I will upload more songs now where we are heading to 100k^^ Also this is a great channel playing old songs on harmonica, why not leave a sub for this fine man :) ua-cam.com/video/WYHz4cJAiOo/v-deo.html
Maybe the song is a cover. But as you probably know the German empire actually aided the Bolshevik party by aiding the release of Vladimir Lenin from exile
I know there were pockets of Germans in Russia, also just an idea for 100k, do a compilation of all marches, instrumental, what have you and what not, would be pretty cool
My grandfather said to me when I was a little boy: "If you have something to eat, then eat it immediatly. If you have alcohol to drink, then drink it directly. If you find a good girl - then love her forever." I miss him. He walked home from Stalingrad.
@@fw_0643 Du hast aber auch Glück, dass du Freunde hast, die mit einer solch schönen Musik mit dir durch den Wald laufen und mit dir zusammen dazu viben. Meine würden mich für verrückt erklären wenn ich sowas anmachen würde :(
@@viktorov1tch in welchem Bundesland wohnst du? Ich glaube das hat etwas mit der Mentalität der Menschen zutun bei uns im Osten wird damit offener umgegangen auch unter den Jugendlichen
Mein Opa war im zweiten Weltkrieg, er fiel, immer wenn ich dieses Lied höre erinnere ich mich an ihn, 😢 Er war in der Wehrmacht, aber er wusste er fällt, er sagte zu meiner Oma immer: „Sorge doch nicht, ihr alle wisst das ich fallen werde, aber ich Kämpfe bis zum Tod!”
This is why there is a German version: After the 1st world war, the Baltic states were under pressure because Germany lost direct connection to them and also lost a lot of territories. The newly-established Soviet state started to expand and the easiest way was to attack small countries (the Baltic states). The German population in the Baltic states (pretty big) formed, with the help of main-land Germany, a paramilitary force to fight off the Bolsheviks (formed the Freikorps). After the victory in the Baltic states, the Freikorps was declared a terrorist group and thus, unconstitutional. So a lot of ex-Freikorps members (a lot of them were also WW1 veterans) went on and fought in the White Army. Briefing: ex-Freikorps members went on and fought in the White Army. Most of them were German WW1 veterans.
I love how a fellow romanian can explain stuff so good. Buna treaba ! Also to add in this subject.There was this ''West Russian Volunteer Army'',formed by some remaining Freikorps in the Baltics under General Rüdiger von der Goltz (also leader of the kinda famous ''Eiserne Division") and the 'Special Russian Corps' .under General Pavel Bermont-Avalov.(was a cossack btw, thus probably the cossack origin of the song ?).This roughly 50.000 strong army was formed mainly by Freikorps, the russian unit and some russian pow's in german custody.
Stahl und Eisen They were promised Latvian citizenship if they were willing to fight for Latvia for more than 4 weeks. The promise of land was a false memory. A state was definitely never promised to them. Political changes caused that no citizenships were granted in the end.
My grandmother would sing this to me when I was just a boy - I never knew what it meant, where it was from, or what it was called. I just recently found it and this song has filled a gap in my heart with nostalgia, I never knew how dark of a song it was.
I dont find it so dark considering the dark times by then. To thebimprisoned Russians the song is dedicated to it miggt be a preperation Song to figgt the battle that would decide if they would end living their knees orbdie standing tall!
Unsere Großmütter trugen alles Leid der Welt, ihre Liebe verloren im Krieg gegen unsere Brüder. Gaben sie alles um unsere Zukunft wieder aufzubauen und bekamen nie den Ruhm, der ihnen gebürt.
Mein Urgroßvater der an der Ostfront war sang ab und zu solche lieder. Als wir Kinder waren hat er uns immer seine Geschichte erzählt und das war für uns seltsam sie zu hören. Zwischen 1918 und 1923 ist er in den Baltischen Länden geblieben. Dort war er der einziege Lothinger.
And also, the Wehrmacht were on most part just doing their jobs, they were SOLDIERS, the "real" nazis were the SS, you know, the ones that literally organized and railroaded the holocaust? (i really don't know why people needs the explanation of this)
@@felipesubiabre314 Not even all SS-Members were Nazis. My Grandfather was forced into it around 1944 after being captured in the Soviet Union. He did not want it, but he was forced to fight at the Western Front in the Name of the SS
@@felipesubiabre314 there was actually a big Part in the Wehrmacht, who comitted crimes etc, but of course Not the biggest part You can not say the Wehrmacht was an Army which was "steril" or clue less about the Things happend. Of course i dont want to offend any former soldier, especially the soldiers who just Served as them, but this also has to be mentioned
This is a great song It combines both German voice and the russian soul is still there Greetings from mongolia, a brother of russians and the friend of germans
I am Russian, but I still feel all the pain and fear that permeate this song. May God rest the soul of my great-grandfather and all the people who died on the fields of this terrible war.
I tried to search into Germany fighting alongside Russia during the Civil War, and from what I found, the song could be about the "West Russian Volunteer Army" which was made up of many Baltic Germans and Russian POWs from the Central Powers who were given liberty in return for fighting for Kerensky
There were many sides fighting in Russian civil war: White army, Red army, Green army, Black army, Kronstadt's marines and even foreigners- Freikorps, Czechoslovak legiones, some British and French military interventions....
@@jakedorent9450 Mostly. As Slovak, I tried few times to study the history of Czechoslovak Legion's deployment in Russia, but it's so complicated. In WWI times, the Triple Entente powers were supporting the sites, who were against peace with Germany. Czechoslovak Legion was fighting Germans, then Bolsheviks, then they were dealing with Bolsheviks, than fighting them again. They were controlling Siberia for a while, then retreat to Europe via Vladivostok and USA.
@@Martina-Kosicanka Yeah, the whole Russian Civil War is confusing in many ways, at one point even the central Powers indirectly participated in the conflict
when i was in the city of haifa in israel i met an elderly woman sitting on her property in front of her house where she sang this song to her grandchildren. When I asked her how she knew this song and, more importantly, where she learned German from, she replied that she comes from East Prussia and that she fled to Palestina at the time of the Third Reich. She said that she is dreaming of returning to Germany to spend her last days there and to die in her home country Germany. but since east prussia no longer exists, it makes no sense for this woman to leave israel. she told me stories about germany and how beautiful this country should be and her stories motivated me to learn the german language. Und mittlerweile beherrsche ich die deutsche sprache sogar sehr gut und bin sogar in der lage im beruf deutsch zu benutzen. Aus dem grund verbindet mich dieses lied sehr stark zu Deutschland.
Really interesting. But of course she could have returned. "east prussia" doesn´t exist, but the country does. Besides: Usbekistan, right strong country, great people, rich history... but a totally neurotic illiterate psychopath as a president. What the F*ck is up with all these ex-ussr countries? Kirgistan, Usbekistan, Kasachstan...all are ruled by some pathetic meatheads and disgusting servile administration that should all end rather in some boot camps than having any kind of power.
