Freezing the one you want to fill is based on the Ideal Gas Law which is PV=nRT where P is pressure, V is volume, T is temperature. If you don’t make one canister colder the gas will only flow till the pressure is equal so the full one would fill the less full one till pressure is equal (gas flows from high to low pressure). Making the recipient canister super cold means the T on the right side of the equation is lower so something on the left side of the equation must be lower too in order for the equation to be equal. The volume V remains constant so the only part of the left side that can change is the pressure P which must be lowered to balance what’s happened on the right side of the equation. So freezing causes the recipient canister to cool and lower the pressure. This results in the partially filled canister being higher pressure relative to the recipient so the gas will flow from the partial to the recipient as desired.
PV=nRT was always my favourite formula. (Especially when the bottle of Coca-Cola is at the, um, "ideal" temperature and freezes solid before your eyes when you open it. Really frustrating, but also really cool to see! (Peace!)
Thanks. Found the adapter on EBay and thought “hey that’s smart”. Tried it last night and it would only work some of the way. Overnight I thought “huh, maybe a combination of ice and heat would work”? First thing in the morning I found this video and I agree, some minutes in the freezer is both easier and safer. 😊
Yes, put the receiving canister in the freezer for till it's very cold to lower the pressure and you can also heat up the filler canister under hot water, to increase the pressure in that one....I have a different set up, but it works...
I came across your video and channel a few months ago and decided to buy one of these valves. I finally got around to buying one and received it yesterday. I started with a small MSR brand canister. On the side of it it has gross weight (canister full)7.40 oz and net weight (canister empty)3.90 oz. I weighed my empty canister on my kitchen scale and it was 3.55oz. I had taken a cold-weather backpacking trip a month prior to this and my stove struggled in low 20° weather. I decided to fill it with propane from a Coleman 1 pound propane cylinder. I have an adapter that fits the 1 pound cylinder so you can use a backpacking stove on it. So after I filled it and weighed it several times to match the net weight I put it in the freezer for one hour took it out attached my backpacking stove, fired it up and it didn’t spit, sputter or anything with the propane. Keep up the video’s and happy hiking.
Thanks Porkchop for your comment. I was born and raised in Charleston SC and my speech pattern is called Gullah/Geechee hope that explains it. Glad you stopped by and commented. 👌
You are The Man,,,!!!!! Thank You Sir,,,,,, That’s one reason that I’ve stayed on the msr white gas side of cooking. Now I’ve gotten a hold of the Firebox stove,,, Oh boy,, has that brought outdoor cooking to a New Level. Again,,, thanks for that timely info video,,, Joshua
thank you that is a great idea. Wish these canisters had a gage on them to make them safer,so when you would know if they are empty or when you had filled them up.
Scrolling through some of your older vids .... I’ve seen this one , a long time ago .... very helpful !!! I probably owe you some of the money I’ve saved after seeing this one . I realize it might be late, but thanks for posting this one!
Thanks so very much!!! I have heard about this tool but was hesitant! I would be worried about over filling. I plan on buying tool ASAP and taking on trail with me. Plenty of partial cans often at hiker boxes. I guess I’m going to guess when filling up and not over filling because of no scale available.
When pick one up at hikers box, put the can that you want to fill in the cold stream water and the one you wsnt it empty under the sunlight for 2 min, then invert the one under the sun and do the fill transfer, you will get the same effect. It is hard to over fill on the hike cuz both loss pressure aftrr use and during transfer they just equalize pressure at same temp.
Be careful to not overfill. There needs to be room for the liquid to expand if the canister gets warm. Weigh a factory can, then don't exceed that weight.
Thank you for this. Remembered this video from when I bought the valve. Just now getting around to using it....when I opened it the directions are only in Korean. Figured either way you were going to be able to help me 😊
Excellent tips, my friend. I’ve been refilling my canister for years too. Saves a little money plus you can always be sure to have enough gas for each trip. I don’t always freeze the empty bottle but what happens if they are the same temp is that you can’t completely fill the empty one. It will fill about half way or just a little more. Definitely need to chill it if you want to fill one all the way.
@@SeniorHiker77 it is an extra step. I like to refill mainly because those small ones are hard to get in my area but I can find the larger ones everywhere. If I could easily buy the small ones I’d probably not bother with filling.
@@SmellNRoses yeah the small ones are always out and the big ones don't fit inside my pot for packing. per gram price on the small ones seem to be almost double. it's not going to break my bank, but i don't like to feel hustled. the small ones you practically only find from hiking/outdoors stores, the medium and large ones are everywhere.
I’ve always been apprehensive when it comes to refilling these containers. I like the idea of condensing partial cans and save a few bucks. Might have to look further into that attachment.
Thanks for reviewing this!! It’s annoying having all those partially filled canisters and this will remedy that problem 👍 You have a lot of great reviews. I just subscribed 🙂
Another UA-camr indicated that chilling the receiving can has resulted in the bottom visibly bulging out after it raises back to room temperature. He verified that the small can was stock full weight of 7.4 oz. As the can temperature raises back to thermal equilibrium, more of the fuel within vaporizes and raises pressure in the can. It's advisable to just mildly warm the donating canister(s). Say by holding them under your shirt for a half hour or something to get them 15+ deg above room temp. And just keep the receiving can at room temp for safety. Should work just as well but is safer. Honestly I'm not sure why this is happening as the operating range of these canisters is down to freezing. Maybe the guy's scale was wrong and he overfilled it. But it's mostly likely because these canisters are filled at the factory at a calibrated ambient temperature. Either way, from my perspective, not worth messing around with.
