Even if I planned and carried out something so heinous I would absolutely fall apart under this kind of pressure. Being interrogated, the media scrutiny a massive court case.... I'd confess to crimes I didn't commit to make it all stop. He just keeps on lying like it's nothing.
I mean he walked around from room to room, with his law patrol badge hanging out of his pocket, badgering each of those kids in the boat…He tries to pin the driving on a young man named Conner, so I firmly believe he even caused the death of his housekeeper…because no one can fall down stairs with such force and never wake up, and then he suggests filing a wrongful death suit, and he makes sure to keep all of the money.,,This man is pure evil. And no one can convince me someone was waiting and when Alec left the kennel at 8:44, someone killed Paul and Maggie in the 6 minutes between then and when their phones died…And Alec wouldn’t have ever told anyone he was at the kennel if that video didn’t turn up.
So he blames his lying on bouts of anxiety from his addiction, but conveniently his addiction has stopped him from telling the truth for the passed 2 years.
Yep. Had he known before he shot them that Paul had shot the video minutes before - which ultimately proved he was there- he would have delayed the killing-Obviously. How awesome was that for Paul to have video evidence to prove he was there minutes before the killing. Alex wasn't counting on that little glitch in the story line.
@@eileenahearn8066 It would've been awesome if Alex *had* noticed that a video-audio was being taken. He'd have possibly changed his mind for good. The horror of this story is that Alex considered two people he loved, lived with and interacted with, individually expendable to some "other *imagined* reality." I mean, was his mind actually thinking that if he wasn't caught that he and Buster could possibly have still enjoyed a thriving life somehow? Had he no thoughts of what this would do to Buster? The whole thing is still just too unbelievable that Alex, himself did this. I mean, they were all close knit, there's no doubt of that. I for one, even two years later cannot buy the very simplified "theory of the case" or prosecutors - that he did it for sympathy - to make lawsuits go away.
Another sign of lying is focusing on unimportant small details while relaying a story. He obviously practiced his performance since he wanted so badly to take the stand. Narcissists also love to testify as a control tactic
Paulette Campbell! You are so correct! Oh, and when I re-watched a certain place in his testimony, I noticed a ridiculous fake spaz attack in wiping away fake snot and tears. That convinced me, and the over-explaining! Bad Actor in every sense.
The fake spaz attack of wiping was such bad acting. The dry as a bone tissue should be entered into evidence. He did muster a few tears, just like an actor can do. The way he can quickly flip from pretend crying and distress to talking in a normal tone and cadence is another tell tell sign.
@@juliepeterson6639 Spot on !!!! He enjoyed murdering his family bc they were standing between him and his wealth. The only thing he ever worshipped. Shallow animal.
He shoulda practiced harder 😆. He is all over changing the story up about the kennels and trying to make the info fit his 1st lies. Heck my 5 yo grandson can focus a lie better that than this grown arse lawyer. He knows too if he tries hes gonna get a butt smack and a bar of soap and the Mimi look. This Alex been lying his whole life and getting away with it....sadly by ppl who know he lies and they choose to ignore him.
@@bauhausoffice I agree, but this is so made up. He didn’t call them that in real life. He really didn’t. It’s so obvious nobody else refer to them as Mags and Paw Paw and in the south when someone is given a name a nickname everybody calls them that I grew up in the south I know plenty of Bubbas and everyone called them Bubba not just their family.
Saying no, I did not when asked if he shot his wife and son, notice he is nodding yes while saying no.That is one of the CLEAR signs of deceit. This man is, without a doubt, guilty of these crimes.
Idk Bout that a lot of people nod no and MEAN Yes and nod yes and mean no it's got to be out of the baseline. So watch to see if when he says no about things you KNOW he didn't do if he shakes his head yes. Then you'll know if it's off.
Using endearing names for his wife and son such as Papa and maggs is a strategy he is using to pretend he love them and was close to them. Ridiculous manipulation ❤
Yes it actually does make me physically sick to my stomach to listen to him. I've still not wrapped my mind around Chris Watts killing his two girls and no one saw that coming. I hope I never do understand how their minds work bc only a mind like theirs can fathom the hows and whys.
@@juliecrane9647 These men are family annihilators. Alex has lost control and can't handle it. Everything was falling apart financially plus the stealing and lying was all coming out. I think he killed the women who worked for them too. Alex never planned on giving her family any money. He told her family to sue him and he'd make sure they got a good deal of money. They did but Alex kept it all. Then things got worse and he needed more money. He handled it by killing his wife and Paul. If Buster was in the trouble Paul was in he'd be gone too. Chris Watts is a special kind of F--- ed up. Killing his baby girls and putting them in oil tanks!
Defense attorney: “Mr. Murdaugh. Why did you lie?” AM: “Because I didn’t know my son had captured my voice on a Snapchat video, and now I have to backtrack BIG TIME.”
😂😂😂😂 for real that sums it up I can’t believe people buy this acting man his so guilty I know one dummy gonna say not guilty though 12 people one gonna buy his bull crap it’s a cold world
He’s biting on an object in his mouth that disperses something to induce tears. After talking about nieces baby he forgets to hide it. You see him roll it in his mouth and bite down then push it into his cheek. I knew he couldn’t be forcing out fake tears on his own. His psychopathy is so severe he can’t fake tears or he would have had a single tear in front of cops nut didn’t.
Learning about who he was as a person, I don't know if I've encountered or witnessed a person who was such a PERFECT fit for prison... the boys will have fun with him in prison!!! Would you consider him a narcissist,too? ...
He’s not sorry to anyone. A psychopath isn’t capable of feeling. He only knows how he’s supposed to feel sorry. Those people he ‘cares’ for while he steals their income and now quite literally, shoots them in the back.
He has been teaching that to his clients for years and years. I'm sure he prepared them for the jurors so he knows how he is suppose to act it's his profession.
It was sooooo chilling when he said the person who killed Paul really hated him. I think he loved Paul until the boat wreck. Then he was done with him. Paul’s being sued lead to Alex’s financial records and misdeeds coming to light. Alex was pissed about all that.
I agree 💯. And he blamed Maggie for posting numerous pictures of the family drinking alcohol and most of them included Paul. Plus amaggie wanted to settle the boat case.
@user-yq7lw9nn6d His murdered son Paul got into a drunken boat accident while he was driving the boat that resulted in the death of one of the passengers. The dead passenger's family was suing AM, which would've brought all his illegal schemes/fraud regarding his legal clients to light. Ostensibly, AM tried to avoid that by killing Paul (and his wife, Maggie).
Boy, you really nailed it. That's exactly what happened. Usually, we just get frustrated and try to do the best we can with what we have, but he took it to the extreme.
The way he can shift from grief to normalcy is not conducive with someone who’s truly overcome with grief. Grief lingers and takes time to transition out of.
I haven’t seen him transition out of his grief. This man lost his wife, son and dad all in a week. I’m not convinced he’s guilty. I don’t think one can make snot fall as he did so professionally? Do you know anyone who can do that? I would imagine my nerves being shot and I can’t imagine being able to dial a phone number, or text or even think after walking up on dead people let alone it be family. Horrible events. Sad regardless of guilt or innocence. Mentally I think this man is a mess.
@@commercialaccount9501100%… when my husband’s brother died suddenly alone in his apartment at age 41 because he had a massive heart attack and lay there for days before their Dad found him….we had a 4 hour drive from where the funeral was to his burial and there were 7 of us packed into a suv… the whole drive up we were laughing telling stories about him…,sometimes deep grief makes you very emotional in several ways and our laughing telling stories was a part of releasing our grief…. I think folks read into things because so many are convinced he’s guilty…. I can’t stand the term “ duper’s delight” and people all say they see a defendant with duper’s delight ( not talking about this case specifically) when it isn’t…. But for the record I think this guy is 1000% guilty having discovered he’s on Paw paw’s video just minutes before the murders!
Simply not true. You'll have to meet a lot more people who grieve. Some people who lose people simply feel numb. The thing is, (and it is weird) is that life, those little bitty moments of life, actually DO go on, just as they did one moment before someone loses someone. It is like you are caught b/w two worlds and you not only function in both of them, you also think in both of them. It is a very strange phenomenon. You not only can, but you often must shift in and out of them. It's plain weird and I say so from experience.
If he can rip off his clients that were friends of his one a Quadrapleadic now and a girl who lost her mother and all the others while he was living a life of luxury then he definitely MURDERED HIS FAMILY
He also used prosititues one of whom has come forward LINDSAY EDWARDS who says he beat and choked her --- interview on UA-cam ua-cam.com/video/XYQH7rmgZCQ/v-deo.html
I don't think he's a very good lawyer, just grandfathered in, his son also got kicked out of law school bc he was cheating. When the boat accident occurred Paul called grandaddy not his dad, that's pretty telling
But a stupid criminal. Play stupid games, win stupid prizes. He's an idiot. The snap chat video is enough for conviction because they didn't shoot themselves.
100% Correct!!! That’s been preoccupying me…he shows no emotion AT ALL…his voice doesn’t even break a little during his testimony…BUSTER IS VERY ODD, at least AM cries, but Buster doesn’t even flinch when images of his dead mother’s bullet ridden body are shown. His girlfriend is a little odd looking too….👍
Who are you people for real to say Buster wasn't crying enough in front of you all or upset enough . Are you f kidding me Alex crying plenty of times you same exact people claim he faking give me f break . B's light minded people like you people why Alex didn't even get fair trial I still say he didn't kill he's wife or son I think he was setup
My woman's intuition tells me that Maggie was afraid of Alex, and she wouldn't have been there alone with him. She thought she would be safe if Paul was there. She knew what was coming when it happened, and with her last thought and breath she ran to her son. RIP, Maggie and Paul. So very sad.
What, aside from your intuition, makes you think Maggie was scared of Alex? There weren't any allegations of abuse or other physical aggression from Alex, were there?
This is one of those trials where the defense never should have let their client take the stand. He tries so hard to appear affable, harmless and wistful, yet immediately, when his stories end, he glares with those telltale shark eyes at the jury and prosecution, not blinking. Very sociopathic.
In typical liars fashion, he answered almost every question by repeating the full question, giving himself more time to conjure up an answer, and in true narcissistic fashion he insisted on taking the stand himself believing that he could con us all into believing he was a loving husband and father. However his evilness came shining through. The best thing that happened was letting him on the stand. In my opinion he is a psychopath. It would not have been noticed much when he was growing up on a farm where he could kill animals big and small, where all the adults surrounding him killed living creatures for fun . A psychopaths dream. Then he grew up to be a snake oil salesman of a lawyer. Just listen to the phonecalls from jail he made to Buster and others . That also shows that he is not a nice person. Even from jail he was manipulating and bossing people to do what he wanted them to do. No loving words at all. He will get on well in jail.
I dont agree thst his eyes are sociopathic. Hes fair skinned with dark eyes that , therefore, stand out. I think he had a good heart to begin with , but something went wrong long ago and caused the use of oxycodone........the beginning of the end. Judging people is a horrible job. I think some people are happy to see a rich man suffer. I'm not saying he is innocent.. he stole money. He seemed to love his family. I think he was in a horrible position of his own inability to stop using drugs and needing money. All of that pressure was intolerable. Maybe he really didnt like his job . Maybe his dad and mom being so Ill was unbearable. Still, you work things out. You dont kill anyone.He looks like he was in anguish. I dont think a psychopath would be in anguish as he realized what hed done and he would never be able to change it back. Drugs and alcohol addiction or even just use/abuse, can cause people to become very mean. Paranoid. Irritable and abusive. I dont think any of this is funny. People are so easy to judge. Yes he was wrong if he did this. But, it's not funny and none of us are perfect. I just cant picture him killing maggie and Paul.
“Don’t talk to anyone without your lawyer” does not translate to “lie to authorities” at the scene of a crime. Invoke your rights - innocent or guilty - and don’t lie. This man is a lawyer and thought his lies would be believed because of who he is.
Excellent comment and point. Don't talk to anyone without a lawyer doesn't mean lie. Why would they tell him that even??? I bet they didn't even say that. Ask him which ones said that. I bet they will say check no I didn't tell him that. Why would he need a lawyer when finding his wife and son deceased??? He shouldn't need a lawyer to describe his findings of his deceased family members. He obviously had some help on this to dispose of weapons and not have gun residue on himself. Either way he's gone for life for stealing from all the deceased and injured.
@@SRHisnum1 Can anyone please explain what happened w/Maggie's phone? Was it taken from the scene of the crime & later found somewhere else? Thank you.
A guilty tell is when they say “ no, I did not” while simultaneously knodding in the affirmative as if to say “yes” instead of shaking their heads “no”. I’ve seen this so many times when watching these court appearances.
@ liz Salazar I was just thinking of Bill Clinton and the Monica Lewinsky interview where he was nodding yes when saying no, as I was reading your comment. Guilty as hell!
It takes a combination of at least 3 body language signs of deception to consider what he was saying at the time he said "no" while nodding (up and down) "yes", to be considered a lie.
He dabs at his eyes and let’s his snot drip down his face without wiping. Every move and word out of his mouth is calculated to elicit sympathy. But then he turns on a dime to argue with the prosecutor. He is disgusting.
Yep, paupa video and then his car ratted on him. He didn’t know about either of those two pieces of sinkers, I bet he sheet his pants more than once. I would’ve confessed immediately! Ok, u got me! I give up!
@@bethpowell8680 The lawyer is lobbing up softballs to humanise him and come across as sympathetic as possible. He went from this wealthy unrelatable monster in peoples minds to a man with a life and a family and a bunch of relatable problems.... none of it changes the fact that he murdered his family but all this narrative building did humanise him somewhat.
TAKE NOTE ON THE "GUARD BIRD" Alex said they are going to make a lot of noise if somethings happening.. and clearly the bird was making noise the day of the murder...also Alex says he lied about going to the kennels that once he told the lie he had to keep telling it - soooooo that's enough for me to say he's lying about shooting Paul and Maggie.
Also when he said on tape... whoever did it had a lot of time and planned it long before. When he changes his story now, tells me he is changing his story as the evidence develops.
I am sorry but anyone that could brutally murder family members and others does not have empathy. His tears and performance is outstanding--but don't be fooled. He's a wolf in sheep clothing.
Aborting a baby is a brutal murder of a family member….but I don’t see any outrage in America over those brutal murders. Twisted how people get all emotionally invested in a case like this though…while being just fine with baby murder.
@@FerallHog your point has zero relevance to this case. I guarantee lots of people that loved Paul and Maggie and want justice for them are also fully against abortion, given the geopolitical atmosphere of SC. Your comment disrespectfully undermines the value and weight of the 22 + 53 years that Paul and Maggie respectively spent living, breathing, thinking and feeling things on this earth. If time is money, their years of living holds much more value than never truly living. If justice for one is justice for all, why are you here?
