Role of camel milk in ASD

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 лип 2024
  • Role of camel milk in ASD
    A descriptive talk by
    Dr Puja Kapoor
    Paediatric neurologist
    Director and Cofounder CONTINUA KIDS

КОМЕНТАРІ • 101

  • @godwinmlay3405
    @godwinmlay3405 Рік тому +7

    Am a parent with a 16yrs autistic boy. We have been using camel milk for my son for since he was 5yrs old. The improvements in the social behaviour was instant from the day he started using this milk..The beauty of it is that it is not an artiificial food, no side effects observed. In absence of a better alternative natural or artificial remedy, "camel milk all the way for me".

    • @kundandas3217
      @kundandas3217 Рік тому

      Is it really helped for social behaviour ? Please reply

  • @Hamismah76
    @Hamismah76 3 роки тому +7

    It is not correct to say there have not been studies done. There is a 2013 study. Worth checking it out Dr. search /key words: Camel Milk as a Potential Therapy as an Antioxidant in Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD)
    Laila Y. AL-Ayadhi and Nadra Elyass Elamin

    • @pujakapoor5731
      @pujakapoor5731 3 роки тому

      There are multiple biased, flawed studies on role of camel milk in autism by the same author.
      Camel milk is still not categorised under proven therapies and is considered a complementary and alternative therapy with no considerable results.
      The reasoning is still under evaluation and not proven yet.

    • @Lovela11
      @Lovela11 2 роки тому +3

      @@pujakapoor5731 as an experienced neurologist you should not defend yourself and argue with parents who are in agony and pain! Each and every sentence of yours is to protect your profession, personality and ego. We all live in an age of free information - let people read, try and face its consequences. DR’s should shed their role as life savers! Most dr’s choose their profession as a means for livelihood just like any others- therefore the covert justifications should be shed!

  • @ajayrawat816
    @ajayrawat816 4 роки тому +10

    Your input is purely based on reading or assumption. Camel milk is definately positive in ASD but yes it is not a 100%solution. it help in reducing hyperactivity and controlling mood of child but therapy like Special Ed/Occupational/sensory etc should always continue. Parents with practical knowledge know better in this regard. It's same like Old people always say drink Warm water early morning but it's not a 100%solution to all your health issues but it is effective practically

    • @continuakids
      @continuakids  4 роки тому +1

      I being a doctor, pediatric neurologist, have gained my knowledge both by reading and practical experience by treating the patients. Sorry, my inputs are not based on assumptions.
      They are based on research and knowledge.
      I have very well reiterated the facts about camel milk and why everything under the sun should not be tried on children with ASD.
      Science does not believe anecdotal reports, it needs evidence before it is turned into a fact.

    • @ajayrawat816
      @ajayrawat816 4 роки тому +3

      @@continuakids well it's a milk after all not a medicine which one should be worried about. I know medicines doctors recomend for hyperactivity & at times cause severe damage to child on top of that doctor don't even take responsibility of such advice when case goes out of hand. As I mentioned Camel milk is not a solution to ASD it just to calm down ASD kid and help in learning things especially during therapies. There is no replacement of therapy it is very clear. But trying Camel milk is not at all harmful, we all consume milk from various source cow, Buffalo, goat or camel.. People in Gulf countries normally drink camel milk just like we drink cow milk in India.. It's a milk afterall and I am telling everyone with a practical knowledge, trust me...

    • @pujakapoor5731
      @pujakapoor5731 3 роки тому

      @@ajayrawat816 If you are consuming camel milk as milk and not as a treatment for autism, I don't have any concerns.
      The video highlights the good qualities of camel milk, but also conveys that it should not be used as a scientific based treatment protocol for autism.
      This video does not compare the good or bad effects of medications versus camel milk.

