ICJ interim ruling on genocide case against Israel - Live
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 січ 2024
- INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE - Friday 26 January 2024
The Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide in the Gaza Strip (South Africa v. Israel) - Request for the indication of provisional measures - The Court to deliver its Order on Friday, 26 January 2024,
Subscribe to our channel bit.ly/AJSubscribe
Follow us on Twitter / ajenglish
Find us on Facebook / aljazeera
Check our website: www.aljazeera.com/
Download AJE Mobile App : aje.io/AJEMobile
@AljazeeraEnglish
#Aljazeeraenglish
#news #icj #icjverdict #icjininternationallaw
How did they not demand an immediate cease fire!!! 30 days to what???? I’m beyond disappointed there’s no justice or morality left in this world. Totally heartbroken 💔
Relax. Experts are going to explain everything to us, simply and well all know what's happening. ✌🇿🇦
In any court you don't get everything you ask for. The court said Isreal must do everything in its power to limit the death and damage. The term " everything in it power" includes a ceasefire. Let's keep that pressure on until Isreal ceases.
The gold and silver of the ZIONIST controlls the International Court of Justice.
That deliberation is useless😂😂😂😂 in South Africa said they win😂😂😂😂
They don't have Jurisdiction to issue Injunctions
Justice delayed is justice denied!
Happens in Syria, Russia, North Korea, Iran and China all the time
@@Barricade379 but Israel is has been doing it for more than 75 years. This is the most important issue in the whole universe.
@@Barricade379 it's only happen in USA, UK, Australia, Canada, France, Poland all the time ... Russia China iran were the most civilized human civilization on earth which is still not Occupied by illegal white supramacist colony by massacred all native brown Americans and still white House don't move to Europe
You are so silly to think your calls for a cease fire will work while you been holding people you kidnapped over 180 of them still in gaza almost 4 months after your barbaric attacks, rape, murder and co, you will learn that not everyone is very stupid.
Stop screaming. They are working it out. It's a legal process and they are doing it in the proper and correct way. Stop acting like stupid hooligans.
Kudos to aljazeera to show the actual ruling instead of commentary. The judgement was a glimmer of hope in a messed up world. Mad respect to judges for cool calm and reasonable judgement
Yessir, that is a key point. I tried watching others, all cut with commentary, no doubt propaganda
Yessir, this is a very important comment
Thank you Al Jazeera for every report you have made on this issue. International Court of Justice, why did Netanyahu meet you before the announcement of the final decision? just so that you can take more 30 days? that's a shame. I believe. soon ICJ will lose its credibility.
reporting bias hate
Thank you South Africa 🇿🇦 🇵🇸
What about Russia
Thank for what? Useless proceedings
Allhumdullillah
Hamas lost
South Africa lost
Israel simply asked to comply with existing statutes
(So must every country - France, UK, Italy, South Africa etc)
So this is less than a slap on the wrist
South Africa has fallen on its face LOL
Alhamdulillah
Let's give our South African brothers a standing ovation and respect. They've proved to be the real UBUNDU Nation. God bless you.
Ignore the genocide committed by saf
For what? For loosing the case? Lol...south africa that supports terror and hamas was humiliated, no cease fire means israel won...eat your heart
South African government is just another corrupt country bowing to Socialism and Communism
@@gili41be careful your karma is watching 😂
@@lakhsaramintdie9954 im so affraid..lol
Remembering Martin L King's famous quote: "Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere". It's a serious matter of humanity to be saved!!
MLK was a Zionist 😆
Hats off to South Africa!
JUSTICE MUST BE SERVED TO SAVE HUMANITY FROM OPPRESSORS
Islam wants to take over thexworld and apply sharia law, now hamas will be present and sadly there is no peace in any Islamic country
Cry harder
*what a mistake in the Qur'an!*
Allah himself testifies that he has a son and he is the son as Christians understand it! Only the Koran writer was too ignorant to know what Son of God means! Allah's word which created everything is Allah himself too! *The Word Allahs which created everything is the Son of God according to Christianity!*
Son of God does not mean that God has a child in Christianity!
*what a mistake in the Qur'an!*
Son of God are 2 titles one referring to the Word of God = God himself and one referring to creation (humans, angels, demons)
HUMANITY must rise up to stop the genocide of GAZA. The International Court of Justice is controlled by the ZIONIST: GOLD AND SILVER.
One month????? Are you kidding .STOP IT IMMEDIATELY RIGHT NOW!!!!
If in one month Israel will not stop, it will be judged at the International criminal court. This is the court of justice, it pronounces generally. Trust me, court did this time very much. Any country what will help Israel from now, will be legally accused.
I don't fully understand the verdict.I heard 1 month (how many more people are going to die...), no mention of immediate ceasefire, no mention of accountability for crimes committed, no mention of illegal occupation, no mention of the next step if Israel doesn't perform its obligation (Israel already made clear it won't)!! It's as if agreeing with South Africa but not holding any Israeli accountable? It called out Hamas, but did not call out the IDF? What's the immediate action? Getting wolves to look after sheep? I am confused if this verdict is any good or use?
