Scott Galloway Shares the Uncomfortable Facts of DEI
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 тра 2024
- Dave Rubin of “The Rubin Report” shares a DM clip of Scott Galloway’s brutal attack on DEI and how affirmative action could easily be redesigned to actually help those who really need help.
Watch Dave Rubin's FULL DIRECT MESSAGE: • 'The View’ Forced to C...
WATCH the MEMBER-EXCLUSIVE segment of the show here: rubinreport.locals.com/
Check out the NEW RUBIN REPORT MERCH here:
daverubin.store/
----------
#RubinReport #ScottGalloway #DEI #affirmativeaction #daverubin
The Direct Message segments of the Rubin Report are a chance for Dave Rubin to directly address current events, political news and the topics of the day. Whether it’s encouraging critical thinking, defending free speech, or fending off political correctness, it’s only by having calm rational conversations about these issues that can help de-escalate the political polarization and help heal our democracy. To hear what Dave has to say on these and a variety of other topics watch this playlist:
• DIRECT MESSAGE | RUBIN...
To make sure you never miss a single Rubin Report video, click here to subscribe:
/ @rubinreport
Looking for smart and honest conversations about current events, political news and the culture war? Want to increase your critical thinking by listening to different perspectives on a variety of topics? If so, then you’re in the right place because on The Rubin Report Dave Rubin engages the ideas of some of society's most interesting thought leaders, authors, politicians and comedians. The Rubin Report is the largest talk show about free speech and big ideas on UA-cam.
Dave allows his guests to speak their minds and his audience to think for themselves.
New videos every week.
The Rubin Report is fan funded through monthly and one-time donations:
rubinreport.com/support
******
Join Dave's Locals community: rubinreport.locals.com/
Order “Don't Burn This Country” the follow up to Dave Rubin’s New York Times bestselling “Don’t Burn This Book” here: daverubin.com/book/
Dave Rubin's book, "Don't Burn This Book" is available at:
www.dontburnthisbook.com
LISTEN to The Rubin Report podcast: www.rubinreport.com/podcast
See Dave LIVE: daverubin.com/events/
Sign up for our newsletter with the best of The Rubin Report delivered to your inbox once a week: www.rubinreport.com/newsletter
Official Rubin Report Merchandise: rubinreport.myshopify.com/
All art on the set are original works by Caylin Rose Janet.
Get a print here: www.caylinrosejanet.com/rubin...
******
Follow Dave on Twitter: / rubinreport
Follow The Rubin Report on Facebook: / rubinreport
Follow Dave on Facebook: / daverubin
Follow Dave on Instagram: rubinreport...
About Dave Rubin: daverubin.com/
"98% of Harvard's faculty is Democratic. That's diversity?" 👏👏👏
DEI, Didn't Earn It.
HAHA Yes, so well put!!
White people earn everything
He still votes for this destruction
Absolutely
I think in the last couple of years, many people have had their eyes opened - how he votes in the next election is the important thing.
He still speaks all the destructive BS tropes narratives rhetoric, he's not worth our time.
He’s an advisor to the Biden campaign
He's full of stuff. His "adversity" score is just renamed "Affirmative Action".
When my white straight male sons were constantly discriminated against it very much polarized my opinion on race.
Yes that's completely unfair.
Who has the power to discriminate against White males? All the people with power are wealthy whites and males.
Yes when it happened to white men that's when it was wrong
If DEI was truly about diversity and not brainwashing activism, they'd do something about the complete lack of diversity in their teaching staff.
It's all about giving more power to Miss Andry.
Uh, you left out teaching racism
@@c.s.440 Yes and no. It's *part* of it, but they are also tied up with the "intersectional" bit. It's a case of them wanting to eat their cake, but still have it.
It is not even so much about that, as it is about money. It always boils down to money. The brainwashed far-left is just a side affect of chasing money and the weak minded have gone cult-like with it. Similar issues on the far-right as well unfortunately. Grifters are going to grift.
