LAND CRUISER 300 VS INEOS GRENADIER. Handling the Media Hype | 4xOverland

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 19 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,1 тис.

  • @AutoExpertJC
    @AutoExpertJC 3 роки тому +170

    Hey mate - I think we agree wholeheartedly on some significant percentage of this, and I take your critical points on advisement. (You are, of course, more of a diplomat than me.) I am somewhat more critical of Toyota's performance with DPF implementations, and 'dusting', etc., but I agree with you that as a tow platform and a reliable off-roader, it is overall very hard to beat, and I doubt the 300 will be substantially worse than the 200 for the average grey nomad towing his van to Dingo Piss Ck. I enjoyed your report, BTW. Well done. I would add with respect that my comments about Toyota being the "king of mediocrity" do not pertain to the Landcruiser exclusively, but to Toyota as a brand more broadly. We are in furious agreement that in general, Toyota has decompiled the secret sauce of reliability - I've never had a shot at them for that. Love your work, dude - I mean that most sincerely. Well done. We'll both watch the 'hot vee' experiment with some interest. Great video mate. I find it hard to disagree with you on the vast majority of it. There's always a disconnect between the suburban LC owner and the actual adventurer to consider, also.

    • @Gabby-qq6rz
      @Gabby-qq6rz 3 роки тому +9

      Well said John, you and Andrew speak with knowledge and in your case piss funny humour,

    • @FilimStar
      @FilimStar 3 роки тому +13

      Its good to see guys acknowledging each other. An interview collab / podcast of you 2 in the same room would be amazing.

    • @gregmillen4712
      @gregmillen4712 3 роки тому +2

      I commented over a week ago that you had been misquoted, even provided a link and reference. Strangely, this comment about someone on the internet being wrong was ignored! I enjoy the work you both produce and hope to see a lot more of it.

    • @ApexHerbivore
      @ApexHerbivore 3 роки тому +2

      @@FilimStar no reply here tho

    • @bjones5240
      @bjones5240 3 роки тому +1

      @@ApexHerbivore he is pissing in ASW pocket here...ASW is worlds ahead of the other clown... John Cadogan...

  • @DriftaholiC
    @DriftaholiC 3 роки тому +108

    It's starting to seem like the best way to get a good modern offroader is to take something made in the 80-90s and then modernise it yourself.

    • @michaelhermans4753
      @michaelhermans4753 3 роки тому +5

      @@booyeah that’s exactly what I’ve done
      But I don’t have apple car play

    • @levisalvini4110
      @levisalvini4110 3 роки тому +1

      That's it!!!

    • @hokz7283
      @hokz7283 3 роки тому +2

      Yep.

    • @safariautoservice7032
      @safariautoservice7032 3 роки тому +2

      Yeap

    • @AshHalls
      @AshHalls 3 роки тому

      Yes true, but be prepared for many repairs and high maintenance. Fantastic if you enjoy working on your own car. It almost becomes a hobby.

  • @andisatyagir6161
    @andisatyagir6161 3 роки тому +67

    Lol when andrew started saying his largest disappointment, i started saying to myself, "is it the split tailgate? Is it?" As he zooms in to the back of the car i actually laughed so hardXD

    • @jhwalter968
      @jhwalter968 3 роки тому

      Absolutely correct - my biggest single complaint about my Discovery 5 TDV6 was the rear hatch - hatches belong on minivans - not off road vehicles.

    • @andisatyagir6161
      @andisatyagir6161 3 роки тому +1

      @@jhwalter968 yeah, i thought land rover would have noticed their mistake from way back when the RR sport came out, especially when the review came out on top gear, which was actually highlighted quite a few times about how convenient the tailgate is, but seems like they haven't noticed, or probably just didn't care...

    • @user-ns8pt7zj5e
      @user-ns8pt7zj5e 3 роки тому +1

      Finally someone address the lack of split tailgate. And yes it is a big deal.

  • @DavidMSA
    @DavidMSA 3 роки тому +146

    I think that all big car-manufacturers who have build real off road vehicles are going more and more soft because there's more money to grab in the SUV-world. I think that, in the future, we are gonna have to rely on smaller car manufacturers who are specialised in other niche markets (mine build, military, agricultural,... ) to have what we want, a real offroad vehicle who can take the punishment of the unbeaten paths. Best Regards, David

    • @RadBunny2269
      @RadBunny2269 3 роки тому +5

      I’m settling into it this reality, sadly.

    • @carholic-sz3qv
      @carholic-sz3qv 3 роки тому

      I totally agree with you, toyota is also going to make a really basic version of it.

    • @carholic-sz3qv
      @carholic-sz3qv 3 роки тому

      @Nathan Marais there is also very basic 200 series on sale.

    • @lukasvass681
      @lukasvass681 3 роки тому +4

      I think emission limits are also an issue. A serious 4x4 produces like 250-400 g of CO2/km. The EU limit is 95 g of CO2/km. So for example MB has to sell 2-3 EVs to sell one G-Wagen…

    • @davidmadej5955
      @davidmadej5955 3 роки тому

      My thoughts exactly.

  • @gman6059
    @gman6059 3 роки тому +41

    I agree 1000% on the split tailgate. It's a phenomenally useful feature.

    • @vatoencabronado
      @vatoencabronado Рік тому +1

      I drove a 100 series for 300k miles and then opted for a GX460, (LC150) as I really didn't want a larger vehicle, but the lack of the split tailgate was a huge compromise... I love that Andrew went on a rant for that specific feature... It is key to have a place to sit or do work while under cover without having to set up any further shade etc. I had to get an awning specifically to replace the lack of a split tailgate! I do love my GX, though :)

    • @remyche8768
      @remyche8768 Рік тому

      I don't know l, I have the gr300 and can reach easier into the back, and it makes good roof for shade

    • @ln5747
      @ln5747 5 місяців тому

      Don't agree. It's a pain to get to the back and the benefits don't outweigh. As an owner of 100 series and 6ft.

