Iron Sights vs Red Dot for EDC [20 Yard Practice at the Range]

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 лип 2024
  • Which do you prefer? Today I head to the range and get some practice in with both on steel at 20 yards.
    TrueTimber here: bit.ly/3VbG2TX
  • Розваги

КОМЕНТАРІ • 96

  • @WHOTEEWHO
    @WHOTEEWHO  Рік тому +2

    Which do you prefer? Today I head to the range and get some practice in with both on steel at 20 yards.
    TrueTimber here: bit.ly/3VbG2TX

    • @joshua_J
      @joshua_J Рік тому

      Who_Tee_Who you know how much I love you but it is your trigger pull making you hit left on all of your shots. Knowing this you could easily adjust your sights so if you are under stress you won't have to think about trigger squeeze.

  • @AllAboutSurvival
    @AllAboutSurvival Рік тому +10

    Personally, I've always been a fan of iron sights for EDC because they're reliable, don't require batteries, and don't have any electronic components that can fail. However, I can definitely see the advantages of a red dot in certain situations, such as low light or when you need to acquire your target quickly. It's great to see both options compared side by side like this. Ultimately, I think it comes down to personal preference and what works best for each individual's shooting style and needs.

    • @eriklambert3809
      @eriklambert3809 Рік тому

      They makes a RMR without batteries. Tier 1 has been loving his.

  • @WillBishnow
    @WillBishnow Рік тому +4

    Good stuff!
    I once had my TX LTC instructor ask us to promise we would carry wherever we possibly could. There was a shooting a a Lubys near us back in the 90s that, because the law made you keep your carry in your vehicle, many people senselessly died while their defense weapons were yards away.

  • @adammanning8882
    @adammanning8882 Рік тому +4

    I was skeptical of dots on pistols, so I bought a relatively inexpensive dot and a relatively inexpensive pistol with an optic cut. I fell in love with the dot, and now I’m about to have my carry gun cut for an EPS

  • @natjonestower3035
    @natjonestower3035 Рік тому +3

    I recently got my first red dot to put on my xd-s 45. Not quite used to it yet, but it definitely hits where the dot is pointed. Pretty good with irons on all of them, including this one, but the dot is something special. Just getting used to the draw and point is worth something, if the battery dies or you just don't have the optic on the gun at the time your muscle memory still knows where to go.

  • @JeRKII
    @JeRKII Рік тому +1

    Thanks for sharing.
    Keep up the good work

  • @nathanwhite5602
    @nathanwhite5602 Рік тому

    Great job on the video 👍

  • @Hunting4Hookers
    @Hunting4Hookers Рік тому

    Huge fan of the Trijicon tritium sights!
    Great video!

  • @reapergrim76
    @reapergrim76 Рік тому

    Great stuff! 👍

  • @dragonrider385
    @dragonrider385 Рік тому +1

    Always a good thing to shoot your EDC every once in a while. I do iron sights, i have a hard time with dots. My glasses seem to make it hard for me to use them.

  • @johnlayne-sr9mw
    @johnlayne-sr9mw Рік тому +1

    Good job dude great video I've thought about putting red dots on my pistols

  • @Dwayne7834
    @Dwayne7834 Рік тому

    Good shooting WTW . Thanks for the video

  • @6mm250
    @6mm250 Рік тому +1

    I just recently got my first red dot ever. I like it a lot , it makes it easier to shoot more better. I'm not totally giving up on irons though. Irons AND red dots , I like 'em both.

  • @mikefair816
    @mikefair816 Рік тому

    Both, all mine are setup with red dot and suppressor height sights.

  • @jameswilson5562
    @jameswilson5562 Рік тому

    Great video

  • @bobcatforever3485
    @bobcatforever3485 Рік тому

    Nice shooting! Take care.

  • @shane3878
    @shane3878 Рік тому +10

    Red dots are fine for hunting and targets. Pass on edc.

    • @aaron9129
      @aaron9129 Рік тому

      Red dots are major lint collectors.

