The Karachi Police Cases: Gender Based Violence, Assault and Crime - Summaiya Syed Tariq -
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 тра 2024
- A harrowing and dark episode of The Pakistan Experience, where Dr. Summaiya Syed Tariq talks about the "bowels of our society"; as the Karachi Police Surgeon, she deals with all kinds of violent crime, Gender Based Violence, and Crime.
On this episode, she discusses police procedure, assault, laws, the two finger test, taboos, child abuse, the Dua Zehra Case, Baldia Town Tragedy and the PIA Crash.
Dr. Summaiya Syed Tariq is the Karachi Police Surgeon. She is a Forensic Consultant and an expert on Clinical management of assault and GBV.
Reach out to her on / drsuetariq
The Pakistan Experience is an independently produced podcast looking to tell stories about Pakistan through conversations.
Please consider supporting us on Patreon:
/ thepakistanexperience
To support the channel:
Jazzcash/Easypaisa - 0325 -2982912
Patreon.com/thepakistanexperience
And Please stay in touch:
/ thepakistanexp1
/ thepakistanexperience
/ thepakistanexpeperience
The podcast is hosted by comedian and writer, Shehzad Ghias Shaikh. Shehzad is a Fulbright scholar with a Masters in Theatre from Brooklyn College. He is also one of the foremost Stand-up comedians in Pakistan and frequently writes for numerous publications.
shehzadghiasshaikh
Facebook.com/Shehzadghias/
shehzad89
Chapters:
0:00 Introduction
2:18 Gender based violence, known assaulters, police procedure, r*pe laws and their shortcomings
12:01 2-finger test, consent under duress, the process of filing a complaint and the anti-r*pe act
21:28 The Taboo for males and minors, sensitivity and empathy, the surrounding culture and attitude
34:30 How she sleeps at night, her first postmortem, court cases and living in the bowels of society and mansplaining
44:42 child sexual abuse, views on women and izzat, Qandeel Baloch, ostracizing of victims, and our disposable population
56:50 Repression, the Zainab alert, mistrust and fear of courts and police, prevalence of domestic violence
1:08:10 mental health pandemic, apathy for violence, financial independence, avenues for women, Dua Zehra’s case and Baldia Town fire
1:20:21 PIA crash victims’ families complaints, body disposal, Karachi’s medico-legal offices, dealing with the pressure
1:27:21 Dealing with sexism and being a woman in the field, and news media’s interference
1:31:04 Q&A - Розваги
I'm from India. Felt so good to listen to such a good educated doctor doing good work to change the society.
Yes. These are the real heroes and more such people need to be brought forward to share and educate the people. Huge respect to the person who decided to take such step and executed it. 👏🏻
@@prb392 Guy relax yourself with your false information, not every problem in society is related to religion and get your head out of the hindutva hatred mentality. In the 7th century, all over the world girls got married at a young age, it was normal for back then, obviously not for today, which is what this doctor is fighting for. The Hindu scriptures are full of raping young girls without permission too, and it happens a LOT in India today which is the rape capital of the world. Does that mean it is the fault of your religion? Do you make the same argument about Hinduism when on average 3 girls are raped in India daily (UN statistic) or is a societal fault due to lack of education. Take your bigotry somewhere else and stop making false equivalencies on everything just to justify your prejudices.
@@prb392 Incest is allowed? Sex with dead bodies is allowed? Please give me a reference,
@@prb392 relax vro apni traf se kuch bhi bolte jao ge kia?
😢😢😢😢😢
This is a heart-wrenching interview. I am so glad you haven't succumbed to celebrity interviews and are keeping the focus on academics, activists, journalists and real-life professional heroes like Dr. Summaiya Tariq. Well done, you!👍
❤
Agreed
90% of the cases which involves family member go unnoticed because Family protects the perpetrator because they depend on them for money, support etc.
Such a smart articulate lady. Grounded and doing such a fabulous job. Trying to make a difference with stoic resilience. God bless. May her tribe increase. Such an asset to any society.
🙌
I'm a final year medical student, with aspirations to pursue psychiatry. After this podcast I'm inspired to go towards the ML field which handles psych of these patients.
You know you've seen an amazing podcast when you're moved to think and change.
Kudos to Shehzad and Dr. Summaiya. An amazing podcast experience ❣
😂die😂😅
❤
All the best, Maria. Kudos to you for making such decision. 💙
I am working in a company who run mental hospitals in England and the way staff deal with patients with hard work, I give really good respect from my heart and soul.
Maria I recommend to you a feminist doctor *Nawal El-saadawi* she was a psychiatrist and surgeon but most important she was also a *writer* you can read her books there is one book called *women and sex* you need to read it, it will benefit you so much, and I will appreciate it if you could give me a feedback about it
Dr. Summaiya ji talked with such clarity and matter of fact disposition that it just stunned me. May the tribe of Dr. Summaiya ji increase not only in Pakistan but all over South Asia including India.