  • @emmanuelgt5
    @emmanuelgt5 3 роки тому +13

    Couldn't agree more about the tailgate. That mini rant was very satisfying. 80 series owner here

  • @realAAron124
    @realAAron124 3 роки тому +22

    I love my 80 series even more after watching this. Been waiting for your opinion of the 300, and I wasn't disappointed.

    • @svenvanwesterloo173
      @svenvanwesterloo173 3 роки тому +5

      I own a 60 series myself, but the 80 series is definitely the best Landcruiser model there is. Analog enough to be repairable in most places/situations, brutally reliable end modern enough to be a comfortable drive and have the enjoyment of some basic luxuries. Parts are widely available at affordable prices and most garages can work on them. Not the case with this 300, if it breaks down in the bush there's 1 solution and that's third party recovery.

    • @Adi-kr5nd
      @Adi-kr5nd 3 роки тому

      @@svenvanwesterloo173 I would also argue the same with the 105 series

  • @matthewbrown7170
    @matthewbrown7170 3 роки тому +3

    Fantastic review. I freaking love your brutal honesty, your blunt reasoning and your transparency of emotion. That emotion especially makes you human and believable, and your credentials speak to the foundation from which you speak. Far more meaningful of a video than one where someone blandly smiles and presents an insultingly insincere hype review.

  • @ruuman
    @ruuman 3 роки тому +34

    The ineos layout is quite well considered, the little bars either side of the switch gear will allow you to do it without looking as you gain muscle memory. Same as your g wagon levers.

    • @jerrymyahzcat
      @jerrymyahzcat Рік тому

      No such thing as muscle memory. Repeated motions train your brain. It’s brain memory of performed/repeated actions.

  • @BorisEkner
    @BorisEkner 3 роки тому +21

    If I had the money I would buy a Grenadier in a heartbeat. But as I don’t have the cash needed, I got the second option on my list; the new Jimny. After driving/testing it for a few weeks, I have no regrets what so ever.

    • @romansteinbrenner
      @romansteinbrenner 2 роки тому +1

      which do you think is better, the toyota troopy76 or the grenadier?

    • @BorisEkner
      @BorisEkner 2 роки тому +2

      @@romansteinbrenner For me, who sleep and dine at hotels, I’d get the Grenadier ahead of any 70-series. But if I was to use the car as a camper I’d get the Troupy as it’s better suited for camping thanks to its large size.

  • @leeperry1629
    @leeperry1629 3 роки тому +5

    Andrew your vast experience and honesty always shines through. Brilliant post 👏🏼

    • @gr3123
      @gr3123 3 роки тому +1

      He’s truly credible unlike the other “journalist” highlighted in this video.

  • @stevejones5999
    @stevejones5999 3 роки тому +3

    I'm with you man!! That tailgate is my kitchen when camping, and my picnic table at lunch.

  • @francoiseverton2516
    @francoiseverton2516 3 роки тому +6

    What a brilliant video. I have enjoyed it so much that i have watched it more than once. Thanks Andrew

  • @aliveoutside248
    @aliveoutside248 3 роки тому +68

    No split tail gate… um yeah we understand. I’ll stick with my 200

  • @nelsonherrera940
    @nelsonherrera940 3 роки тому +5

    Hello! Dear Andreu, a Venezuelan residing in Chile writes you, I have been following you for a couple of years, regarding your comments about the new Land Cruiser L300, I totally agree with you. I know it is not the topic of your channel but maybe Toyota adapted all the modifications based on the changes that current society presents, both contemporary men and women are not so tough, and for that reason, Toyota has softened their line of 4x4 vehicles. Probably, you and the followers of your channel are romantics of adventure and we always seek to do things on our own without so much electronic assistance, that is why we resist changes.
    Take care and stay healthy!

    • @kloschuessel773
      @kloschuessel773 3 роки тому +1

      The customer base simply shifted and therefore the car is being built different.
      You can see that with the g waggon.
      The landcruiser is no different just a light version of the g waggons case.
      Ppl who them new rarely even go offroad.
      Do you see lots of new land cruisers on offroad channels ? No…
      Nobody takes them their. Same with the gs.
      Same with all the land rovers.
      Doesnt really have to do with the ppl becoming softer.
      That ppl became more used to luxury and comfort generally is also true though.
      Thats beside the point

  • @desertfox486
    @desertfox486 3 роки тому +40

    LC 300 is a mall crawler. "Cashed-up bogans" will love it.

    • @dt1260
      @dt1260 3 роки тому +5

      Exactly, build for the rich in the middel east to go shopping

    • @russcattell955i
      @russcattell955i 3 роки тому +3

      Quite so, a few might venture to the boat ramps & caravan sites.

    • @BubblesTheCat1
      @BubblesTheCat1 3 роки тому +11

      You're going to need a tough vehicle to crawl the malls in South Africa now. Hundreds have been burnt to ashes.

    • @mordechaicohen1911
      @mordechaicohen1911 3 роки тому +1

      Not lekker at all

    • @amarbinay6654
      @amarbinay6654 3 роки тому

      Well the middle east are crazy maniac for LAND CRUISER, when this was launch as soon as booked and 50 LC300 delivered on the same day with great celebration. For some reasons the new lc300 were crashed.

  • @MatthewBrigham-1
    @MatthewBrigham-1 3 роки тому +51

    Find yourself a woman that loves you as much as Andrew loves the drop down tailgate.

    • @haanjamiis
      @haanjamiis 3 роки тому +4

      Once you had one, you don't want to get back to not having one.

    • @joshuaculross1387
      @joshuaculross1387 3 роки тому +1

      @@haanjamiis Can confirm. Went from an xtrail with a single piece boot to a hilux with a tub and canopy, having the tailgate has completely changed my setup for the better

  • @marcusrwalker
    @marcusrwalker 3 роки тому +19

    GRENADIER looks really good, and yes I have a 2015 defender. Would keep the defender even if I end up getting a GRENADIER.

