I'm 63, and this solo still gives me the chills. DG is the greatest ever. Notice how really talented guitarists have no need to dance around and showboat. They just play! I've looped this solo into an hour long track, just cant stop listening.
Unless of course you're a virtuoso like Tommy Emmanuel and just naturally hyperactive and can't sit still! That's just his nature and there's no doubt he's really talented! Tommy aside, I still mostly agree with what you're saying. As long as some 'stank face' action such as Joe Bonamassa for example isn't included in that! 😉
He is far better over the last 30 years. Then he was early in his career. He has always been a fantastic guitar player now his voice is even better than it was. He is simply the best.
The neatest thing about David is that unlike so many other legends, he hasn’t missed a beat as he has grown older. I once read that’s because he continues to practice when he’s not playing out. His concert in Pompeii is one for the ages. One of the very best guitarists of all time!👍
Still got the original vinyl, sounds a great as ever. But listening to him playing it over the years, it's amazing how he just gets even better with time.
In 100 years from now teenagers all over the globe will hear this for the first time and say to themselves HOLY FUCK HOW GOOD IS THAT! timeless pink floyd.
And thanks to ridiculous copyright laws, the descendants of David Gilmour will still be collecting royalties from this song when your grandkids are retired. Copyright laws now protect works of art for the life of the artist PLUS ONE HUNDRED YEARS! The original copyright laws in the USA were for 12 years, plus an optional 12 year extension for a maximum total of 24 years, after which the work went into the "public domain." Lobbyists from the entertainment industry and corrupt politicians wrecked the system.
David (and Roger!) created a timeless deliciously depressing album in the purely English manner... David’s solos cry out beautiful sadness that rivals Mozart and Mahler. The Floyd, Led Zep and The Stones forever!
He's not the fastest, or does stuff technically great, he just plays the PERFECT SOLO. Notes, phrases, everything are PERFECT. They just fit the song perfectly.
1 year ago, 2022, I was 68 and yes this solo still gets me going !! Been a fan since 1970 when I first hear PF on Atom Hear Mother (my first PF album) then Meddle !!
Gilmour is brilliant,the notes he chooses, and what notes he sustains the guitar solo almost brings tears to my eyes It's so beautiful, truly a genius. This song never gets old.
Thank you David, for release this Masterpiece of Rock History ... all of your fans thank your forever plays single note you play .. long, long live SIR DAVID forever
@@martincummings7886 Carlos Santana, for starters. With music there will always be a subjective opinion to offer. What Gilmour is able to do with a few monumental notes Santana is also able to do...In Spanish.....
Eddie Van Halen, when asked who his favorite guitarist was, answered “David Gilmour hands down. He can do more with a single note than I can do with the entire fretboard.” Atmosphere is so key and taken for granted by non-guitarists. Plenty of people can play the same notes as Gilmour, but few can make their guitar sing like he can.
Gilmore shines, as always. I read through many of the compliments. It was amazing how many I had to translate. The entire world's favorite band and songs of all time. Mine too!
Magistrale interpretazione del brano.qualunque versione sia ghilmour e sempre magistrale.nella vita non poteva fare altro solo il magistrale chitarrista.dio gli ha dato questo dono e lui lo ha espresso magicamente come tutto il gruppo originale che io ho visto a Rotterdam nel 1971 dove vivevo.ho 74 anni ho tutti i loro cd morirò sicuramente con la loro musica nelle orecchie.Dainese Aldo.emozioni uniche che spaziano nell'infinito.
L'ascolto sempre ad occhi chiusi senza poterne fare a meno di ripensare ai due concerti a cui ho avuto il piacere di assistere e rabbrividirne al ricordo. Ineguagliabile.
I was fortunate to attend The About Face Tour at The Beacon Theater in NYC and at The Jones Beach Theater on Long Island. Not to mention when He toured as Pink Floyd post Roger. It was every bit of PF show you could imagine. Front row seats at Giant Stadium. Comfortably Numb becomes a spiritual event when David is playing.