🙌
Shehzad, can’t thank you
Enough for bringing such dynamic talented gems to this podcast- TPE gives me hope that all is not lost - ❤️❤️❤️
❤
People like Dr Summaiya are angels, salute to people like her❤✌️👏💪
❤
Doc nailed it @1:13:12 “muaashre me violence ziyada hai… but asal me woh violence muaashre ki vajah se hi hai” 👌👌
🙌
Great job finding unsung heroes like Dr Summaiya.
🙌
@@ThePakistanExperience 😊and
What a wonderful women. God bless her. It is a treat to listen to this interview.
🙌
WHAT AN INSPIRATION!! This podcast needs to be broadcasted in every medical college and post graduate institute in Pakistan.
Other than the obvious issues highlighted, i feel this podcast can also be used to reiterate the importance of ethics, empathy and safe medical practices.
🙌
Not only in Pakistan it should be viewed by Indian also specially parents.
Podcasts like this, are the pillar of your channel, regardless of views and catchy topics and blah, this is how real it gets,, kudos to you Shehzad and Salute to ma’am for doing what she’s been doing relentlessly all through her life. #respect
❤
Bravo! Brilliant! One of your best episodes! Please make more such videos like this highlighting issues that we as a collective society pretend do not happen!
🙌
We have created a superficial society in the name of Islam their is so much gender segregation in Pakistan instead of solving the problems of our society gender segregation has created more both genders male or female don't know how to communicate with each other all thanks to our mard e momin mard e haq zia ul haq and his pupils ''the mullahs"
@ThePakistanExperience ❤
"Bowels of Society", so aptly put by the guest.
A darker part of our society that is not talked about.
Thanks for giving this topic the exposure it derserves.
🙌
Delhi mai rool hai agar koi bhi rode accident ho agar wo kisi bhi private or govt hospital mai jaye Sara bill delhi govt pay karti hai
Excellently done! The doctor is a hero and you too are Shehzad! Keep going.
🙌
Thank you for a fantastic podcast, which very sensitively touches upon some very harsh realities of our society. I am not a Pakistani but a very patriotic Indian. However, I recognise that the issues referred to by you are equally prevalent in both societies. I would also like to congratulate and pay tribute to Doctor sahiba for the sterling work that she is doing. May she receive all the support and resources that she needs. I look forward to reading 'The Bowels of Society'.
❤
Yes Dass. This is very sad and unfortunate and this needs to end. 🤍
@pakistan
Experience: as society we lack sexual education. I hope you would a program on the issue.
This is one of the best discussions on this topic. Thank you for bringing this sensitive topic. Great job by the Doctor.
🙌
I regret eating while watching this episode. Dropped my roll paratha within the first few minutes. 😫😫
She's so level headed and calm after seeing such horrible stuff; who needs true crime when you can just listen to her stories? Still loved this episode though ❤❤. Keep it up guys
❤
The look on Shehzad's face. I am so grateful for this conversation.
Congratulate the host for choosing the topic with such knowledgeable guest. Very necessary to talk about these issues.
🙌
Once again, thank you for highlighting major issues and amazing people who are doing a great job
🙌
Great interview.Kudos to both Shehzad and Doctor Saab for informing on this difficult subject.
🙌
Gr8 show. Many many congratulations. This show will help our society to grow for better.
One of the best podcasts that TPE has recorded so far. Absolutely loved it. ❤
❤
Thank you for bringing this issue in the fore front.
🙌
Extremely heart wrenching but soo needed! Thank you TPE !
❤
Shezad, this is a brilliant & thought provoking podcast. One point 'women emancipation': That sounds cliched especially in a closed society where even a woman's dressing up, basic rights are suppressed on various alibis/pretexts be it religion, family honor, societal pressures etc. In closed societies we don't educate our girls & enforce restrictions to curtail their talent and progression. All they can end up is becoming children bearing machines, dependents on their husbands. If the women are educated and economically independent, I can bet you, men will treat them with respect and like a follow human first.
❤
Another incredible show and pertinent show ! Good job Shehzad !
❤
You r doing huge benefit/ favour to this society and country. You literally r a huge asset and blessing for this nation. I literally don't have words to articulate the charity you r donating to this nation through your work. You r literally doing the work, neeki kar darya ma daal, and not for money. A little bit suggestion here, You r doing almost most of the time podcasts on political issues, history, issues related to our society, and others, all these topics require a deep dive into research work and knowledge about contemporary situation that requires a huge time. Additionally, all of these topics are very serious and dark and the negative comments you will get while narrating the reality to people might negatively affect your mental well -being. Therefore, i would suggest may be sometimes if you get a chance, do a lighter podcast, just like the one you did with ali gul pir, and other things that you like to do, that will help your mind to relax a bit, that is so necessary for everyone and especially for you. I wish you a healthy life, mentally and physically and always prosper. Always legend Sir.
