How do you keep a player who wants to leave? | Jamie Carragher & Slaven Bilic | Twitter Q & A

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 20 жов 2024
  • SUBSCRIBE ► bit.ly/SSFootba...
    Slaven Bilic answers your questions on international management and reveals the struggles in keeping a player who wants to leave (ie: Dimitri Payet & Alexis Sanchez)
    ►TWITTER: / skysportsfootball
    ►FACEBOOK: / skysports
    ►WEBSITE: www.skysports.c...

КОМЕНТАРІ • 244

  • @hamizbashir3761
    @hamizbashir3761 6 років тому +687

    Slavin is a good pundit!!! hire him sky!!!

    • @deadlydimitarr
      @deadlydimitarr 6 років тому +13

      He was spot on in the Euros as a pundit. That Euros had terrible teams but great pundits

    • @optix1012
      @optix1012 6 років тому +5

      At the Euro's when one of his players scored and he started dancing on the studio table with all the BBC pundits. CLASS! Gotta love Slavin, hope he gets back into this league or on the TV with the pundits. UK misses you, we need that energy back.

    • @aryanmanchanda3300
      @aryanmanchanda3300 6 років тому +1

      Ricardo Matthews It was at the Euro’s when Payet scored

    • @007Fusiion
      @007Fusiion 6 років тому +1

      He always seems drunk.

    • @vdotme
      @vdotme 6 років тому +1

      Hamiz Bashir he's too good for Sky. He needs 5mins plus to make his great points. Sky wants guys who can make 4-7 soundbites in their halftime talk slot. A bit more time pre and post match but they're competing for headlines not methodically breaking the issues down. This format is excellent for him and us tho.

  • @seanwilkinson4016
    @seanwilkinson4016 6 років тому +1178

    I can't understand a word that foreigner is saying, Bilic is crystal clear though

  • @tobiasen5316
    @tobiasen5316 6 років тому +454

    Slaven is a very good person and pundit. Hope he gets a job soon again.

    • @deadlydimitarr
      @deadlydimitarr 6 років тому +1

      Why is everyone acting like he wasn't in 2016? Rewatch Euro analysis.

    • @callumh5034
      @callumh5034 6 років тому

      He seems to be a good pundit but i feel like he takes too long to say what he wants, like other pundits are more fast paced

    • @snuffmeister6720
      @snuffmeister6720 6 років тому +11

      ^ speaking a second language and putting thought into your words does that

  • @pitty04
    @pitty04 6 років тому +163

    BIlic talks so well. Could listen to him for longer than this.

  • @guillaumeanderson6217
    @guillaumeanderson6217 6 років тому +480

    I really like Bilic. You really saw he cared about West Ham. I really felt sorry for him as Payet betrayed him.

    • @JJones-oi3jc
      @JJones-oi3jc 6 років тому +8

      Guillaume Anderson i know and for what, he could've made a legacy at west ham.

    • @owentaylor1762
      @owentaylor1762 6 років тому +22

      Trust me, all West Ham fans miss this man. Great guy but such a shame it didn't work out

    • @spizzlo
      @spizzlo 6 років тому +4

      Yeah but we also realize now that the team wasn't run very well under him. Everyone loved him but he wasn't the best manager in the end.

    • @RGY33
      @RGY33 6 років тому +5

      Guillaume Anderson betrayed him? Did you not listen Payet had personal problems where he wanted to go back to his homeland

    • @guillaumeanderson6217
      @guillaumeanderson6217 6 років тому +1

      Ryan Sea Level that's no reason to refuse to play for the club. utter disgrace

  • @faisalnasti
    @faisalnasti 6 років тому +141

    Bilic is a great person , have liked him from the beginning

  • @mikallavoll8961
    @mikallavoll8961 6 років тому +213

    "never mentioned Gary Neville" Brilliant Jamie

  • @danielvaldez9946
    @danielvaldez9946 6 років тому +35

    I love his style. Its nice to finally see a pundit that convinces by being calm, poised, and mindful with his arguments.

  • @owentaylor1762
    @owentaylor1762 6 років тому +76

    Great guy and incredibly passionate about the game! Wish it worked out West Ham, was an absolute joy to have a man who loved the club as much as the fans, wish him all the best in the future

  • @eben7447
    @eben7447 6 років тому +94

    Says "off course we have fans in New Zealand "
    Man's heart is still with West ham 🙋

  • @seanyeldrem7607
    @seanyeldrem7607 6 років тому +83

    Really like slaven he seems cool and passionate

  • @ZenekLopata4
    @ZenekLopata4 6 років тому +78

    It's amazing how when they asked ''West Ham have fans in New Zealand?'' his reply was ''Of course *we* have.''