    • @dishha4272
      @dishha4272 3 роки тому +5

      @@continuakids u may be doctor but we are parents.we cannot wait for decades for report and experiments..my doctor also said no to many things but i try once an dsee to myself..somethings have hrlped a lot some donot sp plz everyone try for urself and note changes in diary

    • @pujakapoor5731
      @pujakapoor5731 3 роки тому

      @@dishha4272 Best of luck with your experiments on your child.
      Stay blessed...

  • @prathamgogia6135
    @prathamgogia6135 4 роки тому +1

    Eye opener 🙏

  • @chethanbgowda7708
    @chethanbgowda7708 3 роки тому +3

    Will camel milk helps to increase height

  • @fatimayassin2049
    @fatimayassin2049 3 роки тому

    Dr Camel milk does not have test how you saied it's very solt?

  • @SteveBlaisdell99
    @SteveBlaisdell99 3 роки тому +6

    there are peer reviewed publish studies on this now. I can supply them if anybody wants

    • @pujakapoor5731
      @pujakapoor5731 3 роки тому +1

      There are multiple biased and flawed studies which does not clear the qualification criteria for RCT .
      Our judgement cannot be based on these studies.

    • @ilovedairymilk1
      @ilovedairymilk1 2 роки тому +1

      Do you know what is science direct! There are verified studies published in Science direct. @pujakapoor

  • @ektaupadhyay903
    @ektaupadhyay903 3 роки тому +1

    please do share the source /stores for procuring camel milk in Delhi - NCR.

  • @maimsahb
    @maimsahb 3 роки тому +3

    We use raw camel milk for many years for my 3 autistic children and myself.
    Yes it's very beneficial, it helps with allergies but it can not alone cure autism.
    Cow's milk in western countries is cause of many allergies.
    You need to remove gluten and sugar, processed food too

    • @qaaliqudaar2801
      @qaaliqudaar2801 3 роки тому

      Höw is your kids know did they talk after camel milk and suger free gluten free diet how many years did you see different did you give them any supplements plz help me

    • @maimsahb
      @maimsahb 3 роки тому +2

      @@qaaliqudaar2801
      i did many things all supplliments and everything i have read about.all was waste of time apart from gluten free diet and camel milk.
      if you live in england i can tell you about the flours i buy and mix them, they are
      Farari flour,jawar flour(sorgum)cassava flour (theese 3 flours are available at Quality foods store london) and dove brand free from gluten flour(its available at tesco).
      if you mix these four flours for example 1 cup each and prepare just like normail wheat flour, it makes a bread exactly like wheat which is soft and child will not feel a difference.
      the camel milk can be used in tea and you can make yogurt from it.
      remember this is not gaps diet as gaps diet has no grains which was not possible for me.i give frouts to my kids which many sugar free diets dont allow.
      all this makes a 20% difference.
      it did not develop language for my younger son but makes him much more aware.
      i know parents who dont do diet and their kids bang head or bite other kids.
      once they grow up without diet, you cant keep them at home.
      my older daughter had no diet, was out of control and now lives in a care home.
      you need to do whatever you can to improve their lives.
      its a life time disability.
      my middle son was better than all, he goes to a main stream school, has speech but if i let him eat processed food, he becomes a lost person and makes buzzing noises and runs around.
      my children autism is not genetic and is caused by vaccines and processed foor(baby food in bottles).

    • @qaaliqudaar2801
      @qaaliqudaar2801 3 роки тому

      @@maimsahb thank you so much
      My 3years is also like that if I give him any suger or gluten food he losts his controll 😔 he’s nonverbal and I always search him help i life in Germany but I can order by amazon camel 🐪 milk 🥛 how old is your older dAughter you are not alone I know many mothers have autistic children

    • @maimsahb
      @maimsahb 3 роки тому +1

      @@qaaliqudaar2801
      There is camel milk form in holland.
      I buy from a supplier in the UK and it comes from the Holland.
      I buy frozan and they sell a 500ml bottles for £5:50, iplus postage.
      I buy like 20 kg and keep in freezer.
      The suppliers name is UK Camel Milk and his contract is +447717398348.
      You can ask them to provide you the contact in Germany or Holland.
      The one from Amazon "desert milk" is very expensive. Its not worth it.
      My oldest daughter is 24 now.
      If you look at my channel i have posted her videos how she behaved when she was living with us.
      I miss her every minute but cant keep her home with her brothers.
      Also keeping 3 autistic children at home is not easy.
      Autism is man made, its very rare by nature.
      If it was by nature, you will see autistic people in older generation.
      Its only in people age under 40 o 30.
      You dont see autism in poor african or asian countries.