    • @matribadeneira9766
      @matribadeneira9766 3 роки тому +1

      Nobody asked

    • @terrytees
      @terrytees 3 роки тому +2

      this guy's had a good look around the INEOS and he's coming from a background of fleet 4x4 in africa, mostly TDI300's and 70 series. It's worth a look ua-cam.com/video/d8b1y_OyIUs/v-deo.html

    • @project-overland
      @project-overland 2 роки тому

      Sorry to hear you are stuck with a defender. Are you going to be ok?

  • @ghost6500
    @ghost6500 Рік тому +1

    Thank you! I really value your opinion because of your vast experience with off-roading. When the Grenadier was announced, I registered right away, so I could buy one. But they are asking the same price as a luxurious Defender! I think that Ineos should have only 3 models. One plain Jane working vehicle, ready to be customized by the owner, the other as a Mall Crawler/ football/tennis mom ride with 20" wheels, leather all around, front and read dash cams, sunroofs, buttons, and whistles, 16 speakers, subwoofers, tinted glass, carpeted, onboard internet wifi, center console cooler, etc. and the other an ARMORED model for the high-end business execs, Arnold Schwarznegger and the mafia. Cool, huh?

  • @marcusrwalker
    @marcusrwalker 3 роки тому +43

    Can you do a real deep dive on the GRENADIER, the bmw straight 6 diesel, the solid axels, steel rims, 8 speed auto, all that stuff.

    • @RadBunny2269
      @RadBunny2269 3 роки тому +3

      Please, Andrew! I’m ready to pull the trigger on the Grenadier. Only thing keeping me back is the BMW engine because there’s real reliability questions there to be addressed. That’s all i’m waiting for.

    • @RadBunny2269
      @RadBunny2269 3 роки тому +1

      @@Chris.starfleet It was a commentary. No one has the review unit yet. And even those who got one these past few days couldn’t turn the electrics on, let alone drive it.

    • @olivergunn2796
      @olivergunn2796 3 роки тому +1

      @@RadBunny2269 look at dark side developments on UA-cam they are a tuning company based out of Yorkshire that specialises in VW TDI but they have done a couple BMW 330D's and they go over the weak points and all, seem to be fairly reliable once the swirl flaps are removed

    • @mtadc1545
      @mtadc1545 3 роки тому +3

      @@RadBunny2269 as someone who’s owned and worked on BMWs. They’re great cars, some of their engines are reliable…but very few. Plastic cooling systems, plastic pulleys, constant gasket leaks, PCV valve issues, rear timing chain etc. etc. You really think that would work well off road?

    • @manofausagain
      @manofausagain 3 роки тому

      @@olivergunn2796 isn't that the m57 I think these will have the n57.

  • @miggity_mac
    @miggity_mac 3 роки тому +29

    If you watched the Toyota Engineering release, a lot of the weight savings were in the chassis with a new welding technique

    • @einfelder8262
      @einfelder8262 3 роки тому +6

      They needed a new welding technique because the chassis is thinner and smaller. The "new" welding technique is called spot welding....... I'll wager the axles and CVs are smaller too, meaning as soon as you put a LT tyre on you'll break shit.

    • @vic6820
      @vic6820 3 роки тому +1

      @@tom6549 It's gotta be thinner chassis metal.

  • @jsirkerp
    @jsirkerp 3 роки тому +39

    I knew I was really interested in the Grenadier, when the LC300 release was not as important for me as the interior release of the Grenadier! I know the Grenadier is still months ahead of being production ready, but I am really really hoping they get everything right. Fingers crossed.

    • @kloschuessel773
      @kloschuessel773 3 роки тому +2

      Many do, i do as well.
      Probably only other manufacturers and not consumers that wish ill on the grenadier.
      Maybe defender owners afraid of depreciation, who knows.
      The Grenadier is an extremely exciting release and with these prices…
      The 70 series starts with 30k more?
      The new defender isnt comparable and pricier.
      The old one is uncomfortable, probably more failures and faults and the grenadier should be better…
      And its new. Fresh from the factory.
      And they did it all right with the grenadier i think…
      Established engine. Established factory. Established transmission. Lots of testing now. Established offroad company designing it with magna steyr.

    • @wyattfamily8997
      @wyattfamily8997 3 роки тому +3

      Witha BMW motor.? don't think so.

    • @wyattfamily8997
      @wyattfamily8997 3 роки тому +3

      A 4 x 4 with a BMW motor.? If it breaks down in outback Australia....walk away, it will be months before its fixed.

    • @kloschuessel773
      @kloschuessel773 3 роки тому +2

      @@wyattfamily8997 they put m57s into defenders regularly
      Have you ever had a blown engine in the outback and fixed it yourself?
      Doubt it…

    • @deldridg
      @deldridg 3 роки тому +1

      @@wyattfamily8997 Well, I've had Beemers since 1995 in both petrol and diesel and can say that in something like 1.4 million kms they have not once let me or my family down. Look after them, and they will serve you well. BMW are also very responsive with parts supply, unlike other similar manufacturers and should be serviceable in most country towns, certainly here in Aust. I can't wait for the Grenadier to join our family, partly for this very reason! :-) Cheers - Dave

  • @madmac.4821
    @madmac.4821 Рік тому +1

    I drove LAND CRUISER 80 since 1997 . IT has 4 lit. Straight 6 and manual. I install mechanical lokkar on front Axel. ITs Clocked 650,000 kilometer now. I drove her in city, town, mud, flood and jungle track, Crossing river, drove on gravel ,towing and pulling. Its lifted to 3 inches. Keping 2 sets of wheel for different purposes. It is still running good and I am very pleased.

  • @firebir11
    @firebir11 3 роки тому +13

    Don’t care for the “low profile tires” and the low slung body panels….frankly it’s stupid, but that’s the market they’re following. They do their market research and find this is what most people will buy.

  • @shaoi88
    @shaoi88 3 роки тому +1

    Yes you are 100% right about split tailgate. As a BMW X5 owner the split tailgate has been used to watch my sons numerous soccer matches

  • @robh3895
    @robh3895 3 роки тому +8

    You and John need to do a co-production . 1 in a 300 , 1 in a greny, pick a medium level track find the definitive Aussie 4x4 . You guys would get on great , just don't mention backwards facing scoops.

