Gerry was assembling posters and information to spread awareness that Maddie was missing. He wanted to emphasise the fleck in her iris as a distinguishing point. He was harshly advised against it for the reason the 'abductor' would harm her, or even kill her, because she would be too visible. Gerry went ahead with it anyway saying "it is a good marketing ploy". I think he knew she would not be found so it didnt matter.
They killed her with sedatives. Plain and simple. Her wailing was of a mother who child was dead and not lost. She blamed herself for leaving her. Because a sedated child should be monitored. And their language indicates they already know she's dead. This is the most audacious non- government related cover-up I've ever seen.
100 percent agree with you. I think If suspect Bruckner was involved in any way he was brought in to dispose of the evidence. Cadaver dogs scent etc were right Portuguese police were right ....
If Maddie was heavily sedated, she wouldn't have been awake to get into an accident, but perhaps awake enough to stumble around, and get injured, and died. It was dark in the apartment, so maybe she was alert enough to climb onto the sofa to peek out the window, but fell, and hit her head hard. The child was gone a few days before Katie sounded the alarm. They needed time to dispose of the child, get their alibi straight, then report her missing.
@@Emy53 No evidence that any of the children were sedated. No evidence of a death in the apartment. Kate was reported to be completely distraught on the night she was reported missing, yet we're supposed to believe Maddie died several days earlier and that kate and Gerry wined and dined that night completely naturally?
Hi, I was a nanny for a doctor who used to sedate her four children including a premature baby. I was shown what to give the baby, and the milk went a pink/purple colour. When the parents left, I poured the contents down the sink. I gave him a warm bath, fed him formula and put him down to sleep. There was no way I was going to prison by following this crazy woman's instructions. Just want to add, I have left my children asleep whilst attending a dinner party next door at my neighbour's house and I just didn't feel comfortable. I was just steps from my door but after checking on them a few times, I went home. It just didn't sit right with me. I just couldn't relax and I could see into my home. What were these parents thinking, who leaves the door unlocked whilst in a foreign country?
I did this a couple of times with my Son and could not settle. We had a baby moniter attached to us in our neighbours, but I hated it and did not bother any more. I felt so bad. Right next door too.
God bless you. Sedating children to sleep is child abuse. An older child with an occasional insomnia might warrant a minimal intervention, but a premature baby? My view is the first three months you should be there almost all the time holding the baby as much as possible. There is a reason this time is called “the fourth trimester”.
They actually rented that car 3 days after she disappeared. The dna was found in the apartment however there was 4 matching. The father mother and siblings. There is no conclusive evidence regarding this case. My opinion is that the father was involved whether that was drugging her or not. There is also no evidence that she was abducted. I believe she died in that apartment. She was dumped in the sea before the police were called. one of their friends saw a man carrying a blonde girl around the time that Gerry was standing talking to a friend at that same moment. GERRY DOESNT REMEMBER SEEING HIM. 🤔 I think Gerry organised this whole thing.SHE OVERDOSED. WHY WOULDNT THEY GIVE A POLYGRAPH. IF MY DAUGHTER WENT MISSING I WOULD GIVE A DAM POLY.
I think Maddie died early during the vacation. The last picture shown at the pool shows a child who has not been in the sun. I think she was sedated, got up and climbed onto the sofa trying to look for her parents. She likely fell off the back and died of an ICH, or broke her neck, or died of positional asphyxia. The McCann’s had several days to stage the abduction. Body was likely in the apt. Briefly, then stored somewhere, and later moved in trunk of rent car to unknown final location. Too risky to put her in ocean as parts could wash up later. Also, blood dog found blood in rocks under porch so she could have fallen off high porch and died in the rocks. My question is, how could upstairs neighbor hear children crying for 45 min. And not call Portugal equivalent of 911.???
I think the reason why there was a hit by the dogs in the rental car, is because the child was disposed of in a double bag. The inner bag was disposed of with the child, but the outer bag was kept to use for their luggage. Bodily fluids may have leaked onto that bag, and when they placed it in their rental car, the transfer of death got on the carpet.
Why has the British government paid out 14 million pounds on this one missing child? No other child has anywhere near that amount spent. Nor have they been the subject of appeals from the Royal Family. Why Maddie?
i didn't think they killed the daughter but the thing that angered me was disparity in treatment that the upper classes recieve in contrast to disadvantaged families, like that which i grew up in. when I was a child social services were called out simply because of my poverty as a child. My mother wouldn't have dreamed of leaving me alone all night. If she had, no doubt i would have been put in care. So no, I don't blame the maccanns for accessing what help they could, any parent would, but in reality, if they had been " rough around the edges" most likely their younger kids would have been removed , especially when there are significant suspicions that they sedated their kids. My nieces and nephews would be in care as quick as 1,2,3 if my sister did that. They were afforded much because of their status in the community but in fact they should have known better than us mere "plebians". Furthermore, they easily earned enough to access the child care that was available where they were staying. All that said , i would never harrass them, At the end of the day, they must live with their choices, which were catastrophic.
You are absolutely right. I was the single mother of 3. Their father was a dysfunctional deadbeat. I don't blame anyone else for my bad choice. Life was not easy. I did everything I could to stay working and pay for babysitters and daycare. Tried to be a positive role model. I would have never left my kids alone. We lived in poor areas and it was a field day for children's s services. Look- up Kids For Cash in Luzerne County, Pennsylvania USA. And the McCain s were educated professionals . Its pretty reprehensible.
think they did have the local C&F social services team "assess" them, - but yes agree with everything you have written. Sedating one's own children through medication they could obtain because they wanted peace and quiet?! What! Surely that is a criminal offence in its own right? Thought their behaviours just a few days after losing Madeline were strangely emotionally disconnected. I have a suspicion the Police in Portugal would want this case closed, and am a little sceptical/cynical about recent developments. Above all, never, not once, were my two daughters left alone evenings or at night. Just stunningly, unthinkable stupidity.
@@tonyburton419 great points although I think the police in Portugal have been silenced regarding their own findings/positions regarding the parents. I think Scotland Yard wants this case closed.
I will never ever understand why on earth those two doctors (with their income) nor their friends did not hire a babysitter for their kids. It has bothered me all these years. There is no way I would have left my kids unattended anywhere abroad at that age and I come from a country where you can leave your kids sleeping outside on their afternoon nap basically 'anywhere'. Such a sad case!
Because they narcissistically assumed they knew best, and they sedated their kids so they wouldn’t have to worry about them while they enjoyed their evening with friends. Two medical professionals, their arrogance led to the death of one of their kids, and they had the connections to cover it up.
@@mads597 Okay but sadate is a strong word, she literally have them each (not just Madeline) a half a melitonin gummy made for children. I'm a nanny and many of my clients have me give these to their kids, usually age 4+ as it helps kids relax and fall asleep. The main danger is giving it to them before a bath as they could fall asleep and drown without supervision and also if they take the gummies after brushing their teeth it will cause cavities.
I still believe she died by accident in the Apartment, there was blood behind gge sofa and cadaver and blood dogs reacted to the Apartment and the parents I will always believe they are responsible they didn't even look for her!
correction! The friend of the McCann's reported to have gone to check on Madeleine before Kate told detectives that he stood by the bedroom and listened for signs that the children might be awake. he did not physically enter the room and see Madeleine in her bed.
I get that they're Drs, they have to be professional, detached, as when they're speaking to patients, family etc when they're delivering bad news but the unfortunate thing about the McCanns is that they can come across as smug. Many years ago a 3 year old boy went missing in Greece, and the media were nowhere near as sympathetic or as supportive to that boy's family. It seemed as though because the McCanns were middle class and Drs they were above reproach. That young boy's family was never given the positive publicity that the McCanns received
Yes Ben Needam. Did Kerry the mother, and family want money?. No, just their child back like countlessare others. Kerry and family have expressed their feelings on radio shows TV etc. They are from Sheffield as I am, the contrast between the MacCanns, feelings and the Needam's are planets apart. The Needam's never neglected Ben. Never found him.
After McCann stored Maddie in the bag in the wardrobe he then managed to take her to a rented house with a fridge and stored her there for some weeks until in a panic he and Kate retrieved Maddie and drove her away to be buried or DISPOSED OF - as McCann actually said before correcting himself. They did this on a warm day so that Maddie melted and ripped cadaver fluid over the car and KMcC's clothes and the soft toy cuddle cat. Maddies was disposed of in the remote triangle of south west Portugal in such a way that the McCanns know she will never be found so they are free to sneer at all suggestions of her death being their fault. After the disposal they tried to cleanse the car with disinfectants and leaving the tailgate open for at least two days! But the dog found the cadaver smell.
I don't understand why people refer to this as a disappearance. It's not like she vanished into thin air by magic, or just wandered off into a ditch and got buried alive, or some Moroccan pido snatched her out of her bed and jumped out the window. Still , disappearance is more accurate than abduction. I like to put it like this: she has been hidden from us in a dark place, and won't ever be seen again.
They left their own 3 little children alone, with the door unlocked, in an apartment. I make no apology for my opinion that the couple deserve everything they get...
I've often wondered, if the parents were council house tenants who had left their children, would the social services have got involved and tried to put the other siblings in care. We'll never know but I suspect they would.
They did, they have never stopped being accused. Made up stories in fact they have recwived just as much hatred as support. So no it wudnt just happen to council owners and why council owners why do ppl like you say this and put them down
If you’ve ever actually looked into the case, you’ll really understand the amount they did to put their daughter in jeopardy and why a lot of people strongly suspect they had something to do with her disappearance. The fact cadaver dogs found the scent of death in their hire car in a garage with other vehicles, granted, it could’ve been from a previous hire, but what are the odds? They washed items that could have had evidence on them, like her teddy and blanket, refused a lie detector even though they “had nothing to hide”, publicising her eye defect even though they were advised not to… there’s so much more to the story that really has you question the McCann’s involvement. I think the theory of an accidental OD is the most likely, they would have ALL lost their licenses to practice, most definitely, if found out that they were drugging their kids to have a few drinks at a bar. Who knows if the McCann’s were good parents before she disappeared? Just because there aren’t any reports nor investigations doesn’t mean they were pillar parents. She was 3 after all, that’s not a very long time to detect maltreatment, especially in the form of deliberate drugging. My heart seriously breaks for any parent that loses their child, by any means, but the McCann’s are seriously questionable.