Very good that your canisters last for a long time but I don't want to take a chance of running out of gas so I end up with lots of partially filled canisters. Thanks for your comment Saline Scott.
I see alot of comments but I'll say it anyways, they recommend colder temps because it's easier and get more gas in the tank in liquid state than gas state, the opposite when you use it, some people put isolated skirt around so the gas state get out easier, I don't remember the ratio but it's still something, anything that can save a little bit is always better than nothing, I think it's close to 10-15%, hope that clear enough with traduction. :)
Good information Danny. I've move on to where I just use the canister until it's empty punch a hole then throw away. I carry a extra canister most of the time.✌
Thanks. Its covid time now and those canisters are hard to come by, at least in my area. Everyone's going camping. But the cans of butane are still on the shelf. I just hope no one else figures this out!
If you refill an empty cartridge with a full one, how does that help? The pressures equalize, and you now have not one empty cartridge, you have two half-full cartridges.
You freeze the one to be filled so that you can fill it up. The whole point is this - the smallest 100 grams canisters are very expensive, the 450 grams canisters are the cheapest. You keep carrying only one 100 grams canister and use it, keep refilling it from the big ones and thus achieve substantial savings over time.
@@CampingrocksBgWoW Okay, that I can understand. But he was filling one small canister from another. All that gives you is two half-full small canisters.
Great ‘hack’! Now I can move all those near empty canisters to one. Your first ‘hack’ I learned from you was the Nalgene ‘wide mouth’ collapsible bottle for those midnight runs to the loo, or w your hack, just bring the loo to you! How’s the Lanshan 2 doing?
Great to hear from you David. The LanShan 2P is 2 years old now and started to show some wear. I have a video coming out soon about repairing a pinhole that recently appeared in the roof line on my lanshan 2p tent. Thanks for your comment and will post it in a few weeks.👍
Actually I don't remember the source but I think it was to change the pressure in one can. I don't bother with refilling canisters anymore. I just carry an extra can and use them until empty them punch a hole with my aluminum punch. 👌
Nice to hear it was helpful but I'm starting to use pure butane straight from the can. Check out my video coming out this Saturday using a SOTO Regulator stove you might find it helpful too.
@@SeniorHiker77 Not a bad idea, either. There's a few options for adaptors that work for butane and propane, which then connect to the transfer device so you can make your own 4 season fuel blend that won't wimp out on you in winter. I'm looking to put a little kit together for doing so. The benefit of the campstove canisters, for me, anyway, is that the campstove canisters are somewhat thicker and stronger than the conventional butane canisters and I can fit 2 of the little ones in my little Stanley cook pot perfectly, with room for my stove under the pot lid. I like the lower profile of them for cooking on, as well. But I can certainly see the allure of ditching the campstove containers altogether.
I'm surprised you've not run into these before. I was thinking about doing one of these videos - I've been refilling and consolidating for years too! The G-Works Gas Saver Plus works very well. Just be sure not to over fill the canisters.
@@SeniorHiker77I can see two links for the canister to canister adapters and one for the tool to punch a hole, but not one for the adapter to refill the isobutane canister with butane. Am I missing something?
Cool video. But why should I refill one small canister with another? Is this a gane switching gas between two similar canisters? Or do I miss the reason and logic behind?
Great stuff, can you use bigger tanks and fill up the smaller ones? Those 100g ones are so expensive, but my favorite to bring on 1-3 night trips. Would be cheaper to buy the bigger ones and keep refilling. I assume this is ok, but curious if you knew.. Also, should you only fill up with the same manufacturer, as to not "mix" ? Have a great day
I'm not sure anymore so I quit refilling the canisters. I use the butane canisters from the Asian market and find that cheaper. Nowadays I just carry an extra canister and make sure that I use all before throwing away.
@@SeniorHiker77 btw, I believe those butane cans are the same ones my grill I use in my van takes. You can get those 250g (8.8oz) cans made by Coleman right off the shelves at Walmart, used to be under $3. I must have bought a dozen of those for use with my van setup. I like the idea of just buying those and refilling the butane/propane mixes in 100g and 250g canisters for backpacking stoves when its not freezing temps. Unfortunately, I do a large portion of my backpacking when it's freezing out, so I would just switch back to the butane/propane mixes for those trips. Thanks for the great idea.
Good video mate, and a very good tip to save some material and gas. That is a proper cool American accent. I goin kick ya arse boi........is this Texan?
Hey u can’t empty any of the canisters. Once the pressure equalizes from one can to the other ur done. There is no pressure pump involved. Forcing a little left over gas from one can to the other. He going in circles thinking he’s filling ones up. U need a higher pressure tank or a pump pressurizing the gas to force it in and not equal to the pressure in the can ur trying to fill.
Thank you!! This was super helpful!!! I’m going to buy a crunch it this season. Did you get it online? If you’re at camp, how would you do this without a freezer or scale?
I just added a link to Amazon in the description box for the Crunchit Tool. I bought mine at REI and do all my refills at home or at the office. Hope that helps SectionHiking The AT.
SectionHiking The AT, I've been doing this for years too. After doing it for a while, it's not hard to estimate what "almost full" is. There is no need for a freezer, it just works better with one. As long as the donor (top) canister is warmed in your hands, the liquid squirts right in.
I'm sure they could be refilled with propane with the right adapter and the right pressure but not recommended. In the summer months I use the butane canisters from our Asian market.
So it has been awhile now do you still like refilling these? I love not having to trow them away. But can I still trust the pressure if I'm out with it?
