Sufism In India | Dostcast 153 w/ Rana Safvi

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 23 сер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 498

  • @nerf2752
    @nerf2752 Рік тому +11

    🚨In case people forgot.🚨
    Religious leader of ajmer dargah, khadim sarwar chishti asked for behe@ding nupur sharma.
    source - Ajmer Dargah Cleric Arrested Over Incendiary Remark Against Nupur Sharma

  • @manishadwani386
    @manishadwani386 Рік тому +44

    First devdutt and then Rana ? Bro i think great to talk to people with opposing worldview and who you may not agree but to bring actual disingenious people is a stretch.

    • @devvratmishra9000
      @devvratmishra9000 Рік тому

      Harbans mukhia phir bhi badhiya rehta although he's no less than irfan Habib or romila thapar but he's still someone from the feild.

    • @ksb_067
      @ksb_067 Рік тому +4

      Bro wo uska podcast hai aur usko dusre concepts aur views ko discover krne k liye kisi se conversation krna pade toh kya galat hai jab woh Abhijit Iyer Mitra , abhijeet chavda ko Lata hai toh phir left walo ko problem hoti hogi bhai agar hum right ke hai toh kam se hume ye toh pta hona ki left ke scholars ke views kya hai taki hum usme se galat batao aur myths ko debunk kr sake

    • @devvratmishra9000
      @devvratmishra9000 Рік тому +4

      @@ksb_067
      Uttam , but humara bhi right hai ki hum inke views ko tatti kahein

    • @ksb_067
      @ksb_067 Рік тому

      @@devvratmishra9000 bhai theek per hume left wing jaise nhi behave nhi krna chahiye agar hum sab cheezo bss ek hi nazar se dekhenge toh phir toh galat hi hai na

    • @devvratmishra9000
      @devvratmishra9000 Рік тому +3

      @@ksb_067
      Bhai dekh parakh kar tatti bol raha hoon aise hi nhi bola , Abhijit ka poora podcast hai regarding ganga jamuni tehzeeb , is lady rana safvi ji ka bhi poora Twitter timeline hai for everybody to see jahan ye food jihad faila rahein hain.

  • @Vikii2024
    @Vikii2024 Рік тому +154

    When islam is exposed but u still hope sufism might work against these kafirs .

    • @sushil6509
      @sushil6509 Рік тому

      Sufis did more jehad than any other sect of islam

    • @blahblah05
      @blahblah05 Рік тому +5

      Faxx

    • @abhinav865
      @abhinav865 Рік тому +17

      killer of kanahiya lal where followers of sufi saint of ajmer sharif 🙄🙄🙄

    • @real_Raxter
      @real_Raxter Рік тому +2

      Hat mad@rsa chap

    • @justnobody2172
      @justnobody2172 Рік тому

      @@nischesharma Mohammad ka Lund marte time khada tha 😅😅😁💯✌🏻

  • @nancgeorge4537
    @nancgeorge4537 Рік тому +232

    After this bring Sanjay Dixit who has thoroughly exposed sufism

    • @blahblah05
      @blahblah05 Рік тому +21

      Hell yes

    • @mantajsinghdhillon8840
      @mantajsinghdhillon8840 Рік тому +7

      It’s one’s own wish what to practice and what not don’t become a nazi

    • @nancgeorge4537
      @nancgeorge4537 Рік тому +15

      @@mantajsinghdhillon8840 Try telling this to the Jihadees

    • @ric_clicks9195
      @ric_clicks9195 Рік тому +1

      @@nancgeorge4537 how is this woman related to Jihadis?

    • @ric_clicks9195
      @ric_clicks9195 Рік тому

      @@vikki4957 I haven't listened to the guy in the context. But I believe that the idea isn't the problem, it's the interpretation of the idea by an individual that's the problem. Surely, this woman isn't a jihadee but she still follows this particular idea that you claim is related to them. But the way she has interpreted the idea didn't make her a Jihadee and I'm sure there are many like her.

  • @sarthakarya02
    @sarthakarya02 Рік тому +73

    She is just another version of Romila Thapar

    • @aminabdullah6376
      @aminabdullah6376 Рік тому +11

      Halal version 😹

    • @aminabdullah6376
      @aminabdullah6376 Рік тому +6

      Idk man, atleast you can laugh at Thapar, this was just plain boring...

    • @Temüjin_3162
      @Temüjin_3162 Рік тому

      Low budget one

    • @saterdraj6768
      @saterdraj6768 Рік тому

      What book by Romila Thapar have you read?

    • @sarthakarya02
      @sarthakarya02 Рік тому

      @@saterdraj6768 Ncert books, History of India Vol 1 and 2, instead of reading this shit author read books of Sita Ram Goel ji, Rajiv Malhotra, sanjay Dixit, vikram sampat, Sandeep balkrishna, Meenakshi Jain, j Sai Deepak, Sanjeev sanyal etc etc

  • @ReligioCritic
    @ReligioCritic Рік тому +121

    I just hope she doesn't glorify sufi saints(or rather monsters) like Moinuddin Chisti of Ajmer Sufi Dargah(the guy who claimed to have caught and handed over Samrat Prithiviraj Chauhan to army of Islam,i.e, the army of Muhammad Ghori) and Nizamuddin Auliya who literally cursed polytheism and said that all polytheists will burn in hell.
    Sufism looks beautiful from outside but, it's literally "Bhhed ki khaal mei Bhediya".
    Source: M.A Khan's book Islamic Jihad.
    Edit: Oh i just realized this lady Rana Safvi has been trying to whitewash the atrocities of Mughals by using fake stories of Rakshabandhan and Diwali being celebrated by Mughals.

    • @gyanshodhak
      @gyanshodhak Рік тому +19

      she will probably do exactly this

    • @blahblah05
      @blahblah05 Рік тому +7

      We will not fall prey to this

    • @ronitlenka9205
      @ronitlenka9205 Рік тому

      Podcast dekhna hai to Ranveer Allahbadia ka dekho.
      This channel doesn't provide quality.