    • @randokuruza
      @randokuruza 3 роки тому

      Except John knows sweet FA about 4x4’s

    • @DMSVICAU
      @DMSVICAU 3 роки тому +1

      @@randokuruza
      I’m sure John is quite capable of getting to DingoPiss Creek.

    • @jcv551
      @jcv551 3 роки тому +2

      There has to be a Kia or Hyundai involved or John won’t have anything to do with it. 🙃

    • @DMSVICAU
      @DMSVICAU 3 роки тому +1

      @@jcv551
      That’s a bit of a joke since his DailyDrive (bought with his own money) is a Mitsubishi Triton.

  • @johannesschaller5510
    @johannesschaller5510 3 роки тому +1

    Andrew showing his true colours at 17:48: "The V8 3.5". No matter the subject vehicle, he can't get Series 1 Range Rover out of his blood.
    One of the best commentaries I've seen - thank you Andrew!

  • @daviddenley3512
    @daviddenley3512 3 роки тому +3

    Now that was a well thought out rant Andrew, you made lots of sense to me but there again I'l from the old school of adoring the old Heavy Duty 6 Pot Land Rover 109" hardtop with split tailgate only to be beaten off road by an ex MOD 90 n/a 2.5d but the 6 cyl Rover unit as old and thirsty as it was was excellent.

  • @landrover4444
    @landrover4444 3 роки тому

    What you said about the horizontal split tailgate is spot on. I mean, anyone who has not had one will NEVER understand. I do not want a truck without one for all the reasons you mentioned.

  • @marcusrwalker
    @marcusrwalker 3 роки тому +3

    really like your commentary on this with your huge experience in this field and you make a lot of sense, cheers.

  • @hugoviljoen431
    @hugoviljoen431 3 роки тому +2

    Grenadier for me all the way! I also have to agree on the split tailgate. I bought a Disco 4 V8 last year and its definitely a deal breaker. Such a lovely and usable feature to have. Thank you for the fantastic video as always!

  • @CommanderZarkon
    @CommanderZarkon 3 роки тому +5

    "I want those buttons!" LOL! It does seem like a great setup that Grenadier!

  • @nickgood8166
    @nickgood8166 3 роки тому

    You're correct about the rear horizontal rear tail-gate. On my 105 I put aluminium checker plate. It's your field kitchen table

  • @JohnRolyAU
    @JohnRolyAU 3 роки тому +11

    My 200 Sahara is now 11 years old , I bought it new, has done a LOT of outback and remote touring. It is so heavily modified it is irreplaceable. Infact for the past 4 years it is kept at home and only gets used for touring / camping so we can extend it's life. Once I physically see a 300 I will order one if it looks like it will do the same. Otherwise , I'll put more money into the 200 and keep it going. Anywhere you go in the outback, you hear the idle of the V8 Landcruiser Diesel. You can count Patrols on 1 hand each day.

  • @jasonb4988
    @jasonb4988 2 роки тому +1

    Of course the new LC300 series is a great vehicle. On the other hand the Grenadier is going to be a LEGEND ! Simple, well built, and an excellent execution ! Can’t wait to see it ..

  • @HammerRocks
    @HammerRocks 3 роки тому +4

    I totally agree with you on the split tailgate. I love this feature on my 80 Series Land Cruiser. I often use it as a seat and table when out and about, specially at the beach. Plus it's a handy step when loading the roof rack. It's disappointing Toyota removed this feature. It's like Nissan deleting a diesel option for the Patrol, or Land Rover adding electronics & digital technology to the Defender. Oh wait..., both manufacturers did. I guess this what happens when they sell more to people using them in urban settings than for off-road. I just hope the LC300 isn't the beginning of the end for the Land Cruiser.

  • @nick-3388
    @nick-3388 3 роки тому

    A very honest feedback, your videos might not be as fancy or have those clickbait titles but certainly way more informative & educational than any other channel out there. Much respect! Not sure what's happening to this world where we are only seeking graphics and not quality content!

  • @edwardpeters4700
    @edwardpeters4700 3 роки тому +15

    100% Agree with respect to the split tailgate. The split tailgate is a brilliant design. It's one of my favourite features on any off-road wagon.

    • @Ernesto66Sernas
      @Ernesto66Sernas 3 роки тому +2

      Totally agree with you. The split tailgate is consistently my favorite feature on my 80. I've never looked at any of my friends' car's tailgate the same since.

  • @steviestrange
    @steviestrange 3 роки тому

    I just found you online and I don't know how I haven't found you earlier. Thank you for calling a spade a spade and not falling victim to PR hyperbole.

  • @stoogeadventure7429
    @stoogeadventure7429 3 роки тому +4

    Split tailgates (not barn doors, i can see why people like them, but they probably haven't experienced split tailgates) are the best thing since slice bread.
    love it in my 80 Series, and the storage mod for the lower tailgate is a must.

    • @carholic-sz3qv
      @carholic-sz3qv 3 роки тому +1

      I think toyota could still make it possible if people wants it, its not hard to implement

  • @Telleout
    @Telleout 3 роки тому +1

    Great Video Andrew. I think you have just single handedly raised the price on 200’s another 10%

  • @smashedhulk8492
    @smashedhulk8492 3 роки тому +3

    I watched John Cadogans videos on the 300, and his only complaint I hear that was real and not adjectives was that it had a DVD player still. And I absolutely agree with the loss of the split tailgate. The fold down 3rd row is along the same lines.

    • @ScottMurrayBestFamilyCars
      @ScottMurrayBestFamilyCars 3 роки тому

      CD* And if that's all you took away, you clearly weren't paying attention for 90 percent.

  • @rosiehawtrey
    @rosiehawtrey 3 роки тому +2

    Yup, the Mr Creosote of 4x4s - absolute perfection. You couldn't have put it any better.

  • @yahyataweel506
    @yahyataweel506 3 роки тому +11

    I enjoyed this immensely. I'd love to see you get your hands on these vehicles.