@@RodrigoBorgia thanks for the nice compliments, that's very kind of you. the problem with the ex soviet republics is because that there were so many undemocratic parties and organizations during the collapse of the soviet union. these organizations overran the governments of the respective countries and the later military and financial aid from russia allowed the dictators to retain their power. i mean check out kasakstan. i believe that the "(president)" has been ruling for 25 years and only with russian aid could uprisings be prevented. In addition, the governments ensure that the people are as premitive and uneducated as possible so that they never get the idea of rebelling. that's why i went to israel immediately after i found out that i had jewish ancestry because i am able to study intelligently there and to live in a democracy. I definitely hope that one day democracy and progress will come to these countries.
The last sentence got me. Gratulation zu deinen Deutschkenntnissen! Very sad that these people will be dead very soon and no one really cared to interview and preserve their stories.
@@Túrin_Tura Fascism is the devil ideology not Communism. Don't get me wrong, respect to everyone who fought and died in the wars. But calling communism ideology devil is ridiculous, it may be a lie or unrealistic utopia but definitely not a devil.
@@Tatusiek_1 nope rasional and real. How does red army at that time represent "communism" for you ?. They were the army just try to get power and create socialist system. What they have done as crime are up the them not the ideology.
@@seddam Both of them was the same! Cati oameni au fost ucisi de catre ,,partidul la putere'' in timp de pace?!!! Si culmea: conationali! Deci, tot cetateni din tara sa!
Newsflash. This song has absolutely nothing to do with WW2. It’s about a bunch of Germans that were forced to fight the Soviets during the Russian civil war right after WWI. Please people…do some damn research before making a comment.
Greetings to German bros from a Russian dude. May the souls of all those who died in the war with the Bolsheviks rest in peace, and no more brother killing wars. 🇩🇪 ♥️ 🇷🇺
My Frandma grew up in the DDR, my family is living near Berlin and Lübben since the 11 Century. My Grandma and my Mother told me, the russians were much better to us than the americans. And I also grew up as a boy, living in Lübben and a friend of the russians. Btw I#m very sorry for my bad english...
@@Reichsritter what are you talking about? Germany has developed into the most important economy within the EU, which has the largest domestic market on the world, thus having massive influence on many countries of europe. How is Germany weak now, and why should Germany become "holy" again? Isn't state enforced religion a bit outdated?
@@Reichsritter so we should enact more reforms, which favor poor people? We dont need a "holy eagle" for that. Germany is one of the most democratic countries i the western world, it should not be a problem to fix these problems, if most of the people agree with the solutions.
My post here for eagle mentions. Where eagle and meaning came from, and when passed away. Germany had historical heritage of holy roman empire, till 1945, it died with third reigh. Russia had historical heritage from eastern roman empire, it died in 1917. Those eagles. Both nations could be best friends and united could form new "roman empire". But anglosacsons flooded with money germany and confused russia, that ended in world wars, at the end killing germany and russia as world powers. At the end, now, germany arent even superpower, russia still is, but weak and may break with death of putin.
I know there were many Baltic German officers in the White Russian ranks, and also there were units of ethnic German fighting alongside them in the Baltic theatre of the war. This might be why there’s a German version of the song
@@bangtang1717 I'm fairly certain the song was written by a German songwriter who wanted to honor the White Movement soldiers who fought against the Bolsheviks.
For a time germans were considered The jews of russia because in 17th/18th-19th Century germans Ran so many things in russia especialy bzisnesses but they also we're renown AS Farmers etc
I mean it wasn't entirely selfless since Germans in Slavic nations - Besserabia Germans, Volga Germans and more but especially the Mennonites - were at high risk in the bolshevik revolution for, you know... being Kulaks and all.
Der Vater Meiner Ur-Oma wurde aufgrund seiner Leistungen als Wehrmachtssoldat gegen Ende 1944 als Maschienengewehrschütze zu einer SS-Kompanie beordert um die Großen Verluste auszugleichen und hatte davor schon an der Ostfront bei Stalingrad gekämpft. 1945 war er dann tatsächlich an der Schlacht um Berlin beteiligt und überlebte schließlich bis zum Kriegsende. Dieses Lied sang er damals meiner Ur-Oma vor als dieser mit seiner Familie ins Rheinland zog. Bis heute hat sie sich dies eingeprägt und hat es mir auch vorgesungen als ich anfing mich für die Weltkriege zu interessieren. Mögen die Opfer der Männer und Frauen in diesen Blutigen Konflikten unvergessen bleiben…
Mein uhr-opa war in der leibstandarte.ich habe ihn zwar nie kennen gelernt,habe aber viel von ihm gehört. Er hatte viele orsen und andere sachen da gelassen,die sind aber verschollen... er hatte sogar ein eisernes kreuz 2ter klasse. Er hat auch im ersten weltkrieg gekämpft.da war er aber sehr jung. Er hatte trotzdem viele orden,eine uniform und mehr mit nach hause gebracht. Ist sie aber alle losgeworden....ich weiß immer noch nicht wieso...schlechte erinnerungen?trauer? Wut? Ich bin mir nicht sicher. Aber naja. Ich werde es wohl nicht erfahren.
@@So-ein-typ es geht vielen so, der ganze alte besitz meiner uropas ist weg... so traurig einer gefallen in der luftwaffe, abgeschossen. ein andere kriegsgefangener der russen und später nach hause gekommen. keine papiere, keine uniformen. nichts außer ein paar briefe sind uns geblieben.
Obwohl Krieg natürlich schrecklich für alle involvierten ist, bewundere ich alle die den Mut haben ihre Angst zu überwinden und in die Schlacht zu ziehen, und ich finde, dieses Lied fängt die diese Dualität des Krieges sehr gut ein
Mut? Dummheit. Ich würde doch nicht für irgendwelche Machtgeilen Politiker, losgehen und fremden Väter, Söhne und Brüder töten....Menschen die mir nie etwas getan haben.
@@Langermar Some Germans from the Reichswehr fought in Kolchak's White Army against the Bolshevists. Cf. Dwinger's "Between White and Red". His mother was Russian. Interesting fact: he later joined the SS.
Girls become sad because of Titanic and my heart Will go on Boys become sad because of Fast and Furious and see you again Real men become sad because of war and this wonderful song.
Das Lied handelt vom Bürgerkrieg in Russland, ich weiß nicht, wie es Ihnen geht, aber für mich ist dies das Ereignis, meine Heimat für 70 Jahre zu verlieren.
I find myself coming back to this video time and time again because it is such a good song and it is important to remember the fallen on both sides, not just the victors.I have a great respect for those that fought in both sides of both world wars and those that have fought before and since.
Nein als deutscher darf man das laut kultur nicht sagen. Ich bin absolut gegen national sozialismus aber stolz ist etwas was komplett aus unserer Kultur verbannt wurde.
@@ThEWilliam105 I wouldn't necessarily say it's the US's fault, tho they were responsible for that indoctrination in the first place. But today it's out own goverment and the EU that fear that history is going to repeat itself which is total nonsence when considering how our culture is, especially fuckers like von der leyen that keep on oppressing history and cultural.
Vielen Dank für's Lob :) Jemand hat es mal mit den Gebrüdern Grimm verglichen, welche ebenfalls die deutschen Sagen und Märchen gesammelt, veredelt und der breiten Masse zugänglich gemacht haben und ohne diese unsere Kultur nun weitaus ärmer wäre.