@@ellenresinger1934 my point has every relevance…and you know it. People all crying and up in arms for the wife and son…many of those same people rabidly support murdering innocent babies. If you can’t understand the extreme hypocrisy and blind spot, then you need help.
Guilty people always seem to surround their crime event with real facts to make themselves feel better. It’s also so interesting how he gets choked up at the right times but recovers within seconds.
@@bassface8580totally agree and if u have watched a clip from busters interview (not the trial video but outside interview) when he is asked questions he does the same thing nods his head yes and then denies everything.
@@MeechNChongX slimy bastards the lot of them. Alex is the worst and deserves the rest of his life rotting in jail. A Master Liar and manipulater. He never shed one tear for murdering his wife and kid. What does that say about the mind of this psycho. He tried to cry at the scene and interrogation but he knew what happened. He did it. This is an act and a good one. He seems at first glance to be a sweet old man who loved his family and they were taken from him but no.. he did it make no mistake
@@MeechNChongX Alex did the same thing at the final SLED interview when asked if he killed Maggie & then if he killed Paul. Alex denies it, but his head nods in a yes gesture. The footage is a bit grainy, but you can still see his movements just fine.
I thought this was supposed to be a short story of what you did on a particilar day. Instead we are hearing about dogs peeing on trees. Gosh he is just so down to earth! That is what he wants us to think. Gosh. I am just a simple good old boy...
I think it is interesting how he took the time to spend time with his son and do some of those precious memory making things, knowing that he was going to be ending his life within a few hours. I think it was just an alibi rather than actually special father-son time. It's nice that Paul got to feel like his dad was wanting to spend time with him, but I know that all of that faded away the moment that he realize that his dad had not only shot him, but shot him intentionally and was coming back for more to make sure the job got done. How absolutely horrific that last moment of his life was.
So damn sad! Alex is a monster What the judge said about Alex seeing them in his dreams and around every corner I hope is true! He needs to be haunted by them the rest of his life!
This is what gets me the most. How could someone be this demonic and evil? His son was laughing with his dad, playing around with the dogs literally minutes before. I just can’t imagine or believe how horribly depraved a human being has to be to go through with something like this 😢
Couldn’t agree more. The head bobbing & rocking back & forth, the lip smacking & alligator tears, all BS. He’s a horrible actor & has been caught lying more than a few times so far and the Stuff he blames on his addiction is total BS
I'm not convinced he did it. I think he was involved but I'm not convinced he did the deed. That friend of Paul says on that Netflix thing that Alex wasn't even there for Gloria's "fall" I kinda wonder if he did any of the acts or if he just helped cover it up. I don't trust any of em including buster.
To be fair they were hunting dogs, not really household family pets, most people do keep their hunting dogs outside in big kennels most of the time and from what they showed on the Netflix doc it was just a big fenced in horse stable p much, plenty of room and shelter for them to be comfortable
Exactly!! Dogs are dogs whether they hunt or not; they are pack animals. They yearn to be w a pack or family. It’s cruel to separate them into little isolation cells, just cruel!
@@athenaabell4336 It's called Method Acting. Many Hollywood actors and on Broadway too have learned the technique and ppl pay money to see them perform. Have u ever had an addict in your life ? Lying is very easy for them and even the most cynical find them believable. Until everything is lost to them and still !!!!!.....Your love and hope aches for them to be telling you truths. Alex still has a strong obcession for opioids and if freed he will be in the gutter within days. But hey maybe he won't take anyone with him. But he will. I hope u never find out the hard way. It's a journey many families never recover from.
Weirdest thing to me is when he’s talking about turning over Paul and seeing his brains and all that….he’s “crying” with absolutely no tears then 15 seconds later he’s back to normal again lol
It’s so crazy to me that in any of these murder cases the guilty never asked who did it.. if I was being falsely accused of murder Id want to know who killed my wife and kid and why they weren’t looking for the actual murderer not once do they ever inquire
Well first they are raking him over the coals not even trying to find anyone else who had done this horror.. that's what sucks about cops tunnel vision. Just see one way
@@commercialaccount9501 Because almost instinctively we want answers..we want to help and be helpful.. It's one if your forever loves.. Sounds like TRUTH is important for all...mmho
Having been convinced that this ruthless man had took the lives of his own child and wife i cant stop thinking how it would be impossible for him to have any feelings for the living son. Yet when his son is on the stand he looks at him with so much pride and love in which the son seems astonishingly sharp and educated. I think its all an act to win jury votes. My heart goes mostly to the living son that lost his mom and brother and now is left with this mess publicly trying to make a sense of it all.
I think that particular son worships him, kisses ass, does any and everything he expects of him and more which is why he adores that son and spared his life! It's more so he loves how that son looks up to him and is just like him. I think Paul was a momma boy and busted his balls, highlighted his imperfections and was a torn on his side! The wife of course doted on the baby and showered him with attention most likely since he was born which was an animosity dick probably varied since then! Add naturally growing apart or losing interest in each other over the years is why he so callously killed both of them if he did it! A hatred or disdain for the two that grew
The very noticeable smiling at his son made me sick -to me, it was very obviously for the jury’s benefit. I believe Marian Proctor -Maggie’s sister believes he’s guilty. I feel so sorry for her. She couldn’t understand why Alex wasn’t putting resources-not least time and energy into finding Maggie and Paul’s killer, nor did he seem too anxious about Busters safety. Just another of several reasons I believe he is guilty.
The part in the trial when he first heard the kennel recording, nodding his head yes.. and just how he acted during that part.. and him turning from ghost white to beer red told me all I needed to know right then and there. Made me sick to my stomach
@@criteria9514 he’s had time to prepare for this, even if doesn’t remember everything, than at least have your answers prepared. He must have had to remember how to win millions of dollars for clients and how to steal from them. You can’t have selective memory
@@DeepCurve300 lol he does know something of the night, he just isn't recalling specific details A heavy opiod addiction coupled with a culture of lying due to his career and covering up his addiction for DECADES most definitely gives him some plausible deniability
The sheriff's came up on him alex had a shotgun they saw dead bodies brains splattered n they never put handcuffs on him wow amazing low country at it's fineness
Oh sure, he was at the kennels just minutes before his family was slaughtered but didn't see a thing, and the killers got lucky waiting in the woods to ambush Maggie and Paul with the family's own guns, then toss the lady's phone on the roadside right where Alex is driving by, the killers were geniuses.
Done forget the dogs were also running loose and would've come to "deal with it" if a stranger had been killing M & P - also, who put the dogs back into the kennels?
if he was there- it should have been easy to prove, the problem is no one actually searched. How can you sentence someone to murder when law enforcement couldn't be bothered to search this man's house? Nothing was done. No search of his mothers. No concrete evidence found-nothing
I know right! You notice how he replaced crying with this slow talking, lip smacking?? He makes me sick to my stomach in every way. And i guarantee you there will be one dim wit juror who will say "There is no way he would hurt a hair on sweet little Paw paws head" and not that he blew that little dudes brain right out is what he's really thinking. I believe he gave Paul a death sentence for Mallory and not for her but for ruining his life cause it was crumbling. And he didn't want to have to split half of whatever hidden money she knows he has put away or she would obviously know how good he was doing financially if they got a divorce.
I see some chilling facial expressions when he forgets to act! The energy off him is dark and he’s coming across as fake, yet doing a good job of lying
Yes....im thinking he could be the next anti-Christ!!!! He is scary AF. Its so sickening how he even stole from all of the deceased and injured people and their loved ones much less covering up your kids murders or murdering your wife and child.
hes so DARK! Alex used Hookers and at least one, LINDSAY EDWARDS has come forward that he beat and choked her almost to death! watch her interview on youtube ua-cam.com/video/XYQH7rmgZCQ/v-deo.html
I have no dog in this fight nor will I express an opinion as to this man's guilt or innocence , but as an attorney, what I will say is that the difficult thing about this case for the defense side is that even if Murdaugh is completely innocent of murder, good luck getting a jury to see past his life of lying and deception. Most people will immediately import guilt for one crime strictly based on character evidence, which is why the laws of evidence were crafted specifically to avoid the admission of evidence that might be overly prejudicial to the defendant. Just peruse the comments below and look how many people easily import guilt for murder based on lying in other matters. No one will comprehend this until they find themselves in a situation where people are brutally scrutinizing your life and will appropriate your guilt or innocence based on what they think of you as person. I can't tell you how many clients I've had who made some bad choices in their life but were NOT guilty of the crime they were currently charged and we had to work hard to keep the info out of court that we thought was irrelevant. Human beings will always judge you by the lowest common denominator of your life, which is why you must avoid ever putting yourself in a situation where other human beings will sit in judgment of you with your life in their hands.
Wrong! He lied about being at the kennels with Maggie and Paul. He tried to bribe his mom's care giver to buy himself a solid alibi. He tried to get his housekeeper to say she saw his clothes he wore in Paul's snap chat video. He lied saying he left work at around 5pm v after 6pm to fit his 'couple' hours messing around with Paul at the hunting lodge and claims he can't remember if they met Maggie at the shed or at the house. Come on, man! There's nothing 'innocent' about Alex MURDAugh! Alex is the one who claimed he had a 'wonderful' relationship with his wife whilst abusing opioids for 20 years. She never got over his affair because he didn't change his practice of lying and MANipulating others to get what he want$ and she would never forgive him for embezzling millions$ to feed his addiction$ to $, drugs and po$$e$$ion$. She told her confidant that she would give up everything for all of *IT* to go away and she didn't want to be with him at the hunting lodge but he sister talked her into it as Alex needed her as he just found out his father was terminal and back in the hospital. His father died 2 days after the murders. His mother has end stage Alzheimer's so she has no clue.
Totally correct. His lying didnt help either. Im surprised the defense didnt express just what you expressed. Ive yet to see defenses closing arguments so Im not sure if that was expressed to the jury. Also getting him to testify clearly was a blunder..
@@guywebster8018 I think the defense was hoping Alex's testimony was going to be their Hail Mary! lol 1 juror said he blow snot but didn't shed 1 tear was shed and the Jury was face to face with him. I'm glad he took the stand as now I know how he was ABEL to hoodwink so many people into trusting him. He's TALL and Gregarious > a people person and people like him > a good ole southern boy born and raised in the low country > A man's MAN who know's how to get'r done! who turned out to be a snake in the grASS due to his LUST for $, po$ITion, po$$e$$ion$ and Drug$ so let HIS 'case' be a lesSON for all GREEdy white meN to follow the 10 COMMANDmentS and you too are GOoD
@@deborahhershey3045 lool its not just greedy white men, all greedy people fullstop.im sick of the discrimination against white men, just be quite if u cant say something constructive. And btw, wot white men u talking bout mediterrean white, anglo white, roman white???its just ridiculous.
I feel like those tiny details were given purposely to confuse people. He'll give long drawn out needless filler info til you forgot what detail you were looking for or even the question you asked.
He can stop repeating that PREPARED speech about him stealing money from his Clients. Oh my God so gulty. Yes Maggie had a sense about this so called husband. RIP MAGGIE AND PAUL. PEACE AT LAST. 4/28/23.
@@elainecameron4024 guilty of what? That’s not being sarcastic, I’m sincerely asking. 😄 I haven’t watched all of the videos, I’ve watched out of order and haven’t seen his son’s testimony yet.
He doesn't actually deny shooting them, but instead says, "I would never do anything to intentionally hurt them." It's a type of minimalization that is pretty normal for someone lying.
@@brendakauffman2222 I agree. When someone says “I would never, blah blah blah“, what they’re really saying is “this is what you are to believe of me.“.
and notice he said he would never INTENTIONALLY hurt Mags or Pau Pau.. Him calling his son that pet name literally made me throw up... He was so guilty, even a deaf blind person could tell.
Why would anyone lie about anything if they are innocent, especially after something so horrific like this. An innocent person would be in complete shock. I feel like Buster is emotionless, like he is not surprised on some level. It’s strange. He is also not looking the lawyer in the eye continuously.
If someone is threatening your dearly son over and over, the first thing any parent will do is to make sure there is surveillance cameras around the house and dash cams in the cars. The fact he didn’t do any of this indicate that this guy has so many secrets and glad he got caught.
How about when the police show up you say "My mom is alone down the road get police there, and my son is in Charlotte. Someone is trying to kill us! Set up a roadblock" No didn't cross his mind because he was working his alibi from the very start.
@@ThenVersusNow_ Hope Alex knows drop and roll won't put the fire out where he's headed. He will never admit he premeditated their cold blooded murder. There will be less mercy shown him than he showed his family. And he did it for greed. Just greed !!! Pathetic.
@@juliecrane9647 Problem is hes keeping busy by helping everyone in jail. He wants to be everyone friend . He deserves to be isolated, not amongst people, to take his mind ..off the fact hes a family murderer.
Listening to this again ..my goodness..he talked and talked and talked. .same way he thought he thought apologising over and over for his misdeeds would clear him! So sickening
He did it for YEARS and to the tune of millions of dollars stolen. If he ever contemplated feeling sorry, he would have stopped long ago and counted his blessing he got away with what he did. That never happened. What did happen was he got caught and for THAT he is sorry. Of that, I'm quite sure. You can't tell me he spent millions on primarily on pills and lived to tell the tale. That's just the cover story to hope the court will take some mercy on his addiction issue. Obviously, there was a lot more then a pill problem going on in that family.
I know, I was brutally sexually assaulted and as the VICTIM ont he stand I was NOT allowed to say more than ONE sentence at a time- I was cut off while speaking, cut off while crying in agony, but this heinous murderer is allowed to go on and on and on....
His “CRYING” didn’t move me . Matter of fact … it only made me more convinced he was guilty because he’s switch from sad to being fine within two secs. Crazy how emotions can change .
@@thenightporterOh my goodness yes, that was chilling! One of those things I keep going back to because I almost couldn't believe he said that, like an afternoon exchange with a neighbor while taking out the trash cans except Alex was standing feet away from his murdered wife and son....so strange.
@@thenightporterhis “devastated” mask slipped in that moment back to the normal day to day mask he wears. He fakes all human emotions and protocols. He mimics what he thinks he should do. There are so many ppl like him walking among us too. Quite scary.
@@thenightporterI believe he's definitely involved in their deaths. But I'll give him the fact that "How ya doing?" is just the "proper" Southern thing to do, even near the dead or dying. It's just our way because we're taught from the time we start talking to acknowledge & "speak" to everyone when we have to interact with them, it's the polite & respectful thing to do 🤷🏻♀️
All these threats Paul supposedly got on social media, in bars, etc. and he *still* doesn’t go into detail of what these threats actually were. Why so vague?