It wasnt just a lapse in judgement and they have never really admitted wrongdoing or remorse and for me, that’s what really gets my back up If I had done that not that I would do that I would be crumpled on the floor saying why did I do it, but they have tried to justify their decision saying how close how many yards. It was the way how it was the damn thing at the time, they have spent so much time justifying their poor decisions which cost Madeleine her life, but I don’t wanna see them on dancing on ice I don’t wanna see them anywhere
My god u have to be so right.The twins are in their teens now.I did here something very early in the case about little Madelene she was a little darling.I aslo heard that Madelene was adopted.They should be arrested now why wait and they might tell the truth.I hope they are they look petriefied.
If you've actually looked into the case you would have read the Martin Grime reports: Eddie was a multi-disciplined dog that would alert to the scent of a cadaver, dried blood form a living person and other bodily scents. Eddie made no distinction between alerts, so no one knows if he alerted to the scent of a cadaver or dried blood. Eddie was never put into the car, he only alerted to the passenger side door in which was found a key card. Both Eddie and Keela alerted to the card. Keela would only alert to dried blood. No evidence that any of the children were drugged btw.
When looking into this case. They were asked something like 40 odd questions where they refused to answer all but one. They also were in talks to letting the mothers sister adopt Madeline due to her bad behaviour. Not sure if the adoption part is true but the questions are well documented. The questions could of lead to better Ideas of what happened to their child. If you were the parent surely you would answer all questions they were asked to try their best to find her. They also didn’t look for her. Plus their friend lied about seeing a man carrying a girl last at night. There are too many issues with the parents to fully believe them. As a mother of three I can’t imagine how horrible it would be to lose a child the way they did.
They already answered questions twice to what they were doing that night. She was advised by her lawyer not to answer the questions. None of the questions were posed to help find maddy, tell me one question how it would of helped finding her? Jane tanner did not lie, you cant just say it was made up, given someone confirmed it was them that night.
Also where is the source about her sister which would be her sister in law as its gerrys sister, kate does not have one, taking on maddy? I want a well documented source as you have just claimed.
Correct they didn't cooperate with the PT investigation which suffered outstanding pressures from the British ambassador not to investigate them contrary to all guidelines in missing persons cases.
@@rossblack9559 Kate had never been asked most of the questions she refused to answer. If your child was genuinely missing you would answer police questions over and over again if necessary.
I always agree with what this guy says, but this time I have to disagree! They are to blame, if it was common people who left they kids unattended in a foreign country they would have social services take their other kids away for being neglectful! Damn right disgusting! And il always say it’s their fault. Of course whoever did whatever to her need stringing up! But the parents let it happen 100%!!
The problems with the McCanns is they felt entitled. Doctors, good jobs, rich. The did not want kids annoying them at their dinner everyday and felt they were entitled to having there adult time . Same with their daily activities, leave children at kids club. What they wanted was an adult holiday. I took my son on holiday for 16 years and never dreamt of leaving him. I think they possibly did drug them but like you say the time line doesn’t make sense for disposal of Madeleine.
Yes, I was thinking the same on the latter point: when would the parents have disposed of the body?...not that they couldn't have, but I've not seen a discussion of this issue by people who think they're guilty. It's an odd case at any rate, lots of rumours of cover up, contradictory statements from law enforcement/prosecutors in multiple countries, suspiciously behaving parents, but also a paedophile/sex offender being around at the time and place of the little girl's dissappearance. It doesn't get more confusing than this, I don't think.
I usually enjoy your content Sohom, but there is so much wrong with this video I am not going to be able to finish it. I respect your views as a professional but unfortunately to me this seems very much like a case of a “doctor standing up for another doctor” without knowing the full story (because NONE of us know the full story). In my opinion this is not something you should have covered and certainly not one where you just skim the surface of what is a deeply complex and mysterious case. This is YOUR channel and its totally your right to cover whatever you wish but in my opinion this one has really missed the mark, sorry but that is just how I feel. Look forward to seeing what else you have planned in the future.
From day 1 I personally did not believe their story because of their behaviour afterwards. When the (Human Cadaverine/Human blood) trained dogs went in to the apartment and hire car weeks later it confirmed my suspicions. I don’t for a second believe the parents intended harm but I do believe because of their negligence Madeleine came to harm and to save their own reputations and careers they have covered up at the very least what truly happened. Since then they have made money from this by setting up a foundation and continue to do so. Every now and again this case pops up in the media with yet another red herring to keep the narrative going. There are many MANY other aspects to this case that I will not go into here but basically… the whole thing stinks to high Masonic heaven. Peter Hyatt (Professional statement analyst) puts a very interesting twist on these two ua-cam.com/video/uS6ucYudNAo/v-deo.html
@@claudia-Silva I may be wrong but maybe it comes down to being a healthcare professional that ‘has to toe the line’ on this channel or it could be seen as giving out ‘misleading information’, spreading ‘conspiracy theories’ possibly putting a professional reputation at risk… Or maybe there is a genuine belief in the mainstream narrative. Even still we have our own opinions and personally I’m just following the evidence and body language of these two.
@@claudia-Silva Here in the U.K. at least the trolls are seen as the people not believing the narrative, that believe the parents were somewhat to blame, that covered up their mistreatment of their children to save their own skins both professionally and otherwise.
I'm intrigued how this has effected the twins. Growing up finding out and hearing all these things about your parents, survivors guilt perhaps? I hope they have people to talk to.
As there was no evidence of a forced, "jemmied" window entry,, the McCanns then said that they left the apartment door, unlocked , despite Madeleine having a habit of getting up at night in their home and walking around. No mention of this was made to the police at the time when she disappeared. Then the McCanns tried to give the impression that this mysterious person carried Madeleine out of the small window, which involved raising a noisy, metal shutter, which no one heard, instead of the more quicker, secluded unlocked door by which they entered ! A difficult to believe state of affairs.
I’m sorry but I’m going to have to agree to disagree with your take on this case. They are Doctors as a profession but no parent whatever their profession would be as calm and collected as these two if their own child had actually been abducted. Their behaviour was never that of a parent who’s child had inexplicably disappeared from their ‘home’. “They’ve taken her” was what Kate said when she apparently discovered Madeleine missing. WTF?!! They take the twins to kindergarten (In front of the PAPs may I add) next morning then go jogging on the beach. Right ok! Devastated parent behaviour right there… NOT. I’ll end my rant here but there is so much more to this disgusting case than the mainstream media would ever care to put out. RIP Madeleine and I hope the truth will come out… at some stage.
I still, to this day, cannot get my head around the fact that they would even consider leaving their child/ren, not just the McCann's, but anyone in general, alone, in a motel room. You wouldn't do it in your own home, so why do it anywhere else? You can say what you want about this comment. I don't care. I will forever blame the parents for their utter stupidity.
My mum wouldn't even go down to the grocer van if we were asleep in the flat she did without until dad came home and she could catch his later round. If we were awake we had to go with her.
By leaving them, they put them at risk. To me that is blatant neglect. This has been high profile for so long. Other children go missing daily but they don’t get this much attention. Anything could have happened not just kidnap.
I think that one reason why people were so hard, and to some extent still are so hard, on the McCans is that they were relatively wealthy, educated, professional people who had the resources with no strain at all to ensure the safety of their children. There are so many of us who couldn’t afford a vacation to the next town over without hardship, let alone a nanny for the kids so we can go get drunk while those kids remain safe that choosing to be so irresponsible is hard to understand. They had critical thinking skills. They had money. They were able to do better and didn’t choose to and while you say that they paid the ultimate price, it’s actually that baby who did. As it happens, I don’t think they’re guilty of harming her (beyond drugging her) and I agree that they don’t need to be hounded. The focus should be on the child, not on the poor parenting. But I did want to try to express why I think they still draw ire.
Totally agree! There is a case to answer to which they have miraculously avoided because of their status. The whole thing stinks of one big cover up and one rule for the upper class.
Too many red flags in the whole case. I don’t know of anyone who has ever left their kids alone in a hotel room and it’s much further away from there they were eating than Gerry made out. So many things! Paying their mortgage with donated money wasn’t a good look either. At best they were neglectful and lied about it and at worst they were involved in some way.
Well you just totally blew any credibility regarding your criminal profiling abilities. Everybody and their dogs ( even cadaver and blood detecting ones) smells a rat regarding this couple and their behaviour. The truth behind this case is much darker than most can imagine, no-one is directing blame towards the McCann's to hide personal insecurities. Rather they are seeking justice for a child, the responsibility for who's disappearance lies firmly at the feet of her parents.
I rarely comments to any videos about the McCann case, though I have plenty of thoughts,opinions and beliefs about the case. One thing that’s puzzled me for many years,and that neither the Portuguese or British police have ever picked up on, as far as I know,is something from the very beginning of the holiday. The group were at the airport,one of the adults was filming,and panning from face to face,and when he reached Gerry,he said, “ Cheer up Gerry,you’re on holiday” and a stony faced Gerry replied, “ F**k off,I’m not here to enjoy myself”. That short clip used to be on UA-cam,but recently I’ve had difficulty finding it again. Why wasn’t Gerry ever asked,that was an odd comment to make.. what exactly did you mean..can you please explain… Just WHY weren’t you going on holiday to enjoy yourself? (And as an aside,how disrespectful for a father,sitting next to his three tiny tots,and also in front of his friends’ small children, to use bad language. I’m absolutely certain he wouldn’t use that expression in front of one of his patients.) But I agree totally with you @Maz that it wd be inappropriate for not just Kate McCann,but for any woman in a similar situation to her, to perform on Dancing on Ice. Nothing to do with believing that KMcC shouldn’t have fun. It would just seem so incongruous and unfitting for a parent who is only in the public eye because of a tragedy that happened to their child,to be invited to take part in a TV competition. The case never solved,the poor child’s fate still unknown,the mystery never explained fifteen years later,the parents guilty,if of nothing else, of leaving their tiny children unattended in an unlocked apartment. Surely no parent in such a situation would choose to accept an invitation to appear on an entertainment programme. It would just be wrong and would seem in poor taste. IMHO.
@@yowzer49 I just wrote this exact thing as the first thing in my comment. All the good stuff is gone off of UA-cam now. Gerry also had a discussion with his buddy about Maddy and they were discussing bjs. He circled his nipple and said that Maddy was starting to do that now or it was his daughter and he was asking if Maddy did it too. I can't quite remember it exactly but it was enough to tell me these guys were doing something very wrong with their toddler daughters.
