This channel is fantastic, brings back some strong memories and some good songs to hear... my great-uncle's father fought in the first World War in the east (my family has extensive history in that part of former Germany) and this is one of the songs that I remember hearing as a child when I still lived with that side of my family. I had not remembered the words, but the melody was always a bit of an earworm for some reason. Now that I found this channel and this video, I remember why a lot of those melodies were stuck in my head. Thank you for preserving so many classic melodies, these songs really do tell history better than most school textbooks could in some aspects. It may not have the precise details like the book, but it has more of the spirit and mood than the simple words and maps on a page. Again, thanks for all your hard and valuable work and keep it up 🖤❤💛
Thanks so much for those nice words, I really love working and spreading on these old songs! And I love even more to read, that inspires people in a good way :)
i wouldnt say were blessed...sadly many people in my country are singing these songs again....not to honor our culture but to spread the message the soldeiers who created this song wanted to spread. Even though this song doesnt exaclty to the third reich at all many guys do by singing this song. I admire our culture and the folk lores we have but i dont admire the context these songs are put in.
"Hey Dimitri, what's that?" *grabs telescope* "It looks like the Silesian army...but it's only a quarter of our size. Dont worry, it's an easy win" *the next day* "DIMITRI, YOU SAID IT'D BE EASY!" *meanwhile* *happy German noises*
It always makes me laugh when UA-cam takes these videos down...it shows complete ignorance if German culture. Just listen to the lyrics! It's about stoicism and a sense duty, not rampant evil. If anything it is often pessimistic about "glory".
you are right, this is just about german soldiers who supported the Russian white army, Not Murder Talk, UA-cam really just assumes that these are evil songs Even for WW2 German Songs, almost none of them have anything to do, with the Nazis or things like that nature
Please don't get me wrong, I love this channel and I have been learning how to speak german. But those types of videos rally some undesirable people, extremists, neo-nazis, it becomes a meet-up point. Of course this isn't the intention of Dr.Ludwig, but it happens. It's like random uploads from children that atract pedophiles, youtube removes those videos because of uncultured neo-nazis and extreme right wing that use those songs as ways of meeting up, and youtube does it's best to try and stop those guys from acting up, removing videos or the entire channel because of it. And normal people like us, who just aprecciate the songs and the culture get caught up in between the crossfire.
@@kaboon3489 "undesirable" political views still have 1st Amendment rights in America, where the servers and UA-cam are based. "undesirable" is often a matter of opinion and when it is banned in the US it has to pass the "strict scrutiny" legal test...and banning a song BECAUSE SOME PEOPLE LIKE IT definitely does not pass strict scrutiny.
@@KaiTakApproach Those fall under the hate speech policy of the Terms of Service, so the law in America does not affect the policies of UA-cam. Now, I don't agree with the practice of taking down those videos, but I believe this is the main reason why.
I think its mainly uneducated Karen like people who search YT just to find videos and take them down. I think they get satisfaction and believe they are helping but in reality are being a pest.
Beautiful song. I have cried imagining the pain of those men who gave their freedom and their lives in the fight against the tyranny that devastated their beloved country. Beatiful feeling … Thanks for to share.
i really love this song it feels like one of those you'd sing at a fire (like Vom Barette Schwankt Die Feder and Trum Trum Terum Tum Tum) however i hear no difference between this one and the one from July 12th 2019
Great as always :) There is a cool old German song tapfere kleine soldatenfrau, I was wondering if you already have it in your channel? If you don't, you could upload it. :) I love that song. XD
interesting thought about soviets losing civil war. Maybe the butterfly effect would be that the germans would win second world war, who knows ! maybe the romanov house would end, because of sick heird for the throne, who knows ! wish i was a seer and see these things through lol
Honestly if the whites won the russian civil war it would be no more than a rump state to the Germans and would likely go fascist in the 1930s. Also Russia wouldn’t industrialize until much later than they did, nor as quickly
Now that I think about it, Russia may have still been on Germany’s dinner menu due to the Ostplan, but I don’t know how much Hitler would’ve been frothing at the mouth about Bolshevism if the Reds lost the Russian civil war.