Social media??? He should have the proof,,,or a couple of witnesses but, no. He’s a lawyer with a badge..he should’ve sent the person a certified letter threatening to sue them for harassing paupa 😉👍🏻
Don’t you think they should examine Paul’s cell and social media ? Especially leading up to the murder date. No mention of this at all. Investigation is faulty and not complete for sure.
@@susietapliner Yeah, you'd think there would've been a thorough investigation of Paul's social media activities. Or, maybe there was, and there wasn't much to say about it. 🤔
Did you now Paul? I need too start at the beginning of the trail. Do you think he killed his wife and son. I leave in Norway. I have read about these case many times in our Norwegian newspapers. Please excuse me spelling I did only learn the most important words and grammar. I use google if I don’t understand some words. Have a wonderful day from Hilde in Norway. It’s middle of the night in Norway now.
Listening to his testimony over again, he didn't arrive at his office til around noon on June 7th. Paul was at work and Maggie had left for medical appointments. He had all morning to plant guns and a change of clothing at the shed or kennel area! Thank God the jurors didn't fall for his pathetic performance!
@@kellymcginnis8631 He tried to say he left work early, around 5. A coworker said he was there after 6pm. There's no end to the lies. Thank God the jury put him into the dust bin of bad trash!
@@carolynpatty3711 Agreed Not a good father and husband either. Unlike many people with crippling addiction, he had the means to get help. He could have literally saved his life. His greed got him life in prison.🖐
I find it interesting how different courts are. This court allows witnesses to explain and pretty much say whatever they want as long as it very loosely pertains to the question. Some courts want very short and to the point answers. I wonder if this has to do with the culture of the district or if it's more about the judge's preferences and what he/she will allow.
There's a lot of interesting things about this court. They probably aren't used to cases like this. Everybody and everything ill equipped. I hope he doesn't get away because of these inadequacies
Yes it’s fascinating to me as a Brit watching the trial and proceedings in the court- I like that they are loquacious in the south- the Judge is lovely- can’t imagine saying that about one of ours …
i think the more details shared by AM can help with any inconsistencies if he is lying. it also allows AM to ramble on about really small details and read into how he responds to different questions.
Attorneys being questioned by attorneys, arguing with prosecution attorney..sounds like great grounds for the judge to let them go do it. It didn’t happened to any public witness
I have thought the same. My father was murdered and consequently, I've been through a murder trial. I've never seen witnesses give so much personal history at the beginning of their testimony (although, I certainly see why it is done, here), and be allowed to give so many details - almost like a real conversation rather than question/answer.
He said he turned paul over by his belt loop which is odd considering he saw his brains on the ground, most people would not want to move a body in case you might make it worse.
I honestly think most ppl would be vomiting in absolute shock at the sight of their sons brains at his feet and just his face left. Think about how utterly gruesome that sight was? 🙈
If I found my son like he supposedly found his boy I'd be on my knees and I would roll him over the best I could and I'd be cradling him in my arms rocking and screaming for my baby. To lift his supposed loved son by his belt loop shows you how little this poor excuse for a father loved his son. I remember holding my Dad when my little brother passed at 3months of age and I was nearly 5. I'm 64 now and I can still see my Dad with his head on my chest weeping for his son. It's something you never forget. This father lifted him by his belt loop...disgusting
@@kimrayner4660 it must have been such a blessing to have such a kind of father! And Kim I feel for you as you were such a little girl. I don't know, if I'd find my son murdered I'd probably want to preserve as much evidence as possible. Believe me I love my son very much, but I had a very very different upbringing than you, so for me cuddling is not such a need like for the most people. I would have the feeling my son wouldn't need it in this moment anymore. I could be wrong. I hope we won't experience something like this
This is what doesn’t make sense to me. So they live on a big property, someone supposedly comes onto the property, apprehends Paul’s guns, kills 2 people, then disappears. Alex finds them less than an hour later, maybe even sooner, and when he calls 911 he seems unconcerned that someone is still in the area. He did get a gun to kind of show he was scared, but if his property was truly trespassed by someone, he would be freaking out trying figure out where that someone is. There is no evidence of a car having come or gone from the property. Any alternative hypothesis other than Alex doesn’t make sense.
That's a Big 10-4 right here ! Old buddy I have been thinking the same things. I'm from the South. We work hard to have alot of land here in the South and I can tell you of it was me..... I wouldn't have been able to have jumped and rolled fast enough to where the artillery would be found. That's all I know about my thought on how he reacted in the scene unfold so quickly. I'd had a couple of ARs and a 338 for sure. Lol but to each their own.
❌ He is causing me STRESS - talking so much and saying absolutely nothing at all. He never URGED the cops to find the killers, nor to protect his other son, because all along he knew, that the killer was himself... ❌
The problem with his lying is the exact same with most people who commit a crime and try to lie about it. He is lying about something that he would have had no reason to lie about unless he was involved in killing them. If I were in his place I would have been saying from the 911 call on that I had just been there with them before going to my mom's! He lied from the beginning and wants the jury to believe he just did that spontaneously due to paranoia. Another example if this is the Natalie Holloway case. When her mom went to man who killed her home he came to the door and lied about leaving her at her hotel. If he was innocent he would not have a reason to have lied. Same exact thing here.
He is so detailed about his poor little struggling fruit tree & nice family tailgating memories but he can not tell you what he talked about the last time he saw Paul and Maggie. He cannot tell you his last words to Paul or Maggie. He cannot not tell you what he did back at the house after the murders when he likely was cleaning up before turning on his phone. For the appeal the state needs to trace his steps per this description and analyze the golf cart which may have blood evidence. He killed for the love of his pills, M&P were watching him having sent the email a month earlier. He no doubt planned to make a liability case against his own commercial liability carrier on the hunting lodge, much like Gloria"s case. It is about the money, hiding past crimes, fraudulent insurance proceeds, etc...The BS he tells as he yaps away at nothing to show what a great family man he WAS with cutesy nicknames. Family Annihilator is an apt term.
Diane H Well said. I hadn’t thought about him suing over the deaths! That makes perfect sense given his way of operating. That would have been a major cash cow for him - maybe getting him out of whatever jam he was in financially (that kept bleeding him dry). It had all caught up to him to the point that he couldn’t even cobble together $800K to get Jeanie off his back in-time. That means even his father and his other legal partner wouldn’t even give it to him. That’s huge. His father apparently bailed him out of everything - like Trump’s father did for him so many times.
His insurance would cover accidents not murder. lol He prolly planned on suing the media for causing 2 somebody's to hate Paul so much as to gun him down and his mom was a witness and the one who spared the rod to spoiled him rotten so she too was shot dead. Too bad his couSIN Eddie didn't keep his mouth shut. How much did Alex pay him and expect him to take the fall if caught? 1.2 million? Alex would have gotten him a 'deal' from his part time prosecutor's office for his loyalty to the Family of MURDAugh
Cutesy nicknames and nothing but glorious tales of father and son bonding experiences all day long, as they happily skipped along holding hands through the meadow with great huge smiles on their faces saying “I love you Paw Paw!” And Paw Paw says “I love you too Dad!” Big fat liar….
The question isn't "why did you lie." My question is why didn't AM or anyone on the defense team remember AM lied to the first officer on the murder scene, nullifying his paranoid excuse?
I agree, a person finding their murdered wife and child would be in shock. You’d hardly be able to talk never mind formulate lies. Your brain just wouldn’t be able to do that while trying to comprehend something incomprehensible.
AM didn't show any type of paranoia, so his statement that he was paranoid just doesn't hold up. Plus paranoia has symptoms and none of his law partners, clients or family testify to paranoia. He sights it, when it's convenient, as I believe he claimed drug addition with high usage because it was convenient and made others have more sympathy for him. He may have used opiates at times, but I don't think he was an addict for years taking the amount he claimed because he would have died if he was, and he wouldn't have been able to pull off elaborate money laundering schemes covering lies with lies.
Those annoying nicknames. OMG.Funny how we never heard them during the 911 call, police interrogations, police bodycams, or jailhouse calls. If he thought he was endearing himself with the jury, he thought wrong. They saw right thru him.
To me it seems he was acting in desperation, but he had thought about doing this for some time, planning it for years. That's why he set up strange stalker situations that are quite bizarre. He was never attacked by anyone other than himself or someone he hired to take part. His final act was to set up a double homicide to make it appear that the imaginary stalkers shot the two of them. Doesn't make sense that he was home and in the kennel yet he was unharmed?? Right. The very day he is about to be confronted, 1: His dad is dying. Then 2: His wife and son are murdered. Both extreme pity and sympathy plays. The double murders are a perfect distraction for his embezzlement crime! I hope it was worth it, Alex!!!! IDIOT.
@@larrywakeman4371 Seeking the death penalty would have made Alex’s conviction LESS LIKELY. Also, it was a strategic choice by the prosecution. A capital charge would have allowed the defense team to voir dire the jurors. That’s how trial selection works in Alex’s lowcountry area.
It is important that the public sees these cases, to understand wickedness that occurs in humans sadly. Every second this individual continues opening his mouth it’s fantastic lies build inside his mind for a very- very long time, considering the circumstances. Wow. Mentally disordered to a point of total delusion. I don’t think drugs alone can explain this. At all.
@@doreenplischke2169 not I’ll Evil he knew it was all wrong If he was truly that I’ll he would not lie to cover his tracks He was not in temporary psychosis. He’s learned to lie cheat steal and kill to get his way These aren’t the first of his victims by any means
Hearing him speak at the end about his son Paul was truly troubling. You can speak those words about him,but you took his life away. Yes he was a mean drunk but look at the role model for a father.
The defense should pay a dollar for every “umm” to pay back the clients since they didn’t earn their 600k. This should be a law school course on what not to do when allowing the accused to take the stand.
He never expresses hatred and anger for being accused of this horrendous. Evil act! And pleading for them to please find the people or person that killed them!!
I mean neither did my uncle & he was exonerated with DNA evidence after 17yrs in prison. I’m not saying he’s guilty or innocent, just offering another perspective. Attorneys will advise against “outbursts” & judges will order there be none as well. It’s hard to know what you’d do in this situation whether you were guilty or innocent. I’d like to think I’d lose my ever loving mind, but again, my uncle thought so too but when the time came, he did not.
The most DISGUSTING part of this horrific crime is that this 😈 thought he was SO Smart & Clever that he would get away with 🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️ murdering his son & wife....They ALWAYS think they're smarter than anyone else! Hence very DANGEROUS
When the verdict was read, there was a sigh of relief from the many that have been hurt by this man. RIP Miss Maggie and Paul. Alex is where he belongs, in prison labeled a liar, thief and murderer.
This is how it happened: Alec knew he was about to be found out about his financial crimes. On top of that, he was being pressured on the boat case. He figured as a last resort, with Paul gone he might solve that problem. Only for him to realize that Maggie would know he killed him, so she would have to be killed too.
Or perhaps he killed both of them because he didn't want to have his wife and son go through the embarrassment of him getting fired due to stealing.... or that he was on opioids for the past 20 years... or that he was unable to protect his son from the repercussions of the boating accident. And, if he could convince everyone that he was innocent, he would be able to collect the death benefits of his wife and child AND his father and possibly return all the money he had embezzled. Oh wait... he would NEVER do that!! Instead, he would leave South Carolina and try to find a new life in a new place where no one know of this!! What a greedy, self-centered POS!!!
@@commercialaccount9501 He was at school or else he may have also met the same fate. Allegedly, there was a time where Alex called Buster to come home unexpectedly weeks prior to and asked him to go Deer hunting. Buster had other plans and said No. Ya never know...Alex could have wanted to unalive him then.
@@Countess88 Actually unalive is the word now being used on UA-cam with content creators because they have begun striking channels with those words you used in titles and comments.
Hard not to consider that the lying and thieving that has dominated his whole adult life properly characterizes him as a career criminal, with an absolute lack of integrity. How could anyone believe anything he says? If his addiction is so bad, could he kill to protect it?
AM putting himself on the golf cart put him at a 5ft 2" or so height. Who put the dogs back into their kennels if both Maggie and Paul had been shot shortly after AM left the kennels? It's hard to believe an intruder would have put Grady & Bubba back into their kennels after shooting Maggie & Paul. It's more plausible that that person would leave as quickly as possible, as the dogs may not be familiar with them, and may have been aggressive towards an intruder... correct?
what is missing what is making this all so wierd he thinks no blood equals innocence that fool should have covered himself with their blood he should have gotten his knees dirty with grass stains and dirt he would have been so distraught at the nightmare he walked into the coos would have had to restrain him he would have needed sedation if he used the golf cart earlier then why go in the house see them still not there and then use the truck to go back to the kennel golf carts are much more casual and easy on a vast property it all stinks because he is a complete moron
Some dogs will attack, some will just bark, some will whimper and run, some will on their own go into their kernel quietly. Did these dogs assist with hunting or go out hunting with them because I know some dogs are afraid of loud noises like gun fire but they might have been used to it. But s stranger handling a gun that just harmed their owners may cause them to retreat instead of attack!
The dogs were barking like crazy after the murders. You can hear them. Barking like they were from my experience with dogs they would have raced out of that cage and chased down any intruder. They were dying to get out and chase.
The more this malignant narcissist says paw-paw, the more I want him to NEVER get out of prison. Sorry Alex, your paw-paw defence just couldn't cut it. The weird zombie like rocking back and forth, the lip smacking, the snot dripping...ugh! Guilty!
In discussing this with my sister, she pointed out that they got him becasue of the video that his son Paul took at the Kennels; It proved that Alex was there. My God, the way they failed to process that murder scene properly, if they didn't have that video, he probably would have gotten off, who knows?
Yep that's why he left his phone at the house to make the investigators believe he was napping and not at the kennels planning the right time to ambush his son and hunt down his wife as she tried to flee. He hosed himself off, took his clothes off went back to house to shower and change clothes. Gathered up his clothes, rifles and Maggie's phone and ditched them on the way to his mom's for his alibi to be complete. He tried to get his mom's care provider to lie for him and he would pay for her wedding and get her a cushy job and she only had to say he was there twice as long as he was. 21 minutes to his mom's + 16 minutes back = 37 minutes + 40 min visit = 77 minutes + time to check the bodies and take their pulses would put him away from the property before Paul's last text message ... tells me he waited as long as he could before he killed his wife and son.
Not really. He says they were all there, he left, took quick nap, went to his moms. Saw his mom (witness) and came back to find his family. You have to listen!
That's SLED for you. Good old South Carolina Law Enforcement Division. They are very sloppy. Even the SLED director testified on the stand that she wasn't sure if the officers on the scene were her "guys" that walked around the kennels or if they saw the bodies that night. This is months after the murder and she STILL couldn't tell the court when or where SLED officers were on the property that night and she still didnt know, when she was on the stand, when they arrived or what they saw. She didnt even know which officers were sent there!
