That's the whole message of Red Dead Redemption, don't be an outlaw. Also Red Harlow in Red Dead Revolver are the only protag with happy ending, because he don't do bad things.
Aurthur in the other hand had more moments of happyness in his life, and he felt happy in the gang, so that's fine. John still had struggles in mind during those 4 years, plus knew that people don't forget, that he will have to face his passed in the end. During his gang years, john was clearly the less good in his skin of the two, the most struggling... Arthur saw his life clearer near his end and died feeling redeemed thanks to john and his family
@@nightmarepegasus41412 people misspelling Arthur in a row💀💀 💀 You and that honeybadgersven guy above😭😂 it’s funny not in a mean way but love how as of lately been seeing that everywhere
@@honeybadgersven6540and if you believe in not pitch black when we die Arthur did get a happy ending… In real life there had to have been a few Arthur’s and idk if they had redemption but they maybe ended up in purgatory instead of hell like where 90% of us will go there to redeem or fix our character flaws to be perfect enough for heaven. But yeah shi is crazy
Arthur's life is just sadness and loss, which makes John's death more depressing, because he finally made it, changed, lived a happy life, John's redemption just hits different.
@@sinanaseri3529 Exactly, People start saying ARTHUR's REDEMPTION IS BETTER just because they loved Arthur more, Or never even played the original RDR1 ..
@@SUPERMACY-js7cb Because they didn't play rdr1 and only played Red Dead 2 There is no redemption in Red Dead 2 at all, because this happens by John in Red Dead 1
At least john saw his family one last time before death. But arthur saw his father figure betray him in his last moments. That's what makes arthurs death so sad
I love all the missions that john appear on rdr 2, his interactions and dialogs with arthur are so funny And that badass moment on valentine when arthur saves him hits hard
@@Rl55322 you dont gete a cooler personality out of nowhere 4 years later you dont lose a stuttering problem 4 years later you dont become a better reader 4 years later you dont have a good relationship with ur wife and son 4 years later its clear he was downgraded
Sasuke is the introvert goat of naruto and my favorite character from naruto ngl Sasuke madara indra itachi kakashi and minato are all goated 💯 got the same birthday as Indra too.
Thing bout Arthur is that he not only redeemed himself but he showed others how to as well. Those 4 years John spent were to redeem himself so he doesn’t die a terrible father and husband that nobody’d miss. Mr Marston died a man who lives and dies by family because Arthur showed him the value of brotherhood and familial bonds.
To put it into perspective of how sad it is… RDR1’s story is way closer to the epilogue than the epilogue is to the prologue of RDR2. That is just sad that it was only 4 years of happiness… 4 YEARS!!! Thats the same amount of time as the start of covid was to now.
The worst part is some of those last years were spent trying to fight back against the life he previously lived instead of watching his family grow into the new life Arthur herded them into.
RDR2 is such a fantistic game. I know alot of people dont like the epilogue but it one of my favorite parts of the game. It ties everything into RDR1 so well. I love helping John get Beecher Hope established but its so bitter sweet, knowing John only has a little bit of time before the sins of his past come calling.
That just wouldn’t work the whole reason rdr2 worked is because rdr1 established the gang from the past but left a lot of mystery to it which made it work as a game but there’s no mystery like that for the time before rdr2 and there would be no stakes because every character would have to survive the game
@@haylaytay08 in my opinion I don’t think red dead 3 could be a sequel in any way either though, red dead 1 had a perfect ending for the story as a whole, but I do see what your saying for sure I just love these games man, part 1 is one of my favorite games of all time and I’ll always love it for the memories it gave me We will just have to see what the future offers in the series
@@omglol8425 I think that might be the best idea I’ve seen some people say use a new gang but the red dead redemption series is the story of John marston and his family so unless they can find something to do with Jack the series should probably end here
fun fact: strange man determines the death of them, john shot the strange man twice, killing abigail and john, but on the third shot the gun jammed, sparing jack
He shot 3 shots which the strange man AKA DEATH or GRIM REAPER Made it certain that Abigail, uncle and him die but the last jammed probably why death decided not to 3th degree kill him bye making someone unknowingly kill him at his will.