  • @TrueJaguarPaw
    @TrueJaguarPaw 6 років тому +40

    Still loves west ham utd. When he referred to west ham he did as “we”. Payet kinda caused him issues. He was great at the euro’s broadcast team very

    • @456madhouse
      @456madhouse 6 років тому

      TrueJaguarPaw was waiting for this comment. Not disappointed haha

  • @S3D77
    @S3D77 5 років тому +7

    Not a word out of place, Bilic is such an intelligent and professional man, very well spoken.

  • @irishmax2921
    @irishmax2921 6 років тому +16

    I could listen to him all day! Talks a lot of sense.

  • @HPsauce1234
    @HPsauce1234 6 років тому +135

    to the person who disliked the video. What's to not like? apart from no subtitles for carra 😂

    • @Markooo-zh9us
      @Markooo-zh9us 6 років тому +11

      manchester is red Awkward moment when the Croat speaks better English than Carra 😂

  • @AnuFresh47
    @AnuFresh47 6 років тому +10

    Slavin is really a very good pundit with real experience.We need more pundits like him.

  • @scottcrosby-art5490
    @scottcrosby-art5490 5 років тому +18

    This guy lives and breathes football, Hope he does well with West Brom

  • @shivainvalidos6873
    @shivainvalidos6873 6 років тому +8

    That's a very interesting interview and insightful point of views on what's happening with players and managers between matches! Give Slaven a job Sky!

  • @NoName-zv5rp
    @NoName-zv5rp 6 років тому +32

    Honestly slavin is a good pundit

  • @ClarenceBaloyi
    @ClarenceBaloyi 6 років тому +2

    You gotta love Slavan. What a guy, down to earth and articulate. Would love to see him back in the premier league soon!

  • @Mitotracker
    @Mitotracker 6 років тому +9

    New Zealand fan showing some love for Slaven

  • @MemoryLaneCinema
    @MemoryLaneCinema 6 років тому +21

    A solution to minimize the players power is when it comes to wages. It also improves performance. All clubs should give their players a set wage (not a high one). After that they get bonuses based on how they perform.

    • @ViewsFromTheNorthEnd
      @ViewsFromTheNorthEnd 6 років тому +1

      That is really good but then you get players who are on fire running down their contracts to try get more money.

    • @TheEamonn21
      @TheEamonn21 6 років тому +6

      It will never work because no players will accept

    • @MemoryLaneCinema
      @MemoryLaneCinema 6 років тому +1

      That is the case. They have to accept if all clubs do the same.

    • @70BTHS
      @70BTHS 6 років тому +1

      It's too late for that, prisoner's dilemma would occur, unfortunate but it is what it is now lol

    • @locasenior8229
      @locasenior8229 4 роки тому

      @@MemoryLaneCinema it would always be that one club that one psg or man city or any top 5 club that gives 200 k in wages just for fun.

  • @garyb123fob
    @garyb123fob 6 років тому +7

    Great guy loved him as west ham manager. Sad to hear him still refer to west ham as 'we'. Hope he does well in the rest of his career

  • @steve13191
    @steve13191 6 років тому +3

    I'm a big fan of how Slaven sets his team up especially when they played bigger teams. medium block and compact, loved his tactic of overloading the left side of the pitch with Lanzini, Payet, and cresswell for build up on those games it was very effective. feel sorry for Slaven things went south.

  • @Vintageferguson
    @Vintageferguson 6 років тому +7

    Nice video, I would love to be the man asking the questions. Lucky dude, surrounded by class week in an week out

  • @bleeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
    @bleeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee 6 років тому +58

    ''HE NEVER MENTIONED GARY NEVILLE DID HE?''

  • @markabel8780
    @markabel8780 4 роки тому +2

    He is always so interesting to listen to (Bilic) as he’s intelligent and honest, it gives us a very intelligent insight into football.

  • @TheGkUnion
    @TheGkUnion 6 років тому +2

    Warms my heart to hear slav still refer to west ham as 'we'. Love this man so much despite what happened with this season

  • @aarsenalfan
    @aarsenalfan 6 років тому +4

    Slaven Bilić was the player who wouldn't let you pass him, when he gives you a look you poop your pants, he was a hard cire. That's what every Croatian fan knows about him👍

  • @stuarthopkins1308
    @stuarthopkins1308 6 років тому +2

    I'm pretty sure Slaven said 'we' when referring to West Ham; I so wanted it to work for him and for him to be our manager for years.

