I worked in Oxford Economics and was the only Pakistani there, most of my colleagues were from IMF, Bank of England, World Bank etc. Still my colleagues/Friends are now working in IMF and world bank. I was heading one of the technical team. But learn alot about countries economy etc. This guy is speaking the truth, but keep in mind industry economic is diffrent than theoretical economic.
I would suggest viewers to listen to Miftah Ismail’s podcasts and appearances in different universities. Two times finance minster explains in depth on the root-cause of the issue and how our policies are skewed towards elites. Economy is a broader topic, I respect TCMs efforts in this regard but a much longer video with bunch of economists would probably be a better idea
@@adeilakram is waja se ke jb wo finance minister nhi huta to seminar podcast ma aese policies bata raha huta jo fruitful huti ha country ke liye lakin jb wo finance minister 2 bar lg gia phr un policies ko implement hi nhi kia
@@finalphantom6882 you’ll need to consider that as FM he doesn’t operate in isolation. You will need to understand that how much interference we face from Army. So, ager usay kaam krny diya jaye tou he makes one of the best FMs we currently have. Also, consider that he literally saved pakistan from default. I understand if you don’t get it but we all are, in ways, shallow and root for popular politics
@@adeilakram sab bahane hute ha is trha to IK bhi kehta ha ke foj ne kaam nhi krne diya wrna wo best huta munafiq wo bhi tha ye bhi ha Agr ye sach bolta to jb FM huta usi waqt ye bol deta muje falah bnda ya institution kaam nhi krne de rha Jb mu se zeera nikal jata ha to yaad ata ha ye bhi krna tha wo bhi agr chalo first time benefit dedete ha ke isko pata nhi tha FM bnne ke baad kia huta ha to second time kiu bna jb ye khe rha huta ke iske hath ma kuch nhi or ab phr third time bnne ke liye kehta ha Or kaha default se bachaya Pakistan still default ke risk pr ha Bloomberg ki reports ke mutabiq Age ap bhi samjhdar ha jisne kaam krna huta ha wo bahane nhi bnata irrespective of problems
When borrowing for a short time is normal but when you have to sell or lease your country to repay loans there is a vicious circle and no way you can get out of it
Politics also matters. No prime minister has money in foreign accounts. That's the criteria This is why people don't vote for Raul Gandhi bcoz his mother is Italian citizen.
All said and done, it’s the defense budget that is ripping the budget and starving the citizenry. What is more important IMF loans or the markup on such loans??
Our core issue is lack of education. Be it conventional or be it vocational. Hum achay plumber ya electrician tk nahe bana rahay Hamary kisaan ki output dekhein vs that of Indian kisaan Illiteracy ki waja sy we are now facing labor export challenges in the hands of Bangladesh and India
@@adeilakram yes Indian defense expenditure is five times ours ( about 10% vs our 14% of total budget) but its economy is twenty times ( fifth largest economy in the world) and foreign reserve around 500 billion against our maximum twenty in the past ( currently it’s less than 4 billion ) India kicked out IMF in late nineties and even Bangladesh spends as much on education as is our apparent defense budget. Our priorities being gun & powder first, health & education least and bread & butter last.
@@nofilkhan6743 i started his book (LOOKING BACK) after watching this video. a completely novel idea of presenting numbers in the form of futuristic assumptions. 😍
deeekheee sir meee toooo economy keee upeer baat nae kartaa kyunkee yeee tooo aesaa maslaa hain naaa jooo kise govt seee handlee nae hotaaa filhal deeekhee sir sirf issss country meee economic issue nae or bheee bhot seee issue haim filhal meee kuch suggestion deta hooon 1- Free and fair election through evm or by any advance secure technological method 2- A public referendum should be held wether there should be a parliamentary system or presidential system 3- give provincial.status toooo azad kashmir and gilgit baltistan and create ten provinces in pakistan pakistan keer har province kooo north and south meee divide kardoooo 4- Har province koooo usske natural resources peee ussska right dooo jooo bhee natural resources hooo tooo usske revenue kaaa 70-% usss province koo doooo 5-Change in NFC award 70% should be with federal govt only 30% should be given tooooo provincial govt equally And PFC provincial finance awards jaha provinces har district kooo paiseee deee or pheer DFC (district financial commision)awards 6- Division and transfer of taxes jeseee Twooo types of taxes Direct taxes / Indirect taxes Direct taxes meee income tax, wealth tax coroporaye tax yeee provinces govt collect kareee or ndirect tax jeseeee custom duty excise duty, sale tax or internet tax and mobile calls tax, banking transaction tax yeee sab federal govt collect kareee or service tax property tax water tax, motor vehicle tax or bhot seee chote chote cess yeee sab municipal govt collect kareee 7- Direct elected mayor hooo pakistan meee or municipal election mee changes yeea unkee ekection ki zimedare federal govt keee hooo provinces kiii naaa hooo kyunkiio provinces humeshaa unnseeee ikhtyrat leeete hain indian style panchayat govt hoooo 8- Provinces govt yeaaa municipal govt keee power cheena unka revenue roknaa yeaa unkeee kaam meee mudakhlat kooo illegal or offensable hona chahye or yeee karnee peeee pm yea cm koooo uskii post see hata deena chahyeee ...........Mere agerr yeee suggestion ghalat lagge tooo applog correction kaesakteeee hain shukriyea..........pakistan zindabad 🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰
@@masroorkhalil9655Under Modi Govt 🇮🇳's GDP is growing 8.4 % as per latest WORLD BANK report where as yours is hardly 2%, might go negative and to bankruptcy within a year...so who need help ?? Shahbaz Sharif i guess 🤫
@@freddythomas6955 its a jobless growth noooo manufacturing happening sirf investors neee apppna paisa lagyea huwaa hain interest of returns hasil karnee kelyeee ua-cam.com/video/4BOZ7dnSGdo/v-deo.htmlsi=FIn7J8_6Y5GcEi7L
Biggest problem is establishment they want dollars at any cost to support their lavish lifestyle.