I remember reading about this comment by Gerry or hearing it on U Tube. I remember hearing that there was some talk of sending Maddie to live with a relative. For someone who wanted children and a family so badly, it appears as though Kate may have had trouble handling 3 young children. That comment supposedly by Gerry makes me wonder what they had planned for Maddie. That statement about the nipple was witnessed by 2 doctors, a husband and wife who were friends with one of the Tapas group. They were invited to vacation with McCanns in either Greece or Spain. I cannot remember. The man asked Gerry if Maddie also “did this” as he moved his finger in and out of his mouth. The female doctor looked around to see if others heard and saw this too. She said the conversation got really quiet for an instant and then resumed. Have you seen the 3 pictures of Maddie? One with makeup and pearls, one with her on her back and the “iced lolly” photo? They are all disgusting. The 2 doctors reported the disgusting conversation between Gerry and ?? Oldfield or Payne to the British police twice I remember reading. Also they never had anything to do with that group of people again.
Gerry complained on the way to their vacation; this was pre-planned. They were a group that was sharing their children with each other. This is why the door was unlocked. They would bathe each others kids. They all were rich but refused free baby sitting. Gerry and a friend were seen talking about Maddy and the friend was saying something about Maddy or his own daughter and he was making a circular motion around his nipple while talking about a bj. It's been a long time so these are just bits and pieces I recall. Richard Hall did some excellent research and has a 3 piece video on it. I absolutely believe they are guilty. Kate lied right off the bat about their window being open, then they tested it and the thing didn't open at all. Nope, there's something wrong here and that starts with her parents.
@@claudia-Silva Dick Hall is a UFO hunter who believes the Manchester bombing victims were actors. It’s easy to debunk these lies about not being able to open the window etc ua-cam.com/video/E-T4K1n30wE/v-deo.html
I must admit who other ,than the parents and grannies wash the children in the bath ,that’s the flaw in this story and the conversation overheard by the Gappor couple ,that made me think “SWINGERS “ sad but it goes on ,it did in my area am afraid and probably still does!
Some people just don't comprehend the sinister nature of the world we live in. You can be sure that no matter where you are in the world predators walk amongst us.
I seem to remember a story that the child had been sold by the parents. I don't remember the details. As someone else noted if they' d been poor they would have received much different treatment. I raised 3 girls as a single mother. The father was a dysfunctional deadbeat. I blame nobody for my bad choice. Life was hard. I did all I could to stay working and pay for babysitters and daycare. I would have never leftthem alone. They are grown now and I still worry about them. Its very hard to overlook an educated , professional couple leaving their young children alone , foreign country or not.
@@stompthedragon4010 There was a rumour that they gave all the kids an over the counter treatment to aid sleep, something like kids' melatonin gummies/Calpol. It was never clarified, sorry I can't tell you any more than that.
I do not believe for one minute she was abducted, and those tapas 7 have not told the truth either along with Maddie's parents. Think of the differences of the little boy who went missing in kos, no great funds of millions for his search was made available, yet Maddie's family has had loads, even support was given to them from ex UK PM Blair and brown. Do you not find that alone strange.This brookner guy where has he appeared from in all these years, this guy from Germany, smells more fishy business to close down a case to me.
I’m sorry I would never leave my children alone in a room with the door open drugged them so I could have dinner in a foreign country come on these people are highly educated and as Drs it’s even worse . I have no Sympathy for the parents I am heartbroken over Madeline the mystery of her disappearance I just wonder if the doctors gave her some thing and she was dying and they got scared and got rid of the body I don’t even wanna think about it
Days after Gerry said ' I think the trolls may come to regret their actions'. One of the leading voices asking different questions was found dead in suspicious circumstances in a hotel room.
The reality is no one knows what happened to Madaline. These parents and their friends failed to cooperate and be completely open with the Portuguese Poice from the start. There have never been clear uncontradictory formal statements from Tapas 8. From the outset, this failure to be open and co-operate with the very authorities who were acting for Madeline and trying to help the McCanns opened the door to the negativity that continues. The lawsuits (which were all lost) against Portuguese authorities have not helped the international perception of the McCanns Many resent that they spent a huge amount of money donated to find Madeleine on lawsuits which in essence about defending the McCanns and their egos. We really don't know what happened to Madeline, it remains an open case both in Portugal and the UK. This analysis of a complex multi-faceted international crime sounds simplistic and biased. It sounds like written after reading a couple of Daily Mail articles after Sunday lunch. Does it matter whether some people like or don't like the McCanns ? What's important is a continued unemotional focus on evidence and the pursuit of the truth about what happened to the victim, a frightened little child who possibly suffered great fear and pain and may well be dead. Who cares about whether Kate appears on the On Ice thing? Not your usual or your best!
I have a feeling there is more to this story, the family are more culpable than people think… I feel about this case the way I do with the Ramsey case, the families are culpable.
I have a problem with laughing in unfortunate situations. It’s awful. It makes me feel really bad and the last thing I think is that there’s anything funny going on Nerves and anxiety often bring it on
I told someone my brother had just died and they laughed but I knew I'd just made basically a stranger feel uncomfortable. So don't feel bad. It's awkard
At my aunt's funeral, the six of us who were pallbearers were standing by the hearse as people were arriving and making their way into the church. My aunt was an amazing woman, and we were sharing memories that made us smile and laugh. Suffice it to say that many people gave us looks that made it clear they did not approve. She would have. Maybe it's because I grew up watching MASH (two episodes a night every weeknight!) - I learned that laughter was a good way to cope with tragedy. When I got older and studied psychology, I found out that there is actually empirical evidence behind that truism. I recall reading a paper recently that nervous laughter is not only very common, laughing at humor is simply one type of nervous laughter. FWIW, if you find it that troubling, there are cognitive behavioral approaches to controlling nervous laughter. You could look into that.
I think why the Mccscams are hated so much is because (a) they didn't seem to give two @@@#s about the children They left them in the holiday creche all day everyday and then left them all alone at night! Which is child neglect and (b) They weren't investigated they were calling all the shots They wouldn't be interviewed separately Why not? In every other case suspects are interviewed one at a time The detective was even told not to to 'touch' the parents were laughing and joking a day after Maddie 'went missing ' which put a lot of backs up Not only do this vile couple deserve all the hate they've received and more they should definitely not be allowed to walk free!
They had money and there was a child care facility on site 😅 with all due respect doc, we would slaughter the parents who went out all night too- neglect is neglect.
there's nothing to say that it's an abduction, there's no proof of that yet it was always treated as a missing child or abduction case ... the german man looks like he could be involved but there's no evidence, that's the problem.
I think you need to do a deep dive into this case, there is so much more than what you have mentioned. Parents are guilty. The death happened days before and that gave them time to work out a staged 'abduction' and gave them time to temporarily place Maddy somewhere. What about the forged last photo? What about the blood splatters? What about the cadever found? Dogs don't lie. People do. Including a bunch of well to do professionals who would do anything to save face.
I chastised a woman straight after she crashed her motorcycle once. She made a pretty stupid mistake and missed out on an amputated leg by inches. I should have just kept my mouth shut I reckon. But I also think you should expect people to let you know when you do something stupid. That's human nature.
You haven’t been raised properly. Believing it’s obligatory to attack grieving parents is evidence your parents must be awful people. Shame on your parents for neglecting to teach you compassion.
So much of what your saying makes sense , for me the thing that they did by leaving their children was dreadful , but no-one deserves to be forever punished for a bad choice , but was it just that ?There were other things that seemed odd for me that made me question like them washing Madelines toy ,I can only think if it were me I could never wash that toy ,but I would also NEVER leave my child alone . To get to the point of the dancing on Ice thing ,the reason I would not like her going on it is because it's supposed to be fir celebrities and we have enough contestants on these shows that are not actually celebrities , I think we need to be careful what we give the label celebrity for ,in my mind it should be for some sort of talent or skill .
But they didn't actually find anything. They indicated, but they never found anything. If you knew how often dogs indicated when nothing was there, you'd know better than to take a dog indicating as convincing evidence that something used to be there.
@@valerierodger7700 although they were dogs that had a huge success rate and they indicated in many places. Also who would wash cuddle cat? I would want her scent forever.
When it was the wake of my partner after his suicide, the photos didn't match up what was happening. Most of them were me crying but there was one when looking down looked like I was on a photoshoot. That one photo gave me so much grief especially how his family tried to portray that I didn't care.
My biggest fear is she’s no longer with us. Millions have been spent on finding this poor innocent child. I have to many negative comments about the children being left alone. The parents have to live with the life sentence of guilt and not knowing what happened on a daily basis and wouldn’t wish that on anyone .
I am not a troll but as has been said before no way would I have ever left my child alone anywhere never mind going out for dinner they are the most important thing in your life why would you leave them alone, I have never really sorted out how I feel about the them but if we had left are kids alone we would be in serious trouble when we got back to Britain for neglect but nothing ever happened to them very sad story for that little girl.....
I don't understand why you would call them pillars of the community just because they are doctors in that case they should have known better and got a baby sitter for the night they won't be short of a bob or too on the hole. I respect doctors but when you and others put them above ordinary people you are placing them above the rest of us and some doctors see themselves as gods and treat you that way very sad all round.....
No, the McCanns could not go to the show (skater's on ice, or whatever); because of the reality that the public was so harsh. People respond to grief & tragedy in all different ways. Unfortunately, currently, most people fail to recognize or respect that & create more grief & tragedy by judging other's emotions.
British media sometimes seems like it might be worse than American media when they fixate on certain cases. I’d love to hear your analysis of Amanda Knox and the murder of Meredith (forgot her last name). There seems to be a huge disconnect between Brits and Americans, probably due to media. There is no part of me that believes Amanda and Raphael had anything to do with it. Edit: I made this comment before I got to the end of the video where you answered my questions about Amanda Knox. 😀
You basically say that they wouldn't have done it because there "Doctors and there Pillars of the community" but surely there just human beings that are as capable as anybody else just because there highly educated doesn't mean you can't do bad
Agree with this opinion which helps me let go of my feelings about their critical lapse of judgement. I think the stoicism could have been a combination of personality (doctor profession typically = low neuroticism), grieving and guilt over their tragic mistake.
I’m sorry but you have based your opinions on what been released in the media. You would do well to read the official police files and make another video based on your understanding then.