DEI/Affirmative Action is prejudice of low expectations.
The British public sector has been recruiting on the basis of diversity for the last 30 years and now the country is crippled by mass incompetence.
Australia is fast catching up.
I agree with helping people who are poor, forget the bullsh1t of the race based discrimination.
EXACTLY
I am an adjunct professor. There are 120 professors in my school. No Republicans (I am independent).
The point I like to make is imagine if that was reversed and how the left would react to that. Yet somehow conservatives are gaslit when they bring up the left’s dominance of academia.
@@Fibonaccisghost Even leftist professors self censor. When I bring up the leftist monoculture in Universities, it’s always met with silence. It’s like telling a fish that we are in water.
That should tell us everything we need to know..... Politics have divided Americans to such a toxic level. It makes me sad.
@@Fibonaccisghost A lot of university faculty say "Universities are not biased against conservatives, they just choose not to work there". But not a single one of them will admit to being conservative because it is a pain in the ass to work with a target on your back. They use "othering" to take the spotlight of themselves.
@@Reglaized Well yeah, sure. It'd be like asking why there weren't any capitalists or Austrian economists in the Soviet Union. _"But comrade, surely Marxism is correct. Why would anyone want to undermine the wisdom of the Central Planning Committee?"_
I'm SICK of DIVISION, whether it be by color, race, $$$$, ...... it needs to stop.
Talk to the democrats. I have had friends since I was a little kid that are still Democrats but we're still friends so what they say on the news is all Bs
look am white am male i'm comfortable financially and would love to live in a white country full of people like me and my ilk so get over it fool
So how do you change 250k years of humanity?
@@drewskij2175 HHhH would know.
@@drewskij2175 YHWH
Scott is a pressure release valve for them. They know they are destroying themselves and the pendulum is about the swing back hard.
Even worse than they expect.
@@jerrysingleton4956 Hopefully.
Oh I can only hope...
My thoughts exactly
Cause the problems so that you can provide the "solution" to the problems that you caused in the first place!
Classic big gov...
D.E.I. - Didn't Earn It.................
DEI is making it almost impossible to maintain complex systems. We’re in the early stages but in a generation America will not be able to maintain even its most basic infrastructure. We will slowly become South Africa and talk fondly of a time when we had reliable electricity 24 hours a day, clean drinking water, etc…
Yep, filling critical infrastructure jobs with people whose only qualifications are the diversity check boxes they fill and not their actual job experience, then setting up a system where firing them puts you at risk for discrimination lawsuits makes it impossible to fill the positions with the best, brightest and most qualified people. Even if someone who checks all the right diversity boxes and has the right experience and qualifications applies, if that position is already filled by a less qualified person, HR literally can't do anything to get rid of them to make room for the better person.
Agree - glad other people see it as well - it is already happening. Companies are finding it difficult to get the most basics tasks done. They are going backwards. It is just a matter of time before it all collapses and it will be sooner than later.
Affirmative Action is not “amazing”, it’s a detriment to progress.
He slams on DEI, yet he wants affirmative action for trans/gay etc. That is a HUGE contradiction. Just judge people by their merit, plain and simple...it's not that hard.
And his ridiculous promotion of "adversity score"...just renaming affirmative action to try to dupe you.
he's still a progressive, don't get it twisted, he is not an ally, he is simply, afraid.
@@denroy3 So on the one hand you will probably be totally supportive of the conservative belief that family is the backbone of society and that strong and stable families make for strong, stable and successful individuals. Then on the other hand you will entirely dismiss the effect that not coming from a strong and stable family can have on a person's life and not recognize it can ADVERSELY impact a person's life chances, right?
@@3rdEyeWide I believe in the positive effects of family structure, because my parents divorced, and I experience and witnessed the negative and destructive aftermath. The importance of family is also proven in many statistics.