Report in 1 months, but they should take every action to stop this highly likely act of genocide immediately.
@@mozadded but Israel can still continue to bomb. No ceasefire called.
@@lisaneothey can't called for cease fire, but now leaders in Israel can be charged for committing crimes against humanity and possibly be incarcerated
A historic ruling from the ICJ. Within one month, the accused belligerent must report back to the ICJ on progress made to honour the accountability ruling. 👏👏
And if they don't? Nothing will happen. ICJ has no real power.
Crazy 😝 and nonsense
@@lakhsaramintdie9954
Open your eyes, what do you see?
Everything I have written is verifiable fact.
Now close your eyes & your private reality will return.
The ICJ rejected SA's demand for immediate ceasefire, never said in any of their points that Israel is committing genocide, and Israel can continue fighting. The ICJ ruled that Israel needs to prevent acts of genocide (which they have been doing - they gave weeks of warning to the civilians and allow tons of humanitarian aid) and provide information on how they are doing that, which they will be happy to.
They ruled (Paragraph 85) that Hamas must release ALL hostages immediately and unconditionally - will Hamas honour that ruling?
@@theastronomer5800
What goes around comes around.
Al Jazeera❤😊
Vanity and pride are different things, though the words are often used synonymously. A person may be proud without being vain. Pride relates more to our opinion of ourselves, vanity to what we would have others think of us…
😊
🙏🏻
If the ICJ doesn't give justice to innocent Palestinians, it would the prove that there is no justice in this world. The world want justice for innocent Palestinians.
We know how it stands with "justice" in this world, since the USA was allowed to conduct an illegal war of aggression that cost 1 million Iraqis their lives.
Not only allowed, but also never held accountable for it...
Justce does not equate to intentional genocide.
@@caroshmarow You mean the other way round:
Intentional genocide is not justice...
Why phlistinen map is missing in world map.
There is justice in the world, but it needs the right people to uphold it. The problem is not an absence of justice. But an absence of Just institutions.
Court orders Israel to take all measures to prevent genocide
The ICJ orders Israel to take all measures within its power to prevent genocide.
It says Israel must ensure its forces do not commit genocide and ensure preservation of evidence of alleged genocide.
ICJ orders Israel to report to it within one month
Israel must report to the court within a month on what it is doing to uphold the order to take all measures within its power to prevent acts of genocide in Gaza.
Judge Donoghue says the ruling creates international legal obligations for Israel.
Basically Israel will continue and US will ignore and keep supplying them and nothing will change.
This has huge legal implications for the US and the UK!
All measures like what? Not shooting people who are holding up white flags?
My GOD, thank you South Africa, may GOD take care of you eternally, Thank you to everyone for what you are doing for Palestine, I am not Palestinian but I am Human, and it breaks my heart to see those images from there. I'm asking GOD to give Palestine a victory and for them to be free forever. Ameen
Israel always was against committing genocide. The attack and murder of 1500 Israelis was declaration of war.
Hamas responsible for situation in Gaza, initiating a war and embedding between population, fighting in civil clothes making impossible distinguish between fighter and civilian.
By the time this is done there will be nobody left in Gaza.
Even after seeing all the evidence and killing of mother and innocent children, they still didn't call for immediate ceasefire. I am beyond disgusted.
The ruling rejects Israel's claims that the court doesn't have jurisdiction and finds that South Africa's concerns are valid, and it rules that the Palestinians are a protected class of people. Some important findings here that set the stage to hold Israel accountable.
No, not at all. You are trying to spin the court's ruling by making up your own. The court found no genocide so no ceasefire and Hamas is ordered to release all hostages. Israel will show proof it has provided humanitarian aid to civilians in 30 days. There's no need to lie.
Rulings not findings
It also essentially ruled for an immediate cease•fire, immediate humanitarian aid, immediate prevention of and punishment for gen•cidal incitement and immediate release of hostages at a ratio of 15:2 for all and 16:1 for humanitarian aid. This was a major win although most people in the comments don’t seem to realise that.
@@Samaa-os7hx True.
@@JewelsRoyale Yeah, those of us listening to analysts knew this process was gonna take a long time. It will obviously take too long to save thousands more, but it should be the beginning of the end. The ruling is so much better than I expected, honestly. I thought more of them would lack the courage.
Thank goodness for South Africa's legal team! A superb effort! May God/Allah help the people of Gaza in their suffering.
No ceesefire 😂
@@mfundomkhonta7500 no history, no culture no gratitude from Israelis
Al-Lah is the opposite of God.
Al-Lah is the statue of a däemön
@@stlouisix3Wavering from topic? Craving for attention 😂
Well done ICJ. Thank you for the rulling though left out ceasefire. I call out UGANDA JUDGE, shame on you, what a late down to Uganda and Africa as a whole by your selfish greed.
