Syed Muzammil - IMSciences - Unveiling Layers of Identity Crisis in Pakistan: What Lies Beneath. 1/4

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 вер 2024
  • Join Syed Muzammil, a prominent Political Scientist and prime time talk show host at Capital TV, as he delves into the intricate layers of identity crisis in Pakistan. In this thought-provoking discussion, Muzammil, known for his insightful analysis, uncovers the underlying factors contributing to this crisis and explores the profound implications it has on the nation. As a philosophy enthusiast, vlogger, writer, and social critic, Muzammil brings a unique perspective to this important topic. Don't miss this captivating exploration of Pakistan's identity struggle. Subscribe now and stay tuned for more engaging content from Syed Muzammil at IMSciences.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 646

  • @qalat23
    @qalat23 Рік тому +22

    This is the first Pakistani man that I heard, quoting, Friedrich Nietzsche's, Fyodor Dostoyevsky and Thomas Hobbes from western countries . This is the sign that this man is not limited in Saudi Arabia doctrines. Feel happy listening to such bright mind from Pakistan. Stay save!!

  • @cafewaves
    @cafewaves Рік тому +318

    Yaar yeh to Pakistani lag hi nahi raha...Talk about Jihad in Kashmir and Gazwae hind.. then you are a real Pakistani. Just joking....:)) Wonderful speech..my favourite speaker

    • @abuhuraira8
      @abuhuraira8 Рік тому +24

      Yaar tum to indian lag he nahi rahy talk about hum kasmeer laingy, Akhand bharat and hindutva-secular ideology(HSİ) 🙃 presented by "butcher of gujrat :) then you'll be the real Indian :) btw lots of love from 🇵🇰

    • @dcxtreme6278
      @dcxtreme6278 Рік тому +1

      @@abuhuraira8 thik hai bhai akhand bharat will become reality when india will become a 30Trillion$ economy having a defence budget of 2T$ then it will become a reality
      then after that you have to give modi a new title "Butcher of Pakistan"

    • @reshavgovindam1280
      @reshavgovindam1280 Рік тому +36

      ​@@abuhuraira8 who's talking here ,I am not denying that whatever you are saying, just tell me one thing you guys also have minorities right, where are they, they just disappeared, why there is no growth in that, our Muslim population has risen up in "whatever" condition,from the partition till now . Chalo leave that, tell me one thing, why I haven't seen any representation of your minorities, are they irrelevant, it seems like that tho.. not only Hindus, you guys have Christians , where are they, and lets not talk about forceful conversion yeah, because we all know that 😂😂
      And please sir, if you really want to reply to this , don't answer like , what about that, what about this , please answer my question, because I have accepted what you have said , it's true , it's happening, it's sad , I really don't want it to happen, I don't want my country to become another Pakistan.... ❤❤love Bhai from india

    • @guldukan
      @guldukan Рік тому +5

      @@abuhuraira8 Good one, Pakistanis are accepting their mistake and India is inspiring by Pakistan and trying to Make India a second class Pakistan

    • @abuhuraira8
      @abuhuraira8 Рік тому +4

      ​​@@reshavgovindam1280 ok first of all you said that your muslim population has risen up in "whatever conditions" what does it mean, is this the way you treat your minorities 😔 so basically you're saying that we are beating them but they are still alive,then i must say that same is happening in Pakistan Total population of minorities in West Pakistan (today’s Pakistan) was 3.12% at the time of the country’s first census in 1951, which increased to 3.72% by the census carried out in 1998. Subsequent censuses also reflect a progressive increase in the share of minorities - 2.96 % in second census (1961), 3.25% in third census (1972), 3.33% in fourth census (1981), and 3.72% in fifth Census (1998).
      The 1998 Census data further show that the Hindu population in Pakistan has increased from around 1.5% in 1951 to nearly 2% in 1998😊.#cpd,so just because we have 1.5 percent in Pakistan (west Pakistan) and you have 12pc in india means that you are more religiously tolerant than us,
      Secondly i would like you to know that they are representing Pakistan,can you plz tell me what are you referring to😊
      Leave that but i will tell you one thing that our pms are not butchers just like modi g🤐
      P.s: India will be much better if you treat your minorities in gujrat,manipur and punjab❤ as i mentioned above that your minorities were more than 15pc in 47 and now it have grown in 'whatever' conditions because you can't marganlized your minorities when they are in crores,it will leave your country in utter chaos and leaads it towards civil war, as 🇮🇳 is growing economically, but indians ignore this everytime. And Insha'Allah our generation will be much tolerant and learn from the mistakes we've done in the past and i hope u wants the same in india. And no indian will justify what the bjp is doing ❤️. love from 🇵🇰

  • @ZafarIqbal-qe2po
    @ZafarIqbal-qe2po 5 місяців тому +4

    After hearing Muzamil, there seems to be a ray of hope in Pakistan. The nation must stand up, promote the truth, and make truth as an authority, not the other way around.Thank you

  • @muhammadnaeemshabbir9827
    @muhammadnaeemshabbir9827 10 місяців тому +7

    Listening to Syed Muzammil Shah is not less than a treat. Lots of Love

  • @harisshinwari
    @harisshinwari Рік тому +81

    A bold talk on historical facts. More power to Muzamil Shah.

