@@SpinoAdri2001 The peasantry can play no independent historical role apart from the Proletariate and the Bourgeoisie. Their class content is essentially petit-bourgios, and squeezed between the proletariate and big bourgeoisie, they have no historical future, no prospect of remaking society in their class-image as with the proletariate and the bourgeoisie. This is why, historically, the peasantry vassilates between revolution and counter-revolution. They tail behind either the proletarian revolution or the Bourgeois counter-revolution. Lenin, Trotsky, and the Bolsheviks correctly understood that the socialist revolution in Russia could only triumph if the party of the proletariat (the Bolsheviks) could win over the peasants to follow the workers in a struggle against the big bourgeoisie, and likewise, the Democratic aims of the peasantry could not be won without the workers playing a leading role. Consequently, the role of the working class is considered primary, with the peasantry playing, at best, a supporting role I can recommend reading: Lenin: *"The Peasantry and the Working Class"* (1913) Plekhanov: *"Our differences"* (specifically chapter 5)
Workers peasant alliance .-. The proletariat as a class is of course the sole weilder of all political power but in peasant countries the workers cannot secure socialism without the courting of the peasants, via progressive land reform and their gradual reorganising into the peasant co-operative.
@@engineergaming8695 I think they mean in the sense that we don't actively speak the language, but we learned the words are to sing the song. We may not remember what every word means, exactly, but we know the sounds. We couldn't hold a conversation in the language, but we can sing some revolutionary songs. I know the words to the Spanish "¡A Las Barricadas!", but I'd be hard-pressed to hold a conversation in Spanish. Obviously, Firebringer and I should both actually learn the languages these songs are in, and the fact we haven't is a fault; but that's where we're at right now. Er, if my assumption about Firebringer's meaning is correct. Which it might not be. Idk, internet, UA-cam comments, etc - people say things and get them wrong, I'm definitely not immune to that, lol. Hope you're doing well, stranger.
@@ryantay9642 I may not agree with them, but preventing the opposition from voting is the first step towards dictatorship, unless they openly express the desire to do away with democracy, or restrict the basic freedoms of any group
@@lenny415 Thälmann as well. The man fought social fascists and nazis in Germany, but wasn't allowed to live long enough to see their (sadly, not total) defeat.
@@Musterprolet "Voted in the USSR" I'm going to stop you right there. The votes in the USSR were as real as those in North Korea. There was no choice other than socialism. When the people finally got a chance to make themselves heard in another way other than those fake votes, the entire Eastern Bloc collapsed.
10/10 aber wäre noch 100× krasser wenn du es in die Ernst bush oder noch besser in die Hanns Eisler/Berlin radio Orchesters hättest rein transitioned machen können. Sonst gutes video 👍
That video description is just another example of why modern society is so fucked up. Either you make a statement or you don't, but first posting a video on a modern worker's revolution and then immedeatly distancing yourself from it in the description is just so cowardous.
This is very common on videos that follow this pattern. Particularly because some cover things such as "A Confederate Soldier but your parade is ransacked by a slave revolt", or "A German Tanker in the second world war, but your advance is disrupted by partisan forces", and so on. While some are harmless, the staple comment of distancing is left in the hopes that it will prevent the youtube gods from deleting the videos on grounds of copyright, extremism, or otherwise. Though I can understand where you're coming from, and the confusion.
I like to stay A-political, and am just making these for fun and because I can. It's not that I don't care, I just don't want to start controversy and arguments. Thank you for the feedback though.
@@intemperies2587 That's a valid point, but I am just generally quite pissed off by the culture of distancing yourself just for making yourself immune to potential criticism. The fact is that the setup of the video added some sort of political statement to the song itself and immedeatly distancing yourself from that negates the purpose of the whole video from my point of view.
i said it makes me feel comfy because im in germany and i sang his song a tousand times on protests and this genuinely wakes memories for me and reminds me of all my comrades when im not doing so good at home :3 you cant run around in a blackblock 24/7 just think a lil bit before You build your strawman @@Millwork1075
Sooner than many think. The only reason you see so many Fascists about if that they know they're going to lose, and they are terrified of that for whatever reason
@@asilkinder3609 Try to stand against the wheel of history and the struggle for the birth of a new world all you want. You will only find yourself crushed beneath it. And a good First of May to you all.
@@EyeoftheU Say that communism is good all you want but its not good at all look at the millions of people that died because of communist dictators You hate to see that capitalism works and is way better
@@FaZeAnneFrank1945 Ideas of real power of the people, real democracy equality of opportunity, the absence of national conflicts, the absence of wars, and the exploitation of man by man, this is terrible?