@@kyleerickson6022 russia would most likely join the allies so russia would probably declare war on germany at the start making a war with russia inevitable even if they weren’t communist
@@ЭдитКамю Лол, говоришь так, будто это что-то плохое. Учитывая то, какие "русские" правят в России после революции, и то, сколько десятков миллионов русских людей они помножили на ноль, то сейчас о царе-немце можно только мечтать 👌
I've been trying to find this song with no lyrics and, with the exact same rythm and beat. Literally this exact song and style but, nobody singing. I can't seem to find it anywhere.
Aber bitte, mach sowas nicht, Deine Eltern wären schrecklich traurig!! Sei vorsichtig, trotz aller Liebe zur Musik, was ja grossartig ist. Hab selbst einen "cascadeur" in meiner Familie und immer Angst, dass ihm was passiert! Schönen Tag und LG aus Montreal, Qc, Canada
Inge Mayodon ja habe ich ja auch gesagt das ich so was nicht machen würde weil das einfach fahrlässig ist und ich damit alle gefährden würde aber danke 👍
Also is anyone having loading issues every other UA-cam video that is not dr. Ludwig works and I've even reset my phone came back in to edit this to add this now that it's still not loading
👑 Der Herr unser Gott kennt die Tage der Rechtschaffenen, Und ihr Erbe wird ewiglich bestehen. Sie sollen nicht zuschanden werden zur bösen Zeit, Sondern genug haben auch in den Tagen der Hungersnot. Psalm 37, Vers 18+19👑 Das Lied gefälllt mir sehr! Danke Dr. Ludwig und Gottes reichen Segen!
Traduccion por en Google al español Por la noche el hambre permanece rígida en nuestro sueño, durante el día sonaron los disparos desde el borde del bosque. La miseria acompaña a las columnas y los lobos las acompañan en la escarcha y la niebla. El águila sagrada de Rusia sigue volando Madre, nuestra sangre te pertenece solo a ti, el ejército rojo puede perseguirnos, la bandera sigue brillando. 2. Oh, hay un poder orgulloso, no suenan campanas en la noche roja. Poste pasos, no más libertad, Detrás de alambre de púas se yergue un ejército cansado en silencio Uno canta las viejas canciones atrae la tristeza y el anhelo de nuestro pecho, suena salvaje y desafiante otra vez, en el olvido yace la vieja lujuria. 3. Y como ejército que no tiene hogar, ahora nos movemos de pueblo en pueblo, gente deportada viene a escuchar nuestra canción. El viaje continúa, la gloria y las flores sin sentido. ¡Hogar Hogar! los coros tararean, tu imagen se eleva mil veces, nuestros tenores tocan campanas, los bajos de órgano suenan aburridos y salvajes.
Oh wow. I don't know Latin it any languages but with knowledge of German and English I was able to decipher what it meant..... btw I didn't realize until just now that this was a translation of the song lol
I finally found the fucking source after a year, I can finally put proper artist and album tags on the .mp3 file. This is from the album "Gegen den Strom" by Jungenschaft Schwarzer Adler
Am Ende oder kurz nach dem 1. Weltkrieg ging der Bürgerkrieg und der Krieg zwischen Polen und Russland und auf dem Baltikum noch weiter. Dort kämpften auch noch versprengte deutsche Verbände mit und daher kommen diese Lieder.
Yes. It currently is "Banner" for Germans (due to some change, apparantly after WW1 somewhere), but in Dutch it is still "banier". Not sure why he thought it would be written with a P.
