Casey Neistat YouTube Copyright STRIKE??? - Lawyer Fair Use Reaction
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 лип 2024
- CASEY NEISTAT UA-cam COPYRIGHT STRIKE??? - LAWYER FAIR USE REACTION // In this video, Your UA-cam Lawyer does a Fair Use reaction to the Casey Neistat UA-cam channel. Is Casey Neistat deserving of a UA-cam copyright strike? As your UA-cam attorney, I explain the concept of Fair Use and delve deeper into Fair Use law -- more particularly Fair Use on UA-cam. Throughout the video, I give you Fair Use examples from Casey Neistat Fair Use problems. I discuss Casey Neistat copyright issues and show how Fair Use applies to Casey Neistat. In today’s video, we’re having a little Fair Use fun, and I will show you how to avoid copyright strikes. Thanks for watching!
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
🔥 Check out my video on FAIR USE here: • Fair Use on UA-cam - ...
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
⭐️ JOIN the “Ian Corzine" DISCORD server HERE: / discord
🔵 My favorite Casey Neistat video is called “Make it Count” -- WATCH HERE: • Make It Count
🔴 For more on the LAW UA-camrs need to know, SUBSCRIBE: ua-cam.com/users/IanCorzine?...
🔥 Check out my video on FAIR USE here: • Fair Use on UA-cam - ...
💟 Watch my video on How to Use Music on Instagram here: • How to Use Music on In...
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
AUDIO MUSIC & SOUND FX: Epidemic Sound, “Woke” by Siny, August 31, 2015
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FAIR USE ATTRIBUTION (Title 17 USC Section 107)
I used the following clips from the Casey Neistat UA-cam channel in this video, as criticism, comment, news reporting, and teaching and compliant with UA-cam’s copyright guidelines and United States Federal Law:
Clip No. 1 (copyright movie in background): • i'M Leaving NYC forever.. (0:58 - 1:21)
Clip No. 2 (can you display trademarks w/o permission?): • Make Your Own Dr. Dre ... (0:46 - 0:55)
Clip No 3 (can you use a TV clip to introduce a topic with no Transformation) • NYC Soda Ban explained... (0:07 - 0:33)
Clip No 4 (can you display other people’s social media info w/o consent?) • Instagram i love you (0:13 - 0:55)
Clip No 5 (can you film people in plane w/o permission?) • Free Business Class Up... (0:18 - 0:48)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
✳️MAILING ADRESS: ✳️
Ian Corzine - Your UA-cam Lawyer
3835 E. Thousand Oaks Blvd., Ste. 472
Westlake Village, California 91362
⭐️And also please say "Hi!" on Social Media⭐️:
Twitter: / iancorzine
Instagram: / iancorzine
Facebook: / iancorzinehotm
LinkedIn: / ian-corzine
www.iancorzine.com
The content of this UA-cam channel is provided for informational purposes only and is not intended to constitute legal advice. You should not rely upon any information contained on this UA-cam channel for legal advice. Viewing this UA-cam channel is not intended to and shall not create an attorney-client relationship between you and Ian Corzine or West Corzine, LLP. Messages or other forms of communication that you transmit to this UA-cam channel will not create an attorney-client relationship and thus information contained in such communications may not be protected as privileged. Neither Ian Corzine nor West Corzine, LLP makes any representation, warranty, or guarantee about the accuracy of the information contained in this UA-cam channel or in links to other UA-cam channels or websites. This UA-cam channel is provided "as is," does not represent that any outcome or result from viewing of this channel. Your use viewing of this UA-cam channel is at your own risk. You enjoy this UA-cam channel and its contents only for personal, non-commercial purposes. Neither Ian Corzine, West Corzine, LLP, nor anyone acting on their behalf, will be liable under any circumstances for damages of any kind.
© 2019 Ian Corzine. All rights reserved.
