • @nshorus5001
      @nshorus5001 Рік тому

      @@DipakBose-bq1vv exactly, his statue in london is with other figures that served the empire. Not sure which statue you refer to.

    • @mohsin90ish
      @mohsin90ish Рік тому +1

      They need to take their medication

  • @sainidaljit2
    @sainidaljit2 2 роки тому +4

    Sawan mae Naag Nagin ke Darshan acha manna jata hae. Saalle English bol bol krr deshwasio per robb jadhte the Nehru Gandhi Era ke Chamche.

    • @shrahanchoudhury3384
      @shrahanchoudhury3384 2 роки тому +2

      RSS ka book padhna chor de, sab malum parega kaun desh bhakt the aur kaun goro ke talwe chatne ke liye mercy petition likha karte the.
      Ek baat aur Mandir aur bhajan se desh aage nahi badhta hain IIT, AIIMS, IIM jaise institution se desh aage jata hain.

    • @kabirnegi6882
      @kabirnegi6882 2 роки тому +5

      Chup re gawar

    • @sebastianshaw210
      @sebastianshaw210 2 роки тому +1

      @@kabirnegi6882 chup kar. Teri maa ko bolna kal raat maja nahi aaya, shaniwar ko teri behan ko bei bheje

    • @nash5226
      @nash5226 2 роки тому +1

      Haan Bhai bilkul sahi 100 saal baat modi Shah ko gali dengey naye log....apna toh yahi Hain buss right left karke desh barbaat karte rahenge

    • @mkonduru
      @mkonduru Рік тому

      why are you on chamcha youtube ?? do your own viswaguru