    • @seanfrench1029
      @seanfrench1029 2 роки тому

      Yes, me too. Have I missed the hands-on review seeing as the 300 has hit Aussie shores a while ago?

  • @harveysmith100
    @harveysmith100 3 роки тому

    Happy memories of a split tailgate in Malawi.
    We had rented an 80 series, four lads delivering medical equipment, one chat, Dougie, had brought lots of balloons, he would sit in the cargo section, blow them up and then when we drove through remote villages he would open the top hatch and release the balloons for the kids.
    The joy on their faces will always stay with me,
    Just one more use for a split tailgate.

  • @michaelnugara1
    @michaelnugara1 3 роки тому +4

    Couldn't agree more. I couldn't wait for the ineos, so I bought a 76 series👍

  • @davidmatthews1056
    @davidmatthews1056 3 роки тому +2

    Great discussion, but as you say we really won’t know until we drive it and see what happens after 12 months of them being used. I am restoring an 80 series at the moment and love the split tail gate! Will be interesting to see what the longevity of the 300 is, with electrification coming fast I think the 400 will arrive faster than 14 years.

  • @parasinthephilippines
    @parasinthephilippines 3 роки тому +6

    I'm excited about the Grenadier.
    I live and work in Dubai already owning a Nissan patrol.
    What worries me is the BMW engine as they have a notorious reputation for failure in the Middle East.
    So this might be the Grenadiers achiles heel.
    Ill still be reserving one in October though.

    • @svenvanwesterloo173
      @svenvanwesterloo173 3 роки тому

      Really ? I only know them as very very reliable, both in cars as in boats.

    • @russcattell955i
      @russcattell955i 3 роки тому

      Iveco Daily van engine would be better, tough & reliable.

    • @parasinthephilippines
      @parasinthephilippines 3 роки тому +1

      @@svenvanwesterloo173 I'm specifically referencing the Middle East . They have a terrible reputation due to dust and heat.
      You hardly ever see anyone driving one in Dubai .

  • @tomandtinamatthews6866
    @tomandtinamatthews6866 3 роки тому

    Love the tailgate comment. I love the split gate on my LR3. I put my Coleman stove on it and make breakfast then back it up to a cliff edge and look at mountain views with my wife and my dog. Can't beat it.

  • @Phil_McAvity
    @Phil_McAvity 3 роки тому +7

    I can’t stomach John Cadogan. Good video 👍

    • @Phil_McAvity
      @Phil_McAvity 3 роки тому

      @@Rex_Stuph haha! Yes, absolutely.

  • @fouUili684
    @fouUili684 3 роки тому +1

    I agree with everything you’ve said in this video, the land cruiser starting from the 100 series has had poor approach and departure angles and is slowly becoming a softroader. I’m sad that there’s no 300 series here in the US but I guess now is the best time to buy a 2021 land cruiser and keep it forever, I do love the split tailgate.

  • @andrewbrown9267
    @andrewbrown9267 3 роки тому +11

    ITS LIKE MY TWO DADS ARE HAVING A FIGHT

  • @chrisshelton6677
    @chrisshelton6677 3 роки тому +1

    Brilliant commentary Andrew. Couldn't agree more with you on the tail-gate issue. What were they thinking? When they start catering for old ladies with shopping bags, that's where they lose me. Thanks but no thanks, I am still perfectly happy with my 100 thank you very much. It has been a 22 year affair.

    • @4xoverland
      @4xoverland  3 роки тому

      'When they start catering for old ladies with shopping bags, that's where they lose me.' EXCELLENT.

  • @jonyjonsy
    @jonyjonsy 3 роки тому +10

    Split tailgates are the bomb!

    • @youtubecarspottersguide1
      @youtubecarspottersguide1 3 роки тому

      all wagons had them at one time now only utes have a tail gate to sit on not sure of the disc and the range rovers but they are luxury cars

    • @jonyjonsy
      @jonyjonsy 3 роки тому

      @@youtubecarspottersguide1 my dad's rangie has them. But I don't think the disco's do. It's so sad to see them go. 😞

  • @bigcassssino
    @bigcassssino 3 роки тому

    100% agree with your split tailgate thoughts! Makes all the difference in the world!

  • @Rex_Stuph
    @Rex_Stuph 3 роки тому +7

    Regarding the roof console in the Grenadier. There are few buttons and well spaced, I could see it being an easy muscle memory programming thing. But yes, that interior, much 9 y/o oooooooooooooooh. Do want.

    • @Rex_Stuph
      @Rex_Stuph 3 роки тому +2

      @Abel Harbour What was the worst thing ever (in anything I owned) was the digital display in a BA Fairlane. You had to look at it to see what mode you were in (climate control, audio, etc) and then read what each of the buttons below the screen was assigned to on each screen. Nothing could be controlled by feel. A big panel of 8 defined switches is all I can ask for.

    • @carholic-sz3qv
      @carholic-sz3qv 3 роки тому

      Nope its too big compared to the toyota tacoma roof console for example.

    • @carholic-sz3qv
      @carholic-sz3qv 3 роки тому +1

      @Abel Harbour i know mate, but the fj cruiser had the similar roof control panel

    • @stevejones5999
      @stevejones5999 3 роки тому +1

      @@Rex_Stuph buttons are critical. I drive a Tesla around town - I frequently am either cold or hot because I have to either stretch and try to touch the center screen in the right spot (tricky) or else try and issue voice commands (temperamental and interrupts the music) to adjust the thermostat. Lazy as I am I just endure the wrong temps! Buttons for the win every time.

    • @Rex_Stuph
      @Rex_Stuph 3 роки тому

      @@stevejones5999 I am currently living in the past with a 95 series Prado and a Daihatsu Handi, both with rotary and or slide heater and vent controls that are always exactly in the same location and the positions always represent the same settings. Peak of sensible automotive design :P

  • @robmcd
    @robmcd 3 роки тому

    Dear Andrew. About 10 years ago I drove a Mercedes Benz 0303 V8 coach. I regularly did Jenolan Caves. Coming out I once had a B7 Volvo with more hp by the numbers but it was a joke and I’ve never changed gears so many times in my life. The V8 you could fundamentally idle out.

