I appreciate that this video started with the chorus, so we get an idea of how fugue is built off of it... but there really needs to be a longer version of this (even if barely) with an intro that takes the listener off guard until the melody hits them.
@@johnryan1004 The pedal is unreasonably difficult, many fast passages with leaps. Most professional organists aren't required for that much virtuosity and stamina.
In order for this to breathe new life into the art of rickrolling, it really needs to be happy/triumphant. Please major-ify it! Wicked cool as it is, though.
Liking the end basso sostenuto. This is the best introduction to the method of fugue I've ever seen. If you're musical enough to construct one (and I think plenty of people are), you can come up with a completely new piece every weekend, as I know a certain gentleman in Leipzig had to do in order to earn his living.
I wrote a parody arrangement of Never Gonna Give You Up for piano and violin with three sections: the first is based on the opening of Bach's Italian Concerto no. 1; the second (scherzo) is a polyrhythmic version of the main song; the third is a fast counterpoint section. I have been delaying publishing it for a couple months because I felt like I needed to write a fugue section, but I struggled to get anywhere with it. Now I feel like I don't have to and can just publish what I have already composed.
"Fairest good tidings to thee, O treasured Horatio, for I haveth dost importantest message, to be listened upon with all possible dispatch. Thou needeth only to apply the utmost vigor, and clicketh on dost link."
VOGLIO LO SPARTITO E' semplicemente fantastica. Mi intendo a malapena di armonia, contrappunto,composizione e fuga ma al semplice sentirla,da studente organista, ti dico WOW! Tra un Preludio e Fuga ed un altro del Maestro, al prossimo concerto pretendo di inserire pure questa.
Now I truly believe he’s never gonna give her up. This fugue sounds like a solemn swear which cannot be broken in the fear of death. This is what needs to play as a sound track for that video. Young people should never use the feelings to get some (censored) advantage.
I really enjoyed this, thanks for writing it! I especially loved the long pedal at the end. I am a Christian, and today I saw the message "Plant today, enjoy forever" at a local garden centre. I also heard William Walton's "Spitfire Prelude and Fugue" on the radio. So when I saw this Rick-roll fugue, I knew I'd enjoy it. Jesus can be very playful with those who know him, and him saying he's never gonna give me up is very touching. If you're interested in finding out more about Jesus, simply reply to this comment and I'll do my best to answer any questions, or just watch this video (it's not mine) - aUbJkmHMZMg
Once you go Baroque, you never go back
You know the fugue and so do I
Full counterpoint is what I’m thinking of
You wouldn’t get this from any other guy
I just wanna play this how it's written
Gonna make this sound so nice
I will save this for the right moment - when the situation requires a very dignified and epic Rick-roll. Thank you.
I would 100% offer this for weddings and funerals! You know there's people that would jump on the chance!
I appreciate that this video started with the chorus, so we get an idea of how fugue is built off of it... but there really needs to be a longer version of this (even if barely) with an intro that takes the listener off guard until the melody hits them.
Absolutely!
@@kateshiningdeer3334dude! I was gonna say the same thing 😂
Ah yes, the lost Bach opus "Herr Jesu gibet Euch nimmer auff"
Geilster Kommentar!😂😂😂
Dieser Kommentar hat definitiv zu wenig Likes!
Normalerweise bin ich kein Bach Fan aber der Kommentar hat mich gekillt😂
Can't imagine why you didn't call it "never gonna gifugue up"
Somebody just did ua-cam.com/video/tlV0k-rC-00/v-deo.html
Because that already exists...
@@NeoCat1993 Well..as you can see @sigil5772 wrote this comment before the video you're talking about
@@jackyyi_01 fair enough, apologies. Times are a bit if a blur these days
I am amazed that you came up with this before the other fugue was written, well done.
I just deliberately rickrolled myself for three full minutes. Well done.
I so want to be in a cathedral and hear the organist play this ❤
That would involve a lot of work for the organist. It's technically quite hard I think.
Before or after In the Garden of Eden, by I. Ron Butterfly?
@@Jasper_4444well playing the organ is what they are payed to do… so yeah, I would hope they could play a fugue.
@@johnryan1004 The pedal is unreasonably difficult, many fast passages with leaps. Most professional organists aren't required for that much virtuosity and stamina.