It is interesting to witness the evolution of this solo from its origin in the The Wall live days to the mid-80s. This version is in between the original version and the epic prolonged, slower version that Gilmour made a central part of the show in the late-PF era. Some licks and some phrases appear in this 1984 version that later would be reordered and eventually compose the latest version of the solo. It is also interesting to note that this 1984 version is in the middle also as far as the tempo is concerned: not quite slow as from the Lapse tour but already slower than the The Wall version.
Chris Cornell commented on singing his lyrics differently in the studio versus live he was talking about going into a session without a definite understanding of how his own lyrics were too be sung, he would just try it some certain ways and that was that, that later having it be " different or untypical" versus what Was on wax would bother him like there was never a defined way to do any of that; same applies with David//
Gilmour said in an interview I saw, "It's amazing what a good living you can make bending bits of metal." I suppose he's right in a way, Rembrandt was a master at merely flicking bits of paint.
Wow! I'm loving all the new ones I'm coming across, that I hadn't seen/heard before. I've been totally immersed in PF and Gilmour these past couple of weeks, although a fan since beginning of '70.
The Live in Pompeii version is the best. That's because Gilmour's finale is 2 seconds longer than the next longest I could find. Hey, 2 seconds is 2 seconds!
Best song in the world for sure. Many choices but this one does it. Guitar solo makes love to you and its like he is taking the pics out of all other Guitar players and solos
OMG, that was so good!! I would say I was speechless, but I'm not. I have seen a lot of bands perform, yet the others performed individually for the crowd. These guys were performing for another; with one another....like what, a professional garage band? They were jamming!! And Gilmore on that guitar... the control, the timing, perfect! I'm blown away.
No question about it. It has matured right along with the incredible sounds that he gets from his many guitars... it can be kinda raunchy deep or a sweeter high pitch but regardless never equalled.
Ese mismo tema, 9 años después en la gira Pulse, se convertía en el solo de viola más increíble jamás creado, más de 6 minutos de la magia total, de un viaje astral por el Cosmos. Gracias, maestro David por haber creado una obra insuperable, y gracias a la vida y al destino por haberme hecho contemporáneo de esta maravillosa banda...
Very talented musicians, but god isn’t he fantastically talented. Could listen for hours, love it the most when they look like they’re just really having fun.
Insane rendition. The additional guitarists & artists look like they are in dreamland, swimming in those notes & digging every moment of it. Nick & David meanwhile : muscle memory ❤️ Pink Floyd is a GOAT Superband. PERIOD.
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
I'm 63, and this solo still gives me the chills. DG is the greatest ever. Notice how really talented guitarists have no need to dance around and showboat. They just play! I've looped this solo into an hour long track, just cant stop listening.
Also 63- saw night 3 at LA Sports Area 1980- you would have had goosebumps on your goosebumps.
Can't agree more. Told my wife to play this solo at end of my funeral
Unless of course you're a virtuoso like Tommy Emmanuel and just naturally hyperactive and can't sit still! That's just his nature and there's no doubt he's really talented! Tommy aside, I still mostly agree with what you're saying. As long as some 'stank face' action such as Joe Bonamassa for example isn't included in that! 😉
Amen
Good muzik
The simplicity with which Gilmour creates the most epic music ever heard from an electric guitar will never cease to amaze me.
One of the best guitar solos ever.
+August Vervloet Yes.
One of!? U mean THE best
The BBC radio listener poll years ago agreed by calling it the best guitar solo of all time.
Surprised people aren't commenting "that's not what the tab says!" Lol
Another solos either short or simple. This one is the best.
It was 1985 and now its 2023, time is still with david Gilmour...... ❤❤
october 2024
pls
12th of October 2024@@cbrrr600
Yep. Oct 2024 here....whatever media our world has in 2124, Gilmour and these songs will survive❤
@@LeslieSunshine17 indeed
Listening to David Gilmour’s guitar and voice is the perfect medicine for the soul.
David's masterful guitar playing is some of the most soulful sounds I've ever heard come out of a guitar in the context of great and timeless songs...
