@@pelzebub6664 Hey, you can resume at 1:03:59. There's an additional context clip and then leads into the fanart segment (stream 2). Though if you want to help analytics, I would certainly appreciate the rewatch. :)
I had never seen the actual ending of the Gollum game before, and the ending being a hard cut to Gollum watching two elves making out had me in actual tears of laughter. Thank you.
yknow, after watching the whole thing, I do actually like the whole idea behind the "debates" between gollum and smeagol. They don't really amount to much, mainly because Gollum is basically always just evil while smeagol is the nice option. But the ones at the end where smeagol suddenly becomes an asshole because he wants Mell all for himself, forcing gollum to argue in favour of doing the right thing, makes me feel like there was potential for something neat here.
This game feels like doing a D&D session with an uncooperative DM "I employ my friend and the bird to smuggle my way out via crate" "Um, actually they catch the crate anyway and bring you back to jail"
This is truly a shame for Germany's video game industry...Daedalic was formerly so popular here with their brilliant P'n'C games like the Deponia or he Edna series but it had to come this way. For those who want to learn further, there is a German documentary with English subtitles on Daedalic's downfall (like internal problems, financial etc.)
@@slyseal2091 Ayup, but not the original crew, I think. Not at all. "Poki" the creative lead/director who directed all 4 dropped out of the company already at 2020.
The funniest thing here, is that if Daedelic had stuck to their forte, point-and-click adventure games, I think a Gollum game could have been fine. Take that, take the "convince Smeagol/Gollum" bits which are legitimately a fine way of turning one of the most iconic aspects of the character into a gameplay component, and you could have had an okay game, especially with more resources devoted to the actual writing.
@@Elektrokardiogramm I can't believe there isn't one already. I remember an adventure game for DOS that was basically this but before the point and click interface got popular. I doubt it would be green lit these days tho, we missed that timeline.
@@robinlarin69 "Mt. Doom" is the English translation of the volcano's name in Common Speech. It's derived from its name in Sindarin (one of the Elvish languages): Amon Amarth. It's kind of like translating Pacific Ocean into "Peaceful Sea".
An actual good Gollum game would START in Moria and it would end with Gollum sneaking up on Sam and Frodo after the fellowship split. It would have to be a tracking/survival game, in that order. You would follow the trail of the fellowship, survive on your own with fish and whatever else. I also don't think a Gollum game really needs a supporting cast either. If the dialogue were treated like Hellblade: Senua's Sacrifice, then the internal dialogue of Smeagol's deranged mind while tracking the precious would be extremely compelling.
@@Arkangel630 he literally learned Old English and translated Beowulf and furthered academic insight into fantasy literature beyond what it had been for centuries. They're so far from basic that they show up a lot of contemporary writing.
Thanks for making these supercuts, they're truly the best. Also appreciate the chat reactions, its clear you put a lot of effort into these and just know it's appreciated!
This feels like an attempt to make a game with, for some reason, only the WORST parts of other games. The worst part of uncharted is the climbing, so here's uncharted climbing. The worst part of cage games is the choices that don't matter, so here's a bunch of choices that don't matter, the worst part of many games is instant-loss stealth sections, so here's a bunch of instant loss stealth sections. The worst character in all of LOTR is Gollum, so the whole damn game is about him. This is actually like someone had to make a LOTR game but had a really bad game of poker the night before, filled with "Ok, double down, either I win this hand or I have to add ______" to the game, and then he never won a single hand.
@@radioactivehalfrhyme The worst character in the novels is the first forest that the Hobbits wander into, because Tolkien thought he had to describe every single tree and brush in it like it was a pivotal main character of its own series! The Hobbits may have made it out of there, but a lot of readers sure didn't.
@@yoursonisold8743 i always feel like this is a bit overblown. yes, the story is detailed, but how often does it actually happen that there are pages of just setting the scene?
@@YARGGG_GG It's the worst in the first half of Fellowship and the Mordor sections in Return of the King. Those slow down the pace to a crawl and are not great.
the most baffling part of this game for me are the random huge timeskips it just puts in there an forces you to accept... this just... is not something you are allowed to do with a narrative platform.
