Well victor would never be sitting there cause he’s not stupid enough to do something like that . And Jim’s son is not strong enough to lock Fatima in a basement. I see where ur going but your argument is not valid. Let’s look at everyone who has been swayed by monsters Boyd’s wife what happened . Boyd had to kill her because she wouldn’t listen . Sara is lucky to be alive she killed 4 people because of the monsters only reason she is alive is because of father khatri thinking she held important information . Now let’s look at Elgin he’s a “new guy” in town who has kidnapped a member of “froms” family who is one of the sweetest people in the town . By listening to an evil monster . Now in my mind I don’t know you well but if someone kidnapped your let’s say “sister” or “mom” and time was running out for them in this scenario. What would you do? Believe Elgin after knowing what happens anytime someone listens to a monster or try to get the information to where she is as fast as possible. They didn’t go straight to Torture they gave Elgin an opportunity to tell them. They even brought Sara to tell him her experiences. In my opinion Sara is one of the most strong willed characters considering as of now she is the only one to ever get out of the monsters grasp. Does Sara deserve to die No. does Elgin No. did Boyd’s wife No. but once people start listening to the monsters you have to do drastic things. What Elgin did to Fatima is almost worst then death . The torture that Fatima went through in that cellar giving birth to a monster because of elgins actions . She will never be the same. For all we know she could’ve died in there.
I love how you completely ignored the fact that Fatima killed Tillie in the influence of those creatures. You're just thinking about it from Boyd's perspective. What about Elgin? Remember the guy in the first episode who had to sit in that sack because he left his family alone for one night? Boyd's and his family sense of justice is as fragile as it gets. They are no better than the thing they stand against. Sara is pure evil. The only sensible characters is the show are Jade,Victor,Kenny,Ethan and Kristi. @@babybleach
Elgin was literally going to the root celler with supplies for fathima. Boyd and others could have followed him without alerting him and could have avoided so many things.
They're just showing how far a person can go and break. It was all set up to break boyd he's worst enemy now being reborn through his daughter in law !? That's crazy and if you think about it I believe just like Tabitha and jade Boyd has some past connections. I used to think Donna has some connections too but not anymore. But somethings are definitely connected with boyd !
Actually the Lady would've warned Eljin if they followed him...since Fatima did not start giving birth the moment they caught Elgin going down the stairs..
So its why 2 cars entering the city on the same day were important back in season 1, because its will be always Tabitha and jade souls entering the City on the same day again...
one thing i really appreciated about this season is that characters are actually sharing their findings with one another (even when they try to hide something they usually get found out within the next episode, with a handful of exceptions). it was starting to get REALLY tiring that no one was ever on the same page. i wanted to clap at all the scenes where a character just goes "hey check this out" to someone else
the ending when Julie appeared running clearly as not the current version of her (diff hair & clothes) was probably the scariest moment of the whole show to me bc it felt like something really bad was going to happen
Exactly it gave us the feeling that something important was going to happen especially after Ethan told julie that she could go back to chapters of the story that already happened over all this season finale had a nice touch to it👏🏾
Yes that was Julie story walking So many people didnt get it, her hair was shorter,she was older and kept speaking riddles! But what is most interesting is what the yellow man said about the hole tabitha dug Why is he so concerned?
Jade was being selfish by not talking with anyone. The moment he talks with Tabitha, Tabitha give an answer. The moment he talked with Jim about the numbers, Jim gave the answer.
Remember when Kenny said something like, “we might not make it out of here, but the people that came next might be able too because of us” that absolutely has to mean something
Now it makes sense in season 1 when the monster told Julie “you don’t remember me?” when they were running to Donna’s big house. Pretty wild how they dropped that hint in season 1 episode 2. She definitely time travels and probably ran into the monsters when they were regular human beings.
Or as they were monsters. Remember they just told Victor if he keeps coming down they are going to make him stay so these monsters aren’t without thought
@@taylor6109 i think the monsters have their own thoughts and autonomy to a certain point that doesn't go against the evil entity's plans (the thing that talks to people in the town). They can do whatever they want but still has to follow rules the evil entity gives them like not killing certain town members or allowed to run when attacking town people cuz they have no chance if monsters were allowed to run lol....
Honestly, the seasons are getting boring there is so minimum change in story...all they talk about how the town messed up their mind.... It's getting so irritating and repeating now
@@prajwalburude8003 half episodes are stretched out with non sense talking and ramblings about them freaking out. I wish it was done as a mini series instead of full tv show cuz the writers don't have enough material or story to fill a 1 hr show with 10 episodes each season. i think runtime should be as much as story is told per episode (30min, 55 min, 45 min, etc) and like maybe 5 or 6 episodes per season.
Smiley was reborn because he was promised immortality but was killed by Boyd. Being reborn was just a way to come back and used Boyds loved ones to get at him.
This is a half right answer because in my point of view when boyd killed smiley using his infected blood smileys blood transported to him like he said and his son needed blood so he gived him smileys blood and that's why his girlfriend gave birth to him
"Knowledge comes with a cost" that was directed at Julie, the man in yellow is aware of her story walking. He killed Jim to try an guilt her out of using the story walking ability so she won't go back to the very beginning when the children were sacrificed.
Did she tho? She pretty much sacraficed herself to find Fatima and save Boyd from doing the unthinkable. I don't think it's just her going psycho. Yes she did sth horrible but for the good of others sort of. I more so see it that she tried to help, whilst she knew it's probably over for her since they couldn't let it slide this time (just a theory since who knows if townfolks will learn about what actually happened to Elgin, I have no idea how to spell his name lol).
@@noti4377 He was already convinced he's helping them go home. He said an angel like woman told him so. Doubt he would say a word if Sarah lied to him.
When sara said they don't know what it takes to get you to answer I was like "oh shits about to get real now". Honestly I didn't read expect that. Thought she was going to have some heartfelt deep conversation to convince him, but nah she knew what was up and it was the only way because that's what someone would have had to do to her during her "I'ma save everyone" phase.
IM REALLY REALLY THANKFUL that they didnt just keep on having cliffhangers and now they have given us a proper ANSWERS and DIRECTION on where the show will be going on forwards
The only reason for that is because they finally gave some answers. So I guess we'll have to wait for the final episode of next season to get another solid episode.
I mean, it was great, but only cause the story actually progressed, I still think colony house massacre is the best episode, purely for the fear factor
"This place took everything from boyd. I wont let it take his soul.........i already gave it mine" *continues to pull out a mans eye with a screwdriver* I always liked sara. Even when i had some second thoughts, i always had a feeling she was gonna come in clutch. Sara will probably be the reason everyone leaves, but she'll end up staying as a price.
I wonder what the voice meant when it told Sarah that they would find Fatima too late. Fatima seemed completely fine after she gave birth so maybe it was too late to stop the smiley shithead from being reborn?
I think you are right, that would be really emotional for me, i really like sara, she is kinda my crush too, she is just too sweet and misunderstood, i just feel bad for her 😭😭
But dont you think its odd that as soon as jade screams that and jim asks if he felt better only for him to reveal the answer with the music? Dont you think for a bit that jim might be on it with them? You never know anything in the town
Ethan being able to know things like "storywalkers" ,etc might lead on to him being a host at certain times for the Boy in White to hint/guide the townspeople in the right direction
Damn this is good. He often has some sort of unexplained intuitive knowledge or foresight about what someone should do in certain situations. Possibly Ethan, Victor and the boy in white are all the same reincarnation. Maybe one of them is the original version of Tabitha and Jade's child who they tried to save. That's why the boy in white isn't disfigured like the other children
This is very smart, I’d go as far as to say that BIW IS Tabitha and jade’s son from the beginning. The town’s people sacrificed their daughter, it comes to mind that Miranda and Henry had a daughter and a son, and tabby and Jim had a -living- daughter and a son, maybe even Thomas died early on because he’s “an error” to the matrix, even the call that caused his death might be from the town. Both victor and Ethan can interact with the BIW because he’s the son of the incarnation of their parents.
@@gavmxrphy I think we may eventually find out that Ethan wrote the book based on this soul's experience and escape. Now that time travel (?)/time rifts are official, I somehow believe we may be seeing the process of this cycle but it's already completed somewhere on the timeline. The Cromenockle book is a memory young Ethan has to help assist the story, although he does not know why in this current time 'zone', a la Marvel's Multiverse approach but with all timelines intersecting instead of existing separately.
I just remembered something we all missed. Moreover I confirmed it in the episode at time code 58:15. Future Julie tells Jim “you need to run, you need to get to town right now.” The first time I watched it I figured it was a toss away line. But reflecting on it, why would town be safe from the man in yellow. The answer is that either he cannot enter town, or more likely the totems work on him as well. If the man in yellow has limits, that raises questions about how much actual control he has over this pocket dimension.
I think the man in yellow killed Jim because he was angry at him for stopping him. If you look at past the monsters have to be brought in the town they can't just enter it whenever they want like Boyd had to bring the worms into the town for the cicada monster to enter the town. So I think that the fact they played the song at the tree and not in the town restricted the man in yellow and he can't enter the town. If they had played the it in town they basically would have invited him into the town and he would have carried on to do what he did the last cycle. I think him killing Jim was just that frustration. Julie asked Jim to run to the town that means the town is still safe and he can't reach them in the town.
@ Very possible. The show even told us as much with the whole “let’s not play the song in town,” conversation. That said, I wonder if he truly would need an invite, or if Jim was always the target and he just went where Jim was? I think at the very least, Future Julie had a strong belief the talismans might protect him. Then again, they could have just jumped into the Rv and hung one, so I have no way of proving it.
@@Jeff-sf6cl Its future Julie she knows he would be safe in town. She doesn't believe anything she knows things because she has seen them happen she would have carried a talisman if they were effective I think that town is off limits for the man in yellow right now.
@ You might be 100% right. At the same time, future Julie doesn’t always control her jumps. She didn’t run to Jim saying dad this is when you die. She said “I think this is when it happens.” For all we know she had a talisman and lost in the fight that got her the claw marks. The writers wrote it in a way to give themselves a blank check. They can fill in the details later however they want. I just saw the specific wording as a potential clue. I also agree that town is likely the safest place for anyone.
@Sanskar.Tiwari Actually the most solid theory I've heard so far about that situation if we're both alive by 2026 we'll see,very interesting indeed, I'll add this to my playlist hopefully I remember or somebody sees this and remembers me
@@RahYisrael99 So im guessing that if Elgin didn't get involved, Fatima would've just survived on eating rotting veggies (which they have crapton of and can make more) as it helps stops her thirst and hunger for blood (cuz monsters feed on human blood and Smiley monster was the baby). It seems like in the town there is always multiple ways to handle situations but the town people usually take the first and easiest solution they can come up with in a short amount of time instead of thinking it through.
@@metrics360i think only to specific people. Victor never travelled to the tower himself through the tree. His answer was based upon what the kid on white said to Christopher. And Christopher was one of the parent.
The monsters ARE the original town inhabitants and the ghost kids are the children they sacrificed to live forever. Them becoming monsters was the flaw of the immortality. I can’t wait to see the first town meeting in season 4. I think with the omniscient entity (man in yellow) revealing himself the urgency to escape will go through the roof.
