Quinn posts: Yeah. It's about Dune: YEAH! It's the final main series ultimate guide: HELL YEAH!!!!!! (I wish I had finished books past Messiah, and could safely watch it tho......)
You should do the Fremen Jihad...religious war driven by religious fervor zealocy....68 billion massacred, 10s of planets sterilized and dozens of religions wiped out....
1:07:22 "The Bene Gesserit knew that hierarchical bureaucratic systems were always in danger not because absolute power corrupts absolutely, but because power attracted the corruptible." I like that take.
Dude, it’s perfect. I got chills every time I watched this. Creating the music for Chapterhouse was an incredible journey! Thank you for asking me to be a part of this project! Cannot wait to see where your channel goes next! Though I kind of already know since I’m making the music for that next thing right now 🤔
It's interesting how the Dune books seem to oscillate between books that feel tight in their plotting and books that feel dense in their depths. God Emperor and Chapterhouse feel at times monolithic in the weight of their themes and the scope of their vision, whereas Children and Heretics have more of an adventurous tone to them that makes them more satisfying on initial read, but the God Emperor and Chapterhouse are the wellsprings I keep going back to, if that makes sense.
My guess is that the concept of breakaway Face Dancers with Daniel and Marty was one similar to Other Memories of BG and Leto II. They capture personas of others so perfectly, so completely that each person added becomes another Other Memory in their mind, and who knows, maybe each of their Other Memories as well. That would mean their knowledge and vision would increase geometrically with each added persona, combined with their far superior technology, turning them into Kwisatz Haderach-like beings, far beyond even Leto II's or Duncan's and Teg's capabilities. Yet through all of that, they have no inherent personal identity, they must create one themselves. There is an artificiality to them, a sort of antithesis to what humanity is, as seen and described by Herbert. I don't know what their purpose was, or if it was anything beyond a self insert by Herbert and his partner, but whatever it was, I think they ultimately failed at it when it comes to Duncan and the no-ship. The feeling I got when Duncan set the no-ship towards an unknown destination they were forever separated from the rest of the story, the Old Empire, the Matres and the Ones of Many Faces. That's a real Scattering moment, setting out blindly into an unknown corner of a seemingly infinite universe. Once the travel was complete, they were truly and completely alone, separated from everything they had ever known. I would assume Frank would have brought them into contact with another pocket of Scattering in the next book, using that opportunity to explore other dimensions of the Scattering and its effects on humanity. I don't see any reason why any of the characters in the no-ship would ever have a reason to or have the means to return to the Old Empire. Who knows, there isn't much to go on with. Back in the Old Empire I would expect a lot of disorder and restlessness happening due the unification of BG and HM, the breaking down of the dogmas of the Butlerian Jihad, and the anxious anticipation of the inevitable arrival of the Ones with Many Faces. It sounds like the buildup to Kralizec, and if the no-ship crew were somehow tied to it from the other end, it would be very interesting. Perhaps on the contrary to what Frank's son imagined, the machines weren't going to be the great enemy, but the future of the BG/HM organization, with their first steps towards Cyborg production taken. Maybe the point was going to be that humanity had finally evolved and progressed enough to reintegrate artificial intelligence into the human society, and that would somehow work towards the establishment of a universal democracy that Frank once hinted would be the ending point of the series. Anyway, congrats on finishing your grand project! It has been a fun journey and has also been great to discover others as passionate about Dune as I am. I personally would not be interested in delving into Brian Herbert's books in the slightest, as from the most basic outline they clearly and grossly miss Frank's vision, but others might disagree with me. I would personally recommend you the Mars trilogy by Kim Stanley Robinson, whose writing is somewhat similar to that of GRRM. I think you would enjoy them a lot, and I'd love to see your take on them too.
If there was only one comment one this video, I would vote that this would be it. It's an unique yet comprehensive take on the material and I really like the "alternative' ending you but forth. We will never know, but your theories and points make sense.
I kinda agree with you that the Brian Herbert books just wouldn't be worth a deep dive, but even though I hate where they took the series after Frank's death I still find myself intrigued by them and would like to see Quinn describe the whole shitshow, especially as I'm never gonna read them!
Your Ultimate Guides helped me get through the toughest part of my life after my accident. I can’t count how many times I’ve listened to each one. I would even listen to them in my sleep. Your voice, the music, the images, your wording have all been perfect and life/ sanity saving. Now I am living what feels like the start of a peak in my life, a time of reinvention and self discovery/ evolution. This final Ultimate Guide could not have come at a more perfect time of my life. Thank you for putting so much thought and passion into these invaluable and timeless works!
Thats amazing to hear, often you see comments seeing that videos are helping people in a real low but rarely that they’ve now been able to recover somewhat, its a very hopeful thing to hear, and i hope all of us have that sort of development one day if we feel like we’re at a low right now.
I've always been devastated that Frank Herbert died before completing his vision. I don't think where Brian and KJA took the series was the original intent. The face dancers became something more than themselves. I want to hear that story
Absolutely right Jake. I firmly believe that the Premature death of Frank Herbert was one of the greatest losses to literature in the last century. Who among us can imagine what truths about human nature would have been transmitted by the final novel?
Nah, I still kinda think Frank intended the machines to always be the great enemy. It’s viable that the face dancers ran into Erasmus and were altered.
@@darthbrooks4933 Also face dancers have always been bio machine hybrids!! They were " thinking machines" in violation of the jihad , humanity just didn't realise it yet . Once again they had made machine slaves who had the potential to become enemies! Humanity was so focused on inorganic machine enemies yet they replicated biological ones I still think machines really were defeated and if necessary could be defeated again however humanity has never faced a mass face dancer attack I think the face dancers did combine with some machine remnant but they were the superiors , it had already been proven that biological machines are more powerful
the story is exactly as herbert wanted he wrote the ending already..if you dont like it fine but dont blame Brain and KJA for the plot - their writitng might suck but the story is the story
I'm currently on the third book thanks to you and the movie, so I'll skip this one to avoid spoilers. But here's my comment and like as a thank you, Quinn; this channel should blow up as the years pass and it's well deserved.
Clearly Quinn's promises can be trusted to be fulfilled, no matter how long it takes. A plan coming to fruition across countless generations of youtube videos!
Having encountered you years ago, myself a self anointed Dune expert, I absolutely love your breakdowns and analysis. I’ve waited a long time for this one.
@@calvinsuu1949 sorry, I seldom ever comment on a video and just saw my comment got a reply, haha. You must be referring to Dune Messiah when Paul asks Korba for some specific historical reels about his jihad. Something along the line of tens of billions killed, 90 planets sterilized and 500 or more completely demoralized. Along with the eradication of countless other religions. Korba stated unbelievers, all of them, and Paul states, no, believers all of them.
@@thomaswatson1420 yes somewhat correct...due to paul's control of spacung guild the fremen travelled from planet to planet spreading his prophecy and the human universe simply couldnt do anything
It's crazy to think how influential your coverage of the Dune series is. You got me into the books in 2019, and you really helped create the market for dune on the internet. You definitely deserve some credit for the popularity of the films that we are getting.