#caseyneistat
#fairuse
#iancorzine
#youryoutubelawyer - Навчання та стиль
Ok, everyone. This is the 3rd video of series. How many ⭐️Fair Use ⭐️ questions did you get right?
4 right. Make video about #Extraordinary Facts About Finland
"
I made copyright takedown, first UA-cam removed but because
FTD Facts told to UA-cam ""These videos were originally produced and created by us. These videos were filmed and edited by our team."
So UA-cam returned the video after 10 days because I did not bring an action in the court because of a counter-notification. Stunning action from UA-cam. My initials can be found in stolen content, but still UA-cam returned the video.
I have been driving by car hundreds of kilometers to describe these drone videos and
FTD Facts has been using without permission = 52 seconds out of my videos in one video is NOT FAIR USE.
Stolen content in
Extraordinary Facts About Finland
ua-cam.com/video/WeZAWWWH7SQ/v-deo.html
2:43-2:50
my original video: 4K FINLAND above Drone view Punkaharju from the air
ua-cam.com/video/-vbd9fVyLNk/v-deo.html
1:38 - 1:43
------------------
2. Stolen content in Extraordinary Facts About Finland 2: 52-2: 55
ua-cam.com/video/WeZAWWWH7SQ/v-deo.html
my original video: 4K Finland Parikkala Bird's Eye View - DJI Phantom 3 Pro drone ua-cam.com/video/BdA3JlrqHE4/v-deo.html
2:26 - 2:29
-----------------------
3. Stolen content in Extraordinary Facts About Finland 2: 55-2: 59 ua-cam.com/video/WeZAWWWH7SQ/v-deo.html
my original video: Punkaharju 4K Drone video - beautiful winter scenery ua-cam.com/video/-qaaJJvPqLE/v-deo.html
5:17 - 5:21
-------------
4. Stolen content in Extraordinary Facts About Finland 5:55 - 6:03 ua-cam.com/video/WeZAWWWH7SQ/v-deo.html
my original video: 4K Finland Parikkala Bird's Eye View - DJI Phantom 3 Pro drone ua-cam.com/video/BdA3JlrqHE4/v-deo.html
1:05 - 5:13
-----
5. Stolen content in Extraordinary Facts About Finland 6:10-6:18 ua-cam.com/video/WeZAWWWH7SQ/v-deo.html
my original video: 4K FINLAND above Drone view Punkaharju ilmasta ua-cam.com/video/-vbd9fVyLNk/v-deo.html
2:47 - 2:55
---
6. Stolen content in Extraordinary Facts About Finland 6:41 -6:47 ua-cam.com/video/WeZAWWWH7SQ/v-deo.html
my original video: 4K FINLAND above Drone view Punkaharju ilmasta ua-cam.com/video/-vbd9fVyLNk/v-deo.html
3:43 - 3:49
----
7. 4. Stolen content in Extraordinary Facts About Finland 8:28 -8:33 ua-cam.com/video/WeZAWWWH7SQ/v-deo.html
my original video: Finland above Punkaharju 4K beautiful winter scenery ua-cam.com/video/-qaaJJvPqLE/v-deo.html
6:09 - 6:14
--
8. 4. Stolen content in Extraordinary Facts About Finland 8:55 - 9:06 ua-cam.com/video/WeZAWWWH7SQ/v-deo.html
my original video: RUKA 4K - Rukatunturi Finland - Bird`s Eye view ua-cam.com/video/qwTYnUSPlks/v-deo.html
2:49 - 3:00
Fair Use ? My opinionis: NO
Missed 2, damn
hello lan , 3 years ago 2016 i will started youtube Chanel bcoz i will give value and info .i am shy introverted 2019 i never did this. anxiety , judging ,fear is coming when I am thinking to start a youtube Chanel .what i do pls reply
-6
hi Ian, when using Casey's videos in your video is fair use?
