It was cheap. Sraha and Fatima stories were great and consistent. They had scary, bloody things with sacrifice. The forest magical memory scene was cheap and shit. No visuals, no scary thing. She is just crying and crying. Felt as an after season shooting in a forest to cramp some answers because without that scene, we get some answer and some new mystery, but very little of both. With the forest scene, it felt as a big revolution as the fans wanted, but it was so poorly done I believe it was an aftershoot, and it looks horrible. Honestly, I hate the actress. She is shit and now Jim is dead, we are going to see even more of her, so I am out. Will read a wiki page in a year if I get interested to know more. Oh and f kids could not have learned 1 word in English after centuries? All the monsters speak perfect English, and those kids were torturing people with their anghkooe for years on, but could not have learned the word "remember"? Bullshit.
I don't think Christopher and Miranda had a child together. She said they were there from the beginning and during that time with Miranda and Christopher. Miranda was already Married and have Eloise and Victor. When she said they were there from the beginning she meant when it all started. when the town was still "normal" before the children sacrifice and I'm guessing it would be during the Witch era which is on the late 1600.
@@gilbirdsareawesome bruh I seen a theory on this on another channel i think, best one ive seen yet on this topic Basically the theory is that when Boyd killed smiley, the same way he passed on his DNA/blood to smiley, smiley passed his DNA/blood to boyd without boyd realising, after that Ellis i think had a blood transfusion from boyd, which transfers the smiley dna to ellis, then Ellis has romance with Fatima which passed the DNA to her, after that she's got pregnant with smiley....not my theory like I said so don't credit me 👍
The Man in Yellow might have been behind the calls from Thomas but he definitely was the voice on the radio from Season 1 - "your wife shouldn't be digging that hole jim" He said that again to Jim before killing him.
Yeah, I notice this too. I wonder if the reason the man in yellow talks about Jim knowing too much is because he figured out how to use the numbers in the tree
@@Wakka12321 he always used Jim to discourage Tabitha from finding out the secrets. Now that the secrets are out, Jim serves no purpose to the Man in Yellow. It felt like a revenge murder.
I think it's because jims smart and he was finally helping them out solve the puzzles his perspective was a danger to the people who come out at night maybe
I think Julie is the one to the crack the code. She was able to come to the exact location and time of Jim's death and she could have definitely done things differently to save Jim. Maybe next time she time travels she will be able to make some changes to the future or past which will help the town is some way. The only way they win is to cheat the system which is Julie time travelling.
Makes me think Jim is actually smarter than jade and more vital to the solving the towns puzzles, man in yellow seen Jim as a risk to solving the towns issues so he killed him off
well. he's new. don't think he knows the whole story with Sarah. And he seems like someone who doesn't really believe anyone would cause him physical pain. Even when Boyd smashed his hand I was like "you gonna tell now?"
I have a theory about Eloise. While escaping from the root cellar, she managed to get into the tree and escape to the real world. She sought help from adults, telling them what she had experienced, but no one believed the little girl's words and she was considered mentally ill. When she grew up, she became the author of the book that Ethan read.
Excellent analysis. However, Miranda and Christopher didn’t have a child together. Tabitha said that her and Jade were original inhabitants of the town before the children were sacrificed. They had a child together wayyyyy back then: in the beginning. However, their child was taken from them and sacrificed, and they tried to stop it from happening, but they failed. They will keep getting resurrected, like the monsters, through reincarnation until they succeed.
A endless cycle of them trying to save the kids is why fromville exist. Its obvious that the place is fueled by hope so they keep saving these kids that doesnt let the roots get the blood to grow. The story thats told to the kids that gave them hope[in this time cycle] is Ethans Kromncle story. And julie will tell the kids. Those kids are supposed to be sacrifice while having high hopes the blood is what grows the far away trees. Miranda Tabitha jade. In all time cycles saved the kids. The fallen tree in the beginning is a broken faraway tree becuase no blood has been sacrificed. The original people made a choice for immortality. They have that. People keep breaking the rules of the sacrifice and the curse creates the same story over and over. Kill the kids poor their blood on the root. The tree in the beginning will not be broken. Nobody can get into fromville. Only the people who sacrificed their kids will remain there forever. 💯
The creatures , cicada monster, kimono lady and now the man in yellow in the bad side with other bad entities coming in future episodes , and on the "good" side you have the boy in white, and the crusty kids who can barely send a message , how tf are the townsfolk gonna survive 😭🙏🏽
@@sekoaib If jade is the one who made the bottle tree in a pass life, then it makes sense that hed pick some complicated ass cypher. Especially based on music
The man in the yellow appeared because he was angry that Jade and Tabatha remembered.. He said their was a price for knowledge.. What a better price to pay than kill her husband. The boy white is the person who told the kids the story that gave the children hope. The hope that they poured into the roots that made the tree. The man in yellow is the evil entity that Martin referred to. The boy in white referred to him in season 2, that he was angry. Sara said he is laughing at you. One of the town people in season 1 when during the storm said you think he is angry. The town started changing when Jade and Tabatha appeared. I think the town recycles with their deaths. The entity appered to Boyb as Abby. He lied to Boyd when he said it feeds on hope. Hope weakens it. The town people had hope when they built the tower so he destroyed it. I don't think everyone is reincarnated. They are brought there so it can feed off their fear. Tabatha and Christopher were there in the beginning and was given eternal life. Since they didn't partake in sacrifice, their eternal life is different. Its thru reincarnation.
Julie says in this final scene that he should go back to the city, that it is safer. I believe that now in the next season the monsters will walk through the forest during the day, but they will not enter the city at night. This makes it more difficult for them to save the children and also highlights Victor's concern about the trees getting closer.
That’s a smart theory, it means that the forest is gonna move closer and closer to the town. And the monsters may be able to walk in the forest during the day, which means the people would be trapped in the town….24/7
I think the new cycle in town began when Tabitha and Jade arrived in the town the same day..Victor had said that two cars arrived on the same day last time when everyone died..it might have been when Miranda and Christopher were in this town. So all these were happening in loops just with different characters. Also maybe till now the time in this town was not going forward...When Boyd broke that music box in that ruins , somehow he changed the cycle..time started again and that's why it's winter now and the boy in white also grew up.
I'm starting to think the good and bad things along with new knowledge affects the energy of the place. When they start to try new things and learn more it causes the other side to push back. Or something 😂🤣 And Tabitha finding victor and ending back their gave the chance for the biw to grow.
Fun part is that Smiley actor actually has that haunting smile 😅 originally he was planned to only appear as an extra. ( Among monsters, but became fans favorite and git more screen time)
I don't think it's like that the monster's were normal humans but they sacrifice their kids to live forever so smiley needed to reborn somehow that's why fatima was just the reason
Season 3 gave Fatima way too much screen time. A lot of back and forth with characters and many episodes were a drag. Especially 3-8. First 2 and last 2 were the only decent ones.
I literally slept through 80% of the season. They are gonna make this show in 9 Seasons when its 90% random bullshit that no one are gonna even remember and 10% decent story, exactly like Lost was.
@@hpttm749100%. I skipped so much of S3. What snoozefest full of filler scenes. At this rate we need like 10 seasons and I'm probably going to check out before it's done.
Dude in the yellow jacket was actually the guy who spoke to Jim over the phone when the built the radio tower. If you recall if mentioned “your wife should have never dug that hole” the same thing he said over the phone.
They found out that's where the kids where sacrificed and Julie knowing about it puts the monsters in danger. Also where they sleep. The man in yellow is probably the one who told them they can gain immortality that way.
@@verity_amo yeah, it was obious that yellow one is the one behind idk how people still dont believe that, but who is he... is he a monster or a human, ahhh so many questions
Here's a thought. The show considers Julie a 'Storywalker.' When Victor remembered The Boy in White talking to Christopher, Victor said that "...and then they were murdered in the dark. But someone who loved them told them a story. This story gave them hope. And when the children laid on the stones, they poured their hopes into the roots the roots that made the symbol and those roots became the tree." Maybe that person who loved them was Tabitha or Jade, and the story that they told the children is somehow related to what is happening to the town. Another thing that seems very likely moving into S4 is that Tabitha rekindles her connection with Viktor, and maybe even remembers what ended up happening to his sister, assuming she is still alive. Randall also seems to know about this place, with insights like "Dying isn't the worst thing that can happen to you here..." certainly feels like he is the reincarnation of Martin. Being chained up like that in wherever he is for however long he has been there certainly seems like a fate worse than death.
No, I think it could be possible that Randall is the reincarnation Martin. Since the place were Martin was seemed to be connected to past. If you remember when Julie ended up in the dungeon she saved Boyde from the well and she said she heard the voice of her mom from when she was trapped under the house. Perhaps Martin was alive a long time ago before the place was in ruines, and after passing on the curse, he was able to die and reincarnate. They probably left him there to torture him for attempting to save the kids.
@tegathemenace Yes. One of them is Tabitha and Jade's daughter. They were not able to save her from being sacrificed in their past lives. You can reference the last episode when Tabitha explains this to Jim. ***
@@freelanxeI say that because I kept wondering why did the dream play out in 3rd person 🤔 Normally in dreams you would experience it through your own eyes 👀 If she was the little girl running, she would have looked up and what ever took her would have been shown. Instead the dream was like perspective of watching. These are just my thoughts though lol
I means the first time had a dream it warned him to tell the bus to turn around the second time helped save 3 people. Can really fault him for believing in it a 3rd time
Jade: we used to sing them lullabies Tabitha: I know why. I know why I see those children. Why Jade can see them. That’s why there’s more than one bracelet - I kept making them. Somewhere, deep down, I remember. It’s because we’ve been here before - me and Jade. The reason I felt what Miranda felt is because I was miranda and Jade was Christopher. We’ve come back over and over again because we failed the first time. Jade and I were here in the beginning. We tried to save those children and set them free because one of them was ours. She was our daughter.
