Please check out the band Intronaut! A lot of their songs could make great Time Consuming videos! Some songs I’d recommend are Fast Worms, Sul Ponticello, Cubensis and Killing Birds with Stones. Edit: Didn’t think I’d find so many Intronaut fans in the wild wth
I would love to see "beneath the white rainbow" from their last album. It's has a very strong hamasian feel to it, and I think its my favorite song from them.
Great Analysis! I have a theory about the fifth vocal line: I think it was positioned so that the word "have" lines up with the chord change. That way this vocal line can have one pitch per word without any clashing tones when it crosses the bar line.
Dude, thank you for putting all the effort and time into these videos! I really appreciate that you do all the "graphics" by hand with drawings and paperwork. Amazing! Also the explanations a easy to follow. Really good job! 👏
The "arts and craft" portion alone of your videos is amazing, I'd definitely would not have the patience for it :) Thanks for a great explanation on an amazing song!
I love these videos because they give me new things to listen to. The video on Clipping was only one of many. I've always found counting time signatures and overlapping signatures fascinating. Whenever one of your videos come up, I get excited and it's the first thing I look at. I like Haken (been looking at their stuff over the past 6 months and realized I've been missing out). I've know of them for a while, but never paid attention before. Thanks, Yogev. Love your channel.
I got into Haken in 2020 and was blown away by their first four albums. I've always liked this part of Somebody, but I've been hearing Vox III's melody wrong this entire time. It sounds like Vox V has a harmony too.
Every single one of their albums are so vastly different from one another, that they cannot be compared. So they really havent peaked anywhere, as there is nothing to compare
Awesome. A simpler version of those over-the-bar vocals is in that sick section of Specular Reflection/Extremophile Elite by BTBAM! Always loved how it sounds
UltraPolymeter sections are a good way to add variety to a track, and if you are an electronic producer they are pretty easy to make. I have some in my 1st album, tho that album aged considerably compared to my latest but I'll include another one in the 6th that I'm working on.
So happy to see you talking about Haken, and about Somebody especially! It’s been a favorite of mine for years, but there were still layers that I hadn’t consciously noticed (vox V woooaa), so thanks for that. Also congrats for getting out of your comfort zone with the singing
Duuuuuuuuude... what a huge leap forward in your visual language. I'm a melody guy, polymeter comes to me through flow and your new melodic additions visually & sonicly made this whole thing go down like butter. You're the cutting edge of rhythm analysis. 🔥
My choir covers Haken's Somebody, and in that section the stranger changed the bass so I could sing it. I sing the 9 syllable version, and the first 2 parts I have 4 notes per bar (half, dotted quarter, half, dotted quarter) My lyrics would repeat after 9 bars, but instead after 8 bars my bass changes to something with 8 notes per bar (¼ ¼ ⅛ ¼ ¼ ¼ ⅛ ¼). So now, what should've been one more bar until restarting, becomes half a bar, so we technically don't restart. So 5 bars later (half + 4.5) I finally start the line on the one. At that point I have 3 bars left, so I never finish a loop. The stranger also added a role where a singer sings on all off-beats, so 7 per bar, repeating on bar 9. We got this line ingrained in our head so hard that we sometimes sing other songs with "I wish I could have been somebody". example: יונתן הקטן I wish I - could have been somebody I wish I could have been some - body I wish I could have been somebody I wish I could have been somebody I wish I could have - been somebo- dy I wish I could
I always loved this song and especially this section. And I thought it was really catchy and it motivated me to sing along. I never took the time to anaylze it though. Thanks for that 👍
So happy to see you back and covering new songs and bands! That's amazing! :D Looking forward to seeing what you will come up with next. Maybe cover some of Leprous new songs? :D :D :D :D
Yogev, you may have meant B natural in the second half of the first guitar melody you showed on the edit. It’s correct on your big boards afterwards. Otherwise amazing! So great to see Haken getting more academic attention.
also, we previously did a cover of Haken's Cockroach King, and we had trouble nailing the part that goes back and forth between 10/8 and 9/8. I was inspired by your channel to made a video explaining the aksak there, how the different intstrumental (in our case vocal) layers go together, it was really fun (and exhausting, I didn't even have to make it clear for a general audience and it was still so much work, how do you do this crap aghh 😂)
Yogev, I really think you are worrying about your singing too much. That’s very decent, and we are here not for the vocal lessons. And you are brave enough to sing! I would had never sing in a video, which will be watched by thousands of people. Great work!