I have to agree with the Organism. I always thought Daniel and Marty were meta characters, like a self-insert from Frank Herbert, meant to be Frank Herbert and his wife, Beverly Herbert. I got the feeling he knew he wasn't going to be able to complete the story, so those two characters, gardening, watching the inhabitants of the no-ship, discussing them getting away, and their plans for them, were like Herbert admitting the ending had escaped him, perhaps due to age or health, as the couple gardening invoked images or feelings of an older, retired couple, reflecting on life, and the inhabitants of the no-ship, Herbert's characters, his creations, were like his children, and he had great hopes, dreams, and plans for them, but he knew he wouldn't be able to see what becomes of them. I certainly never thought they were robots from before the Butlerian Jihad, though I did think the Honored Matres may have been feeling some remanent of the old thinking machines who were trying to go on with their existence beyond the human occupied space, only to have their ancient enemy and creators invade their space. But then again, I wasn't the one to find boxes and boxes of notes in an attic that contradict much of what was actually written in the original novels, so what do I know of Frank Herbert's intentions for continuing the Dune universe...
I also think, Chapterhouse was a worthy end to the story. I mean, the "universe" has pre-novel history (that includes the main characters) and it will a post-novel future. And the end of Chapterhouse either resolved the most important plot-lines or put them well on their way to be resolved in a post-novel future. Mind you, Frank was not someone who explained his universe beyond what was actually necessary to tell the story, leaving much open to individual interpretation... which would also be in line with the vast time-frame (in which truth is easily lost in legend). Thus, leaving open what was left open at the end of Chapterhouse is a good way to conclude Dune. That said, I don't think the son's sequels are as bad as they are often made out to be. Of course they are far from "daddy's" books. But a nice and interesting continuation and conclusion. My biggest problem with them is the whole Facedancers on Ithaca plot line... that was so infuriatingly lazy writing. Mentats such as Duncan and Miles would have never allowed them to remain undetected for this long... not with all the signs and evidence that had been piling on from the very day when they "escaped" from the Handlers' homeworld. Did they really believe, the old Rabbi was "sporty" enough to flee? Did they really believe that Thufir's awakening failed because the "witches" failed?? Did they really not connect the dots between the saboteurs skillfully evading security systems without a traitor among those who set them up and controlled them? Did they really not remember that the Rabbi was with Thufir on the Handlers' world, when it was revealed that he was a Facedancer?? Did they really not think about properly locking the doors of the interrogation room (or the bridge or any other vital place)?? Would Miles really not have stepped in to catch the revealed Facedancer, before he killed the guards and went to the bridge?? Why didn't any of the Reverend Mothers with their superior fighting skills step in at that point?? This made me rage-quit multiple times... though I'm glad that I picked the book up again to read to the end. It's a bit too hunky-dory, when compared to Frank's novels, but I think it is a nice conclusion. And were it not for that disastrously bad Facedancers on Ithaca plotline, it would actually be a rather good book. Still not on "daddy's" Level, but still good.
I agree with you. Herbert’s wife had cancer and he devoted much of his time to care for her so probably had no time to write a 7th book. He leaves it for each of us to figure it out. I think it’s a great ending as life continues and we don’t always have to know the future… Idaho and Sheana escape prescience.
Another highly anticipated ultimate guide, the best yet! Fantastic music too. I am very glad I dropped everything to watch this. A perfect example of why you should always have notifications turned on for Quinn's Ideas. Excellent work as always Quinn, always worth the wait 💜
Three years ago, I came for the Game of Thrones lore, but I stayed for the Dune lore ^^ But what I actually wanted to say was that you and your Ultimate Guide are the reason I got into Dune. Thank you so much for that.
AFTER WATCHING THE DUNE MOVIE MY INTEREST IN READING WAS SPARKED AGAIN, AFTER READING EACH BOOK I WOULD ALWAYS WATCH THESE VIDEOS TO MAKE SURE I DIDNT MISS ANYTHING OR JUST SIMPLY HEAR THE LORE AGAIN, I LOVE LISTENING ON A LONG DRIVE OR BEFORE I SLEEP, BEEN WAITING FOR CHAPTERHOUSE THANK YOU, HOPE ALL IS WELL QUINN GGOD BLESS YOU
Quinn is the dune GOAT let's be honest, once I'm done reading the first law trilogy I'm going to check out the dune books! Cheers Quinn my lad, and happy Easter eh
Amazing series! I highly recommend continuing on with the 3 "stand-alones" and "The Age of Madness" trilogy. They're all one big part of "The First Law" story. As for Dune, Frank Herbert's first 6 original Dune books is all you need to read of that story. And maybe the Dune Encyclopedia, if you can get your hands on a copy.
@@eddiepolo6047 I'm halfway through the second book and I agree man, awesome series and I LOVE the way Joe writes his characters, I've heard good things about the stand-alones, I'll definitely check them out! :)
BRAVO!!!! It was worth the wait! I would love if you did a Quinn Talks unscripted video on where you think Dune Book 7 may have gone in more detail based solely on your opinion, and conjecture from what the previous novels seemed to have been setting up throughout the six original novels. Even better still would be if you maybe decided to do a full fan fiction on Dune Book 7. Whether it be in a video format, or written form; I would be happy with either. Any direction you may take the story has got to be better than the hot mess we got stuck with in Hunters and Sandworms of Dune. I definitely consider your interpretations as the most consistent with what Frank Herbert seems to have intended of all the content currently available. Diskette of Dune Book 7 notes in a deposit box be damned! Congratulations, and I hope you continue with more Dune content in some form on your channel. Thanks for everything you have done to make Dune resonate to everyone.
That would be pretty interesting to me also. I never read any of the sequels/prequels, so my last experience of Dune is the conclusion of Chapterhouse Dune. It's haunting because it hints at a very different direction the next book might go. I like to think that the feared enemy the Honored Matres were running away from was Daniel and Marty ... just those two, and the minions under their thrall. To me, it makes sense that it would be just those two. If these advanced face dancers absorb others, why not each other? The end result would be that only the strongest remain, absorbing all the others. But being aware of the deep loneliness of Leto II, they would end with two remaining rather than one, just so they'd have each other to talk to. Anyway, the sheer power of these two hints that the universe beyond the "net" is full of similarly powerful and dangerous entities ... ones that weren't so weak like the Honored Matres that they'd need to run away back to the old imperium. So that's the sort of realm I imagined we'd see in the next book. I imagined Duncan and the others thrown into a completely unknown unimaginably expansive realm where they were motes among giants. I imagined that like Daniel and Marty, these giants would be quintessentially homo sapiens, so they are the true fulfillment of Leto's Golden Path. Those caught in the "net" would be doomed dead-enders to the machine killers. That Duncan and a small handful of others somehow managed to escape the net was luck, rather than part of any plan. I don't know what Herbert may have planned. I just imagine that if he had gone in this direction, it would creatively free him up to bring in completely new beings with very different themes and messages to convey.