  • @tttturvey
    @tttturvey 3 роки тому +3

    Spilt tail grate is also great for changing nappies on 🤣

  • @warrenjoubert4027
    @warrenjoubert4027 3 роки тому

    Thanks you Andrew. Don't always agree with you on everything you usually say, but in this video I'm with you 100%. Great production- with common sense reasoning. I enjoyed it.

  • @ubernoob103
    @ubernoob103 3 роки тому +21

    I love how he roasts Matt Watson and Carwow. Well deserved honestly, theyve become hugely clickbaity.

  • @AggyGoesOutdoors
    @AggyGoesOutdoors 3 роки тому +1

    I love a good Andrew "old man shouts at cloud" rant. 🤣 I must say though, I've got a split tailgate on my Mitsi and I love it.

  • @The_Opinion_of_Matt
    @The_Opinion_of_Matt 3 роки тому +26

    The Land Cruiser is, sadly, evolving into a Road Cruiser.

    • @frilime1710
      @frilime1710 3 роки тому

      How about Land Crawler? :-)

    • @The_Opinion_of_Matt
      @The_Opinion_of_Matt 3 роки тому +2

      @@frilime1710 Land Yacht?

    • @j.franklin4999
      @j.franklin4999 3 роки тому +4

      Mall Cruiser

    • @youtubecarspottersguide1
      @youtubecarspottersguide1 3 роки тому

      lux car for the posh resorts in the US we had 200 's priced at$90k us dollars and lexugly lx570@$100k us dollars if we only had diesel in the States id never have to buy a car again

    • @normjones8867
      @normjones8867 2 роки тому

      It makes sense really the vast majority will be sold in Melbourne & Sydney. Likely will only ever be driven in the city.

  • @StevenJohnson-jv1iw
    @StevenJohnson-jv1iw 3 роки тому

    Love your authenticity. You are true to yourself and that for me makes your channel fantastic. Thanks!

  • @raffs_adv
    @raffs_adv 3 роки тому +13

    I have been following the Ineos Grenadier for some time now, and I think it’s what true 4x4 driving is all about, I can’t wait to buy one.

    • @tonydoggett7627
      @tonydoggett7627 3 роки тому

      A Toyota Fortuner GX or a Mahindra Pik-up will be 1/3 of the price. Both far better off road.

    • @backsa6214
      @backsa6214 3 роки тому +1

      @@tonydoggett7627 Mahindra is better than fortuner

    • @carholic-sz3qv
      @carholic-sz3qv 3 роки тому

      What about the bmw engines......!? There is also no assurance that the ineos will be "perfect"

    • @tonydoggett7627
      @tonydoggett7627 3 роки тому +1

      Your not one of these pommies that puts grills on every light, ladders and roof racks to stand on for a photo?
      Nobody has that junk on their 4WD’s in Australia.

  • @anandasharma1041
    @anandasharma1041 3 роки тому +1

    Simply brilliant Andrew. Loved the postmortem of these two very hyped and anticipated vehicles....it's going to open a lot of people's eyes before they start to dip into their pockets !

  • @Damakel
    @Damakel 3 роки тому +3

    I'd LOVE to hear your thoughts on the UAZ Hunter and UAZ "Bukshanka"

  • @phillipchandler8862
    @phillipchandler8862 3 роки тому +1

    Just make the split tailgate an option. Sorted.
    Have seen and ridden in the Prototype Ineos Grenadier here in the UK where it is touring for potential clients to see. Still a work in progress but was pretty impressive considering short time from conception to reality.

  • @brucelumsden94
    @brucelumsden94 3 роки тому +9

    Well done, Andrew. I turned that other fella off well before his video was through.

    • @IanCotterill
      @IanCotterill 3 роки тому

      Same here Bruce. He lost all my respect when he slated the LandCruiser platform.

    • @janethall148
      @janethall148 3 роки тому

      Me too

  • @chelseadaddy7061
    @chelseadaddy7061 3 роки тому +1

    Spot on about the split tailgate! It's what separates the LC200 and Range rover from all other 4x4s! It's even great fun in my small electric smart eq2!

  • @harolddriscoll7104
    @harolddriscoll7104 3 роки тому +4

    I own a 2012 Tacoma. One of the main reasons for buying it was it's reliability.

  • @benmmm7359
    @benmmm7359 2 роки тому

    Thanks for the great video as usual, Andrew!
    I’m going to the Ineos preview event in NSW tomorrow. Excited to see the Grenadier in the metal!!

  • @BubblesTheCat1
    @BubblesTheCat1 3 роки тому +4

    I think we need to get John in a new Landcruiser with an aluminium shiita behind it, and send him off to Dingo piss Creek, with some mates, beers and of course his blue singlet...
    Yesss ssh! !!

  • @doneB830
    @doneB830 3 роки тому

    Tell John I have just competed 400 000km on good and bad roads in Australia with a cruiser v8 diesel without a single problem and yes it still has the original brake rotors and wheel bearings with one new battery .

  • @kacolorado
    @kacolorado 3 роки тому +4

    Wouldn't be surprised to see Toyota bring back an FJ in a couple years, for a more pure/fun off-roader. The Land Cruiser hasn't been a Land Cruiser since the 80 series. And I owned a 100 series...

    • @4xoverland
      @4xoverland  3 роки тому +3

      Bring back the FJ? I'll eat a bowl of yoghurt if that happens.

    • @4xoverland
      @4xoverland  3 роки тому +4

      I really hate yoghurt.

  • @gibbethoskins8621
    @gibbethoskins8621 3 роки тому +2

    That Inios interior is awesome, who doesn't want a switch panel on the roof like an aircraft? So good, they've also put switches ready to just plug in additional accessories 👌🏽 And yep you can't beat a fold down tail gate, they are awesome.

    • @jerrymyahzcat
      @jerrymyahzcat Рік тому

      The switchgear on the ceiling is actually ridiculously difficult to use when driving and impossible when off-road. You have to come to a complete stop, look up and then switch what’s needed.