Anyone who arrives at the conclusion she was abducted has not investigated this to any level I’m not surprised they received hate, they were responsible for their daughters death and disappearance and spent their lives post Maddie globetrotting everywhere except where Maddie would be, and doing everything except looking for her - why - because they knew where she was
Special request, Doc: Please get into the mind of the person who killed Mary Jane Kelly, supposed 5th victim of Jack the Ripper, despite a difference in, erm, styles between Jack and her killer. Just go off the description on Wikipedia, as described by Thomas Bond, surgeon, an early, perhaps first, English offender profiler. (I'm a bit lightheaded, and haven't even finished reading what "Jack" had done to the young woman, but I'd be interested in your thoughts on the perpetrator. I'm not squeamish, _but_ )
Good call, but I believe that it was same killer than had killed the othe four canonical victims. The massive escalation was due to the murder happening indoors; the killer could spend as much time as he liked with the body, unlike the other four, hence the horrific post mortem injuries.
You never mentioned Madeline once. I reckon Madeline was dead a few days. Also the Portuguese Police were sure they were guilty. They refused a Polygraph. Who cares about dancing on ice. They used the money to pay off there mortgage. The Mc Canns should have got jail for neglect. Ye,, how about Gerry playing tennis 2 days after Madeline,,,,,Death. And kate jogging on the beach. Why did they hire out a car,,,
I think what you are saying is right, i agree. However sedation was never proved just a theory. I agree, i see so much vitriol. The most hypocritical thing with people who disbelieve the larents cringe on about how much attention it gets, whilst at the same time giving it the exact same attention over other missing children, including forums.
I’ve come to the opinion that the parents are innocent, but I just can’t ever get my mind around their childcare plan (or lack thereof). Obviously, they could have never known what would happen. It’s just so hard to wrap your mind around it, especially knowing this was a group of doctors with access to a hundred better options - how could they have even had fun while having to get up constantly? Why not just hire or bring a sitter? Or one parent stay home? Again, I’m not blaming them for the abduction, but I just get stuck on this part. That part of the case is actually more of a mystery to me than the abduction. Maybe they have explained and I missed it, but I’ve never seen them actually give an explanation. I don’t want them punished or bullied, just to understand why they made that choice.
The babysitting was free. They refused after it was suggested that they accept it. That only happens for a reason. Please don't be so naive. The whole group was leaving their kids sedated behind unlocked doors. They were bathing each other's children. This was all on purpose, not by accident.
Have you watched the Netflix series? The McCanns explained that they didn’t want to use the resort’s babysitting service because it meant the kids would probably wake up when they went to get them. (the service wasn’t for the rooms but more like a centralized daycare location). All of the group agreed. I’m not saying that’s a good excuse (it’s not), but it is the reason they gave.
The friend admitted he didn’t see Madeline because he didn’t go into the room Saw the twins in their cots. Fact 9.30 check They are still under suspicion by Portugal police.
I think you are very naive sir the parents and the friends are responsible and everyone is keeping the secret. As for the dancing in ice argument how ludicrous to think she ever would go on a tv show after the whole world thinks she’s guilty
Losing a child doesn't strengthen your faith. It would make ne question it. I am not religious, but i hear despicable comments by some people, that God has a plan. I haven't heard it here, but that seems to be what religious fanatics believe. What merciful God would want this to happen to an innocent child? I would appreciate not hearing religious comments, because this has nothing to do with ones beliefs or any devine plan.
I heard the Podesta brothers were involved and the person that did all the leg work was removed from posting it as well as most things involved with famous people and children.
Are you familiar with Richard halls rigorous work on this case? Peter Hyatts statement analysis? Regardless of what happened, they still are grieving parents.
They prob sedated them at home too. Go out they are to blame any non selfish person wouldnt leave there kids, jimmy saville was a pillar of the community
I don't thing that they should suffer for the rest of their lives but they should not be gaining in any way of the back of neglecting their children. This includes gaining money from it or any celebrity status. This shows a lack of remorse for what they have done and they are not helping themselves in any way shape or form. If your a doctor and you are saying that it is dangerous to sedate a child then how could they not have known this? I really don't understand you perspective on this and they should not be working at doctors any more if they have put their own children in a life threatening situation using drugs. Surely if they did not know this they are not qualified practice any more. If they had not tried to gain celebrity status and had stopped working as doctors then people would not have so much anger towards them and would be more forgiving.
I'm only four minutes into this video and I can already see how biased you are towards the McCanns. Objectivity is crucial when discussing any true crime story, so I'm afraid this will not be worth my time.
A totally bias video towards mccanns !!!! Youve missed out crucial facts !!! Dogs , phone records and deletes , even the tanner sighting was clear up !! A very weak video and a lack of facts within it Very poor
To be honest, I don't have a definite opinion about this case, but I have an idea why parents behave in such a way. When a person disappears, the main suspect is usually the one who was with the missing person last. We know this from the movies. There's no sign of a break-in or blood or anything in the apartment. I'm sure even at this very moment the Portuguese police already were treating the parents as prime suspects and that's where all the tension between them and media started. Yes, the parents acted irresponsibly and risky. No doubt about it. But the police did not finish their work in the first hours either - the apartment had to be secured and the whole area searched with dogs and patrols, they had to immediately contact Interpol and contact the Spanish border services, etc. Why is it that after so many years after the disappearance of the child, it is discovered that this German was approximately where Madeleine disappeared, and the Portuguese authorities had no idea about him in 2007? Days before Madeline's disappearance, suspicious men had been going around asking about orphaned children, and no one had investigated it. Why is there no camera footage from bars, streets whatever? Why the hotel cameras were switched off? I mean, yeah, the parents may act weird , but still, all the attention is on them, everyone is judging them. But why is no one prosecuting the investigators on both sides? I've seen documentary footage of what it looks like around the hotel at night - so dark, so creepy. I hope after this tragedy it is now lit and there are cameras. As for whether parents should have fun - well that's their decision how they should live, and whoever wants to troll them will always troll them.
Some very dodgy decisions made far worse by their professional position of responsibility. At the very least. As far as Gerry is concerned do not many consultants, cardiac and Neuro in particular border on psychopathology in any case? I am led to believe that this is how they cope with the enormity of what they do? Committed suicide? Yesterday’s parlance surely?
Who saw Madeline in the room ? David Payne 😂😂 He said he went into the room and Kate was dressed and was there a while She said he never entered the apartment and she was in a towel and he was there a few seconds Why was he there ? Because Gerry had asked him to help take the kids to the recreation area ? Earlier Gerry had agreed with Kate the kids were going straight to bed Sorry my friend - you have not investigated this case at all have you
Your acting is dreadful 😮if I were you I would go back to my regular day job, some of the facts you quoted are incorrect, whereas there's many hard accurate facts widely known and easily accessible, you don't necessarily need the contaminated crime scene or the cadaver dogs the Portuguese authority should of given Mr Amaral more time and support including support from UK police.
I can't get over leaving the children drugged & the door ajar, even if they were in the room the drugging (dangerous in any amount for children, toddlers, as Dr they know this)......child abuse for sure.....sooo sad
Gerry was assembling posters and information to spread awareness that Maddie was missing. He wanted to emphasise the fleck in her iris as a distinguishing point. He was harshly advised against it for the reason the 'abductor' would harm her, or even kill her, because she would be too visible. Gerry went ahead with it anyway saying "it is a good marketing ploy". I think he knew she would not be found so it didnt matter.
8 888
They killed her with sedatives. Plain and simple. Her wailing was of a mother who child was dead and not lost. She blamed herself for leaving her. Because a sedated child should be monitored. And their language indicates they already know she's dead.
This is the most audacious non- government related cover-up I've ever seen.
100 percent agree with you. I think If suspect Bruckner was involved in any way he was brought in to dispose of the evidence. Cadaver dogs scent etc were right Portuguese police were right ....
I doubt doctors would accidentally give a lethal dose to their children also why would they do it?
If Maddie was heavily sedated, she wouldn't have been awake to get into an accident, but perhaps awake enough to stumble around, and get injured, and died. It was dark in the apartment, so maybe she was alert enough to climb onto the sofa to peek out the window, but fell, and hit her head hard.
The child was gone a few days before Katie sounded the alarm. They needed time to dispose of the child, get their alibi straight, then report her missing.
@@Emy53 No evidence that any of the children were sedated. No evidence of a death in the apartment. Kate was reported to be completely distraught on the night she was reported missing, yet we're supposed to believe Maddie died several days earlier and that kate and Gerry wined and dined that night completely naturally?
No evidenc whatsoever that any of the children were sedated, so what's so plain and simple then?
Hi, I was a nanny for a doctor who used to sedate her four children including a premature baby. I was shown what to give the baby, and the milk went a pink/purple colour. When the parents left, I poured the contents down the sink. I gave him a warm bath, fed him formula and put him down to sleep. There was no way I was going to prison by following this crazy woman's instructions. Just want to add, I have left my children asleep whilst attending a dinner party next door at my neighbour's house and I just didn't feel comfortable. I was just steps from my door but after checking on them a few times, I went home. It just didn't sit right with me. I just couldn't relax and I could see into my home. What were these parents thinking, who leaves the door unlocked whilst in a foreign country?
I did this a couple of times with my Son and could not settle. We had a baby moniter attached to us in our neighbours, but I hated it and did not bother any more. I felt so bad. Right next door too.
@@andreamacgillivray3653 I also wondered why they didn’t use a baby monitor and to leave the door open is highly suspect.
@@sheilaboland6285almost as if they “wanted” her to be taken, irresponsible fools 🙄
Almost 😂😂😂@@___Alina___24
God bless you. Sedating children to sleep is child abuse. An older child with an occasional insomnia might warrant a minimal intervention, but a premature baby? My view is the first three months you should be there almost all the time holding the baby as much as possible. There is a reason this time is called “the fourth trimester”.
The dogs picked up the scent of death in their rental car and they found her blood. How were they not arrested for this?!?
That’s not enough evidence for any conviction
They actually rented that car 3 days after she disappeared. The dna was found in the apartment however there was 4 matching. The father mother and siblings. There is no conclusive evidence regarding this case. My opinion is that the father was involved whether that was drugging her or not. There is also no evidence that she was abducted. I believe she died in that apartment. She was dumped in the sea before the police were called. one of their friends saw a man carrying a blonde girl around the time that Gerry was standing talking to a friend at that same moment. GERRY DOESNT REMEMBER SEEING HIM. 🤔 I think Gerry organised this whole thing.SHE OVERDOSED. WHY WOULDNT THEY GIVE A POLYGRAPH. IF MY DAUGHTER WENT MISSING I WOULD GIVE A DAM POLY.