@gwensstacy442technically is Getting revenge will result some consequences in the future Arthur saved John just so he would watch his family grow But he was still fight the past of those that killed his friends Which resulted in his death
@@LowTierMarstonit would’ve. If he had listened to Abigail to not go and kill Micah they could’ve lived peacefully but when John did kill Micah the Pinkertons found out and then used John to kill the remaining people in the van Der linde then kill John
@@Redeadedxts He would not have lived peacefully he was literally living next to Black Water using his real name, they would've found him eventually, and if he didn't go both Charles and Sadie would have most likely been killed and Micah would've gotten away to cause more harm.
@@LowTierMarston true, but I’m jus talking about John. Yeah Sadie and Charles would’ve died, Micah would’ve caused more trouble but 8 years later the pinkertons wouldn’t be in black water still searching for John. The money from the cabin at mount hagen did allow him to pay off debts and other fees but even if he hadn’t had that money he still would’ve slowly payed off the debt.
John was kinda stupid in 1911. Arthur said to run and don’t look back. So what does John do? Kills Micah which alerts the Pinkertons to him which leads to the kidnapping of his family, then at the barn, keep in mind Arthur’s death wish was for John to run and don’t look back, sends his family off and gets him self killed. His swimming ability wasn’t the only thing the man lacked
If he stayed with them after the army showed up at Beechers Hope, then they would have spent their lives in constant danger which John obviously doesn’t want for them
You mean 1907, Micah and Arthur were never characters in the first game. And also, John would've already been found out since he literally USED his Real Name for buying his house, very near to Blackwater
Because even if he ran they’d just find him, and his family would always be in danger, so instead he sacrifices himself so that Abigail and Jack will be safe
I honestly think john crapped all over arthurs work and he gave john good advice about revenge being a fools game,which costed john his freedom and his peace and then his life
Would you let the person who ruined the gang you were in, who got a bunch of your friends and family killed, and killed your brother (who saved you). Would you let that person go free? I personally wouldn’t.
@omglol8425 john disrespected arthurs last wishes regardless,arthur risked his life for john and his family so they don't have to endure the stress of the government coming after them or any other gangs,he wanted his life away from any violence regardless of what kind and let him be a normal hard working man like everybody else but john decided that his feelings were more important than then fact that arthurs sacrifice and wishes were ignored by his closest friends,he wanted anything but violence for them,but no they ignored his death bed wishes
Arthur gave his last breath to save john. Only for him to commit the mistake of going after Micah, which led to Ross finding where he is and starting the events of red dead redemption
John did so much for the government in rdr1, helped so many innocent people, became famous, then he just died. He became a really good man and then they just killed him. He deserved better.
Arthur gave him life and he gave life to his family, his son😔
Fact
fact
He didn’t though he saved himself
@@DeadX2Arthur saved John
@@DeadX2 Arthur got killed for John
You cannot live a bad life and expect good things to happen to you - Arthur Morgan
Yeah
Exactly ❤
Poor John . When I first played rdr1 I cried when he died and he tried to give his family a happy life..😢
1911 John marstone ❤❤
That's the whole message of Red Dead Redemption, don't be an outlaw. Also Red Harlow in Red Dead Revolver are the only protag with happy ending, because he don't do bad things.
Only 4 years...
Yep that’s the point of the edit good job
@@DeadX2 ey atleast he got happiness aurthur on the other hand....
Aurthur in the other hand had more moments of happyness in his life, and he felt happy in the gang, so that's fine. John still had struggles in mind during those 4 years, plus knew that people don't forget, that he will have to face his passed in the end. During his gang years, john was clearly the less good in his skin of the two, the most struggling... Arthur saw his life clearer near his end and died feeling redeemed thanks to john and his family
@@nightmarepegasus41412 people misspelling Arthur in a row💀💀 💀
You and that honeybadgersven guy above😭😂 it’s funny not in a mean way but love how as of lately been seeing that everywhere
@@honeybadgersven6540and if you believe in not pitch black when we die Arthur did get a happy ending…
In real life there had to have been a few Arthur’s and idk if they had redemption but they maybe ended up in purgatory instead of hell like where 90% of us will go there to redeem or fix our character flaws to be perfect enough for heaven.
But yeah shi is crazy
John only had 4 years of real happiness 💔 (not including his childhood)
his childhood probably wasn't that great either
@@AnimeFan22858not at all,he was saved by dutch of being hanged when he was a kid😂
actually 12
@@emirkara771 not exactly,being 8 years with nowhere to go and looking for job doesnt seem happiness
Yea but most of the gang were never able to find happiness to begin with
"It all started with an hug"
"It all ended with one too"
Damn..