I've been wondering what to call those "lyric cycles". There's one in The Books' "Beautiful People" that uses a 5-syllable lyric against a 6-note melody. If you used lyrics, melody, and rhythm, you could create a three-layer cycle with a single performer. For example, a 5-syllable lyric, using a 4-note melody, and a 2-2-3 rhythm. The cycle length would be lcm(5, 4, 3) * ((2+2+3)/3) = 140 subdivision pulses.
When I was watching the "stupid joke" part I found that I too am extremely handsome and I am a prog drummer as well. On another note, I did not know Haken. I went ant listen to them first and I absolutely love the sound. Love your channel!
Seeing as you are in to Haken, why not take the vocal insanity of their song "Puzzle Box" into consideration for another video soon? I am to this day completely baffled that they manage to perform that live.
How long did that stop motion intro take to make? That's neat lol. Great video, Im not a musician at all but I love breakdowns like this. Awesome channel my dude 🎉
Sorry to nitpick when I'm not even done the video, but @1:55 I believe the initial Bb on the 3rd and 4th repetitions is either wrongly notated or played, it sounds like a B? Other than than loving the video, looking forward to the rest 😅 edit: everywhere else it's a B so we're def all on the same page :D thanks for all your hard work with this stuff Yogev, love the videos!
Reminds me alot of the acapella bit in their (imo) Magnum Opus "Crystalize", from the EP "Restoration" (ua-cam.com/video/DjaE3w8j6vY/v-deo.htmlsi=-uY5D5oPiZLR7IST&t=555, starts at 9.15). Actually, I just notice that this song only has 1m on spotify, please people, if you like Haken, check it out. It'll change your life!
2:00 Shouldn't the melody in bars 3 and 4 start with B natural? At least that's what is sounds like then. And also 6:43. The second note in the keyboard line was E (and sounded E), but for some reason there's an A on the board in that place.
Finally! the day has come! haken x Yogev!!!
Yo we have the same pfp
and this song, the most overlooked song on the mountain, it doesn't have big riff moments, but man all the elements are peak prog
Amazing! Thanks for taking the time to feature our music!
Yall are insane!!
I’m glad you’re covering Haken! The first time I heard this section of Somebody it blew my mind
Ah yes, Please keep Going on the haken road, they have tons of great rythmic stuff! 🤩
Yogev puts good effort into the charts despite his channel size.
Textbook overqualified for the job.
Hi man, doesn't matter if 1 person is listening or 1,000,000, quality is top priority.
You deserve it !
this has always been one of the coolest parts by haken in my mind. if you make more haken videos, it would be very welcomed!
I loved trying to sing Somebody, glad you're tackling it!
Please check out the band Intronaut! A lot of their songs could make great Time Consuming videos! Some songs I’d recommend are Fast Worms, Sul Ponticello, Cubensis and Killing Birds with Stones.
Edit: Didn’t think I’d find so many Intronaut fans in the wild wth
He should, Intronaut are my favorite band
@@JRam998 Nice to find another intronaut fan in the wild! They are soo underrated
Fast worm mid section is my ringtone
@@leonardotiezzi2904 understandable haha
Matt Lynch is a beast!
Haken is my favorite band. Happy to see you covering them! They're incredible, and have lots of crazy rhythmic stuff
The material of your content is pure luxury. This is definitely much appreciated and, in cases like this one, more than needed.