He is far better over the last 30 years. Then he was early in his career. He has always been a fantastic guitar player now his voice is even better than it was. He is simply the best.
One the few that can send chills through your body and tears from your eyes at the same time.
I always get chills hearing the solo.
The neatest thing about David is that unlike so many other legends, he hasn’t missed a beat as he has grown older. I once read that’s because he continues to practice when he’s not playing out. His concert in Pompeii is one for the ages. One of the very best guitarists of all time!👍
Not only does he practice, but he literally still makes songs
Still got the original vinyl, sounds a great as ever. But listening to him playing it over the years, it's amazing how he just gets even better with time.
Like good wine, just get better with time. I was born too late to see so many great guitarists live
The Pompeii performance is outta this world!
We just attended his concert in Rome, the man still got it! amazing grandpa!
I’ve heard it hundreds of times and still get goosebumps when David Gilmour begins singing.
In 100 years from now teenagers all over the globe will hear this for the first time and say to themselves HOLY FUCK HOW GOOD IS THAT! timeless pink floyd.
Best boom
They've been my bomb since birth time in 73.
Saw Gilmour in concert when I had a chance. Not disappointed!
And thanks to ridiculous copyright laws, the descendants of David Gilmour will still be collecting royalties from this song when your grandkids are retired. Copyright laws now protect works of art for the life of the artist PLUS ONE HUNDRED YEARS! The original copyright laws in the USA were for 12 years, plus an optional 12 year extension for a maximum total of 24 years, after which the work went into the "public domain." Lobbyists from the entertainment industry and corrupt politicians wrecked the system.
Unfortunately kids these days only like miley cyrus, fetty wap and stuff that doesn't involve actual musical instruments.
I saw pink floyd in 1994 pregnant, my son is now 20, he is a musician now, he loves pink floyd, as I do, now he has 3 albums. Pink floyd the best💫
A concert with no cell phones. The good ole days
I like David's older wiser,crustier voice! His guitar licks have gotten smoother!
David (and Roger!) created a timeless deliciously depressing album in the purely English manner... David’s solos cry out beautiful sadness that rivals Mozart and Mahler. The Floyd, Led Zep and The Stones forever!
I'm 75 years old and only just heard it for the 1st time , magnificent music and voice .....
Have u been living in a cave??? Lol jk
With 74 still the same voice. Long live David Gilmour. 💪
The same because the lyrics didn't push his vocals when young. A very smart way to write, if you want to be performing the songs later on in life.
@@MrDemoncrusher His voice doesn't change since his appearance on the second Floyd album.
glad he a better back up band
@@MrDemoncrusher agree but also would add that I think it's not so much the lyrics as it's about NOT screaming.👍
@@philsavage9127 not like roger. Screaming made his voice destroy
Gilmour , what a legend there are no words to explain , there are no words to describe how awesome he is !!!!!
He's not the fastest, or does stuff technically great, he just plays the
PERFECT SOLO. Notes, phrases, everything are PERFECT. They just fit the song perfectly.
The casual greatness of David Gilmour’s guitar! Music like this comes once in a lifetime! Wish the tune never ended!
David makes this musical piece of art seem so easy - the man is a genius and no one can convince me otherwise.
Saw David Gilmour About Face Tour Live 1984 Boston Orpheum. Incredible concert, from a great solo album. One of the best.
Incredible
Dave was so powerful then and sounds even stronger in his 70’s. Rock forever !!!!!!! This song will never die.
His voice just gets better....
One of my favorite all-time songs. Thank you for sharing and God bless everyone
David Gilmour....take a bow...!!! what a solo....he is amongst the few who still has not lost touch...
1 year ago, 2022, I was 68 and yes this solo still gets me going !!
Been a fan since 1970 when I first hear PF on Atom Hear Mother (my first PF album) then Meddle !!
What a shame these are all old men now. Talented guys like this shouldn't age. RIP Richard William Wright.
As soon as we enter this old world we have an expiration date!
You clearly didn't hear about Justin Bieber!