    • @prabhahyades1233
      @prabhahyades1233 Рік тому +11

      But he had insert modi and India as usual in a typical Pakistani way

    • @plfofficial
      @plfofficial  Рік тому +2

      Part 2 uploaded now
      ua-cam.com/video/9x6dxQGo87o/v-deo.html

    • @aneelRmd
      @aneelRmd Рік тому

      ​@@prabhahyades1233
      SYEDs are Ashraf!
      They play good cop bad cop .
      But fcuk AJLAFs & Pasmandas anyways!

    • @Kim_jong_un_the_devil
      @Kim_jong_un_the_devil Рік тому +2

      ​@@prabhahyades1233 they will always remain anti hindu whether they become ex Muslim 😂

    • @Indiannrespect
      @Indiannrespect Рік тому

      ​@@plfofficialwhy u cut down the video when he criticised imran Khan? Imran Khan is biggest hypocrite and he is know that.

  • @shaolinzen726
    @shaolinzen726 Рік тому +13

    highly impressed by this pakistani intellectual from a fellow south asian nepalese . I am amazed people like you have to be invited all over the world to share the experience.

  • @jvsuryanarayana
    @jvsuryanarayana Рік тому +64

    The demand to hear Mr. Syed Muzammil is a very good indication of the people of Pakistan willing to hear alternate thinking.

    • @plfofficial
      @plfofficial  Рік тому +3

      Part 2 uploaded now
      ua-cam.com/video/9x6dxQGo87o/v-deo.html

    • @primordialarchetypes2927
      @primordialarchetypes2927 Рік тому

      @@plfofficial Thanks for the great content...........love from India. Hope that a critical mass of 'roshan khayalis' like Syed can get Pakistan out of the quagmire.

  • @munishbhardwaj1884
    @munishbhardwaj1884 Рік тому +24

    Syed Muzammil is literally one of the few learned people in Pakistan. Requires courage in a radicalized country to speak truth.

    • @plfofficial
      @plfofficial  Рік тому +2

      Part 2 uploaded ua-cam.com/video/9x6dxQGo87o/v-deo.html

  • @WorldPeaceAndProsperity
    @WorldPeaceAndProsperity 6 місяців тому +3

    I can listen to this man hour after hour. Absolutely brilliant speaker.

  • @jaspal8jan
    @jaspal8jan Рік тому +31

    Muzammil, the bravest and honest Pakistani I have ever watched on UA-cam..
    Muzammil, you are born in wrong nation, if you were born in India, you would have been a big shot in India's foreign ministry..

    • @advaita6523
      @advaita6523 Рік тому +6

      He is an atheist, Agla glat jageh peda Hoya taa hee rational aa. India chh peda hunda ta kattar mulla ban na c.

    • @TheBackpacker26
      @TheBackpacker26 Рік тому

      Aise log hi America mai top par jaate hai, or aise pakistan jaise hi countries se jaate hai , sab society ko samj kar jaata hai

    • @riturajput2462
      @riturajput2462 Рік тому +3

      He would play victim card here

    • @kanishkkumar5431
      @kanishkkumar5431 Рік тому

      @@riturajput2462 yess. .like any other india muslim ...... here the so called minority don't bother about economy. ..they knows hindus r theur fir their prblm....
      But in pakistan ..muslims r leading and they r showing their true islam ..

  • @capreal26
    @capreal26 Рік тому +45

    Not an expert on Pakistan's history but this man's ideas and oration are extremely compelling.

    • @trilokyamohanchakra6351
      @trilokyamohanchakra6351 8 місяців тому

      12:00 yeh bolta nhi toh main maanta, hosakta hain ki its his safety net

  • @jacobin1973
    @jacobin1973 Рік тому +35

    Absolutely brilliant oration. The fundamental problem of Pakistan is its denial of its own history and embrace of foreign histories and foreign ideologies that create anachronistic culture. There is a fantastic book written about 40 years ago by VS naipal called amongst the believers. It encapsulates the issues and identity crisis faced amongst the Islamic colonized lands. Brilliant read. Great talk. Keep up the good work.

    • @riturajput2462
      @riturajput2462 Рік тому

      This is British Pakistan created by british. They wanted only Islam as identity to use these people with their concept of jihad. Britain defeated OTTOMANS, made israel. What was their love for muslims of india?Zero. Show one statement by british regretting the partition after the genocide in punjab

    • @aaravsharma7914
      @aaravsharma7914 Рік тому +3

      he also talked about Modi radicalizing India.. do Godis agree with that?

    • @infynvn
      @infynvn Рік тому

      ​​@@aaravsharma7914did modi asked to kill minorities or something like that? Or started his campaign? Your lies won't work, Your personal hate for modi won't convince anyone and if I tell you india became 5th fastest and largest economy , your () () will burn and you will start calling me bhakt , sangi , RSS , andh bhakt etc! Or tell you regarding infrastructure like smart cities , bullet train , hyperloop train , elon musk investing in india and so many companies are investing so you will start using such names .... UNIFORM CIVIL CODE IS A PILLAR OF SECULARISM ( ITS HINDUTAV FOR YOU)
      IYOU LOVE WITH OUT PASSPORT AND VISA BANGLADESHIS ( YOUR HEART BEAT FOR THEM ) THIS IS WHY YOU DON'T LIKE CAA AND NRC.