I wonder as to the motives of Uganda's Judge Julia SEBUTINDE? How did she qualify to be a member of the ICJ? Certainly, it must not have been on humanitarian terms!
They basically said stop killing so many civilians and publicly talking about genocide.
Stop killing any
And provide necessary supplies to civilians.
Yep. No provisional measures, everything is in shape of ISRAEL SHOULD. Recommendations.
Hamas lost
South Africa lost
Israel simply asked to comply with existing statutes
(So must every country - France, UK, Italy, South Africa etc)
So this is less than a slap on the wrist
South Africa has fallen on its face LOL
@@vinm300sure thing buddy. 🔻🇵🇸✌🏽
SO PROUD OF MY COUNTRY SA.We are for the people of GAZA .FREEDOM IS COMING TOMORROW
❤ 🇿🇦
proud of you :')
Don't know what are referring to. Yes thanks to SA but all is futile
and we are proud of SA! much Love!
dont hold your breath
what more they need to see to order immediate ceasefire ?????
Thank you first of all to Al Jazeera for ap 44:49 44:49 complete reportage, and all you have done and tried to do (at great cost) throughout the conflict.
Al Jazeera was the key media pushing propaganda (fake news) for the Qatar funded terrorist wars against Libya & then Syria
Please understand that this is an interim ruling, and the final ruling has yet to be announced. South Africa has asked the court for a temporary measure to halt Israeli operations inside Gaza in the meantime to prevent further loss of life.
interim ruling: A decision by the court in civil proceedings that only deals with part of the matter in dispute.
Now if Israel and the US follow the ruling of the International Court of Justice (ICJ) and if the final ruling was the complete ceasefire plus if Israel is found guilty, then we will have a very bright future for Palestine. However, if Israel and the US don’t comply, then they will demonstrate that the ICJ, ICC, and UN are just a joke, and these international entities will lose their authority in no time.
The court found no genocide. No ceasefire was granted. Israel to submit a "report" in 30 days to show they have provided humanitarian aid to Gaza.
@@sandybennett_itsme
Here's a Summary that I copied from one of the comments:
The court agrees with South Africa's case and requested measures to be effected immediately in stopping the harm and to Palestinians, and for all necessary aid to be given to Palestinians.
The court also mentioned that Hamas to release Israel hostages unconditionally. (while I don't get what this last part has to do with the case)
Provisional measures (at least what I captured):
1. ...take all measures to prevent all acts of [killings and damage, emotional or physical].
2. ...Israel must not commit any acts of [harm]
3. ..Israel shall take all measures within it's power to [prevent and punish those who commit genocide against Palestinians].
4. [Israel to effectively allow all necessary humanitarian aids].
5. [Israel must prevent the destruction and insure preservation of evidence of acts above and the punishment against those who commit it].
6. [Israel must submit reports on the measures done to insure the above within one month of the order] (which South Africa shall get a copy of and can provision).
Most of above measures were voted in-favor 15:20 or 16:10.
Please note that Israel is not forced to enforce nor accept any of the above unfortunately.
Especially when Israel has around 10,000 hostages @@Pain-And-Gain
@@Pain-And-Gain I watched the entire video. The general findings are: The court did not find genocide, no ceasefire, Israel lectured to prevent civilian casualties (as everyone should during war anyway), Hamas ordered to release all hostages. Israel must show the court it has provided humanitarian aid to civilians and preserve any evidence of "claimed genocide" in the next 30 days. You can post a transcript if you wish but the summary is enough.
People must understand this
Those to whom the people said, “The people have assembled against you, so fear them.” But this only increased them in faith, and they said, “Allah is sufficient for us, and what an excellent Trustee.”
Quran (3:173)
Yes,indeed ALLAH S.W.T. Great ☝️☝️☝️☝️☝️☝️☝️☝️☝️☝️☝️☝️☝️🤲
Allah is sufficient for us
And is the best of judges
Apparently not. Still waiting for a miracle from Allah.
HAMAS=human-animals
I am originally from Slovakia, I am very proud of my homeland. They did not let US and Israel to bully them. And they tried...Thank you Slovakia! Proud to be Slovak, so proud of Judge Peter Tomka, ICJ.
God bless south africa ❤❤❤ Thank you for the Government of South Africa and South African People ❤ Free palestine🇵🇸
I was actually surprised that the US judge voted for. God bless her! Hope that she doesn't get into trouble with her career back home.
Lol. Voted for what? Just useless verdict anyway
@@bbtco8758 voted for instead of against.
We’ll see what effect this verdict has. They can’t force compliance on Israel, but most Western countries take ICJ rulings seriously. If Israel does not comply they may lose their support.
@@bbtco8758where do you learn your English?
@@rezag8369you're joking, they're together. Western worlds are complicit.
