For those that didn't quite get the last point that Sameer made. He is arguing that the Sana'a palimpsest is authoritative because it was in a mosque. This is ironi-- excuse me! This is stupid because he admits that the text was wiped and replaced with Uthmanic text.
Akhi Farid, there's a deaf person in the comment section, and I also saw a comment of another one. Plz add subtitles in your videos so that our deaf Muslim brothers and sisters can also see them and understand. السلام عليكم و رحمة الله وبركاته
@Joseph Colden lol they didn't read it when were a muslim suddenly read after they are x muslim " ohh wait a second let me start finding some mistakes in the quran " I don't soeak Arabic or even close to a scholar but yea google and some Islamophobes will help me
@Joseph Colden You cannot comment and interpret the Qur'an as you want. This is pretty dangerous though, if you do not learn the historical context behind it. (For example the verse "And kill them wherever you find them…(2:191)". If you do not know the context, that may lead you to extremism)
So acording to Sameer, all of the memorization of the Quran which is traced back to the companions and to the lips of the prophet(PBUH), all of that is incorect, and acording to Sameer this anonymously written document (which Semeer's own source describes as inacurate), is acurate. Farid, Keep at it. Dua from California.
TechThrough Time if your talking about Sameer I agree the dude is just and idiot you can't describe him any other way and while California has its problems I don't think it's general population is that bad
They choose islam to get fame and get some youtube content to make some dollers or they are not either muslim they have any hate against islam or they have their brain washed with some of the anti islamic people and they agree with their way of thinking but honestly they are fighting themselves with depression anixity but they show smile and peacefulness that how happy they are without islam
lets reflectandponder No, they leave because they are disillusioned by Islam’s tenets or beliefs such as the modern-day homophobia, or forcing women to wear hijab and other strictly enforced behavioural rules, or it seems outdated, irrelevant or constricting, or illogical, or there are many poorly claims such as the Miraj or stories taken from other sources, or there is a lack of interest, or better ways to live your life, or more freedom of action and thought outside Islam, or you might be LGBTQ, or...The list goes on and everybody has their reasons for leaving, just as you have yours for staying. Remember, the very great majority of Muslims are Muslim due to geography and family, not because they came to the conclusion that Islam was the best way to live. There is, after all, compulsion in religion, despite what Muslims might claim. Try leaving Islam and see if there’s no compulsion. Finally, it must be Zionist money behind these few UA-cam Ex-Muslims. How many have gotten wealthy again? I forgot the number. 😂
F.A F.A But your god also has a terrible hell for disbelievers, so that makes it cruel beyond any human being because it can choose not to torture people it has created, yet it does. Sounds a lot like humans creating a god and making that god utter threats to keep people in line and under control. I don’t like that idea of a god. Surely something better could be imagined by 7th Century minds, or perhaps not.
a stranger Can you provide evidence that your book isn’t merely a man-made book? First, show your god to exist, then show the book to be divine. Do not quote from a book because the book is merely the claim for itself. That’s circular logic.
Ex muslim fallacy: When they learn something (badly) for the first time and then automatically assume other muslims will also have never heard it before either
@Ozymandias Nullifidian That's not a "Muslim fallacy": As you see in this video, if these non-Muslims just studied any aspect of Islamic theology, instead of relying on fragments from random sources that have no correlation, they would find the truth. For example, Abdullah Sameer acts like the Sanaa manuscript is a text being hidden from the Muslims, because "it destroys" the Quran preservation claim. However, many Muslims have known about this stuff for centuries, and there have been hundreds of books written on the subject of variant readings. However, certain Muslims in certain countries are ignorant of this, and don't do their research. These orientalists aren't bringing up topics which haven't been resolved and explained, there are so many books about these topics; it's up to people to research themselves.
@@taimur74 Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more. Hafs Quran in 2:10 it says that Muslims get condemned to hell for lying and in the Warsh Quran the same passage says they get condemned to hell for being LIED TO He "said" (qaala), "My lord knows ..." (21:4) Hafs verses Warsh "Say" (qul): My lord knows ... Hafs version qaala is the perfect tense and therefore Muhammad is the subject of the verb, but in the Warsh version qul is the imperative and therefore the subject is God who is commanding Muhammad/Muslims. This difference is repeated in 21:112. Example of new ruling of Fiqh due to change in grammatical position of a word: Top one is Qiraat Hafs and the bottom is Qiraat Duri. In Hafs Recitation, Arjulakum (being mansub) is linked to washing, while in Duri recitation, Arjulikum (being Majrur) is linked to wiping. Thus, we get two fiqh rulings from the two recitations i.e.: 1. Feet are to be washed in wudu. 2. Feet are to be wiped. According to Koran 37:12 (Hafs Version) - “ But you (Mohamed) wonder, while they mock” Koran. 37:12 (Al- Doori version) - “But I(Al lah) wonder, while they mock
@@reizalash1443 Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more. Hafs Quran in 2:10 it says that Muslims get condemned to hell for lying and in the Warsh Quran the same passage says they get condemned to hell for being LIED TO He "said" (qaala), "My lord knows ..." (21:4) Hafs verses Warsh "Say" (qul): My lord knows ... Hafs version qaala is the perfect tense and therefore Muhammad is the subject of the verb, but in the Warsh version qul is the imperative and therefore the subject is God who is commanding Muhammad/Muslims. This difference is repeated in 21:112. Example of new ruling of Fiqh due to change in grammatical position of a word: Top one is Qiraat Hafs and the bottom is Qiraat Duri. In Hafs Recitation, Arjulakum (being mansub) is linked to washing, while in Duri recitation, Arjulikum (being Majrur) is linked to wiping. Thus, we get two fiqh rulings from the two recitations i.e.: 1. Feet are to be washed in wudu. 2. Feet are to be wiped. According to Koran 37:12 (Hafs Version) - “ But you (Mohamed) wonder, while they mock” Koran. 37:12 (Al- Doori version) - “But I(Al lah) wonder, while they mock
Br Farid. May Allah makes you keep doing the good work and protects you from all diseases either they are physically or spiritually and makes you remain his humble, kind and honorable servant life long.
