Doing Redstone how Mojang Intended (Then doing it better)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 бер 2021
- I recently purchased the Minecraft guide to redstone, an official Mojang product designed to teach people how to use Redstone. Learning redstone is hard, and every redstone circuit in Minecraft has it's use, with thousands of variations of all the Minecraft redstone circuits. This Mojang Approved redstone guide is a very good starting point, but it definitely has some odd builds! In this Minecraft redstone video we take the Mojang approved redstone contraptions and improve Mojangs redstone.
Inspired by Playing Minecraft How Mojang Intended:
• Beating Minecraft the ...
Buy the book (this is an affiliate link, so I get a small amount for every purchase!):
amzn.to/3111RdZ
Filming channel: / thatmumbojumbo2
Instagram: / officialmumbo
Twitter: / thatmumbojumbo - Ігри
I cannot think of someone more qualified to make this video! :)
I can.
What about...
MysteryOre?
Lol your finnaly back, but not uploading
Huhh.. The legend himself
Hello im an og. I was here at 800 subs! I was the one who suggested mastering 1.9 combat.
Oh yeah
You’re the guy that made the original video
If Mumbo wrote the Minecraft Redstone Manual it would be called “It’s really quite simple.”
*Shut up and take my money*
Meanwhile in the background *Mumbo explaining how simple it is to create 20x5 slime/honey piston gate*
@@typowynieogar The manual is from 2017 so maybe mumbo could ask them for a new edition and he gives input and get named into it?
Genius. I would buy for sure 🔥
Omg I literally said the same thing out loud a few minutes into the video 😂😂😂
Alternate title: “Mumbo replacing all of the redstone dust with observers in Minecraft builds”
Lol
Yes. Lol.
Why is that so true
*Reject redstone. Become observer.*
@@Mapbim indeed
Mojang: This is a redstone clock
Me: thats a weird design for a lag machine.
trident killer
Its a design thats especially popular in 2b2t...
hmmm
@@snailsaredumb9412 hmmmmm mighty suspicous...
yeah I mean the easier design is just like 800 boats
I sometimes forget Mojang actually intended redstone to do stuff, I’ve seen so many crazy contraptions that seem to not be intended that I forget there is some redstone things that are intended
Man idk wtf this means
Exactly.
@@davudedgell2772 Like how there are a lot of redstone machines that will use buggy or unintended concepts (mojang constantly trying to patch out auto-fishers comes to mind)
I heard somewhere that Bedrock redstone was how it's supposed to work but they kept some bugs on java.
@@jackofalltradeshermes if bedrock works as intended, then I’m happy Java got it broken. As a bedrock redstoner, it can say that bedrock redstone is terrible, it’s very buggy and random. One time I built a pillar of observers attached to a slime pillar getting pushed by a piston, these observers powered pistons, it was completely random which pistons actually activated, some would fire, some wouldn’t, and next time it would be different. It’s terrible.
Note: Zombies don't seek shade from sunlight but skeletons do.
this was an old behavior, also the machine will not work with skell too because now they avoid holes in the ground, that's why mumbo used opened trapdoor, so they think that is a full block.
Also only OG remember when water moats are overpowered and protect you from every mob because they simple dont swin.
@@Feorblack Well, undead mobs now sink, so a moat still protects against zombies and skeletons. And if the mpbs cannot get out on the other side (two blocks high) then you still have total safety.
Noted
@@Feorblack skeletons still seek for shade in daytime, I can perfectly see it on my survival world. Also, since the holes still have trapdoors, they should still be able to pathfind, whether the trapdoors are opened or not. I mean, Mumbo showed it himself.
@@CityNaturePig Yeah, moats is a good protective option again since this update, not so overpowered anymore since it do not work against creeper and we also have phantons now.
I remember on early minecraft that I put a moat in every build for safety, also look's cool. Now I simple spam torch everywhere.
“im not entirely sure but its certainly teaching them something”
sounds like school
Yup, that is the entire American schooling system summed up in one sentence
Edit: all the school systems. Happy?
Uehrhehfhe
Hr he yt0
@@thegreatmindgorb8948 indian too XD
@@luidgi1381 yeah!