I worked in Oxford Economics and was the only Pakistani there, most of my colleagues were from IMF, Bank of England, World Bank etc. Still my colleagues/Friends are now working in IMF and world bank. I was heading one of the technical team. But learn alot about countries economy etc. This guy is speaking the truth, but keep in mind industry economic is diffrent than theoretical economic.
I would suggest viewers to listen to Miftah Ismail’s podcasts and appearances in different universities. Two times finance minster explains in depth on the root-cause of the issue and how our policies are skewed towards elites.
Economy is a broader topic, I respect TCMs efforts in this regard but a much longer video with bunch of economists would probably be a better idea
Miftah bolta kuch or ha krta kuch ha is kisam ke bndo ko munafiq bolte ha
@@finalphantom6882 and how have you reached this conclusion?
@@adeilakram is waja se ke jb wo finance minister nhi huta to seminar podcast ma aese policies bata raha huta jo fruitful huti ha country ke liye lakin jb wo finance minister 2 bar lg gia phr un policies ko implement hi nhi kia
@@finalphantom6882 you’ll need to consider that as FM he doesn’t operate in isolation. You will need to understand that how much interference we face from Army. So, ager usay kaam krny diya jaye tou he makes one of the best FMs we currently have.
Also, consider that he literally saved pakistan from default. I understand if you don’t get it but we all are, in ways, shallow and root for popular politics
@@adeilakram sab bahane hute ha is trha to IK bhi kehta ha ke foj ne kaam nhi krne diya wrna wo best huta munafiq wo bhi tha ye bhi ha
Agr ye sach bolta to jb FM huta usi waqt ye bol deta muje falah bnda ya institution kaam nhi krne de rha
Jb mu se zeera nikal jata ha to yaad ata ha ye bhi krna tha wo bhi agr chalo first time benefit dedete ha ke isko pata nhi tha FM bnne ke baad kia huta ha to second time kiu bna jb ye khe rha huta ke iske hath ma kuch nhi or ab phr third time bnne ke liye kehta ha
Or kaha default se bachaya Pakistan still default ke risk pr ha Bloomberg ki reports ke mutabiq
Age ap bhi samjhdar ha jisne kaam krna huta ha wo bahane nhi bnata irrespective of problems
Dear TCM original should have" Downloading option in all video
The biggest hurdle is the government itself. Let the private sector run its course and sell/close the 213 SOEs.
Same who didnt pay taxes and shut their shutters?
When borrowing for a short time is normal but when you have to sell or lease your country to repay loans there is a vicious circle and no way you can get out of it
India investment se nahi, apni educated awam ki wajha se tarakki kar raha hai..
Politics also matters. No prime minister has money in foreign accounts. That's the criteria
This is why people don't vote for Raul Gandhi bcoz his mother is Italian citizen.
@@banksterkid5930 kya bolna chah rahe ho bhai
Unfortunately We are.Emergency State.
Well brief and adviced
100% true
All said and done, it’s the defense budget that is ripping the budget and starving the citizenry.
What is more important IMF loans or the markup on such loans??
That’s not the case. India is spending way more. Issue is interference in Politics by Military which is NONE OF THEIR BUSINESS
Our core issue is lack of education. Be it conventional or be it vocational.
Hum achay plumber ya electrician tk nahe bana rahay
Hamary kisaan ki output dekhein vs that of Indian kisaan
Illiteracy ki waja sy we are now facing labor export challenges in the hands of Bangladesh and India
@@adeilakram yes Indian defense expenditure is five times ours ( about 10% vs our 14% of total budget) but its economy is twenty times ( fifth largest economy in the world) and foreign reserve around 500 billion against our maximum twenty in the past ( currently it’s less than 4 billion ) India kicked out IMF in late nineties and even Bangladesh spends as much on education as is our apparent defense budget. Our priorities being gun & powder first, health & education least and bread & butter last.