@@FaZeAnneFrank1945 Well, that is, you are for wars, poverty, while so that 2% -5% will be rich Hunger even now and unemployment, lack of opportunities, paid education and medicine Do you approve of all this?well, if so, then you what else is there to say
@@YourLocalAntifascist Literally how. It is one of the Cleanest and Safest forms of energy in the world. and it is highly efficient One Ton of Thorium = 200 Uranium = 3,500,000 tons of coal
@@aguy6771 Wow everything you just said is wrong. Look at France for example, they have to put billions of euros each year to keep their plants up to date, costing the taxpayer money that could have been spent on renewables. Then you have the tons of nuclear waste that have to be stored save for many thousands of years, finding a place for that is hard and just recently we discovered that one of our old disposal places from the 2000s was not save, so now we have to put millions into digging that waste up again.... Then you have to acutally get the componants for nuclear fusion, the enrichment of uranium for fusion is process that is really bad for the enviorment. And to finally kill your argument, even the WNA abd OECD (wich are lobby organisations FOR nuclear energy) that doubling the nuclear cabicity would only decrease the greehouse gas emision by 4%. So to sum up, nuclear is to expensive, has far to much long term risks, and is far to inefficient.
@@YourLocalAntifascist There are better new generations of nuclear that are being tested, but I would agree that renewables are simply better unless nuclear fusion ever becomes viable. I believe (don't quote me on this) that offshore wind turbines generate power ~98% of the time, so the myth of "what if the wind isn't blowing" is stupid. Also nuclear is mostly controlled by large corporations (at least in the US) and small scale investment is basically impossible, so renewables are just a better source, especially since the government and corporations aren't especially interested (in the US.)
Hannes Wader was from the West. The Einheitsfront was proposed before 1933 as a means to keep Mustache Man from seizing all power. It diidn't work because the Reichstag fire panicked enough people into giving him control.
The poor man that's suffering because he is lazy and doesn't want to work is a capitalist myth to justify wealth disparity and widespread poverty among the working class. Anyone is willing to work, even if some may not be as enthusiastic about it as others. Tell me, what was the unemployment rate in the Soviet Union?
Everyone is willing to work if it ensures a secure life If you work 9-5 but are barely able to make a living, is that fair? We the workers are what keeps our society intact, without us the big men in their office chairs would be nothing, only we have the power to keep the wheel spinning
@@inzlt8142 Without ownership, you have no rights to what you use. "Don't cling so hard to your possessions, for you have nothing, if you have no rights"
@@chnb517 That's why he have to stop supporting the capitalists and the politicians who enable them. Let's instead support politicians who work for the people.
The Scottish Revoultion: Radical socalists storm the Holywood palierment and excute all Scottish Memebers of Palierments and in state a Socalist coup, The Socalist provisional goverment addreses the nation and declares immediate independence from the UK as the civals are radicly invited into the people's army.
@@softandwet7584 bud I couldn't care sbt that I'm not csptulst do u think ama just sit a cry while thr country goes into poverty? No we build jobs and abolish currency.
@@TheScottishBOLSHEVIK Build jobs with what money, and abolish currency and replace it with what? Scotland doesn’t have the resources to function without imports so how do you plan on paying for that
@@softandwet7584 I don't care bud authority rules all and captlism and the entire world will be locked out of our borders Scotland is for celtics and Scots only not 8b humans.
@@TheScottishBOLSHEVIK they’ll be locked out of your borders and you’ll run out of food and medicine within a week, the people will either leave on mass or starve to death. (That’s assuming the English don’t just overthrow you the same day it pops off) And Scotland for the celts? Sounding a bit BUF there mate, you sure you’re a socialist?
The liberation of the working class is a task for the worker alone
Don't forget the peasants
@@SpinoAdri2001 As a auxiliary to the proletarian movement, yes
@@SpinoAdri2001 The peasantry can play no independent historical role apart from the Proletariate and the Bourgeoisie. Their class content is essentially petit-bourgios, and squeezed between the proletariate and big bourgeoisie, they have no historical future, no prospect of remaking society in their class-image as with the proletariate and the bourgeoisie. This is why, historically, the peasantry vassilates between revolution and counter-revolution. They tail behind either the proletarian revolution or the Bourgeois counter-revolution. Lenin, Trotsky, and the Bolsheviks correctly understood that the socialist revolution in Russia could only triumph if the party of the proletariat (the Bolsheviks) could win over the peasants to follow the workers in a struggle against the big bourgeoisie, and likewise, the Democratic aims of the peasantry could not be won without the workers playing a leading role. Consequently, the role of the working class is considered primary, with the peasantry playing, at best, a supporting role
I can recommend reading:
Lenin: *"The Peasantry and the Working Class"* (1913)
Plekhanov: *"Our differences"* (specifically chapter 5)
Workers peasant alliance .-.
