So It Has Come To This: The Collector Booster Box Game For Magic: The Gathering | Why? Why?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 23 лют 2023
- Thanks to Scopely for sponsoring this video - Download Star Trek Fleet Command on iOS & Android and battle in the Star Trek universe here: pixly.go2cloud.org/SH3f6
Be sure to also watch "Dealing With Difficult Commander Players" here: • Dealing With Difficult...
A reminder that my Discord has a 100% free "Looking For Game" section, with games of everything from Commander to Modern (and even Pauper) firing off. So if you want to get some webcam Magic, just check out / discord
#MagicTheGathering #mtg #secretlair
►This episode is brought to you thanks to our wonderful Patreon community. Join to support the show, or just Shuffle Up & Play with other awesome people on our Patron Discord by going to / tolariancommunitycollege
►This show is made in part due to Card Kingdom. You can help us out by visiting our affiliate link at www.CardKingdom.com/TCC - Ігри
Did you miss the regular booster box game for Phyrexia All Will Be One? Watch it here: ua-cam.com/video/pLwW_ZSmdS4/v-deo.html
What do you think about the price increases for the next 3 sets that just dropped on Amazon $300 set box's 🤔
You really sped up the ad too much xD
dude we need more flesh and blood content😮💨
The gap between value and price continues to get worse with sealed. The solution? Apparently, WotC believes its increasing the price on sealed some more. I really enjoyed opening sealed products but for the last 16 months I just can't justify the cost and now it looks like it's another year of singles only. It's depressing and I just don't understand why they think this is good for the game.
@@MH-pe8wj Had to check to make sure...
The only one that's outrageous is Commander Masters.
Lord of the Rings is high, but less than $200 for set boosters (collector's are out of line high, though,) and MotM are at a regular price (nowadays...) but draft boosters are high compared to set ones.
Either they're gonna raise set prices for MotM, or they lower the draft (we know they won't do that...)
For a second there I didn’t think he’d defeat the shrink wrap boss.
he needs to grab Rudy's Tool
Hahaha
Given his open disdain for collector boosters, I'd imagine there was a temptation to throw down the box in frustration right there and end the video.
I was fully prepared for a 35min shrink wrap fight set to lofi music
Bought a Collector Booster box myself, and can confirm. That is some tough plastic, probably to keep the oil in.
The fact that all these foil, borderless, alternate art cards are so cheap is actually good. Affordable cards are good. The problem is the price of the box.
Solid agree. The collectors boosters would make excellent prize packs if the boosters were distributed to game stores in limited runs at the same price as draft boosters.
Sadly, due to Influencers and larger game stores, a false demand has made them so over printed, that as soon as release hits, the Big game stores and Influencers rip everything, presell, and then flood market to the point that a small lgs has and will literally go under, solely from Magic sales. The game needs more players and alot less greedy people trying to make a buck.
That’s the point of the video
When I watched these to live vicariously through you I didn't expect to also feel the pain
I just love the fact that the most valuable card in your collectors box of All Will be One is a card thats not technically in All Will Be One XD
It's got the ONE logo, and you can get them in every kind of pack from the set, so curious as to why you consider it not in the set?
@@syndieouellet2763 You ought to look very closely at that Sheoldred, especially the set symbol. In fact, look the other Praetors with the Richard Whitters concept art and see what their set symbols are...
@@exclamation744 ah I see now, thanks, I only saw Elesh Norn and assumed the others were the same.
@@syndieouellet2763 in the packs yeah but not standard.
@@exclamation744 you can't get that version of sheoldred outside phyrexia ONE though. So this is a moot point.
Omg, thank you so much for adding the "Now Playing" element to these videos! I've always enjoyed the music for the booster box games, so this is great.
Part of me wanted this to just be 30 min of The Prof "struggling" with the packaging and then rolling to credits.
underrated comment
Make it a HowToBasic type video where it's him trying his damnedest to get through the shrinkwrap, be it with fire, a jackhammer, cooking it in a sauté pan and sitting down for dinner only to break his fork on it, etc. Every time something doesn't work, it shows a quick cut-in to his face and a frustrated scream as his sanity deteriorates for half an hour!
All the card treatments are a good reminder that when everything is special, nothing is special.
I miss the excitement of opening a foil and that being something to enjoy and know you got a price boost. Now there's too many arts which is fine for just playing but makes opening packs less enjoyable at times.
100%
@@ttray1744 and the fact that a lot of foils lower price now
@@SpindlyTree86 My favorite pack I opened back in the day was a Non-foil Cavern of Souls and a Foil Gisela, Blade of Goldnight. Makes me sad that people don't get to enjoy that feeling anymore. New arts are cool but there are so many it feels not special anymore.
