Breaking Bad - Letting Jane Die (S2E12) | Rotten Tomatoes TV

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 3 чер 2021
  • Breaking Bad - Letting Jane Die: Walter (Bryan Cranston) watches Jane (Krysten Ritter) die.
    BUY THE SERIES: www.fandangonow.com/details/1...
    Watch the best Breaking Bad scenes & clips:
    • Breaking Bad | TV Scen...
    US Air Date: 2008
    Network: AMC
    Starring: Aaron Paul, Bryan Cranston, Krysten Ritter
    Director: Colin Bucksey
    © Sony
    ► Learn more about this show on Rotten Tomatoes: www.rottentomatoes.com/tv/brea...
    What to Watch Next:
    ► Certified Fresh TV: bit.ly/2FC8sQi
    ► Top TV Dramas: bit.ly/2HSMnOs
    ► Most Anticipated Shows: bit.ly/2GQb8cq
    ► TV Shows by Channel & Streaming Platform: bit.ly/2GKXHuv
    More Rotten Tomatoes:
    ► Subscribe to ROTTEN TOMATOES TV: bit.ly/2qTF6ZY
    ► Subscribe to the ROTTEN TOMATOES NEWSLETTER: www.rottentomatoes.com/newsle...
    ► Follow us on TWITTER: bit.ly/2mpschF
    ► Like us on FACEBOOK: bit.ly/2COySMI
    ► Follow us on INSTAGRAM: bit.ly/2FlxGC6
    Rotten Tomatoes TV delivers Fresh TV at a click! Subscribe now for the best trailers, clips, sneak peeks, and binge guides for shows you love and the upcoming series and TV movies that should be on your radar.
  • Фільми й анімація

КОМЕНТАРІ • 729

  • @Twofirmfeet1024
    @Twofirmfeet1024 2 роки тому +3497

    Moral of the story: meth is fine, heroin is not

    • @westyard.1517
      @westyard.1517 2 роки тому +2

      If you knew anything about drugs you'd understand that heroin (opiate) is a lot easier to overdose and die of than meth (amphetamine). Amphetamines just boost your brain and cns while opiates literally sedate your entire body, even your respiratory system (that's how people OD, they stop breathing).

    • @barnacleboi2595
      @barnacleboi2595 2 роки тому +125

      @@westyard.1517 Yep, very fine line between catching a beautiful nod and overdosing. Basically, makes your brain feel so good that it loses the ability to accurately sense the CO2 levels in the body. Even kills the pain of suffocation. Dark.

    • @jonathangetachew1522
      @jonathangetachew1522 2 роки тому +125

      I don't know much about drugs, but one thing I do know, both meth and heroin can and probably will kill you, but since heroin is usually injected as opposed to meth or at least in Jesse's case, it'll probably kill you faster.

    • @CallMeX881
      @CallMeX881 Рік тому +13

      i only do alcohol can someone tell me the difference between the 2?

    • @miranha3872
      @miranha3872 Рік тому +6

      Yeah, if u use heroin, be VERY carefully, to not choke 👍

  • @roudyman777
    @roudyman777 5 місяців тому +1275

    Bryan Cranston has come out and said this was the hardest scene to film because he saw his own daughter in Jane. Completely heartbreaking.

    • @neilpemberton5523
      @neilpemberton5523 3 місяці тому +6

      ​@gonez.r You obviously have no kids.

    • @EirwenVivantel
      @EirwenVivantel 3 місяці тому +34

      ​@gonez.r no but Jane's actor is a young woman, so it must have made Bryan think of his own child and what she could've been like. A lot of parents think of there children when bad things happen to younger people or people in general

    • @roudyman777
      @roudyman777 3 місяці тому +3

      @@EirwenVivantel 💯

    • @monhi64
      @monhi64 2 місяці тому +1

      @@EirwenVivantel I know I know but you don’t just see your daughter in every youngish woman. Nor does it explain why he didn’t see his kids in any of the other young deaths. Possible she had some level of substance situation although she would be quite young for that. It was the first of supervillain Walt so I could definitely see it being a harder scene

    • @EirwenVivantel
      @EirwenVivantel 2 місяці тому +2

      @@monhi64 Mkay

  • @abdulqudz89
    @abdulqudz89 2 роки тому +3683

    it's mad to know that bryan cranston actually cried for fifteen minutes after shooting this scene.

  • @rgkong8783
    @rgkong8783 9 місяців тому +1166

    I always loved the detail of Walt getting scared for Jane and trying to help her for that moment.

    • @haydaruysal9416
      @haydaruysal9416 7 місяців тому +104

      There were a lot of thoughts in walt's mind.. He was going to help her by İnstict but he thought for a moment before help...

    • @MrSir07
      @MrSir07 7 місяців тому +149

      Walt was trying to fight Heisenberg, but unfortunately Walt lost.

    • @alessandroofthemediterranean
      @alessandroofthemediterranean 7 місяців тому +17

      ​@@MrSir07deep

    • @naegleriafowleri2230
      @naegleriafowleri2230 6 місяців тому +67

      @@alessandroofthemediterranean not really and that's what a lot of people get wrong, they think is switch or double personality is NOT walt was always heisenberg since he was born, since high school since grey matter, he was always like this, he simply repressed it, put on a mask, this was ALWAYS his real personality that's why he always felt bitter about the grey matter and why he left gretchen, he didn't like that she was rich and all this life that he couldn't, he always wanted that, his cancer liberated him and freed him to be who he always was. That's why despite having made millions, already had enough money, he continued, he always wanted power, wealth, etc that's why he left gretchen

    • @animemanXLK
      @animemanXLK 4 місяці тому +27

      He knew Jane was getting in the way and wanted her gone. He obviously thought letting her choke was easier and less complicated than actually helping her.