I get this message a lot! "This video was found to contain copyrighted material. It is being monetized but revenue is being shared with the
copyright owner." I don't use other people's recordings when making my videos but create my own music. Yes, it is not always original music
because I'm teaching songs on my channel. Shouldn't the copyright owner be able to only take 5% of my revenue if I'm only putting their material
into 5% of my video? That is NOT what is happening. They are revenue sharing the whole video cutting my revenue WAY DOWN or cutting my
ability to monetize completely. That's not fair.
I will always get 5 on 5 because I am master arguer. 😂 I think #1 and #3 are so borderline, both opinions are justifiable. #1 could be argued to be sufficiently transformed because there is no audio, and it is a piece of the background wallpaper, and not a featured standalone visual. #3 could be argued to be educational in the sense that it is just relating a segment of actual news, and if anything, would drive more traffic to that news airing. Great video.
LOL! You are so funny 😂 So, it would be ok if I did a quiz video with Star Wars (no sound) playing in the background??
Ian Corzine Star Wars should thank you for getting someone to watch it! 😝
With each of these Fair Use Tutorials, I’m beginning to get a better understanding of Fair Use.
Oh, good, Pauline. People were saying to me time and time again that it was really hard to understand. I am hoping to help people better understand with these 👊🏼😀
Likewise!
Hey Ian,
Thank You For Your Wonderful Videos.
I have question regarding the fair use,
I have made a video using stock images (Copyrighted), it is a poem and the vector images reveals themselves as the respective word indicating that particular emotion comes in the poem. Will it come under fair use policy?
These are so helpful. I keep missing number 3. 😂 And I especially appreciate that 2-5 second explanation!
Hey Someday! Thank you so much -- I really have fun making them -- whenever I am questioned for watching videos for a long time -- I'm like "I'm working!"
Does the fair use statute relate only to the specific clip used or by the entire work? For example if a clip is used (like the news clip) and then the situation or context provided by the clip is transformative, would that be fair use? I haven’t seen any language in the statute that clarifies this. Thanks Ian you rock!
Hi Ian, last year I performed the electric violin with Michael Franti at BottleRock Music festival. Is it considered "Fair Use" posting video clips of the concert that my friends took?
Hey Ian! I have a question. For the videos that they claimed as copyright content, if it follows under the fair use guidelines, can I dispute it and claim the revenue instead of "sharing revenue with copyright claimer" ? 😅
Thanks so much! I can't wait to see your channel grow to millions of subs. You're helping out so many UA-camrs.
You're so sweet! Yeah, you have the big problem. You're doing so well on YT, that a "shared revenue" video really hurts your bottom line. For a lot of us, we'll put up with demonitized videos cuz we don't lose much. Well, ultimately, YT is a private company and so they march to their own drum when it comes to copyright. So, if you went to them and said, "This video is totally legal Fair Use!" They could just say, "So what? We don't technically follow the law." However, YT is a good company and can be swayed by persuasive legal arguments. So, that is a long-winded way of saying, "Yes" you should try. What's the worst that could happen? They could say, "No."
Hey Ian - love the tie! This series is really (I mean REALLY) useful. I have a question about using public domain literary work in videos, specifically using excerpts of poetry, novels or reference books. If material is defined as 'public domain', is it allowable to use it freely, without the commentary, critique etc that feature in fair use, across all jurisdictions (US, EU, global)?
A question about the people on the airplane if the video is monitised is it still ok ?
Hey OIS! Thanks for watching. Yes, the video can still be monetized -- this question was more directed at what rights the people have to their images.
Ian, I am LOVING these fair use quizzes! I think I could be a UA-cam lawyer... hmmm ok maybe not quite yet. But you've got me studying hard lol! Keep 'em coming!
Hey Adriana! Thank you so much for watching! Yeah, they are really fun to make -- and YES, you could be a UA-cam lawyer, too!
You Tube loves Casey. They wouldn't DARE give him a copyright strike.
Haha! So, true ... Thanks so much for taking the time to watch!
Ian I really appreciate these vids on fair use as it seems to be such a grey area especially when you throw in article 13. Great break down, funny I was watching The Godfather in Casey's vid and you answered the question I was thinking.