I do think he loved Paul as much as he could love but ultimately I sincerely believe Paul had disgraced the family name, Paul had really embarrassed him and I think Paul had become too big of a liability for him and all he had. I think he convinced himself that if Paul was no longer around it just might lessen the impact of the boat crash. That night destroyed their lives irreparably. I think he assessed the lawsuit and at some point just made a decision that Paul presented too big a threat to their way of life and with him gone the lawsuit might go away and the sympathy his death would garner just might restore his good name as well.
And Maggie either saw something she shouldn’t have so she had to go too. OR she was against the idea or would never go for it so he decided to ice her too. But I think you’re 100% right.
The thing is if he had just let his kid take the fall the family would be a lot better off. It’s not far off for kids who have generational wealth act a fool while their parents feel shame and send them away or condemn them. Like Caroline Kennedy.
@@kendallleingangIt was Rosemary Kennedy that the father Joe Kennedy had lobotomized & institutionalized at St. Coleta's. But you're right about everything else with this case. Lots of generational entitlement & protecting the family image & name. Paul's liability with the boat crash was going to cost Alex too much reputational & financial harm. And expose Alex's other embezzlement crimes. The only way to try & get out of having his whole fake world come crumbling down on him was this. It's selfish, sick & totally sociopathic.
I believe that if Alex Murdaugh was innocent of these murders, he would have been much more composed when giving testimony. There's something about knowing you're innocent that would lead you to be truly focused on presenting facts of the experience without whining and cringing. There perhaps would be anger at being accused and that would be evident in his demeanor. His childlike behaviour feels like an act to me, especially given his propensity for lying, and continually negotiating his way of of trouble until it all came to a head. This act is just pathetic.
his memory and his answers do not make any sense. he can recall such unique small details, but cant recall other major things that you think you would remember. I remember exactly where I was and what I was doing on September 11th... It is hard for me to imagine not being able to recall more details on the day my wife and son was shot and i was literally there minutes before it happened.
Agree! And it seems that the jury members agree about this too. The ones I've seen interviewed stated that they thought it was a mistake for him to take the stand. But this was the way he "successfully" operated for such a long time, he thought he could convince them.
Not being composed and acting like he's crying, sobbing, wiping dry tears while manufacturing a few, but his emotions change on a dim, from sobbing to lucid. People's emotions in real life don't change on a dime like this.
I have a theory: I think that Alex drove the golf cart up the road and threw Maggie's phone on the side of the road then came back to the house before he left. Reason is, he didn't want to travel with BOTH his phone AND Maggie's phone together because it would possibly show up in the digital data. That would also explain why it was less than a half mile from the house. If he took Maggie's phone in his car when he drove to his mother's house, he probably would have tossed it a few more miles away. Just a theory but it makes sense.
THATS the EXACT theory of a youtube Channel MOB Crew -- the 56 steps Maggie's phone took was exactly 160 feet which is exactly where the golf cart would stop at Moselle and he'd walk to throw into the forest!
28:38 Alex describing the last seconds he spoke to his wife and child. Anyone that has any doubt about his guilt won't after listening to this. I'm thinking the whole time he's talking, "bro your wife and son get their brains shot out of their heads within minutes so WTF are rambling on about?" Finished up watching Alex and at the end once again when asked to talk about Maggie he said over & over how she didnt work. He also brought this up in his 2nd interview with SLED. And to say that Paul was ADHD and that he use to run around like some sick child is just unbelievable to me. I never watched Alex testimony during the trial so watching it now I don't think he even liked his family I actually think he hated them. Buster wouldve been dead as well if he couldve gotten him home.
Yep, I haven't seen that part, but I would agree. I worked for a woman who owned a business; she was her husband's boss (she hired him after he retired from a car plant, to keep more money in their pockets). He helped her in the heavy lifting, manly part, which he should have been happy to do because she provided a good living for them. However, he resented it and only wanted to be retired. He talked to me in the office (said he thought she didn't love him; it was awkward, so I tried to convince him otherwise). He just wanted to go set in the coffee house chatting up his dad or friends (and run around town feeling important). His wife was a hard worker and didnt expect laziness from anyone. She was more encouraging to get prople to work...not a slave driver. She didnt ask anything she was not also willing to do or help with. Later, her husband tried to make a pass at a big chested, wildish, youger woman, who went and told our boss that and that her husband wanted to divorce her. It is sad but some people just use others for money, whether men or women .. and don't appreciate family.
Same I think he hated Maggie and resented supporting her. She didn’t work but they had so much help. Why? Her gun shot wounds seemed more personal than Paul’s too. Clearly intended to make her suffer and have intense fear before she died. I wonder if he spoke to her during or before he shot her.
@@TheLolly881 I think it was a defense strategy to show that he cared about them, as you said show he cared. But also to maybe show that he couldn't possibly have killed these two people he refers to with these cutesy nicknames. But it came off really repulsive.
Everything Alex does everyone claims he killed them or he's lying ..He didn't get a fair trial with open minded people . Rogon should of been investigated harder than Alex or at least same . Theri something up with this Rogon kid cops lying destroying evidence . Fact is how did sled team no hold back recording back three weeks in trial . But yet Rogon done went cops next day pointing he's finger at Alex . Rogon the one that seem to know all the answer . he pin pointing exactly where when he Paul sight gun in ..I think Paul friend stole them weapons I think Rogon involved or help plan this out . Rogon last one talk Paul knew exactly where Paul was . Why didn't cops want Maggie data deleted it . When that could prove Alex innocent
When he was denying murdering, he was saying no as he waved his head yes. That's a classic give away of someone lying. All trained law enforcement, psychologists, and health personnel know this. I wS in law enforcement and that is common knowledge. Criminals always think they are smarter than everyone else
he does a lot of nodding anyway though, plus there needs to be more than one tell. I want them to ask WHY he didnt stop at his mums on the way home from work. why go home then go out?
This man has been lying his whole life it’s as natural as lying can get.
Even if I planned and carried out something so heinous I would absolutely fall apart under this kind of pressure.
Being interrogated, the media scrutiny a massive court case.... I'd confess to crimes I didn't commit to make it all stop. He just keeps on lying like it's nothing.
Just like that woman in Florida that “didnt” kill her daughter sick heartless people man… the Anthony’s
Pathological liar
What a shocking family this is ……Like a Rot that runs through them..
I mean he walked around from room to room, with his law patrol badge hanging out of his pocket, badgering each of those kids in the boat…He tries to pin the driving on a young man named Conner, so I firmly believe he even caused the death of his housekeeper…because no one can fall down stairs with such force and never wake up, and then he suggests filing a wrongful death suit, and he makes sure to keep all of the money.,,This man is pure evil. And no one can convince me someone was waiting and when Alec left the kennel at 8:44, someone killed Paul and Maggie in the 6 minutes between then and when their phones died…And Alec wouldn’t have ever told anyone he was at the kennel if that video didn’t turn up.
"So you've waited TWO YEARS to tell us the real story about the kennels" ?
Convenient, huh? 😏
Yeah, once a video of him at the kennels appeared and proved it 🙄
So he blames his lying on bouts of anxiety from his addiction, but conveniently his addiction has stopped him from telling the truth for the passed 2 years.
Yep. Had he known before he shot them that Paul had shot the video minutes before - which ultimately proved he was there- he would have delayed the killing-Obviously. How awesome was that for Paul to have video evidence to prove he was there minutes before the killing. Alex wasn't counting on that little glitch in the story line.
@@eileenahearn8066 It would've been awesome if Alex *had* noticed that a video-audio was being taken. He'd have possibly changed his mind for good. The horror of this story is that Alex considered two people he loved, lived with and interacted with, individually expendable to some "other *imagined* reality." I mean, was his mind actually thinking that if he wasn't caught that he and Buster could possibly have still enjoyed a thriving life somehow? Had he no thoughts of what this would do to Buster? The whole thing is still just too unbelievable that Alex, himself did this. I mean, they were all close knit, there's no doubt of that. I for one, even two years later cannot buy the very simplified "theory of the case" or prosecutors - that he did it for sympathy - to make lawsuits go away.
Another sign of lying is focusing on unimportant small details while relaying a story. He obviously practiced his performance since he wanted so badly to take the stand. Narcissists also love to testify as a control tactic
Paulette Campbell! You are so correct! Oh, and when I re-watched a certain place in his testimony, I noticed a ridiculous fake spaz attack in wiping away fake snot and tears. That convinced me, and the over-explaining! Bad Actor in every sense.
The fake spaz attack of wiping was such bad acting. The dry as a bone tissue should be entered into evidence. He did muster a few tears, just like an actor can do. The way he can quickly flip from pretend crying and distress to talking in a normal tone and cadence is another tell tell sign.
@@juliepeterson6639 Spot on !!!! He enjoyed murdering his family bc they were standing between him and his wealth. The only thing he ever worshipped. Shallow animal.
He shoulda practiced harder 😆. He is all over changing the story up about the kennels and trying to make the info fit his 1st lies. Heck my 5 yo grandson can focus a lie better that than this grown arse lawyer. He knows too if he tries hes gonna get a butt smack and a bar of soap and the Mimi look. This Alex been lying his whole life and getting away with it....sadly by ppl who know he lies and they choose to ignore him.
Agreed! I was thinking the same thing as well. Hes just so confident He can testify and out smart the state.
Why does a grown man talk like a 3 year old? Me, Paw paw, bus, mags, grumpy, stewy, my daddies, my meemaw, the meow meow and the ruff ruff.
Roro
😭😂
People from the south commonly use pet names for family members, etc. It stems back from early America.
@@bauhausoffice They call family members pet names? That would explain all the incest.
@@bauhausoffice I agree, but this is so made up. He didn’t call them that in real life. He really didn’t. It’s so obvious nobody else refer to them as Mags and Paw Paw and in the south when someone is given a name a nickname everybody calls them that I grew up in the south I know plenty of Bubbas and everyone called them Bubba not just their family.
He’s murdering me with that lip smacking
Same
It was killing me!!!!!!!
Intolerable...
Uggghhh yes
Lip smacking can be related to withdrawl
Saying no, I did not when asked if he shot his wife and son, notice he is nodding yes while saying no.That is one of the CLEAR signs of deceit. This man is, without a doubt, guilty of these crimes.
It's not that clear cut. It would depend on your baseline behaviors. Some people just do that. But I definitely took note of that action.
Do you have a time stamp?
@@staybeautiful305 First few questions, right at the beginning.
Came here to say this
Idk Bout that a lot of people nod no and MEAN Yes and nod yes and mean no it's got to be out of the baseline. So watch to see if when he says no about things you KNOW he didn't do if he shakes his head yes. Then you'll know if it's off.
Using endearing names for his wife and son such as Papa and maggs is a strategy he is using to pretend he love them and was close to them. Ridiculous manipulation ❤
I absolutely agree.
Yes it actually does make me physically sick to my stomach to listen to him. I've still not wrapped my mind around Chris Watts killing his two girls and no one saw that coming. I hope I never do understand how their minds work bc only a mind like theirs can fathom the hows and whys.
He doesn't sound natural when he says papa or maggs either.
Ttue
@@juliecrane9647 These men are family annihilators. Alex has lost control and can't handle it. Everything was falling apart financially plus the stealing and lying was all coming out. I think he killed the women who worked for them too. Alex never planned on giving her family any money. He told her family to sue him and he'd make sure they got a good deal of money. They did but Alex kept it all. Then things got worse and he needed more money. He handled it by killing his wife and Paul. If Buster was in the trouble Paul was in he'd be gone too. Chris Watts is a special kind of F--- ed up. Killing his baby girls and putting them in oil tanks!
They just letting him talk and talk. The more he talks the more you’re convinced he’s lying.
Even the first ten minutes of his talking do not add up. I can't put the dot on the i.
That is what liars do.
Defense attorney: “Mr. Murdaugh. Why did you lie?”
AM: “Because I didn’t know my son had captured my voice on a Snapchat video, and now I have to backtrack BIG TIME.”
do you thank they well get him to admit it i mean the state
Wow he said that I did not hear that part. I just want him to go to prison so bad
😂😂😂😂 for real that sums it up I can’t believe people buy this acting man his so guilty I know one dummy gonna say not guilty though 12 people one gonna buy his bull crap it’s a cold world
He’s biting on an object in his mouth that disperses something to induce tears. After talking about nieces baby he forgets to hide it. You see him roll it in his mouth and bite down then push it into his cheek. I knew he couldn’t be forcing out fake tears on his own. His psychopathy is so severe he can’t fake tears or he would have had a single tear in front of cops nut didn’t.
@@chelsea_1961 Does such a thing really exist?
I have noticed the oddest mouth movements during the trial. Could that be what that is about?
I probably watched this video over 15 times and the more I watch it the more I'm confident the jury made the right decision
Learning about who he was as a person, I don't know if I've encountered or witnessed a person who was such a PERFECT fit for prison... the boys will have fun with him in prison!!! Would you consider him a narcissist,too? ...
Me too. I find something different almost every time I watch it. Something I didn't catch before. He's guilty.
So you watched it 15 times 🤥 15x3=45 hours 😂
@@antoniovazquez2800 it's crazy BUT it true lol
He has to think hard to answer questions so he is lying..
He’s not sorry to anyone. A psychopath isn’t capable of feeling. He only knows how he’s supposed to feel sorry. Those people he ‘cares’ for while he steals their income and now quite literally, shoots them in the back.
A thief and a liar is always a murderer.
He has been teaching that to his clients for years and years. I'm sure he prepared them for the jurors so he knows how he is suppose to act it's his profession.
Excellent point
Psychopaths can feel for THEMSELVES - they lack empathy to feel for others - so they can feel angry or sad or happy for THEMSELVES
Not a psychopath a Sociopath
It was sooooo chilling when he said the person who killed Paul really hated him. I think he loved Paul until the boat wreck. Then he was done with him. Paul’s being sued lead to Alex’s financial records and misdeeds coming to light. Alex was pissed about all that.
Exactly.
I agree 💯. And he blamed Maggie for posting numerous pictures of the family drinking alcohol and most of them included Paul. Plus amaggie wanted to settle the boat case.
Oh now y wood he b sued?
@user-yq7lw9nn6d
His murdered son Paul got into a drunken boat accident while he was driving the boat that resulted in the death of one of the passengers.
The dead passenger's family was suing AM, which would've brought all his illegal schemes/fraud regarding his legal clients to light.
Ostensibly, AM tried to avoid that by killing Paul (and his wife, Maggie).
Boy, you really nailed it. That's exactly what happened. Usually, we just get frustrated and try to do the best we can with what we have, but he took it to the extreme.