@@newsmansuper2925 Dune 7.... sounds very woke.... 🤣 The sand was a fiery orange as the sun began to set over Arrakis. It was a time of change, a time of awakening. The old ways were no longer enough, no longer relevant to the complex world that was emerging. The people of Arrakis were waking up to new possibilities, to new ways of thinking and being. At the heart of this change was the spontaneous movement known as reformers. They were a group of individuals who rejected the strict order and conformity of the old ways, choosing instead to embrace freedom, creativity, and individuality. They sought to break down the rigid hierarchy of the past and build a new society based on equality and respect for all.
You've done it. You've really done it. You've captured the highlights, choice clips of the philosophy, the wheels within wheels feel of Dune, and even steered around a few of the unnecessarily clunky bits. I could listen to this all day. Thank you Quinn! And at this point - I would take your guess at a fitting sequel storyline in preference to any others I've seen.
I'm only 16 mins into this video, but I felt compelled to say "this is fucking amazing" already. I first stumbled upon your channel a few years ago, searching for Dune videos on UA-cam, and quickly became addicted to this channel. You have great taste in literature, and I love the way that you analyze and present these stories. I know this last video has been a long time coming, and it does not disappoint at all. I'm beyond excited to watch this video of you analyzing my favorite of Frank Herbert's books. The music is also unreal; it definitely sets a tone and gives the video depth within depth. lol. You are a one-of-a-kind channel, Quinn. Great fucking job, and keep up the amazing work!
I started reading Dune today, all thanks to you. I've been falling asleep to your playlists for a couple weeks now, learning all about Dune. Thanks for giving meaning to my life.
@@Emanon... Huh? Sure man I have plenty of meaning to my life, but listening to these stories as I fall asleep has greatly helped me in ways I can't convey. Don't make it weird. It's not that deep.
What a journey! I've been around since (near) the beginning, and when you shifted to Dune, I was so excited, because until then I'd never really had anyone to geek out over Dune with, besides my uncle (who now watches your channel). I was in sixth grade reading Chapterhouse when Frank passed away, so it's always been a fascinating puzzle box to me. Keep up the amazing content, Quinn!
Thank you for all your effort. I first stumbled across your youtube channel several years ago and enjoyed your content on Dune back then. But, I "lost" your channel as I went through several moves and career changes. One day a few months ago, I wondered, "whatever happened to that youtube channel on Dune I loved so much?" And wow, you've added so much more great content. Do continue with your work! You do an awesome job.
The first 4 dune books are great but i feel the last 2 are underrated masterpieces in their own way. They have so much weight behind them. Chapterhouse and heretics may not be as iconic as the first or children uf dune, but i really do enjoy re-reading them every now and again just so i can re-visit their batshit craziness lol
Yes, I honestly thought you'd given up or something else happened and you'd decided to not finish, been waiting so long thank you so much these are pure gold content
I started watching the first part of this epic series nearly five years ago. It's amazing. Now we've finally gotten the conclusion to Frank Herbert's original series.
Thank you Quinn. This series has rekindled my love for Dune, and has been inspiring a lot of new ideas inside of me. These videos have been truly impressive, well made and a sincere love letter to Herbert's universe. Thank you for all the entertainment, and your hard work / passion.
It was great to finally see this! Thank you for making the Ultimate Guide to Dune series! I wouldn’t have continued the other books after Dune if it weren’t for Part 1. Your Chapterhouse video was great and the music is fantastic!
Hey Quinn! You were the reason I finally sat down and read/listened to all the Dune books. I came for the Dune, stayed for Ideas of Ice and Fire. But I love that now your channel is all about YOUR Ideas! Keep up the great work!
Holy smokes, I had to make sure I had time to watch this in one sitting, and I'm glad I did. I got some friends of mine (also from the Netherlands) that only know the Dune movie(s) or even just the Westwood games, to check your channel for more a way more in-depth look at the Dune universe than they could ever imagine there was after just the games and movie. Your channel rekindled my love for the Dune saga all over again, and 20 years after reading the books, I will start reading them again soon. Thank you so much for that!
Excellent work, Quinn! I love the Dune series so much and there’s no way I could possibly have summarized it as effectively as you have with these 7 videos. Thank you for your hard work!
when i die and if i go to the afterlife. the first thing I will be doing is finding frankherbert and asking him to tell me the end of this series. when starting this series I had no idea it was never finished. there will forever be a dune sized hole in my heart, mind, and soul
Quinn, this was really extraordinary. I think you captured the feel and wonder of Frank Herbert's Dune books beautifully. I have listened to all 7 of your Ultimate Guides and have enjoyed them immensely. Thank you so much for this incredible piece of work. I think it will stand as an important analysis of Frank Herbert's work. I think you captured Frank Herbert's intensions very faithfully. It is one of my most favorite series of books, and I have read and reread them in my life. I have always spent a lot of time thinking about what it meant. I have incorparated many of Frank's ideas into my own beliefs about how to live a life, as well as how to be a good leader and person. Your Guides have given me new thoughts about the ideas of Dune. I will reread the books again later in my life. I will continue to follow your wonderful work in the future. Thank-you very much, Brendan
Thank you for another banger, Quinn - you've made quite probably the only complete "version" of all the Frank Herbert Dune books we'll ever see. Great use of music and fan art to bolster the narrative!
After watching the first video in this series I was inspired to read the novels for myself and loved them. I've been looking forward to this video for a long time. Thank you for the hard work and creativity you put into these wonderful videos! ❤
Amazing vid. This book was probably the most difficult for me to follow. This video helped me clear a few things up. Thanks for all your hard work over the years Quinn.
I read the books in my youth, and often listen to the audiobooks in these later years. And while I have always enjoyed your videos, this series of Dune videos has been outstanding. There are times I prefer them to audiobooks, as I wind down from my day. Thank you for all the time and effort. Truly. 🙋🏼♂️
Thank you! I just watched all 7 breakdown videos for the third time. I recommend these videos to anyone who wants more DUNE, but doesn't have time to read the books. The art in the videos is amazing, but you can listen to them in your car, or while doing other tasks, like a podcast.
Thank you Quinn! You’ve got me reading The Dark Forest and it is genuinely unsettling! Dune was the first series to kindle my love of sci-fi so I can’t thank you enough for this series! The wait was worth it!
I had my own moment of prescience for this video. I checked yesterday and the day before; two, three, four times I checked your channel, knowing you had a video of Chapterhouse, yet unable to find it. Yet today I check again and it is here. Thank you Quinn!
As someone who was only exposed to Dune through the original 89’s movie your videos provided an extraordinary amount of information and was articulated in way that felt like I read the books myself….thank you
I couldn't help but be struck by the pull back on the old cathode TV screen and you all in white that you were channeling The Architect from The Matrix. In a way you have been an architect building a cohesive exploration of the Dune universe. Your videos have always impressed me with their breakdowns of just how complex the whole Dune saga is. Universal themes of humanity. I do hope you find ways to keep going. I've only read a couple of the Brian Herbert books and although they don't hold a candle to his father's work I would welcome your thoughtful deep dives on them.