@@lockedin60 And all thanks to the first two humans!
@@wataboutya9310 You think so? This planet and Galaxy has an end date.
Agreed!
Paradise opens up when david starts singing.
Dave is a very extraordinary artist with superb skills & techniques on the fret board.
Gilmour is brilliant,the notes he chooses, and what notes he sustains the guitar solo almost brings tears to my eyes It's so beautiful, truly a genius. This song never gets old.
Thank you David, for release this Masterpiece of Rock History ... all of your fans thank your forever plays single note you play ..
long, long live SIR DAVID forever
Best damn song, written by the best damn band EVER. Long live The Floyd.
Mick Ralph’s & Dave Gilmour .....perfect British mix of slow blues an raging solo...bout as good as we got..
One of the best all time greatest songs...thank you Rodger and David..I have probably listened to it 200X
This is a very good version
Wow. I know now David's solos are a masterpiece. It is God's will that I learn how to play these solo's.
For me too!
David is just soooo damn effortless. He's simply the best!!
Gary moore? Blackmore?
Mark Knopfler, Rory Gallagher, Matthias Jabs, Eddie van Halen, Angus & Malcolm Young, Steve Clark, Phil Collen, Yngwie Malmsteen
@@CE-22 page?????????????THE ZEUS
This was my first concert. And it changed my life Dave
David "fuck " Gilmour 🎸🎵🎼🎶🎸😎👊
Where was the concert?
@@Michael-mm3fm pine knob michigan or dte
Still amazes me that 54 people disliked this.
Gilmore is superb especially "live"
Well, it's up to 150. There are always fools out there that dislike for no reason. One of the best guitar solos of all time has to be his song.
@@kenkobra I didnt leave a dislike but I really didnt like how they did Rogers part in this version.
Just a Justin Bieber's fans. Poor persons
Fuck me! His name is GILMOUR, you twat!
@@massoutt /r/gatekeeping
Everyone loves solo #2, which is technically incredible, but I love solo #1 the most. It's just so beautiful.
The first one is my favorite. It is much more melodic and incredibly beautiful as you say.
For me, they both come hand in hand. Both awesomely unique in their own way and crafted to perfection
Agree, I love the first solo..perfect
Gilmour=legendary guitarist. What else is there to say?
He also has a beautiful voice!
Nothing else to say hes the best ever in history
and absolutely gorgeous to look at when he was a young man in Pink Floyd
Good looking too. That's what else to say.
A lot. He is even better in real life. It's possible, green oilskin, warm smile.
It's amazing how his performance of this song got better as he got older.
Please don’t leave soon mr.gilmour 🥺🖤🖤we love you
Possibly the greatest atmospheric guitarist in history.
Exactly. Their are faster and more technically dazzling players but in terms of note choice and overall impact the man is really hard to top.
Not Probably HE IS THE GREATEST OF ALL TIME END OF
@@martincummings7886 Carlos Santana, for starters. With music there will always be a subjective opinion to offer. What Gilmour is able to do with a few monumental notes Santana is also able to do...In Spanish.....
Eddie Van Halen, when asked who his favorite guitarist was, answered “David Gilmour hands down. He can do more with a single note than I can do with the entire fretboard.”
Atmosphere is so key and taken for granted by non-guitarists. Plenty of people can play the same notes as Gilmour, but few can make their guitar sing like he can.
Ed O’Brien is a strong contender 😊
Gilmore shines, as always. I read through many of the compliments. It was amazing how many I had to translate. The entire world's favorite band and songs of all time. Mine too!
David, I watched you playing in Dallas. It was great.
This song is a story that travels through generations .... A timeless Masterpiece !
Magistrale interpretazione del brano.qualunque versione sia ghilmour e sempre magistrale.nella vita non poteva fare altro solo il magistrale chitarrista.dio gli ha dato questo dono e lui lo ha espresso magicamente come tutto il gruppo originale che io ho visto a Rotterdam nel 1971 dove vivevo.ho 74 anni ho tutti i loro cd morirò sicuramente con la loro musica nelle orecchie.Dainese Aldo.emozioni uniche che spaziano nell'infinito.