    • @ReligioCritic
      @ReligioCritic Рік тому +6

      @@ronitlenka9205 I would say Vinamre is way better than Ranveer, because Ranveer asks questions as if he is taking an interview and not doing a podcast. I don't have anything against Vinamre but, i don't like this lady.

    • @shailendra9564
      @shailendra9564 Рік тому

      @@ronitlenka9205 😂😂 ya talking all nonsense, stupid ghost stories, Hanuman saving only him,other such pseudoscience and bullshit..
      Only gobar bhakt association members can like what ranveer is doing nowadays because low IQ levelbis required to understand his topics
      He started good, now he is what a chaatu does and

  • @harshshelar
    @harshshelar Рік тому +16

    You just brought a Mughal sympathizer.

  • @CuriousManish09
    @CuriousManish09 Рік тому +42

    Why these people do not call gems like j Sai Deepak...

    • @real_Raxter
      @real_Raxter Рік тому +10

      Exactly kal hi vaad yt channel pe dekhe the 2 episodes
      Itna informative and straight to the point

    • @ad8331
      @ad8331 Рік тому

      Because he is not fit to have a podcast along with. Let him be good for debates.

  • @mjj9482
    @mjj9482 Рік тому +40

    Why it is problematic to some people if we ask factual questions... If sufism so peaceful why were lakhs of Hindus massacred and why are so many mazars keep popping up out of no where on roads . Why can't we have discussion on good and bad things about other religions it is only limited for Hinduism

    • @real_Raxter
      @real_Raxter Рік тому +3

      Exactly

    • @ad8331
      @ad8331 Рік тому +1

      Dude Sufis never massacred Hindus, it was the Wahabis, Barelvis and Salafis who did it.

    • @rutvikrs
      @rutvikrs Рік тому

      ​@SAM33R I think you have been fed a story without history, don't take my word, research:
      1. Moinddin Chisti did come with the Ghurid army, Ghori to be specific. He aids in his campaigns against Prithviraj Chauhan.
      2. Hindus started worshipping at his shrine much later during waves of deislamising and gentrification due to the fall of Muslim empires. Prithviraj Raso is definitely wrong but so are the Turkic sources from which Hindus worshipping him are conjured up. Fun fact the same texts mention Jai Chand, Prithviraj's general being in possession of 700 dragons which Chisti drives away with a magical barrier.
      3. The graves of
      Babur: Taken to Afghanistan, intact till today.
      Shah Jahan: catacombs of Taj Mahal
      Akbar: Near Delhi but destroyed and defiled by the Jat army.
      Aurangzeb: Khuldabad, MH. Survived multiple attempts of destruction. Restored by ASI.

    • @rutvikrs
      @rutvikrs Рік тому

      ​@@ad8331 Sufi history is complex but the majority of them were not good by the standards of those days and today. There are some Sufis who were sanitized, some who were non discriminatory but were bullied by the Ullema into taking several anti Hindu/Buddhist/Jain practices.
      Please pick up the historical documents of any Sufi place and read the original sources. It's horrendous. I have a second cousin in Pune whose family were ardent followers of a mazar in North Karnataka l. The person learned Turkic and Persian to understand his spiritual master better. He wanted to create a website to promote tourism. In the course of five years of reading the original sources, he turned kattar Hindu. He returned from US and has started working for Hindutva organisations.
      This negationism is what causes a majority of Hindus to be suspicious of Muslims. When Hindus can be critical of their own religious practices and community leaders, it's disappointing to see Muslims not do the same. This effort should have come from within, decades ago.

    • @SURESHK-pune
      @SURESHK-pune Рік тому

      Sufis were helpful to Hindus

  • @nobitalulu7067
    @nobitalulu7067 Рік тому +26

    Vinamre what are you doing man !

    • @real_Raxter
      @real_Raxter Рік тому +1

      Yep pta nhi kya chu panti chal rhi hai
      Kuch ache avashya hai jaise lakshay Chaudhary wala

  • @djmoh.6509
    @djmoh.6509 Рік тому +18

    They use light Noor to cover there dark face .

  • @karun_vv7190
    @karun_vv7190 Рік тому +58

    25:32 Meditation and Namaaz are not the same things. Meditation is about realisation, to connect with roots of nature, to empty yourself completely from all that is man made, to forget even a single word that man has created, to feel and realise.

    • @weiwei7571
      @weiwei7571 Рік тому +2

      Let me give you a brief explanation my brother what namaz is? read it mindfully!
      The Salah (namaz) is the second pillar after Shahada - Ashadu an la ilaha illa illa-ilah, wa ashadu anna muhammadan rasul ullah meaning, “there is no god but Allah, and Muhammad is the messenger of Allah”.
      The word salah (in Arabic: ‏صلاة‎) is used by Muslims across the globe and refers to the daily prayer. But prayer is also said by Arabic words “dua” and “dhikr” both meaning prayer. The actual meaning of the word in Salah or Salat in Arabic means connection, contact, or communication.
      It is referring to establishing a connection with the creator, Allah subhanahu wa ta’ala. By praying Salah you are seeking nearness to Allah and are nurturing that relationship through worship. Allah has made prayer mandatory for all Muslims for many reason.
      1. As a mean of self-purification.
      2. Spirituality
      3. To spend time in remembrance of him (i.e. to prevent you from wrongdoing).
      4. Source of strength and patience.
      5. For bringing peace and tranquility to your life.
      6. Distinguishing between a believer and a non-believer (kafir).
      7. As a mean for erasing your sins and seeking forgiveness.
      8. Developing good character and discipline.

    • @karun_vv7190
      @karun_vv7190 Рік тому +12

      @@weiwei7571 it's more like you need to remind yourself again and again that there is not got but "Allah". Ofcourse it's your belief do what you want to, but it's a fact that it divides you and others. Mediation is about connecting to soil where you born . Realising god is within everything. Not limited by one name or one section. How is it meditation, when you keep reminding yourself which is based on faith and not exploring. Mediation works as the field where one asks the question "why". It's a realm where faith has no place but realisation. That's why i said Namaz cannot be compared with meditation because the purposes itself is very different.

