"It won't hurt you," they say

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 чер 2024
  • Purcell Prusiks are personal anchors that are supposedly "safer" because they slip. We show you how to tie them and we tested them a bunch in this episode. Our data is on our blog at www.hownot2.com/post/purcell
    Other episodes referenced:
    Prusik Tests • Prusik, Auto Blocks, a...
    Falling on Ascenders • Does PURCELL PRUSSIK s...
    Can you Prusik 2 ropes • Can you prusik double ...
    Girth Hitch Testing • This seems sharp
    Cow Tail Testing • This would BREAK your ...
    Sign up for our newsletter for our giveaways www.hownot2.com/sign-up
    👉 Learn and SHOP at www.hownot2.com/shop
    👉 Best EMAILS on Earth: www.hownot2.com/signup
    👉 SUPPORT US and get gear discounts hownot2.com/support
    👉 10% off ROCKY TALKIE by clicking www.hownot2.com/rocky
    00:00 It slips they say
    00:39 What is a prusik
    02:01 What is a purcell prusik and how to tie it
    05:27 Uses for Purcell Prusik
    07:59 Pros and cons
    09:12 Slow pulls
    10:43 When do you break
    11:51 Drop Tests
    14:09 Rabbit trails
    17:54 Graphs and Charts

КОМЕНТАРІ • 219

  • @HowNOT2
    @HowNOT2  11 місяців тому +10

    Sign up for our newsletter for our giveaways www.hownot2.com/sign-up

    • @TrueHelpTV
      @TrueHelpTV 11 місяців тому +1

      Much love, thank you *I wish we were neighbors

  • @J.Cannon420
    @J.Cannon420 9 місяців тому +19

    This beginner who's trying not to die appreciates knowing that prusiks should be 3mm narrower than the host rope. Thank you!

  • @hoggif
    @hoggif 11 місяців тому +79

    This is interesting to get more into different type of personal anchors. Looking forward to seeing Petzl adjust and hopefully Kong slyde as well. I guess that would cover almost all common personal anchors.

    • @testboga5991
      @testboga5991 11 місяців тому +6

      Absolutely! Do the Petzl adjust and Kong Slyde!😊

    • @tubosolinas
      @tubosolinas 11 місяців тому

      @@testboga5991 for the Kong Kisa also!

    • @thefack149
      @thefack149 11 місяців тому +3

      Petzl adjust is just so smooth and with an eashook it's so fast. Bulky, yes, but so quick to deploy and take slack

    • @scottmartin7213
      @scottmartin7213 11 місяців тому +1

      Vote for petzl adjust

    • @hoggif
      @hoggif 11 місяців тому

      @@thefack149 I never noticed eashook. That could be so handy in some applications and you can attach it to a sawn loop too (unlike some other similar models I have).
      In general use I tend to find triple locking carabiners or ball lock ones quite fast to use.

  • @trollmcclure1884
    @trollmcclure1884 11 місяців тому +23

    I've tried the two finger method and it really makes the hole bigger. Excellent

  • @kevinorr6880
    @kevinorr6880 11 місяців тому +14

    I appreciated this simply because of the knit tying tutorial. Then, additionally the shock absorption was quite interesting. I’m not a fall-geek, and still enjoyed your efforts.

  • @BudgetAdventure
    @BudgetAdventure 7 місяців тому +5

    as a user of the Purcell Prusik, this is a super useful video! I use a 3 /2 wrap instead of just having 3 wraps on each side.

  • @chrissonnenschein6634
    @chrissonnenschein6634 11 місяців тому +10

    Been using things like this purcell prussik for roof and chimey jobs for years. Never taught , but seemed good use of knot skills learned in my youth helping arborists. So glad to see testing on something I do. But yes, It is not my sole safety for steep pitch or other serious consideration where I may think a deadly whipper would be on the agenda before the next break.

  • @GrigoraAus
    @GrigoraAus 11 місяців тому +4

    I find an easy way to make the purcell is to make the Prussik on an empty toilet paper roll, that way it's shaped nicely and easy to dress. then put the other end through and then pull out the roll and tighten.
    Yes other methods are easy enough, but especially on longer purcells its nice to get all the twists out and such before putting it through the prussik and this holds it all in place nicely.

  • @novadea1643
    @novadea1643 11 місяців тому +3

    Very interesting, goes to show that no matter what kind of PAS you're using DO NOT FALL ON IT, at best you'll be hurting.