@@rezag8369lol uou are too naive
I love my country!!!😭🇿🇦but where’s the ceasefire?????
It is effectively the ceasefire۔ Whether israhell follows is to be seen
There is no ceasefire because the court found no genocide. All those genocide claims are lies.
Cry more
The UN peacekeepers need to go in
Shameful that judges didnt call for but being that Israel is a terrorist state is known to threat and kill people they were probably scared of them.
I’m just relieved that the Palestinian people will receive aid (food, water , heat, medical supplies etc) that they desperately need. Super proud of my South African people for standing up for victims of apartheid instead of just sitting idle. God bless Palestine 🇵🇸 God bless South Africa 🇿🇦 and every peace loving country on earth.
I am watching here because other streams have comments turned off. Thank you for keeping comments open.
This trial is not at the guilty/not guilty stage yet. First, this preliminary ruling is just to determine whether there is a case for genocide committed by israel. Meaning, does South Africa present evidence of it. The ICJ determined yes, there's a valid case, and they just issued a few provisional measures on israel to change the indiscriminate warcare, bombing, and targetting of Palestinian civilians and war crimes in Gaza specifically. Unfortunately, israel will probably disobey and this trial will take many more months and even years for South Africa to argue the case, before the judges finally rule israel guilty of genocide, and punish them by imprisoning israeli war criminals...
This is important, but we can't rely solely on the slow trial processes to rescue the thousands of Palestinians being killed each week. Keep taking direct actions, like protests, calling politicians, boycotting, disrupting weapons factories, sending donations to Palestinians. We the people have power to bring aid and help enact justice for Palestine.
🤲🇵🇸🙏🏻
💯👍🏿 Thank you❤️🇵🇸❤️🇸🇸
The ICJ cannot charge or imprison the war criminals. That’s the job of the ICC.
Precisely this is only the prelim...so it will have to go through a few process
Absolutely!
Also follow the work and support ICJP who are the lawyers working to collect evidence to support cases against western politicians and media at the ICC!!!!
Now is the time to ramp up pressure! It’s all working! We can’t be discouraged. We owe it to the people of Gaza and all of Palestine to not be discouraged, and to keep pressure up for them, to do what they cannot.
Summary:
The court agrees with South Africas case and requested measures to be effected immediately in stopping the harm and to Palestinians, and for all necessary aid to be given to Palestinians.
The court also mentioned that Hamas to release Israel hostages unconditionally. (while I don't get what this last part has to do with the case)
Provisional measures (at least what I captured):
1. ...take all measures to prevent all acts of [killings and damage, emotional or physical].
2. ...Israel must not commit any acts of [harm]
3. ..Israel shall take all measures within it's power to [prevent and punish those who commit genocide against Palestinians].
4. [Israel to effectively allow all necessary humanitarian aids].
5. [Israel must prevent the destruction and insure preservation of evidence of acts above and the punishment against those who commit it].
6. [Israel must submit reports on the measures done to insure the above within one month of the order] (which South Africa shall get a copy of and can provision).
Most of above measures were voted in-favor 15:2 or 16:1.
Please note that Israel is not forced to enforce nor accept any of the above unfortunately.
It's good judgement to start a strong case against isreal, now everything they do is under scrutiny.
Thanks for this
The occupation cannot ignore international law. There are also implications for the countries supporting the occupation with weapons and funding.
Thank you for information.
Hamas wouldn’t do it. Hamas isn’t a signatory, it operates outside of the court.
Palestinians are considered humans however, so Israel should fulfil its obligations to follow the ruling. They can reduce their hostages using special forces, I wonder why they are not doing so.
Well done 👏 South Africa 🇿🇦 ❤. Thank you for standing for justice. Now action is needed. Shame on you Arab and Muslim leaders that couldn't do atleast what South Africa did
In the year 2022 to 2023, over 27000 people were murdered in South Africa, which is more than those killed in Gaza in this war. Perhaps they should start looking after their own citizens.
So no tough criticism. The court has basically told them to start abiding by the convention ( which they know they should be doing; ensure they bring people to account who are doing this ( they won't ) ; and report back to court in 1 month to see if they've done their homework. This is a travesty of any sort of international law/ justice. The ONLY good thing I can say is 2 judges only disagreed inc Israel. Otherwise wth is this going to do for Palestine? - They didn't even really call Israel out on its conduct. What a disgrace!!
understanding international law is understanding that you need proof and a long investigation to proof the accusation. you can not call out a state on its conduct if you don't know if they have done that what you accuse them of.
This was about provisional measures. If Israel fails to comply it will look bad when they decide on the merits
The accountability of individuals must be prosecuted by the ICC, criminal court, unlike ICJ which is court of justice, intended to uphold human rights for all people. But the US & UK are blocking the ICC prosecutor Imran Khan from investigating the claims brought to it by several organizations, including the Palestinian Liberation Organization. There are numerous cases brought to the ICC, but Khan is preventing their prosecution, due to the US threats against him and his position. Universal justice remains an outstanding right for the Palestinian people. Imran Khan must be removed from office for his overt discrimination against the Palestinian people.
