What I liked about this video is he got right to the point of the differences, and spoke in a clear understandable voice. He also did a short demonstration of how they both work. Great video! 👍
I bought the TH Platform and love it. I had looked at the Misti and didn’t like the look of it - it looked flimsy and cheap, and when I saw the price, I said to myself, “forget it.” I know a lot of people swear by the Misti but I think the TH one is better all round - robust, reasonably priced, easy to use, and it looks much nicer! This is a good review.
Bought my first stamping platform today. Amazon Prime £23.60 Tim Holtz Stamping platform. I researched all the others and for me the Tim Holtz was decently priced and it had the best stamping area in my opinion. Thanks for doing this video. So glad I made the right choice. Happy crafting everyone.
I do have a Tim Holtz version. Love it. I never even looked at the Misti....over priced for one. Two....I dont buy from people claiming to be Christian, throwing it out there to get business then turning around and being so very rude and hateful to people via social media, etc. Being a Christian shouldn't need to be said, people should see it in your actions and how you treat others.
Thanks so much for your comparison video of these two products. I’m just getting back into stamping and had no idea which one would be better? I agree that the Tim Holt’s stamp platform is more practical and definitely more price friendly. Your video was very helpful!
Thank you for the information and not having unnecessary conversation while doing your demonstrations. I am glad I came across this demonstration. I was about to buy the Misti stamper,but the price was too much for my budget so I was holding off for a sale. I will be purchasing the Tim Holtz thanks to this video.
Happened by your video. Great review. I knew nothing of either products so the video was very interesting. Thanks for sharing. I have one question for anyone - would the TH Platform work with rubber stamps on wood? Of course, take the stamp off the wood.
Edit: I misunderstood and thought you wanted to stamp on wood. If you carefully remove the stamp from the wood base, yes, it should work just fine. There are products out there to help convert wood base stamps to just rubber cling stamps. My original reply: If the wood is thin (very) then yes. I used it to stamp a small sentiment on a small - and thin - wood embellishment. I used the "rubber" side of the platform lid. I also used a small glue dot to hold the embellishment in place on the platform, then rubbed it off when I was done.
For some reason, I am having problem with stamping completely, I have restamped the part that didn’t stamp out but still didn’t still stamp out completely- also used versamark. Any ideas. I own the Tim Holtz platform. Thank you🥰
Make sure your stamp platform is on the correct side. I know sometimes when I don’t have it placed on the right side of the door it won’t stamp evenly. Also if there’s an air bubble trapped underneath the stamp that can sometimes affect the quality of stamping as well.
I think it's a shame that My Sweet Petunia has been able to get away with claiming that the MISTI is an original invention. Although printing presses have been around for centuries, a man named J.B. Lieberman is the one who actually invented the personal printing press (which is essentially what a MISTI is) and called it the Herity Press. J.B. Lieberman was actually such a purveyor of personal printing that he wrote a book about printing as a hobby, and even had a printing club. He even went so far as to have his personal printing press patented, and you can still view the patent (along with J.B.'s detailed diagrams of the press, so you can see how obviously similar the MISTI is to it) on Google's patent database. Iliana, a.k.a. My Sweet Petunia, has basically stolen his invention and claimed it as her own, and then was able to get a court (who is undoubtedly ignorant of the original invention) to support her claim. All of this in addition to her reputation regarding her unprofessional treatment of customers in the past, which I will not delve into right now. Long story long, I will never buy anything from her.
Totally agree Alegra! That woman is a real piece of work. My blood boils every time I see a craft influencer go on and on about this "fantastic" invention. The fact that she then tries to pass herself off as a christian gives me an additional bad taste in my mouth.
i think what is remarkable about the fact is that sweet petunia brought back a good invention and modernizied to get into the world of crafts, and i enjoyed it every time i use it. that`s what is good about it, and above all that is a wonderful tool. Instead of worrying who invented it, why don`t people invent or re - invent other tools we may use as well.....
Allegra, I totally agree with you! There are other companies like Stampin’ Up! that have also made stamping tools similar to Tim Holtz and the Misti!! I don’t understand why sweet petunia isn’t suing Stampin’ Up too?! LOL 😂 I think that the owner of The Misti is upset because Tim Holtz’s price is so much more affordable, bigger and better than what she “invented”!!! It’s ridiculous, everyone in this industry and others come up with similar stamps, inks ect. Tim Holtz rocks, he has a great personality, and has come up with such amazing products! 💗👍🏼 Like they all say, “karma’s a bitch!” What goes around comes around! Thanks for the info, I had no idea about the original inventor?! PS This just goes to show you how much class Tim Holtz actually has! Maybe that’s why he’s so much more successful than she’ll ever be!😊💗👍🏼
I know this is an older video, but seriously, your video was exactly what I needed to see. Your comparison was precise, to the point, and showed everything I was curious about. Thank you!!❤😊😊
Thanks for this video! I saw the Misti in a video some months back and wanted one but the price.....!!!! So I found an online video that shared how to use an IKEA frame to do a stamping tool yourself. So I made one ( I am Swedish after all;-)!) and have really liked using it. The cost came down to around ten dollars. The problem, as with the Misti comes when I want to stamp on larger papers. So I will definitely go for a TH platform now thanks to your clear and good review!
Thank you so much for posting this review!! I had been wanting a MISTI stamp platform for a while, and then saw the difference in the prices of each one. I just received my Tonic Tim Holtz platform, and I haven't had a chance to use it yet. I'm so glad; it looks like I made the right choice!
It would take some being creative. You would need to fold the rest of the journal back so that one one page goes underneath the door. You would not be able to put the full journal under the door and have it close all the way. I hope that helps answer your question.
@@OffKilterCrafterIan It is so pity! Tim Holtz could have been created something for the journals! I love stamping on it! Thank you for answering me ;)
@@canadaverydry It really would depend on the size of the journal. If you can get it under the lid without trouble and in a position it accordingly, it would work. A thick or hardcover journal would not. So, using a cahier/pocket or thin, flexible journal should work.
When I first saw the MISTI online, I had no prior information to affect my opinion of the tool. My first thought was that it was a great idea, but then I saw the price. I believed that it was grossly overpriced for a plastic tool and refused to buy it. Then the TH one came out! In my opinion, his design is superior, and his price point is what I would expect for a tool with that size and spcification. I bought his and love it!
Great review. I have always held off from buying a MISTI due to the exorbitant price, so I was so happy when I started to see reviews for the Tonic platform. I bought one last week and I love it! :)
Thank you Ian, I am a brand new subscriber to your channel, but For what I have seen so far I am going to be here quite often. Great job on the comparison.
Useful video, thanks, even though I ordered the TH stamping tool last week from Amazon and it’s coming from the UK, it’s good to see a video reinforcing my belief that I made the right choice. My TH stamping tool is arriving this week and I can’t wait. I’m terrible at stamping with acrylic blocks. I’ve dropped them too many times on to my ink blended backgrounds with an inked stamp attached, and ruined the background, or the image or sentiment I stamped was incomplete and I find it impossible to restamp an image with acrylic blocks. On principle I refused to buy a Misti because the company sued competitors, and the ridiculous price point also put me off. Two pieces of plastic with a hinge for almost twice the price of a TH platform, is absurd. Anyway, no more stamping errors for me!
Hi Ian! I just got my TH Stamp Platform, and have been playing with it today....I LOVE IT!!!! OH.MY.GOODNESS!!! IT. IS. AWESOME! I cannot say enough good things about it. The quality of Tim Holtz products, at HALF the price....(that just makes me sad) is second to none!
Am laughing at the sour reviews from Misti users not that I blame them since for the price of their 1 Misti they could get 2 Tonic/Tim Holtz platforms, oh BUT they'd buy the Tonic/Tim Holtz one if it was carried in a store with 40% off coupon. You know they never got their Misti for 40% off!!! I thought the Misti was clever but their price point was way too high for what it does plus I had the WRMK letterbox press that could do similar task but took up a lot of space. I've seen the Tonic/Tim Holtz one as low as $31.99 - skip a few fast food meals one month or Starbucks coffees and you can afford that. My health thanks me for skipping the fast food and my craftroom likes the new Tonic/Tim Holtz stamping platform.