  • @SomervilleMetalWorks
    @SomervilleMetalWorks 3 роки тому +4

    I've put my name down for the Ineos even though i've got an S5 Patrol. I just like land rovers lol

  • @markcowling3890
    @markcowling3890 3 роки тому

    Loved it Andrew. Everything you said was spot on. Nobody could have said it better. Well done.

  • @donkinzett3961
    @donkinzett3961 3 роки тому +3

    Andrew I think we all need to actually wait until they arrive and get realy tested in Australian conditions

  • @davidbland1859
    @davidbland1859 3 роки тому +1

    Yes Andrew, I totally agree with you about the horizontal split tailgate. It would be a must have when touring. Maybe Toyota might make a split tailgate as an option. One can hope!!

  • @directgrover
    @directgrover 3 роки тому +3

    'jurnos' ... I think Andrew is becoming Aussie now! 😂

  • @5JSG
    @5JSG 3 роки тому +1

    Andrew this 3.5 twin turbo will do just fine in high and low speed because both turbos are different size and have two different stages. Smaller turbo has very little lag and ment for low speeds and the bigger turbo starts spooling at higher speeds.

  • @shekharmoona544
    @shekharmoona544 3 роки тому +7

    Andrew: "After my careful analysis of this platform with my numerous years of experience..."
    Cadogen: "Shitsville" "Shit box" 🤣🤣 I just summed up 90% of his videos.

    • @JE-ti3cz
      @JE-ti3cz 3 роки тому

      Couldn’t agree more, just an arrogant shit !

  • @damongroves6130
    @damongroves6130 3 роки тому +1

    I have 2 cars on the Road, a p38 Rangie (horizontal split tailgate) and a 2006 Rav4 (barn door style tailgate)
    I feel that the advantage of not having to add the weight of a rear wheel carrier on a barn door style means the space inside is far more useable especially when your tyres no longer fit in the standard wheel well (as in my Rangie)
    Other than that, Great vid

  • @stephen_101
    @stephen_101 3 роки тому +4

    The Grenadier interior looks top class imho. The switches are big, chunky and well set out.
    In the touchscreen age this is nice touch.

    • @AdamMansbridge
      @AdamMansbridge 3 роки тому +1

      But you can't put your radio in a ceiling console

  • @pacman5590
    @pacman5590 3 роки тому +2

    Interesting views on John’s reviews, you are my top two watched for honest reviews. I’m torn by both your reviews. I agree with you on most aspects of reliability but agree with a John when it comes to the DPF filter issue - Toyota not covering themselves with glory there! Keep up the great work! 👍

  • @jamesmckenzie9551
    @jamesmckenzie9551 3 роки тому +11

    There was a good V6 at low RPM, the 4.0L in the FJ cruiser. But look at the conditions, it had electronic assistance with the crawl control, mechanical assistance with the rear e-locker, it also weighs literally a ton less than the new Landcruiser. It’s a case of matching up the power plant, mass and projected performance nicely. But the big 300? No, I sucked it up and bought a 200 last year instead.

    • @rawnature8148
      @rawnature8148 3 роки тому

      That's the engine out of the mum soccer car prado. Have one and 360k km on the engine and does not miss a beat and walks dunes/beaches/rocks and can pull far more than the car is rated for. Great donk

    • @carholic-sz3qv
      @carholic-sz3qv 3 роки тому +1

      Toyota has a reason to use a smaller v6 engine and they have tuned/tested it very well, also people forget about the increasing pressure on emissions regulations on car manufacturers.

    • @daddymack415
      @daddymack415 3 роки тому +2

      @@rawnature8148 every car can pull more than they are rated for... getting them to stop is the problem 😉

    • @rawnature8148
      @rawnature8148 3 роки тому

      @@daddymack415 5 ton up the side of a mountain in recovery (yes on dirt). Braking wasn't an issue so much as getting it moving up a very steep section.

  • @haanjamiis
    @haanjamiis 3 роки тому

    So many uses for split tailgate. For sitting, eating, climbing up to access roofbox/rack, changing diapers (in a rain while upper part acts like umbrella, putting things on when camping. Etc-etc. Love it on my Disco4! Would miss it so much. Other then size, the second reason why I would not change from D4 to LC150 (Prado).

  • @stefanfrittiert1038
    @stefanfrittiert1038 3 роки тому +4

    Love the Grenadier so excited! It was also developed in Austria by Magna, who also build the G-Wagen. I live in Austria and saw a couple of Grenadier testing onroad some months ago.

    • @mtadc1545
      @mtadc1545 3 роки тому

      Horrible rusting issues from the Gelandewagens that came from that factory though.

    • @stefanfrittiert1038
      @stefanfrittiert1038 3 роки тому

      @@mtadc1545 many cars are built there, I guess they solved the issues. BMW Z4\Toyota Supra, Jaguar I-Pace, Mini Countryman

  • @derciobene3458
    @derciobene3458 3 роки тому +1

    100% Agreed when you said that when you looked at the 300 it reminded you of something a businessman would get in after a meeting. I got the same vibes, like, something I would take to a business meeting to show off how important I am, and not something I'd take to the middle of nowhere (like Land Cruisers are supposed to be). It gave me sort of an "Cadillac Escalade" vibe.
    Gotta say, it's gonna be interesting seeing the land cruiser with more electronic equipment and a V6 3.5 engine.
    Cheers

  • @capfrankyv
    @capfrankyv 3 роки тому +6

    You mentioned something about the v6 and it caught my attention, the torque ...
    Engine V6
    Ford V6 4.0 SOHC 210 hp and 345 nm torque @ 3700 rpm
    Chevrolet V6 4.3 Vortec 200 hp and 350 nm torque @ 2800 rpm
    Mitsubishi 6G75 V6 3.8 MIVEC 250 hp and 330 nm torque @ 2750 rpm
    Engine Straight Six
    Toyota 1FZ-FE 4.5 straight six 220 hp and 373 nm torque @ 3200 rpm
    Nissan TB48DE 4.8 straight six 250 hp and 420 nm torque @ 3600 rpm
    What i mean by this is because these V6s have their peak torque quite close and even lower than the straight six

    • @4xoverland
      @4xoverland  3 роки тому +35

      I'm talking less about numbers and more about driving ability and feel. And I said VERY clearly - rock bottom RPM! Idle speed! So these numbers mean little. It's a notion and has yet to be proven, disproven. Anyone driving over rocks at 2750 RPM is someone without talent.