That was not aim of this decision. This is only a decision regarding which provisional measures should be implemented in order to prevent or stop action that are genocide or Can lead ti genocide. The decision is positive as no warfare towards civilians and civilstructure is allowed until final decision regarding genocide is made
Clawless verdict . They useless . The global south will abandon this useless biased institution
Thank you South Africa 🇿🇦. Jazakhallahu Khiran this hearing and pronunciation will bring the case of genocide to the fore for public discussion, attention and debates and also the faces of the genocide supporters. My eyes are full of tears 😭😭😭.
I wish am a South African at this moment.
😂
Freedom for Palestine and Gaza ❤
Well done South Africa. This is amazing so far and is small progress until the full hearing can be completed. It’s a start to the exposure of this genocide. Patience is key here however anyone with eyes knows this is a genocide.
But they didn’t call for a ceasefire.
No. They didn’t. And they didn’t call for withdrawal of troops.
That's what I came here to know! What was the final ruling?
crappy , corrupt system, that's all it is
Were you expecting ceasefire😀😄
they told to cease hostilities. is that not ceasefire
South Africa WON. The world won. All you amazing people across the globe, your efforts helped. Thank you. Humanity is alive in the hearts of the good people of the world. We stand on the right side of history. Madiba smiles on us all.
Lol. Only Israel won here. We all lost
How? The court found no genocide and did not order a ceasefire. You cannot make up your own version of the findings, the video proves you lied.
@@bbtco8758what you mean
Sadly israel takes the win for that one , there is no justice in this world
@@sandybennett_itsme this is an interim order finding that South Africa has cause. Did you not listen Karen? That Israel is to desist from any action to injure or harm. What do think that means? South Africa is not done. The genocide intent will surface. The proof is there. You sound disappointed. You want another 1000's of babies to die Karen?
The court’s preventive measures are effective immediately. So, any violations in the next 30 days will indicate deliberate breach.
Hanas should release the hostages . Why no mention of their wrong doing...Always blame Israel, you hypocrite. God blesses and protects Israel, HIS CHOSEN PROMISED NATION abd Chisen People the Israelites 🙏🇮🇱
Thank you South Africa 🇿🇦🇵🇸🤝🏻🇮🇳 Free Palestine ❤
Of course you thank South Africa because you're one feathers. Only birds of the same feathers flock together.
Also on every judgement it was only 1or2 judges against on every section! So very positive!
CEASEFIRE NOW! THE 1 MONTH FOR REPORTS SHOULD HAVE INCLUDED A CEASEFIRE FOR THE REPORTS AND THE REVIEW PERIOD AT A MINIMUM !!!
hamas said no
@@emmanuelh2304 They said they would agree to ceasefire put in place by ICJ if Israel agrees to it.
It basically did i think. They disallowed Isreal to kill any gazans.
@@emmanuelh2304IDF also said no to having all the Israeli hostages freed in return of a permanent ceasefire 🤡🤡🤡
Prison is for the poor, richs has laywers.
Bravo South Africa, your flag has gained immense prestige.
Speak, your lips are free.
Speak, it is your own tongue.
Speak, it is your own body.
Speak, your life is still yours.
See how in the blacksmith's shop
The flame burns wild, the iron glows red;
The locks open their jaws,
And every chain begins to break.
Speak, this brief hour is long enough
Before the death of body and tongue:
Speak, 'cause the truth is not dead yet,
Speak, speak, whatever you must speak.
😂
7:21
Proud to be South African always, but particularly today. We are nudging the course of history towards a more just world. Hulle weet nie wat ons weet!
Wat weet jy
Sa accomplished embarrassment thats all.
@@dont_talk2me you can always leave if you are not happy here
Wat weet ons?
On the contrary ithe judges currently seem to rule that your comment is embarrassing, good try though, racist much?
Nothing embarrassing about real equality, justice, freedom & peace for all.@@dont_talk2me
SANCTIONS to Israhell! ARREST THOSE CRIMINALS!!!
Come and arrest them 😘
Yes everyone should start making up their sanctions for them
For what? Israel is not guilty.
hypocrite!!!!!!
@@sandybennett_itsmeyeah right, they've been guilty for decades
The icj calls for the immediate release of all hostages immediately but did not call for a ceasefire by Isreal. While hamas is a group Isreal is a state and cannot continue its acts of eliminating every Gazans. The icj gave isresl 1 month to object to its ruling. This will translate in over 10,000 more unalived Palestinians.
No mention is made of the thousands of Palestinians hostages held in Isreal jails without charges or trials.