People who have the support of family and friends are more likely to achieve success in life. It makes logical sense that a person with strong social circles would have a positive indicator for completing education.
Scott Galloway has had some fail moments, too. He's lived in a bubble and is affected by falsehoods from the corporate press more than he knows. But he is a good guy, and I followed him for years on UA-cam. He's more of a truth-seeker than Bill Maher has been. I am pleased to see him take an objective stance like this. It was good stuff, overall.
he's an economic elite, he is only afraid of the entire system breaking and HIM losing everything, he's a pressure release valve, nothing more.
plenty of the economic and political elite are "good guys" but they still sit and gorge themselves, ever trying to get more wealthy, more influential, even Scott cannot help himself, he will gorge himself even as the effects of it, as wealth accumulates ever more at the top, at his feet and others, and he'll do nothing, he's just cognizant enough to see what's going on.
He has no will to stop.
100% He's a good guy. That's my take too. I used to get his email all the time and enjoyed it. But I gotta cut back. He is very sharp as a business mind as well. So good that someone claiming to be a strategist not knowing him becomes instantly suspect to me.
The liberal arguing to conserve values. Like a conservative.
he was arguing for affirmative action. Like dave said, he's a liberal. Those are liberal values. Lefists aren't liberal.
No, that's the Overton Window portraying a liberal as a conservative because the radicals have shouted themselves into being portrayed as the moderates.
@@sub-harmonik I get all that. I was drawing attention to the irony of a liberal expressing a conservative mindset.
That’s not what being liberal or conservative in philosophy means
@@elgaen555 Isn't it?
Sanity at last...DIE is racist...
I have talked with all kinds of leftists, and almost none of them talk like Mr. Galloway. Nearly all believed special benefits should be given to benefit certain races and women while at the same time denying that the blatant discrimination against whites, males, and especially white males has been taking place, or admitting it that it is happening but saying that they deserve it.
In their mind they're "debunking myths".
Because according to their philosophy you *literally* cannot be racist or sexist towards "anyone with more power and privilege than yourself. And since they think homeless white guys have more power and privilege than Oprah there's no conflict in their minds
Thats because leftism is a disease for the weak and privilaged
That's a supremacy mentality. But that's exactly why ⚫ s created DEI and affirmative action
These are what we commonly refer to as "stupid people."
@@d1gw33d There are a scary number of them in positions of power.
DEI/Affirmative Action is ALWAYS amazingly distructive social engineering!! 🙄
DEI is affirmative action. Difference being it has a fresh coat of paint, casts a wider net, and is far more destructive.
Affirmative Action is being challenged in the courts, so it was renamed DEI
“Let’s fight racism via racism!”
It's really really simple at this point. You help the people who don't have. It should be income based, not based on some silly immutable characteristic or sexual preference.
He's absolutely right: we're not helping minorities now, we're discriminating against a minority, heavily and with great malice.
DEI
"Division
Exclusion
Indoctrination"
Where is the "EJD" (Equal Justice Department) in these colleges? It's not about trying to solve historic problems and issues! It's about fairness and the right to real education. Ask the parents of all the Kids in the Baltimore School System (and other Democrat controlled systems) who can't spell, read, do math or know anything about real history. Just ask a kid, what is 3x3x3, or how many States are there, or how to read a letter from their Grandparents written in script. So Sad! Communism=Democrat
As bad as that sounds it is worse, wokeness = 5 year old coloring book of reality.
DEI and socialism are two sides of the same coin when it comes to discriminating against the majority for the benefit of a minority whilst ignoring the economic consequences.
I like Christopher Rufo's idea of EMC - Equality, Merit, and Colorblindness.
He completely misunderstood affirmative action by giving an example of Taiwanese billionaire daughter. Asians are not considered minority in college admissions. Their number is in fact suppressed to below 25% despite the population doubled the last two decades.
Liberals are scared to talk about the elephant in the room, the race, you know. Instead he is blaming Asians?