I think Maddie died early during the vacation. The last picture shown at the pool shows a child who has not been in the sun. I think she was sedated, got up and climbed onto the sofa trying to look for her parents. She likely fell off the back and died of an ICH, or broke her neck, or died of positional asphyxia. The McCann’s had several days to stage the abduction. Body was likely in the apt. Briefly, then stored somewhere, and later moved in trunk of rent car to unknown final location. Too risky to put her in ocean as parts could wash up later. Also, blood dog found blood in rocks under porch so she could have fallen off high porch and died in the rocks. My question is, how could upstairs neighbor hear children crying for 45 min. And not call Portugal equivalent of 911.???
I think the reason why there was a hit by the dogs in the rental car, is because the child was disposed of in a double bag. The inner bag was disposed of with the child, but the outer bag was kept to use for their luggage. Bodily fluids may have leaked onto that bag, and when they placed it in their rental car, the transfer of death got on the carpet.
The smell of cadaver was also detected on kate McCann's clothes and the stuffed toy she used too constantly carry around with her
Why has the British government paid out 14 million pounds on this one missing child? No other child has anywhere near that amount spent. Nor have they been the subject of appeals from the Royal Family. Why Maddie?
Deflection - to stop anyone pointing the finger at the parents
They spent much on fighting libel cases, NOT looking for Maddie
The parents were terrible to endanger their children in the way they did. Truly shocking!
i didn't think they killed the daughter but the thing that angered me was disparity in treatment that the upper classes recieve in contrast to disadvantaged families, like that which i grew up in. when I was a child social services were called out simply because of my poverty as a child. My mother wouldn't have dreamed of leaving me alone all night. If she had, no doubt i would have been put in care. So no, I don't blame the maccanns for accessing what help they could, any parent would, but in reality, if they had been " rough around the edges" most likely their younger kids would have been removed , especially when there are significant suspicions that they sedated their kids. My nieces and nephews would be in care as quick as 1,2,3 if my sister did that. They were afforded much because of their status in the community but in fact they should have known better than us mere "plebians". Furthermore, they easily earned enough to access the child care that was available where they were staying. All that said , i would never harrass them, At the end of the day, they must live with their choices, which were catastrophic.
You are absolutely right. I was the single mother of 3. Their father was a dysfunctional deadbeat. I don't blame anyone else for my bad choice. Life was not easy. I did everything I could to stay working and pay for babysitters and daycare. Tried to be a positive role model. I would have never left my kids alone. We lived in poor areas and it was a field day for children's s services. Look- up Kids For Cash in Luzerne County, Pennsylvania USA. And the McCain s were educated professionals . Its pretty reprehensible.
@@stompthedragon4010 Agreed
think they did have the local C&F social services team "assess" them, - but yes agree with everything you have written. Sedating one's own children through medication they could obtain because they wanted peace and quiet?! What! Surely that is a criminal offence in its own right? Thought their behaviours just a few days after losing Madeline were strangely emotionally disconnected. I have a suspicion the Police in Portugal would want this case closed, and am a little sceptical/cynical about recent developments. Above all, never, not once, were my two daughters left alone evenings or at night. Just stunningly, unthinkable stupidity.
@@tonyburton419 great points although I think the police in Portugal have been silenced regarding their own findings/positions regarding the parents. I think Scotland Yard wants this case closed.
@@mads597 Quite possibly.
I will never ever understand why on earth those two doctors (with their income) nor their friends did not hire a babysitter for their kids. It has bothered me all these years. There is no way I would have left my kids unattended anywhere abroad at that age and I come from a country where you can leave your kids sleeping outside on their afternoon nap basically 'anywhere'. Such a sad case!
Because they narcissistically assumed they knew best, and they sedated their kids so they wouldn’t have to worry about them while they enjoyed their evening with friends. Two medical professionals, their arrogance led to the death of one of their kids, and they had the connections to cover it up.
@@mads597 Okay but sadate is a strong word, she literally have them each (not just Madeline) a half a melitonin gummy made for children. I'm a nanny and many of my clients have me give these to their kids, usually age 4+ as it helps kids relax and fall asleep. The main danger is giving it to them before a bath as they could fall asleep and drown without supervision and also if they take the gummies after brushing their teeth it will cause cavities.
Because oftentimes wealthy people are super tight with their money. I know a guy who earns 80k+ and refuses to pay for a sitter. 🤷🏻♀️
@@consciencekiller not an excuse for child neglect
@@m0bz0mb38 Obviously it isn't. I was simply answering a question
I still believe she died by accident in the Apartment, there was blood behind gge sofa and cadaver and blood dogs reacted to the Apartment and the parents
I will always believe they are responsible they didn't even look for her!
correction!
The friend of the McCann's reported to have gone to check on Madeleine before Kate told detectives that he stood by the bedroom and listened for signs that the children might be awake. he did not physically enter the room and see Madeleine in her bed.
Conveniently!
Stuff of the tapas bar said, there was no checking, they never left the table.
Its obvious he says "I will go and check but i am not saying i saw maddie" cos if maddie is found hes in the poo big time
I get that they're Drs, they have to be professional, detached, as when they're speaking to patients, family etc when they're delivering bad news but the unfortunate thing about the McCanns is that they can come across as smug. Many years ago a 3 year old boy went missing in Greece, and the media were nowhere near as sympathetic or as supportive to that boy's family. It seemed as though because the McCanns were middle class and Drs they were above reproach. That young boy's family was never given the positive publicity that the McCanns received
Yes Ben Needam. Did Kerry the mother, and family want money?. No, just their child back like countlessare others. Kerry and family have expressed their feelings on radio shows TV etc. They are from Sheffield as I am, the contrast between the MacCanns, feelings and the Needam's are planets apart. The Needam's never neglected Ben. Never found him.
After McCann stored Maddie in the bag in the wardrobe he then managed to take her to a rented house with a fridge and stored her there for some weeks until in a panic he and Kate retrieved Maddie and drove her away to be buried or DISPOSED OF - as McCann actually said before correcting himself.
They did this on a warm day so that Maddie melted and ripped cadaver fluid over the car and KMcC's clothes and the soft toy cuddle cat.
Maddies was disposed of in the remote triangle of south west Portugal in such a way that the McCanns know she will never be found so they are free to sneer at all suggestions of her death being their fault.
After the disposal they tried to cleanse the car with disinfectants and leaving the tailgate open for at least two days! But the dog found the cadaver smell.
I don't understand why people refer to this as a disappearance. It's not like she vanished into thin air by magic, or just wandered off into a ditch and got buried alive, or some Moroccan pido snatched her out of her bed and jumped out the window.
Still , disappearance is more accurate than abduction.
I like to put it like this: she has been hidden from us in a dark place, and won't ever be seen again.
YEA so she openned the window , then the shutters ,, then buggered off!!!! The child was obviously OCD off the scale!!!!
They left their own 3 little children alone, with the door unlocked, in an apartment. I make no apology for my opinion that the couple deserve everything they get...
The door was open actually, so that they could peek in without waking the kids up. So…yeah. Even worse than unlocked and hard to grasp.
Ben Needham is forgotten, sadly...
I've often wondered, if the parents were council house tenants who had left their children, would the social services have got involved and tried to put the other siblings in care. We'll never know but I suspect they would.
That's a good point .
Everyone knows they would've been up a creek if they were ordinary people.
I agree ... money gets away with more than the average person
They did, they have never stopped being accused. Made up stories in fact they have recwived just as much hatred as support. So no it wudnt just happen to council owners and why council owners why do ppl like you say this and put them down
I have the the feeling that it’s because they are doctors that the general population are showering them with so much hatred
If you’ve ever actually looked into the case, you’ll really understand the amount they did to put their daughter in jeopardy and why a lot of people strongly suspect they had something to do with her disappearance. The fact cadaver dogs found the scent of death in their hire car in a garage with other vehicles, granted, it could’ve been from a previous hire, but what are the odds? They washed items that could have had evidence on them, like her teddy and blanket, refused a lie detector even though they “had nothing to hide”, publicising her eye defect even though they were advised not to… there’s so much more to the story that really has you question the McCann’s involvement. I think the theory of an accidental OD is the most likely, they would have ALL lost their licenses to practice, most definitely, if found out that they were drugging their kids to have a few drinks at a bar. Who knows if the McCann’s were good parents before she disappeared? Just because there aren’t any reports nor investigations doesn’t mean they were pillar parents. She was 3 after all, that’s not a very long time to detect maltreatment, especially in the form of deliberate drugging. My heart seriously breaks for any parent that loses their child, by any means, but the McCann’s are seriously questionable.
Body never found,body that can't speak.
It wasnt just a lapse in judgement and they have never really admitted wrongdoing or remorse and for me, that’s what really gets my back up
If I had done that not that I would do that I would be crumpled on the floor saying why did I do it, but they have tried to justify their decision saying how close how many yards. It was the way how it was the damn thing at the time, they have spent so much time justifying their poor decisions which cost Madeleine her life, but I don’t wanna see them on dancing on ice I don’t wanna see them anywhere
My god u have to be so right.The twins are in their teens now.I did here something very early in the case about little Madelene she was a little darling.I aslo heard that Madelene was adopted.They should be arrested now why wait and they might tell the truth.I hope they are they look petriefied.
@@theresedoyle2832 I really doubt she is adopted, she looks the spitting image of her parents
If you've actually looked into the case you would have read the Martin Grime reports: Eddie was a multi-disciplined dog that would alert to the scent of a cadaver, dried blood form a living person and other bodily scents. Eddie made no distinction between alerts, so no one knows if he alerted to the scent of a cadaver or dried blood. Eddie was never put into the car, he only alerted to the passenger side door in which was found a key card. Both Eddie and Keela alerted to the card. Keela would only alert to dried blood. No evidence that any of the children were drugged btw.
When looking into this case. They were asked something like 40 odd questions where they refused to answer all but one. They also were in talks to letting the mothers sister adopt Madeline due to her bad behaviour. Not sure if the adoption part is true but the questions are well documented. The questions could of lead to better Ideas of what happened to their child. If you were the parent surely you would answer all questions they were asked to try their best to find her. They also didn’t look for her. Plus their friend lied about seeing a man carrying a girl last at night. There are too many issues with the parents to fully believe them. As a mother of three I can’t imagine how horrible it would be to lose a child the way they did.
They already answered questions twice to what they were doing that night. She was advised by her lawyer not to answer the questions. None of the questions were posed to help find maddy, tell me one question how it would of helped finding her? Jane tanner did not lie, you cant just say it was made up, given someone confirmed it was them that night.