I have a new found love for South Africa 🇿🇦 ❤
No cease-fire, no nothing. Useless ICJ
Whattttt omgggg
So the judge said Isreal must prevent anything from Article 2 of genocide convention:
(a) Killing members of the group;
(b) Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group;
(c) Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its
physical destruction in whole or in part;
(d) Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group;
(e) Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group.
^ This is kind of what a ceasefire is....right? So w/o saying it they kinda did say it
Useless indeed. Wasted everyone's time.
Effectively, what the court said means ceasefire. They just didn't use that word.
@@Bathing824💯👍🏿thank you
Does this mean any supportive role of other nations, ie selling weapons to Isreal, will be complicit in the act?
Very good question. I guess it would mean that. How will the USA respond. @@maroonpilgrim
Britain too
I think S.A has stated they will be going after the nations that are complicit in a separate case
Guys hope again in humanity
Let's hope so, but there is something called the Hague Act that protects the US and its allies from charges
This is such a joke. I see so clearly now what is happening in this world. The poor will always be taken advantage of by these monsters
You're just working this out?
Well done South Africa. We are bursting with patriotism that we haven't felt for a long time. It's early days. Israel is known For not complying with any rules, but you opened the Vetoists Pandora box. Morality and humanity must prevail!!!!
Why didn't they ask Israel to release hostages? They took loads of medical staff, doctors and nurses, hostage when they attacked hospitals.
Not to mention the over 2000 children, women & males they imprisoned without trial ie kidnapped & held hostage before October 7th
I doubt they have any living hostages.. The Jews hatred for Palestinians runs deep( men,women and obviously children)
They're hamas supporters
Hostages? I've never heard Israhell taking hostages. They only kill!
This violence started since the creation of Israel and the Zionist movement
Alhamdullilah! They really were over technical with their verdicts, but if one listens closely, the court ruled that Israel should not continue with its current actions. I don't know if that can be defined as a ceasefire, but its a step in the right direction. For those giving up hope because the word "ceasefire" wasn't mentioned, understand that even the word itself is inflammatory especially for people as sensitive as Israelis. If they are offended, they might go on a 1-month killing spree again so the judge was very careful with her wording. Even so, the crimes of the terror state of Israel have literally been highlighted for the world to see. There is no going back to naturalisation after this. And Allah S.w.t knows best. FREEPALESTINE! From the River to the sea!
This is the vest explanation I read. Thank you. May Allah reward you for this level headed comment
Alhumdulillah, FREE FREE PALESTINE
💯👍🏿Thank you❤️ 🇵🇸❤️🇿🇦
Sure =))
Thanks-that explanation squeezed into my brain abi more easily
GOD bless our African brothers and sisters for valiantly standing against these atrocious acts of injustice; for possessing the conviction & resolve to act while the rest of the world stands idly by, watching!
The ICJ is incapable of giving True Justice. Ref. Bakassi ( Nigeria/Cameroon)
This now needs to go to the ICC. FULL ON.
Thank you South Africa 🇿🇦 🙏🙏 Nelson Mandela would be darn proud of you now. His legacy lives on. Thank you all judges for holding up to the purity and integrity of the law. You have restored our faith in legal system in preserving humanity 🙏 respect to all. Another step in the start of the end of oppression.
Ya he and his grandson love Hamas
On May 14, 1948, Israeli commandos, armed by British, held positions along roads leading from Jerusalem to the sea. they awaited orders,...when Ben Gurion announced that the British mandate was over and the UN voted to accept the state of Israel., they climbed assigned trucks and the killing of Palestinian people living in coastal fishing towns began. They called it "war of independence". Bulldozers were used to bury and mask the graves in orchards, fields and streets of what would become Beach resorts.
The bones of those Palestinians are still found by workers repairing or expanding parking lots or gardens on what used to be fishing towns.
Golda Meir wrote: "“It was not as if there was a Palestinian people in Palestine and we came and threw them out and took their country away from them. They did not exist.”" in an attempt to erase history while unmasking herself because if there were not Palestinian people...what was the independence war about?
This is so STUPID!!!!
it did not start october 7,
It started 70 years ago
I feel like a lot of politics is going on here. But still, most important thing is that the claims are considered valid and so it will move on to a real ruling. As for immediate actions, it's also not as negative as it may appear. It ruled that Israel needs to take measures to stop all the actions it took which are considered genocidal, effective immediately. This means that if Israel just goes ahead and continues on the same path it not only makes it harder for them when the real ruling will happen, but it will also mean they didn't comply with today's ruling.
Well articulated, thank you! Kudos
But in the case of Russia it took them only 8 days to give a final ruling to stop the war.
And what happens if they don't comply?
@@kirimkamal4872 Yeah and that case was far from this kind of destruction, let alone clear signs genocidal intent. There's definitely politics involved here. On the other hand, Israel will probably ignore everything anyway, just like Russia did.
@@mosesnkosi4252 Hopefully that carries over to when the court will rule a definitive verdict, whenever that will happen. I don't know I'm not a lawyer. But they did impose Israel to come with results within a month and I'm not sure if they said anything about what they'll do in a month from now.