    • @lunamaria1048
      @lunamaria1048 3 роки тому +13

      @@4xoverland *drops mic and walks away*

    • @capfrankyv
      @capfrankyv 3 роки тому

      @Uncle Pete I would not know if the Ford essex that you mention is the same ford cologne that i mentioned

    • @capfrankyv
      @capfrankyv 3 роки тому +1

      @@4xoverland The secret is in the reduction of transfer case , for example in the case of the Rover v8 3.5 it has 258 nm @ 2500 rpm (really it is not much for a v8 engine) but it has an excellent reduction 3.32.1 , against part I put the jeep wrangler rubicon v6 3.6, it has 285 hp and 350 nm @ 4000 rpm ... but it has a transfer reduction 4 to 1 with a very short first gear of 5.13, that is to say, a quite impressive torque sensation surpassing many, I don't know if I'm wrong

    • @PhatToni
      @PhatToni 3 роки тому

      @@4xoverland For a given number of cylinders, engine layout has almost nothing to do with low down torque. Head/valve/port/manifold design plays way more of a part in low down torque. Coming from a guy that hates V6s

  • @jaanakasamarakone7902
    @jaanakasamarakone7902 3 роки тому

    Andrew, I bought LC 79 with a 1HZ out of the last batch Toyota Dealer here in Sri Lanka imported. I felt so good about my decision after I watched ur video.

  • @Tonigr
    @Tonigr 3 роки тому +10

    If you ask me (i know you did not), a "real" LandCruiser has rear barn doors!

    • @michaelhermans4753
      @michaelhermans4753 3 роки тому +3

      Barn doors are the bomb

    • @hieuphan4264
      @hieuphan4264 3 роки тому

      Sooo…. All the cruiser ( 80,100,110,200) with split tail gates is fake cruiser ? Like a copy version from china ?

    • @Tonigr
      @Tonigr 3 роки тому +2

      @@hieuphan4264 Yes! 😜
      I just wanted to hold against the strong opinion for tail gates (as always with ASPW, everything is either super duper over the top or the biggest fail ever). And if you ask people about land cruisers, most of them think about the 40 or 70 series (the real shit 😍) - both popular examples with barn doors.

    • @hieuphan4264
      @hieuphan4264 3 роки тому

      @@Tonigr so i was wrong the whole time… half of the land cruiser line up is fake !!!

    • @Tonigr
      @Tonigr 3 роки тому +1

      @@hieuphan4264 Yeah! More than half of the line up if you count the Prados in. 😂
      (making a lot of friends here)

  • @seandavie3672
    @seandavie3672 3 роки тому +1

    One of your best videos ever! Thanks so much!

  • @aron2199
    @aron2199 3 роки тому +6

    I would say, Andrew, once the dealership learned that you are an influencer, their treatment of you would be much better than that available to the average joe.

    • @nnoddy8161
      @nnoddy8161 3 роки тому +1

      He is a Toyota fan-boy and we will never know what 'specials' he gets for his loyalty and defence of the brand.

  • @ChibaCityBlues
    @ChibaCityBlues 3 роки тому +2

    The Grenadier look so tempting. And they seem to do things the right way.
    Thy bought the Smart Factory and now producing Smart cars for practice. The 6 cylinder BMW engines are incredible. Super reliable and so smooth. Steyr Puch is designing the 4WD. Again one of the best companies in the world for that kind of job...
    Carraro is supplying the solid axles, which is also an excellent choice. And looking at the axles, they look solid. The differentials alone...
    My guess is, that the drivetrain of the Grenadier will be really good.
    It seems as if they make all the right choices.

  • @watda011
    @watda011 3 роки тому +7

    Andrew what about the Grenadier's plastic BMW engine? It has a history of faults and been around for ages. Would you really pick it over a 300 series based on realiabilty? They even had to take the engine plastic cover off it to fit under the bonnet and numerous critical parts are all made from plastic. Transmission is great on it, suspension, platform etc etc but l think they dropped the ball on picking the engine. I would wait a couple of years on both before purchasing as you have suggested.

    • @snowyren5135
      @snowyren5135 3 роки тому +1

      I had a 530d and it was very reliable and powerful, a great car. And I’ve driven plenty of new land cruisers and prados for work.

  • @A.Rahman.
    @A.Rahman. 3 роки тому +1

    @4xoverland the weight saving coming from:
    1-Engine
    2-Aluminum Roof panel, doors and engine hood
    3-new welding of panel reduce overlap
    4-eliminate the split door in the back

  • @andrewevans7184
    @andrewevans7184 3 роки тому +3

    Less than two minutes out of 26 on the Ineos Grenadier, you should've said this video was going to be about the Land Cruiser 300 and left it at that.

  • @kclamer
    @kclamer 3 роки тому

    Andrew is absolutely right about V6 needing to rev. My 2018 Tacoma pushes 5600rpm going up a hill, no power at all until it hits over 3k.

  • @freakysteve140281
    @freakysteve140281 3 роки тому +11

    80% of these vehicles will never see a dirt road. Especially in the higher trim levels.

    • @carholic-sz3qv
      @carholic-sz3qv 3 роки тому +2

      Yeah specially the brand new vehicles.

    • @randokuruza
      @randokuruza 3 роки тому +1

      I don’t know anyone who owns one that doesn’t go off-road.. this is a myth

    • @ridef0rlife
      @ridef0rlife 3 роки тому +2

      Who gives a fk what others do with their cars?

    • @kloschuessel773
      @kloschuessel773 3 роки тому

      I would say 99% for the first 15 years.
      Dirt road maybe and some grass but no real offroad.