Another example of how all contemporary western music, from show tunes of the 30s and 40s, to jazz, to pop, to even heavy metal owes so much to Bach.
When you go to church and realize you just got Rick rolled.
We’re no strangers to Bach.
I love Ba-Rick music! 😅
Deserves more likes
Time to Baroque n'Roll!
🎼🎶🎶
🎹🎹
🎹🎹
If it ain't Ba-Rick...
As an organist this might be fun to perform only to rickroll everyone listening sounds good and difficult lol
What a childish thought.
Uhh, do it.
Right before church...
Do it man! Do it!
The most baroque way to rickroll
Love it !
You've been Baroque -rolled! 😂
TBF, the point of Rickrolling is the dance, meaning the video part.
Never gonna vote you down, never gotta close this tab or report you!
Was never so happy to be rick rolled in my life!
this is the ONLY version I care to ever listen to again in my life
Astounding! So that's what Rick S. Bach sounds like.
"yes, this is a sad fugue" 😭
Saddina
Many contrepunto mistakes. Horrible, sorry😢
@@SequentialCircuitProphet5 sorry maestro, hope in Giacomo's forgiveness🙏🙏
@@SequentialCircuitProphet5 Thank you for your feedback...but could you show me these mistakes you're talking about?
In order for this to breathe new life into the art of rickrolling, it really needs to be happy/triumphant. Please major-ify it! Wicked cool as it is, though.
People missed the best dad joke yet.
Good Rick Rolls are fugue and far between.
It would be oddly appropriate if someone rickrolled a wedding with this instead of playing the usual "here comes the bride" processional.
This my new favourite genre of art/shitpost
IMHO, I can't name this a shitpost, bro is creating an incredible things none of us can do
Agreed!
@@hoteymaks
❤ Exactly. 😊
I’m telling you the baroque is COMING BACK
Oh, so it is getting a renaissance?
@@kimvibk9242underrated comment, bravo
It’s my main obsession on electric guitar.
Sir Richard of Æstley took the Bach seat.
Thee knoweth the rul'r and so doth I
As someone who's studied 18th century harmony, this totally cracked me up! Well done!
This is BRILLIANT. You are amazingly talented, Giacomo. Thanks so much for this
Extremely clever - subscribed immediately. The fugue is one of my favourite music forms.
"Umineko no naku koro ni" has some nice fugues in its soundtrack.
Liking the end basso sostenuto. This is the best introduction to the method of fugue I've ever seen. If you're musical enough to construct one (and I think plenty of people are), you can come up with a completely new piece every weekend, as I know a certain gentleman in Leipzig had to do in order to earn his living.
Bishop: I sympathize with the plight of this temptation, but please don't.
I've been rickrolled by Bach! Yay!
Beautifull fuggue, I am pleased to be rickrolled this way!
Hahahaaa, WONDERFUL! Thanks for all of the work you put into this, not insignificant!
This is fuguelicious!
Awesome & clever cover.
I suspect that J.S. Bach would give this an A+.
THIS IS BRILLIANT!!!!!!!!
Found this on Easter Sunday. Feels just right.
_Very_ clever and _inventive._ Bravo! 👏
"Jolly good show!" - pops
This is utterly terrifying
I wrote a parody arrangement of Never Gonna Give You Up for piano and violin with three sections: the first is based on the opening of Bach's Italian Concerto no. 1; the second (scherzo) is a polyrhythmic version of the main song; the third is a fast counterpoint section. I have been delaying publishing it for a couple months because I felt like I needed to write a fugue section, but I struggled to get anywhere with it. Now I feel like I don't have to and can just publish what I have already composed.
This is more fun to listen to than the original song. Thank You!
Hilariously brilliant! Best of Good Fortune in giving us more innovative fun like this!
I'm gonna start playing fugues ! Inspiring +well done .
I'm fan of both, Astley and Bach. So this is just perfect! 🤩
Wow, totally awesome. I totally love fugues with fond memories of the first Bach organ fugues that I played when I was a kid.
Best version of the song I've heard
This. This is genius. Never had kitsch achieved such heights. Magnificent. Bravo.
You plumbed the musical depths of the anguished romance of the Rick himself. Classiest baroque Rickroll ever.
Changing my will to request a performance of this at my memorial.
I am speechless. With laughter and respect.