Hey Joe!
@@Nobody-vj7mj hello brotha
Haha! Well, thanks so much Joe for watching. I really appreciate you!
Can I use 30 secs video from Jimmy fallon late night show(Donald Trump "huge" conversation) for my video(memes purpose).. is it copyright strike from TV network?? please sir reply me.. it's very important for me. Please! please! reply..
Thank you.
I am new to your channel and I have absolutely loved your Fair Use playlist. Hope you make more!
how do I email you, I got a copyright strike on a video I believe is fair use,
Congrats on 11K!
Thanks Maddy!
Damn, haven't seen a dinosaur phone like Casey's in a while.
I recently posted a video taken at a Wreath Laying Ceremony at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier. "Taps" was played for appx. 64 seconds. I received a Copyright Claim for "A Hero's Return". Normally, when there is a content claim, I swap out the music from UA-cam's Audio Library. But, in this case, the "free" version was longer than the one in the video. So, I disputed the claim.
I argued (in good faith) on two fronts: Public Domain, and Incidental Use.
Public Domain: because Taps had been written in the 1800's and is now in the Public Domain
Incidental Use because the playing of Taps is traditional at Military Funerals and Public Ceremonies honoring the Military Dead.
Since this video was taken at a Public Event at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier, featuring music traditionally played at such events, it was a Fair use under the Public Domain and Incidental Use theories.
The Copyright Claim was removed in about 3 days
I will be videoing a Memorial Day Ceremony later today. I am crossing my fingers I don't need to repeat this process all over again.
Good for you!! It is great to hear that someone had success dealing with copyright and UA-cam!! Keep up the good work. 👊😁
Hi Ian
Recently I got copyright on video concert of Jay Sean I recorded while I’m at the event. I file dispute but i prostrated i delete the video right away. Is this the right thing I did. Thank you for your respond.
Hey Lolaa! Thanks for watching -- was it the right thing? Well, it really is a balancing test. For stuff that is really important to you, you may want to file a dispute but for passing concert footage, I don't know that it is worth it. BUT, it is a lesson to be aware of where you are filming!
Ian Corzine Thank you so much
So interesting!!! I always learn so much from your videos! Random question for you, thoughts on UA-cam fights? I've been following the James Charles fight today
Hey Abbi! Thanks for watching! Yeah, they're bound to happen. Hopefully, both Tati and James will be ok in the future.
brilliant! Love these!
Thank you so much!! Hopefully everyone is learning what is and what isn't Fair Use acceptable. Thanks for watching AND please let me know if you ever have any questions. 👊😁
Great content Ian. Love it! For any of these that weren’t fair use is there even the remotest chance that Casey or a smaller creator would be called out for such a use in actual practice? Thanks Ian! 👊🏼
Hey Trev! Thanks for watching and the compliment! LOL! There is probably NO chance. Can you guess how much money Casey makes for YT? My lessons are for NORMAL people like us 👊🏼😀
@@iancorzine Ok then - could you please teach me to be NOT NORMAL? 😀
Hey Ian, this is a great video! Keep doing such.
Great series Ian! It will be interesting how this all unfolds in the next few years. I'm sure Casey gets a ton of copyright claims. Big UA-camr = Big Money. Heck, big companies and even bogus companies are abusing the YT copyright claims across the board (Big and small channels!). I'm not against copyright claims when they are legit. So many aren't.
You know it Edie!! Soooooooo many subscribers are telling me stories of claims against their original work. Even one person who wrote a song and someone else is claiming it as their song and YT is not taking the side of the original artist. It is so frustrating!! 😢😢 I feel so sorry for the legitimate people.
@@iancorzine exactly!! I've seen some YT musicians with that very problem. As for myself, I've had claims were the song is completely wrong (a completely different song) and on my kids channel I'm getting claimed for my own recordings of traditional/public domain songs. The funny thing is when I look up the publisher's sound recording, they note it as traditional as well. Plus when you dispute the claim, you're disputing with the company placing the claim. Of course, they're gonna reject it. Insanity.