This dude is only sorry he was caught..I feel no sympathy for him whatsoever, I feel he is a seasoned performer!!
I feel he's sorry for what happened or for what did, if he did it but the damage is already done..too late to feel sorry now
The way he can shift from grief to normalcy is not conducive with someone who’s truly overcome with grief. Grief lingers and takes time to transition out of.
Everyone grieves differently. There's no set way to grieve. Ppl who are grieving can literally be crying one minute and laughing the next
I haven’t seen him transition out of his grief. This man lost his wife, son and dad all in a week. I’m not convinced he’s guilty. I don’t think one can make snot fall as he did so professionally? Do you know anyone who can do that? I would imagine my nerves being shot and I can’t imagine being able to dial a phone number, or text or even think after walking up on dead people let alone it be family. Horrible events. Sad regardless of guilt or innocence. Mentally I think this man is a mess.
@@commercialaccount9501100%… when my husband’s brother died suddenly alone in his apartment at age 41 because he had a massive heart attack and lay there for days before their Dad found him….we had a 4 hour drive from where the funeral was to his burial and there were 7 of us packed into a suv… the whole drive up we were laughing telling stories about him…,sometimes deep grief makes you very emotional in several ways and our laughing telling stories was a part of releasing our grief…. I think folks read into things because so many are convinced he’s guilty…. I can’t stand the term “ duper’s delight” and people all say they see a defendant with duper’s delight ( not talking about this case specifically) when it isn’t…. But for the record I think this guy is 1000% guilty having discovered he’s on Paw paw’s video just minutes before the murders!
@@godsgrace5777curious if you still agree with this comment knowing he was caught on the phone’s video minutes before they were murdered?
Simply not true. You'll have to meet a lot more people who grieve. Some people who lose people simply feel numb. The thing is, (and it is weird) is that life, those little bitty moments of life, actually DO go on, just as they did one moment before someone loses someone. It is like you are caught b/w two worlds and you not only function in both of them, you also think in both of them. It is a very strange phenomenon. You not only can, but you often must shift in and out of them. It's plain weird and I say so from experience.
If he can rip off his clients that were friends of his one a Quadrapleadic now and a girl who lost her mother and all the others while he was living a life of luxury then he definitely MURDERED HIS FAMILY
I'm not saying he isn't guilty, but I think I could rip off people and not be capable of killing my family.
Gina pafitis. He killed them for the love of money all of his family are gold diggers.
He also used prosititues one of whom has come forward LINDSAY EDWARDS who says he beat and choked her --- interview on UA-cam ua-cam.com/video/XYQH7rmgZCQ/v-deo.html
@@heatherbrown8803Yeah, But it make it much easier to belief that he has no scruples at all. 😂
As he shakes his head “YES”, he denies shooting his wife and youngest son! 😢
Yes, I saw that. He really did kill them. He will never admit it.
He’s a good lawyer. Watch him guide his own lawyer through this. He knows how to bs people and that’s exactly what he’s doing
Yes indeed,
He's a Sorry lawyer stealing like he did.
@@operationmockingbird216 wow. Facts.
I don't think he's a very good lawyer, just grandfathered in, his son also got kicked out of law school bc he was cheating. When the boat accident occurred Paul called grandaddy not his dad, that's pretty telling
But a stupid criminal. Play stupid games, win stupid prizes. He's an idiot. The snap chat video is enough for conviction because they didn't shoot themselves.
”Did you shoot Maggie and Paul?” ”No, I did not” and the same time nods yes…..
What are you, a member of the body language behavior panel?
Nodding yes while saying no is irrelevant. Murdaugh is innocent.
Thought the same thing !
He nods alot anyway though 🤦
That, plus he didn’t say “No I did not…”. He said I would never hurt Maggie or Paul. He evaded answering the question.
Good catch
Buster shows absolutely no emotion in the entire trial.
100% Correct!!! That’s been preoccupying me…he shows no emotion AT ALL…his voice doesn’t even break a little during his testimony…BUSTER IS VERY ODD, at least AM cries, but Buster doesn’t even flinch when images of his dead mother’s bullet ridden body are shown. His girlfriend is a little odd looking too….👍
@@lindsayclark6453 he's a psycho like his dad
He's probably numb.
Grief can do strange things to people, like throwing them into denial altogether for a period of time after the initial loss.
@@lindsayclark6453absolutely agree. There is distancing yourself from emotion yet having natural emotions vs having none at all bc you don’t care.
Who are you people for real to say Buster wasn't crying enough in front of you all or upset enough . Are you f kidding me Alex crying plenty of times you same exact people claim he faking give me f break . B's light minded people like you people why Alex didn't even get fair trial I still say he didn't kill he's wife or son I think he was setup
My woman's intuition tells me that Maggie was afraid of Alex, and she wouldn't have been there alone with him. She thought she would be safe if Paul was there. She knew what was coming when it happened, and with her last thought and breath she ran to her son. RIP, Maggie and Paul. So very sad.
Maggie was as much of a POS as her husband and her sons.
What, aside from your intuition, makes you think Maggie was scared of Alex?
There weren't any allegations of abuse or other physical aggression from Alex, were there?
THIS IS SO SAD. RIP MAGGIE AND PAUL. LISTEN TO THIS OVERSIZED BOY.
Agreed. This whole case is very sad. I hope that Alex will repent of his actions before God.
P
This is one of those trials where the defense never should have let their client take the stand. He tries so hard to appear affable, harmless and wistful, yet immediately, when his stories end, he glares with those telltale shark eyes at the jury and prosecution, not blinking. Very sociopathic.
Indeed those black eyes are chillingly demonic...OMG
Ya but the evidence of him being there the jury would have known about!
His mistake was lying and saying he wasn’t there!
@@rhondacranford5389 His mistake was doing the crimes...
In typical liars fashion, he answered almost every question by repeating the full question, giving himself more time to conjure up an answer, and in true narcissistic fashion he insisted on taking the stand himself believing that he could con us all into believing he was a loving husband and father. However his evilness came shining through. The best thing that happened was letting him on the stand. In my opinion he is a psychopath. It would not have been noticed much when he was growing up on a farm where he could kill animals big and small, where all the adults surrounding him killed living creatures for fun . A psychopaths dream. Then he grew up to be a snake oil salesman of a lawyer. Just listen to the phonecalls from jail he made to Buster and others . That also shows that he is not a nice person. Even from jail he was manipulating and bossing people to do what he wanted them to do. No loving words at all. He will get on well in jail.
I dont agree thst his eyes are sociopathic. Hes fair skinned with dark eyes that , therefore, stand out. I think he had a good heart to begin with , but something went wrong long ago and caused the use of oxycodone........the beginning of the end. Judging people is a horrible job. I think some people are happy to see a rich man suffer. I'm not saying he is innocent.. he stole money. He seemed to love his family. I think he was in a horrible position of his own inability to stop using drugs and needing money. All of that pressure was intolerable. Maybe he really didnt like his job . Maybe his dad and mom being so Ill was unbearable. Still, you work things out. You dont kill anyone.He looks like he was in anguish. I dont think a psychopath would be in anguish as he realized what hed done and he would never be able to change it back. Drugs and alcohol addiction or even just use/abuse, can cause people to become very mean. Paranoid. Irritable and abusive. I dont think any of this is funny. People are so easy to judge. Yes he was wrong if he did this. But, it's not funny and none of us are perfect. I just cant picture him killing maggie and Paul.
“Don’t talk to anyone without your lawyer” does not translate to “lie to authorities” at the scene of a crime.
Invoke your rights - innocent or guilty - and don’t lie. This man is a lawyer and thought his lies would be believed because of who he is.
You have the right to remain silent anything you say can and will be used against you in a court of law.
Excellent comment and point. Don't talk to anyone without a lawyer doesn't mean lie. Why would they tell him that even??? I bet they didn't even say that. Ask him which ones said that. I bet they will say check no I didn't tell him that. Why would he need a lawyer when finding his wife and son deceased??? He shouldn't need a lawyer to describe his findings of his deceased family members. He obviously had some help on this to dispose of weapons and not have gun residue on himself. Either way he's gone for life for stealing from all the deceased and injured.
@@SRHisnum1 Can anyone please explain what happened w/Maggie's phone? Was it taken from the scene of the crime & later found somewhere else? Thank you.
Always invoke your rights
@@isabellind1292 I believe found along road thrown out by "one of the controlled" ...
A guilty tell is when they say “ no, I did not” while simultaneously knodding in the affirmative as if to say “yes” instead of shaking their heads “no”. I’ve seen this so many times when watching these court appearances.
@ liz Salazar I was just thinking of Bill Clinton and the Monica Lewinsky interview where he was nodding yes when saying no, as I was reading your comment. Guilty as hell!
...and he's quite the head shaker. His lawyers probably should have had him worked a little more on head shaking 🙄
It takes a combination of at least 3 body language signs of deception to consider what he was saying at the time he said "no" while nodding (up and down) "yes", to be considered a lie.
Nodding his head tongue thrust mouth movements are also a sign of Parkinson’s. Also his central nervous system could be jacked up bc of all the drugs
Correction: These are signs of deception from the body that MIGHT mean someone is with holding information or lying.
He dabs at his eyes and let’s his snot drip down his face without wiping. Every move and word out of his mouth is calculated to elicit sympathy. But then he turns on a dime to argue with the prosecutor. He is disgusting.
there has been zero video proof.
He knows the law Things and how he must act
@@dbrand1
Zero video proof of what.
@@dbrand1
Are you saying that in order for someone to be convicted of crimes, we must have 100% video proof?
Emotions don't change on a dime like he does on the stand.
It’s strange that he only admitting lying about being on the scene after the tape was discovered .
Yep, paupa video and then his car ratted on him. He didn’t know about either of those two pieces of sinkers, I bet he sheet his pants more than once. I would’ve confessed immediately! Ok, u got me! I give up!
I feel like he’s talking in circles getting off the point to confuse the jury. “The jury is smart”
Exactly! He's had time to make up a story to fit the exposed video
@@tinawindham6958 that’s wonderful isn’t it!
@@bethpowell8680 The lawyer is lobbing up softballs to humanise him and come across as sympathetic as possible.
He went from this wealthy unrelatable monster in peoples minds to a man with a life and a family and a bunch of relatable problems.... none of it changes the fact that he murdered his family but all this narrative building did humanise him somewhat.
TAKE NOTE ON THE "GUARD BIRD" Alex said they are going to make a lot of noise if somethings happening.. and clearly the bird was making noise the day of the murder...also Alex says he lied about going to the kennels that once he told the lie he had to keep telling it - soooooo that's enough for me to say he's lying about shooting Paul and Maggie.
Also when he said on tape... whoever did it had a lot of time and planned it long before. When he changes his story now, tells me he is changing his story as the evidence develops.
@@nippy2 excellent point!! He talking about himself in third person
I am sorry but anyone that could brutally murder family members and others does not have empathy. His tears and performance is outstanding--but don't be fooled. He's a wolf in sheep clothing.
He's crying for himself. I'd cry to ,if I was headed to prison the rest of my life
Aborting a baby is a brutal murder of a family member….but I don’t see any outrage in America over those brutal murders. Twisted how people get all emotionally invested in a case like this though…while being just fine with baby murder.
@@FerallHog your point has zero relevance to this case. I guarantee lots of people that loved Paul and Maggie and want justice for them are also fully against abortion, given the geopolitical atmosphere of SC. Your comment disrespectfully undermines the value and weight of the 22 + 53 years that Paul and Maggie respectively spent living, breathing, thinking and feeling things on this earth. If time is money, their years of living holds much more value than never truly living. If justice for one is justice for all, why are you here?
@@ellenresinger1934 my point has every relevance…and you know it. People all crying and up in arms for the wife and son…many of those same people rabidly support murdering innocent babies. If you can’t understand the extreme hypocrisy and blind spot, then you need help.
@@ellenresinger1934 I assume you are Pro Aborting innocent children, Ellen. Yet you opine and virtue signal for young Paul. How evil.
Guilty people always seem to surround their crime event with real facts to make themselves feel better. It’s also so interesting how he gets choked up at the right times but recovers within seconds.
The first questions asking did he kill them he nods his head as in yes but says no. Body language didn't lie there
@@bassface8580totally agree and if u have watched a clip from busters interview (not the trial video but outside interview) when he is asked questions he does the same thing nods his head yes and then denies everything.
@@MeechNChongX slimy bastards the lot of them. Alex is the worst and deserves the rest of his life rotting in jail. A Master Liar and manipulater. He never shed one tear for murdering his wife and kid. What does that say about the mind of this psycho. He tried to cry at the scene and interrogation but he knew what happened. He did it. This is an act and a good one. He seems at first glance to be a sweet old man who loved his family and they were taken from him but no.. he did it make no mistake
@@MeechNChongX Alex did the same thing at the final SLED interview when asked if he killed Maggie & then if he killed Paul. Alex denies it, but his head nods in a yes gesture. The footage is a bit grainy, but you can still see his movements just fine.
I thought this was supposed to be a short story of what you did on a particilar day. Instead we are hearing about dogs peeing on trees. Gosh he is just so down to earth! That is what he wants us to think. Gosh. I am just a simple good old boy...
I think it is interesting how he took the time to spend time with his son and do some of those precious memory making things, knowing that he was going to be ending his life within a few hours. I think it was just an alibi rather than actually special father-son time. It's nice that Paul got to feel like his dad was wanting to spend time with him, but I know that all of that faded away the moment that he realize that his dad had not only shot him, but shot him intentionally and was coming back for more to make sure the job got done. How absolutely horrific that last moment of his life was.
So damn sad!
Alex is a monster
What the judge said about Alex seeing them in his dreams and around every corner I hope is true!
He needs to be haunted by them the rest of his life!
This is what gets me the most. How could someone be this demonic and evil? His son was laughing with his dad, playing around with the dogs literally minutes before. I just can’t imagine or believe how horribly depraved a human being has to be to go through with something like this 😢
@@anavrodriguez2502 i didnt followed all this but why you guys think it was planed? I think something escalated
@@rooibosvanille862 no, it was definitely planned.
💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔💔
I believe he was exaggerating his show of grief. Most people become quietly emotional without scrounging their faces in a bizarre show.
Yes! He seemed to be hamming it up.
Kinda like Amber was with Johnny
Couldn’t agree more. The head bobbing & rocking back & forth, the lip smacking & alligator tears, all BS. He’s a horrible actor & has been caught lying more than a few times so far and the Stuff he blames on his addiction is total BS
I'm not convinced he did it. I think he was involved but I'm not convinced he did the deed. That friend of Paul says on that Netflix thing that Alex wasn't even there for Gloria's "fall" I kinda wonder if he did any of the acts or if he just helped cover it up. I don't trust any of em including buster.