  • @Hickory_Dickory_Cock
    @Hickory_Dickory_Cock Рік тому +1892

    The fact that she opens her eyes as she dies too see Walt just standing over her is chilling 🥶

    • @dogsmith
      @dogsmith Рік тому +320

      I don't think she was looking at him. I think she was already gone.

    • @BingTheKing
      @BingTheKing 9 місяців тому +30

      @@dogsmithyou’re right

    • @ImGazu
      @ImGazu 9 місяців тому +57

      She was already dead at that point.

    • @zidanemedeiros6196
      @zidanemedeiros6196 8 місяців тому +57

      She was already dead. It was just a body's reaction

    • @karriemramzy9256
      @karriemramzy9256 8 місяців тому +7

      Nah she was already dead

  • @gradyspencer3943
    @gradyspencer3943 4 місяці тому +501

    This is the moment Jane became Diesenberg

  • @drxela123
    @drxela123 2 роки тому +1807

    I know it's a meme to say on every video "This is when he became Heisenberg," etc, but I genuinely believe this is the moment that set Walt's soul onto the path of darkness. Up until this point, he was making bad decisions because he felt like he had to. He didn't want his family to end up poor after he died so he did what he felt he had to do, regardless of the consequences.
    However, this was in my mind the first calculated move he makes. He wasn't trying to protect himself, he wasn't forced into a situation, he just notices that Jane starts to die, almost goes to save her and then realises things will be easier for him with Jesse if she dies. So he makes the calculated decision that her dying simply makes things easier, not because it absolutely had to do it.

    • @Overthinking-rain
      @Overthinking-rain Рік тому +94

      He let Jane die because he didn't want Jesse to leave the business and go somewhere else with her, As you say, everything would have been easier for Walt if she died but it was an evil act not to have saved her

    • @craigsmart1986
      @craigsmart1986 Рік тому +160

      She threatened to expose him even after he gave Jesse the money, so he kinda was forced into it.

    • @tuneboyz5634
      @tuneboyz5634 Рік тому +52

      Walt did the right thing

    • @TheBusttheboss
      @TheBusttheboss Рік тому +21

      He was making bad decisions that he did not have to way before this. They were just less morally significant bad decisions than this one.

    • @drxela123
      @drxela123 Рік тому +14

      @@TheBusttheboss Give me an example so we can discuss it. I'm genuinely curious, because I truly felt that this was the first one that really solidified him as a villain.

  • @barsdover6905
    @barsdover6905 2 роки тому +3033

    He actually killed Jane himself by shaking Jesse resulting of Jane fallin to her back

    • @945user2
      @945user2 2 роки тому +134

      yeah also noticed this

    • @DTheCritical
      @DTheCritical 2 роки тому +256

      @@945user2 They wanted to make it more morally grey if its his fault

    • @orangepotatoleo
      @orangepotatoleo 2 роки тому +13

      Woah 🤯

    • @captaindesperatehousewife7138
      @captaindesperatehousewife7138 Рік тому +350

      Jane DID this to herself, she took the drugs, leading to her ending up in this situation. If you wanna blame Walter for her death, might as well blame Jane's father having her and causing her death too.
      With that being said, I suppose IF Walter could have done something to save her at that moment, you could say he's a bad person. However, she still caused her death...

    • @benmoffatt5424
      @benmoffatt5424 Рік тому +96

      @@captaindesperatehousewife7138 This comment is bullshit lol. She has a heroin addiction for goodness sake. If you’re going to point the finger at anyone, then either Jesse is to blame, as he’s the one that caused her to spiral and turn back to the needle or Walt is to blame, as he literally could of saved her but chose not to for his own selfish reasons.

  • @Beatlemania202
    @Beatlemania202 2 роки тому +530

    It’s sad because she could’ve gotten help and was already doing good being sober before she was with Jesse

    • @relyes327
      @relyes327 2 місяці тому +13

      Yes but on the night they were supposed to run with the moneys she wanted to shoot the remaining H down their vains and absolutely heartbreakingly still succumbs to the addiction. It was a perfect storm of her relapse via Jesse and being shaken by Walt to create a horrific end for her. I’ll always maintain that Walt did what he did mainly for himself but also Jesse since he was going down the same path however it still is unforgivable to let Jane die like that. Great show

    • @markygg2441
      @markygg2441 Місяць тому +4

      i doubt it maybe let's say they manage to get clean both but question is for how long? what happens if their money runs out or they fight one way or another one of them gonna slip up back to their old ways

  • @SurrealScotsman
    @SurrealScotsman Рік тому +251

    2:14 - Goodbye Walt, hello Heisenberg.

    • @riya6207
      @riya6207 5 місяців тому +4

      Nah Walter stood on business in this scene fr

    • @abcdefzhij
      @abcdefzhij Місяць тому

      Moggay!

    • @rogerrocha6962
      @rogerrocha6962 Місяць тому +2

      This is the moment when he realized he wasn't going back to be Walt. He just started to hide Heisenberg when he had to

  • @Jackal_El_Lobo34
    @Jackal_El_Lobo34 6 місяців тому +214

    I love the Brian Cranston's facial expressive performance. No dialogue and you can still tell what Walt was thinking when he chose to let Jane die. Going from crying/self hate like "what have I done" to sudden internal reicomposer and silent justification emphasizing a "it had to be done" thought process.

    • @BROWNlES
      @BROWNlES 3 місяці тому +7

      Walt and Heisenberg conflicting. Brilliantly portrayed.

  • @tjyoyo3
    @tjyoyo3 2 роки тому +497

    If Walt let her live he’d most likely lose Jesse in the long run as he becomes more and more addicted to heroin. It’s just such an insane ripple effect that transpired after letting her die.