Quran beeing preserved word for word and letter by letter is a lie. Allah said he would preserve Quran . That was lie. Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more. ??? What did Allah say feed 1 or feed 3 or more if you miss a fast ??? And which Quran do Muslims memorize all different 10 Qira'at and all 7 Ahruf ? Muslims repeat the same stupid lies they think they become true by repeating it over and over and over
Brother Farid I really enjoy and learn a lot from your videos, you have vanquished a lot of doubts I had since childhood about the deen. May Allah bless you and increase you in knowledge.
If he is an EX-muslim, why is he still going after his EX? Why is he spreading lies? Is he having stalking tendencies? Anyway, let's enjoy his stupidity it's really entertaining especially when brother Farid does the response.
Goliya Rajaa yeah my guy I mean how petty can he be? He says EVERY aspect of Islam is bad (God forbid) and yet all he does is talk about it and claim it's the reason everyone is suffering and other bullshit like that but trust me if the guy ever meets me Islam isn't going to be the source of his misery it's going to be me cause people this idiotic can only learn through a good beating
Al-Hijr 15:9 إِنَّا نَحْنُ نَزَّلْنَا ٱلذِّكْرَ وَإِنَّا لَهُۥ لَحَٰفِظُونَ Indeed, it is We who sent down the Qur'an and indeed, We will be its guardian. 😍😍😍😘😘😘
@@MegaWondu learn about the 7 Ahruf and 10 Qirat you can search in on a youtube channel called Arabic 101. The different copies is not something unknown buddy, wake up!
Quran beeing preserved word for word and letter by letter is a lie. Allah said he would preserve Quran . That was lie. Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more. ??? What did Allah say feed 1 or feed 3 or more if you miss a fast ??? And which Quran do Muslims memorize all different 10 Qira'at and all 7 Ahruf ? Muslims repeat the same stupid lies they think they become true by repeating it over and over and over
I don’t like admitting this but man, these ex Muslims need to give it up. We get it, you left the Deen of Islam, sorry no Blue Peter badges for you folks.
Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more. Hafs Quran in 2:10 it says that Muslims get condemned to hell for lying and in the Warsh Quran the same passage says they get condemned to hell for being LIED TO He "said" (qaala), "My lord knows ..." (21:4) Hafs verses Warsh "Say" (qul): My lord knows ... Hafs version qaala is the perfect tense and therefore Muhammad is the subject of the verb, but in the Warsh version qul is the imperative and therefore the subject is God who is commanding Muhammad/Muslims. This difference is repeated in 21:112. Example of new ruling of Fiqh due to change in grammatical position of a word: Top one is Qiraat Hafs and the bottom is Qiraat Duri. In Hafs Recitation, Arjulakum (being mansub) is linked to washing, while in Duri recitation, Arjulikum (being Majrur) is linked to wiping. Thus, we get two fiqh rulings from the two recitations i.e.: 1. Feet are to be washed in wudu. 2. Feet are to be wiped. According to Koran 37:12 (Hafs Version) - “ But you (Mohamed) wonder, while they mock” Koran. 37:12 (Al- Doori version) - “But I(Al lah) wonder, while they mock
Why is it that these ex-Muslim are so obsessed with Islam, it's almost like they are trying to convince themselves that leaving Islam was the right thing.. I mean move on already, unless of course their life is really empty now
They probably think that they must “liberate” people from Islam, which is stupid and they think that they have been deceived when they have not. If a Christian or non muslims converts to Islam, they are eager to move on from their past. They dont label themselves as ex non muslim and bully people on the internet who arent muslim.
No. I mean it's OK if they academically criticize us. They have rights to do that. But with that little knowledge about Islamic traditions and preservation of Islamic texts, how can even they try to make a statement. This is the case with Sameer. They are in the state of asking questions. We will answer as they don't know. But the case is, people like Sameer trying to get easy cheap and fast names and fames. They are not in the position to make a statement as they are not intellectually, professionally competent. Yet they are trying to act smart by making a statement. They have rights to do so, but at least should have decency.
Quran beeing preserved word for word and letter by letter is a lie. Allah said he would preserve Quran . That was lie. Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more. ??? What did Allah say feed 1 or feed 3 or more if you miss a fast ??? And which Quran do Muslims memorize all different 10 Qira'at and all 7 Ahruf ? Muslims repeat the same stupid lies they think they become true by repeating it over and over and over
when they studied it in detail,its mostly a student work due to the material,hand writing,teacher correction etc.Palimpsest is still mainly used in north africa to learn write the quran
Dear Farid, don't refer points as "mistakes" - because they're pure hypocrisy and cherry picks. He *did* fully read all the stuff he provided, he just hides crap according to his favour. Calling them mistakes would be lying .
i had a chance to meet a ex muslim, and that was so honest and he just said he leave Islam because he says its hard to follow islam. In the end it's a loss for him
Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more. Hafs Quran in 2:10 it says that Muslims get condemned to hell for lying and in the Warsh Quran the same passage says they get condemned to hell for being LIED TO He "said" (qaala), "My lord knows ..." (21:4) Hafs verses Warsh "Say" (qul): My lord knows ... Hafs version qaala is the perfect tense and therefore Muhammad is the subject of the verb, but in the Warsh version qul is the imperative and therefore the subject is God who is commanding Muhammad/Muslims. This difference is repeated in 21:112. Example of new ruling of Fiqh due to change in grammatical position of a word: Top one is Qiraat Hafs and the bottom is Qiraat Duri. In Hafs Recitation, Arjulakum (being mansub) is linked to washing, while in Duri recitation, Arjulikum (being Majrur) is linked to wiping. Thus, we get two fiqh rulings from the two recitations i.e.: 1. Feet are to be washed in wudu. 2. Feet are to be wiped. According to Koran 37:12 (Hafs Version) - “ But you (Mohamed) wonder, while they mock” Koran. 37:12 (Al- Doori version) - “But I(Al lah) wonder, while they mock
Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more. Hafs Quran in 2:10 it says that Muslims get condemned to hell for lying and in the Warsh Quran the same passage says they get condemned to hell for being LIED TO He "said" (qaala), "My lord knows ..." (21:4) Hafs verses Warsh "Say" (qul): My lord knows ... Hafs version qaala is the perfect tense and therefore Muhammad is the subject of the verb, but in the Warsh version qul is the imperative and therefore the subject is God who is commanding Muhammad/Muslims. This difference is repeated in 21:112. Example of new ruling of Fiqh due to change in grammatical position of a word: Top one is Qiraat Hafs and the bottom is Qiraat Duri. In Hafs Recitation, Arjulakum (being mansub) is linked to washing, while in Duri recitation, Arjulikum (being Majrur) is linked to wiping. Thus, we get two fiqh rulings from the two recitations i.e.: 1. Feet are to be washed in wudu. 2. Feet are to be wiped. According to Koran 37:12 (Hafs Version) - “ But you (Mohamed) wonder, while they mock” Koran. 37:12 (Al- Doori version) - “But I(Al lah) wonder, while they mock
Quran beeing preserved word for word and letter by letter is a lie. Allah said he would preserve Quran . That was lie. Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more. ??? What did Allah say feed 1 or feed 3 or more if you miss a fast ??? And which Quran do Muslims memorize all different 10 Qira'at and all 7 Ahruf ? Muslims repeat the same stupid lies they think they become true by repeating it over and over and over
"A manuscript *PRESERVING* an original quran text THAT HAD BEEN ERASED" This statement is stupid. If it is erased it was because it should NOT be preserved that is logic. What should have been preserved is the Uthmanic text which is actually what we have so yes Islam is true!