Like someone named Heard? Her dog got stung by a bee you know.
The fact that he keeps his dogs locked in kennels tells me all I need to know about him
To be fair they were hunting dogs, not really household family pets, most people do keep their hunting dogs outside in big kennels most of the time and from what they showed on the Netflix doc it was just a big fenced in horse stable p much, plenty of room and shelter for them to be comfortable
They’re hunting dongs. Not family pets.
@@samsnothavingit2788 not comfortable. Heartless, concrete floor.. ugly as hell. Hunting dogs don’t like such cruel place either.
@@laurensvibe8464 AHA, ok..that’s why them deserve a cold, ugly, and heartless home ? Hunting dogs ? What poor accusation
Exactly!! Dogs are dogs whether they hunt or not; they are pack animals. They yearn to be w a pack or family. It’s cruel to separate them into little isolation cells, just cruel!
he can never just answer the question directly. he has to give the back story and full explanation for his answer. Just answer the question!
A sure sign that he is lying. It’s disgusting.
My dad does this!!! 😂😂 it’s infuriating
@@heartmountain1696 no not necessarily my dad does this and he’s not a liar or a nasty man
Gives him time to lie
I see No tears & lying comes as natural as breathing to this man smh 🤦🏻♀️. Hope the jury comes to the right verdict
You don't see the tears and snot dripping from his face? Not stating any opinion just commenting on what I saw.
I agree, hopefully they follow the judge's instructions closely, obey the letter of the law, and acquit.
Crying because he usbscared sh"^less
@@genekirby8568 I was thinking the same thing after reading that lol…nobody that has eyes can deny his many tears and snot…js
@@athenaabell4336 It's called Method Acting. Many Hollywood actors and on Broadway too have learned the technique and ppl pay money to see them perform. Have u ever had an addict in your life ?
Lying is very easy for them and even the most cynical find them believable.
Until everything is lost to them and still !!!!!.....Your love and hope aches for them to be telling you truths.
Alex still has a strong obcession for opioids and if freed he will be in the gutter within days. But hey maybe he won't take anyone with him. But he will. I hope u never find out the hard way. It's a journey many families never recover from.
He recovers after pretend crying the quickest ive ever seen anyone! Lol good acting performance
Weirdest thing to me is when he’s talking about turning over Paul and seeing his brains and all that….he’s “crying” with absolutely no tears then 15 seconds later he’s back to normal again lol
He trying hold back he's tears even Maggie sister did the same thing ,he's brother did same thing buster didn't cry at all
This man lied about taking the last cookie as a kid and never stopped! It’s sad how many people his lies have hurt
It’s so crazy to me that in any of these murder cases the guilty never asked who did it.. if I was being falsely accused of murder Id want to know who killed my wife and kid and why they weren’t looking for the actual murderer not once do they ever inquire
If you were being falsely accused, wouldn't it be obvious to you that law enforcement doesn't know who really did it? So why would you ask?
Well first they are raking him over the coals not even trying to find anyone else who had done this horror.. that's what sucks about cops tunnel vision. Just see one way
@Y15..Most overlook this..very telling....
@@commercialaccount9501
Because almost instinctively we want answers..we want to help and be helpful..
It's one if your forever loves..
Sounds like TRUTH is important for all...mmho
Ding ding ding!
Having been convinced that this ruthless man had took the lives of his own child and wife i cant stop thinking how it would be impossible for him to have any feelings for the living son. Yet when his son is on the stand he looks at him with so much pride and love in which the son seems astonishingly sharp and educated. I think its all an act to win jury votes. My heart goes mostly to the living son that lost his mom and brother and now is left with this mess publicly trying to make a sense of it all.
His living son also seems to have no real empathy like his dad
That s because Butthead needs canteen money to bribe the prisoners. Needs Carrot top for his toppings.
SO SORRY IF .Y WRITING NOT GOOD CUZ I CANT HARDLY SEE I HOPE U UNDERSTAND MY SITUITION PLEASE TRY TO BE KIND
I think that particular son worships him, kisses ass, does any and everything he expects of him and more which is why he adores that son and spared his life! It's more so he loves how that son looks up to him and is just like him. I think Paul was a momma boy and busted his balls, highlighted his imperfections and was a torn on his side! The wife of course doted on the baby and showered him with attention most likely since he was born which was an animosity dick probably varied since then! Add naturally growing apart or losing interest in each other over the years is why he so callously killed both of them if he did it! A hatred or disdain for the two that grew
The very noticeable smiling at his son made me sick -to me, it was very obviously for the jury’s benefit. I believe Marian Proctor -Maggie’s sister believes he’s guilty. I feel so sorry for her. She couldn’t understand why Alex wasn’t putting resources-not least time and energy into finding Maggie and Paul’s killer, nor did he seem too anxious about Busters safety. Just another of several reasons I believe he is guilty.
That part where he’s answering no but his head is saying yes ! goosebumps
Exactly! ❤
@@HopefulInterventions what time was that at? i'd like to go watch it again.
The part in the trial when he first heard the kennel recording, nodding his head yes.. and just how he acted during that part.. and him turning from ghost white to beer red told me all I needed to know right then and there. Made me sick to my stomach
Already building his defense at the crime scene, odd behavior for just finding your son and wife murdered
EXACTLY
I think I would be so hysterical, I may do and act all kinds of crazy ways though.
I'm not saying he is innocent, but he is an attorney.
When a family pronounces Murdaugh as Murdock and Alex as Alec, I don't trust any of em.
😂
Also some of these folks were saying " Murdick" weird 🤦 Alec ,Alex ,Alick 🤦
Murdock is the correct pronunciation.
@@marshadavies8440 the correct pronunciation is " Murr- - Daa "
@@Snail.1 stupidly childish
It’s amazing how much he learned from the records
He was under the influence...it changes what you remember and how you behave
@@criteria9514 he’s had time to prepare for this, even if doesn’t remember everything, than at least have your answers prepared. He must have had to remember how to win millions of dollars for clients and how to steal from them. You can’t have selective memory
@@criteria9514 No excuse for murder though. I could drink until the room spun and i would still know atleast something of the night.
@@DeepCurve300 lol he does know something of the night, he just isn't recalling specific details
A heavy opiod addiction coupled with a culture of lying due to his career and covering up his addiction for DECADES most definitely gives him some plausible deniability
The sheriff's came up on him alex had a shotgun they saw dead bodies brains splattered n they never put handcuffs on him wow amazing low country at it's fineness
When your last name sounds like Murder..
😂😂😂😂😂 RIGHT! My thoughts exactly
Alex (Big Redd) Murdawg is his prison name now
@@G274Me haha
Names present interesting ironies sometimes, don't they: Bernie Madoff (made off) with millions.
You are too funny
Oh sure, he was at the kennels just minutes before his family was slaughtered but didn't see a thing, and the killers got lucky waiting in the woods to ambush Maggie and Paul with the family's own guns, then toss the lady's phone on the roadside right where Alex is driving by, the killers were geniuses.
He also didn't hear anything - aren't gun shots loud?
Done forget the dogs were also running loose and would've come to "deal with it" if a stranger had been killing M & P - also, who put the dogs back into the kennels?
Two 5’2 inch killers no less….junior ninjas on the loose? Maybe the same ones from the Jodi Arias Case?
if he was there- it should have been easy to prove, the problem is no one actually searched. How can you sentence someone to murder when law enforcement couldn't be bothered to search this man's house? Nothing was done. No search of his mothers. No concrete evidence found-nothing
@@sonia354 or it was the Black man. 😂 Just a lil humor.
I love how he tries to act like he's trying to hold back from crying but he's really trying to think of how he should lie to sound believable
I know right! You notice how he replaced crying with this slow talking, lip smacking?? He makes me sick to my stomach in every way. And i guarantee you there will be one dim wit juror who will say "There is no way he would hurt a hair on sweet little Paw paws head" and not that he blew that little dudes brain right out is what he's really thinking. I believe he gave Paul a death sentence for Mallory and not for her but for ruining his life cause it was crumbling. And he didn't want to have to split half of whatever hidden money she knows he has put away or she would obviously know how good he was doing financially if they got a divorce.
@@cwatson42785 If I was given a dollar for each time he said the word "Paw Paw..." I'd never have to work again!
@@cwatson42785 he's so pathetic!!! Sickening narcissistic lying murderer! He better not get no dim wit and get a mistrial!
desgrgrghrd
It's pitiful. Terrible acted.
I see some chilling facial expressions when he forgets to act! The energy off him is dark and he’s coming across as fake, yet doing a good job of lying
Yes....im thinking he could be the next anti-Christ!!!! He is scary AF. Its so sickening how he even stole from all of the deceased and injured people and their loved ones much less covering up your kids murders or murdering your wife and child.
He's not doing a good job of lying he's a POS
Excellent points
hes so DARK! Alex used Hookers and at least one, LINDSAY EDWARDS has come forward that he beat and choked her almost to death! watch her interview on youtube ua-cam.com/video/XYQH7rmgZCQ/v-deo.html
💯
Paul's video solved the case and proved Alex was there. RIP Paul and Maggie.
I have no dog in this fight nor will I express an opinion as to this man's guilt or innocence , but as an attorney, what I will say is that the difficult thing about this case for the defense side is that even if Murdaugh is completely innocent of murder, good luck getting a jury to see past his life of lying and deception. Most people will immediately import guilt for one crime strictly based on character evidence, which is why the laws of evidence were crafted specifically to avoid the admission of evidence that might be overly prejudicial to the defendant. Just peruse the comments below and look how many people easily import guilt for murder based on lying in other matters. No one will comprehend this until they find themselves in a situation where people are brutally scrutinizing your life and will appropriate your guilt or innocence based on what they think of you as person. I can't tell you how many clients I've had who made some bad choices in their life but were NOT guilty of the crime they were currently charged and we had to work hard to keep the info out of court that we thought was irrelevant. Human beings will always judge you by the lowest common denominator of your life, which is why you must avoid ever putting yourself in a situation where other human beings will sit in judgment of you with your life in their hands.
Wrong! He lied about being at the kennels with Maggie and Paul. He tried to bribe his mom's care giver to buy himself a solid alibi. He tried to get his housekeeper to say she saw his clothes he wore in Paul's snap chat video. He lied saying he left work at around 5pm v after 6pm to fit his 'couple' hours messing around with Paul at the hunting lodge and claims he can't remember if they met Maggie at the shed or at the house. Come on, man! There's nothing 'innocent' about Alex MURDAugh! Alex is the one who claimed he had a 'wonderful' relationship with his wife whilst abusing opioids for 20 years. She never got over his affair because he didn't change his practice of lying and MANipulating others to get what he want$ and she would never forgive him for embezzling millions$ to feed his addiction$ to $, drugs and po$$e$$ion$. She told her confidant that she would give up everything for all of *IT* to go away and she didn't want to be with him at the hunting lodge but he sister talked her into it as Alex needed her as he just found out his father was terminal and back in the hospital. His father died 2 days after the murders. His mother has end stage Alzheimer's so she has no clue.
Totally correct. His lying didnt help either. Im surprised the defense didnt express just what you expressed. Ive yet to see defenses closing arguments so Im not sure if that was expressed to the jury. Also getting him to testify clearly was a blunder..
@@guywebster8018 I think the defense was hoping Alex's testimony was going to be their Hail Mary! lol 1 juror said he blow snot but didn't shed 1 tear was shed and the Jury was face to face with him. I'm glad he took the stand as now I know how he was ABEL to hoodwink so many people into trusting him. He's TALL and Gregarious > a people person and people like him > a good ole southern boy born and raised in the low country > A man's MAN who know's how to get'r done! who turned out to be a snake in the grASS due to his LUST for $, po$ITion, po$$e$$ion$ and Drug$ so let HIS 'case' be a lesSON for all GREEdy white meN to follow the 10 COMMANDmentS and you too are GOoD
@@deborahhershey3045 lool its not just greedy white men, all greedy people fullstop.im sick of the discrimination against white men, just be quite if u cant say something constructive. And btw, wot white men u talking bout mediterrean white, anglo white, roman white???its just ridiculous.
✔️✔️✔️✔️✔️✔️✔️✔️✔️✔️💯
This testimony is so damming. He controls his emotions so well. He is also super hung up on tiny meaningless details.
I feel like those tiny details were given purposely to confuse people. He'll give long drawn out needless filler info til you forgot what detail you were looking for or even the question you asked.
they say the signs of a lie is too much detail
He rambles on about irrelevant details to avoid giving the prosecutor more time to ask hard questions.
He can stop repeating that PREPARED speech about him stealing money from his Clients. Oh my God so gulty. Yes Maggie had a sense about this so called husband. RIP MAGGIE AND PAUL. PEACE AT LAST. 4/28/23.
The way that he answers no yet continuously shakes his head yes everytime
he was so close to them Buster didnt even know his dads birthday.
Buster is guilty as heck
@@elainecameron4024 I so agree - he has shown no sorrow in court, just smirking all the time! I see no empathy in him at all!
Lol many people dk their families bdays that means nothing
@@elainecameron4024 guilty of what? That’s not being sarcastic, I’m sincerely asking. 😄 I haven’t watched all of the videos, I’ve watched out of order and haven’t seen his son’s testimony yet.
Buster needs to be the next one on trial for what he did to that boy.
When he denies shooting Maggie and Paul, aka Mags and Papa, he shakes his head yes while saying no.
Omggggg I saw it!!!!!!
Wow
He doesn't actually deny shooting them, but instead says, "I would never do anything to intentionally hurt them." It's a type of minimalization that is pretty normal for someone lying.
@@brendakauffman2222 I agree. When someone says “I would never, blah blah blah“, what they’re really saying is “this is what you are to believe of me.“.
and notice he said he would never INTENTIONALLY hurt Mags or Pau Pau.. Him calling his son that pet name literally made me throw up... He was so guilty, even a deaf blind person could tell.
Why would anyone lie about anything if they are innocent, especially after something so horrific like this. An innocent person would be in complete shock. I feel like Buster is emotionless, like he is not surprised on some level. It’s strange. He is also not looking the lawyer in the eye continuously.
Is buster is other son.? If so, he said he believes his dad is innocent.
If you just listen. You can hear in his voice that he’s getting nervous. And tells these long winded stories to feel comfortable
He said he would never “intentionally” hurt his family???
Exactly and he also said he wasn't in his right frame of mind and that he wasn't thinking clearly. Then he says he's sorry to Maggie and Paul!
I caught that too!!!
@@denjack2542 I was thinking the same thing. Sounded like a hidden admission of something. 😢
Yeah..🤐🫣
If someone is threatening your dearly son over and over, the first thing any parent will do is to make sure there is surveillance cameras around the house and dash cams in the cars. The fact he didn’t do any of this indicate that this guy has so many secrets and glad he got caught.