Haken’s the best 🤘 They’re heavily influenced by Gentle Giant, especially shown when they do these layered vocal sections.
7:55 Look at Thomas Haake, thats where all of that stuff has gone. A tribute the unpredictable god.
I would love to see "beneath the white rainbow" from their last album. It's has a very strong hamasian feel to it, and I think its my favorite song from them.
haha piano go duh DEEEE duh dayn dayn da DEEEE da day duh
This is some pretty early Santa! Somebody is one of those few life-changing songs out there
Great Analysis!
I have a theory about the fifth vocal line: I think it was positioned so that the word "have" lines up with the chord change. That way this vocal line can have one pitch per word without any clashing tones when it crosses the bar line.
Also it sounds super cool :)
Dude, thank you for putting all the effort and time into these videos! I really appreciate that you do all the "graphics" by hand with drawings and paperwork. Amazing! Also the explanations a easy to follow. Really good job! 👏
Thanks so much !
I love the "analog" graphic style, it's super fun !
OHHH MY FUCKING GOD finally some love for this song, the most criminally underrated haken song
This is my personal favourite song of the album. Super emotional and well thought out !
I've always loved how smart that part of Somebody is, which may be my favorite Haken song ever ! So cool to see it here !
Finaly, Yogev tackles the best band in the world. Utterly brilliant work, sir. Some good laughs, too. A+
Man I love Haken, glad to see you tackle them and somebody is such a perfect fit for your analysis.
3:29 i love singing along to this part
Dude your singing is fine. Does the job well doesn’t have to be fancy but it works
The "arts and craft" portion alone of your videos is amazing, I'd definitely would not have the patience for it :) Thanks for a great explanation on an amazing song!
I love these videos because they give me new things to listen to. The video on Clipping was only one of many. I've always found counting time signatures and overlapping signatures fascinating. Whenever one of your videos come up, I get excited and it's the first thing I look at. I like Haken (been looking at their stuff over the past 6 months and realized I've been missing out). I've know of them for a while, but never paid attention before. Thanks, Yogev. Love your channel.
Ohhh this makes me very happy !
I love that clippin song, it's crazy !
10:31 you still have that epic "phantoms" graphic! wow!
Oh hell yeh.
I have the 'Bleed' boards of the other wall !
ive listened to haken so much as soon as you said "have you ever wondered" i thought you were going to say "have you ever wished to be somebody"
Would love to see more Haken. Great work!
I got into Haken in 2020 and was blown away by their first four albums. I've always liked this part of Somebody, but I've been hearing Vox III's melody wrong this entire time. It sounds like Vox V has a harmony too.
So happy to learn from you again...
Thanks !
They peaked with The Mountain. What a fantastic album.
Every single one of their albums are so vastly different from one another, that they cannot be compared. So they really havent peaked anywhere, as there is nothing to compare
I guess they knew it was their peak and that's why they called it The Mountain
Awesome. A simpler version of those over-the-bar vocals is in that sick section of Specular Reflection/Extremophile Elite by BTBAM! Always loved how it sounds
Haken is a great underrated band definitely, the 3 last records are too awesome, saw them live and it was fantastic
Yeaaah more Haken stuff pleaaase ! 😍
Omg, i love this song, thank you. Do more haken!
UltraPolymeter sections are a good way to add variety to a track, and if you are an electronic producer they are pretty easy to make.
I have some in my 1st album, tho that album aged considerably compared to my latest but I'll include another one in the 6th that I'm working on.
6th !! nice !
Send a song here!
So glad you're doing Haken!!
So happy to see you talking about Haken, and about Somebody especially! It’s been a favorite of mine for years, but there were still layers that I hadn’t consciously noticed (vox V woooaa), so thanks for that.
Also congrats for getting out of your comfort zone with the singing
Man, I'm surprised people haven't left the channel the moment ANY sort of melody comes out of my mouth hahah
The Mountain is a masterpiece!
man this must've Haken a long time to make
Duuuuuuuuude... what a huge leap forward in your visual language. I'm a melody guy, polymeter comes to me through flow and your new melodic additions visually & sonicly made this whole thing go down like butter. You're the cutting edge of rhythm analysis. 🔥
Oh man I'm so happy to hear !!!!