    • @jidrit999
      @jidrit999 Рік тому +11

      true. desert ideology cannot fathom what meditation is. They just want heaven

    • @karun_vv7190
      @karun_vv7190 Рік тому +4

      @Rehan Sheikh this is what Namaaz do to you.. while Meditation makes you realise that even this person is a creature of this beautiful mother nature. To realise God you have to see pass God. To listen to God, you have to let go of all the words that man has created. Don't worry Sheikh this is not for you. You will discard this as devil's words. This is for those who actually see pass the word of man and finally see what is beyond.

    • @SP-wg9bb
      @SP-wg9bb Рік тому

      True ..no hate but both arent relatabke at all

  • @zameenaasmaan6039
    @zameenaasmaan6039 Рік тому +11

    Bhai Content se kaam nahi chal raha toh Comment section se engagement lene par aa gaye itni jaldi?? Ye ummeed toh nah thi.
    I read somewhere that she is the same lady who once said the crap that.. Mughals brought and started the culture of Rakshabandhan in India.
    Would suggest if you can bring people like Sudhanshu Dwivedi; you and the audience all will going to learn many things.

    • @lacchaaparatha
      @lacchaaparatha Рік тому

      Sudhanshu trivedi boht toxic sa hai or uska face thoda तोते jesa h pr bhai

  • @arj7424
    @arj7424 Рік тому +34

    Sufism is Hindu o ko pagal banata hi

  • @theniravpanchal
    @theniravpanchal Рік тому +37

    Bhai You are on Wrong track.

  • @kapildangra4975
    @kapildangra4975 Рік тому +6

    Why don't you bring Sanjay Dixit....... this woman just said raksha bandhan was started by Mughals 💀💀💀

  • @karun_vv7190
    @karun_vv7190 Рік тому +7

    My only Criticism is this, when she talks about people of God, she is referring to all humans and animals or just people who follow that particular thing because Islam makes it very clear who is and is not people of God, believer and non believers. Either she does not know this or not saying it, that actually we non believers are going to hell anyways.

  • @iamhb1006
    @iamhb1006 Рік тому +72

    Thank you for bringing her. Her lies has already been exposed many times but i find it cute. Still trying so hard hoping people will believe her.

    • @deception6666
      @deception6666 Рік тому +1

      It is easy to believe her than to believe that ,there are many Gods..lol
      N monkey and elephant are one of them

    • @nambardarumeshgurjar519
      @nambardarumeshgurjar519 Рік тому +1

      @@deception6666 well , prophet goes on donkey back to heavens 😂 and cut moon in two halves now that believable, MADARSACHAP

    • @ydl589
      @ydl589 Рік тому

      @@deception6666 i will rather choose to worship a monkey or elephant than a maniac, pedophile, pervert woh become great by dividing people

    • @arp637
      @arp637 Рік тому

      @@deception6666 lmao, muhammad flew on a half donkey half men to moon 🤣🤣

    • @mangopudding5979
      @mangopudding5979 Рік тому

      Her lies were exposed? How? Could you please explain?

  • @piyushpahilwani770
    @piyushpahilwani770 Рік тому +10

    1 question to her :- Agar islam itna superior religion h toh... Usse chorne pe death kyu h quran m.

  • @mrityunjay1055
    @mrityunjay1055 Рік тому +42

    People in comments need to take a chill pill. Why so much resentment against those who have a different world-view. Infact its good that people who are not typically pro Hinutva/Right/Indic wing as per what you believe, are coming on podcasts.
    For eg I heard Rana Safvi today, I have also heard Sanjay Dixit on multiple occasions. After hearing to Rana Safvi's purvapasha, I can safely say Sanjay Dixit has stronger points.

    • @Anonymous-st3gy
      @Anonymous-st3gy Рік тому

      Kya kare iss podcast ne unfortunately chutiyo ko attract kiya hai :l

    • @thendino1
      @thendino1 Рік тому +1

      Because some folks are trying to hide what Sufism was really all about. You should thank ppl in the comments section who are exposing the BS and lies being spread on purpose.

    • @real_Raxter
      @real_Raxter Рік тому +7

      Why the hell will we be chill when a g-hadi is on a podcast

    • @deception6666
      @deception6666 Рік тому

      Listen elite islamic scholars , then islam will make more sense to you.

    • @valmikivaani
      @valmikivaani Рік тому +2

      Hate them as they Hate you or perish. However I think you come from right place except that you sound a bit convinced by Rana's hogwash

  • @Vaishnavi1
    @Vaishnavi1 Рік тому +18

    Sufism is all about love and light and the formula for water is H2SO4.

  • @dr.ankitamishra6803
    @dr.ankitamishra6803 Рік тому +39

    Negative role of sufis should also be brought to light, like in kashmir as the front army of Islamists.

  • @saitandale8482
    @saitandale8482 Рік тому +17

    Kitna badal gaya re tu 😂😂😂😂😂 content ke naam par

    • @rashidrazakhan9153
      @rashidrazakhan9153 Рік тому +1

      Bhai kiya BDL gya, bhut sare perspective h logo ke alg alg.
      Ye admi bas jaan na chahtha h

    • @real_Raxter
      @real_Raxter Рік тому

      @@rashidrazakhan9153 flat earth prove kar puncture putra

    • @THENKSHOW_q
      @THENKSHOW_q Рік тому +1

      @@rashidrazakhan9153 rapist rasool koi prophet nhi hota

  • @NC-zu7mm
    @NC-zu7mm Рік тому +17

    I'm happy to see people are aware of Sufism ( the Invader , betrayals , they are not muslim according to wahabis)

  • @sahil.xzz0
    @sahil.xzz0 Рік тому +85

    Dislaimer: Sufism is not a part of Islam and a sufi is not a Muslim, this is the opinions of most of the Islamic scholars. They change Islam according to their mood.