Do I dare tell you that until today when I stumbled on your video...I had NO CLUE I could use rubber stamps in my Tim H platform. Seriously...you made my day!!
You have convinced me! It’s definitely the Tim Holtz and your video explains a lot which I would never have thought about! It is now a ‘must have’ instead of a ‘ what on earth do you do with this?’ Thank you so much for your great video! Cheers Donna.
Thank you for the comparison, it confirmed what I thought. I have the misti but loved the idea that you can stamp larger cards or background stamps with TH Stamp Platform. Also the two flat edges are perfect for ease of stamping larger sheets of card etc. Husband buying me a TH Stamp Platform for my birthday this week 😜
I loved this! Thank you! I was wanting a Misti for over a year, since seeing it on Jennifer McGuires channel. However, when Joann Fabrics was having their spring sale a month ago, the Tim Holtz stamp platform was about 35% off so I bought that instead. I'm so glad I did! It's a much better tool by far, after seeing the Misti up close in your video. I didn't realize the acrylic top on the Misti was so flimzy! Wow! I'm really happy with my choice now! Thank you!
Thanks again Ian. Yes! Totally gonna love it and you can’t beat the price! I paid only $24. Heck ya! I did a Joann’s online haul. Got carried away. LOL can’t wait! Do you have a review on ink pads (dye, pigmented, and hybrid ink pads)? I was just going to order one from each company. (Stampin up, Simon Says, Hero Arts, Gina K, My Fav. Things, and so on) to try them all out. I want them all!!!! LOL.
Ian!.. Loved Your Demonstration!! & Comparison!! I have Not.. as Ayer.. bought either!.. Didn’t realize I needed one!! But! Lo & Behild!.. I DO!! Will go with the TH!! Thanks Again!! GBU!❤️
I would have purchased a MISTI but over here in Australia the price is ridiculous. After seeing my friend's Tim Holtz Stamp Platform I decided to go with it instead. I even managed to buy it when it was reduced in price and with no shipping charges. Yay! This is great comparison vid and the Tim Holtz one looks sturdier. So glad I didn't splurge on the MISTI. Oh and I have just subscribed and given this vid a thumbs up.
I'm really glad that I came across this video. I saw a video quite a while ago (probably on Tim's channel) showing his platform). I'm new to stamping and had never seen such a device and was amazed by the ingenuity, but I didn't really feel a need for it until very recently. And the most recent stamping videos I've watched show the Misti (which I had never heard of, being familiar only with Tim's version). Well, crafter after crafter seemed to be using the Misti, which made me wonder if it was superior to Tim's. Thank you so much for this comparison, I'll be purchasing one of Tim's platforms. 👍🏻😁
I waited for someone to come up with a platform that was less expensive than the MISTI, and was thrilled when Tim came out with his, as I could tell, it was not only cheaper but better made, and it could easily hold larger paper. Thanks for your comparison. I love. my TH Platform!
I just found your video on the Tim Holtz Platform. I have a mini Misti. I don't mind telling you as soon as I can afford it, I'll be buying a Platform. I like everything about The Platform. I have to agree with all the comments I've read on this video. I think Tim Holtz took the time to really think about what a crafter could and couldn't use. He's a crafter also and I really think this makes for a better product. Thanks for sharing with us. I subscribe today! Thanks for being there!
I just order the TH traveler stamp platform and can't wait for it to get here! As I was looking for a stamp platform, I came across the misti and I wear my heart skipped a beat at the price! Never will I ever pay that much for a stamp aid! Id rather spend the money on art and craft supplies where i get more bang for my buck! Seeing that Tim and Tonic came out with their own design (which looks more professional) I was so happy and could wait to get it! Things came up and I couldn't get it right away and now hearing that it's being discontinued I jumped on it paying $25.00 on the Wal-Mart app. I don't see how people have issues with stamping with TH unless their stamp is too close to the raised edges or too close to the magnets. I dont like stamping on foam unless im stamping in my art journal which I have an old mouse pad for that reason. Seeing how raised all 3 edges of the misti are would bother the check out of me because I can see the paper bending and wrinkling like you had happen and also since the paper isn't flat all around, makes it seem easier to hit and mess up plus are you really going to get a 2nd press correctly with the paper bending like that? I don't think so. Also just by looking at the misti it looks like a diy picture frame one with the 3 rulers looking like they're pieced together instead of one piece, the stamping glass looks really cheap and if hit on a soft spot could cause it to crack or break into pieces even. I just think for $80 probably plus shipping it should look totally more professional made and not have all 3 sides raised so much. Now comes to the fact that i don't understand how misti can sue TH and Tonic as they are 2 completely different designs but just serve the same purpose. To me that's like Velveeta suing Kraft. 2 different recipes but they're both mac n cheese. To me that's beyond petty and THE MAJOR reason im so glad I didn't get a cheaper smaller sized misti.
This was a great video. Thank you so much for the comparison of these two products. I have the original misti and was quite excited about it when it first debuted. My enthusiasm has since waned..quite a bit. My cover has cracked quite badly. Sometimes I think the only thing holding it together is the protective vinyl sheet. Which I had a very hard time positioning. I have now been looking for the Tim Holtz stamp platform and only recently found that it is almost impossible to find. So sad. Wish I had bought one when they first came out. Thanks again for a very well done video.
Great comparison/review, Ian! I currently own the MISTI you used in the demo and love it. I'm very tempted by the new TH Platform and will most likely add that to my tool arsenal in the future especially for my larger projects. I'll keep my Misti for traveling and for my smaller projects. I also like the foam piece in the Misti for the clear stamps as it helps create a clean image with the first stamp so I think I would miss that in the TH Platform. The only thing I would add to your review is that if you have never used a stamping platform, you really need to get one. It will change the quality of your work for the better. It also makes creating layered stamp images so easy. I have actually stored away most of my stamp blocks in favor of my Misti. Thanks for the great review. I always enjoy your videos and find them very helpful.
Leslie, you should check out Hedghog Hollow's review on the TH Platform. She added a thin piece of Fun Foam to fix the problem you spoke of regarding the clear stamps. She had some other good ideas you might be interested in.
I love it, just got it yesterday. Order it from Walmart, price $29.99. Now that is a great price.Scrapbooking-Warehouse has it 26.49, did not see that in time. Love the entire design.
I have a large Misti, but I'm looking for something a bit smaller and more convenient for more general use. I'm sold on the Tim Holtz Stamp Platform. Tonic Engineering does it again. Your demonstration and comparison were super helpful. Thanks.
I've been using the Tim Holtz for a couple weeks, and have a couple points to add: 1) if you are using a big ink pad, the lip on the lid gets in the way and is a little messy, 2) I don't think photopolymer stamps stamp as well on the Tim Holtz-- seems to give some uneven coverage vs. the misti with the foam pad. My verdict-- I like both for diff. Reasons, but am not ready to trash my misti!