    • @yumnykiddd1312
      @yumnykiddd1312 4 місяці тому +10

      Her dad wouldn't have been neglected at his job that caused 2 planes to collide

    • @ImMisogynistic
      @ImMisogynistic 3 місяці тому +9

      @@yumnykiddd1312not walts fault in any way bro lmao

    • @landondixon3739
      @landondixon3739 3 місяці тому +9

      @@ImMisogynisticyes it kinda was. The guy was well respected with air traffic control and only accidentally let the planes crash because his daughter Jane died. Jane died indirectly because of Walter, if he hasn’t broke into Jessie’s house and shook Jessie to try to wake him up, he wouldn’t have knocked Jane onto her back and she wouldn’t have died

    • @INeatFreak
      @INeatFreak 3 місяці тому +4

      @@landondixon3739 maybe if he was a good parent, then Jane wouldn't be doing Heroin don't you think? And also why did he go to work while still grieving over her daughter, knowing he can not perform well for this work? It was definetly his fault not Walt's that those planes collided.

    • @landondixon3739
      @landondixon3739 3 місяці тому +13

      @@INeatFreak bro that’s not how heroin addiction works. Tons of people who come from good homes and supportive parents become addicts.

  • @erikiceberg
    @erikiceberg Рік тому +143

    This left my soul hurting for entire DAYS after watching this episode.

  • @DeepakPandey-cx5sf
    @DeepakPandey-cx5sf 11 місяців тому +154

    The scene before this death scene with Jane's father and Walt at bar makes it even scarier to watch. Dude!

  • @engineer8363
    @engineer8363 2 роки тому +415

    This is the moment Jane died.

    • @mob4556
      @mob4556 2 роки тому +91

      This is the moment Sherlock Holmes has joined the chat

    • @Centsmade
      @Centsmade 2 роки тому +19

      What makes you say that ?

    • @remoobko8440
      @remoobko8440 2 роки тому +1

      It foreshadowed her funeral.

    • @bobplanderlinde329
      @bobplanderlinde329 2 роки тому +7

      @@mob4556 hahahaha clever counter

    • @-BuddyGuy
      @-BuddyGuy 2 роки тому +7

      @@mob4556 He's an engineer he just ran some calculations and presented his results, whether they are obvious or not is more of a question for the guys over in marketing

  • @smokelife6315
    @smokelife6315 3 роки тому +384

    Jane crossed Heisenberg.

    • @Radimunto
      @Radimunto 2 роки тому +19

      No, she crossed an overdose. Heisenberg being there was just a coincidence. If he wouldn't have been there, she would've died anyway.

    • @7Saucy
      @7Saucy 2 роки тому +103

      @@Radimunto probably not. In an episode before this happens, Jessie explains how they need to lay together on their sides to prevent them the possibility of choking on their own vomit when laying on their back. Walt pushed Jessie which caused Jane to lay on her back and she choked on her own vomit. If Walt didn't show up, she probably wouldn't have died

    • @gabrielsandoval7331
      @gabrielsandoval7331 2 роки тому +1

      @@7Saucy that summarizes it very well.

    • @relyes327
      @relyes327 4 місяці тому +5

      @@7SaucyI still think they would’ve died of overdose if Walt didn’t shake Jesse. They were obviously addicted and with that much money and the urge to use they wouldn’t be able to resist no matter where they could’ve went. Rip great scene

    • @Adrabit
      @Adrabit 4 місяці тому

      ​@@relyes327+1

  • @hulkjelly6876
    @hulkjelly6876 2 роки тому +226

    In the end, Walt made the right decision for Heisenberg.

  • @Familliarsurroundings
    @Familliarsurroundings 6 місяців тому +98

    Every single performance in this show made by Brian Cranston is just heart wrenching. Barely any words were spoken in this scene and you can still FEEL how he feels and almost hear his thoughts. He is a GODLY actor

    • @KB-sv7fm
      @KB-sv7fm 6 місяців тому

      Walter is a monster.

  • @ILOVEGOOOOOOLD
    @ILOVEGOOOOOOLD 9 місяців тому +95

    wow I never noticed the shaking of Jesse to wake up is what put Jane on her back. Walt practically murdered her

    • @evanjacob5416
      @evanjacob5416 8 місяців тому +25

      Yes, however it was unwittingly. He was given a chance to save her after that but ultimately chose not to.

    • @Mihael_Lugo
      @Mihael_Lugo 19 днів тому +3

      @@evanjacob5416 That's still murder. How he killed her it's not relevent

    • @user-mg7wh8zq6v
      @user-mg7wh8zq6v 15 днів тому +1

      ​@@Mihael_Lugoi disagree, clearly the cause of her death is the overdose

    • @TheDarkestStarDC
      @TheDarkestStarDC 12 днів тому +2

      @@user-mg7wh8zq6vhonestly I work in harm reduction, this isn’t an overdose. She would have lived had he not been there. She died of asphyxiation from throwing up, which she would not have done had he not caused her to move. An overdose would have been her stopping breathing, not throwing up. It may not have been premeditated but Walt caused her death unequivocally

    • @enanny0616
      @enanny0616 9 днів тому

      @@Mihael_Lugoit’s not murder, Walt has nothing to do with her overdose

  • @jwhittle91
    @jwhittle91 2 роки тому +236

    Walt made a full measure decision

    • @chetankeshari
      @chetankeshari 2 роки тому +5

      What scale did he use?

    • @zoxyy.1x
      @zoxyy.1x 2 роки тому

      @@chetankeshari wym

    • @DTheCritical
      @DTheCritical 2 роки тому

      @@zoxyy.1x Measuring you can use scales to measure/quantify something

    • @zoxyy.1x
      @zoxyy.1x 2 роки тому

      @@DTheCritical k

    • @tjyoyo3
      @tjyoyo3 2 роки тому

      Zoxyy ж wym wym

  • @phantomslay5612
    @phantomslay5612 4 місяці тому +20

    That one moment where Walt cries when he realizes that he didn’t save Jane right as she chokes to death really changes the scene for me. He let her die but he wasn’t proud of what he did.