@@aleesac5414 One of the children was theirs, so they obviously didn't agree with sacrificing them and were probably killed. They never went through with the deal, so they weren't made immortal, like the rest. I think next season we'll see who exactly they were and how they died. They were the ones who read the story to the children that gave them hope.
I have a hunch that Jim’s death might not be permanent and that Julie will somehow find a way to save him. While that could make for an interesting twist, it might not be the best direction for the story. If deaths can be undone through time travel, it risks undermining the tension and diminishing the Big Bad’s overwhelming power and sense of danger. Jim’s death is a powerful moment that reinforces just how terrifying and unstoppable the Big Bad truly is.
@@the__lone__thinker I really liked him in season 1, but he became somewhat irrelevant after that. It’s a shame because the actor was great, and his role as an engineer added an interesting layer to his character. They could have done so much more with that after the whole radio tower storyline, but unfortunately, they didn’t.
Yeah Julie's gonna try to change a canon event, and from the hair, she's tried several times. Are Randall and Marielle story walkers too? Worms(lava) matures to insects (cicada) 🤔
What would be crazy is if jim is the man in yellow who was created out of hate. He kills every version of himself. He wants to be the only version. He didnt want his wife looking for answers like digging that hole. He probably doesn't like the fact tabitha and jada had a kid in another life. And now he just hates everything except his kids which is why he doesn't kill julie who tries to save every version of jim or the boy in white who probably represents ethan. It would be a cool twist. Then again i think jim is the reincarnation of Henry so idk lol
8:35 There is absolutely zero doubt that Tabitha and Jade’s story goes back much farther than Miranda and Christopher.. After remembering their past lives, Tabitha said to Jim “We’ve come back over and over again because we failed the first time.” So, yeah….. that question is answered! 😎
Jim dying pretty much alone was frustrating, that was clearly Julie from the future, so no one is going to know he’s been dead and everyone is running around right now with all the new information. It’s heartbreaking, I hated his character but he was fun to watch still in the first two seasons being a father just grasping at straws to save his family. I hope they give Jim some sort of happy ending cuz man did not deserve that.
Julie came from the future to stop his death because she knew he was dead so obviously they found out he died. I'm sure once he didn't come back to town by dark they were worried and wondering where he was. They probably went looking for him the next morning. He died where he was when they left him so they would have known where to look too.
Miranda and Christopher didn't have a child together, their past selves did. They didn't reincarnate once, they have reincarnated many times. Their first incarnations were more than likely 150+ years prior and that's most likely when they had the child together. Miranda and Christopher were just the previous iterations of Tabitha and Jade, there were MANY more before them, going all the way back to the originals where this all started. They've been arriving in From and failing to save the children each time since, starting the reincarnation of themselves again.
Do u think they lived in the settlement village? Remember Tabitha dreamt of it as a child. That village is tied to everything but we don't know how yet. I agree, I think they've reincarnated many times even before they lived in town with the children.
@@danielleschiazza6172 i think that they were at settlement villlage, maybe tabitha and jade's first version didnt accepted the ritual, so they didnt became monsters but as their child was taken so they are reincarnated every time.
I can't be the only one who felt really bad for Elgin lol. He only had good intentions, just like Sara. The town manipulated him in the same way it's manipulated everyone else. I think people are being too harsh toward him, he just wanted to do the right thing
Yeah torturing him was not necessary I bet that if they explained it to him properly he would have listend. Or they could go to fatima all together. Acosta did something good for the first time, also boyd is a hypocriet
@@LalaLala-jz4td ya it’s easy to say that as an outside observer, but put yourself in their shoes, times running out, and his stalling still led to ritual summoning happening. If they had been earlier maybe it might’ve changed things, but somehow it feels like they were always going to be late regardless of the method they used to get Elgin to talk.
Imagine the intensity of the next town meeting if that happens.... with Boyd talking about the smiley , tabitha and jade revealing what they found....but I think that will take may be 1 to 3 episodes.. cause of Jim's death!
@@beewest5704this is my biggest gripe with the show. It seems so many characters know things but no one is willing to come together to share what they have learned with everyone else bc others might think they are “crazy”. Also why was Victor right outside of the room where Fatima was? But just standing there?
It kinda feels like the town is in the grips of two vampiric forces, one feeds off their hope, one feeds off their fear, and both sides are unwilling to release them.
I agree. There is more than one "being" controlling things. I also think there was more than one event. The thing with the children is one event but what about the settlement village? That village is a lot older than the town. Something horrible happened there too. Tabitha dreamt about it.
The good thing with this series is that they kept it under super natural realm with a mix of time travel and time loop and not the concept of time overpowering the supernatural element , because when jim thought that some one is behind all this i thought we are going to see that some people are behind this all and the show would not have been that much fun then.
I’m thinking perhaps it’s the song that allowed the monster to be in that area during the day. Perhaps that’s what happened when victor was a kid. Someone found out about the music, but played it in town instead of taking the same precautions, so they were allowed to roam through an unsuspecting town during the day and that’s how almost everyone was slaughtered.
The episode when Boyd gives smiley the worms and says "My Blood Is Your Blood" (mf wasn't joking, now thats his grandson) but thats the same episode Fatima became pregnant or at least believes shes naturally pregnant. Elgin is big dummy Has no one told him to not mess with crazy people..... GOD DAMN SARA AIN'T FUCKING AROUND 😉
@eternity.in.a.m0m3nt OMG you're right! I forgot this show makes nothing but complete sense. Thanks Poindexter! 😊 (The user listed above made a dumbass comment, I cooked him with my reply and so he eventually deleted his comment) His comment said "Sperm doesn't work like that gynecologist"
Last week I said I doubted if we were gonna get any answers besides Fatima's baby in the finale. I've never never been so happy to be wrong in my life!
Spoiler Alert for Season 4 & onwards - Season will change to Spring - Man in yellow is the puppet master/architect - Randall is the reincarnation of Martin - Great massacre reset - Ethan is the author
Julie can definitely impact events when she travels back. Like this video showed she dropped the rope down to Boyd when he was trapped. I am sure it will take her a couple tries before she learns how to change things when she travels back
very insightful, trully she helped boyd with the rope, even without knowing what she was doing or the part she was playing, so when she eventually gets a hand of it, it will be crazy
She didnt change the story by dropping the rope to Boyd .She was always gonna drop the rope to Boyd.If she didnt drop the rope to Boyd that would be a change in the story. 13:37
Smiley wasn’t reborn because of their child sacrifice. Boyd touched him with an open wound then gave Ellis the blood transfusion which infected Ellis who then “impregnated” Fatima. So smiley is basically Boyd’s grandson 😂
How does this theory explain what the Angel was doing? This whole horror pregnancy was the Angel's planning (somehow) Fatima's pregnancy gave everyone hope and this place feeds on hope
I didn’t know this was the season finale! I wasn’t prepared for it. Oh gosh, now I have to wait for the new season! I definitely felt the intensity of this episode after coming back from multiple episodes that were a little slow..
Julie probably mess up timeline by trying to fix something. She will probably be main character in s4 because she will try to save her dad by fixing timeline. Sarah got +3000 aura in this episode😂😂 EDIT: Thanks for 117 liks 🥳🥳
@ They are my favs ! Hate Acosta , Randall is trouble, Ellis is so useless like he could die and no one would care if it wasn’t for Boyd, Julie is not too far but I feel like she will become more interesting next season, Mariel is sus and useless as well - for now. Love Donna also, Fatima as well but like season 1 Fatima
But still she failed in trying to save Jim. We will see that in later seasons that she will attempt to change the past, but the end of S3 shows us she won’t be able to succeed
@@mucmac3586season 1 they showed Fatima lining up clothes at the house in the backyard. I knew they wouldn’t show it more often after that. Lmao. I just found out recently that the writers are from the show lost. Omg we gonna be here for a while!!😂
I have a theory...those children were sacrificed and Miranda & Christopher don't want to give their daughter but someone took from them. But we get to know that once your children are sacrificed those people can't die so as a punishment the people who murdered their children knowingly become monsters because they committed a sin but since Miranda & Christopher refused they are chosed by the childeren as a pure soul and they'll be reincarnated again and again until both of they free all the children souls
But it is really a hell, reincarnating to face your greatest failure over and over again, with new innocent people in the mix, and getting killed and overcome by the monsters who started all of this from the beginning.
They were the ones that the boy in white had said loved the children and read them a story that gave them hope which created the roots and the bottle trees. One of the children was their daughter and they didn't want to sacrifice them but I believe the others killed them and sacrificed their daughter anyway, along with the other children. So they were reincarnated as Miranda and Christopher and died again and then reincarnated again as Tabitha and Jade. In the beginning they were actually a couple who shared a daughter. I honestly believe they were reincarnated more than that. I think they've been around a lot longer. Remember Tabitha had a dream about the settlement village as a child and she hid behind the red rocks because something horrible happened. That village is an older settlement than the town though. The man Jade saw there, that was drinking blood from a skull appeared to be dressed in clothes from the 1700's or so. I believe this entity has offered deals to more people than just the monsters. Obviously that man drinking blood from a human skull was doing some kind of occult ritual. There is a lot more to this than we think.