This is the fugue I didn’t know I needed in my life! 👏 👏 👏
LOVE does not begin to describe my reaction to this video. This made my year! Thank you. ❤
"Fairest good tidings to thee, O treasured Horatio, for I haveth dost importantest message, to be listened upon with all possible dispatch. Thou needeth only to apply the utmost vigor, and clicketh on dost link."
Hey that's pretty good - surprisingly! Nonsense topic but done well and well played too. I'd like to hear another one.
I think, the group of knowing Rick Astley and his meme and what is a fugue is small.
Yet here I am! Own his cassette from the ‘80s, married to a person who hates him, and I know what a fugue is. Let the fun begin…
The lowest parts seem appallingly difficult for an organist with only two feet! However, I love it! Can't wait to hear it on a church organ!
Bro actually hit a banger!
Great job 🔥
Well, now I know what to use if I ever want to Rick Roll my dad.
Secretly if you peel away the layers all organists have been playing Rickn A’s greatest hit right under our noses. Bravo!
A fugue commitment's what I'm looking for...
That’s the best thing I’ve heard all week !
I do hope they play that at Ashley’s memorial. I might haven’t at mine.
Who else doesn't hear this as sounding like the song?
Absolutely awesome. I've been rickrolled and I loved it. ❤
If it ain't baroque, don't fix it! This takes a Bach seat to no-one....
Very nice; well done!
VOGLIO LO SPARTITO
E' semplicemente fantastica. Mi intendo a malapena di armonia, contrappunto,composizione e fuga ma al semplice sentirla,da studente organista, ti dico WOW!
Tra un Preludio e Fuga ed un altro del Maestro, al prossimo concerto pretendo di inserire pure questa.
That was surprisingly good!
Spectacular 👍
Awesome!!😎 JS would love this no doubt. Keep on rocking (fugue) style.
That's actually damned well composed ! Congrats, I think I will enjoy learning to play it during my hollydays ^^
Love the explanations as well !
Good luck finding an organ with a low Bb pedal.
I was considering trying it on a piano first, where would have I found an organ anyway ? ;-; @@fullario
Brilliant. Absolutely brilliant.
Genius. Of the absolute highest kind.
Looks like you got Bach to really roll Ricky. Got 'em rolled pretty well. Rolled him four ways from Sunday, in fact.
Freakin' brilliant.
I have no idea what's going on here, but I appreciate the hard work.
Outstanding! This makes me want the sheet music and a pedal board for my Hammond SK.
Well done! Be glad you didn't have to play it yourself, it's set quite challenging... 😁
Never gonna fugue you up, but epic.
This is brilliant!
Love it, plz continue !
I was fuguerolled.
Now I truly believe he’s never gonna give her up. This fugue sounds like a solemn swear which cannot be broken in the fear of death. This is what needs to play as a sound track for that video. Young people should never use the feelings to get some (censored) advantage.
Very decent work, thank you!
Fugatto in shape of Pop Fashion. Wonderful.
I am so happy to know this vid. You make my day. I subscribed.
Organist here! Good job! Just so that you know, organs do not have a low B-flat, but otherwise, it definitely looks like orgam music. Bravo!
Brilliant
This is epic
Yo tell me how the fck we are all intentionally rickrolling ourselves these days and just goddamn loving it
You’ve just been Bach-rolled!
You have been rickrolled, in baroque
Well, that’s just brilliant!
I really enjoyed this, thanks for writing it! I especially loved the long pedal at the end.
I am a Christian, and today I saw the message "Plant today, enjoy forever" at a local garden centre. I also heard William Walton's "Spitfire Prelude and Fugue" on the radio. So when I saw this Rick-roll fugue, I knew I'd enjoy it. Jesus can be very playful with those who know him, and him saying he's never gonna give me up is very touching.
If you're interested in finding out more about Jesus, simply reply to this comment and I'll do my best to answer any questions, or just watch this video (it's not mine) - aUbJkmHMZMg
This made my day, thank you!
I guess "Baby's Got Bach" is in the works.
Sounds so tragic
Especially when somebody was rickrolled
Just watching the intervals hurts the little space between my fingers
If I'm ever getting married again I want this as my wedding music and if my fiancée does not like it then she's not the one.
Stock, Aitken and Waterman are geniuses
The Rick-Roll we never knew we needed!
This is very impressive! Have any organists performed this live yet (or expressed interest in doing so)? I think it would be a great encore piece.