@@dr.ludwig Ja, die Gebrüder Grimm haben viel zum Erhalt der Kultur beigetragen. Ich bin Schweizer, und dein Kanal hat mir etwas mehr über meinen Nachbarn im Norden beigebracht.
My grandfather was born after the great war, in 1925 or something. However his father fought at the German ranks durning this time (we are Polish). Unfortunately I couldn't meet him, but my grandfather lived to 2017 and he told me stories about how after the great war his father would sit on his chair and croon the songs he have heard from his German comrades. May both my Grandfather and his father rest in peace, great song.
Egal welcher politischen Ansicht man nun auch ist, man sollte mMn das Lied dafür nehmen was es ist oder wofür es eigentlich geschrieben wurde. Es ist wunderschön aber es klingt auch so viel Leid und Sehnsucht mit. Ich bin froh niemals einen Krieg miterlebt zu haben und ich hoffe das bleibt nicht nur für mich sondern auch für alle nach mir so.
i live in germany and it's so sad to see how many people here are ashamed of the past. Yes, it wasn't nice back then, but we have to live with history because it brought us to what Germany is today
You have no idea about German history.. It was good. The Kaiserreich was one of the best places before the war. Everything besides the 12 dark years is absolutely GREAT history. We don't live with it.. We should be proud. After all the Germans created this modern stupid shit world.
I love this song. it does a really good job of painting the bleak picture of an exhausted army with no place to return to and little hope of victory. And yet in the chorus there's this spark of defiance that i think is really quite beautiful.
Das Europa von damals brannte lichterloh, zigmillionen Tote. Alle sechs Brüder meiner einen Großmutter sind gefallen. Das Europa von heute ist ein Paradies du Held!
The Friekorp and the White army soldiers fighting in the civil war together must have been a melancholic sight as both past enemies realise they just lost both of their Empires.
You can download Audacity and record the sound straight from you sound card it's easy and I use this since on Spotify the sound quality is A LOT higher.
@Captain Blyat I am sure that Poland attacked the Bolsheviks first to grab land and anyways the Soviets never had any intentions to do military invasion(s) of Europe.
My parents are from Soviet Union. In childhood, they learned German at school. Because "you must know the language of the enemy" even though the war is long gone. It was in 70s, in a small village in Central Asia, USSR.
Ooh this is beautiful! I don't know which I like better - the guitar, the voices, the obvious language or how they sing slow, at first, then the rhythm fastens, then slows down again - and repeats! Amazing!(I've heard this kind before, but I can't get over how good it(this song is - and I just came across it!). I'm sorry it took me this long, Dr. Ludwig.
a while ago I thought german sounded very rude, and I couldn't be anymore wrong, those songs have been helping me to learn the language, as I want to get into WW2 and WW1 reenactment, german is very beautiful.
@Belu-NationalSozialistische DeutscheArbeiterPartei Kannst du bitte mir was Sie meinen erklären? Ich frage weil vielleicht wir haben eine gleiche Meinung.Vielen Dank!
1. Eine wunderschöne Melodie; daß macher wähnt, es gäbe eine russische Version, ist glaubhaft und naheliegend. 2. Ein ergreifender Text, der dem Pathos des Krieges den Spiegel der Tatsächlichkeit engegenhält und dem Menschen (hier: Soldaten) dessen stets neuerliche Verführbarkeit gleich mit - großartig. 3. Ein Text, der deutlich aufzeigt, zu welcher Feierlichkeit und blumigem Wortgirlandentum unsere schöne deutsche Muttersprache mit Leichitgkeit fähig ist - ein Genuss, ihr zuzuhören ! Besten Dank, Dr. Ludwig
Songs like this make me relate to my German brethren who fought across the world. Makes me humble that I am still here despite whatever is thrown at me by the world
Why do I keep listening to this sad song? A song of defeat. This one and Die Grenzwacht Hilt Im Osten, which are along the same subject, are my favorite, i listen to them a lot.
there are forces that do not want the russian and german people to be friends. because that's what they're afraid of. i hope that our peoples can have a good future and can live peacefully with each other and be friends
Ich habe einen deutschen Vater und eine russische Mutter, meine Familie in Russland liebt Deutschland und die deusche Kultur , trotz der aktuellen Lage... Ich habe Hoffnung, dass beide Länder irgendwann wieder eine gute Beziehung zueinander pflegen werden❤ Sehr schönes Lied
Блять, ти дебіл, ви роzzіяни їбані імперіці, при любій владі ви хочете знищити і асимілювати інших, яка нахуй дружба з цивілізованою країною. Ти хоч трохи історію вчи, вас потрібно ізолювати.
Ich habe zu DDR - Zeiten eine Russisch-Sonderschule besucht, und habe bei einer sogenannten Russisch-Olympiade der DDReinen 2.Platz belegt, auf den ich heute noch stolz bin. Auch ich liebe die Russische Kultur. Ich bin sehr traurig, dass meine lange geplante Reise nach Moskau zum Bolschoi-Ballett durch die polit. Umstände ins Wasser fiel, ich hoffe, dass ich es bald nachholen kann!! 😍
I lost all my great grandfathers in WW2, one in the Baltic Sea, another one somewhere in Hungary, one in Stalingrad. My fathers family fled from Marienburg to Berlin. My grandma fled with her mom and her sisters from the russians as fast as they could from Usedom to a "safe" place. WW2 really messed it up for everybody.
Viele Grüße nach Russland, Bruder. Ich liebe Russland und die russische Kultur. Hoffentlich werden unsere Länder in Zukunft wieder den Weg zueinander finden🇩🇪🇷🇺. Ich würde viel lieber mit den Russen zusammen gegen das böse Kämpfen. Viele Grüße von einem deutschen Soldaten, ich hoffe wir stehen irgendwann zusammen auf dem Feld, singen lieder und trinken Bier zusammen.🇩🇪🍻🇷🇺
@@ye-yo89Well i am russian and Ukrainian and for me it hurts even more since the war broke out but also thanks for your support i hope that this Putin will get his punishment for all innocents which died in war and still are suffering. My German is sadly not so good because i am only studying here and then i am going back to America but i have to say you’re country changed alot you Germans were once a so proud and strong nation i hope this time will come back anyways enough talking stay safe.
Amerika wird das immer verhindern, weil sie sonst niemand mehr brauchen würde. Die Technologie aus Deutschland, die Ressourcen aus Russland und niemand hätte eine Chance.
![Wo alle Straßen enden [German soldier song][+English translation]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1FUxefT7WmA/mqdefault.jpg)
![Wo alle Straßen enden [German soldier song][+English translation]](/img/tr.png)
![Die Grenzwacht hielt im Osten [German folk song][+English translation]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/NlqyBIQ-Cac/mqdefault.jpg)
![Nachts steht Hunger starr in unserm Traum [German soldier song][+English translation]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/HDW-eO-z-Es/mqdefault.jpg)
![„Wir sind des Geyers schwarzer Haufen“ • Soldatenlied [+Liedtext]](/img/n.gif)
I will upload more songs now where we are heading to 100k^^ Also this is a great channel playing old songs on harmonica, why not leave a sub for this fine man :) ua-cam.com/video/WYHz4cJAiOo/v-deo.html
i agree
Maybe the song is a cover. But as you probably know the German empire actually aided the Bolshevik party by aiding the release of Vladimir Lenin from exile
@@caz8577 Yes because the Tsar, the cousin of Wilhelm, decided to ally against Germany.
what is the original name of the song(russian)?