Also where is the source about her sister which would be her sister in law as its gerrys sister, kate does not have one, taking on maddy? I want a well documented source as you have just claimed.
Correct they didn't cooperate with the PT investigation which suffered outstanding pressures from the British ambassador not to investigate them contrary to all guidelines in missing persons cases.
@@rossblack9559 Kate had never been asked most of the questions she refused to answer. If your child was genuinely missing you would answer police questions over and over again if necessary.
@@ruthbashford3176 Such as? It's crazy to think someone like urself fantasies about missing children and parents you don't know
I always agree with what this guy says, but this time I have to disagree! They are to blame, if it was common people who left they kids unattended in a foreign country they would have social services take their other kids away for being neglectful! Damn right disgusting! And il always say it’s their fault. Of course whoever did whatever to her need stringing up! But the parents let it happen 100%!!
The problems with the McCanns is they felt entitled. Doctors, good jobs, rich. The did not want kids annoying them at their dinner everyday and felt they were entitled to having there adult time . Same with their daily activities, leave children at kids club.
What they wanted was an adult holiday. I took my son on holiday for 16 years and never dreamt of leaving him.
I think they possibly did drug them but like you say the time line doesn’t make sense for disposal of Madeleine.
Yes, I was thinking the same on the latter point: when would the parents have disposed of the body?...not that they couldn't have, but I've not seen a discussion of this issue by people who think they're guilty. It's an odd case at any rate, lots of rumours of cover up, contradictory statements from law enforcement/prosecutors in multiple countries, suspiciously behaving parents, but also a paedophile/sex offender being around at the time and place of the little girl's dissappearance. It doesn't get more confusing than this, I don't think.
I usually enjoy your content Sohom, but there is so much wrong with this video I am not going to be able to finish it. I respect your views as a professional but unfortunately to me this seems very much like a case of a “doctor standing up for another doctor” without knowing the full story (because NONE of us know the full story). In my opinion this is not something you should have covered and certainly not one where you just skim the surface of what is a deeply complex and mysterious case. This is YOUR channel and its totally your right to cover whatever you wish but in my opinion this one has really missed the mark, sorry but that is just how I feel. Look forward to seeing what else you have planned in the future.
AGREED. Totally inappropriate.
From day 1 I personally did not believe their story because of their behaviour afterwards. When the (Human Cadaverine/Human blood) trained dogs went in to the apartment and hire car weeks later it confirmed my suspicions. I don’t for a second believe the parents intended harm but I do believe because of their negligence Madeleine came to harm and to save their own reputations and careers they have covered up at the very least what truly happened. Since then they have made money from this by setting up a foundation and continue to do so. Every now and again this case pops up in the media with yet another red herring to keep the narrative going. There are many MANY other aspects to this case that I will not go into here but basically… the whole thing stinks to high Masonic heaven. Peter Hyatt (Professional statement analyst) puts a very interesting twist on these two ua-cam.com/video/uS6ucYudNAo/v-deo.html
@@lucieni 🎯
@@claudia-Silva I may be wrong but maybe it comes down to being a healthcare professional that ‘has to toe the line’ on this channel or it could be seen as giving out ‘misleading information’, spreading ‘conspiracy theories’ possibly putting a professional reputation at risk… Or maybe there is a genuine belief in the mainstream narrative. Even still we have our own opinions and personally I’m just following the evidence and body language of these two.
@@claudia-Silva Here in the U.K. at least the trolls are seen as the people not believing the narrative, that believe the parents were somewhat to blame, that covered up their mistreatment of their children to save their own skins both professionally and otherwise.
I'm intrigued how this has effected the twins. Growing up finding out and hearing all these things about your parents, survivors guilt perhaps? I hope they have people to talk to.
Yes, they'll be 18 soon, full adults and I'm sure many questions they have too. It's touching that Sean wants to find the 'bad man' himself.
Good point
As there was no evidence of a forced, "jemmied" window entry,, the McCanns then said that they left the apartment door, unlocked , despite Madeleine having a habit of getting up at night in their home and walking around. No mention of this was made to the police at the time when she disappeared. Then the McCanns tried to give the impression that this mysterious person carried Madeleine out of the small window, which involved raising a noisy, metal shutter, which no one heard, instead of the more quicker, secluded unlocked door by which they entered ! A difficult to believe state of affairs.
I’m sorry but I’m going to have to agree to disagree with your take on this case. They are Doctors as a profession but no parent whatever their profession would be as calm and collected as these two if their own child had actually been abducted. Their behaviour was never that of a parent who’s child had inexplicably disappeared from their ‘home’. “They’ve taken her” was what Kate said when she apparently discovered Madeleine missing. WTF?!! They take the twins to kindergarten (In front of the PAPs may I add) next morning then go jogging on the beach. Right ok! Devastated parent behaviour right there… NOT. I’ll end my rant here but there is so much more to this disgusting case than the mainstream media would ever care to put out. RIP Madeleine and I hope the truth will come out… at some stage.
@@claudia-Silva That’s exactly what clinched it for me. I’ve watched the footage of Eddie and Keela and it was very compelling.
@@claudia-Silva Me too.
I'm sorry but the parents did this they should have been prosecuted years ago
Weird that Dr Das has liked this comment despite saying the complete opposite in his video.
@@cw9007Exacting what I thought
I still, to this day, cannot get my head around the fact that they would even consider leaving their child/ren, not just the McCann's, but anyone in general, alone, in a motel room.
You wouldn't do it in your own home, so why do it anywhere else?
You can say what you want about this comment. I don't care.
I will forever blame the parents for their utter stupidity.
My mum wouldn't even go down to the grocer van if we were asleep in the flat she did without until dad came home and she could catch his later round. If we were awake we had to go with her.
By leaving them, they put them at risk. To me that is blatant neglect. This has been high profile for so long. Other children go missing daily but they don’t get this much attention. Anything could have happened not just kidnap.
I think that one reason why people were so hard, and to some extent still are so hard, on the McCans is that they were relatively wealthy, educated, professional people who had the resources with no strain at all to ensure the safety of their children. There are so many of us who couldn’t afford a vacation to the next town over without hardship, let alone a nanny for the kids so we can go get drunk while those kids remain safe that choosing to be so irresponsible is hard to understand. They had critical thinking skills. They had money. They were able to do better and didn’t choose to and while you say that they paid the ultimate price, it’s actually that baby who did.
As it happens, I don’t think they’re guilty of harming her (beyond drugging her) and I agree that they don’t need to be hounded. The focus should be on the child, not on the poor parenting. But I did want to try to express why I think they still draw ire.
Totally agree!
There is a case to answer to which they have miraculously avoided because of their status. The whole thing stinks of one big cover up and one rule for the upper class.
This is something upper middle class British parents do. A rather cold parenting until children are old enough to be abandoned in a boarding school.
Too many red flags in the whole case. I don’t know of anyone who has ever left their kids alone in a hotel room and it’s much further away from there they were eating than Gerry made out. So many things! Paying their mortgage with donated money wasn’t a good look either. At best they were neglectful and lied about it and at worst they were involved in some way.
People like you are so horrifically judgmental. I’m sure you think you’re an awesome, perceptive person but you’re really just hateful.
Read the PJ Files
Well you just totally blew any credibility regarding your criminal profiling abilities. Everybody and their dogs ( even cadaver and blood detecting ones) smells a rat regarding this couple and their behaviour. The truth behind this case is much darker than most can imagine, no-one is directing blame towards the McCann's to hide personal insecurities. Rather they are seeking justice for a child, the responsibility for who's disappearance lies firmly at the feet of her parents.
No dancing on ice!Severely inappropriate!Only reason she needs to be on TV is for her missing daughter.That is taking the pi--.
I rarely comments to any videos about the McCann case, though I have plenty of thoughts,opinions and beliefs about the case.
One thing that’s puzzled me for many years,and that neither the Portuguese or British police have ever picked up on, as far as I know,is something from the very beginning of the holiday.
The group were at the airport,one of the adults was filming,and panning from face to face,and when he reached Gerry,he said, “ Cheer up Gerry,you’re on holiday” and a stony faced Gerry replied, “ F**k off,I’m not here to enjoy myself”. That short clip used to be on UA-cam,but recently I’ve had difficulty finding it again.
Why wasn’t Gerry ever asked,that was an odd comment to make..
what exactly did you mean..can you please explain…
Just WHY weren’t you going on holiday to enjoy yourself?
(And as an aside,how disrespectful for a father,sitting next to his three tiny tots,and also in front of his friends’ small children, to use bad language. I’m absolutely certain he wouldn’t use that expression in front of one of his patients.)
But I agree totally with you @Maz that it wd be inappropriate for not just Kate McCann,but for any woman in a similar situation to her, to perform on Dancing on Ice.
Nothing to do with believing that KMcC shouldn’t have fun.
It would just seem so incongruous and unfitting for a parent who is only in the public eye because of a tragedy that happened to their child,to be invited to take part in a TV competition.
The case never solved,the poor child’s fate still unknown,the mystery never explained fifteen years later,the parents guilty,if of nothing else, of leaving their tiny children unattended in an unlocked apartment.
Surely no parent in such a situation would choose to accept an invitation to appear on an entertainment programme. It would just be wrong and would seem in poor taste. IMHO.
@@yowzer49 this is so interesting, I’d never heard of this before.
@@mads597 I found it… ua-cam.com/video/fioaKZwljgw/v-deo.html
@@yowzer49 I just wrote this exact thing as the first thing in my comment. All the good stuff is gone off of UA-cam now. Gerry also had a discussion with his buddy about Maddy and they were discussing bjs. He circled his nipple and said that Maddy was starting to do that now or it was his daughter and he was asking if Maddy did it too. I can't quite remember it exactly but it was enough to tell me these guys were doing something very wrong with their toddler daughters.
I remember reading about this comment by Gerry or hearing it on U Tube. I remember hearing that there was some talk of sending Maddie to live with a relative. For someone who wanted children and a family so badly, it appears as though Kate may have had trouble handling 3 young children. That comment supposedly by Gerry makes me wonder what they had planned for Maddie. That statement about the nipple was witnessed by 2 doctors, a husband and wife who were friends with one of the Tapas group. They were invited to vacation with McCanns in either Greece or Spain. I cannot remember. The man asked Gerry if Maddie also “did this” as he moved his finger in and out of his mouth. The female doctor looked around to see if others heard and saw this too. She said the conversation got really quiet for an instant and then resumed. Have you seen the 3 pictures of Maddie? One with makeup and pearls, one with her on her back and the “iced lolly” photo? They are all disgusting. The 2 doctors reported the disgusting conversation between Gerry and ?? Oldfield or Payne to the British police twice I remember reading. Also they never had anything to do with that group of people again.