    • @saynradhe8085
      @saynradhe8085 Рік тому +2

      ​@@aaravsharma7914lol chamchas are here also,

    • @humzanafees9348
      @humzanafees9348 Рік тому

      @@aaravsharma7914Modi is radicalizing the country, before modi, everyone around the world even me as a Pakistani used to see India in a positive way, but after modi, India’s image as a country has been getting pieced up, the economy and GDP may be good, but a high economy doesn’t mean anything, you can look at America and see how they have the highest economy and GDP, but the country goes through gun violence, racism, sexism, it’s an imperial state

  • @jeevakumarramachandran2038
    @jeevakumarramachandran2038 Рік тому +47

    FANTASTIC, AMAZING orator,I adore you. Words cannot describe my appreciation. Pakistan and India needs scholars and thinkers like you. A big God bless to you and your entire family. Wow.

    • @plfofficial
      @plfofficial  Рік тому +1

      Part 2 uploaded now
      ua-cam.com/video/9x6dxQGo87o/v-deo.html

    • @ssryr6427
      @ssryr6427 Рік тому

      😂😂😂😂😂

  • @pakkhakii5595
    @pakkhakii5595 2 місяці тому +1

    I'm so proud for being a listener of this great man ❤
    .we need to be like him

  • @ninaagrawal1094
    @ninaagrawal1094 Рік тому +72

    Very nice analysis. Don't limit yourself to Pakistan only, visit India, Bangladesh,Nepal too.
    Be brave enough to acknowledge that Pakistanis didn't fight for independence actually.
    It was given on the platter NOT EARNED.

    • @subhasisghosh66
      @subhasisghosh66 Рік тому

      Not a single leader of Muslim League ever went to jail for freedom. This is completely unlike leaders of Congress. The British created Pakistan as a renter state to counter the influence of Communism.

    • @fireangel911
      @fireangel911 Рік тому

      Ohh yeah was only due to the GANDHIS India got freedom... rest of them were irrelevant.

    • @doctormafia6300
      @doctormafia6300 Рік тому +3

      Nice that u didn't forget Nepal like everyone acts like we don't even exist in south asia

    • @infynvn
      @infynvn Рік тому

      ​@2107Slashpolitical party never fought for freedom it's normal citizen's who fought ,don't paste self created story , congress party was representing the ideology of certain people.

    • @MohitYadav-yo9qe
      @MohitYadav-yo9qe Рік тому +1

      Rather that posting nonsense try to read some history. You will come across the contributions of Khudai Khidmatgars and bow your head with respect for them in freedom struggle!!

  • @sanjeevsood531
    @sanjeevsood531 Рік тому +33

    Muzammil is an educated and well-read Pakistani. His criticism of PM Modi is surprising because he does not justify it by quoting specific reasons.
    He should do what Dr Ishtiaq Ahmed did, visit India. He can still be critical of PM Modi but Only then his criticism of PM Modi can be taken as valid. Otherwise, it is simply a bias.

    • @WishfulThinking511
      @WishfulThinking511 Рік тому +4

      Totally agree

    • @shreepadbhat9739
      @shreepadbhat9739 Рік тому

      These are all fed by Indian sicular English Media which works as front voice box for commies, naxalites, evangelists and islamist jihadis who combined want anarchy in India!!

    • @aaravsharma7914
      @aaravsharma7914 Рік тому +4

      As he said truth is what makes you uncomfortable. Just like you inner Andh bhakt was made uncomfortable with his comment on you 'idol'

    • @WishfulThinking511
      @WishfulThinking511 Рік тому +3

      @@aaravsharma7914 I m no bhakt.. I belong to Mamta Banerjee 💕.. always have .. I am talking about India .. you however I am unsure even belong to people who brought you.. 😖😖😖

    • @subhasisghosh66
      @subhasisghosh66 Рік тому +6

      @@aaravsharma7914 Seems you are incapable of rasing valid debating points and are reduced to making personal comments. By any chance are you a self certified Liberal?

  • @almasdeen8087
    @almasdeen8087 Рік тому +10

    Syed muzammil shah is very intaligent and wellnon historyen journalist and best speaker this time God bless you

    • @plfofficial
      @plfofficial  Рік тому +1

      He is one of the most prominent speakers. Follow our channel for more interesting debates

  • @praveenkishor1486
    @praveenkishor1486 Рік тому +14

    His no speech completed without cursing modi and current India. Earlier they used to curse Gandhi Nehru Indira now they are praised. Few years from now they will be praising even modi.

    • @riturajput2462
      @riturajput2462 Рік тому

      True. They hate indias religion but lovel their islamism. Hyoocrites. India is fighting jihad islalmic terrorism. Pakistan is not fighting terrorism from hindus. They can't equate with india. No hindu is exploding bombs there

    • @mudassaram1410
      @mudassaram1410 Рік тому

      Why do we need to curse Gandhi or Nehru 😂😂😂, your andhbakht are more than enough for that😂🤣🤣

    • @Blessheed
      @Blessheed 6 місяців тому

      I'm an Indian and I can criticize Modi when he's wrong or when he lies, something he is addicted to. You can criticize any leader you don't agree with if there's a valid point.