This fr got me crying
@@puppydogtails9093 did i really writed something soo goddamn good?
@@Carl08Mk sarcasm bro
@@UsmanKing7427 or it could be legit, no one knows
Arthur's life is just sadness and loss, which makes John's death more depressing, because he finally made it, changed, lived a happy life, John's redemption just hits different.
What redemption, Arthur had WAY better redemption,
@@GarryVIDS331The main redemption is for John, but for Arthur, you decide whether he will reach redemption or not
@@sinanaseri3529 Exactly, People start saying ARTHUR's REDEMPTION IS BETTER just because they loved Arthur more, Or never even played the original RDR1 ..
@@SUPERMACY-js7cb Because they didn't play rdr1 and only played Red Dead 2 There is no redemption in Red Dead 2 at all, because this happens by John in Red Dead 1
@@SUPERMACY-js7cb And if you decide to play Arthur with low honor, there is no redemption at all
Rest in peace Uncle may there be no lumbago in heaven
It's very serious😂
😂😂😂😂
He actually died in the last recording of finishing building house john
@@TV_WOMAN808elaborate
Lol
At least john saw his family one last time before death. But arthur saw his father figure betray him in his last moments. That's what makes arthurs death so sad
But this More sad the death of John because he's finally can lived whit His family
Perdón si no escribo bien inglés
I never thought of it like that but damn… you’re right
Honestly Rdr1 John scares me, Rdr2 John is you're friendly next door neighbor
I love all the missions that john appear on rdr 2, his interactions and dialogs with arthur are so funny
And that badass moment on valentine when arthur saves him hits hard
Kinda makes sense tho. When your family is held hostage you gotta lock in
Meanwhile the player: John:
Lowest honor
10k+ kills
Robbed every place
1500$ bounty in every state
He is looks kinda funny in rdr2 before epilogue, the way he walks around the camp and his voice
@@Rl55322 you dont gete a cooler personality out of nowhere 4 years later
you dont lose a stuttering problem 4 years later
you dont become a better reader 4 years later
you dont have a good relationship with ur wife and son 4 years later
its clear he was downgraded
One of your best John edits tbh
Sasuke is the introvert goat of naruto and my favorite character from naruto ngl Sasuke madara indra itachi kakashi and minato are all goated 💯 got the same birthday as Indra too.
@@gustavmyers29this edit has nothing to do with anime…?
@@gustavmyers29what is bro yapping about
@@SirSparklepuff his pfp
@@Scared_Yoda tbh who cares obviously you do cause you commented in response right? Also if you know you know.
Uncle died protecting John’s family. They are not bonded by blood, but they’re still family to uncle. RIP, the one-shot kid🙏
The worst of all that he wasnt part of their lifes at the start
This is an example that ‘everything can vanish in a blink of an eye’.. 💔
John's redemption arc in RDR2 hits different. Arthur Morgan's life was filled with sadness and loss.
Thing bout Arthur is that he not only redeemed himself but he showed others how to as well. Those 4 years John spent were to redeem himself so he doesn’t die a terrible father and husband that nobody’d miss. Mr Marston died a man who lives and dies by family because Arthur showed him the value of brotherhood and familial bonds.
just 4 years of peace...
Longer than many of us may say. His life was full
To put it into perspective of how sad it is… RDR1’s story is way closer to the epilogue than the epilogue is to the prologue of RDR2. That is just sad that it was only 4 years of happiness… 4 YEARS!!! Thats the same amount of time as the start of covid was to now.
only 4 years of happiness,rockstars writers really knows how bad a life of a criminal or a outlaw is,
"You saved my life more than once. To give mine for yours is as it should be"
Eagle Flies
RIP Arthur Morgan, still crying to this day 😭
"Nothig ever last forever"💔
I Love red dead clips he make the best edits
RDR2 Epilogue makes RDR1 even sadder than it already was... 😢
I will always cry. Jack will always be lonely.
If only he knew where charles or sadie was😢
And Tilly!
And Mary-Beth
@@themissinlynk6998tilly has a husband and a child, she isn't lonely
@CR7DA_GOAT he meant if Jack knew where Tilly was too
Antagonizing uncle as john he says”how many years you got left Uncle? 3-4 years?” it refers to his death at rdr1
Using “Everybody wants to rule the world” adds a whole nother level of pain to this 😣💔
This is sad bro💔
“No man can walk out on his own story.”