Gerry complained on the way to their vacation; this was pre-planned.
They were a group that was sharing their children with each other. This is why the door was unlocked. They would bathe each others kids. They all were rich but refused free baby sitting.
Gerry and a friend were seen talking about Maddy and the friend was saying something about Maddy or his own daughter and he was making a circular motion around his nipple while talking about a bj. It's been a long time so these are just bits and pieces I recall.
Richard Hall did some excellent research and has a 3 piece video on it. I absolutely believe they are guilty. Kate lied right off the bat about their window being open, then they tested it and the thing didn't open at all. Nope, there's something wrong here and that starts with her parents.
You’re just about as mixed up as it’s possible to be, you have reached a erroneous conclusion based on internet misinformation.
@@claudia-Silva Dick Hall is a UFO hunter who believes the Manchester bombing victims were actors.
It’s easy to debunk these lies about not being able to open the window etc
ua-cam.com/video/E-T4K1n30wE/v-deo.html
@@goncaloamaral7846 its not misinformation
@@iseultmackinnon8197 watch the video I’ve provided a link above to: I’ve proved the claim wrong. There’s other errors in the post.
I must admit who other ,than the parents and grannies wash the children in the bath ,that’s the flaw in this story and the conversation overheard by the Gappor couple ,that made me think “SWINGERS “ sad but it goes on ,it did in my area am afraid and probably still does!
Some people just don't comprehend the sinister nature of the world we live in. You can be sure that no matter where you are in the world predators walk amongst us.
I seem to remember a story that the child had been sold by the parents. I don't remember the details. As someone else noted if they' d been poor they would have received much different treatment. I raised 3 girls as a single mother. The father was a dysfunctional deadbeat. I blame nobody for my bad choice. Life was hard. I did all I could to stay working and pay for babysitters and daycare. I would have never leftthem alone. They are grown now and I still worry about them. Its very hard to overlook an educated , professional couple leaving their young children alone , foreign country or not.
Who sells their first born child?
Nobody.
@@peterjamescullen bad, evil people
@@stompthedragon4010 Not these guys. And not in the full view of the world.
Why did they do it? Because it was an accident, with the sedatives … is a common theory
I did not know the children were sedated. Was there another child involved?
@@stompthedragon4010 There was a rumour that they gave all the kids an over the counter treatment to aid sleep, something like kids' melatonin gummies/Calpol. It was never clarified, sorry I can't tell you any more than that.
@@ShipsKat thanks. In any case this was horrendous and they shoild have been charged and lost the other kids.
Calpol night was not available at this time, but don't forget Kate is an anaestologist.
We all know they did it …. You aren’t helping
Do tell.
You're the expert 🤦♀️
@@clairehooton2211 yea … dogs don’t lie … cadaver alert in apartment and their hire car … explain please these inconsistencies
Watch Richard Halls in-depth analysis.
@@linoleumbonypart385 you are a typical example of the Dunning-Kruger effect.
I think it was an accident, then cover up. They had help. They didn't get rid of her, someone did it for them. It's who you know. Just my opinion.
The government sent a top Press Officer the day after. Gerry clearly has friends in high places.
@@markjones1337 he certainly does.
Agree
Why did this event garner so much attention? Tragedies like this occur much too often, and all are not in the media as this was/is.
I think your University education was wasted on you . Perhaps you should research every aspect of the case before making this program .
I do not believe for one minute she was abducted, and those tapas 7 have not told the truth either along with Maddie's parents. Think of the differences of the little boy who went missing in kos, no great funds of millions for his search was made available, yet Maddie's family has had loads, even support was given to them from ex UK PM Blair and brown. Do you not find that alone strange.This brookner guy where has he appeared from in all these years, this guy from Germany, smells more fishy business to close down a case to me.
I’m sorry I would never leave my children alone in a room with the door open drugged them so I could have dinner in a foreign country come on these people are highly educated and as Drs it’s even worse . I have no Sympathy for the parents I am heartbroken over Madeline the mystery of her disappearance I just wonder if the doctors gave her some thing and she was dying and they got scared and got rid of the body I don’t even wanna think about it
I agree. That is like child abuse imo
@@sherrihinton8567 Highly unlikely
Days after Gerry said ' I think the trolls may come to regret their actions'. One of the leading voices asking different questions was found dead in suspicious circumstances in a hotel room.
Bit too coincidental for me. Almost like it was all a set up.
No. You're seeing conspiracy theories where there are none. And a dead person can't regret anything.
The reality is no one knows what happened to Madaline. These parents and their friends failed to cooperate and be completely open with the Portuguese Poice from the start. There have never been clear uncontradictory formal statements from Tapas 8. From the outset, this failure to be open and co-operate with the very authorities who were acting for Madeline and trying to help the McCanns opened the door to the negativity that continues. The lawsuits (which were all lost) against Portuguese authorities have not helped the international perception of the McCanns Many resent that they spent a huge amount of money donated to find Madeleine on lawsuits which in essence about defending the McCanns and their egos. We really don't know what happened to Madeline, it remains an open case both in Portugal and the UK.
This analysis of a complex multi-faceted international crime sounds simplistic and biased. It sounds like written after reading a couple of Daily Mail articles after Sunday lunch. Does it matter whether some people like or don't like the McCanns ? What's important is a continued unemotional focus on evidence and the pursuit of the truth about what happened to the victim, a frightened little child who possibly suffered great fear and pain and may well be dead. Who cares about whether Kate appears on the On Ice thing? Not your usual or your best!
I have a feeling there is more to this story, the family are more culpable than people think…
I feel about this case the way I do with the Ramsey case, the families are culpable.
Hi Sohom, love your work, Would you please do a video on Jonbenet Ramsey. Thank you. All the best.
Car wasn’t searched for days, then the police dogs flagged up the car
Of course the dog will flag up a car the child had been in previously. If you don't understand the reason why, then you are a bit dumb.
Days? Dogs didn’t come until months later.
Nope. The dogs alerted on the rental car that the McCanns didn’t rent until a month after the disappearance. Meant nothing.
It was 30 meters at least and condo faced street. They made a tragic response. That poor child. Get a babysitter.
I have a problem with laughing in unfortunate situations. It’s awful. It makes me feel really bad and the last thing I think is that there’s anything funny going on
Nerves and anxiety often bring it on
I told someone my brother had just died and they laughed but I knew I'd just made basically a stranger feel uncomfortable.
So don't feel bad.
It's awkard
At my aunt's funeral, the six of us who were pallbearers were standing by the hearse as people were arriving and making their way into the church. My aunt was an amazing woman, and we were sharing memories that made us smile and laugh. Suffice it to say that many people gave us looks that made it clear they did not approve.
She would have.
Maybe it's because I grew up watching MASH (two episodes a night every weeknight!) - I learned that laughter was a good way to cope with tragedy. When I got older and studied psychology, I found out that there is actually empirical evidence behind that truism.
I recall reading a paper recently that nervous laughter is not only very common, laughing at humor is simply one type of nervous laughter. FWIW, if you find it that troubling, there are cognitive behavioral approaches to controlling nervous laughter. You could look into that.
I think why the Mccscams are hated so much is because (a) they didn't seem to give two @@@#s about the children They left them in the holiday creche all day everyday and then left them all alone at night! Which is child neglect and (b) They weren't investigated they were calling all the shots They wouldn't be interviewed separately Why not? In every other case suspects are interviewed one at a time The detective was even told not to to 'touch' the parents were laughing and joking a day after Maddie 'went missing ' which put a lot of backs up Not only do this vile couple deserve all the hate they've received and more they should definitely not be allowed to walk free!
They had money and there was a child care facility on site 😅 with all due respect doc, we would slaughter the parents who went out all night too- neglect is neglect.
Dr Das, I think if you took the time to watch Richard Halls in-depth analysis your opinion may change.
Richard Hall is a UFO hunter and.
UA-cam conspiracy theorist not a a
criminologist. He’s never solved a crime in his life. Act your age.
I agree.
there's nothing to say that it's an abduction, there's no proof of that yet it was always treated as a missing child or abduction case ... the german man looks like he could be involved but there's no evidence, that's the problem.
I think you need to do a deep dive into this case, there is so much more than what you have mentioned. Parents are guilty. The death happened days before and that gave them time to work out a staged 'abduction' and gave them time to temporarily place Maddy somewhere. What about the forged last photo? What about the blood splatters? What about the cadever found? Dogs don't lie. People do. Including a bunch of well to do professionals who would do anything to save face.
I chastised a woman straight after she crashed her motorcycle once. She made a pretty stupid mistake and missed out on an amputated leg by inches. I should have just kept my mouth shut I reckon. But I also think you should expect people to let you know when you do something stupid. That's human nature.
You haven’t been raised properly. Believing it’s obligatory to attack grieving parents is evidence your parents must be awful people. Shame on your parents for neglecting to teach you compassion.
So much of what your saying makes sense , for me the thing that they did by leaving their children was dreadful , but no-one deserves to be forever punished for a bad choice , but was it just that ?There were other things that seemed odd for me that made me question like them washing Madelines toy ,I can only think if it were me I could never wash that toy ,but I would also NEVER leave my child alone . To get to the point of the dancing on Ice thing ,the reason I would not like her going on it is because it's supposed to be fir celebrities and we have enough contestants on these shows that are not actually celebrities , I think we need to be careful what we give the label celebrity for ,in my mind it should be for some sort of talent or skill .
If I had made a bad choice like that I'd want to die
It was the British Cadaver dogs that threw a spanner in the works for me
But they didn't actually find anything. They indicated, but they never found anything.
If you knew how often dogs indicated when nothing was there, you'd know better than to take a dog indicating as convincing evidence that something used to be there.
@@valerierodger7700 although they were dogs that had a huge success rate and they indicated in many places. Also who would wash cuddle cat? I would want her scent forever.
doctors r used to being celebrities...
When it was the wake of my partner after his suicide, the photos didn't match up what was happening. Most of them were me crying but there was one when looking down looked like I was on a photoshoot. That one photo gave me so much grief especially how his family tried to portray that I didn't care.