![Nachts steht Hunger starr in unserm Traum [German soldier song][+English translation]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/qq76LCiP2Ds/mqdefault.jpg)
![Nachts steht Hunger starr in unserm Traum [German soldier song][+English translation]](/img/tr.png)
![Die Grenzwacht hielt im Osten [German folk song][+English translation]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/MlqSGHpxdmw/mqdefault.jpg)
![Unser liebe Fraue [Landsknecht song][+English translation]](/img/n.gif)
One of my favorites of all time, showed this to some who’ve never heard any German music & they loved it to their surprise, not to mine👍🏻
I completely agree with this. Just wait until the person hears the Emperor's concerto!
Another Settlement needs our help Vault boy
try ua-cam.com/video/Pg8GlYeCWuM/v-deo.html
wir zind des geyers schwarzer haufen
love it from the first try
I am a Russian
Melancholisch und stürmisch zugleich. Ein großartiges Stück.
First its a German Volounteer song now its a Freikorp song
UA-cam : so how many times u wanna upload
Ludwig : Ja
Ein sehr schön anzuhörendes Lied, welches uns etwas über unsere Geschichte vermittelt.
This channel is fantastic, brings back some strong memories and some good songs to hear... my great-uncle's father fought in the first World War in the east (my family has extensive history in that part of former Germany) and this is one of the songs that I remember hearing as a child when I still lived with that side of my family. I had not remembered the words, but the melody was always a bit of an earworm for some reason. Now that I found this channel and this video, I remember why a lot of those melodies were stuck in my head. Thank you for preserving so many classic melodies, these songs really do tell history better than most school textbooks could in some aspects. It may not have the precise details like the book, but it has more of the spirit and mood than the simple words and maps on a page. Again, thanks for all your hard and valuable work and keep it up 🖤❤💛
Thanks so much for those nice words, I really love working and spreading on these old songs! And I love even more to read, that inspires people in a good way :)
Dr Ludwig buon giorno🌞 molto primo canzone preferito con bellissima musica🎶🎶 mi piace😍grazie e complimenti💕❤🍷
Beautiful, Deutschland is blessed to have folks like Ludwig posting these treasures here, otherwise they'd be lost to time
i wouldnt say were blessed...sadly many people in my country are singing these songs again....not to honor our culture but to spread the message the soldeiers who created this song wanted to spread. Even though this song doesnt exaclty to the third reich at all many guys do by singing this song. I admire our culture and the folk lores we have but i dont admire the context these songs are put in.
Ich Muss zur schule aber zuerst dieses schöne lied anhören
Das ist richtig Patriotisch. Bravo.
Echt toll!
die ganzen alten Lieder sind viel besser als der rap Mist von meinen Klassenkameraden
@@kristiank.7670 jup
@@kristiank.7670 Sie sind
Richtig und wichtig
That is so beautiful that I cryed
@EinSoldat! Well, I deeply criticize the biased and lying leftist way to tell history that is teach in the schools. Did I answer your question?
Me too
Its so beautiful my mom told me to turn it off cause her computer has louder speakers lol
@@infiliush1934 Funny, looking at the symbol in your name.
@@tiwaz4598 Yes, the communist logo, or whatever the soviets used it.
Absolutes Lieblingslied.
Dabei fühle ich etwas, was schon lange verloren scheint.
You feel something that seems lost....for long long time.
Patriotismus ?
Deutschland?
Deutschland!
Wieder ein sehr schönes flottes Lied, was man wieder mitsingen kann. Einfach sehr schön
Favorite song
"Hey Dimitri, what's that?"
*grabs telescope*
"It looks like the Silesian army...but it's only a quarter of our size. Dont worry, it's an easy win"
*the next day*
"DIMITRI, YOU SAID IT'D BE EASY!"
*meanwhile*
*happy German noises*
This song could also tell
about freikorps and Silesian natives versus Polish and French armies in civil war in 1919-21
@@Aleksander---- I am sure it is from the "Eiserne Division" in the baltic
@@SoaCrow I know, i mean it could tell a story at the same time, with a bit converted text
Кек
War had no happiness, no matter the victories. There was always a new widow, and a new soul lost to humanity’s forever squabbling.
Better translation, thanks. This one is soo much better, it's perfect.