Yeah. Jasmine, one of the monsters that guy was simping for, said they didn't choose to be that way. I think they were tricked. I do think the evil entity is controlling them.
As for the kids not telling them. The boy in white said it earlier. He said to victor that they need to figure it out on their own, it is clear that every time they straight up tell them, they end up failing.
maybe their "straight up tell them" have always been cryptic and not actually a direct explanation... kinda like all of this series. Please don't let this show become like Lost.
So is Smiley now technically Boyd’s grandson??? I’d love a meeting with the 2 of them in season 4 with Smiley calling him Grandpa! And honestly Sara was definitely my favorite character this season.
@@CG3theRealtor I can't stop laughing 🤣. This dialogue make so much sense now. That look on his face when he saw smiley emerging out of that slime... He was like " I killed this motherfucker only for him to come back as my grandson "... Lol 🤣
I think Julie is the one who told story to those 7 kids. Remember when Victor told Tabitha and Sarah that those children were sacrificed by whom they loved and someone told them a story which gave them a hope and they put all their hopes in the root and it became faraway trees. Maybe Julie went back when those children were getting sacrificed and told them story that one day people will come in this town to save them.
No, it’s a world with vampire monsters, reincarnation, ghost kids, talismans, time travel, teleportation, sacrifice, worm pathogens in blood, cicada sounds, creepy ventriloquists, puzzle paintings, rituals What could possibly be the clear picture? How could these all relate it’s such a mind boggle
I'm also curious about Victor's dad, Henry, pointing out the Motel sign and the pool, but without the motel itself. It being mentioned and the motel being a questionable absence could mean something. Also, the motel sign with all its lights on was also highlighted in the opening credits.
Yes. She is a story walker means she must have travelled to the past to meet these people. That's why they remember her. It also explains why martin knows her. The future version of julie must have met him in the past through story travelling.
When Miranda died, that creature came running to kill her. But throughout the entire series, these creatures were only shown walking, and in this scene, that creature was running.
i think somewhere is explained that they changed behaviour when boyd found the stones. not sure if they also were running prior to that or what things did change.
I dont think Julie saying that "this is when it happens" its about Jims death but a lot of them dying. She also said that she has to warn others in town, so I think it's something related to what happened to Victor before, when the creatures killed everyone. Maybe the man in yellow isn't the only one who can walk in daylight, and it might have something to do with the monster's rebirth.
If they’re stuck in a time loop it can be another town massacre like what victor went through. It’s nuts this yellow jacket guy can walk around in the day
That was my theory episode 7 season 3! When victor was telling his story all the things he was experiencing as a kid was happening at the same time he was explaining ! I said man I think there all going to get slaughtered and it will start over again. But then I ask… why?
Sara is how you create an Anti Hero. Somebody who literally hit rock bottom then realized that the only way out is UP! BEAUTIFUL SHOW! SEASON 3 WAS BEAUTIFUL!
Hold on, it all makes sense how the rope got thrown down to Boyd. Martin was still changed to the wall. So obviously Julie was there when it originally happened.
I think ultimately it will be the bootstrap paradox, different or changed events leading to same result, because that future exists because of the occurance of Julie travelling to past, to change said future. Maybe she just needs to not travel back
@@Psycheandsarcome Same. I think we have seen the "version" of the story where she tossed the rope down. We now know there are time loops involved in more than one way (the reincarnation of Tabitha and Jade). My guess is that Julie (and Marielle and Randall) will be able to alter the original timeline, perhaps save the children from being sacrificed.
@@prestoncourtney346ok Mr inpatient how about you just don’t watch any current shows anymore and wait for every series to end so you can binge watch on a streaming platform. Every show has cliffhangers. Deal with it or watch it 3years from now
@@prestoncourtney346 Did you pay attention?? like at all? We know why some maybe all the characters are there now. They cant explain it all that would ruin the mystery
@@amandawalker7739 yea but it really doesnt explain anything, all it does it just explains that Tabitha and Jade are reincarnations (this btw most likely tells us that in this universe everyone reincarnates but most people cant remember and are not connected to this place) and we also learnt that the monsters were once humans that made a sacrifice so that instead of reaincarnating they can live forever and not lose their memories but it somehow went down hill. However we still dont know anything really, we dont know why this happened, we dont know what is the mysterious evil force that controls all of this, there is more questions than before.
I feel like the playing of the music notes unlocked and began the "endgame" of the cycle. Them "remembering" solidified their relationship (Tabby and Jade) so Jim had to go, The Town is purging the non essential players maybe as in anyone who isnt connected to somebody from a past cycle Jim was a vessel for Tabby to get to Fromville and now that shes remembered his purpose was served.. Feel like the countdown is on for them to either save the kids or die and the cycle begins again.
jim was very vital to overall story - he figured out signal thing in first season, he solved the numbers puzzle, which our genius jade couldn't, he was just not into threesome stuff perhaps
maybe the boy in white only drip-fed them information so they could prepare, otherwise they would have to do it all at once. (i bet the whole next season is gonna take place over like 48 hours lol. that would be like them)
This is the first theory video I've stumbled across on this show. I never watched Lost, but I know a lot of people theorized about it together online, and I'm so excited to finally have a show where I can get a little bit of that experience. This show is such a good mystery. Anyway, thank you for an amazing video!
@@primal8700To be fair Julie was behind him. He couldn't abandon his daughter and MiY might target her if they ran together so he made sure his daughter was safe by telling her to run away while he stayed there holding back the man
I think the children are saying 'anghkooey' instead of 'remember' as some kind of way to keep the creatures from understanding/finding them. It may keep them hidden somehow. Or if it was so long ago, perhaps it was the language that they spoke when they died.
What I also found interesting that I haven't seen anyone talk about, that that the Ginger Demon, (Smiley) ran at her Miranda in the flashback. Kenny's character points in S1 how the monsters always just walk slowly, and never seem to run, simply because they do not have to. But when Miranda got close to the tree, Smiley ran to get her. It knew that she had to be stopped.
I do believe that the man in yellow is behind all the “visions” of Father Kadri , Boyds wife , Christofer etc . Him taking their shape and influencing Boyd and Jade , thought a familiar face . If he’s powerful enough to show up out of nowhere to kill Jim and stop Julie to keep the story in line , that means he’s deff powerful enough to do something like that . Which also ties in with the Dr.Mabuse theory
I was thinking the same thing. I had been wondering the entire show why some are having visions of "ghosts" and others having visions/ hearing voices from unknowns.
I still think about what Tabitha said in season 1, he asked Jim ''did we survive the crash?'' when they were writing on their wall, like if they are being controlled in some mind control thing. Also Elgin said to Fatima that water is important when he was talking to her near the lake. After he talked with her in that scene, the water thing was never mentioned again. Water SEEMS to be an important thing in Town but they haven't figured it out yet. Maybe someone needs to swim deep down the lake and they''ll find something
Surprised no one has done that yet or even mentioned it. Also surprised this comment doesn’t have more likes, maybe it’s something that will come up next season 🤷🏾♂️
The rebirth of smiley seems to simply be the result of the ritual since they are the original people, Original Jade and Tabitha were also part of the ritual but didnt go through with it which is why they too are somewhat immortal as they always return as different people as Miranda, Christopher and Jade,Tabitha
How fucked up would it be if the next children's song in the show is "he rolled off the table, and onto the floor. And then my poor [meatball] rolled right out the door”
I think man in yellow must be the from the past when he was just immortal but not ghost, as time proceeds and they feed on souls and bodies they become like present ghost, So I think Julie went into past and tried to save his father
Here's a thought. The show considers Julie a 'Storywalker.' When Victor remembered The Boy in White talking to Christopher, Victor said that "...and then they were murdered in the dark. But someone who loved them told them a story. This story gave them hope. And when the children laid on the stones, they poured their hopes into the roots the roots that made the symbol and those roots became the tree." Maybe that person who loved them was Tabitha or Jade, and the story that they told the children is somehow related to what is happening to the town. Another thing that seems very likely moving into S4 is that Tabitha rekindles her connection with Viktor, and maybe even remembers what ended up happening to his sister, assuming she is still alive. Randall also seems to know about this place, with insights like "Dying isn't the worst thing that can happen to you here..." certainly feels like he is the reincarnation of Martin. Being chained up like that in wherever he is for however long he has been there certainly seems like a fate worse than death.
The man in yellow is terrifying. Not because of the way he looks or anything, but because of what he represents. He’s way out of place and especially during the day time. I can’t wait to see what happens.
I thought the same, her hair is dyed pure black instead of her usual brunette, its also split in the middle and also her outfit is not what she wore before
LOL jokes aside. i think the kids are cursed by the evil entity that controls monster and towns people. The kids are cursed with not being allowed to say the actual word they are trying to say to Tabitha and Jade lol Instead of jade hearing "Remember" from the kids. All Jade can hear is Anhkoowee when in actuality the kids were saying "remember" lmao
I think that town massacre that was mentioned before happens when residents are close to knowing how to get out of that place or rather, when they remember how to do it because every one of them are equivalents of the first group and are somehow connected to them, like tabitha-miranda. The perpetrator of the massacre is the guy in yellow, who supervises it all from behind the curtains and when the inhabitants are close to solving it (the numbers are notes, the song is a lullaby that they sang to children, etc.) he resets the whole process by killing all the unaware residents in day time, thus resetting the entire group and the whole process begins start over with a new group. He is not affected by talismans or anything, so he can calmly start the process again with new unsuspecting participants, which is why each version of the group failed to solve the puzzle because when they get close, they are all simply killed by the guy in yellow.
Why does the man in yellow not kill Julie instead of Jim? As a story walker Julie is the most dangerous person for him. Even Jade is much more dangerous for him, because he's the only one, who constantly tries to find the solution and is very close to it. Jim is just an irrelevant person in the whole story.
I think the man in yellow didn't plan to kill only Jim, I assume that after killing him he went for the rest including Julie.The guy in yellow appears and calmly just approaches jim, he doesn't pay attention to Jim telling him to move away, he just says his sarcastic remarks and kills him, he just came to end the party as he did every time with every group that was approaching a solution. Strange thing in that scene is that Man in yellow didn't say a word to or about julie or even notice her, but he has the same ironic-cynical way of speaking as monsters. The fact that convinces me to this theory is that victor, recalling the massacre, emphasized that it took place during the day time and normal monsters don't appear during day time unlike the Man in yellow
@@marcinkobylak5478 Well, if your theory is true, then we know, that Julie won't be killed, because the Future Julie is alive. Maybe a lot people get killed by the yellow guy, but not Julie. I guess, no person will get killed, which is important to the story in fromville.
Knowledge comes at a cost , I think he was talking about jade playing that violen sound that helped him gain knowledge about their past lives but at the cost of him being there too
Bro I was just thinking how fucking crazy that is that literally exactly what happened to Elgins eye was how the civil war soldier face was. I was having doubts that everything tied together in some meaningful way and was starting to fear they were making things up as they went along but this episode shows how every single thing we've seen from the start has meaning which is so satisfying
Yeah Elgin is reincarnated because he dreamt of this place before even seeing the tree, just like Tabitha and her past version Miranda, only I don't know if that makes him one of the original people of the town or if he has any relation with the children like jayde and tabitha
Yep... everyone who entity talks to are reincarnation of town people from the past.... Julie, Jade, Victor, Miranda, Christopher, Tabitha's son, Boyd, Boy's wife, Elgin, Fatima. Looks like Yellow Man is targeting all people who are reincarnations like Julie or people who knows about the past or at least is able to solve all the mysteries like Jim lol
the man in yellow told jim that "knowledge always comes with a cost" . that tingled my cranium a bit. that led me to H.P lovecraft's redition of the king in yellow. he literally holds the secrets of the universe there and has the ability of manipulation and reincarnation with so much more. he is also connected to "the king in yellow" play. it's like the town is going through a play of sorts. same characters played by different people.