@@ttray1744 I have a golgari insect deck and I'm trying to foil it out with all the oldest foils possible and man it's expensive. Looking up in the $500 range for all the cards in their oldest foils
Ever since my disappointing box of Baldur's Gate, I always take the advice "Buy Singles from your LGS." So much so, that I've met a few great friends at the LGS, and even started hosting large Magic nights locally. Not buying things like collector boosters has made me appreciate The Gathering so much more.
Yeah, baldur's gate was a really odd set to open. Infinite amount of the same legends and none of the good cards...
Buy singles! From locals in the store or the store itself!
it's still fun to get a pack here an there because I find stuff I didn't know about, but putting the time in to look at the sets and know what I want and don't want, and to buy the stuff I want feels so much better in the long run. I ended up buying the phyrexian showcase lands for my vampire orzov deck and it kind of hurt to spend $25 bucks on lands but not as much as buying a set booster box and just *hoping* I got them.
@@wildhearses If you add up the money you would spend on sealed, you quickly have enough to buy some ridiculous singles. Rasputin Dreamweaver is a Legends Rare, reserved list, with only two printings in 1994: English and italian Legends. In Europe you can get it for 210 USD in nice condition, and that is the english version, italian is much cheaper.
He is a bomb in commander, he ramps colorless mana, gives you 7 colorless when you manage to flicker him, you can build a mean eldrazi tron.
Yeah I only ever buy draft booster boxes if I actually want to draft. Otherwise singles are the way
I learned this lesson the hard way…. Twice…
4:00 I laughed hard at the first Showcase foil having an amazing value of just $0.05!
I imagine the conversation with his sponsors go something like this:
Prof: I need $240 to do this episode.
Sponsor: Why?
Prof: I like to burn other people's money. It makes me feel compleat.
I see what you did there😁
@theflamingpandai no, but I think it worked for the joke.
Can't wait to see the Commander Masters Collector's Box with 4 packs!!!!
Wait a minute
Paying extra for extra chance, only guarantees that you'll be paying extra.
Thanks for the reminder Prof.
It's insane how good the cards look but my disappointment is that some look almost the same. Also, I really love that manga art.
Idk, I don't really like how so many cards don't really look like Magic cards anymore. B&W art also makes it harder to tell what's actually depicted, and being absolutely coated with foil Phyrexian symbols looks kind if gaudy IMO, and doesn't help with the art being hard to identify.
@@TheBizzerker I can see why would think that way but personally I like it when they deviate from their usual design every now and then and try something else. Gotta experiment with new things sometimes
I love the art but hate the oil slick treatment. Makes them look and feel like cheap plastic knock offs and reminds me of fake yugioh
@@PieMan061 The oil slick is only in the compleat edition box. None of these cards are the oil slick cards. I think you mean the step and compleat foils which are the ones with all the logos on them.
@@kylesmith987 ….gosh danggit why do they need so many alternate treatment names. Regardless, I hate them
3:00 I thought this video might be a joke where professor tries to open the box for 30 minutes and after that be like: well, it doesn't open. Thanks for watching!
I cracked a phyrexia collector booster display myself today and let's just say - I didn't even get to 150$.
I deserve it.
to add to this: just cracked a Dominaria Remastered draft too and well, it would've actually made the booster box game and contained more value than the Phyrexia collector box I opened yesterday.
If not for the alt art Force of Will I pulled on my second to last pack, that box would've been very comparable to the Profs though. Until then the highest value I pulled was Yawgmoth, alt art No Mercy, foil Entomb and two Mystical Tutors.
So yeah, gonna end on that high note. Hopefully got pack-cracking out of my system for at least a couple of months now lol
@@TheLastDaysOfSorrow Dominaria Remastered was Awesome for me! I easily doubled my money, but I seemed unusually lucking hitting a $10-30 card in almost every pack. Honestly, I kept expecting someone to jump out and say that I was pranked.
I just finished opening mine. I didn't even reach 120$. My woes are many, and my days will now be few. I didn't think I could possibly get under HALF the sale price, but I did.
I will now always stare at this box with shame, thinking I could've got something over 25 dollars.
"Purchase only the individual cards that you wish to acquire instead of buying packs of cards in pursuit of acquiring these desired cards through random chance."
There that's a good slogan. You can put that on a t-shirt if you want, Prof.
Yeah, Elesh Norn single price is much more palatable after watching this.