I like how mumbo still gets surprise how his machine works with him having years of experience
At that point your brain just understands and goes into automatic mode. Like your brain just knows what it needs to do
Welcome to the life of a coder
Welcome to redstone
And coding
I mean, that's honestly Redstone, circuits, and computer programming. All of them are literally, "This should work and it doesn't," and "I don’t think this will work. Oh wait, it does."
@@antmess9789and then think why it worked
Observers, compact ice, and bubble streams really revolutionized redstone and made it far more accessible and less daunting to lower skilled players. It's amazing to see how far this game has come since beta.
idk, as an unskilled redstoner, those things have made advanced redstone a lot MORE daunting for me
How dare they try to write a book without asking you to write it
Truee
@Levi pretty sure the comment was sarcasm.... at least I HOPE it was....
@@BenjaminAnderson21 wooooooosh
@@right7403 I just said, "pretty sure the comment is sarcasm..." so whooshing me is incorrect.
@@BenjaminAnderson21 I meannnnnnn...
THE SACRED TEXTS!
What do you mean?
Sorry i dont know because i never
Gonna Give You Up
Lol get rickrolled 👀
Bruh
Where’s my literally nothing Connor it’s been _Months_ you know what you did
why is the text so scared :/
Don't touch them.
I’m pretty sure the manual was written before observers where added so I’d like to consider that is they had those improvements they would use them
Actually, they have an entire section on observers in the book!
There must have been a new one that was created but I was thinking the exact same thing. I remember the original red stone book coming out when I was like in early middle school or maybe even elementary tbh.
@@jfrogfoot the one from like 2012, red with a somewhat golden redstone texture plastered on the front, with "REDSTONE HANDBOOK" displayed on it? if so, i remember those as well lmao.
This is like going back to the beginner tutorials when you're a maxed out player
Only the OGs remember the old Redstone Handbook
I still have that handbook
I still have it too!
Yea
But what about people who never
gonna give you up
Lol get rickrolled
Same I still got it
I still have all of them
Minecraft redstone handbook: **teaches basic redstone stuff**
Mumbo jumbo redstone tutorials: *i am 4 parallel universe ahead of you*
That book actually shows you QC (without explanation), that's not the most basic thing at all
@F**СК МE - СНЕСK MY РR0FILЕ bot no bad reported
Lol
Armor stand swapper
Mumbo: "This is a winner"
The original armor stand swapper is WAAAAY cheaper, and that's a win for a noob
you don’t have that many armor sets you need to swap on to
do you? as a noob
@@harryhelina9859 I watched the video again after two years of making that comment to give you an answer. Something like that could be ideal for a minigame in which you have teams, each with a colored leather armor. In order to restock the armor, you swap the armor stands.
Generally speaking, no, you won't have more than one standard armor and the one you save in case you die and need to recover your good armor and don't want to go naked.
Just got into redstone for the first time since beta, and it is just crazy how different everything is now. Most of my automated farms are essentially just an observer and piston now, when in the past it would have been some big redstone circuit that I would have just given up on after a few attempts.
Mumbo is like the teacher who says your homework is “good” but then tells you the “correct” way of doing it
Points off for not using the method they taught
And one of the most efficient way to do it..
"Your homework is good, but it can be *BETTER* "
700th like
He is also that cool teacher who gives you points for doing it the taught way then teaches you the easier way you will learn next year
Redstone contraptions in a minecraft book: small, simple and easy to understand
Observers: Allow us to introduce ourselves
the books are written before they added observers if im not wrong so yeah they need to rewrite the book
Observers: "Observe."
observers are simple though? they just send a pulse everytime the block infront of it gets updated
@@sm8tal229 Jea i definetly understand every building and redstone contraption with observers.... But a Book would be very helpful just saying
Comparators:
I've always had great success just matching the button to the surface it's on. I usually do this in mountain sides where there's exposed stone, a slightly tucked away stone button is almost invisible if you're not looking for it.
There were way older versions of these books, I had them, I'm guessing they updated them and didn't really improve upon much, hence the lack of observers and buttons on the floor and stuff.