Defecting the blame to the minority who voice the least. Still being politically correct. Hence Asians should NOT vote democrat.
This guys politics are what the politics of America should be, Scott Galloway is quickly becoming one of my favorite people on planet earth.
No it has nothing to do with the diversity it's about narcissistic nepotism. The practice of surrounding yourself with useful idiots. That way you can never be dethroned.
the French Monarch thought this as well..
Still no.
Who determines the adversity scores? The only truely fair thing is to base it on merit alone.
Clearly a very destructive policy. Time for change.
Lowering expectations for anything does not level the playing field. It destroys the field.
I agree with everything he said but he’s still gonna vote against what he’s saying.
If you set policy by social economic status rather than race, your policies are no longer racist.
How fucking hard is that to grasp? Pretty difficult apparently.
They want us to keep talking about race, gender etc because it detracts from the real issue.
Class.
Class is correlated with IQ which is correlated with race.
Long time former fan of Prof G. Scott has been completely unhinged since Covid while Trump was in office. Its good to see him make necessary adjustments and be more objective after being wrong on so many topics. Bravo, Scott but its too little too late.
He's just afraid to lose his wealth and luxury when the system breaks, he wants them to release the pressure on the working poor so he can stay wealthy.
its very obvious, he's just the only one who has the balls to start speaking pretty obvious truths, but he has no willpower to avert course, even in his own personal existence.
I used to email him and gently push back on some of the unhinged parts.
Pointy-headed, tenured Academicians never held accountable are no different than entrenched bureaucrats. Neither should be in a position of dictating policy.
Nope. He's still trying to justify it. This "Good idea gone wrong" horseshit. It was never a good idea.
Exactly, his AHA moment is about as filled in as his hair.
I can’t get promoted at work because I’m a straight white male. Boss tells me that I have to find a way to overcome “my baggage” of being born white and male.
He lost me at a AA is a wonderful thing.
Thomas Sowell was on firing line in 1980 and the woman in the discussion was making all these claims about how AA hasn't had enough time yet to make the changes in disparities. When Sowell asked "how long are your failed policies going to continue for before you realize that they don't work" To which she replied that in another 20 years or so we'll see the disparities eliminated. That was 40 years ago and the disparities continue and will always continue because that's part of the AA industrial complex.
Everything is an industrial complex now.
Climate change
Racism
Sexism
and Affirmative action
etc etc etc
These things continue because there is an infrastructure in place that needs them to.
I REALLY want to hear these same people talk about how the Supreme Court decision of last year proving how ivy league dismisses over half (that's a majority) of asian men just because of their race. They use rich Taiwanese business tycoon's daughter as an example, but what about that guy's son who was probably forced into third choice or lower because of his genetics?
Ivy league was proven at the highest court to be the only known truly institutionalized racism at this time. It was majority asian men affected, but every account shows a decent (not a good thing) percentage of white male students being dismissed because of ethnicity as well (around a quarter). This prevented many asian and white men below 45 years of age from college at all and potentially better lives.
We still hear practically NOTHING from anyone on this.
How would their homelands accept americand in their schools?
Scott Galloway for President!
Race based anything is racist. Affirmative Action is state sponsored racism. Back in the '90's Newt Gingrich was advocating abolishing Affirmative Action and replacing it with assistance based on socio-economic issues, like Galloway suggests....
watch his 18 min TED talk ... good stuff.
WOW. EVERY HIGH SCHOOL KID NEEDS TO HEAR THIS!!!!!!!!!!
Coleman Hughes has been making that same argument for almost 10 years.
Corporate DEI is a ludicrous exercise. Problem is that the talent pool is really shallow in certain high skills, so to meet the DEI stats, we resort to hiring archetypal “diverse” people into low skill hurdle areas. We also hire highly qualified, typically elite, Indian and Asian professionals who keep our standards of excellence in high skill hurdle positions. Presto, DEI stats satisfied. So we effectively have a welfare state and a meritocracy running in parallel.