Senior Hiker 77 I kinda thought somewhere along the line I thought you said that somewhere. With little ones I can’t upgrade equipment Often when buy new shoes ever 3 months as they grow🙄 so for now I’m sticking with the stove I have . But I thought refilling maybe be nice. But I guess really in the end you still have a can left over either way
I don't think so but I use small canister to small and large to large. When stops hissing I'll weight it and check against a new full canister. Hope that helps. 👌😎
@@SeniorHiker77 Friend, the biggest benefit imo is when you refill the smallest from the biggest. The small canisters are very expensive but they are the most compact and lightweight to carry and use. So you buy the cheapest biggest canisters and use them to refill only one small or smaller that you use all the time.
I bought a digital kitchen scale to weigh mine. I use the jetboil cans. I know that the jetboil 100gram cans when empty are 94grams (g), 194g when full. The 230g cans when empty are 126g, 356g when full. the 450g cans when empty are 195g, 645g when full. you can also use the transfer tool to empty a can completely by heating a can then turning the valve to let any trapped gas/air/pressure escape. you can weigh your cans while empty and use a magic marker to write on the bottom how much it weighs when empty. once you start filling them up you can start and stop at any time to unscrew and weigh. I always fill 10g less (put 90g in a 100g can) because with temp changes the can builds pressure. today you can weigh a can and it says 194g and tomorrow can be a warmer day and it will say a different temp which may be over.
g g I am in the US. I used “grams” because I wanted to, the can is measured in grams and ounces. If you have a digital scale does it really matter what I measured in? Most digital scales measure in multiple units (lbs, grams, ounces, etc.). If you have a non-digital scale, convert it. Either unit is not the right or wrong way. It is about how a person wants to measure it. I used grams. Have a blessed day! :)
I'm well impressed with this and as I'm a fair weather hiker using butane to refill canisters is fine for me. Plus I really object to these camping gas firms riding what is obviously a gravy train. There isopro is nothing special compared to industrial isopro used in blowlamps they just want to make more money selling the stuff
@@SeniorHiker77 Just discovered today in my local garden supplies centre the gas cartridges they supply for the weed flame wands are isobutane. exactly the same gas mix as the standard camping gas canisters Even the threads on top are the same so your canister to canister adaptor will fit fine or you can use a flexible hose style burner direct. They cost here in the UK the same price as an MSR 100 small canister but have over three times the amount of gas . This could be handy for winter campers.
Newbie here (with some decades behind me not new to life but new to this stuff) with a Q for anyone who knows: So I just got the AOTU stove and a Toaks 750 ml cup and did a test boil with a standard Primus 8 oz canister. I found I could not make the 3 minute boil time unless I cranked the thing up to what seemed like all the way AND, in the bottom of the cup, there was a quarter sized bright red spot, as if the thing might burn through the bottom of the cup. Sooo, all systems normal? Something might be wrong? Please advise. Thanks.
I never liked any store that burns like a blow tourch for that very reason. I always felt like it would burn a hole in my titanium 750 pot. I personally use a Snow Peak Giga Power or the Litemax seem to have a softer flame. Hope that helps. ATB
So how come the containers don’t just reach an equilibrium? Some of you say we are freezing the receiving container? That would lower the pressure, but I mean, physically there isn’t a way to really empty empty the donor canister, is there?
I come to realize that the only way is to use a canister until it's empty then punch a hole using an aluminum punch then throw them away. Thanks for a very thoughtful comment Michael. 👍
Not like this entirely unsafe or anything. But just a couple warnings: ."Disposable" tanks should not be "refilled". .Buy a refillable tank that is d.o.t. approved and has a bleeding valve. .the d.o.t. portion serves to allow you to legally transport refilled gas cylinders, and safely. .Do not transport refilled gas cylinders, that are one use(disposable), because this could be illegal, potentially dangerous. I think if your refilling, you need a tank that has a bleeding valve. MOST IMPORTANTLY. Do not put straight propane in a propane/butane or propane/isobutane cylinder. The thin walled cylinders that have these mixes are made for these mixes that are lighter and more easily to carry. As well, the butane portion puts out more energy with less gas spent, making it more efficient with the amount of volume. But putting propane in the mix cylinders that have thin walls could be a problems. Propane needs thicker walled tanks.
Actually I quit refilling my canisters. I carry a full spare and the one I'm trying to use up. Don't forget to use an aluminum punch to put a hole before disposing that canister.
I read somewhere not to refill the isobutane cans with straight propane. the pressure of propane is too much to handle for the thin cans. that is why propane bottles are so thick and heavy.
These canisters cannot handle pure propane. Refilling with regular propane is dangerous and definately not DOT approved. What I would recommend is purchasing the FlameKing 1lb refillable propane kit and empty tanks. Theese are the only 1lb DOT approved tanks that you can buy that are refillable. The main disadvantage of course is they are heavy (2lbs 8oz when full) and probaly not the best for backpacking, but perfectly fine for car camping, tailgating or RV use.