I think that book came out around 1.8
Just like coding, on first day they teach you how to print string "hello world" then you realize there's a ton of ways to print "hello world"
An accurate analogy
True
Not true at all D:
Good Analogy
@@Temerold_se To build off that, not only can you use built in print functions, the second you get around to displaying that text in an actual window, the various ways you can show "Hello World" become technically endless
Next video: I wrote my own "How to redstone" book and successfully sold it to Mojang
It would make no sales because it would be so complicated
@@c0mae its actually really simple
Maybe it could be the redstone guide book to pro redstoners
@@c0mae Mumbo knows really easy redstone too. That is, easy for us smoothbrains
More like how to do observers
This is science vs. engineering, to a T - Taking core theoretical concepts and making them into useful designs! To make a great redstone build, as much thought goes into the actual theory (circuits etc.) as does the optimization and final design. So cool.
one thing I do have to say is its cool that observers have made these contraptions so much easier, these things were made before observers so to see that these things were made so much easier by a simple block being added is very nice
I think what we learned here is that Mumbo needs to write his own redstone book.
What an idea, I'd be all over that it could be like odea with all the builds but in a Nice book that you can always reference when you need
I still have my scholastic minecraft books from 2012. included the redstone one. Good memories.
I'll second that motion.
Let’s see how many subs I can get from this comment
current Subs 2780
Yes
i think that mob killer was meant for skeletons since they actually seek out shade instead of accepting fate
Or zombie villagers
These zombies must be millennials
Not related but your pfp is spicy
@@TheBluePhoenix008 gen z*
Does the Seeking shade effect over right other rules though? Cause normally mobs won't cross redstone lines, and the entire trap seemed to be blocked off by a line of redstone.
The reason why all the pistons have so many repeaters is actually because the wanted the book to be helpful to both Java and Bedrock players - In bedrock, you need repeaters behind a piston except in special cases for them to fire
That cant possibly be the case. The armor stand build and trap build both use quasi connectivity, which dont exist in bedrock.
The most confusing thing about Redstone is the placement direction of observers. Definitely backwards. Will never get used to it.
“I’m not entirely sure, it’s certainly teaching them something, anyway” is the most conclusive sentence I think i’ve ever heard.
the wording confuses me
That’s the exact purpose of school lol
That's exactly what teachers say
@@Praecantetia ikr
I'm not entirely sure what this conclusion is, but it's certainly concluding something, anyway
I think people are supposed to recognize the suboptimal designs of the builds, and improve them as part of the learning process, a soft encouragement for people to teach themselves and get them to think like a red stone engineer.
I kinda prefer the big and loud piston clock. It really feels like a power generator, and you can build a nice metal, stone, and glass she'll around it to really sell the industrial generator look.
Mojang: "No! We can't make a redstone book with only observers but no redstone!"
Mumbo: "Yes you can"
To be fair observers are like transistors, you could make a lot of different logic gates with transistors, same here.
That book was created before observers
@@ZeoZephyr I thought it was new lol
@@tridiots3681 this book has existed since before 1.12, so like...
The book is 7 year old
Mumbo: "My girlfriend thought i wanted to learn more about redstone... Oh, bless her."
*Self-confidence: Level 100*
The joke isn’t that she thought he wanted to learn more about redstone, it’s that she thought reading a book about redstone would be a sensible way to go about it.
well, I too am confident that my Redstone skills are better than an official beginner textbook guide lol
@@erich_ika keep your pride up brother, keep your pride up ✨
4:34 zombies don’t seek out shade. Skeletons does
7:20 back then you weren't able to place buttons on the ground
For why lever and not button: The book is old back then you couldnt place buttons on the ground
For why the repeater: The book is old back then you coudlnt place redstone on pistons
I think the same with observers
@Hai Red As I said, its old, back then it wasnt possible.
@@theepicwizard4631 They have one contraption with observers, and also a whole section on them!
@@Living_Murphys_Law Sorry. I haven't seen them
@@ForgottenInfluencer Buttons on top of blocks was added in 1.8, which came out in 2014.
And for the Redstone on pistons, I think that came in 1.3, or for 2012.
Observers were added in 1.11, which was 2016.
Since the book was made in 2017, all three of these were in the game.
Mumbo: **says that redstone maybe is complicated**
Everyone: *Visible confusion*
69likes
It's really quite simple
I’ve enjoyed this! I’ve been learning redstone since 2019 and I have learned some new stuff today.