  • @stereothrilla8374
    @stereothrilla8374 11 місяців тому +5

    I use this as an adjustable manual handbrake on a temporary rope zip line on my property. It trails behind the zip line pulley with no weight on it. You lightly wrap your hand around it (with gloves on of course) and as you’re approaching the end of the line you take your hand off. As the prusik is trailing the pulley and all of your forward momentum and weight are on the pulley which is clipped into your harness as the prusik starts to engage it starts to shift your weight from the pulley to having your weight on the prusik giving you a soft catch. Work’s beautifully! As the pulley then naturally travels back to you as it has less resistance, it shifts your weight back onto the pulley at which point you can easily reach up and tend the prusik with your hand again. The system also does a wonderful job at not turning you into a human pendulum. I know this is not ideal zip line setup but for a line that gets moved around the property and setup with dramatically varying levels of speed and height the system works extremely well. Way better than trying to rig and re rig tire, compression spring or bungee breaking systems all the time.

    • @heli400
      @heli400 5 місяців тому

      Nice! just check it for wear often, going fast on a zip line you'd have to worry about friction melting the prusik

  • @boondocksaintsfan
    @boondocksaintsfan 11 місяців тому +8

    Not sure if this is going to make sense, but there are two concepts I was given for the Purcell Prusik.
    1st: You can tie it with the knot inside the prusik loop to maximize how short you can make the loop, but limits the extension a little. The std design with the knot outside of it limits how short you can make it.
    2nd: This concept came from an OG SAR climber I know...you can make double Purcell Prusik by using a much longer cord (30'?), and tying a second Prusik on the tail end (where you usually connect to your harness) after completing the construction of the std Purcell. You then pass the first/completed Purcell Prusik through that second one and you can girth hitch the middle to your hard points. This gives you two adjustable tethers (and a mountain of cord).

  • @andyman127
    @andyman127 11 місяців тому +1

    The consistency of inconsistent materials is super comforting, and these videos are great for understanding climbing systems.
    Thank you

  • @niknik0815
    @niknik0815 10 місяців тому

    Dude, your videos have gotten soooo much better! And still improving man, this was such a good video!! Thank you!

  • @JCO2002
    @JCO2002 10 місяців тому +5

    Glad I'm a caver, not a climber. We don't have to worry about shock-loading. All of our lines are static, most of them 11mm pit rope. Avoid sharp edges and you're fine. In fact, we have a couple of 13mm static ropes that will cut a groove in the limestone rather than get damaged themselves. We use those for fast and dirty recon of new sites. The only drawback is they're very heavy.

    • @nomars4827
      @nomars4827 19 днів тому

      Glad I'm a sofa rester, not a caver or climber. We don't have to worry about ropes and knots.

  • @mountainmandoug
    @mountainmandoug 11 місяців тому +6

    This is an outstanding video. So informative, covering the topic so well. I will recommend it to many people.

  • @tehrater480
    @tehrater480 10 місяців тому

    Been waiting for this!!! Thank you so much, can’t wait wait for the next one

  • @2002mitchell
    @2002mitchell 7 місяців тому +1

    Love the Purcell Prusik on a loop! I've been using them for over 10 years as my primary anchor system. I use 2 of them as my PAS for sport climbing and 1 when multi-pitch climbing. 6mm accessory cord tied with a double fishermans knot girth hitched to my harness hard points It's so nice to be able to easily get into the most comfortable position at an anchor. Great video, thanks for testing!

  • @razia9689
    @razia9689 11 місяців тому

    Great video! Even though it was a long one you packed in so much information and clever tests.
    I can see myself sharing this with people in the future :)

  • @kulmajaba
    @kulmajaba 11 місяців тому +5

    Great stuff. I use a Purcell prusik as a personal anchor, but I place the double fisherman close to the prusik knot to maximise the length adjustability. Probably doesn't effect the strength much but a friend had the double fisherman get partially inside the prusik when the prusik got loose, so that's a risk to be aware of.

  • @brandondone2888
    @brandondone2888 11 місяців тому +1

    Great video Ryan. Loved the "how to" set it up with different examples. Thank you.

  • @harlanstockman5703
    @harlanstockman5703 11 місяців тому +1

    From now on, this will be the youtube video I'll search for when i try to remember how to tie this!

  • @danielwendell542
    @danielwendell542 11 місяців тому

    Super informative, and love some Prusik knots!