As demonstrated in a UA-cam video for the Tim Holtz Stamp Platform, if you are having trouble stamping clear stamps with the Tonic Stamp Platform, buy a 2 mm thick 9" x 12" or 12" x 18" (not sure of the dimensions on the double size foam) at Michaels or Joann's for 89 cents or 99 cents, respectively. Don't buy thicker foam for obvious reasons (surprising that a stamper can't figure that out) or your cardstock will "slip" off of the foam! You can then place the 2 mm foam onto the Tim Holtz Stamp Platform to stamp clear cling stamps if that's your preference. But as several UA-cam videos for the Tim Holtz Stamp Platform demonstrate, many stampers do stamp clear cling stamps with no problem. I haven't had a problem so far on the hard surface. But I did buy black foam at both Michaels and Joann's to see if they work with the Tim Holtz Stamp Platform after reading that a stamper's cardstock "slipped" off of the foam. There's no problem as long as you buy the 2 mm foam. Myself, I prefer stamping clear stamps without the foam on my Tim Holtz Stamp Platform and have gotten great results. I prefer stamping big background stamps with the Tim Holtz Stamp Platform vs stamping them with my MISTI because the solid sturdy Tim Holtz lid seems to produce a more solid image than that done with the MISTI. I think it's because the weight of the Tim Holtz lid helps in stamping/applying pressure to a large image. The MISTI lid is very light weight; so, it seems that I have to press more firmly and more times when stamping large background images using my MISTI. I especially like that the Tim Holtz Stamp Platform lid is detachable as I take my lid with stamps to the sink to wash off/clean my stamps and lid. I find that I spend more time cleaning my MISTI and don't use the 2 Novus acrylic cleaners that I bought when I got my MISTI because of the toxic warnings on both bottles. I also especially like the *lower* price and higher quality of the Tim Holtz Stamp Platform!
Great comparison. I have the Hampton Arts version and love it. I have seen a couple people mention tbat with clear photo polymer stamps, not all areas stamp well... have ypu tried this? If you have, would like your answer on how it does. Thanks
I am SO glad you did this comparison. I agree with you that the Tim Holtz and Tonic Stamping Tool is a better value than MISTI. I have used the MISTI since it has been available. I tried to stamp a piece of 12 x12 cardstock with a cling stamp and the lid of my MISTI cracked with the CPR method of trying to get a good image. Also, my card stock wrinkled. I realize there is a bigger MISTI for the larger card stock, but I didn't expect the lid to crack with light pressure. Thank you for showing us this comparison. I know what my next crafting purchase will be.
I just purchased this item last week and didn’t notice you had to switch the plate when it comes to rubber stamps and clear stamps. Thought I got a defective one. Thanks for explaining. Lol will give it a try again.
I bought the original MISTI and waited until inventory met demand to get it. There were no magnets or grid papers included then. I don't mind the protective sheet I keep on the lid when I store it, and I bought the recommended cleaning product (I found it and magnets for a better price elsewhere) to preserve the etching on the lid. My only gripe has been a fear of cracking the hinges because the lid doesn't lie flat on the table when open and inking my stamp. Cure: a few sheets of fun foam and all is well. IF my MISTI ever breaks I will probably replace it with the TH platform, but I am sticking with my MISTI until or if that happens. Thanks for a great comparison!
+Susan Dickson I totally agree if you have one already, use it until you wear it out. For those looking to get one the Tim Holtz one is the best one to go with in my opinion. Great idea about using the fun foam!
Great review and comparison Ian. I refused to pay the outrageous price for the MISTI. I purchased the We R platform from HSN very cheaply before the legal issues and before I heard about the Tonic Tim Holtz platform. Even though the We R doesn't have a magnetic base, it's been great. However, if I ever have issues with it not being magnetic, I will definitely buy this one. In my opinion, they are both much better than the MISTI. TFS! ❤️
you can magnetise your We R platform too - Google it. Having said that - I just bought the Tim Holtz stamping Platform - because I didn't have any at all - except the Stampin Up Stampamajig - which I used a fair bit :) ua-cam.com/video/fmo242-MoN0/v-deo.html
Thank you for your time doing this video. I decided on the Tonic. I will give a shout out to office supply they had the best price for the Tonic even with the shipping and handling. Hope this helps if you are looking to save some money.
I have both and I use the mist you the most, mostly because I almost had to stand on the TH platform with a bigger stamp. I have often wondered if my particular platform has a problem and shouldn’t be that way. Thanks for the great comparison.
Great video Ian and thank you. I’ve had my Tim Holtz platform for some time now and love it. I’ve been thinking of getting the Misti, but after seeing your video I believe I will pass on that purchase. From the first time using my TH, I’ve loved it. New stubbie here.
I just got my platform yesterday, and I've not had a chance to play with it yet. I do have the original MISTI, and I have to say that at just my own first look of the platform that it really makes me feel like it is STURDY. I REALLY like that this doesn't have that stupid plastic covering over the grid, and yes, I recognize that the current MISTI's don't have it, it still is an annoyance every time I touch the lid; my fingers don't like that texture at all. I have always had great performance with my MISTI, and have no complaints about that at all. So, for me, it comes down to the design of the actual tool. I like that I don't have to have a "Memory" version to stamp on 12 x 12 papers. The design is actually so well thought out. If you look at the rulers on the sides of the original MISTI, there's an extra tick or two between a couple of the numbers on the ruler. Obviously I am not a freak about being exact or that would drive me crazy. I have a second MISTI that I got when my first MISTI started cracking on the edges and hinges, and I have just set that aside for use when the first one actually did bite the dust. So, what am I going to do? I'm going to reach for the Tim Holtz platform as my first choice of a tool. I am going to keep my MISTI in use when doing assembly line type of stamping, and my 2nd MISTI that I can use with Tack n' Peel for all those unmounted stamps that I've wanted to use, but haven't mounted yet. I also have a cheap-o DVD case that I keep set up with the stamps that I use on the backs of cards that I make, and that will continue to be at my fingertips. But when it comes down to nuts and bolts, I am glad to put my new TH stamping platform into the work-horse position, and as the MISTI's begin to crumble and break they will just go into the trash and I'll chalk that purchase up to a lesson well learned. I am also glad to support a product made by a leader in the industry and someone who hasn't gone crazy threatening to sue people for making their own versions of the tool.
I could not agree more! I am so impressed with how steady the Tim Holtz Stamp Platform feels. I feel like I could stand on it and it won't break. That of course is not true, but all kidding aside it really does feel like I can put some heavy pressure on it and it is not going to break. Thanks for taking the time to watch my review and share your thoughts with me.
Well said. I honestly regret giving the creator of MISTI any money because of her less than professional behavior even when she was shipping out defective product. Glad to see there are better alternatives now.
I tend to stamp on things, much thicker than paper. I didn't stand on it, but I did kneel on it, as I was stamping on corrugated cardboard. . Of course I didn't put all of my weight on it, but the platform was fine afterwards!! This would depend on a persons weight of course, and I am sure Tonic and TH do not advise doing this, but I was willing to chance it!! Lol!
Nice tutorial Ian, thank you. This makes me sad that Tim's stamping platform is now so hard to find. I found it on Amazon for $57, with free shipping, but as of 12/20/19 there are only 5 in stock. Guess who's gettin that for christmas!!
Hi I’m a new subbie, when the Misti come out, I so so wanted it, but the price was way beyond my means, so I started to save. Then something else come up and I had to use the money I had. (Just thought I’d say I’m not a kid I’m almost 60 and been crafting since I was 3) so house and family have to come before crafting. But I could still stamp the old way so I could wait........then the Tim Holtz come out, as soon as I saw it I knew it was for me, so I changed from the Misti in my mind! A wee while later I was looking at a craft magazine, they were offering the Tim Holtz one as a gift for subscribing to the magazine, well I’m disabled and can’t always get out to get my fav mag, so was looking for the best deal in the mags I like (I like them all lol) so this was manna from heaven.......so I got my Tim Holtz AND my fav mag that I pay for each quarter, so what could be better.......nothing, I love it, I’d fight to keep it if I had to lol, now I’m looking at all his stuff, they are such great value, I think that is because he is a crafter and a normal guy who loves what he does and loves to share, he gets out there showing what he has, not like a lot of others hiding behind the name of a company. So I think you could say, this oldie is a Tim Holtz fan!!! I watched this because I find it interesting the comparison videos, and also male crafters, we need more of them on the tube, they have different ideas a lot of the time.....so I’m off to see what else you have done, I know this was last year so am hoping there is some goodies to watch! Huggles xxxAnnxxx in Uk 🇬🇧 .