    • @mayankindian3750
      @mayankindian3750 19 днів тому

      Andbhakt wo to bole hi na jo 1947 se ek party ki gulami karne me lage hue hai ok 😊​@@mudassaram1410

    • @mayankindian3750
      @mayankindian3750 19 днів тому

      ​@@mudassaram1410 or pakistan to bna hi andbhakt ki dukan hai to Pakistani to bilkul bhi na bole

  • @HOG1070
    @HOG1070 Рік тому +17

    Always pleasure to listen to Muzammil

    • @plfofficial
      @plfofficial  Рік тому +2

      Part 2 uploaded ua-cam.com/video/9x6dxQGo87o/v-deo.html

  • @kanishkkumar5431
    @kanishkkumar5431 Рік тому +11

    Pakistanis r scared of learning about their hindu past. ...
    They will be afraid when they will know about great hindu civilization which were superpower in terms of economy. ..art...culture. ..science. .literature. .philosophy. ..peace and heritage

    • @tractorandfarmingvlogs8931
      @tractorandfarmingvlogs8931 Рік тому +3

      It was called Sindhu my fellow Indian. You have also suffering from identity crisis 😀

    • @abdullahamabood5693
      @abdullahamabood5693 Рік тому

      Not all so called Pakistanis were hindus.. tunnel vision

    • @kanishkkumar5431
      @kanishkkumar5431 Рік тому

      @@tractorandfarmingvlogs8931 sindhu and hindus both r same

    • @radhas2156
      @radhas2156 10 місяців тому +1

      ​@@tractorandfarmingvlogs8931But we know we belong to this Motherland. Are you still searching the desert you came from?? Who were your ancestors?? Mohammad bin kasim?? So that means you people don't belong here.

  • @AmnaNawaz-zk2ze
    @AmnaNawaz-zk2ze Рік тому +3

    GOD BLESS YOU SIR SYED MUZAMIL SAHIB YOU DOING GREAT
    FOR ALL OF US PAKISTANIS WE
    PAKISTANI YOUNGSTER'S APPRICIAT'S YOUR EFFORTS FOR PPAPAKISTANI JOURNALISM I LIKE YOUR TALKS AND THOGTHS I LIKES YOUR ANALYTICAL VIEWS MOSTLY
    JUST STAY BLESSED AND SAFE ALWAYS FROM EVIL PEOPLE'S AROUND YOU ALWAY WITH YOUR ENTIER FAMILY MEMBERS AS WELL
    WHAT A INTULACUAL PERSON YOU ARR

  • @gurinderjitnagra7199
    @gurinderjitnagra7199 Рік тому +6

    Wow this man speak truth in Pakistan god bless him

  • @naman35100
    @naman35100 Рік тому +6

    My favorite speaker from Pakistan...
    ❤❤❤

  • @ahadkhankhattak9936
    @ahadkhankhattak9936 Рік тому +3

    Lots of respect Syed Muzamil to you as a Pashtun✌️

  • @naveedshahzad8977
    @naveedshahzad8977 Рік тому +2

    This man can bring the change . Everyone wake up to reality. Read more and get knowledge. Wisdom

  • @raziagauhar9018
    @raziagauhar9018 Рік тому +5

    Excellent realistic and bold talk

  • @rafizaman2518
    @rafizaman2518 Рік тому +4

    Muzamil...your eloquence armed with knowledge in your backpack is par excellence
    Bravo, so proud of you! MashAllah
    Would love to meet you one day, InshAllah ❤

  • @readerfocus3158
    @readerfocus3158 Рік тому +5

    " Assalamualaikum " from Syed Muzzamil is mesmerizing

    • @patriot4932
      @patriot4932 Рік тому +2

      Bhai usse achi cheezein boli hai usne shaayd samaj ni aya apko

  • @neelamsingh4952
    @neelamsingh4952 Рік тому +9

    Mindblowing Talk 👍👍♥️

    • @plfofficial
      @plfofficial  Рік тому

      Part 2 uploaded ua-cam.com/video/9x6dxQGo87o/v-deo.html

  • @SarojEkka-zc3nq
    @SarojEkka-zc3nq Рік тому +10

    Even the best intellectual in Pakistani hate Modiji without any reason. When he wins elections, then somehow, that is still reversing democracy 😮. Economic growth & less terrorism in the Modiji government but still not good. Pakistan is islamic Republic, but india can not be a hindu Republic. Completely hipocracy every time

    • @zohairfahmee3238
      @zohairfahmee3238 Рік тому +3

      Hypocricy is you say something else and do something else. Pakistan was created because of identity nerrative but India projects itself as secular nation. If india decides we want to become a hindu state that is absolutely fine but stop pretending you are a democracy and secular state.

    • @deepakishere-e1d
      @deepakishere-e1d Рік тому +2

      @@zohairfahmee3238 Hindu means a secular person by birth...It is one of the inheret character of being a Hindu, even the best of you fails to understand Hindu system of thoughts.

    • @comradehasnainkhan1247
      @comradehasnainkhan1247 Рік тому +1

      @@deepakishere-e1d We pashtuns called every indian Hindu it is a geographycal name and it has nothing to do relegion

    • @zohairfahmee3238
      @zohairfahmee3238 Рік тому +2

      @@deepakishere-e1d Deepak I am not saying hinu as a religion or person. I am mentioning the state policy of hindutwa which is very clear and cannot be hidden under the emotional doctrine.

    • @shailajakotian9730
      @shailajakotian9730 Рік тому

      @@zohairfahmee3238 typical Pakistani mindset, believing in your own propaganda

  • @shehzadsheikh573
    @shehzadsheikh573 Рік тому +3

    Congratulations to you @syedmuzamil,
    You beautifully taught the root cause of Pakistani’s, undoubtedly we are lacking our identity we are lost ppl …..anyways I’m sure giving like lectures one day make the change .
    Good job 👍 muzamil sb keep it up ❗️

  • @chandanbanakar333
    @chandanbanakar333 Рік тому +10

    Hindustan mein kuch reverse nahi hora Bhai .. I myself am a linguistic minority and I'm free to speak my language lol

    • @biswajitchowdhury6353
      @biswajitchowdhury6353 Рік тому

      What about religions minority and human rights in Modi's India?