The proletariat as a class is of course the sole weilder of all political power but in peasant countries the workers cannot secure socialism without the courting of the peasants, via progressive land reform and their gradual reorganising into the peasant co-operative.
@@SharpieWaterOfficial Communism is dying everywhere. Even the Soviets got rid of it 33 years ago. It sucks.
Es hört sich großartig an, wie immer während des Refrain die Menge mitsingt oder ins Chaos verfällt. 10/10
I know I'm too much of a revolutionary, when I don't need to know the language to know the song.
dude... the song's original language was IN german
@@engineergaming8695 I think they mean in the sense that we don't actively speak the language, but we learned the words are to sing the song. We may not remember what every word means, exactly, but we know the sounds. We couldn't hold a conversation in the language, but we can sing some revolutionary songs. I know the words to the Spanish "¡A Las Barricadas!", but I'd be hard-pressed to hold a conversation in Spanish. Obviously, Firebringer and I should both actually learn the languages these songs are in, and the fact we haven't is a fault; but that's where we're at right now. Er, if my assumption about Firebringer's meaning is correct. Which it might not be. Idk, internet, UA-cam comments, etc - people say things and get them wrong, I'm definitely not immune to that, lol. Hope you're doing well, stranger.
@@n.r.4579 average leftist comment
Glory to revolutionary workers movement!
Equality and justice for all!
capitalism for win
@CallumGaming sorry your in the wrong century go back to the 1700s
Except if you are conservative, libertarian, christian, right-wing, capitalist.
@@ryantay9642 I may not agree with them, but preventing the opposition from voting is the first step towards dictatorship, unless they openly express the desire to do away with democracy, or restrict the basic freedoms of any group
@@ryantay9642 “Justice for all except for people who are against us”
A happy First of May to all comrades!
INTERNATIONAL DAY OF WORKERS' SOLIDARITY
Nah
May the ghosts of Haywood and Hill smile upon our German brethren.
And the ghosts of luxemberg and liebneckt
@@lenny415 Thälmann as well. The man fought social fascists and nazis in Germany, but wasn't allowed to live long enough to see their (sadly, not total) defeat.
It's near folks they will have to choose a side soon.
They've already chosen a side, back in '89, and most people sided against socialism.
@@mihaimatei255 conditions have changed the exploitation is brazen
@@mihaimatei255 They didn’t, vast majority voted for socialism in USSR
@@Musterprolet "Voted in the USSR" I'm going to stop you right there. The votes in the USSR were as real as those in North Korea. There was no choice other than socialism. When the people finally got a chance to make themselves heard in another way other than those fake votes, the entire Eastern Bloc collapsed.
I'm sorry, it's not near, it's done since 1989.
10/10 aber wäre noch 100× krasser wenn du es in die Ernst bush oder noch besser in die Hanns Eisler/Berlin radio Orchesters hättest rein transitioned machen können. Sonst gutes video 👍
Danke fürs Feedback!
Perfect for what happened this May Day a few days ago, workers of the world, unite!
@@KieZetkin International Workers’ Day. All across the world workers rose up and protested their conditions and demanded better wages and treatment.
Workers rights are non negotiable
Self government for the working class, no authority above the free organisation of the people
That video description is just another example of why modern society is so fucked up. Either you make a statement or you don't, but first posting a video on a modern worker's revolution and then immedeatly distancing yourself from it in the description is just so cowardous.
This is very common on videos that follow this pattern. Particularly because some cover things such as "A Confederate Soldier but your parade is ransacked by a slave revolt", or "A German Tanker in the second world war, but your advance is disrupted by partisan forces", and so on.
While some are harmless, the staple comment of distancing is left in the hopes that it will prevent the youtube gods from deleting the videos on grounds of copyright, extremism, or otherwise.
Though I can understand where you're coming from, and the confusion.
I like to stay A-political, and am just making these for fun and because I can. It's not that I don't care, I just don't want to start controversy and arguments. Thank you for the feedback though.
@@krel7160is also correct with his statement.
I put these on all of my videos.
@@intemperies2587 That's a valid point, but I am just generally quite pissed off by the culture of distancing yourself just for making yourself immune to potential criticism. The fact is that the setup of the video added some sort of political statement to the song itself and immedeatly distancing yourself from that negates the purpose of the whole video from my point of view.
für frieden und sozialismus!