Es ist sehr schön .Leid und Sehnsucht.
❤
It always makes me laugh when UA-cam takes these videos down...it shows complete ignorance if German culture. Just listen to the lyrics! It's about stoicism and a sense duty, not rampant evil. If anything it is often pessimistic about "glory".
you are right, this is just about german soldiers who supported the Russian white army, Not Murder Talk, UA-cam really just assumes that these are evil songs
Even for WW2 German Songs, almost none of them have anything to do, with the Nazis or things like that nature
Please don't get me wrong, I love this channel and I have been learning how to speak german.
But those types of videos rally some undesirable people, extremists, neo-nazis, it becomes a meet-up point.
Of course this isn't the intention of Dr.Ludwig, but it happens. It's like random uploads from children that atract pedophiles, youtube removes those videos because of uncultured neo-nazis and extreme right wing that use those songs as ways of meeting up, and youtube does it's best to try and stop those guys from acting up, removing videos or the entire channel because of it.
And normal people like us, who just aprecciate the songs and the culture get caught up in between the crossfire.
@@kaboon3489 "undesirable" political views still have 1st Amendment rights in America, where the servers and UA-cam are based. "undesirable" is often a matter of opinion and when it is banned in the US it has to pass the "strict scrutiny" legal test...and banning a song BECAUSE SOME PEOPLE LIKE IT definitely does not pass strict scrutiny.
@@KaiTakApproach Those fall under the hate speech policy of the Terms of Service, so the law in America does not affect the policies of UA-cam. Now, I don't agree with the practice of taking down those videos, but I believe this is the main reason why.
I think its mainly uneducated Karen like people who search YT just to find videos and take them down. I think they get satisfaction and believe they are helping but in reality are being a pest.
Sehr schön,Danke fürs hochladen. 👍👍👍⚫⚪🔴
Just recently listened to this song completely, God, it's cool!
Beautiful song.
I have cried imagining the pain of those men who gave their freedom and their lives in the fight against the tyranny that devastated their beloved country.
Beatiful feeling …
Thanks for to share.
i really love this song
it feels like one of those you'd sing at a fire (like Vom Barette Schwankt Die Feder and Trum Trum Terum Tum Tum)
however i hear no difference between this one and the one from July 12th 2019
Great as always :)
There is a cool old German song tapfere kleine soldatenfrau, I was wondering if you already have it in your channel? If you don't, you could upload it. :) I love that song. XD
Das Lied passt genau in der heutigen Situation !!!
"Keine Freiheit mehr"
⚪🔵⚪
Danke für dieses Wundervolle Lied. Passt zur Aktuellen Situation!!! Und auch noch im Englischen besser Übersetzt gute Arbeit Dr.Ludwig
Welche Situation?
@@ro_1758Russland/Ukraine ?
The violin at the end is just the cherry on top of the sweeties, nicest and tastiest cake ever
One of my favorite songs about the Russian civil war and all that had a hand in it. If only the soviets lost.
interesting thought about soviets losing civil war. Maybe the butterfly effect would be that the germans would win second world war, who knows ! maybe the romanov house would end, because of sick heird for the throne, who knows ! wish i was a seer and see these things through lol
Honestly if the whites won the russian civil war it would be no more than a rump state to the Germans and would likely go fascist in the 1930s. Also Russia wouldn’t industrialize until much later than they did, nor as quickly
@@kyleerickson6022 they might of intervened at the start of ww2 though making it much quicker
Now that I think about it, Russia may have still been on Germany’s dinner menu due to the Ostplan, but I don’t know how much Hitler would’ve been frothing at the mouth about Bolshevism if the Reds lost the Russian civil war.
@@kyleerickson6022 russia would most likely join the allies so russia would probably declare war on germany at the start making a war with russia inevitable even if they weren’t communist
За Веру, Царя и Оттечество!
Ваш царь был немцем
@@ЭдитКамю Лол, говоришь так, будто это что-то плохое.