Man those 4 years were the only time John got to rest
The epilogues in rdr2 are truly awsome ❤
Arthur saved his life for 4 years...
More like 12 years
I'm assuming you're basing off of the 1899 time frame as Arthur and not the john time jump after lol@@GeoHjalle
Nah it's 12 years actually.
John died in 1911.
@@slimstrait780 oh i forget that
he didnt
Life catches up to you no matter how late!
Uncle: “what colour’s my beard, John?”
"You are, good Man Arthur"
Yes ❤😢
The worst part is some of those last years were spent trying to fight back against the life he previously lived instead of watching his family grow into the new life Arthur herded them into.
love rdr2 it has so much potential I hope we get a really good update soon 😢
I miss them 💔
Arthur said "when the time comes ,you gotta run and don't look back" but this time John don't have other options.....
14 years later but still really sad
If only uncle didn’t have “LuMbAgO”
Uncle wasn't all that useful in a gun fight tbf, he really was old at that point.
@@slimstrait780 its the lumbago
it's scary how quickly time flies..time wasted can never be got back.
Bro should have popped a potent health tonic
he forgot to restock, he only had canned beans
He forgot to refill his dead eye
Lo siento Bro su producción fue finalizada en 1910
bro u made the most depressing edit into comedy XD
He forgot to load up with max ammo
Damn, this short coming up after a top hitting moments in rdr 1
You left me-John Marston
Rdr1 and rdr2 just hit hard man its sad
Uncle the goat R.I.P
Beautiful edit😢
"I love you"
Famous last words.
imagine needing a whole ass army to kill just one man, he was a fighter until the very last but he fought for his family
Best rdr editor🔥
Dam this one hits different 😢
“Just because it looks good doesn’t mean it will be good”
Nostalgia goes crazy rn
When uncle got shot he stood up
Those were two of the best games I ever played
RDR2 is such a fantistic game. I know alot of people dont like the epilogue but it one of my favorite parts of the game. It ties everything into RDR1 so well. I love helping John get Beecher Hope established but its so bitter sweet, knowing John only has a little bit of time before the sins of his past come calling.
Arthur gave him life and he gave life to his family😢
Arthur redeem himself
John redeem the family
Only four years I feel sad😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😮😮
Red Dead 3 needs to be another prequel
That just wouldn’t work the whole reason rdr2 worked is because rdr1 established the gang from the past but left a lot of mystery to it which made it work as a game but there’s no mystery like that for the time before rdr2 and there would be no stakes because every character would have to survive the game
@@haylaytay08 in my opinion I don’t think red dead 3 could be a sequel in any way either though, red dead 1 had a perfect ending for the story as a whole, but I do see what your saying for sure
I just love these games man, part 1 is one of my favorite games of all time and I’ll always love it for the memories it gave me
We will just have to see what the future offers in the series
@@Vermillion-ty4zr I agree with that red dead 3 is gonna struggle deeply with its plot
@@Vermillion-ty4zrno more red dead games. We already know about most things mentioned in rdr2.
@@omglol8425 I think that might be the best idea I’ve seen some people say use a new gang but the red dead redemption series is the story of John marston and his family so unless they can find something to do with Jack the series should probably end here
That last scene hits hard 😭
😢 John is the best
Getting rdr1 for Christmas… I’m so damn excited to play
fun fact: strange man determines the death of them, john shot the strange man twice, killing abigail and john, but on the third shot the gun jammed, sparing jack
No.
He shot 3 shots which the strange man AKA DEATH or GRIM REAPER
Made it certain that Abigail, uncle and him die but the last jammed probably why death decided not to 3th degree kill him bye making someone unknowingly kill him at his will.
@John_Marston_Rip_Van_Winkle your still alive john?????
@@jacobfleming4464 nah we got phones in heaven, ohh sorry we got phones in hell
@@John_Marston_Rip_Van_Winkle dammmmmmmnnnn
John Martson is my favourite character in the franchise... Almost cried when he died in RDR 1...
only if he didn't go after micah
I mean he bought the house with his real name so eventually he would be found
Only 4 happy years of his life
Revenge is a fools game
Arthur Morgan 1899
@gwensstacy442technically is
Getting revenge will result some consequences in the future
Arthur saved John just so he would watch his family grow
But he was still fight the past of those that killed his friends
Which resulted in his death
Fans: shut up! 💥🔫😡
@@ChefHinIn all reality,him getting revenge didn't change anything cause they would've found regardless.