  • @pierceklinke13
    @pierceklinke13 11 місяців тому +10

    Cool to see these results! I use a 60cm nylon sling (girth hitched) for my PAS when single pitch climbing and when I am multipitch climbing I always clove in using my rope. Seems like regardless of what method you use, the basic gist is don't go above the anchor and if you do then don't fall onto your PAS

  • @testboga5991
    @testboga5991 11 місяців тому +1

    Second video on your channel that covers a topic I was just researching by chance 😂

  • @sakithree
    @sakithree 11 місяців тому +2

    This is all super interesting!! But, I'd also love to see some less "extreme" fall examples.
    Yes, I know these fall factor ~2 falls are interesting to see, and it's always fun to see gear break.
    However, I think some "sensible" falls where the person isn't really above the attachment point (FF < 1) would be very informational!!
    It would be amazing to be able to see the different forces one would feel if one fell on pas (dyneema loops), dyneema sling, nylon sling, purcell, connect adjust, etc.

  • @EdFudge
    @EdFudge 11 місяців тому

    Finally! Thanks so much!

  • @rodrigoruiz976
    @rodrigoruiz976 11 місяців тому +3

    With dyneema slipping at 300N, you don’t even need a fall for it to slip. If you just let it hang with the weight of a person, it would already slip.

  • @mixpix
    @mixpix 11 місяців тому

    Thanks for the testing.

  • @cal1776
    @cal1776 11 місяців тому

    All your videos are interesting, this one especially Thanks.

  • @jordanallred6791
    @jordanallred6791 11 місяців тому

    Love to see it! Thank you

  • @drclimb
    @drclimb 4 місяці тому

    The effect you describe with the maximum force is called jerk or jolt, thats the change of acceleration over time (da/dt).
    Love your videos, great job!

  • @ahilbilyredneksopinion
    @ahilbilyredneksopinion 10 місяців тому

    My new favorite 3 words....
    Super good enuff.
    Love it

  • @johngo6283
    @johngo6283 11 місяців тому

    13:08: the tip of making the PP extra short is GOLD!!!

  • @freesk8
    @freesk8 10 місяців тому

    Great work. Thanks.

  • @benjaminbordson7502
    @benjaminbordson7502 11 місяців тому +1

    Great content Ryan. Regarding the long high line one you used. I found it more practical to use a climbing rope or section of rope tied in with a standard tree climbing system. Weave it through/around the anchor, clove hitch one side to a biner/harness, and leave a tail for a Blake's hitch. Super practical and you can have about as long of a system as you want while being able to wrap it around things like trees and poles if you want. Perhaps even more practical with a split tail or eye n eye. Idk maybe one more thing to play with.

  • @JasonMinahan
    @JasonMinahan 11 місяців тому +1

    Thank you! What a great video!!

    • @JasonMinahan
      @JasonMinahan 11 місяців тому

      I kinda just want to use a screamer as a personal anchor now. Yikes!
      Absolutely breaking my gear fear and placing it where it should be. On fall factor twos!

  • @speckofdust272
    @speckofdust272 3 місяці тому

    Great tips 👍

  • @cjwaasdorp2478
    @cjwaasdorp2478 8 місяців тому +2

    FYI: spine breaking is probably what you worry about when talking about the body taking the force.
    The part of the spine that is probably most worrisome can resist about 2kN before accounting for soft tissue that'll absorb some force. (in vitro)
    When they studied forces on patients in vivo, it seems that the back can take about 3.4/3.7 kN before ~50% of folks will break their low/mid back (granted, the studies include older folks, avg age ~50 since that's who gets most back fractures in the medical world). Younger folks can tolerate ~4-6kN and part of that depends on how much time the force is spread over (as Ryan mentions), but also other factors like if you're upright/vertical vs horizontal when you the rope catches (e.g. horizontal = more torque and force on weaker parts of the spine vs vertical = more compression on the parts of the spine that are used to seeing some compression... same concept as compressive vs shear forces when you're talking about breaking bolts... except on your spine...).
    Also, in the physics/biomechanics world, the technical term for force over time is "impact". Force spread out over more time = less impact. Concentrated into less time = more impact. Makes sense if you think about a whip. Barely any force, yet cracking a whip hurts because it's such a short time = more impact.

    • @gibsonclimbs
      @gibsonclimbs 6 місяців тому

      Im a boulderer and about a month and a half ago fell 25 feet, thus breaking my spine exactly where you just said (L1 burst fracture) I’ve been curious about how many kilonewtons the fall was but it’s hard to tell. I’m assuming it was somewhere in the 6-8kn zone. Got surgery and am doing better now, soon to return to climbing

  • @juliusnickl1545
    @juliusnickl1545 11 місяців тому

    thanksalot for all that content 🌞

  • @angrybirder9983
    @angrybirder9983 11 місяців тому +4

    There is a reason via ferrata gear moved away from friction-based shock absorbers and now excluseively uses tearing shock absorbers.