    • @bettylove8771
      @bettylove8771 3 роки тому +3

      @@qaaliqudaar2801 hey, I am not of experience within autism but I’ve been researching about camel milks effects on autism after a friend of mine got her 5 year older who is non verbal began to speak after her visit to our home country and learned that her child should just consume camel milk and teff ( a gluten free flour from Eritrea and Ethiopia). I was very amazed and intrigued by how much it helped her child and I so just wanted to encourage you to try it out but I can ask her for more details about what she did for you, if you would like that.
      You can find teff on Amazon
      God bless you and Good luck

  • @seemealam4040
    @seemealam4040 4 роки тому

    If we don't know the reason why do we have told by psychologist to take different therapies .

    • @pujakapoor5731
      @pujakapoor5731 3 роки тому

      Nobody in the world knows the cause of autism till date.
      We know that it may be the consequence of environmental and genetic factors. A lot of research is ongoing on both the factors. New genes responsible for autism are constantly identified . Environmental and immunological factors are under constant study.
      Treatment protocol is based on the modification of symptomology, and not as a treatment of cause.
      As we can only modify the environmental factors and so the various protocols defined by the psychologist.

    • @mathswithushachawra4001
      @mathswithushachawra4001 Рік тому

      ​No body doesn't cause of autism. No body doesn't know medicine to reduce this.
      Why do waste our time and money.

  • @user-wg3bl5id1c
    @user-wg3bl5id1c 2 роки тому +3

    I am the mother of a three-year-old autistic boy who was diagnosed with mild autism last week.After understanding autism, I think that the symptoms of autism of my son before the age of 2 are heavier. constipation, less words, repeated stereotypes, but i never thought he was asd. In order to improve the digestion of children, I started to do massage and food treatment for my son at the age of 2. since that , my son was obviously cheerful, and his speech was fluent.I think massage and dietary therapy have given great help, and now I insist on doing it every day.
    My son is drinking camel milk powder as well just for three days, and there is no significant improving but i think it will helpful. I I will share with you about my son's situation with my treatment if you are interested in. I hope to share more valueable info with you.

    • @mariahzafar5576
      @mariahzafar5576 2 роки тому +1

      Yes please ,could you tell me how u manage your child

    • @mariahzafar5576
      @mariahzafar5576 2 роки тому

      My child showing autistic symptoms

    • @pavanshejwal5037
      @pavanshejwal5037 Рік тому

      How's the result ...?

    • @kajalarora7683
      @kajalarora7683 Рік тому

      Kya autism me camel milk ke benefits hai plz tell me????

    • @selad2938
      @selad2938 Рік тому

      Hello Dear, did you see any improvement after using the camel milk for your kid? Please let me know because I have 3 kids who have are atustic. I would like to try the camel milk if it is useful.

  • @zaidalhafi2540
    @zaidalhafi2540 3 роки тому

    Correct your info about Camel please

    • @pujakapoor5731
      @pujakapoor5731 3 роки тому

      My information is based on the scientific literature studied during the medical course.It is not based on some anecdotal case report or some non verified RCT.
      My course ,and my experience says it is of no proven use in treating autism spectrum disorder....

    • @Lovela11
      @Lovela11 2 роки тому +1

      @@pujakapoor5731 as long as you (conventional medicine) have no cure, let poor parents seek solace in some camel milk or elephants poo! Why creating paranoia among them! Let the kids drink salty camel milk - that’s better than water we drink! The restaurant food we eat! The chocolate, crisps we eat! Which research does not say Coca-Cola, crisps, GM products, emulsifiers etc., are not good- yet we consume!
      As long you have no alternative to offer… please!