These videos have been great! I appreciate you helping us to understand more about what qualifies as "FAIR USE".
Do you give prizes to your slowest students? This week I missed the Godfather one, I think I was just loving that it was playing in the background and wanted him to pass the darn FU test. Thank you MA for another great video 😊
Yes, MA. I have an online course and free checklist coming out for my most devoted viewers like you! TQMA!
Sorry for a second post, but just wanted you to know I shouted you and your channel out during my stream last evening. I had 41-42 people on at one point (not bad for a little channel like mine). I told them about the work you do, how you've been growing at a rapid pace, and that anyone concerned about copyright or trade mark law should watch your videos and subscribe. I also told them about our discussion having to do with the Imperial Cog flag seen in my videos as it was asked several times by my viewers. Thanks Ian, long live the Empire!
Stormey! You never have to apologize for multiple comments. The more the better! Thank you, thank you! That was so kind of you - I am so grateful for you!
Another awesome quiz! Thanks!
Takes you back to high school, right? LOL!
First of all, I think hoodies should be your new style. LOVE this new format - SO HELPFUL!
LOL! When editing, I wear them all time! I get so cold editing my dungeon! Haha!
But for the soda ban clip with 2 people talking, he did say "there's been a lot of talk about the soda ban", that doesn't qualify as commenting on that clip?
Nice job Ian, love the break down and actually learned a little. Thank you!
Haha! Thanks so much Craig! I'm glad you learned a little -- when I can keep a busy man like you with young kids engaged, that's the ultimate compliment!
More fair use fun!
Just for you Tom!!👊😁
Yes.. Short clip is the Best for best Fair Use..
I proved it.. 😎👍
Yeah!! good for you!!. 👊😁 Thanks for watching and for sharing your success.
Referring to the last point, does a UA-cam video not count as commercial then? Even though the creator is getting paid by ad sense etc.
Please please reply... Review on tech zone , hooked, hyperloop, quantum tech hd channels how they use others videos more than 10 -20 seconds without giving credit and doesn't got copyright strike ....
Please please make a review how we also make videos like this channels under fair use..
i warm request from heart please ❤️❤️
Very interresting Video Ian!! There is "Saul" inside you!!! .-)
LOL! I know -- I sometimes feel that way -- "It's All Good!"
Great analysis 👍
Shoot! This one was hard!
🤣🤣 BUT did you learn something??? That's what matters. Thanks for watching. 👊😁
very interesting ! Funny, i was thinking about him and copyrights an year ago... mostly for music. My guess is that UA-cam pay directly to the owner the fee.
Hey Dave! Thanks for your help with this one. Yeah, it's the old adage "The bigger, the more"
Always FUN!
Just for you Linda!! 🤣🤣🤣
He's got plenty of old videos with popular, copyrighted music. That was back before he was monetized though, so I don't think he cared as much then lol
So much music I would love to use and clips, i recently finished a vid and at the end i flipped a coin whether I should post it or not..."not" won. Just didnt want to chance it.
Yeah, I know -- don't know if you noticed, but I had to switch some of it out on the clips -- I'm not dumping WuTang on YT without getting a strike
@@ehJoe Really Joe? Why did you not just out a vanilla Epidemic tune on there??? 😉
@@iancorzine I use Epidemic but the music I wanted to use was not.
@@iancorzine I actually had some Redbull clips as well that even though worked perfect I decided it wasn't worth it.
Thanks for this. It was very helpful.
Hey Christian! Thanks very much!
Well I think "right" is subjective... I also love Casey and my opinions may differ from yours on some of these... ;)
Ha Jim! The most loaded comment ever ... ok, which ones do you see differently? Can't be the Godfather one, right?