Actually Season 3 done a pretty good job, explaining not everything and the last scream of Jade representing not only our frustration but also the character's frustration as well. But I also agree with white Boy, See how difficult it was for Tabitha to admit she was/is Maranda, and if he came and tell them everything, who they are, what they should do, they will end up suspecting him and not beleiving that theory. Jim death was neccessary for entity to win. Just how amazing jim is, He just put small effort to understand the dates and he figure it out, or guessed it. He's the one who comes up with Tower. But entity didnt make his move because he was more concerned/scared about his family and just after he breaks that bubble, Enitity himself came to kill Jim, Because Jim is bigger threat to them as he is a f**king genius and Jade loved him lol. Jim is an outsider, He is nowhere connected with the place so maybe he didnt come in the contract, they form during the sacrifice. Jim was right not to play the song T-T !!
The town aka the Evil entity that is controlling monsters and people manipulates easily, the people who are incarnations of past town people. I think it couldn't manipulate him so easily as it could with boyd, jade, christopher, miranda, julie, that guy with scars and hearing bugs, elgin, sarah, and victor. Jim was like the audience who already watched the show and knows the story lol so entity killed him off quick AF after that figuring out music notes lmao But i think Jim might get reincarnated in future season tho lol maybe Season 5 or 6.
Jim was killed because his doubt/fear was the only thing keeping Tabitha and Jade from figuring this place out. The man in yellow kept calling him to keep him afraid and let him know you better hold your wife back from figuring anything out. Once he started helping them he was done for
What a season finale 🤯 But I can't stop thinking about the little village where jim and kenny found the new food source. When they stayed over night, they heard something walking around outside. And they said it sounded different from the monsters. So what was it? The man in yellow? Another kind of monster?
Hmmm so do you think the same for when Boyd and Sara went out and camped at night and their tent got attacked? Or you think that was a big ahh spider ?
Idk I have a feeling the boy in white is the son of the man in yellow and that the boy in white was the first to be sacrificed or killed and the man in yellow was the first to become immortal and maybe that's why they're special since they were the first and they're probably son and father.
I think the boy in white was meant to be sacrificed as well but he got away. When Tabitha and Jade both remember that Ankhooey means "remember", Jade says "We tried to save them, because one of them.." I think he was about to say "one of them escaped and told us they were going to kill the others"
@@FieryFlamingFajitas Tabitha said they had a daughter, I think that's what they meant. Miranda couldn't see the boy in white, it was Victor who told her about it. Tabitha also couldn't see the boy in white (apart from the lighthouse scene where no one else but the boy could show her the way) but her son could. Interesting correlation. Also Ethan almost instinctively seen the boy in white as good, as his friend. What if the first "Tabitha and Jade" had two kids?
No it isn't, you don't pay attention to shit. She was literally already pregnant, and was about to tell Ellis when he got stabbed. Then after that is when Boyd gave him the transfusion. So no, you're objectively incorrect. How would that even make sense? The worms killed Smiley, why would they help revive him? You think Smiley's blood got into Boyd or something? You're forgetting one thing guy, Kristy did the autopsy on him. The bodies are shriveled up and the organs are desiccated. There is no blood flowing in their veins. The villagers sacrificed their children for immortality. The more likely explanation is some kind of curse within the town, and pregnancies are are vulnerable to being effectively hijacked if a villager dies, they get reborn. Immortality doesn't have to mean invincibility. She was most likely legitimately pregnant, and his soul was able to overcome and consume the pregnancy and take its place.
@@daethe 90% of theories surrounding this show actually make me want to jump off a cliff. It's either bullshit that watching one episode can disprove or just straight up nonsense people just say for no reason. It's so frustrating
@@Toast2005 thats what makes it fun and interesting to talk about. If a show is just downright fact of the matter and easy to get, no one would talk about it cuz everything is easily explained and solved.
@sparda9060 Yeah but that doesn't mean they make sense. People just say random shit because of head cannon. It's like they don't even try and make it make it sense
Julie coming back in time was the knowledge the man in yellow was saying comes at a cost. so julie coming back is the reason jim dies creating a time loop. If you watch the man in yellow when he says that knowledge comes at a cost hes looking at julie then looks over to jim meaning hes saying it to julie about her coming back in time
I think the knowledge comes at a cost part was more so tied to Tabitha and jade remembering the past lives and what happened to the kids. The man in yellow wants to prevent them from knowing and breaking the cycle
I think Julie just figured out who that guy was right then and there. She didn’t give off the vibe that she knew what the man in yellow was yet, that must have been her first time seeing him. She only knew her dad dies that day by there old RV. If she knew the man in yellow I believe she would know how dangerous he is and made Jim run off away from him.
I agree 💯%! Knowledge comes at a price meant Julie figuring out she could time walk and then her using that knowledge to try and change the story is why the man in yellow punished her by killing her dad again.
Boyd is often shown wearing a yellow shirt, he was wearing it in this episode as well. Could also be some reference to the book " the king in yellow" and being lost in carcosa like they talked about in true detective
I'm just glad that they finally gave Victor more scenes, I always though his character was the key to many things, since he's been there the longest, he grew up there, is friends with the boy in white, who knows the towns deepest darkest secrets, but most of season 1 and 2 focused on other useless characters that doesn't help in solving the puzzles. At least now we know more, because they finally decided to give a bit of a focus on Victor's story, his past especially, and his father also gave important information. This season is great, hopefully season 4 will be just as good.
There is a quote from Dracula: "There are worse things than death" is what he says to Jonathan Harker, the frightened young man who at the beginning of the book is sent to Transylvania for the negotiations of the castle and who at the end of the story will kill Dracula to save his soul.
Someone watching this channel has insider behind the scenes knowledge as I read a comment under one of your previous predictions videos (think it was ep.7) that mentioned spoilers - stating that Julie would turn up with short hair from the future, Jim was going to die and a man in yellow appears, exactly what happened! I couldnt believe someone had mentioned it in your comments 3 eps ago!
The tension in every From season be like Start of Season: Crazy shit happens, impossible to wait for the next episode 😱 Middle of Season: Characters just strolling around town and talking leading to nowhere 🥱 End of Season: Get the answers of the seasons's mystery but introduce new mystery for the next season 🤯
@@voizcrackI do feel that Lost answers enough of the questions by the end but it takes way too long to get there. I didn’t love any of the characters enough to watch every single episode of each season. Recaps on UA-cam are awesome for this.
I kept seeing this show mentioned around my UA-cam feed and decided to try it out. Omg this show is insane! It’s so good it has me completely locked in. I literally binged all 3 seasons in the last month. Can’t wait for season 4 cuz I have so many more questions.
How when Tabitha is Miranda so that must mean that Ethan is Victor and Julie is elose and Jim is Victor's dad wich means that Thomas must be the boy in white or he Can be the man in yellow 🤔
@@bjsworld-gf6kh But can Ethan be Victor if Victor is still alive? Same with Jim and Henry? I would assume there would be only one version of someone at the same time. And I don't think it has to follow the current family lines. Because Tabitha had a child with Jade, now they are not a couple. She later came back as Miranda and had Victor and Eloise with Henry, while Jade was there as Christopher. Now as Tabitha she's with Jim and has Julie and Ethan. So the story must unfold atleast a little bit different each time.
Ethan is one of the ones who can stop the man in yellow that's why she was being told to kill him. All the children of the 'reincarnations' have abilities. Ethan, Victor, Julie .. the boys can see "the boy" (who I'm thinking may be another child of previous reincarnations) and Julie can story walk I wonder if Eloise saved herself by story walking
The boat. They've got to travel out of From on running salt water BETWEEN WORLDS to break magical charms, avoid magical creatures, and get home. That could mean ocean water, or the galaxy, metaphorically. Probably ocean water because space ain't salty. But the ancients thought it might be. And that's really all that matters.
and then hear me out, the ship they're on, crashes on an island...and maybe this island happens to be in the south pacific, but it has been known to be other places at other times. It happens around the time a plane crashes at the island too.
My theory!!! Julie cannot influence things directly. I think in the future, she will try to help multiple times and eventually realize that only the residents themselves can change things somehow. The boy in white hinted at this as well. In the future, she will decide to only assist indirectly and from a distance. All the clues, I believe, are left by her, Julie, and Eloise. (Why Eloise? Because she’s Victor’s sister, and Julie is her reincarnation. Eloise is definitely alive and will later meet Julie. Or maybe she’s trapped by the man in yellow.) Randall is a tragic analog of the guy hanging on the wall. If everyone dies again, he might pass these insects to a future version of Boyd. He might commit suicide, leaving his spirit tied to the wall or something like that. Another thought: if you wish to die by your own will, death won’t save you from this place, and you become its ghost, so you still can’t escape. If the current residents die, only Ethan will remain. His thoughts about not wanting to forget what his Asian grandmother looked like remind me of how Victor also didn’t want to forget, which is why he drew and collected keepsakes. Ethan will probably come to this conclusion too. I think the boy in white might also be another version of Victor or Ethan who killed himself and became a ghost. It’s like a game-eliminated players (i.e., previous residents) can’t participate anymore, even if they somehow survived. They still remain prisoners of this place. Only the current residents/players have the ability to significantly change anything.
Listen to the little subtle Bible references in FROM. Boyd being called "Mr. Fish and loaves" Boyd's last name Stevens being derived from St. Stephen's, the first Christian Matyr put to death after Jesus. Boyd's wife Abby name means "Church or Monestry" Fr. Kathri saying the Church in town is like no other Church he's seen before ( probably because Abby is a play on words) Ellis who is Boyd's son name literally means "God is my Father" Fr. K telling Boyd to come down off his cross because he can't save everyone. Martin saying that the town was "Just the tip of the spear" instead of "tip of the iceberg" alluding to the Spear of Destiny. Fr. K saying there's no Bibles in town and also Book 74 isn't written yet but possible can be with the whole town. Martin telling Boyd, "My blood is your blood" parallel to Christ and the Last Supper when Jesus told the disciples to drink his blood and eat his flesh. The last episodes being named "Revelations. The Boy in White saying"the end is the beginning" referencing the Book of Genesis which literally means "The Beginning " The Tree in the road is either the Tree of Life or the Tree of Knowledge in The Garden of Eden. The painting of Ellis and Fatima that parallels Adam and Eve (But I believe that Fatima represents Lilith) Lilith gave birth to Demons in a Datk Cave much like the Boy in White said the monsters were born in the dark and why Fatima had Smiley in a dark root cellar. Acosta calls Boyd "God King" when venting to Kenny about her gun and treatment. There's a theory about a Flood coming to town and we know that Boyd owns a boat. The Polaroid Camera that shows a picture of Boyd's house and Boyd even saying that his "Boat was missing" (But why would he say that when he only learned that Abby bought him a boat while driving before they came across the Tree and he never seen it in person. There are 12 Talisman's and Christ had 12 disciples. Boyd stating the Town can't break him much like Job in the Bible who the Devil waged against God that he could Break Job so he would turn his back on God. Martin chained up looks like Jesus on the Cross along with 2 other skeletons mirroring the Crucifixion of Jesus and the 2 thieves. And plenty more Bible or Religous elements that aren't just a coincidence.