Many qualified hard-working people have been harmed by these misguided dei actions. Likely they will remain permanently scarred for the remainder of their working lives. Despicable.
From a deep-fried Southern Conservative---I love it!!!
So socialism. Got it. How about meritocracy, instead?
the Elite despise that, even Scott will never go for it, not really, they all want to continue their nepotistic family systems, Scott absolutely wants to put his kids into positions of power they didn't earn, and will, so Meritocracy is off the table.
Unfortunately, pure meritocracy creates a massive wealth gap and results in neo-feudalism, where basically everyone gets left behind.
@@baTonkaTruck what do you think you live in now? the number of people in my area of Mississippi who have risen out of poverty into middle class is a staggering low amount, none have "made it".
@@keithfilibeck2390 If I’ve learned one thing: “It can always get worse.”
@@keithfilibeck2390. You voted for your poverty - you voted Republican. Mississippi is a toilet of poverty and despair.
Always enjoy your videos Mr. Rubin but this one was particularly excellent. Kudos!
Wonderful truth.
Absolutely right!
Wow this guy makes so much sense and it is so refreshing to hear him say what we all know.
Brilliant!!!!
I think the answer would be to fix the elementary and high schools so everyone has the option of a good education. Then they are prepared for what they want to do when they graduate. Affirmative Action and DEI don't solve anything.
This is! Wow I can't wait till this interview. That sounds like a fantastic proposal from him. Don't lower standards or use any sort of affirmative action based on immutable chararistics.
The people that should be getting a hand up are those who need it as in... kids from the lower end of the economic spectrum that have great potential and have worked hard but whose parents don't have the money to put them through an ivy league education.
Put the resources and money towards getting as many of them as possible through the programs to produce the largest amount of highly educated individuals that can drive innovation for the future.
Neurodiversity should be the main factor of value in an institution of education searching for diversity
It's more than a bit tragic watching these folks 1/2 wake up and then so act like they're totally onto it all while completely unaware that they're not just REALLY late to the party but are still half manipulated.
They've been provoking a revolution... and the DA's over in the History Dept. finally woke up enough to go, "Uh, guys? This doesn't usually work out very well for people like us."
And this is why the quality of effort and products have been turning to crap. All careers and companies are being told to keep hiring for diversity sake (color of ones skin, how their identify, who they sleep with, etc.) rather than hiring for quality sake (an individual who is applying for a position that they worked on educating themself or has past experience and knows how to do the job).
I'm an old school liberal too.
I have never changed my stance.
Today I am considered an alt right extremist.
This guy isnt changing his vote
You need to have scott on!
Since the estimated $40 trillion spent on the War on Poverty since 1964 was to help poor people, I would suggest that we change our strategy from "help the poor" to "help the poor who want to be helped to improve themselves to become contributing members of our society". The first step is getting government out of the help business; the activists and politicians coopted the need to help the poor into an unmitigated disaster. If that doesn't change then there is no hope; for anybody.
I don’t trust administrators to implement ANY preferential admissions policies. They’ll just revert back to the status quo.
Mr. Galloway is at a key inflection point - he'll either back down on his statements and fall in line, or continue to be vocal, get viciously attacked for it, and become more disenchanted with progressivism.
In general, he is right. I dont believe in affirmative action in 2024 but his premise is correct
As a registered and practicing American Independent, I 1000% agree with Scott Galloway here. If we're going to have affirmative action for college admissions, it should be based on background and family wealth. That's it, full stop.
Thanks for a great video!
I'm a old school conservative and I find nothing wrong with anything the Scott Galloway said.
This speaks to the core existential problem Americans have been facing now for years. We are divided over politics and bending over backwards to avoid offending people. I'm tired of this attachment to sensitivity over correcting somebody's label and the fixation on grieving the many better days of past decades (most of which I did not live through). Our culture desperately needs to reverse course ASAP, and we have the power to do it. We just have to care enough about uniting over the things that matter most - dignity, honest and transparency, kindness, love, and being willing to cooperate with one another.