I kind of can't believe this video finally exists! I really appreciate the amount of effort (practical, artistic, and emotional) that went into producing this. Looking forward to marathoning your entire Ultimate Guide to Dune series next time I have 7+ hrs to spare :) I'm also very excited to see you do some graphic novel deep dives as well. Anything by BKV and Jodorowsky especially.
Quinn, you are incredible!! I now understand Dune , the later novels, so much better. I may re-read them. I have a much better appreciation of them now.
Quinn thank you for helping me become reacquainted with a universe and story I adored in my youth. Frank Herbert was a brilliant man who didn't just see complexities of the human condition and society that most miss, he used them as the heart of his epic work. Thank you for helping us see all of that more clearly Quinn!
This is a superb piece of work. A labour of love. Even though I've read all the books I was still gripped!. The structure, cadence, artwork, everything. Brilliant.
Thank you so much for sharing your love of Dune with us, Quinn! I had always been a little intimidated by it… having heard of its deeply Philosophical nature and densely layered narrative structure. Your videos helped me break up the story into digestible chunks…I really appreciate the work you’ve done to accomplish this!
Worth waiting for! Excellent video. I am unsure whether another book was planned. Maybe, maybe not. I think he could have gone on forever, and this was an ending as good as anyone. But I am always flabbergasted by FH. I consider myself an intelligent man, philosophically inclined and with an interest in religious history, but the Dune saga never ceases to amaze me. Being able to write books that are so much above even the most dedicated reader, is no small feat. And maybe my memory fails me, but Rebecca wasn't a wild Reverend mother. Her father protested against her going through the spice agony. He only did it to repay a debt. The chock Rebecca went through disgusted him. Or am I getting old? :)
It's been years since I've read it but my recollection is that you're right. Her father didn't want this for her. Mainly because he was afraid it would turn her away from the Jewish religion. And he was right, that's exactly what happened.
Best summary of Chapterhouse I've ever heard. Well done, sir. The end of this video really brings home the disappointment that Frank Herbert never finished the story and the abject failure of the supposed sequels. I'm certain that the lessons of the Butlerian Jihad we're totally lost on Brian Herbet and Anderson. I believe that the original point Frank Herbert was ultimately making was the overreaction of the Jihad and he was setting up an ultimate resolution hinted in the later novels. Some kind of human machine merging that would overcome the face dancer "Gods", perhaps? We'll never know..........
Thanks, for finally finishing this series. I remember when it started 5 years ago, and that when you earned my sub. Thanks so much. This was wonderful!
I'm so proud of you Quinn! This is excellent and the only guide I send to friends who get confused when they start reading Dune. Your passion and dedication are visible all over these videos and I just love all the artwork you find and edit at just the right moment. Awesome work!
I’m watching the ads most times I return to this video because I’m so happy it’s out!! This video is so well done. It makes me wish more channels did novel recaps like this 😭 thank you for making this video, Quinn! I’m taking my time with finishing it.
I’ve been waiting for this like everyone else, and it did not disappoint. A request. You know Herbert as well as anyone. There’s controversy about how authentic the Herbert/Anderson finale is. I’d love to hear your ideas. Where do you think it was going? I know you can’t know, but I’d love to hear your ideas.
Thank you, I've really enjoyed this series. Ive been reading these books for years now and It's nice to listen to someone who shares my love. So again... a massive thank you to everyone who worked on this series. 👍👍
The way you've broken this out into parts just shows that everything after the potential Denis Villeneuve adaptation of Dune Messiah should be in the form of serialized TV series. Very well done.
Dune is a 3 part movie, Just because of 2021 tech the story was lost again... but the internet will gush... I'll wait for a a reall Movie version (hopefully b4 I die)
Checkout all of the original music for this video! ua-cam.com/video/dtRkNuYi53E/v-deo.html
Will you ever do a video of how you think herbert would have done his final planned book?
Thanks Quinn. Don't forget about Foundation.
Quinn posts: Yeah.
It's about Dune: YEAH!
It's the final main series ultimate guide: HELL YEAH!!!!!!
(I wish I had finished books past Messiah, and could safely watch it tho......)
Have you checked out Children of Time? What's not to hate about sentient spiders?
Who is ARTIST DOES YOUR RHEME MUSIC???
It is happening!
Crossover Dune collaboration for Wizards & Warriors?!
You should do the Fremen Jihad...religious war driven by religious fervor zealocy....68 billion massacred, 10s of planets sterilized and dozens of religions wiped out....
@@cagoenlaleche!!!!
Woah Kings and generals . I love that channel
I literally just left your fourth crusade video to take a break when I noticed this was uploaded
1:07:22
"The Bene Gesserit knew that hierarchical bureaucratic systems were always in danger not because absolute power corrupts absolutely, but because power attracted the corruptible."
I like that take.
This is quoted from Frank Herbert himself in an interview in the late '60s following the success of Dune.
Frank Herbert actually said that
I can't help but disagree, because power *does* change people, and it's always at a price.
Dude, it’s perfect. I got chills every time I watched this. Creating the music for Chapterhouse was an incredible journey! Thank you for asking me to be a part of this project!
Cannot wait to see where your channel goes next! Though I kind of already know since I’m making the music for that next thing right now 🤔
You made the music for this?? that’s amazing. Right away I felt like ‘this vibe would be really fitting for a theatrical Chapterhouse’
Wait how many times have you watched this
Hell yeah! Way to go, man!
Fantastic music! I’m so impressed
I love when content creators vibe. Great video Q you know we all waited for it.
And Quinn wept. For there were no more worlds left to conquer.
There is... another... a legend. A treasure not as bright as the original 6, but purer than the false idols that came after them... *Revenant*
Lol . Alexander the great
Actually Dean Craig Pelton@@shanenolan8252
THANK YOU for CHAPTERHOUSE - DUNE, Quinn!
It's been a long time, but well worth the wait!
agreed thank you quinn!
Despite having read Chapter House so many times, your narrative makes it seem like it's the first time. Great job :D
Nicely said I think I missed a lot - during my reads.
Not your fault, it's definitely a challenging reading
This is why I live Quinn’s ideas!
Is it as confusing as how Quinn makes it seem?
It's interesting how the Dune books seem to oscillate between books that feel tight in their plotting and books that feel dense in their depths. God Emperor and Chapterhouse feel at times monolithic in the weight of their themes and the scope of their vision, whereas Children and Heretics have more of an adventurous tone to them that makes them more satisfying on initial read, but the God Emperor and Chapterhouse are the wellsprings I keep going back to, if that makes sense.
I can't say it any better than you have!
🙌👏 Well said. Packed full of soul food in those books!
absolutely true
still, i do also love going back to both children and heretics.
Aptly put!
If i start a DUNE book-any DUNE book- i have to read all six of them. I don't bother with the expanded universe.
"Everything about you is a cesspool. You have no style."
It was too much.
Best line in the book, I genuinely laughed.
My guess is that the concept of breakaway Face Dancers with Daniel and Marty was one similar to Other Memories of BG and Leto II. They capture personas of others so perfectly, so completely that each person added becomes another Other Memory in their mind, and who knows, maybe each of their Other Memories as well. That would mean their knowledge and vision would increase geometrically with each added persona, combined with their far superior technology, turning them into Kwisatz Haderach-like beings, far beyond even Leto II's or Duncan's and Teg's capabilities. Yet through all of that, they have no inherent personal identity, they must create one themselves. There is an artificiality to them, a sort of antithesis to what humanity is, as seen and described by Herbert.