I believe that they are all stuck in a loop, because remember when Boyd was stuck in a well, Julie was the one that threw him the rope. At the end of Season 3, she runs on screen with short black hair and scratches on her face.
I predicted that the baby that was growing was smiley. Fatima got pregnant after smiley died. and we can deduce that the baby inside fatima has a similar diet that the monsters have. When smiley died in the first place, the other monsters didn't seem to care at all, which implies that they knew he will be reborn. They got that ability by sacrificing the anghkooey kids.
I am wondering if Eloise is also a “story walker” and is trying to participate in the resolution but in a less direct method than Julie is taking. Like maybe she is the one who moved Boyd and Sara’s tent or moving Jasper in the caves. And maybe she is stuck just moving through the timelines which is why she has never found (even if Victor is willing to believe that random body parts belonged to her). I am thinking that she will show herself to Julie at some point and maybe they will work together to drive the resolution of the story.
I think it would make sense for the children of Tabatha/Miranda to be „similair“. So Eloise and Judith both being storywalker just like Victor and Ethan are more like „storyteller“…
nah bro dragged a pregnant woman and trapped her in a room idc what voice tells me to do that im saying no. also if he didnt tell she wouldve died prob and then whta hes just a part of th e community again? you kidnap my wife like that i dont care what your intentions were ur getting sarah'd to the eye on sight
@@hadashaphelps822 i really like when directors keep the killer in tv show and use them to things like this very creative i really like sarah in this show
Where's that spoiler that said the ending scene was Eloise, Miranda, and Victor in a car together?🤣 and that Jade would take the talisman and the monsters would kill a lot of townfolks?🤣
Perhaps since now that they know the truth about where the monsters came from, they’re gonna be forced to leave town and that’s why this new guy showed up? And what is Jim‘s problem with taking advice ? When somebody tells him to run, he does the complete opposite.
@@solarium4884 what monsters are in the forest?? The only ones we see in the forest are the ones who come out at night because they come from the cave/tunnels, through the woods and into town. There are others things in the woods that are apparently more terrifying than the monsters according to what the voices told Sara and Kenny and Jim heard something walking around at night in the settlement village but we never see what is out there. I think maybe the thing kenny and Jim heard was the man in yellow.
I think the man in yellow only showed up because jim needed to go, it's like normally everything is fine letting the monsters handle things but jim is going to mess things up even further so he had to go, i think since he started supporting Tabitha and giving her the courage to solve the mystery he was going to encourage her to do more and the man in yellow can't have them leaving so he broke the non interfere rule so he could keep the story going because he's never interfered before even though he always could. Someone mentioned a long time ago this is a game between a good entity and a bad entity, the boy in white must be the good entity and the guy in yellow must be the bad one and the man in yellow has been winning this whole time but jim must cause him to lose so he had to step in just like the boy in white tried to help before but he stopped because he was probably giving away too much help😊
Everyone online keeps saying that the Settler and the Civil War soldier with the missing eye must be an earlier incarnation of Jade. But it's an earlier incarnation of Elgin--who got his eye freakin' cut out (again!) in this episode. This is *his* (whoever "he" is) cycle being re-run, not Jade's.
so martin recognized julie when she traveled to the room they were all chained up in because she’ll prolly try to time travel to save everyone and run into Martin along the way. will be cool to see his story
I remember when Boyd was stuck in that chimney thing and Martin helped him and i was wondering how Martin was able to throw the rope to Boyd when he was chained to the wall. Julie was there that time too, she just doesn't remember.
Can't wait for season 4 to come out so we can watch another 10 episodes without any answers and knowing just as much after 40 episodes as we did after watching the very first episode :)
Kenny: "The monsters always walk they never run." Season 1 episode 2. Kind of feel like time isn't set and maybe Smiley being born from Fatima changed him somehow. Also when Boyd killed him they didn't seem upset. Like it was suppose to happen. Idk this show is wild I love it.
I honestly do not understand the praise for this finale. It took literally the season finale to half ass answer 2 things... 1) some of them are reincarnated again to save the children. 2) the night monsters can be reborn. So wtf are they supposed to "remember" to save the children? Since they know how night monsters are reborn, they know to prevent it. And who tf is the kimono lady? They never clarified this. Now they add another antagonist (the man in the yellow jacket), adding more questions. Im done with this show. Horrible writing. Literally waited until season finale to mouth feed you half assed answers. Peace out From, it has been... slow and boring lol.
that happens when you’re impatient and literally have no comprehension skills. Your questions about the finale don’t even make any sense. It’s a mystery show bro, it’s not the end of the series, but you expect them to write out all the answers? Of course they are mouthfeeding us. What’s the point in telling us now who kimono lady is? How would they know? The people in the town don‘t know wtf is going and we as viewers don‘t know wtf is going on as well, that’s literally the point. But there have been a lot of clues and they are starting to figure things out now. And they didn’t just randomly throw in a new random villain. They alluded to the man in yellow a while back (radio voice, paintings of Miranda). If you need everything spelled out to you for you to understand, then the show is just not for you.
What made me happy with this episode is that they finally start to answer stuff instead of asking more. Making Fatima say "it promised they'd live forever" was an awesome movie. We now already know what happened, who did what and why they did it. No more questions were made, just the ones that still need answers: 1 - Who's Martin? 2 - What are those worms Boyd carried after meeting Martin? 3 - Why there's electricity there and where does it come from? 4 - Who is the Boy in White really? 5 - Does Boyd has a role in all this reincarnation stuff? 6 - Does everybody that gets there had been there before? Or just some people? 7 - What's the deal with Julie "time traveling"? 8 - What the hell is happening with Marielle and Randall and why they are so hopeless? 9 - What's the ultimate motivation of the "big bad" that promised the people immortality? Those were the ones I could remember without thinking much. VERY good that they didn't create even more stuff to be answered.
Martin might be Randal in one of the possible realities as he recognises Julie plus there are 2 more sceletons)) electricity is somehow explained with dr mabuse (the background story of the character). Julie’s also a time traveler because in episode 102 there was a monster who recognised her
Now this is what I was talking about .. this was the high stakes I’ve been looking for all season … best episode by far and I hope they don’t do the same thing they did this season with next season
The bloody civil war guy that Jade saw was missing an eye so I'm thinking that it could have been Elgin seeing as though he's missing an eye now & was collecting blood for Fatima
Season 4 Ep 1: The town is in chaos. Boyd is coming to pieces. Elgin has a patch. Acosta is the new sheriff. Jim is found with his throat ripped out. Jade and Miranda get awkward. The monsters plan on celebrating that night with the return of smiley and Jade remarks that Anghkooey is the most ridiculous word for remember. What future Julie does she has always already done. We are just witnessing her doing it this time.
Acosta is getting on my damn nerves! She just got there and she thinks she runs shit! She refuses to take that uniform off! She WAS a cop. She isn't anymore. If anyone takes over it is going to be kenny. Acosta still hasn't gotten it through her head! She still doesn't understand that things in that town are not like they are in the real world. She is treating everything like it is!
Because it's a time loop. Only one timeline exists so when you "change the past" you're not actually changing the past because the past is already predetermined in this series.
It's nice to hear from multiple other videos i'm not the only one who thought this season was very heavy with dialog and introducing NEW elements, NEW Town and people mechanics and even more secrets compared to little to no answers like the ratio of new stuff on the board compared to answers given its 10:1
I don’t think Miranda and Christopher had a baby. Tabitha said her and jade were the first ones in Fromville so that means it was even bore Miranda got there as a previous reincarnation. That’s why she said they kept coming back. Great video like always bro
@@Sheed96 right... Jade and tabhitha were a couple in their past life. They didn't sacrificed their child for immortality but they died and in order to save their kid they keep Reincarnating.
@@BrainPilotMiranda and Christopher definitely didn’t have a daughter together (that literally wouldn’t have made sense). It was an earlier version that were around when the other kids got sacrificed, including their daughter. That’s also why there are 3 bracelets. The bracelet Tabitha finds in the diner was the one made by her for Jade, in their original incarnation. We know there is one that Tabitha made for Jim when Julie was born and then there’s the bracelet in Henry’s car that Miranda made for him (that Tabitha found which caused her to freak out in the car). Besides that little error, your video was great and I really enjoyed it! It’s crazy how many of the parents were actually evil enough to sacrifice their children like that. It’s like the town knew how to draw those specific kind of people to it. Ooh I’m so excited for season 4! Don’t know how I’m gonna last so long! 😂
Miranda and Christofer didn’t have a baby together. Original Tabitha and Jade from the same era when the kids were sacrificed had a child and that child was one of the sacrificed kids.
After reading so many fan theories I came to the point, it's just a show do not get attached to much in these. Whatever will happen it will happen . FROM best series fr deserves appreciation on big stage.
I have a theory that Jim will come back because It will add an Interesting layer to the story even further, with him being the only one who died and came back, born again similar to the monsters, since they are allowed to live forever etc
So I wonder IF that's why the voices was telling Sara to kill Ethan... Then she would become a creature... That's why the people have on clothes from different time periods.
no she killed jade's friend the day he and jade came to town and had a car accident, she killed him in the clinic, so that's not enough to become a monster
@@artart5165no budd killing an adult dont make sara a monster she need to kill a child to be a monster just like it mentioned in last episode think about it
Season 3 of From has now concluded! What did you think of the finale? Let me know your thoughts in the comments!