In the video, your filling one gas can to another gas can and are the same, so why don't you use the one with gas in Thay are the same can so you don't need to do that
I don't do that anymore I just use them until empty, punch a hole and throw away. Thanks for watching one of my old videos. Your comment is greatly appreciated. 👌👍
Out of all the things to refill these are the dumbest because they have the worst valve design out of any of them and no way to vent excess pressure unless you have the one type of adapter with a pressure release. That being said, I like to run propane torches on the odorless blend of LPGs you get from headshops that they use to make BHO or the ones from the UK that addicts sniff and the easiest and safest way I've found to do that is to refill the odorless butane first into these canisters and then into the propane canisters because there isn't an easy way to go right from those plastic adapters on a can of butane into a 1lb propane tank without first going through one of these flat gas canisters and I haven't died yet. I'm not saving a few bucks though I'm taking the most expensive LPG and putting it into the cheapest canister and losing 20% in the process but I fing hate the smell they add to propane
Freezing the one you want to fill is based on the Ideal Gas Law which is PV=nRT where P is pressure, V is volume, T is temperature. If you don’t make one canister colder the gas will only flow till the pressure is equal so the full one would fill the less full one till pressure is equal (gas flows from high to low pressure). Making the recipient canister super cold means the T on the right side of the equation is lower so something on the left side of the equation must be lower too in order for the equation to be equal. The volume V remains constant so the only part of the left side that can change is the pressure P which must be lowered to balance what’s happened on the right side of the equation. So freezing causes the recipient canister to cool and lower the pressure. This results in the partially filled canister being higher pressure relative to the recipient so the gas will flow from the partial to the recipient as desired.
Wow I guess you right. Lol. Thanks for that comprehensive explanation. 👌👍
Oh man, I haven’t had to think about the ideal gas law since college. Thanks for the review!
@@tridoc99 Ideal Gas Law - the STINKIEST farts after eating Taco Bell!
A+
PV=nRT was always my favourite formula. (Especially when the bottle of Coca-Cola is at the, um, "ideal" temperature and freezes solid before your eyes when you open it. Really frustrating, but also really cool to see! (Peace!)
Dad it lowers pressure so that the warmer pressurized one fills the difference between them is why you freeze one. Love you and your videos
I knew that. Love you too. Lol
Love this comment! Family is what matters.
Thank you for your service to and for our country!
It lowers the boiling point, which indirectly lowers the pressure.
Awwwwwwhhh
Love from Kashmir
Himalayas
Thanks. Found the adapter on EBay and thought “hey that’s smart”. Tried it last night and it would only work some of the way. Overnight I thought “huh, maybe a combination of ice and heat would work”? First thing in the morning I found this video and I agree, some minutes in the freezer is both easier and safer. 😊
Yes, put the receiving canister in the freezer for till it's very cold to lower the pressure and you can also heat up the filler canister under hot water, to increase the pressure in that one....I have a different set up, but it works...
Nice demo. Now, after three years, I am reviewing this again to refill my cannisters. Much appreciated, Sir.
I came across your video and channel a few months ago and decided to buy one of these valves. I finally got around to buying one and received it yesterday. I started with a small MSR brand canister. On the side of it it has gross weight (canister full)7.40 oz and net weight (canister empty)3.90 oz. I weighed my empty canister on my kitchen scale and it was 3.55oz. I had taken a cold-weather backpacking trip a month prior to this and my stove struggled in low 20° weather. I decided to fill it with propane from a Coleman 1 pound propane cylinder. I have an adapter that fits the 1 pound cylinder so you can use a backpacking stove on it. So after I filled it and weighed it several times to match the net weight I put it in the freezer for one hour took it out attached my backpacking stove, fired it up and it didn’t spit, sputter or anything with the propane.
Keep up the video’s and happy hiking.
Thanks Mark K. That was good to hear.
I love the way you speak. It reminds me of my grandfather from Texas and I miss him so much. Thank you!
Thanks Porkchop for your comment. I was born and raised in Charleston SC and my speech pattern is called Gullah/Geechee hope that explains it. Glad you stopped by and commented. 👌
Very instructive.I bought a 500g cylinder to refill my little 100g ones at a much reduced cost
I'm glad this video was useful for you. Thanks for taking time to comment 🙂
You are The Man,,,!!!!!
Thank You Sir,,,,,,
That’s one reason that I’ve stayed on the msr white gas side of cooking. Now I’ve gotten a hold of the Firebox stove,,, Oh boy,, has that brought outdoor cooking to a New Level. Again,,, thanks for that timely info video,,,
Joshua
You welcome Joshua glad that video helped. ✌
thank you that is a great idea. Wish these canisters had a gage on them to make them safer,so when you would know if they are empty or when you had filled them up.
Yes a gauge would be nice but they cost enough without a gauge. Lol
Agree@@SeniorHiker77
@@SeniorHiker77 agree but if it is portable then the extra cost would be worth it because of the safety factor just saying.
Scrolling through some of your older vids .... I’ve seen this one , a long time ago .... very helpful !!! I probably owe you some of the money I’ve saved after seeing this one . I realize it might be late, but thanks for posting this one!
You welcome MP. LOL
Thanks so very much!!! I have heard about this tool but was hesitant! I would be worried about over filling. I plan on buying tool ASAP and taking on trail with me. Plenty of partial cans often at hiker boxes. I guess I’m going to guess when filling up and not over filling because of no scale available.
The link below has the overfill button on it. My tool is the old version. Thanks for the comment Mark.
Senior Hiker 77 Thank you so very much Senior Hiker!! Take care now.
When pick one up at hikers box, put the can that you want to fill in the cold stream water and the one you wsnt it empty under the sunlight for 2 min, then invert the one under the sun and do the fill transfer, you will get the same effect. It is hard to over fill on the hike cuz both loss pressure aftrr use and during transfer they just equalize pressure at same temp.
Be careful to not overfill. There needs to be room for the liquid to expand if the canister gets warm. Weigh a factory can, then don't exceed that weight.
Thanks Danny for the good advice.👍
Always educating us. Enjoy all your videos. Keep on teaching us.