It was dutch's quote
Its sad how this story is and then you remember they arent real but yet again they are so real😞
John should have listened to Abigail
Wouldn't have changed nothing
@@LowTierMarstonit would’ve. If he had listened to Abigail to not go and kill Micah they could’ve lived peacefully but when John did kill Micah the Pinkertons found out and then used John to kill the remaining people in the van Der linde then kill John
@@Redeadedxts exactly
@@Redeadedxts He would not have lived peacefully he was literally living next to Black Water using his real name, they would've found him eventually, and if he didn't go both Charles and Sadie would have most likely been killed and Micah would've gotten away to cause more harm.
@@LowTierMarston true, but I’m jus talking about John. Yeah Sadie and Charles would’ve died, Micah would’ve caused more trouble but 8 years later the pinkertons wouldn’t be in black water still searching for John. The money from the cabin at mount hagen did allow him to pay off debts and other fees but even if he hadn’t had that money he still would’ve slowly payed off the debt.
it breaks my heart knowing my two favourite protagonists didn’t get their happy ending 😢
“REVENGE IS A FOOLs GAME ”
-morgan
X X X
X X
If John would have only lisend
At least he gets to see his brother again
John can live happily as long you play the epilogue
John🌟
At least he had 4 years of peace
John:”It’s Green You Old Bastard!”
X
X
X
X
this is the most emotional mission
They always die, the good ones
i saw it coming, i obviously saw it coming, but edit still hit hard
John was kinda stupid in 1911. Arthur said to run and don’t look back. So what does John do? Kills Micah which alerts the Pinkertons to him which leads to the kidnapping of his family, then at the barn, keep in mind Arthur’s death wish was for John to run and don’t look back, sends his family off and gets him self killed.
His swimming ability wasn’t the only thing the man lacked
If he stayed with them after the army showed up at Beechers Hope, then they would have spent their lives in constant danger which John obviously doesn’t want for them
You mean 1907, Micah and Arthur were never characters in the first game. And also, John would've already been found out since he literally USED his Real Name for buying his house, very near to Blackwater
@@svb_zer0318 no no, I mean 1911, he knew but didn’t mention it. Should’ve just ran
Because even if he ran they’d just find him, and his family would always be in danger, so instead he sacrifices himself so that Abigail and Jack will be safe
@ then just prepare. He took down the Mexican Army. What’s to say he can’t do that to the Pinkertons
25 hours of sadness😢
I honestly think john crapped all over arthurs work and he gave john good advice about revenge being a fools game,which costed john his freedom and his peace and then his life
Would you let the person who ruined the gang you were in, who got a bunch of your friends and family killed, and killed your brother (who saved you). Would you let that person go free? I personally wouldn’t.
@omglol8425 john disrespected arthurs last wishes regardless,arthur risked his life for john and his family so they don't have to endure the stress of the government coming after them or any other gangs,he wanted his life away from any violence regardless of what kind and let him be a normal hard working man like everybody else but john decided that his feelings were more important than then fact that arthurs sacrifice and wishes were ignored by his closest friends,he wanted anything but violence for them,but no they ignored his death bed wishes
Arthur never says revenge is a fools game to John
@@user-hx6gs9rq7u he doesn’t? I thought he did
@@omglol8425 He only tells him to run and not look back
Good old days
Legends died with honor 😢❤
"Nothing Ever Lasts Forever"
Arthur gave his last breath to save john. Only for him to commit the mistake of going after Micah, which led to Ross finding where he is and starting the events of red dead redemption
I just completed the game and I was crying, the game is at its prime, it's the most majestic game I've ever played.
nothing ever lasts forever
The greatest story in a game ever
This is heartbreaking 😢😢😢100
I don't know what happened but I knew when I read the pictures.
I understand it now
John did so much for the government in rdr1, helped so many innocent people, became famous, then he just died. He became a really good man and then they just killed him. He deserved better.
I love it bro❤ I hope you can do on Arthur
You are right do more on Arthur or Dutch
Man i love thr red dead series
Nothing Ever lasts forever
The best family💔
Fire Edit bro
Some seconds or minutes are enough to change us...
The quality 😮
vibes 100%
Press F Uncle and John