  • @tomorowsnobodys
    @tomorowsnobodys 2 роки тому +501

    Hardest scene to watch in the whole series

    • @canadianmeatpie8245
      @canadianmeatpie8245 2 роки тому +47

      It was Walter at his most pure evil

    • @bootes33
      @bootes33 2 роки тому +8

      @@canadianmeatpie8245 I feel this is bad but also maybe worse he poisoned Brock, who only survived by accident really

    • @nunyabiz2016
      @nunyabiz2016 2 роки тому

      Not really, I was glad she died. She was a big threat to Walt

    • @bryang473
      @bryang473 Рік тому +112

      nah this has nothing on skylar singing to Ted

    • @NicholasShilabro
      @NicholasShilabro Рік тому +1

      It was disgusting

  • @BlancaPaloma26
    @BlancaPaloma26 8 місяців тому +27

    Omg I never noticed that he accidentally turned her on her back. That's why she choked, he really did kill her.

  • @lampham5525
    @lampham5525 8 місяців тому +87

    The fact her death changed Jesse to become a better person, Walt did many evil thing for Jesse but also helped him became a better person than him

  • @mr.thunder1219
    @mr.thunder1219 6 місяців тому +210

    walt's face as she dies is so haunting. You can see the panic in his eyes. Then there's like this repressed relief. And then the guilt just pours out.
    Also I always loved the fact that before this scene walt was with her dad at the bar

  • @basedjj93
    @basedjj93 4 місяці тому +121

    Walt was sick af for this. Even if jane was bad for Jesse. This is just absolutely inhumane

    • @mohamedomar4824
      @mohamedomar4824 Місяць тому

      He couldn’t interfere

    • @butteredsalmonella
      @butteredsalmonella Місяць тому

      Can't believe a drug kingpin would do something as inhumane as this...

  • @Freglum
    @Freglum 11 місяців тому +68

    “Walter don’t save her! It’s a cannon event!”

  • @mydeadtrim
    @mydeadtrim 4 місяці тому +21

    i like how in the show it’s up to you to interpret why walt let jane die
    maybe he did it to control jesse more
    maybe he viewed jane as a parasite to jesse and didn’t want him to use the hard drugs anymore and eventually he himself ODing
    maybe he viewed jane as a distraction
    who knows there’s many instances of walt going out of his way to help jesse and many more instances of him completely ruining his life

    • @relyes327
      @relyes327 4 місяці тому +7

      I feel like Jesse and Jane, two crackheads who’ve built an addiction to heroin with a big bag of money, were destined to die by overdose even if Walt saved Jane. Still doesn’t make it any easier to watch Walt’s internal conflict

    • @mydeadtrim
      @mydeadtrim 4 місяці тому +4

      @@relyes327 yea exactly he wanted to help but something stopped him, me personally i think walt viewed jane as a free ticket for jesse OD’ing.
      I say this because earlier Walt was very hesitant in giving 600k to jesse not because he didn’t want to but because he said he’d end up shooting it all. I’m not defending walt for all the other terrible things he’s done to him but i think i’m this case he was protecting jesse

    • @quieteron1516
      @quieteron1516 2 місяці тому

      He wanted his partner back and saw her as the cause of Jesse becoming a Junkie and hoped the OD would set him straight seeing what it can do

  • @salihahjihad1240
    @salihahjihad1240 Місяць тому +6

    I use to hate Jane but now I understand. She was fine until she met Jesse, Jesse didn’t fully understand of her chip and how her being sober was important. If he did, he wouldn’t had done it in front of her or do it at all. She wanted him to go to a meeting with her but he thought it was stupid. It just makes me sad because the person she was before Jesse was a person trying to be good versus when she got back on it, she would say, do, or even miss things to simply lay in bed with Jesse and get high all day. It breaks my heart💔

  • @dayschange2
    @dayschange2 2 роки тому +115

    This is such an uncomfortable scene to watch. Every time, I keep hoping that Walt will do the right thing. He killed off part of his soul letting this happen. And he'd been doing that for awhile by this point, so much that some of the pieces went without notice, but you KNOW he felt it here.

  • @animalcrossingfan0768
    @animalcrossingfan0768 5 місяців тому +24

    Jane’s dad probably wishes he called the cops on Jane after this

  • @merlinho0t
    @merlinho0t 10 місяців тому +38

    I can watching fictional people getting shot and stabbed all day, it’s these kinds of deaths that make my stomach queasy.

  • @therealuncleowen2588
    @therealuncleowen2588 Місяць тому +5

    Watching this scene with my then wife was very eye opening. I feel strongly that Walt was morally compelled to help Jane. My ex-wife said that nobody has any responsibility to help anybody else in life. I was already suspecting that she was an unfeeling psychopath and that conversation confirmed it. She's beautiful and very charming, but it is all an act. Every interaction is transactional for her. She's the mother of my children. I say as little as possible about her to them. It breaks my heart to watch each of them come to realize, as they grow up, that their mother feels no actual emotion towards them. I do my best as their father, but there's a void I can't fill. Her next husband is starting to see it too.
    When we were going through the divorce, I had to realize that she would destroy me without remorse if I didn't give her what she wanted. She twice falsely accused me of assault, the second time I believe the only reason she withdrew the charges was because she realized I would be unable to pay child support while in prison. I don't think I'll ever be able to trust someone enough to marry again.