That is a very good breakdown of the bible/christianity connections. Also I'd like to add that we already saw a few biblical plagues come to be in the show. The cicadas and famine.
Never grew up or cared about Christianity beyond a bit of fun with Supernatural, so this is a genuine question. Would the man in yellow then be one of the horsemen? Doesn't each one have a specific color?
Whew thank god for Sarah but know knowing Jade and Tabitha had a baby together is mind blowing and they keep coming back to save them , Julie going back or in the future now because she had short her she may have tried to save Jim a few times. And poor Jim, but the man in yellow now they have a daytime monster! Can't wait for season 4🎉
The boat is not at the picture of the house because Boyd has never seen his house with the boat because they were surprising him with it on the trip there
The theme song for the show states "whatever will be will be" which I think they chose that song because as the stories continually tell themselves through numerous generations, the same things have happened and as Ethan said, the chapters and stories cannot be changed.
A town wide search by every member of the town, and nobody thinks of checking the root cellar for Fathima. A place that people from the town have been before and know it exists, and know where it is. Just incredible 😂
@@waynedonoghue4071 They actually did check, but if you remember as Fatima screams weren't heard because her mouth was covered by the ghost. and you couldn't have known about the hidden room.
@@waynedonoghue4071 they already checked, elgin and ellis already checked the cellar and tabitha and victor were in that same cellar when fatima was missing
The man in yellow is surrounded by RED in the painting. The monster is RED is the wall painting, if colors matter, the man in yellow might be an avatar for the monster. He seems to be a tier higher than the rest of the night monsters. The kimono lady is also something else, maybe some forest creature unknown so far. She can manifest as a spirit and in the physical plane at the same time...
If you think about it Julie being a story walker gives her the ability to change things because had she not entered the ruins and throw the rope down for Boyd then I'm pretty sure Boyd was fucked, this tells us she can alter things that have happen.
@ but the point is that the Julie Jim just saw was a storywalker from the future, what I’m saying is I don’t think the ppl in the present will know about the man in yellow until she takes that exact walk we jus saw her take, she’ll obviously end up telling them but I think he’ll do more dmg before Julie goes to try save Jim
@@mritachi3878 They will know if Julie tells them. Just like she can tell Boyd about Martin and how she threw a rope down to help him. That’s the biggest issue with them now. They absolutely don’t communicate with each other like they should.
@@dagod8418 bruh... This is what I mean. She can't tell them this until this event happens in the future, in other words they will not know the circumstances of Jim's death until Julie wakes up from seizure at the ruins sometime in the future!
Victor was right, Sarah is the scariest person in the town.
Truly
She's amazing ❤
If that was Victor or Jim son sitting in that chair do you think they would have done the same thing they did to Elgin?
Well victor would never be sitting there cause he’s not stupid enough to do something like that . And Jim’s son is not strong enough to lock Fatima in a basement. I see where ur going but your argument is not valid. Let’s look at everyone who has been swayed by monsters Boyd’s wife what happened . Boyd had to kill her because she wouldn’t listen . Sara is lucky to be alive she killed 4 people because of the monsters only reason she is alive is because of father khatri thinking she held important information . Now let’s look at Elgin he’s a “new guy” in town who has kidnapped a member of “froms” family who is one of the sweetest people in the town . By listening to an evil monster . Now in my mind I don’t know you well but if someone kidnapped your let’s say “sister” or “mom” and time was running out for them in this scenario. What would you do? Believe Elgin after knowing what happens anytime someone listens to a monster or try to get the information to where she is as fast as possible. They didn’t go straight to Torture they gave Elgin an opportunity to tell them. They even brought Sara to tell him her experiences. In my opinion Sara is one of the most strong willed characters considering as of now she is the only one to ever get out of the monsters grasp. Does Sara deserve to die No. does Elgin No. did Boyd’s wife No. but once people start listening to the monsters you have to do drastic things. What Elgin did to Fatima is almost worst then death . The torture that Fatima went through in that cellar giving birth to a monster because of elgins actions . She will never be the same. For all we know she could’ve died in there.
I love how you completely ignored the fact that Fatima killed Tillie in the influence of those creatures.
You're just thinking about it from Boyd's perspective. What about Elgin? Remember the guy in the first episode who had to sit in that sack because he left his family alone for one night? Boyd's and his family sense of justice is as fragile as it gets. They are no better than the thing they stand against. Sara is pure evil. The only sensible characters is the show are Jade,Victor,Kenny,Ethan and Kristi. @@babybleach
Sara is the mvp of the episode
Facts I love it
Sarah is so cute
Yessss, I do hope Elgin survives though 😭 He couldn’t help his part in the story.
Word! As soon as I saw her face listening to Accosta's bullshitt, I was like, "Well, girl, you FULLY redeemed!"
@@tionyt couldn't he though? Could have just said it after the first hammer drop
Deep down, we all know that if Victor locked in, even smiley won't be smiling anymore
He will soon 😊 maybe you could say he wore a yellow coat and SPOILED himself a little too much 😊 hv a gd day
@@froyoaorta9646 A good day to you too mate
victor would snipe em next season
@@Yujiro945 forsho
Nah Victor coming in clutch next season, definitely ready to lock in
Elgin was literally going to the root celler with supplies for fathima. Boyd and others could have followed him without alerting him and could have avoided so many things.
yep. honestly, Elgin being swayed by torture isn't that believable to me? idk
That's what I was saying.
They're just showing how far a person can go and break. It was all set up to break boyd he's worst enemy now being reborn through his daughter in law !? That's crazy and if you think about it I believe just like Tabitha and jade Boyd has some past connections. I used to think Donna has some connections too but not anymore. But somethings are definitely connected with boyd !
I prefer the Sara thing 😂
Actually the Lady would've warned Eljin if they followed him...since Fatima did not start giving birth the moment they caught Elgin going down the stairs..
So its why 2 cars entering the city on the same day were important back in season 1, because its will be always Tabitha and jade souls entering the City on the same day again...
Wow
DAMN
Ohhh that makes sense.
which means Boyd and someone else had to have got there same day. perhaps Abby is Eloise reincarnated and Boyd is Martin? 🤔
Remember when victor said it has not happened after a long time
one thing i really appreciated about this season is that characters are actually sharing their findings with one another (even when they try to hide something they usually get found out within the next episode, with a handful of exceptions). it was starting to get REALLY tiring that no one was ever on the same page. i wanted to clap at all the scenes where a character just goes "hey check this out" to someone else
yes the opposite of season two
Donna half the time: 'what is going on here?' 😂
Yea that was starting to really piss me off. May have not made it thru the season if it continued.
Yes I really like seeing characters communicate more, they seem more united and I think that is important to making this cycle special/different.
Yeah same I hate when they don’t just say important things to each other and they run around in circles all season
the ending when Julie appeared running clearly as not the current version of her (diff hair & clothes) was probably the scariest moment of the whole show to me bc it felt like something really bad was going to happen
Exactly it gave us the feeling that something important was going to happen especially after Ethan told julie that she could go back to chapters of the story that already happened over all this season finale had a nice touch to it👏🏾
It reminded me of the series "Dark", where alt-Martha appears with short hair and a scar
It hints that Julie will go back in time to save her dad
Yes that was Julie story walking
So many people didnt get it, her hair was shorter,she was older and kept speaking riddles!
But what is most interesting is what the yellow man said about the hole tabitha dug
Why is he so concerned?
Some real Marty and Back to the Future vibes 😂
Jade was representing ALL of us in that scene 😂😂
LITERALLY I WAS THINKING THIS IS ALL OF US RIGHT NOW
Ahaha we all felt that😂
tbf the children probably don't have that much power
Jade was all of us all season
Jade was being selfish by not talking with anyone. The moment he talks with Tabitha, Tabitha give an answer. The moment he talked with Jim about the numbers, Jim gave the answer.
Remember when Kenny said something like, “we might not make it out of here, but the people that came next might be able too because of us” that absolutely has to mean something
means Kenny is a dawg who puts his life on the line for others
Now it makes sense in season 1 when the monster told Julie “you don’t remember me?” when they were running to Donna’s big house. Pretty wild how they dropped that hint in season 1 episode 2. She definitely time travels and probably ran into the monsters when they were regular human beings.
Or as they were monsters. Remember they just told Victor if he keeps coming down they are going to make him stay so these monsters aren’t without thought
@@taylor6109 i think the monsters have their own thoughts and autonomy to a certain point that doesn't go against the evil entity's plans (the thing that talks to people in the town). They can do whatever they want but still has to follow rules the evil entity gives them like not killing certain town members or allowed to run when attacking town people cuz they have no chance if monsters were allowed to run lol....
Honestly, the seasons are getting boring there is so minimum change in story...all they talk about how the town messed up their mind....
It's getting so irritating and repeating now
@@prajwalburude8003 half episodes are stretched out with non sense talking and ramblings about them freaking out. I wish it was done as a mini series instead of full tv show cuz the writers don't have enough material or story to fill a 1 hr show with 10 episodes each season. i think runtime should be as much as story is told per episode (30min, 55 min, 45 min, etc) and like maybe 5 or 6 episodes per season.
@@sparda9060 true....i just watch the entire episode skipping
Isn’t it funny Boyd said my blood is your blood now mf when he killed smiley and now he technically smileys grandpa🤣
Yea damn true 😂 now next season I want the smiley to call boyd Grandpa 😂🤣
so maybe that's why Fatima got pregnant? Thru Boyd's blood, then Ellis'
So if they kill a monster another has to get reborn cause they were promised eternal life?!😢
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
😂😂
Smiley was reborn because he was promised immortality but was killed by Boyd. Being reborn was just a way to come back and used Boyds loved ones to get at him.
facts
Damn right.
These is one of series ineed to re-watch
This is a half right answer because in my point of view when boyd killed smiley using his infected blood smileys blood transported to him like he said and his son needed blood so he gived him smileys blood and that's why his girlfriend gave birth to him
@@gegeswfsdYeah! That sounds really interesting!
"Knowledge comes with a cost" that was directed at Julie, the man in yellow is aware of her story walking. He killed Jim to try an guilt her out of using the story walking ability so she won't go back to the very beginning when the children were sacrificed.
she didn't really change the past, she came back to save her dad from dying that day only for her to be the reason he dies in the first place.
@arbnormetolli7642 Julie could be like the boy in white. For her to successfully influence things through time, she might have to do it indirectly.
@@darthrevan5732thou sir are smart!
@@arbnormetolli7642how is she the reason he dies? How do you know that guy wouldn’t have killed Jim either way?
If she is story walking, doesn't that mean Jim is not really dead yet?
Sarah really became quite the Anti-hero this season and im here for it.