    • @TheBackpacker26
      @TheBackpacker26 Рік тому

      ​@@biswajitchowdhury6353and tell us about Bengal

    • @anujkr6039
      @anujkr6039 Рік тому

      ​@@biswajitchowdhury6353modi is a politician, here in India we have a Constitution which gives the rights and law to all persons equally, unless it becomes hindu nation means the change of constitution, that is impossible, also we have many languages which can't be suppressed and nobody is suppressing even modi is not doing it,
      all you see of Hindu rastra and harm to minority specially Muslims are more of a hoax, news media and social media keeps it hot to discuss in other countries to somehow defame India,, we have 140cr population so some incident happens in all community , the number 140cr is really huge so anything seems big

    • @biswajitchowdhury6353
      @biswajitchowdhury6353 Рік тому

      @@TheBackpacker26 Bengal is a war field of Brahmin badi and Islamist Zehadi, most dangerous two power...

  • @rajashekerp
    @rajashekerp Рік тому +21

    Muslims need to understand the definition of secularism. Secularism is not only allowing the people of different faiths to follow thier religion but also appreciate and respect their beliefs

    • @indiancitizen4715
      @indiancitizen4715 Рік тому +3

      Hindus appreciate muslims ? In muslims idol worship is not done and in Jews also but some hindus will force you to do idol worship

    • @chetnasingh7747
      @chetnasingh7747 Рік тому +1

      Ye kr denge to ye apne religion k nhi rhege😅 inke religion ka brotherhood only ummati k liye hain

    • @indiancitizen4715
      @indiancitizen4715 Рік тому +3

      Brotherhood kaise hogi ?sab Shanti se rhe isme brotherhood h na ki sabko jabardasti Jai shree Ram bolwao aur jabardasti apne dharm ko appreciate karwao

    • @Yashas12
      @Yashas12 Рік тому

      Bhai hinduism and islam are pole apart in approach.. Aaj duniya me kahi bhi koi dhamaka hota, aagajani hoto hai, picche islam hi milega, kyunki ye khud me ek biased aur extreme religion hai. Bilkul hinduon me bhi bahot chutiye hain lekin islam is mamle me bahot bahot zyada aage hai

    • @Yashas12
      @Yashas12 Рік тому +1

      ​@@indiancitizen4715jo sach ha muslaman hoga wo tolerant ho hi nhi skta hai, kyunki uski nazar me wo sahi hai aur baki sab galat hai. Debate culture hai hi nhi islam me, mai as a hinduo veda pe debate kr skta hun.. Aap quran pe sawal nhi kr skte hain, log chalu leke aa jayenge marne
      Aaj europe me kya ho rha hai, kal inko shelter diya aur aaj tabahi macha rhe hai.
      So the crux is islam is the biggest challenge to free speech and democracy in modern times

  • @egowar
    @egowar Рік тому +3

    Brilliant. My most favourite.

  • @Indica2658
    @Indica2658 11 місяців тому +2

    Over 1400 Indus Valley civilisation sites have been discovered, of which 925 sites are in India and 475 sites in Pakistan... Pta chlta pappa kon hei? Turkey Arab Iran Mongol Ya Bharat
    Btw superb talk Sayed Muzzmmil.... Dint knw such ppl exist in Pakistan

  • @mithra2396
    @mithra2396 Рік тому +5

    A ray of hope for Pakistan

  • @raviinder6406
    @raviinder6406 Рік тому +5

    Syed Muzammil .. The Best ..👍🙏

    • @csheru
      @csheru Рік тому

      Best ??? Sikularism ka keeda abhi gaya nahi hai

  • @Akber13
    @Akber13 Рік тому +1

    I must say that it was very well prepared and nicely delivered. Remaining to the point and not deviating a bit is an art that only few know in Pakistan. Thanks for posting this talk.

  • @REThunderbird1990
    @REThunderbird1990 Рік тому +1

    Love from India. Muzammil is superstar of Indian subcontinent

  • @nalinikoutha2091
    @nalinikoutha2091 Рік тому +6

    Sll intellectuals sitting innpakistan think modi is supressing minorities but when they visit india their view will.change. dr ishtiaq ahmed used to say this but presently he is in india and has changed his.view seeing.muslims aremable to practice their faith freely

  • @rammie09
    @rammie09 Рік тому +7

    The current Indian state is not forcing any propoganda. We are only showing the world what our true identity is. Because, in India, a decade ago, Muslims can practice Islam, Christians can practice Christianity and Hindus practice secularism. But the tide is turning around for good now. Nobody should be worried.

  • @sougatamukherjee1975
    @sougatamukherjee1975 Рік тому +5

    Best orator in Pakistan.

    • @plfofficial
      @plfofficial  Рік тому

      Part 2 uploaded ua-cam.com/video/9x6dxQGo87o/v-deo.html

  • @SamsonMasih-vy4ry
    @SamsonMasih-vy4ry 10 місяців тому

    Great Syed Muzamil,Absolutely impressed with your genuineness .Aap ke jaise pak ko chahiye.what a knowledge & method of interpretation. Will people of pak sitting infront of you undetstand & change

  • @VinayKumar-ek1gh
    @VinayKumar-ek1gh Рік тому +7

    Vedic civilization flourished along the Indus river and then it reached Ganga-yamuna valley. You can't insert division in a single entity.