    • @abhinav865
      @abhinav865 Рік тому +19

      I like wahabis and sunni more atleast they are honest to there religion and also to the kafirs

    • @sahil.xzz0
      @sahil.xzz0 Рік тому +2

      @@abhinav865 There is no sect exist as wahabism, people just claim salafis to be wahabis

    • @syedussadat422
      @syedussadat422 Рік тому

      Sufi is not a muslim ..... any proof ??

    • @sahil.xzz0
      @sahil.xzz0 Рік тому

      @@syedussadat422 ask any islamic scholar who is from Ahle sunnah al jammah, they will tell you the truth and the ideology of sufism

    • @syedussadat422
      @syedussadat422 Рік тому

      @@sahil.xzz0 i want know from you...
      As you told this

  • @vikata5499
    @vikata5499 Рік тому +8

    She is so कर्कश to listen. My ears are hurting arter 30 sec.

    • @JS-mn4xs
      @JS-mn4xs Рік тому +2

      Yeah same issue with me..i was interested to listen to her to get a different perspective but inki awaaj se hi irritation ho gaya shuru mei so couldn't watch at all

    • @ioy6966
      @ioy6966 Рік тому

      Use smoothing software

  • @friendlyvimana
    @friendlyvimana Рік тому +17

    have a bad bad feeling about this one.

  • @valmikivaani
    @valmikivaani Рік тому +3

    For all the Kumbaya singers in the comment section, she herself says they came with the marauders rapists, the so called army, how much more obvious it has to be that these Sufis were either spys or part of the contingent destroying Bharat

  • @kratik52000
    @kratik52000 Рік тому +3

    Vinamre i love your podcasts but this woman is a hypocrite trying to show how good islam is , which it definitely isn't sorry bro but really disappointed

  • @humshuklajihain9173
    @humshuklajihain9173 Рік тому +21

    I say Eww to Sufism.

  • @HamidKhan-sk3dn
    @HamidKhan-sk3dn 2 місяці тому +1

    Amazingly insightful and conveyed with a lot of love for Allah and humanity. So easy-going and still hugely deep and honest. Bravo ms.Rana safvi. Live long and keep doing the good job!

  • @blahblah05
    @blahblah05 Рік тому +10

    BREAKING NEWS : DOSTCAST HOST VINAMRE'S HEAD GONE MISSING

  • @Bh_di_ss
    @Bh_di_ss Рік тому +55

    Big L from my side for bringing her

    • @devvratmishra9000
      @devvratmishra9000 Рік тому +12

      Mera bhi isse badhiya to devdutt Pattnaik hi tha , aur devdutt Pattnaik kitna bada wala hai 😭😭😭lekin isse phir bhi badhiya hai.

    • @aayushhh95
      @aayushhh95 Рік тому +3

      Its kind of fine, though. You need different thoughts for bringing about a variety in perspectives. Let them speak, and then we can have our counter perspectives. Dialogue is important.

    • @sohan7068
      @sohan7068 Рік тому +7

      Unsubscribed

    • @ninadkulkarni8198
      @ninadkulkarni8198 Рік тому +4

      Massive L

    • @shravan.rabari
      @shravan.rabari Рік тому +1

      Bro editors deleting comment lol,
      Itne intellectual bante ho freedom of speech vagera per comment delete kyu kar rahe ho, this host is doing nothing but sugarcoated soft propoganda and clean washing Sufism which is devil in disguise. Delete this comment as well. I am certified hater 😎 there is nothing jamuna ganga tehzeeb

  • @aishikadhikary7475
    @aishikadhikary7475 Рік тому +2

    Man...phew...this comment section is literally filled with puritanical talibani hindutvavaadis. Kya ho gaya bhai logo ko. Iss desh ko bui Afghanistan ya Saudi Arabia jaisa banana hai kya? Take chill pill and try listen to other people's viewpoints rather than just showering hate.

  • @onlypants2191
    @onlypants2191 Рік тому +6

    Bro this is the wrong track.

  • @Raj_wardhan123
    @Raj_wardhan123 Рік тому +5

    Irony is Islamic tyrant AURANGZEB was also Sufi 😂🫡

  • @Advaitvaadi
    @Advaitvaadi 6 місяців тому +1

    Great insightful podcast

  • @yourmom4
    @yourmom4 Рік тому +2

    The hate and toxicity in comment section damn grow up bro

  • @jayabisht1870
    @jayabisht1870 Рік тому +7

    She is one of the best historians of India and one of my favorites.
    Love to read her articles and books.
    Always a pleasure. Thank you very much for inviting her to your show.
    And yes Sufism is indeed an interesting movement that came to India through Persianized Turko Mongols,Turko Afghans.
    I live in Delhi, so here are so many remnants of Sufi culture.
    Moreover Indo-Islamic monuments, philosophical ideas, architecture,language,music,culture have imprints of Sufism (wrapped in Persianized form)

    • @dalitnahipehlehinduhu6569
      @dalitnahipehlehinduhu6569 Рік тому

      When u read whitewashed history of Sufism

    • @cpol1146
      @cpol1146 Рік тому

      let me tell you that Aurangzeb was a sufi too. He followed every tenet of sufism. The amount of hatred written in these sufi text for others, is something you cant even imagine. Dont believe me , read yourself. Or you should do a podcast with IAS Officer (Retd.) Sanjay Dixit on the topic of sufi, he will tell you the reality of sufi with facts & quoting from their own books & atrocities they have done on hindus.
      Their religious books openly talks about hatred towards polytheists/idolaters like us hindus, killing us, destroying our temple, raping our women etc.Just for the reason that we are following our faith. And these things are literally written in is-lamic books like qu-ran, hadiths, fatawa e alamgiri etc. Dont believe me, read yourself. Bs itna kahunga ki pairo ke neeche se zameen khisak jayegi & these people believe in these things. Or you can read a book called - Understanding Mohmad by Ali Sina. Its available on internet for free as PDF. Here is the link to downnload - www.faithfreedom.org/understanding-muhammad-free-download/
      Or you can follow people like, Ex muslim Sameer, Ex Muslim Sahil, Zafar Heretic, Sachwala on youtube.
      And so called liberal hardcore Islamists will tell you about Quran verse 5: 32 in order to present islam as peaceful but they never tell the whole truth that is they never tell the full context which is from Quran verse 5:27 - 5:34. So if someday any liberal Islamists tells you about 5:32, ask them what is written in Quranic verse 5:27-5:34.