I know there were pockets of Germans in Russia, also just an idea for 100k, do a compilation of all marches, instrumental, what have you and what not, would be pretty cool
My grandfather said to me when I was a little boy: "If you have something to eat, then eat it immediatly. If you have alcohol to drink, then drink it directly. If you find a good girl - then love her forever."
I miss him. He walked home from Stalingrad.
Me too
My grandfather to
@@infiliush1934 Schlesier here. The Vandals ... prost.
Fuck man, that’s sad.
un grande tu abuelo, saludos desde hispanoamérica, chile.
Some people say german is an ugly, aggressive language. No. German is such a beautiful language.
😗
But it's a cold language
people claiming this have big crooked noses and love money
I suggest people that say this should necer listen to any east european language lol
@@talhayilmaz5828 how can it be cold?
German music just captures men’s brotherhood like no other.
Faxx
@@drameye9433bandage
That feeling is called called Männerbund.
True man
Ja mein bruder
Dieses lied singen und währenddessen im Wald mit Freunde übernachten. Es gibt nichts besseres
❤️
Oder einfach wenn man mit Freunden im Wald spazieren geht das is so ein geiles Gefühl vorallem so im Herbst bei Nebel 👌🏼
@Meinungs Freiheit warum hab ich Glück 😂
@@fw_0643 Du hast aber auch Glück, dass du Freunde hast, die mit einer solch schönen Musik mit dir durch den Wald laufen und mit dir zusammen dazu viben. Meine würden mich für verrückt erklären wenn ich sowas anmachen würde :(
@@viktorov1tch in welchem Bundesland wohnst du? Ich glaube das hat etwas mit der Mentalität der Menschen zutun bei uns im Osten wird damit offener umgegangen auch unter den Jugendlichen
"Mother, our blood is only yours"
talking about mother Russia
@@germankaiser7309 nö
German Kaiser no
@@terziluyurm2211 Yes it does
@@germankaiser7309 White Russia, yes, not the communist bullshit russia
Mein Opa war im zweiten Weltkrieg, er fiel, immer wenn ich dieses Lied höre erinnere ich mich an ihn, 😢 Er war in der Wehrmacht, aber er wusste er fällt, er sagte zu meiner Oma immer: „Sorge doch nicht, ihr alle wisst das ich fallen werde, aber ich Kämpfe bis zum Tod!”
ein ehrbarer Mann
Deinem Opa großen Dank. 🇩🇪
Ruhe in Frieden einer von vielen Helden!✝️
@@JoelMüller-b6f Dubious statement
@@JoelMüller-b6fWieso Held
This is why there is a German version: After the 1st world war, the Baltic states were under pressure because Germany lost direct connection to them and also lost a lot of territories. The newly-established Soviet state started to expand and the easiest way was to attack small countries (the Baltic states). The German population in the Baltic states (pretty big) formed, with the help of main-land Germany, a paramilitary force to fight off the Bolsheviks (formed the Freikorps). After the victory in the Baltic states, the Freikorps was declared a terrorist group and thus, unconstitutional. So a lot of ex-Freikorps members (a lot of them were also WW1 veterans) went on and fought in the White Army.
Briefing: ex-Freikorps members went on and fought in the White Army. Most of them were German WW1 veterans.
I love how a fellow romanian can explain stuff so good.
Buna treaba !
Also to add in this subject.There was this ''West Russian Volunteer Army'',formed by some remaining Freikorps in the Baltics under General Rüdiger von der Goltz (also leader of the kinda famous ''Eiserne Division") and the 'Special Russian Corps' .under General Pavel Bermont-Avalov.(was a cossack btw, thus probably the cossack origin of the song ?).This roughly 50.000 strong army was formed mainly by Freikorps, the russian unit and some russian pow's in german custody.
Stahl und Eisen They were promised Latvian citizenship if they were willing to fight for Latvia for more than 4 weeks. The promise of land was a false memory. A state was definitely never promised to them. Political changes caused that no citizenships were granted in the end.
Thanks for the background!!
Well.. sending Lenin back to Russia was not a good idea..
Well there were also the volga germans
"Heimat, Heimat!" summen die Chöre... Wunderschön❤
gänsehaut. im gedanken daran unter welchen umständen man dieses lied gemeinsam anstimmte, stehen mir die haare zu berge.
@@Maroder12 jawohl Kamerad 🍺
🖤🖤🖤
❤❤❤
💛💛💛
Was redest du da von kamerad mein gott das dunkelste capitel unserer geschiechte sche$$ naz$$ schwei$ save warst du noch net mal an einer front
@@melvinvoggel9792 wer ist hier n Nazi? Wegen dem "Kamerad"? Junge wie Cringe...
My grandmother would sing this to me when I was just a boy - I never knew what it meant, where it was from, or what it was called. I just recently found it and this song has filled a gap in my heart with nostalgia, I never knew how dark of a song it was.
are you american ?
@@peeron6829 Yes, and she was from Germany and so was my mother, why do you ask?
She was hella based.
I dont find it so dark considering the dark times by then. To thebimprisoned Russians the song is dedicated to it miggt be a preperation Song to figgt the battle that would decide if they would end living their knees orbdie standing tall!
Unsere Großmütter trugen alles Leid der Welt, ihre Liebe verloren im Krieg gegen unsere Brüder. Gaben sie alles um unsere Zukunft wieder aufzubauen und bekamen nie den Ruhm, der ihnen gebürt.
Gott mit uns!
Das Bild ist ja Mal wirklich sehr schön, und das Lied natürlich auch^_^
Einen schönen Tag Kameraden!!!!
Dir auch Kamerad !
@@cedricheuser5052 dir auch
Gott mit uns
Duetschland uber alles mein bruder
Wotan mit uns
Ein sehr schönes Lied und das Bild passt auch sehr gut.👍❤
Sehr Gute Arbeit Dr.Ludwig
muchas canciones suenan mejor en alemán
Mein Urgroßvater der an der Ostfront war sang ab und zu solche lieder. Als wir Kinder waren hat er uns immer seine Geschichte erzählt und das war für uns seltsam sie zu hören. Zwischen 1918 und 1923 ist er in den Baltischen Länden geblieben. Dort war er der einziege Lothinger.
Why does everyone think that German soldier songs are Nazis songs?
While yes the Whermacht sang them they don't deserve the dominitazation
And also, the Wehrmacht were on most part just doing their jobs, they were SOLDIERS, the "real" nazis were the SS, you know, the ones that literally organized and railroaded the holocaust? (i really don't know why people needs the explanation of this)
@@felipesubiabre314 en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myth_of_the_clean_Wehrmacht
@@felipesubiabre314 Not even all SS-Members were Nazis. My Grandfather was forced into it around 1944 after being captured in the Soviet Union. He did not want it, but he was forced to fight at the Western Front in the Name of the SS
@@felipesubiabre314 there was actually a big Part in the Wehrmacht, who comitted crimes etc, but of course Not the biggest part
You can not say the Wehrmacht was an Army which was "steril" or clue less about the Things happend. Of course i dont want to offend any former soldier, especially the soldiers who just Served as them, but this also has to be mentioned
@@twobuddys6910 yes sadly this happend a lot. Lots of unnesessary deaths
This is a great song
It combines both German voice and the russian soul is still there
Greetings from mongolia, a brother of russians and the friend of germans
Robert Nikolaus Maximilian Freiherr von Ungern-Sternberg approves this comment :D
A brother of russians? You mean asian russians?