    • @shane3878
      @shane3878 Рік тому +2

      @@aaron9129 I only have one and it's on my 10mm. They do help for those of us with old eyes trying to hit the sweet spot on a deer. It's a safe queen. As far as edc, yes, lint and failure are concerns. And I couldn't easily and rapidly transition between a pistol with and without. Nearly 50 yrs of open sights is hard to forget. :)

    • @shane3878
      @shane3878 Рік тому

      @@alexduke5402 Like I said, fine for hunting. I don't need to shoot any better with open sights as far as defensive distances go and under 7 yds, I practice not using the sights. Plus, I'll pass on the expense. I'd rather buy more ammo or use on my 7mm-08 AR build. :)

    • @eriklambert3809
      @eriklambert3809 Рік тому

      ​@@alexduke5402try an enclosed one. Takes a lot of the fears about lint away. The only thing I've personally had happen was water at the emitter.

  • @Charles_ONeal
    @Charles_ONeal Рік тому

    great video.

  • @coreyrowe2052
    @coreyrowe2052 Рік тому

    I know it's early but I'm gonna go ahead and say it. Congratulations on 500k subscribers!

  • @brucelewis1017
    @brucelewis1017 Рік тому

    Looks like some nice guns and red dots

  • @blakegregory969
    @blakegregory969 Рік тому

    Good video.

  • @mogulrider
    @mogulrider Рік тому

    Good job. I've always wondered what red dot would on a hunting rifle with pic rail. You should try it whootee

  • @franksparks1126
    @franksparks1126 Рік тому

    Good shooting, especially with the red dot. Never shot with red dot. I think I'll look into one, I'm just mediocre with a handgun, and it was always a rifle guy, but don't shoot much anymore. And it did seem you were really having a good time.

  • @Z7d3nR4
    @Z7d3nR4 Рік тому

    Thanks.

  • @charlesmorgan1879
    @charlesmorgan1879 Рік тому +1

    Ive never used a red/green dot on a hand cannon , ill have to see of a rental range offers that option !

  • @ExcavationNation
    @ExcavationNation Рік тому +1

    Nice video!

  • @scubaguy007
    @scubaguy007 Рік тому

    I've carried the same Block 19 since 2001. I've carried other guns, mostly Blocks. I like the 1911, I have 2, but I'd never want to carry one. I'd rather have my Block 21, or Block 30. I'd like to get a Gen 5 Block 21 MOS. T'would be Saaweet! God bless ya, and have a great day sir!

  • @wheeler71
    @wheeler71 Рік тому

    Thx for the post 👍🎯 carry on 🔫 🇺🇲

  • @TheJohndeere212
    @TheJohndeere212 Рік тому +1

    I always used iron sights

  • @beardedlunchbox780
    @beardedlunchbox780 Рік тому

    I switch between s&w40, g17 and dagger. And I'm looking for the cz p10 s to put in the rotation

  • @ExplicitBoricua101
    @ExplicitBoricua101 Рік тому

    Man this video drops just as I’m really looking into RD for my edc…..l

  • @chrisgabbert658
    @chrisgabbert658 Рік тому

    👍😊 1911 a1 sights 😔 but paint helps I’m old and half blind.

  • @mikemccauley8089
    @mikemccauley8089 Рік тому

    Just subscribed, always entertaining videos! Man you need to work on your fitness, couple years you will be sighting in at 10 yds because you can’t walk to 20! From experience get checked out before you go down a not so pleasant path, 5 bypasses, 4 stints, 2 ablation’s, 6 or so heart attacks, eleven heart caths, just glad to still be here so get checked out, get rid of the dad bod so you can make videos for many years to come!

  • @gkhanjriii91-04
    @gkhanjriii91-04 Рік тому +1

    That Glock 357 has a whole lotta boogie behind it 💥💥💥💥💥🔫

  • @alraybaca6235
    @alraybaca6235 Рік тому

    Pretty Kool enjoy the video

  • @danielandrews7028
    @danielandrews7028 Рік тому

    So what are the best sights short of getting a red dot? I put Kyle defoor sights on all my pistols a few years back.

  • @leemckee1272
    @leemckee1272 Рік тому

    Maybe do a video on best sights to upgrade 1911

  • @jesseboutdoors
    @jesseboutdoors Рік тому

    Always good to shoot your carry gun. I try to at least once a month.

  • @johniverson3572
    @johniverson3572 Рік тому

    Good job. Is there a reason you're landing all your shot on the left half of the target. My issue also.