  • @ninadkulkarni8198
    @ninadkulkarni8198 Рік тому +8

    Shameful

  • @Shubham70070
    @Shubham70070 Рік тому +5

    @Dostcast please invite Retd. IAS Sanjay dixit ji 🙏

  • @ankushyadav6814
    @ankushyadav6814 Рік тому +3

    There are many ex Muslims channel bring anyone of them they will explain Islam better.

  • @_Pooja_baisoya.
    @_Pooja_baisoya. Рік тому +34

    Isse accha shri bhagwat geeta padhlo

    • @Stoiccynic224
      @Stoiccynic224 Рік тому +1

      Ohh the same Geeta that promotes casteism.

    • @acee001
      @acee001 Рік тому +3

      @@Stoiccynic224 oh bhai pata hota ni kuch bas bolna sa matlab you can be any caste for becoming brahman learn the vedas like that whatever skill you have you can become caste karan and krishna even had a convo on it lmfaooo hindu hoka ya bol raha ha sharam kar

    • @Stoiccynic224
      @Stoiccynic224 Рік тому

      @@acee001 what you said was only true for vedic period. Bhagwat Geeta was written much later and it clearly mentions the social hierarchy of castes. You probably haven't read it.

    • @acee001
      @acee001 Рік тому

      @@Stoiccynic224 bro it dosent promote it it says change is constant and he he clearly talked about individual duties not birth duties no mention of krishna saying its good arjun trained as a warrior so he was one and thats dharma dharma isnt caste bro and if you have read bhagwat gita you would clearly know how much one can learn from it you just a left side hater who dosent know anything not the context the story nothing
      here a video for you as proof - ua-cam.com/video/Y8F1dY6g34w/v-deo.html&ab_channel=Swarajya
      stop believing nonsense do your own research

    • @Stoiccynic224
      @Stoiccynic224 Рік тому

      @@acee001 I can give you another video proof showing the cast promotion in Geeta and how it promotes discrimination.
      It's better if you go read it yourselves with an open mind like I did.

  • @blahblah05
    @blahblah05 Рік тому +14

    Bhai vinamre inlogo ko kyu bularaha jab itne sarey aur log hai to
    J sai deepak
    Anand rangnathan
    Abhijit chavda
    Sanjay dixit
    Meenakshi jain
    Vishnu shankar jain
    Anuj dhar
    Vikram sampath
    Aur bhi bhot hai tu inlogo ko kyu nahi bulata ?

    • @Stoiccynic224
      @Stoiccynic224 Рік тому +2

      So he should only call right wing nationalists???

    • @sudarshan3965
      @sudarshan3965 Рік тому

      🤣 mat dekh. Nhi dekhna to

    • @blahblah05
      @blahblah05 Рік тому +2

      @@Stoiccynic224 sanjay dixit , abhijit chavda , anand ranga and j sai deepak are not right wing (about rest i dont know )
      They are indic wing
      Moreover calling them would be greater then calling someone to speak over sufism (jihad)

    • @blahblah05
      @blahblah05 Рік тому

      @@sudarshan3965 abe jha2 maine apna opinion diya hai smjha
      Ye to vahi baat hogyi ki jisko government psnd nahi hai india ki vo desh choad de
      Meri marzi mai apna opinion du ya nai teri g mai kyu jalan horahi ?

    • @Stoiccynic224
      @Stoiccynic224 Рік тому +1

      @@blahblah05 just because j sai Deepak said so it doesn't make him any less right wing. It's so obvious which side of political spectrum they belong if we go by the conventional definition of these classificatios.

  • @loveforhumanity6260
    @loveforhumanity6260 Рік тому +6

    Lanat 😡😡,Kabr pujnewalon ko islam se naa jodo 😐😐

  • @Vinaykumar-ix1cj
    @Vinaykumar-ix1cj Рік тому +4

    Sufism is bellow shariyat.....

  • @sadbradwithabat2413
    @sadbradwithabat2413 Рік тому +4

    If bullshit were to be a person, i can surely say it's name would be Rana Safvi

  • @thesachinb
    @thesachinb Рік тому +2

    She looks confused and very relevant to what she said about 5 blinds and an elephant. She still can't simplify things.

  • @Farid.biology
    @Farid.biology Рік тому +13

    Let me tell you guys, Sufism is not Islam, Sufism is completely different.!!!

    • @shubham470
      @shubham470 Рік тому +1

      yhe u r right but before 11-12 century,then after it used to convert people into i$lam

    • @ydl589
      @ydl589 Рік тому +3

      Whatever it's still g-hadi ideology

    • @shubham470
      @shubham470 Рік тому

      @@ydl589 100% bro

  • @ajaydalaya2195
    @ajaydalaya2195 5 місяців тому

    Most sufis were actually ex muslims. They interpreted islam in their own way by mentionjng muhammad in a minimalist way.

  • @Shubham-0909
    @Shubham-0909 Рік тому +5

    exmuslim gang kidhar ho bhaii....

  • @nambardarumeshgurjar519
    @nambardarumeshgurjar519 Рік тому +8

    😂Sanjay Dixit ko bula mat Lena varna saara vaham mit jayega ....

  • @foodiebeauty...
    @foodiebeauty... Рік тому +6

    This was really a Cancer cast.