It was great! Gave just enough answers without ruining the mystery. I’m excited to see where they go for season 4!
It was cheap. Sraha and Fatima stories were great and consistent. They had scary, bloody things with sacrifice. The forest magical memory scene was cheap and shit. No visuals, no scary thing. She is just crying and crying. Felt as an after season shooting in a forest to cramp some answers because without that scene, we get some answer and some new mystery, but very little of both. With the forest scene, it felt as a big revolution as the fans wanted, but it was so poorly done I believe it was an aftershoot, and it looks horrible. Honestly, I hate the actress. She is shit and now Jim is dead, we are going to see even more of her, so I am out. Will read a wiki page in a year if I get interested to know more.
Oh and f kids could not have learned 1 word in English after centuries? All the monsters speak perfect English, and those kids were torturing people with their anghkooe for years on, but could not have learned the word "remember"? Bullshit.
Suxed
Definitely the best season💯 Finale was 🔥🔥🔥
I don't think Christopher and Miranda had a child together. She said they were there from the beginning and during that time with Miranda and Christopher. Miranda was already Married and have Eloise and Victor. When she said they were there from the beginning she meant when it all started. when the town was still "normal" before the children sacrifice and I'm guessing it would be during the Witch era which is on the late 1600.
The fact that smiley is now Boyd’s grandson is hilarious
😂😂😂
Omg lmao I didn’t think about that. Like I knew it “wasn’t her baby” but like it was-ish. lol
@@gilbirdsareawesome bruh I seen a theory on this on another channel i think, best one ive seen yet on this topic
Basically the theory is that when Boyd killed smiley, the same way he passed on his DNA/blood to smiley, smiley passed his DNA/blood to boyd without boyd realising, after that Ellis i think had a blood transfusion from boyd, which transfers the smiley dna to ellis, then Ellis has romance with Fatima which passed the DNA to her, after that she's got pregnant with smiley....not my theory like I said so don't credit me 👍
@@gilbirdsareawesome He's more in common with his grandmother tbh. Although I doubt he racked up her body count even in his first incarnation.
@@Gully_Lethalz_165 Holy shit! That actually adds up! Great theory!
Jim died doing what he always loved, not listening to his family
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
😂😂😂😂
I laughed my ass off
Well technically he was on his own because he listened to Tabitha needing alone time. Still laughed though
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 yes!
I want to see Victor's actor nominated (and winning) an Emmy for his work in this season.
same! that would be awesome!
he’s great in comparison to the other actors in from but compared to all other actors in shows, i doubt he will be nominated or win
@@237.zr9 well he better win over anyone in Ryan Murphy's freaking stuff...
I think Jade's acting is as good
Ain't nominating no dumb dumb
Sarah is the True MVP of this Episode
She really is sis said my soul gone I'ma handle it 😭
Taking the eye was magnificent work
She was thanos when you want something done sometimes you have to do it yourself she was cold for that diff the MVP
@ 😂😂😂😂💀💀💀
For real!!!!
The Man in Yellow might have been behind the calls from Thomas but he definitely was the voice on the radio from Season 1 - "your wife shouldn't be digging that hole jim" He said that again to Jim before killing him.
Yeah, I notice this too. I wonder if the reason the man in yellow talks about Jim knowing too much is because he figured out how to use the numbers in the tree
@@Wakka12321 he always used Jim to discourage Tabitha from finding out the secrets. Now that the secrets are out, Jim serves no purpose to the Man in Yellow. It felt like a revenge murder.
I think it's because jims smart and he was finally helping them out solve the puzzles his perspective was a danger to the people who come out at night maybe
@@Wakka12321it’s def because of that
we got Einstein over here
I think Julie is the one to the crack the code. She was able to come to the exact location and time of Jim's death and she could have definitely done things differently to save Jim. Maybe next time she time travels she will be able to make some changes to the future or past which will help the town is some way. The only way they win is to cheat the system which is Julie time travelling.
@@krthe1748 unfortunately it looks that way. I cannot stand her character and was hoping they’d get ride of her this season.
Julie should act like Boy in White, calm and give clear instructions so they would be more likely to follow her
she probably can't change the past as they have already happened like Ethan told,maybe she can affect the future .
I agree. I think she gas to go back to the beginning and stop the children from being sacrificed.
@@BilliEMusics exactly! Why didn't she tell Jim that he was about to die!
I can't get over Jim's death. Goddamn it!
Just when he was really open minded and started listening to Jade and Tabitha so much!
@@Malvenido he will be back for sure or maybe a ghost,but i Don t think he'story Is over.
Makes me think Jim is actually smarter than jade and more vital to the solving the towns puzzles, man in yellow seen Jim as a risk to solving the towns issues so he killed him off
Jim is henry
@@leighann1566 when you see everything he Can be 😀
@natalist8391 just my theory, they have a lot in common
Man, the scene where Victor cried over his mom and sister's grave was so incredibly heartbreaking. The actor did a phenomenal job.
Victor's performance is one of my favorites
He’s the only one who can act on the show damn near…some of the casting is horrific
“She was so small. There wasn’t much left…”
Damn it VICTOR😭
@@andykaufmen tabitah and her "no no no, please" and "fuckin" in every episode are just the worst. You can turn her into a drinkin game if you want.
Him and boyd actors deserve fucking awards for their performances
Elgin is tough lol as soon as I would’ve seen Sarah come in the room and give that speech I would’ve told. 🤣 sarah is a savage
He’s pretty well liked. I’ll lay you 10 to 1 we get Elgin with an eyepatch next season.
😂😂
FACTSS!! 😂 I was thinking the same thing - I'm more afraid of her than the creatures 🤣
Me as soon as I saw Boyd with that bag😭😂
well. he's new. don't think he knows the whole story with Sarah. And he seems like someone who doesn't really believe anyone would cause him physical pain. Even when Boyd smashed his hand I was like "you gonna tell now?"
Elgin big ass being tied up with string was crazy work😂
Wire
Right!😂
He could've gave everybody in that room work all at once😂
Lmaoooo 😂😂😂😂😂
Girl exactly! 😂
Jim had like three business days to run away😂
He probably didn't realize that the guy was one of them. Why would he, as far as he knows they don't come out in daylight
Didn't he saw the scratches on Julie's face 🤔🤔@@penlavits3305
yeah and he was processing what tabitha was saying as well
@@penlavits3305his daughter warned him, but he didn't listen and proceeds to his death 😂
It was day time and that was just some old man as far as he knew. His inability to run when Julie told him to cost him everything.
I have a theory about Eloise. While escaping from the root cellar, she managed to get into the tree and escape to the real world. She sought help from adults, telling them what she had experienced, but no one believed the little girl's words and she was considered mentally ill. When she grew up, she became the author of the book that Ethan read.
@@Toska7241 that sounds interesting
wow good point.
didn't victor say he found her remains?
@ he found “what’s left of her”, could be anyone
Eloise was the best at hiding, thats what Victor said, I think she's alive too
Excellent analysis. However, Miranda and Christopher didn’t have a child together. Tabitha said that her and Jade were original inhabitants of the town before the children were sacrificed. They had a child together wayyyyy back then: in the beginning. However, their child was taken from them and sacrificed, and they tried to stop it from happening, but they failed. They will keep getting resurrected, like the monsters, through reincarnation until they succeed.
I guess he means Miranda and Christopher were part of the resurrection chain thus they technically had a child together many past lives ago.
@@maze9415 I cant believe u summarised his long essay with better comprehension lol than him
@ True!
That was a great explanation..love it 😊
A endless cycle of them trying to save the kids is why fromville exist. Its obvious that the place is fueled by hope so they keep saving these kids that doesnt let the roots get the blood to grow. The story thats told to the kids that gave them hope[in this time cycle] is Ethans Kromncle story. And julie will tell the kids. Those kids are supposed to be sacrifice while having high hopes the blood is what grows the far away trees. Miranda Tabitha jade. In all time cycles saved the kids. The fallen tree in the beginning is a broken faraway tree becuase no blood has been sacrificed. The original people made a choice for immortality. They have that. People keep breaking the rules of the sacrifice and the curse creates the same story over and over. Kill the kids poor their blood on the root. The tree in the beginning will not be broken. Nobody can get into fromville. Only the people who sacrificed their kids will remain there forever. 💯
The creatures , cicada monster, kimono lady and now the man in yellow in the bad side with other bad entities coming in future episodes , and on the "good" side you have the boy in white, and the crusty kids who can barely send a message , how tf are the townsfolk gonna survive 😭🙏🏽
Good sides probaly the great spider too
Writing stupid numbers on papers in bottles, how do they expect people to figure out that that’s a song
@sekoaib Did you see the last episode?
Not the crusty kids.😅
@@sekoaib If jade is the one who made the bottle tree in a pass life, then it makes sense that hed pick some complicated ass cypher. Especially based on music
Elgin losing his eye made me think of the guy jade seen who was missing his eye…. Really looking forward to next season
Wow I forgot about that
@jameltanderson what episode was that in?