@abimbola chabi u are a troll did you watch the video where i said that another one destroyed Sameer? And you keep talking like a fool? You are so deluded and brainwashed you can not even see the truth man you are lost.
صلی اللّٰہ علیہ وآلہ وسلم علیہ السلام سلام اللہ علیہا رضی اللہ تعالیٰ اجمعین رحمتہ اللہ Shia and Sunni are brother thank you for this video very informative brother keep up the good work mashAllah defending were will excellent my brother like always all the best to Muslim and atheism
I don't understand why he didn't just keep quite after he left Islam, it's almost as if he did all this for the popularity.. If Imam Murrah were alive today, he would be so ashamed of Sameer.
Oh my god. Allah knows best how much I love my brothers for the sake of Allah so much!!! 😍😍😍 0.01 yanni yanni.. May Allah increase the noor in ur heart and in our hearts too akhi.
Masha Allah brother farid. I was in search of the refutation of sana'a manuscript related missionary lies. Felicitation goes to u from the core of my heart. Jay smith & co are continuously lying on this issue. His attacks on preservation of the quran and quran different versions are too clever, for the audience to identify the mis-information. Would you refute his claims related to this subject? (As a series after cp,ap,wood,asameer....)
The San'a manuscript is an student manuscript, it is thoroughly described by Asma Hilali in her book "The Sanaa Palimpsest: The Transmission of the Qur'an in the First Centuries AH"
Quran beeing preserved word for word and letter by letter is a lie. Allah said he would preserve Quran . That was lie. Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more. ??? What did Allah say feed 1 or feed 3 or more if you miss a fast ??? And which Quran do Muslims memorize all different 10 Qira'at and all 7 Ahruf ? Muslims repeat the same stupid lies they think they become true by repeating it over and over and over
Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more. Hafs Quran in 2:10 it says that Muslims get condemned to hell for lying and in the Warsh Quran the same passage says they get condemned to hell for being LIED TO He "said" (qaala), "My lord knows ..." (21:4) Hafs verses Warsh "Say" (qul): My lord knows ... Hafs version qaala is the perfect tense and therefore Muhammad is the subject of the verb, but in the Warsh version qul is the imperative and therefore the subject is God who is commanding Muhammad/Muslims. This difference is repeated in 21:112. Example of new ruling of Fiqh due to change in grammatical position of a word: Top one is Qiraat Hafs and the bottom is Qiraat Duri. In Hafs Recitation, Arjulakum (being mansub) is linked to washing, while in Duri recitation, Arjulikum (being Majrur) is linked to wiping. Thus, we get two fiqh rulings from the two recitations i.e.: 1. Feet are to be washed in wudu. 2. Feet are to be wiped. According to Koran 37:12 (Hafs Version) - “ But you (Mohamed) wonder, while they mock” Koran. 37:12 (Al- Doori version) - “But I(Al lah) wonder, while they mock
-.-.Example of different ruling of Fiqh due to change in grammatical position of a word: Top one is Hafs and the bottom is al Duri. In Hafs Recitation, Arjulakum (being mansub) is linked to washing, while in Duri Quran recitation, Arjulikum (being Majrur) is linked to wiping. Thus, we get two fiqh rulings from the two different Quran riwayat i.e.: 1. Feet are to be washed in wudu. 2. Feet are to be wiped. Chapter Five: 6 The Wiping or Washing of the Feet in the ‘Wudhu’ The scholars of Islam have differed on the type of purification of the feet required for the parts of the ‘wudhu. It is different in riwayah of Hafs an Asim comp to al-Douri from the Qiraʼat of Abu 'Amr ibn al-'Ala' al-Basri.
@@FaridResponds Both recited by Muhammad ? Bc the old guy kept forgeting what he said the day before. Which was revealed by Allah and how come Muhammad changed the words of Allah. BTW Muslims say there is only 1 Quran and every Quran has the same words ? I guess that is taqiyya also
I've read the variations on wikipedia,as a native arabic speaker, all of them seem to me extremely subtle like a dot or additive conjunction و / ف/ ا so i don't see any significant difference in meanings. Christian friends are trying to jump to conclusions and make benefit of these subtle variations to tell that it's not preserved , well at least the Sana'a Manuscript doesn't say that Jesus was a god , lol , cuz that would be total BS for me
@@Torchtn Nope, Educated with factual information, not religious dogma. Have seen the evidence with my own eyes. Perfectly preserved is a myth. You would have better luck finding a unicorn.
Would they actually look at the Sanaa manuscript, they should notice that 90% of "variations" aint variations, but either the letters faded out or the traces of the letters cant be reconstructed, due to the long time that has passed(1400+ years).
I know there were Jews in Yemen but many left after the creation of the state of Israel. If you mean independent sources about the Jews in Medina from Jewish sources, I have not looked into it much. I know the Jews in Yemen may have been converts due to the Jews in Medina.