L'ascolto sempre ad occhi chiusi senza poterne fare a meno di ripensare ai due concerti a cui ho avuto il piacere di assistere e rabbrividirne al ricordo. Ineguagliabile.
es difícil comentar cuando no tienes palabras para qué tus oídos no puedan creer lo qué suena gracias Gilmur x tu magia
David is a man out of time here with all these 80’s musicians…
I was fortunate to attend The About Face Tour at The Beacon Theater in NYC and at The Jones Beach Theater on Long Island. Not to mention when He toured as Pink Floyd post Roger. It was every bit of PF show you could imagine. Front row seats at Giant Stadium. Comfortably Numb becomes a spiritual event when David is playing.
PINK DAVID FLOYD GILMOUR...the best!!!!
❤❤❤è sempre un piacere ascoltarlo troppo belli gli assoli la canzone è stupenda come lui del resto❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
GREAT NICK MASON !!!
How does he do it? It's magic. Nobody can repeat this.
This performance is a gift to the world and this is the most incredible live performance band to ever grace this 🌎⭐️💥!
my favourite song of all time,but no matter of when,why or wtf for every single time it brings me to tears (floods of) xx
It is interesting to witness the evolution of this solo from its origin in the The Wall live days to the mid-80s. This version is in between the original version and the epic prolonged, slower version that Gilmour made a central part of the show in the late-PF era. Some licks and some phrases appear in this 1984 version that later would be reordered and eventually compose the latest version of the solo. It is also interesting to note that this 1984 version is in the middle also as far as the tempo is concerned: not quite slow as from the Lapse tour but already slower than the The Wall version.
The next year, 1986, at the Colombian appeal concert he did a blinding rendition. Puts this one - and every other one - in the shade.
Chris Cornell commented on singing his lyrics differently in the studio versus live he was talking about going into a session without a definite understanding of how his own lyrics were too be sung, he would just try it some certain ways and that was that, that later having it be " different or untypical" versus what Was on wax would bother him like there was never a defined way to do any of that; same applies with David//
Crazy. I was 7 yrs old when this happened. And now only 2 years ago I finally started listening Pink Floyd!
I was 31 when this happened and had been listening to Pink Floyd since 1968.
Listen to this PF song......"Careful with that ax Eugene" from Ummagumma
I was not even born. I only started listening to them now (I'm 26). Now I know why so much people went nuts for them when I was 14.
If only 1 band to listen to for the rest of my life....Floyd!!
Enjoy catching up with it all!
Awesome cut. One of my favorite live versions. Personally, I rate it tops of all live covers I've seen. Whatever, it's one amazing piece of work.
Amazing indeed 😎🎸🪶🎈🥁🙌🧭✌️🎹😎🎶🎼🌎👣🎵🎤✝️☮️🎶🎼
I Second that,, David Gilmour, The Best, Vocalist & Guitarist!!!
So gifted ,voice and guitar, combination almost impossible...
Auguri a tutti i fans dei pink floyd e a gjilmoorr x un buon 2024.
david gilmours voice and guitar playing is so soothing, what a god
Gilmour said in an interview I saw, "It's amazing what a good living you can make bending bits of metal."
I suppose he's right in a way, Rembrandt was a master at merely flicking bits of paint.
Quite probably the greatest solo of all time....and he plays it better now than he did back then....its matured like a fine Cabernet Sauvignon....
Wow! I'm loving all the new ones I'm coming across, that I hadn't seen/heard before. I've been totally immersed in PF and Gilmour these past couple of weeks, although a fan since beginning of '70.
The Live in Pompeii version is the best. That's because Gilmour's finale is 2 seconds longer than the next longest I could find. Hey, 2 seconds is 2 seconds!
Wow, nice show. Thanks for sharing. 👍🤟❤ PF forever!
Doesn't matter if 54 ppl disliked this... their taste must be up their arse.
Comfortably Numb is beyond amazingly brilliant.