@@Валерий-е4г6э
Well yes but actually yes
@@tigerii10.5cmpog4 love from Turkey bro
"Brother" more like play thing lmao!
I am Russian, but I still feel all the pain and fear that permeate this song. May God rest the soul of my great-grandfather and all the people who died on the fields of this terrible war.
The Song sing about the bolschewicken war about the Kosaks. The Kosaks stand on the side from Russia. Bevor the Kommis came.
Під цю пісню різали руським солдатикам голови під Києвом у березні 2022, ех, пригадую аж мурахи по шкірі)))
@@lovvv7774It's because of people like you that the war will never end
@@rplay4447 Ага, тому що руські повинні померти усі) з ними не буде життя на Україні. Ви нам за усе відповісте.
@@rplay4447 sure he's guilty. Because it was him who brought those russian soldiers to Kyiv. Right? Right?
2:02 gives me the chills. Every single hair on my arms stick up. Amazing song. Well done.
Me too, truly inspiring
I concur, these soldiers longing for their hown homeland really hits the feelz
Agreed, this song has such Pathos
the same goes for *ceddin deden* but that is turkish. not german
🥲🥲🥲🤗🇩🇪
I tried to search into Germany fighting alongside Russia during the Civil War, and from what I found, the song could be about the "West Russian Volunteer Army" which was made up of many Baltic Germans and Russian POWs from the Central Powers who were given liberty in return for fighting for Kerensky
There were many sides fighting in Russian civil war: White army, Red army, Green army, Black army, Kronstadt's marines and even foreigners- Freikorps, Czechoslovak legiones, some British and French military interventions....
Or is it the Cossack song of Krasnov during the Second World War.
@@Martina-Kosicanka If im not mistaken, The Foreigners supported mostly the White Movement
@@jakedorent9450 Mostly. As Slovak, I tried few times to study the history of Czechoslovak Legion's deployment in Russia, but it's so complicated. In WWI times, the Triple Entente powers were supporting the sites, who were against peace with Germany.
Czechoslovak Legion was fighting Germans, then Bolsheviks, then they were dealing with Bolsheviks, than fighting them again. They were controlling Siberia for a while, then retreat to Europe via Vladivostok and USA.
@@Martina-Kosicanka Yeah, the whole Russian Civil War is confusing in many ways, at one point even the central Powers indirectly participated in the conflict
when i was in the city of haifa in israel i met an elderly woman sitting on her property in front of her house where she sang this song to her grandchildren. When I asked her how she knew this song and, more importantly, where she learned German from, she replied that she comes from East Prussia and that she fled to Palestina at the time of the Third Reich. She said that she is dreaming of returning to Germany to spend her last days there and to die in her home country Germany. but since east prussia no longer exists, it makes no sense for this woman to leave israel. she told me stories about germany and how beautiful this country should be and her stories motivated me to learn the german language.
Und mittlerweile beherrsche ich die deutsche sprache sogar sehr gut und bin sogar in der lage im beruf deutsch zu benutzen. Aus dem grund verbindet mich dieses lied sehr stark zu Deutschland.
Was für eine tolle Geschichte!
@@dr.ludwig danke
Really interesting. But of course she could have returned. "east prussia" doesn´t exist, but the country does.
Besides: Usbekistan, right strong country, great people, rich history... but a totally neurotic illiterate psychopath as a president. What the F*ck is up with all these ex-ussr countries? Kirgistan, Usbekistan, Kasachstan...all are ruled by some pathetic meatheads and disgusting servile administration that should all end rather in some boot camps than having any kind of power.
@@RodrigoBorgia thanks for the nice compliments, that's very kind of you.
the problem with the ex soviet republics is because that there were so many undemocratic parties and organizations during the collapse of the soviet union. these organizations overran the governments of the respective countries and the later military and financial aid from russia allowed the dictators to retain their power. i mean check out kasakstan. i believe that the "(president)" has been ruling for 25 years and only with russian aid could uprisings be prevented. In addition, the governments ensure that the people are as premitive and uneducated as possible so that they never get the idea of rebelling. that's why i went to israel immediately after i found out that i had jewish ancestry because i am able to study intelligently there and to live in a democracy. I definitely hope that one day democracy and progress will come to these countries.
The last sentence got me. Gratulation zu deinen Deutschkenntnissen!
Very sad that these people will be dead very soon and no one really cared to interview and preserve their stories.
Tragic, with it's own sort of beauty. I can't stop listening to it.
Indeed it is tragic. Young german men fighting and dieing in a losing war in a foreign land. All in a desperate hope to defeat an evil ideology.
@@Túrin_Tura Fascism is the devil ideology not Communism. Don't get me wrong, respect to everyone who fought and died in the wars. But calling communism ideology devil is ridiculous, it may be a lie or unrealistic utopia but definitely not a devil.
@@seddam then you must be delusional
@@Tatusiek_1 nope rasional and real. How does red army at that time represent "communism" for you ?. They were the army just try to get power and create socialist system. What they have done as crime are up the them not the ideology.
@@seddam Both of them was the same! Cati oameni au fost ucisi de catre ,,partidul la putere'' in timp de pace?!!! Si culmea: conationali! Deci, tot cetateni din tara sa!
Newsflash. This song has absolutely nothing to do with WW2. It’s about a bunch of Germans that were forced to fight the Soviets during the Russian civil war right after WWI. Please people…do some damn research before making a comment.
Greetings to German bros from a Russian dude. May the souls of all those who died in the war with the Bolsheviks rest in peace, and no more brother killing wars. 🇩🇪 ♥️ 🇷🇺
What are you talking about your country and ours are different we are not even ethnically close but ok sure no more wars.
@@CalebVonGames don’t be a douche bag
👍🏻🤛
Appreciate it from Germany 🇩🇪🤝🇷🇺
My Frandma grew up in the DDR, my family is living near Berlin and Lübben since the 11 Century. My Grandma and my Mother told me, the russians were much better to us than the americans. And I also grew up as a boy, living in Lübben and a friend of the russians. Btw I#m very sorry for my bad english...
May Germany's Holy eagle always fly.
nah, the holy roman empire was quite weak in its last years.
@@Reichsritter what are you talking about? Germany has developed into the most important economy within the EU, which has the largest domestic market on the world, thus having massive influence on many countries of europe. How is Germany weak now, and why should Germany become "holy" again? Isn't state enforced religion a bit outdated?
@@Reichsritter so we should enact more reforms, which favor poor people? We dont need a "holy eagle" for that. Germany is one of the most democratic countries i the western world, it should not be a problem to fix these problems, if most of the people agree with the solutions.
@@brinkipinki Our country is a leftist shithole nowadays.