  • @jayh-gb7gz
    @jayh-gb7gz 3 місяці тому +5

    i’ll never stop being heartbroken over this scene and her death

  • @martin310186
    @martin310186 2 роки тому +369

    Outstanding acting by Brian Cranston! From 1:05 - 1:32 you can actually see, how "Walther" is struggling with "Heisenberg". We witness the inner conflict - ending with Heisenberg taking the upper hand and, well... let's Jane die.
    That whole scene is perfectly accompanied with a great score. That's why we simply just love Breaking Bad

    • @zoxyy.1x
      @zoxyy.1x 2 роки тому +17

      It’s “Bryan” and “Walter”

    • @lewislw4344
      @lewislw4344 2 роки тому +16

      Its not that exactly. Like, he is an amazing actor, but in that scene he said in an interview that he suddenly saw his own irl daughter in Jane and that image just hurt him so much that he couldn't help but cry. He said it himself in an interview.

    • @Akizine
      @Akizine Рік тому +2

      wultuh

    • @pazhampori2586
      @pazhampori2586 7 місяців тому

      Bruh he is just standing

    • @tastypotato9272
      @tastypotato9272 6 місяців тому

      Put your d away Walther

  • @yulian7435
    @yulian7435 2 роки тому +188

    don't forget jane threatened and blackmailed walt that if didn't give more money to jessey, she would ruine his life and "burn him to the ground".

    • @serkanturkmen6342
      @serkanturkmen6342 Рік тому +22

      Yes ! Jane the Devil

    • @CrocodileWhispers
      @CrocodileWhispers Рік тому +59

      and walt would have to take that threat seriously because a heroin junkie will literally do anything for a heroin high

    • @logger22
      @logger22 Рік тому +15

      It really just shows how both Jesse and Jane were ignorant and desperate for the money and their junky lives. Walt wants to do things more clean and subtle while Jane pretty much takes advantage of Jesse’s half and gets so desperate despite not realizing how stupid and selfish it was to grab the money and continue doing drugs and wanting to spend it all immediately. Even her threat just makes the money useless, and risks losing Jesse as he is affiliated with Walt.

    • @JaneDoe-xx6hp
      @JaneDoe-xx6hp 11 місяців тому +22

      Still not an excuse to allow someone to willingly die. He was going to save her, but chose selfishness instead. Jane wasn't perfect, but he still chose to let her die. He thought about helping, going towards it like it was instinct, but then chooses not to. Not to mention, none of this would have happened if he wasn't too proud to take Gretchen and Elliot's offer.

    • @bangtannies
      @bangtannies 8 місяців тому +13

      ​​@@JaneDoe-xx6hp"none of this would've happened" this show itself wouldn't happen if Walt took their offer pls💀 also don't blame it all on Walt when Jane was already killing herself by taking drugs. She didn't care about her own life how can u say others to do it when she herself didn't

  • @adamatherton3584
    @adamatherton3584 2 роки тому +215

    My thoughts are that Walt simply made a quick, full measure decision on Jesse’s behalf. I may be filling in the blanks, but it appears as though Walt wanted what’s best for Jesse and if he had left Jesse to his own decisions, it likely would’ve led to his death.
    It’s my opinion, but it feels that Walt chose inaction as a way to save Jesse from himself.
    This also fits with Walt’s personality of superiority of feeling like he knows what’s best for Jesse.

    • @greggh
      @greggh 2 роки тому +36

      Walt simply made a quick, full measure decision on WALT'S behalf.

    • @javxion6576
      @javxion6576 Рік тому

      What you have to do is to throw him in rehabilitation like in season 3

    • @AJ-er3yz
      @AJ-er3yz 8 місяців тому +3

      *whats best for WALT himself.

    • @warrenc1829
      @warrenc1829 6 місяців тому +1

      She was blackmailing Walt…

    • @aj8124
      @aj8124 2 місяці тому

      at the ending of it all she would’ve became a HUGE liability so Walt did what he had to do & i can respect it. not only he prevented Jesse from possibly OD’ing but he also prevented Jane from causing any problems in the future in terms of future blackmail etc. plus i hated her smug face & it was clear that she only wanted Jesse for the money. she didn’t care about him enough to even introduce him to her father but as soon as she found out that he had BANK to collect all of a sudden you claiming him?

  • @KempoYoutubeChannel
    @KempoYoutubeChannel 3 роки тому +261

    Walt cries in pity rather than shock. He is not really upset whatsoever

    • @billyjoel9313
      @billyjoel9313 2 роки тому +97

      really in the moment I think Bryan Cranston was crying from pure terror because he imagined it was his daughter OD'ing and it just killed him.

    • @zoxyy.1x
      @zoxyy.1x 2 роки тому +1

      @@billyjoel9313 yeah

    • @lewislw4344
      @lewislw4344 2 роки тому +14

      @@billyjoel9313 Yep. He said this himself in an interview

    • @marcusvergara6193
      @marcusvergara6193 Рік тому +3

      If you knew anything of the show, you would know that’s untrue.

    • @cubchoobii8350
      @cubchoobii8350 3 місяці тому +1

      Did you watch the show?

  • @shelbycarow7707
    @shelbycarow7707 3 місяці тому +13

    This was one of his first dark Heisenberg moments.

    • @tusharagarwal5306
      @tusharagarwal5306 2 місяці тому +3

      His first dark moment was him killing Krazy 8 and suggesting to dissolve Emilio's body in acid.

    • @penjamin1479
      @penjamin1479 2 місяці тому +2

      Remember that time he decided to profit off of people's addiction to life ruining drugs only to benefit his own family? lol.

    • @zachryder3150
      @zachryder3150 18 днів тому

      Pretty privilege strikes again!

  • @animemanXLK
    @animemanXLK 4 місяці тому +7

    I just noticed when Walter shakes Jesse to wake him up he pushes Jane onto her back were she vommits and chokes to death. So he didn't just watch her die and choose to do nothing he was the reason she started choking in the first place

  • @artbyfinn7757
    @artbyfinn7757 4 місяці тому +11

    In the scene where they celebrated about getting the money and going clean, I actually felt already sad when they watched the drugs with a doubt "yeah we can do that..."
    I knew they wouldn't immediately, and the next time was fatal 😢

  • @heru-deshet359
    @heru-deshet359 2 роки тому +30

    What happens when you don't listen to your father.