Children were sedated! They were always concerned about that. If Maddy wasn't sedated would not have been abducted!
My biggest fear is she’s no longer with us. Millions have been spent on finding this poor innocent child. I have to many negative comments about the children being left alone. The parents have to live with the life sentence of guilt and not knowing what happened on a daily basis and wouldn’t wish that on anyone .
"devouted catholics" is a v creative take...almost like defrocked
I am not a troll but as has been said before no way would I have ever left my child alone anywhere never mind going out for dinner they are the most important thing in your life why would you leave them alone,
I have never really sorted out how I feel about the them but if we had left are kids alone we would be in serious trouble when we got back to Britain for neglect but nothing ever happened to them very sad story for that little girl.....
I don't understand why you would call them pillars of the community just because they are doctors in that case they should have known better and got a baby sitter for the night they won't be short of a bob or too on the hole.
I respect doctors but when you and others put them above ordinary people you are placing them above the rest of us and some doctors see themselves as gods and treat you that way very sad all round.....
No, the McCanns could not go to the show (skater's on ice, or whatever); because of the reality that the public was so harsh.
People respond to grief & tragedy in all different ways. Unfortunately, currently, most people fail to recognize or respect that & create more grief & tragedy by judging other's emotions.
Faith is faith. Latching on to an image of church goer does not exonerate you. Oh dear the parents are desperate and pretenders.
British media sometimes seems like it might be worse than American media when they fixate on certain cases. I’d love to hear your analysis of Amanda Knox and the murder of Meredith (forgot her last name). There seems to be a huge disconnect between Brits and Americans, probably due to media.
There is no part of me that believes Amanda and Raphael had anything to do with it.
Edit: I made this comment before I got to the end of the video where you answered my questions about Amanda Knox. 😀
You basically say that they wouldn't have done it because there "Doctors and there Pillars of the community" but surely there just human beings that are as capable as anybody else just because there highly educated doesn't mean you can't do bad
Perhaps he'd like to analyse Dr Shipman
Agree with this opinion which helps me let go of my feelings about their critical lapse of judgement. I think the stoicism could have been a combination of personality (doctor profession typically = low neuroticism), grieving and guilt over their tragic mistake.
Well as long as you can forgivetheir critical lapse of judgment the world can fish be a better place now !
That's because they had something to do with it
I’m sorry but you have based your opinions on what been released in the media. You would do well to read the official police files and make another video based on your understanding then.
Celebrity's have urged police 😂😂😂 knowing the parents have hidden her the scumbags
Anyone who arrives at the conclusion she was abducted has not investigated this to any level
I’m not surprised they received hate, they were responsible for their daughters death and disappearance and spent their lives post Maddie globetrotting everywhere except where Maddie would be, and doing everything except looking for her - why - because they knew where she was
Special request, Doc: Please get into the mind of the person who killed Mary Jane Kelly, supposed 5th victim of Jack the Ripper, despite a difference in, erm, styles between Jack and her killer. Just go off the description on Wikipedia, as described by Thomas Bond, surgeon, an early, perhaps first, English offender profiler. (I'm a bit lightheaded, and haven't even finished reading what "Jack" had done to the young woman, but I'd be interested in your thoughts on the perpetrator. I'm not squeamish, _but_ )
Ohhhh good call
Good call, but I believe that it was same killer than had killed the othe four canonical victims. The massive escalation was due to the murder happening indoors; the killer could spend as much time as he liked with the body, unlike the other four, hence the horrific post mortem injuries.
“Catholics are unique creatures “ said by a recovering Catholic.
You never mentioned Madeline once. I reckon Madeline was dead a few days. Also the Portuguese Police were sure they were guilty. They refused a Polygraph. Who cares about dancing on ice. They used the money to pay off there mortgage. The Mc Canns should have got jail for neglect. Ye,, how about Gerry playing tennis 2 days after Madeline,,,,,Death. And kate jogging on the beach. Why did they hire out a car,,,
I think what you are saying is right, i agree. However sedation was never proved just a theory. I agree, i see so much vitriol. The most hypocritical thing with people who disbelieve the larents cringe on about how much attention it gets, whilst at the same time giving it the exact same attention over other missing children, including forums.
I’ve come to the opinion that the parents are innocent, but I just can’t ever get my mind around their childcare plan (or lack thereof). Obviously, they could have never known what would happen. It’s just so hard to wrap your mind around it, especially knowing this was a group of doctors with access to a hundred better options - how could they have even had fun while having to get up constantly? Why not just hire or bring a sitter? Or one parent stay home? Again, I’m not blaming them for the abduction, but I just get stuck on this part.
That part of the case is actually more of a mystery to me than the abduction. Maybe they have explained and I missed it, but I’ve never seen them actually give an explanation. I don’t want them punished or bullied, just to understand why they made that choice.
The babysitting was free. They refused after it was suggested that they accept it.
That only happens for a reason. Please don't be so naive. The whole group was leaving their kids sedated behind unlocked doors. They were bathing each other's children.
This was all on purpose, not by accident.
Have you watched the Netflix series? The McCanns explained that they didn’t want to use the resort’s babysitting service because it meant the kids would probably wake up when they went to get them. (the service wasn’t for the rooms but more like a centralized daycare location). All of the group agreed.
I’m not saying that’s a good excuse (it’s not), but it is the reason they gave.
The friend admitted he didn’t see Madeline because he didn’t go into the room
Saw the twins in their cots.
Fact
9.30 check
They are still under suspicion by Portugal police.
I think you are very naive sir the parents and the friends are responsible and everyone is keeping the secret. As for the dancing in ice argument how ludicrous to think she ever would go on a tv show after the whole world thinks she’s guilty
Losing a child doesn't strengthen your faith. It would make ne question it. I am not religious, but i hear despicable comments by some people, that God has a plan. I haven't heard it here, but that seems to be what religious fanatics believe. What merciful God would want this to happen to an innocent child? I would appreciate not hearing religious comments, because this has nothing to do with ones beliefs or any devine plan.
Thank you for bringing such a compassionate view to this news story.❤
One of your more sensible videos. Agree with you on everything.
I heard the Podesta brothers were involved and the person that did all the leg work was removed from posting it as well as most things involved with famous people and children.
Just read the police investigation documents pj files online!
Are you familiar with Richard halls rigorous work on this case? Peter Hyatts statement analysis?
Regardless of what happened, they still are grieving parents.
Statement analysis is backed up by what? And richard hall the one who believes in shapeshifting reptilians?
They prob sedated them at home too. Go out they are to blame any non selfish person wouldnt leave there kids, jimmy saville was a pillar of the community
I don't thing that they should suffer for the rest of their lives but they should not be gaining in any way of the back of neglecting their children. This includes gaining money from it or any celebrity status. This shows a lack of remorse for what they have done and they are not helping themselves in any way shape or form. If your a doctor and you are saying that it is dangerous to sedate a child then how could they not have known this? I really don't understand you perspective on this and they should not be working at doctors any more if they have put their own children in a life threatening situation using drugs. Surely if they did not know this they are not qualified practice any more. If they had not tried to gain celebrity status and had stopped working as doctors then people would not have so much anger towards them and would be more forgiving.
It was intentional, they & the media made alot of money !
Could you do a video on Darlie Routier?
Read the pj files ….. damning
you're a it boring mate
I'm only four minutes into this video and I can already see how biased you are towards the McCanns. Objectivity is crucial when discussing any true crime story, so I'm afraid this will not be worth my time.
The psychology might be bang on the money, but the detection is what matters.
Also thanks Doc, you must work really hard, keep going .you're doing lots of good by educating and helping people gain empathy . ❤️
I second that. He is terrific
A totally bias video towards mccanns !!!! Youve missed out crucial facts !!! Dogs , phone records and deletes , even the tanner sighting was clear up !!
A very weak video and a lack of facts within it
Very poor
To be honest, I don't have a definite opinion about this case, but I have an idea why parents behave in such a way. When a person disappears, the main suspect is usually the one who was with the missing person last. We know this from the movies. There's no sign of a break-in or blood or anything in the apartment. I'm sure even at this very moment the Portuguese police already were treating the parents as prime suspects and that's where all the tension between them and media started. Yes, the parents acted irresponsibly and risky. No doubt about it. But the police did not finish their work in the first hours either - the apartment had to be secured and the whole area searched with dogs and patrols, they had to immediately contact Interpol and contact the Spanish border services, etc. Why is it that after so many years after the disappearance of the child, it is discovered that this German was approximately where Madeleine disappeared, and the Portuguese authorities had no idea about him in 2007? Days before Madeline's disappearance, suspicious men had been going around asking about orphaned children, and no one had investigated it. Why is there no camera footage from bars, streets whatever? Why the hotel cameras were switched off? I mean, yeah, the parents may act weird , but still, all the attention is on them, everyone is judging them. But why is no one prosecuting the investigators on both sides? I've seen documentary footage of what it looks like around the hotel at night - so dark, so creepy. I hope after this tragedy it is now lit and there are cameras. As for whether parents should have fun - well that's their decision how they should live, and whoever wants to troll them will always troll them.
Completely agree with your take. Everything you said.
Some very dodgy decisions made far worse by their professional position of responsibility. At the very least.
As far as Gerry is concerned do not many consultants, cardiac and Neuro in particular border on psychopathology in any case? I am led to believe that this is how they cope with the enormity of what they do?
Committed suicide? Yesterday’s parlance surely?
Who saw Madeline in the room ?
David Payne 😂😂
He said he went into the room and Kate was dressed and was there a while
She said he never entered the apartment and she was in a towel and he was there a few seconds
Why was he there ?
Because Gerry had asked him to help take the kids to the recreation area ?
Earlier Gerry had agreed with Kate the kids were going straight to bed
Sorry my friend - you have not investigated this case at all have you
Why didn't you annalise their body language? Which seemed very strange.
Probably because Dr Das is a psychiatrist and body language analysis is pseudoscience.
Your acting is dreadful 😮if I were you I would go back to my regular day job, some of the facts you quoted are incorrect, whereas there's many hard accurate facts widely known and easily accessible, you don't necessarily need the contaminated crime scene or the cadaver dogs the Portuguese authority should of given Mr Amaral more time and support including support from UK police.
100% agree with you!!!
I can't get over leaving the children drugged & the door ajar, even if they were in the room the drugging (dangerous in any amount for children, toddlers, as Dr they know this)......child abuse for sure.....sooo sad
The host of this vídeo is so naive or is just a doctor thing? Have each others back.