Ann thank you so much for the wonderful words about this video. I really do hope you enjoy my other videos and please comment on my videos letting me know what you thought or if you have any questions. So glad to hear you got the Tim Holtz's stamp platform and I so happy to hear you love it. I use mine SO much!
Hi Ian, I have the middle size Misti, I got the Tim Holtz platform as a free gift in the UK, I love it, I like that it feels more robust. I've not had any problems with ink staining, I reach for it before my Misti which I loved but it always felt like I might break it ( I'm 6ft tall with big hands) lol. Ps loving the Dr who Tshirt. X
Totally agree Ian- I have both and you are right on the mark with the comparisons! I just found your channel and subscribed and gave your comparison video a thumbs up. I think they are both great tools and am not going to get involved in all the fighting between the lovers of both. But if I had to choose only one or had not bought one yet, I would recommend the Tim Holtz Tonic Studio Stamp Platform and I used it on a video I posted today (which is why UA-cam recommended your video to me:)
Looking to buy thus comparing. I do like that the Misti 'lid' opens up like a book. Just seems easier for transferring ink. I agree the difference in cost is a little ridiculous.
Thank you for your video. I was torn between the MISTI and the Tim Holtz stamping platforms. I will purchase the Tim Holtz stamping platform as it meets my needs better.
Thanks for this great review! I'm wondering about sampling on a hard surface in the TH Platform, where we stamp on foam in MISTI. Also, I noticed that you ink the TH Platform while the cover was tipped up, rather than laying it flat. Why is that? Will the top not lay flat? Thanks!
So far its worked very well because I feel like I can put more pressure on it without breaking it. You are able to lay the lid flat, I was trying to keep it all in the video frame. Great question!
Finally! Someone who is not afraid to say what he prefers. I have been wanting to buy something and everyone seems to run afraid from My Sweet Petunia because she is so litigious. Thank you. If I can find one, Tonic, Tim Holtz it will be.
Thank you for what I feel is an unbiased report. It was frustrating waiting for 6 months while Tonic sorted out some legal issues, and apparently they had to make some changes for copyright issues. One item that would have been an issue had I known, but the Tonic is made in China and I couldn't find where Misti is manufactured.
Way back when I was looking for a stamping platform, I looked at the Misti. There were two things I didn't like, the price "yikes"!! and how confining I felt it was. I bought a Stamparatus from Stampin Up, before they stopped selling them. So glad I did. After seeing your video, I like the Tim Holtz. It has some of the same features as the Stamparatus.
What one would be best for carpel tunnel & arthritis? I never could justify the cost of MISTY. TH's platform is more reasonable but still difficult for me to justify. Thanks for the review
So glad I didn't MISTI anything :) The price is forbidden, and the quality is unacceptable. I'm going for a Tim Holtz! Yay! You got a new subscriber here Ian.
Thank you for this video Ian. I didn't know which one to invest in but after seeing this I'm now sold on the Tim Holtz. . I'm a new subscriber to your channel by the way and so far I love it! Keep up the great work.
I can't believe I couldn't find either at Joann.com, very surprised, anyone know if the stores carry the Tim Holtz one?Also wondering, and yes obviously I haven't done much stamping yet, but why do you need a different side for unmounted rubber stamps and the clear cling stamps? And then I just have to say...You have such beautiful hands!! I was a hand & foot model for a short time yrs ago, it was fun, you should look into it, if you haven't already! Just saying :)
Because of the different thicknesses that clear cling stamps have vs. the thickness of rubber mounted stamps. Each side gives enough room for the stamps to stamp nicely.
What I liked about this video is he got right to the point of the differences, and spoke in a clear understandable voice. He also did a short demonstration of how they both work. Great video! 👍
Thank you so Much for your compliments.
I bought the TH Platform and love it. I had looked at the Misti and didn’t like the look of it - it looked flimsy and cheap, and when I saw the price, I said to myself, “forget it.” I know a lot of people swear by the Misti but I think the TH one is better all round - robust, reasonably priced, easy to use, and it looks much nicer! This is a good review.
Thank you I'm was wanting to know which one to buy and this was very helpful.
Glad it was helpful!
Bought my first stamping platform today. Amazon Prime £23.60 Tim Holtz Stamping platform. I researched all the others and for me the Tim Holtz was decently priced and it had the best stamping area in my opinion. Thanks for doing this video. So glad I made the right choice. Happy crafting everyone.
I’m so glad to hear you liked my review.
Thanks, will be buying the Tim Holtz one.
Thank you for this concise review of each platform. Exactly what I was looking for. I made my purchase of the Tim Holtz today!
You are welcome!
I do have a Tim Holtz version. Love it.
I never even looked at the Misti....over priced for one. Two....I dont buy from people claiming to be Christian, throwing it out there to get business then turning around and being so very rude and hateful to people via social media, etc. Being a Christian shouldn't need to be said, people should see it in your actions and how you treat others.
Thanks so much for your comparison video of these two products. I’m just getting back into stamping and had no idea which one would be better? I agree that the Tim Holt’s stamp platform is more practical and definitely more price friendly.
Your video was very helpful!
So glad to hear you found my video to be helpful.
Thank you for the information and not having unnecessary conversation while doing your demonstrations. I am glad I came across this demonstration. I was about to buy the Misti stamper,but the price was too much for my budget so I was holding off for a sale. I will be purchasing the Tim Holtz thanks to this video.
+Marie Jones I’m glad to hear you’ll be getting it. You will be happy you did.
Thanks so much for this review. I agree with your decision.
My pleasure!
Happened by your video. Great review. I knew nothing of either products so the video was very interesting. Thanks for sharing. I have one question for anyone - would the TH Platform work with rubber stamps on wood? Of course, take the stamp off the wood.
I don’t know for sure, but I think there is a good chance it will work.
Edit: I misunderstood and thought you wanted to stamp on wood. If you carefully remove the stamp from the wood base, yes, it should work just fine. There are products out there to help convert wood base stamps to just rubber cling stamps. My original reply: If the wood is thin (very) then yes. I used it to stamp a small sentiment on a small - and thin - wood embellishment. I used the "rubber" side of the platform lid. I also used a small glue dot to hold the embellishment in place on the platform, then rubbed it off when I was done.
Thks for sharing. I have both and appreciate both designs.
Thanks for watching.
For some reason, I am having problem with stamping completely, I have restamped the part that didn’t stamp out but still didn’t still stamp out completely- also used versamark. Any ideas. I own the Tim Holtz platform. Thank you🥰
Make sure your stamp platform is on the correct side. I know sometimes when I don’t have it placed on the right side of the door it won’t stamp evenly. Also if there’s an air bubble trapped underneath the stamp that can sometimes affect the quality of stamping as well.
Ian - thank you very much for the tips🥰
Do you know if they still make the TH Platform. I can't seem to find it anywhere.
Sadly, I think they stopped making it after a court ruling in a copyright case.
I think it's a shame that My Sweet Petunia has been able to get away with claiming that the MISTI is an original invention. Although printing presses have been around for centuries, a man named J.B. Lieberman is the one who actually invented the personal printing press (which is essentially what a MISTI is) and called it the Herity Press. J.B. Lieberman was actually such a purveyor of personal printing that he wrote a book about printing as a hobby, and even had a printing club. He even went so far as to have his personal printing press patented, and you can still view the patent (along with J.B.'s detailed diagrams of the press, so you can see how obviously similar the MISTI is to it) on Google's patent database. Iliana, a.k.a. My Sweet Petunia, has basically stolen his invention and claimed it as her own, and then was able to get a court (who is undoubtedly ignorant of the original invention) to support her claim. All of this in addition to her reputation regarding her unprofessional treatment of customers in the past, which I will not delve into right now. Long story long, I will never buy anything from her.
+Alegra Kuiper My goodness! I didn’t know all of that about the MISTI creator.