    • @suckston
      @suckston Рік тому

      he comes and lets you die? you do realize that walter killed her by pushing her on her back and then not lifting a finger while she choked on her own vomit?

  • @josephst.george7841
    @josephst.george7841 Місяць тому +2

    First time I saw this scene I had to pause the show for a few minutes to digest it

  • @HunnyBunz1138
    @HunnyBunz1138 Місяць тому +2

    This is honestly one of the most brutally heartbreaking moments of the show

  • @themcusbiggestfan3210
    @themcusbiggestfan3210 8 місяців тому +7

    "Let It Die, Let It Die!"
    - The Lorax Movie

  • @hairbruh4915
    @hairbruh4915 9 місяців тому +32

    He didnt let her die, he killed her. 0:34 he flips her over, which then causes her to choke on her own vomit.

    • @bangtannies
      @bangtannies 8 місяців тому +22

      Nah stop blaming Walt. Jane took the heroine,and died. It was her decision to choose this path,also she was dragging Jesse into this path. She was nasty

    • @hairbruh4915
      @hairbruh4915 8 місяців тому +11

      @@bangtannies Regardless of where her path would lead here, it doesnt change the fact that walter killed her. Stop being a walt apologist.

    • @jessielee1803
      @jessielee1803 8 місяців тому +24

      ​@@bangtanniesjesse dragged her down first. She was clean for 18 months before they met. She started back again when jesse was doing meth.

    • @nuabe8285
      @nuabe8285 8 місяців тому +14

      Ha yes I remember that scene when Walt injected heroin in her and Jesse’s bodies, truly heartbreaking to see him drug them without their consent

    • @hairbruh4915
      @hairbruh4915 8 місяців тому +10

      @@nuabe8285 you can try to frame it anyway you please, it will not change the fact that he flipped her over and deliberately didn’t flip her back

  • @Qoxvjskabzfaizb
    @Qoxvjskabzfaizb 2 місяці тому +2

    this scene was freaking haunting bro, I had to pause it for a second to take a breather

  • @Ironheart73
    @Ironheart73 Місяць тому +3

    Goes to show that acts of evil is not just a matter of comission but also omission. This is the point Walter really became Evil.

  • @georgefisherfan
    @georgefisherfan 4 місяці тому +4

    In the original script, he was supposed to push directly Jane in order to kill her, but Cranston said to Vince Gilligan watchers would have hated his character at this point so they decided to kill her indirectly, by pushing Jesse and making her lay accidentally on her back.

  • @FoTwentyVlogs
    @FoTwentyVlogs 3 місяці тому +5

    1:08 that shot is lowkey chilling

  • @ntaentae6264
    @ntaentae6264 2 місяці тому +3

    This is probably the saddest death in the series tbh

  • @madsecond5025
    @madsecond5025 8 місяців тому +15

    It's not that Walt let Jane die, he actually killed her by shaking Jesse and turning Jane on her back, which lead to death by choking. One could argue those two would have been in New Zealand the next day if Walt didn't go to Jesses house.

  • @miguelporras8366
    @miguelporras8366 3 місяці тому +15

    At the beginning of this episode, Walt was very cautious putting Holly on her side to avoid choking.
    Then he lets Jane die by letting her looking upwards.
    Twisted turn

    • @Frank-yb2hw
      @Frank-yb2hw 3 місяці тому

      nice detail

    • @VictorIV0310
      @VictorIV0310 3 місяці тому +5

      Phoenix is the episode title. One is born while another dies.

    • @miguelporras8366
      @miguelporras8366 3 місяці тому

      @@VictorIV0310 touché

  • @cameronbrowne8710
    @cameronbrowne8710 6 місяців тому +5

    He didn't kill Jane by shaking jesse. He killed Jane by allowing her to lay on her back and actively aspirate on her on vomit. At that point he might as well have shot her in the head

    • @KB-sv7fm
      @KB-sv7fm 6 місяців тому +2

      Heisenberg realized that a dead Jane could NEVER rat him out to the DEA. Any idiot would have rolled Jane on her side so that she could clear her throat.

  • @Gabagool93
    @Gabagool93 4 місяці тому +5

    People always talk about how this changed Walt to Heisenberg but I feel like Jesse changed to a darker and more sad character after this and never came back. The entire dynamic of this show changed in this scene from a dark comedy to dark horror.

  • @carlosgonzales386
    @carlosgonzales386 Місяць тому +2

    Tutorial on what not to do when your homie is dying.

  • @peterwolfe2328
    @peterwolfe2328 Місяць тому +1

    At the end of Walt's cry, you can see some of Heisenberg fighting through. The way he holds his brow and turns his neck, on full display during the Say My Name scene. You can see that persona fighting for control.

  • @shalafi1849
    @shalafi1849 6 місяців тому +8

    One of the best scenes of the show

  • @roddydykes7053
    @roddydykes7053 2 місяці тому +2

    Grossest/hardest to watch minute or so of the show.

  • @ok.6539
    @ok.6539 9 місяців тому +21

    The truth, as harsh as it can be, is that this would eventually have happened, even without Walt being present, and considering they now have 480k to spend on heroin, i think it would happen very quickly, likely to both of them. So, in a twisted way Walt not saving her, and 'supporting' Jesse (rescuing him from the drughouse and sending him to the therapy center) most likely saved his life.
    They weren't going to quit together, one (and due to that, both of them) was doomed to die. And if Jane was to die first, without Walts help Jesse would have overdosed/died too eventually. Same thing if Jesse died first, Jane would have od'ed too eventually. They couldn't go on together.