Thanks Jodi. 💋💋💋
Thx much for the clear explanation of how to refill and save the little left over
You're welcome Amok
Thank you for this. Remembered this video from when I bought the valve. Just now getting around to using it....when I opened it the directions are only in Korean. Figured either way you were going to be able to help me 😊
Lol I can read Korean but don't know what I'm reading.
Excellent tips, my friend. I’ve been refilling my canister for years too. Saves a little money plus you can always be sure to have enough gas for each trip. I don’t always freeze the empty bottle but what happens if they are the same temp is that you can’t completely fill the empty one. It will fill about half way or just a little more. Definitely need to chill it if you want to fill one all the way.
Actually I quit refilling just use until completely empty then punch a hole and throw away. I started carrying an extra full canister. 👌
@@SeniorHiker77 it is an extra step. I like to refill mainly because those small ones are hard to get in my area but I can find the larger ones everywhere. If I could easily buy the small ones I’d probably not bother with filling.
@@SmellNRoses yeah the small ones are always out and the big ones don't fit inside my pot for packing. per gram price on the small ones seem to be almost double. it's not going to break my bank, but i don't like to feel hustled. the small ones you practically only find from hiking/outdoors stores, the medium and large ones are everywhere.
I’ve always been apprehensive when it comes to refilling these containers. I like the idea of condensing partial cans and save a few bucks. Might have to look further into that attachment.
I was apprehensive too but these tools are brass, aluminum or plastic and don't produce any sparks.
Just ordered the G-works valve after watching this....thanks for the informative post🤓
Thanks for your comment and glad you found the info helpful.✌
This is so helpful! I never knew you could do that! Thanks for sharing!
You're welcome glad it was helpful.🤜🤛👍
I purchased one of those filling valves recently and now I know about putting canister in the freezer, I might be able to get it to work.
Be careful. I quit refilling my canisters just use them until empty. 👌
Thank you so much for the video and listing all the used adapters
That an old video but still relevant. I quit refilling and just use them until empty.
That's awesome, I didnt know they sold that. I hate counting on the float method to see how full it is. Great video
Glad I could help JJ.👍
Float method eh?
Wow,never knew that tool existed, thanks for sharing, cheers
You're welcome CB. ATB
Thanks for reviewing this!! It’s annoying having all those partially filled canisters and this will remedy that problem 👍 You have a lot of great reviews. I just subscribed 🙂
Thanks Mark
Another UA-camr indicated that chilling the receiving can has resulted in the bottom visibly bulging out after it raises back to room temperature. He verified that the small can was stock full weight of 7.4 oz. As the can temperature raises back to thermal equilibrium, more of the fuel within vaporizes and raises pressure in the can. It's advisable to just mildly warm the donating canister(s). Say by holding them under your shirt for a half hour or something to get them 15+ deg above room temp. And just keep the receiving can at room temp for safety. Should work just as well but is safer. Honestly I'm not sure why this is happening as the operating range of these canisters is down to freezing. Maybe the guy's scale was wrong and he overfilled it. But it's mostly likely because these canisters are filled at the factory at a calibrated ambient temperature. Either way, from my perspective, not worth messing around with.
Hey I like your process will try it next time, thanks WWH.
Oh snap! knew I kept all the old cans for a reason 😄 good stuff, thanks for sharing!
You are welcome Mountain Lust.😁😁😁
That’s a great idea. My canister last so long that I don’t think I’ll be worried about refilling them. I know it would save money over time though.
Very good that your canisters last for a long time but I don't want to take a chance of running out of gas so I end up with lots of partially filled canisters. Thanks for your comment Saline Scott.
Hello friend, Very interesting gadgets. I need to get them. Take Care and Keep Exploring The Outdoors.
Thanks John .ATB
Thanks was looking for the butane one but you said what i needed XD
Thanks for stopping by.👍
Good advise. I've been considering one of these, but haven't pulled the trigger. I just might have to do this. Thanks!!
One of my subs suggested using body heat on the donating canister instead of refrigerator. I might try that next time, don't want to over fill. 👌
I see alot of comments but I'll say it anyways, they recommend colder temps because it's easier and get more gas in the tank in liquid state than gas state, the opposite when you use it, some people put isolated skirt around so the gas state get out easier, I don't remember the ratio but it's still something, anything that can save a little bit is always better than nothing, I think it's close to 10-15%, hope that clear enough with traduction. :)
Good information Danny. I've move on to where I just use the canister until it's empty punch a hole then throw away. I carry a extra canister most of the time.✌
@@SeniorHiker77 👍
Genius! Thanks so much for this! Can’t wait to refill some of mine and get rid of some clutter.
Jennifer when I got rid of the clutter I just use the canister until empty. I don't refill anymore.
Thanks. Its covid time now and those canisters are hard to come by, at least in my area. Everyone's going camping. But the cans of butane are still on the shelf. I just hope no one else figures this out!
I went to butane for summer and fall. ATB
Well that's a pretty helpful tool I didn't know if you could do that. Thanks for sharing!
I've guit with refilling now i just use one until it's empty but carry a full can too. Lol
@@SeniorHiker77 haha nice.
SH77, got my G-Works adapter and giving it a go. Thanks for the instructions since the the ones they sent are in Korean.
Lol I'm married to a Korean pkus my brother in law always translates for me. Good luck.😄
Ye this is a great tool just subscribed. Hi from Australia 👍👍
Welcome aboard. ATB
If you refill an empty cartridge with a full one, how does that help? The pressures equalize, and you now have not one empty cartridge, you have two half-full cartridges.