I don't know what their purpose was, or if it was anything beyond a self insert by Herbert and his partner, but whatever it was, I think they ultimately failed at it when it comes to Duncan and the no-ship. The feeling I got when Duncan set the no-ship towards an unknown destination they were forever separated from the rest of the story, the Old Empire, the Matres and the Ones of Many Faces. That's a real Scattering moment, setting out blindly into an unknown corner of a seemingly infinite universe. Once the travel was complete, they were truly and completely alone, separated from everything they had ever known. I would assume Frank would have brought them into contact with another pocket of Scattering in the next book, using that opportunity to explore other dimensions of the Scattering and its effects on humanity. I don't see any reason why any of the characters in the no-ship would ever have a reason to or have the means to return to the Old Empire. Who knows, there isn't much to go on with.
Back in the Old Empire I would expect a lot of disorder and restlessness happening due the unification of BG and HM, the breaking down of the dogmas of the Butlerian Jihad, and the anxious anticipation of the inevitable arrival of the Ones with Many Faces. It sounds like the buildup to Kralizec, and if the no-ship crew were somehow tied to it from the other end, it would be very interesting. Perhaps on the contrary to what Frank's son imagined, the machines weren't going to be the great enemy, but the future of the BG/HM organization, with their first steps towards Cyborg production taken. Maybe the point was going to be that humanity had finally evolved and progressed enough to reintegrate artificial intelligence into the human society, and that would somehow work towards the establishment of a universal democracy that Frank once hinted would be the ending point of the series.
Anyway, congrats on finishing your grand project! It has been a fun journey and has also been great to discover others as passionate about Dune as I am. I personally would not be interested in delving into Brian Herbert's books in the slightest, as from the most basic outline they clearly and grossly miss Frank's vision, but others might disagree with me. I would personally recommend you the Mars trilogy by Kim Stanley Robinson, whose writing is somewhat similar to that of GRRM. I think you would enjoy them a lot, and I'd love to see your take on them too.
If there was only one comment one this video, I would vote that this would be it. It's an unique yet comprehensive take on the material and I really like the "alternative' ending you but forth. We will never know, but your theories and points make sense.
That's a great take on what the 7th book could have been.
I kinda agree with you that the Brian Herbert books just wouldn't be worth a deep dive, but even though I hate where they took the series after Frank's death I still find myself intrigued by them and would like to see Quinn describe the whole shitshow, especially as I'm never gonna read them!
Also great take on where the 7th book would have gone, I think you're pretty close to the mark
@@darren806 I did read them, years ago, & while I agree with you, I also enjoyed them quite a bit.
I too would greatly enjoy a deep dive into them
Your Ultimate Guides helped me get through the toughest part of my life after my accident. I can’t count how many times I’ve listened to each one. I would even listen to them in my sleep. Your voice, the music, the images, your wording have all been perfect and life/ sanity saving. Now I am living what feels like the start of a peak in my life, a time of reinvention and self discovery/ evolution. This final Ultimate Guide could not have come at a more perfect time of my life. Thank you for putting so much thought and passion into these invaluable and timeless works!
Hope you're feeling better now homie
@@LordBathtub I AM. Thank You! 🙏
Thats amazing to hear, often you see comments seeing that videos are helping people in a real low but rarely that they’ve now been able to recover somewhat, its a very hopeful thing to hear, and i hope all of us have that sort of development one day if we feel like we’re at a low right now.
I've always been devastated that Frank Herbert died before completing his vision. I don't think where Brian and KJA took the series was the original intent. The face dancers became something more than themselves. I want to hear that story
Absolutely right Jake. I firmly believe that the Premature death of Frank Herbert was one of the greatest losses to literature in the last century. Who among us can imagine what truths about human nature would have been transmitted by the final novel?
Nah, I still kinda think Frank intended the machines to always be the great enemy. It’s viable that the face dancers ran into Erasmus and were altered.
@@darthbrooks4933 Also face dancers have always been bio machine hybrids!!
They were " thinking machines" in violation of the jihad , humanity just didn't realise it yet .
Once again they had made machine slaves who had the potential to become enemies!
Humanity was so focused on inorganic machine enemies yet they replicated biological ones
I still think machines really were defeated and if necessary could be defeated again however humanity has never faced a mass face dancer attack
I think the face dancers did combine with some machine remnant but they were the superiors , it had already been proven that biological machines are more powerful
the story is exactly as herbert wanted he wrote the ending already..if you dont like it fine but dont blame Brain and KJA for the plot - their writitng might suck but the story is the story
The ultimate truth is we do not know
It's been 84 years.... thanks for making this!!!!
I can only imagine how much work went into this masterpiece. Thank you Quinn and Jamez!
You’re in for a ride!
Is Jamez the editor or is this a Collab?
I'm currently on the third book thanks to you and the movie, so I'll skip this one to avoid spoilers. But here's my comment and like as a thank you, Quinn; this channel should blow up as the years pass and it's well deserved.
Enjoy! I deeply enjoyed Children of Dune.
@@timbertome2443 great book, probably my favorite so far, but I'm with God Emperor now so that might change x)
Book 4 is a doozy just a heads up 3 much easier to read than 4. Quinn's review was much better than reading book 4
Clearly Quinn's promises can be trusted to be fulfilled, no matter how long it takes. A plan coming to fruition across countless generations of youtube videos!
Hail God Emperor Quinn! May we never stray from his golden path
Having encountered you years ago, myself a self anointed Dune expert, I absolutely love your breakdowns and analysis. I’ve waited a long time for this one.
Dune expert, eh? So what was the statistics given to Paul on the fremen jihad?
@@calvinsuu1949 sorry, I seldom ever comment on a video and just saw my comment got a reply, haha.
You must be referring to Dune Messiah when Paul asks Korba for some specific historical reels about his jihad. Something along the line of tens of billions killed, 90 planets sterilized and 500 or more completely demoralized. Along with the eradication of countless other religions. Korba stated unbelievers, all of them, and Paul states, no, believers all of them.
@@thomaswatson1420 yes somewhat correct...due to paul's control of spacung guild the fremen travelled from planet to planet spreading his prophecy and the human universe simply couldnt do anything
It's crazy to think how influential your coverage of the Dune series is. You got me into the books in 2019, and you really helped create the market for dune on the internet. You definitely deserve some credit for the popularity of the films that we are getting.