  • @Pronax299
    @Pronax299 6 років тому +5

    Great insight from Bilic!

  • @s_lafi
    @s_lafi 6 років тому +3

    Bilic! What a pundit! Sky.. he should be hired!

  • @IgboKezie
    @IgboKezie 6 років тому +1

    Love Bilic, fantastic manager, good pundit; honest as the day is long. Ducks nothing speaks much sense with passion and insight. Look forward to seeing him back in the game

  • @dylanmiles6690
    @dylanmiles6690 6 років тому +9

    Jamie carrager sounded so surprised when slaven said we have fans from NZ (i support united from NZ)

  • @senate_shakya_
    @senate_shakya_ 6 років тому +33

    No player is bigger than the club.
    Ask Bayern Munich.

  • @jamonen919
    @jamonen919 6 років тому +7

    West ham has a big following in new Zealand cause of Winston Reid

  • @four4633
    @four4633 6 років тому +1

    Bilic was great, informative, and ENTERTAINING. He should coach pundits!

  • @Det6x
    @Det6x 6 років тому +7

    Carragher was begging for him to say Gary Neville at the end haha

  • @mrnoodlelai
    @mrnoodlelai 6 років тому +2

    Hey I am from New Zealand. But I am a Liverpool fan

  • @fremmer007
    @fremmer007 6 років тому +1

    We miss Slaven. He will always be remembered for the last season at The Boleyn.

  • @Jijkgf
    @Jijkgf 6 років тому +1

    it nice to hear from a coach that don't have any thing to hied

  • @fred_.oOOo._
    @fred_.oOOo._ 6 років тому +3

    Great interview!

  • @lllancaste
    @lllancaste 6 років тому

    Will always love Slav for the last season at the Boleyn Ground and still considers himself a west ham fan

  • @velouris76
    @velouris76 4 роки тому

    Have to say, when he did punditry during either last WC or Euro Championship, Slaven was superb! He should really be signed up as main half time pundit for Sky.

  • @ashishjohar4974
    @ashishjohar4974 6 років тому

    Slaven is the best guest MNF had so far..he provided so many insights of the game and management..hire him for permanent if possible..he can become top pundit like GNeville with his huge experience

  • @deadlydimitarr
    @deadlydimitarr 6 років тому +19

    Board needs to show ambition for a player to stay. Then the manager needs to appeal to the players' demands in approaches.
    Kroos would never want to play in a Conte or Simeone system for example.
    That's really all there is to it and of course wages. Not sure why money is a primary factor for players though. Greedy players aren't exactly the best in this game anyway imo.

    • @EdwinLuciano
      @EdwinLuciano 6 років тому +6

      "Not sure why money is a primary factor for players though."
      They're people. What's the primary reason people wake up in the morning and drag themselves to work everyday?
      "Greedy players aren't exactly the best in this game anyway."
      Who are the best players in this game, Suraj? What do they have in common?

    • @deadlydimitarr
      @deadlydimitarr 6 років тому +1

      Edwin Luciano,
      Well I mean your average guy working 30,000k a year isn't the same as 100,000 a week. Greed is am understatement if you abandon your club/manager just for money. Note the word primary.
      I don't see Hazard, Messi, Ronaldo, Bale, Modric, Kroos, Lewa, etc, as greedy, and leaving clubs for solely money. It's usually to win trophies which is understandable.

    • @4LP3E
      @4LP3E 6 років тому +3

      the greed is from their agent

    • @deadlydimitarr
      @deadlydimitarr 6 років тому

      6IXVI Super,
      Oh yeah mans like Riola. Verratti would have been at Juve or a Prem club by now if it weren't for that snake.

    • @irieite9666
      @irieite9666 6 років тому +1

      I usually disagree wholeheartedly with your comments Suraj. Usually because it is trolling Arsenal lol. But I have too agree with you about Greed.
      It is obscene to me that these guys earn so much when there are kids starving Worldwide.
      My wages are a meagre 10k a year but I am always happy. It is scientifically proven that helping people makes you happier.
      I trully believe money is the most addictive substance in the whole world.
      When Sevilla won Europa League back to back I won 14 grand in bets. I staked almost the whole lot again the next season and lost it ironically when sevilla 3-peated.....
      It was then that I converted too Nyabinghi Rastafari after hearing the gospel of the most high and honourable of Jahs Prophets Robert Nesta Marley. I have now found love and happiness with less concern for wealth and status.