Note to myself for rewatches (and perhaps useful for any other arachnophobes out there): 1:32:40 - 1:34:00 small spoders 1:45:20 - 1:51:50 *BIG* spoder
"We're at 4 hours 41 minutes, thank god!" And this is where I'm grateful you include the unedited footage time in the description because you were a sweet summer child in that moment -Though maybe that was current stream time but ya know-
4 hours, 41 minutes out of the 15+ hours from all combined streams... One joke that wasn't covered was, "after this I'm going to want to play Gravity Rush 2 and then after that I'm going to want to play more Gollum" like a perfect cycle
It must have been very difficult to make this supercut because all of Gollum is so good. It heralded a wonderful year for the video game industry of 2023, but I still believe it is GOTY by far. 👍
This was so sad, Daedalic was an icon in the German video game community. The witty writing and humor, the tackling of difficult themes was so distinctly German that will not be able to be achieved by other studios I‘m 100% certain. There will never be an Edna 3 :((
Don’t give up hope entirely. There’s a company in Japan who made a series called Rune Factory. They went bankrupt but they were then revived by another company who brought the same ppl back to continue the series. You never know what could happen.
Jan Baumann (Poki) the Lead Developer of both the Edna and Deponia Series left the Studio in 2020 to focus on his musical career, so he for example wasn't part of this mess. If he returns to game developing remains to be seen, but any serious continuation of these series without him would've probably been doomed anyway. He was the Head behind them, for example he developed Edna 1 mostly by himself and the writing of all games in those series was done largely by him.
There are a true small handful of character moments in this that are actually great, and it’s so sad to see. I genuinely laughed so much at the orc’s “What did I JUST say” when he immediately went in the feeding trough.
I REALLY really love your editing style man! Please keep making these! Like the bits where Joe talks in Golum's voice and you sync the little gif perfectly? That's so nice!
Gollum is one of the most recognizable LOTR characters, and also probably the one with the most pop culture influence, even people who know nothing of LOTR know about "my precious", and i bet that is the only thing the suits cared about
@@lithobreak3812 sure hes popular. but its hard to imagine him as the most compelling game protagonist from LOTR. its like making a star wars game from C3-PO's perspective
3:20:26 Holy shit I just noticed that they didn't model any bolt in this shot so he just fucking SUMMONS A BOLD OUT OF FUCKING NOWHERE IN THE NEXT SHOT
Thank you so much for making this, I enjoyed this much more than watching the vod :) Also appreciate the chatless version, wasn't an issue here but sometimes chat on screen really bothers me
loved the edits in this, the tony hawk grind and the fedora on Gollum's head were so seamless I thought it was part of the game lmao. glad I got to experience the game through this playthrough
I think it could have had potential, but as a completely different type of game. As an RPG that allows itself to diverge from 'canon' and explore alternate possibilities with different choices, and with the internal conflict with Sméagol/Gollum made more impactful and engaging, I'd say there could have been something really cool.
thank you mr. joe, this video auto played while i was at my dentist appointment and i knew immediately what it was after hearing crazy frog and trying not to laugh
Hey, I know it's one of his older things at this point, but would you consider making a Supercut of his Disco Elysium streams? I can't find a full one here on youtube; the only guy that started one stopped after a few streams.
From what I know 2 of the highlight channels are either working on/planning to work on the disco streams. Some thing to do with not having access to all the streams or waiting to see if Joe will play Disco Elysium Final Cut. BUT no matter what it'll happen some day. Extremely requested on these channels!
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
It's like a bad cash-grab movie tie-in game... but there's no movie!
Hi, just a small question can one just skip to where the shorter unlisted video ended? Or are there new clips sprinkled in?
@@pelzebub6664 Hey, you can resume at 1:03:59. There's an additional context clip and then leads into the fanart segment (stream 2). Though if you want to help analytics, I would certainly appreciate the rewatch. :)
Sure there’s a movie. It’s called
“Gollum Defies All Expectations | Joseph Anderson Supercut”
Thank fuck we'll never have any movies about the lord of the rings property after this disaster.
@@EE-jp5ev You sure about that? Just remember Rings of Power and anything Star Wars related.
Imagine Gollem telling Gandalf: "I spent a year training a bird to ring a bell so a fat idiot could help me escape... and I didn't even get out."