    • @gruboziarnisty
      @gruboziarnisty Місяць тому +1

      And the reason is what?

    • @angrybirder9983
      @angrybirder9983 Місяць тому

      @@gruboziarnisty Because it's more reliable and always produces the correct amount of force and IIRC they can even be made to produce different forces at different parts of the shock absorber (they start off with a lower force and increase it with increasing brake distance).
      Friction-based absorbers have a tendency to NOT produce the right amount of force. An old and dirty rope might stop you too hard and a wet rope might slip too easily. And IIRC the forces were all over the place, even when not old, dirty or wet.
      I'm not saying that a friction-based absorber that produces a precise amount of force is impossible to build, but the design I'm thinking of is quite complex, can't vary the braking force along the length of the rope and is probably too bulky to climb with that thing hanging off the harness.
      Plus, tearing shock absorbers have the entire brake distance folded up nicely inside, while friction-based ones have about 1m of rope hanging around.
      TL;DR: Tearing shock absorbers will reliably NOT kill you on a factor 4 fall, friction-based absorbers don't.

  • @marcmancini8275
    @marcmancini8275 11 місяців тому

    I made my own Personal Anchor out of a section of Resc Tech (teufelburger) and a 7mm Sterling acc cord in a michoacan hitch, and use a kong Ottino as a prussik tender. it works great for single handed adjustment to shorten or lengthen, and is #supergoodenough that I don't feel the need to buy a connect adjust, etc.

  • @aurorainvictus1320
    @aurorainvictus1320 10 місяців тому

    2:20 - 3:15 very helpful sling / general purpose loop knot tying.

  • @mikelarin8037
    @mikelarin8037 11 місяців тому +4

    I've been using the klemheist version of this for years with a 6mm cord. Not sure I'd ever go to anything else for the price. I've got mine set to a fully stretched arms length. I'd love to see what you could get if you fell with your super long one. Haha

  • @juanmckelvey
    @juanmckelvey 11 місяців тому +3

    @hownot2
    Thanks for the video. I do rescue so we use Purcell Prusiks all the time. Are you familiar with the Aztek Edge Kit? We use them as personal anchor, travel restraint and for patient rescue and a million other things.

  • @allstarwoo4
    @allstarwoo4 11 місяців тому +2

    You already covered a lot but I feel like if people are really worried about shock load they could just do one less wrap when setting up the Purcell Prusik.

  • @MichaelWilliams-xs1cf
    @MichaelWilliams-xs1cf 11 місяців тому

    Sobering. Outstanding. Mans out here doing God's work.

  • @kolbykidd793
    @kolbykidd793 4 місяці тому

    You can add a little loop above and adjust in both directions with one hand

  • @jackvanlierop6090
    @jackvanlierop6090 11 місяців тому +1

    I've been using this setup for multipitch rock climbing with 5m of 6mm cord, but I use a double fisherman's and add a butterfly above for an extended rappel!

    • @ndazza
      @ndazza 2 місяці тому

      Thank you stranger! I'll be trying this next time I'm outdoors

  • @timonix2
    @timonix2 11 місяців тому +1

    My takeaway is that for factor falls greater than 1.5 ish you really need a screamer of some sort. But that's not really a thing when climbing and walking around above the anchor is really common.

  • @dongrider9040
    @dongrider9040 11 місяців тому

    08/02/2023 Hello How. This video was very interesting. I did not know about using this rope knot on a rescue basket. The second point is what if you use one additional loop in the prusikis. I have used this knot but not very often because I do not do tree work. My weight is over 300 lbs when loaded to work. My naked weight is just under 250 lbs. The four loop prusiks are both for climbing and movement in the tree. I do enjoy watching the profession plan for a fall. That tales BALLS Thanks again, DON

  • @nomars4827
    @nomars4827 19 днів тому

    With dyneema woopie sling you can theoretically find the optimal length for "stuck through" part. It is also possible to make few such parts with pulled out parts of rope between "stuck through" parts.
    This can make gradually increasing stopping forcethat can be adjusted. Friction parts of rope will be distributed so heat problem should also be less of a worry

  • @kevinwatson3190
    @kevinwatson3190 11 місяців тому +1

    That search and rescue guy is a pretty cool guy ;)

  • @johnjriggsarchery2457
    @johnjriggsarchery2457 10 місяців тому

    I've broken out of a tree twice and was saved by my rope without my split tail slipping. The bounce in my True Blue made both events comfortable so my opinion is that whether or not your fiction knot slips doesn't matter.