Totally agree Alegra! That woman is a real piece of work. My blood boils every time I see a craft influencer go on and on about this "fantastic" invention. The fact that she then tries to pass herself off as a christian gives me an additional bad taste in my mouth.
i think what is remarkable about the fact is that sweet petunia brought back a good invention and modernizied to get into the world of crafts, and i enjoyed it every time i use it. that`s what is good about it, and above all that is a wonderful tool. Instead of worrying who invented it, why don`t people invent or re - invent other tools we may use as well.....
Allegra, I totally agree with you! There are other companies like Stampin’ Up! that have also made stamping tools similar to Tim Holtz and the Misti!! I don’t understand why sweet petunia isn’t suing Stampin’ Up too?! LOL 😂 I think that the owner of The Misti is upset because Tim Holtz’s price is so much more affordable, bigger and better than what she “invented”!!! It’s ridiculous, everyone in this industry and others come up with similar stamps, inks ect. Tim Holtz rocks, he has a great personality, and has come up with such amazing products! 💗👍🏼 Like they all say, “karma’s a bitch!” What goes around comes around! Thanks for the info, I had no idea about the original inventor?! PS This just goes to show you how much class Tim Holtz actually has! Maybe that’s why he’s so much more successful than she’ll ever be!😊💗👍🏼
That’s just not how patent law works
Thanks Ian. Great comparison and I totally agree! Nice to support a company that stands by their products!
I agree too.
I did not buy the Misti because of its price. So glad I waited! Loving the TH Platform!!
I wish I had waited.
I know this is an older video, but seriously, your video was exactly what I needed to see. Your comparison was precise, to the point, and showed everything I was curious about. Thank you!!❤😊😊
Glad it was helpful!
Thanks for this video! I saw the Misti in a video some months back and wanted one but the price.....!!!! So I found an online video that shared how to use an IKEA frame to do a stamping tool yourself. So I made one ( I am Swedish after all;-)!) and have really liked using it. The cost came down to around ten dollars. The problem, as with the Misti comes when I want to stamp on larger papers. So I will definitely go for a TH platform now thanks to your clear and good review!
I love the fact that the Tim Holtz Stamp Platform lets you get bigger papers in. I can't stop talking about how much I love this tool.
Thank you so much for posting this review!! I had been wanting a MISTI stamp platform for a while, and then saw the difference in the prices of each one. I just received my Tonic Tim Holtz platform, and I haven't had a chance to use it yet. I'm so glad; it looks like I made the right choice!
You made a great choice. Let me know how you like it once you use it.
Can we stamp on a journal with them? Thank you
It would take some being creative. You would need to fold the rest of the journal back so that one one page goes underneath the door. You would not be able to put the full journal under the door and have it close all the way. I hope that helps answer your question.
@@OffKilterCrafterIan It is so pity! Tim Holtz could have been created something for the journals! I love stamping on it! Thank you for answering me ;)
@@canadaverydry It really would depend on the size of the journal. If you can get it under the lid without trouble and in a position it accordingly, it would work. A thick or hardcover journal would not. So, using a cahier/pocket or thin, flexible journal should work.
I’m making the switch!! Thanks for sharing.
Hope you enjoy it!
Thank you for the review. We are brand new to stamping and this video review has helped us to decide which one to buy right from the start. :)
I’m so glad to hear my review helped. I hope you enjoy it as much as I enjoy using mine.
When I first saw the MISTI online, I had no prior information to affect my opinion of the tool. My first thought was that it was a great idea, but then I saw the price. I believed that it was grossly overpriced for a plastic tool and refused to buy it. Then the TH one came out! In my opinion, his design is superior, and his price point is what I would expect for a tool with that size and spcification. I bought his and love it!
I love it too.
Thanks for the detailed review. I have the MISTY and was interested in the Tim Holtz Platform. Your information was very helpful.
+beaconoflight37 I’m glad my information could help.
Great comparison video! I am making the switch! Thanks for helping me make that decision.
+Evelyn Quast Glad to hear my video helped you make the switch.
love the comparison, looking to buy a stamp platform and after your demo I will be buying the Tim Holtz..Thanks for the review
+Margaret Laughlin You are welcome. I hope you enjoy it.
Great review. I have always held off from buying a MISTI due to the exorbitant price, so I was so happy when I started to see reviews for the Tonic platform. I bought one last week and I love it! :)
Woohoo! Glad you got it.
Thank you Ian, I am a brand new subscriber to your channel, but For what I have seen so far I am going to be here quite often. Great job on the comparison.
+Tracey Bradshaw Thank you for subscribing! I really hope you enjoy my future videos. I always love to hear from you in the comments of each video.
Useful video, thanks, even though I ordered the TH stamping tool last week from Amazon and it’s coming from the UK, it’s good to see a video reinforcing my belief that I made the right choice. My TH stamping tool is arriving this week and I can’t wait. I’m terrible at stamping with acrylic blocks. I’ve dropped them too many times on to my ink blended backgrounds with an inked stamp attached, and ruined the background, or the image or sentiment I stamped was incomplete and I find it impossible to restamp an image with acrylic blocks. On principle I refused to buy a Misti because the company sued competitors, and the ridiculous price point also put me off. Two pieces of plastic with a hinge for almost twice the price of a TH platform, is absurd. Anyway, no more stamping errors for me!
👍🏻
Thank. you Ian. Very thorough and easily understood. awesome vid.
Glad you found it helpful!
good review. Thanks.
Thank you!
Hi Ian! I just got my TH Stamp Platform, and have been playing with it today....I LOVE IT!!!! OH.MY.GOODNESS!!! IT. IS. AWESOME! I cannot say enough good things about it. The quality of Tim Holtz products, at HALF the price....(that just makes me sad) is second to none!
I'm glad you are enjoying your Stamp Platform.
Am laughing at the sour reviews from Misti users not that I blame them since for the price of their 1 Misti they could get 2 Tonic/Tim Holtz platforms, oh BUT they'd buy the Tonic/Tim Holtz one if it was carried in a store with 40% off coupon. You know they never got their Misti for 40% off!!! I thought the Misti was clever but their price point was way too high for what it does plus I had the WRMK letterbox press that could do similar task but took up a lot of space. I've seen the Tonic/Tim Holtz one as low as $31.99 - skip a few fast food meals one month or Starbucks coffees and you can afford that. My health thanks me for skipping the fast food and my craftroom likes the new Tonic/Tim Holtz stamping platform.
+Vincentia Faddis It's such a great tool!
Vincentia Faddis I got my Misti for 40$ lol The normal sized not the small one.
Hi! Can you tell me what's the size of the tim stamp platform, please?
Do I dare tell you that until today when I stumbled on your video...I had NO CLUE I could use rubber stamps in my Tim H platform. Seriously...you made my day!!
Glad I could help! Hope you enjoy the new found ability of your tool. 😁
You have convinced me! It’s definitely the Tim Holtz and your video explains a lot which I would never have thought about! It is now a ‘must have’ instead of a ‘ what on earth do you do with this?’ Thank you so much for your great video! Cheers Donna.
Thank you very much. Glad you found my video helpful.
Thank you for the comparison, it confirmed what I thought. I have the misti but loved the idea that you can stamp larger cards or background stamps with TH Stamp Platform. Also the two flat edges are perfect for ease of stamping larger sheets of card etc. Husband buying me a TH Stamp Platform for my birthday this week 😜
+Victoria Burgess Happy birthday and I hope you enjoy it as much as I do.
I loved this! Thank you! I was wanting a Misti for over a year, since seeing it on Jennifer McGuires channel. However, when Joann Fabrics was having their spring sale a month ago, the Tim Holtz stamp platform was about 35% off so I bought that instead. I'm so glad I did! It's a much better tool by far, after seeing the Misti up close in your video. I didn't realize the acrylic top on the Misti was so flimzy! Wow! I'm really happy with my choice now! Thank you!
Glad to hear your happy with your choice. Thanks for watching my video.