How about when the police show up you say "My mom is alone down the road get police there, and my son is in Charlotte. Someone is trying to kill us! Set up a roadblock" No didn't cross his mind because he was working his alibi from the very start.
@@ThenVersusNow_ Hope Alex knows drop and roll won't put the fire out where he's headed. He will never admit he premeditated their cold blooded murder. There will be less mercy shown him than he showed his family. And he did it for greed. Just greed !!!
Pathetic.
Good point , lack of cctv etc means you have stuff to hide .
@@juliecrane9647
Problem is hes keeping busy by helping everyone in jail.
He wants to be everyone friend .
He deserves to be isolated, not amongst people, to take his mind
..off the fact hes a family murderer.
@@ThenVersusNow_
Exactly ...agree with you 💯
"Tell us about your relationship with Maggie." He proceeds to describe her as a person. Not responsive. Pure deception.
“A girl”
Listening to this again ..my goodness..he talked and talked and talked. .same way he thought he thought apologising over and over for his misdeeds would clear him! So sickening
You are right he is a liar!!!
Yep and everyone was criticizing the DA for letting him ramble and ramble but it absolutely was the right thing because he buried himself!
I have been trying to figure out the eyes...sharks wow
He did it for YEARS and to the tune of millions of dollars stolen. If he ever contemplated feeling sorry, he would have stopped long ago and counted his blessing he got away with what he did. That never happened. What did happen was he got caught and for THAT he is sorry. Of that, I'm quite sure. You can't tell me he spent millions on primarily on pills and lived to tell the tale. That's just the cover story to hope the court will take some mercy on his addiction issue. Obviously, there was a lot more then a pill problem going on in that family.
I can't believe they let him keep explaining all these thing's
Yep distractions.
Bc he tells on himself
Lawyer buddies...🤥
I know, I was brutally sexually assaulted and as the VICTIM ont he stand I was NOT allowed to say more than ONE sentence at a time- I was cut off while speaking, cut off while crying in agony, but this heinous murderer is allowed to go on and on and on....
Right! I’m like why are they letting him say so much when all they ask is simple questions.
His “CRYING” didn’t move me . Matter of fact … it only made me more convinced he was guilty because he’s switch from sad to being fine within two secs. Crazy how emotions can change .
The same way he was devastated at Moselle that night and then turned and said, "Hi, how are ya?" to the LEO.
@@thenightporterOh my goodness yes, that was chilling! One of those things I keep going back to because I almost couldn't believe he said that, like an afternoon exchange with a neighbor while taking out the trash cans except Alex was standing feet away from his murdered wife and son....so strange.
@@thenightporterhis “devastated” mask slipped in that moment back to the normal day to day mask he wears. He fakes all human emotions and protocols. He mimics what he thinks he should do. There are so many ppl like him walking among us too. Quite scary.
Yes exactly! That stopped me dead in my tracks I had to rewind it over and over. So CHILLING
@@thenightporterI believe he's definitely involved in their deaths. But I'll give him the fact that "How ya doing?" is just the "proper" Southern thing to do, even near the dead or dying. It's just our way because we're taught from the time we start talking to acknowledge & "speak" to everyone when we have to interact with them, it's the polite & respectful thing to do 🤷🏻♀️
All these threats Paul supposedly got on social media, in bars, etc. and he *still* doesn’t go into detail of what these threats actually were. Why so vague?
Social media??? He should have the proof,,,or a couple of witnesses but, no. He’s a lawyer with a badge..he should’ve sent the person a certified letter threatening to sue them for harassing paupa 😉👍🏻
Don’t you think they should examine Paul’s cell and social media ? Especially leading up to the murder date. No mention of this at all. Investigation is faulty and not complete for sure.
@@susietapliner Yeah, you'd think there would've been a thorough investigation of Paul's social media activities. Or, maybe there was, and there wasn't much to say about it. 🤔
Paul has always been threatened and assaulted online and in public. That's well known especially online.
Did you now Paul? I need too start at the beginning of the trail. Do you think he killed his wife and son. I leave in Norway. I have read about these case many times in our Norwegian newspapers. Please excuse me spelling I did only learn the most important words and grammar. I use google if I don’t understand some words. Have a wonderful day from Hilde in Norway. It’s middle of the night in Norway now.
Listening to his testimony over again, he didn't arrive at his office til around noon on June 7th. Paul was at work and Maggie had left for medical appointments. He had all morning to plant guns and a change of clothing at the shed or kennel area! Thank God the jurors didn't fall for his pathetic performance!
in closing the prosecutor said he was not at work until 5 pm
@@kellymcginnis8631 He tried to say he left work early, around 5. A coworker said he was there after 6pm. There's no end to the lies. Thank God the jury put him into the dust bin of bad trash!
He is not a very convincing actor. Very poor performance.
@@carolynpatty3711 Agreed Not a good father and husband either. Unlike many people with crippling addiction, he had the means to get help. He could have literally saved his life. His greed got him life in prison.🖐
I find it interesting how different courts are. This court allows witnesses to explain and pretty much say whatever they want as long as it very loosely pertains to the question. Some courts want very short and to the point answers. I wonder if this has to do with the culture of the district or if it's more about the judge's preferences and what he/she will allow.
There's a lot of interesting things about this court. They probably aren't used to cases like this. Everybody and everything ill equipped. I hope he doesn't get away because of these inadequacies
Yes it’s fascinating to me as a Brit watching the trial and proceedings in the court- I like that they are loquacious in the south- the Judge is lovely- can’t imagine saying that about one of ours …
i think the more details shared by AM can help with any inconsistencies if he is lying. it also allows AM to ramble on about really small details and read into how he responds to different questions.
Attorneys being questioned by attorneys, arguing with prosecution attorney..sounds like great grounds for the judge to let them go do it. It didn’t happened to any public witness
I have thought the same. My father was murdered and consequently, I've been through a murder trial. I've never seen witnesses give so much personal history at the beginning of their testimony (although, I certainly see why it is done, here), and be allowed to give so many details - almost like a real conversation rather than question/answer.
What a horrible, terrible liar .🤢🤮
He said he turned paul over by his belt loop which is odd considering he saw his brains on the ground, most people would not want to move a body in case you might make it worse.
Yanked his belt loop so hard to turn him over that his phone “popped out”
I’m sure in a situation like that you’re not thinking properly enough to think “ohh I better not move or touch anything”
I honestly think most ppl would be vomiting in absolute shock at the sight of their sons brains at his feet and just his face left. Think about how utterly gruesome that sight was? 🙈
If I found my son like he supposedly found his boy I'd be on my knees and I would roll him over the best I could and I'd be cradling him in my arms rocking and screaming for my baby. To lift his supposed loved son by his belt loop shows you how little this poor excuse for a father loved his son. I remember holding my Dad when my little brother passed at 3months of age and I was nearly 5. I'm 64 now and I can still see my Dad with his head on my chest weeping for his son. It's something you never forget. This father lifted him by his belt loop...disgusting
@@kimrayner4660 it must have been such a blessing to have such a kind of father! And Kim I feel for you as you were such a little girl. I don't know, if I'd find my son murdered I'd probably want to preserve as much evidence as possible. Believe me I love my son very much, but I had a very very different upbringing than you, so for me cuddling is not such a need like for the most people. I would have the feeling my son wouldn't need it in this moment anymore. I could be wrong. I hope we won't experience something like this
This is what doesn’t make sense to me. So they live on a big property, someone supposedly comes onto the property, apprehends Paul’s guns, kills 2 people, then disappears. Alex finds them less than an hour later, maybe even sooner, and when he calls 911 he seems unconcerned that someone is still in the area. He did get a gun to kind of show he was scared, but if his property was truly trespassed by someone, he would be freaking out trying figure out where that someone is. There is no evidence of a car having come or gone from the property. Any alternative hypothesis other than Alex doesn’t make sense.
You and me both..
It's the case of the missing perpetrator. Never is he worried about finding the people who killed his family. Never.
That's a Big 10-4 right here ! Old buddy I have been thinking the same things. I'm from the South. We work hard to have alot of land here in the South and I can tell you of it was me..... I wouldn't have been able to have jumped and rolled fast enough to where the artillery would be found. That's all I know about my thought on how he reacted in the scene unfold so quickly. I'd had a couple of ARs and a 338 for sure. Lol but to each their own.
@@TeaSpiracyI’m also a fan of the behavior panel.
Or going back to their house without police with him. No fear about that.
He would have their blood on his shoes knees, hands legs and white t shirt.
❌ He is causing me STRESS - talking so much and saying absolutely nothing at all. He never URGED the cops to find the killers, nor to protect his other son, because all along he knew, that the killer was himself... ❌
And he stated, "Whoever killed Paul hated him and had been thinking about this a long time." How would he know that unless he did it?
"Did you shoot your wife?"
"No, I did not!" *Nodding vigorously*
I noticed that
i’m glad someone else noticed this too. such conflicting body language.
He nods his head a lot during all kinds of testimony. So, for him, this doesn't seem to be a subconscious "tell", but rather a nervous habit.
He’s a highly experienced lawyer, how could he make such a blatant rookie mistake? The only explanation is that he did it.
Such a liar what an evil selfish person
Truest words he said was "on June 7th I wasn't thinking clearly..... i dont think i was capable of reason"
THE CONFESSION AND APPOLOGY
The problem with his lying is the exact same with most people who commit a crime and try to lie about it. He is lying about something that he would have had no reason to lie about unless he was involved in killing them. If I were in his place I would have been saying from the 911 call on that I had just been there with them before going to my mom's! He lied from the beginning and wants the jury to believe he just did that spontaneously due to paranoia. Another example if this is the Natalie Holloway case. When her mom went to man who killed her home he came to the door and lied about leaving her at her hotel. If he was innocent he would not have a reason to have lied. Same exact thing here.
Great point about the 911 call!
Exactly! ❤
He is so detailed about his poor little struggling fruit tree & nice family tailgating memories but he can not tell you what he talked about the last time he saw Paul and Maggie. He cannot tell you his last words to Paul or Maggie. He cannot not tell you what he did back at the house after the murders when he likely was cleaning up before turning on his phone. For the appeal the state needs to trace his steps per this description and analyze the golf cart which may have blood evidence. He killed for the love of his pills, M&P were watching him having sent the email a month earlier. He no doubt planned to make a liability case against his own commercial liability carrier on the hunting lodge, much like Gloria"s case. It is about the money, hiding past crimes, fraudulent insurance proceeds, etc...The BS he tells as he yaps away at nothing to show what a great family man he WAS with cutesy nicknames. Family Annihilator is an apt term.
Diane H Well said. I hadn’t thought about him suing over the deaths! That makes perfect sense given his way of operating. That would have been a major cash cow for him - maybe getting him out of whatever jam he was in financially (that kept bleeding him dry).
It had all caught up to him to the point that he couldn’t even cobble together $800K to get Jeanie off his back in-time. That means even his father and his other legal partner wouldn’t even give it to him. That’s huge. His father apparently bailed him out of everything - like Trump’s father did for him so many times.
His insurance would cover accidents not murder. lol He prolly planned on suing the media for causing 2 somebody's to hate Paul so much as to gun him down and his mom was a witness and the one who spared the rod to spoiled him rotten so she too was shot dead. Too bad his couSIN Eddie didn't keep his mouth shut. How much did Alex pay him and expect him to take the fall if caught? 1.2 million? Alex would have gotten him a 'deal' from his part time prosecutor's office for his loyalty to the Family of MURDAugh
Cutesy nicknames and nothing but glorious tales of father and son bonding experiences all day long, as they happily skipped along holding hands through the meadow with great huge smiles on their faces saying “I love you Paw Paw!” And Paw Paw says “I love you too Dad!”
Big fat liar….
And he never wondered or suspected who killed Maggie and Paul, never acted outraged that they'd been killed.
Great comment 👍👌👏
Why does he just sit there nodding like a dang bobblehead!?!?! nodding while denying he killed them. Sickening
The question isn't "why did you lie." My question is why didn't AM or anyone on the defense team remember AM lied to the first officer on the murder scene, nullifying his paranoid excuse?
Interesting angle
I agree, a person finding their murdered wife and child would be in shock. You’d hardly be able to talk never mind formulate lies. Your brain just wouldn’t be able to do that while trying to comprehend something incomprehensible.
AM didn't show any type of paranoia, so his statement that he was paranoid just doesn't hold up. Plus paranoia has symptoms and none of his law partners, clients or family testify to paranoia. He sights it, when it's convenient, as I believe he claimed drug addition with high usage because it was convenient and made others have more sympathy for him.
He may have used opiates at times, but I don't think he was an addict for years taking the amount he claimed because he would have died if he was, and he wouldn't have been able to pull off elaborate money laundering schemes covering lies with lies.
Those annoying nicknames. OMG.Funny how we never heard them during the 911 call, police interrogations, police bodycams, or jailhouse calls. If he thought he was endearing himself with the jury, he thought wrong. They saw right thru him.
I felt like I needed a translator, trying to listen to him talk.
To me it seems he was acting in desperation, but he had thought about doing this for some time, planning it for years. That's why he set up strange stalker situations that are quite bizarre. He was never attacked by anyone other than himself or someone he hired to take part. His final act was to set up a double homicide to make it appear that the imaginary stalkers shot the two of them. Doesn't make sense that he was home and in the kennel yet he was unharmed?? Right. The very day he is about to be confronted, 1: His dad is dying. Then 2: His wife and son are murdered. Both extreme pity and sympathy plays. The double murders are a perfect distraction for his embezzlement crime! I hope it was worth it, Alex!!!! IDIOT.
DEATH PENALTY - how can ANYONE blow a wife's brains out AND ruthlessly murder a SON????? HEINOUS SICK EVIL CALCULATED CRIMES!
@@larrywakeman4371 Seeking the death penalty would have made Alex’s conviction LESS LIKELY. Also, it was a strategic choice by the prosecution. A capital charge would have allowed the defense team to voir dire the jurors. That’s how trial selection works in Alex’s lowcountry area.
Cunning as it appears…part of a deep pathology that gives us insight into the psyche of a very ill person indeed.
It is important that the public sees these cases, to understand wickedness that occurs in humans sadly. Every second this individual continues opening his mouth it’s fantastic lies build inside his mind for a very- very long time, considering the circumstances. Wow. Mentally disordered to a point of total delusion. I don’t think drugs alone can explain this. At all.
@@doreenplischke2169 not I’ll
Evil he knew it was all wrong
If he was truly that I’ll he would not lie to cover his tracks
He was not in temporary psychosis. He’s learned to lie cheat steal and kill to get his way
These aren’t the first of his victims by any means
Lying is second nature to Alex. You can' t believe anything he says.