You have taught me more than that book has. Honestly I kind if just put that book back on the shelf, watched a few of your videos, then figured the rest out by myself.
It's a good thing Mumbo didn't write this book because it will cause the reader's brain to implode in on itself
Why not that it's hard or something
Rub those brain cells faster! You can do it! 😂
Trust me, as a programmer, I've seen stuff a million times weirder then any redstone constraption ever
@@andraskmeczo575
You mean wearder than a bedrock bug...
Wait theta impossible
@@dungeontnt i mean you got a point... but tbh honest, nothing beats the BUD switches and quasy connectivity😂
Glad someone with actual skill/experience finally made this 😂
lol yes
Facts
*cries in doing this a month ago*
.
the man itself
Today, the armor stand switch is even more useful than before. Amazing.
Petition for mumbo to write an advanced redstone book
mumbo: "Lets make it better!"
*literally just adds observers*
*literally just works*
*literally says it’s not that complicated*
the funny thing is that observers didn't exist when the book was made
@@-Chicken_ *literally the truth*
Alternate title - How school teaches you vs How it is suppose to be in practical life
School teaches you to teach you concepts so yeah
@@aahillakhani399 but teaches you how to do stuff in a more complicated way
@@aahillakhani399 Yeah
@Lestat Gonzalez Yeah, but look at that piston clock. You'll never use it, but it still teaches a bunch of other things that you will use. It's the same for school.
@Lestat Gonzalez This and you also don't know why you need to know some things
For the piston squisher, since you said it was designed before we could crawl, that was also before we could even have redstone dust placed on top of pistons and powering them without breaking.
I love how well he conveys that the book is actually really high quality just not the best tasks for the job
I’m still dying to know what 7 million looks like in Minecraft...
It’s more likely that he’ll do a 10 million blocks video when he hits 10 million.
@@kyandenton maybe he already did and he is just waiting for his channel to reach 10 million subscribers
Then make it yourself dont die he isnt gonna make it
Do it yourself
*cues clip of Dream flying over gold blocks*
Who else wants Mumbo to actually make a redstone guide book now lmao
Or at least a tutorial series “school of redstone”
Tutorial series “It’s really quite simple”*
@@sweetcorm It's really just quite simple, a toddler could easily make it. -Shows a huge complicated computer ai that plays minecraft inside of minecraft inside of minecraft while simulating an entire universe-
Let’s see how many subs I can get from this comment
current Subs 2780
His "Minecraft: 10 Redstone Projects for Beginners" is actually really helpful. He gives you a world download with all the materials you need, and then in each segment he teaches you a new redstone circuit and then gives you a goal of something to create. You pause the video, build the contraption in your own world, and then keep watching to see how Mumbo would solve the same problem. (Just note, there are some errors importing it to 1.16. So you either have to use the version it was made in or pay close attention to his set-up.)
I second this
I genuinely enjoyed this video so so so much. Also can't wait for season 8!
This is the most Mumbo video out there! XD Taking something that was intended for a certain purpose and using for something way better
I'd love nothing more than a "Mumbo's guide to redstone" book. Just imagine it!
Whole book is just 4 words: "It's actually quite simple."
10/10 would buy again.
“Maybe minecraft redstone is confusing and weird...”
People who aren’t Mumbo: and now he gets it
It’s really quite simple
For the first, the secret door kinda thing I love to have them with hopper below and you have to throw the correct named item on the ground otherwise it doesn't open.
Obviously way more complicated than the simple design but so much fun
You could also use campfires, then you don't need a minecart, you could just use normal hoppers(but redirecting with water first is ideal)
Alternate title: Mumbo flexing on mojang for 11 minutes 20 seconds straight
lol true
Yep
Haha true
Im very new to mc so this hurts my brain... dont even onow what redstone is lol
@@ravenstar1397 it's electricity in real life, it's an implementation of electricity to the game, but the mechanics of real world and game is very different.
9:48 I think that the “top section” in the redstone guide was like that because before 1.16 any redstone on top of pistons would pop off when it extended.