  • @ShwetabhSenpai
    @ShwetabhSenpai Рік тому +3

    bring jay sai deepak pg radio also did a podcast with him a year ago

  • @MaltSingle
    @MaltSingle Рік тому +1

    After all the stellar guests so far, all u could find was her, Dissapointed. Neway after the malana cream is out of ur system hopefully it'll be back to normal. Cheers

  • @ManishSharma-ku7ij
    @ManishSharma-ku7ij Рік тому +7

    Good for Muslims to understand from their historical point of view. Little to gain for Hindus here. I am glad she mentioned Kun Faya Kun, it and many songs like it(Tajdar-e-haram) are Islamic Bhajans put out in public domain to reel in non-Muslims.

    • @mangopudding5979
      @mangopudding5979 Рік тому

      Reel in non mus lims? What do you mean?

    • @ManishSharma-ku7ij
      @ManishSharma-ku7ij Рік тому

      @@mangopudding5979 Kun Faya Kun, Tajdaar e Haram aren't secular songs. They are Islamic songs like Hindu bhajans. Using them in popular culture is done to attract non Muslims.

    • @harshaggarwal9463
      @harshaggarwal9463 Рік тому +2

      Speak for yourself ! who are you to say who can gain something from this and who cannot

    • @ManishSharma-ku7ij
      @ManishSharma-ku7ij Рік тому

      @@harshaggarwal9463 Feel free to ignore if you don't like my comment. They are Islamic bhajans whether you like it or not.

    • @ShwetabhSenpai
      @ShwetabhSenpai Рік тому

      The problem is not with the music, it is with the superficial so called philosophical ideas

  • @valmikivaani
    @valmikivaani Рік тому +17

    @vinamr Kasana, Bro first of all you have been doing great and much thanks for bring one gem after another, yet I don't know if you are playing the game or you have entered the game in naivete, anyway how, now since you are in it, it would be best, to follow this podcast with rebuttal from Sanjay Dixit and Dr Faiyaz Ahmad Faizi, both have scholarly works on Sufism and are a must have antigen after this cancer cast, sorry for the strong language, but we love you too much to get lost in the left's ecosystem

  • @nerf2752
    @nerf2752 Рік тому +2

    This Guest went on all psedo secular anti hindu channels like laundry, wire, BBC & desh bukt.

  • @Vinaykumar-ix1cj
    @Vinaykumar-ix1cj Рік тому +3

    Call sunjay dixit for sufism

  • @hemjoshi192
    @hemjoshi192 Рік тому +3

    Well try , now wash your sins by bringing Sanjay Dixit , he will tell you What suffism is .

  • @Nytt280
    @Nytt280 Рік тому +4

    With due respect
    Ma'am's half of the vocabulary are lyrics of coke studio
    And thats how we relate ❤️

  • @rutvikrs
    @rutvikrs Рік тому +7

    Yuck

  • @kungfu_india
    @kungfu_india Рік тому +2

    I love your postcasts brother. BUT THIS PODCAST HAS SO MUCH OF MISINFORMATION.

  • @divyanshgoel8125
    @divyanshgoel8125 5 днів тому

    Superb video hazrat nizamuddin auliya id the best sufi saint in the world

  • @vickyvidhyarthi2987
    @vickyvidhyarthi2987 Рік тому +8

    please bring sanjay dixit to podcast to talk about sufism

  • @ioy6966
    @ioy6966 Рік тому

    People are saying here she is brainwashing people by glorifying Mughals and Islam. Listen to the podcast properly she is explaining Sufism and about saints in India and about the divine.

  • @rratedgabru5349
    @rratedgabru5349 Рік тому +2

    Lol, for Muzzlim the sufis maybe saints like Burham wani was a hero, but as per the lived experiences of Hindus, the sufis were simply conversion specialist and competitors to the Hindu gods and culture. Hence you will see a Sufi dargah next every prominent ancient temple. Whereever there was a temple the sufis would set up shrine not from it for obvious reasons.
    And then the other mature if sufis were that of J1had all major massacres of Hindus during riots were initiated and executed by sufis.
    And
    Coming to Nizam Uddin, we all know now what "Chap Tilak sab cheen li" really means.
    The author has exposed he real agenda and position by giving it a typical Muzzlim apologist/Taqiyya twist and meaning.
    Tumara invader culture tumko Mubarak, Humko Pakistan nahi bana hai. 🙏

  • @aryamann5878
    @aryamann5878 Рік тому +8

    thanks for bringing her to podcast❤

  • @keepbreathing2659
    @keepbreathing2659 Рік тому +1

    The dargah thing is not islamic

  • @nikhilgoswami99
    @nikhilgoswami99 Рік тому +1

    Call J Sai Deepak sir

  • @SURESHK-pune
    @SURESHK-pune Рік тому

    Very informative thing abt Sufism
    It's softest n accomadativr part of islam

  • @kantusgaming5602
    @kantusgaming5602 Рік тому +1

    Sufism is not Islam

  • @akram5865
    @akram5865 Рік тому +2

    Sufism has been and will be the traditional Islam :D
    loved the podcast!

  • @jagdishramanathan2091
    @jagdishramanathan2091 11 місяців тому

    sufism is same as all firqas of islam .bloodletting is the basic thing . Mystical dance and music is takia of derwishs ie tabligis in islam !

  • @sudarshan3965
    @sudarshan3965 Рік тому +13

    It was great listening to her. Came to know about a lot of new things.

    • @real_Raxter
      @real_Raxter Рік тому +6

      Apne culture ko jaanlo pehle phir doosro se influence hona
      Please

  • @pragya6413
    @pragya6413 Рік тому +1

    Idk I just got bored and laughed lol , the inaccuracies and just self made stuff lol 😂

  • @snehapandey9107
    @snehapandey9107 Місяць тому

    Why don't u bring ex Muslim sahil or adam seeker 😳😕😕😕😕😕😕😕😕😕😕

  • @d.i.guns_
    @d.i.guns_ Рік тому +2

    didn't ask + L + ratio

  • @llllllll859
    @llllllll859 Рік тому +2

    Koi batayega kya chal raha hai yaha....kon hai ye aaurat ! aur kya bate chal rahi hai ?