  • @johnsmith8981
    @johnsmith8981 10 місяців тому +1

    "secure the victim" that sounds way more ominous than "secure the patient" 😂

  • @brucewarren5248
    @brucewarren5248 10 місяців тому

    I never intend to climb anything more difficult than a 15 foot ladder. However, I would not do anything with any sort of string, rope or line without checking your videos first. I have seen others do videos on splicing Dynemma and realized your videos are the only ones I trust. BTW, Dynamma is an interesting product. It is super strong, but has some interesting quirks that I discovered on your videos.

  • @runwords_
    @runwords_ 11 місяців тому +1

    I'd be interested if the friction of the Purcell Prusik could be tuned with a lower friction material lining the knot or a sheath. Granted it would either have to melt during the slide as to not slip too much or the sheath would need to have a gradient where the friction would increase the farther the knot slips.

  • @PiotrS-a
    @PiotrS-a 11 місяців тому

    Good video👍🏻

  • @tr33m00nk
    @tr33m00nk 4 місяці тому

    I can appreciate the skill, knowledge and consideration of so many factors demonstrated in these tests. The one thing missing, I think, is an explanation of the relevance/meaning for the "average climber". Is one sling construction significantly better/safer than the others? Or are these sling variations just for use in 'advanced' climbing and not relevant for the rest of us? Yes, I did watch the last few minutes of this video. But telling us to go watch other videos and blogs and suggesting (sort of) that we shouldn't use "personal anchor systems" (at all?) because the tests seem to show that they aren't safe doesn't seem like a satisfactory conclusion to a 18 minute 'technical analysis'.

  • @henryczenczek3359
    @henryczenczek3359 10 місяців тому +1

    I use the Purcell Prussik as my personal anchor/leash with a 7mm nylon cord but I drop one of the loops on the load side of the prussik knot. This (in theory) will reduce the friction in the prussik knot and maybe reduce the peak loads on your tree drop test.

    • @paulnormandy6247
      @paulnormandy6247 9 місяців тому

      I do the same but I recently switched to 5.9mm Powercord

  • @ShurikB93
    @ShurikB93 11 місяців тому

    I use double Purcell Prusik (PP),
    1 big loop with 2 PP at the ends girth hitch it to the harness, with big wirelock carabineer.
    Find it super useful,
    Apples to apples seems safe enough.

  • @DaddyVet3D
    @DaddyVet3D 6 місяців тому

    4:15 mann, I thought I was tying this properly but I clearly wasn’t. What a shocker!

  • @corygrossman1
    @corygrossman1 11 місяців тому

    Super damn cool dude

  • @vieuxacadian9455
    @vieuxacadian9455 11 місяців тому +1

    Terrific video . Why can't We tie a double bowline on bight for the belt anchor point?

  • @d.h.601
    @d.h.601 10 місяців тому

    Super good enough

  • @paulnormandy6247
    @paulnormandy6247 3 місяці тому

    I know it's an old video but the updated way of tying a purcell does not have a bfk; just a double fish, a prusik and the girth hitch to your hard points. If you need a shelf you can add or remove an overhand. It's much more simple to tie and can be easily converted to a loop of cordalette.

  • @cyrusyoder4789
    @cyrusyoder4789 2 місяці тому

    2:03 Figure 8 BFK version is definitely better! You can use the tail as a rappell extension if you tie a standard figure 8 follow through with it!

  • @alexcole8438
    @alexcole8438 10 місяців тому

    Nice video! I was hoping you'd try taking loops out of the pruzuk. Maybe if it was 2 on one side and 1 on the other, instead of 2 on both sides, it would slide more. Having the too loops above and the single loop below i would expect to slide easiest

  • @glennreynolds962
    @glennreynolds962 10 днів тому

    I use a purcell as an edge restraint Or as a restraining device on an articulated work platform.