Учитывая то, какие "русские" правят в России после революции, и то, сколько десятков миллионов русских людей они помножили на ноль, то сейчас о царе-немце можно только мечтать 👌
@@insomnious7592 хз Сталин и Ленин тоже не были русскими, но скольких русских они убили
@@ЭдитКамю убивали тех кто был хоть как то против новой власти
Vielen danke I DrLudwig
This is badass!!
Awe i want a 1 h version cuz i like it so much D:
First, but how are there no views but 3 thumbs up
Danke Herr Ludwig for this masterpiece!
Diese Melodie kommt mir von irgendwo bekannt vor.
Woher denn?
I've been trying to find this song with no lyrics and, with the exact same rythm and beat. Literally this exact song and style but, nobody singing. I can't seem to find it anywhere.
Beautiful song damn
we need them in nowadays so badly :(
they aint comming back formthe dead , all you can do is be like them
Strength
best song of all time
My new favorite song
Währ das nicht so gefährlich mit Kopfhörern Fahrrad zu fahren würde ich das mir die ganze Zeit anhören wenn ich zur Schule fahre einfach klasse 👍
Aber bitte, mach sowas nicht, Deine Eltern wären schrecklich traurig!! Sei vorsichtig, trotz aller Liebe zur Musik, was ja grossartig ist. Hab selbst einen "cascadeur" in meiner Familie und immer Angst, dass ihm was passiert! Schönen Tag und LG aus Montreal, Qc, Canada
Inge Mayodon ja habe ich ja auch gesagt das ich so was nicht machen würde weil das einfach fahrlässig ist und ich damit alle gefährden würde aber danke 👍
@@evnerhara2913 Bravo, bin stolz, dass Du vernünftig bist. Recht schönes Wochenende ohne Virus!!!
Música recia para gente recia!!!
Hermosa!!! 🇪🇦🇩🇪
Also is anyone having loading issues every other UA-cam video that is not dr. Ludwig works and I've even reset my phone came back in to edit this to add this now that it's still not loading
I had this too yesterday when it came out but today it just worked without complications
Is this a real upload did UA-cam take down the original
Asking myself the same thing
Considering it's next in my recommended, I sincerely doubt it was taken down. Most likely it has updated translations.
It’s pretty much just improved translations.
How many times you reuploaded this song??
It's another version
Bitte sag mir, dass das auf Spotify ist
das gute zeug gibts nie auf spotify
Impressive song.
mein Lieblingslied
Another one forgot to add to favorite list :D
Good song
love this song
👑 Der Herr unser Gott kennt die Tage der Rechtschaffenen, Und ihr Erbe wird ewiglich bestehen.
Sie sollen nicht zuschanden werden zur bösen Zeit,
Sondern genug haben auch in den Tagen der Hungersnot.
Psalm 37, Vers 18+19👑
Das Lied gefälllt mir sehr!
Danke Dr. Ludwig und Gottes reichen Segen!
Amen. ✝️
@@Koresos. Gott segne dich Patriot😍❤🙏
Ulrike Jahnz Gott segne und behüte dich, Schwester.
I see a Russian eagle, I click.
*GPOP*
Traduccion por en Google al español
Por la noche el hambre permanece rígida en nuestro sueño, durante el día sonaron los disparos desde el borde del bosque. La miseria acompaña a las columnas y los lobos las acompañan en la escarcha y la niebla.
El águila sagrada de Rusia sigue volando Madre, nuestra sangre te pertenece solo a ti, el ejército rojo puede perseguirnos, la bandera sigue brillando.
2. Oh, hay un poder orgulloso, no suenan campanas en la noche roja.
Poste pasos, no más libertad, Detrás de alambre de púas se yergue un ejército cansado en silencio Uno canta las viejas canciones atrae la tristeza y el anhelo de nuestro pecho, suena salvaje y desafiante otra vez, en el olvido yace la vieja lujuria.