But sometimes I don't know what I want next until chance gives me some new cards to build around. So there's that.
Your "Buy Singles" playmat is my go-to. Has a remarkably dapper dragon on it too.
I love that one!
The fact that full art foil phyrexian text lands are less than $2 really says something….I’m not even sure what it says….but it’s something
I get it, not everyone can read Phyrexian text...yet😏
@@ferdithetank7535 and nobody will ever read it
@@MrCenturion13 I recently did a little buying and got 70 Beta basic lands from different people. All artworks, some dark Beta, none in pristine condition but all look really nice in sleeves. I used to play foil basics from Mirrodin and Unhinged, now its all Beta in all my decks. All the new fancy versions made me do it. Putting Beta basics from 1993 into all my decks now, if i run out i will buy more.
Some go for unglued nonfoil basics, this set pre-dates foil cards and these are the first fullart basic lands ever released to my knowledge, and there is only one version for each.
Some go for unlimited basics as the only white-bordered cards in the deck (apart from dual lands) for easier fetchland use. Or revised basic lands to go with revised dual lands, again for fetchland use.
What i feel is that all the variants make people desire a permanent solution across all decks. One recognizable version across all decks and be done with it. So a newer, fancier version comes along and noone cares. Fetchlands play a role, failing to quickly find your fetchland target feels bad.
With these new ones, and i agree they look nice, the sensible options are: Ignore them, or buy 100 and use them consistently for ALL your decks.
@@MrCenturion13 I still do not like alpha, it makes weird wear patterns on the sleeves which make your deck marked. This matters for tournaments, not for EDH, in tournaments Alpha comes with the burden of having to re-sleeve the entire deck often.
I like the consistency. I think Alpha/Beta and Unglued basics are most recognizable across the table, 1993 due to nostalgia and Unglued due to the very good, unique design. Its like these are most friendly for people with impaired vision.
Beta is a bit of a flex, as these are pricy. The reason why i do not go for unlimited to match my white-bordered dual lands is a bit sick, i play no white-bordered duals. I play foreign limited black-bordered french/italian/german duals. These raise eyebrows, they look even better than Beta. Frame looks like 4th edition black-bordered, color saturation and print quality are really high, and many people do not even know these exist. Low print run. So its always a bit of a moment when you play a black-bordered french Underground Sea.
Something I want is "Tolaria community college beats to grade papers to" which is just a playlist of the music used for the booster box game
I listen to the lofi channel on Spotify - same type of music.
A significant amount of the music is Kevin MacLeod, who is copyright free and has all of his music on UA-cam
I love how enthusiastic Prof is. He clearly loves Collector Boosters.
Also: The box appears to pass the stretch test.
I just like watching you play these games, because I would be furious just buying it.
DMR truly should have been the MtG 30th anniversary release with the M30 proxies inserted randomly for nostalgia.
I'm so happy that the listing for the music shows up..
Thank you so much. It was hard trying to find some of those.
Ah the booster box game, where the card is either worth all the money in your wallet or worth less than the gum under your shoe
I played my first game on your discord. It was so fun. . . This community is amazing and welcoming. Loved it!
The music shout-outs are really appreciated! Keep up the great work Prof!!
Finally you added a bar that shows what music is playing! Thank you prof!
Hey! I just noticed the music box that pops up between tracks. Thanks a lot for that! I'm sure many others appreciate it too!
This video was hilarious! I've never seen videos like this but it was great. Please do more of these!
Thanks for adding the music info. I’d always been curious
Really appreciate you posting the song info in your vids!
These are some of my favorite videos! Thanks Prof!!
Not sure if I'm noticing the "Now Playing" for the first time or if it's a new addition. Either way, love it.
Love your content! Do you have a list of what you use to not have too bright a light and keep the cards in focus?
That Sheoldred was pretty sweet
I got a box from my Husband and pulled every variation of Kaito in foil but hey I also pulled some actually good cards.
Many magic the gathering players ask the question: why and who put you up to this?
Lol for real
Thanks for showing the songe title and artist! :) Really appreciate it!
I’m so glad you choose to play the collector boosters game!
The magic is how fast they empty your pockets
Before I even watch I want to say I fully enjoy the box game with the professor. More box game all day long.
I got myself a pack 2 weeks ago for my birthday. The most value I got, no kidding is a foil basic land. Overall less than 5$ value😅😅 I was quite mad at myself for falling in the trap!