  • @shahidahmed5779
    @shahidahmed5779 3 роки тому +2

    Won't drinking raw camel milk upset young children's stomach and effect there health due to the live bacteria if not pasteurised?

    • @teresaolofson1377
      @teresaolofson1377 Рік тому +1

      Shadid we have been lied to about what a raw food is. Its not vegetables or fruits. Its raw cheese and raw butter and raw milk and raw fish. I have been eating this way for years along with many others who follow a raw primal diet. Their skin is unlike others. You can always tell the skin of someone who eat raw animal fats in their diet on a daily basis. Can you imagine eating raw bone marrow?

    • @AMam-ib9dq
      @AMam-ib9dq 7 місяців тому

      ​@@teresaolofson1377my grandfather used to feed raw meet and animal fat to his children once in a while and they do so in some middleeastern countries. It is not like they eat raw meat all the time but some parts of the animal once in a while.

  • @amaragrico1
    @amaragrico1 3 роки тому +7

    Please let's not get blinded with lab tested protocol only as scientific. As a parent of autistic child, where in we have seen child getting improved in front of our eyes. And please guide the people only with what you know and don't comment on what you don't know..please

    • @pujakapoor5731
      @pujakapoor5731 3 роки тому

      As a pediatric neurologist after studying medicine for 10 years, practising more than 10 years and consulting around 7000 children, I believe more in science and facts than anything else.
      I appreciate your authentication of role of camel milk in ASD based on your personal experience but my profession dictates to believe in facts.
      You need to review the video again to get the take home message.

    • @amaragrico1
      @amaragrico1 3 роки тому +3

      @@pujakapoor5731 Madam, I have visited so many neurologists, but no clear idea or solution for my son's Asd issue. But the recent research in gut brain axis has so many answers. I find limited answers, solutions and results at allopathy, where as I find so many success stories with various diet protocols.

    • @pujakapoor5731
      @pujakapoor5731 3 роки тому

      @@amaragrico1 Having multiple solution to the concern does not prove they are correct.
      Gut axis is a hypothesis, still not proven. You have so many options like high doses of vit B12, chelation, camel milk, l carnosine, DHA, omega supplement , homeopathy etc based on gut hypothesis.
      They still are under research and not included in the guidelines yet.
      You have to define to what extend you have to use the above treatment, compromising the therapies which are evidence based.

    • @Lovela11
      @Lovela11 2 роки тому +1

      @@pujakapoor5731 oh no dr! For you everything seems hypothesis, no research data, no evidence-! Looks like you back up your experience and qualifications than recent researches across the globe!!

    • @Lovela11
      @Lovela11 2 роки тому

      @@pujakapoor5731 what is evidence based? NHS here often-in majority cases- points out this, for not administering a treatment or medicine, while another continent uses this successfully Based on EVIDENCE! Get Few millions funding for a research based on YOUR SO CALLED HYPOTHESIS, few scientists conducts few studies within their limited resources- EUREKA! Evidence! Isn’t this THE SO CALLED EVIDENCE! This evidence is good until another research brings up with the evidence that EARLIER RESEARCH WAS WRONG!
      Wake up dr!

  • @Navodaypraveen
    @Navodaypraveen Рік тому

    Selling camel milk is my family business. My father used to sell camel milk in MP. Presently i am living in Gurgaon if anyone need camel milk i can arrange in reasonable price.