Hopefully he gets some money too ha
@@thecarter8700you don’t get it without attribution
I have to agree with the Organism. I always thought Daniel and Marty were meta characters, like a self-insert from Frank Herbert, meant to be Frank Herbert and his wife, Beverly Herbert. I got the feeling he knew he wasn't going to be able to complete the story, so those two characters, gardening, watching the inhabitants of the no-ship, discussing them getting away, and their plans for them, were like Herbert admitting the ending had escaped him, perhaps due to age or health, as the couple gardening invoked images or feelings of an older, retired couple, reflecting on life, and the inhabitants of the no-ship, Herbert's characters, his creations, were like his children, and he had great hopes, dreams, and plans for them, but he knew he wouldn't be able to see what becomes of them. I certainly never thought they were robots from before the Butlerian Jihad, though I did think the Honored Matres may have been feeling some remanent of the old thinking machines who were trying to go on with their existence beyond the human occupied space, only to have their ancient enemy and creators invade their space. But then again, I wasn't the one to find boxes and boxes of notes in an attic that contradict much of what was actually written in the original novels, so what do I know of Frank Herbert's intentions for continuing the Dune universe...
In that case...the planet of testing would be Pandora. 😉
Hence my refusal to see the "extended universe" sequels as canon...
And you are totally miss reading what has happened.
I also think, Chapterhouse was a worthy end to the story. I mean, the "universe" has pre-novel history (that includes the main characters) and it will a post-novel future. And the end of Chapterhouse either resolved the most important plot-lines or put them well on their way to be resolved in a post-novel future.
Mind you, Frank was not someone who explained his universe beyond what was actually necessary to tell the story, leaving much open to individual interpretation... which would also be in line with the vast time-frame (in which truth is easily lost in legend). Thus, leaving open what was left open at the end of Chapterhouse is a good way to conclude Dune.
That said, I don't think the son's sequels are as bad as they are often made out to be. Of course they are far from "daddy's" books. But a nice and interesting continuation and conclusion. My biggest problem with them is the whole Facedancers on Ithaca plot line... that was so infuriatingly lazy writing. Mentats such as Duncan and Miles would have never allowed them to remain undetected for this long... not with all the signs and evidence that had been piling on from the very day when they "escaped" from the Handlers' homeworld. Did they really believe, the old Rabbi was "sporty" enough to flee? Did they really believe that Thufir's awakening failed because the "witches" failed?? Did they really not connect the dots between the saboteurs skillfully evading security systems without a traitor among those who set them up and controlled them? Did they really not remember that the Rabbi was with Thufir on the Handlers' world, when it was revealed that he was a Facedancer?? Did they really not think about properly locking the doors of the interrogation room (or the bridge or any other vital place)?? Would Miles really not have stepped in to catch the revealed Facedancer, before he killed the guards and went to the bridge?? Why didn't any of the Reverend Mothers with their superior fighting skills step in at that point??
This made me rage-quit multiple times... though I'm glad that I picked the book up again to read to the end. It's a bit too hunky-dory, when compared to Frank's novels, but I think it is a nice conclusion. And were it not for that disastrously bad Facedancers on Ithaca plotline, it would actually be a rather good book. Still not on "daddy's" Level, but still good.
I agree with you. Herbert’s wife had cancer and he devoted much of his time to care for her so probably had no time to write a 7th book. He leaves it for each of us to figure it out. I think it’s a great ending as life continues and we don’t always have to know the future… Idaho and Sheana escape prescience.
Another highly anticipated ultimate guide, the best yet! Fantastic music too. I am very glad I dropped everything to watch this. A perfect example of why you should always have notifications turned on for Quinn's Ideas. Excellent work as always Quinn, always worth the wait 💜
Three years ago, I came for the Game of Thrones lore, but I stayed for the Dune lore ^^
But what I actually wanted to say was that you and your Ultimate Guide are the reason I got into Dune. Thank you so much for that.
Quinn helped me get into Dune a few years ago and its great to see his channel grow. Glad we finally got this guide.
AFTER WATCHING THE DUNE MOVIE MY INTEREST IN READING WAS SPARKED AGAIN, AFTER READING EACH BOOK I WOULD ALWAYS WATCH THESE VIDEOS TO MAKE SURE I DIDNT MISS ANYTHING OR JUST SIMPLY HEAR THE LORE AGAIN, I LOVE LISTENING ON A LONG DRIVE OR BEFORE I SLEEP, BEEN WAITING FOR CHAPTERHOUSE THANK YOU, HOPE ALL IS WELL QUINN GGOD BLESS YOU
Quinn is the dune GOAT let's be honest, once I'm done reading the first law trilogy I'm going to check out the dune books! Cheers Quinn my lad, and happy Easter eh
Did you mean "First Law trilogy"?
@@eddiepolo6047 woops yah totally did
Amazing series!
I highly recommend continuing on with the 3 "stand-alones" and "The Age of Madness" trilogy.
They're all one big part of "The First Law" story.
As for Dune, Frank Herbert's first 6 original Dune books is all you need to read of that story. And maybe the Dune Encyclopedia, if you can get your hands on a copy.
@@eddiepolo6047 I'm halfway through the second book and I agree man, awesome series and I LOVE the way Joe writes his characters, I've heard good things about the stand-alones, I'll definitely check them out! :)
Thank you Quinn for taking us on this beautiful tale.
BRAVO!!!! It was worth the wait! I would love if you did a Quinn Talks unscripted video on where you think Dune Book 7 may have gone in more detail based solely on your opinion, and conjecture from what the previous novels seemed to have been setting up throughout the six original novels. Even better still would be if you maybe decided to do a full fan fiction on Dune Book 7. Whether it be in a video format, or written form; I would be happy with either. Any direction you may take the story has got to be better than the hot mess we got stuck with in Hunters and Sandworms of Dune. I definitely consider your interpretations as the most consistent with what Frank Herbert seems to have intended of all the content currently available. Diskette of Dune Book 7 notes in a deposit box be damned! Congratulations, and I hope you continue with more Dune content in some form on your channel. Thanks for everything you have done to make Dune resonate to everyone.
That would be pretty interesting to me also. I never read any of the sequels/prequels, so my last experience of Dune is the conclusion of Chapterhouse Dune. It's haunting because it hints at a very different direction the next book might go. I like to think that the feared enemy the Honored Matres were running away from was Daniel and Marty ... just those two, and the minions under their thrall.
To me, it makes sense that it would be just those two. If these advanced face dancers absorb others, why not each other? The end result would be that only the strongest remain, absorbing all the others. But being aware of the deep loneliness of Leto II, they would end with two remaining rather than one, just so they'd have each other to talk to.
Anyway, the sheer power of these two hints that the universe beyond the "net" is full of similarly powerful and dangerous entities ... ones that weren't so weak like the Honored Matres that they'd need to run away back to the old imperium.
So that's the sort of realm I imagined we'd see in the next book. I imagined Duncan and the others thrown into a completely unknown unimaginably expansive realm where they were motes among giants. I imagined that like Daniel and Marty, these giants would be quintessentially homo sapiens, so they are the true fulfillment of Leto's Golden Path. Those caught in the "net" would be doomed dead-enders to the machine killers. That Duncan and a small handful of others somehow managed to escape the net was luck, rather than part of any plan.
I don't know what Herbert may have planned. I just imagine that if he had gone in this direction, it would creatively free him up to bring in completely new beings with very different themes and messages to convey.
Dahl's music is AMAZING. The music, laced in parallel with Quinn's narration, makes for an auditory masterpiece. Chef's Kiss 👏🏾 👏🏾 👏🏾
Yes! This is my favorite outside of the original Dune. I. Am. Stoked.