Ofcourse Nabi musa took the Israelites to Arabia Mt. Sinai is in Arabia The jews went to Arabia after jesus cause the next prophet would be from that people You can find arabia I'm their scriptures Even nabi Musa circled around the kaaba It's in their torah and our Quran
Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more. Hafs Quran in 2:10 it says that Muslims get condemned to hell for lying and in the Warsh Quran the same passage says they get condemned to hell for being LIED TO He "said" (qaala), "My lord knows ..." (21:4) Hafs verses Warsh "Say" (qul): My lord knows ... Hafs version qaala is the perfect tense and therefore Muhammad is the subject of the verb, but in the Warsh version qul is the imperative and therefore the subject is God who is commanding Muhammad/Muslims. This difference is repeated in 21:112. Example of new ruling of Fiqh due to change in grammatical position of a word: Top one is Qiraat Hafs and the bottom is Qiraat Duri. In Hafs Recitation, Arjulakum (being mansub) is linked to washing, while in Duri recitation, Arjulikum (being Majrur) is linked to wiping. Thus, we get two fiqh rulings from the two recitations i.e.: 1. Feet are to be washed in wudu. 2. Feet are to be wiped. According to Koran 37:12 (Hafs Version) - “ But you (Mohamed) wonder, while they mock” Koran. 37:12 (Al- Doori version) - “But I(Al lah) wonder, while they mock
For those that didn't quite get the last point that Sameer made. He is arguing that the Sana'a palimpsest is authoritative because it was in a mosque. This is ironi-- excuse me! This is stupid because he admits that the text was wiped and replaced with Uthmanic text.
❤
السلام عليكم و رحمة الله وبركاته 🙂 great video Akhi Farid
I thought that was the point you was trying to make but wasn’t quite sure. Barakallahufeek akhi.
Akhi Farid, there's a deaf person in the comment section, and I also saw a comment of another one. Plz add subtitles in your videos so that our deaf Muslim brothers and sisters can also see them and understand. السلام عليكم و رحمة الله وبركاته
U should upload more often. We need a lot more debunking videos
Notice, when "ex-muslims" leave Islam, they suddenly become scholars and know everything about the Deen. That is their common point.
I know
Their diplomas prove it all 💸
With every patreon account, comes a certificate
@Joseph Colden lol they didn't read it when were a muslim suddenly read after they are x muslim " ohh wait a second let me start finding some mistakes in the quran " I don't soeak Arabic or even close to a scholar but yea google and some Islamophobes will help me
@Joseph Colden Lol. Just because you have read something doesn't mean you've understood it the way it was supposed to be understood. Stupid logic
@Joseph Colden You cannot comment and interpret the Qur'an as you want. This is pretty dangerous though, if you do not learn the historical context behind it.
(For example the verse "And kill them wherever you find them…(2:191)". If you do not know the context, that may lead you to extremism)
Don't forget to wash your hands!
Lmao 😂😂
Could you travel to the future and get us the cure?
I found you
@@sulemantimetraveller5091 We are all real Imam Murrahs. Imam Murrahs are multiplying.
CP: Wait, that proves trinity.
@@sulemantimetraveller5091 CP, AP, and Sameer all have a sum total of 1 brain cell. This is the best proof for the trinity.
Sameera has been educated yet again.
Yet he never learns
@@NeoLegendX Well of course :) He will only learn when his bedtime comes.
Hahaha
Sameera
You mean sammouri
So acording to Sameer, all of the memorization of the Quran which is traced back to the companions and to the lips of the prophet(PBUH), all of that is incorect, and acording to Sameer this anonymously written document (which Semeer's own source describes as inacurate), is acurate. Farid, Keep at it. Dua from California.
You ask me, this guy is a total joke.
But then again, your in california. The biggest joke here in the US.
@@techthroughtime6170 how come xD
TechThrough Time if your talking about Sameer I agree the dude is just and idiot you can't describe him any other way and while California has its problems I don't think it's general population is that bad
3:55 my bad.
THE AGGREGATE of these muslim orientalists utilize this as their primary argument. How pathetic
"Ex-muslim" highly ignorant of Islam..What a shocker!
They choose islam to get fame and get some youtube content to make some dollers or they are not either muslim they have any hate against islam or they have their brain washed with some of the anti islamic people and they agree with their way of thinking but honestly they are fighting themselves with depression anixity but they show smile and peacefulness that how happy they are without islam
lets reflectandponder No, they leave because they are disillusioned by Islam’s tenets or beliefs such as the modern-day homophobia, or forcing women to wear hijab and other strictly enforced behavioural rules, or it seems outdated, irrelevant or constricting, or illogical, or there are many poorly claims such as the Miraj or stories taken from other sources, or there is a lack of interest, or better ways to live your life, or more freedom of action and thought outside Islam, or you might be LGBTQ, or...The list goes on and everybody has their reasons for leaving, just as you have yours for staying. Remember, the very great majority of Muslims are Muslim due to geography and family, not because they came to the conclusion that Islam was the best way to live. There is, after all, compulsion in religion, despite what Muslims might claim. Try leaving Islam and see if there’s no compulsion.
Finally, it must be Zionist money behind these few UA-cam Ex-Muslims. How many have gotten wealthy again? I forgot the number. 😂
a stranger Can you please give evidence that your specific god exists? Thank you.
F.A F.A But your god also has a terrible hell for disbelievers, so that makes it cruel beyond any human being because it can choose not to torture people it has created, yet it does. Sounds a lot like humans creating a god and making that god utter threats to keep people in line and under control. I don’t like that idea of a god. Surely something better could be imagined by 7th Century minds, or perhaps not.
a stranger Can you provide evidence that your book isn’t merely a man-made book? First, show your god to exist, then show the book to be divine. Do not quote from a book because the book is merely the claim for itself. That’s circular logic.
Ex muslim fallacy: When they learn something (badly) for the first time and then automatically assume other muslims will also have never heard it before either
😂👍🏻 السلام عليكم و رحمة الله وبركاته
Abdul Rahim Anjum وعليكم السلام ورحمة الله وبركاته
@@abdulrahimanjum1971.
و عليكم سلام و رحمة الله و بركاته
@Ozymandias Nullifidian Sure, because non muslims can't also have an interest in certain conclusion being chosen...
@Ozymandias Nullifidian That's not a "Muslim fallacy": As you see in this video, if these non-Muslims just studied any aspect of Islamic theology, instead of relying on fragments from random sources that have no correlation, they would find the truth. For example, Abdullah Sameer acts like the Sanaa manuscript is a text being hidden from the Muslims, because "it destroys" the Quran preservation claim. However, many Muslims have known about this stuff for centuries, and there have been hundreds of books written on the subject of variant readings. However, certain Muslims in certain countries are ignorant of this, and don't do their research. These orientalists aren't bringing up topics which haven't been resolved and explained, there are so many books about these topics; it's up to people to research themselves.