  • @crypto1300
    @crypto1300 Рік тому

    I started on stock Glock sights and became pretty proficient with them. But with a red dot, I can shoot much, much faster and accurate. Although, my EDC is a stock G43X with Ameriglo iron sight.

  • @chrisb9478
    @chrisb9478 Рік тому +5

    Dots for all pistols if you train enough. Enclosed for duty.

  • @oldplace2844
    @oldplace2844 Рік тому

    Pistol red dots need longer hoods to better protect the glass both from damage and from glare. That's been my biggest complaint. I've found pistols that naturally point well to be some of the best. I've got a P-38 that points nearly dead on naturally and it's easily the pistol I am most accurate with, particularly when moving.

  • @charlesreediii5083
    @charlesreediii5083 Рік тому +1

    Ive noticed you like the left side of target.

  • @alanfox1309
    @alanfox1309 Рік тому

    i really wish i could carry. but the uk gun laws are such it's 5 years for the pistol and 5 for the ammo. oh the joys of living in the uk.

  • @TheTonygong
    @TheTonygong Рік тому

    Have a good evening

  • @adarshasokansindhya
    @adarshasokansindhya Рік тому

    ❤❤❤

  • @cleetismcdougall5425
    @cleetismcdougall5425 Рік тому

    Both on a carry. Red dot set up to cowitness

  • @mrpearson8591
    @mrpearson8591 Рік тому

    👍👍

  • @robertzimmerman9194
    @robertzimmerman9194 Рік тому

    I am an iron sight shooter. I have red dot on my 22lr, may get one for my S&W 40. But I will always use iron sights on my 1911''s

    • @cleetismcdougall5425
      @cleetismcdougall5425 Рік тому

      I felt the same way….until I bought a optic cut slide and filled it with Wilson Combat parts. I don’t carry my 1911 but it’s my favorite target pistol. I shoot my Ruger Mark IV the most but only because it is cheaper to feed.

  • @radiowaveguitarist1332
    @radiowaveguitarist1332 Рік тому

    Adam, have you ever shot a pistol with Bomar Sights. They're adjustable and fits on a 1911.

  • @mopesrus7266
    @mopesrus7266 Рік тому

    WTW, What is your opinion of the PSA? I've been tempted to add one to me EDC lineup.

  • @jeandrenth4949
    @jeandrenth4949 Рік тому

    Hey WTW, I asked about the True Timber gear and forgot to ask…does it fit as labeled? I’m not 6’6” but I am 6’3” 250lbs. Do you get like 2X or 3X and/or 2XT or 3XT? Thanks for any feed back.

    • @WHOTEEWHO
      @WHOTEEWHO  Рік тому +1

      I am 6 foot 6 and 275 lbs. I wear the XXL shirts

    • @jeandrenth4949
      @jeandrenth4949 Рік тому

      Thanks WTW. Now try out that Iver Johnson 1911 Eagle XL 10 long slide. Like to hear your thoughts!

  • @donaldstone540
    @donaldstone540 2 місяці тому

    Your follow ups might be faster cuz of the RD....or because its a 9mm vs .45 acp and .357 Sig....just saying

  • @robertwies6806
    @robertwies6806 Рік тому

    Looks like red dot is the way to go. Do you have a discount code for us?

  • @silvergrizzly316
    @silvergrizzly316 Рік тому

    Hey my brother, my EDC is Glock 32 .357 sig and I love it!!! Little expensive to shoot but it's a straight shooter for sure!!! 👍👍

  • @brandontomczyk5013
    @brandontomczyk5013 Рік тому

    9mm and 357 is not that different in caliber. but generally different powder loads. i say this because of my 350 legend. i can reload 9mm but its a 357. they are very close

  • @markreaves8086
    @markreaves8086 Рік тому

    44 mag with 44 special.

  • @chrisaerts6489
    @chrisaerts6489 Рік тому

    Im east of you tonight. Over in Gatlinburg for my 50th birthday.

    • @WHOTEEWHO
      @WHOTEEWHO  Рік тому +2

      Happy birthday!

    • @chrisaerts6489
      @chrisaerts6489 Рік тому

      @@WHOTEEWHO Im in Gatlinburg. The guns and ammo supply is back to normal compared to Wisconsin. Buds gun shop is amazing.