3. Y como ejército que no tiene hogar, ahora nos movemos de pueblo en pueblo, gente deportada viene a escuchar nuestra canción.
El viaje continúa, la gloria y las flores sin sentido. ¡Hogar Hogar! los coros tararean, tu imagen se eleva mil veces, nuestros tenores tocan campanas, los bajos de órgano suenan aburridos y salvajes.
Oh wow. I don't know Latin it any languages but with knowledge of German and English I was able to decipher what it meant..... btw I didn't realize until just now that this was a translation of the song lol
Gracias por la traduccion bro
immer wieder geil :D
Wasn’t this already made before
Anyone got a clue who this particular recording is from? I can't find any upload of this recording that actually mentions the performers
I finally found the fucking source after a year, I can finally put proper artist and album tags on the .mp3 file. This is from the album "Gegen den Strom" by Jungenschaft Schwarzer Adler
their banner aint standing anymore...
Nachtsss steht Hunger starr in unser’m Traum….
The song I'll sing on ww3
Warum hast du dieses Video ein zweites mahl hochgeladen?
Wollte ich nur mal fragen.
♥️♥️♥️🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼
wann auf spotify
The tone kind of resembles war. A slow start, then fast, then stopped, and repeated over.
‘ May the red army hunt us, our banner still shines brightly! ‘ Hurra!
You won't prob answer this but I wonder where you got the background picture from, I would love to have it.
If you go to my Christmas 2020 video, there is a download link with all my pictures^^
@@dr.ludwig Oh okay! Dankeschön ^^
Please, make russian subtitles
You know any of the names of the singers?
Weiß jemand wer das gesungen hat?
Does anyone know who has sung this version?
Reupload ????
I need videos like this without music, any recommends?
Is this on Spotify??
Who are performing this?!
ja
Russia?
Video description
Written for the German troops that fought within Russia during the Russian Civil War (?), if I interpreted the description correctly.
Von wo stammt das Lied und welche Bedeutung hat es? LG
Am Ende oder kurz nach dem 1. Weltkrieg ging der Bürgerkrieg und der Krieg zwischen Polen und Russland und auf dem Baltikum noch weiter. Dort kämpften auch noch versprengte deutsche Verbände mit und daher kommen diese Lieder.
@@dr.ludwig Vielen Dank für die hilfreiche Antwort. 😁😁👍👍
@@dr.ludwig Also sind die Lieder von deutschen gemacht worden?
Warum lädst du manche Lieder 2 mal hoch
Weil sie oftmals gesperrt werden und dann wieder entsperrt werden. Oder weil es neue Versionen gibt ^^
How can you buy this song? Can't find it
Download it my friend.
You can Convert it with many apps
👍👍
База
this feel like germans singing about their future misery in thr gulag
❤
Panier should be banier I think
Yes. It currently is "Banner" for Germans (due to some change, apparantly after WW1 somewhere), but in Dutch it is still "banier". Not sure why he thought it would be written with a P.
No more brother wars.
alles über mich
Und was
Why not on spotify?
Bayern 2x0 PSG.
- Coutinho ⚽
- Lewamdowisk ⚽
🏆🏆
TROPA DOS NEYMARZETE LOUUUUCCCOOOOOO PAUUUUUU NOOOOO CUUUUUUU DO BAYERNNNNNNNNN TA IN SHOCK????? 🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷
Red’ deutsch
Bloody onions...
Hello Bavaria ball
Hello, make a Saxonyball!
#StandWithHongKong
can please anyone explaine how is it possible that the nazi song can still be recorded? i know this one is not nazi one but i mean the other
Usually they only go for German channels, american or especially asian ones have not such big problems.
Das ist soweit ich weiß, kein Nazi Lied. Sondern ein Freikorps Lied.
"Noch fliegt Russlands heiliger Adler"
⚪⚪⚪⚪⚪
🔵🔵🔵🔵🔵
⚪⚪⚪⚪⚪
🇾🇪⚫️⚪️🔴
Muzikalni glumci a ne ratnici