Did she tho? She pretty much sacraficed herself to find Fatima and save Boyd from doing the unthinkable. I don't think it's just her going psycho. Yes she did sth horrible but for the good of others sort of. I more so see it that she tried to help, whilst she knew it's probably over for her since they couldn't let it slide this time (just a theory since who knows if townfolks will learn about what actually happened to Elgin, I have no idea how to spell his name lol).
She can just explain to you Elgin as “they told me that this would help us get home! You understand Elgin.”
@@noti4377 He was already convinced he's helping them go home. He said an angel like woman told him so. Doubt he would say a word if Sarah lied to him.
This is the side effect when weebs watches this show.
When sara said they don't know what it takes to get you to answer I was like "oh shits about to get real now". Honestly I didn't read expect that. Thought she was going to have some heartfelt deep conversation to convince him, but nah she knew what was up and it was the only way because that's what someone would have had to do to her during her "I'ma save everyone" phase.
IM REALLY REALLY THANKFUL that they didnt just keep on having cliffhangers and now they have given us a proper ANSWERS and DIRECTION on where the show will be going on forwards
Learned the lessons of lost
I think this is the best episode of the entire show so far
The only reason for that is because they finally gave some answers. So I guess we'll have to wait for the final episode of next season to get another solid episode.
Sadly Every season it's the last epsiode that is only better .
for sure like finnaly some answers
I mean, it was great, but only cause the story actually progressed, I still think colony house massacre is the best episode, purely for the fear factor
it was !!!! i watched it 4 times
"This place took everything from boyd. I wont let it take his soul.........i already gave it mine"
*continues to pull out a mans eye with a screwdriver*
I always liked sara. Even when i had some second thoughts, i always had a feeling she was gonna come in clutch. Sara will probably be the reason everyone leaves, but she'll end up staying as a price.
I wonder what the voice meant when it told Sarah that they would find Fatima too late. Fatima seemed completely fine after she gave birth so maybe it was too late to stop the smiley shithead from being reborn?
I think you are right, that would be really emotional for me, i really like sara, she is kinda my crush too, she is just too sweet and misunderstood, i just feel bad for her 😭😭
@@RaviSinhaa Lmao me and my friends always saying, this, we be like "i can fix her " or " she's just to fine to leave "
Nah, this one of the best theories I seen so far. This would make the "Ending" insane.
Yeah, you're probably right, although I don't want that for her😭
In season one when Jim, Tabitha, and Ethan are writing on the wall, Jim says “I figured it out, the answer is 12.”
Yoo, no comment, lemme fix that
Omg, I’m shook
Holy Shi- you're so damn right
Which episode?
@ it’s ep 4 I think
Jade: SAY ANYTHING OTHER THAN ANGHKOOEY!!!
massively long buildup of the kids walking up.
Kids: anghkooey
But dont you think its odd that as soon as jade screams that and jim asks if he felt better only for him to reveal the answer with the music?
Dont you think for a bit that jim might be on it with them?
You never know anything in the town
😂😂😂
@@MohamedAhmed-i1t1nCould Jim have possibly sacrificed Thomas 🤔🤔🤔
@@BigGoat313 eye opening theory
I love this show so much it literally makes me tear up from how eerie it can be
Ethan being able to know things like "storywalkers" ,etc might lead on to him being a host at certain times for the Boy in White to hint/guide the townspeople in the right direction
Damn this is good. He often has some sort of unexplained intuitive knowledge or foresight about what someone should do in certain situations. Possibly Ethan, Victor and the boy in white are all the same reincarnation. Maybe one of them is the original version of Tabitha and Jade's child who they tried to save. That's why the boy in white isn't disfigured like the other children
I was thinking the same, like how no one wonders how this kid knows all this stuff 😂
This is very smart, I’d go as far as to say that BIW IS Tabitha and jade’s son from the beginning. The town’s people sacrificed their daughter, it comes to mind that Miranda and Henry had a daughter and a son, and tabby and Jim had a -living- daughter and a son, maybe even Thomas died early on because he’s “an error” to the matrix, even the call that caused his death might be from the town. Both victor and Ethan can interact with the BIW because he’s the son of the incarnation of their parents.
@@gavmxrphy I think we may eventually find out that Ethan wrote the book based on this soul's experience and escape. Now that time travel (?)/time rifts are official, I somehow believe we may be seeing the process of this cycle but it's already completed somewhere on the timeline. The Cromenockle book is a memory young Ethan has to help assist the story, although he does not know why in this current time 'zone', a la Marvel's Multiverse approach but with all timelines intersecting instead of existing separately.
I always thought they looked somewhat similar and both good friends with Victor. They are similarities you cant really ignore
I just remembered something we all missed. Moreover I confirmed it in the episode at time code 58:15. Future Julie tells Jim “you need to run, you need to get to town right now.” The first time I watched it I figured it was a toss away line. But reflecting on it, why would town be safe from the man in yellow. The answer is that either he cannot enter town, or more likely the totems work on him as well. If the man in yellow has limits, that raises questions about how much actual control he has over this pocket dimension.
I think the man in yellow killed Jim because he was angry at him for stopping him. If you look at past the monsters have to be brought in the town they can't just enter it whenever they want like Boyd had to bring the worms into the town for the cicada monster to enter the town. So I think that the fact they played the song at the tree and not in the town restricted the man in yellow and he can't enter the town. If they had played the it in town they basically would have invited him into the town and he would have carried on to do what he did the last cycle. I think him killing Jim was just that frustration. Julie asked Jim to run to the town that means the town is still safe and he can't reach them in the town.
@ Very possible. The show even told us as much with the whole “let’s not play the song in town,” conversation. That said, I wonder if he truly would need an invite, or if Jim was always the target and he just went where Jim was? I think at the very least, Future Julie had a strong belief the talismans might protect him. Then again, they could have just jumped into the Rv and hung one, so I have no way of proving it.
@@Jeff-sf6cl Its future Julie she knows he would be safe in town. She doesn't believe anything she knows things because she has seen them happen she would have carried a talisman if they were effective I think that town is off limits for the man in yellow right now.
@ You might be 100% right. At the same time, future Julie doesn’t always control her jumps. She didn’t run to Jim saying dad this is when you die. She said “I think this is when it happens.” For all we know she had a talisman and lost in the fight that got her the claw marks. The writers wrote it in a way to give themselves a blank check. They can fill in the details later however they want. I just saw the specific wording as a potential clue. I also agree that town is likely the safest place for anyone.
@Sanskar.Tiwari Actually the most solid theory I've heard so far about that situation if we're both alive by 2026 we'll see,very interesting indeed, I'll add this to my playlist hopefully I remember or somebody sees this and remembers me
This episode was nice and fast-paced, why didn't they do this for the rest of the season?!?!? Good one.
this was the best episode! the whole season was not great but this topped it
Because that’s not how stories work bone head
@@sheambitious29lachelle17 For sure I was so disappointed cause it was too short, LOL
I swear the writers know they only have 10 episodes but write like they have more when they actually don’t
MGM+ probably demanded 10 episodes, writers only had enough content for 7 or 8
Elgin went through all that for nothing. 😂 I can't wait to see his face in season 4 after he finds out Fatima gave birth to a monster. Smh
Yeah he was definitely pimped by the kimono woman. Had Fatima not drank the blood she would have died thus Smiley not being reborn.
Elgin saved her life in exchange for the rebirth of the antichrist.
She would had starved and died if he didnt feed her
@@RahYisrael99the lady in the kimono can get it 😋
@@RahYisrael99 So im guessing that if Elgin didn't get involved, Fatima would've just survived on eating rotting veggies (which they have crapton of and can make more) as it helps stops her thirst and hunger for blood (cuz monsters feed on human blood and Smiley monster was the baby). It seems like in the town there is always multiple ways to handle situations but the town people usually take the first and easiest solution they can come up with in a short amount of time instead of thinking it through.
I was happy that Sara gave Elgin that treatment 😂
Funfact: The smiley ran towards miranda although it was supposed to walk💀
Yes, same with in season 2 Victor said that bottle tree takes you to tower and then they just changed that in season 3
@@metrics360i think only to specific people. Victor never travelled to the tower himself through the tree. His answer was based upon what the kid on white said to Christopher. And Christopher was one of the parent.
@@metrics360thought that too, and then realized he might have just been wrong
Maybe it's a plot hole or the creature knew that she must be killed ASAP so she doesn't go through it
My thoughts!
The monsters ARE the original town inhabitants and the ghost kids are the children they sacrificed to live forever. Them becoming monsters was the flaw of the immortality. I can’t wait to see the first town meeting in season 4. I think with the omniscient entity (man in yellow) revealing himself the urgency to escape will go through the roof.
The next town meeting will be in season 7
Yeah. Jasmine, one of the monsters that guy was simping for, said they didn't choose to be that way. I think they were tricked. I do think the evil entity is controlling them.
who can the Man in yellow be? Their entity god or smt? Cuz he seemed to be walking around during daytime
I think you’re wrong
@ he’s the deity of that place. He’s not human he’s not a monster he’s the one who controls the puppet
So Martin gave Boyd the worms, Boyd gave Ellis the blood transfusion, Ellis "impregrantes"Fatima, Smiley is reborn! The cycle continues!!! Flip
I never noticed this until now. You are a genius.
wow thats actually a really cool pick up omg
This made me aroused
You mean monster need people to their future for reborn.
Fatima was already pregnant when Elilis received the transfusion.
This season finale was probably the best one yet. Really ties everything together and builds the entire world so to speak.
As for the kids not telling them. The boy in white said it earlier. He said to victor that they need to figure it out on their own, it is clear that every time they straight up tell them, they end up failing.
Yes its like saying "Just defeat the Satan Lord"
How??
You will become devastated.
You need to become stronger and stronger and then see the Endboss
@PuppyTheTiny or it's more like you all will have to sacrifice yourself but they're like nah it has to be another way
maybe their "straight up tell them" have always been cryptic and not actually a direct explanation... kinda like all of this series. Please don't let this show become like Lost.
So is Smiley now technically Boyd’s grandson??? I’d love a meeting with the 2 of them in season 4 with Smiley calling him Grandpa! And honestly Sara was definitely my favorite character this season.
That’s hilarious from the fact when Boyd killed him he did say my blood is your blood now mf🤣🤣
@@CG3theRealtor I can't stop laughing 🤣. This dialogue make so much sense now. That look on his face when he saw smiley emerging out of that slime... He was like " I killed this motherfucker only for him to come back as my grandson "... Lol 🤣
so basically the town is an incest fest 😂😂
Exactly. So now it comes full circle and all the people and monsters are connected in some way.
Just a surrogacy
This show has such a dark vibe to it. I can't explain it but just reading an episode review before going to bed gave me a full night of nightmares.
I think Julie is the one who told story to those 7 kids. Remember when Victor told Tabitha and Sarah that those children were sacrificed by whom they loved and someone told them a story which gave them a hope and they put all their hopes in the root and it became faraway trees. Maybe Julie went back when those children were getting sacrificed and told them story that one day people will come in this town to save them.
Yeah thats Possible since she always tell stories to Ethan
That's my theory as well .
@@OharaMariJ It is Ethan that usually tells story to Julie, She told that in the episode she passed the "portal"
This is absolutely making sense and this gonna happen next.