@@sorin8560 I don’t remember the number I think maybe 3 they left the town trying to find food because their crops went bad
The man in the yellow appeared because he was angry that Jade and Tabatha remembered.. He said their was a price for knowledge.. What a better price to pay than kill her husband. The boy white is the person who told the kids the story that gave the children hope. The hope that they poured into the roots that made the tree. The man in yellow is the evil entity that Martin referred to. The boy in white referred to him in season 2, that he was angry. Sara said he is laughing at you. One of the town people in season 1 when during the storm said you think he is angry. The town started changing when Jade and Tabatha appeared. I think the town recycles with their deaths. The entity appered to Boyb as Abby. He lied to Boyd when he said it feeds on hope. Hope weakens it. The town people had hope when they built the tower so he destroyed it. I don't think everyone is reincarnated. They are brought there so it can feed off their fear. Tabatha and Christopher were there in the beginning and was given eternal life. Since they didn't partake in sacrifice, their eternal life is different. Its thru reincarnation.
this is a pretty solid theory ngl
I thought the song was going to be the one on the music box Martin was warning Boyd about. Saying he's coming they're running out of time.
Bro playing chess
I think Boyd is also reincarnated
That’s why those things torture him not kill him
Sara said THEY are laughing, not he.
Julie says in this final scene that he should go back to the city, that it is safer. I believe that now in the next season the monsters will walk through the forest during the day, but they will not enter the city at night. This makes it more difficult for them to save the children and also highlights Victor's concern about the trees getting closer.
Makes sense
Can you explain the trees part pls
@@josipzavacki6800 In season 1 Victor told Ethan that the trees where moving outside of colony house
@@noninveni3099 i know but what does that mean
That’s a smart theory, it means that the forest is gonna move closer and closer to the town. And the monsters may be able to walk in the forest during the day, which means the people would be trapped in the town….24/7
I think the new cycle in town began when Tabitha and Jade arrived in the town the same day..Victor had said that two cars arrived on the same day last time when everyone died..it might have been when Miranda and Christopher were in this town. So all these were happening in loops just with different characters.
Also maybe till now the time in this town was not going forward...When Boyd broke that music box in that ruins , somehow he changed the cycle..time started again and that's why it's winter now and the boy in white also grew up.
I'm starting to think the good and bad things along with new knowledge affects the energy of the place. When they start to try new things and learn more it causes the other side to push back. Or something 😂🤣 And Tabitha finding victor and ending back their gave the chance for the biw to grow.
Fun part is that Smiley actor actually has that haunting smile 😅 originally he was planned to only appear as an extra. ( Among monsters, but became fans favorite and git more screen time)
He surely born to play smiley monster..
He should’ve been in that Smile movie!
I’m glad he’s back tbh lol. I know he’s evil but he’s the creepiest of the monsters by far.
i thought they finished the script before they even started filming? are you sure?
The cop could be Smiley's sister! 😮
Smiley's revival kinda ties back to when boyd killed him saying my blood is your blood and now Fatima gave birth to Smiley
😂 more like my grandson is your
I don't think it's like that the monster's were normal humans but they sacrifice their kids to live forever so smiley needed to reborn somehow that's why fatima was just the reason
Thats not how sperm works
@@eternity.in.a.m0m3nt I know how sperm works but in this case even the old man said to Boyd my blood is ur blood he's not Boyd father or family
Now Boyd is related to Smiley. That’s his grandson
Season 3 gave Fatima way too much screen time. A lot of back and forth with characters and many episodes were a drag. Especially 3-8. First 2 and last 2 were the only decent ones.
Exactly how I feel, this whole thing could’ve happened in two episodes
I totally agree you! Especially about Fatima
I literally slept through 80% of the season. They are gonna make this show in 9 Seasons when its 90% random bullshit that no one are gonna even remember and 10% decent story, exactly like Lost was.
@@hpttm749100%. I skipped so much of S3. What snoozefest full of filler scenes. At this rate we need like 10 seasons and I'm probably going to check out before it's done.
The whole show after watchin it this far just annoyed me. Too many holes in the story line not making sense. Poorly written honestly
Dude in the yellow jacket was actually the guy who spoke to Jim over the phone when the built the radio tower. If you recall if mentioned “your wife should have never dug that hole” the same thing he said over the phone.
He must be behind the Thomas phonecalls & the dinner radios.
They found out that's where the kids where sacrificed and Julie knowing about it puts the monsters in danger. Also where they sleep.
The man in yellow is probably the one who told them they can gain immortality that way.
No way really??1!?
Surprised people didn't realise that straight away lmao
@@verity_amo yeah, it was obious that yellow one is the one behind idk how people still dont believe that, but who is he... is he a monster or a human, ahhh so many questions
Sara said i got this Boyd, this is light work for me lol
@@peanut0187 Sara is definitely top five characters in this show.
She said 'hold my beer bruh' 😂😂😂😂❤
Sarah is in my top 3!
Here's a thought. The show considers Julie a 'Storywalker.' When Victor remembered The Boy in White talking to Christopher, Victor said that "...and then they were murdered in the dark. But someone who loved them told them a story. This story gave them hope. And when the children laid on the stones, they poured their hopes into the roots the roots that made the symbol and those roots became the tree." Maybe that person who loved them was Tabitha or Jade, and the story that they told the children is somehow related to what is happening to the town.
Another thing that seems very likely moving into S4 is that Tabitha rekindles her connection with Viktor, and maybe even remembers what ended up happening to his sister, assuming she is still alive.
Randall also seems to know about this place, with insights like "Dying isn't the worst thing that can happen to you here..." certainly feels like he is the reincarnation of Martin. Being chained up like that in wherever he is for however long he has been there certainly seems like a fate worse than death.
randall being a reincarnation of Martin seems like a stretch. Surely he was already alive before Martin died, he's a grown man.
@@ajbased44 I also suspect Martin was as real as Abby
No, I think it could be possible that Randall is the reincarnation Martin. Since the place were Martin was seemed to be connected to past. If you remember when Julie ended up in the dungeon she saved Boyde from the well and she said she heard the voice of her mom from when she was trapped under the house. Perhaps Martin was alive a long time ago before the place was in ruines, and after passing on the curse, he was able to die and reincarnate. They probably left him there to torture him for attempting to save the kids.
And perhaps that’s why Randall keeps saying” dying is the worst thing that can happen to you here”
I was thinking the same that Randall and Martin are connected 🤔 he recognised Julie and called her by name so there has to be more to it
Tabitha’s dream makes sense now, that was probably a memory of one of her past lives.
I think that was her and Jade daughter getting snatched up'd to be honest...
@ that’s a good theory too!
@@SereneDivine23 is the anghooeey kid her daughter?
@tegathemenace Yes. One of them is Tabitha and Jade's daughter. They were not able to save her from being sacrificed in their past lives. You can reference the last episode when Tabitha explains this to Jim. ***
@@freelanxeI say that because I kept wondering why did the dream play out in 3rd person 🤔 Normally in dreams you would experience it through your own eyes 👀 If she was the little girl running, she would have looked up and what ever took her would have been shown. Instead the dream was like perspective of watching. These are just my thoughts though lol
Elgin is such an idiot it’s dangerous. They already KNOW that the town isn’t trying to help them.
Now he's a one eyed idiot
@@BrainPilot😂😂😂😂😂
@@BrainPilot🤣
I means the first time had a dream it warned him to tell the bus to turn around the second time helped save 3 people. Can really fault him for believing in it a 3rd time
now his a one eyed pirate
Jade: we used to sing them lullabies
Tabitha: I know why. I know why I see those children. Why Jade can see them. That’s why there’s more than one bracelet - I kept making them. Somewhere, deep down, I remember. It’s because we’ve been here before - me and Jade. The reason I felt what Miranda felt is because I was miranda and Jade was Christopher. We’ve come back over and over again because we failed the first time. Jade and I were here in the beginning. We tried to save those children and set them free because one of them was ours. She was our daughter.
The first iterations of Jade and Miranda are reincarnated but in a different way than the creatures.
@@aleesac5414 One of the children was theirs, so they obviously didn't agree with sacrificing them and were probably killed. They never went through with the deal, so they weren't made immortal, like the rest. I think next season we'll see who exactly they were and how they died. They were the ones who read the story to the children that gave them hope.
this scene was goosebumps apart from the smiley reincarnation
I have a hunch that Jim’s death might not be permanent and that Julie will somehow find a way to save him. While that could make for an interesting twist, it might not be the best direction for the story. If deaths can be undone through time travel, it risks undermining the tension and diminishing the Big Bad’s overwhelming power and sense of danger. Jim’s death is a powerful moment that reinforces just how terrifying and unstoppable the Big Bad truly is.
This idiot Jim should never be saved. He is just a burden to the whole town.
@@the__lone__thinker I really liked him in season 1, but he became somewhat irrelevant after that. It’s a shame because the actor was great, and his role as an engineer added an interesting layer to his character. They could have done so much more with that after the whole radio tower storyline, but unfortunately, they didn’t.
@@the__lone__thinker He was the one who figured out the numbers.