Channel called Muslim allegations hunters destroyed this nonsense.
Agree! The owner of Muslim Allegation Hunters channel is an excellent Muslim apologist.
Daniel Anderson nice
Daniel Anderson Yeah, he is
For good
Daniel Anderson yup I can tell the dude is going places with his studies 😊
Thanks ya Sameer for making our Emaan even stronger and for giving Farid such entertainement over the years
there are different versions of Quran ? I thght Allah would protect his book and nobody can change his words ?
@@SheikhAlladeen so original 😂.. how can we possible refute this claim of jackass smith and hatun the hyena both of them don’t speak Arabic 🤔
@@SheikhAlladeen don't you have any better question than this? come on
@@taimur74 Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more.
Hafs Quran in 2:10 it says that Muslims get condemned to hell for lying and in the Warsh Quran the same passage says they get condemned to hell for being LIED TO
He "said" (qaala), "My lord knows ..." (21:4) Hafs verses Warsh "Say" (qul): My lord knows ...
Hafs version qaala is the perfect tense and therefore Muhammad is the subject of the verb, but in the Warsh version qul is the imperative and therefore the subject is God who is commanding Muhammad/Muslims. This difference is repeated in 21:112.
Example of new ruling of Fiqh due to change in grammatical position of a word:
Top one is Qiraat Hafs and the bottom is Qiraat Duri.
In Hafs Recitation, Arjulakum (being mansub) is linked to washing, while in Duri recitation, Arjulikum (being Majrur) is linked to wiping. Thus, we get two fiqh rulings from the two recitations i.e.:
1. Feet are to be washed in wudu.
2. Feet are to be wiped.
According to Koran 37:12 (Hafs Version) - “ But you (Mohamed) wonder, while they mock”
Koran. 37:12 (Al- Doori version) - “But I(Al lah) wonder, while they mock
@@reizalash1443 Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more.
Hafs Quran in 2:10 it says that Muslims get condemned to hell for lying and in the Warsh Quran the same passage says they get condemned to hell for being LIED TO
He "said" (qaala), "My lord knows ..." (21:4) Hafs verses Warsh "Say" (qul): My lord knows ...
Hafs version qaala is the perfect tense and therefore Muhammad is the subject of the verb, but in the Warsh version qul is the imperative and therefore the subject is God who is commanding Muhammad/Muslims. This difference is repeated in 21:112.
Example of new ruling of Fiqh due to change in grammatical position of a word:
Top one is Qiraat Hafs and the bottom is Qiraat Duri.
In Hafs Recitation, Arjulakum (being mansub) is linked to washing, while in Duri recitation, Arjulikum (being Majrur) is linked to wiping. Thus, we get two fiqh rulings from the two recitations i.e.:
1. Feet are to be washed in wudu.
2. Feet are to be wiped.
According to Koran 37:12 (Hafs Version) - “ But you (Mohamed) wonder, while they mock”
Koran. 37:12 (Al- Doori version) - “But I(Al lah) wonder, while they mock
Br Farid. May Allah makes you keep doing the good work and protects you from all diseases either they are physically or spiritually and makes you remain his humble, kind and honorable servant life long.
Quran beeing preserved word for word and letter by letter is a lie. Allah said he would preserve Quran . That was lie.
Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more. ??? What did Allah say feed 1 or feed 3 or more if you miss a fast ??? And which Quran do Muslims memorize all different 10 Qira'at and all 7 Ahruf ?
Muslims repeat the same stupid lies they think they become true by repeating it over and over and over
Brother Farid I really enjoy and learn a lot from your videos, you have vanquished a lot of doubts I had since childhood about the deen. May Allah bless you and increase you in knowledge.
there are different versions of Quran ? I thght Allah would protect his book and nobody can change his words ?
If he is an EX-muslim, why is he still going after his EX? Why is he spreading lies?
Is he having stalking tendencies?
Anyway, let's enjoy his stupidity it's really entertaining especially when brother Farid does the response.
He was an ex Ismaili (false Muslim) then he converted to Sunni Islam then became an atheist
He saw the islamophobic industry how other's like david wood etc are making money spreading lies about islam so he decided to start a career.
Ya Allah humiliate that murtad
Goliya Rajaa I know right?
Goliya Rajaa yeah my guy I mean how petty can he be? He says EVERY aspect of Islam is bad (God forbid) and yet all he does is talk about it and claim it's the reason everyone is suffering and other bullshit like that but trust me if the guy ever meets me Islam isn't going to be the source of his misery it's going to be me cause people this idiotic can only learn through a good beating
Sameer lookin good in the thumbnail 👌
What's that rockman thing
I cant watch his demb videos
@Imam Murrah’s son I got it.
Thanks
Al-Hijr 15:9
إِنَّا نَحْنُ نَزَّلْنَا ٱلذِّكْرَ وَإِنَّا لَهُۥ لَحَٰفِظُونَ
Indeed, it is We who sent down the Qur'an and indeed, We will be its guardian.
😍😍😍😘😘😘
@a stranger hafijun didn't know meaning?
@a stranger guardian which mean Allah himself save Quran
@a stranger did u understand guardian meaning
@a stranger what you try to saying??
@a stranger 😂😂😂😂
Quran is one ☝️ and never changes until judgement day ,
💚
there are different versions of Quran ? I thght Allah would protect his book and nobody can change his words ?
@@SheikhAlladeen that were what all thought for long ... we need to face the reality!
@@MegaWondu sorry what do you mean reality ?
@@MegaWondu learn about the 7 Ahruf and 10 Qirat you can search in on a youtube channel called Arabic 101. The different copies is not something unknown buddy, wake up!
May everyone be safe at home, and may Allah send barakat to you and your family and friends
Quran beeing preserved word for word and letter by letter is a lie. Allah said he would preserve Quran . That was lie.
Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more. ??? What did Allah say feed 1 or feed 3 or more if you miss a fast ??? And which Quran do Muslims memorize all different 10 Qira'at and all 7 Ahruf ?