I remember finding your videos on DUNE and yelled out loud "Yes! FINALLY!" It was such a privilege to follow your videos as you posted them.
Frank Herbert not finishing Dune is like the burning of the library of Alexandria. it feels like a huge piece of the human story is gone forever.
He did finish it.
maybe chat gtp can do it
@@newsmansuper2925 Dune 7.... sounds very woke.... 🤣
The sand was a fiery orange as the sun began to set over Arrakis. It was a time of change, a time of awakening. The old ways were no longer enough, no longer relevant to the complex world that was emerging. The people of Arrakis were waking up to new possibilities, to new ways of thinking and being.
At the heart of this change was the spontaneous movement known as reformers. They were a group of individuals who rejected the strict order and conformity of the old ways, choosing instead to embrace freedom, creativity, and individuality. They sought to break down the rigid hierarchy of the past and build a new society based on equality and respect for all.
@@uthikoloshe Chat GTP must want to an hero beng forec to write this way
@@newsmansuper2925 that defies the jihad though
You've done it. You've really done it. You've captured the highlights, choice clips of the philosophy, the wheels within wheels feel of Dune, and even steered around a few of the unnecessarily clunky bits. I could listen to this all day. Thank you Quinn!
And at this point - I would take your guess at a fitting sequel storyline in preference to any others I've seen.
I've adored this series Quinn, thank you so much for all the effort and time you take into these guides.
I'm only 16 mins into this video, but I felt compelled to say "this is fucking amazing" already. I first stumbled upon your channel a few years ago, searching for Dune videos on UA-cam, and quickly became addicted to this channel. You have great taste in literature, and I love the way that you analyze and present these stories. I know this last video has been a long time coming, and it does not disappoint at all. I'm beyond excited to watch this video of you analyzing my favorite of Frank Herbert's books.
The music is also unreal; it definitely sets a tone and gives the video depth within depth. lol.
You are a one-of-a-kind channel, Quinn. Great fucking job, and keep up the amazing work!
No way this is out! Time for a glass o wine and a classy evening with Quinn
I started reading Dune today, all thanks to you.
I've been falling asleep to your playlists for a couple weeks now, learning all about Dune.
Thanks for giving meaning to my life.
Come on now, surely your life has lots of meaning? You might just not have discovered the meaning yet, that's all.
@@Emanon... Huh? Sure man I have plenty of meaning to my life, but listening to these stories as I fall asleep has greatly helped me in ways I can't convey. Don't make it weird. It's not that deep.
What a journey! I've been around since (near) the beginning, and when you shifted to Dune, I was so excited, because until then I'd never really had anyone to geek out over Dune with, besides my uncle (who now watches your channel). I was in sixth grade reading Chapterhouse when Frank passed away, so it's always been a fascinating puzzle box to me. Keep up the amazing content, Quinn!
Thank you for all your effort. I first stumbled across your youtube channel several years ago and enjoyed your content on Dune back then. But, I "lost" your channel as I went through several moves and career changes. One day a few months ago, I wondered, "whatever happened to that youtube channel on Dune I loved so much?" And wow, you've added so much more great content. Do continue with your work! You do an awesome job.
The first 4 dune books are great but i feel the last 2 are underrated masterpieces in their own way. They have so much weight behind them. Chapterhouse and heretics may not be as iconic as the first or children uf dune, but i really do enjoy re-reading them every now and again just so i can re-visit their batshit craziness lol
Better than book one what are you talking about makes no sense.
Think I speak for everyone when I say. Thank you so much Quinn for going to all this effort 👍👍
Whoooooa it is finally time!!!! What a way to start my Sunday! Thank you Quinn!
Yes, I honestly thought you'd given up or something else happened and you'd decided to not finish, been waiting so long thank you so much these are pure gold content
Hell of a way to celebrate Easter! Thanks Quinn :-)
I started watching the first part of this epic series nearly five years ago. It's amazing. Now we've finally gotten the conclusion to Frank Herbert's original series.
I just finished Chapterhouse and I loved it. Miles Teg might be my favourite character of the saga.
Thank you Quinn. This series has rekindled my love for Dune, and has been inspiring a lot of new ideas inside of me. These videos have been truly impressive, well made and a sincere love letter to Herbert's universe. Thank you for all the entertainment, and your hard work / passion.
Wow it's finally here! Congratulations on finishing it Quinn, been waiting for this for so long!
OMG , I gave up believing this day would come. THANK YOU !!!
It was great to finally see this! Thank you for making the Ultimate Guide to Dune series! I wouldn’t have continued the other books after Dune if it weren’t for Part 1. Your Chapterhouse video was great and the music is fantastic!
I've been sitting outside in the sun smoking a brisket and listening to this all day.
Great day!
Hey Quinn! You were the reason I finally sat down and read/listened to all the Dune books. I came for the Dune, stayed for Ideas of Ice and Fire. But I love that now your channel is all about YOUR Ideas! Keep up the great work!
Hey Quinn, I can't believe it's been 5 years. Great work again bro, and thank you for your work and genuine love for our favorite sci fi. You the man.
I have waited so long for this! Thank you for blessing us Quinn.
I look forward to seeing your posts. What excellent narrative, editing and production.
Holy smokes, I had to make sure I had time to watch this in one sitting, and I'm glad I did. I got some friends of mine (also from the Netherlands) that only know the Dune movie(s) or even just the Westwood games, to check your channel for more a way more in-depth look at the Dune universe than they could ever imagine there was after just the games and movie.
Your channel rekindled my love for the Dune saga all over again, and 20 years after reading the books, I will start reading them again soon. Thank you so much for that!
Excellent work, Quinn! I love the Dune series so much and there’s no way I could possibly have summarized it as effectively as you have with these 7 videos. Thank you for your hard work!
when i die and if i go to the afterlife. the first thing I will be doing is finding frankherbert and asking him to tell me the end of this series. when starting this series I had no idea it was never finished. there will forever be a dune sized hole in my heart, mind, and soul
How beautifully said
Quinn, this was really extraordinary. I think you captured the feel and wonder of Frank Herbert's Dune books beautifully. I have listened to all 7 of your Ultimate Guides and have enjoyed them immensely. Thank you so much for this incredible piece of work. I think it will stand as an important analysis of Frank Herbert's work. I think you captured Frank Herbert's intensions very faithfully. It is one of my most favorite series of books, and I have read and reread them in my life. I have always spent a lot of time thinking about what it meant. I have incorparated many of Frank's ideas into my own beliefs about how to live a life, as well as how to be a good leader and person. Your Guides have given me new thoughts about the ideas of Dune. I will reread the books again later in my life. I will continue to follow your wonderful work in the future. Thank-you very much, Brendan
Thank you for another banger, Quinn - you've made quite probably the only complete "version" of all the Frank Herbert Dune books we'll ever see. Great use of music and fan art to bolster the narrative!