You freeze the one to be filled so that you can fill it up. The whole point is this - the smallest 100 grams canisters are very expensive, the 450 grams canisters are the cheapest. You keep carrying only one 100 grams canister and use it, keep refilling it from the big ones and thus achieve substantial savings over time.
@@CampingrocksBgWoW
Okay, that I can understand. But he was filling one small canister from another. All that gives you is two half-full small canisters.
He was combining them. One had a little, one had more....
Leave them half full, and put a hole in them using your "tracer" ammunition.... makes them nice and "safe".
Thanks for checking in and for your comment 👍
Great ‘hack’! Now I can move all those near empty canisters to one.
Your first ‘hack’ I learned from you was the Nalgene ‘wide mouth’ collapsible bottle for those midnight runs to the loo, or w your hack, just bring the loo to you! How’s the Lanshan 2 doing?
Great to hear from you David. The LanShan 2P is 2 years old now and started to show some wear. I have a video coming out soon about repairing a pinhole that recently appeared in the roof line on my lanshan 2p tent. Thanks for your comment and will post it in a few weeks.👍
Senior Hiker 77 GTK! Thxs.
Thank you for the review.
Would you please share the source that suggests putting canisters into the freezer before refilling?
Thank you!
Actually I don't remember the source but I think it was to change the pressure in one can. I don't bother with refilling canisters anymore. I just carry an extra can and use them until empty them punch a hole with my aluminum punch. 👌
Great video ☺️ 👍 good idear 😁
Another helpful video, thank you
Thanks again for stopping by.✌
This was incredibly helpful!
Thanks for this!
Nice to hear it was helpful but I'm starting to use pure butane straight from the can. Check out my video coming out this Saturday using a SOTO Regulator stove you might find it helpful too.
@@SeniorHiker77
Not a bad idea, either.
There's a few options for adaptors that work for butane and propane, which then connect to the transfer device so you can make your own 4 season fuel blend that won't wimp out on you in winter. I'm looking to put a little kit together for doing so.
The benefit of the campstove canisters, for me, anyway, is that the campstove canisters are somewhat thicker and stronger than the conventional butane canisters and I can fit 2 of the little ones in my little Stanley cook pot perfectly, with room for my stove under the pot lid.
I like the lower profile of them for cooking on, as well. But I can certainly see the allure of ditching the campstove containers altogether.
Very cool. I had no idea that there is an adapter for this. I'll be picking one up for sure.
Check out the links in the description box for 2 types of adapters. Thanks Brant & Garvey for your comment. 😀
I'm surprised you've not run into these before. I was thinking about doing one of these videos - I've been refilling and consolidating for years too! The G-Works Gas Saver Plus works very well. Just be sure not to over fill the canisters.
@@KrizAkoni the new g-works has a overfill button, check the link.😀😀😀
Yep, I have that one!
@@KrizAkoni can I use your sometime. Lol
Never knew the putting in freezer thing. I did a review on a different model one. Have to try putting in freezer for 20 minutes
I also have the Jeebel but didn't use it because I didn't want to duplicate your review. Lol
@@SeniorHiker77 Lol.. oh ok....
Where do you get the black round thing to refill from big the big bottle? Thank you for your awesome video.
I got that from aliexpress.com.
@@SeniorHiker77 Great video. Any chance you could find us a link or at least find us a name to search for this adapter? Thanks!
@@danharrison5285 Check out the description tab you will find the link to that adapter. ATB
@@SeniorHiker77I can see two links for the canister to canister adapters and one for the tool to punch a hole, but not one for the adapter to refill the isobutane canister with butane. Am I missing something?
@@danharrison5285 I added another link for that adapter. Thanks for pointing that out.
Cool video. But why should I refill one small canister with another? Is this a gane switching gas between two similar canisters? Or do I miss the reason and logic behind?
No logic that why I use one until it's empty then throw it away. I carry an extra full canister an use it when the other is empty. 👌
Great stuff, can you use bigger tanks and fill up the smaller ones? Those 100g ones are so expensive, but my favorite to bring on 1-3 night trips. Would be cheaper to buy the bigger ones and keep refilling. I assume this is ok, but curious if you knew..
Also, should you only fill up with the same manufacturer, as to not "mix" ?
Have a great day
I'm not sure anymore so I quit refilling the canisters. I use the butane canisters from the Asian market and find that cheaper. Nowadays I just carry an extra canister and make sure that I use all before throwing away.
@@SeniorHiker77 btw, I believe those butane cans are the same ones my grill I use in my van takes. You can get those 250g (8.8oz) cans made by Coleman right off the shelves at Walmart, used to be under $3. I must have bought a dozen of those for use with my van setup. I like the idea of just buying those and refilling the butane/propane mixes in 100g and 250g canisters for backpacking stoves when its not freezing temps. Unfortunately, I do a large portion of my backpacking when it's freezing out, so I would just switch back to the butane/propane mixes for those trips. Thanks for the great idea.
@@Hangs4Fun yep I have to switch back to the mix in cold weather too.
Thank you for the links and info.
You bet!
Thanks. I’ve been looking for a product like this.
You must be binge watching my videos. Lol
Yes that's what I use.
You can refill those containers with one adapter and use propane - much cheaper and works better.
I don't use propane in the winter/cold weather. Thanks for taking time to comment. 👌
Great tip, but the first Amazon link doesn't show any canister adapter..?
You right Claus, check that link now. It will show a newer adapter than the one I used.