    • @youknow6968
      @youknow6968 Рік тому

      What are you talking about?

    • @VinayKumar-ek1gh
      @VinayKumar-ek1gh Рік тому +2

      @@youknow6968 He says in a way that Indian civilization is along the Ganga-yamuna valley and Pakistani civilization is along the Indus river valley thereby creating a false narrative that Indians and Pakistanis are different people..

    • @youknow6968
      @youknow6968 Рік тому

      @@VinayKumar-ek1gh how's that a false narrative?
      Please provide your reasons.

    • @VinayKumar-ek1gh
      @VinayKumar-ek1gh Рік тому +1

      @@youknow6968 so you're saying that Pakistan is a different civilization and has nothing to do with India.

    • @youknow6968
      @youknow6968 Рік тому

      @@VinayKumar-ek1gh I'm asking you to clarify what you're saying.
      Why do you feel the need to live of others statements?
      Be brave enough to Make your own statement, justify yourself, and if need be defend it. Or are you a coward?

  • @tayyabtahirsays
    @tayyabtahirsays Рік тому +2

    SO True

  • @Blessheed
    @Blessheed 6 місяців тому +1

    Stay safe from the "establishment" bro, you are one of the few learned man in that country.

  • @njaveri37
    @njaveri37 6 місяців тому +1

    THERE IS NO FINAL TRUTH EVERY TRUTH IS IN PROCESS

  • @abdurehman5696
    @abdurehman5696 Рік тому +4

    Perfectly said 👌

    • @plfofficial
      @plfofficial  Рік тому

      Part 2 uploaded ua-cam.com/video/9x6dxQGo87o/v-deo.html

  • @mehboobmemon311
    @mehboobmemon311 Рік тому +4

    You missed the whole point..
    1st. Pakistan shouldn't have been created, It was the Muslim league who lost elections of 1937 and was denied of Power Sharing by Congress. So they massively protested with Islamic activists for separate state.
    2nd. Now, Pakistan is created with the name of Islam. Every ethnicity accepted and even sacrificed many things for this Dream Land, Pakistan.
    Therefore, Pakistan should become Islamic State, with a strong centre on Islamic policies and independent provinces for their ethnic identity.
    Unfortunately, it was high jacked by Pakistani establishment since its inception.
    Hence Identity Crisis.

  • @ShivamKumar-qy6fl
    @ShivamKumar-qy6fl Рік тому +13

    Pakistan me sirf Identity crisis hi nahi educational crisis bhi hai.

  • @TheVinie1974
    @TheVinie1974 Рік тому +5

    When you know your roots belong to mother India but you are born in pakistan you become Syed Muzammil Shah 😊

    • @abdullahtayyab3344
      @abdullahtayyab3344 Рік тому

      but i can say that he would not want to associate himself as an indian and you wouldnot either becuase he is actually against your modi sahab and most of the leadership so fuck off. i actually remeber listening to one of his podcasts where he discussed exactly that and indians starting degrading him calling him kay kuch bhi ho hai to pakistani , this is wrong about your mentality you all think you are the right ones.

    • @rakhimukerji7937
      @rakhimukerji7937 Рік тому

      We all have multiple identities.

    • @humzanafees9348
      @humzanafees9348 Рік тому

      India is a diverse country. It’s not a nation.

  • @tiger7208
    @tiger7208 Рік тому +1

    Can we have this man in india for some talk like this ? It is so brilliant..thanks muzamil

  • @shanuchatterji
    @shanuchatterji Рік тому +1

    Sir, you are very bold..i scared it may annoying to your establishment 😢

  • @umerhayat1590
    @umerhayat1590 8 місяців тому +1

    We love you Muzamil bhae 🎉

  • @saadkhankhalil
    @saadkhankhalil Рік тому +4

    Amazing talk👍

  • @Sricon85
    @Sricon85 Рік тому +3

    He is a brilliant man.No doubt about it

    • @plfofficial
      @plfofficial  Рік тому

      Part 2 uploaded ua-cam.com/video/9x6dxQGo87o/v-deo.html

    • @riturajput2462
      @riturajput2462 Рік тому

      He is just saying what all know. We know pakistan has no identity. No language of its own No culture its own. Future is bleak. Future is dark uncertain. Pakistan has been used now west has no use for them

  • @getevennow
    @getevennow Рік тому

    Maybe instituting the goose step could up the national self esteem. Brutal, but Frederick Niche would approve of it..

  • @dashingdecentkhan
    @dashingdecentkhan Рік тому +2

    Such a polish mind. mind blowing awesome. where is the next part.

  • @a2d2charlie13
    @a2d2charlie13 Рік тому +6

    I wish Indian Muslims to given same rights as Pakistani Hindus!

    • @agrippa-theskeptic9346
      @agrippa-theskeptic9346 Рік тому +5

      Ya Allah, that will be the day!
      We could reduce the Indian Muslims to 1.6% of the population from current 15%!!