Totally agree with you. Great review. I'm gifting my mini misti away. Love the Tonic platform! I'm so grateful Tim was able to bring it to us. 😃
I after for such a great price too.
Just bought a stamp platform Tim Holtz. Can’t wait to get it in the mail. Thanks for the review.
I think you are going to love it.
Thanks again Ian. Yes! Totally gonna love it and you can’t beat the price! I paid only $24. Heck ya! I did a Joann’s online haul. Got carried away. LOL can’t wait! Do you have a review on ink pads (dye, pigmented, and hybrid ink pads)? I was just going to order one from each company. (Stampin up, Simon Says, Hero Arts, Gina K, My Fav. Things, and so on) to try them all out. I want them all!!!! LOL.
Fantastic review! Thank you for creating and sharing this video.
You are welcome. I am so glad to hear you enjoyed it!
Ian!.. Loved Your Demonstration!! & Comparison!! I have Not.. as Ayer.. bought either!.. Didn’t realize I needed one!! But! Lo & Behild!.. I DO!! Will go with the TH!! Thanks Again!! GBU!❤️
I’m glad you liked my demonstration and comparison. I hope you enjoy it just as much as I enjoy mine.
I would have purchased a MISTI but over here in Australia the price is ridiculous. After seeing my friend's Tim Holtz Stamp Platform I decided to go with it instead. I even managed to buy
it when it was reduced in price and with no shipping charges. Yay! This is great comparison
vid and the Tim Holtz one looks sturdier. So glad I didn't splurge on the MISTI. Oh and I have
just subscribed and given this vid a thumbs up.
+Catherine Cowie You made the right choice in my opinion. Thanks for subscribing and I hope you enjoy my other videos.
Really had video troubles. I could hear it, but only got stills as I moved the cursor along.
I’m sorry to hear that.
I’m definitely switching to the Tim Holtz stamp platform. Thanks for the info!
Your welcome!
Great review!
Thank you!
I'm really glad that I came across this video.
I saw a video quite a while ago (probably on Tim's channel) showing his platform).
I'm new to stamping and had never seen such a device and was amazed by the ingenuity, but I didn't really feel a need for it until very recently.
And the most recent stamping videos I've watched show the Misti (which I had never heard of, being familiar only with Tim's version).
Well, crafter after crafter seemed to be using the Misti, which made me wonder if it was superior to Tim's.
Thank you so much for this comparison, I'll be purchasing one of Tim's platforms. 👍🏻😁
Awesome! I’m glad to hear my video helped.
I waited for someone to come up with a platform that was less expensive than the MISTI, and was thrilled when Tim came out with his, as I could tell, it was not only cheaper but better made, and it could easily hold larger paper. Thanks for your comparison. I love. my TH Platform!
+cheryl johnson Woohoo! Glad you are enjoying yours as much as I love mine.
I just found your video on the Tim Holtz Platform. I have a mini Misti. I don't mind telling you as soon as I can afford it, I'll be buying a Platform. I like everything about The Platform. I have to agree with all the comments I've read on this video. I think Tim Holtz took the time to really think about what a crafter could and couldn't use. He's a crafter also and I really think this makes for a better product. Thanks for sharing with us. I subscribe today! Thanks for being there!
+Gloria Sperring Glad to hear you are getting it. I think it's a great staking tool.
+Gloria Sperring Oh! I almost forgot! Thanks for subscribing!! 😁
I'm a newbie in cardmaking and wondering what to buy. Glad that I saw your video. Thanks.
I hope you can find it. Unfortunately, it was discontinued so it may be hard to find.
@@OffKilterCrafterIan oh no!! 😔 Didn't even notice that your video was 6 years ago. Got excited.
I don't own any platforms, so with this video I'm going with the Tim Holtz one. thx u for your input Crafter Ian.
You are so welcome.
I just order the TH traveler stamp platform and can't wait for it to get here! As I was looking for a stamp platform, I came across the misti and I wear my heart skipped a beat at the price! Never will I ever pay that much for a stamp aid! Id rather spend the money on art and craft supplies where i get more bang for my buck! Seeing that Tim and Tonic came out with their own design (which looks more professional) I was so happy and could wait to get it! Things came up and I couldn't get it right away and now hearing that it's being discontinued I jumped on it paying $25.00 on the Wal-Mart app. I don't see how people have issues with stamping with TH unless their stamp is too close to the raised edges or too close to the magnets. I dont like stamping on foam unless im stamping in my art journal which I have an old mouse pad for that reason. Seeing how raised all 3 edges of the misti are would bother the check out of me because I can see the paper bending and wrinkling like you had happen and also since the paper isn't flat all around, makes it seem easier to hit and mess up plus are you really going to get a 2nd press correctly with the paper bending like that? I don't think so. Also just by looking at the misti it looks like a diy picture frame one with the 3 rulers looking like they're pieced together instead of one piece, the stamping glass looks really cheap and if hit on a soft spot could cause it to crack or break into pieces even. I just think for $80 probably plus shipping it should look totally more professional made and not have all 3 sides raised so much. Now comes to the fact that i don't understand how misti can sue TH and Tonic as they are 2 completely different designs but just serve the same purpose. To me that's like Velveeta suing Kraft. 2 different recipes but they're both mac n cheese. To me that's beyond petty and THE MAJOR reason im so glad I didn't get a cheaper smaller sized misti.
I like the analogy of the recipes. Good job!
Thanks for helping me decide on which stamp platform to buy...Tim Holtz stamp platform looks like the winner.
+Alicia Mayo I agree!
This was a great video. Thank you so much for the comparison of these two products. I have the original misti and was quite excited about it when it first debuted. My enthusiasm has since waned..quite a bit. My cover has cracked quite badly. Sometimes I think the only thing holding it together is the protective vinyl sheet. Which I had a very hard time positioning.
I have now been looking for the Tim Holtz stamp platform and only recently found that it is almost impossible to find. So sad. Wish I had bought one when they first came out.
Thanks again for a very well done video.
I have been able to find it on Amazon still. You might try there.
@@OffKilterCrafterIan thanks. I did look there but the shipping is almost as much as the platform. Will see what happens.😏
Great comparison/review, Ian! I currently own the MISTI you used in the demo and love it. I'm very tempted by the new TH Platform and will most likely add that to my tool arsenal in the future especially for my larger projects. I'll keep my Misti for traveling and for my smaller projects. I also like the foam piece in the Misti for the clear stamps as it helps create a clean image with the first stamp so I think I would miss that in the TH Platform. The only thing I would add to your review is that if you have never used a stamping platform, you really need to get one. It will change the quality of your work for the better. It also makes creating layered stamp images so easy. I have actually stored away most of my stamp blocks in favor of my Misti. Thanks for the great review. I always enjoy your videos and find them very helpful.
I think you are right, if you don't have a stamp tool you really should get one. Glad you liked the review!
Leslie, you should check out Hedghog Hollow's review on the TH Platform. She added a thin piece of Fun Foam to fix the problem you spoke of regarding the clear stamps. She had some other good ideas you might be interested in.
I love it, just got it yesterday. Order it from Walmart, price $29.99. Now that is a great price.Scrapbooking-Warehouse has it 26.49, did not see that in time. Love the entire design.
Thanks for the price alert! 😍
Thanks for the review. I love them both for different reasons--- Leaning towards the Tonic more.
It's a good way to lean ;-)
I have a large Misti, but I'm looking for something a bit smaller and more convenient for more general use. I'm sold on the Tim Holtz Stamp Platform. Tonic Engineering does it again. Your demonstration and comparison were super helpful. Thanks.
Thank you! Glad you found my video helpful.
I've been using the Tim Holtz for a couple weeks, and have a couple points to add: 1) if you are using a big ink pad, the lip on the lid gets in the way and is a little messy, 2) I don't think photopolymer stamps stamp as well on the Tim Holtz-- seems to give some uneven coverage vs. the misti with the foam pad. My verdict-- I like both for diff. Reasons, but am not ready to trash my misti!
