They didn't totally erase. They kept safety copies, all or most of which have now been released. "Long May You Run" (Neil), "Black Coral" (Stills), "Taken At All" (Nash), "Human Highway" (Neil), Midnight On The Bay"(Neil).
Hearing this great stuff now almost 50 years later makes we want to dust off the old Yamaha...maybe even today...well it is raining again in Old London Town.
Thanks you so much for your love and support towards my career, you're such a hug fan Well I want to personally appreciate you for being my great fan and also thank you for your lovely comments on my post it really means a lot to me have you ever had an opportunity to attend any of my concerts so far?.
These guys are great But, He stills sounds different without Stills And Crosby. Don't know if that is just what I am used to, or their sound was just that special. Anyway this was a great performance by an iconic human being.
Graham Nash has never pretended to be anything except a kid from Manchester who got some breaks.. but he does have a singular gift for harmonies and CSN and CSN and Y would never have got past a rehearsal without his leadership management and holding things together. Musically the least gifted .. granted..but his career is still going And his best songs still stand up.
@@Mystic-ql7qg no, not everyone! Those who’ve not spent much of their life in music wouldn’t know the difference! But in this case, the poor performance detracts from the quality of this Neil Young classic!
This is one of the most beautiful things I have listened to in a long time. Thank you.
Nash sounds very like Neil Young.Hadnt noticed this before. Great song.Simple yet full of music.
I agree
The story goes Stills and Young invited Nash and Crosby to sing on that album and they erased the latter's parts.
They didn't totally erase. They kept safety copies, all or most of which have now been released. "Long May You Run" (Neil), "Black Coral" (Stills), "Taken At All" (Nash), "Human Highway" (Neil), Midnight On The Bay"(Neil).
@@stevebrooks4th That Taken at All is quite good. I haven't heard the CSNY Black Coral, I guess that's the one on the "Carry On" box set.
@@Cpayne30 Yes, it's on the Stills box set. Human Highway and Midnight on the Bay were just released on Neil's Archives Vol. 2.
The Long May You Run version on Neil's Decade album has CSNY voices on this song.
Anything definitive or hearsay..etc..it's very good on many levels!...thanks to everyone and..chrome is overrated!..let's move forward!
What a treat the whole night was! Thanks for posting.
Hey I know something about this place: Jim McGuinn, Mike Bloomfield, John Prine. Why was Graham there?
Hearing this great stuff now almost 50 years later makes we want to dust off the old Yamaha...maybe even today...well it is raining again in Old London Town.
Thanks you so much for your love and support towards my career, you're such a hug fan
Well I want to personally appreciate you for being my great fan and also thank you for your lovely comments on my post it really means a lot to me
have you ever had an opportunity to attend any of my concerts so far?.
Timeless magic of an “everyone” song❤❤❤
Thank you Graham!!
Beautiful and wonderful at play.
Lovely post!
Just finished Graham's autobiography a few weeks ago. It's great to finally hear this song!
Tender and beautiful. I love this. --- Scott from Grand Rapids Michigan.
That’s a nice version
Gorgeous Graham
Excellent!
Brilliant. Thank you. ❤
Great song.
Did Graham have shoes on he still has beautiful voice. I think Neil Stephen an Graham need to do SOMETHING together ❤ 😢
Yes, he wore shoes this time.
Mastered
Love them
Sounded amazing
These guys are great But, He stills sounds different without Stills And Crosby. Don't know if that is just what I am used to, or their sound was just that special. Anyway this was a great performance by an iconic human being.
Graham Nash has never pretended to be anything except a kid from Manchester who got some breaks.. but he does have a singular gift for harmonies and CSN and CSN and Y would never have got past a rehearsal without his leadership management and holding things together. Musically the least gifted .. granted..but his career is still going And his best songs still stand up.
They were all as talented as each other
Sorry, timing and phrasing is way off. In my view, poorly done.
Everybody's a critic!
@@Mystic-ql7qg no, not everyone! Those who’ve not spent much of their life in music wouldn’t know the difference! But in this case, the poor performance detracts from the quality of this Neil Young classic!
i kind of agree. nash not the genius other three were and two still are.