    • @indiancitizen4715
      @indiancitizen4715 Рік тому +1

      Fooliest person on earth , hindu population Pak me 1947 me hi reduce hua tha partition ki vajah se 7.2 million hi du yha aye the aur vha 7.5 million muslim Gaye the to reduce nhi hoga kya

    • @brijesh5907
      @brijesh5907 Рік тому

      Thats what both minorities should be in same condition as an Indian Hindu i second that or lets exchange Minorities

    • @anujkr6039
      @anujkr6039 Рік тому

      They already have the same rights as any other community,, person talking with a mindset of religious nation can't get the views of secular country, keep thinking with your narrow mindset

  • @601gateway
    @601gateway 10 місяців тому

    You should become the Prime Minister of Pakistan.......... I am sure people of Pakistan will see the change with modern outlook

  • @infinit128
    @infinit128 Рік тому +4

    Take my word,soon he will be declared as enemy of Pakistan .He understood Pakistan but don't understood the mindset of Pakistani. Nobody can remove the layers upon layers of Rigorious Islamic Ideology since the birth of Pakistan.

    • @shreepadbhat9739
      @shreepadbhat9739 Рік тому +1

      I think he is smart enough to see possible jihadi reaction 'sar tan se juda' and to settle aborad any day!!

  • @subhasisghosh66
    @subhasisghosh66 Рік тому +2

    With Dr Ishaque Ahmed, Muzzamil is one of the few persons who is able to honestly speak about Pakistan. However please note that Jinnah's speech of 11th Aug is a cunning statement to ensure that all Muslims did not migrate to Pakistan and swamp it to destitution.

    • @HelloBoy145
      @HelloBoy145 Рік тому

      can you clarify? I did not understand

  • @maheshpant518
    @maheshpant518 Рік тому +3

    Happy to listen to an enlightened mind. Allah kare jor e juban aur jiyada. You have yourself mentioned during the talk that different people perceive the same reality differently depending upon the conditioning of their minds. This holds true for you as well-my friend. You land all Pakistani's like you understand India according the conditioning of your minds. India's reality is very different. Please tour India and develop your opinion. I am happy to see you enlighten young minds.

    • @agrippa-theskeptic9346
      @agrippa-theskeptic9346 Рік тому

      Mahesh pant,
      Why do you need to invoke Allah?
      Wouldn’t Bhagwan do?
      Have you ever heard a Pis’stani invoke Bhagwan?
      Or, are you one of those guys who uses Hindu name to fool the surroundings, especially Hindu girls?

    • @patriot4932
      @patriot4932 Рік тому +1

      Allah doesn't exist say ishwar

    • @csheru
      @csheru Рік тому

      Aa gaye sikular bhand.....Allah kya hota hai ? Ishwar , Bhagwan nahi bola ja raha hai

    • @agrippa-theskeptic9346
      @agrippa-theskeptic9346 Рік тому

      @@csheru Miyan secular bhand toh tum ho jo Hindu ho kar Allah ko invoke karte ho.
      Humne to tujhe ek niche wali step tak offer ki, parantu tere jaise chu#*&tiye samajhen tab na!

  • @naeembakhsh7676
    @naeembakhsh7676 10 місяців тому +1

    Excellent.

  • @tys6430
    @tys6430 Рік тому +11

    I love this man. We need someone like him to be our Prime Minister.

    • @tys6430
      @tys6430 Рік тому

      @@asmikhan3454 what does that mean?

    • @avishekbhattacharjee812
      @avishekbhattacharjee812 Рік тому

      ​@@asmikhan3454Ek 1400saal purana Quran padke Ayotollah ya Khalifa ban sakte h to modern scientific, secular education leke PM bnane me kya problem h 😂 Aapko talibaniyo se problem nahi h leki pade likhe logo se h😂😂😂jahil

    • @looneydesi
      @looneydesi Рік тому

      @@asmikhan3454jab imran khan jis ney shaid he koi book pari ho bus cricket khyla hai PM bun sakta hai to ye kyon nahi bun sakta ?

  • @atheistatheist6767
    @atheistatheist6767 10 місяців тому

    doing great work for pakistan. awaring them with our knowledge . intelligancy

  • @razaqrehmat21
    @razaqrehmat21 Рік тому +1

    So excellent video and informative decussation please make a vedio on punjab partition and it's historic back ground

  • @NimatRabbani
    @NimatRabbani 5 місяців тому +1

    Good

  • @pankajbala3618
    @pankajbala3618 Рік тому +2

    Why Modi?He should work on his perceptions about Modi ji and conditions of Muslims in india .Indian Muslims are more islamist than nationalist .l🇮🇳🇮🇳

  • @insaneidea
    @insaneidea Рік тому +2

    Why muslims population increased in India after partition but Hindu population reduced in Pakistan??

  • @85666cghj
    @85666cghj Рік тому +1

    Jinna ne do kauni nazariya doya aue bola hindu and Muslim can't live together .
    But Hindu and Muslim were living together From past 300-400 years .
    So jinna was also fascists.
    Even after separation jinna s own family had not gone to pakistan.
    ❤❤❤❤ By the way love from India to every secular mind of pakistan

  • @Razdanvinodk
    @Razdanvinodk Рік тому +4

    An erudite conversation, indeed! Open-minded societies that have love of knowledge and respect for other viewpoints and remain tolerant to other people,free from prejudices, ultimately progress and reach heights in every respect, surely!

  • @subodhsingh9533
    @subodhsingh9533 Рік тому

    Although freedom fighters of freedom movement might have cursed the partition movement, take it for granted young prophessor, you are being blessed by those souls.