I had never seen the actual ending of the Gollum game before, and the ending being a hard cut to Gollum watching two elves making out had me in actual tears of laughter. Thank you.
Big fan of your content! Disappointed that you're still wanting to self-harm with more Gollum playthroughs. 😂
I was definitely surprised to find out not only do you like Omori but also Josepth Anderson😭🌹
Literally thought this was a shit post until I saw it myself. What even is this game?! Gollum is a cuck?
wow the man is in the joeseph ander canmd clubd
yknow, after watching the whole thing, I do actually like the whole idea behind the "debates" between gollum and smeagol.
They don't really amount to much, mainly because Gollum is basically always just evil while smeagol is the nice option. But the ones at the end where smeagol suddenly becomes an asshole because he wants Mell all for himself, forcing gollum to argue in favour of doing the right thing, makes me feel like there was potential for something neat here.
This game has everything a Gollum gamer could ever need. It even has Gollum.
Except it has Smeagol too, which is detrimental to being able to Gollum effectively.
laughed so hard I coughed, thanks fam
At times, the game might even bear resemblance to the eponymous character, a genuine Gollum experience if you will
Final rating: 4/10
And DLC.
2:49:20 Chat chanting along with the orcs every time Joe respawns is too good.
LOOK! BALLS!
LOOK BALL 🤢
LOOK
BALLS
ARGHHH
DEATH
AHHH
LUCK
BALLSS
LUCK BALLLLLLLS
LOOK
BALLS
Underrated chat message:
"He's a Psychopath who plays for money" D: "
Well, everysingle content creator from video-format to live-streamers play for money??? It is their main or side income source???
Chill out, dude. It's a reference to Persona 5, when you go to the cinema and watch a parody of Batman: The Dark Knight.
@@diamondhamster4320
its an in joke you pipit @@diamondhamster4320
@@diamondhamster4320 You are not cogniferous
@@ccasserole5267 Yes, I am just facts and logic kind of guy.
This game feels like doing a D&D session with an uncooperative DM
"I employ my friend and the bird to smuggle my way out via crate"
"Um, actually they catch the crate anyway and bring you back to jail"
with how bad this game is, comparing it to dnd is the first time I see someone do a comparison to dnd correctly
@@Tom3kkk wait I like dnd tho ;-;
@@ross719 dnd is good
@@Catterjeeo yes it is
CRYING laughing at the whole chat spamming “AAAAAAH DEATH!” “LOOK BALLS LOOK BALLS”
Lock Balls!
This is truly a shame for Germany's video game industry...Daedalic was formerly so popular here with their brilliant P'n'C games like the Deponia or he Edna series but it had to come this way. For those who want to learn further, there is a German documentary with English subtitles on Daedalic's downfall (like internal problems, financial etc.)
Interesting! Thanks for the advice
@@nerdError0XF Huh, wrote you a response but UA-cam apparently doesnt like me :/
ain't no way the deponia people wrote this
@@slyseal2091 Ayup, but not the original crew, I think. Not at all. "Poki" the creative lead/director who directed all 4 dropped out of the company already at 2020.
@totallyrat424 yep, it happens sometimes even when you arent using any bad words. Happened to me multiple times recently, weird
Died laughing when Gollum did a perfect grind on that rail.
**Tony Hawk's Pro Skater Trick SFX**
@kjj4478 i actually heard it in my head now i am cackling on the toilet thanks.
Welcome back, pilot.
The funniest thing here, is that if Daedelic had stuck to their forte, point-and-click adventure games, I think a Gollum game could have been fine. Take that, take the "convince Smeagol/Gollum" bits which are legitimately a fine way of turning one of the most iconic aspects of the character into a gameplay component, and you could have had an okay game, especially with more resources devoted to the actual writing.
Point-and-click adventure and LotR sound like they'd go perfectly together.
But would a point-and-click game ever get the go-ahead/afford LotR licensing?
@@Elektrokardiogramm I can't believe there isn't one already. I remember an adventure game for DOS that was basically this but before the point and click interface got popular. I doubt it would be green lit these days tho, we missed that timeline.