My post here for eagle mentions. Where eagle and meaning came from, and when passed away. Germany had historical heritage of holy roman empire, till 1945, it died with third reigh. Russia had historical heritage from eastern roman empire, it died in 1917. Those eagles. Both nations could be best friends and united could form new "roman empire". But anglosacsons flooded with money germany and confused russia, that ended in world wars, at the end killing germany and russia as world powers. At the end, now, germany arent even superpower, russia still is, but weak and may break with death of putin.
Es ist wirklich unglaublich dass du soviele alte Lieder in solch guter Qualität zur Verfügung stellst
Rest In Peace all the people who died in the First World War
Not ,,First world War''! It was named ,,The Great War''!
@@marianungureanu5836 here in Germany we say The first world War
@@NugaKrabi6143 Here in Belgium too
*second cuz we can't forget the clutch in the 7 year's war !!!
And second war too
I know there were many Baltic German officers in the White Russian ranks, and also there were units of ethnic German fighting alongside them in the Baltic theatre of the war. This might be why there’s a German version of the song
what was the original? or what were the other versions
@@bangtang1717 I'm fairly certain the song was written by a German songwriter who wanted to honor the White Movement soldiers who fought against the Bolsheviks.
For a time germans were considered The jews of russia because in 17th/18th-19th Century germans Ran so many things in russia especialy bzisnesses but they also we're renown AS Farmers etc
I mean it wasn't entirely selfless since Germans in Slavic nations - Besserabia Germans, Volga Germans and more but especially the Mennonites - were at high risk in the bolshevik revolution for, you know... being Kulaks and all.
it is anazing aint it!
Der Vater Meiner Ur-Oma wurde aufgrund seiner Leistungen als Wehrmachtssoldat gegen Ende 1944 als Maschienengewehrschütze zu einer SS-Kompanie beordert um die Großen Verluste auszugleichen und hatte davor schon an der Ostfront bei Stalingrad gekämpft. 1945 war er dann tatsächlich an der Schlacht um Berlin beteiligt und überlebte schließlich bis zum Kriegsende. Dieses Lied sang er damals meiner Ur-Oma vor als dieser mit seiner Familie ins Rheinland zog. Bis heute hat sie sich dies eingeprägt und hat es mir auch vorgesungen als ich anfing mich für die Weltkriege zu interessieren.
Mögen die Opfer der Männer und Frauen in diesen Blutigen Konflikten unvergessen bleiben…
Mein uhr-opa war in der leibstandarte.ich habe ihn zwar nie kennen gelernt,habe aber viel von ihm gehört.
Er hatte viele orsen und andere sachen da gelassen,die sind aber verschollen... er hatte sogar ein eisernes kreuz 2ter klasse. Er hat auch im ersten weltkrieg gekämpft.da war er aber sehr jung. Er hatte trotzdem viele orden,eine uniform und mehr mit nach hause gebracht. Ist sie aber alle losgeworden....ich weiß immer noch nicht wieso...schlechte erinnerungen?trauer? Wut? Ich bin mir nicht sicher. Aber naja. Ich werde es wohl nicht erfahren.
@@So-ein-typ es geht vielen so, der ganze alte besitz meiner uropas ist weg... so traurig
einer gefallen in der luftwaffe, abgeschossen. ein andere kriegsgefangener der russen und später nach hause gekommen. keine papiere, keine uniformen. nichts außer ein paar briefe sind uns geblieben.
Мой прадед был в красной армии, но повоевал только с японцами в 1945
mein ur opa starb 1945 in russland und mein anderer war als funker für flugzeuge zuständig und überlebte aber respekt an deinen uropa
Sic Luceat Lux
Obwohl Krieg natürlich schrecklich für alle involvierten ist, bewundere ich alle die den Mut haben ihre Angst zu überwinden und in die Schlacht zu ziehen, und ich finde, dieses Lied fängt die diese Dualität des Krieges sehr gut ein
sie mussten in die schlacht ziehen, ihnen blieb keine andere wahl
Mut? Dummheit. Ich würde doch nicht für irgendwelche Machtgeilen Politiker, losgehen und fremden Väter, Söhne und Brüder töten....Menschen die mir nie etwas getan haben.
And as an army that has no home,
We move now expelled from city to city
Beautiful lyrics
blüht mir es herz bei dem lied
Da werde ich auch ganz Patriotisch 😢
2024 jemand da ?
Hier
Hier
Ja mein Kamerad
Bis ans Lebensende Kamerad! Heimat lebt ewig in meinem Jungen Herzen weiter!
Na klar doch, werde ich noch lange sein B)
UA-cam:I bet Dr. Ludwig is gonna upload another German soldier song
Dr Ludwig: *Uploads Russian* *Soldier song*
UA-cam: *surprise pikachu face*
hahaha XD
Russian: Oh, a channel with German songs. I think I'll subscribe.
Dr Ludwig: *uploads Russian song instead*
I am imagining this Pikachu with Armband, holding baton as one of UA-cam 2019 Thoughtcrime Preventing Battalion's police officer :)
@@Langermar
Some Germans from the Reichswehr fought in Kolchak's White Army against the Bolshevists. Cf. Dwinger's "Between White and Red". His mother was Russian. Interesting fact: he later joined the SS.
it's in german language... still enough for a deletion.
Girls become sad because of Titanic and my heart Will go on
Boys become sad because of Fast and Furious and see you again
Real men become sad because of war and this wonderful song.
Much agreed!
Das Lied handelt vom Bürgerkrieg in Russland, ich weiß nicht, wie es Ihnen geht, aber für mich ist dies das Ereignis, meine Heimat für 70 Jahre zu verlieren.
I'm a girl.. Why am I here then am I real man
Я армянин, говорю на русском, и... Люблю немецкую культуру после армянской. Армянскую культуру я люблю больше. Но эта песня очень красивая.
Yea, I have dedicated my whole history classes and studies to this stuff.
Great soldier song 👍🏻 Thanks for your work as always Ludwig 😃
Tiens une française, sympa de voir une compatriote parmi les musiques allemandes.
Matring Bonjour compatriote, nous ne sommes pas nombreux ici... Ou alors les autres sont tapis dans l'ombre 😁
@@LaPatrioteFrancaise C'est vrai la plupart sont allemands. Sauf cette fois, les russes se sont réveillés et se sont ajoutés aux commentaires.
Matring Effectivement.
I find myself coming back to this video time and time again because it is such a good song and it is important to remember the fallen on both sides, not just the victors.I have a great respect for those that fought in both sides of both world wars and those that have fought before and since.
Respekt, unseren Soldaten, die das erleben mussten. Gott mit euch und allen Gefallenen.
This song introduced me to your channel, thank you for the work of gathering together so much beautiful folk music.
And thank you for the interest
Ich liebe mein Land,darf ich das noch sagen?Ich werde unsere Kultur nie vergessen,wir waren Mal ein Land voller Dichter und Denker
Genios musicales y científicos también
Nein als deutscher darf man das laut kultur nicht sagen.
Ich bin absolut gegen national sozialismus aber stolz ist etwas was komplett aus unserer Kultur verbannt wurde.
Leider
@@X_thespinne And who decided that ? Americans?
@@ThEWilliam105 I wouldn't necessarily say it's the US's fault, tho they were responsible for that indoctrination in the first place.