Never
@@asilkinder3609 über sozialismus kann man ja reden aber für krieg?
@@ehgwergtr i dont understand german,make it english
@@asilkinder3609 why you are for war? Bc this guy said for peace and socialism and you said never. So you are for war?
@@ehgwergtr not for war just not for socialism
dat makes me feel so comfy omg thank you for making this
i love revolutionary music too
Looks like we got a trans club in the comment section x3
Nothing more comforting than listening to a riot or protest as I'm sitting in my room
i said it makes me feel comfy because im in germany and i sang his song a tousand times on protests and this genuinely wakes memories for me and reminds me of all my comrades when im not doing so good at home :3 you cant run around in a blackblock 24/7 just think a lil bit before You build your strawman @@Millwork1075
where did you get the audio of the people singing?
The audio is from a cover of the song by Hannes Wader: ua-cam.com/video/unb9i5C_y4s/v-deo.html
@@ourillworld thank you
@@ourillworld hi Rosa 👋
Soon brothers and sisters, soon.
very soon, comrade.
Sooner than many think.
The only reason you see so many Fascists about if that they know they're going to lose, and they are terrified of that for whatever reason
Never
@@asilkinder3609 Try to stand against the wheel of history and the struggle for the birth of a new world all you want. You will only find yourself crushed beneath it. And a good First of May to you all.
@@EyeoftheU Say that communism is good all you want but its not good at all look at the millions of people that died because of communist dictators
You hate to see that capitalism works and is way better
Ah the Germans and the color red quite historical
Please second spartakist revolution
Ein Ende der Lohnabhängigkeit und ein Ende dem Kapital.
Вся власть Советам!
terrible idea
@@FaZeAnneFrank1945 Ideas of real power of the people, real democracy equality of opportunity, the absence of national conflicts, the absence of wars, and the exploitation of man by man, this is terrible?
@@meteorplay3487 yes
@@FaZeAnneFrank1945 Well, that is, you are for wars, poverty, while so that 2% -5% will be rich Hunger even now and unemployment, lack of opportunities, paid education and medicine Do you approve of all this?well, if so, then you what else is there to say
@@meteorplay3487 I don’t remember what I was talking about and I dont care enough to argue bc arguing on the internet is useless so good day my friend
DRUM LINKS ZWEI DREI
База
When you demand to free Lina E.
What version of Einheitsfrontlied is this? Do you have a link? (nvm, its in desc)
Do not close the Nuclear Factories
Why? Nuclear sucks.
@@YourLocalAntifascist Literally how. It is one of the Cleanest and Safest forms of energy in the world. and it is highly efficient One Ton of Thorium = 200 Uranium = 3,500,000 tons of coal
@@aguy6771 Wow everything you just said is wrong.
Look at France for example, they have to put billions of euros each year to keep their plants up to date, costing the taxpayer money that could have been spent on renewables. Then you have the tons of nuclear waste that have to be stored save for many thousands of years, finding a place for that is hard and just recently we discovered that one of our old disposal places from the 2000s was not save, so now we have to put millions into digging that waste up again....
Then you have to acutally get the componants for nuclear fusion, the enrichment of uranium for fusion is process that is really bad for the enviorment.
And to finally kill your argument, even the WNA abd OECD (wich are lobby organisations FOR nuclear energy) that doubling the nuclear cabicity would only decrease the greehouse gas emision by 4%.
So to sum up, nuclear is to expensive, has far to much long term risks, and is far to inefficient.
@@YourLocalAntifascist There are better new generations of nuclear that are being tested, but I would agree that renewables are simply better unless nuclear fusion ever becomes viable. I believe (don't quote me on this) that offshore wind turbines generate power ~98% of the time, so the myth of "what if the wind isn't blowing" is stupid. Also nuclear is mostly controlled by large corporations (at least in the US) and small scale investment is basically impossible, so renewables are just a better source, especially since the government and corporations aren't especially interested (in the US.)
@@aguy6771 and super expensive
Hannes Wader!
Will the workers work with farmers or screw them over?
East German songs is hot af
Hannes Wader was from the West. The Einheitsfront was proposed before 1933 as a means to keep Mustache Man from seizing all power. It diidn't work because the Reichstag fire panicked enough people into giving him control.
This is from 1934.
@@projectpitchfork860 Song from the 30s AND this singer was in West Germany lmao
Fash are jealous of our songs.
Schön wär's. :/
✊✊✊✊✊
too moderate
Indeed tovarish, Most are, but they are halfway there.
Many revolutionary parties formed as splits out of moderate ones. KPD out of SPD, Bolsheviks out of the RSDLP, and so on.