❤
I do a weekly "fraudcast" with Mustafa Chaudhary and Murtaza Chaudhru on the Alien Broadcast channel, which is lighter. TPE par bhi comedians bulata hoon more
@@ThePakistanExperience yeah the fraudcast is a nice lighter podcast , i regularly listen to it too. Thank you
Have no words to praise this conversation. So honest. Informative. Bringing awareness.
🙌
I feel very fortunate to have been her student. Amazing woman. Mashallah. #inspiration
🙌
Thank you for talking this sensitive issue openly. It's very important to bring awareness to community so they can protect theirs kids from evil peoples. Please keep up great show.
Thank you again!
Thank you again
Best one yet IMO. Very insightful. Indeed a personaility to be celebrated.
🎉
🙌
Such an amazing podcast. Went from soul wrenching to eye opening to hope instilling. Shehzad bhai hosted with such empathy ❤
Hats off to Dr. Summaiya and everyone who is working bravely without acknowledgment and appreciation.
Being a medical student myself, this podcast has inspired me to explore the medicolegal field as a career as well. Its much needed.
Thank you Shehzad sir for consistently educating us on all ascpects of society. May Allah bless your efforts and hardwork. Ameen.
❤
This is the best podcast in the entire TPE series, IMO
🙌❤
We need these types of Podcasts. ❤❤❤
❤
A great interview of a sensitive yet very professional doctor.
Such thoughtful discussion. Very sensitive topics. Respect to both the host and the guest. Waiting for her book. Waiting for more episodes from this podcast
🙌
much much informative video. Good job Shahzad Keep it up man.
🙌
Very profound dealing of a very sensitive issue ! Well done Shehjad and hats off to the doctor for her commitment and empathy . It should be shown on national TV !
🙌
Very informative 👏... our society needs to educate and aware about this....
🙌
Thank you for the insight, keep up the good work
🙌
Sir, rapes mostly occurs in families , known person.
Even in advanced countries, it'is true'.
My dear Shehzad! Another marvelous discussion. Doctor S Tariq is so gracious in giving such elaborate answers. My sincere gratitude & regards to her. Gratitude to you too for inviting her to discuss this malaise which is prevalent in the subcontinent. Love & stay blessed 🎉
🙌❤
You're gem of a person, Bro you are special. The level of intellect along with humour, its a lethal combo. you have always covered a unique or distinctive angle on the socio-political issues. MASHALLAH you are Godgifted. keep up the good work👍..stay blessed 🧿🧿🧿🧿🧿
❤
May Allah SWT protect the little angels and everyone else from the sick minds of horrible people. A must needed discussion, you are doing a great job Shehzad, and setting a new standard of discussion in Pakistan.
❤
you mean merital rape .orat jab cammel pe baithi ho or pregnent bhi ho toh bhi usay husband ko khush karna hai nahi toh frishtay sari raat lanatay dengay
Amazing podcast. Thanks
Thank you for being a true hero madame.
Amazing Ghias, it reminds me of the childhood abuse which almost we all face in different ways.
Sorry to know that you had to go thru it brother ❤🙏🏻
Sending love ❤
I am so proud and pleased to know about this lady. Wish I could kiss the ground she walks on. May Allah Almighty bless you..
An informative podcast. Aesay podcasts hotay rehna chahiyay though many of us wont like to hear about such things
An eye opener for all and an inspirational talk.
🙌
Amazing discussion!
🙌
Shehzad bhai, I’m not oversimplifying this horrible situation but I think it starts with Jab chota bacha masti karta hai to maa kehti rai “sabr rakh, mein tere baap ko bataungi” just think of what that puts in the child’s mind with regards to gender roles! The very least is “meri maa abbu ke be ghair kuch nai bigar sakti! The other thing is when men beat their wives in front of their children !
Good job. Great to listen to those who actually do work.
🙌
Appreciated! Shehzad you're doing great job.
🙌
Amazing program Shahzad it's pleasure watching your podcast. My little input is I am sure the biggest problem of society today is population blast and our infrastructure development just cannot cope up rather far far behind. I know and can easily prove that Pakistan population is more than 350 million today. Dr.Summaiya Bibi is doing amazing work But we need hundreds such icons now to bring some change for our country. Of course you are also one best. Stay Blessed !
❤
Excellent interview yaar. I have also worked with children who have been abused and families that are dealing with that here in the US in impoverished communities. It is amazing to see that even in a rich country like America, we don't do much better than countries with less resources like Pakistan. She was such an incredible leader. Someone like her can improve things wherever she finds herself.