    • @Seeker2400
      @Seeker2400 Рік тому

      I need raw fresh camel milk please share contact details

    • @ritikji2037
      @ritikji2037 Рік тому

      Contact number

  • @naveenkumar4106
    @naveenkumar4106 2 роки тому

    Find medicine and give solutions treatment on autism otherwise don’t waste everyone time

  • @maryamkhurram5386
    @maryamkhurram5386 2 роки тому

    Urdu b bol lea kro gory na bna kro bus

  • @9i9film34
    @9i9film34 4 роки тому +9

    My daughter is 3 years old she have autism I am giving camel milk I got many benefits. Like some she forget shouting, fingers flapping, beating his hand on door but all removed after drink camel milk
    But same due to corona lockdown I can getting camel milk I thought lets check my daughter is normal or not but iam wrong in just 15 days my daughter started again that stupid things this new smelling legs lol same shouting and beating head on door. Now I am going to start again that camel milk.
    Sorry I can understand. But still iam confused but seriously iam saying right iam not giving any therapy.

    • @continuakids
      @continuakids  4 роки тому +1

      I don't doubt your findings.But the take home message is that don't get overenthusiastic about the results of camel milk and stop other therapies which are scientifically proven.

    • @ajayrawat816
      @ajayrawat816 4 роки тому +1

      919FILM- I can understand your finding but my strong advice will be not to avoid therapies.. Therapies are must, trying camel milk definitely is good but only therapy will help your child with special education & sensory issues. Camel milk calm down your child but it does not automatically teach things.. That should be done through therapies. Parents gets over excited and stop therapies that's why medical experts condemn Camel Milk as there is no scientific evidence. I do second that as well. I support camel milk but therapies must be continued along with camel milk...

    • @MrGinz4uuu
      @MrGinz4uuu 3 роки тому +1

      Did u give pesturized camel milk?

    • @pujakapoor5731
      @pujakapoor5731 3 роки тому

      @@ajayrawat816 That is the purpose of the video..
      Thank you for putting your thoughts on the platform.
      With so many therapies, parents often gets confused between scientific and proven, and unscientific and popular.

    • @989237659
      @989237659 3 роки тому +3

      @@continuakids which therapy scientifically proven to cure autism there is no such therapy which can cure autism camel milk is better than having cows A1 milk at least my child is having better milk than cow milk

  • @abhishektiwari786
    @abhishektiwari786 3 роки тому +1

    Camel milk may not be medicine but why you are so against it!! Is it harmful? NO

    • @continuakids
      @continuakids  3 роки тому

      I am not against usage of camel milk.
      I am against usage of camel milk as a treatment for ASD. Have multiple stories where parents got deviated to alternative therapies without fully exploiting the scientific proven therapies. To get deviated with something which is not much useful, cause a lot of damage in long run.

  • @theskychef
    @theskychef 4 роки тому +1

    Camel milk if it got no benefit, it's not harmful. But the available drugs got no benefit and it's harmful for sure.

    • @continuakids
      @continuakids  4 роки тому

      That is what I want to convey .
      Camel milk has no proven benefits in ASD. I have reteriated the good qualities of camel milk but they are not proven to be beneficial in ASD. My point is,one should not treat your child as a guinea pig and try each and everything under the sun.

    • @theskychef
      @theskychef 4 роки тому +2

      @@continuakids if you give a healthy option to your kid such as camel milk doesn't mean you treat the kid as a guinea pig.
      It's proven that goat or camel milk is much better than cow milk .

    • @continuakids
      @continuakids  4 роки тому

      @@theskychef I have seen parents forcibly giving camel milk, over other options of food and milk, leading to other vitamin and mineral deficiency.
      This overenthusiam over camel milk sometimes take over the scientific proven effects of therapy.
      The point is not be get involved in something which is still not proven.

    • @pujakapoor5731
      @pujakapoor5731 3 роки тому +1

      You change your statement very frequently .
      Now you are saying it may not be beneficial.
      Do you know the cost of camel milk?
      Why waste the resources when we dont know the end results.
      There are hundred thousand treatments which are on Google.
      If we will try each and everyone then we may deviate from the real treatment.

    • @apathak7
      @apathak7 Рік тому

      @@pujakapoor5731 mam, i have watched most of your videos, have u seen homeopathic medicine working in autism children?