Yeah Julie's gonna try to change a canon event, and from the hair, she's tried several times. Are Randall and Marielle story walkers too? Worms(lava) matures to insects (cicada) 🤔
What would be crazy is if jim is the man in yellow who was created out of hate. He kills every version of himself. He wants to be the only version. He didnt want his wife looking for answers like digging that hole. He probably doesn't like the fact tabitha and jada had a kid in another life. And now he just hates everything except his kids which is why he doesn't kill julie who tries to save every version of jim or the boy in white who probably represents ethan. It would be a cool twist. Then again i think jim is the reincarnation of Henry so idk lol
8:35 There is absolutely zero doubt that Tabitha and Jade’s story goes back much farther than Miranda and Christopher.. After remembering their past lives, Tabitha said to Jim “We’ve come back over and over again because we failed the first time.” So, yeah….. that question is answered! 😎
i knew all that Jade and tabitha time was suspicious, you could smell the chemistry, the actor and actress did a great job hinting something more
Same, had me thinking they were gonna have an affair or something lol
Especially when Jim tried to check him, and he responded with "she's a grown-up"
2026 is loooong. Hope the monsters don’t find me before then…
Hold up 2026?! WTF
shiit I hope the apocalypse hasn't started yet...
im satisfied tbh, i can die now knowing whats actually happening in the town.
@@itwasntme300we still don’t actually know lol
@@itwasntme300 only thing I figured out is that there is time travel now .
Boyd should have just let go elgen and follow him at a distance to the root seller that would have been easy
No, maybe the creature might have stop him.
@@Pinprick_of_joythe creature could have warned Elgin or who knows what, we don’t know all the powers it has. I think it’s solid plot.
Or let sarah do the job the forst time he thought of torture was quicker lol
Bro I was saying this. Should have just let him go
My thoughts exactly…
In a single episode happened more than the entirety of 2 seasons, thankfully.
Jim dying pretty much alone was frustrating, that was clearly Julie from the future, so no one is going to know he’s been dead and everyone is running around right now with all the new information. It’s heartbreaking, I hated his character but he was fun to watch still in the first two seasons being a father just grasping at straws to save his family. I hope they give Jim some sort of happy ending cuz man did not deserve that.
right he didn't deserve that at all!! smh ruined my day!!
Tabitha: "Tell me you figured it out."
Jim: "Oh I did and the answer is 12."
S1e5
Julie came from the future to stop his death because she knew he was dead so obviously they found out he died. I'm sure once he didn't come back to town by dark they were worried and wondering where he was. They probably went looking for him the next morning. He died where he was when they left him so they would have known where to look too.
@@jackashmore I liked Jim, I would’ve been very sceptical of people visions and shit too, I would’ve thought people were going crazy
Miranda and Christopher didn't have a child together, their past selves did. They didn't reincarnate once, they have reincarnated many times. Their first incarnations were more than likely 150+ years prior and that's most likely when they had the child together. Miranda and Christopher were just the previous iterations of Tabitha and Jade, there were MANY more before them, going all the way back to the originals where this all started. They've been arriving in From and failing to save the children each time since, starting the reincarnation of themselves again.
Do u think they lived in the settlement village? Remember Tabitha dreamt of it as a child. That village is tied to everything but we don't know how yet. I agree, I think they've reincarnated many times even before they lived in town with the children.
@@danielleschiazza6172 i think that they were at settlement villlage, maybe tabitha and jade's first version didnt accepted the ritual, so they didnt became monsters but as their child was taken so they are reincarnated every time.
I can't be the only one who felt really bad for Elgin lol. He only had good intentions, just like Sara. The town manipulated him in the same way it's manipulated everyone else. I think people are being too harsh toward him, he just wanted to do the right thing
Yeah torturing him was not necessary I bet that if they explained it to him properly he would have listend. Or they could go to fatima all together. Acosta did something good for the first time, also boyd is a hypocriet
@@LalaLala-jz4td ya it’s easy to say that as an outside observer, but put yourself in their shoes, times running out, and his stalling still led to ritual summoning happening. If they had been earlier maybe it might’ve changed things, but somehow it feels like they were always going to be late regardless of the method they used to get Elgin to talk.
Imagine the intensity of the next town meeting if that happens.... with Boyd talking about the smiley , tabitha and jade revealing what they found....but I think that will take may be 1 to 3 episodes.. cause of Jim's death!
acosta is gonna expose everything and get boyd ran outta town
They will have no meeting discussing anything.
@@beewest5704this is my biggest gripe with the show. It seems so many characters know things but no one is willing to come together to share what they have learned with everyone else bc others might think they are “crazy”. Also why was Victor right outside of the room where Fatima was? But just standing there?
Sarah and Boyd torturing "poor" Elgin is going to be a very distracting thing.
@@ma.2099 right which is dumb considering they're main goal is to escape lol. It annoys the crap outta me
It kinda feels like the town is in the grips of two vampiric forces, one feeds off their hope, one feeds off their fear, and both sides are unwilling to release them.
I agree. There is more than one "being" controlling things. I also think there was more than one event. The thing with the children is one event but what about the settlement village? That village is a lot older than the town. Something horrible happened there too. Tabitha dreamt about it.
@@danielleschiazza6172thats probably where the children where sacrificed. On the Rocks which are stained red by theire blood
The good thing with this series is that they kept it under super natural realm with a mix of time travel and time loop and not the concept of time overpowering the supernatural element , because when jim thought that some one is behind all this i thought we are going to see that some people are behind this all and the show would not have been that much fun then.
Being made to guess every week is the point! It's a slow burn, it's cerebral, it's thrilling, I'm so glad they got renewed
Fr , this is a show where the mystery is the hook , once that mysteries gone no one cares anymore
@@hotcoko6 no I hate that I just want to see the whole thing already
This finale was fantastic! The last 5 episodes were really rough in dragging the story, but this was awesome! Excited for season 4.
@@ScottUhlMusic how was it fantastic? We’re still stuck with all the useless characters.
I have a feeling they will do a time jump and we will spend the whole season just to get back to what happened at the end here.
It was stupid and boring asf and explained nothing except victor's story..more questions rather than any answers lol
I’m thinking perhaps it’s the song that allowed the monster to be in that area during the day. Perhaps that’s what happened when victor was a kid. Someone found out about the music, but played it in town instead of taking the same precautions, so they were allowed to roam through an unsuspecting town during the day and that’s how almost everyone was slaughtered.
The episode when Boyd gives smiley the worms and says "My Blood Is Your Blood" (mf wasn't joking, now thats his grandson) but thats the same episode Fatima became pregnant or at least believes shes naturally pregnant.
Elgin is big dummy
Has no one told him to not mess with crazy people.....
GOD DAMN SARA AIN'T FUCKING AROUND 😉
But Sarah was once just as dumb or worse because she murdered people
Not how sperm works gynecologist
@eternity.in.a.m0m3nt
OMG you're right! I forgot this show makes nothing but complete sense.
Thanks Poindexter! 😊
(The user listed above made a dumbass comment, I cooked him with my reply and so he eventually deleted his comment)
His comment said
"Sperm doesn't work like that gynecologist"
How did I not think of this 😂 that's hilarious. technically he's his grandchild now.
@@AxelBee9😂😂😂 dude really thinks logic applies in a show that has talismans, monsters and is set in a different dimension.
Bet money when Tabitha got the phone call for her to get distracted to drop Thomas, that call was from the future in fromville
Bro don’t spoil season 5 before season 4
Oh my god.
I had never considered that
@@CallMeConConbro thinking in 5D
The directors are asking you to delete your comment
Finally some answers. Was gonna give up on this show after this season but that finale will have me coming back for more, for sure.
The next release will be in 2026. It's not even 2025. I'm done.
freaking hell
Yup! It sucks! 14 months between season 1 and season 2. 17 months between season 2 and season 3! How long between 3 and 4? It's ridiculous.
@@danielleschiazza6172 it is a quality show, so it takes time, but yeah it sucks
@@danielleschiazza6172
Like gta 6
It's because we got some answers so now we pay the price of waiting LOL
Last week I said I doubted if we were gonna get any answers besides Fatima's baby in the finale. I've never never been so happy to be wrong in my life!
Spot on theory’s here.
I def agree how annoying it is that they don’t share their issues with each other.
Spoiler Alert for Season 4 & onwards
- Season will change to Spring
- Man in yellow is the puppet master/architect
- Randall is the reincarnation of Martin
- Great massacre reset
- Ethan is the author
How did you know
When is s4
@@Diddyparty_6 2026
How do you know that
Cap
Julie can definitely impact events when she travels back. Like this video showed she dropped the rope down to Boyd when he was trapped. I am sure it will take her a couple tries before she learns how to change things when she travels back
very insightful, trully she helped boyd with the rope, even without knowing what she was doing or the part she was playing, so when she eventually gets a hand of it, it will be crazy
Yes! I think she has to be the one to travel back to the beginning and stop the children from being sacrificed.
She didnt change the story by dropping the rope to Boyd .She was always gonna drop the rope to Boyd.If she didnt drop the rope to Boyd that would be a change in the story. 13:37
Dont be confused with the illusion of choice and free will with predestination.
Ethan explained that she cant change the story. It would be a paradox: something that has al ready happened cant be changed.
Too many theories have been open until now, which has made this show outstanding. This show should have at least 5-6 seasons.
That would be a good amount of seasons for it for sure!
Smiley wasn’t reborn because of their child sacrifice. Boyd touched him with an open wound then gave Ellis the blood transfusion which infected Ellis who then “impregnated” Fatima. So smiley is basically Boyd’s grandson 😂
Holy shit you’re right,damn that’s *F* upppp! I freaking love this show,pity we have to wait 2 more years 🥹..that’s a long wait
Woooww. That’s attention to detail
fatima was already pregnant before lol
How does this theory explain what the Angel was doing? This whole horror pregnancy was the Angel's planning (somehow) Fatima's pregnancy gave everyone hope and this place feeds on hope
@@balthazarina She was Probably the main entity's servant. Since he promised the creatures to be Immortal.