Hearing him speak at the end about his son Paul was truly troubling. You can speak those words about him,but you took his life away. Yes he was a mean drunk but look at the role model for a father.
Paul might have known what his father was and wanted to protect his mother from this monster
He's sorry his lies don't hold up. Period. He's as sick as his secrets.
I believe he's sorry he got caught and may have to actually serve a sentence.
The defense should pay a dollar for every “umm” to pay back the clients since they didn’t earn their 600k. This should be a law school course on what not to do when allowing the accused to take the stand.
Just curious how many likes did you get total with this videos comments:D kinda funny seeing you over and over again haha
So much lip smacking and whatever he keeps doing with his tongue, put it at .5 speed it’s even funnier 😂
Lmao!!! 😂😂🤣
It's from the anti psychotic meds he's on- my brother in law does the same thing and he's on bipolar meds..
Omg, thank you, this is hilarious 😂
He never expresses hatred and anger for being accused of this horrendous. Evil act! And pleading for them to please find the people or person that killed them!!
I mean neither did my uncle & he was exonerated with DNA evidence after 17yrs in prison. I’m not saying he’s guilty or innocent, just offering another perspective. Attorneys will advise against “outbursts” & judges will order there be none as well. It’s hard to know what you’d do in this situation whether you were guilty or innocent. I’d like to think I’d lose my ever loving mind, but again, my uncle thought so too but when the time came, he did not.
Agree, don’t believe he did it!
@@Marie-rp9nt Explain the video
He put a time limit on the reward for any info leading to his wife and son's murder ....who does that?
@@deborahhershey3045 Someone who loves his money more than his family! And probably scared someone would work hard to earn that reward!
The most DISGUSTING part of this horrific crime is that this 😈 thought he was SO Smart & Clever that he would get away with 🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️ murdering his son & wife....They ALWAYS think they're smarter than anyone else! Hence very DANGEROUS
The most deranged man on the planet.
When the verdict was read, there was a sigh of relief from the many that have been hurt by this man. RIP Miss Maggie and Paul. Alex is where he belongs, in prison labeled a liar, thief and murderer.
Yep
Absolutely 💯💯💯
thankfully they will not treat him well inside
So crazy how he’s nodding yes to every No answer he gives.
Proves he’s lying
This is how it happened: Alec knew he was about to be found out about his financial crimes. On top of that, he was being pressured on the boat case. He figured as a last resort, with Paul gone he might solve that problem. Only for him to realize that Maggie would know he killed him, so she would have to be killed too.
Or perhaps he killed both of them because he didn't want to have his wife and son go through the embarrassment of him getting fired due to stealing.... or that he was on opioids for the past 20 years... or that he was unable to protect his son from the repercussions of the boating accident. And, if he could convince everyone that he was innocent, he would be able to collect the death benefits of his wife and child AND his father and possibly return all the money he had embezzled. Oh wait... he would NEVER do that!! Instead, he would leave South Carolina and try to find a new life in a new place where no one know of this!! What a greedy, self-centered POS!!!
So why keep the other son alive?
@@commercialaccount9501 He was at school or else he may have also met the same fate. Allegedly, there was a time where Alex called Buster to come home unexpectedly weeks prior to and asked him to go Deer hunting. Buster had other plans and said No. Ya never know...Alex could have wanted to unalive him then.
@@Ursweetplace - what’s with this god-awful word ‘unalive”?!?! It sounds so illiterate. DEAD or KILL - are the correct words.
@@Countess88 Actually unalive is the word now being used on UA-cam with content creators because they have begun striking channels with those words you used in titles and comments.
Hard not to consider that the lying and thieving that has dominated his whole adult life properly characterizes him as a career criminal, with an absolute lack of integrity. How could anyone believe anything he says? If his addiction is so bad, could he kill to protect it?
He sure is a liar - but lying does not automatically make you a murderer as well.
@@nimmischueller1528 depends what lies you tell
I do not believe he has an addiction. If a person took 75 to 125 tabs a day such as he said he dïd. It is a great cover story.
@@shawnasabino7958how could a lawyer or a father function with those many tabs?
He’s a pretty good actor. 😮
AM putting himself on the golf cart put him at a 5ft 2" or so height. Who put the dogs back into their kennels if both Maggie and Paul had been shot shortly after AM left the kennels? It's hard to believe an intruder would have put Grady & Bubba back into their kennels after shooting Maggie & Paul. It's more plausible that that person would leave as quickly as possible, as the dogs may not be familiar with them, and may have been aggressive towards an intruder... correct?
what is missing
what is making this all so wierd
he thinks no blood equals innocence
that fool should have covered himself with their blood
he should have gotten his knees dirty with grass stains and dirt
he would have been so distraught at the nightmare he walked into
the coos would have had to restrain him
he would have needed sedation
if he used the golf cart earlier
then why go in the house
see them still not there
and then use the truck to go back to the kennel
golf carts are much more casual and easy on a vast property
it all stinks because he is a complete moron
Good point? Wouldn’t the dogs have attacked?
Great point that
Some dogs will attack, some will just bark, some will whimper and run, some will on their own go into their kernel quietly. Did these dogs assist with hunting or go out hunting with them because I know some dogs are afraid of loud noises like gun fire but they might have been used to it. But s stranger handling a gun that just harmed their owners may cause them to retreat instead of attack!
The dogs were barking like crazy after the murders. You can hear them. Barking like they were from my experience with dogs they would have raced out of that cage and chased down any intruder. They were dying to get out and chase.
The more this malignant narcissist says paw-paw, the more I want him to NEVER get out of prison. Sorry Alex, your paw-paw defence just couldn't cut it.
The weird zombie like rocking back and forth, the lip smacking, the snot dripping...ugh! Guilty!
😂😂😂
In discussing this with my sister, she pointed out that they got him becasue of the video that his son Paul took at the Kennels; It proved that Alex was there. My God, the way they failed to process that murder scene properly, if they didn't have that video, he probably would have gotten off, who knows?
Yep that's why he left his phone at the house to make the investigators believe he was napping and not at the kennels planning the right time to ambush his son and hunt down his wife as she tried to flee. He hosed himself off, took his clothes off went back to house to shower and change clothes. Gathered up his clothes, rifles and Maggie's phone and ditched them on the way to his mom's for his alibi to be complete. He tried to get his mom's care provider to lie for him and he would pay for her wedding and get her a cushy job and she only had to say he was there twice as long as he was. 21 minutes to his mom's + 16 minutes back = 37 minutes + 40 min visit = 77 minutes + time to check the bodies and take their pulses would put him away from the property before Paul's last text message ... tells me he waited as long as he could before he killed his wife and son.
@@deborahhershey3045Wow, I missed the offer to pay for her wedding. He is a diabolical fiend without remorse!
Not really. He says they were all there, he left, took quick nap, went to his moms. Saw his mom (witness) and came back to find his family. You have to listen!
I don't even think they found the gun
That's SLED for you. Good old South Carolina Law Enforcement Division. They are very sloppy. Even the SLED director testified on the stand that she wasn't sure if the officers on the scene were her "guys" that walked around the kennels or if they saw the bodies that night. This is months after the murder and she STILL couldn't tell the court when or where SLED officers were on the property that night and she still didnt know, when she was on the stand, when they arrived or what they saw. She didnt even know which officers were sent there!
Wow! His mouth/tongue movements and the head bobbing are controlling him more than anything!
Is that an addiction thing with his mouth it’s really annoying 😪😝
@@nataliebrandt7620 Possibly a Pinocchio thing when he lies only his nose doesn't grow, just his lips flap! 😂😂
And his hands shaking like a 🍃
He like a puppet on a string imo 😂
Drugs
First two minutes of his testimony says it all: his mouth is saying no while he's literally nodding YES. Body language at its loudest!
The scary question is, how could his defence lawyers consciously do this job when they likely know more and instinctively know more.
Because that's a defense attorney's job lol
For the root of all evil which is money lmao?? Like do you think they’re doing this just for the hell of it
Well one of his lawyers is a politician in the senate so there's that. You can't trust a politician or a lawyer
Really? Cmon now
Evilness, defending child rapist and murders. I wouldn't do it.
I'm only 6minutes in and I can already tell he's conjured up an answer for everything.
I do think he loved Paul as much as he could love but ultimately I sincerely believe Paul had disgraced the family name, Paul had really embarrassed him and I think Paul had become too big of a liability for him and all he had. I think he convinced himself that if Paul was no longer around it just might lessen the impact of the boat crash. That night destroyed their lives irreparably. I think he assessed the lawsuit and at some point just made a decision that Paul presented too big a threat to their way of life and with him gone the lawsuit might go away and the sympathy his death would garner just might restore his good name as well.
I think they got into and argument over what you said and it escalated
And Maggie either saw something she shouldn’t have so she had to go too. OR she was against the idea or would never go for it so he decided to ice her too. But I think you’re 100% right.
The thing is if he had just let his kid take the fall the family would be a lot better off. It’s not far off for kids who have generational wealth act a fool while their parents feel shame and send them away or condemn them. Like Caroline Kennedy.
Narcissists cannot love. Black hole of nothingness.
@@kendallleingangIt was Rosemary Kennedy that the father Joe Kennedy had lobotomized & institutionalized at St. Coleta's. But you're right about everything else with this case. Lots of generational entitlement & protecting the family image & name. Paul's liability with the boat crash was going to cost Alex too much reputational & financial harm. And expose Alex's other embezzlement crimes. The only way to try & get out of having his whole fake world come crumbling down on him was this. It's selfish, sick & totally sociopathic.
I believe that if Alex Murdaugh was innocent of these murders, he would have been much more composed when giving testimony. There's something about knowing you're innocent that would lead you to be truly focused on presenting facts of the experience without whining and cringing. There perhaps would be anger at being accused and that would be evident in his demeanor. His childlike behaviour feels like an act to me, especially given his propensity for lying, and continually negotiating his way of of trouble until it all came to a head. This act is just pathetic.
his memory and his answers do not make any sense. he can recall such unique small details, but cant recall other major things that you think you would remember. I remember exactly where I was and what I was doing on September 11th... It is hard for me to imagine not being able to recall more details on the day my wife and son was shot and i was literally there minutes before it happened.
Agree! And it seems that the jury members agree about this too. The ones I've seen interviewed stated that they thought it was a mistake for him to take the stand.
But this was the way he "successfully" operated for such a long time, he thought he could convince them.
Not being composed and acting like he's crying, sobbing, wiping dry tears while manufacturing a few, but his emotions change on a dim, from sobbing to lucid. People's emotions in real life don't change on a dime like this.
I have a theory: I think that Alex drove the golf cart up the road and threw Maggie's phone on the side of the road then came back to the house before he left. Reason is, he didn't want to travel with BOTH his phone AND Maggie's phone together because it would possibly show up in the digital data. That would also explain why it was less than a half mile from the house. If he took Maggie's phone in his car when he drove to his mother's house, he probably would have tossed it a few more miles away. Just a theory but it makes sense.
THATS the EXACT theory of a youtube Channel MOB Crew -- the 56 steps Maggie's phone took was exactly 160 feet which is exactly where the golf cart would stop at Moselle and he'd walk to throw into the forest!
Probably planted the guns somewhere too while he was at it
It’s the crying on cue for me!!!! SMH !!! I’m soooo glad the jury saw through him and his MANY lies !! 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
28:38 Alex describing the last seconds he spoke to his wife and child.
Anyone that has any doubt about his guilt won't after listening to this.
I'm thinking the whole time he's talking, "bro your wife and son get their brains shot out of their heads within minutes so WTF are rambling on about?"
Finished up watching Alex and at the end once again when asked to talk about Maggie he said over & over how she didnt work. He also brought this up in his 2nd interview with SLED.
And to say that Paul was ADHD and that he use to run around like some sick child is just unbelievable to me.
I never watched Alex testimony during the trial so watching it now I don't think he even liked his family I actually think he hated them. Buster wouldve been dead as well if he couldve gotten him home.
Yep, I haven't seen that part, but I would agree. I worked for a woman who owned a business; she was her husband's boss (she hired him after he retired from a car plant, to keep more money in their pockets). He helped her in the heavy lifting, manly part, which he should have been happy to do because she provided a good living for them. However, he resented it and only wanted to be retired. He talked to me in the office (said he thought she didn't love him; it was awkward, so I tried to convince him otherwise). He just wanted to go set in the coffee house chatting up his dad or friends (and run around town feeling important). His wife was a hard worker and didnt expect laziness from anyone. She was more encouraging to get prople to work...not a slave driver. She didnt ask anything she was not also willing to do or help with. Later, her husband tried to make a pass at a big chested, wildish, youger woman, who went and told our boss that and that her husband wanted to divorce her.
It is sad but some people just use others for money, whether men or women .. and don't appreciate family.
Same I think he hated Maggie and resented supporting her. She didn’t work but they had so much help. Why? Her gun shot wounds seemed more personal than Paul’s too.
Clearly intended to make her suffer and have intense fear before she died. I wonder if he spoke to her during or before he shot her.
I HATE hearing him call Paul "Papa"; it's so childish. Calling Maggie, his dead wife, "Maggs" is also so insulting.
Me too! It’s like he was calling them by their nickname to show he “cared” about them.
I couldn't agree with you more. You hit the nail on the head with this one. 👏
How disrespectful and insulting!🤮 prison is to good for him.
@@TheLolly881 I think it was a defense strategy to show that he cared about them, as you said show he cared. But also to maybe show that he couldn't possibly have killed these two people he refers to with these cutesy nicknames. But it came off really repulsive.
Exactly! I agree. @@maureenbrown6697
Everything Alex does everyone claims he killed them or he's lying ..He didn't get a fair trial with open minded people . Rogon should of been investigated harder than Alex or at least same . Theri something up with this Rogon kid cops lying destroying evidence . Fact is how did sled team no hold back recording back three weeks in trial . But yet Rogon done went cops next day pointing he's finger at Alex . Rogon the one that seem to know all the answer . he pin pointing exactly where when he Paul sight gun in ..I think Paul friend stole them weapons I think Rogon involved or help plan this out . Rogon last one talk Paul knew exactly where Paul was . Why didn't cops want Maggie data deleted it . When that could prove Alex innocent
When he was denying murdering, he was saying no as he waved his head yes. That's a classic give away of someone lying. All trained law enforcement, psychologists, and health personnel know this. I wS in law enforcement and that is common knowledge. Criminals always think they are smarter than everyone else
he does a lot of nodding anyway though, plus there needs to be more than one tell. I want them to ask WHY he didnt stop at his mums on the way home from work. why go home then go out?
Junk science
I noticed that also but he’s seems to nod his head a lot during testimony.
Has to be multiple actions to really tell if he’s lying
That's literally how he talks it's a soothing habit he has. Nothing to do with lying 🙄