@@khaliddurrani6432 agreed.
@@khaliddurrani6432 Pakistan defense budge is in pkr… what does that have to do with foreign loans
Well educated person in the pak from India
Kamal kr gye hain uncle ❤
Great sir
Zabardast.
He talks like an economic sage.
He is the Head of PIDE.
@@nofilkhan6743 i started his book (LOOKING BACK) after watching this video. a completely novel idea of presenting numbers in the form of futuristic assumptions. 😍
deeekheee sir meee toooo economy keee upeer baat nae kartaa kyunkee yeee tooo aesaa maslaa hain naaa jooo kise govt seee handlee nae hotaaa filhal deeekhee sir sirf issss country meee economic issue nae or bheee bhot seee issue haim filhal meee kuch suggestion deta hooon
1- Free and fair election through evm or by any advance secure technological method
2- A public referendum should be held wether there should be a parliamentary system or presidential system
3- give provincial.status toooo azad kashmir and gilgit baltistan and create ten provinces in pakistan pakistan keer har province kooo north and south meee divide kardoooo
4- Har province koooo usske natural resources peee ussska right dooo jooo bhee natural resources hooo tooo usske revenue kaaa 70-% usss province koo doooo
5-Change in NFC award
70% should be with federal govt only 30% should be given tooooo provincial govt equally
And PFC provincial finance awards jaha provinces har district kooo paiseee deee
or pheer DFC (district financial commision)awards
6- Division and transfer of taxes jeseee
Twooo types of taxes
Direct taxes / Indirect taxes
Direct taxes meee income tax,
wealth tax coroporaye tax yeee provinces govt collect kareee
or ndirect tax jeseeee
custom duty excise duty, sale tax or internet tax and mobile calls tax, banking transaction tax yeee sab federal govt collect kareee
or service tax property tax water tax, motor vehicle tax or bhot seee chote chote cess yeee sab municipal govt collect kareee
7- Direct elected mayor hooo pakistan meee or municipal election mee changes yeea unkee ekection ki zimedare federal govt keee hooo provinces kiii naaa hooo kyunkiio provinces humeshaa unnseeee ikhtyrat leeete hain
indian style panchayat govt hoooo
8- Provinces govt yeaaa municipal govt keee power cheena unka revenue roknaa yeaa unkeee kaam meee mudakhlat kooo illegal or offensable hona chahye or yeee karnee peeee pm yea cm koooo uskii post see hata deena chahyeee
...........Mere agerr yeee suggestion ghalat lagge tooo applog correction kaesakteeee hain shukriyea..........pakistan zindabad 🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰
Excellent
Best Annalise
Aur yeh sab kuch ghantaaa hoga Pakistan mein. Daydreaming karo bas Madrasachaap Kaum Aetmi taakat😅😅
Can you please not add music the next time. Can't understand a single word
in policy making 'the confession of an economic htman' is true.
Baikaari mulk,, beegh mangthay rahooo sarriii zindigi
Sab say pahalay Terror factory band karnay padaygay. Oor safeed hathy miltry pe lagam lagoghay.
India ne usaka sona IMF ko becha nahi tha lekin giravi rakha tha, bewakuf! 🤦🏾♂
❤
no wonder this video doesn't have good reviews as he himself said we as nation are interested in politics and not economy. Very sad
Chy da har ye aw da lata ye nu dyra grana da
Translate into urdu ur self
Kamaskam p m modi ka atmanirbhar he adopt karlo.
Joke of all time
Hire me !...i can give my assistance, an Indian solution to the Pakistan economical problem. I will charge 💲300/day
Give your service to modi govt so they can reduce enmpolyment with the help of your services 😂😂😂😂
@@masroorkhalil9655Under Modi Govt 🇮🇳's GDP is growing 8.4 % as per latest WORLD BANK report where as yours is hardly 2%, might go negative and to bankruptcy within a year...so who need help ?? Shahbaz Sharif i guess 🤫
@@freddythomas6955
its a jobless gdp manufacturing kuch india meee nae horae sirf investorooo neee paisa lagyea howa hain appne returns panee kelyeee
@@freddythomas6955
its a jobless growth noooo manufacturing happening sirf investors neee apppna paisa lagyea huwaa hain interest of returns hasil karnee kelyeee
ua-cam.com/video/4BOZ7dnSGdo/v-deo.htmlsi=FIn7J8_6Y5GcEi7L
@@freddythomas6955 _Oversmart pejeet trying to scam its neighbours_ 🤢🤮
Bf