+Kim Hargis That is totally fair.
As demonstrated in a UA-cam video for the Tim Holtz Stamp Platform, if you are having trouble stamping clear stamps with the Tonic Stamp Platform, buy a 2 mm thick 9" x 12" or 12" x 18" (not sure of the dimensions on the double size foam) at Michaels or Joann's for 89 cents or 99 cents, respectively. Don't buy thicker foam for obvious reasons (surprising that a stamper can't figure that out) or your cardstock will "slip" off of the foam! You can then place the 2 mm foam onto the Tim Holtz Stamp Platform to stamp clear cling stamps if that's your preference. But as several UA-cam videos for the Tim Holtz Stamp Platform demonstrate, many stampers do stamp clear cling stamps with no problem. I haven't had a problem so far on the hard surface. But I did buy black foam at both Michaels and Joann's to see if they work with the Tim Holtz Stamp Platform after reading that a stamper's cardstock "slipped" off of the foam. There's no problem as long as you buy the 2 mm foam. Myself, I prefer stamping clear stamps without the foam on my Tim Holtz Stamp Platform and have gotten great results.
I prefer stamping big background stamps with the Tim Holtz Stamp Platform vs stamping them with my MISTI because the solid sturdy Tim Holtz lid seems to produce a more solid image than that done with the MISTI. I think it's because the weight of the Tim Holtz lid helps in stamping/applying pressure to a large image. The MISTI lid is very light weight; so, it seems that I have to press more firmly and more times when stamping large background images using my MISTI.
I especially like that the Tim Holtz Stamp Platform lid is detachable as I take my lid with stamps to the sink to wash off/clean my stamps and lid. I find that I spend more time cleaning my MISTI and don't use the 2 Novus acrylic cleaners that I bought when I got my MISTI because of the toxic warnings on both bottles. I also especially like the *lower* price and higher quality of the Tim Holtz Stamp Platform!
Great comparison. I have the Hampton Arts version and love it. I have seen a couple people mention tbat with clear photo polymer stamps, not all areas stamp well... have ypu tried this? If you have, would like your answer on how it does. Thanks
+Melody Gengler I will let you know if that's true if I see that happening.
I have the Tim Holtz platform mini and am getting the larger one. I love it for the price.
Tiger price is great!
I am SO glad you did this comparison. I agree with you that the Tim Holtz and Tonic Stamping Tool is a better value than MISTI. I have used the MISTI since it has been available. I tried to stamp a piece of 12 x12 cardstock with a cling stamp and the lid of my MISTI cracked with the CPR method of trying to get a good image. Also, my card stock wrinkled. I realize there is a bigger MISTI for the larger card stock, but I didn't expect the lid to crack with light pressure. Thank you for showing us this comparison. I know what my next crafting purchase will be.
+Christine Bishop Oh no! Sorry to hear you cracked your MISTI. I hope you enjoy the THSP!
Just ordered the Tim Holtz Stamp Platform today and can't wait to use it!!
I just purchased this item last week and didn’t notice you had to switch the plate when it comes to rubber stamps and clear stamps. Thought I got a defective one. Thanks for explaining. Lol will give it a try again.
So glad to hear I was able to help. Yes, make sure you are flipping the plate. Big difference!
I bought the original MISTI and waited until inventory met demand to get it. There were no magnets or grid papers included then. I don't mind the protective sheet I keep on the lid when I store it, and I bought the recommended cleaning product (I found it and magnets for a better price elsewhere) to preserve the etching on the lid. My only gripe has been a fear of cracking the hinges because the lid doesn't lie flat on the table when open and inking my stamp. Cure: a few sheets of fun foam and all is well. IF my MISTI ever breaks I will probably replace it with the TH platform, but I am sticking with my MISTI until or if that happens. Thanks for a great comparison!
+Susan Dickson I totally agree if you have one already, use it until you wear it out. For those looking to get one the Tim Holtz one is the best one to go with in my opinion. Great idea about using the fun foam!
Great review and comparison Ian. I refused to pay the outrageous price for the MISTI. I purchased the We R platform from HSN very cheaply before the legal issues and before I heard about the Tonic Tim Holtz platform. Even though the We R doesn't have a magnetic base, it's been great. However, if I ever have issues with it not being magnetic, I will definitely buy this one. In my opinion, they are both much better than the MISTI. TFS! ❤️
+Susan Forti I wish I had never bought MISTI now that I have this one.
you can magnetise your We R platform too - Google it. Having said that - I just bought the Tim Holtz stamping Platform - because I didn't have any at all - except the Stampin Up Stampamajig - which I used a fair bit :) ua-cam.com/video/fmo242-MoN0/v-deo.html
Thank you for your time doing this video. I decided on the Tonic. I will give a shout out to office supply they had the best price for the Tonic even with the shipping and handling. Hope this helps if you are looking to save some money.
+Beth Maciaszek Good to know.
I have both and I use the mist you the most, mostly because I almost had to stand on the TH platform with a bigger stamp. I have often wondered if my particular platform has a problem and shouldn’t be that way. Thanks for the great comparison.
Great video Ian and thank you. I’ve had my Tim Holtz platform for some time now and love it. I’ve been thinking of getting the Misti, but after seeing your video I believe I will pass on that purchase. From the first time using my TH, I’ve loved it. New stubbie here.
I’m so glad you found my review helpful. Thanks for subscribing.
Thank you ian. I have the Tonic platform and love it.
+Jeanine Delsignore It's so amazing.
I just got my platform yesterday, and I've not had a chance to play with it yet. I do have the original MISTI, and I have to say that at just my own first look of the platform that it really makes me feel like it is STURDY. I REALLY like that this doesn't have that stupid plastic covering over the grid, and yes, I recognize that the current MISTI's don't have it, it still is an annoyance every time I touch the lid; my fingers don't like that texture at all. I have always had great performance with my MISTI, and have no complaints about that at all.
So, for me, it comes down to the design of the actual tool. I like that I don't have to have a "Memory" version to stamp on 12 x 12 papers. The design is actually so well thought out. If you look at the rulers on the sides of the original MISTI, there's an extra tick or two between a couple of the numbers on the ruler. Obviously I am not a freak about being exact or that would drive me crazy. I have a second MISTI that I got when my first MISTI started cracking on the edges and hinges, and I have just set that aside for use when the first one actually did bite the dust.
So, what am I going to do? I'm going to reach for the Tim Holtz platform as my first choice of a tool. I am going to keep my MISTI in use when doing assembly line type of stamping, and my 2nd MISTI that I can use with Tack n' Peel for all those unmounted stamps that I've wanted to use, but haven't mounted yet. I also have a cheap-o DVD case that I keep set up with the stamps that I use on the backs of cards that I make, and that will continue to be at my fingertips.
But when it comes down to nuts and bolts, I am glad to put my new TH stamping platform into the work-horse position, and as the MISTI's begin to crumble and break they will just go into the trash and I'll chalk that purchase up to a lesson well learned. I am also glad to support a product made by a leader in the industry and someone who hasn't gone crazy threatening to sue people for making their own versions of the tool.
I could not agree more! I am so impressed with how steady the Tim Holtz Stamp Platform feels. I feel like I could stand on it and it won't break. That of course is not true, but all kidding aside it really does feel like I can put some heavy pressure on it and it is not going to break. Thanks for taking the time to watch my review and share your thoughts with me.
Well said. I honestly regret giving the creator of MISTI any money because of her less than professional behavior
even when she was shipping out defective product. Glad to see there are better alternatives now.
I tend to stamp on things, much thicker than paper. I didn't stand on it, but I did kneel on it, as I was stamping on corrugated cardboard. . Of course I didn't put all of my weight on it, but the platform was fine afterwards!! This would depend on a persons weight of course, and I am sure Tonic and TH do not advise doing this, but I was willing to chance it!! Lol!