  • @JeevanKumar-pn6oq
    @JeevanKumar-pn6oq Рік тому +3

    by the sufis we re who were acctive participants of kashmiri exodus......

  • @farhatfatima1
    @farhatfatima1 Рік тому +11

    Oh I see so many hate comments instead of what she is trying to spread through her books. Well done it was great listening to both of you in conversation. My best wishes to you and your whole team.

    • @mojojojo8184
      @mojojojo8184 Рік тому

      These people know only hate

    • @QuickNews999
      @QuickNews999 Рік тому +25

      Just go through primary sources and read the words of Sufi themselves and you will understand how bigoted they are .

    • @mojojojo8184
      @mojojojo8184 Рік тому

      @@charvaka_guy wo bhi haramzade hai

    • @abhinav865
      @abhinav865 Рік тому +2

      Hate is obvious a man was killed in udaipur because of sufi saints 1990s rape scandal of ajmer sharif how can we forget such things .

    • @abhinav865
      @abhinav865 Рік тому +20

      @@mojojojo8184 can you explain sufism to kanhaiya lal family who lost his life because of sufi radicals .

  • @JayrajSinghPuwar
    @JayrajSinghPuwar Рік тому

    Listen sufi songs

  • @nextroncontrol3568
    @nextroncontrol3568 Рік тому +7

    Listening to this podcast was very soothing, spiritual and knowledgable too. By seeing the comments, I cud only say that things should be viewed or perceived in a context. Without bringing the context, one will unnecessarily bother himself and others too. Anyway, I wish best of luck to Vinamre for all his future endeavors. Naushad

  • @reshavgovindam1280
    @reshavgovindam1280 Рік тому +8

    Wohhh , this guy brings Abhijit, and many right wing UA-camrs , there nobody has any problems ,jo sahi bhi hai , har ek perspective dekhna hum, par jab dusre side ke logo ko laate hai , sabko itni jalti hai , itne hate kar rahe hai,
    Yeh podcast hai , yaha pe hum information lene aate hai , aur logo ki perspective sunne aate hai , dono sides ko woh bhi , guys please keep your calm
    Yahi hota hai , jab aapka subscribers base itna jaldi growth hota hai , unnecessary or unwanted log aa jate hai
    Thak Gaya hu yeh sab dekhte dekhte iss channel pe, pehle sahi tha yeh channel jab log koi productive discussion karte the comments section me, abhi toh bas tatti log aa chuke hai

    • @d.i.guns_
      @d.i.guns_ Рік тому

      NO

    • @d.i.guns_
      @d.i.guns_ Рік тому

      Stop ignoring me

    • @blahblah05
      @blahblah05 Рік тому

      To fir isko bol ki sanjay dixit ko lekar aye jisne sufism ko expose kra tha pura

    • @ydl589
      @ydl589 Рік тому

      Sorry to reply on your fûçkery par na toh yeh sahi information de rahi hai aur well sufiyo ki kya hi baat karana woh toh the hi invader aur barbarians

  • @manavendraagnihotri7191
    @manavendraagnihotri7191 Рік тому +2

    सूफी को glorify करने का क्या फायदा जब सबका मकसद एक ही है काफिरो का खात्मा।
    काफिरो को मजहब से जोड़ने के लिए एक कम कट्टर तरीका खोजा गया जिसका नाम सूफी है।भ्रमित होने की जरूरत नही,एक ही हवाहवाई किताब से दोनों ही पैदा हुए हैं ये बात समझ मे आ जाये तो ही अच्छा है।

    • @abdulhakeem3873
      @abdulhakeem3873 Рік тому

      We will meet on judgment Day..
      Are you ready..

    • @manavendraagnihotri7191
      @manavendraagnihotri7191 Рік тому

      @@abdulhakeem3873 हवाहवाई का असर लग रहा है

  • @enamyazdani9209
    @enamyazdani9209 Рік тому +1

    loved this lodcast

  • @yashagar4443
    @yashagar4443 Рік тому +3

    Loved this podcast.A staunch atheist and capitalist and politically centre left.

  • @ksb_067
    @ksb_067 Рік тому +1

    I like Sufi music 🎵 and it is really good no doubt but Sufism isn't the same way as it is portrayed in Bollywood movies it has a darker side to it but there were Sufis who were really good

  • @RaviNirban
    @RaviNirban Рік тому +1

    Your content is really good, please change your upload timing to 7-8 PM and use hook thumbnail.

  • @divyanshubaranwal3090
    @divyanshubaranwal3090 Рік тому +2

    saab jhuth bhul rahii hai, Sanjay Dixit ko bula dena aa jaega samajh me.

  • @yourmom4
    @yourmom4 Рік тому +2

    Great podcast vinamra ,loved it ❤️❤️❤️

  • @_Arsh_x9
    @_Arsh_x9 Рік тому +8

    Thanks a lot for bringing her on podcast

  • @minhajwomenjammu
    @minhajwomenjammu Рік тому +2

    MashaAllah.... great effort mam....Allah swt bless you in abundance!