  • @REPULSINGNNF
    @REPULSINGNNF 6 років тому +7

    He'll be a premier league next year 100 percent. He sounds very knowledgable obviously lol

    • @shade346
      @shade346 4 роки тому

      And he is, croats are very inteligent ppl

  • @ouroborosnagyok9306
    @ouroborosnagyok9306 6 років тому +1

    this is brilliant, love Slaven

  • @frenkie14
    @frenkie14 6 років тому

    You guys probably don't know but Bilic had a rock band in Croatia before he started managing. I'm a West Ham fan from Croatia. ⚒

  • @arjitjere7951
    @arjitjere7951 6 років тому

    Slaven always seemed as a decent Person when he was manager and he seems very insightful as a pundit.welcome change to the board

  • @satyam4125
    @satyam4125 6 років тому

    You feel like listening to Slaven Bilic whenever he speaks .. that's a sign of a great pundit.

  • @redmed10
    @redmed10 3 роки тому

    Lesson learned from this video. Never let an individual agent have more than one player at your club. The more players they have the more effect they will have on your club. The more knowledge they will have about your club and therefore more control they have over your club.

  • @aimer3042
    @aimer3042 6 років тому +1

    First time i see Jamie Carragher not rebutting and sitting there quietly listening to Bilic..

  • @BallersLife
    @BallersLife 6 років тому +3

    Hard to listen to him, but good insightful answers to the questions nevertheless.

  • @JesusChristMyLord
    @JesusChristMyLord 4 роки тому +1

    Jamie is one of the reasons I refuse to come back...

  • @shabanaahmed4709
    @shabanaahmed4709 6 років тому

    Nice to see slav back coyi

  • @kenyanyoutubetrends385
    @kenyanyoutubetrends385 6 років тому +17

    uefa league of nations = top 10 anime fights

  • @parsoumash
    @parsoumash 6 років тому +13

    "He never mentioned Gary Neville" lmao

  • @SlyCarey
    @SlyCarey 6 років тому +15

    Just can't not love Slaven

  • @iputyouinmyoveni5541
    @iputyouinmyoveni5541 6 років тому +1

    Always likes slavan, wouldn't mind him replacing Wenger. If it's not year 2040

  • @Chirishgambino
    @Chirishgambino 5 років тому

    i do miss slav, he probably did need to go but he'll always be welcome at west ham

  • @unknownuser-to6tb
    @unknownuser-to6tb 6 років тому +10

    I'm from New Zealand and support West Ham actually
    Who am I kidding? I support Arsenal :)

  • @MrFluidwill
    @MrFluidwill 4 роки тому

    Slaven Bilic total geezer x

  • @novelist5380
    @novelist5380 6 років тому +5

  • @saneman6188
    @saneman6188 6 років тому

    Honest man.

  • @welshhibby
    @welshhibby 6 років тому +6

    Slavin is a great guest...Sky need to get him as a pundit and drop Gary Neville

  • @jolfen1837
    @jolfen1837 6 років тому

    Class act, hope he gets hired at West Brom

  • @fz4898
    @fz4898 3 роки тому

    Bilic is amazing

  • @bikashpandey6510
    @bikashpandey6510 6 років тому +1

    Salven is a Nobel person

  • @Olympiamaniac
    @Olympiamaniac 6 років тому

    Interesting insights

  • @khaliboy07
    @khaliboy07 6 років тому

    Bilic was actually talking about man city. Soon their players will become bigger than the club

  • @MESSI-fx1ob
    @MESSI-fx1ob 5 років тому +4

    Slaven is awesome hire him now

  • @samroche6859
    @samroche6859 6 років тому +6

    With the backing of smarter, less tyrannical owners, perhaps Slaven would still be at West Ham

  • @olayinkaamara385
    @olayinkaamara385 6 років тому +7

    If a player refuses to play and wants to leave then clubs should cancel their wages.

    • @eldio2124
      @eldio2124 6 років тому +2

      Olayinka Amara you cant you have to abide by their contract. The player can always say he’s injured or feeling sick and there’s no way to disprove that.

    • @imo098765
      @imo098765 6 років тому

      thats fair enough, you get paid to be this clubs player, if you dont play for this club you shouldnt get paid

    • @four4633
      @four4633 6 років тому

      Steve Gerrard medicals!