@@iancorzine Well, the Matt Lauer one. He was just reporting facts, but after you explained it, I can totally see your point. I feel like everything Casey does is artistic and transformative. I think I'm going to stick to LLC's and taxes. LOL.
@@jimhart LOL! You are so funny! Speaking of that -- I'm going to need your help coming up. Have a new LLC that I formed and want your opinion on some formation docs. I'll be in touch!
@@iancorzine Let me know how I can help!
Your information seems like sound advice concerning how to keep it legal onUA-cam. However, there content developers like The Fat Rat are receiving copyright strikes from people claiming to own the material in question. How do you prevent, stop, or revers a strike on material you produced claimed by a Content Pirate?
Great vid!
Love these fair use quiz game vids, I watched the James Charles one too.
You did??? Thanks so much! Yeah, I was trying to figure out a way to make boring, old copyright law fun! Haha!
Hey Ian, your channel is bossmanscrubs - (it's cool) - really helpful tips on Fair Use and something I've been searching for a long time, but hadn't found the answers. I'm starting a new channel and looking to use clips and your guidance makes this goal a whole lot more realistic, big thanks Sir!
Dirty Shed -- I was having a bad day, and you just made me feel GREAT! Good on you -- good luck with the channel -- with an attitude like that, I know you're going to kill it!
Oh man I'm so glad I could help you out. Since YT is really cracking down right on copyright violations, the creators need to know about Fair Use. In fact, I have made several more recent videos that discuss Fair Use even more. Go ahead and watch those and you will soon become a copyright expert. Thanks for watching. 👊😁
Hmm . . . the voting links didn't show up for me (I use Chrome browser).
Really?? Sorry about that.😢 I just tried it using Chrome and the links showed up for me.... The only thing I can think of is that maybe you have pop-ups blocked or something along those lines. If I were you I would google it to find an answer. Good luck and please let me know if you have any other problems or questions.
@@iancorzine I see that I installed the "Block youtube ads" Chrome extension a long time ago. I disabled it, restarted my browser and now the links show up. Shame on me for blocking youtube ads! :)
Ian, you said Casey's use in the last clip was not for advertising but if the video is monetized, it is for a commercial purpose. How about that? If you're using someone's image for a commercial benefit, a re they not entitled to a payment? Seems that's open to interpretation.
Hey Jerry. Really great question! I address this in future videos, but this is where practicality meets the law. Technically, you’re right UA-cam videos that are monetized are a commercial use. However, at least in California, the original creator has a larger burden. He or she is got to prove that the image was used for an explicit advertising purpose. In this case, it wasn’t an advertising purpose. However, even if you were subject to different law, and the standard was less , Most of the time it would be hard to prove that your image was tied directly to a sum of money that was made by the borrower creator. There may be some egregious cases out there, where a UA-camr makes fun of a person, in the video makes the UA-camr $1 million. But that’s definitely the exception.
Thanks Ian, that's valuable information to know, that intent trumps the eventual result and incidental benefit (monetization) isn't the benchmark. You're providing a tremendous service to UA-camrs with this channel.
Even Casey can make mistakes with fair use, crazy! Thanks for the info brother!👍
Just for you you bro!!
AHAHAHAHAHAA 8:18 she is using her Phone,,,,Upside down while texting....IMposttible unless it is OFF :D
This guy is reviewing all of the channels, hope mine isn’t next :D
Hmmmm.....Let me have a check.........🤣🤣🤣
That was Fun Ian!
Well, thanks Suzy for playing! You can choose the prize from Door #1, #2, or #3!
you did a great job on this video
Thank you so much! I really appreciate your kind words. 👊😀
This is a nice video idea!!!
Thank you so much Shaggy!! I am trying to educate creators on what is and what isn't Fair Use acceptable. Thanks for watching and please let me know if you ever have any questions. 👊😁
I can't remember where I saw/heard/read it now (and it was only earlier today) that fair use may not be considered if you are trying to monetise your video which contains the fair use content.