    • @allahlesboslu2_9
      @allahlesboslu2_9 Рік тому

      Softysm is well packaged p r opoganda of same s u nni i &!@ m

    • @real_Raxter
      @real_Raxter Рік тому

      Namaz padh jaa

    • @anotherhyderabadi4357
      @anotherhyderabadi4357 Рік тому

      @@real_Raxter tu jaake ling ki pooja kar 😂 purity chahiye toh mere ling ki pooja karle

  • @Ayushsharma-qc7qx
    @Ayushsharma-qc7qx Рік тому

    ❤️

    • @Ayushsharma-qc7qx
      @Ayushsharma-qc7qx Рік тому +1

      @@gargvanit just the dost cast and vinamar bhai ❤️

    • @shailendra9564
      @shailendra9564 Рік тому

      @@gargvanit 🤣 jab tak modi k tattooo ko chaato na, tab tak tum jaise andhbhakton ko hum Hindu nahi lagte aur baaki saare jihadi aur muslim..
      Swami Vivekananda ji ko padh , Modi Yogi ko gaali dena shuru kar dega..
      He criticized all nonsense rituals, over the top cow worshipping and pseudoscience related ramayan and Mahabharata

    • @shailendra9564
      @shailendra9564 Рік тому

      @@gargvanit did any muslim baghao your sister or mother 🤣 so much of hatred for them.
      The day one religion discriminate people and torture them ,God decided to fuck them
      Casteism led to downfall of India not Invaders
      No wonder India went to shit place because of people like you who see surnames (caste).
      first.. sanskrit becoming dead language because only Brahmins should read and write
      then discriminating against people from caste which started rajputs false pride of only one community fighting and giving India in platters to Invaders, then great shivaji maharaj came allowing all caste to fight for motherland, then again Peshwas started caste system which led to fall of Maratha Empire..
      And the British used all hatred of Indians against each caste and religion and fucked us so bad..

    • @shailendra9564
      @shailendra9564 Рік тому

      @@gargvanit 🤣🤣 I know very well about Islam. I have read Ambedkar's book on Islam
      Par aisa hai na jab khud k ghar meh hi khot ho, toh dusre ko blame kya karna. Bahar vaale toh will use every opportunity to fuck you..
      Also, you should read Ambedkar and his Book annihilation of caste and riddles of Hinduism..
      Your sister and mother are studying, working have equal rights because of him..
      Widows can remarry unlike death and humiliation for life which existed for centuries..
      Banks,worker rights,law and many other fields..
      Tum jaise bhadwon ne hi Dalit ko centuries se alag rakha hai.. imagine India without caste..
      Knowledge in every caste, if every caste would have known to write and read sanskrit,
      science in India got halted because of such system
      What Europe is today, India could have been
      Varna RSS, brahmanvadi log toh auraton ko ghar meh kitchen meh hi rakhte.

    • @shailendra9564
      @shailendra9564 Рік тому

      @@gargvanit 🫡 thank you for your andhbhakti.
      Also, look around all inventions are done by whom, what we study in science,read scientists name? You casteist fucks will feel the reality and the reason why India lags behind.
      Also, go tell your Daddy Modi Yogi to remove all ambedkar photos from every government institution. And put any right wing scholars ( oh crap such things don't exist), since all decent right wingers have studied in IIT and AIIMS established by nehru only then comes chaddi RSS who studied gaumutra and gobar ,
      you should bark.
      I am better than people who believe all scientific inventions came from ramayan and Mahabharata like plastic surgery, nuclear technology, WiFi, internet and gaumata can cure cancer..

  • @JeevanKumar-pn6oq
    @JeevanKumar-pn6oq Рік тому +1

    mediatation is of two types one is inner realzing inner aatma and other is outward concentrating on god

  • @_Arsh_x9
    @_Arsh_x9 Рік тому +6

    #freepalestine #freepalestine #freepalestine

    • @pmishra786
      @pmishra786 Рік тому +20

      UA-cam pe daal do Palestine...Free hi free ho jayega

    • @_Arsh_x9
      @_Arsh_x9 Рік тому

      @@pmishra786 #freepalestine hogahi वो भी israel me hi, wait and watch bros

    • @devvratmishra9000
      @devvratmishra9000 Рік тому

      @@pmishra786
      Shabaash 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

    • @blahblah05
      @blahblah05 Рік тому

      @@pmishra786 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

    • @_Arsh_x9
      @_Arsh_x9 Рік тому

      @@gargvanit Palestine to lekar rahenge लकिन, wait a sec/ Jews eat beef, Jews broken idols of Gods, diff between Jews and islam is 1 step ahead, Jews and muslim live together in Palestine, and Muslim are whose help to protect Jews in Palestine OK

  • @mayursawale1555
    @mayursawale1555 Рік тому +8

    In this polarisation..it is important to understand and respect each other faith..to avoid misunderstanding and build trust.nice podcast..hope more people try to get it

    • @vishnuprasad7574
      @vishnuprasad7574 Рік тому +13

      Understand and respect each other faiths 😂😂😂
      Others faiths have clear understanding on how to deal with disbelievers idolators polytheist etc

    • @d.i.guns_
      @d.i.guns_ Рік тому +1

      No.

    • @blahblah05
      @blahblah05 Рік тому +5

      @@vishnuprasad7574 ya they are very clear with their approach but we hindus are still thinking that qll faiths are equal lmao

    • @blahblah05
      @blahblah05 Рік тому

      Stfu go read some history of sufism

    • @ydl589
      @ydl589 Рік тому

      Agar muslim apane scriptures me se kaafir,murshid, murtad,mulahid,nisaar inake bare me likhi aayate aur women ko kisi bhi tarah se oppress karane wali aayate hata de to mei islam kabool kar lunga

  • @akashkarn8617
    @akashkarn8617 Рік тому +2

    You got the Worst guest Vinamre :)

  • @ioy6966
    @ioy6966 Рік тому +1

    Very good video ☺️📸

  • @siddharththakkar5902
    @siddharththakkar5902 Рік тому

    loved it vinamre

    • @real_Raxter
      @real_Raxter Рік тому +1

      Successfully manipulated
      I recommend you listen once to
      J. Sai Deepak
      And
      Abhijit Chavda
      To remove the trash inserted in your mind by the society and bollywood
      It's not your fault it's just that initiate to watch the right content once

    • @lookintoit4537
      @lookintoit4537 Рік тому

      @@real_Raxter Both of those (and Sanjay Dixit) are hacks. They are not looking for answers. They have decided to support a viewpoint, and will say anything to support those. Now that you are convinced that I'm a leftie, let me tell you that I love listening to AIM, Anand Ranganathan and Vikram Sampath.