Thank you Senior Hiker 77 Good tip I'll check it out
Glad it was helpful.👍
Thank you for sharing. Be safe.
Thanks. Use it up, wear it out, make it do or do without.
Nowadays i just carry a spare and use one up then throw it away. ✌
@@SeniorHiker77 I subscribed, and thumbs up. I found you through Muskrat Jim's channel.
great info! thanks for making the video
You're welcome Michael.✌
How do you store the leftover fuel after opening it? If I unscrew it from the jetboil, will the fuel leak out?
I don't think so Chris.👌
If you talking about the hissing sound that happens on all canister stoves.
Lindal valves on isobutane canisters are self-sealing. There is no need for a cover. The plastic top is there just to protect the threads from dirt.
Curious to why fill a canister from another? What's the purpose? Just use it ....?
Thanks and that's exactly what I've learned. Use until empty punch hole then just throw away. Lol
Thank you i needed this info 👍👍👍
You're welcome glad I could help. Atb
Good video mate, and a very good tip to save some material and gas. That is a proper cool American accent. I goin kick ya arse boi........is this Texan?
Accent from Charleston SC. LOL
Hey u can’t empty any of the canisters. Once the pressure equalizes from one can to the other ur done. There is no pressure pump involved. Forcing a little left over gas from one can to the other. He going in circles thinking he’s filling ones up. U need a higher pressure tank or a pump pressurizing the gas to force it in and not equal to the pressure in the can ur trying to fill.
Actually Tony I quite refilling canisters. I just bring an extra one and use them until empty then punch a hole and dispose of it. 😀
Thanks for posting!
Thank you!! This was super helpful!!! I’m going to buy a crunch it this season. Did you get it online? If you’re at camp, how would you do this without a freezer or scale?
I just added a link to Amazon in the description box for the Crunchit Tool. I bought mine at REI and do all my refills at home or at the office. Hope that helps SectionHiking The AT.
SectionHiking The AT, I've been doing this for years too. After doing it for a while, it's not hard to estimate what "almost full" is. There is no need for a freezer, it just works better with one. As long as the donor (top) canister is warmed in your hands, the liquid squirts right in.
Could they be refilled with propane?
I'm sure they could be refilled with propane with the right adapter and the right pressure but not recommended. In the summer months I use the butane canisters from our Asian market.
@@SeniorHiker77 80/20 mix so I always thought it would be fine
What’s the name of the adapter for the long bottle?
Jeebel converter for butane canister on amazon or aliexpress.
@@SeniorHiker77 Thank you!
In my latest video I reviewed how to use it. If you have time take a look.
So it has been awhile now do you still like refilling these? I love not having to trow them away. But can I still trust the pressure if I'm out with it?
I moved on to the pure butane canisters at least for the summer.
Senior Hiker 77 I kinda thought somewhere along the line I thought you said that somewhere. With little ones I can’t upgrade equipment Often when buy new shoes ever 3 months as they grow🙄 so for now I’m sticking with the stove I have . But I thought refilling maybe be nice. But I guess really in the end you still have a can left over either way
Yep I haven't got the full solution yet.
Very helpful info. Thank you.
Thanks for stopping by. ATB
Is it possible to over fill them? How do you kno when it’s full?
I don't think so but I use small canister to small and large to large. When stops hissing I'll weight it and check against a new full canister. Hope that helps. 👌😎
yes, it could explode too if they are heated (in the sun for example) afterwards. you should have a 80% "air" room inside left.
@@SeniorHiker77 Friend, the biggest benefit imo is when you refill the smallest from the biggest. The small canisters are very expensive but they are the most compact and lightweight to carry and use. So you buy the cheapest biggest canisters and use them to refill only one small or smaller that you use all the time.
@@CampingrocksBgWoW Excellent idea.🤜🤛👍
Is if ok if i refill it again after its empty? Or should i put it in freezer again before refill again?
I refill again by cooling
Ok sie. So no need to freeze ir again. Just refiled it again. Thank u
Is it possible to overfill them? I don’t want them to explode.
Actually I don't know Chris Z. I don't think so since both are the same size they would equal out.
I bought a digital kitchen scale to weigh mine. I use the jetboil cans. I know that the jetboil 100gram cans when empty are 94grams (g), 194g when full. The 230g cans when empty are 126g, 356g when full. the 450g cans when empty are 195g, 645g when full. you can also use the transfer tool to empty a can completely by heating a can then turning the valve to let any trapped gas/air/pressure escape. you can weigh your cans while empty and use a magic marker to write on the bottom how much it weighs when empty. once you start filling them up you can start and stop at any time to unscrew and weigh. I always fill 10g less (put 90g in a 100g can) because with temp changes the can builds pressure. today you can weigh a can and it says 194g and tomorrow can be a warmer day and it will say a different temp which may be over.
g g I am in the US. I used “grams” because I wanted to, the can is measured in grams and ounces. If you have a digital scale does it really matter what I measured in? Most digital scales measure in multiple units (lbs, grams, ounces, etc.). If you have a non-digital scale, convert it. Either unit is not the right or wrong way. It is about how a person wants to measure it. I used grams. Have a blessed day! :)
Great info 77...😎👌
Thanks Hike Camp.😀😀😀
I want have one.. But here is very expensive... And in local (Indonesia) is not production this...
Thank you, very helpful!
Thanks Eric glad you stopped by and took time out your busy schedule to comment. It's greatly appreciated.
:-) I never knew! Thank you for sharing*
You're welcome nseight.👍
where do you live? it looks cold.
Not cold, Georgia USA.