"Knowledge comes with a price" was said for Jim as he got the knowledge of the notes!!! And then was murdered!!!
I think Jim had a lot of knowledge about the place.
"I figured it out. And the answers 12."
Lol Julie also had a shirt with illusion on it and another with 12 in a circle with other numbers.
I didn’t know this was the season finale! I wasn’t prepared for it. Oh gosh, now I have to wait for the new season! I definitely felt the intensity of this episode after coming back from multiple episodes that were a little slow..
Julie probably mess up timeline by trying to fix something. She will probably be main character in s4 because she will try to save her dad by fixing timeline. Sarah got +3000 aura in this episode😂😂
EDIT: Thanks for 117 liks 🥳🥳
Lol the Sarah part is so true
@@DanieB322 she and Boyd are only two persons who doesn't care if they hands get dirty
@ They are my favs ! Hate Acosta , Randall is trouble, Ellis is so useless like he could die and no one would care if it wasn’t for Boyd, Julie is not too far but I feel like she will become more interesting next season, Mariel is sus and useless as well - for now. Love Donna also, Fatima as well but like season 1 Fatima
@@DanieB322 So true
But still she failed in trying to save Jim. We will see that in later seasons that she will attempt to change the past, but the end of S3 shows us she won’t be able to succeed
the budget for the costumes are so low Julies wig in the scene with Jim looks insane
i hope if elgin will be alive in season 4 he finally get to change his clothes
@motre4839 😂😂😂 they are stuck in time and space, there is no clothes shop nearby
They have a storage unit under the diner with clothes from former fromsville residents! They just chose not to bathe or change 😂@@mucmac3586
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@mucmac3586season 1 they showed Fatima lining up clothes at the house in the backyard. I knew they wouldn’t show it more often after that. Lmao. I just found out recently that the writers are from the show lost. Omg we gonna be here for a while!!😂
Overall Season 3 was 90% venting 10% story
I have a theory...those children were sacrificed and Miranda & Christopher don't want to give their daughter but someone took from them. But we get to know that once your children are sacrificed those people can't die so as a punishment the people who murdered their children knowingly become monsters because they committed a sin but since Miranda & Christopher refused they are chosed by the childeren as a pure soul and they'll be reincarnated again and again until both of they free all the children souls
But it is really a hell, reincarnating to face your greatest failure over and over again, with new innocent people in the mix, and getting killed and overcome by the monsters who started all of this from the beginning.
I think Julie's going to be the one to save the children.
@@gottod6895 yes it's kinda a loop hole they stuck in and till now they don't even know who is behind all this
@@Interdacted I doubt
They were the ones that the boy in white had said loved the children and read them a story that gave them hope which created the roots and the bottle trees. One of the children was their daughter and they didn't want to sacrifice them but I believe the others killed them and sacrificed their daughter anyway, along with the other children. So they were reincarnated as Miranda and Christopher and died again and then reincarnated again as Tabitha and Jade. In the beginning they were actually a couple who shared a daughter. I honestly believe they were reincarnated more than that. I think they've been around a lot longer. Remember Tabitha had a dream about the settlement village as a child and she hid behind the red rocks because something horrible happened. That village is an older settlement than the town though. The man Jade saw there, that was drinking blood from a skull appeared to be dressed in clothes from the 1700's or so. I believe this entity has offered deals to more people than just the monsters. Obviously that man drinking blood from a human skull was doing some kind of occult ritual. There is a lot more to this than we think.
I'm afraid the actor playing Smiley has been typecast. He's just too perfect for this.
I believe that they are all stuck in a loop, because remember when Boyd was stuck in a well, Julie was the one that threw him the rope. At the end of Season 3, she runs on screen with short black hair and scratches on her face.
yep no one notices the hair difference
I predicted that the baby that was growing was smiley. Fatima got pregnant after smiley died. and we can deduce that the baby inside fatima has a similar diet that the monsters have. When smiley died in the first place, the other monsters didn't seem to care at all, which implies that they knew he will be reborn.
They got that ability by sacrificing the anghkooey kids.
I find that hard to believe since nearly everyone heard about this spoiler week's ago🤷🏾♂️ but if u did figure it out yourself then fair enough 👍
Fatima was pregnant before smiley died
@@Gully_Lethalz_165yeah this one 100% read spoilers.
The birth scene messed me up lol
@@fribourgjean8922 nah. i'll see the episodes again to verify. I could be wrong.
That was a wild wild wild finale. Had to watch twice to understand everything going on.
What if Michael is just still stuck on the island?
Sarah went from the bottom to the top in 10 seconds. From the most hated to the most loved
Yeah she did a full 180!
I am wondering if Eloise is also a “story walker” and is trying to participate in the resolution but in a less direct method than Julie is taking. Like maybe she is the one who moved Boyd and Sara’s tent or moving Jasper in the caves. And maybe she is stuck just moving through the timelines which is why she has never found (even if Victor is willing to believe that random body parts belonged to her). I am thinking that she will show herself to Julie at some point and maybe they will work together to drive the resolution of the story.
so interesting my mom had the same theory. either way she’s definitely still alive. otherwise they wouldn’t keep dancing around the topic so much 😭
I think it would make sense for the children of Tabatha/Miranda to be „similair“. So Eloise and Judith both being storywalker just like Victor and Ethan are more like „storyteller“…
Poor Elgin, he didnt know
nah bro dragged a pregnant woman and trapped her in a room idc what voice tells me to do that im saying no. also if he didnt tell she wouldve died prob and then whta hes just a part of th e community again? you kidnap my wife like that i dont care what your intentions were ur getting sarah'd to the eye on sight
I loved it and I kinda dug Sara goin gangster (still kinda terrifying at the same time)
Yeah she went rogue! Different vibe for sure
Aye yo, I thought to myself Sara ain’t play with him.
@@_michaelfaith ikr! She almost looked possessed when she went into the room
@@hadashaphelps822 i really like when directors keep the killer in tv show and use them to things like this very creative i really like sarah in this show
I too @@commisionerq1374
I'm glad they brought Smiley back, he was my favorite monster
😂😂
He was my favorite out of the monsters but F!@# him 😂😂
So the monsters were all human way back in the past and Julie can time travel? -Remember way back when one of the monsters recognised Julie?
All the theories i read came true 😭😭 how are ya’ll so smart
Most of us was seeing spoilers/leaks for the past few weeks so😒...
Leaks
They're not all geniuses, they saw spoilers lol
@@Alicia_1970 oh ok i didnt know about the leaks cos im new to the fandom, i binge watched 3 seasons this month 😅
Where's that spoiler that said the ending scene was Eloise, Miranda, and Victor in a car together?🤣 and that Jade would take the talisman and the monsters would kill a lot of townfolks?🤣
julie was screaming GO BACK TO THE TOWN
maybe the man in yellow cant travel in the town freely and in exchange he can walk in daylight
@solarium4884 exactly what i was thinking
The talismans probably still work even if he’s out during the day
@@LED816 he'll have to see
Perhaps since now that they know the truth about where the monsters came from, they’re gonna be forced to leave town and that’s why this new guy showed up? And what is Jim‘s problem with taking advice ? When somebody tells him to run, he does the complete opposite.
@@solarium4884 what monsters are in the forest?? The only ones we see in the forest are the ones who come out at night because they come from the cave/tunnels, through the woods and into town. There are others things in the woods that are apparently more terrifying than the monsters according to what the voices told Sara and Kenny and Jim heard something walking around at night in the settlement village but we never see what is out there. I think maybe the thing kenny and Jim heard was the man in yellow.
Man Jim was my favourite character...from the very first episode he was the most relatable character 😢😢
I think the man in yellow only showed up because jim needed to go, it's like normally everything is fine letting the monsters handle things but jim is going to mess things up even further so he had to go, i think since he started supporting Tabitha and giving her the courage to solve the mystery he was going to encourage her to do more and the man in yellow can't have them leaving so he broke the non interfere rule so he could keep the story going because he's never interfered before even though he always could. Someone mentioned a long time ago this is a game between a good entity and a bad entity, the boy in white must be the good entity and the guy in yellow must be the bad one and the man in yellow has been winning this whole time but jim must cause him to lose so he had to step in just like the boy in white tried to help before but he stopped because he was probably giving away too much help😊
Everyone online keeps saying that the Settler and the Civil War soldier with the missing eye must be an earlier incarnation of Jade. But it's an earlier incarnation of Elgin--who got his eye freakin' cut out (again!) in this episode. This is *his* (whoever "he" is) cycle being re-run, not Jade's.
good catch
100%
It’s Boyd , Elgin is also Boyd , soldier is Boyd too
@@adrianaonly3151Elgin isn’t Boyd lol we saw his eye get taken out
Great point hahaha 😅😂
lesson learned: when someone tells you to run..just run and dont ask questions
so martin recognized julie when she traveled to the room they were all chained up in because she’ll prolly try to time travel to save everyone and run into Martin along the way. will be cool to see his story
I remember when Boyd was stuck in that chimney thing and Martin helped him and i was wondering how Martin was able to throw the rope to Boyd when he was chained to the wall. Julie was there that time too, she just doesn't remember.