"LOTR isn't high brow, the mountain is called Mt. Doom" is the funniest thing I've ever heard
Tbf thats what peasants call it, it does have a serious name too. Right?
Truly a Joe-type take.
@@robinlarin69Orodruin.
@@poudink5791 "joe-type take"? a "joe-take" perhaps? a "joke" if you will!
@@robinlarin69 "Mt. Doom" is the English translation of the volcano's name in Common Speech. It's derived from its name in Sindarin (one of the Elvish languages): Amon Amarth.
It's kind of like translating Pacific Ocean into "Peaceful Sea".
"How is this game more impervious to breakage than uh... oh we did it!" sums up most of this experience to be honest.
Gollum murmuring "biiiirddd" while jumping into oblivion is something I didn’t know I needed, thank you.
1:53:11 Changing the Gollum voice counter to 11037 when he says "previousLY ON prison break", sneaky.
31:00 this edit was INCREDIBLE
i legit died when i noticed it
45:20 That's actually a really nice attention to detail that I would never expect from a game in this state.
Chat during the AHHH DEATH LOOK BALLS part was killing me
An actual good Gollum game would START in Moria and it would end with Gollum sneaking up on Sam and Frodo after the fellowship split. It would have to be a tracking/survival game, in that order. You would follow the trail of the fellowship, survive on your own with fish and whatever else. I also don't think a Gollum game really needs a supporting cast either. If the dialogue were treated like Hellblade: Senua's Sacrifice, then the internal dialogue of Smeagol's deranged mind while tracking the precious would be extremely compelling.
I watched this while going through all the process of resetting my windows laptop so I didn't feel alone in my excruciating journey
I was in absolute hysterics after the part that starts at 2:47:46 when chat starts spamming "ARRGGGGH, DEATH, LOOK BALLS"
Genuinely killed me
In defense of both the Hobbit and LOTR books they seem basic because they are literally used as the baseline for all modern western fantasy stories.
Anyone who calls them basic shows they haven't read them and its insanely funny every time
@@Arkangel630Why read the books when you can play the LotR PS2 games? It's basically the same thing. Certified nerd emoji moment.
@@Arkangel630 he literally learned Old English and translated Beowulf and furthered academic insight into fantasy literature beyond what it had been for centuries. They're so far from basic that they show up a lot of contemporary writing.
Yeah lotr has probably influenced joes own fantasy writing and he doesn’t even realize
Thanks for making these supercuts, they're truly the best. Also appreciate the chat reactions, its clear you put a lot of effort into these and just know it's appreciated!
Look! Balls! Look! Balls! Look! Balls!
This feels like an attempt to make a game with, for some reason, only the WORST parts of other games. The worst part of uncharted is the climbing, so here's uncharted climbing. The worst part of cage games is the choices that don't matter, so here's a bunch of choices that don't matter, the worst part of many games is instant-loss stealth sections, so here's a bunch of instant loss stealth sections. The worst character in all of LOTR is Gollum, so the whole damn game is about him. This is actually like someone had to make a LOTR game but had a really bad game of poker the night before, filled with "Ok, double down, either I win this hand or I have to add ______" to the game, and then he never won a single hand.
The worst character in all of LOTR is Gollum??? I have some extremely tedious singing elves from the early chapters of Fellowship to introduce to you.
@@radioactivehalfrhyme The worst character in the novels is the first forest that the Hobbits wander into, because Tolkien thought he had to describe every single tree and brush in it like it was a pivotal main character of its own series! The Hobbits may have made it out of there, but a lot of readers sure didn't.
@@yoursonisold8743LMAO
@@yoursonisold8743 i always feel like this is a bit overblown. yes, the story is detailed, but how often does it actually happen that there are pages of just setting the scene?
@@YARGGG_GG It's the worst in the first half of Fellowship and the Mordor sections in Return of the King. Those slow down the pace to a crawl and are not great.
i LOVE these supercuts!!!! please keep making them!!!
the most baffling part of this game for me are the random huge timeskips it just puts in there an forces you to accept... this just... is not something you are allowed to do with a narrative platform.
chat just chanting "DEAAAATHHH, LOOK BALLS, LOOK BALLS" at every reset in the chapter 10 stealth section KILLED ME
"Doctor lingard"
a milestone moment in the jph timeline
This game has the most hilarious falling deaths I’ve ever seen.