  • @onlytruthissupreme7541
    @onlytruthissupreme7541 Рік тому +8

    Nothing is reversing in India.India was secular is secular and shall always remain secular.Even during Modi's time, two big states' CMs (TN & AP) are christian and have become CMs on polular votes of the state where 80% people are Hindus. 2 CMs are also Christian but those are smaller states.India is a secular country not only because Indian constitution is secular but also because the hindus are secular by nature & character otherwise it would not have been possible to adopt unanimously a secular constitution.A constitution can never be imposed in any country if 80% or even less of polulation do not subscribe it by choice.Muzammil is very intelligent and knowledgeable but alike other intellectuals of Pakistan he too bears just cursory knowledge about the structure and character of hindu societies. Even being an Indian I am a big admirer of his oratorial skill and knowledge.I would suggest him that he should start studying the present day India.Since he is a voracious reader he would become the most learned and genuine expert on India in Pakistan which is, otherwuse a 'not available' commodity in today's Pakistan as Mr Sakil Chaudhary often quites.

    • @kanishkkumar5431
      @kanishkkumar5431 Рік тому +2

      He is just scared learning about great hindu civilization ...which were superpower in terms of culture ..peace. ..economy art. ..science. .philosophy music etc

  • @mobasharahmadtabassam3904
    @mobasharahmadtabassam3904 9 місяців тому +1

    A beutifu speech with reality, but who care it.

  • @Indica2658
    @Indica2658 11 місяців тому +1

    Grt talk Dint knw such ppl exist in Pakistan

  • @puneetsharma4687
    @puneetsharma4687 Рік тому

    I don't want to sound negative, but nothing will ever change in Pakistan

  • @kumara9828
    @kumara9828 Рік тому

    Muzambil man with good heart🎉❤

  • @Makrania
    @Makrania Рік тому

    One thing I can’t figure out about the Syed cast is, why do they need to add Shah to their names? Is that because a double reminder is needed for anyone in doubt?

  • @Blendproducts
    @Blendproducts 4 місяці тому +1

    Pakistan needs you very badly. Good luck!

  • @mylord3003
    @mylord3003 Рік тому +3

    Muzammil drags modi but never cared to mention about Ashoka, chandragupta and the Hindu, Buddhists past of baakistan until MbQ entered. Pakistanis are composition of coverts and immigrants since Alexandrr days.
    When invaders and their soldiers came they settle there and later migrants from Persia and Arabs too settled.

  • @naveedakhtar8747
    @naveedakhtar8747 Рік тому

    Dost,
    Ye Pakistani he hy.
    I m very proud of him....

  • @AbdullahKhan-og7in
    @AbdullahKhan-og7in Рік тому +1

    there is no identity crises in Pakistan , we hv freedom of everything its just our economy that contain us to 3rd world , if we become economic power then our culture dominate this region . its just economic game

    • @himmsingz
      @himmsingz Рік тому

      What culture? All you have as culture is keechar!

  • @muralidharbelavadi2722
    @muralidharbelavadi2722 Рік тому

    First Pakistani talking intellectually! Good keep it up bring intellectual revolution in your Country which is lacking! Break the Shackles of Religious Mullahs! God Bless You

  • @TatheerHussain-n1v
    @TatheerHussain-n1v Рік тому +1

    Very intractive session

  • @ECOMGURUONLINE
    @ECOMGURUONLINE Рік тому

    we shall learn our identities in best interest of nation.

  • @indy500tabasco8
    @indy500tabasco8 Рік тому

    He speaks the truth. Pakistan needs to be religions free😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊

  • @princedubey3102
    @princedubey3102 Рік тому +3

    Syed muzammil is the second intellectual person after Hassan Nissar whom I listen with great interest .

  • @messageoflifeislove
    @messageoflifeislove Рік тому

    Impressive and important

  • @adilamin686
    @adilamin686 Рік тому

    He is right!

  • @justanequestrian5809
    @justanequestrian5809 Рік тому

    Excellent analysis

  • @KailashKumar-hx3gy
    @KailashKumar-hx3gy 10 місяців тому

    Mujmil sahab ko selute h jo apni 5000 year civilization ko samajh rahe h jo real history h educated student hamesa sach bolata h madarsa student hi aj tak pakistan m h kya itna sach bolne wale ko pakistan pacha payega selute karte h is sakhsiat ko

  • @RajeshKumar-rf8mm
    @RajeshKumar-rf8mm Рік тому +1

    fascinating as always ❤

  • @satishchandradeshpande3402
    @satishchandradeshpande3402 Рік тому +4

    His talk always fascinates me.

  • @jkh.7788
    @jkh.7788 7 місяців тому +1

    Great 👍

  • @behari5
    @behari5 Рік тому +1

    Let's hope at least some of the audience sets themselves thinking in this direction.

    • @plfofficial
      @plfofficial  Рік тому

      Part 2 uploaded ua-cam.com/video/9x6dxQGo87o/v-deo.html

  • @mratheist637
    @mratheist637 Рік тому +1

    My favourite speaker

  • @mylord3003
    @mylord3003 Рік тому +4

    I thought muzammil will speak only the truth. But when he dragged modi, he showed that his true color. Please do not believe him entirely. Verify .

  • @OneWorld2024-u9q
    @OneWorld2024-u9q Рік тому +2

    He talks a lot or sense, but he too talks nonsense, about Hindus and Gujrat, Modi and hindu muslims issues.. BE WARE. the best Pakistani intellect, can only talk 80 percent truth!

  • @annnilsson501
    @annnilsson501 Рік тому

    Highly intelligent talk 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏❤️❤️❤️