Could this be the case or affect people who do reaction videos? Some of those have thousands of views. Are they NOT monetised? Can they be? I see some who do the "stop and critique" the songs, regularly, others who watch the whole way through, then comment at the end.
I understand your 2-5sec clip "rule", but I would think if you wanted to do a true critique of a song, it would be better to stop after a verse or part thereof, but after 5 sec could destroy the 'mood' a song is trying to build. How would these work?
Very informative 👍
Thanks for watching 👊🏻😊 Bilal, What kind of content do you make?
So is it fine to put Casey's pic in your thumbnail, and use his partial videos in your clip without his explicit consent? Great channel! Greetings from Bay Area!
Thank you so much for watching!! You are very observant aren't you. I'm keeping my fingers crossed that I don't get a strike. 👊😁
Hi Ian, when you are using Casey's videos in your video is fair use ? Thanks for your answer, you are great 💪💪💪
Hi ReSmart!! Good catch there. Yes, while I am using Casey's video, I am "transforming" it so it is considered Fair Use and "hopefully" won't get flagged by YT's content ID. I always hold my breath a little when I upload a new video hoping that YT doesn't find anything wrong with it. It's not an exact science, but experience does help you know what is acceptable and what is not. Thanks for watching and for reaching out. 👊😁
Yes!!! 5/5!!! Great vid!!!!!❤️❤️❤️
Hey Mads! Thanks so much for taking the QUIZ! On top of all the other ones you have!
Subbed but it was a different Kasey that sent me here 😉🇦🇺
Thanks for the follow. Your content looks informative, I'll check it out.
Hey Zeke! Thanks for watching 👊🏻😊 let me know if you have questions.
Ohhh well this was my worst one only 2 out of 5, no fair maybe next time thanks for the fun 🐈✌️💕
SHAKA! Well, these ones were harder -- it's totally ok. Just keep practicing!
@@iancorzine ty 🙋
Whoa whoa...I thought I was your favorite UA-cam creator. 🤷🏻♂️ The Godfather clip? That was not coincidental.... Ian- I’m talking about your channel tonight on my stream (8:30 pm EST).
🤣🤣🤣
IANAL, but I would argue that a mere 24 seconds out of an entire feature-length film, scaled down and in distorted perspective, with absolutely no audio, and not even a particularly visually-striking 24 seconds, is so extremely non-prejudicial to the potential revenue of the original work, and it constitutes such a small portion of the new work, that it very arguably qualifies as fair use. I knew you would say no because the "no" answer said "it's not transformative", which I agree it isn't, but one isn't absolutely required to check that box for it to constitute fair use.
Then again, we're using different definitions of "transformative" because commentary and education is also often blatantly non-transformative. It's also true that UA-cam would have no problem failing to find Fair Use in this case, and that your emphasis is UA-cam policies, not the law, which is arguably appropriate since those policies matter far more than the actual law in most cases.
I made a video about subliminal messages in advertising. Most of the subliminal messages are innocent and isn’t accusing anyone of anything. Will I get in trouble for this?
Like this survey I had some correct
Did you? Great Carin! Is Fair Use becoming a little more clear for you?
@@iancorzine yes thanks
4 out of 5 this time. I like Casey too! Love these games because I learn in a fun way!!!! Thanks.
They are fun to make AND yes, they are educational as well. 👊😁
Hey Ian!! Just found your channel and followed IMMEDIATELY. I'm prepping to launch my channel officially after much hesitation due some of the to the subject matter...COMIC BOOKS. I've followed channels such as Comicstorian and Comics Explained for years & I'm curious as to how they're operating in fair use when they're using actual recently published comic books & art or re-telling (paraphrasing ) the actual printed story. I'm looking to do something similar..BUT different as I'm an actual comic book professional artist & lean heavily on the art side but I plan on using others' works in a similar fashion for some reviews & story re-telling. Based on your videos I see SOME alteration (by blotting out the text) but combined with the length of use of the work in the videos sometimes exceeding 20+ seconds, it seems somewhat a gray area to me. Please help before I launch!!
i really love ur video sir
Wow! What a compliment! Thanks for taking the time to watch!
welcome. always
Fair use very complicated I better don't use it recently UA-cam post a video UA-cam said there is no such a thing call fair use we can't and not allowed to use even 1 second other UA-cam content that's the truth there no fair use use your own content then its gonna be fair use
Hey, Ian. Could you get a copyright strike for using Casey's clip and showing the Godfather? Good question!