QUINN has struck gold again. My brother has done it again!!!! 👏🏿👍🏿👐👌
After watching the first video in this series I was inspired to read the novels for myself and loved them. I've been looking forward to this video for a long time. Thank you for the hard work and creativity you put into these wonderful videos! ❤
Seriously as a guy that loves the story but hasn't read the books I deeply appreciate it. I really am grateful. Keep the Sci Fi coming please!
Amazing vid. This book was probably the most difficult for me to follow. This video helped me clear a few things up. Thanks for all your hard work over the years Quinn.
I've been a huge fan of your guide to dune series. Happy to see chapter house
Hey Quinn, I wanted to thank you. Because of your channel I started reading the Dune cycle. I finished god emperor a few days ago, loved it!
Worth the wait in every wait, Quinn. You’ve outdone yourself. Excellent musical addition, and mixing.
I read the books in my youth, and often listen to the audiobooks in these later years. And while I have always enjoyed your videos, this series of Dune videos has been outstanding. There are times I prefer them to audiobooks, as I wind down from my day.
Thank you for all the time and effort. Truly.
🙋🏼♂️
You finally did it! Congrats, this is a really impressive achievement
Thank you! I just watched all 7 breakdown videos for the third time. I recommend these videos to anyone who wants more DUNE, but doesn't have time to read the books. The art in the videos is amazing, but you can listen to them in your car, or while doing other tasks, like a podcast.
Ayyyeeee Thanks for the hard work Quinn, Tadhya was great btw
Thank you Quinn! You’ve got me reading The Dark Forest and it is genuinely unsettling! Dune was the first series to kindle my love of sci-fi so I can’t thank you enough for this series! The wait was worth it!
Thank you so much for this. I have listened to all of the and appreciated your hard work
4:49 That's Mars. I'm so happy I can now recognize it anywhere.
Great job with this one, man. Quite possibly your best work.
I had my own moment of prescience for this video. I checked yesterday and the day before; two, three, four times I checked your channel, knowing you had a video of Chapterhouse, yet unable to find it.
Yet today I check again and it is here.
Thank you Quinn!
It's here!!
Thank you for all you put in!
Do a Malazan Deep Dive please!!
god THIS would be almost too perfect. O_O
As someone who was only exposed to Dune through the original 89’s movie your videos provided an extraordinary amount of information and was articulated in way that felt like I read the books myself….thank you
I waited too long for this final chapter. Thank you Quinn!
I couldn't help but be struck by the pull back on the old cathode TV screen and you all in white that you were channeling The Architect from The Matrix. In a way you have been an architect building a cohesive exploration of the Dune universe. Your videos have always impressed me with their breakdowns of just how complex the whole Dune saga is. Universal themes of humanity.
I do hope you find ways to keep going. I've only read a couple of the Brian Herbert books and although they don't hold a candle to his father's work I would welcome your thoughtful deep dives on them.
I kind of can't believe this video finally exists! I really appreciate the amount of effort (practical, artistic, and emotional) that went into producing this. Looking forward to marathoning your entire Ultimate Guide to Dune series next time I have 7+ hrs to spare :)
I'm also very excited to see you do some graphic novel deep dives as well. Anything by BKV and Jodorowsky especially.
Quinn, you are incredible!! I now understand Dune , the later novels, so much better. I may re-read them. I have a much better appreciation of them now.
oh this just made my day! might not have gotten an easter basket from my mom but at least we got this! thanks Quinn's Ideas!
This piece had a clarity that I required to revisit Chapterhouse again, 25 years since I first read it. Awesome work!
Thank you for all your hard work on these guides Quinn. The best Dune content on UA-cam.
Quinn thank you for helping me become reacquainted with a universe and story I adored in my youth. Frank Herbert was a brilliant man who didn't just see complexities of the human condition and society that most miss, he used them as the heart of his epic work.
Thank you for helping us see all of that more clearly Quinn!
I'm 5 min in, and I gotta say, love the added production value -- it's awesome
This is a superb piece of work. A labour of love. Even though I've read all the books I was still gripped!. The structure, cadence, artwork, everything. Brilliant.
S A M P L E T E X T
For real though, great job as always, and some amazing art choices. Thanks for finishing this out!
Thank you so much for sharing your love of Dune with us, Quinn! I had always been a little intimidated by it… having heard of its deeply Philosophical nature and densely layered narrative structure. Your videos helped me break up the story into digestible chunks…I really appreciate the work you’ve done to accomplish this!
Worth waiting for! Excellent video. I am unsure whether another book was planned. Maybe, maybe not. I think he could have gone on forever, and this was an ending as good as anyone. But I am always flabbergasted by FH. I consider myself an intelligent man, philosophically inclined and with an interest in religious history, but the Dune saga never ceases to amaze me.
Being able to write books that are so much above even the most dedicated reader, is no small feat. And maybe my memory fails me, but Rebecca wasn't a wild Reverend mother. Her father protested against her going through the spice agony. He only did it to repay a debt. The chock Rebecca went through disgusted him. Or am I getting old? :)
It's been years since I've read it but my recollection is that you're right. Her father didn't want this for her. Mainly because he was afraid it would turn her away from the Jewish religion. And he was right, that's exactly what happened.
Best summary of Chapterhouse I've ever heard. Well done, sir. The end of this video really brings home the disappointment that Frank Herbert never finished the story and the abject failure of the supposed sequels. I'm certain that the lessons of the Butlerian Jihad we're totally lost on Brian Herbet and Anderson. I believe that the original point Frank Herbert was ultimately making was the overreaction of the Jihad and he was setting up an ultimate resolution hinted in the later novels. Some kind of human machine merging that would overcome the face dancer "Gods", perhaps? We'll never know..........
Thanks, for finally finishing this series. I remember when it started 5 years ago, and that when you earned my sub. Thanks so much. This was wonderful!
I'm so proud of you Quinn! This is excellent and the only guide I send to friends who get confused when they start reading Dune. Your passion and dedication are visible all over these videos and I just love all the artwork you find and edit at just the right moment. Awesome work!
Best Dune Videos on the Internet. Been waiting for this one!
I’m watching the ads most times I return to this video because I’m so happy it’s out!! This video is so well done. It makes me wish more channels did novel recaps like this 😭 thank you for making this video, Quinn! I’m taking my time with finishing it.
I’ve been waiting for this like everyone else, and it did not disappoint.
A request. You know Herbert as well as anyone. There’s controversy about how authentic the Herbert/Anderson finale is.
I’d love to hear your ideas. Where do you think it was going? I know you can’t know, but I’d love to hear your ideas.
Thank you, I've really enjoyed this series. Ive been reading these books for years now and It's nice to listen to someone who shares my love. So again... a massive thank you to everyone who worked on this series. 👍👍
The way you've broken this out into parts just shows that everything after the potential Denis Villeneuve adaptation of Dune Messiah should be in the form of serialized TV series. Very well done.
Dune is a 3 part movie, Just because of 2021 tech the story was lost again... but the internet will gush... I'll wait for a a reall Movie version (hopefully b4 I die)
Great vid! I want them to make movies up through God Emperor but I think the last two books would do best as a 2 season limited series.
This is incredible work.
I know what I'm doing this afternoon. So glad this dropped now.