Muslims repeat the same stupid lies they think they become true by repeating it over and over and over
@@SheikhAlladeen you don’t know what your talking about, your just making arguments out of your ass, LOL
I don’t like admitting this but man, these ex Muslims need to give it up. We get it, you left the Deen of Islam, sorry no Blue Peter badges for you folks.
Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more.
Hafs Quran in 2:10 it says that Muslims get condemned to hell for lying and in the Warsh Quran the same passage says they get condemned to hell for being LIED TO
He "said" (qaala), "My lord knows ..." (21:4) Hafs verses Warsh "Say" (qul): My lord knows ...
Hafs version qaala is the perfect tense and therefore Muhammad is the subject of the verb, but in the Warsh version qul is the imperative and therefore the subject is God who is commanding Muhammad/Muslims. This difference is repeated in 21:112.
Example of new ruling of Fiqh due to change in grammatical position of a word:
Top one is Qiraat Hafs and the bottom is Qiraat Duri.
In Hafs Recitation, Arjulakum (being mansub) is linked to washing, while in Duri recitation, Arjulikum (being Majrur) is linked to wiping. Thus, we get two fiqh rulings from the two recitations i.e.:
1. Feet are to be washed in wudu.
2. Feet are to be wiped.
According to Koran 37:12 (Hafs Version) - “ But you (Mohamed) wonder, while they mock”
Koran. 37:12 (Al- Doori version) - “But I(Al lah) wonder, while they mock
Why is it that these ex-Muslim are so obsessed with Islam, it's almost like they are trying to convince themselves that leaving Islam was the right thing.. I mean move on already, unless of course their life is really empty now
They probably think that they must “liberate” people from Islam, which is stupid and they think that they have been deceived when they have not. If a Christian or non muslims converts to Islam, they are eager to move on from their past. They dont label themselves as ex non muslim and bully people on the internet who arent muslim.
@muhammad noor exactly, this brings food into the table.
He got it from James White's presentation. LeL. Explains a lot.
No. I mean it's OK if they academically criticize us. They have rights to do that. But with that little knowledge about Islamic traditions and preservation of Islamic texts, how can even they try to make a statement. This is the case with Sameer. They are in the state of asking questions. We will answer as they don't know. But the case is, people like Sameer trying to get easy cheap and fast names and fames. They are not in the position to make a statement as they are not intellectually, professionally competent. Yet they are trying to act smart by making a statement. They have rights to do so, but at least should have decency.
I love you for the sake of Allah farid. May Allah reward you infinitely for what you do
Quran beeing preserved word for word and letter by letter is a lie. Allah said he would preserve Quran . That was lie.
Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more. ??? What did Allah say feed 1 or feed 3 or more if you miss a fast ??? And which Quran do Muslims memorize all different 10 Qira'at and all 7 Ahruf ?
Muslims repeat the same stupid lies they think they become true by repeating it over and over and over
Anyone attacking Islam is either mad depressed or shutting up his inner voice, nchaAllah yehdihom
These Ex muslims never fail me to make me Laugh as hard as possible !!
The ending though 😆
😂 السلام عليكم و رحمة الله وبركاته
Did not expect that !
when they studied it in detail,its mostly a student work due to the material,hand writing,teacher correction etc.Palimpsest is still mainly used in north africa to learn write the quran
I can't with this guy, not just because he talks utter tripe, but because he sounds just like mandark from dexters laboratory 🙈🙈😂😂😂😂😂
You don't know how helpful all your explainations are,
Jazakallahu khair,
Baarakallahu feekum❤
Dear Farid, don't refer points as "mistakes" - because they're pure hypocrisy and cherry picks. He *did* fully read all the stuff he provided, he just hides crap according to his favour. Calling them mistakes would be lying .
What are you talking about
i had a chance to meet a ex muslim, and that was so honest and he just said he leave Islam because he says its hard to follow islam. In the end it's a loss for him
Notice how Sameer says عتمان instead of عثمان.
He "learnt" his Izlam from English sources only.
Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more.
Hafs Quran in 2:10 it says that Muslims get condemned to hell for lying and in the Warsh Quran the same passage says they get condemned to hell for being LIED TO
He "said" (qaala), "My lord knows ..." (21:4) Hafs verses Warsh "Say" (qul): My lord knows ...
Hafs version qaala is the perfect tense and therefore Muhammad is the subject of the verb, but in the Warsh version qul is the imperative and therefore the subject is God who is commanding Muhammad/Muslims. This difference is repeated in 21:112.
Example of new ruling of Fiqh due to change in grammatical position of a word:
Top one is Qiraat Hafs and the bottom is Qiraat Duri.
In Hafs Recitation, Arjulakum (being mansub) is linked to washing, while in Duri recitation, Arjulikum (being Majrur) is linked to wiping. Thus, we get two fiqh rulings from the two recitations i.e.:
1. Feet are to be washed in wudu.
2. Feet are to be wiped.
According to Koran 37:12 (Hafs Version) - “ But you (Mohamed) wonder, while they mock”
Koran. 37:12 (Al- Doori version) - “But I(Al lah) wonder, while they mock
Our great schalar is back! 🔥🔥🔥
Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more.
Hafs Quran in 2:10 it says that Muslims get condemned to hell for lying and in the Warsh Quran the same passage says they get condemned to hell for being LIED TO
He "said" (qaala), "My lord knows ..." (21:4) Hafs verses Warsh "Say" (qul): My lord knows ...
Hafs version qaala is the perfect tense and therefore Muhammad is the subject of the verb, but in the Warsh version qul is the imperative and therefore the subject is God who is commanding Muhammad/Muslims. This difference is repeated in 21:112.
Example of new ruling of Fiqh due to change in grammatical position of a word:
Top one is Qiraat Hafs and the bottom is Qiraat Duri.
In Hafs Recitation, Arjulakum (being mansub) is linked to washing, while in Duri recitation, Arjulikum (being Majrur) is linked to wiping. Thus, we get two fiqh rulings from the two recitations i.e.:
1. Feet are to be washed in wudu.
2. Feet are to be wiped.
According to Koran 37:12 (Hafs Version) - “ But you (Mohamed) wonder, while they mock”
Koran. 37:12 (Al- Doori version) - “But I(Al lah) wonder, while they mock
I thought Sameer was supposed to “SpReaD RaTiOnAlITy aNd EnlIGhtEnMeNT” 🤦♂️🤦♂️
Thank you Farid.