Also there may have been no observers at the time of writing the book
Arthur Khazbs WE ARE FARMERS BUM BUM BUM BUM BUM BUM
@@ArthurKhazbs I don’t think the repeaters were really needed though
@@ArthurKhazbs observers were added in 1.11
I got an ad right when i clicked on the timestamp
Aw man... I can literaly watch any video this man has made, and it would be like watching it for the first time even if I already watched it beacause I'll still won't undertand a bit about what he is saying... and I will love every minute.
Thank you so much Mumbo for reminding me I still have the redstone handbook! I need to do *something* with it.
Next ilmango video. Doing Minecraft how MumboJumbo intended then doing it better.
this, this would be EPIC... in fact, I'd be chuffed to bits if this came out!
Lol
He would make them so lag efficient you could run thousands of these contraptions at a time with 1mspt of lag
@@spicybaguette7706 so your saying a stronger pc
He cant
*British man with a mustache uses Minecraft to criticize and simplify an educational piece of literature*
LMAO
😂😂😂
"With a moustache" he says
@@Mikesapien yes'nt
British man with a mustache uses Minecraft to criticize and simplify an educational piece of literature
Mumbo: the instructions are pretty easy to follow
Me: *resumes to look at the book and then at my contraption that went horribly wrong* 😃
4:16 Sry mumbo zombies are not that intelligent as go to there. This trap works only with skeletons.
mumbo uploads
everyone "time to drop everything and watch this for 10 minutes"
11 get it right. Hahaha 🤣
@@mutantmutant8534 11:19 smh... 🤣
That is so accurate! I was playing minecraft and I left my world as soon as I got a notification
17 minutes
@@inventiveowl395 11:20 🤣
Mumbo: *Everything is incredibly simple to follow*
Contraption: *Self building working Falcon 9*
XD lol imagine a working starship bfr in minecraft
@@Mapsa_ It's easy. Build the shell, then fill it with TNT.
Lmfao
@@thomasbecker9676 Not Engin explosion powered, you idea is exploding engine.
@@leovillant768 That's the point.
Having not played minecraft in years, it's weird to see these videos and realize just how much redstone has changed, as far as new tools being implemented.
That went by a lot faster than I realised. Good stuff, Mumbo
Vickie thinking he was doing research for a video is the most wholesome thing ever, lol
The funny part is he honestly could write a book about redstone and it likely would be on a top selling chart
Bless her :')
its a reasonable assumption, mumbo isnt really as good at redstone as everyone thinks he his. not saying hes bad, just overrated.
@@joshr5151 No, everything about this comment is just plain wrong. I’m not a Mumbo fan but I’m hermitcraft completionist so I watch everything.
@@miniciominiciominicio he is pretty decent at redstone, but what I think people mean by overrating is the fact that people see him as the best, which he is not at all.
‘Maybe minecraft redstone is just confusing and weird’
- Mumbo, 2021
@roblox King it’s a bot, report and move on
I built your armor stand swapper and it was cheap and surprisingly easy to build just looking at it! I wish i could be as good as you at redstone. I am okay at it but i need to get better. I enjoy doing redstone.
Mumbo: Maybe minecraft redstone is just confusing and weird
Grian: YES! FINALLY!!!
Next steps to improving redstone ability:
-Learn to read Minecraft code (where one usually discovers all the weird shiz)
-Watch tutorials from the technical Minecraft community... on everything
-Talk with SciCraft constantly about compactifying contraptions (because that usually involves weird redstone)
compactifying should be a real word, it sounds so much cooler than compacting
@@theneonbop ikr
Commands be difficult to learn :/
Last step to improving redstone ability:
*-Make sure you are learning how to do redstone in the type of Minecraft you are in (EX: Bedrock and Java).*
@@aperson6081 minecraft code is in java, which is probably a lot more complicated than commands, i tried learning javascript once and didn't get very far, java is even harder i think
for some reason javascript and java are different things its very confusing
Mumbo's definition of improving Redstone: make it more complicated
But also smaller and faster
Lol
@@ultimatedude5686 and weirder and more confusing
The reason for all the repeaters at the end is because Pistons used to not work by simply putting Redstone over them you had to direct the Redstone directly at it and you couldn't do that when they were side by side without repeaters
My biggest problem with redstone is how gated the better designs are. You need to have slime and access to the nether. Some servers I've been on save nether travel as a special server wide event, so I have to build with the old methods until I'm allowed to use quarts. It's useful knowing how to make old contraptions like the piston clock. Personally, I prefer the 5 minute clock (arrow shooting at a button or an item dropping.) 9:40 I made something like that pre combat update, but my blocks extended from the roof and had a timer set so it would shuffle the layout depending on how long you took. I aligned them in a 20x20 grid, making an ever changing maze. It was one of my most annoying builds, but it was worth the time to see other player's frustrations as they try to navigate it. My timers were a mix of hopper clocks, 5 minute clocks, and daylight sensors. The maze was also lightless. I used slabs as the floor and lit them up from below to make a glowing edge lighting effect.