From the whole world, thank you to the people of South Africa !!!
Shame that Judge Robin SON was not able to show up.
Seriously judge starts with October 7?
Shame on the U.N
The People United will Never be defeated !!! ✊
May justice be served and enforced
From INDONESIA to SOUTH AFRICA and many other COUNTRIES, we are all PALESTINIAN BROTHERHOOD 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸 WE STAND IN HUMANITY ✊🏻✊🏻✊🏻✊🏻✊🏻 salam 🇵🇸
😂
Then you must condemned HAMAS action before you are talking about humanity...if you can't condemned HAMAS then your not talking humanity but ideology
Is their anything else South Africa want to do
Just mind your business and take care of your own country !!!
South Africa you should see what did the terrorist do to Israel on 7th of October and now Israel is defending its own country
And it's not in terms of Genocide
How can you accuse Israel on this situation
All the ICJ is waste of time and money
I stand with Israel
🤲🏻🇵🇸❤️🇹🇯🇰🇬❤️🇿🇦❤️🇨🇳❤️🇵🇰❤️🇹🇷❤️🇷🇺
@@JD_Awesomehuita zavali eblo
Israel breached UN resolutions at a rate of almost one per month (10-12 per year) since that country came in existence. There was no actions or measures taken by any so called International agencies to prevent them from doing so. So in its all weight this is going to be another document to that pile. Unfortunately whether it is today or 2000 years ago, the rule is big fish eat little fish.😢
the boycotts will start rolling faster now, you should join
@@djpaulcfunkeddub3951exactly. And there's laws in the US against supporting genocide.
The UN made the ambassador of Iran chair of a human rights committee. Yes, Iran. Iran is the main sponsor of the terrorists in Gaza. Is a country which shot over 2k protestors a year ago. Is a country which has sharia laws. They were made head of the committee for HUMAN RIGHTS. That should tell you enough about the UN. It has unfortunately become an antisemitic vehicle which holds a completely different standard for Israel, a democracy where the highest judge is an Arab, and ignores the autocracies surrounding them which were ethnically cleansed of Jews in the last century.
@@s.gharavi1614 Thank you Mr Gharavi, good to know, will start advocating for them to be enforced
@@djpaulcfunkeddub3951 you can look up " Section 1091 of Title 18, United States Code", which "prohibits genocide whether committed in time of peace or time of war." And The DoD Leahy law in "Section 362 of Title 10", but there's lots of domestic as well as international laws.
Lots of words, that almost sounds like compassion but ends up leaving a bitter taste in one’s mouth. So much talking about nothing, leaving everyone bemused, disappointed and hopeless. This is obfuscation on an Olympic level and the court took Gold!
Thanks so much South African people and president of all together beside of Palestinian people
Thanks so much South Africa
❤Thank you South Africa. History will remember this moment.
South Africa 🇿🇦 thank you so much and we with you
Viva South Africa Viva Palestine 🇵🇸🇵🇸🍉🍉🇿🇦🇿🇦❤️❤️❤️
Justice for both parties
We need
Thank you Ms Pandor.. regardless of where it goes from here ... thank you
Thank you for what ? Not stopping holocaust?
Palestinians have the right of resistance against the oppressor, apartheid and colonial state of Israel, even the armed resistance. Israel being the oppressor and illegitimate force doesn't have any right of defence, their rhetoric of defence is absolutely absurd and ridiculous.
October 7th mate
@@xcpointx Satan's race
The occupier has no right of self defense!
1948 & you're no mate of his, save the colonial language, we can all see through it Sherlock@@xcpointx
There is no apartheid and there is no genocide bud
Justice denied. Court should have ordered immediate ceasefire and open Rafah crossing to let aid come in.
Delaying for 1 month means additional continuing Genocide in Gaza !!!!!
We must recognize that the ICJ cannot be a "disinterested" court in deciding the genocide issue since the ICJ is tied to the UN and so likely has great concern about possibly alienating the United States (Israel's partner in genocide) who annually dumps more money than any other country into the UN. The ICJ doesn't want to offend the UN's US "cash cow" and have the UN lose all that money by the ICJ's going against the US position and labeling Israel genocidal - which it truly is!
Honestly, if the ICJ can't declare Israel to be genocidal by now, with all the evidence supporting that conclusion, the ICJ is really not worth consulting or having. The ICJ lacks courage and conviction: So it should be cancelled. And we should also dump the essentially powerless (and therefore useless) UN - thus saving Americans a lot of US taxpayer dollars annually!
Thankyou South Africa ❤
For embarrassing itself. Haha
@@dont_talk2me How exactly?
SUNAK and STARMER Need to Explain Why They Supported ISRAEL
Because Israeli Jewish money via the Rothschild's dynasty owns them. They also own most of the U.S. Congress and Presidency.