  • @ZergBert1
    @ZergBert1 11 місяців тому +1

    After you video on cow's tails, I was wondering, "OK, but how does a Purcell-Prusik anchor do in similar conditions?" I had not gotten around to asking directly, but here you are, anyway, with a video on the Purcell-Prusik. As if you'd read my mind...
    Background: I come from a world that is not generally populated with rope-climbing knowledge but nevertheless fall protection is of great interest: namely square-rigged sailing ships. The things we climb are intentionally designed to be climbed and, in general, falls are actually pretty rare. In the old days of wooden ships and iron men, there was no fall protection at all. If you fell, you fell. End of story. But as this world has moved on, over the course of the last 120 years, evolving from commercial shipping into sail training and historical interest, there is a greater emphasis on safety. Fall protection has taken a higher priority due to insurance and the desire of organizations not to damage their volunteers/employees. These organizations have, slowly, evolved various systems to protect (at least, in theory) their sailors. But in many ways, this world is still a long way away from the climbing world. A common way of thinking is that, as long as the gear doesn't break and you stop the fall, life is good. Climb down and have some tea. Not a lot of thought is given to shock loading or what a fall factor 2 can do to a human body if abruptly arrested. You would absolutely shudder if I told you what was being used for fall protection 20 years ago. We've evolved since then, and currently, in my organization, we are using a Purcell-Prusik as a personal anchor (we say "lanyard" because, well, it's nautical...). It's made 10mm dynamic line. I'm told that it was tested and deemed "plenty good enough" if one were to fall on it. And perhaps it may be, but I have always been thankful that I have never found myself putting the theory to the test.

    • @ZergBert1
      @ZergBert1 11 місяців тому

      It would be interesting to see some testing done on Via Ferrata Sets (which consist of two tethers with a zip-strip to reduce shock loading).

  • @andrewhunter6536
    @andrewhunter6536 11 місяців тому +1

    Did you clip the end of the daisy or shorten it? If you clipped the end it’s equivalent to testing the fully extended Purcell. A (correctly) shortened daisy seems more useful to test and might absorb better

  • @matthiashejlskov5008
    @matthiashejlskov5008 11 місяців тому

    I like the double fisherman, but i start it like you started the figure eight, and tie the fisherman around both ends, that way it makes an eye that will cinch down on the carabiner when weighted so it stays put better.

  • @timseguine2
    @timseguine2 11 місяців тому

    With the dyneema you tested near then end, with it slipping well below 1KN, we shouldn't even expect it to slow you down, only make you accelerate slightly less quickly. That slight drop in the rate of acceleration is completely counteracted though I would suspect from the additional travel distance of the fully extended prussik. Meaning it basically it is worse than nothing and you are taking a hard fall on static protection.

  • @susmonkey9683
    @susmonkey9683 9 місяців тому

    If you get the chance to it might be fun to test the petzl adjust vario it would be interesting to see how strong it is compared to the regular petzl adjust with a sewn end

  • @zh3178
    @zh3178 11 місяців тому

    top knot(ch)
    ha... haha hah
    great info, as always.
    thanks duder!

  • @seekerstan
    @seekerstan 11 місяців тому

    I've never done climbing, but I am a sailor & Tugboat operator, so I've done a lot with ropes. In construction and shipboard safety harnesses, they include an engineered shock absorber that is a replace after it dose its job tool . I'm sure it weighs more than the slings you are making, but you can count on the amount of shock absorption it will provide.

    • @wyattroncin941
      @wyattroncin941 11 місяців тому +1

      In climbing, a single use absorber is called a screamer.
      They're not used very much at all because of the cost of replacement, bulk, and at we simply avoid taking any falls that generate enough force to need a screamer. They are used in ice climbing for marginally strong ice anchors, but on rock you'll pretty much never see them.

    • @JonathanFisherS
      @JonathanFisherS 11 місяців тому

      Something similar is used in Via Feratta sets.

  • @susmonkey9683
    @susmonkey9683 10 місяців тому

    Suggestion when you test the petzl adjust test the breaking strength if you just clip the metal and not the rope as well

  • @mattbaker1683
    @mattbaker1683 10 місяців тому

    Try the same with one of those Edelrid aramid slings, 22kN rated and they work as a Purcell prusik, would be interesting to find out the numbers.

  • @WowCoolHorse
    @WowCoolHorse 5 місяців тому

    it would be cool if you got a thermal camera to monitor the friction heat during slow pull tests, if not for actual data then just for the visual aspect

  • @bautistasilvestre378
    @bautistasilvestre378 11 місяців тому +1

    Hi! Maybe for the "not adjustable end" you could try a... Double bowline... I'm not sure how call it. I mean the same knot which is used by Stefano for example. Anyway, thanks for this one, I really enjoyed it

    • @Benlucky13
      @Benlucky13 11 місяців тому +1

      'bowline on a bite' is what I've always heard those called, the one where you start by tying an overhand on a bite and transform it into a bowline.

  • @tomcrigstar
    @tomcrigstar 2 місяці тому

    i made my Prucell out of Edelrid Aramid cord sling. been working amazing for years. since the aramid is a lot stiffer its a lot easier to handle and adjust, but id love to know how it compares to nylon or dyneema that you tested here.