    • @WHOTEEWHO
      @WHOTEEWHO  Рік тому +2

      @Chris Aerts also check out rocky mtn knives and guns across the street

    • @chrisaerts6489
      @chrisaerts6489 Рік тому

      @@WHOTEEWHO I did. That place is awesome. They have the cva single shot. I only brought so much cash with. Might have to wait until I find it back home.

  • @jamesdowell9676
    @jamesdowell9676 Рік тому

    👍💯🇨🇱

  • @mikefranklin1253
    @mikefranklin1253 Рік тому

    Then change the sights on that 1911. It's not that hard.

  • @user-np2lu3wv2q
    @user-np2lu3wv2q 7 місяців тому

    Tech is cool. Train for the tech. Get used to the tech. Get dependent on the tech. Die because your battery did. I'll pass. I trained myself out of the kisser button and peep sight on my bow for the exact same reason. If you don't train to the worst case scenario, well.. I guess it's on you.

    • @WHOTEEWHO
      @WHOTEEWHO  7 місяців тому

      Most have backup sights as well

  • @richardphelan8284
    @richardphelan8284 Рік тому

    Lol all on left side

  • @WolfZiLLA84
    @WolfZiLLA84 Рік тому

    Irons for me. With my kind of luck... the screws would shear off and I'd have the optic fly into my face at 200mph... all while being in a not good situation and needing to use it. I'll pass on extra stress. Maybe on a wheelgun.. but I'm not mounting my Holosun on my SP101 .357 anytime soon.

  • @dmg4415
    @dmg4415 Рік тому

    All Your groups are to the left, either Your stance are a little of or You have to adjust the sights just a tad, about 4 to 6 inches to the right.

  • @DinoNucci
    @DinoNucci Рік тому +1

    Irons for EDC.
    Dot for range.

  • @grumpyolesilverback7211
    @grumpyolesilverback7211 Рік тому

    So, old soldier here. This is my opinion, backed by experience of training soldiers for more than a “couple” of years. You need the basic fundamentals first…with ANY weapon. Iron sights must be first to be learned. It enforces the basics of marksmanship. Once you can produce accurate and repeatable results you can graduate to optics of your choice. Point being, your stance, hand placement, trigger control, breathing, recoil control….I can go on for awhile, has already been mastered. Optics allow you to find your target with sights brought to bare faster. Now, God forbid your red dot fails. It won’t matter. Especially in this day and age of an EMP burst attack. Analog first folks. Never can go wrong.
    Stay safe and stay true.

  • @mikefranklin1253
    @mikefranklin1253 Рік тому +1

    Just based on my experience, when you need a battery it will fail.

    • @WHOTEEWHO
      @WHOTEEWHO  Рік тому

      It also has irons on it. So even if the battery fails, you are still as good as just having irons

    • @mikefranklin1253
      @mikefranklin1253 Рік тому +1

      LOL, my luck it will burst into flames and explode.

  • @NicoEl119
    @NicoEl119 Рік тому

    I dont think Who Tee practices enough with iron sights.

  • @garrettforchrist2700
    @garrettforchrist2700 Рік тому +1

    Can you see what your aiming at with the red dot at night?🇺🇲✝️🇺🇲
    1 Peter 1:18,19

  • @dickdastardly8150
    @dickdastardly8150 Рік тому

    Luminescent irons EDC for me. No batteries, easy to charge. Some night sights generate their own glow with chemical reaction. Red dots do give you a bigger sight picture, good for quick target acquisition and switching target's. But imo to bulky and cumbersome from added weight, needs to be charged by batteries or solar, gets dirtier way easier and is more difficult to clean. They make screens for debris but that's more weight and space. Simple glow iron set is easier to conceal and less likely to get snagged. I really only enjoy red dots on long guns, pdw, carbine.
    Interesting demonstration. 1911 GI sights are very tiny but you still hit at twenty with the first one a head shot, nice. 9mm always stable and red dot definitely keeps it on target. The g31 was surprisingly stable as well. Great shooting.

  • @Monster_2_82
    @Monster_2_82 Рік тому

    neither. I got an idea. how about a prism scope reticle etched into something as small as a red dot. primary arms kinda does it already.