  • @24SparrowJack
    @24SparrowJack 6 років тому +10

    How do you keep a player who wants to leave? tell them you're under contract with this club

    • @EdwinLuciano
      @EdwinLuciano 6 років тому +1

      You don't think Slavin told Dimitri Payet that he was under contract? What eventually happened? Did West Ham keep Payet or did he go where he wanted to go in the end?

    • @TheLordoftheRavens
      @TheLordoftheRavens 6 років тому

      +Edwin Luciano That's because it ended up being the best option for both sides. Payet wanted to leave, and him being distracted and not performing at 100% as well as the speculation that caused issues for the other players meant that it was better for West Ham to let him go. But if they really wanted to keep him, they could have for the duration of his contract. That doesn't mean he would have played well for the team (or even played at all), but he would have remained at the club.
      Another thing that clubs can do to keep a player under control is simply bench him for half a season. That might not have worked in Payet's specific case, but if, for example, a player wants to move to a bigger club, it could be great. After all, most big clubs would probably be less inclined to sign a player who hasn't played for half a year (or even a full year). That player might also stop getting called up to his national team for the same reason. The player would then essentially have to play well for his club because it would be the only way to get other clubs interested in signing him again. And if the player continues to refuse of fulfill his contractual obligation to his club, that might completely ruin his career (which he obviously wouldn't want).

  • @buongiornoatutti1513
    @buongiornoatutti1513 6 років тому

    BESIKTAS SENI UNUTMICAK KRAL

  • @MarcusEMunya
    @MarcusEMunya 6 років тому

    Answer: You don't.

  • @mickeytheears6259
    @mickeytheears6259 6 років тому

    Would love to share a pint with this man

  • @ShimmyWalker
    @ShimmyWalker 6 років тому +1

    what is the women saying at 15:57?

  • @fu516
    @fu516 6 років тому

    This guy is good, he should be a pundit

  • @RB26DETT_
    @RB26DETT_ 6 років тому

    bilic is a nice guy

  • @sanjamatsuri
    @sanjamatsuri 3 роки тому

    Dear Nane 😍

  • @duniamachado4669
    @duniamachado4669 6 років тому

    No play

  • @ibrahimshabir7026
    @ibrahimshabir7026 6 років тому +4

    Offer them a chocolate bar

  • @MemoryLaneCinema
    @MemoryLaneCinema 6 років тому +4

    Checking social media in half-time and players looking at themselves in the mirror during half-tme. ARE YOU NOT SUPPOSED TO TALK ABOUT THE GAME AND TACTICS DURING HALF-TIME??????

  • @akhilraaj
    @akhilraaj 6 років тому

    When he said Juventus,I was like ok but Man U ?? They’re just throwing money at everyone,why would anyone leave unless they sell them ?!

    • @lovinglifeforreaal5689
      @lovinglifeforreaal5689 6 років тому

      Akhil Raaj are you stupid? Man utd is and always will be bigger then any player. You don't like it here? Leave. Simple.

  • @Deku20235
    @Deku20235 6 років тому

    Give him more money

  • @singranguk
    @singranguk 3 роки тому

    No player is bigger then the club in Juventus . True as we can see Ronaldo been tempted and behaving like a an ordinary player

  • @baldinib1055
    @baldinib1055 6 років тому +2

    slaven look like my uncle,who is a ladies charmer.

  • @citternboy
    @citternboy 3 роки тому

    Slaven talks sense

  • @haafayn6075
    @haafayn6075 3 роки тому

    The same Bilic that forced a move from West Ham to Everton

  • @markwoods1504
    @markwoods1504 6 років тому

    MNF not the same without you Carra

  • @wtfbonkers9539
    @wtfbonkers9539 5 років тому

    slavan who

  • @flaviantropy
    @flaviantropy 6 років тому +1

    Jamie with a dig at Gary at the very end. lol

  • @DanceySteveYNWA
    @DanceySteveYNWA 6 років тому

    And all dat.

  • @walidkhan616
    @walidkhan616 6 років тому +14

    Send a bunch of local gangsters to their house. Worked for slippy G

  • @ALSDI2
    @ALSDI2 4 роки тому

    It easy to keep a player who wants to leave just threaten to sell them

  • @itsmebivin
    @itsmebivin 6 років тому

    Coutinho> Liverpool?

    • @jakovcu
      @jakovcu 6 років тому

      This is story like Sancez, Suarez,Payet,... nothing new

  • @MrCro-zo7ex
    @MrCro-zo7ex 4 роки тому

    You cant keep player if he wants to leave. Players are not slaves