Hey Crazy! Thanks for watching! Actually, yes, I could, but I did a lot of work to demonstrate Fair Use of the clip -- commentary, critique, and reaction -- so if you want to review content on your channel in the future, make sure you use the Fair Use techniques and short clips!
@@iancorzine Thanks Ian. I worry about copyright problems--not so much with UA-cam, but with copyright holders. Legal fees can be expensive, even if you do it right. Currently, I have a book of Basic language software programs published (in print--a real publisher) in 1983 that has been copied to a pdf without my permission and given away free. I submitted a DCMA form request, and I'm waiting. It's been 2 weeks. Can I try to sue if they don't respond? The company is in Panama.
missed 2 points
thanks so much for giving helpful info
Hey Michael! Let me guess 1 and 3? Haha!
yep
the movie in th background and the news clip part :D you are right hahahha
uhm, i have no idea what si consigliere means.
Cool
Thanks for watching bro!
Awesome
hey Ramiz! Thanks so much for watching!
@@iancorzine you too sir and i ve a question though i m doing anime can you come to my channel and see my work and to me if it under copy law to something sir with deep respect to sir.
Sure. I'll check it out once I get through this pile of work on my desk.
namasthe friend
1- yes you do he is using film/book to teach/educate/explain as methaphor of things in chapters/scene and the point of things in life change closing chapters and change in life death one person runing things to another- yet did not give vuppola/puzo/towne credit in his sighting or paramonts 1972 distribution or who ever owns the B today- it was educational and omg- 24 seconds out of a 178 minute (3 hour film) it was teaching so I totally do not see it as using to sell godfather or take profit from the film-(he a had to throw the mob thing in and tell the damn story for that- it made you want to go get to cinge watch for those who knew the film and go look up to find out more if you didn't so did the owner a favor to deen one to purchase (or remind me to get it in dvd cause only have it in VHS and (omg changing /transforming the godfather sad thought) so cuppala/distributo whoever highly doubtful would strike it- when considering this guys base at least a quarter of them went to either purchase or rewatched the art in film- just saying the point of vopyright is not to make something off of the use of someone elses stuff (steal and sell, plagiarizer-pass it off as your own- this guy was not doing that at all- not being a pirate -2- if bose or beets did not want there logos seen in public they would not put logos on their merch- looks like he may be changing one to look like the other-so transforming, educational as teaching other to do same -maybe a commentary on cost boise/beets good but one better quality one looks cool or something but again once we buy their stuff we should be able to make it look however based on our maybe not wanting to be bullied/not wanted to be stolen in are area which might consider on cooler than the other- what ever- he wasn''t trying to sell them (yet he as the current owner certainly could -cause they already got their money and taxes already paid ) 3. not cause of Matt but never said what clip was from nbc, not a use for learning about the ban cause stopped to soon to get info or comment on bloomburgs ban so I would say no 4. for exactly for why you said- if out in the world for the world- same with if you in a public place like a mall or plane- well I gues I only disagree with 1
I get this message a lot! "This video was found to contain copyrighted material. It is being monetized but revenue is being shared with the
copyright owner." I don't use other people's recordings when making my videos but create my own music. Yes, it is not always original music
because I'm teaching songs on my channel. Shouldn't the copyright owner be able to only take 5% of my revenue if I'm only putting their material
into 5% of my video? That is NOT what is happening. They are revenue sharing the whole video cutting my revenue WAY DOWN or cutting my
ability to monetize completely. That's not fair.