    • @randomperson2680
      @randomperson2680 2 місяці тому

      yeah i also think so, yes walt is the one to blame here but even if he didn't inadvertently flip jane on her back, jane and jesse would probably still end up extremely addicted or dead without intervention

  • @Mii.2.0
    @Mii.2.0 2 роки тому +6

    R.I.P Jane. 🙏🕊

  • @abdul-azizfawaz541
    @abdul-azizfawaz541 Рік тому +5

    This is the moment Walt became Heisenberg

  • @benoitbrown9400
    @benoitbrown9400 4 місяці тому +25

    You can try to moralize it with "drugs are bad" or "Walt saved Jesse by letting it happen" but the fact is they were sleeping in that side position specifically to avoid this danger, which is actually a reasonable thing to do. The only reason Jane x'ed is because Walt overstepped his bounds, same as he always does. Someone does something bad in a smart way, Walt messes it up out of his own selfishness.

    • @prettyboishah2898
      @prettyboishah2898 Місяць тому

      Dang I didn't actually know that. So ppl who do drugs like this heroin actually sleep on their side to prevent this? Is this a real thing sleeping on your side?

    • @mpownage4806
      @mpownage4806 Місяць тому +2

      @@prettyboishah2898even if you use alcohol or anything that induces vomiting/nausea its a good idea to sleep on your side and have something in your back to not roll over

    • @dwellsinthedark4056
      @dwellsinthedark4056 Місяць тому +1

      Trying to empathize with a junkie drug abuser saying "They were laying in that side position to avoid danger" is crazy. They were shooting mad heroin up their arms, if not that day they'd have died by ODing within the month or worse, hurt someone while they were in fugue state

  • @linbele
    @linbele 2 місяці тому +11

    for added realism, krysten ritter took a few shots of heroine before filming. what a great actor.

  • @prachisharma444
    @prachisharma444 5 місяців тому +3

    I feel so stupid right now after finishing the show. When I watched this episode I thought Walt couldn't help her because if he called an ambulance, then Jesse would garner attention from the police for using Meth and Heroine, which would put him back on DEA's radar. What I didn't know was that a person having an OD could be saved by anyone else without any doctor/expert. I just realised that Walt could have saved her but purposely let her die.

  • @decayedphoenix8865
    @decayedphoenix8865 6 місяців тому +20

    Little did the viewer know, that there was not one, but two deaths here. One was, obviously jane, but the other was Walter. After this episode, only Heisenberg remained.

    • @redshot5403
      @redshot5403 4 місяці тому +2

      To me, Walter white died when he laughed maniacally after Skyler gave away the money

    • @decayedphoenix8865
      @decayedphoenix8865 4 місяці тому +1

      @@redshot5403 eh, idk

    • @gman955
      @gman955 4 місяці тому

      @@decayedphoenix8865No no, redshot’s got a point.. The man historically laughed his weak soul out. At this point in watching Jane die Walt simply had no chiral balance anymore. There was just pure Heisenberg decisions after sitting in that basement

    • @decayedphoenix8865
      @decayedphoenix8865 21 день тому

      ​@@gman955 I'm convinced

  • @KenSamaGomenasai
    @KenSamaGomenasai 4 місяці тому +3

    The moment Heisenberg defeated Walter White once and for all

  • @Ghostsfan420
    @Ghostsfan420 3 місяці тому +9

    Twomad playing overwatch 2

  • @engineear5571
    @engineear5571 3 місяці тому +1

    Man the music in this scene is so atmospheric

  • @riya6207
    @riya6207 5 місяців тому +6

    I cried so hard watching this scene

  • @warrenc1829
    @warrenc1829 6 місяців тому +7

    Best scene in the entire series. So dark.

    • @jackraider1039
      @jackraider1039 5 місяців тому +1

      I actually almost threw up watching it and plus it kind of traumatized me a bit.

  • @Timothy1395
    @Timothy1395 2 місяці тому +2

    This is the first thing that Walt does that is officially considered evil in the show imo. He only gets worse and worse and eventually irredeemably evil by Season 7.

  • @tremblence
    @tremblence 4 місяці тому +7

    The funny thing is------------- and nobody is mentioning this:
    If Walter wasn't there...... she would have died either way........ so yeah he could have saved her, but its worth noting that she would be DEAD if he didn't enter the room
    Ultimately I blame her, as much as I find her beautiful, cute etc........... great acting, great writing, great show

  • @ariell6489
    @ariell6489 Місяць тому +1

    This is when Walter lost his soul.

  • @thecowboy9698
    @thecowboy9698 3 місяці тому +2

    Something to point out is that at this time, Walt let another man's daughter die, while just shortly prior to that, he himself had become a father to a daughter himself.
    When I saw this scene for the first time, it really got to me. I saw a very close relative of mine pass, and this scene brought those memories back.
    Unfortunately, this is where I believe Walter White died, and Heisenberg was truly born. I personally believe it was truly this act of letting Jane die is what hardened Walt.

  • @madtingz2288
    @madtingz2288 Рік тому +18

    i was screaming "roll her overrrrrr"

  • @alihassanahmed8186
    @alihassanahmed8186 2 роки тому +8

    Walt has left the chat
    Heisenberg has entered

  • @gun1987gunn
    @gun1987gunn 3 місяці тому +1

    This is the moment Branston Pickle became Bryan Cranston. Bravo Vince

  • @AdoredGriffin
    @AdoredGriffin 5 місяців тому +4

    Jane Should Have Just Stopped Vomiting SMH 🤦

  • @toastergaming7783
    @toastergaming7783 5 місяців тому +1

    "Xbox, record that" - Aaron Paul

  • @camillelallement3988
    @camillelallement3988 2 роки тому +44

    He killed himself by killing Jane. It's Walter's demise. And the rise of Heisenberg. That's why he is crying.