Thanks mam...الله يحفظك
Jazkallahukhair for the great video.
9:13 😂 I thought it will be hard to find funny clips of Sameer.
"And who would be averse to the religion of Abraham except *one who makes a fool of himself.* "
2:130
brother your vedio is very very important for all.
May allah bless you amin.
I was just thinking on when will you upload🤣
MashaAllah. Entertaining and educational.
Quran beeing preserved word for word and letter by letter is a lie. Allah said he would preserve Quran . That was lie.
Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more. ??? What did Allah say feed 1 or feed 3 or more if you miss a fast ??? And which Quran do Muslims memorize all different 10 Qira'at and all 7 Ahruf ?
Muslims repeat the same stupid lies they think they become true by repeating it over and over and over
Br Farid showed many times how easy it is to destroy these hypocrites 😂😂
"A manuscript *PRESERVING* an original quran text THAT HAD BEEN ERASED"
This statement is stupid. If it is erased it was because it should NOT be preserved that is logic. What should have been preserved is the Uthmanic text which is actually what we have so yes Islam is true!
@abimbola chabi it is called "inglish" (to see the difference with "english" watch the word "palimpsest" pronounced by Sameer 😉)
abimbola chabi Lmao he definitely refuted him by giving clear reasons and showed how ignorant sameer is, have you even watched the video?
@abimbola chabi u are a troll did you watch the video where i said that another one destroyed Sameer? And you keep talking like a fool? You are so deluded and brainwashed you can not even see the truth man you are lost.
I don’t know what’s worse. Sameer’s voice or someone dragging sharp nails down a wall.
صلی اللّٰہ علیہ وآلہ وسلم علیہ السلام سلام اللہ علیہا رضی اللہ تعالیٰ اجمعین رحمتہ اللہ Shia and Sunni are brother thank you for this video very informative brother keep up the good work mashAllah defending were will excellent my brother like always all the best to Muslim and atheism
9:13 .. Aahahahahahahahahahaahhah!! Wow.. This is the same guy who laughed at CP before. and he stands next to him.. Lol.
Brother I found your channnel recently. May Allah accept your hard work. You present everything gracefully as if you have put no effort into it!
Another videos.. thank you brother...im bored on this lockdown.
I love
Muhammad ﷺ
I don't understand why he didn't just keep quite after he left Islam, it's almost as if he did all this for the popularity.. If Imam Murrah were alive today, he would be so ashamed of Sameer.
Because of money
Imam Murrah is alive bro! A SCHULLAH does not die!?!?!?! السلام عليكم و رحمة الله وبركاته
@Emperor Darth Jar Jar Snoke
Nickname AbDoller
Guess what, I am alive and ashamed.
Oh my god. Allah knows best how much I love my brothers for the sake of Allah so much!!! 😍😍😍 0.01 yanni yanni.. May Allah increase the noor in ur heart and in our hearts too akhi.
AMEEN, ya Rabb! 😊❤☝🏾️
Masha Allah brother farid. I was in search of the refutation of sana'a manuscript related missionary lies. Felicitation goes to u from the core of my heart.
Jay smith & co are continuously lying on this issue. His attacks on preservation of the quran and quran different versions are too clever, for the audience to identify the mis-information. Would you refute his claims related to this subject? (As a series after cp,ap,wood,asameer....)
The San'a manuscript is an student manuscript, it is thoroughly described by Asma Hilali in her book "The Sanaa Palimpsest: The Transmission of the Qur'an in the First Centuries AH"
are you Muslim
is this how coronavirus looks like when he enters humen body in end of the video
it's actually both ebola mixed with corona :(
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@skepticoeye6785 very funny 😑
One of your best brother Farid. Well done.
Quran beeing preserved word for word and letter by letter is a lie. Allah said he would preserve Quran . That was lie.
Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more. ??? What did Allah say feed 1 or feed 3 or more if you miss a fast ??? And which Quran do Muslims memorize all different 10 Qira'at and all 7 Ahruf ?
Muslims repeat the same stupid lies they think they become true by repeating it over and over and over
Now sameer starting to regret his decision left Islam.
How Do u know
@@sahabazkhan7304 I don't know. But last time he uploaded video was 4 month ago.. I think this is a good sign.
Ur channel is growing CRAZY
The jahash doesn't learn
Muslim Allegation Hunter already exposed and blew his argument into pieces
May Allah bless you, Farid. Keep up the good work. 👍🏻
Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more.
Hafs Quran in 2:10 it says that Muslims get condemned to hell for lying and in the Warsh Quran the same passage says they get condemned to hell for being LIED TO
He "said" (qaala), "My lord knows ..." (21:4) Hafs verses Warsh "Say" (qul): My lord knows ...
Hafs version qaala is the perfect tense and therefore Muhammad is the subject of the verb, but in the Warsh version qul is the imperative and therefore the subject is God who is commanding Muhammad/Muslims. This difference is repeated in 21:112.
Example of new ruling of Fiqh due to change in grammatical position of a word:
Top one is Qiraat Hafs and the bottom is Qiraat Duri.
In Hafs Recitation, Arjulakum (being mansub) is linked to washing, while in Duri recitation, Arjulikum (being Majrur) is linked to wiping. Thus, we get two fiqh rulings from the two recitations i.e.:
1. Feet are to be washed in wudu.
2. Feet are to be wiped.
According to Koran 37:12 (Hafs Version) - “ But you (Mohamed) wonder, while they mock”
Koran. 37:12 (Al- Doori version) - “But I(Al lah) wonder, while they mock
I believe he just cherry picking any topic regardless to suits his agenda; creating syubhah (doubt) among muslims.
It's pure entertaining how these Iblisians AKA ex Muslims like sister Abdullah Sameera embarrass themselves on basics of Islam! 😆
Great
I wish I have memory eating Sheep
Abdullah Sameer has sense, brain, and logic eating sheep-s. Go borrow one from him. السلام عليكم و رحمة الله وبركاته
amazing how this was only 2 weeks ago.
-.-.Example of different ruling of Fiqh due to change in grammatical position of a word:
Top one is Hafs and the bottom is al Duri.