Thanks
I'm well impressed with this and as I'm a fair weather hiker using butane to refill canisters is fine for me.
Plus I really object to these camping gas firms riding what is obviously a gravy train.
There isopro is nothing special compared to industrial isopro used in blowlamps they just want to make more money selling the stuff
I agree.👍
I just started using pure butane canisters with the adapter that will let you connect directly to the stove.
@@SeniorHiker77 Just discovered today in my local garden supplies centre the gas cartridges they supply for the weed flame wands are isobutane. exactly the same gas mix as the standard camping gas canisters
Even the threads on top are the same so your canister to canister adaptor will fit fine or you can use a flexible hose style burner direct.
They cost here in the UK the same price as an MSR 100 small canister but have over three times the amount of gas .
This could be handy for winter campers.
Great information 👌
You don't throw it away, you RECYCLE IT!
Didn't have enough room to keep any more. Lol
helpful vid. Thank you
Glad you found it helpful. Thanks for taking time out your busy schedule to make that comment. ✌
$29.95 on Sale on eBay as of today. This is the lowest price ever. And quite likely to be even lower AFTER New Years'.
Thanks for the tip AZ.👌
Those butane cans do not like cold weather.
That's for sure they don't like cold weather. Lol
Asian store?
Newbie here (with some decades behind me not new to life but new to this stuff) with a Q for anyone who knows:
So I just got the AOTU stove and a Toaks 750 ml cup and did a test boil with a standard Primus 8 oz canister.
I found I could not make the 3 minute boil time unless I cranked the thing up to what seemed like all the way AND, in the bottom of the cup, there was a quarter sized bright red spot, as if the thing might burn through the bottom of the cup.
Sooo, all systems normal? Something might be wrong? Please advise. Thanks.
I never liked any store that burns like a blow tourch for that very reason. I always felt like it would burn a hole in my titanium 750 pot. I personally use a Snow Peak Giga Power or the Litemax seem to have a softer flame. Hope that helps. ATB
Thankyou SH77 !
You are welcome Mini.👍
thank you for information
Any time
So how come the containers don’t just reach an equilibrium? Some of you say we are freezing the receiving container? That would lower the pressure, but I mean, physically there isn’t a way to really empty empty the donor canister, is there?
I come to realize that the only way is to use a canister until it's empty then punch a hole using an aluminum punch then throw them away. Thanks for a very thoughtful comment Michael. 👍
Thanks SH 77
You are welcome Ripper218 hope it was helpful. 👌
Awesome!
Not like this entirely unsafe or anything.
But just a couple warnings:
."Disposable" tanks should not be "refilled".
.Buy a refillable tank that is d.o.t. approved and has a bleeding valve.
.the d.o.t. portion serves to allow you to legally transport refilled gas cylinders, and safely.
.Do not transport refilled gas cylinders, that are one use(disposable), because this could be illegal, potentially dangerous.
I think if your refilling, you need a tank that has a bleeding valve.
MOST IMPORTANTLY.
Do not put straight propane in a propane/butane or propane/isobutane cylinder. The thin walled cylinders that have these mixes are made for these mixes that are lighter and more easily to carry. As well, the butane portion puts out more energy with less gas spent, making it more efficient with the amount of volume. But putting propane in the mix cylinders that have thin walls could be a problems. Propane needs thicker walled tanks.
one last note: The bleeding valve is helpful bc it will alert you when it's full.
Actually I quit refilling my canisters. I carry a full spare and the one I'm trying to use up. Don't forget to use an aluminum punch to put a hole before disposing that canister.
If it’s so cold outside that the butane won’t boil (no pressure), then I’M NOT GOING camping!!! 🥶
Thanks for stopping by happy New Year
I will probably refill them with 1 pound propane...... propane burns hotter. Thanks for the idea
I read somewhere not to refill the isobutane cans with straight propane. the pressure of propane is too much to handle for the thin cans. that is why propane bottles are so thick and heavy.
These canisters cannot handle pure propane. Refilling with regular propane is dangerous and definately not DOT approved.
What I would recommend is purchasing the FlameKing 1lb refillable propane kit and empty tanks. Theese are the only 1lb DOT approved tanks that you can buy that are refillable. The main disadvantage of course is they are heavy (2lbs 8oz when full) and probaly not the best for backpacking, but perfectly fine for car camping, tailgating or RV use.
In the video, your filling one gas can to another gas can and are the same, so why don't you use the one with gas in Thay are the same can so you don't need to do that
I don't do that anymore I just use them until empty, punch a hole and throw away. Thanks for watching one of my old videos. Your comment is greatly appreciated. 👌👍
Out of all the things to refill these are the dumbest because they have the worst valve design out of any of them and no way to vent excess pressure unless you have the one type of adapter with a pressure release.
That being said, I like to run propane torches on the odorless blend of LPGs you get from headshops that they use to make BHO or the ones from the UK that addicts sniff and the easiest and safest way I've found to do that is to refill the odorless butane first into these canisters and then into the propane canisters because there isn't an easy way to go right from those plastic adapters on a can of butane into a 1lb propane tank without first going through one of these flat gas canisters and I haven't died yet.
I'm not saving a few bucks though I'm taking the most expensive LPG and putting it into the cheapest canister and losing 20% in the process but I fing hate the smell they add to propane
I don't refill those canisters anymore. I just use them until empty punch a hole then though away
Hello my UA-camr
Glad you stopped by
useful :)
Thanks for taking time out your busy schedule to make comment on my video. 👍
Playback speed 1.75x... thank me later!
?