    • @SOY.O.G
      @SOY.O.G 2 роки тому +4

      Nah he became heisenberg when walt jacked off at the walmart

    • @nrlds268
      @nrlds268 2 роки тому +2

      @@SOY.O.G What?

    • @SOY.O.G
      @SOY.O.G 2 роки тому +3

      @@nrlds268did i stutter??

    • @carlosmachado5532
      @carlosmachado5532 2 роки тому +7

      So... are you saying... *"THIS IS THE EXACT MOMENT THAT WALTER BECOME HEISENBERG"* ?

    • @PlgDctr
      @PlgDctr 2 роки тому

      ThIs Is DuH mOmEnT

  • @reid_fe4r630
    @reid_fe4r630 2 роки тому +5

    Right as I was startimg to warm up to Jane, she dies. :(

  • @UnlicensedGamer
    @UnlicensedGamer 23 дні тому +2

    Its so hard to watch this. My sister died due to something like this and I all I can think of is her like this and no one there to help her. I wish I was there to save her. Its been 07/05/2022 I miss her so much.

  • @Rocket66380
    @Rocket66380 Місяць тому

    This scene talk has much words can do… best show of all time

  • @sygilber
    @sygilber 2 дні тому

    I never noticed that Walt actually shed a tear after Jane died

  • @plutonotdead
    @plutonotdead 21 день тому +1

    imagine if he had asked her father at the bar about his daughter's name, the story might have took a huge turn there because he wouldn't kill her then.

  • @markygg2441
    @markygg2441 Місяць тому +1

    Well once an addict always an addict you put them in bad situation they just go right back

  • @saulgoodman7215
    @saulgoodman7215 2 роки тому +11

    This is the moment Jane died

  • @bernardogonzalez1453
    @bernardogonzalez1453 8 місяців тому +13

    If we pay much attention to Jane's move, is possible to see that is not a credible movement. But stills being an unforgettable scene

  • @stagna1959
    @stagna1959 9 місяців тому +30

    Gus was right : you cant trust junkie, even if he was your best friend, saved your life etc. It is even worse if junkie has a junkie girlfriend and they use drugs together. It is guaranteed disaster . She drags him down even if he by some miracle has mental strenght to get clean and stay clean if he was alone.They could even blackmail Walt together.
    So from business point of view Walt did the right thing. From point of self preservation he did right thing, he did not wanted to get caught which would probably happen if Jane was with Jesse for longer period of time.
    From moral point of view it was of course wrong and even against the law not to help dying drug addict who is choking in her own vomit. But if you enter the world of illegal drug business, you have to forget all moral principles you had before. What was right before becomes wrong and what was wrong before becomes right thing to do if you want to succeed and survive in this harsh world.

    • @jonathanjohnson9611
      @jonathanjohnson9611 7 місяців тому

      Yep. Jesse was willing to turn his back on Walt and let his druggie girlfriend push him around. They would've either blew through the cash in a month, or one of them would of overdosed long before then.
      Can't trust a junkie

    • @richardsmith8790
      @richardsmith8790 5 місяців тому +1

      Well said

    • @ceramikxxx5882
      @ceramikxxx5882 4 місяці тому

      Exactly. Walt let her die because walt was afraid jane being alive would lead jesse to his death.

  • @CodyTravers_
    @CodyTravers_ 4 місяці тому +2

    In one fell swoop, Walt met Gus, got chastized by him for unprofessional behavior, had the biggest drug deal thus far while missing his daughters birth, HAD ANOTHER MAN CARRY HER TO HER BIRTH BY THE WAY, get extorted by Jane, then watch her die shortly after

  • @lordskysixss
    @lordskysixss 7 місяців тому +7

    Jane was a liability, i'm sad for her father though...

  • @antonychigurh8939
    @antonychigurh8939 11 днів тому

    this is the moment

  • @FusionAura232
    @FusionAura232 9 місяців тому +14

    She knew too much and couldn't escape her own physiological prison she created. This was gonna happen one way or another.

  • @flightofthebumblebee9529
    @flightofthebumblebee9529 8 місяців тому +53

    Walt genuinely did care. He wanted both Jesse and Jane to get clean. Jane wasn't hearing it. She needed to go.

    • @youarelife3437
      @youarelife3437 6 місяців тому +12

      she could have been helped still. The writers could have done so much more with this character but they offed her too quick

    • @hdbuckets8154
      @hdbuckets8154 6 місяців тому

      @@youarelife3437I liked her at the start, but she became an unlikeable character after blackmailing Walt and being a greedy asswipe

    • @brockgadao415
      @brockgadao415 5 місяців тому

      You're right.

    • @irvinmorales1409
      @irvinmorales1409 5 місяців тому +6

      ​@@youarelife3437
      Jane had to go since she threatened to expose Walt and was unstable due to her addiction.

    • @youarelife3437
      @youarelife3437 5 місяців тому +1

      @@irvinmorales1409 But more importantly she was the love interest of Jesse. Could have been used so much better. They could have made her change her mind, put her in rehab too. Could have been anythng.

  • @belingonza318
    @belingonza318 2 роки тому +1

    Had to protect his interests .

  • @saturdaysequalsyouth
    @saturdaysequalsyouth 3 місяці тому

    "Well, that was a freebie."

  • @Jeffrey-zb5nq
    @Jeffrey-zb5nq 8 місяців тому +3

    Este fue el punto sin retorno , todas tus acciones te ponen en "El camino"

  • @botep5529
    @botep5529 2 роки тому +14

    And... This is why I sleep on my side

    • @eiyukabe
      @eiyukabe Рік тому +1

      It really is better for you.

    • @coal159
      @coal159 9 місяців тому +1

      She was sleeping on her side, Walt pushed her over

  • @Alispun2003
    @Alispun2003 7 місяців тому

    How come I watched the whole show but never saw this scene wtf