Like the little tag to the song on the bottom left corner...other then Kevin Mclouds music I wondered about the other tunes you used. (like having them play when I open packs)
Thanks prof. Love your work
My recent purchases: Unlimited Tropical Island, english Legends Rasputin Dreamweaver, a Time Spiral from Urzas Saga, and 1998 Urzas Saga prerelease foil Lightning Dragon. All 4 are reserved list, one is for fun/collecting and the first ever official release of a foil card, 3 are great for commander. Apart from the unlimited Dual, what you paid for the boxes gives you enough budget to buy the others. These are truly iconic cards. Price for both boxes also gets you in range for a real Dual land.
Just wanted to say hey. Thanks for what you do. You're top notch my guy
The first 3 songs sound nice on 2x speed. This should be a factor worth considering for these types of videos where fast-forwarding is so useful
Wow, I love the message of this video! It can all be summed up with just 2 words at 32:37!!! 😊
I've never been lucky enough to open a collector pack, and I love this set, so this was a blast to watch!
@@justinthomas4731 you serious? Haha. Even if it's not the card I'm after, I would be very thankful!
I was really waiting for this to be a 30 minute video watching Prof trying to open the box.
Never thought I'd a see a game i've been playing for almost 4 years sponsor your video prof.
I did a sealed thing with friends early this week with my box of Dominaria Remastered. My box, though, was pretty fantastic in terms of value. 2 FoWs (one old border, one full art), Mystical and Enlightened tutors (old border Mystical), foil full art Entomb, full art Urza's Incubator, BoP, regular and full art Mystic Remora, Gauntlet of Power. So in the end it was really good. But still - we played so that was the big important part.
You can definitely draft collector packs, I’ve done this quite a bit now, it’s pretty fun, specially for not great draft formats like all will be one
I got a collector box of All Will Be One on release day for 225$ from my LGS and even had the guy behind the counter pick my box from a case that one box taken out. The box ended up being pure fire as I pulled an Elesh Norn regular art foil, the Step and Compleat foil Jin-Gitaxias, Progress Tyrant and also a foil Borderless Concept Praetor Vorinclex, Monstrous Raider. Three cards almost got me as much value as the cost of the box!!!!! I was VERY happy to say the least. Cheers and good luck to the rest of you.
I just opened my collectors yesterday, compleat vorinclex, four Nissa with two being compleat, 4 wanderer, foil norn, and well over $560 in value.
I was absolutely floored, and had a total of 12 planeswalkers in the box, new kaya, two Kaitos, it was amazing.
I was expecting to get burnt, but sometimes the luck pulls through
I like the feeling of opening packs. It’s fun. I get to keep bulk and build out a bunch of commander decks
I buy sealed product for non-draft reasons all the time! (only bundles because they're great storage boxes)
I don't know how recent it is but, thank you for the now playing .
Thank you for being so brave
Meanwhile there's also the excitement of receiving in the mail those specific proxies you ordered
Oh wow this hurt. So nice to get this dose of reality without having dropped that much money for it.
me and 3 friends actually DID draft a collector box once, we did a 4 player draft of Strixhaven, and it was one of the most fun drafts i've ever done, it was such a weird and fun environment, tho i suspect that it was in part because of the archive cards.
You definitely can draft set boosters! for friends it feels like a better experience, competitive wise it probably isn't as good!
My shop once held a
Collector Booster Draft
and it was awesome.
Peoples decks were great, and it was chais style do we could play with any sets collector boosters
thanks for the playlist box, also thanks for the fun,
The Collector's and Booster box games are my favorite, though I must admit that your lessons in buying singles hasn't quite sunk in. It's hard buying a $100 card, when I can get a box of cards and grow my collection.
I'm trying to look for deals, but they are hard to come by with singles 😔
something that may help: consider why you are growing your collection. Is having a lot of cards what you want from the game? what is the point of having a larger collection for you? is it for options for deckbuilding? is it because it feels good? is it because you want to have more cards than your friend? consider also that the majority of cards you own will never be looked at played with, used, etc. bar specific circumstances that the average mtg player won't likely be meeting. basically, if you want to build decks proxy, if you want singles buy them. I promise it will save you money in the long run. Plus if you are buying singles you get the exact card you want 100% of the time rather than any pack randomness.
If I played competitively I would buy singles (and I do buy singles to finish a deck), but my friends and I play casually. I use the cards that go unnoticed in pauper and just for fun.
I have sold my collection through the years (out of guilt and shame, because I was made to feel bad about playing the game), and I definitely don't have more cards than my friends.