Nice stuff, thanks! looking forward to see more progress groups.
BTBAM also does the sort of lyrical isorhtyhm thing in Specular Reflection and Extremophile Elite. Isorhtyhms in general are a lot of fun to write.
yeahhhhhhhhhh!!!! more haken , pleace
Handsome man strikes again! Thanks for this, I love this song
Cool room decorations
My choir covers Haken's Somebody, and in that section the stranger changed the bass so I could sing it.
I sing the 9 syllable version, and the first 2 parts I have 4 notes per bar (half, dotted quarter, half, dotted quarter)
My lyrics would repeat after 9 bars, but instead after 8 bars my bass changes to something with 8 notes per bar (¼ ¼ ⅛ ¼ ¼ ¼ ⅛ ¼).
So now, what should've been one more bar until restarting, becomes half a bar, so we technically don't restart.
So 5 bars later (half + 4.5) I finally start the line on the one. At that point I have 3 bars left, so I never finish a loop.
The stranger also added a role where a singer sings on all off-beats, so 7 per bar, repeating on bar 9.
We got this line ingrained in our head so hard that we sometimes sing other songs with "I wish I could have been somebody".
example: יונתן הקטן
I wish I - could have been
somebody I wish I could
have been some - body I
wish I could have been
somebody I wish I could
have been somebody I wish
I could have - been somebo-
dy I wish I could
hahahahahah we used to do that with יונתן הקטן all the time
Hell yeah its Dopemass already 🤘
I always loved this song and especially this section. And I thought it was really catchy and it motivated me to sing along. I never took the time to anaylze it though. Thanks for that 👍
always loved this song but now I even love it way more - thanks bro!
This man is a freakin genius!!! 👍👍👍👍
Reminds me of Happy with What You Have to Be Happy With by King Crimson
This part is one of my most favourite pieces of music of all time. It's so incredibly well written!
i take this video as a recommendation to this song, amazing piece of art! cheers from brazil, love your channel dude!
Awesome! Thank you!
Amazing stuff, ver gentle giant
Mind blowing ❤❤
Very cool!
So happy to see you back and covering new songs and bands! That's amazing! :D
Looking forward to seeing what you will come up with next. Maybe cover some of Leprous new songs? :D :D :D :D
Ohhhh any specific song ?
@@YogevGabay well their newest track Silently Walking Alone has a pretty weird second verse :)
This has been so great, Yogev
Would love to have a video about the break in Puzzle Box with the cool glitchy beat
Didn't heard of that band before, thanks for the discovery ! (#vocalist 😂 )
Yogev, you may have meant B natural in the second half of the first guitar melody you showed on the edit. It’s correct on your big boards afterwards. Otherwise amazing! So great to see Haken getting more academic attention.
Yup yup that's my bad !
I love Haken (as I love Meshuggah). So... thanks for all :)
Your honestly a good singer!
Now we know the secret to drumming in a prog band.
more haken! more haken!!
#vocalist
also, we previously did a cover of Haken's Cockroach King, and we had trouble nailing the part that goes back and forth between 10/8 and 9/8.
I was inspired by your channel to made a video explaining the aksak there, how the different intstrumental (in our case vocal) layers go together, it was really fun (and exhausting, I didn't even have to make it clear for a general audience and it was still so much work, how do you do this crap aghh 😂)
Weirdly was my favourite off that album years ago. Never thought I'd see an analysis of it!
Yogev what a joy have you back painting and showing this coloured tables of rhythms, awesome as always
Thank you so much 😀
No, no, no, I never wondered that. But I am wondering about it now.
You are this nonstop purple force I have been hearing so much about?