Can't wait for season 4 to come out so we can watch another 10 episodes without any answers and knowing just as much after 40 episodes as we did after watching the very first episode :)
Absolutely…they tread over same ground endlessly …the casting tells me I should have no faith in these show runners.
The creatures that come at night do not run , they walk to hunt but in case of victor's mother the smiley one ran to hunt her
Kenny: "The monsters always walk they never run."
Season 1 episode 2.
Kind of feel like time isn't set and maybe Smiley being born from Fatima changed him somehow. Also when Boyd killed him they didn't seem upset. Like it was suppose to happen. Idk this show is wild I love it.
Best show I’ve seen in ages. Up there with Lost, Dark, Breaking Bad. Brilliant mystery box concept. 2026 is a long wait…..
Dark? No. Surely not!
How dare you put it with Dark!
DARK IS FKNG TOP 1 BY FAR
Wait… 2026?!? Noooooooo
@@UK_Vlogs_IN everyone liking dark, yall read the whole series? id find it hard to pay attention to a show if u have to read the whole thing.
@@jamielynn3603Jamie lynn has just admitted she has never read a book
Miranda and Christopher didn't have a child. Their first incarnations had.
YES
That's what they're remembering
The boy in white
No they had a daughter. It's not the boy in white.
@@PsychoMantis308they had a daughter.
I honestly do not understand the praise for this finale. It took literally the season finale to half ass answer 2 things... 1) some of them are reincarnated again to save the children. 2) the night monsters can be reborn.
So wtf are they supposed to "remember" to save the children? Since they know how night monsters are reborn, they know to prevent it.
And who tf is the kimono lady? They never clarified this. Now they add another antagonist (the man in the yellow jacket), adding more questions. Im done with this show. Horrible writing. Literally waited until season finale to mouth feed you half assed answers. Peace out From, it has been... slow and boring lol.
word bro word
that happens when you’re impatient and literally have no comprehension skills. Your questions about the finale don’t even make any sense. It’s a mystery show bro, it’s not the end of the series, but you expect them to write out all the answers? Of course they are mouthfeeding us. What’s the point in telling us now who kimono lady is? How would they know? The people in the town don‘t know wtf is going and we as viewers don‘t know wtf is going on as well, that’s literally the point. But there have been a lot of clues and they are starting to figure things out now. And they didn’t just randomly throw in a new random villain. They alluded to the man in yellow a while back (radio voice, paintings of Miranda). If you need everything spelled out to you for you to understand, then the show is just not for you.
Knowledge comes at a cost. They haven't paid enough? That was unwarranted.
He was talking directly to Julie.
"I figured it out and the answers 12."s1e5 Bud low key knew a lot of info
The man is the yellow jacket warned Jim not to let Tabitha dig the whole at the end of season 2. He was the voice on the radio
Season 1
Whole ❌ Hole ✅
Is hole 1nd is the end of season 1 not s2 s2 is tabitha in hospital
Also by hole it could mean thw subconsious digging deep to find the memories
What's with the hole?
I ain’t gonna lie Jim picking up that stick like he actually bout to kill him is crazy 😂
What made me happy with this episode is that they finally start to answer stuff instead of asking more. Making Fatima say "it promised they'd live forever" was an awesome movie. We now already know what happened, who did what and why they did it. No more questions were made, just the ones that still need answers:
1 - Who's Martin?
2 - What are those worms Boyd carried after meeting Martin?
3 - Why there's electricity there and where does it come from?
4 - Who is the Boy in White really?
5 - Does Boyd has a role in all this reincarnation stuff?
6 - Does everybody that gets there had been there before? Or just some people?
7 - What's the deal with Julie "time traveling"?
8 - What the hell is happening with Marielle and Randall and why they are so hopeless?
9 - What's the ultimate motivation of the "big bad" that promised the people immortality?
Those were the ones I could remember without thinking much. VERY good that they didn't create even more stuff to be answered.
Also, who or what moved Boyd and Sarah while they were in that tent in the Season 1 Finale🤔
Also what was that bright light they saw that caused the forest to look like it was covered with spider webs when they got out?🤔
Martin might be Randal in one of the possible realities as he recognises Julie plus there are 2 more sceletons)) electricity is somehow explained with dr mabuse (the background story of the character). Julie’s also a time traveler because in episode 102 there was a monster who recognised her
Think that was the lighthouse @@thisisrandomlol4784
The boy in white is the man in yellow from the future.
In the pictures taken they seem similar.
This season was full of conversations and consolation but this ending was amazing ❤.
Yeah it was one of the best episodes of the season for sure!
the most explanatory finale ever, just people telling what happened, flashbacks and memories should be show no told
Yea. But I feel like we were shown a lot all season. And now we are told exactly what everything means.
Now this is what I was talking about .. this was the high stakes I’ve been looking for all season … best episode by far and I hope they don’t do the same thing they did this season with next season
The bloody civil war guy that Jade saw was missing an eye so I'm thinking that it could have been Elgin seeing as though he's missing an eye now & was collecting blood for Fatima
Season 4 Ep 1: The town is in chaos. Boyd is coming to pieces. Elgin has a patch. Acosta is the new sheriff. Jim is found with his throat ripped out. Jade and Miranda get awkward. The monsters plan on celebrating that night with the return of smiley and Jade remarks that Anghkooey is the most ridiculous word for remember.
What future Julie does she has always already done. We are just witnessing her doing it this time.
This all sounds very possible.
New sheriff would be Kenny. That was terrible analysis.
@@BLOCKchainGANGgang I do have to agree it makes more sense that Kenny would be sheriff, not Acosta
Acosta is getting on my damn nerves! She just got there and she thinks she runs shit! She refuses to take that uniform off! She WAS a cop. She isn't anymore. If anyone takes over it is going to be kenny. Acosta still hasn't gotten it through her head! She still doesn't understand that things in that town are not like they are in the real world. She is treating everything like it is!
@@maze9415 I’ll drop the series if acosta becomes the sheriff
If she can't change the past how was she able to give Boyd the rope
Probably she was ment always to give the rope
It was meant to happen, she can't change anything
Julie can change things. Just because Ethan said that's not how it works doesn't mean its true.
But its probably loop, you think you are changing things but acctualy you from the future already did that
Because it's a time loop. Only one timeline exists so when you "change the past" you're not actually changing the past because the past is already predetermined in this series.
It's nice to hear from multiple other videos i'm not the only one who thought this season was very heavy with dialog and introducing NEW elements, NEW Town and people mechanics and even more secrets compared to little to no answers like the ratio of new stuff on the board compared to answers given its 10:1
I don’t think Miranda and Christopher had a baby. Tabitha said her and jade were the first ones in Fromville so that means it was even bore Miranda got there as a previous reincarnation. That’s why she said they kept coming back. Great video like always bro
Interesting! Maybe almost like an Adam and Eve thing. Glad you enjoyed the vid man!
@@BrainPilotexactly...
@@Sheed96 right... Jade and tabhitha were a couple in their past life. They didn't sacrificed their child for immortality but they died and in order to save their kid they keep Reincarnating.
In a way if u think about it tabby and jade are also immortal, cos they die but get reincarnated after, so there immortal too🤷🏾♂️kinda 😅
@@BrainPilotMiranda and Christopher definitely didn’t have a daughter together (that literally wouldn’t have made sense). It was an earlier version that were around when the other kids got sacrificed, including their daughter. That’s also why there are 3 bracelets. The bracelet Tabitha finds in the diner was the one made by her for Jade, in their original incarnation. We know there is one that Tabitha made for Jim when Julie was born and then there’s the bracelet in Henry’s car that Miranda made for him (that Tabitha found which caused her to freak out in the car).
Besides that little error, your video was great and I really enjoyed it!
It’s crazy how many of the parents were actually evil enough to sacrifice their children like that. It’s like the town knew how to draw those specific kind of people to it. Ooh I’m so excited for season 4! Don’t know how I’m gonna last so long! 😂
Miranda and Christofer didn’t have a baby together. Original Tabitha and Jade from the same era when the kids were sacrificed had a child and that child was one of the sacrificed kids.
Came here to say this. 👍
The first incarnation had a baby together, miranda Christopher, jade and Tabitha all are their reincarnations
NGL they should've put Smiley in the Smile movies, cuz his smile is really unsettling 😂😂😂😂😂😂❤
FRRRRR
I felt bad for elgin honestly.
When smiley was reborn, just before he broke out of the sack, he looked exactly like the cave painting in red.... Thoughts?
@@Dark_Daze don’t remember the cave painting but now that you mention it the sack looked like those red rocks that Tabatha remembered
After reading so many fan theories I came to the point, it's just a show do not get attached to much in these. Whatever will happen it will happen . FROM best series fr deserves appreciation on big stage.
Que sara. From intro
I have a theory that Jim will come back because It will add an Interesting layer to the story even further, with him being the only one who died and came back, born again similar to the monsters, since they are allowed to live forever etc
So I wonder IF that's why the voices was telling Sara to kill Ethan... Then she would become a creature... That's why the people have on clothes from different time periods.
no she killed jade's friend the day he and jade came to town and had a car accident, she killed him in the clinic, so that's not enough to become a monster
@artart5165 They told her to do that cause they were working her up to killing a child.. .
@@artart5165no budd killing an adult dont make sara a monster she need to kill a child to be a monster just like it mentioned in last episode think about it