I really appreciate the addition of hello neighbor chase music during the first chase. You’re doing gods work
“The Lord of the Rings is generic fantasy” - guy who wrote a book titled “The Wizard and the Dragon”
Legends say that if you beat the game fast enough, you get a letter in the mail that contains the ring, and you get to become gollum.
I feel like playing this for ten hours has the same effect.
Nagito Gollum nearly made me cry laughing I can’t fucking believe this
just watched the whole thing, great video!
how did you watch a 3h video that got released 45 minutes ago? 😅
@@CayoCosta123 very quickly....
@@noarmsnolife6665 Congratulations! You are now the Number 1 youtube speedrunner! You are also the only one...I think...
Note to myself for rewatches (and perhaps useful for any other arachnophobes out there):
1:32:40 - 1:34:00 small spoders
1:45:20 - 1:51:50 *BIG* spoder
🕷
get well soon 🕷🕷🕷🕷🕷🕷🕷
I've been looking so forward to this supercut. From the bottom of my heart- thank you.
"It gets worse"
Joseph- I dont believe you
*Words before disaster*
"We're at 4 hours 41 minutes, thank god!" And this is where I'm grateful you include the unedited footage time in the description because you were a sweet summer child in that moment
-Though maybe that was current stream time but ya know-
4 hours, 41 minutes out of the 15+ hours from all combined streams...
One joke that wasn't covered was, "after this I'm going to want to play Gravity Rush 2 and then after that I'm going to want to play more Gollum" like a perfect cycle
This was amazing, I nearly fell out of my chair when Sae said Joseph Anderson, top notch editing.
Joe: wait, this section is pretty good!
This game: hold my stinking maggoty bread
It must have been very difficult to make this supercut because all of Gollum is so good. It heralded a wonderful year for the video game industry of 2023, but I still believe it is GOTY by far. 👍
The most surprising thing to me is that Siri gave a useful answer to such a specific question.
This was so sad, Daedalic was an icon in the German video game community. The witty writing and humor, the tackling of difficult themes was so distinctly German that will not be able to be achieved by other studios I‘m 100% certain. There will never be an Edna 3 :((
Don’t give up hope entirely.
There’s a company in Japan who made a series called Rune Factory. They went bankrupt but they were then revived by another company who brought the same ppl back to continue the series. You never know what could happen.
Jan Baumann (Poki) the Lead Developer of both the Edna and Deponia Series left the Studio in 2020 to focus on his musical career, so he for example wasn't part of this mess.
If he returns to game developing remains to be seen, but any serious continuation of these series without him would've probably been doomed anyway. He was the Head behind them, for example he developed Edna 1 mostly by himself and the writing of all games in those series was done largely by him.
Thank you so much for this. Suffering through all of this must have been a pain in the ass, but I laughed my ass off regularly at the video.
“You’re a psychopath who games for money!”
Lmao
“Previous Leon” absolutely killed me, incredible
Hey I just wanted to say thank you for making these fun supercuts! Your edits with the golem-voice-face and the rings count was really hilarious
1:53:07
Beautiful joke. The secret reveal of the true mastermind behind Gollem is lovely for viewers paying attention.
10 chapters and 3 hours of pure suffering. Thank you so much
The Tony Hawk sound at 31:00 had me in tears! 😂😂
ok adding the hello neighbor chase sound effects among other things was funny ty for this good supercut
Thank you as always for the supercut avarisi O7
Bro this game need to be modded to hell, with mountain doom flowing with green sugary goodness.
There are a true small handful of character moments in this that are actually great, and it’s so sad to see. I genuinely laughed so much at the orc’s “What did I JUST say” when he immediately went in the feeding trough.
yeah i literally died when gollum said "my precious" 😂😂😂
I’ve never clicked on a notification so fast, thank you so much!
Took me way to long to realize Hell Enabler was actually Hello Neighbor
+2
I REALLY really love your editing style man! Please keep making these! Like the bits where Joe talks in Golum's voice and you sync the little gif perfectly? That's so nice!
was a gollum game ever in demand, from like anyone
who is this for
Gollum is one of the most recognizable LOTR characters, and also probably the one with the most pop culture influence, even people who know nothing of LOTR know about "my precious", and i bet that is the only thing the suits cared about
I am a Gollum enjoyer, very Gollumcore experience.