I like the slow phase of the story, things slowly starting to make somewhat sense, thats how you keep series alive
Omg yes, I also like the slow pace of it
"slowly" is an understatement.
No, it’s a world with vampire monsters, reincarnation, ghost kids, talismans, time travel, teleportation, sacrifice, worm pathogens in blood, cicada sounds, creepy ventriloquists, puzzle paintings, rituals
What could possibly be the clear picture? How could these all relate it’s such a mind boggle
It's really not that well made. They created a slew of set pieces and puzzle boxes to bounce characters between and are making the rest up as they go
@@tmanharp You think that because the show ain't finished.
I'm also curious about Victor's dad, Henry, pointing out the Motel sign and the pool, but without the motel itself. It being mentioned and the motel being a questionable absence could mean something. Also, the motel sign with all its lights on was also highlighted in the opening credits.
The monster from season 1 episode 2 that recognize Julie. Just made my brain go into overdrive with Julie being a story walker
Wow this makes so much sense now
Omg. It makes so much sense now
I think Julie is Victor's sister.
Wait was does this mean ?
Yes. She is a story walker means she must have travelled to the past to meet these people. That's why they remember her. It also explains why martin knows her. The future version of julie must have met him in the past through story travelling.
Should we give this channel its flowers, they predicted alot of what happened this season
Yep
When Miranda died, that creature came running to kill her. But throughout the entire series, these creatures were only shown walking, and in this scene, that creature was running.
I noticed that too!!
I am assuming they can run, but only do so when they feel like it. They are immortal, after all.
Pretty sure they can run but they choose to walk to strike more fear/ tension
i think somewhere is explained that they changed behaviour when boyd found the stones. not sure if they also were running prior to that or what things did change.
@@meggi8048 it was said that they stopped shrieking but nothing mentioning. running
I dont think Julie saying that "this is when it happens" its about Jims death but a lot of them dying. She also said that she has to warn others in town, so I think it's something related to what happened to Victor before, when the creatures killed everyone. Maybe the man in yellow isn't the only one who can walk in daylight, and it might have something to do with the monster's rebirth.
Or maybe the man in yellow is going to hunt everyone
If they’re stuck in a time loop it can be another town massacre like what victor went through. It’s nuts this yellow jacket guy can walk around in the day
That was my theory episode 7 season 3! When victor was telling his story all the things he was experiencing as a kid was happening at the same time he was explaining ! I said man I think there all going to get slaughtered and it will start over again. But then I ask… why?
What if everybody gets killed as soon as they remember the past? Or at least when some of them do it, like Thabita and Jade...
Sara is how you create an Anti Hero. Somebody who literally hit rock bottom then realized that the only way out is UP! BEAUTIFUL SHOW! SEASON 3 WAS BEAUTIFUL!
Julie absolutely CAN change the story. She tossed the rope down to Boyd.
Hold on, it all makes sense how the rope got thrown down to Boyd. Martin was still changed to the wall. So obviously Julie was there when it originally happened.
But she was "storywalking" when that happened. She affected the story.
I think ultimately it will be the bootstrap paradox, different or changed events leading to same result, because that future exists because of the occurance of Julie travelling to past, to change said future. Maybe she just needs to not travel back
@@Psycheandsarcome Same. I think we have seen the "version" of the story where she tossed the rope down.
We now know there are time loops involved in more than one way (the reincarnation of Tabitha and Jade). My guess is that Julie (and Marielle and Randall) will be able to alter the original timeline, perhaps save the children from being sacrificed.
That episode was insane! We found out way more than I could have ever expected to.
Where?!?! Another finale with little reveals but no explanation into what and how the town is
@prestoncourtney346 Yeah, they’re keeping it going for at least two more seasons. They can’t give us all the answers, just some.
@@prestoncourtney346ok Mr inpatient how about you just don’t watch any current shows anymore and wait for every series to end so you can binge watch on a streaming platform. Every show has cliffhangers. Deal with it or watch it 3years from now
@@prestoncourtney346 Did you pay attention?? like at all?
We know why some maybe all the characters are there now. They cant explain it all that would ruin the mystery
@@amandawalker7739 yea but it really doesnt explain anything, all it does it just explains that Tabitha and Jade are reincarnations (this btw most likely tells us that in this universe everyone reincarnates but most people cant remember and are not connected to this place) and we also learnt that the monsters were once humans that made a sacrifice so that instead of reaincarnating they can live forever and not lose their memories but it somehow went down hill.
However we still dont know anything really, we dont know why this happened, we dont know what is the mysterious evil force that controls all of this, there is more questions than before.
I feel like the playing of the music notes unlocked and began the "endgame" of the cycle. Them "remembering" solidified their relationship (Tabby and Jade) so Jim had to go, The Town is purging the non essential players maybe as in anyone who isnt connected to somebody from a past cycle Jim was a vessel for Tabby to get to Fromville and now that shes remembered his purpose was served.. Feel like the countdown is on for them to either save the kids or die and the cycle begins again.
I kind of agree with this because Victoria hid that violin and they make a point of showing us that more than once. Maybe things get worse from here.
jim was very vital to overall story - he figured out signal thing in first season, he solved the numbers puzzle, which our genius jade couldn't, he was just not into threesome stuff perhaps
btw dont forget we have version of jim on town now - victor's father
I dont like it he was my fav character 😢
maybe the boy in white only drip-fed them information so they could prepare, otherwise they would have to do it all at once.
(i bet the whole next season is gonna take place over like 48 hours lol. that would be like them)
This is the first theory video I've stumbled across on this show. I never watched Lost, but I know a lot of people theorized about it together online, and I'm so excited to finally have a show where I can get a little bit of that experience. This show is such a good mystery. Anyway, thank you for an amazing video!
man in yellow was so scary even when I first saw him
it was so obvious that jim needed to run
You want a hug?
Jim being Jim was just waiting to die. Classic Jim
@@primal8700To be fair Julie was behind him. He couldn't abandon his daughter and MiY might target her if they ran together so he made sure his daughter was safe by telling her to run away while he stayed there holding back the man
@@beast266 okay, instead of saying these things, you can simply say "I'm Jim", it's enough
I think the children are saying 'anghkooey' instead of 'remember' as some kind of way to keep the creatures from understanding/finding them. It may keep them hidden somehow. Or if it was so long ago, perhaps it was the language that they spoke when they died.
I’m thinking it was their language back then
It was most likely the language they spoke at the time, but they never explicitly said what the exact time period was when the kids were killed right?
What I also found interesting that I haven't seen anyone talk about, that that the Ginger Demon, (Smiley) ran at her Miranda in the flashback. Kenny's character points in S1 how the monsters always just walk slowly, and never seem to run, simply because they do not have to. But when Miranda got close to the tree, Smiley ran to get her. It knew that she had to be stopped.
Genius
I do believe that the man in yellow is behind all the “visions” of Father Kadri , Boyds wife , Christofer etc . Him taking their shape and influencing Boyd and Jade , thought a familiar face . If he’s powerful enough to show up out of nowhere to kill Jim and stop Julie to keep the story in line , that means he’s deff powerful enough to do something like that . Which also ties in with the Dr.Mabuse theory
I was thinking the same thing. I had been wondering the entire show why some are having visions of "ghosts" and others having visions/ hearing voices from unknowns.
Which one is the Dr Mabuse theory??
I was legitimately expected the yellow man to say "It's me, I'm behind it all".
Still waiting on that giant spider.
maybe the man in yellow IS the giant spider
Maybe the giant spider was the friends we made along the way
that's his mount!
What giant spider?
@@Piffhefner try watching the show again but this time pay attention.
I still think about what Tabitha said in season 1, he asked Jim ''did we survive the crash?'' when they were writing on their wall, like if they are being controlled in some mind control thing.
Also Elgin said to Fatima that water is important when he was talking to her near the lake. After he talked with her in that scene, the water thing was never mentioned again. Water SEEMS to be an important thing in Town but they haven't figured it out yet. Maybe someone needs to swim deep down the lake and they''ll find something
Surprised no one has done that yet or even mentioned it. Also surprised this comment doesn’t have more likes, maybe it’s something that will come up next season 🤷🏾♂️
The rebirth of smiley seems to simply be the result of the ritual since they are the original people, Original Jade and Tabitha were also part of the ritual but didnt go through with it which is why they too are somewhat immortal as they always return as different people as Miranda, Christopher and Jade,Tabitha
Exactly they keep saving the kids breaking the rules of the game. They need to sacrifice the kids/ their own kid this time. Boy in white also
I think when tabitha got the phone call that distracted her long enough for thomas to roll off the changing table, it was from fromville in the future
Because that was necessary to set in motion the chain of events to bring her to the town?
i had that very same thought
How fucked up would it be if the next children's song in the show is "he rolled off the table, and onto the floor. And then my poor [meatball] rolled right out the door”
“Fromville”😂
@@Perfectlyimperfect9186 man people explaining this show turning themselves creative 😂
Just now finished watching. Completed it in 4 days. The explanation filled the small gaps I had. Thank you
i fking completed in 2 whole days and 1 night... literally insanse
The man in yellow has to be the final boss. Surely the one controlling everything that’s going on. Wow what an ending.
I think man in yellow must be the from the past when he was just immortal but not ghost, as time proceeds and they feed on souls and bodies they become like present ghost, So I think Julie went into past and tried to save his father
Or he's the entity the children's souls get fed to🤔
I thought the man in yellow was the guy on the radio from the first season
@@mitchnewland4916 He is.
Here's a thought. The show considers Julie a 'Storywalker.' When Victor remembered The Boy in White talking to Christopher, Victor said that "...and then they were murdered in the dark. But someone who loved them told them a story. This story gave them hope. And when the children laid on the stones, they poured their hopes into the roots the roots that made the symbol and those roots became the tree." Maybe that person who loved them was Tabitha or Jade, and the story that they told the children is somehow related to what is happening to the town.
Another thing that seems very likely moving into S4 is that Tabitha rekindles her connection with Viktor, and maybe even remembers what ended up happening to his sister, assuming she is still alive.
Randall also seems to know about this place, with insights like "Dying isn't the worst thing that can happen to you here..." certainly feels like he is the reincarnation of Martin. Being chained up like that in wherever he is for however long he has been there certainly seems like a fate worse than death.
Acosta can be the reincarnation of Victor's sister.
The man in yellow is terrifying. Not because of the way he looks or anything, but because of what he represents. He’s way out of place and especially during the day time. I can’t wait to see what happens.
And plus that yellow suit is horrifying
And with red eyes
i think the julie we saw at the end was Julie from the future cause she said "this is when it happens "
she might have story walked in the past cause she knew when he was going to die and she also said she have to change the story
Exactly, exactly
I thought the same, her hair is dyed pure black instead of her usual brunette, its also split in the middle and also her outfit is not what she wore before
Of she was from the future she had a haircut and way different clothing
Yes and this is probably why she didn’t run when Jim told her too
Jim casually just let dude rip his throat thinking he can beat the monster
he didnt know it was a monster as he has never seen one in the daytime before
I think that man in yellow guy was an entity or god of those monster thats. Why he can walk in daytime
@ well it’s someone he never seen before and plus the dude in yellow looks like a monster don’t look like a human
That means no one in the town will know about the man in yellow.
