wow this recording is just so perfect. Applause to Anna for her beauty, acting, and singing! Applause the the costume designers and stage designers as well!!! Just wow!!
I love it but I can't understand a single word of what she says and I am French ^^. I am still a big fan of hers but really the subtitles are actually a big help !
@@christophan1 et surtout comprendre ce qu'elle dit ben c'est quand même mieux ^^. C'est quand même hyper important en fait ! c'est de l'opéra... donc du théâtre :) .
Anna has some defects as Manon - pitch, pronunciation. And yet she is so magnetic that she manages to create a thrilling Manon. By the way, the scenery is funny - the Eiffel Tower is nowhere near the Cours le Reine!
Crediamo oramai che il Re sopracuto la Netrebko non lo fara' piu' tanto spesso...dopo le ultime esibizioni....addio Elvire, addio Lucie, addio Manon...per fare poi del Verismo....peccato.
first there is the russian accent, and she doesn't pronounce correctly, her vowels are too round and too soft. French is a language that necessitates a clear enunciation with "mordant" and precise consonants. Plus you have to differenciate the different nasal sounds. It is so easy in french to hear if someone is a stranger or not.
зачем брать произведения, где много колоратуры, у нее не подвижный голос, гагагага вот эти, в половину нот не попадает, то, что маэстро написал не соблюдает, ужас. лирическому сопрано петь нужно то. что позволяет голос, а не ради хайпа браться за все подряд. позорище
ralphoperaphile yet...she continuously packs opera houses wherever she goes. She, too, is well received at the Met, the very place she recorded this , in your opinion, singing flat, French is mush and wobble. Enjoy it!
@@alexandroalvarez2464 True - but that might just be an indication of the decline in vocal standards over recent years; after all, who else is there? I'm afraid I don't enjoy it when I can hear singers who do it so much better, However, I don't begrudge her success; anyone who can perform opera demands admiration.
❤c est l une de ses meilleures interprétations , très magnifique
The best Manon I’ve seen!!!
I love her easyness and freedom!
These shows are already legendary and iconic of the early 2000s.
Brava, Anna!
wow this recording is just so perfect. Applause to Anna for her beauty, acting, and singing! Applause the the costume designers and stage designers as well!!! Just wow!!
Как Нетребко хороша! И внешность- как картинка ! И голос - чудо! Залюбуешься, заслушиваешься!
Wonderful!!as always!!!
Ну бесподобно же анна вы чудо как всегда брависсимо пусть вас окружает любовь и обожан
Que naturalidad cantando. Que voz y que interpretacion.
Que facilidad para atacar los agudos
Apasionada Anna como siempre.
!! BRAVA ANNA !!
Красавица необыкновенная Чудо,как хороша! В восхищении! Анна,Вы прекрасны, особенно в те годы!
Если сбросит вес,будет такая же красавица!!!
Как жалко, что с такой красавицей не сняты музыкальные фильмы.С каким удовольствием мы бы их смотрели!
@@verabagryanova6253
Да, тоже об этом подумала.
Belle interprétation ❤
Красива и прекрасна !👏👏👏👏👏🌹🌹🌹🌹👍
Wow Anna. !!! Excellent All around !
Очарование в каждой нотке, в каждом жесте😍
Bella
Ah...la jeunesse....
:/..
This video show in a glance how the people react to her.. All the men fall in love, the women are amazed
Grande!!!
Aie, le son!!!
I love it but I can't understand a single word of what she says and I am French ^^. I am still a big fan of hers but really the subtitles are actually a big help !
oh come on...haha.
@@MaestroWenarto i am really serious : not a single word =) But still beautiful.
@@christophan1 et surtout comprendre ce qu'elle dit ben c'est quand même mieux ^^. C'est quand même hyper important en fait ! c'est de l'opéra... donc du théâtre :) .
Таисия меня зовут слово обожание дописала гуд бай а анну нетребко люблю и тьяго и юсифа тоже .браво тася
Anna has some defects as Manon - pitch, pronunciation. And yet she is so magnetic that she manages to create a thrilling Manon. By the way, the scenery is funny - the Eiffel Tower is nowhere near the Cours le Reine!
je l'aime
Manon's costume is channelling definite Brigitte Bardot vibes.
She is very good like a liric soprano (light and easy), but I don't like her in dramatic roles!
Helena Ivanova x2
0:59
Il faudrait un sous-titrage, on ne comprend rien au texte.
Lovely, just what one wants in a Manon!
But
Those high notes are painfully flat, non?
She very much looks like Gina Lolobrigida in the 50’s in that production . Her acting is very good but her French not so much.
@@christophan1 oui je suis française.
@@christophan1 Merci ☺️
U r right regarding Anna's resemblance to Lolobrigida.❤❤❤
Crediamo oramai che il Re sopracuto la Netrebko non lo fara' piu' tanto spesso...dopo le ultime esibizioni....addio Elvire, addio Lucie, addio Manon...per fare poi del Verismo....peccato.
Terrible french i cant understand a single thing even though i’m french
Céline Fiszbin What's the most problems from her diction?
first there is the russian accent, and she doesn't pronounce correctly, her vowels are too round and too soft. French is a language that necessitates a clear enunciation with "mordant" and precise consonants. Plus you have to differenciate the different nasal sounds. It is so easy in french to hear if someone is a stranger or not.
Céline Fiszbin Wow! Thank you so much!
When I practice that song, always think about your comments!♡
good luck ! French is better sung in a natural way, don't deform it
Je confirme... Son français est désastreux !!!
зачем брать произведения, где много колоратуры, у нее не подвижный голос, гагагага вот эти, в половину нот не попадает, то, что маэстро написал не соблюдает, ужас.
лирическому сопрано петь нужно то. что позволяет голос, а не ради хайпа браться за все подряд. позорище
Si il y a des français ne faisais rien 😂(vous pouvez paniquer)
She sings flat, her French is mush and and the wobble is starting. Apart from that, she's great.
ralphoperaphile yet...she continuously packs opera houses wherever she goes. She, too, is well received at the Met, the very place she recorded this , in your opinion, singing flat, French is mush and wobble. Enjoy it!
@@alexandroalvarez2464 True - but that might just be an indication of the decline in vocal standards over recent years; after all, who else is there? I'm afraid I don't enjoy it when I can hear singers who do it so much better, However, I don't begrudge her success; anyone who can perform opera demands admiration.
Mmmm,,, sobre valorada
Es una puesta absurda.
she is really a very pretty girl and a very good singer - I'd love to hear the role of Manon sung by a mezzo soprano - I'd fit better
It's a shame you have no fucking idea what you're talking about.
Manon is not Carmen!
@ariasnribs7243: i spilled my coffee when I read your answer (Y)
lmao...you know shes hitting high Ds
Ridicule.Manon was written for a lyric soprano not for a mezzo
0:41