I'm color blind, purple means nothing to me
Yooo you're finally doing the best band on this earth? I demand to know wtf is happening in The Architect
hahahaha that's another Haken song?
@@YogevGabay Yep
Can you believe that they actually play shit like this live? And it sounds amazing, too. I love this band.
Incredible stuff as always man!
Yogev, I really think you are worrying about your singing too much. That’s very decent, and we are here not for the vocal lessons. And you are brave enough to sing! I would had never sing in a video, which will be watched by thousands of people. Great work!
hahaha I really HOPE no one takes vocal lessons from me!
Thanks !!
7:58 Cant forget Chorse's Josh Griffin
Dude...please deep dive in Haken...and we need more of your vocals...
I will dive more into them.
I will not dive more into singing.
That's just how life will be.
It's for your own safety !
huuuuge job!!
sounds like they got inspiried by listening to king crimsons three of a perfect pair album!
I've been wondering what to call those "lyric cycles". There's one in The Books' "Beautiful People" that uses a 5-syllable lyric against a 6-note melody. If you used lyrics, melody, and rhythm, you could create a three-layer cycle with a single performer. For example, a 5-syllable lyric, using a 4-note melody, and a 2-2-3 rhythm. The cycle length would be lcm(5, 4, 3) * ((2+2+3)/3) = 140 subdivision pulses.
This video is good good good good good good good.
Haken was the first band I saw where people had to sing lower because their concert volume is only as high as needed and does not blow your ears
Let's gooooo, more Haken!
When I was watching the "stupid joke" part I found that I too am extremely handsome and I am a prog drummer as well.
On another note, I did not know Haken. I went ant listen to them first and I absolutely love the sound. Love your channel!
SEEE?!?! we're all handsome.
Hell yeah!! Love Haken, they’re my go-to other than Meshuggah
Keep up the great work! Hope to listen to a Distorted Harmony new album soon!
Oh I wishhhhhhhhhh
"That's a good sign." LOL
You're missing Josh Griffin in your lineup of handsome prog drummers.
Oh shiiiittt he's the Caligulas Horse dude?
@@YogevGabay that's the one!
Seeing as you are in to Haken, why not take the vocal insanity of their song "Puzzle Box" into consideration for another video soon? I am to this day completely baffled that they manage to perform that live.
noted !!
How long did that stop motion intro take to make? That's neat lol. Great video, Im not a musician at all but I love breakdowns like this. Awesome channel my dude 🎉
All the editing is insanely good, you should be proud of the videos you make cause they are top-notch. You should be charging for this lol
hahahaha that took a while indeed!
Happy you enjoy the stuff !
more haken please
EXTREMLY!!! (Also, I qualify)
Now please make Sempiternal Beings make sense
Bald bearded prog metal drummers. btw, great song, great explanation, great video. Thanks from a bald bearded prog metal guitarist.
Vox 5 lands on the last snare hit, so I think it works out
Sorry to nitpick when I'm not even done the video, but @1:55 I believe the initial Bb on the 3rd and 4th repetitions is either wrongly notated or played, it sounds like a B? Other than than loving the video, looking forward to the rest 😅
edit: everywhere else it's a B so we're def all on the same page :D thanks for all your hard work with this stuff Yogev, love the videos!
Hi man, I'm a drummer, there's only so much melodic info I can get right hahahahahahahah
yes!!!
NONWAYYYY HAKEEEEEEN!!!!!
Reminds me alot of the acapella bit in their (imo) Magnum Opus "Crystalize", from the EP "Restoration" (ua-cam.com/video/DjaE3w8j6vY/v-deo.htmlsi=-uY5D5oPiZLR7IST&t=555, starts at 9.15). Actually, I just notice that this song only has 1m on spotify, please people, if you like Haken, check it out. It'll change your life!
2:00
Shouldn't the melody in bars 3 and 4 start with B natural? At least that's what is sounds like then.
And also 6:43. The second note in the keyboard line was E (and sounded E), but for some reason there's an A on the board in that place.