@@fletchedfps yeah true but Julie went back in the past to try to save him
Julie changed the story, now the monsters walk at night. Man this series is so good.
that scene where tabitha kneels down in front of the child and she says "anghkooey" i bust out laughing
same lmaooo
😂 😂 especially after Jade’s rant earlier on
LOL jokes aside. i think the kids are cursed by the evil entity that controls monster and towns people. The kids are cursed with not being allowed to say the actual word they are trying to say to Tabitha and Jade lol Instead of jade hearing "Remember" from the kids. All Jade can hear is Anhkoowee when in actuality the kids were saying "remember" lmao
Lmaooo I felt so bad for laughing I expected words not "anghkooey" again 😭
😂😂😂😂😂
I think that town massacre that was mentioned before happens when residents are close to knowing how to get out of that place or rather, when they remember how to do it because every one of them are equivalents of the first group and are somehow connected to them, like tabitha-miranda. The perpetrator of the massacre is the guy in yellow, who supervises it all from behind the curtains and when the inhabitants are close to solving it (the numbers are notes, the song is a lullaby that they sang to children, etc.) he resets the whole process by killing all the unaware residents in day time, thus resetting the entire group and the whole process begins start over with a new group. He is not affected by talismans or anything, so he can calmly start the process again with new unsuspecting participants, which is why each version of the group failed to solve the puzzle because when they get close, they are all simply killed by the guy in yellow.
That would maybe also explain why the child in white (potentially the good counterpart to the man in yellow?) can't explain anything to them
I just don't know what he gains during such a cycle and what his goal is, I doubt it's something as simple as feeding on their fear or failures
Why does the man in yellow not kill Julie instead of Jim? As a story walker Julie is the most dangerous person for him. Even Jade is much more dangerous for him, because he's the only one, who constantly tries to find the solution and is very close to it. Jim is just an irrelevant person in the whole story.
I think the man in yellow didn't plan to kill only Jim, I assume that after killing him he went for the rest including Julie.The guy in yellow appears and calmly just approaches jim, he doesn't pay attention to Jim telling him to move away, he just says his sarcastic remarks and kills him, he just came to end the party as he did every time with every group that was approaching a solution. Strange thing in that scene is that Man in yellow didn't say a word to or about julie or even notice her, but he has the same ironic-cynical way of speaking as monsters. The fact that convinces me to this theory is that victor, recalling the massacre, emphasized that it took place during the day time and normal monsters don't appear during day time unlike the Man in yellow
@@marcinkobylak5478 Well, if your theory is true, then we know, that Julie won't be killed, because the Future Julie is alive. Maybe a lot people get killed by the yellow guy, but not Julie. I guess, no person will get killed, which is important to the story in fromville.
Knowledge comes at a cost , I think he was talking about jade playing that violen sound that helped him gain knowledge about their past lives but at the cost of him being there too
Elgin is the cultist in the past, the soldier, the guy who drink blood in skeleteon, it was reincarnation to Elgin
Bro I was just thinking how fucking crazy that is that literally exactly what happened to Elgins eye was how the civil war soldier face was. I was having doubts that everything tied together in some meaningful way and was starting to fear they were making things up as they went along but this episode shows how every single thing we've seen from the start has meaning which is so satisfying
Not everyone there is a reincarnation.
@daethe Yeah but Elgin is.
Yeah Elgin is reincarnated because he dreamt of this place before even seeing the tree, just like Tabitha and her past version Miranda, only I don't know if that makes him one of the original people of the town or if he has any relation with the children like jayde and tabitha
OMG ELGIN AND THE PIONEER GUY DRINKING BLOOD FROM THE SKULL ARE MISSING THE SAME EYEBALL
Who is the pioneer I’m finding it difficult remembering
@@sheermoo1247 the creepy guy Jade saw in the snow this season, when Kristi fell over and caught in the bear trap
Woah.. Good one😮
Yep... everyone who entity talks to are reincarnation of town people from the past.... Julie, Jade, Victor, Miranda, Christopher, Tabitha's son, Boyd, Boy's wife, Elgin, Fatima. Looks like Yellow Man is targeting all people who are reincarnations like Julie or people who knows about the past or at least is able to solve all the mysteries like Jim lol
And the civil war soldier
0:22 That uniform must smell quite ripe now...
the man in yellow told jim that "knowledge always comes with a cost" . that tingled my cranium a bit. that led me to H.P lovecraft's redition of the king in yellow. he literally holds the secrets of the universe there and has the ability of manipulation and reincarnation with so much more.
he is also connected to "the king in yellow" play. it's like the town is going through a play of sorts. same characters played by different people.
This is also why the child in white won't reveal anything to them, potentially the man in yellows good counterpart?
So technically Boyd’s wife was right when she was killing people to send them “home” but little did she know they would be right back eventually
nope...how come then she did not show up?
Good point, I Think she was right
@@sgtbanjo she did, as acosta
@@dlouise64 now that was accident by a trigger happy cop...she was in great panic throwing bullets random.
What if the cop is his wife 😂
Whenever I'm in a group and I don't know what to speak, I just say 'ANGHKOOEY'
Actually Season 3 done a pretty good job, explaining not everything and the last scream of Jade representing not only our frustration but also the character's frustration as well. But I also agree with white Boy, See how difficult it was for Tabitha to admit she was/is Maranda, and if he came and tell them everything, who they are, what they should do, they will end up suspecting him and not beleiving that theory. Jim death was neccessary for entity to win. Just how amazing jim is, He just put small effort to understand the dates and he figure it out, or guessed it. He's the one who comes up with Tower. But entity didnt make his move because he was more concerned/scared about his family and just after he breaks that bubble, Enitity himself came to kill Jim, Because Jim is bigger threat to them as he is a f**king genius and Jade loved him lol. Jim is an outsider, He is nowhere connected with the place so maybe he didnt come in the contract, they form during the sacrifice.
Jim was right not to play the song T-T !!
The town aka the Evil entity that is controlling monsters and people manipulates easily, the people who are incarnations of past town people. I think it couldn't manipulate him so easily as it could with boyd, jade, christopher, miranda, julie, that guy with scars and hearing bugs, elgin, sarah, and victor. Jim was like the audience who already watched the show and knows the story lol so entity killed him off quick AF after that figuring out music notes lmao But i think Jim might get reincarnated in future season tho lol maybe Season 5 or 6.
I think even Jim was very important this episode the way he cooperated and brought the idea of the notes
thats why the man in yellow showed up to kill Jim. He opened the key for the 2 people.
Jim was killed because his doubt/fear was the only thing keeping Tabitha and Jade from figuring this place out. The man in yellow kept calling him to keep him afraid and let him know you better hold your wife back from figuring anything out. Once he started helping them he was done for
@@pandalace_ That makes sense when he pretended to be Thomas and kept calling him on the phone.
What a season finale 🤯
But I can't stop thinking about the little village where jim and kenny found the new food source.
When they stayed over night, they heard something walking around outside. And they said it sounded different from the monsters. So what was it? The man in yellow? Another kind of monster?
It sounded like a tree monster moving around. Maybe the totems come alive at night and will be mad that they stole their crops.
Hmmm so do you think the same for when Boyd and Sara went out and camped at night and their tent got attacked? Or you think that was a big ahh spider ?
@@bluechains3452 I always thought this!! That metal mannequins come to life!
Can't believe that the man in the yellow was the real bay harbor butcher all along
It’s over they know
Idk I have a feeling the boy in white is the son of the man in yellow and that the boy in white was the first to be sacrificed or killed and the man in yellow was the first to become immortal and maybe that's why they're special since they were the first and they're probably son and father.
Same with Victor and Henry..
I think the boy in white was meant to be sacrificed as well but he got away. When Tabitha and Jade both remember that Ankhooey means "remember", Jade says "We tried to save them, because one of them.." I think he was about to say "one of them escaped and told us they were going to kill the others"
I thought he was about to say because one of them was our daughter but what you said is also interesting @FieryFlamingFajitas
@@FieryFlamingFajitas Tabitha said they had a daughter, I think that's what they meant. Miranda couldn't see the boy in white, it was Victor who told her about it. Tabitha also couldn't see the boy in white (apart from the lighthouse scene where no one else but the boy could show her the way) but her son could. Interesting correlation. Also Ethan almost instinctively seen the boy in white as good, as his friend. What if the first "Tabitha and Jade" had two kids?
no@@FieryFlamingFajitas, he was gonna say one of them was ours
Greatest series I’ve seen since in a long time
Your breakdowns are the only thing helping me to survive this show LOL. Thank you.
When Boyd killed Smiley he said ''My Blood is your blood'' this is how Fatima got pregnant with Smiley, He is basically the grandchild of Boyd now.
Oh yeaa😭😭
No it isn't, you don't pay attention to shit. She was literally already pregnant, and was about to tell Ellis when he got stabbed. Then after that is when Boyd gave him the transfusion. So no, you're objectively incorrect. How would that even make sense? The worms killed Smiley, why would they help revive him? You think Smiley's blood got into Boyd or something? You're forgetting one thing guy, Kristy did the autopsy on him. The bodies are shriveled up and the organs are desiccated. There is no blood flowing in their veins.
The villagers sacrificed their children for immortality. The more likely explanation is some kind of curse within the town, and pregnancies are are vulnerable to being effectively hijacked if a villager dies, they get reborn. Immortality doesn't have to mean invincibility. She was most likely legitimately pregnant, and his soul was able to overcome and consume the pregnancy and take its place.
@@daethe 90% of theories surrounding this show actually make me want to jump off a cliff.
It's either bullshit that watching one episode can disprove or just straight up nonsense people just say for no reason. It's so frustrating
@@Toast2005 thats what makes it fun and interesting to talk about. If a show is just downright fact of the matter and easy to get, no one would talk about it cuz everything is easily explained and solved.
@sparda9060 Yeah but that doesn't mean they make sense. People just say random shit because of head cannon. It's like they don't even try and make it make it sense
Remember in season 1 when the monster asked Julie if she remembers him? Now it all makes sense
Julie coming back in time was the knowledge the man in yellow was saying comes at a cost. so julie coming back is the reason jim dies creating a time loop. If you watch the man in yellow when he says that knowledge comes at a cost hes looking at julie then looks over to jim meaning hes saying it to julie about her coming back in time
Julie came from the future to prevent Jim's death.
It could be, but it could also be implying the knowledge of the towns people that wanted to be immortal.
I think the knowledge comes at a cost part was more so tied to Tabitha and jade remembering the past lives and what happened to the kids. The man in yellow wants to prevent them from knowing and breaking the cycle
I think Julie just figured out who that guy was right then and there. She didn’t give off the vibe that she knew what the man in yellow was yet, that must have been her first time seeing him. She only knew her dad dies that day by there old RV. If she knew the man in yellow I believe she would know how dangerous he is and made Jim run off away from him.
I agree 💯%! Knowledge comes at a price meant Julie figuring out she could time walk and then her using that knowledge to try and change the story is why the man in yellow punished her by killing her dad again.