@@BifronsCandle that is true. and every time the modarates betray the revolution.
@@BifronsCandle Only German communist party one should support is the KPD-ML
8/10 not enough Molotov cocktails
✊🏼
anti communist diclaimer hahahahhahahaha
communist disclamer
BAHAHAHAHAHHAAHAHHAHAHHHHHH
AHHHAHAHAAHHAHAHAH
XAXAXAXAXAXXAXAXAAXAXAXAXAA
*becomes lenin*
When america controls Europe Abit too much
In order to truly be a part of a worker’s revolution, you need to be willing to work in the first place.
Everybody is willing to work. Even the capitalists. Although they don’t do it.
The poor man that's suffering because he is lazy and doesn't want to work is a capitalist myth to justify wealth disparity and widespread poverty among the working class.
Anyone is willing to work, even if some may not be as enthusiastic about it as others.
Tell me, what was the unemployment rate in the Soviet Union?
As an active communist, all of my comrades are either already workers or students getting ready to enter the job market
@@daniels0376 2% or even less.
Everyone is willing to work if it ensures a secure life
If you work 9-5 but are barely able to make a living, is that fair? We the workers are what keeps our society intact, without us the big men in their office chairs would be nothing, only we have the power to keep the wheel spinning
Democratic communisme > Capitalisme
UUURRRAAAAA!!! 💪☭
you will own nothing and be happy
You don't need to own things to use or consume them.
@@inzlt8142 you vill eat ze bugs
@@inzlt8142 Without ownership, you have no rights to what you use. "Don't cling so hard to your possessions, for you have nothing, if you have no rights"
@@chnb517 That's why he have to stop supporting the capitalists and the politicians who enable them. Let's instead support politicians who work for the people.
Yes.
When you don't know shit about basic economics :
Idk man, some Germans are really competent
when you love the taste of the bosses boot
I think your dear Makhno was also kind of an anti-capitalist.
@@plantlover711 i'm not anarchist lol (it doesn't work, like communism)
keep licking those boots
Soy revolution
You are revolution?
@@The-Devils-Advocate He is confusion.
@@InfiniteDeckhand it seems so
Lenin killed innocent people!
People he killed:
bro speaks Spanish
ANTI-ANTIFA FROM GREECE.
Fascist then ?
@@purpleguythomas anti-communist
@@ΕλληνικόςΕθνικισμός-δ4ν So you are a fascist?
@@purpleguythomas Such an simple understanding of anti-leftist ideas.
@@kubakornijenko1927 antifa means antifascists, double anti crosses out anti
Freikorps voran against such nonsense!
Ich bin Kapitalismusfan. Könnt ihr kommis bitte nach Venezuela auswandern.
Nein, die deutsche Arbeiterklasse wird den deutschen Staat stürzen, der Sozialismus muss weltweit sein, nicht nur in einem Land
Venezuela’s situation is a product of them liberalizing their markets.
"communism doesn't work! just look at this poor nation we ravaged!"
The best form of socialism is national socialism and Germany needs socialism again!
Nothing says socialism like mass privatization and megacorps.
@@BifronsCandle Thats why its good.
@@mojewjewjew4420 That's why it's literally just capitalism and improves nothing
The fact that you're calling national socialims a type of socialism gives me second-hand embarrasment. Please just abreviate and call yourself a nazi.
@@mojewjewjew4420 It was nver good and never will be
Bozo
The Scottish Revoultion: Radical socalists storm the Holywood palierment and excute all Scottish Memebers of Palierments and in state a Socalist coup, The Socalist provisional goverment addreses the nation and declares immediate independence from the UK as the civals are radicly invited into the people's army.
Scotlands economy immediately collapses as it no longer has English tax to fund its social institutions
@@softandwet7584 bud I couldn't care sbt that I'm not csptulst do u think ama just sit a cry while thr country goes into poverty? No we build jobs and abolish currency.
@@TheScottishBOLSHEVIK Build jobs with what money, and abolish currency and replace it with what? Scotland doesn’t have the resources to function without imports so how do you plan on paying for that
@@softandwet7584 I don't care bud authority rules all and captlism and the entire world will be locked out of our borders Scotland is for celtics and Scots only not 8b humans.
@@TheScottishBOLSHEVIK they’ll be locked out of your borders and you’ll run out of food and medicine within a week, the people will either leave on mass or starve to death. (That’s assuming the English don’t just overthrow you the same day it pops off)
And Scotland for the celts? Sounding a bit BUF there mate, you sure you’re a socialist?
Да здравствует Великая Социалистическая Революция!
Пролетарии всех стран объеденяйтесь !
Смерть капитализму !