In Hafs Recitation, Arjulakum (being mansub) is linked to washing, while in Duri Quran recitation, Arjulikum (being Majrur) is linked to wiping. Thus, we get two fiqh rulings from the two different Quran riwayat i.e.:
1. Feet are to be washed in wudu.
2. Feet are to be wiped.
Chapter Five: 6 The Wiping or Washing of the Feet in the ‘Wudhu’
The scholars of Islam have differed on the type of purification of the feet required for the parts of the ‘wudhu.
It is different in riwayah of Hafs an Asim comp to al-Douri from the Qiraʼat of Abu 'Amr ibn al-'Ala' al-Basri.
And?
@@FaridResponds Different words in different riwayat even to the point of changing fiqh ruling = Corrupted Quran
@@muhammadibnwaraqa No. Both were recited by the Prophet peace be upon him.
@@FaridResponds Both recited by Muhammad ? Bc the old guy kept forgeting what he said the day before. Which was revealed by Allah and how come Muhammad changed the words of Allah.
BTW Muslims say there is only 1 Quran and every Quran has the same words ? I guess that is taqiyya also
@@FaridResponds Both were recited by the Prophet peace be upon him ? Uthman wrote Mushaf al Uthmani and burned everything else the old man was saying
First and foremost this sameer cartoon belongs to which family.i want to know his background and Biography...
Mashallah, you doing a great Job Brother, keep up the great Work, to expose these liers!
jazakallah khairan
You are truly amazing farid may Allah bless you and make us meet in paradise ♥
Brother Frarid I can't wait for your Next video
Your humour is awesome 😁😂😂😄😄😆😆😄😄😄and the editing goes well...jazakallah brother for refuting these lost ppl 😁👌👍👍
Awesome video
Mashallah I love it when you expose these clowns😂 you are doing a great job
Mommy is proud of him!!
Happy birthday brooo 😍😍
AHHAHA cheers bro
Well he is a solid rock man...
That includes his brain...
Dr. Samer Al-Ameri discussed this very well
Please make dua for my iman
I've read the variations on wikipedia,as a native arabic speaker, all of them seem to me extremely subtle like a dot or additive conjunction و / ف/ ا so i don't see any significant difference in meanings. Christian friends are trying to jump to conclusions and make benefit of these subtle variations to tell that it's not preserved , well at least the Sana'a Manuscript doesn't say that Jesus was a god , lol , cuz that would be total BS for me
You should start a series called 'Educating Sameer' lol
Abdallah sounds like a little cartoon Rabbit from a Pixar movie lol
The whole reason to Burn variants was to delete incorrect unofficial copies
Brother! You are legend keep roasting these guys ,he basically mislead the ignorances.
best approach , may allah help you refute this type of nonesense
Akhi Kareem may Allah SWT reward you for dealing with these dogs
That last clip! Am dead! 🤣🤣🤣
Allah bless you
👍congratulation Farid!
Farid thank you for finally admitting that there have been changes to the Quran!
@@Torchtn Nope, Educated with factual information, not religious dogma. Have seen the evidence with my own eyes. Perfectly preserved is a myth. You would have better luck finding a unicorn.
@@truthinchristapologetics3542
When did he admitted that?
@@mohammedabdallah7210 Have you watched the video?
@@truthinchristapologetics3542
Yes I watched it and didn't hear him saying that, so can you tell me when did he say this?
@@mohammedabdallah7210 You must be deaf. Variants, different words, etc... are changes.
Sameer wishes to believe that it's a "Solid Rock Palimpsest". LOL.
Would they actually look at the Sanaa manuscript, they should notice that 90% of "variations" aint variations, but either the letters faded out or the traces of the letters cant be reconstructed, due to the long time that has passed(1400+ years).
2:28 I thought it was passive voice and active voice like in English grammar. And how does that still change the message in the Qur'an?
The fact that the research paper he was reading refuted his very own argument build on his eeading of the paper 😅
Let's mention Sameer as Mr ignorant. I mean I am using bad words for him. It fits with his activities.
Islamophobia industry taste sweet to ex-muslim. May Allah give you more patient, Farid.
You are lives saviour😢
Alhamdulillah
I have a question do we have jewish sources that jews we're in Arabia in 7th century?
I know there were Jews in Yemen but many left after the creation of the state of Israel. If you mean independent sources about the Jews in Medina from Jewish sources, I have not looked into it much. I know the Jews in Yemen may have been converts due to the Jews in Medina.
Ofcourse
Nabi musa took the Israelites to Arabia
Mt. Sinai is in Arabia
The jews went to Arabia after jesus cause the next prophet would be from that people
You can find arabia I'm their scriptures
Even nabi Musa circled around the kaaba
It's in their torah and our Quran
If you can show a timeline of the Quranic manuscripts would be helpful.
go to the islamic awareness website they compiled most of the Quran with old manuscripts on their website
Wonderful
Salam alaikum brown farid, wallah hearing ur Salam I start laughing 😆 thinking what’s going to come from u, great work . BarakAllahu feek
Quran riwaya of Hafs 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer: 1. According to Warsh 2:184 how many poor people must you feed after missing a fast? Answer 3 or more.
Hafs Quran in 2:10 it says that Muslims get condemned to hell for lying and in the Warsh Quran the same passage says they get condemned to hell for being LIED TO
He "said" (qaala), "My lord knows ..." (21:4) Hafs verses Warsh "Say" (qul): My lord knows ...
Hafs version qaala is the perfect tense and therefore Muhammad is the subject of the verb, but in the Warsh version qul is the imperative and therefore the subject is God who is commanding Muhammad/Muslims. This difference is repeated in 21:112.
Example of new ruling of Fiqh due to change in grammatical position of a word:
Top one is Qiraat Hafs and the bottom is Qiraat Duri.
In Hafs Recitation, Arjulakum (being mansub) is linked to washing, while in Duri recitation, Arjulikum (being Majrur) is linked to wiping. Thus, we get two fiqh rulings from the two recitations i.e.:
1. Feet are to be washed in wudu.
2. Feet are to be wiped.
According to Koran 37:12 (Hafs Version) - “ But you (Mohamed) wonder, while they mock”
Koran. 37:12 (Al- Doori version) - “But I(Al lah) wonder, while they mock
Great job 👍
Nice response! I also think you should listen to Dr. Shabir Ally's video about the Sana'a manuscript.
Wow