Nice tutorial Ian, thank you. This makes me sad that Tim's stamping platform is now so hard to find. I found it on Amazon for $57, with free shipping, but as of 12/20/19 there are only 5 in stock. Guess who's gettin that for christmas!!
Very nice. I hope you enjoy it.
Thanks for the review. I am definitely going to buy the Tim Holtz platform. It looks as though it's a great tool like most of Tim's products.
I think you will enjoy it. Let me know your thoughts when you get it.
Thx for the video now I know which one to buy. Tonic Studios Tim Holtz Stamp Platform
Better do it soon. They are going to stop selling them soon.
Hi I’m a new subbie, when the Misti come out, I so so wanted it, but the price was way beyond my means, so I started to save. Then something else come up and I had to use the money I had. (Just thought I’d say I’m not a kid I’m almost 60 and been crafting since I was 3) so house and family have to come before crafting. But I could still stamp the old way so I could wait........then the Tim Holtz come out, as soon as I saw it I knew it was for me, so I changed from the Misti in my mind! A wee while later I was looking at a craft magazine, they were offering the Tim Holtz one as a gift for subscribing to the magazine, well I’m disabled and can’t always get out to get my fav mag, so was looking for the best deal in the mags I like (I like them all lol) so this was manna from heaven.......so I got my Tim Holtz AND my fav mag that I pay for each quarter, so what could be better.......nothing, I love it, I’d fight to keep it if I had to lol, now I’m looking at all his stuff, they are such great value, I think that is because he is a crafter and a normal guy who loves what he does and loves to share, he gets out there showing what he has, not like a lot of others hiding behind the name of a company. So I think you could say, this oldie is a Tim Holtz fan!!! I watched this because I find it interesting the comparison videos, and also male crafters, we need more of them on the tube, they have different ideas a lot of the time.....so I’m off to see what else you have done, I know this was last year so am hoping there is some goodies to watch! Huggles xxxAnnxxx in Uk 🇬🇧
.
Ann thank you so much for the wonderful words about this video. I really do hope you enjoy my other videos and please comment on my videos letting me know what you thought or if you have any questions. So glad to hear you got the Tim Holtz's stamp platform and I so happy to hear you love it. I use mine SO much!
Hi Ian, I have the middle size Misti, I got the Tim Holtz platform as a free gift in the UK, I love it, I like that it feels more robust. I've not had any problems with ink staining, I reach for it before my Misti which I loved but it always felt like I might break it ( I'm 6ft tall with big hands) lol. Ps loving the Dr who Tshirt. X
+Stephanie Drury Could not agree more. Thanks for noticing my shirt. 😍
You made my decision as to which one to purchase!
+Susan Hilley Glad I could help you make a decision.
I have the Hampton Arts Stamp Perfect , and I like it well enough but I am seriously thinking of trying the Tim Holtz one. Thanks for the review :)
+Karlene Moore I think you should give it a try.
I’m waiting on my Tim Holtz to be delivered! Now I’m MORE excited!
Awesome!
will the Misti Creative Corners work in the Tim Holtz? That would be great!
Great question! I don’t have them so I don’t know the answer for sure. However, I suspect that they will.
Totally agree Ian- I have both and you are right on the mark with the comparisons! I just found your channel and subscribed and gave your comparison video a thumbs up. I think they are both great tools and am not going to get involved in all the fighting between the lovers of both. But if I had to choose only one or had not bought one yet, I would recommend the Tim Holtz Tonic Studio Stamp Platform and I used it on a video I posted today (which is why UA-cam recommended your video to me:)
Glad to hear you agree Karen. Well said!
Love the reviews, really helpful. But even better, the Dr Who T shirt. So cool.
+Helen Webb I love me some Doctor Who! Lol
Looking to buy thus comparing. I do like that the Misti 'lid' opens up like a book. Just seems easier for transferring ink. I agree the difference in cost is a little ridiculous.
Thank you for your video. I was torn between the MISTI and the Tim Holtz stamping platforms. I will purchase the Tim Holtz stamping platform as it meets my needs better.
I’m glad my video helped. Make sure to buy it soon as it will be pulled from shelves soon.
Excellent review. Thank you.
Thank you! I’m glad you liked it.
Thanks for this great review! I'm wondering about sampling on a hard surface in the TH Platform, where we stamp on foam in MISTI. Also, I noticed that you ink the TH Platform while the cover was tipped up, rather than laying it flat. Why is that? Will the top not lay flat? Thanks!
Maureen Morton Yes it does lay flat. He was keeping it raised to keep it in video frame.
So far its worked very well because I feel like I can put more pressure on it without breaking it. You are able to lay the lid flat, I was trying to keep it all in the video frame. Great question!
You are correct Maureen!
Finally! Someone who is not afraid to say what he prefers. I have been wanting to buy something and everyone seems to run afraid from My Sweet Petunia because she is so litigious. Thank you. If I can find one, Tonic, Tim Holtz it will be.
I hope you can find one!
Amazon
I sold my Misti and bought a TH platform. Best decision I've made in a while. 🙂 Anne
+daboyzom1961 Good for you! I might give mine away.
have a Cuttlebug All-in-one that I don’t use too often. It already looks somewhat like a stamp positioner. It can be used for that!
Thank you for what I feel is an unbiased report. It was frustrating waiting for 6 months while Tonic sorted out some legal issues, and apparently they had to make some changes for copyright issues. One item that would have been an issue had I known, but the Tonic is made in China and I couldn't find where Misti is manufactured.
I am glad you liked my review!
I went for the TH one because it was the only one out of all the press's I saw being demoed with a 12x12 paper.
I think that is a huge plus for those who scrapbook.
I don't have a misty and I don't have a Tim Holtz one. where did you say I can get the Tim Holtz one I do need one. Thanks for ur video.
+lucy mar You can get it on Amazon or Simon Says Stamp.
Glad I found this in the comments. I tried finding the seller you mentioned but didn't catch 'says'. Simon's stamps is not the same. lol
Way back when I was looking for a stamping platform, I looked at the Misti. There were two things I didn't like, the price "yikes"!! and how confining I felt it was. I bought a Stamparatus from Stampin Up, before they stopped selling them. So glad I did. After seeing your video, I like the Tim Holtz. It has some of the same features as the Stamparatus.
I totally agree!
What one would be best for carpel tunnel & arthritis? I never could justify the cost of MISTY. TH's platform is more reasonable but still difficult for me to justify. Thanks for the review
+Pat Cyzauskas I think because there are better grip points the Tim Holtz Stamp Plaform would be the best.
Excellent review - I've ordered a Tim Holtz SP off the back of this video :)
+Rach J Let me know how you like it.
So glad I didn't MISTI anything :) The price is forbidden, and the quality is unacceptable. I'm going for a Tim Holtz! Yay!
You got a new subscriber here Ian.
Thanks for subscribing! I hope you enjoy my future videos.
I have both and will continue to use them both. I have the original, 1st gen. MISTI and I always feel a little envious of the etched version.
I can agree to that.
Thank you for this video Ian. I didn't know which one to invest in but after seeing this I'm now sold on the Tim Holtz. . I'm a new subscriber to your channel by the way and so far I love it! Keep up the great work.
+Morena1268 I’m so glad to hear my video helped you. I’m also glad to hear you subscribed. I hope you enjoy my future videos.
I can't believe I couldn't find either at Joann.com, very surprised, anyone know if the stores carry the Tim Holtz one?Also wondering, and yes obviously I haven't done much stamping yet, but why do you need a different side for unmounted rubber stamps and the clear cling stamps? And then I just have to say...You have such beautiful hands!! I was a hand & foot model for a short time yrs ago, it was fun, you should look into it, if you haven't already! Just saying :)
Because of the different thicknesses that clear cling stamps have vs. the thickness of rubber mounted stamps. Each side gives enough room for the stamps to stamp nicely.