He is a wonderful guitarist
the greatest guitar solo x2 . total genius
The guitar to this solo is just simply amazing!
Best song in the world for sure.
Many choices but this one does it.
Guitar solo makes love to you and its like he is taking the pics out of all other Guitar players and solos
Very few bands have two signature voices... ❤❤
OMG, that was so good!! I would say I was speechless, but I'm not. I have seen a lot of bands perform, yet the others performed individually for the crowd. These guys were performing for another; with one another....like what, a professional garage band? They were jamming!! And Gilmore on that guitar... the control, the timing, perfect! I'm blown away.
I would say that over the years he has improved his voice
No question about it. It has matured right along with the incredible sounds that he gets from his many guitars... it can be kinda raunchy deep or a sweeter high pitch but regardless never equalled.
Yeah, just like M.Knopfler:)
Här kommer ni att få höra världens bäst solo någonsin på sin gitarr.Helt jävla fantastiskt,helt otroligt solo.
Watching in quarantine...Raff Ravenscroft is in this...he did the original sax of Baker Street by Gerry Rafferty...the greatest sax solo of all time
I’d say Will You is up there? I’m not saying Raf Ravenscroft isn’t incredible! Loads of amazing sax on Floyd and other artists albums
Esse solo de guitarra é mágico, espetacular.
La misma voz....pero la guitarra ha evolucionado de una manera magistral.
Un rockero virtuoso.
Saw him there in '84. He was on fire.
Да это супер концерт! Дай Бог им всем здоровья!
David Gilmour, grandioso desde siempre, increíble musico, maravilloso ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Ese mismo tema, 9 años después en la gira Pulse, se convertía en el solo de viola más increíble jamás creado, más de 6 minutos de la magia total, de un viaje astral por el Cosmos. Gracias, maestro David por haber creado una obra insuperable, y gracias a la vida y al destino por haberme hecho contemporáneo de esta maravillosa banda...
yes, i was in highschool when i first heard this song....mr.david is awesone guitarist..
Very talented musicians, but god isn’t he fantastically talented. Could listen for hours, love it the most when they look like they’re just really having fun.
ONE of the best solos ever.
2 of the best solos ever
Simply thre best guitar for ever sand ever!!!! Thsnkd Guilmor!
Masterpiec of the Floyd. David Gimour is a guitar master.
I saw this concert live, in the fox theater in St Louis MO, good old days........
love this live version...classs!
I adore this song ..!!!
hi there! yea u cant beat a bit o pink floyd aye!
more music we both luv;)
so howz ur day been...?
leigh mccallum Hay sweet, im good thanks , how are you ?....Pink Floyd rocks !!!
yeah, i'm good too!!
so wot u doin 2nite anything special??
mad how much music we 'ave n common!!
msg bk.xx
leigh mccallum Its all about having good taste sweet......Anyone on our level where music is concerned... Rocks...!!!!
Have been a fan since 1972. Wore my Meddle album out with my JBL studio monitors.
David is simply brilliant
The only black mark on his career is the "Fake Floyd" nonsense...
……….no words, jaw on floor with goose pimples.
Слушаю с 80х и по сей день, браво!
This has to be one of the best efforts
Delightful to see Mick Ralphs
HOW can you tell you are a great guitarist?? When Mick Ralphs from Mott the Hoople and Bad Company is your rhythm guitarist!!!!!! AWESOME SONG!!
Insane rendition. The additional guitarists & artists look like they are in dreamland, swimming in those notes & digging every moment of it.
Nick & David meanwhile : muscle memory ❤️
Pink Floyd is a GOAT Superband. PERIOD.
Gilmour/Clapton and Knopfler should of all got together and done a set, that would of been THE concert of all time !!!!
Well anyone of them might just be dead any day now.... but your list is mine as well.
Gary Moore aswell
Let's add Jerry Garcia too that.
@@seanhealy9671 if you like Gary then go and see a track I uploaded in 2008, Gary Moore and BB King The Thrill is Gone - its her eon UA-cam
@James Mcrory:... Would HAVE.