@@lithobreak3812 sure hes popular. but its hard to imagine him as the most compelling game protagonist from LOTR. its like making a star wars game from C3-PO's perspective
Watching this made me want to play buy and play Styx. Maybe that counts for something.
What a great start to the Gollum trilogy.
cant wait for the before the storm style chapter in between entries 🔥🔥🔥
31:03 dude lol - that gd TH stinger followed by the sigh….. PRICELESS 😂
Thank you so much for everything you do
3:20:26
Holy shit I just noticed that they didn't model any bolt in this shot so he just fucking SUMMONS A BOLD OUT OF FUCKING NOWHERE IN THE NEXT SHOT
I love when he reads reviews and just says "Is it?" in an exasperated tone after every positive comment lol
I mean, I would as well.
damn, hello neighbour left an impression if like 3 years later it's still so vividly remembered as such a bad stream
This video has already broken me and I'm 4 minutes in I'm sobbing laughing
thank you for making these videos, they make my day
Seriously thank you for doing these.
Remember: Joe said that this game was better than 12 Minutes.
In a sense.. one gets a lot more enjoyment and fun out of this than from that incest mess of a brainfart..
Love these stream highlights. Thanks for the content.
Bruh of course this releases right after I finish the entire first vod lol. oh well, thanks for these avarisi
I like how the game has about 6 instances of quest logic and they still break half the time
This game really is the goty... gollum of the year :)
Thank you so much for making this, I enjoyed this much more than watching the vod :)
Also appreciate the chatless version, wasn't an issue here but sometimes chat on screen really bothers me
This is the first video of yours I have seen, pretty great
loved the edits in this, the tony hawk grind and the fedora on Gollum's head were so seamless I thought it was part of the game lmao. glad I got to experience the game through this playthrough
I’m convinced that gollum turned off joes mic so he didn’t have to listen to crazy frog anymore
Incredible editing. You're amazing
Minecraft mods are more faithful and accurate to the LotR lore then an officially licensed LotR game... What a time to be alive
8:00 Streamer-specific features! Soon the game will be sending a fucking DMCA for streaming it!
The deadly premonition music, just A+
Little did Joseph know, that the secret cheat code to this game was in fact alt+F4
Holy shit how is this so good. 5 minutes in and im already dying
I love how the frail old mans beard points up everytime his speaking animation starts
LOTR Gollum, aka Crazy Frog's Prison Sim
This channel is a treasure
LETS GOOOOOOOOO
CRAZY FROGGGGGG
my god this is a trainwreck, i love trainwrecks but sadly noone has done a supercut of the other live is strange games yet
It's so well edited
Way too dank. Could have been a gory, dark humour and cool B-tier stealth game like Styx Duology games but instead it is just this.
I think it could have had potential, but as a completely different type of game.
As an RPG that allows itself to diverge from 'canon' and explore alternate possibilities with different choices, and with the internal conflict with Sméagol/Gollum made more impactful and engaging, I'd say there could have been something really cool.
Great supercut for a messy game. I especially liked the Golem Joe animation
thank you mr. joe, this video auto played while i was at my dentist appointment and i knew immediately what it was after hearing crazy frog and trying not to laugh
See I could watch Killers of the Flower Moon. Oooooorrrrrrrrrrr
The Gollum Pro Skater moment killed me xD
1:45:12 to be fair, falling down stairs is better than life is strange 2.
Hey, I know it's one of his older things at this point, but would you consider making a Supercut of his Disco Elysium streams? I can't find a full one here on youtube; the only guy that started one stopped after a few streams.
From what I know 2 of the highlight channels are either working on/planning to work on the disco streams. Some thing to do with not having access to all the streams or waiting to see if Joe will play Disco Elysium Final Cut. BUT no matter what it'll happen some day. Extremely requested on these channels!
i love it when a voice line appears multiple times and chat starts repeating it
incredible, simply watching Gollum gameplay caused my computer to glitch out