Go watch 1 hour of a live jazz concert and you'll get it. Those guys figured it out 100 years ago, and they haven't stopped.
Proclaiming to be the son of an "immigrant" (His mother is from England) is no different than badgering the daughter of a "Taiwanese Equity Billionaire".
I totally agree with him...up to the point of green being what matters. Why is their an expectation that parents should pay for their grown ass adult children to further their education? College kids are typically legal age adults. Why should the economic status of their parents matter? Get rid of all the BS on colleges and go back to teaching. Dorms now look like elegant facilities. When i was in school they were terrible. Get rid of all the fluff thats driving up the cost such that you can't take out a small loan thats reasonable to pay off and make an investment in yourself.
Their should be only one color and it is Green. I totally agree. The poor kids need the most help.
If a system is based on need and adversity, then would that explain why everyone needs to be a victim in today's society...?
Everyone in the entire world has their own problems they need to deal with. Turning it into a competition is just unnecessary noise that serves no purpose.
Affirmative action programs come too late, and present the idea to the recipients that they need benevolence from an exclusive university to succeed (and therefore only very few will).
School choice. Set up families and kids from the beginning to be owners of their own lives, and by the time they get to college-age, they're more likely to be ready.
It's called getting back toward a meritocracy. I have no issue helping smart kids from any background get with other smart kids in the right classes with the right instructors. But you have to base it on merit. Let the kid from the poor neighborhood test high or prove him/herself and then assist from there as needed. It's lowering standards for some and raising for others that I detest.
What he is saying: Instead of preferential treatment based on one criteria let's base it on a different criteria - one that I want. Because, as always, his way is more fair, more just and better in every way. . The hubris never stops with certain people.
Would love to hear more Scott Galloway!!
Boeing uses DEI ....hmmm
Thomas Sowell made this same point decades ago. Diversity involves more than just skin color.
Revux leadership team is stacked with industry experts.
DEI - Didn’t Earn It
We love you Dave!
Thank you for that, it was enlightening. Turns out the only reason I got through college was affirmative action too. And I'm a white straight female
Stand up on your own 2 feet, own your situation, stop playing the victim.
the guy is right.
Love this show
“Vote the right way”… yeah, there is no right way to vote in our corporateocracy…
DEI means never getting the best man for the job!
Trying to solve the problem from the same place as the problem. Round and around in circles nothing really fundamentally changing. Change your mind.
"True liberalism" is all about introducing Americans to the basics of communism AKA Socialism AKA progressivism AKA liberalism
That's an actual liberal position that makes sense and has some understandable logic.
Can we please start calling it DIE
Love
It
Well said!
Mr Scott has been on a roll lately. I'm sure he's got a me too coming right around the corner lol
He summarized my view perfectly
Affirmative Action was enormously beneficial in its day, and if we could be so brave as to revise Affirmative Action by coloring it green, as Dr. Galloway says, we might be able to accomplish authentic diversity. I also think that Ivys, specifically, Harvard and Yale, who have real poverty and exclusion happening in public schools just beyond their gates, could put money where their DEI mouth is and seek talent in those tough hoods. Talent doesn’t see a poverty line, but poverty keeps the talented at bay and at risk. NCR Davis, WWII author
Nailed it
He used California as an example but the goals of DEI can be implemented through the admission matrix convoluted ways to effectively reach the same outcome while reducing transparency if it’s part of the algorithm.
Wow, what a breath of fresh air. May not agree on all, but I like where he's coming from.
he's a millionaire who will continue to gorge himself on attaining wealth, watch actions, not words, its easy to point out how bad things are, he's just the first elite to say so, eventually they all will, and that's all they will do, talk talk talk, then create MORE programs for the welfare do-nothing class of citizens, and the working poor will foot the bill.