  • @rubyf1993
    @rubyf1993 11 місяців тому +1

    Will you test some Via Ferrata kits as well? Curious about the results

  • @beingaware8542
    @beingaware8542 11 місяців тому

    The swinging thing skews the results. Your drop tower is cool, but maybe some stairs and a way to mske the falls straight. Great video!

  • @wyattroncin941
    @wyattroncin941 10 місяців тому

    I wpuld be interested to see bluewater ropes' dynamic purcell prusik cord tested on the drop tower

  • @vincentyoch5632
    @vincentyoch5632 11 місяців тому

    Have you done testing on the multitude of friction hitches arborists use for ascent, descent, fliplines/ adjustable personal anchors?

  • @alandoak5146
    @alandoak5146 11 місяців тому +4

    Can your pull tester integrate force over distance to calculate energy? I think that'd be a useful datapoint.

    • @angrybirder9983
      @angrybirder9983 11 місяців тому

      I think it only measures time and not distance, but with a separate x(t) measurement, it should be possible to calculate.

    • @BridgetWirth
      @BridgetWirth 11 місяців тому

      Just out of curiosity, why would you or anybody else need/want a measurement of energy here? It's not a very useful metric for the use of this kind of equipment, which is why everything is rated in terms of force. Theoretically you could get a rough approximation of the energy by slapping a meter stick to the drop tower and using E = m*g*h where m is mass, g is 9.8 m/s^2 (gravity on earth) and h is the total distance traveled from the beginning to end. This would only work with really static lines though, like dyneema. If you wanted to find it with a more dynamic system you could do a simple pull test to find the spring constant k via hooks law (F = k*x) and then use E = 1/2*k*h^2. That said, your value for k will be very different when the system has knots that slip, deform, etc. and hooks law would still be a rough approximation at best.
      My point is you *could* roughly calculate the energy and power with relative ease, but it doesn't give you any useful information so why would you bother? It's appropriate that force is the primary metric to consider here. Energy is kind of an abstract measurement for assessing safety in these kinds of systems, force is all we need to make well informed decisions. It's like wanting your car speedometer to measure energy; sure you can do it but it's kind of irrelevant as speed is a much more useful thing to know.

    • @alandoak5146
      @alandoak5146 11 місяців тому

      @@BridgetWirth A spring is poor model for textiles (cordage, webbing, rope, etc) in destructive pull tests: energy is dissipated in the frictional heating and melting of the weave, plastic deformation of the fibers, chemical bonds being stretched and broken, etc. Once a metal spring experiences plastic deformation, you can throw Hook out the window.
      The human body is incapable of generating the same forces as a rigid mass, especially for shorter drops and less elastic/dissipative textiles, a rigid mass is a poor predictor. But, like you said, gpe is trivial to calculate, and it might be interesting to compare that to the Joules/meter that a textile can dissipate during failure.

    • @alandoak5146
      @alandoak5146 11 місяців тому

      @@BridgetWirth For example, we know that a 1m rope will survive the 700J of energy in a 1m fall. The complication I guess with doing the same exercise with dyneema, a larger portion of that 700J is going into the climber's kidneys and spine.

    • @angrybirder9983
      @angrybirder9983 11 місяців тому

      @@BridgetWirth Energy is a measure for how much of a fall it can hold on its own before it's fully extended (or breaks).
      A shock absorber that can absorb 6kJ over 1.5m of distance before it is fully extended can hold an 80kg person that fell 6.14m (from start of the fall to the first point where the shock absorber is under tension), assuming there are no other shock absorbing parts in the system.

  • @timonschatz5611
    @timonschatz5611 9 місяців тому

    It would i terresting to know how much shock is absorbed by the persobal anchor for Via Ferratas in comparison

  • @mudskipper3650
    @mudskipper3650 10 місяців тому

    Can you also please test a Petzl Connect Adjust lanyard under the same sort of conditions? Drop test & slow pull to destruction.

  • @lolipop1428
    @lolipop1428 3 місяці тому

    Could you also try other friction hitches? Would an autoblock be shock absorbing enough for a safe fall?

  • @glennwidener3235
    @glennwidener3235 6 місяців тому

    Question: were your drop tests in 6 or 7mm? Indications are that if they were in 7mm, the impact forces would be less in 6mm.