Boyd is often shown wearing a yellow shirt, he was wearing it in this episode as well. Could also be some reference to the book " the king in yellow" and being lost in carcosa like they talked about in true detective
WOAHHH
I'm just glad that they finally gave Victor more scenes, I always though his character was the key to many things, since he's been there the longest, he grew up there, is friends with the boy in white, who knows the towns deepest darkest secrets, but most of season 1 and 2 focused on other useless characters that doesn't help in solving the puzzles. At least now we know more, because they finally decided to give a bit of a focus on Victor's story, his past especially, and his father also gave important information. This season is great, hopefully season 4 will be just as good.
Evil songs blast radius!
Jade is dope!
I really like Jade
Randel is martin because randel didn’t fear dying, he rather to than being there eternally suffering
Angkoey
Nah
There is a quote from Dracula: "There are worse things than death" is what he says to Jonathan Harker, the frightened young man who at the beginning of the book is sent to Transylvania for the negotiations of the castle and who at the end of the story will kill Dracula to save his soul.
Someone watching this channel has insider behind the scenes knowledge as I read a comment under one of your previous predictions videos (think it was ep.7) that mentioned spoilers - stating that Julie would turn up with short hair from the future, Jim was going to die and a man in yellow appears, exactly what happened! I couldnt believe someone had mentioned it in your comments 3 eps ago!
Someone dumped a bunch of spoilers to the season finale several weeks ago to Reddit and other places, and they all turned out to be true.
@@c_huntermc script got leaked huh...
The tension in every From season be like
Start of Season: Crazy shit happens, impossible to wait for the next episode 😱
Middle of Season: Characters just strolling around town and talking leading to nowhere 🥱
End of Season: Get the answers of the seasons's mystery but introduce new mystery for the next season 🤯
I only watched like 2 seasons of Lost can anyone tell me is Lost like this every season as well?
@@voizcrack yes
And this is why I refuse to watch this show.
@@voizcrackI do feel that Lost answers enough of the questions by the end but it takes way too long to get there. I didn’t love any of the characters enough to watch every single episode of each season. Recaps on UA-cam are awesome for this.
@@voizcrack yes. its basically the same show with monsters
I kept seeing this show mentioned around my UA-cam feed and decided to try it out. Omg this show is insane! It’s so good it has me completely locked in. I literally binged all 3 seasons in the last month. Can’t wait for season 4 cuz I have so many more questions.
Ethan is the Man in yellow. The storymaker. Sarah was rightfully being told to kill him in order to free everyone
And her killing the second guy in the car with jade? How does that relate if Ethan was supposedly the evil man in yellow?
That would defeat the whole premise of the show
How when Tabitha is Miranda so that must mean that Ethan is Victor and Julie is elose and Jim is Victor's dad wich means that Thomas must be the boy in white or he Can be the man in yellow 🤔
@@bjsworld-gf6kh But can Ethan be Victor if Victor is still alive? Same with Jim and Henry? I would assume there would be only one version of someone at the same time. And I don't think it has to follow the current family lines. Because Tabitha had a child with Jade, now they are not a couple. She later came back as Miranda and had Victor and Eloise with Henry, while Jade was there as Christopher. Now as Tabitha she's with Jim and has Julie and Ethan. So the story must unfold atleast a little bit different each time.
Ethan is one of the ones who can stop the man in yellow that's why she was being told to kill him.
All the children of the 'reincarnations' have abilities. Ethan, Victor, Julie .. the boys can see "the boy" (who I'm thinking may be another child of previous reincarnations) and Julie can story walk
I wonder if Eloise saved herself by story walking
The boat. They've got to travel out of From on running salt water BETWEEN WORLDS to break magical charms, avoid magical creatures, and get home. That could mean ocean water, or the galaxy, metaphorically. Probably ocean water because space ain't salty. But the ancients thought it might be. And that's really all that matters.
and then hear me out, the ship they're on, crashes on an island...and maybe this island happens to be in the south pacific, but it has been known to be other places at other times. It happens around the time a plane crashes at the island too.
Ok I admit I lost track on this
Does anyone else remember Boyd seeing a lighthouse before he went into a faraway tree???
Yes with Sara. But i don't remember if he has told anyone about seeing the lighthouse.
My theory!!!
Julie cannot influence things directly. I think in the future, she will try to help multiple times and eventually realize that only the residents themselves can change things somehow. The boy in white hinted at this as well. In the future, she will decide to only assist indirectly and from a distance. All the clues, I believe, are left by her, Julie, and Eloise.
(Why Eloise? Because she’s Victor’s sister, and Julie is her reincarnation. Eloise is definitely alive and will later meet Julie. Or maybe she’s trapped by the man in yellow.)
Randall is a tragic analog of the guy hanging on the wall. If everyone dies again, he might pass these insects to a future version of Boyd. He might commit suicide, leaving his spirit tied to the wall or something like that.
Another thought: if you wish to die by your own will, death won’t save you from this place, and you become its ghost, so you still can’t escape. If the current residents die, only Ethan will remain. His thoughts about not wanting to forget what his Asian grandmother looked like remind me of how Victor also didn’t want to forget, which is why he drew and collected keepsakes. Ethan will probably come to this conclusion too.
I think the boy in white might also be another version of Victor or Ethan who killed himself and became a ghost. It’s like a game-eliminated players (i.e., previous residents) can’t participate anymore, even if they somehow survived. They still remain prisoners of this place.
Only the current residents/players have the ability to significantly change anything.
What do you mean by, 'her, Julie and Eloise?' you mentioned Julie twice or was it a typo?
@ typo
Your wife shouldn’t have dug that hole, Jim.
Im glad they finally tied back to that. One thing answered from 2 seasons ago lol
I didn't get it
@@Blackstar-yd3yf He was the one on the radio lmao..even the guy in the video says it...sweetie how slow can you be...but love you
@@nemishka93 I m disabled sorry 😐
@@nemishka93 How slow can you be?
Listen to the little subtle Bible references in FROM.
Boyd being called "Mr. Fish and loaves"
Boyd's last name Stevens being derived from St. Stephen's, the first Christian Matyr put to death after Jesus.
Boyd's wife Abby name means "Church or Monestry"
Fr. Kathri saying the Church in town is like no other Church he's seen before ( probably because Abby is a play on words)
Ellis who is Boyd's son name literally means "God is my Father"
Fr. K telling Boyd to come down off his cross because he can't save everyone.
Martin saying that the town was "Just the tip of the spear" instead of "tip of the iceberg" alluding to the Spear of Destiny.
Fr. K saying there's no Bibles in town and also Book 74 isn't written yet but possible can be with the whole town.
Martin telling Boyd, "My blood is your blood" parallel to Christ and the Last Supper when Jesus told the disciples to drink his blood and eat his flesh.
The last episodes being named "Revelations.
The Boy in White saying"the end is the beginning" referencing the Book of Genesis which literally means "The Beginning "
The Tree in the road is either the Tree of Life or the Tree of Knowledge in The Garden of Eden.
The painting of Ellis and Fatima that parallels Adam and Eve (But I believe that Fatima represents Lilith)
Lilith gave birth to Demons in a Datk Cave much like the Boy in White said the monsters were born in the dark and why Fatima had Smiley in a dark root cellar.
Acosta calls Boyd "God King" when venting to Kenny about her gun and treatment.
There's a theory about a Flood coming to town and we know that Boyd owns a boat.
The Polaroid Camera that shows a picture of Boyd's house and Boyd even saying that his "Boat was missing" (But why would he say that when he only learned that Abby bought him a boat while driving before they came across the Tree and he never seen it in person.
There are 12 Talisman's and Christ had 12 disciples.
Boyd stating the Town can't break him much like Job in the Bible who the Devil waged against God that he could Break Job so he would turn his back on God.
Martin chained up looks like Jesus on the Cross along with 2 other skeletons mirroring the Crucifixion of Jesus and the 2 thieves.
And plenty more Bible or Religous elements that aren't just a coincidence.
Wow
This is genius
Wow
That is a very good breakdown of the bible/christianity connections.
Also I'd like to add that we already saw a few biblical plagues come to be in the show. The cicadas and famine.
Never grew up or cared about Christianity beyond a bit of fun with Supernatural, so this is a genuine question. Would the man in yellow then be one of the horsemen? Doesn't each one have a specific color?
Martin said the monsters were the tip of the spear and the town was the worst part
Whew thank god for Sarah but know knowing Jade and Tabitha had a baby together is mind blowing and they keep coming back to save them , Julie going back or in the future now because she had short her she may have tried to save Jim a few times. And poor Jim, but the man in yellow now they have a daytime monster! Can't wait for season 4🎉
Tabitha had too many husbands one had to go. Poor Jim just when he started not being so annoying again.
The boat is not at the picture of the house because Boyd has never seen his house with the boat because they were surprising him with it on the trip there
The theme song for the show states "whatever will be will be" which I think they chose that song because as the stories continually tell themselves through numerous generations, the same things have happened and as Ethan said, the chapters and stories cannot be changed.
A town wide search by every member of the town, and nobody thinks of checking the root cellar for Fathima. A place that people from the town have been before and know it exists, and know where it is.
Just incredible 😂
Actually they checked there too but the the second door was hidden and Fatima was silent.
@@PungeonMon No they didn’t
@@waynedonoghue4071 They actually did check, but if you remember as Fatima screams weren't heard because her mouth was covered by the ghost. and you couldn't have known about the hidden room.
@@waynedonoghue4071 they already checked, elgin and ellis already checked the cellar and tabitha and victor were in that same cellar when fatima was missing
Rewatch the episode ! The cellar was checked multiple times.
The man in yellow is surrounded by RED in the painting. The monster is RED is the wall painting, if colors matter, the man in yellow might be an avatar for the monster. He seems to be a tier higher than the rest of the night monsters. The kimono lady is also something else, maybe some forest creature unknown so far. She can manifest as a spirit and in the physical plane at the same time...
If you think about it Julie being a story walker gives her the ability to change things because had she not entered the ruins and throw the rope down for Boyd then I'm pretty sure Boyd was fucked, this tells us she can alter things that have happen.
Good point and that’s why Jim won’t be dead.
Just realised the characters are not gonna find out about the man in yellow until Julie story walks which by then it’ll probably be too late
They will if she tells them. She need to talk to Boyd first though. And tell him about Martin.
@ but the point is that the Julie Jim just saw was a storywalker from the future, what I’m saying is I don’t think the ppl in the present will know about the man in yellow until she takes that exact walk we jus saw her take, she’ll obviously end up telling them but I think he’ll do more dmg before Julie goes to try save Jim
Thankyou! I said the same thing. The town folk will have no idea what happened to Jim.
@@mritachi3878 They will know if Julie tells them. Just like she can tell Boyd about Martin and how she threw a rope down to help him. That’s the biggest issue with them now. They absolutely don’t communicate with each other like they should.
@@dagod8418 bruh... This is what I mean. She can't tell them this until this event happens in the future, in other words they will not know the circumstances of Jim's death until Julie wakes up from seizure at the ruins sometime in the future!
Finally a great episode! To bad we have to wait a couple years for the next season 😫😩
It’s more like a year and 2 months.
@@the.average.studentsThey are dramatic
This wait is gunna suck 😢
But now you have the answers. So let's see fans will comeback.
@@Tracy.W yep. I heard it’s not due until winter 2026 😢
This is one of series ineed to binge re watch again after s4
I've been confused throughout this season. I wish I found your channel sooner. How you connected things is so good.