But today it's out own goverment and the EU that fear that history is going to repeat itself which is total nonsence when considering how our culture is, especially fuckers like von der leyen that keep on oppressing history and cultural.
Dieses Lied lässt mich der Melancholie verfallen, danke für Deine Arbeit, die Tonqualität ist überragend
My son, a 7-year-old, says "this is the best German song I've ever heard!"
He is a fine gentleman with good taste then!
@@dr.ludwig Very true ludwig. Very true.
This song was from a proud NAZI.
Your Son clearly doesnt know "Die 3 Besoffskis"
a refined gentleman in the making, he is.
I loved it, it sounds perfect.
Greetings from Argentina
why did you take our war criminals
@@gamerdrache6076 I've got them
@@gamerdrache6076 war criminals?
@@fuxihutterer8088 Yes war criminals, you need i'd joke about that?
This is a song about the West Russian Volunteer Army (White), which fought against the Bolsheviks along with the German Freikorps
German Legion Version
Perfektes Geschenk zu meinem Geburtstag heute. Vielen Dank und weiter so!
Benny Döring Alles gute Kamerad!🇩🇪🍻
Etwas das gesagt werden muß, Dr Ludwigs kanal ist so voller deutscher Geschichte, daß dieser ein Kulturgut an sich ist.
Vielen Dank für's Lob :)
Jemand hat es mal mit den Gebrüdern Grimm verglichen, welche ebenfalls die deutschen Sagen und Märchen gesammelt, veredelt und der breiten Masse zugänglich gemacht haben und ohne diese unsere Kultur nun weitaus ärmer wäre.
@@dr.ludwig Ja, die Gebrüder Grimm haben viel zum Erhalt der Kultur beigetragen. Ich bin Schweizer, und dein Kanal hat mir etwas mehr über meinen Nachbarn im Norden beigebracht.
My grandfather was born after the great war, in 1925 or something. However his father fought at the German ranks durning this time (we are Polish). Unfortunately I couldn't meet him, but my grandfather lived to 2017 and he told me stories about how after the great war his father would sit on his chair and croon the songs he have heard from his German comrades. May both my Grandfather and his father rest in peace, great song.
Egal welcher politischen Ansicht man nun auch ist, man sollte mMn das Lied dafür nehmen was es ist oder wofür es eigentlich geschrieben wurde. Es ist wunderschön aber es klingt auch so viel Leid und Sehnsucht mit. Ich bin froh niemals einen Krieg miterlebt zu haben und ich hoffe das bleibt nicht nur für mich sondern auch für alle nach mir so.
Ich komme nicht umher zu schreiben, dass mich all diese Lieder bis tief ins Mark berühren. Dein Kanal überrascht mich immer wieder aufs Neue.
Das freut mich wirklich, ich habe noch einige äußerst gute Perlen, die kommen müssen!
i live in germany and it's so sad to see how many people here are ashamed of the past. Yes, it wasn't nice back then, but we have to live with history because it brought us to what Germany is today
You have no idea about German history.. It was good. The Kaiserreich was one of the best places before the war. Everything besides the 12 dark years is absolutely GREAT history. We don't live with it.. We should be proud. After all the Germans created this modern stupid shit world.
Im not ashamed of the past...
@@papakush420-gg I love my Germanic history.. And Blood!
⚫⚪🔴
🇩🇪🇩🇪🇩🇪
@@frontgamet.v1892 💯💪👍
@@papakush420-gg Hope you are proud of your country and blood! You deserve it.. Everybody can be proud and love their history.
I love this song. it does a really good job of painting the bleak picture of an exhausted army with no place to return to and little hope of victory. And yet in the chorus there's this spark of defiance that i think is really quite beautiful.
Probably one of the most beautiful songs I've ever heard and I'm not even German
XD
I love this song and I love the history behind it. It sings to the heart and tells the story of bravery and suffering better than a movie could.
This is one of the only times I decided to learn a song. I regret nothing. Greetings from a brother in the British isles
Wenn ich sowas höre und Europa heute ansehe, will ich nur noch heulen.
Wenn ich mir das anhöre und auf Russland heute schaue, möchte ich weinen.
Das Europa von damals brannte lichterloh, zigmillionen Tote. Alle sechs Brüder meiner einen Großmutter sind gefallen. Das Europa von heute ist ein Paradies du Held!
one of the good songs you can listen to to hear that good pronunciation as you learn german :D
Listen to Heino, he sings very clearly.
The Friekorp and the White army soldiers fighting in the civil war together must have been a melancholic sight as both past enemies realise they just lost both of their Empires.
Verdammt... wer da nicht eine Träne im Auge hat ist hier total fehl am Platz.
Richtig gut gelungenes Lied!
Danke dir sehr Ludwig das wieder hochzuladen.
Diese Version ist meiner Meinung nach besser.
Road to 100k Kamerad! :)
I download almost every song you upload , so nice music .
@@dr.ludwig Thanks for the heart .
You can download Audacity and record the sound straight from you sound card it's easy and I use this since on Spotify the sound quality is A LOT higher.
Super Kanal! Besten Dank!
Love this tune ♥❤💛
Cheers from Poland
@Captain Blyat thanks
@@MW-wh8hh Communism killed more people more than all fascist states combined
@@firstnamelastname4337 wtf you are talking
@@bobafett9518 you know damn well what I'm talking about
@Captain Blyat I am sure that Poland attacked the Bolsheviks first to grab land and anyways the Soviets never had any intentions to do military invasion(s) of Europe.
Ein ganz fantastisches Lied,vielen Dank 👏👏👏👍🇩🇪🙋🏼♂️
🙋🏼♂️
🙋🏼♂️
🙋🏾♂️
🙋🏻♂️
🙋
My parents are from Soviet Union. In childhood, they learned German at school. Because "you must know the language of the enemy" even though the war is long gone. It was in 70s, in a small village in Central Asia, USSR.
多么智慧的父母！
@@planckmax5434 so we are in copper
Beautiful war song. You Germans are the warriors of Europe.
From the Philippines 🇵🇭
Not anymore now we are the Central Bank and Suger Daddy of the EU thx for that Western Germany
🫡
Ja, die Deutschen sind ein Bruder der Briten und ein Feind der Franzosen
Ooh this is beautiful! I don't know which I like better - the guitar, the voices, the obvious language or how they sing slow, at first, then the rhythm fastens, then slows down again - and repeats! Amazing!(I've heard this kind before, but I can't get over how good it(this song is - and I just came across it!).
I'm sorry it took me this long, Dr. Ludwig.
Not only German soldiers in Russia there were also Russian soldiers in German ranks during WW1.
The white army even fought with the Axis forces though unfortunately they were getting to an age too old for battle at that time
@@neucoolhip2089 no they fought alongside Axis forces
@@tylerdarroch5512
And then Operation Keelhaul happened.
@@louplibre9734 I didnt know about this. Thank you for sharing
@@tylerdarroch5512you mean the Central powers? The axis are nazis and fascists from WW2
a while ago I thought german sounded very rude, and I couldn't be anymore wrong, those songs have been helping me to learn the language, as I want to get into WW2 and WW1 reenactment, german is very beautiful.