Amazing podcast and kudos to Dr. Sumaiya
🙌
i wish her the best in her work. it was such a mind-bending experience listening to her.
Implementation is highly important for these Laws.
Uff brilliant brilliant. Kudos for this vlog. To the Doctor and the person who made this VLog
Shehzad , one of your best programs. Hats off to Dr Tariq for the brave work she is doing.
❤
Proud to say she’s my teacher currently ❤
Such an eye opener . Never thought it was this bad
🙌
Heartening to see such dedicated and smart medical personnel. May Allah bless her ❤.
Thank you for your podcasts. Truly a service to society!
❤
Shezad broo, this was just amazing to watch and listen to,
Keep it up pleaseeeee
Love from Canada
❤
brilliant interview Doc.
🙌
Very informative session
Bless her ❤ what an incredible and inspiring lady...
❤
Informative af
This is the best episode of your podcast
🙌
Iron lady. We need more podcasts like this I mean this is incredible got lot of inspiration and motivation.
🙌
What an excellent podcast! Hats off to the lady for the work she has been doing. And I am becoming a huge fan of you Shehzad, you are doing a great job.
❤
Young girls must get the highest education for financial freedom if and when needed. Unfortunately women look for “rich and wealthy” man who will take care of them. Please stand up on your own feet, knees and shoulders. No man will abuse a woman if she is absolute financially independent.
Most women can't do it due to family issues like sanctions and financial conditions
Any woman who works all day and comes home to work AGAIN is a WORTHLESS SLAVE. The west is full of abused women ans THEY ALL WORK.
She knows her work v well..more duas for her ...may our society have ہدایت AAMEEN
Amazing to learn about the work she's doing!
🙌
Dr. Summaiya, pls pls write your book! Pls pls write it all- we look forward to reading - we need to educate ppl at large how ugly our society really is -
I agree
Sad but true. Protect your self people
there was this meme trend extremely viral and people even were enjoying the orignal video. the meme trend was "chumi shumi lelu koi masla to nai", when you watch the orignal video you will get to know an adult man is molesting a kid in some hostel in Sindh. in that video it was his first meeting with the kid, which means there must be more to molestation and even rape. but it was extremely devastating for me how a harassment video was a famous meme trend in Pakistan. sick!!
Well Narrated Podcast.
So proud of you shehzad. Keep Going Bhaiya. You are doing Amazing work. And Take Care of your mental health. We Need People Like You. ❤
❤
Thank you Shehzad, you're doing a godly service to this country ❤
❤
Her personality is magical!!
🙌
Hats off to such strong lady 👏 💪..respect n love ❤️ for her
❤
Salute to the parents of dr summayya
Phenominal lady❤❤❤
Best ever podcast content and guest are love.
❤
This Dr sahiba is amazing and incredibly realistic. Shehzad constantly appears to want to run our culture down but she doesn’t take the bait and remains objective.
Well presented
🙌
She's such a strong lady, I couldn't even hear these stories without flinching and she has to live with them. We need more people like her in our society. Thank you Shehzad for this Podcast!
Everything was great until the end, where she blamed people for damaging things like buses, parks, and govt properties. It is also the govt's job to maintain the facilities they're providing as the tax deductions happens on regular basis and not just once like the facilities we are given. Even in first world countries, whenever there is chaos and no consequences people behave similarly and we have seen it. It's the work of law to make sure that public properties are safe and govt's job to maintain them.
🙌
Man, I think this episode earns more respect for you! Thank you for raising the issues!
🙌
It's very painful gd and great interview
🙌
The lady is quite candid on the issue of rape and violence in our society, and she has answered all the questions. Thank you and thank her for that🙏🏽
But,
I have an impression by this lady’s narrative that the police in these cases of violence and rape are very efficient. What abt those crimes being committed by the police and victims and doctors being targeted by the perpetrators when they are influential persons? How the female experts/ doctors are kept safe in this jungle of lawlessness?
Great one Shezad
❤
What a great what a great session . Wish she would have given more gruesome example of what is going around us
, 5/6 examples with details and end result as well good result or bad so it becomes emboss in our mind
Shehzaad Bhaai bahut achha kiya aap ney
Sr
Dr. Ma’am was equally helpful in atleast mentioning not reported cases
Good job dear
Keep it up 👍
🙌
Love your work, Shehzad, and huge respect to Dr. Tariq. But one thing I feel the need to comment on is the discussion at the end. It's remarkable how much weight we want to place on the state when it comes to failures and refuse to acknowledge our societal failings. Dr. Tariq had to insist that the state did, in fact, provide functioning bathrooms. But 'people' (staff or visitors) keep breaking them.
❤
More power to this wonder woman, May she be blessed
Shahzad sahib! You are doing great job 👏 well done 👏 i salute you 👏
❤