  • @Zogg1281
    @Zogg1281 11 місяців тому

    Very cool!! I've just converted my original style petzl Zyper by updating the rope in it and using a couple of Petzl Adjusts so that the cow's tails can be adjusted. I'd love to send you some photos if that's possible? Thanks

  • @rootvalue
    @rootvalue 11 місяців тому

    Hi, it took me about 8 minutes to realize what the subject of this video was. I’ve never watched a video about knots, but I was happy to do so and will watch more. Not sure why UA-cam suggested it to me, but your style is great. Maybe one sentence on what to expect in the video at the start would help. 😂❤

    • @HowNOT2
      @HowNOT2  11 місяців тому +2

      The first 30 seconds (other than the 4 second hook at the beginning) is all about the premise of the video. I try to be clear about what you are going to see.

    • @rootvalue
      @rootvalue 11 місяців тому

      @@HowNOT2 I’m a dork. I loved learning from you. 👍

  • @TommyMacMXClimber
    @TommyMacMXClimber 10 місяців тому

    So call me crazy, but the only application I've ever considered for the PP is for rope soling (on lead) a bolted route where finding a ground anchor (boulder, tree, good low crack) is not an option. The idea being: climb to the first bolt, clip a PP to it, then clip the end of the rope to the sliding end of the PP (having pre-connected other end of rope to my grigri on my belay loop). Crazy? Indeed. But potential advantages: (1) if you fall shortly above the 1st bolt, the PP should keep the fall force below factor 2 (but seeing the video, I'd keep the PP on 6mm or less to get more slippage and lower forces), and (2) once clipped into the 2nd bolt, the PP would add a little bit of dynamic quality for a fall (not much due to friction thru 'biners, but more is better in this case IMHO) and so that's good. I do loads of rope-solo leading and don't bother with a PP if I have a good ground anchor, as there's plenty of dynamic quality in the system once several meters of rope are out and the first piece has been placed, especially given that I'm not (and no one should) ever taking big whippers while rope soling... So I'd love to see the PP tested in this kind of application...

  • @niceguy191
    @niceguy191 11 місяців тому

    So would a two-wrap nylon version be best? Or would it then slide too much and compromise the rope? Either way, these are single use it seems as the rope gets a bit of damage and the knot gets too tight

  • @mikebularz9019
    @mikebularz9019 9 місяців тому

    Ive been using two long slings with knots for my PAS and cleaning gear for years, what system is your best recommended option for everyday climbing?

  • @r0000g
    @r0000g 11 місяців тому

    11:52 after doing the drop test on the prusik, were you able to move the... knot? up and down again or does it just fuse to the rest after stretching and pulling?

  • @joaquins90
    @joaquins90 11 місяців тому

    Hey, How much difference in the load between the solid weights and a bag of meat?? (or something similar to use as a dummy)
    I'm not asking for all the drop tests to be done with something softer because would be much harder to set them up, specially for the short drops, but some particular one, specially in static rope, to consider the difference in shock load for the compliance of the weight.

  • @macelbayardi8453
    @macelbayardi8453 11 місяців тому

    So what do you guys consider the best for a good fall absorbing personal anchor device?
    Thinking in a scenario, where we are developing a Highline Permarig space, with space nets, where people can stand, and therefore can take a Fall in Factor 2? And as "normal" weights here, people are around 60kgs - 90 kgs
    We want to advice of safety and good practices around Highline, and notice new generations to keep playing, rigging and highlining safe

  • @Kankudai69
    @Kankudai69 11 місяців тому

    I played with tying one with a single strand.
    I tied the prusik first and then tied off the short end.
    It makes it a bit less clumsy. Opinions?

  • @GhillieInventor
    @GhillieInventor 11 місяців тому +1

    We’ve made Purcell prusiks out of 8mm dynamic half/twin rope with the thought that it will provide even lower forces in a fall. I’d be curious how that compares and if there’s anything we’re overlooking making that a bad idea.

    • @wyattroncin941
      @wyattroncin941 10 місяців тому

      Bluewater actually makes 6.5,7, and 8 mm dynamic cord advertised as for these.
      Would be interested to see that cord tested as well

  • @SuicidaI_Tendencies
    @SuicidaI_Tendencies 10 місяців тому

    New to your videos, Can you test car seat belt? I've done many engine replacement where I've used seat belt to hoist the motor back into the vehicle. Engine varies from 3 Cylinders to 4 Cylinders to 5 Cylinders to 8 Cylinders. I usually used two seat belts, been doing this for over 20 years, never head a engine fall, never had a seat belt rip. Just curious how strong are seat belts. It's just easier to swing the engine while it's on the engine hoist with seat belts rather than chain links. Thanks in advance!