Everyone should be outraged by the reality. It doesn't look like that at all. Killing Jesus, the innocents, again and again, one more time in history. Just poor people end up in jail or committing a crime.
my utmost respect to All these judges especially the ones who their country are pro Israel
No ceasefire???!!! Shame on ICJ!!!
Someone well avast said a ceasefire is a demand when there's an armed conflict bt with a genocidal it's with an immediate effect which ICJ said ...so u think we should not help israel with its historic defeat as a win
One of the orders should force Israel to change its military tactics however they won't. What it does show that ICJ has jurisdiction on this.
They should be prosecuted for crimes against humanity
Will hamas change their tactics?
@@leonhue722 Average media sheep.
If there is no daily abuse and subjugation of Palestinians then Hamas has no role left to serve. I'm not justifying their actions but simply saying citing that everything is connected@@leonhue722
@@leonhue722
why would they?
they are the ones defending against occupation and genocide.
Bring the U.K. and U.S to account for willingly and knowingly supporting and arming this genocide.
One step at a time
Biden should do jail time, if he manages to live through a trial!
The court should immediately impose a ceasefire.
Thank you South Africa. You up this case because you know meaning of genocide.
much appreciated thank you south africa❤❤❤👍👍👍
Please take action quick because kids are daying in Gaza help quick 😢
Oh and kids in Ukraine are on vacation? So ignorant
@@Barricade379who said anything about disregarding Ukrainian lives?
Though the court has not agreed to South Africa's request for cease fire in Gaza, it has directed entry of basic services and humanitarian assistance into Palestinian enclave which can be equated to a 50 % plus narrative for cease fire. As the direction cannot be accomplished parallel to a war like situation. Hence a peaceful presence is required to meet this direction. By this ICJ has reinstated faith of the people of this world that some form of natural justice prevails to protect humanity.
Mocking of justice
The world would be in a very sad state of affairs had the court ruled otherwise.
Indeed. It would have been a very dark world.
It would make their jobs obsolete when all evidence is from the UN body, all Israel's "evidence" is from their own findings 😂 and they were put on the side at beginning
Why do you say so?
No ceasefire? Shame on you ICJ.
Israel won
No genocide and no ceasefire.
@@sandybennett_itsmeThe charge of genocide has merit you might need to rewatch the hearing as clearly you missed that part.
@@casualSimRacer3312it is a win. Listen again. Maybe some youtubers will make a video later explaining in laymens language.
@@andrewjohnson5365 What was the ruling on genocide? I watched the entire video. I realize many will be grasping at straws if the ruling did not go as they expected but honestly today was a win for Israel no matter how you try to spin it. You cannot deny this ruling.
Thank you South Africa 🇿🇦
FREE PALESTINE 🇵🇸
I'm surprised that they have given the Israelis a whole month to comply with the order of the court, considering the amount of casualties and decimation of the Gaza Strip. 😢 Surely a week would suffice...
To report back...
They asked hamas to return all the hostages immediately
And they asked Israelis to prevent the genocide
How is this going to play out according to u?
Israel can continue to bomb after all hostages are returned. And u have 1 month for them to submit a report. U want to drag this another month? How many more children's death is that? This is disappointing.
U ruled in favour of SA but it still doesn't feel like a win
That's just how the law works, it's in favor of SA because they are right to say that innocent lives are being lost and they should stop but that doesn't technically make it genocide.
@keithmaliko451Because there is no genocide. And there is not even a ceasefire. This means that Israel is right in the war. But it had to try to harm innocent civilians1
Agree. They didn't ask Zionists to return 6,000 Palestinian prisoners/hostages. They didn’t acknowledged that Zionists killed their own people on 7th of October. So disappointing.
Are the hostages returned yet?
"all measures within its power" I hate that subjective, wishy-washy drivel. And why did they say Hamas has to release all hostages? That sadly would appear as some condition Israel would argue that nullifies the court ruling.
God bless South African people ministration thanks South African people God bless for them humanity always number one free Palestine
😭Oct 7th is not the History of the case Mrs president. This is injustice to the Palestinians. But my heart is at peace knowing that the Day of judgement is coming for everyone and there will be justice. This is so sad.
Indonesia has filed for before Oct 7, back to 1948. Israel are going to need an army of lawyers to defend this.
The only way I can go about my day is with "KNOWING" that THE MOST HIGH GOD, THE CREATOR OF HEAVEN AND EARTH "WILL" AVENGE THE WICKED EVIL DOERS ON EARTH.
He is separating the wheat and the TARES before our very eyes; telling us "be ye separate" "do not partake in their wicked ways". One can not have a heart or soul and condone, aid, assist or rally for this EVIL. They will not be spared and given the mercy they REFUSE to give others ON THAT GREAT DAY.
All Praise Honor and Glory to The Most High OUR POWER 🙌🏻🙌🏾🙌🙌🏾