To me, that redstone handbook feels like Kindergarten-12th grade math, while Mumbo’s redstone is like college calculus.
the handbook is more like K-6, mumbo is 7-12, and scicraft are calculus professors
@@apttewly Yeah, that is very true
Vicky thinking you bought that book for research is adorable
My heart exploded, the wholesome girl 😭
Mumbo: This is brilliant.
Mumbo: But _I_ like this.
you should make your own redstone guide, you're a redstone genius
Mumbo:
Makes flipping pages in a book look better than Hollywood
"Let's get these guys kitted out in the finest clobber." Sometimes, Mumbo, you become twice as British in a sentence 😂
innit
@@ABananaJenson "Innit, doe?" I hear Lauren Cooper in my head 😂
Yes
@@leovillant768 innit
my mind was blown for that armour stand contraption never seen anything like it before ever!
There's also an older version of the Redstone guide it came up in a box set with three other books and it was the official Minecraft guide books back in the day
Next thing you know Mumbo writes his own Redstone Handbook
OkAye
Then it's going the say its quite simple at the beginning
I want it
I would buy it.
YES! I WANT ONE!
I love how Mumbo’s channel started out with compacting redstone using complacated chains of block update detectors and has evolved into... compacting redstone using complicated chains of observers... come to think of it nothing has changed tbh
This was really cool! It would be really cool of you could cover the whole book.
Honestly, your channel has taught me 90% of the redstone I know
I get the feeling those Minecraft systems were intended so both Java AND Bedrock players could make it.
Nah, they don't work in bedrock
@Seth Dkny also Bedrock slime blocks shoot them lower so it absolutely couldn't work
@@edwardcarrescia232 they do work just need to tweak it little by setting slime block one block down and only problem is that you can only swap two armor stands
The book was made before Bedrock was released
Don't forget that the book cane out at around 1.5-1.8 times. Things like observers didn't exist. And some of the AI has also been changed
day 2 of telling mumbo to put a lamp in the lobby of pacific that lights up when someone is shopping so if someone else comes there theres no confusion
It may be a bit glitchy, but I'm still a fan of the redstone repeater clock. The smallest possible afaik is just 2 repeaters con
nected by redstone. Add a start button and a reusable piston kill switch, and it's still pretty convenient.
The best part about this video is how it goes from the most beautiful stunning camera shots and angles ever to “Minecraft graphics”
Only OG’s will remember the handbook
I quite literally bought it just to be able to (hopefully) understand what mumbo is taking about
It didn’t work
@@shrekwizowskee2910 me too
oh yes
Yeah, I bought all the four of them when they came out.
I still have all the minecraft handbooks
Mojang : explaining Redstone the simple way
Mumbo : "proceed to make it complicated"
Really cool video. Fun to see things done in different ways.
I love the 'drifting' minecart from 10:32 onwards.
The surprising part is... *I HAVE THE BOOKS!!!*
It is weird the oldest Minecraft books most of us still have
Noice
Same here
Cool! I have this set of 4 minecraft books but idk whether the red stone one is the one Mumbo has
Ok
How to make a bulky Redstone contraption better -
Literally just replace everything with observers
You know what, I’m going to create the most complex machine with Redstone that has ever been created but instead of making it out of all these weird components I’m just going to plop down observers technically replacing all the blocks in that machine with observers and seeing if it works
@Leo Pool huh--
That little story at the end is just the best
You should make your own book about redstone! great video!