Welcome to the right side
Wieder ein ganz tolles Lied , was man gut mitsingen kann. Prima
Germany is the great country, great people, most advanced technology! Germans is Germans! Nothing more, nothing less! Just great nation!!!
fucking black eagle the golden lion and eagles is god on the earth jahuß
Too bad your government is letting rapist in.
that is what they thought in ww2 and ww1
As a German I can say: Yes, we love our country, but not like those facist monsters back than
@Belu-NationalSozialistische DeutscheArbeiterPartei Kannst du bitte mir was Sie meinen erklären?
Ich frage weil vielleicht wir haben eine gleiche Meinung.Vielen Dank!
Sehr schönes Lied! Wir grüßen allen ! Alle gute Gedanken von den Brüdern aus Rumänien!
1. Eine wunderschöne Melodie; daß macher wähnt, es gäbe eine russische Version, ist glaubhaft und naheliegend.
2. Ein ergreifender Text, der dem Pathos des Krieges den Spiegel der Tatsächlichkeit engegenhält und dem Menschen (hier: Soldaten) dessen stets neuerliche Verführbarkeit gleich mit - großartig.
3. Ein Text, der deutlich aufzeigt, zu welcher Feierlichkeit und blumigem Wortgirlandentum unsere schöne deutsche Muttersprache mit Leichitgkeit fähig ist - ein Genuss, ihr zuzuhören !
Besten Dank, Dr. Ludwig
Ich suchte seit drei Tagen das Lied. Richtig der Ohrwurm!
Congrats on 100k!!!
Songs like this make me relate to my German brethren who fought across the world. Makes me humble that I am still here despite whatever is thrown at me by the world
Why do I keep listening to this sad song? A song of defeat. This one and Die Grenzwacht Hilt Im Osten, which are along the same subject, are my favorite, i listen to them a lot.
sehr schön, traurig, magisch, tief, und nachdenklich zugleich ♡ ♡ ♡ sowohl russisch als auch deutsch, dieses Lied ist wirklich toll ♡
Das ist wunderschön
You can feel the sadness, the exhaustion, in this song. Haunting. My family fled Germanic Europe after the Great War because of the Reds.
I love these marching songs that gradually pick up the tempo
Ich habe momentan Flash backs und brauche das um darauf zurecht zu kommen. Danke dir für deine wertvolle Arbeit
there are forces that do not want the russian and german people to be friends. because that's what they're afraid of. i hope that our peoples can have a good future and can live peacefully with each other and be friends
What "forces?" Elaborate.
@@binbows2258he was supposed to spew out some of alt-right conspiracy theories but instead chose to keep it mysterios
Ich habe einen deutschen Vater und eine russische Mutter, meine Familie in Russland liebt Deutschland und die deusche Kultur , trotz der aktuellen Lage... Ich habe Hoffnung, dass beide Länder irgendwann wieder eine gute Beziehung zueinander pflegen werden❤ Sehr schönes Lied
Блять, ти дебіл, ви роzzіяни їбані імперіці, при любій владі ви хочете знищити і асимілювати інших, яка нахуй дружба з цивілізованою країною. Ти хоч трохи історію вчи, вас потрібно ізолювати.
Ich habe zu DDR - Zeiten eine Russisch-Sonderschule besucht, und habe bei einer sogenannten Russisch-Olympiade der DDReinen 2.Platz belegt, auf den ich heute noch stolz bin. Auch ich liebe die Russische Kultur. Ich bin sehr traurig, dass meine lange geplante Reise nach Moskau zum Bolschoi-Ballett durch die polit. Umstände ins Wasser fiel, ich hoffe, dass ich es bald nachholen kann!! 😍
one of the best German songs, greetings from Poland
Гитлер вошёл в чат
@@Vito_Carleone Loosing the war are we ? :)
This would fit GREAT in ending credits of a game where you play as a german private going from Poland to Stalingrad and back to Berlin.
не знаю почему, но мне очень нравятся немецкие песни!
Same
Мне тоже всегда они нравятся
prepare brothers of europe.
Hab das immer bei den Pfadfindern gesungen, danke fürs Lied!
Grgr111 ich werde es wohl auch mal bei uns einführen. Dpsg kennt leider hauptsächlich nur Pop Songs.
Zeitloses Meisterwerk.
Immer wieder ein Quell...Nie zuvor gehört. Danke, Dr. Ludwig
I lost all my great grandfathers in WW2, one in the Baltic Sea, another one somewhere in Hungary, one in Stalingrad. My fathers family fled from Marienburg to Berlin. My grandma fled with her mom and her sisters from the russians as fast as they could from Usedom to a "safe" place. WW2 really messed it up for everybody.
My Grandmother had to flee from Silesia Oder-Neiße. Sadly only she and her sister are the only ones I know from my family.
Dulce et Decorum Est pro Patria Mori.
May God rest their souls.
why are all of the freikorps songs so good
Danke für dieses Wundervolle Lied. Passt zur Aktuellen Situation!!!
I love German song and i love people , love from Kosova
Can't stop listening to it, damn, it's so catchy....
Immer wenn es mir schlecht geht höre ich dieses Lied ❤
As a Russian I gotta tell ya this is a great song, be proud of what you are german people don’t resent your sovereignty to anyone
The Russian people may forgive us our government.
@@andlem Ich kümmere mich nicht um deine Regierung, nur deine Meinung ist mir wichtig, Bruder
Спасибо
Viele Grüße nach Russland, Bruder. Ich liebe Russland und die russische Kultur. Hoffentlich werden unsere Länder in Zukunft wieder den Weg zueinander finden🇩🇪🇷🇺. Ich würde viel lieber mit den Russen zusammen gegen das böse Kämpfen. Viele Grüße von einem deutschen Soldaten, ich hoffe wir stehen irgendwann zusammen auf dem Feld, singen lieder und trinken Bier zusammen.🇩🇪🍻🇷🇺
@@ye-yo89Well i am russian and Ukrainian and for me it hurts even more since the war broke out but also thanks for your support i hope that this Putin will get his punishment for all innocents which died in war and still are suffering. My German is sadly not so good because i am only studying here and then i am going back to America but i have to say you’re country changed alot you Germans were once a so proud and strong nation i hope this time will come back anyways enough talking stay safe.
Не думал что ты будешь выкладывать русские песни! I don’t think what you will upload Russian songs!
YOSOPON correction* I haven’t thought that you are going to upload russian songs!
Green Brick Studio ok
One of the most unique and haunting songs I’ve ever heard. I don’t understand the context but I love it. Thanks for uploading. Vielen dank
I would love too see Germany and Russia would understand each other better and would become strong allies! Much love from Germany
🇩🇪 🤝 🇷🇺
Better dead than red
Hat sich nicht so gut entwickelt
@@TheMilano98 ach man jetzt ist eh alles für die Katz😐
Amerika wird das immer verhindern, weil sie sonst niemand mehr brauchen würde. Die Technologie aus Deutschland, die Ressourcen aus Russland und niemand hätte eine Chance.
Jeder Schuß ein Russ
Schöner song er baut schnell auf und fällt wieder und baut wieder zudem ist das Bild sehr schön was ich meine es passt perfekt zu dem Lied