I really enjoy flipping through my bulk, and rediscovering cards, and then go, "Let's try to make this work. "
@@sidious247 in that case, if you still want to be gathering cards for those reasons, may I suggest bulk lots? obviously the cards may not necessarily all be NM as they would be out of packs but it will still be a way to bolster your collection to do more to the stuff you want but will still save you money
The real value of Dominaria Remastered comes from being able to draft one of the most well loved draft formats of 2022
I cracked my Magicfest Philly VIP packs which were 60$ market value, got
According to the shrodinger's cat experiment there is a universe where collector boxes have 36 packs for the same price
The Schroedinger's Cat thought experiment is a critique of the copenhagen interpretation of Schroedinger's equation though, so I don't think it applies IRL.
@@malakimphoros2164 i clearly don't know what i'm talking about but I want to believe we could spend 240$ for 36 collectors packs
@@matteorossi1172 You could spend 350$ for 4 packs in Commader Masters
That Sheoldred looks so good though! I want to get one in perfect condition, get it graded and then put it on display
Cracking packs is so much fun though. I often think about how much fun it would be just to sit down with one of these creators and talk about the game while opening packs.
What is the 1st song on these booster box games?? I cant seem to figure it out I like it its like perfect for openings.
Really like what you did with the music
I got the message Professor! Obviously you wanted to tell us that collector boosters are much better value then draft boosters. It is rigorously proven in this video!
Hey, I’m at least glad to see you enthusiastic about the Star Trek game in this video!
when you draft with friends, how do you guys do it? do you end up playing 1v1's? or multiplayer
Almost did this. Glad I decided to get a set box instead. 9 mythics including elesh Norn. Wouldn't risk it a second time though. Just going to save up for lotr release🤤
What a small sample size to try to dunk on collector boxes? Rudy from the 3rd Floor Basement opened some slammers
Bought a Collectors Booster box, First pack had a Foil, Phyrexian Elesh Norn, Mother of Machines The 4th had a Step and Completed showcase Atraxa, Grand Unifier. The 5th had a Step and Compmeted PanharMomicon. Not a bad box.
love the now playing box!
14:26 the price in my binder just took a big hit and i couldn't be happier for it
Had lots of fun as usual with this. I would once again like to request considering a softer, less intrusive sound alert when you pull a money card. That "Cha Ching" is very loud and imo ruins the chill vibe your great music Playlist brings to the table.
Thanks for putting music credits in the video.
27:23 What an apt description of this box.
How do you sell your cards? do you just give it to the LGS or online
When I first saw the showcase Malcator at 6:42 , my mind immediately gave me the "Jar Jar Binx" interpretation of the artwork.
Where is the link to the Phyrexian Booster Draft you mentioned in the video?
NGL... those phyrexian lands with the cool line art are goddamn beautiful...
Dunno whether it's the alcohol or mah brain but ''after the laughter from them resides'' tickled me to the next plane over. That was a throw away sentence but it hit me with the big funny haha's. you win todays funny.
The "Now Playing" feature is awesome
Finally I know what is being said in the Cha Cha song “Dance!” I thought possibly it was saying “Dab!”
I love cracking packs!! It’s a rush, a gamble. I once bought a single pack of Throne of Eldraine from Walmart for no reason, just cause I saw it at checkout. Hit a borderless foil Oko before he was banned. Sold it for $100 the next FNM!!! Dopamine packs 4 life lol
Is there a reason you do not count tokens or signed art cards in the price total? I have seen you open really expensive tokens such as mechtitan before and they were not counted, even though they would have put you over the top and were worth more then rares you counted.
I was starting to think it was going to be a half hour of just getting the wrapping off the box haha.
there's something so funny about the loud cash register sound effect playing when you open a $2 card out of a $20 booster
Fun to watch a collector box game!
Closer then I expected you to get honestly
Wow, the quality of these have gone way up.
Fantastic addition of the song titles.
Love the most expensive card.
I may have missed a previous video or so and they might not be completely new (or maybe this is the first video, idk!), but just wanted to say they're some really nice QOL changes to the format.
On the chance you read this: does your local lgs really let you sell all these cards all the time so close to launch? I lived by coolstuff in florida for a few years until just recently, and they'd never be accepting sales of any of the cool new cards, really.
Played a draft yesterday with a Dominaria Remastered Box I bought. Even with the draft enviroment not being the best, and the 24 boosters sorta paying their cost, the fun drafting with friends was priceless. Drafts are always fun with good friends... I just hope WotC don't forget that, as many players fears that draft boosters could be dropped entirely in the future...
That step-and-compleat foil treatment is so cool, but it's always so disappointing to see that booster slot taken by a 10 cent common.